Retired Officials Who Joined Legal Profession

8/10/2019 Retired Officials Who Joined Legal Profession

1/28Page 1

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACIVIL APPELLALTE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 11454-11459 OF 2014(Arisi! "#$ "% S.L.P. (C& N"s.90'-)*+2010&

S.SESHACHALAM , ORS. ETC. ..A//$s

Vrs#s

CHAIRMAN AR COUNCIL OF

TAMIL NADU , ORS...Rs"3$s

ITH

CIVIL APPEAL NO.114'0 OF 2014(Arisi! "#$ "% S.L.P. (C& N".*4*2'+2012&

THE ELDER LAERS6 ASSOCIATION , ORS. ..A//$s

Vrs#s

STATE OF IHAR , ANR. ..Rs"3$s

J U D 7 M E N T

R. BANUMATHI, J.

L8 !r$3.

2. $r r"8is" $" S:$i" 1' E;/$i" II (5& "%

T


2/28Page 2

=$r 3is$i!#isi! $is :/ss "% 38":$s %r"< "$r />

!r3#$s r"//i! i $ r s$ri!$ %$r $ir /> 3!r

3i3 "$ 8 = r$i"/ @sis r $ "i$s %//i! %"r

:"si3r$i" i $s /s.

*. Sii:

;:/#3s $ rs"s >" 8 r$ir3 %r"< sr8i: 3 r

i r:i$ "% r$ir/ @%i$s %r"< $ir "% $ ir S$$ A38":$s6 /%r F#3 A:$. F"r

:"8i: /s ://!i! $ r"8isi"s "% T

3!r >" 8 r"//3 $


3/28Page 3

A38":$s6 /%r F#3 A:$ $ //$s %i/3 >ri$

$i$i"s :"$3i! $$ $ @%i$ "% /%r F#3 A:$ is

3i3 $" $ ?i "% 38":$s >" r i r:i$ "% si"

"r !r$#i$= "r "$r $r3 $ @$: "% >ri$ $i$i"s %i/3 @= $ r$ir3

"%%i:i/s >" 3 r"//3 $

i


4/28Page 4

r$ir rs"s >" r"//3 s 38":$s

%$r 3


5/28Page 5

@%i$ 3 $$ :"$ %"r< $ @sis %"r 3i/ "% /# s #/$r 8irs Ar$i:/ 14 "% $ C"s$i$#$i" "%

I3i.

). Mr. Pr


6/28Page 6

$ 38":$s >" r %#//= :"i: is 8i! r$i"/ ;#s >i$ $ "@:$s s"#!$ $"

@ :i83 @= $ A:$ i #s$i".

9. Mr. R#3rs>r Si! /r3 :"#s/ ri!

%"r $ S$$ "% ir s#@" r:i8

si" 3 "$r $r


7/28Page 7

" s$ # $ r:$i: s$ri!$ %$r

:" 3!r.

10. 8 :r%#//= :"si3r3 $ s#@=rs 3 >/%r s:


8/28Page 8

r"8i3 $$ S$$ r C"#:i/ i: s// @ :r3i$3 $" $ r"ri$ %#3 "r%#3s :"s$i$#$3 #3r s#@-s:$i" (2&. /%rs:8r $r is i$r =#i%"r= "%s/ "% A38":$s6 /%r F#3 S$


9/28Page 9

F#3 A:$6& >s /s" :$3. S""s


10/28Page 10

(1& T 7"8r


11/28Page 11

T %#:$i"s "% $ Tr#s$ C"" s @ i$s$3i! =$i! :"$i3 i s#@-s:$i" (1& 8r= ..%. 1.2.2001&Pr"8i33 $$ >r $ Tr#s$ C"


12/28Page 12

#i8/$ $" $r


13/28Page 13

()& r rs" >" s @ i3 i$i %i8 =rs "% is 3


14/28Page 14

%i8 =rs s " /? r#s

=@/ $" $ "


15/28Page 15

F#3 3 i$ >s s#@ ": $ r$ir3

" /i3 $" $ Tr#s$ C"" 8 r"//3 >i$ $

r C"#:i/ i


16/28Page 16

i:


17/28Page 17

r i r:i$ "% si" "r "$r $r rs $" @ r$i"/ 3

rs"@/. T si3 :/ssi%i:$i" i "#r 8i> s ;#s

>i$ $ "@:$ s"#!$ $" @ :i83.

19. S$$


18/28Page 18

r"//3 s 38":$s %$r $ir r$irr #/s r $r$3

3i%%r$/= >i$"#$ = rs"@/ @sis. #$ >r #/s

3 ##/s r $r$3 3i%%r$/= Ar$i:/ 14 3"s "$

/=. C/ss /!is/$i" is $$ >i:


19/28Page 19

3is:ri"< $ ri8i/!

is :"%rr3 >"< 3 $ rs"s "$ s" %8"#r3 "

rs"@/ 3is$i:$i" "r s#@s$$i/ 3i%%r: : @ %"#3

#s$i%=i! $ i:/#si" "% " 3 $ ;:/#si" "% $ "$r

%r"< s#: ri8i/!.

22. i/ Ar$i:/ 14 %"r@i3s :/ss /!is/$i" i$ 3"s

"$ %"r@i3 rs"@/ :/ssi%i:$i" "% rs"s "@:$s 3

$rs:$i"s @= $ /!is/$#r %"r $ #r"s "% :i8i!

s:i%i: 3s. #$ :/ssi%i:$i"


20/28Page 20

r/$i" $" $ "@:$ s"#!$ $" @ :i83 @= $ A:$. T

3i%%r$i >i: is $ @sis "% $ :/ssi%i:$i" 3 $

"@:$ "% $ A:$ r $>" 3is$i:$ $i!s. $ is :ssr=

is $$ $r $ @sis "%

:/ssi%i:$i" 3 $ "@:$ "% $ A:$. I$ is "/= > $r

is " rs"@/ @sis %"r :/ssi%i:$i" $$ /!is/$i"


21/28Page 21

-m%lo$eesWelfare Association 3rs.,(2004& 2 SCC )' 3

#tate of un6a' 3rs. 8s.Amar Nat" o$al 3rs. (2005& '

SCC )54 $:.

24. R:$/= i $ :s "% r. #u'ramanian #am$

8s. irector, +) Anr. (2014& SCC '2 $is C"#r$

:"si3r3 $ r":ss "% :/ssi%i:$i" 3 >$ s"#/3 @

r!r33 s :/ss %"r #r"ss "% /!is/$i" /3 i rs

(5& 3 ()0& s #3r-

5. T C"s$i$#$i" r$ s"#/3 @ r!r33 s :/ss %"r #r"ss "% /!is/$i" 3 i r/$i" $" />:$3 " r$i:#/r s#@:$. Tr is @"#3 $" @ s"


22/28Page 22

"%%: #3r $ PC A:$ 19 s $" @ $r$3#//= 3 si. A= 3is$i:$i" $< " $ @sis "% $ir s$$#s "r "si$i" isr8i: %"r $ #r"ss "% i#ir=+i8s$i!$i" is "$i!@#$ r$i%i:i/ " 3 "%%3s Ar$i:/ 14.

25. I $ /i!$ "% $ >//-s$$/3 ri:i/s "%

i$rr$$i" "% Ar$i:/ 14 i$ is $" @ s >$r $r is

i$//i!i@/ 3i%%r$i @$> $ :/ssi%i:$i" "% 38":$s >"

3 s$ # r:$i: s$ri!$ %$r r"/" s$r$ $ir r:$i: %$r 3$r $ 3i%%r$i

s ;#s >i$ $ "@:$ "% $ A:$.

2'. T r"%ssi" "% /> is "@/ ://i!. T /!/

%r$ri$= $"i/s 3= 3 i!$ $" @ s#::ss%#/ i $ r"%ssi".

A/$"#! i$ is $r# $$ s/">/= >"r?i! "6s >= # is $ "r< i

= r"%ssi" i:/#3i! /> @#$ ii$i//= ="#! 38":$s 8

$" r=rs


23/28Page 23

ii$i/ =rs :"#/3 >i$ $ @s: "% /!is/$i" :":ri!

$is $= s$r#!!/ $"


24/28Page 24

:"/%r %#3 s:i$ i! "s 3 ;:$$i"s 3 33i:$

$ir >"/ /i8s $" $ r"%ssi"s r $ r/ 3sr8rs.

L>=rs >" r"/ $" 8 38"$3 $ir >"/ /i8s $" $

r"%ssi". F"r $s r$ir3 rs"s s"


25/28Page 25

A:$ >"#/3 :$#//= $ :/ssi%i:$i" "% />=rs i$" $s $>"

:$!"ris is rs"@/ :/ssi%i:$i" 8i! ;#s >i$ $

"@:$ "% $ A:$.

29. F#r$r "% $ir

@i! /:3 3i%%r$/= $ $ :/ss "% />=rs >" :"s $is

r"%ssi" s $ s"/


26/28Page 26

r:i$ "% si" %r"< $ C$r/ 7"8r


27/28Page 27

i$rr$$i" "% Ar$i:/ 14 "% $ C"s$i$#$i" "% I3i 3 ri!$/=

:":/#33 $$ $r is rs"@/ :/ssi%i:$i" @$> $

38":$s >" 3 s$ # r:$i: %$r 3"#/3

@ ri!$ $" s= $$ $ r$ir3 "%%i:i/s >" "i3 /!/ r"%ssi"

:"s$i$#$ sr$ :/ss 3 $ 3is$i$/


28/28

s:#ri$= i $ %"r< "% %i:i/ ssis$: $" #i"rs 3 $

>/%r s: $r is " r@i$rriss i ;:/#3i! $< %r"< $

/i:@i/i$= "% ir S$$ A38":$s6 /%r F#3 A:$ 19*.

T Di8isi" : "% $ P$ Hi! C"#r$ /=i! i$s ">

3:isi" i edar Nat" Tiari v. #tate of i"ar 2011 (2& PLJR 401

ri!$/= 3isri$ $i$i" 3 > 3" "$ %i3 =

i%ir

Documents

Retired Officials Who Joined Legal Profession