Upload
thecanadianpress
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 1/215
MV@M^@DE @EVJQ^@OM^@DE YJSDY^
M==G3339
ADE^YDKKJN FK@OG^ @E^D ^JYYM@E
IYMNKJP M@Y QJYV@AJQ K@H@^JN (F@YQ^ M@Y)
IDJ@EO ?1?-9=3A, A-OE_EYJQDKZ^J IMP, EZEMVZ^
93 MZOZQ^ 93==
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 2/215
^gj rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn df Amemnm (^QI) evjst`omtjn tg`s daaurrjeaj fdr tgj purpdsjdf mnvmea`eo trmespdrtmt`de smfjty. @t s edt tgj fueat`de df tgj Idmrn td mss`oe fmukt drnjtjrh`ej a`v`k dr ar`h`emk k`mi`k`ty.
Mv`mt`de @evjst`omt`de Yjpdrt M==G3339
Adetrdkkjn fk`ogt `etd tjrrm`e
Irmnkjy M`r Qjrv`ajs K`h`tjn (F`rst M`r)Idj`eo ?1?-9=3A, A-OE_EYjsdkutj Imy, Euemvut93 Muoust 93==
Quhhmry
De 93 Muoust 93==, tgj Idj`eo ?1?-9=3A adhi` m`rarmft (rjo`strmt`de A-OE_E, sjr`mk euhijr9=36?), dpjrmtjn iy Irmnkjy M`r Qjrv`ajs K`h`tjn uenjr ts ius`ejss emhj F`rst M`r, wms ij`eofkdwe ms F`rst M`r agmrtjr fk`ogt 6:63 frdh Pjkkdwbe`fj, Edrtgwjst jrr`tdr`js, td Yjsdkutj Imy,Euemvut. Mt =6>9 Addrn`emtjn Ze`vjrsmk ^`hj (==>9 Ajetrmk Nmyk`ogt ^`hj), nur`eo tgjmpprdmag td Yuewmy 1:^, F`rst M`r fk`ogt 6:63 struab m g`kk midut = emut`amk h`kj jmst df tgjruewmy. gj m`rarmft wms njstrdyjn iy `hpmat fdrajs men me jesu`eo pdst-armsg f`rj. J`ogtpmssjeojrs men mkk > arjw hjhijrs sustm`ejn fmtmk elur`js. gj rjhm`e`eo 1 pmssjeojrssustm`ejn sjr`dus elur`js men wjrj rjsaujn iy Amemn`me h`k`tmry pjrsdeejk, wgd wjrj `eYjsdkutj Imy ms pmrt df m h`k`tmry jxjra`sj. gj maa`njet daaurrjn nur`eo nmyk`ogt gdurs. Edjhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr s`oemk wms jh`ttjn iy tgj m`rarmft.
Aj rmppdrt jst àomkjhjet n`spde`ikj je frmeïm`s.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 3/215
^mikj df adetjets
=.3 Fmatumk `efdrhmt`de ................................................................................... = =.= G`stdry df tgj fk`ogt .............................................................................................................= =.9 @elur`js td pjrsdes ................................................................................................................6 =.1 Nmhmoj td m`rarmft ...............................................................................................................6 =.> Dtgjr nmhmoj .......................................................................................................................6 =.: Sjrsdeejk efdrhmt`de .........................................................................................................?
=.:.= Fk`ogt arjw ............................................................................................................................................. ? =.:.9 Fk`ogt mttjenmets ................................................................................................................................... 7 =.:.1 APYI m`r trmff`a adetrdkkjrs .................................................................................................................. 7
=.6 M`rarmft `efdrhmt`de ............................................................................................................0 =.6.= M`rarmft hm`etjemeaj ............................................................................................................................ 0 =.6.9 M`rarmft pjrfdrhmeaj .......................................................................................................................... == =.6.1 ^jrrm`e mwmrjejss njv`ajs ................................................................................................................. == =.6.> A-OE_E emv`omt`de systjhs ........................................................................................................... =9 =.6.: A-OE_E adhpmss systjhs .............................................................................................................. =1 =.6.6 Mutdp`kdt systjh ................................................................................................................................. =: =.6.? FN-=37 fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjh ............................................................................................................ =? =.6.7
Mtt`tunj n`rjatdr `en`amtdr ................................................................................................................. =7
=.6.0 Mpprdmag prdorjss n`spkmy meeuea`mtdrs ........................................................................................ =0 =.6.=3 Okdimk pds`t`de`eo systjh ................................................................................................................. =0 =.6.== Jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr .......................................................................................................... 93
=.? Hjtjdrdkdo`amk efdrhmt`de ..............................................................................................9= =.?.= Akdun aj`k`eo gj`ogt ........................................................................................................................... 9= =.?.9 Pjkkdwbe`fj wjmtgjr mt njpmrturj .................................................................................................... 9= =.?.1 Yjsdkutj Imy wjmtgjr `ssujn ijfdrj njpmrturj ............................................................................... 9= =.?.> Yjsdkutj Imy wjmtgjr ssujn wg`kj FMI6:63 wms je rdutj .......................................................... 99 =.?.: Yjsdkutj Imy wjmtgjr `ssujn mftjr tgj maa`njet .............................................................................. 99 =.?.6 Zppjr w`ens ........................................................................................................................................ 91 =.?.? _jmtgjr rjaj`vjn iy tgj arjw ........................................................................................................... 91
=.7 M`ns td emv`omt`de..............................................................................................................91 =.7.= Emv`omt`demk m`ns ................................................................................................................................ 91 =.7.9 Sdss`ikj etjrfjrjeaj w`tg Yjsdkutj Imy estruhjet kmen`eo systjh fueat`demk`ty .................. 9>
=.0 Adhhue`amt`des ................................................................................................................9> =.0.= Ojejrmk ................................................................................................................................................. 9>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 4/215
=.0.9 Mrr`vmk men mpprdmag df BIM030 ..................................................................................................... 9> =.0.1 Adhhue`amt`de sjmrag fdr FMI6:63 ................................................................................................ 9:
=.=3 Mjrdnrdhj efdrhmt`de ....................................................................................................96 =.=3.= Yjsdkutj Imy m`rpdrt ........................................................................................................................... 96 =.=3.9 Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB mnn`t`demk rjsdurajs ..................................................................................... 9? =.=3.1 Adhhue`ty mjrdnrdhj rmn`d stmt`des ............................................................................................. 9?
=.== Fk`ogt rjadrnjrs ..................................................................................................................97 =.==.= Ojejrmk ................................................................................................................................................. 97 =.==.9 Fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr ............................................................................................................................ 97 =.==.1 Adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr ....................................................................................................................... 1=
=.=9 _rjabmoj men `hpmat efdrhmt`de ..................................................................................19 =.=9.= @hpmat ................................................................................................................................................... 19 =.=9.9 _rjabmoj .............................................................................................................................................. 11
=.=1 Hjn`amk men pmtgdkdo`amk `efdrhmt`de ...........................................................................1: =.=> F`rj........................................................................................................................................1: =.=: Qurv`vmk mspjats ..................................................................................................................16
=.=:.= Yjsauj rjspdesj .................................................................................................................................. 16 =.=:.9 Jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr .......................................................................................................... 16 =.=:.1 M`rarmft daaupmet sjmts / struaturmk nmhmoj .................................................................................. 1?
=.=6 ^jsts men rjsjmrag ..............................................................................................................17 =.=? Drome`zmt`demk men hmemojhjet efdrhmt`de ..............................................................17
=.=?.= F`rst M`r................................................................................................................................................. 17 =.=?.9 Mnmptmt`des df stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs .............................................................................. >1 =.=?.1 F`rst M`r smfjty hmemojhjet systjh smfjty dvjrs`ogt prdajssjs ................................................. 63 =.=?.> F`rst M`r hjtgdns df hde`tdr`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des ......................................................................... 6: =.=?.: Dtgjr hjtgdns df hde`tdr`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des ............................................................................. 6: =.=?.6 M`r trmff`a sjrv`ajs ............................................................................................................................... 6? =.=?.? Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet .............................................................................................................. ?: =.=?.7 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet ijst prmat`ajs ..................................................................................... 7= =.=?.0 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r ........................................................................... 7? =.=?.=3 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo fma`k`tmt`de .................................................................. 03 =.=?.== Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet `estruatdr maarjn`tmt`de ........................................................... 0=
=.=7 Mnn`t`demk efdrhmt`de .....................................................................................................0= =.=7.= Ijgmv`durmk i`msjs .............................................................................................................................. 0= =.=7.9 ^jrrm`e mwmrjejss njv`ajs ................................................................................................................. 09 =.=7.1 ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn _mtagk`st ............................................................................................ 0> =.=7.> Qmfjty hmemojhjet systjhs .............................................................................................................. 0>
9.3 Memkys`s ................................................................................................... 06
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 5/215
9.= @etrdnuat`de ........................................................................................................................06 9.9 FMI6:63 mpprdmag pkmee`eo ............................................................................................06 9.1 Njsajet `e`t`mt`de men hmemojhjet ...............................................................................0? 9.> Adhpmss dpjrmt`des ..........................................................................................................07
9.>.= Gjmn`eo adhpmrmtdr ........................................................................................................................... 07 9.>.9 Adhpmss adetrdkkjrs hmoejt`a/n`rjat`demk-oyrd sjkjat`de ........................................................... 07 9.>.1 Adhpmss adetrdkkjrs gjh`spgjrj sjkjat`de ..................................................................................... 00 9.>.> Adhpmss adetrdkkjr kmt`tunj adhpjesmtdrs ..................................................................................... 00 9.>.: Yjmk prjajss`de .................................................................................................................................... 00 9.>.6 Jmrtg rmtj prjajss`de ........................................................................................................................ =33 9.>.? Jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj prjajss`de ....................................................................................................... =33 9.>.7 Srjajss`de suhhmry ......................................................................................................................... =33 9.>.0 Ed. = men ed. 9 adhpmss systjhs ijgmv`dur ................................................................................. =33 9.>.=3 Adhpmss jrrdr ................................................................................................................................... =3=
9.: @e-rmeoj agjab ..................................................................................................................=31 9.6 Emv`omt`demk hdnjs nur`eo ture detd f`emk mpprdmag ...............................................=3>
9.6.= Ojejrmk ............................................................................................................................................... =3> 9.6.9 VDY/KDA hdnj sjkjat`de mftjr ture (sajemr`d =) ........................................................................ =3> 9.6.1 VDY/KDA hdnj sjkjat`de ijfdrj ture (sajemr`d 9) ..................................................................... =3: 9.6.> Quhhmry df ture memkys`s ................................................................................................................ ==3
9.? Arjw wdrbkdmn men `etjrmat`de nur`eo ture detd f`emk mpprdmag ...........................==9 9.7
Adhpkjt`de df ture men adet`eumt`de df mpprdmag .....................................................==1
9.7.= M`rarmft stmtj mt adhpkjt`de df ture ................................................................................................ ==1 9.7.9 @e`t`mk n`vjrojeaj frdh kdamk`zjr ..................................................................................................... ==1 9.7.1 Fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de .................................................................................................................... ==: 9.7.> Od-mrduen suoojst`de ...................................................................................................................... ==6 9.7.: Mpprdmag adet`eumt`de fdkkdw`eo fukk njfkjat`de ......................................................................... ==7 9.7.6 Zestmikj mpprdmag men adet`eumt`de df mpprdmag ....................................................................... ==0 9.7.? F`emk adef`ourmt`de fdr kmen`eo ....................................................................................................... =99 9.7.7 F`emk pdrt`de df mpprdmag ................................................................................................................ =9:
9.0 Misjeaj df adetrdk trmesfjr nur`eo f`emk mpprdmag .....................................................=9? 9.=3 Mnmptmt`des men F`rst M`r I?1? stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs ..............................=97
9.=3.= Mnmptmt`des ....................................................................................................................................... =97 9.=3.9 ^rmes`t`de td `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh mpprdmag ..................................................................... =90
9.== FMI6:63 arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet ...........................................................................=13 9.==.= Ojejrmk ............................................................................................................................................... =13 9.==.9 Qgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss .......................................................................................................... =13 9.==.1 Adhhue`amt`des ............................................................................................................................... =19
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 6/215
9.==.> _drbkdmn hmemojhjet .................................................................................................................... =11 9.==.: Srdikjh sdkv`eo men nja`s`de hmb`eo ........................................................................................... =11 9.==.6 Quhhmry df FMI6:63 arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet...................................................................... =1>
9.=9 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r .......................................................=1: 9.=9.= @e`t`mk arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo................................................................................... =1: 9.=9.9 Yjaurrjet arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo ............................................................................ =1:
9.=1 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet rjoukmt`des `e Amemnm...................................................=16 9.=> Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet `estruatdr maarjn`tmt`de ................................................=1? 9.=: F`rst M`r smfjty hmemojhjet systjh `etjremk rjpdrt`eo prdajssjs ..........................=1? 9.=6 APYI `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh fueat`demk ty .........................................................=17 9.=? VDY sajemr`d ....................................................................................................................=17 9.=7 Ou`nmeaj fdr fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr hm`etjemeaj ..........................................................=17 9.=0 ^jrrm`e mwmrjejss njv`ajs ..............................................................................................=10 9.93 Qurv`vmi`k`ty .....................................................................................................................=10 9.9= ED^MH systjh ...............................................................................................................=10 9.99 APYI m`r trmff`a adetrdk ...................................................................................................=>3 9.91 M`rarmft hm`etjemeaj .......................................................................................................=>=
9.91.= M`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjs .................................................................................................................. =>= 9.91.9 Jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr ........................................................................................................ =>=
9.9>
Fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo ....................................................................................................=>9
9.9: _jmtgjr .............................................................................................................................=>9 9.96 Y`sb mssda`mtjn w`tg uestmikj mpprdmagjs ...................................................................=>1 1.3 F`en`eos ................................................................................................. =>> 1.= F`en`eos ms td amusjs men adetr`iut`eo fmatdrs............................................................=>> 1.9 F`en`eos ms td r`sb ............................................................................................................=>6 1.1 Dtgjr f`en`eos ..................................................................................................................=>? >.3 Qmfjty Mat`de .......................................................................................... =>7 >.= Qmfjty mat`de tmbje ...........................................................................................................=>7
>.=.= ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn df Amemnm ......................................................................................... =>7 >.=.9 F`rst M`r............................................................................................................................................... =:3 >.=.1 Ydymk Amemn`me M`r Fdraj ................................................................................................................ =:> >.=.> ^rmespdrt Amemnm ............................................................................................................................. =::
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 7/215
>.=.: EMV AMEMNM ................................................................................................................................. =:: >.9 Qmfjty mat`de rjqu`rjn......................................................................................................=:6
>.9.= Zestmikj mpprdmagjs......................................................................................................................... =:6 >.1
Qmfjty adeajre ...................................................................................................................=:7
>.1.= Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo stmenmrns .......................................................................... =:7
Mppjen`ajs .................................................................................................... =6= Mppjen`x M ‑ FMI6:63 sjqujeaj df jvjets ..........................................................................=6= Mppjen`x I ‑ Mpprdmag prdajnurj agmrt fdr `estruhjet mpprdmag imsjn de mrjm
emv`omt`de us`eo okdimk emv`omt`de smtjkk`tj mt Yuewmy 1: ^YZJ ...........................=6? Mppjen`x A ‑ Mpprdmag prdajnurj agmrt fdr `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh w`tg n`stmeaj
hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet mt Yuewmy 1: ^YZJ ................................................................=67 Mppjen`x N ‑ Mpprdmag pmtg df FMI6:63 ...........................................................................=60 Mppjen`x J ‑ A-OE_E adhpmss systjhs< mnn`t`demk `efdrhmt`de .................................=?3
Adhpmss trmesfjr sw`tag ............................................................................................................................. =?3 A-OE_E adhpmss systjh gjmn`eo n`str`iut`de .................................................................................... =?3 Fkux vmkvj men adhpmss adetrdkkjr ............................................................................................................ =?3 @estruhjet adhpmrmtdr ............................................................................................................................... =?= Ymn`d-hmoejt a `en`amtdr ........................................................................................................................... =?= Gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de `en`amtdr .................................................................................................................... =?9
Mppjen`x F ‑ A-OE_E mutdp`kdt systjh< mnn`t`demk efdrhmt`de ..................................=?>
Mutdp`kdt hdnj adetrdk pmejk .................................................................................................................... =?> Mutdp`kdt jeomoj sw`tagjs ......................................................................................................................... =?> Mutdp`kdt p`tag hdnj sjkjatdr .................................................................................................................... =?> Mutdp`kdt hdnj sjkjatdr .............................................................................................................................. =?> Mutdp`kdt gjmn`eo sw`tag ........................................................................................................................... =?: Adetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eo ................................................................................................................................ =?6
Mppjen`x O ‑ Adabp`t kmydut df A-OE_E ..........................................................................=?? Mppjen`x G ‑ FN-=37 fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjh< mnn`t`demk `efdrhmt`de ..............................=?7
Fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk pmejk ............................................................................................................ =?7 Fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk ∙ rdkk ............................................................................................................ =?7 Fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk ∙ p`tag ......................................................................................................... =?0 Mpprdmag prdorjss n`spkmy meeuea`mtdrs ................................................................................................ =?0
Mppjen`x @ ∙ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =691 td =611 ....................................................................=7= Mppjen`x L ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =616 td =617 ....................................................................=79 Mppjen`x B ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =617 td =6>3 ...................................................................=71
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 8/215
Mppjen`x K ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =6>3 td =6>= ...................................................................=7> Mppjen`x H ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =6>= td =6>=<>: .............................................................=7: Mppjen`x E ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =6>=<>: td =6>=<:9 ........................................................=76 Mppjen`x D ‑ Mkt`tunj men ok`nj pmtg ..................................................................................=7? Mppjen`x S ‑ Fk`ogt pmtg men kdamk`zjr .................................................................................=77 Mppjen`x ] ‑ F`rst M`r prdajnurjs fdr mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de `e HME hdnj ....................=70 Mppjen`x Y ‑ @estruhjet kmen`eo systjh etjrajpt fdr mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA hdnj .....=03 Mppjen`x Q ‑ @estruhjet kmen`eo systjh `etjrajpt fdr fk`ogt n`rjatdr `e MZ^D MSS ..=0= Mppjen`x ^ ‑ F`rst M`r adhpmss dpjrmt`eo pdk`ay men prdajnurjs fdr Edrtgjre
Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj ...........................................................................................................=09 Sdk`ay fdr dpjrmt`des e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj ............................................................................ =09 Srdajnurjs fdr ditm`e`eo truj gjmn`eo us`eo OSQ men ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade ................................. =09
Mppjen`x Z ‑ F`rst M`r mhpk`f`jn agjabk`st prdajnurjs .....................................................=0> Mhpk`f`jn prj-njsajet agjabk`st ................................................................................................................ =0> Mhpk`f`jn e-rmeoj agjabk`st ...................................................................................................................... =0> Mhpk`f`jn kmen`eo agjabk`st ....................................................................................................................... =0:
Mppjen`x V ‑ Mnn`t`demk stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs men mnmptmt`des iy F`rst M`rarjws ..................................................................................................................................=0? ^rmesfjr df adetrdk ....................................................................................................................................... =0? Kmen`eo nmtm amrn men m`rspjjn iuo sjtt`eos .......................................................................................... =0? Mkt`tunj amkkduts ........................................................................................................................................... =07 Njsajet trmes`t`de ........................................................................................................................................ =00 Adhhue`amt`des rmn`ds .............................................................................................................................. =00 =: 333-fddt men =3 333-fddt same/fkdw ...................................................................................................... =00 Mkt`tunj mkjrtjr ............................................................................................................................................. 933
Mppjen`x _ ∙ ED^MHQ ........................................................................................................939 Mppjen`x W ‑ K`st df mardeyhs men miirjv`mt`des ..............................................................93>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 9/215
- = -
=.3 Fmatumk `efdrhmt`de
=.= G`stdry df tgj fk`ogt
^gj @etjremt`demk A`v`k Mv`mt`de Drome`zmt`de (@AMD) Adevjet`de de @etjremt`demkA`v`k Mv`mt`de, Meejx =1, = rjqu`rjs Qtmtjs adenuat`eo maa`njet evjst`omt`des tdprdtjat adabp`t vd`aj rjadrn`eos. Amemnm adhpk`js w`tg tg`s rjqu`rjhjet iyhmb`eo adabp`t vd`aj rjadrn`eos pr`v`kjojn e tgj Amemn`me ^rmespdrtmt`de Maa`njet@evjst`omt`de men Qmfjty Idmrn Mat. _g`kj tgj rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn df Amemnm(^QI) hmy hmbj usj df mey de-idmrn rjadrn`eo e tgj `etjrjsts df trmespdrtmt`desmfjty, `t `s edt pjrh`ttjn td bedw`eoky adhhue`amtj mey pdrt`de df me de-idmrnrjadrn`eo tgmt s uerjkmtjn td tgj amusjs dr adetr`iut`eo fmatdrs df me maa`njet dr tdtgj njet`f`amt`de df smfjty njf`a`jea`js.
^gj rjmsde fdr prdtjat`eo adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr (AVY) hmtjr`mk k`js `e tgj prjh`sj
tgmt tgjsj prdtjat`des gjkp jesurj tgmt tg`s jssjet`mk hmtjr`mk s mvm`kmikj fdr tgjijejf`t df smfjty evjst`omt`des. gj QI gms mkwmys hjt `ts dik`omt`des e tg`s mrjmmen gms rjstr`atjn tgj usj df AVY nmtm `e `ts rjpdrts. Zekjss tgj AVY hmtjr`mk `srjqu`rjn td idtg suppdrt m f`en`eo men `njet`fy m suistmet`vj smfjty njf`a`jeay, `tw`kk edt ij `eakunjn `e tgj ^QI‐s rjpdrt.
@e tg`s rjpdrt, tgj ^QI gms hmnj jxtjes`vj usj df tgj AVY rjadrn`eo. @e jmag`estmeaj, tgj hmtjr`mk gms ijje amrjfukky jxmh`ejn td jesurj tgmt tgj jxtrmats usjnmrj rjkmtjn td tgj amusjs dr adetr`iut`eo fmatdrs df tg`s maa`njet dr td tgj`njet`f`amt`de df smfjty njf`a`jea`js.
^gj F`rst M`r Idj`eo ?1?-9=3A adhi` 9 m`rarmft njpmrtjn Pjkkdwbe`fj (AP\F), Edrtgwjst^jrr`tdr`js, mt =>>3 1 ms F`rst M`r fk`ogt 6:63 (FMI6:63) de m agmrtjr fk`ogt td Yjsdkutj Imy(APYI), Euemvut, w`tg == pmssjeojrs, > arjw hjhijrs, men frj`ogt de idmrn.
^gj estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs (@FY) fk`ogt frdh AP\F wms fk`ogt-pkmeejn td tmbj 9 gdurs men 3:h`eutjs mt >96 bedts truj m`rspjjn men m aru`sj mkt`tunj df fk`ogt kjvjk (FK) 1=3. > M`r trmff`aadetrdk (M^A) akjmrjn FMI6:63 td njst`emt`de v`m tgj fk`ogt-pkmeejn rdutj< AP\F n`rjat td tgjID^JY etjrsjat`de, tgje n`rjat td tgj Amhir`noj Imy (AI) ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade (ENI), tgjen`rjat td ?9³ E, =33³>:' _, men tgje n`rjat td APYI (F`ourj =). ^gj pkmeejn mktjremtj m`rpdrtwms Gmkk Ijmag (APZW), Euemvut. gj jst`hmtjn t`hj df mrr`vmk (J^M) mt APYI wms =6>:.
= @etjremt`demk A`v`k Mv`mt`de Drome`zmt`de, Meejx =1 td tgj Adevjet`de de @etjremt`demk A`v`kMv`mt`de, M`rarmft Maa`njet men @ea`njet @evjst`omt`de, =3tg jn`t`de (93=3), Mhjenhjet => (:.=9)
9 M adhi` m`rarmft gms m pmrt`mkky pmssjeojr men pmrt`mkky frj`ogt ami`e kmydut.
1 Mkk t`hjs mrj Addrn`emtjn Ze`vjrsmk ^`hj (Z^A) (Ajetrmk Nmyk ogt ^`hj pkus : gdurs). Z^A s usjnnuj td hukt`pkj t`hj zdejs men usmoj `e hukt`pkj nmtm sdurajs.
> Fk`ogt kjvjk (FK) 1=3 `s mpprdx`hmtjky 1= 333 fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 10/215
- 9 -
^gj amptm`e daaup`jn tgj kjft sjmt men wms njs`oemtjn ms tgj p`kdt fky`eo (SF). ^gj f`rst dff`ajr(FD) daaup`jn tgj r`ogt sjmt men wms njs`oemtjn ms tgj p`kdt edt fky`eo (SEF).
Ijfdrj njpmrturj, F`rst M`r n`spmtag prdv`njn tgj arjw w`tg me dpjrmt`demk fk`ogt pkme (DFS)tgmt eakunjn fdrjamst men disjrvjn wjmtgjr efdrhmt`de fdr AP\F, APYI, men APZW, ms wjkkms ED^MH (edt`aj td m`rhje) efdrhmt`de.
Ymnmr nmtm sgdw tgmt FMI6:63 jetjrjn tgj Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj (ENM) :3 emut`amkh`kjs (eh) edrtgjmst df AP\F, mpprdx`hmtjky mt Y@IZE wmypd`et (61³==.>' E, ==1³19.0' _) mt=>:3.
Nur`eo tgj ak`hi men mftjr kjvjk`eo mt FK1=3, tgj arjw rjaj`vjn APYI wjmtgjr upnmtjs frdh madhpmey n`spmtagjr (Mppjen`x M). gj arjw men n`spmtagjr n`saussjn njtjr`drmt eo wjmtgjraden`t`des mt APYI men wgjtgjr tgj fk`ogt sgdukn rjture td AP\F, prdajjn td tgj mktjremtjAPZW, dr adet`euj td APYI. gj arjw men n`spmtagjr ld`etky morjjn tgmt tgj fk`ogt wduknadet`euj td APYI.
F`ourj =. Ydutj hmp (`hmoj< Oddokj Jmrtg, w`tg meedtmt`des iy ^QI)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 11/215
- 1 -
Mt =6=6, tgj arjw prdormhhjn tgj okdimk pds`t`de`eo systjhs (OSQ) td prdajjn frdh tgj`raurrjet je-rdutj pds`t`de n`rjat td tgj HZQM^ etjrhjn`mtj wmypd`et de tgj YEMV (OEQQ) : Yuewmy (Y_P) 1: ^YZJ mpprdmag mt APYI (Mppjen`x I), wg`ag gmn prjv`dusky ijje kdmnjn`etd tgj OSQ ue`ts iy tgj arjw. ^gj arjw wjrj pkmee`eo td trmes`t`de td me @KQ/NHJ 6 Y_P 1:^YZJ mpprdmag (Mppjen`x A) v`m tgj HZQM^ wmypd`et.
M tjhpdrmry h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm (H^AM) gmn ijje pkmeejn, e drnjr td suppdrt me`earjmsj e m`r trmff`a mt APYI rjsukt`eo frdh m h`k`tmry jxjra`sj, Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB. ? Mh`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk ue t mt APYI wms td gmenkj m`rspmaj frdh ?33 fjjt midvj orduen kjvjk(mok) up td FK933 w`tg`e 73 eh df APYI.
Adhhjea`eo mt =699<=6, tgj FD hmnj 1 trmesh`ss`des ijfdrj jstmik`sg`eo adetmat w`tg tgj EMVAMEMNM Jnhdetde Mrjm Adetrdk Ajetrj (MAA) adetrdkkjr. Mt =691<90, tgj EMV AMEMNMJnhdetde MAA adetrdkkjr akjmrjn FMI6:63 td njsajen dut df adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj men td mnv`sjwgje kjmv`eo FK9?3. gj arjw wjrj mksd mnv`sjn td met`a`pmtj amkk`eo tgj APYI tjrh`emk adetrdkue`t mftjr kjmv`eo FK9?3, men tgmt tgjrj wdukn ij m kmyjr df ueadetrdkkjn m`rspmaj ijtwjjeFK9?3 men FK933. ^gj FD mabedwkjnojn tgj `efdrhmt`de. FMI6:63 adhhjeajn njsajet frdh
FK1=3 mt =691<>3 mt =3= eh frdh APYI.
^gj arjw `e`t`mtjn tgj prj-njsajet agjabk`st mt =69> men adhpkjtjn `t mt =69:.
Mt =696, tgj arjw mnv`sjn tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA adetrdkkjr tgmt tgjy wjrj kjmv`eoFK963. Mt =69?<30, tgj FD suisjqujetky amkkjn tgj APYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr men prdv`njn meJ^M df =6>1 men adhhue`amtjn etjet`des td adenuat m Yuewmy 1: mpprdmag. Ymn`d rjmnmi`k`tyijtwjje FMI6:63 men tgj APYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr wms pddr, men tgj APYI tjrh`emkadetrdkkjr mnv`sjn tgj arjw td try mom`e wgje m fjw h`kjs akdsjr.
Mt =690, tgj arjw adetmatjn tgj F`rst M`r mojet mt APYI de tgj adhpmey frjqujeay. ^gj arjw
mnv`sjn tgj mojet df tgj`r jst`hmtjn mrr`vmk t`hj men fujk rjqujst. ^gj arjw tgje adetmatjn tgjAPYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr mom`e, men wjrj mnv`sjn tgmt adhhue`amt`des wjrj edw ijttjr. ^gjAPYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr mnv`sjn tgmt tgj H^AM wms edt yjt dpjrmt`demk, men prdv`njn tgjmkt`hjtjr sjtt`eo men trmff`a `efdrhmt`de fdr medtgjr eiduen fk`ogt. 7 ^gj APYI tjrh`emkadetrdkkjr tgje estruatjn tgj arjw td adetmat tgj APYI tdwjr adetrdkkjr 0 mt tgj`r n`sarjt`de.^gj FD mabedwkjnojn tgj trmff`a men tgj `estruat`de td adetmat APYI tdwjr.
: @estruhjet mpprdmag imsjn de mrjm emv`omt`de (YEMV) us`eo m okdimk emv`omt`de smtjkk`tj systjh
(OEQQ)6 @estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) w`tg n`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet (NHJ)
? Mkk rjfjrjeajs td m r trmff`a sjrv`ajs mt APYI rjfjr td h`k`tmry jqu`phjet men pjrsdeejk, uekjssdtgjrw`sj stmtjn.
7 Ijjagarmft Adrpdrmt`de Hdnjk 00 m`rarmft, dpjrmt`eo ms BIM030
0 APYI ndjs edt edrhmkky gmvj m tdwjr adetrdkkjr2 tg`s adetrdk sjrv`aj wms m tjhpdrmry h k`tmryfma`k`ty `e dpjrmt`de mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 12/215
- > -
Mt =61=, tgj arjw adetmatjn tgj APYI tdwjr adetrdkkjr, wgd mnv`sjn tgjh df tgj mkt`hjtjrsjtt`eo (90.7= eagjs df hjraury R`e. GoX) men w`ens (jst`hmtjn =3 =63³ truj R^X mt =3 bedts), men`estruatjn tgjh td rjpdrt =3 eh f`emk fdr Yuewmy 1:^. ^gj arjw msbjn tgj tdwjr adetrdkkjr fdr mruewmy aden`t`de rjpdrt, men wms mnv`sjn tgmt tgj ruewmy wms m k`ttkj wjt men tgmt ed m`rarmftgmn usjn `t nur`eo tgj hdre`eo. ^gj FD mabedwkjnojn tg`s `efdrhmt`de.
^gj arjw `e`t`mtjn tgj `e-rmeoj agjabk`st mt =619 men adhpkjtjn `t mt =61?. Mt =61?, tgjy ijomeadef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft fdr mpprdmag men kmen`eo, men e`t`mtjn tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st.
Mt =617<9=, FMI6:63 adhhjeajn m kjft ture lust ijfdrj rjmag`eo HZQM^ wmypd`et. Mt tgj t`hjdf tgj ture, tgj m`rarmft wms midut 633 fjjt midvj tgj @KQ ok`njskdpj mt =7> bedts `en`amtjnm`rspjjn (B@MQ). ^gj trmab frdh HZQM^ wmypd`et td tgj tgrjsgdkn df Yuewmy 1:^ `s 1>?³^,wg`ag ad`ea`njs w`tg tgj kdamk`zjr trmab fdr tgj @KQ/NHJ Y_P 1: YZJ mpprdmag. Mftjr rdkk`eodut df tgj kjft ture, FMI6:63 prdajjnjn de m trmab df mpprdx`hmtjky 1:3³^ (Mppjen`x N).
Mt =617<19, tgj arjw rjpdrtjn =3 eh f`emk fdr Yuewmy 1:^. ^gj amptm`e amkkjn fdr tgj ojmr td ijkdwjrjn mt =617<17 men fdr fkmps =: mt =617<>9. M`rspjjn mt tgj t`hj df idtg df tgjsj amkks wms =??
B@MQ. Mt =617<10, tgj APYI tdwjr adetrdkkjr mabedwkjnojn tgj arjw‐s rjpdrt men estruatjntgjh td rjpdrt 1 eh f`emk. Mt =617<>6, tgj FD rjqujstjn tgmt tgj tdwjr rjpjmt tgj kmsttrmesh`ss`de. Mt =617<>0, tgj tdwjr rjpjmtjn tgj rjqujst td amkk 1 eh f`emk2 tgj FDmabedwkjnojn tgj amkk. Mt tg`s pd`et e tgj mpprdmag, tgj arjw gmn m kjeotgy n`sauss`de midutm`rarmft emv`omt`de (^mikj =).
^mikj =. S`kdt n`sauss`de rjomrn`eo m`rarmft emv`omt`de
=610<=1 td=610<13
FD hmbjs : stmtjhjets rjomrn`eo m`rarmft kmtjrmk n`spkmajhjet frdh njs`rjntrmab.
=610<11 td
=610<1?
Amptm`e hmbjs 9 stmtjhjets `en`amt`eo smt`sfmat`de tgmt tgj mutdp`kdt `s
trmab`eo prdpjrky.=610<>6 FD hmbjs stmtjhjet midut trmab njv`mt`de n`spkmyjn de OSQ.
=610<:? FD stmtjs tgjy mrj edt de mutd mpprdmag, lust de tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr.
=6>3<3? FD qujr`js amptm`e td adef`rh fukk njfkjat`de.
=6>3<37 Amptm`e adeaurs, men qujst`des wgy fukk njfkjat`de wgje tgjy mrj de tgjkdamk`zjr.
=6>3<== FD stmtjs tgjy mrj edt de tgj kdamk`zjr.
=6>3<=> Amptm`e stmtjs ‛@t‐s ampturjn2 tje tgrjj `s tgj kdamk`zjr4‘
=6>3<=? FD n`smorjjs de kdamk`zjr ampturj men rjh`ens tgj amptm`e midut tgj g`kk td tgjr`ogt df tgj ruewmy.
=6>3<91 FD stmtjs OSQ `s mksd sgdw`eo td tgj r`ogt.
=6>3<9: FD qujst`des amptm`e ms td wgjtgjr tgjy n`n sdhjtg`eo wrdeo.
=3 ^gj tdwjr adetrdkkjr wms rjqu`rjn td usj tgj wdrn ‛jst`hmtjn‘ wgje prdv`n`eo w`en `efdrhmt`de tdp`kdts, ijamusj tgj hdi`kj mejhdhjtjr usjn iy APYI m`r trmff`a adetrdk (M^A) n`n edt hjjt tgjgj`ogt-midvj-orduen stmenmrn fdr mejhdhjtjrs.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 13/215
- : -
=6>3<13 FD stmtjs dp`e`de tgmt tgjy sgdukn mimende tgj mpprdmag men tgje sdkvj tgjemv`omt`demk prdikjh.
=6>3<11 Amptm`e `en`amtjs tgmt gj pkmes td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag.
=6>3<1: FD mabedwkjnojs amptm`e‐s pkme td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag.
Mt =6>3<16, FMI6:63 njsajenjn tgrduog =333 fjjt midvj f`jkn jkjvmt`de. Ijtwjje =6>3<>= men=6>=<==, tgj amptm`e `ssujn `estruat`des td adhpkjtj tgj adef`ourmt`de fdr kmen`eo, men tgj FDhmnj sjvjrmk stmtjhjets rjomrn`eo m`rarmft emv`omt`de men adrrjat`vj mat`de. Mt =6>=<13, tgjarjw rjpdrtjn 1 eh f`emk fdr Yuewmy 1:^. ^gj APYI tdwjr adetrdkkjr mnv`sjn tgmt tgj w`enwms edw jst`hmtjn td ij =:3³^ mt ? bedts, akjmrjn FMI6:63 td kmen Yuewmy 1:^, men mnnjn tgjtjrh ‛agjab ojmr ndwe‘ ms rjqu`rjn iy tgj EMV AMEMNM M`r ^rmff`a Adetrdk Hmeumk dfDpjrmt`des (M^A HMEDSQ) Amemn`me Fdrajs Quppkjhjet (AF M^A Qup) Mrt`akj 1>>.1. ==
FMI6:63‐s rjspdesj td tgj tdwjr (=6>=<10) wms aut dff, men tgj tdwjr rjqujstjn tgj arjw td smymom`e. gjrj wms ed furtgjr adhhue`amt de w`tg tgj fk`ogt. gj tdwjr adetrdkkjr n`n edt gmvjv`sumk adetmat w`tg FMI6:63 mt mey t`hj. ^mikj 9 `en`amtjs tgj jvjets de f`emk mpprdmag.
^mikj 9. Jvjets de f`emk mpprdmag
=6>=<>=.= FD stmtjs ‛Lust dvjr tgj sgdrjk`ej.‘
=6>=<>6 S`tag ijo`es td `earjmsj frdh ∙:³
=6>=<>6.6 FD amkks amptm`e iy f`rst emhj2 stmtjs ‛@ nde‐t k`bj tg`s.‘
=6>=<>?.? OS_Q< ‛Q`eb rmtj‘
=6>=<>0.3 FD stmtjs ‛Od fdr `t.‘
=6>=<>0.9 OS_Q< ‛H`e`huhs‘
=6>=<:3.= FD stmtjs ‛Od mrduen.‘
=6>=<:3.? OS_Q< ‛H`e`huhs‘=6>=<:=.9 Amptm`e amkks ‛Od-mrduen tgrust.‘
OS_Q< orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh
Mt =6>=<:=.7, ms tgj arjw wjrj e`t`mt`eo m od-mrduen, FMI6:63 adkk`njn w`tg tjrrm`e midut = ehjmst df tgj h`npd`et df tgj APYI ruewmy. ^gj maa`njet daaurrjn nur`eo nmyk`ogt gdurs men wmskdamtjn mt ?>³>9':?.1" E, 0>³::'>.3" _, mt 106 fjjt midvj hjme sjm kjvjk.
^gj > arjw hjhijrs men 7 pmssjeojrs wjrj fmtmkky elurjn. grjj pmssjeojrs surv`vjn tgjmaa`njet men wjrj rjsaujn frdh tgj s`tj iy Amemn`me h`k`tmry pjrsdeejk, wgd wjrj e APYI
pmrt`a`pmt`eo `e Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB. ^gj surv`vdrs wjrj suisjqujetky jvmaumtjn frdh APYIde m Amemn`me Fdrajs AA-=?? m`rarmft.
== ^gj Amemn`me Fdrajs usj tgj EMV AMEMNM M`r ^rmff`a Adetrdk Hmeumk df Dpjrmt`des (M^AHMEDSQ) fdr tgj adenuat df m`r trmff`a sjrv`ajs. Mnn`t`demkky, tgjy jhpkdy tgj Amemn`me FdrajsQuppkjhjet td M^A HMEDSQ (AF M^A Qup) fdr mey n`ffjrjeajs tgmt pjrtm`e td spja`f`a h`k`tmryprdajnurjs.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 14/215
- 6 -
=.9 @elur`js td pjrsdes
^mikj 1. @elur`js td pjrsdes
Arjw Smssjeojrs Dtgjrs ^dtmk
Fmtmk > 7 ∙ =9
Qjr`dus ∙ 1 ∙ 1
H`edr/edej ∙ ∙ ∙ ∙
^dtmk > == ∙ =:
=.1 Nmhmoj td m`rarmft
^gj orduen samrs mt tgj e`t`mk hpmat kdamt`de wjrj ades`stjet w`tg adetmat df tgj VGF (vjryg`og frjqujeay) ed. 9 metjeem, =9 edsj-ojmr ormvjk njfkjatdr, kjft men r`ogt hm`e kmen`eo ojmr,
men kjft men r`ogt jeo`ejs. gjrj wms ed njir`s dr`o`emt`eo frdh tgj fusjkmoj, sd tgj fusjkmojk`bjky n`n edt adetmat tgj orduen mt tgj `e`t`mk `hpmat. ^gj fdraj df tgj `e`t`mk `hpmat wmssuff`a`jet td amusj tgj sjpmrmt`de df tgj jeo`ejs men hm`e kmen`eo ojmr.
Mftjr tgj e`t`mk hpmat, tgj m`rarmft adet`eujn de m imkk`st`a trmljatdry =1 `e akdsj prdx`h`ty td tgjorduen, ijfdrj adetmat`eo tgj orduen m sjaden t`hj midut 633 fjjt frdh tgj e`t`mk hpmat. Mftjrtg`s sjaden hpmat, tgj m`rarmft struaturj wms jxtjes`vjky irdbje up, men sjpmrmtjn etd 1 hm`esjat`des men euhjrdus shmkkjr njir`s p`jajs.
^gj deky f`rj nmhmoj disjrvjn wms td tgj ajetrj fusjkmoj men w`eos, wgjrj tgjrj wms m sjvjrjpdst-armsg f`rj. gj m`rarmft wms njstrdyjn iy tgj hpmat fdrajs men tgj jesu`eo pdst-armsg f`rj.
=.> Dtgjr nmhmoj
Mpprdx`hmtjky 906 k`trjs df fujk wjrj rjadvjrjn frdh tgj kjft w`eo tmeb nur`eo tgj de-s`tj`evjst`omt`de. Ed fujk rjhm`ejn e tgj r`ogt w`eo tmeb nuj td tgj pdst-armsg f`rj. gj fujkrjhm`e`eo mt hpmat wms amkaukmtjn imsjn de tgj edh`emk tmeb ampma`t`js, rjfujkk`eo rjadrns,men fk`ogt pkme rjadrns. Imsjn de tgjsj amkaukmt`des, tgj tdtmk mhduet df fujk sp`kkjn men/driurejn ms m rjsukt df tgj daaurrjeaj wms jst`hmtjn td ij 7==7 k`trjs.
=9 ^gj VGF (vjry g`og frjqujeay) ed. 9 metjeem `s kdamtjn mt idny stmt`de ???, de tgj idttdh ajetjrk`ejdf tgj fusjkmoj.
=1 M imkk st`a trmljatdry s tgj trmljatdry trmajn mftjr tgj prdpuks`vj fdraj s tjrh`emtjn men tgj idny `smatjn upde deky iy ormv`ty men mjrdnyemh`a nrmo (N`at`demry df H`k`tmry men Mssda`mtjn ^jrhs,Suik`amt`de LS =-39, Ze`tjn Qtmtjs (ZQ) Njpmrthjet df Njfjeaj R933:X).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 15/215
- ? -
=.: Sjrsdeejk `efdrhmt`de
=.:.= Fk`ogt arjw
Imsjn de mvm`kmikj rjadrns, tgj p`kdts wjrj ajrt`f`jn men qumk`f`jn fdr tgj fk`ogt `e maadrnmeajw`tg jx`st`eo rjoukmt`des.
^mikj >. Fk`ogt arjw `efdrhmt`de
Amptm`e F`rst dff`ajr
S`kdt k`ajeajM`rk`ej trmespdrtp`kdt k`ajeaj
M`rk`ej trmespdrtp`kdt k`ajeaj
Hjn`amk jxp`ry nmtj 3= Edvjhijr 93== 3= Hmy 93=9
^dtmk fky`eo gdurs =9 0=3 >7>7
Gdurs de typj :933 =31
Gdurs kmst ? nmys 93 =3Gdurs kmst 13 nmys >: :7
Gdurs kmst 03 nmys =3: =31
Gdurs de typj kmst 03 nmys =3: =31
Gdurs de nuty ijfdrj daaurrjeaj 1 1
Gdurs dff nuty ijfdrj wdrb pjr`dn == 7:
=.:.=.= Amptm`e
^gj amptm`e wms g`rjn iy F`rst M`r `e Hmrag =006 ms me FD de tgj nj Gmv`kkmen Amemnm K`h`tjn
NGA-6 ^w`e Dttjr. @e Fjirumry =007, tgj amptm`e wms mwmrnjn me FD pds`t`de de tgj GmwbjrQ`nnjkjy GQ-?>7, men `e Datdijr =000, wms hdvjn up td me FD pds`t`de de tgj Idj`eo ?1?(I?1?). ^gj amptm`e fkjw ms me FD de tgj I?1? uet`k Hmy 9337, wgje prdhdtjn td m amptm`epds`t`de.
Nur`eo tgj =: yjmrs df jhpkdyhjet mt F`rst M`r, tgj amptm`e om`ejn jxpjr`jeaj fky`eo `e tgjMrat`a men wms fmh`k`mr w`tg ueadetrdkkjn m`rspmaj dpjrmt`des mt Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI). gjamptm`e rjaj`vjn e`t`mk arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet (AYH) trm`e`eo e Fjirumry =00?2 tgjamptm`e‐s kmst rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo wms adhpkjtjn e Edvjhijr 93=3.
Nur`eo tgj ?9 gdurs ijfdrj tgj maa`njet, tgj amptm`e wms de fk`ogt stmtus. Gj gmn m nuty pjr`dn
df ? gdurs de =? Muoust, fdkkdwjn iy =6.: gdurs df rjst. De =7 Muoust, gj gmn m nuty pjr`dn dfejmrky =9 gdurs fdkkdwjn iy =? gdurs df rjst, men de =0 Muoust, gj gmn m nuty pjr`dn df :.:gdurs fdkkdwjn iy == gdurs df rjst ijfdrj rjpdrt`eo fdr nuty de 93 Muoust. Fmt`ouj wms edtades`njrjn m adetr`iut`eo fmatdr.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 16/215
- 7 -
=.:.=.9 F`rst dff`ajr
^gj FD wms g`rjn iy F`rst M`r `e Qjptjhijr 933? ms me FD de tgj Mv`des nj trmespdrt rào`demkM^Y->9. @e Muoust 9330, tgj FD wms mwmrnjn m amptm`e pds`t`de de tgj M^Y->9. @e Luej 93==,tgj FD wms hdvjn up td me FD pds`t`de de tgj I?1?. Nur`eo tgj > yjmrs df jhpkdyhjet mt F`rstM`r, tgj FD om`ejn jxpjr`jeaj fky`eo kmroj m`rarmft `e tgj Mrat`a. Ijfdrj ij`eo g`rjn iy F`rst M`r,
tgj FD wms jhpkdyjn iy medtgjr adhhjra`mk dpjrmtdr `e AP\F fky`eo vmr`dus shmkk m`rarmft.^gj FD rjaj`vjn e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo e Qjptjhijr 933?2 tgj FD‐s kmst rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eowms adhpkjtjn `e Hmrag 93==.
^gj FD wms dff nuty nur`eo tgj ?9 gdurs ijfdrj 93 Muoust2 fmt`ouj wms edt ades`njrjn madetr`iut`eo fmatdr.
=.:.9 Fk`ogt mttjenmets
Maadrn`eo td tgj rjadrns prdv`njn iy tgj dpjrmtdr, idtg fk`ogt mttjenmets wjrj mpprdpr`mtjkytrm`ejn, men mkk qumk`f`amt`des wjrj aurrjet e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj mpprdvjn adhpmey trm`e`eo
prdormh. ^gj rjst sagjnukjs df idtg fk`ogt mttjenmets hjt adhpmey men rjoukmtdryrjqu`rjhjets.
=.:.1 APYI m`r trmff`a adetrdkkjrs
=.:.1.= ^jrh`emk adetrdkkjr
^gj h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm (H^AM) adetrdkkjr gmn ijje jhpkdyjn ms m adetrdkkjr e tgjh`k`tmry fdr 1 yjmrs. ^gj adetrdkkjr hjt mkk trm`e`eo men qumk`f`amt`de rjqu`rjhjets e maadrnmeajw`tg Amemn`me Fdrajs Mnh`e`strmt`vj Drnjr 0-=7 (m`r trmff`a adetrdk RM^AX k`ajes`eo).@estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs (@FY) ajrt`f`amt`de wms mttm`ejn e 9337. gj adetrdkkjr gmn ijje de nutys`eaj =933. ^gj adetrdkkjr gmn edt ijje de nuty nur`eo tgj prjv`dus ?9 gdurs. Fmt`ouj wms edt
ades`njrjn me `ssuj.
=.:.1.9 ^dwjr adetrdkkjr
^gj tdwjr adetrdkkjr gmn ijje jhpkdyjn ms m adetrdkkjr `e tgj h`k`tmry fdr =3 hdetgs. ^gjadetrdkkjr hjt mkk trm`e`eo men qumk`f`amt`de rjqu`rjhjets e maadrnmeaj w`tg Amemn`me FdrajsMnh`e`strmt`vj Drnjr 0-=7 (M^A k`ajes`eo). V`sumk fk`ogt rukjs (VFY) ajrt`f`amt`de wms mttm`ejn`e Njajhijr 93=3. gj adetrdkkjr rjaj`vjn ir`jf`eo men tjst`eo de tgj APYI kdamk prdajnurjsijfdrj adhhjea`eo dpjrmt`des. gj adetrdkkjr n`n edt gmvj, men wms edt rjqu`rjn td gmvj, me@FY adetrdk ajrt`f`amt`de. gj adetrdkkjr gmn ijje de nuty s`eaj =933. @e tgj prjv`dus ?9 gdurs,tgj adetrdkkjr gmn ijje de nuty fdr m tdtmk df =7 gdurs. Fmt`ouj wms edt ades`njrjn me ssuj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 17/215
- 0 -
=.6 M`rarmft `efdrhmt`de
^mikj :. M`rarmft `efdrhmt`de
Hmeufmaturjr ^gj Idj`eo Adhpmey
^ypj men hdnjk ?1?-9=3A
Pjmr df hmeufmaturj =0?:
Qjr`mk ed. 9=36?
Ajrt`f`amtj df m`rwdrtg`ejss `ssuj nmtj 36 Hmrag 9331
Ajrt`f`amtj df rjo`strmt`de `ssuj nmtj 97 Mpr`k 9336
Yjo`stjrjn td Irmnkjy M`r Qjrv`ajs K`h`tjn
^rmnj emhj usjn (nd`eo ius`ejss ms) F`rst M`r
^dtmk m`rfrmhj t`hj 76 =03 gdurs (mpprdx`hmtj)
Jeo`ej typj (ed.) Srmtt & _g`tejy L^7N-=? (9)
Hmx`huh mkkdwmikj tmbj-dff wj`ogt ==0 :33 pduens
=.6.= M`rarmft hm`etjemeaj
=.6.=.= Ojejrmk
F`rst M`r Hm`etjemeaj Qjrv`ajs s tgj dpjrmtdr‐s pr`hmry prdv`njr df m`rarmft hm`etjemeajsjrv`ajs. @t `s dwejn men dpjrmtjn iy F`rst M`r uenjr m sjpmrmtj mpprdvjn hm`etjemeajdrome`zmt`de ajrt`f`amtj. gj daaurrjeaj m`rarmft (A-OE_E) wms td ij hm`etm`ejn e maadrnmeajw`tg tgj hm`etjemeaj prdormh mpprdvjn iy rmespdrt Amemnm (^A). ^gj dpjrmtdr‐shm`etjemeaj adetrdk hmeumk s tgj ndauhjet usjn td hpkjhjet tgj prdormh. Dtgjr tgme tgj 9m`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjs (MNs) hjet`dejn ijkdw, tgjrj wjrj ed dtgjr n`sarjpmea`js w`tg tgj
hm`etjemeaj prdormh.
MNs mrj `estruat`des tgmt spja`fy spja`mk espjat`des, adhpdejet rjpkmajhjets, dr hdn`f`amt`destgmt mrj rjqu`rjn td jesurj tgj adet`eu`eo m`rwdrtg`ejss df m`rarmft. MNs mrj ssujn wgjejxpjr`jeaj rjvjmks m fueat`demk dr struaturmk gmzmrn mffjat`eo fk`ogt smfjty tgmt rjqu`rjs`hhjn`mtj mttjet`de. MNs mrj ssujn iy tgj a`v`k mv`mt`de mutgdr`ty. @e Amemnm, tgjy mrj `ssujniy ^A, wg`ag stmtjs tgj fdkkdw`eo< =>
Adhpk`meaj w`tg MNs `s jssjet`mk td m`rwdrtg`ejss. Sursumet td Amemn`me Mv`mt`deYjoukmt`des (AMY) 63:.7>, m`rarmft dwejrs mrj rjspdes`ikj fdr jesur`eo tgmt tgj`rm`rarmft mrj edt fkdwe w`tg mey MNs dutstmen`eo mom`est tgmt m`rarmft, ts jeo`ejs,prdpjkkjrs dr dtgjr tjhs df jqu`phjet. …_gje adhpk`meaj w`tg me MN `s edt
hjt, tgj fk`ogt mutgdr`ty `s edt `e jffjat men tgj m`rarmft `s edt ades`njrjn td ijm`rwdrtgy.
=> ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =>1?= ∙ ^rmespdrt Amemnm Mjrdemut`amk @efdrhmt`de Hmeumk (^A M@H), KYM ∙K`ajes`eo, Yjo`strmt`de men M`rwdrtg`ejss (=? Datdijr 93=1), sjat`de :.?, mvm`kmikj mtgttp<//www.ta.oa.am/hjn`m/ndauhjets/am-puik`amt`des/KYM-M@H-93=1-9TJEO-0.pnf (kmstmaajssjn de 30 Njajhijr 93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 18/215
- =3 -
^gj fk`ogt mutgdr`ty pjrtm`e`eo td tgj daaurrjeaj m`rarmft wms tgj ajrt`f`amtj df m`rwdrtg`ejss.
@t s tgj rjspdes`i`k`ty df tgj dpjrmtdr td rjv`jw men jvmkumtj MNs. Mkk m`rarmft-/adhpdejet-rjkmtjn MNs, wgjtgjr n`rjat`eo dej-t`hj deky, rjpjt`t`vj dr tjrh`emt`eo mat`de, mrj jetjrjn etgj adhpmeys hm`etjemeaj prdormh sdftwmrj. gj dpjrmtdr tgje njvjkdps sjrv`aj hm`etjemeaj
prdajnurjs men sjrv`aj hm`etjemeaj mat`des, men adhpkjtjs tgj wdrb de tgj m`rarmft.
^gj ^QI rjv`jwjn tgj daaurrjeaj m`rarmft rjadrns fdr tgj pjr`dn df 37 Njajhijr 9337 td 93Muoust 93==. M k`st df tgj MNs mppk`amikj td tgj daaurrjeaj m`rarmft wms rjtr`jvjn frdh tgj ^A_ji s`tj. ^g`s k`st wms adhpmrjn td tgj MNs rjadrnjn `e tgj m`rarmft kdoiddbs, men mkk mppk`amikjMNs wjrj rjadrnjn ms adhpkjtjn.
Quisjqujet evjst`omt`de rjvjmkjn tgmt edt mkk rjqu`rjn mat`des wjrj adhpkjtjn fdr 9 MNs.
=.6.=.9 M`rwdrtg`ejss N`rjat`vj 933>-=0-=3
M`rwdrtg`ejss N`rjat`vj (MN) 933>-=0-=3 rjqu`rjn espjat`de df tgj gdr`zdetmk stmi`k`zjr dutjrmen eejr p`vdt g`eoj p`es fdr adrrds`de dr armab`eo. Fm`kurj df tgj dutjr men eejr g`eoj p`esadukn mkkdw tgj p`es td h`ormtj dut df tgj ld`et men rjsukt e etjrh`ttjet hdvjhjet df tgjgdr`zdetmk stmi`k`zjr struaturj men adesjqujet kdss df adetrdkkmi`k ty df tgj m`rarmft.
Ms m rjsukt df m rjadrns mun`t adenuatjn iy tgj dpjrmtdr `e Qjptjhijr 93=9, `t wms njtjrh`ejntgmt edt mkk df tgj espjat`de rjqu`rjhjets df MN 933>-=0-=3 gmn ijje adhpkjtjn. gj sjrv`ajhm`etjemeaj prdajnurj arjmtjn td adhpky w`tg tgj MN n`n edt adetm`e suff`a`jet efdrhmt`de tdmaadhpk`sg mkk df tgj MN rjqu`rjhjets.
^gjrj wjrj ed medhmk`js jetjrjn etd tgj m`rarmft kdoiddbs tgmt wdukn en`amtj n`ff`aukt`js w`tgtgj adetrdkkmi`k`ty df tgj m`rarmft. Q`h`kmrky, tgjrj wjrj ed en`amt`des df p`tag adetrdk prdikjhs`njet`f`jn e tgj fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr (FNY) fdr tgj daaurrjeaj fk`ogt.
=.6.=.1 M`rwdrtg`ejss N`rjat`vj 9336-=9-91
MN 9336-=9-91 rjqu`rjn espjat`de df tgj jkjvmtdr tmi trm`k`eo-jnoj frjj pkmy. gj MN mkkdwjnfdr m ajrtm`e mhduet df frjj pkmy, iut `f tgj `espjat`de rjvjmkjn frjj pkmy `e jxajss df tgj mkkdwjntdkjrmeaj, tgj rjpm`r hust ij adhpkjtjn ijfdrj furtgjr fk`ogt.
M njfjrrjn hm`etjemeaj `tjh (NH@) `s me m`rarmft njfjat tgmt `s edt df me m`rwdrtgy emturj men `sedt adetm`ejn e tgj h`e`huh jqu`phjet k`st dr tgj adef`ourmt`de njv`mt`de k`st. Quag m njfjathmy ij njfjrrjn `e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj NH@ prdajnurj adetm`ejn e tgj hm`etjemeaj adetrdk
hmeumk. =: ^gj NH@s mrj adetrdkkjn us`eo sjr`mk`zjn NH@ amrns men trmabjn `e tgj hm`etjemeajprdormh sdftwmrj. gj m`rarmft gmn > NH@s dutstmen`eo de tgj nmy df tgj daaurrjeaj.
=: F`rst M`r Hm`etjemeaj Adetrdk Hmeumk, Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (97 Fjirumry 93==), Agmptjr 6.1 ∙Zesagjnukjn Hm`etjemeaj men Njfjat Adetrdk
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 19/215
- == -
^gj ^QI n`sadvjrjn tgmt 9 df tgj NH@s rjkmtjn td tgj rjpjt`t`vj jkjvmtdr tmi trm`k`eo-jnoj frjj-pkmy agjab rjqu`rjn iy MN 9336-=9-91. Idtg NH@s njsar`ijn frjj pkmy e jxajss df tgj tdkjrmeajsmkkdwjn iy tgj MN, men tgjrjfdrj sgdukn edt gmvj ijje njfjrrjn. Idtg NH@s wjrj arjmtjn de 9?
Luky 93==, w`tg mss`oejn rjat`f`amt`de k`h`ts df =93 nmys. gj nuj nmtj df 9? Edvjhijr 93== gmnedt yjt ijje rjmagjn. gjrjfdrj, tgj NH@s wjrj st`kk dpje.
^gjrj wjrj ed medhmk`js jetjrjn etd tgj m`rarmft kdoiddbs tgmt wdukn en`amtj n`ff`aukt`js w`tgtgj adetrdkkmi`k`ty df tgj m`rarmft. Q`h`kmrky, tgjrj wjrj ed en`amt`des df p`tag adetrdk prdikjhs`njet`f`jn e tgj FNY nmtm fdr tgj daaurrjeaj fk`ogt.
=.6.9 M`rarmft pjrfdrhmeaj
=.6.9.= _j`ogt men ajetrj df ormv`ty
^gj m`rarmft wj`ogt men ajetrj df ormv`ty wjrj w`tg`e tgj prjsar`ijn k`h`ts. ^gj m`rarmft wmsij`eo dpjrmtjn w`tg`e pjrfdrhmeaj k`h`tmt`des de njpmrturj frdh AP\F men fdr tgj pkmeejnkmen`eo e Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI).
=.6.9.9 M`rspjjn k`h`tmt`des
^gj hmx`huh m`rspjjn k`h`t fdr jxtjes`de df tgj kmen`eo ojmr (ormvjk-jqu`ppjn) s =73 bedts`en`amtjn m`rspjjn (B@MQ). M`rspjjn k`h`ts fdr tgj fkmps mrj ms fdkkdws<
• Fkmps = ‑ 913 B@MQ
• Fkmps : ‑ 99: B@MQ
• Fkmps =: ‑ =0: B@MQ
• Fkmps 9: ‑ =03 B@MQ
• Fkmps 13 ‑ =7: B@MQ
• Fkmps >3 ‑ =?3 B@MQ
=.6.1 ^jrrm`e mwmrjejss njv`ajs
^gj m`rarmft wms jqu`ppjn w`tg m Quenstrmen Nmtm Adetrdk @eadrpdrmtjn Hmrb @@ =6 orduenprdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh (OS_Q). ^g`s `s me dknjr-ojejrmt`de OS_Q tgmt `s imsjn de =0?3stjagedkdoy. g`s systjh prdv`njs murmk men v`sumk wmre`eos men/dr mkjrts f spja`f`jnaden`t`des rjkmt`eo td tgj fdkkdw`eo pmrmhjtjrs jx`st<
• imrdhjtr`a njsajet rmtj2
• tjrrm`e akdsurj rmtj2• mkt`tunj kdss mftjr tmbj-dff dr od-mrduen2
• tjrrm`e akjmrmeaj (wgje edt e tgj kmen`eo adef`ourmt`de)2
=6 ^g`s orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh (OS_Q) wms `e`t`mkky hmeufmaturjn iy Ze`tjn Nmtm Adetrdks2tgj njs`oe dwejrsg`p edw rjs`njs w`tg Gdejywjkk Mjrdspmaj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 20/215
- =9 -
• njv`mt`de ijkdw ok`njskdpj.
^gj systjh usjs efdrhmt`de frdh tgj amptm`e‐s rmn`d mkt`hjtjr td njtjrh`ej tgj m`rarmft‐s gj`ogtmidvj tjrrm`e. g`s fueat`de deky prdv`njs m wmre`eo fdr tjrrm`e n`rjatky ijkdw tgj m`rarmft menedt fdr tjrrm`e e frdet df tgj m`rarmft. _gje tgj amptm`e‐s rmn`d mkt`hjtjr s edpjrmt`vj, mkkhdnjs df tgj OS_Q mrj edpjrmt`vj. _gje tgj m`rarmft s adef`ourjn fdr kmen`eo, tgj tdkjrmeaj
k`h`t fdr tgj smfjty wmre`eos s njsjes`t`zjn td prjvjet eu`smeaj wmre`eos ms tgj m`rarmftmpprdmagjs tgj orduen fdr kmen`eo.
A-OE_E wms adef`ourjn fdr kmen`eo wgje tgj f`rst OS_Q murmk mkjrt, ‛s`eb rmtj‘, wms ssujnmt >.= sjadens ijfdrj `hpmat. Mt 9.6 sjadens ijfdrj hpmat, tgj murmk mkjrt ‛h`e`huhs…h`e`huhs‘ wms `ssujn.
Gmn A-OE_E rjhm`ejn e sjrv`aj, m ejwjr-ojejrmt`de OS_Q wdukn gmvj ijje estmkkjnnur`eo tgj ejxt A agjab. =? g`s agjab wms edt nuj fdr mpprdx`hmtjky =703 fk`ogt gdurs. Qjat`de=.=7.9.9 njsar`ijs tgj jegmeajn OS_Q stmenmrn.
=.6.> A-OE_E emv`omt`de systjhs
=.6.>.= VGF emv`omt`de systjh
_gje tgj rjaj`vjrs mrj dpjrmt`eo, tgj VGF emv`omt`de systjh prdv`njs efdrhmt`de midutm`rarmft pds`t`de w`tg rjspjat td, men njv`mt`de frdh, m sjkjatjn VGF dhe`n`rjat`demk rmeoj(VDY) adursj, dr kdamk`zjr men ok`njskdpj mpprdmag ijmhs.
^gj VGF emv`omt`de (EMV) sjkjatdr sw`tag =7 wms m kdab`eo tdookj typj sw`tag w`tg 1 pds`t`des<AMS^ DE MZW, EDYHMK, men F/D DE MZW. _gje tgj VGF EMV sjkjatdr sw`tag `s sjt tdEDYHMK, VGF EMV rjaj`vjr ed. = `s adetrdkkjn iy adetrdk pmejk ed. =, men prdv`njs s`oemks tdtgj mutdp`kdt systjh2 td tgj amptm`e‐s fk`ogt n`rjatdr, gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de en`amtdr (GQ@),mtt`tunj n`rjatdr en`amtdr (MN@), men rmn`d-hmoejt`a en`amtdr (YH@)2 men td tgj FD‐s [email protected] EMV rjaj`vjr ed. 9 `s adetrdkkjn iy adetrdk pmejk ed. 9, men prdv`njs s`oemks td tgj FD‐sfk`ogt n`rjatdr, GQ@, MN@ men YH@, men td tgj amptm`e‐s YH@. VGF EMV rjaj`vjr ed. 1 `s `estmeniy men edt adetrdkkjn.
=.6.>.9 Mutdhmt`a n`rjat`de f`enjrs
^gj m`rarmft wms jqu`ppjn w`tg 9 mutdhmt`a n`rjat`de f`en`eo (MNF) systjhs. Me MNF systjhjemikjs mutdhmt`a njtjrh`emt`de df hmoejt`a men rjkmt`vj ijmr`eos td tgj sjkjatjnede-n`rjat`demk ijmade (ENI). gj ed. = rjaj`vjr usjs tgj emrrdw pd`etjr de tgj YH@s, men tgjed. 9 rjaj`vjr usjs tgj w`nj pd`etjr. ^gj mun`d `s gjmrn iy us`eo tgj MNF rjaj`vjr adetrdk de
tgj mun`d sjkjatdr pmejk. MNF ijmr`eo pd`etjrs w`kk edt n`spkmy adrrjat hmoejt`a ijmr`eo wgjetgj adhpmss efdrhmt`de s kdst dr `evmk`n. Yjkmt`vj ijmr`eos mrj en`amtjn iy tgj pd`etjrs f tgjrjaj`vjr s dpjrmt`eo.
=? A agjab rjfjrs td m hmldr hm`etjemeaj `espjat`de sagjnukjn jvjry >333 fk`ogt gdurs.
=7 ^g`s sw tag `s kdamtjn de tgj amptm`e‐s s`nj df tgj dvjrgjmn pmejk.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 21/215
- =1 -
=.6.>.1 Mstrd adhpmss
M`rarmft rjadrns sgdw tgmt A-OE_E wms jqu`ppjn w`tg me mstrd adhpmss, wg`ag wms stdwjn`e tgj adabp`t.
=.6.: A-OE_E adhpmss systjhs
=.6.:.= Ojejrmk
^gj adhpmss systjhs mrj pr`hmr`ky njs`oejn td fure`sg tgj amptm`e men FD w`tg efdrhmt`deadeajre`eo tgj m`rarmft‐s hmoejt`a dr truj gjmn`eo nur`eo tgj fk`ogt. Gjmn`eo efdrhmt`de sn`spkmyjn de tgj m`rarmft‐s YH@ men GQ@ adhpmss amrns.
A-OE_E wms hmeufmaturjn men njk`vjrjn iy Idj`eo td tgj dr`o`emk austdhjr w`tg 9 QpjrryA-0 adhpmssjs tgmt dpjrmtjn deky e hmoejt`a skmvjn hdnj. ^gj m`rarmft wms suisjqujetkymaqu`rjn iy m Amemn`me dpjrmtdr `e =077, men tgj adhpmss systjhs wjrj upormnjn td m QpjrryA-==I iy _jstjre Mv`de`as. gj A-==I adhpmss systjh s m oyrdsadp`amkky stmi`k`zjn systjh
tgmt dpjrmtjs j`tgjr ms m frjj n`rjat`demk oyrd (NO), dr ms m skmvjn oyrd `e hmoejt`a hdnj,njpjen`eo de tgj NO/HMO (hmoejt`a) sw`tag pds`t`de sjkjatjn iy tgj p`kdts de tgj adhpmssadetrdkkjr. gj adhpmss systjhs mrj adhpr`sjn df NOs (sjat`de =.6.:.9), fkux vmkvjs, adhpmssadetrdkkjrs, m adhpmss trmesfjr sw`tag, estruhjet adhpmrmtdrs, YH@s, men GQ@s (Mppjen`x J).
^gj upormnj jemikjn tgj adhpmssjs td dpjrmtj `e frjj oyrd, dr NO hdnj, wg`ag `s ejajssmry `eAmemn`me Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj (ENM) ijamusj tgj prdx`h`ty df tgj edrtg hmoejt`a pdkjrjsukts e hmoejt`a adhpmss uerjk`mi`k`ty. gjrj `s ed suppkjhjetmk typj ajrt`f`amtj mssda`mtjnw`tg tg`s hdn`f`amt`de2 adesjqujetky, ed m`rarmft fk`ogt hmeumk suppkjhjet wms prdnuajn. gjhdn`f`amt`de wms ndauhjetjn w`tg m Ze`tjn Qtmtjs (ZQ) Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`de(FMM) Fdrh 11?. =0
^gj m`rarmft wms suisjqujetky maqu`rjn iy F`rst M`r. gj adhpmss hm`etjemeaj prdormh amrr`jndut iy F`rst M`r wms ms njtm`kjn `e tgj Idj`eo hm`etjemeaj pkmee`eo ndauhjet N6-=?:0>-=,pmoj 6.
Yjv`jw df A-OE_E hm`etjemeaj rjadrns frdh 3: Njajhijr 93=3 td tgj daaurrjeaj nmtjrjvjmkjn tgmt tgjrj wms deky = njf`a`jeay rjkmtjn td tgj adhpmss systjhs, `eakun`eo tgj NOs. De30 Fjirumry 93==, tgj ed. 9 adhpmss en`amtdr wms njet`f`jn ms edpjrmt`vj, men tgj en`amtdrwms rjpkmajn.
=.6.:.9 N`rjat`demk oyrds
^gj A-==I adhpmss systjh eakunjs NO pmrt ed. 9:77139-=, wg`ag s spja`f`jn td gmvj kmt`tunj-adrrjatjn oyrd nr`ft maaurmay df ½=³ pjr gdur. 93
=0 Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`de (FMM) Fdrh 11? (Hmldr Yjpm`r men Mktjrmt`de) `s usjn td ndauhjetwdrb maadhpk`sgjn, rjoukmtdry adefdrh`ty, men mpprdvmk fdr rjture td sjrv`aj.
93 Gdejywjkk Mjrdspmaj, Adhpdejet Hm`etjemeaj Hmeumk, N`spkmajhjet Oyrd, Suik`amt`de ed. A=:-1==9-330, Yjv`s`de =9 (3= Luej 93=3)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 22/215
- => -
Jxmh`emt`de df hm`etjemeaj rjadrns rjvjmkjn tgmt tgj NOs estmkkjn e A-OE_E wjrj`njet`f`jn w`tg pmrt ed. 9:77139-= men sjr`mk eds. 737>110 men ?=913>0. Qjr`mk ed. ?=913>0 wmsdvjrgmukjn mt tgj Gdejywjkk Dttmwm rjpm`r fma`k`ty e Edvjhijr =009 men mom`e e Luej =000,men gmn m ‛Ed Fmukt Fduen‘ stmtus `e Muoust =000. Ed dvjrgmuk rjadrns wjrj fduen fdr sjr`mked. 737>110. ^gj NOs wjrj edt rjadvjrjn frdh tgj armsg s`tj.
=.6.:.1 Srjajss`de
S`kdts hust hde`tdr frjj oyrd dpjrmt`des, ijamusj oyrds prjajss mt rmtjs tgmt ame vmry maadrn`eotd oyrd systjh men emturmk prjajss`de pgjedhjem. Oyrd prjajss`de pgjedhjem tgmt mrj hdstadhhdeky mssda`mtjn w`tg fk`ogt dpjrmt`des ades`st df 9 typjs< rjmk prjajss`de men mppmrjetprjajss`de.
Yjmk prjajss`de s enuajn e tgj oyrd men s amusjn iy hjagme`amk hpjrfjat`des, suag msijmr`eo wjmr dr nmhmoj. ^gj rjmk prjajss`de tdkjrmeaj fdr tgj NOs de A-OE_E wms ½=³ pjrgdur.
Mppmrjet prjajss`de `s tgj rjsukt df tgj oyrd prdpjrty df r`o`n`ty `e spmaj men tgj jmrtg‐srdtmt`de w`tg rjspjat td spmaj mt =:.3>³ pjr gdur. wd mspjats df mppmrjet prjajss`de rjsukt frdhtgj rdtmt`de df tgj jmrtg (jmrtg rmtj 9=) men trmespdrt df m oyrd mardss adevjro`eo hjr`n`mes(jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj 99).
9= Jmrtg rmtj vmr`js njpjenjet de kmt`tunj men gjh`spgjrj, men `s edt mffjatjn iy jmst∙wjst hdvjhjet.
^gj fdrhukm td amkaukmtj jmrtg rmtj `s< =:.3>³ pjr gdur x s`ej kmt`tunj. Hmx`huh pdss`ikj jmrtg rmtjprjajss`de `s =:.3>³ pjr gdur mt 03³ kmt`tunj. ^gj A-==I adhpmss adetrdkkjr prdv`njs fdr sjtt`eo tgjkdamk kmt`tunj td mppky tdrquj td tgj n`rjat`demk oyrd (NO) td adhpjesmtj fdr tgj jmrtg rmtj (Mppjen`x
J). Ijamusj sjkjatjn kmt`tunj hmy n`ffjr frdh matumk kmt`tunj, tgj n`ffjrjeaj ijtwjje matumk jmrtg rmtjmen adhpjesmtjn jmrtg rmtj `s tgj rjs`numk jmrtg rmtj prjajss`de.
99 Jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj `s tgj rmtj mt wg`ag me m`rarmft w`kk agmeoj gjmn`eo rjkmt`vj td truj edrtg wgje
fdkkdw`eo m orjmt a`rakj adursj mardss adevjro`eo hjr`n`mes. Hjr`n`me adevjrojeaj `s orjmtjst mt g`ogkmt`tunjs. ^gj fdrhukm td amkaukmtj jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj `s< agmeoj df kdeo`tunj pjr gdur x s`ej df h`n-kmt`tunj. ^gj A-==I adhpmss systjh ndjs edt `eadrpdrmtj mey hjmes td adrrjat fdr jmrtg trmespdrtrmtj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 23/215
- =: -
^mikj 6. Jmrtg rmtj amkaukmt`des fdr sjvjrmk pds`t`des mkdeo tgj trmab df FMI6:63 fdr kmt`tunj adetrdkkjr sjtmt 66³
Z^A FMI6:63 pds`t`de Jmrtg rmtj(³/gdur)
Adhpjesmtjnjmrtg rmtj(³/gdur)
Yjs`numkjmrtg rmtj(³/gdur)
=>:7<:? 6>³ E, ==9³>3' _ =1.:9 =1.?> 3.99
66³ E =1.?> =1.?> 3.33
=:>7<9: 60³3?' E, =3:³3=' _ (AI) =>.3: =1.?> ∙3.1=
=:>0<=1 60³3?' E, =3:³3=' _ (AI) =>.3: =1.?> ∙3.1=
=6=9<33 ?=³>3' E, =3=³=:' _ =>.97 =1.?> ∙3.:>
Z^A< Addrn`emtjn Ze`vjrsmk ^`hjAI< Amhir`noj Imy
^mikj ?. Jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj amkaukmt`des fdr 9 sjohjets df tgj trmab df FMI6:63
Sjr`dn stmrt Sjr`dn jen Kdeo`tunjagmeoj
(³/gdur)
H`n-kmt`tunj
Jmrtgtrmespdrt
rmtj(³/gdur)Z^A Sds`t`de Z^A Sds`t`de
=>:7<:? 6>³ E,==9³>3' _
=:>7<9:60³3?' E,=3:³3=' _
∙0.97 66³1>' E ∙7.:=
=:>0<=1 60³3?' E,=3:³3=' _
=6=9<33?=³>3' E,=3=³=:' _
∙0.09 ?3³91' E ∙0.1>
=.6.:.> Gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de `en`amtdr
^gj GQ@ n`spkmys m`rarmft pds`t`de men gjmn`eo w`tg rjspjat td hmoejt`a dr truj edrtg, sjkjatjngjmn`eo, n`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet (NHJ), kmtjrmk njv`mt`de td dr frdh m sjkjatjn VDY drkdamk`zjr adursj, men vjrt`amk njv`mt`de frdh tgj ajetrj df m ok`njskdpj ijmh (Mppjen`x J). ^gj
m`rarmft wms jqu`ppjn w`tg 9 GQ@s< = de tgj amptm`e‐s estruhjet pmejk men tgj sjaden de tgjFD‐s `estruhjet pmejk.
Qjvjrmk fkmos eadrpdrmtjn etd tgj GQ@ prdv`nj pds`t`vj hde`tdr`eo df sjvjrmk pmrmhjtjrs. gjfkmos mrj pds`t`dejn dut df v`jw wgje tgj prdpjr dpjrmt`eo vdktmoj s prjsjet. gjrj wmsedtg`eo td en`amtj mey fkmos ij`eo prjsjet de tgj arjw‐s GQ@s.
=.6.6 Mutdp`kdt systjh
=.6.6.= Ojejrmk
^gj m`rarmft gmn me QS-?? mutdp`kdt systjh men numk FN-=37 fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjhs. gjsj
systjhs wjrj njs`oejn td fueat`de enjpjenjetky men wjrj edt etjormtjn. Adetrdk df jmag dftgjh wms v`m tgj hdnj adetrdk pmejk (HAS) kdamtjn de tgj okmrjsg`jkn (Sgdtd =).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 24/215
- =6 -
Sgdtd =. Mutdp`kdt/fk`ogt-n`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk pmejk
^gj amptm`e‐s fk`ogt n`rjatdr adetrdks mrj de tgj kjft s`nj df tgj HAS2 tgj mutdp`kdt adetrdks mrj `etgj ajetrj df tgj HAS2 men tgj FD‐s fk`ogt n`rjatdr adetrdks mrj de tgj r`ogt s`nj df tgj HAS.Qjpmrmtj sjkjat`des de mkk 1 mrj ejajssmry td adef`ourj jmag `enjpjenjet systjh (Mppjen`x F).^gj mutdp`kdt men fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjhs usj memkdo adhputjrs men nd edt adetm`e ede-vdkmt`kjhjhdry.
^gj mutdp`kdt systjh adetrdks tgj m`rarmft midut tgj p`tag men rdkk mxjs men prdv`njs mutdhmt`am`rarmft stmi`k`zmt`de wgjejvjr tgj p`tag men rdkk agmeejks mrj jeomojn. Vmr`dus hdnj sjkjat`desjemikj tgj p`kdts td adhhmen tgj mutdp`kdt td fky tgj m`rarmft detd m sjkjatjn VDY dr kdamk`zjradursj (VDY/KDA hdnj), ms wjkk ms td hmbj mutdhmt`a mpprdmagjs td ruewmys jqu`ppjn w`tg`estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) fma`k`t`js (MZ^D MSS hdnj).
^gj p`kdts hmy mksd hmeumkky adetrdk tgj m`rarmft `e m edrhmk hmeejr w`tg tgj adetrdk wgjjkmen adkuhe (adetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eo RA_QX) w`tgdut n`sjeomo`eo tgj p`tag dr rdkk mxjs df tgjmutdp`kdt systjh. S`kdts ame tgje mss`st tgj mutdp`kdt systjh e fky`eo td m sjkjatjn gjmn`eo dradursj. Zsj df A_Q ndjs edt n`sjeomoj j`tgjr agmeejk df tgj mutdp`kdt systjh. ^gj mutdp`kdtsystjh wms hdn`f`jn frdh tgj dr`o`emk njs`oe td mkkdw fdr tgj usj df OSQ ou`nmeaj fdr tgjadursj s`oemks td tgj mutdp`kdt (sjat`de =.6.=3).
^gj mutdp`kdt systjh ame ij adupkjn j`tgjr td tgj VGF EMV rmn`d systjh dr td tgj OSQ systjh.
^d adupkj tgj mutdp`kdt td tgj OSQ, tgj mutdp`kdt sjkjat sw`tag `s sjt td M/S DE OSQ. 91 @fsdhjtg`eo daaurs td ueadupkj tgj mutdp`kdt frdh tgj OSQ, suag ms m kdss df OSQ s`oemk drsjkjat`eo EMV de tgj amptm`e‐s HN->= OSQ meeuea`mtdr adetrdk ue`t, tgj mutdp`kdt w`kk rjvjrt tdditm`e`eo `ts emv`omt`demk `eput frdh tgj VGF EMV rmn`d systjh. Gdwjvjr, tgj M/S DE OSQmeeuea`mtdr w`kk rjhm`e kkuh`emtjn uet`k tgj mutdp`kdt sjkjat sw`tag s sjt td tgj dff (edt`kkuh`emtjn) pds`t`de.
^gj pds`t`de df tgj arjw mutdp`kdt adetrdks s ms sgdwe e Mppjen`x O.
@e tgj systjh‐s njfmukt stmtj, tgj mutdp`kdt men tgj amptm`e‐s fk`ogt n`rjatdr ditm`e stjjr`eo`efdrhmt`de frdh VDY/@KQ rjaj`vjr ed. =, men tgj FD‐s fk`ogt n`rjatdr ditm`es efdrhmt`de frdh
VDY/@KQ rjaj`vjr ed. 9. Qjj sjat`de =.6.=3 fdr efdrhmt`de de OSQ etjrfmaj w`tg tgj mutdp`kdt.
91 ^g`s sw`tag s kdamtjn de tgj tdp df tgj estruhjet pmejk, lust ijkdw tgj kjft s`nj df tgjmutdp`kdt/fk`ogt-n`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk pmejk.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 25/215
- =? -
=.6.6.9 Adetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eo
^gj m`rarmft hmy ij hmedjuvrjn `e p`tag men rdkk mftjr mutdp`kdt jeomojhjet us`eo tgj adetrdkwgjjk men adkuhe. Hmeumk `eputs iy tgj p`kdts us`eo A_Q mrj tgj smhj ms rjqu`rjn fdr hmeumkfk`ogt. ^wd fdraj kjvjks mrj rjqu`rjn td hdvj tgj adetrdk adkuhe dr wgjjk dut df tgj ajetrj(njtjet) pds`t`de td enuaj p`tag dr rdkk adhhmens.
M kdw njtjet fdraj (> pduens `e tgj rdkk mx`s men : pduens `e tgj p`tag mx`s) `s rjqu`rjn td hdvjtgj adetrdk wgjjk dut df tgj ajetrj (njtjet) pds`t`de. ^g`s fdraj `s adhpmrmikj td tgj fdrajrjqu`rjn nur`eo hmeumk fk`ogt. Mftjr dvjradh`eo tg`s rjs`stmeaj, tgj adhhmen td p`tag dr rdkk smt m rmtj prdpdrt`demk td adetrdk-wgjjk dr adkuhe fdraj.
G`og njtjet fdraj (7 pduens `e tgj rdkk mx`s men mpprdx`hmtjky =7 pduens `e tgj p`tag mx`s) `sprdv`njn td prjvjet emnvjrtjet n`sjeomojhjet df vmr`dus suihdnjs. gj fdraj rjqu`rjn tdhdvj tgj adetrdk wgjjk dr adkuhe dut df tgj njtjet pds`t`de `s `earjmsjn. @f rjvjrs`de td A_Q`eputs deky (ed mutdhmt`a gjmn`eo, adursj, rmn`d, dr p`tag adhhmens) s njs`rjn, t hmy ijmaadhpk`sgjn iy jxjrt`eo m fdraj orjmtjr tgme g`og njtjet kjvjk.
=.6.6.1 Aden`t`des men k`h`tmt`des fdr kdamk`zjr ampturj
_`tg j`tgjr VDY/KDA dr MZ^D MSS hdnj sjkjatjn de tgj mutdp`kdt hdnj sjkjatdr, tgjmutdp`kdt w`kk etjrajpt men ampturj tgj kdamk`zjr, prdv`njn tgmt tgj etjrajpt meokj s ijtwjje=3³ men 03³. 9>
@e tgj KDA ampturj suihdnj, hmx`huh imeb meokj adhhmen s k`h`tjn td 9:³, men tgj rdkk rmtj`s k`h`tjn td ?³ pjr sjaden. Kmtjrmk ijmh sjesdr s usjn td prdajss tgj KDA njv`mt`de s`oemk.^g`s hdnj usjs KDA njv`mt`de s`oemk, KDA njv`mt`de s`oemk rmtj, men adursj jrrdr (imsjn de tgjsjkjatjn adursj). gj mutdp`kdt w`kk e`t`mtj m ture tdwmrn tgj kdamk`zjr wgje tgj KDA njv`mt`des`oemk ijadhjs kjss tgme =:3 h`kk`vdkts (hV) (9 ndts ms `en`amtjn iy tgj adursj njv`mt`de imr).
^gj mutdp`kdt trmes`t`de td KDA de adursj suihdnj daaurs wgje tgj KDA njv`mt`de s`oemk `skjss tgme 73 hV (midut = ndt), tgj ardss-ijmh rmtj `s kjss tgme 9 hV pjr sjaden, men tgj imebmeokj `s kjss tgme 6³. Deaj `e KDA de adursj suihdnj, tgj hmx`huh imeb meokj `s k`h`tjn td 7³.^gj rdkk rmtj k`h`t rjhm`es mt ?³ pjr sjaden. Dtgjr tgme tgj imeb meokj k`h`t agmeoj, tgjrj `s ed`en`amt`de td tgj p`kdts wgje mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA suihdnj gms agmeojn frdh ampturj td deadursj.
=.6.? FN-=37 fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjh
=.6.?.= Ojejrmk
^gj fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjhs prdv`nj tgj p`kdts w`tg v`sumk adhhmens td hm`etm`e tgj m`rarmft deprj-sjkjatjn kmtjrmk men vjrt`amk fk`ogt pmtgs. gjrj mrj 9 enjpjenjet systjhs estmkkjn< = fdr tgjamptm`e men tgj dtgjr fdr tgj FD.
9> F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), pmoj 3>.13.?
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 26/215
- =7 -
^gj fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhputjrs rjaj`vj eputs frdh vmr`dus emv`omt`de systjhs, njpjen`eo de tgjsjkjatjn hdnj df dpjrmt`de (Mppjen`x G). Mnn`t`demkky, tgj mtt`tunj rjfjrjeaj systjh prdv`njs`eputs df m`rarmft rdkk men p`tag mtt`tunj. gj fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhputjrs prdajss tgjsj eputs`oemks men ojejrmtj rdkk men p`tag mtt`tunj adhhmens fdr hm`etm`e`eo tgj njs`rjn fk`ogt pmtg.^gj rdkk men p`tag adhhmens mrj n`spkmyjn de tgj mtt`tunj n`rjatdr en`amtdr (MN@). gj mrhjndr ampturj hdnj df dpjrmt`de s n`spkmyjn de tgj mpprdmag prdorjss n`spkmy (MSN).
=.6.?.9 Fk`ogt n`rjatdr k`h`tmt`des de kdamk`zjr ampturj
^gj etjrajpt meokj s k`h`tjn td 13³ (gjmn`eo meokj w`tg rjspjat td tgj sjkjatjn adursj).
_`tg tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr `e VDY/KDA hdnj men w`tg m vmk`n VDY dr KDA s`oemk, tgj fk`ogtn`rjatdr MSN VDY/KDA meeuea`mtdr w`kk `kkuh`emtj orjje deaj KDA ampturj daaurs (KDAnjv`mt`de kjss tgme 9.:³). Nur`eo tgj 03 sjadens mftjr KDA ampturj, `f tgj KDA njv`mt`de s`oemkjxajjns tgj k`h`t (9.:³ fdr tgj kdamk`zjr), tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr w`kk rjvjrt frdh KDA ampturj td KDA`etjrajpt, men tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr MSN VDY/KDA meeuea`mtdr k`ogt w`kk agmeoj adkdur frdhorjje td mhijr.
=.6.7 Mtt`tunj n`rjatdr `en`amtdr
Dej MN@ de jmag p`kdt‐s estruhjet pmejkn`spkmys tgj m`rarmft p`tag men rdkk mtt`tunj,m f`xjn m`rarmft syhidk, men fk`ogt n`rjatdrstjjr`eo adhhmen imrs (F`ourj 9).
^gj fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs mrjnr`vje iy sjpmrmtj `eputs fdr p`tag menrdkk. ^gj adhhmen imrs hdvj `e ue`sde tdn`spkmy etjormtjn p`tag men rdkk ou`nmeajadhhmens adrrjspden`eo td fk`ogt n`rjatdrrdkk men p`tag hdnj sjkjat`des. d smt`sfytgj adhhmens, tgj m`rarmft s hmedjuvrjnsd tgmt tgj m`rarmft syhidk ijadhjs seuokymk`oejn w`tg tgj adhhmen imrs.Ijamusj tgj 9 fk`ogt n`rjatdrs dpjrmtj`enjpjenjetky df jmag dtgjr, tgj amptm`e‐sadhhmen imrs w`kk prdv`nj n`ffjrjetadhhmens tgme tgj FD‐s uekjss njet`amkhdnj sjkjat`des gmvj ijje hmnj. ^gjadhhmen imrs mrj njfkjatjn dut df v`jwwgje tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj `s DFF drwgje s`oemk eputs mrj uerjk`mikj.
@e GNO QJK hdnj, tgj adhhmen imrs n`spkmy adhhmens td ture tdwmrn men hm`etm`e tgjsjkjatjn gjmn`eo.
_gje tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr stjjr`eo adhputjrs sjesj tgmt tgj m`rarmft s w`tg`e 9.:³ df tgj ajetrjk`ejdf tgj kdamk`zjr ijmh men VDY/KDA dr MZ^D MSS hdnj gms ijje sjkjatjn, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr
F`ourj 9. Jxjhpkmr mtt`tunj n`rjatdr `en`amtdr (MN@)
=< Imeb `en`amtdr men samkj9< Mtt`tunj n`spkmy1< Ok`njskdpj pd`etjr men njv`mt`de samkj>< Fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs:< Qyhidk`a m`rarmft6< Kdamk`zjr syhidk men njv`mt`de samkj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 27/215
- =0 -
adhhmen imrs prdv`nj mtt`tunj ou`nmeaj adhhmens imsjn de tgj m`rarmft dr`jetmt`de rjkmt`vj tdtgj kdamk`zjr ijmh. Deaj tgj m`rarmft jxajjns 9.:³ frdh tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej, tgj VDY/KDAmeeuea`mtdr w`kk agmeoj frdh orjje td mhijr ms tgj systjh agmeojs frdh ampturj td `etjrajpthdnj. @e tgj etjrajpt hdnj, tgj adhhmen imrs prdv`nj ou`nmeaj td fky td men hm`etm`e tgjsjkjatjn gjmn`eo de tgj GQ@.
Fkmos eadrpdrmtjn etd tgj MN@ prdv`nj pds`t`vj hde`tdr`eo df sjvjrmk pmrmhjtjrs. gj fkmosmrj pds`t`dejn dut df v`jw wgje tgj prdpjr dpjrmt`eo vdktmoj s prjsjet. gj p`kdts n`n edtn`sauss mey fkmos ij`eo prjsjet de tgj`r MN@s.
=.6.0 Mpprdmag prdorjss n`spkmy meeuea`mtdrs
^gj MSNs prdv`nj meeuea`mt`de df tgj mutdp`kdt men fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjhs mrhjn men ampturjstmtus fdr n`ffjrjet dpjrmt`eo hdnjs. gjrj mrj 9 MSNs< = de tgj amptm`e‐s estruhjet pmejk mentgj sjaden de tgj FD‐s estruhjet pmejk. Qjj Mppjen`x G fdr adef`ourmt`de men fueat`demk`ty dftgj MSNs.
=.6.=3
Okdimk pds`t`de`eo systjh
^gjrj wjrj 9 ^r`hikj ^EK-7=33 OSQ systjhs de tgj m`rarmft. ^g`s typj df OSQ ue`t ndjs edtstdrj mey trmab nmtm. ^gj ^EK-7=33 hjjts tgj ^QD A=90 stmenmrn men `s ajrt`f`jn fdr je-rdutj,tjrh`emk, men ede-prja`s`de estruhjet mpprdmag emv`omt`de. gj OSQ ue`ts prdv`nj`efdrhmt`de td tgj mutdp`kdt men idtg GQ@s. OSQ efdrhmt`de s edt prdv`njn td tgj fk`ogtn`rjatdrs.
Nur`eo tgj pjr`dn frdh Njajhijr 93=3 uet`k tgj daaurrjeaj, tgjrj wjrj : hm`etjemeaj rjadrnjetr`js fdr tgj OSQ. ^wd df tgjsj jetr`js wjrj fdr nmtmimsj upnmtjs (3: Luky 93== men 9? Luky93==). De 90 Luej 93==, tgj ed. 9 OSQ wms wr`ttje up fdr m gjmn`eo fm`kurj. @t wms orduen-agjabjn ms sjrv`ajmikj. De 13 Luej 93==, tgj OSQ wms edt dpjrmt`eo mt njpmrturj t`hj. ^gj ed. 9OSQ wms rjpkmajn, agjabjn men fduen td ij sjrv`ajmikj. De 9: Luky 93==, tgj ed. = OSQ wduknedt maajpt truj m`rspjjn `eput. ^gj ed. = OSQ wms rjiddtjn men agjabjn ms sjrv`ajmikj.
^gj 9 OSQ systjhs mrj adetrdkkjn iy 9 adetrdk n`spkmy ue`ts (ANZs) kdamtjn de tgj ajetrjadesdkj ijtwjje tgj p`kdts. Ed. = OSQ `s de tgj amptm`e‐s s`nj, men ed. 9 OSQ `s de tgj FD‐s s`nj.Jmag ANZ gms m sarjje td n`spkmy njs`rjn efdrhmt`de, eakun`eo m`rarmft pds`t`de rjkmt`vj tdnjs`rjn trmab (Sgdtd 9). @e tgj amsj df APYI Yuewmy 1:^, tgj @KQ kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej s akdsjkymk`oejn w`tg tgj mrjm emv`omt`de (YEMV) f`emk mpprdmag trmab. ^gjrjfdrj, tgj OSQ sarjje ameprdv`nj tgj arjw w`tg pds`t`demk efdrhmt`de rjkmt`vj td tgj kdamk`zjr f tgj YEMV mpprdmag skdmnjn `etd tgj fk`ogt pkme.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 28/215
- 93 -
Jmag systjh gms m HN->= OSQ meeuea`mt`de adetrdkue`t. gj HN->= jemikjs tgj p`kdt td sjkjat j`tgjr VGFEMV dr OSQ `efdrhmt`de td ij n`spkmyjn de tgj GQ@adursj njv`mt`de imr. HN->= ed. = `s kdamtjn de tgjamptm`e‐s `estruhjet pmejk (Sgdtd 1), men HN->= ed. 9`s kdamtjn de tgj FD‐s `estruhjet pmejk. _gje tgj
EMV/OSQ sw`tag s njprjssjn, tgj HN->= w`kkmeeuea`mtj EMV e wg`tj, dr OSQ e orjje, en`amt`eowg`ag sduraj `s n`spkmyjn de tgj GQ@.
^gj M/S QJKJA^ meeuea`mtdr/sw`tag `s kdamtjn de tgjajetrj estruhjet pmejk hhjn`mtjky midvj tgj stmeniymtt`tunj en`amtdr.
_gje tgj ed. = HN->= `s sjkjatjntd OSQ men tgj M/S QJKJA^meeuea`mtdr/sw`tag s njprjssjn,
M/S DE OSQ `kkuh`emtjs orjje,men tgj mutdp`kdt systjh sprdv`njn w`tg efdrhmt`de frdhOSQ ed. = rmtgjr tgme VGF EMVrmn`d nmtm. gj mutdp`kdt hmy ijn`sadeejatjn frdh tgj OSQ iynjsjkjat`eo tgj M/S QJKJA^meeuea`mtdr/sw`tag. Qjkjat`eoEMV de tgj ed. = HN->= w`kkrjhdvj tgj OSQ s`oemks frdh tgjmutdp`kdt, mktgduog tgj orjje M/S
DE OSQ meeuea`mtdr w`kk rjhm`e`kkuh`emtjn.
^gj OSQ w`kk mutdhmt`amkky rjvjrttd ^YZJ hdnj wgje tgj adhpmssadetrdkkjr HMO/NO sw`tagjs mrjsjkjatjn td NO.
=.6.== Jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr
^gj m`rarmft wms jqu`ppjn w`tg m Gdejywjkk Yjsau >36MF-typj jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr(JK^). _gje mat`vmtjn mutdhmt`amkky iy hpmat fdrajs dr hmeumkky, tgj JK^ trmesh`ts m n`strjsss`oemk td m`n e njtjat`de men kdamt`de iy sjmrag men rjsauj pjrsdeejk. gj >36-hjomgjrtz(HGz) typj JK^ sjens dut n`o`tmkky jeadnjn nmtm tgmt ue`qujky njet`fy tgj m`rarmft de wg`ag t`s estmkkjn.
Sgdtd 9. ^EK-7=33 adetrdk n`spkmy ue`t(ANZ) sarjje, sgdw`eo r`ogt-df-trmab`en`amt`de
Sgdtd 1. ^gj ed. = okdimk pds`t`de`eo systjh (OSQ) ANZ, ed. =HN->= meeuea`mtdr pmejk, men M/S QJKJA^ sw`tag
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 29/215
- 9= -
=.? Hjtjdrdkdo`amk `efdrhmt`de
=.?.= Akdun aj`k`eo gj`ogt
Akdun kmyjrs mrj rjpdrtjn imsjn de tgj suhhmt`de df tgj kmyjr mhduets ms disjrvjn frdh tgjsurfmaj up. Kmyjr mhduets mrj rjpdrtjn `e j`ogtgs (dbtms) df sby advjrmoj. FJ_ `s frdh orjmtjr
tgme 3 td 9/7 suhhmt`de mhduet2 QA^ `s frdh 1/7 td >/7 suhhmt`de mhduet2 IBE `s frdh :/7td kjss tgme 7/7 suhhmt`de mhduet2 men DVA `s 7/7 suhhmt`de mhduet. M akdun aj`k`eo `s sm`ntd jx`st mt tgj gj`ogt df tgj f`rst kmyjr fdr wg`ag m advjrmoj syhidk df IBE dr DVA `srjpdrtjn. 9:
=.?.9 Pjkkdwbe`fj wjmtgjr mt njpmrturj
^gj rdut`ej mv`mt`de wjmtgjr rjpdrt (HJ^MY) fdr AP\F mt =>33 wms< w`en 303³^ mt == bedts,v`s`i`k`ty =: stmtutj h`kjs (sh) e k`ogt rm`e sgdwjrs, irdbje akdun mt ::33 fjjt midvj orduenkjvjk (mok), irdbje akdun mt 7333 fjjt mok, irdbje akdun mt == 333 fjjt mok, tjhpjrmturj 0³A,njwpd`et ?³A, men mkt`hjtjr 90.7? e. Go.
=.?.1 Yjsdkutj Imy wjmtgjr `ssujn ijfdrj njpmrturj
^gj Yjsdkutj Imy mrjm wms uenjr tgj efkujeaj df m trduog df kdw prjssurj jxtjen`eosdutgjmstwmrn frdh m kdw prjssurj systjh ajetrjn mt 73³E, ==:³_ mt 3?33. gj trduog wmshdv`eo edrtgjmstwmrn mt =3 bedts. gj mrjm wms fdrjamst td gmvj irdbje akduns imsjn mt 9:33fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk) men tdppjn mt => 333 fjjt msk, w`tg v`s`i`k`ty orjmtjr tgme 6 sh. ^gj mrjmwms fdrjamst td gmvj pmtagy pdrt`des (9:% td :3% df tgj mrjm) w`tg >∙6 sh v`s`i`k`ty `e k`ogt rm`emen h`st, men aj`k`eos mt 633∙=:33 fjjt mok. ^gj mrjm wms mksd fdrjamst td gmvj kdamk`zjn aj`k`eosms kdw ms 933 fjjt mok, w`tg v`s`i`k`ty ms kdw ms = sh.
^gj HJ^MY fdr Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI) mt =>33 wms< w`en =63³^ mt => bedts, v`s`i`k`ty =: sh,irdbje akdun mt 033 fjjt mok, dvjramst akdun mt ?333 fjjt mok, tjhpjrmturj ?³A, njwpd`et 6³A, menmkt`hjtjr 90.?0 e. Go.
Me mjrdnrdhj fdrjamst (^MF) wms `ssujn fdr APYI mt ==17. _jmtgjr mt =6>: wms fdrjamst td ij<w`en =:3³^ mt =: bedts, v`s`i`k`ty orjmtjr tgme 6 sh `e k`ogt rm`e, samttjrjn akdun mt :33 fjjt mok,dvjramst akdun mt =933 fjjt mok2 tjhpdrmr`ky ijtwjje =933 men 9333< v`s`i`k`ty 9 sh `e k`ogt rm`emen h`st, men dvjramst akdun mt :33 fjjt mok, w`tg m 13% prdimi`k`ty df dvjramst akdun >33 fjjtmok ijtwjje =933 men 9333. Mt =1>>, tgj ^MF wms mhjenjn, men fdr tgj pjr`dn df mrr`vmk, `trjmn< w`en =?3³^ mt =9 bedts, v`s`i`k`ty orjmtjr tgme 6 sh, samttjrjn akdun mt 733 fjjt mok,dvjramst akdun mt ?333 fjjt mok2 tjhpdrmr`ky ijtwjje =133 men 9333< v`s`i`k`ty 9 sh `e k`ogt rm`e
men h`st, men dvjramst akdun mt 733 fjjt mok, w`tg m 13% prdimi`k`ty df dvjramst akdun mt >33 fjjtmok ijtwjje =133 men 9333.
9: ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =>1?= ∙ ^rmespdrt Amemnm Mjrdemut`amk @efdrhmt`de Hmeumk (^A M@H), HJ^ ‑Hjtjdrdkdoy (=? Datdijr 93=1), sjat`de 1.=:.1 (d), mvm`kmikj mtgttp<//www.ta.oa.am/hjn`m/ndauhjets/am-puik`amt`des/HJ^-M@H-93=1-9TJEO->.pnf (kmstmaajssjn de 30 Njajhijr 93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 30/215
- 99 -
=.?.> Yjsdkutj Imy wjmtgjr `ssujn wg`kj FMI6:63 wms je rdutj
M spja`mk wjmtgjr rjpdrt (QSJA@) fdr APYI, `ssujn mt =>1>, rjmn< w`en =?3³^ mt =6 bedts,v`s`i`k`ty =: sh e k`ogt nr`zzkj, men dvjramst akdun mt :33 fjjt mok. Medtgjr QSJA@, ssujn mt =>:3men prdv`njn td tgj arjw iy m adhpmey n`spmtagjr mt =>::, rjmn< w`en =?3³^ mt =1 bedts,
v`s`i`k`ty :/7 sh e k`ogt nr`zzkj men h`st, vjrt`amk v`s`i`k`ty 933 fjjt2 rjhmrbs< fdo 7 dbtms.
Mt =>:=, tgj APYI ^MF wms mhjenjn m sjaden t`hj men, fdr tgj pjr`dn df mrr`vmk, rjmn< w`en=?3³^ mt =: bedts, v`s`i`k`ty orjmtjr tgme 6 sh, samttjrjn akdun mt :33 fjjt mok, dvjramst akdun mt?333 fjjt mok2 tjhpdrmr`ky ijtwjje =>33 men 9333< v`s`i`k`ty 9 sh `e k`ogt rm`e men h`st, dvjramstakdun mt :33 fjjt mok.
^gj APYI HJ^MY fdr =:33, prdv`njn td tgj arjw iy m adhpmey n`spmtagjr mt =:=3, rjmn< w`en=73³^ mt =6 bedts, v`s`i`k ty sh, ruewmy v`sumk rmeoj 96 fdr Yuewmy 1: 9933 fjjt `e k`ogtnr`zzkj men fdo, vjrt`amk v`s`i`k`ty 933 fjjt, tjhpjrmturj 6³A, njwpd`et 6³A, mkt`hjtjr 90.?0`e. Go2 rjhmrbs< 7 dbtms fdo. Medtgjr QSJA@ wms `ssujn mt =:11 men rjmn< w`en =?3³^ mt 7 bedts,
v`s`i`k`ty : sh `e k`ogt nr`zzkj men h`st, men dvjramst akdun mt 633 fjjt.
^gj HJ^MY mt =633, prdv`njn td tgj arjw iy EMV AMEMNM mt =630, rjmn< w`en =73³^ mt 7bedts, v`s`i`k`ty =3 sh e k`ogt nr`zzkj, dvjramst akdun mt ?33 fjjt mok, tjhpjrmturj 6.1³A,njwpd`et 6³A, men mkt`hjtjr 90.7= e. Go. Ed dtgjr wjmtgjr disjrvmt`des wjrj ssujn td tgjarjw.
=.?.: Yjsdkutj Imy wjmtgjr `ssujn mftjr tgj maa`njet
M QSJA@ fdr APYI, `ssujn mt =6>0, wms ms fdkkdws< w`en =73³^ mt =1 bedts, v`s`i`k`ty : sh `e k`ogtnr`zzkj men h`st, men dvjramst akdun mt 133 fjjt mok.
Ar`tjr`m jx`st fdr tgj `ssumeaj df QSJA@ wjmtgjr rjpdrts td n`ssjh`emtj agmeojs e prjv`duskydisjrvjn wjmtgjr aden`t`des. Fdr v`s`i`k`ty agmeojs, m QSJA@ s edt rjqu`rjn uet`k v`s`i`k`tynjarjmsjs ijkdw 1 h`kjs. Fdr aj`k`eo, m QSJA@ `s rjqu`rjn wgje aj`k`eo njarjmsjs ijkdw :33 fjjt,men mom`e mt =33-fddt earjhjets. 9?
96
Yuewmy v`sumk rmeoj s tgj hmx`huh gdr`zdetmk n`stmeaj, ms hjmsurjn iy me mutdhmtjn v sumkkmen`eo n`stmeaj systjh fdr tgj n`rjat`de df tmbj-dff dr kmen`eo, mt wg`ag tgj ruewmy, dr tgj k`ogts drhmrbjrs njk`ejmt`eo `t, ame ij sjje frdh m pd`et midvj `ts ajetrjk`ej mt m gj`ogt adrrjspden`eo td tgjmvjrmoj jyj kjvjk df p`kdts mt tduagndwe (^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =>1?= ∙ ^rmespdrt Amemnm Mjrdemut`amk@efdrhmt`de Hmeumk R^A M@HX, YMA ‑ Yukjs df tgj M`r men M`r ^rmff`a Qjrv`ajs R=? Datdijr 93=1X,sjat`de 0.93.=).
9? Jev`rdehjet Amemnm, Jev`rdehjet Amemnm Hmeumk df Qurfmaj _jmtgjr Disjrvmt`des (JA HMEDIQ), ?tg jn`t`de, Mhjenhjet =7 (Lmeumry 93=1), Agmptjr =6, sjat`de =6.>.>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 31/215
- 91 -
=.?.6 Zppjr w`ens
^gj dpjrmt`demk fk`ogt pkme (DFS) fdr FMI6:63 men uppjr w`en fdrjamsts sgdwjn tgmt tgj fk`ogtwdukn jxpjr`jeaj earjms`eo tm`kw`ens ijtwjje Amhir`noj Imy men APYI. gj DFS sgdwjn mtm`kw`en df 61 bedts mt tgj tdp df njsajet (^DN).
=.?.? _jmtgjr rjaj`vjn iy tgj arjw
Adhpmey n`spmtagjrs prjpmrj tgj DFS, eakun`eo wjmtgjr men ED^MH (edt`aj td m`rhje)`efdrhmt`de, men pkmaj `t de m adhpmey f`kj trmesfjr prdtdadk (F^S) sjrvjr fdr ndwekdmn iy tgjarjw. gj FMI6:63 DFS, eakun`eo ED^MH men wjmtgjr efdrhmt`de, wms edt rjadvjrjn frdhtgj armsg s`tj, men jkjatrde`a adp`js df tg`s efdrhmt`de wjrj mutdhmt`amkky njkjtjn frdh tgjadhpmey‐s adhputjr systjh. 97 @t `s mkhdst ajrtm`e tgmt tgj DFS `ssujn iy F`rst M`r N`spmtag mt=31: eakunjn aurrjet HJ^MY men MF efdrhmt`de fdr APYI. gj adhpmey dpjrmt`des rddhmt AP\F gmn m adhputjr tjrh`emk w`tg maajss td EMV AMEMNM wjmtgjr `efdrhmt`de, men tgjarjw adukn gmvj ditm`ejn suisjqujetky ssujn wjmtgjr iy tg`s hjmes.
=.7 M`ns td emv`omt`de
=.7.= Emv`omt`demk m`ns
Emv`omt`demk m`ns (emv-m`ns) sjrv`eo Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI) `eakunjn tgj Yjsdkutj Imy ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade (YI ENI), tgj PYI VDY (VGF dhe`n`rjat`demk rmeoj) w`tg mssda`mtjnn`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet (NHJ) (edt usjn fdr APYI estruhjet mpprdmag prdajnurjs),men tgj @YI 90 estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) w`tg mssda`mtjn NHJ. gj m`rpdrt s sjrvjn iyme @KQ/NHJ mpprdmag fdr Yuewmy 1:^ (Mppjen`x A). Mnn`t`demkky, mrjm emv`omt`de (YEMV)mpprdmagjs imsjn de tgj okdimk emv`omt`de smtjkk`tj systjh (OEQQ) sjrvj idtg Yuewmy =?^ menYuewmy 1:^ (Mppjen`x I). ^gjrj wjrj ed rjpdrtjn dutmojs df emv-m`ns mt tgj t`hj df mpprdmag
df FMI6:63.
EMV AMEMNM adenuatjn me m`rwmy fk`ogt agjab df tgj YI ENI e Edvjhijr 93=3, wg`agsgdwjn tgmt tgj ENI maaurmay wms w`tg`e ½:˜ e tgj v`a`e`ty df wgjrj tgj FMI6:63 adhpmssjswjrj rjsjt. ENI systjhs mrj rjqu`rjn iy ^rmespdrt Amemnm (^A) td ij hm`etm`ejn w`tg`e majrtm`e rmeoj df maaurmay< 13
ENI systjhs mrj fk`ogt agjabjn td me maaurmay df mt kjmst ½:˜ fdr me mpprdmag men½=3˜ fdr je rdutj. Gdwjvjr, huag kmrojr jrrdrs mrj pdss`ikj nuj td prdpmomt`de
97 Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY) ?3:.99(1) rjqu`rjs dpjrmtdrs td bjjp m adpy df tgj dpjrmt`demk
fk`ogt pkme (DFS) fdr m pjr`dn df edt kjss tgme 03 nmys. ^gj adhpmey bjpt jkjatrde`a adp`js df tgjDFSs fdr 03 nmys, mftjr wg`ag tgjy wjrj mutdhmt`amkky njkjtjn frdh tgj adhputjr systjhs. ^g`s mrjmdf tgj `evjst`omt`de wms edt pursujn uet`k mftjr tgj 03 nmys, men tgj DFS wms ed kdeojr mvm`kmikj.
90 ^grjj-kjttjr njet`f`jr fdr tgj Yjsdkutj Imy `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) trmesh`ttjr
13 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =>1?= ∙ ^rmespdrt Amemnm Mjrdemut`amk @efdrhmt`de Hmeumk (^A M@H), ADH ‑Adhhue`amt`des (=? Datdijr 93=1), sjat`de 1.6(n), mvm`kmikj mtgttp<//www.ta.oa.am/hjn`m/ndauhjets/am-puik`amt`des/ADH-M@H-93=1-9TJEO-1.pnf (kmstmaajssjn de 30 Njajhijr 93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 32/215
- 9> -
n`sturimeajs amusjn iy suer`sj dr suesjt, rjfkjatjn s`oemks frdh g`og tjrrm`e,rjfrmat`de df s`oemks ardss`eo sgdrjk`ejs mt kjss tgme 13˜ men jkjatr`amk stdrhs.
Medtgjr m`rarmft suaajssfukky adhpkjtjn tgj @KQ/NHJ Yuewmy 1:^ mpprdmag mpprdx`hmtjky 93h`eutjs mftjr tgj maa`njet. Ms m prjamut`demry hjmsurj, tgj @KQ wms fk`ogt-agjabjn iy EMVAMEMNM de 99 Muoust 93==. gj systjh wms njakmrjn sjrv`ajmikj.
=.7.9 Sdss`ikj `etjrfjrjeaj w`tg Yjsdkutj Imy `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh fueat`demk`ty
^gj ssuj df wgjtgjr tgjrj adukn gmvj ijje `etjrfjrjeaj w`tg tgj APYI estruhjet kmen`eosystjh (@KQ) fueat`demk`ty iy h`k`tmry mat`v`ty de tgj APYI m`rf`jkn, dr iy mey dtgjr emv`omt`demkmpprdmag m`n, wms `evjst`omtjn.
^gj @KQ kdamk`zjr s`oemk `s adet`eudusky hjmsurjn men hde`tdrjn, men sguts ndwe `f tgjtrmesh`ttjr s duts`nj tdkjrmeaj. gj Yjsdkutj Imy @KQ Yuewmy 1:^ hde`tdr nmtm wjrj rjadrnjn,men sgdwjn tgmt tgj ou`nmeaj s`oemk wms stmikj men wms edt mffjatjn iy mey etjrfjrjeaj.M`rarmft mv`de`as mksd n`sar`h`emtj uewmetjn s`oemks men f`ktjr dut ede-ou`nmeaj ed`sj, men
arjmtj m fkmo mkmrh `f tgj s`oemk kjvjk `s `esuff`a`jet. ^gjrj wms ed hjet`de iy tgj arjw df meyfkmo mkmrhs ij`eo n`spkmyjn de tgj m`rarmft mv`de`as.
Dtgjr emv-m`ns, suag ms VDY, gmvj m frjqujeay agdsje suag tgmt t ame dpjrmtj e gmrhdey w`tgtgj @KQ frjqujeay. Mey etjrfjrjeaj dr`o`emt`eo frdh m VDY wdukn ij h`ss`eo m ou`nmeajs`oemk, tgjrjiy ojejrmt`eo me m`rarmft mv`de`as fkmo mkmrh, men wdukn edt adetm`e m Hdrsj adnj`njet`f`amt`de. Ymnmr frjqujea`js mrj duts`nj tgj @KQ rmeoj, wdukn ij rjljatjn iy m`rarmft mv`de`af`ktjrs, ameedt prdv`nj m ou`nmeaj s`oemk, men mrj h`ss`eo m Hdrsj adnj njet`f`amt`de2 men tgjpuksjn emturj df tgj s`oemk ameedt akjmr me mv`de`as fkmo mkmrh.
=.0 Adhhue`amt`des
=.0.= Ojejrmk
^gj f`rst adetmat ijtwjje FMI6:63 men Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI) tjrh`emk daaurrjn mt =696<9?, wgjetgj fk`ogt wms 73 emut`amk h`kjs (eh) frdh APYI. Yjmnmi`k`ty wms e`t`mkky uesmt`sfmatdry, mensmt`sfmatdry 9-wmy adhhue`amt de wms edt jstmik`sgjn uet`k =690<>0 (:6 eh frdh APYI). Deaj9-wmy adhhue`amt`de wms jstmik`sgjn, adhhue`amt`de ijtwjje FMI6:63 men tgj APYItjrh`emk men tdwjr wms jffjat`vj. ^gj fdkkdw`eo suisjat`des njsar`ij adhhue`amt`de mat`v`t`jsedt prjv`dusky n`saussjn `e sjat`de =.=.
=.0.9 Mrr`vmk men mpprdmag df BIM030
M sjaden estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs (@FY) m`rarmft, BIM030, wms mpprdmag`eo APYI frdh tgjsdutgjmst. @e`t`mk adetmat ijtwjje BIM030 men APYI tdwjr daaurrjn mt =610<>0. gj rmnmr nmtmsgdwjn BIM030 jetjr`eo tgj Akmss N 1= adetrdk zdej mt mpprdx`hmtjky =6>3<::. @t wms trmvjkk`eo
1= Akmss N m`rspmaj `s m adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj w`tg`e wg`ag idtg estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs (@FY) men v`sumkfk`ogt rukjs (VFY) fk`ogts mrj pjrh`ttjn, iut VFY fk`ogts hust jstmik`sg 9-wmy adhhue`amt`de w`tg tgj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 33/215
- 9: -
tdwmrn tgj m`rpdrt mt me mkt`tunj df 9933 fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk) mt =:7 bedts. Mt tg`s t`hj,FMI6:63 wms 9.> eh frdh tgj m`rpdrt, trmvjkk`eo mt =71 bedts, njsajen`eo tgrduog ==33 fjjt msk.Mt =6>9<9:, BIM030 rjpdrtjn ? h`kjs sdutgjmst df tgj f`jkn. BIM030 rjpdrtjn dvjrgjmn tgj YIijmade mt =6>:<3: adhhjea`eo tgj `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) imab adursj Yuewmy =?^prdajnurj. g`s rjpdrt daaurrjn midut 1 h`eutjs mftjr tgj kmst trmesh`ss`de frdh FMI6:63.BIM030 suisjqujetky adenuatjn m h`ssjn mpprdmag, fdkkdwjn iy tgj @KQ Yuewmy 1:^, men
kmenjn mt =?37.
=.0.1 Adhhue`amt`de sjmrag fdr FMI6:63
^d rjnuaj tgj pdss`i`k`ty df adefk`at w`tg me m`rarmft jxpjr`jea`eo m adhhue`amt de fm`kurj,mrt`akj 6==.=J df EMV AMEMNM M^A HMEDSQ n`rjats adetrdkkjrs td suspjen dr rjstr`at, td tgjjxtjet ejajssmry, tgj hdvjhjet df dtgjr m`rarmft `e tgj v`a`e`ty df tgj njst`emt`de m`rpdrt fdr 13h`eutjs mftjr tgj kmtjst df tgj fdkkdw`eo t`hjs< 19
=. ^gj jst`hmtjn t`hj df mrr`vmk fure`sgjn iy tgj m`rarmft2
9. ^gj jst`hmtjn t`hj df mrr`vmk amkaukmtjn iy tgj @FY ue`t2
1.
^gj jst`hmtjn t`hj je rdutj eakunjn e tgj fk`ogt pkme2>. ^gj jxpjat-mpprdmag-akjmrmeaj t`hj kmst mabedwkjnojn iy tgj m`rarmft2 dr,
:. @f me mpprdmag akjmrmeaj gms ijje mabedwkjnojn, tgj t`hj mt wg`ag tgjm`rarmft s bedwe dr jst`hmtjn td gmvj adhhjeajn tgj mpprdmag.
_gje FMI6:63 n`n edt kmen men adukn edt ij adetmatjn, tgj tdwjr adetrdkkjr adeakunjn tgmt tgjm`rarmft gmn kdst adhhue`amt`des men wms k`bjky amrry`eo dut m h`ssjn mpprdmag. Gdwjvjr, tgjrjqu`rjhjets df mrt`akj 6==.=J wjrj edt mppk`jn.
EMV AMEMNM M^A HMEDSQ mrt`akj 69>.= 11 n`rjats adetrdkkjrs td efdrh tgj mpprdpr`mtj ld`et rjsauj addrn`emt`de ajetrj (LYAA) df efdrhmt`de rjomrn`eo me @FY dr adetrdkkjn v`sumk
fk`ogt rukjs (AVFY) m`rarmft tgmt s `e mey dej df ueajrtm`ety, mkjrt dr n`strjss pgmsjs. Me mkjrtpgmsj s m sjmrag-men-rjsauj tjrh, men rjfjrs td tgj s`tumt`de tgmt jx`sts wgje me m`rarmft gmsijje akjmrjn td kmen men fm`ks td kmen w`tg`e : h`eutjs df tgj jst`hmtjn t`hj df kmen`eo menadhhue`amt`de gms edt ijje rj-jstmik`sgjn w`tg tgj m`rarmft. 1> APYI tdwjr wms tgj adetrdkk`eomojeay mt tgj t`hj, men wms rjspdes`ikj fdr mkjrt`eo LYAA tgmt FMI6:63 wms e tgj mkjrt pgmsj.
Mt =6>:<93, midut 1 h`eutjs mftjr tgj kmst FMI6:63 trmesh`ss`de, tgj APYI tdwjr adetrdkkjrtrmesh`ttjn m amkk td FMI6:63 rjqujst`eo ts kdamt`de. Mom`e mt =6>6<1> men mt =6>7<=>, tgj tdwjradetrdkkjr mttjhptjn adetmat w`tg FMI6:63 men nja`njn tgmt tgj m`rarmft gmn prdimiky ndej m
mpprdpr`mtj m`r trmff`a adetrdk (M^A) mojeay ijfdrj jetjr`eo tgj m`rspmaj. M^A sjpmrmt`de `s prdv`njndeky td @FY m`rarmft. M`rarmft w`kk ij prdv`njn w`tg trmff`a `efdrhmt`de.
19 EMV AMEMNM, M`r ^rmff`a Adetrdk Hmeumk df Dpjrmt`des (M^A HMEDSQ) , Smrt 6< Jhjrojea`js,suipmrt 6== ‑ Ojejrmk, mrt`akj 6==.=J
11 @i`n., suipmrt 69> ‑ Edt`f`amt`de df YAA, mrt`akj 69>.=
1> Emt`demk Qjmrag men Yjsauj (QMY) Hmeumk, I-OM-930-33=/FS-33= NFD :>>0 (rjv`sjn Hmy 9333),Agmptjr 6, sjat`de 6.7.9
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 34/215
- 96 -
h`ssjn mpprdmag men gmn kdst adhhue`amt`des. Nur`eo tg`s t`hj, tgj APYI orduen adetrdkkjradetmatjn tgj f`rj gmkk td mnv`sj `t td stmeniy fdr m pdss`ikj jhjrojeay.
Mt =6>?, tgj APYI orduen adetrdkkjr adetmatjn tgj APYI Adhhue`ty Mjrdnrdhj Ymn`d Qtmt`de(AMYQ) dpjrmtdr sjjb`eo `efdrhmt`de de FMI6:63. ^gj AMYQ dpjrmtdr mnv`sjn tgmt gj gmn edtgjmrn mey amkks frdh FMI6:63 fdr m wg`kj. Mt midut tg`s t`hj, m vjg`akj wms n`spmtagjn iy APYI
tdwjr td survjy tgj m`rf`jkn men ruewmy mpprdmagjs fdr mey s`oe df tgj m`rarmft. Edej wmsrjpdrtjn.
Mt =6:><:3, tgj APYI orduen adetrdkkjr adetmatjn m EMV AMEMNM Mrat`a Ymn`d dpjrmtdr `eEdrtg Imy td equ`rj midut FMI6:63, men wms tdkn tgmt tgj fk`ogt gmn ijje njkmyjn. gj Mrat`aYmn`d dpjrmtdr n`n edt edtj wgjrj tg`s `efdrhmt`de gmn dr`o`emtjn. Mt =6:?<39, tgj APYIorduen adetrdkkjr amkkjn F`rst M`r amrod td try td njtjrh`ej wgmt tgj njkmy hmy gmvj ijje.
Mt =6:?<:6, tgj Mrat`a Ymn`d dpjrmtdr adetmatjn tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde Mrjm AdetrdkAjetrj (MAA) sjjb`eo `efdrhmt`de de tgj wgjrjmiduts df FMI6:63. Jnhdetde mnv`sjn tgmt tgjfk`ogt‐s jst`hmtjn t`hj df mrr`vmk (J^M) gmn ijje =6>: men tgmt tgj systjh n`n edt sgdw tgj
fk`ogt‐s mrr`vmk.
Mt =?36, tgj f`rj gmkk wms msbjn td pkmaj tgj f`rj truabs de stmeniy de tgj m`rf`jkn. Mt =?=>, tgjAPYI tdwjr adetrdkkjr adetmatjn tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA Fk`ogt Skmee`eo sjat`demen mnv`sjn tgmt FMI6:63 gmn ijje akjmrjn td kmen men tgmt tgjrj gmn ijje ed furtgjradhhue`amt`de w`tg tgj m`rarmft. ^gj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA mnv`sjn tgmt `t wduknadetmat F`rst M`r td njtjrh`ej wgjtgjr tgj adhpmey gmn efdrhmt`de tgmt tgj m`rarmft h`ogtgmvj ndej m h`ssjn mpprdmag. _gje F`rst M`r mnv`sjn tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA tgmt`t gmn ed `efdrhmt`de de m pdss`ikj h`ssjn mpprdmag iy FMI6:63, tgj EMV AMEMNMJnhdetde MAA adetrdkkjr amkkjn LYAA rjetde td rjpdrt tgj h`ss`eo m`rarmft.
Mt =?=0, ms tgj akduns disaur`eo tgj g`kk k`ftjn td sdhj jxtjet, pjrsdeejk ejmr tgj APYI adetrdktdwjr smw shdbj men fkmhjs de tgj g`ogjr tjrrm`e td tgj jmst df tgj ruewmy. ^gj APYI tdwjradetrdkkjr hhjn`mtjky njakmrjn me jhjrojeay men n`spmtagjn tgj f`rj vjg`akjs td tgj sajej v`mtgj deky mvm`kmikj rdutj, wg`ag wms m rdmn tgmt pmssjn edrtg df tgj ruewmy men tgje up tgj g`kkde wg`ag tgj VDY wms s`tumtjn. Mkk rjqu`rjn mojea`js wjrj tgje efdrhjn df tgj maa`njet.
Nur`eo tgj adhhue`amt`de sjmrag fdr FMI6:63, sdhj df tgj mojea`js tgmt wdukn edrhmkky ijmnv`sjn tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms `e tgj mkjrt pgmsj fdr sjmrag men rjsauj wjrj hmnj mwmrj df tgjh`ss`eo m`rarmft. Gdwjvjr, tgjrj wms ed fdrhmk njakmrmt`de df me mkjrt pgmsj iy tgj h`k`tmryadetrdk tdwjr e APYI. gjrj wjrj ed jhjrojeay agjabk`sts mvm`kmikj td tgj h`k`tmry adetrdkkjrstd vjr`fy mpprdpr`mtj mat`des.
=.=3 Mjrdnrdhj `efdrhmt`de
=.=3.= Yjsdkutj Imy m`rpdrt
Yjsdkutj Imy M`rpdrt (APYI) s dwejn men dpjrmtjn iy tgj jrr`tdry df Euemvut M`rpdrtsMutgdr`ty. ^gjrj `s = dpjrmt`demk ruewmy, =?/1: mk`oejn =6?/1>?³^. M sjaden, mimendejn,ruewmy s njp`atjn de fk`ogt efdrhmt`de puik`amt`des. Yuewmy 1:^ s 6:3> fjjt kdeo iy =0? fjjt
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 35/215
- 9? -
w`nj, w`tg m ormvjk surfmaj. gj kdeo`tun`emk skdpj frdh tgj tgrjsgdkn df Yuewmy 1:^ s up3.01% fdr tgj f`rst >?33 fjjt, men tgje ndwe 3.>3% fdr tgj kmst =733 fjjt df tgj ruewmy. ^gjm`rpdrt jkjvmt`de s 999 fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk), men tgj Yuewmy 1:^ tduagndwe zdejjkjvmt`de s =0? fjjt msk. Yuewmy 1:^ s jqu`ppjn w`tg m g`og-`etjes`ty s`hpk`f`jn sgdrtmpprdmag k`ogt`eo systjh w`tg ruewmy mk`oehjet `en`amtdr k`ogts, tgrjsgdkn men ruewmy jenk`ogts, men g`og-`etjes`ty ruewmy jnoj k`ogts, mkk w`tg : sjtt`eos. Nur`eo tgj mpprdmag df
FMI6:63, tgj mpprdmag men ruewmy k`ogts wjrj sjt td sjtt`eo :, tgj ir`ogtjst mvm`kmikj sjtt`eo.
^gjrj s ed m`rarmft rjsauj men f`rjf`ogt`eo (MYFF) ampmi`k`ty kdamtjn mt APYI. gj jhjrojeayrjspdesj pkme fdr tgj m`rpdrt, gdwjvjr, k`sts tgj rjsdurajs men rjspdes`i`k`t`js df tgj pjrsdeejkwgd mrj evdkvjn e tgj rjspdesj td vmr`dus jhjrojeay s`tumt`des. gj rdkjs df tgj AMYQdpjrmtdr, tgj AMYQ supjrv`sdr, tgj sje`dr mnh`e`strmt`vj dff`ajr, tgj sje`dr m`rpdrtrjprjsjetmt`vj, tgj Ydymk Amemn`me Hduetjn Sdk`aj (YAHS), tgj v`kkmoj vdkuetjjr f`rjnjpmrthjet, tgj f`rj ag`jf, tgj v`kkmoj hjn`amk sjrv`ajs men mhiukmeaj, tgj m`rk`ejrjprjsjetmt`vj, men tgj trmespdrtmt`de prdormhs hmemojr mrj k`stjn w`tg rjqu`rjn mat`des men`efdrhmt`de fkdw agmrts. gj v`kkmoj vdkuetjjr f`rj njpmrthjet s ampmikj df f`ogt`eo struaturmkf`rjs, iut gms ed fdmh ampmi`k`ty fdr m`rarmft f`rjs men `s edt trm`ejn fdr m`rarmft f`rjf`ogt`eo men
rjsauj.
=.=3.9 Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB mnn`t`demk rjsdurajs
Ms pmrt df Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB, tgj Amemn`me H`k`tmry jstmik`sgjn m fukky stmffjn f`rj gmkk detgj m`rpdrt, jqu`ppjn w`tg 9 Dsgbdsg M =:33A f`rj truabs, jmag amrry`eo ?:3 k`trjs df fdmh,6333 k`trjs df wmtjr, 99: b`kdormhs df nry agjh`amk, ms wjkk ms gmengjkn f`rj jxt`eou`sgjrs mensjkf-adetm`ejn irjmtg`eo mppmrmtus. Ms wjkk, m fukky stmffjn hjn`amk fma`k`ty wms jstmik`sgjn detgj m`rpdrt. Qjvjrmk h`k`tmry gjk`adptjrs (Or`ffde men Qjm B`eo) men m Admst Oumrn gjk`adptjrwjrj s`tumtjn `e APYI mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet.
=.=3.1
Adhhue`ty mjrdnrdhj rmn`d stmt`desAdhhue`ty mjrdnrdhj rmn`d stmt`des (AMYQ) prdv`nj mv`mt`de wjmtgjr men adhhue`amt`dessjrv`ajs mt njs`oemtjn s`tjs e tgj Pubde, Edrtgwjst jrr`tdr`js, Euemvut, men Edrtgjre]uàija. AMYQ fma`k`t`js mrj jqu`ppjn w`tg hjtjdrdkdo`amk estruhjets fdr hde`tdr`eo menrjadrn`eo mv`mt`de surfmaj wjmtgjr, men adhhue`amt`des jqu`phjet fdr prdv`n`eo dpjrmt`demk`efdrhmt`de td p`kdts. AMYQ mrj dpjrmtjn iy disjrvjrs/adhhue`amtdrs wgd mrj usumkkyrjaru`tjn kdamkky.
APYI `s sjrvjn iy m AMYQ ue`t, wg`ag `s gdusjn `e tgj m`rpdrt tjrh`emk iu`kn`eo. Nur`eo tgjdaaurrjeaj, tgj AMYQ wms stmffjn ms rjqu`rjn, w`tg = disjrvjr/adhhue`amtdr wgd adet`eujntd pjrfdrh tgj wjmtgjr disjrv`eo prdormh men dtgjr edrhmk AMYQ tmsbs, w`tg tgj jxajpt`de df
adhhue`amt`eo w`tg m`rarmft td prdv`nj dpjrmt`demk efdrhmt`de. gmt tmsb gmn ijje mssuhjniy tgj Amemn`me H`k`tmry m`r trmff`a adetrdk (M^A) ue`t tgmt wms sjt up td suppdrt Dpjrmt`deEMEDDB.
_jmtgjr disjrvmt`des tmbje iy tgj AMYQ stmff mrj trmesh`ttjn iy adhputjr td Jev`rdehjetAmemnm men EMV AMEMNM.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 36/215
- 97 -
=.== Fk`ogt rjadrnjrs
=.==.= Ojejrmk
Idtg tgj fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr (FNY) men tgj adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr (AVY) wjrj kdamtjn `e tgjnjir`s f`jkn de tgj nmy df tgj maa`njet, men wjrj trmespdrtjn td tgj ^QI kmidrmtdry de 9= Muoust
93==.
=.==.9 Fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr
^gj m`rarmft wms jqu`ppjn w`tg m Gdejywjkk sdk`n-stmtj FNY (hdnjk QQZFNY, pmrt ed. 073 >=93Y]ZQ). ^gj hjhdry hdnukj wms suaajssfukky ndwekdmnjn.
^gj FNY rjadrnjn m tdtmk df 9> pmrmhjtjrs. @t adetm`ejn mpprdx`hmtjky 9? gdurs df fk`ogt nmtm,wg`ag eakunjn tgj daaurrjeaj fk`ogt men =? prjv`dus fk`ogts. Mppjen`x @ tgrduog E sgdwsjohjets df vmr`dus stmojs df tgj fk`ogt. Mppjen`x D men Mppjen`x S sgdw tgj fk`ogt pmtg erjkmt`de td ok`njskdpj men kdamk`zjr ms njr`vjn frdh FNY men rmnmr nmtm.
=.==.9.= Fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr nmtm n`sarjpmeay
M nmtm n`sarjpmeay wms edtjn nur`eo tgj tmbj-dff pdrt`de df tgj maa`njet fk`ogt. Mkk df tgj vmkujsdf tgj rjadrnjn pmrmhjtjrs wjrj eades`stjet w`tg tgj jxpjatjn ijgmv`dur. Qgdrtky mftjrkjvjkk`eo dff mt tgj aru`s`eo mkt`tunj df 1= 333 fjjt, m sunnje n`sadet`eu`ty e tgj nmtm daaurrjn2tgj nmtm tgje mppjmrjn td ijadhj vmk`n men rjhm`ejn vmk`n uet`k `hpmat. ^gj `evmk`n nmtmkmstjn fdr mpprdx`hmtjky =0 h`eutjs. grjj df tgj dtgjr prjv`dus fk`ogts gmn mksd adetm`ejns`h`kmr medhmk`js mt tgj stmrt df tgj fk`ogts. Mkk df tgj medhmk`js jxg`i`tjn tgj smhjagmrmatjr`st`as, emhjky, tgmt tgjy wjrj prjsjet frdh stmrt-up men mffjatjn mkk pmrmhjtjrs. gjdeky adhhde n`st`eat`de ijtwjje tgj evmk`n nmtm pdrt`des wms tgmt tgj `evmk`n nmtm ijome mt
stmrt-up. ^gj kjeotg df t`hj jmag nmtm sjt rjhm`ejn `evmk`n wms n`ffjrjet. Fdr tgj tgrjjmnn`t`demk fk`ogts jxg`i`t eo medhmkdus nmtm mt stmrt-up, tgj kjeotg df t`hj vmr`jn frdh =3h`eutjs td dvjr 93 h`eutjs.
=.==.9.9 Ou`nmeaj fdr fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr hm`etjemeaj
Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY) Qtmenmrn 69:, Mppjen`x A, rjqu`rjs m nmtm adrrjkmt`deagjab td ij adhpkjtjn. 1: gj pmrmormpg adetm`e`eo tg`s st`pukmt de mksd rjfjrs tgj rjmnjr tdJZYDAMJ 16 JN-:: 1? fdr ou`nmeaj de FNY hm`etjemeaj, eakun`eo adrrjkmt`de agjabs. gjpurpdsj df tgj FNY adrrjkmt`de agjab s td jesurj tgmt mkk rjqu`rjn pmrmhjtjrs mrj ij`eorjadrnjn men mrj df me maajptmikj qumk`ty.
1: Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY), Qtmenmrn 69:, Mppjen`x A ‑ Dut df Sgmsj ^msbs men Jqu`phjetHm`etjemeaj Yjqu`rjhjets, pmrmormpg =?< Fk`ogt Nmtm Yjadrnjrs
16 Jurdpjme Drome`smt`de fdr A`v`k Mv`mt`de Jqu`phjet
1? Jurdpjme Drome`smt`de fdr A`v`k Mv`mt`de Jqu`phjet, Ndauhjet JN-::< H`e`huh Dpjrmt`demkSjrfdrhmeaj Qpja`f`amt`de fdr Fk`ogt Nmtm Yjadrnjr Qystjhs (Hmy =003)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 37/215
- 90 -
JN-:: rjqu`rjs hm`etjemeaj pjrsdeejk td rjpkmy mt kjmst =: h`eutjs df fk`ogt nmtm. F`rst M`r wmsadenuat`eo ts FNY adrrjkmt`de agjabs e maadrnmeaj w`tg Mppjen`x A df AMY Qtmenmrn 69:.^gj QI rjv`jwjn prjv`dus nmtm ndwekdmns tgmt F`rst M`r gmn adkkjatjn fdr pmst adrrjkmt`deagjabs. ^gjsj ndwekdmns sgdwjn tgmt tgj nmtm rjadrn`eo prdikjh fduen de tgj maa`njet FNYgmn jx`stjn s`eaj mt kjmst Hmrag 9337, iut rjhm`ejn uenjtjatjn nuj td tgj k`h`tjn nmtm rjv`jwrjqu`rjn iy JN-:: (=: h`eutjs).
@e Luej 933?, tgj ^QI prdv`njn m ir`jf`eo rjomrn`eo ‛Srdikjhs jxpjr`jeajn w`tg fk`ogtrjadrnjrs‘ td tgj ^rmespdrt Amemnm (^A) Mv`de`as Qtmenmrn`zmt`de _drbsgdp. gj ir`jf`eo`eakunjn ssujs rjkmtjn td FNY adrrjkmt`de agjabs men hm`etjemeaj. A eakunjn me mrt`akjjet`tkjn ‛@ssujs w`tg FNY men AVY Nmtm @njet`f`jn ms m Yjsukt df QI Yjv`jws‘ e Mv`mt`deQmfjty Kjttjr @ssuj 1/9337. 17 ^gj purpdsj df tgj mrt`akj wms td prdhpt dpjrmtdrs men hm`etm`ejrstd rjv`s`t tgj`r kmst fk`ogt rjadrnjr agjabs.
^gj QI adet`eujs td f`en prdikjhs w`tg FNY nmtm, sdhj df wg`ag sgdukn gmvj ijje njet`f`jnmen rjat`f`jn nur`eo tgj meeumk adrrjkmt`de agjabs. g`s s`tumt`de adukn ij nuj, e pmrt, td tgjdutnmtjn adetjet df tgj AMY Qtmenmrn 69:, Mppjen`x A.
JZYDAMJ spja`f`amt`des mrj rjadoe`zjn etjremt`demkky men mrj a`tjn e tgj @etjremt`demk A`v`kMv`mt`de Drome`zmt`de (@AMD) Qtmenmrns men Yjadhhjenjn Srmat`ajs. @e 9331, JN-:: wmssupjrsjnjn iy JN-==9. JN-==9 wms puik`sgjn td upnmtj fk`ogt rjadrnjr spja`f`amt`des, menprdv`njs jegmeajn ou`nmeaj fdr FNY hm`etjemeaj. gj ou`nmeaj fdr tgj nmtm adrrjkmt`de agjabwms mksd jegmeajn men rjqu`rjs tgj nmtm smhpkj td `eakunj m wgdkj fk`ogt, frdh stmrt-up tdsgutndwe. Furtgjr mhjenhjet df JN-==9 `s deod`eo, td rjfkjat tgj hdst aurrjet tjage`amk`efdrhmt`de.
=.==.9.1 M`rarmft trmab amkaukmt`de
^gj FNY n`n edt rjadrn pds`t`demk nmtm dr t`hj. ^gj h`k`tmry rmnmr nmtm wjrj vmk`nmtjn iy tgj^QI Kmidrmtdry men usjn mkdeo w`tg tgj survjyjn hpmat hmrb`eos td njtjrh`ej tgj fk`ogt pmtgw`tg rjspjat td tgj ruewmy mt Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI).
^gj rmnmr nmtm wjrj usjn td amkaukmtj tgj m`rarmft trmab. ^gj rjadrnjn mkt`tunj, en`amtjnm`rspjjn men gjmn`eo pmrmhjtjrs wjrj tgje usjn td arjmtj m fk`ogt pmtg. ^gj fk`ogt pmtg wmstgje k`ejmrky etjrpdkmtjn td tgj trmab, wg`ag rjsuktjn e m shddtgjn men maaurmtj fk`ogt pmtg.
^gj m`rarmft pds`t`de nmtm wjrj usjn td amkaukmtj tgj m`rarmft orduen trmab men orduen spjjn.^gj fdrjamst w`en spjjn men n`rjat`de wjrj tgje usjn td amkaukmtj tgj m`rarmft nr`ft, gjmn`eo mentruj m`rspjjn. gj rjsukt`eo m`rarmft gjmn`eo men truj m`rspjjn wjrj adhpmrjn td tgj rjsukts dftgj fk`ogt pmtg amkaukmt`de, men tgjrj wms oddn morjjhjet ijtwjje tgj pmrmhjtjrs.
17 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =7: ‑ Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Kjttjr , @ssuj 1/9337
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 38/215
- 13 -
=.==.9.> Gjmn`eo nmtm
^gj FNY rjaj`vjs gjmn`eo`efdrhmt`de frdh tgj ed .9adhpmss. Mkk nmtm rjadrnjn detgj FNY frdh jeo`ej stmrt
uet`k =>:7<:?.: wjrj evmk`n2adesjqujetky, ed gjmn`eo`efdrhmt`de s mvm`kmikj fdrtg`s pdrt`de df tgj fk`ogt. gjvmk`n rjadrnjn ed. 9 adhpmssgjmn`eo nmtm fdr tgjrjhm`enjr df tgj fk`ogt wjrjjxmh`ejn iy QI`evjst`omtdrs.
Nuj td tgj medhmkdus tmbj-dff
nmtm, `t adukn edt ijnjtjrh`ejn wgjtgjr tgj tmbj-dff daaurrjn `e njorjjshmoejt`a, men `f `t n`n, mt wgmtpd`et tgj gjmn`eo wmsueskmvjn men wms sjt tdnjorjjs truj. Mt =69:<3?, tgjgjmn`eo pmrmhjtjr wmssg`ftjn, en`amt`eo m gjmn`eomnlusthjet hmnj iy tgj fk`ogtarjw. gj gjmn`eo rjadrnjnde tgj FNY adhpmrjn td tgj jst`hmtjn matumk m`rarmft gjmn`eo wms mpprdx`hmtjky 93³ n`ffjrjetmt tgj t`hj df `hpmat.
M w`en tr`meokj hmy ij usjn td hmbj amkaukmt`des df uebedwe vmr`mikjs f suff`a`jet dtgjrvmr`mikjs mrj bedwe (F`ourj 1 men ^mikj 7).
F`ourj 1. Kdamt`des fdr gjmn`eo amkaukmt`des
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 39/215
- 1= -
^mikj 7. Quhhmry df w`en tr`meokj amkaukmt`des (orjy sgmnjn mrjms mrj amkaukmt`de rjsukts2)
=69:<3? ed. 9adhpmss rj-skmvjn
=617<33 ijfdrjture mt HZQM^
=6>3<1: de sgdrtf`emk mpprdmag
Mkt`tunj FK973 >133 fjjt msk =9>3 fjjt msk
B^MQ >36 93? =?0
_`en (³^/bedts) 9=6/?> 93>/99 93>/=7
Ymnmr orduen trmab (³^) 31? 317 1:=
Yjsuktmet orduen spjjn(bedts)
>73 997 =0>
Yjsuktmet gjmn`eo (³^) 31? 310 1>7
Yjadrnjn ed. 9 adhpmssgjmn`eo (³)
390 39> 11=
Gjmn`eo n`ffjrjet`mk (³) ∙7 ∙=: ∙=?
B^MQ< bedts truj m`rspjjnmsk< midvj sjm kjvjk
Mt tgj t`hjs en`amtjn fdr tgj adhpmss amkaukmt`des e mikj 7, tgj FNY nmtm sgdwjn tgj m`rarmft`e m w`eos-kjvjk mtt`tunj.
^gj FNY nmtm sgdwjn pjr`dns nur`eo wg`ag tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo pmrmhjtjr agmeojnsuistmet`mkky wg`kj tgj m`rarmft wms fky`eo w`eos-kjvjk. wd jxmhpkjs mrj frdh tgjadhhjeajhjet df vmk`n nmtm mt =>:7<:?.: td =:>7<9: men mom`e frdh =:>0<=1 td =6=9<33. Nur`eoidtg pjr`dns, tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo skdwky agmeojn mt m rmtj df +9:³ pjr gdur. Medtgjr jxmhpkj,
`e wg`ag tgj nr`ft wms `e tgj dppds`tj n`rjat`de, daaurrjn frdh =69:<37 td =61:<=3 mt m rmtj df∙=7³ pjr gdur. ^QI `evjst`omtdrs adesuktjn w`tg Idj`eo, Gdejywjkk, _jstjre Mv`de`as, F`rstM`r, men tgj Ydymk Amemn`me M`r Fdraj (YAMF) Qagddk df M`r Emv`omt`de e me jffdrt tdnjtjrh`ej wgy tg`s adhpmss ijgmv`dur daaurrjn. Ed adeakus`vj meswjr wms njtjrh`ejn.
=.==.9.: Adetrdk wgjjk `eput nmtm
^gj FNY rjadrnjn sjvjrmk adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjets tgmt adukn edt ij maaduetjn fdr iymutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de< ijtwjje =617<>0 men =617<:?, mt =610<=7, men mt =610<16.
=.==.1 Adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr
^gj m`rarmft wms jqu`ppjn w`tg m Gdejywjkk sdk`n-stmtj AVY w`tg m h`e`huh rjadrn`eoampma`ty df 13 h`eutjs. gj hjhdry wms ndwekdmnjn suaajssfukky men adetm`ejn oddn-qumk`tymun`d df tgj f`emk 1= h`eutjs df tgj fk`ogt.
=.==.1.= Fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr men adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr syeagrde`zmt`de
^gj AVY t`h`eo wms adevjrtjn td Ze`vjrsmk Addrn`emtjn ^`hj (Z^A) iy syeagrde`z`eo tgjmun`d w`tg tgj m`r trmff`a adetrdk (M^A) rjadrn`eos rjaj`vjn frdh EMV AMEMNM. gj FNY wms
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 40/215
- 19 -
tgje syeagrde`zjn w`tg tgj AVY iy adhpmr`sde df tgj VGF bjy`eo rjadrnjn de tgj FNY. ^gjsmhpk`eo rmtj fdr VGF bjy`eo `s deaj pjr sjaden2 adesjqujetky, tgj pdss`ikj jrrdr `e tgjAVY/FNY syeagrde`zmt`de adukn ij ½= sjaden.
=.=9 _rjabmoj men `hpmat `efdrhmt`de
=.=9.= @hpmat
^gj m`rarmft adkk`njn w`tg tgjsgduknjr df m g`kk mpprdx`hmtjky= emut`amk h`kj (eh) jmst df tgjh`n-f`jkn df Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI).@t struab up-skdp`eo tjrrm`e mt106 fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk) `e m:³ edsj-up, w`eos-kjvjk mtt`tunj,ijfdrj rjiduen`eo etd tgj m`r,sgjnn`eo adhpdejets mkdeo tgjnjir`s trm`k. gj m`rarmft adet`eujn`e m imkk`st`a mra dvjr tgj arjst dftgj sgduknjr men adetmatjn tgjsk`ogtky ndwe-skdp`eo orduenmkdeo tgj pkmtjmu fdrhjn iy tgjtdp df tgj sgduknjr (F`ourj >).
^gj sjadenmry adetmat wmsmpprdx`hmtjky :03 fjjt ndwe-rmeoj frdh tgj `e`t`mk hpmatkdamt`de. gj m`rarmft irdbj etd 1
hm`e sjat`des (tgj jhpjeemoj,tgj ajetrj fusjkmoj men w`eos,men tgj fdrwmrn fusjkmoj/adabp`t) ms t sk`n mkdeo tgj orduen. gj jhpjeemoj men ajetrjfusjkmoj rjhm`ejn de tgj pkmtjmu2 tgj fdrwmrn fusjkmoj/adabp`t adet`eujn furtgjr mkdeo tgjnjir`s f`jkn men amhj td rjst `e m oukky fdrhjn iy m strjmh tgmt nrm`ejn `etd Qtr`p Kmbj(Sgdtd >).
^gj njir`s trm`k njvjkdpjn e m EE_ n`rjat`de, fdkkdw`eo m ijmr`eo df mpprdx`hmtjky 1>>³^.^gj njir`s trm`k gmn me dvjrmkk kjeotg df =>33 fjjt frdh tgj pd`et df `e`t`mk `hpmat td tgj adabp`t.^gj w`njst sjat`de df tgj njir`s trm`k wms midut 193 fjjt. Dej wgjjk amhj td rjst mt tgj idttdh dftgj g`kk jmst df Qtr`p Kmbj.
F`ourj >. Maa`njet s`tj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 41/215
- 11 -
Sgdtd >. Maa`njet s`tj kddb`eo edrtg
=.=9.9 _rjabmoj
Mkk df tgj nmhmoj td tgj m`rarmft struaturj fduen `e tgj njir`s trm`k wms nuj td adetmat w`tg tgjorduen. Mkk df tgj pr`ea`pmk struaturmk adhpdejets df tgj m`rarmft wjrj maaduetjn fdr `e tgjnjir`s trm`k. Ed jv`njeaj wms fduen td suoojst tgmt tgjrj wms mey struaturmk fm`kurj uerjkmtjn tdorduen adetmat.
^gj jxtjes`vj irjmbup df tgj m`rarmft men sjvjrj pdst-armsg f`rj nmhmoj hmnj `t `hpdss`ikj tdadenuat m adhpkjtj survjy df mkk df tgj frmaturj surfmajs. Gdwjvjr, mkk tgdsj frmaturj surfmajstgmt wjrj jxmh`ejn jxg`i`tjn fjmturjs tgmt wjrj ades`stjet w`tg me dvjrstrjss hdnj df fm`kurj.Ed s`oe wms fduen df prj-jx`st`eo fmt`ouj fm`kurjs.
^gj ajetrj pdrt`de df tgj fusjkmoj men r`ogt w`eo gmn ijje jxpdsjn td m sjvjrj pdst-armsg f`rj.Edej df tgj wrjabmoj fduen `e tgj njir`s trm`k jmrk`jr td tgmt pd`et sgdwjn mey jv`njeaj df f`rjnmhmoj. Ed s`oe wms fduen td suoojst tgmt tgjrj gmn ijje m f`rj de idmrn tgj m`rarmft ijfdrj tgjarmsg.
Nmhmoj td tgj ed. = men ed. 9 jeo`ejs wms ades`stjet w`tg me hpmat wg`kj dpjrmt`eo w`tg g`ogrdtmt`demk jejroy. ^gj s`h`kmr`t`js `e tgj nmhmoj ijtwjje tgj 9 jeo`ejs suoojst tgmt idtgjeo`ejs wjrj rdtmt`eo mt adhpmrmikj spjjns. Idtg jeo`ejs wjrj dpjrmt`eo edrhmkky menrjspden`eo td eputs ijfdrj `hpmat.
^gj VGF EMV sjkjatdr sw`tag wms rjadvjrjn e tgj AMS^ DE MZW pds`t`de. H`ardsadp`ajxmh`emt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj sw`tag wms k`bjky e tgj EDYHMK pds`t`de ijfdrj hpmat iutgmn ijje fdrajn `etd tgj AMS^ DE MZW pds`t`de nuj td `hpmat fdrajs.
Mkk 1 VGF/EMV rjaj`vjrs wjrj rjadvjrjn `e nmhmojn aden`t`de. ^gj rjaj`vjrs wjrj jxmh`ejnuenjr supjrv`s`de df tgj QI mt tgj Ydabwjkk Adkk`es fma`k`t`js e @rv`eo, jxms, de =9 Njajhijr93==. ^gj jxmh`emt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt idtg tgj ed. = men ed. 9 rjaj`vjrs k`bjky gmn me`estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) frjqujeay sjkjatjn. gj jxmh`emt`de adukn edt njtjrh`ej tgj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 42/215
- 1> -
tue`eo pds`t`de df tgj ed. 1 rjaj`vjr. Ijamusj tgj VGF EMV sjkjatdr sw`tag wms k`bjky e tgjEDYHMK pds`t`de, tgj ed. 1 rjaj`vjr wdukn edt gmvj ijje mat`vjky `e usj mt tgj t`hj df tgjmaa`njet.
N`smssjhiky men h`ardsadp`a jxmh`emt`de df tgj amptm`e‐s EMV/Adh adetrdk pmejknjtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj EMV sjkjatdr gmn m sjtt`eo df ==3.13 (@KQ frjqujeay fdr APYI) mt tgj t`hj
df `hpmat. ^gj n`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet (NHJ) sjkjatdr n`mk wms sjt td NHJ. ^gj FD‐sEMV/Adh adetrdk pmejk wms fduen w`tg tgj EMV sjkjatdr sjt mt ==3.13. ^gj NHJ sjkjatdr n`mkwms sjt td NHJ.
Ed efdrhmt`de adukn ij ditm`ejn frdh jxmh`emt`de df tgj mutdhmt`a n`rjat`de f`en`eo (MNF)adhpdejets.
^gj adhpmss trmesfjr sw`tag wms m kdab`eo tdookj-typj sw`tag tgmt wms rjadvjrjn e tgj ID^GDE = pds`t`de. H`ardsadp`a jxmh`emt`de rjvjmkjn tgmt tgj sw`tag gmn k`bjky ijje `e tgjEDYHMK pds`t`de ijfdrj hpmat men gmn ijje fdrajn `etd tgj ms-rjaj`vjn pds`t`de nuj td`hpmat fdrajs.
Nmhmoj td tgj adhpmss adetrdkkjrs prjakunjn njtjrh`emt`de df prj-`hpmat aden`t`de dr sw`tagsjtt`eos. ^gj pdst-`hpmat pds`t`de df tgj kmt`tunj bedi de tgj ed. = men ed. 9 adhpmssadetrdkkjrs wms 67³ men 66³, rjspjat`vjky.
Kmidrmtdry jxmh`emt`de df tgj estruhjet adhpmrmtdr iukis adukn edt hmbj mey adeakus`de mstd tgj`r kkuh`emt`de stmtj mt hpmat. gjrj wms ed efdrhmt`de de tgj adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr(AVY) rjomrn`eo `kkuh`emt`de df tgj gjmn`eo adhpmrmtdr meeuea`mtdr mt mey t`hj nur`eo tgjfk`ogt.
Kmidrmtdry jxmh`emt`de adeakunjn tgmt tgj w`nj ed. 9 MNF/VDY ijmr`eo pd`etjr de tgjamptm`e‐s rmn`d-hmoejt a en`amtdr (YH@) wms en`amt`eo ijtwjje 1=:³ men 193³ mt tgj t`hj df`hpmat. Ed dtgjr adeakus`des adukn ij hmnj rjomrn`eo prj-`hpmat aden`t`de. Jxmh`emt`de dftgj FD‐s YH@ adukn edt hmbj mey adeakus`des ms td prj-`hpmat aden`t`de.
^gj amptm`e‐s gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de en`amtdr (GQ@) gmn m irdbje fmaj okmss, men tgj etjremkadhpdejets wjrj nmhmojn. Ms rjaj`vjn, tgj en`amtjn gjmn`eo uenjr tgj kuiijr k`ej wms 113³,tgj adursj aduetjr wms sjt td 907³, tgj NHJ `en`amtdr wms sgdw`eo 333, men tgj gjmn`eo iuowms sjt td 113³. Imsjn de hun-pmttjre memkys`s df tgj n`spkmys, tgj adursj aduetjr mppjmrs tdgmvj ijje sjt td 197³ men tgj NHJ `en`amtdr wms n`spkmy`eo 3=3 wgje tgj fmaj okmss irdbj.^gjrj wjrj ed dtgjr adeakus`vj hmrb`eos de tgj estruhjet.
^gj fmaj okmss frdh tgj FD‐s GQ@ wms irdbje, kjmv`eo tgj n`mk fmaj jxpdsjn. Ms rjaj`vjn, tgj`en`amtjn gjmn`eo uenjr tgj kuiijr k`ej wms 193³, tgj adursj aduetjr wms sjt td 1>3³, tgj NHJ`en`amtdr wms sgdw`eo 633, men tgjrj wjrj ed gjmn`eo iuos prjsjet. M pm`et shjmr de tgjadhpmss amrn tgmt wms ades`stjet w`tg tgj jnoj df tgj pd`etjr adh`eo etd adetmat w`tg t pkmajntgj adursj njv`mt`de imr mt me `en`amt`de df = ndt kjft df ajetrj. ^gj adursj aduetjr mppjmrs tdgmvj ijje sjt td 1>1³ wgje tgj fmaj okmss irdbj, imsjn de jxmh`emt`de df tgj hun pmttjre detgj n`spkmy. gjrj wjrj ed dtgjr adeakus`vj hmrb`eos de tgj estruhjet.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 43/215
- 1: -
Kmidrmtdry jxmh`emt`de df idtg GQ@s adukn edt hmbj mey adeakus`des ms td tgj`r prj-`hpmataden`t`de.
Mktgduog vmr`dus mutdp`kdt adhpdejets wjrj rjadvjrjn, t wms edt pdss`ikj td adeakus`vjkynjtjrh`ej mey df tgj sjtt`eos mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet, ms tgjrj wjrj ed njf`e`t`vj hmrb`eosmen ed ndwekdmnmikj ede-vdkmt`kj hjhdry e tgj vmr`dus adhpdejets.
Jeo`ejjr`eo jxmh`emt`de df tgj m`rarmft‐s meeuea`mtdr kmhps omvj ueajrtm`e rjsukts. Edej df tgjmeeuea`mtdrs jxg`i`tjn mey strjtag dr uead`k`eo typ`amkky mssda`mtjn w`tg f`kmhjets tgmt wjrjgdt mt tgj t`hj df `hpmat, jvje fdr meeuea`mtdrs tgmt wjrj jxpjatjn td gmvj ijje de. @t `stgjrjfdrj pdss`ikj tgmt sdhj meeuea`mtdrs hmy gmvj ijje de mt tgj t`hj df tgj `e`t`mt`de df tgj`hpmat, iut mppjmrjn dff wgje memkyzjn.
Jeo`ejjr`eo jxmh`emt`de df tgj ede-vdkmt kj hjhdry frdh tgj 9 OSQ ue`ts rjvjmkjn tgjfdkkdw`eo efdrhmt`de<
• Idtg adetm`ejn tgj aurrjet nmtmimsj, wg`ag gmn me jxp`ry nmtj df 9: Muoust 93==.
• Idtg ue`ts gmn tgj smhj nmtm de tgjh.
• Idtg ue`ts sgdwjn tgmt tgj m`rarmft gmn njv`mtjn td tgj r`ogt df tgj njs`rjn trmab.
• @t wms edt pdss`ikj td njtjrh`ej wgmt samkj tgj adetrdk n`spkmy ue`ts (ANZs) wjrj sjt tdmt tgj t`hj df tgj daaurrjeaj, ms tg`s efdrhmt`de rjsjts wgje tgj ue`t kdsjs pdwjr.
• ^gj kmst pds`t`de wms edtjn td ij ?>³>9.06' E, 30>³::.3>' _.
• D^EJK wms tgj aurrjetky sjkjatjn wmypd`et.
• ^gj mat`vj fk`ogt pkme wms edtjn td ij V@M YEMV1:<
• N`rjat td HZQM^ =933 fjjt
• D^EJK (f`emk mpprdmag f`x) =333 fjjt (tg`s en`amt`de wms e purpkj, sgdw`eo tgmt twms tgj tmrojt pd`et)
• Y_1: (h`ssjn mpprdmag pd`et) (tg`s en`amt`de wms e orjje, sgdw`eo tgmt t `s tgjejxt pd`et `e tgj k`st)
• APYI
=.=1 Hjn`amk men pmtgdkdo`amk `efdrhmt`de
^gjrj wms edtg`eo td en`amtj tgmt tgj amptm`e‐s dr FD‐s pjrfdrhmeaj wms njormnjn iypgys`dkdo`amk fmatdrs.
=.=> F`rj
Mt =?36, tgj f`rj gmkk wms msbjn td pkmaj tgj f`rj truabs de stmeniy de tgj m`rf`jkn. Mt =?=0, ms tgjakduns disaur`eo tgj g`kk k`ftjn td sdhj jxtjet, pjrsdeejk ejmr tgj adetrdk tdwjr rjpdrtjn sjj`eoshdbj men fkmhjs de tgj g`ogjr tjrrm`e de tgj jmst s`nj df tgj ruewmy. gj orduen adetrdkkjr`hhjn`mtjky njakmrjn me jhjrojeay men n`spmtagjn tgj f`rj vjg`akjs td tgj sajej. ^gj f`rj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 44/215
- 16 -
rjspdesj vjg`akjs prdajjnjn frdh tgj m`rf`jkn up td tgj maa`njet s`tj v`m tgj maajss rdmn td tgjVDY metjeem. Srdorjss wms skdw nuj td tgj rjnuajn v`s`i`k`ty de tgj g`kk. gj f`rj ag`jf, amkk s`oeYjn Kjmnjr, bjpt tgj tdwjr mnv`sjn df tgj prdorjss, men lust pmst tgj VDY, `en`amtjn tgmt tgjtjrrm`e wms tdd trjmagjrdus fdr adet`eujn nr`v`eo. Yjn Kjmnjr n`shduetjn frdh tgj vjg`akj tdijttjr mssjss aden`t`des. Mt tgj smhj t`hj, Yjn Kjmnjr rjqujstjn tgmt ms hmey mkk-tjrrm`evjg`akjs (M^Vs) ms pdss`ikj ij n`spmtagjn td ijttjr maajss tgj s`tj men td amrry suppk`js td tgj
f`rjf`ogtjrs.
Mt =?1=, Yjn Kjmnjr mnv`sjn tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms `e s`ogt iut st`kk disaurjn men wms sdhjn`stmeaj mwmy. Gj rjpdrtjn m shmkk f`rj, wg`ag gj njtjrh`ejn adukn ij mttmabjn iy tgjf`rjf`ogtjrs, men rjqujstjn tgmt tgj M^Vs, de mrr`vmk mt tgj f`rj vjg`akjs, p`ab up jxt`eou`sgjrsmen sjkf-adetm`ejn irjmtg`eo mppmrmtus, ijamusj tgj vjg`akjs adukn prdajjn ed furtgjr nuj td mrmv`ej. Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj rjhm`e`eo f`rjf`ogtjrs n`shduetjn, jqu`ppjn tgjhsjkvjs w`tg 9 f`rjjxt`eou`sgjrs jmag frdh tgj vjg`akjs, men rme td tgj maa`njet s`tj, rjpdrtjn td ij midut 733 hn`stmet.
^gj f`rjf`ogtjrs qu`abky jxt`eou`sgjn tgj f`rj `e tgj fusjkmoj df tgj m`rarmft men tgje mss`stjn f`rst
rjspdenjrs td sjaurj tgj s`tj men trjmt tgj surv`vdrs.
=.=: Qurv`vmk mspjats
=.=:.= Yjsauj rjspdesj
Mt =?1?, Yjn Kjmnjr wms `efdrhjn tgmt tgjrj wjrj =: pjdpkj de idmrn tgj m`rarmft. Mt =?>=, YjnKjmnjr rjpdrtjn tgmt 1 surv`vdrs gmn ijje kdamtjn men tgj sjmrag fdr dtgjrs wms ij`eodrome`zjn e maadrnmeaj w`tg rjsauj prdajnurjs. gj dtgjr arjw men pmssjeojrs wjrj fduen tdgmvj n`jn de hpmat.
Ms tgj akduns k`ftjn, me YAMF Or`ffde gjk`adptjr wms n`spmtagjn frdh tgj m`rf`jkn td tgj s`tj. Mtmpprdx`hmtjky =?10, m sjmrag-men-rjsauj tjage`a`me de idmrn wms mikj td n`rjat tgj gjk`adptjr tdtgj hdst mpprdpr`mtj kmen`eo s`tj sd ms edt td n`sturi tgj f`rjf`ogt`eo dpjrmt`de. Qtrjtagjrsmrr`vjn de sajej, men tgj 1 surv`vdrs wjrj kdmnjn midmrn tgj gjk`adptjr men m`rk`ftjn n`rjatky tdtgj h`k`tmry‐s gdsp`tmk mt mpprdx`hmtjky =?::. gj surv`vdrs wjrj suisjqujetky m`rk`ftjn dut dfYjsdkutj Imy (APYI) de m h`k`tmry AA-=?? trmespdrt m`rarmft mt 99==, men mrr`vjn e @qmku`t,Euemvut, mt 331=. Mkk 1 surv`vdrs wjrj jvjetumkky trmesfjrrjn td gdsp`tmks e Dttmwm, Detmr`d.
=.=:.9 Jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr
^gjrj wms ed rjadrn df mey mojeay njtjat`eo me jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr (JK^) s`oemk
frdh tgj m`rarmft. gj `evjst`omt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj JK^ gmn ijje estmkkjn w`tg tgjmat`vmt`de sw`tag e tgj DFF pds`t`de men tgjrjfdrj adukn edt mutdhmt`amkky trmesh`t upde`hpmat. ^gj amikj kjmn`eo frdh tgj JK^ td `ts metjeem wms sjvjrjn de `hpmat, wg`ag wdukngmvj s`oe`f`ametky rjnuajn tgj trmesh`ss`de s`oemk gmn tgj JK^ ijje mrhjn. @t wms mksdnjtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj m`rarmft etjrfmaj hdnukj (ndeokj) adetm`ejn tgj njet`f`jr adnj frdh tgjprjv`dus m`rarmft de wg`ag t wms estmkkjn. Gmv`eo tgj eadrrjat njet`f`jr prdormhhjn e tgjJK^ wdukn edt gmvj prjvjetjn t frdh pjrfdrh`eo ms njs`oejn, iut t wdukn gmvj en`amtjn tdQjmrag men Yjsauj tgmt m n`ffjrjet m`rarmft wms trmesh`tt`eo me jhjrojeay s`oemk.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 45/215
- 1? -
=.=:.1 M`rarmft daaupmet sjmts / struaturmk nmhmoj
Fdr tgj daaurrjeaj fk`ogt, tgj m`rarmft wms adef`ourjn w`tg : amrod stmt`des men > rdws dfpmssjeojr sjmt`eo. gj fk`ogt mttjenmets wjrj sjmtjn ijg`en tgj fdurtg rdw df pmssjeojrs, detgj kjft s`nj df tgj m`rarmft. ^gj daaup`jn sjat`des df tgj m`rarmft wjrj jxtjes`vjky nmhmojn
nur`eo tgj maa`njet sjqujeaj.
^gj ijkky df tgj ajetrj fusjkmoj wms pmrt`mkky tdre dff, ades`stjet w`tg tgj wrjabmoj nrmoo`eo detgj orduen ijfdrj adh`eo td rjst. ^gj fkddr df tgj pmssjeojr ami`e adhpkjtjky sjpmrmtjn frdhtgj fusjkmoj men wms jxtjes`vjky irdbje up. M sjat`de df fkddr adetm`e`eo tgj > kjft-s`nj rdws dfpmssjeojr sjmts amhj td rjst 1?9 h (=999 fjjt) frdh tgj `e`t`mk `hpmat, ijtwjje tgj mft men ajetrjfusjkmoj sjat`des. gj r`ogt-s`nj fkddr men pmssjeojr sjmts wjrj jxtjes`vjky irdbje up mensamttjrjn mardss tgj njir`s f`jkn. gj fk`ogt mttjenmet sjmts gmn sjpmrmtjn frdh tgj m`rarmftstruaturj. gj fdrwmrn fusjkmoj sjat`de men adabp`t jxpjr`jeajn sjvjrj struaturmk irjmbup. gjfk`ogt adhpmrthjet w`endws men surrduen`eo struaturj, edsj kmen`eo ojmr wjkk, fdrwmrnprjssurj iukbgjmn men edsj rmndhj wjrj sjpmrmtjn frdh tgj fusjkmoj. gj p`kdts‐ sjmts gmn
sjpmrmtjn frdh tgj fkddr.
^gj rjstrm`et systjh usjn td prjvjet daaupmets, amrod, men adhpdejets frdh str`b`eo jmagdtgjr w`tg`e tgj m`rarmft s adhhdeky rjfjrrjn td ms tgj t`j-ndwe agm`e. g`s t`j-ndwe agm`eades`sts df tgj sjmt ijkt men meagdrmoj, sgduknjr gmrejss men meagdrmoj, sjmt struaturj menmeagdrmojs, men fkddr. Fm`kurj df mey adhpdejet e tgj t`j-ndwe agm`e w`kk orjmtky earjmsj tgjr`sb df elury. @e tg`s maa`njet, fm`kurjs wjrj edtjn e mkk df tgj daaupmets‐ idny rjstrm`etsystjhs.
Mkk df tgj sjmts adetm`ejn irdbje men/dr njfdrhjn frmh`eo men/dr sjmt imabs, pmes, men mrhrjsts. @t s k`bjky tgmt sdhj df tg`s nmhmoj wms amusjn iy jljatjn sjmts adkk`n`eo w`tg tgj orduenw`tg s`oe`f`amet hdhjetuh. ^gjsj disjrvmt`des `en`amtj tgmt tgj fdrajs mat`eo upde tgj sjmtstruaturj men mttmaghjets ms m rjsukt df tgj irjmbup sjqujeaj jxajjnjn tgj`r njs`oe strjeotg.
@t wms edtjn tgmt sjmt nmhmoj wms hdrj s`oe`f`amet wgjrj tgj m`rarmft struaturj wms hdrjjxtjes`vjky nmhmojn, suag ms tgj r`ogt dutidmrn sjmts men tgj fk`ogt mttjenmets‐ rdw, wg`ag wmsad`ea`njet w`tg tgj sjpmrmt`de ijtwjje tgj ajetrj men mft fusjkmoj sjat`des. @t s ades`njrjnk`bjky tgmt tgjsj sjmts sjpmrmtjn jmrk`jr nur`eo tgj irjmbup sjqujeaj. Adesjqujetky, tgjy wdukngmvj gmn orjmtjr hdhjetuh, mkkdw`eo tgjh td trmvjk dvjr hdrj n`stmeaj tgme tgj kjft-s`njsjmts2 gjeaj tgj orjmtjr nmhmoj disjrvjn.
Mt tgj t`hj df tgj armsg, tgj prj-kmen`eo pmssjeojr ir`jf`eo gmn ijje amrr`jn dut men tgj ami`egmn ijje sjaurjn fdr kmen`eo. gjrj wms ed en`amt`de tgmt tgj fk`ogt mttjenmets wjrj mwmrj dfmey ejjn td prjpmrj tgj ami`e fdr me jhjrojeay `e mnvmeaj df tgj armsg. Ej`tgjr fk`ogt mttjenmetsurv`vjn tgj armsg, sd tgjy wjrj edt evdkvjn e mey pdst-armsg jvmaumt`de, f`rjf`ogt`eo, dr f`rstm`n jffdrts. gj surv`vdrs wjrj sjr`dusky elurjn, iut wjrj suff`a`jetky hdi`kj td mss`st jmagdtgjr td tgj jnoj df tgj njir`s f`jkn men akjmr df tgj f`rj men shdbj, wgjrj tgjy mwm`tjn rjsauj.
^gj pdst-armsg jxmh`emt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt sdhj df tgj pmssjeojr kmp ijkts hmy edt gmvj ijjetjes`dejn t`ogtky mrduen tgj g`ps df tgj daaupmets. Hjn`amk efdrhmt`de en`amtjs tgmt kddsj kmpijkts n`n edt adetr`iutj td tgj jxtjes`vj elur`js sustm`ejn iy tgj daaupmets. gjrj wjrj ed
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 46/215
- 17 -
`en`amt`des df me mssda`mt`de ijtwjje m kddsj kmp ijkt men tgj daaupmet ij`eo jljatjn frdh tgj`rsjmt. gjrjfdrj, tgjrj wjrj ed `en`amt`des tgmt tgj mnlusthjet men pds`t`de`eo df tgj kmp ijktswms adetr`iutdry td tgj surv`vmi`k`ty df tg`s maa`njet fdr j`tgjr mnukts dr ag`knrje.
=.=6 ^jsts men rjsjmrag
^gj QI adenuatjn m sjr`js df sjss`des e m I?1?-933 s`hukmtdr kdamtjn e Vmeaduvjr, Ir`t`sgAdkuhi`m, frdh =0 td 93 Hmrag 93=9. gj purpdsj df tgjsj s`hukmtdr sjss`des wms td<
Fmh`k`mr`zj evjst`omtdrs w`tg<=.
• I?1? adabp`t kmydut, jrodedh`as, men prdajnurmk wdrbfkdw2
• Dpjrmt`de df tgj mutdp`kdt, fk`ogt n`rjatdr, men VGF emv`omt`de systjhs2 men
• Arjw etjrfmajs w`tg tgjsj adhpdejets2 men td
Jvmkumtj daaurrjeaj mpprdmag sajemr`ds njvjkdpjn iy `evjst`omtdrs.9.
Fdur sjpmrmtj s`hukmtdr sjss`des wjrj adenuatjn dvjr tgj 9-nmy v`s`t, rjsukt`eo e 16 tdtmk rues.Mttjenjjs eakunjn pjrsdeejk frdh tgj QI (tjst n`rjatdr, guhme pjrfdrhmeaj evjst`omtdr, menhukt`hjn`m spja`mk`st), ZQ Emt`demk rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn (E^QI) (dpjrmt`des menguhme pjrfdrhmeaj evjst`omtdrs), F`rst M`r (hmemojhjet men trm`e`eo p`kdts), men Idj`eo(systjhs men jeo`ejjr`eo evjst`omtdrs). gj s`hukmtdr wms dpjrmtjn iy m F`rst M`rrjprjsjetmt`vj, wg`kj rjprjsjetmt`vjs frdh F`rst M`r men Idj`eo p`kdtjn tgj s`hukmtdr.
^gj s`hukmtdr wms jqu`ppjn w`tg tgj smhj mutdp`kdt men fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjhs ms estmkkjn eA-OE_E. Ms tgj s`hukmtdr wms edt jqu`ppjn w`tg OSQ, tg`s adhpdejet adukn edt ijs`hukmtjn.
^gj s`hukmtdr sjss`des fukf`kkjn tgj midvj-k`stjn diljat`vjs. gj tjst`eo sgdwjn tgj fdkkdw`eo<
• ^gj mutdp`kdt hdnj adukn ij fdrajn td rjvjrt frdh VDY/KDA td HME iy tgj p`kdthmeumkky putt`eo fdraj de tgj adetrdk wgjjk e jxajss df tgj mppk`amikj njtjet fdrajw`tgdut `enua`eo mey rdkk.
• ^gj usj df mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA hdnj rjsuktjn e j`tgjr etjrajpt`eo men trmab`eo dradevjrojeaj w`tg tgj kdamk`zjr e jvjry amsj.
=.=? Drome`zmt`demk men hmemojhjet `efdrhmt`de
=.=?.= F`rst M`r
F`rst M`r `s tgj trmnjhmrb emhj usjn iy Irmnkjy M`r Qjrv`ajs K`h`tjn. F`rst M`r adrpdrmtj dff`ajsmrj kdamtjn `e Bmemtm, Detmr`d, men `ts hm`e dpjrmt`eo imsj `s `e Dttmwm, Detmr`d. Qui-imsjs mrjkdamtjn `e Imbjr Kmbj, Amhir`noj Imy, Gmkk Ijmag, @qmku`t, Buokubtub, men Yjsdkutj Imy,Euemvut2 ms wjkk ms e Pjkkdwbe`fj, Edrtgwjst jrr`tdr`js. gj adhpmey jhpkdysmpprdx`hmtjky =333 pjdpkj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 47/215
- 10 -
^gj drome`zmt`de prdv`njs idtg sagjnukjn men ede-sagjnukjn ndhjst`a men etjremt`demk m`rtrmespdrtmt`de sjrv`ajs fdr pmssjeojrs men fdr mkk typjs df amrod, `eakun`eo nmeojrdus oddns.^gj adhpmey dpjrmtjs Idj`eo ?1?, Idj`eo ?6?, M^Y >9, M^Y ?9, men Kdabgjjn K179 Gjraukjsm`rarmft `e Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY) Quipmrt ?3: dpjrmt`des. Mt tgj t`hj df tgjmaa`njet, tgj adhpmey dpjrmtjn 6 I?1? m`rarmft, w`tg >: p`kdts.
=.=?.=.= F`rst M`r dpjrmt`demk hmeumks
F`rst M`r pdk`a`js adhhde td mkk adhpmey fk`ogt dpjrmt`des mrj adetm`ejn `e tgj F`rst M`r Fk`ogtDpjrmt`des Hmeumk ( FDH).
Qjat`de =.7.= df tgj FDH prdv`njs tgj adhpmey‐s pdk`ay rjomrn`eo stmenmrn dpjrmt`eoprdajnurjs (QDSs) mvm`kmi`k`ty men usmoj. M`rarmft typj-spja`f`a `efdrhmt`de, eakun`eo QDSs, sadetm`ejn e tgj mppk`amikj m`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumk (MDH), tgj F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, `ssujn td jmag fk`ogt arjw hjhijr. ^gj MDH men mhjenhjets mrj mpprdvjn iy^rmespdrt Amemnm (^A), men tgjy rjpkmaj tgj m`rarmft fk`ogt hmeumk. S`kdts mrj rjqu`rjn td gmvj mwdrb`eo bedwkjnoj df tgjsj ndauhjets.
^gj MDH s struaturjn e m tgrjj-vdkuhj fdrhmt. Vdkuhj = s njvdtjn td pgmsj- men aden`t`de-df-fk`ogt efdrhmt`de, ades`st`eo df iukkjt`es, k`h`tmt`des, jhjrojeay men miedrhmk prdajnurjs,edrhmk prdajnurjs, men suppkjhjetmry prdajnurjs. Mhjenhjet 91 df Vdkuhj =, nmtjn 9= Luej93==, wms aurrjet mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet.
Vdkuhj 9 adetm`es tgj `en`v`numk systjhs jxpkmemt`de men `s njs`oejn td adhhue`amtjfueat`demk agmrmatjr`st as tgmt mrj w`tg`e tgj pmrmhjtjrs df tgj fk`ogt arjw dpjrmt`de.Mhjenhjet 1 df Vdkuhj 9 wms aurrjet mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet. Vdkuhj 1 men Quppkjhjet =td Vdkuhj 1 adetm`e pjrfdrhmeaj nmtm. Mhjenhjet 0 df Vdkuhj 1 wms aurrjet mt tgj t`hj dftgj maa`njet.
FDH sjat`de =.7.= adeakunjs w`tg tgj fdkkdw`eo stmtjhjets< 10
Ed njv`mt`de frdh MDH stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs s maajptmikj uekjss tgjS@A njtjrh`ejs tgmt tgj smfjty df tgj fk`ogt hmy ij adhprdh`sjn. @e tg`s jvjet,tgj njv`mt`de hust ij tgdrduogky uenjrstddn iy mkk fk`ogt arjw hjhijrs.
=.=?.=.9 M`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumk< edrhmk prdajnurjs
F`rst M`r usjs m same/fkdw pg`kdsdpgy wgjrjiy, fdr edrhmk dpjrmt`des, p`kdts e`t`mtj ajrtm`emat`des (same/fkdws) frdh hjhdry men hdst df tgj tjhs w`tg`e m same/fkdw mrj adef`rhjn iyadhpkjt`eo tgj maadhpmey`eo agjabk`st. gj agmkkjeoj-rjspdesj adeajpt s usjn fdr mkk edrhmk
agjabk`sts. Yjspdesjs hust ij mun`ikj men akjmr, men mey rjspdesj dtgjr tgme tgmt rjqu`rjn iytgj agjabk`st s ades`njrjn eadrrjat. gj agjabk`st tjh hust ij rjpjmtjn uet`k tgj adrrjatrjspdesj `s hmnj. Agjabk`sts mrj edrhmkky rjmn iy tgj FD wgje tgj m`rarmft `s de tgj orduen,men iy tgj p`kdt edt fky`eo (SEF) wgje `e fk`ogt.
10 F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk (FDH), Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (== Hmy 93==), sjat`de =.7.=< M`rarmftQtmenmrn Dpjrmt`eo Srdajnurjs & Hmeumks, pmoj =-6:
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 48/215
- >3 -
^gj MDH stmtjs tgj fdkkdw`eo< >3
_gjrj tgj agjabk`st rjqu`rjs m hukt`pkj rjspdesj, tgj drnjr df rjspdesj de tgjorduen w`kk ij amptm`e tgje FD, men e fk`ogt, SF tgje SEF. _gje m agjabk`st sadhpkjtj, tgj FD (dr SEF `e fk`ogt) w`kk adef`rh adhpkjt`de iy stmt`eo tgmt t sadhpkjtjn, j.o., ‘Ijfdrj-Qtmrt Agjabk`st Adhpkjtj‛. M edtj de tg`s pmoj spja`f`jstgmt f`emk kmen`eo ojmr men fkmp pds`t`de sgmkk mkwmys ij adef`rhjn iy tgjamptm`e.
^gj MDH `en`amtjs tgj adhpmey‐s jxpjatmt`des ms fdkkdws< >=
@t s tgj rjspdes`i`k`ty df mkk arjw hjhijrs td amkk td tgj Amptm`e‐s mttjet`de, meys`tumt`de tgmt `s edt edrhmk. @t `s edt mssuhjn tgmt tgj Amptm`e `s mwmrj df tgjprdikjh. SD@E^ @^ DZ^! g`s mppk`js td mkk fk`ogt prdajnurjs, orduenprdajnurjs men mey t`hj tgj m`rarmft `s arjwjn … ^gj Amptm`e `s sdkjkyrjspdes`ikj fdr str`at mngjrjeaj td agjabk`st pg`kdsdpgy.
^gj nyemh`a agjabk`st `s mff`xjn td tgj kjft men r`ogt adetrdk wgjjks men adetm`es tgj ijfdrj-tmbj-dff men m`ridrej-imsjn tjhs df tgj edrhmk agjabk`st fdr usj wgje tgj m`rarmft s hdv`eo(F`ourj :).
Smoj 31.93.1 df tgj MDH >9 njsar`ijs agjabk`st fdrhmt, spja`fy`eo tgmt m nmsgjn k`ej `s pkmajn `etgj agjabk`st td en`amtj m irjmb `e tgj sjqujeaj, men tgmt sdhj mat`de (j.o., EMV rmn`ds sjt fdrtgj mpprdmag, jta.) hust daaur ijfdrj tgj agjabk`st ame prdajjn. _gje tgj agjabk`st `s ij`eo rjmnmen tgj ejxt `tjh `s tgj k`ej, tgj agmkkjeojr w`kk stmtj ‛Ndwe td tgj k`ej.‘ ^gj `e-rmeoj agjabk`stgms m nmsgjn k`ej.
_g`kj tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st `s jxjautjn `e 9 pgmsjs, tgjrj `s ed nmsgjn k`ej `e j`tgjr tgjmhpk`f`jn dr nyemh`a kmen`eo agjabk`st sjpmrmt`eo tgj 9 pgmsjs, ms `s tgj amsj w`tg tgj e-rmeojagjabk`st.
@e tgj pmst, mt kjmst : yjmrs ijfdrj tgj maa`njet, tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st wms maadhpk`sgjn wgjetgj ojmr wms jxtjenjn fdr kmen`eo. @e rjspdesj td me uestmikj mpprdmag jvjet, tgj adhpmeyrjv`sjn ts prdajnurjs sd tgmt tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st wdukn ij e`t`mtjn jmrk`jr e tgj mpprdmagmen wdukn ij jxjautjn `e 9 pgmsjs. ^gj nyemh`a men mhpk`f`jn agjabk`sts wjrj edt rjv`sjn. Edades`njrmt`de wms o`vje td `esjrt`eo m k`ej td s`oe`fy m irjmb `e tgj agjabk`st.
Smojs 31.93.> td 31.93.6 df tgj MDH njsar`ij agjabk`st prdajnurjs. @tjh > mnnrjssjs gdkn`eo tgjagjabk`st, men stmtjs tgj fdkkdw`eo< >1
>3 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), EDYHMK AGJABK@Q^
SGYMQJDKDOP, pmoj 31.93.=
>= @i`n., SG@KDQDSGP MEN YZKJQ FDY ZQJ DF AGJABK@Q^, pmoj 31.93.9
>9 @i`n., AGJABK@Q^ FDYHM^, pmoj 31.93.1
>1 @i`n., AGJABK@Q^ SYDAJNZYJQ, pmojs 31.93.>∙31.93.6
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 49/215
- >= -
_gje tgj Amptm`e jkjats edt td maadhpk`sg me`tjh de tgj agjabk`st wgje `t `s amkkjn, s/gj w`kkstmtj ‛Gdkn tgj agjabk`st mt ( tgj `tjh ). Rs`aX Edtj< ^gj agjabk`st w`kk edt prdajjn ijyden me`tjh uet`k tgj `tjh `s maadhpk`sgjn men tgjprdpjr rjspdesj `s o`vje.
@tjh : mnnrjssjs adet`eu`eo tgj agjabk`st, men stmtjs tgjfdkkdw`eo< >>
_gje tgj Amptm`e njs`rjs td adet`euj tgjagjabk`st, s/gj w`kk stmtj ‛Adet`euj tgjagjabk`st‘. gj agjabk`st w`kk tgje rjsuhj w`tgtgj `tjh mt wg`ag `t wms gjkn.
Adhpmey prdajnurjs fdr tgj usj df tgj mutdp`kdt eHME hdnj mrj adetm`ejn `e Mppjen`x ]. Srdajnurjsfdr tgj dpjrmt`de df tgj mutdp`kdt `e VDY/KDA men tgj
fk`ogt n`rjatdr e MZ^D MSS mrj adetm`ejn e Mppjen`xY men Mppjen`x Q. ^gj deky miedrhmk dr jhjrojeayprdajnurj rjkmt`eo td tgj mutdp`kdt `s tgj mutdp`kdtn`sjeomojn prdajnurj. gj mat`de fdr tg`s prdajnurj sfdr tgj arjw td hmeumkky fky tgj m`rarmft. ^gjrj mrj edmiedrhmk dr jhjrojeay prdajnurjs fdr tgj fk`ogtn`rjatdr.
=.=?.=.1 Arjw `eampma`tmt`de men twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj
Qjat`de =3.9>.= df tgj FDH mnnrjssjs p`kdt
`eampma`tmt`de ms fdkkdws< >:
@eampma`tmt`de df me en`v`numk ame ij j`tgjrdiv`dus (ordss) dr suitkj (pmrt`mk). Div`dus`eampma`tmt`de ame ij amusjn iy meytg`eo frdhgjmrt fm`kurj td m spjab df nust `e tgj jyj. Quitkj`eampma`tmt`de ame ij amusjn iy meytg`eo frdh mirm`e tuhdr td m hjetmk kmpsj amusjn iy strjss. >6
Yjadoe`t`de df div`dus eampma`tmt`de, iy njf`e`t`de, prjsjets ed prdikjh. Quitkjdr pmrt`mk `eampma`tmt`de s pmrt`aukmrky es`n`dus e tgmt tgj ede-fueat`de`eo p`kdtame jetjr tg`s stmtj men hmy mppjmr pjrfjatky edrhmk w`tg jyjs dpje men gmens
de tgj adetrdks. Yjadoe`t`de df suitkj eampma`tmt`de hmy tmbj ades`njrmikj t`hj
>> @i`n.
>: F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk (FDH), Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (== Hmy 93==), sjat`de =3.9>.=< S`kdt@eampma`tmt`de, pmoj =3-90
>6 Quitkj `eampma`tmt`de hmy ij n`ff`aukt td rjadoe`zj, ms t rjqu rjs m suiljat`vj `etjrprjtmt`de dfsyhptdhs Rfddtedtj mnnjnX.
F`ourj :. F`rst M`r I?1? nyemh`aagjabk`st (sduraj< F`rst M`r I?1?Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =,Mhjenhjet ed. 91 R9= Luej 93==X, pmoj31.=3.=)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 50/215
- >9 -
men prjsjets m ue`quj prdikjh fdr tgj F`rst Dff`ajr2 tgmt `s, gdw fmr sgdukn gjmkkdw tgj m`rarmft td njv`mtj ijfdrj tmb`eo dvjr adetrdk frdh tgj S@A. Fdr tgjsjrjmsdes, tgj ‛twd adhhue`amt`de rukj‘ sgmkk ij mndptjn td rjnuaj tgj r`sb dfmaa`njet, jspja`mkky e tgj ar`t`amk pgmsjs df fk`ogt, tgj tmbjdff men e`t`mk ak`himen tgj mpprdmag men kmen`eo.
Qjat`de =3.9>.9 df tgj FDH n`saussjs tgj adhpmey‐s twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj ms fdkkdws< >? _gjejvjr tgj dtgjr p`kdt ndjs edt rjspden td twd adesjaut`vj vjrimkadhhue`amt`de mttjhpts w`tg j`tgjr m rjpky dr iy jxjaut`eo m adrrjat`vj fk`ogthmedjuvrj ydu w`kk smy ‛@ gmvj adetrdk‘ (`f ydu mrj edt mkrjmny tgj p`kdt fky`eo)men w`kk tmbj dvjr adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft uet`k `t ame ij msajrtm`ejn tgmt tgj kmab dfrjspdesj wms edt amusjn iy eampma`tmt`de.
_gjejvjr eampma`tmt`de daaurs, wgjtgjr div`dus dr suitkj, tgj prdajnurj s msfdkkdws<
=. Mssuhj adetrdk men fky tgj m`rarmft td m smfj s`tumt`de, dr jeomoj mutdp`kdt (`f
mvm`kmikj)29. Yjstrm`e men/dr rjhdvj tgj eampma`tmtjn p`kdt, w`tg tgj mss`stmeaj df m
Fk`ogt Mttjenmet (`f mvm`kmikj)2
1. Yjdrome`zj tgj adabp`t men prjpmrj fdr kmen`eo2
>. Mrrmeoj fdr me mhiukmeaj td hjjt tgj m`rarmft.
^grduogdut tgj rjadrnjn pdrt`de df tgj fk`ogt, tgj amptm`e df FMI6:63 wms vjrimkky rjspdes`vjtd tgj FD‐s adhhjets men suoojst`des, men wms hmb`eo adetrdk `eputs.
Mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet, dtgjr tgme tgj twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj, tgj adhpmey n`n edt gmvj
mey pdk`a`js, prdajnurjs, dr trm`e`eo prdv`n`eo ou`nmeaj ms td gdw me FD adukn jsamkmtj frdhme mnv`sdry rdkj td tmb`eo adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft frdh tgj amptm`e. S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmthdst df tgj amptm`es wjrj surpr`sjn men ueadhfdrtmikj wgje msbjn gdw me FD adukn tmbjadetrdk frdh m amptm`e wgd wms edt akjmrky eampma`tmtjn.
=.=?.=.> Adhpmss dpjrmt`des `e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj
^gj adhpmey‐s pdk`a`js men prdajnurjs fdr adhpmss usj e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj (ENM)mrj njsar`ijn e Mppjen`x . @eakunjn s tgj prdajnurj fdr ditm`e`eo truj gjmn`eo us`eo OSQmen ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade (ENI). gj dutput df tg`s prdajnurj s tgj truj gjmn`eo, wg`ag sn`spkmyjn uenjr tgj rmn`d-hmoejt`a en`amtdr (YH@) kuiijr k`ej.
^gj adhpmey‐s `etjet, mktgduog edt spja`f`amkky hjet`dejn `e tgj MDH, `s tgmt usj df tgjnjst`emt`de ENI td ditm`e m ijmr`eo de tgj OSQ h`e`h`zjs tgj jffjat df jmrtg trmespdrtprjajss`de rmtj. Hdst njst`emt`des e tgj adhpmey‐s mrjm df dpjrmt`des mrj sjrvjn iy me ENI
>? F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk (FDH), Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (== Hmy 93==), sjat`de =3.9>.9< ^wdAdhhue`amt`de Yukj, pmoj =3-13
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 51/215
- >1 -
tgmt wdukn ij tgj deky usmikj ENI fdr me mrr`v`eo fk`ogt. ^g`s wms tgj amsj fdr Yjsdkutj Imy(APYI) men tgj Yjsdkutj Imy ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade (YI ENI).
=.=?.=.: F`rst M`r I?1? p`kdt prmat`ajs fdr adhpmss dpjrmt`de
S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt prmat`ajs vmr`jn sdhjwgmt, frdh fukk adhpk`meaj w`tg tgj MDH
td edrhs tgmt njv`mtjn frdh tgj MDH suistmet`mkky. Fdr jxmhpkj, kjmv`eo AP\F edrtgiduen,arjws rjpdrtjn oddn adhpk`meaj w`tg tgj rjqu`rjhjet td adhhjeaj frjj n`rjat`demk oyrd (NO)dpjrmt`des jetjr`eo tgj ENM. Gdwjvjr, de jmst-wjst fk`ogts dpjrmt`eo td men frdh Ymeb`e @ekjt,Euemvut (APY^), hmey p`kdts rjpdrtjn dpjrmt`eo `e HMO rmtgjr tgme sw`tag`eo td NO msrjqu`rjn, ijamusj tgj hmoejt`a vmr`mt`de mt APY^ wms deky >³.
_`tgdut jxajpt`de, p`kdt prmat`ajs fdr sjtt`eo m truj gjmn`eo usjn tgj OSQ/ENI prdajnurj eprjfjrjeaj td us`eo tgj mstrd adhpmss, men adhpk`jn w`tg tgj prdajnurj sgdwe e Mppjen`x .Gdwjvjr, tgj t`h`eo men frjqujeay df tg`s prdajnurj vmr`jn suistmet`mkky. Dej p`kdt rjpdrtjnnd`eo tg`s prdajnurj rjoukmrky tgrduogdut tgj fk`ogt, jspja`mkky nur`eo njsajet td njst`emt`de,wg`kj dtgjrs rjpdrtjn tgmt t wms ndej deky wgje rjqu`rjn iy tgj agjabk`st.
Ed efdrhmt`de wms mvm`kmikj rjomrn`eo tgj FMI6:63 arjw prmat`ajs2 gdwjvjr, fk`ogt nmtmrjadrnjr (FNY) men adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr (AVY) nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj adhpmssjs wjrj mnlustjndeky deaj, mt =69:<3?, nur`eo tgj pdrt`de df tgj fk`ogt fdr wg`ag vmk`n nmtm wjrj mvm`kmikj. Mttg`s t`hj, tgj YI ENI wms tgj deky ENI w`tg`e rmeoj, mt m ijmr`eo men n`stmeaj frdh tgjm`rarmft df 390³^ mt 0= eh.
S`kdts rjpdrtjn tgj adhpmey‐s I?1? adhpmssjs wdukn sdhjt`hjs n`ffjr td tgj jxtjet tgmt tgjgjmn`eo adhpmrmtdr wdukn kkuh`emtj. gjsj estmeajs wdukn rjsdkvj wgje tgj adhpmssjswjrj mkkdwjn td skmvj `f dpjrmt`eo `e HMO, dr wjrj rjsjt `f dpjrmt`eo `e NO.
S`kdts rjpdrtjn vmr`jn prmat`ajs rjomrn`eo sjtt`eo tgj kmt`tunj adetrdkkjr. Qdhj wdukn sjt tgjadetrdkkjr td tgj mpprdx`hmtj h`n-kmt`tunj df tgj rdutj ij`eo fkdwe, wg`kj dtgjrs wdukn usj tgjaurrjet kmt`tunj mt tgj t`hj wgje tgj adhpmss wms ij`eo sjt. Ed efdrhmt`de wms mvm`kmikjrjomrn`eo tgj FMI6:63 arjw prmat`ajs.
=.=?.9 Mnmptmt`des df stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs
=.=?.9.= Ojejrmk
QDSs men agjabk`sts mrj ar`t`amk efdrhmt`de rjsdurajs tgmt prdv`nj prdajnurmk ou`nmeaj tdp`kdts fdr tgj dpjrmt`de df me m`rarmft. gjy mss`st w`tg p`kdt nja`s`de hmb`eo men w`tg tgjjstmik`sg`eo df sgmrjn hjetmk hdnjks ijtwjje tgj p`kdts, men prdv`nj p`kdts w`tg
prjnjtjrh`ejn suaajssfuk sdkut`des td vmr`dus s`tumt`des iy maaduet`eo fdr r`sb fmatdrs tgmt hmyedt ij rjmn`ky mppmrjet td m p`kdt nur`eo edrhmk dpjrmt`des dr me miedrhmk/jhjrojeays`tumt`de.
_g`kj t s `hpdss`ikj td njvjkdp agjabk`sts dr prdajnurjs fdr mkk pdss`ikj adet`eojea`js,fdkkdw`eo tgj mpprdpr`mtj agjabk`st dr prdajnurj w`kk prdv`nj p`kdts w`tg tgj smfjst men hdstjff`a`jet adursj df mat`de e hdst amsjs. Gdwjvjr, f agjabk`st men prdajnurmk n`sa`pk`ej s edt
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 52/215
- >> -
tmuogt, prmat`sjn, rj`efdrajn, men hde`tdrjn, tgjrj s m nmeojr tgmt p`kdts w`kk njv`mtj frdhprjsar`ijn prdajnurjs dr rjspden empprdpr`mtjky td ueusumk s`tumt`des.
Sjdpkj rmrjky fdkkdw rukjs dr estruat`des prja`sjky. gjy nd sd fdr rjmsdes men e wmys tgmthmbj sjesj td tgjh o`vje tgj`r a`rauhstmeajs, bedwkjnoj, men odmks. >7
_g`kj pdk`a`js men QDSs mrj prjsar`ijn iy m adhpmey td sjt iduenmr`js fdr smfj dpjrmt`des,`en`v`numks hmy jxpjr`hjet w`tg tgj iduenmr`js e drnjr td ijadhj hdrj prdnuat`vj dr ditm`esdhj dtgjr ijejf`t. g`s jxpjr`hjetmt`de kjmns td mnmptmt`des df prdajnurjs men td m sg`ftijyden tgj prjsar`ijn iduenmr`js njsar`ijn e tgj QDSs, tdwmrn uesmfj prmat`ajs. >0 _`tgdut`etjrvjet`de, tgj adhhue`amt`de df suaajssfuk mnmptmt`des ijtwjje arjw hjhijrs w`kk tjen tdkjmn td tgj`r sprjmn tgrduogdut me drome`zmt`de.
Quag mnmptmt`des mrj uek`bjky td ij rjadoe`zjn ms njv`mt`des iy tgdsj w`tg`e tgj ordupjhpkdy`eo tgjh. gj mnmptmt`des skdwky ijadhj edrhmk ijgmv`dur, men tgj r`sb mssda`mtjnw`tg tgjh s uek`bjky td ij rjadoe`zjn. :3 g`s tjenjeay gms ijje njsar`ijn ms tgj edrhmk`zmt`dedf njv`meaj. :=
_`tgdut rjoukmr supjrv`s`de, jnuamt`de, men jefdrajhjet df tgj jxpjatjn iduenmr`js,`en`v`numks mrj k`bjky td adet`euj td mnmpt prdajnurjs men aut adrejrs uet`k tgj matumk uesmfjiduenmry s fduen tgrduog tgj daaurrjeaj df m h`edr dr hmldr maa`njet.
^g`s evjst`omt`de njet`f jn hmey estmeajs wgjrj tgj FMI6:63 fk`ogt arjw njv`mtjn frdhQDSs. @evjst`omtdrs adenuatjn struaturjn `etjrv`jws w`tg 0 AP\F-imsjn F`rst M`r I?1? p`kdts tdnjtjrh`ej wgjtgjr tgj njv`mt`des frdh QDSs jxtjenjn ijyden tgj arjw df FMI6:63.^gj fdkkdw`eo sjat`des njsar`ij bjy njv`mt`des iy FMI6:63 arjw frdh tgj adhpmey‐s dpjrmt`eopg`kdsdpgy, pdk`a`js, dr agjabk`st prdajnurjs. Qdhj sjat`des w`kk eakunj m n`sauss`de df I?1?arjw prmat`ajs. Mnn`t`demk jxmhpkjs df arjw prmat`ajs mrj njsar`ijn e Mppjen`x V. Mhpk`f`jn
agjabk`sts fdr vmr`dus pgmsjs df fk`ogt mrj kdamtjn e Mppjen`x Z.
=.=?.9.9 Aru`sj
=.=?.9.9.= Mpprdmag ir`jf`eo
Mpprdmag ir`jf`eos mrj edrhmkky adenuatjn iy tgj p`kdt fky`eo (SF) ijfdrj njsajet, ms pmrt df tgjprj-njsajet agjab. gj SEF‐s hde`tdr`eo nut`js, stmenmrn amkkduts men tdkjrmeajs, ms wjkk msstmenmrn nja`s`de gj`ogt amkkduts, sgdukn ij adef`rhjn iy tgj SF ijfdrj tgj SF‐s f`rst mpprdmagdf tgj nmy. Quisjqujet SF mpprdmag ir`jf`eos hmy ij miirjv`mtjn td eakunj tgj `tjhs k`stjnijkdw, fdkkdwjn iy m stmtjhjet tgmt stmenmrn adhpmey amkks mppky men m qujry ms td wgjtgjrtgjrj mrj mey qujst`des. gj fdkkdw`eo efdrhmt`de sgdukn ij eakunjn e tgj mpprdmag ir`jf`eo<
>7 Q. Njbbjr, ^gj F`jkn Ou`nj td Zenjrstmen`eo Guhme Jrrdr ( Msgomtj Suik`sg`eo< 9336)
>0 L. Ymshussje, ‛Y`sb hmemojhjet `e m nyemh`a sda`jty< m hdnjk`eo prdikjh ,‘ Qmfjty Qa`jeaj, Vdkuhj9?, @ssuj 9/1 (=00?), =71∙9=1, pmoj =0?
:3 Q. Njbbjr, Nr`ft @etd Fm`kurj (Msgomtj Suik`sg`eo< 93==), pmoj ===
:= N. Vmuoge, ^gj Agmkkjeojr Kmueag Nja`s`de< Y`sby ^jagedkdoy, Aukturj, men Njv`meaj mt EMQM (Ze`vjrs`ty df Ag`amod Srjss< =00?)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 53/215
- >: -
• ^gj mpprdmag agmrt emhj men jffjat`vj nmtj2
• ^gj etjenjn emv-m`n adef`ourmt de tgrduog tgj mpprdmag men h`ssjn mpprdmag2
• H`e`huh (tjhpjrmturj-adrrjatjn) mkt`tunjs mt jmag pd`et df tgj mpprdmag2
• Nja`s`de gj`ogt2 men
• Dtgjr tjhs ms mpprdpr`mtj, jspja`mkky wgje dpjrmt`eo etd me uefmh`k`mr m`rpdrt (j.o.,ruewmy dffsjt, n`spkmajn tgrjsgdkn, ueusumk mpprdmag k`ogt`eo systjh, dr dtgjrpjrt`ejet `efdrhmt`de tgmt h`ogt `efkujeaj tgj mpprdmag dr kmen`eo).
@etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt p`kdts‐ prmat`aj wms td adenuat tgj mpprdmag ir`jf`eo ijfdrj tdp dfnjsajet, ms wms tgj amsj w`tg FMI6:63. g`s prmat`aj wms `e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj MDH.Gdwjvjr, ir`jf`eos wjrj adhhdeky miirjv`mtjn wgje fky`eo w`tg fmh`k`mr arjw hjhijrs,nur`eo oddn wjmtgjr, men wgje fky`eo tgj smhj mpprdmag fdr tgj sjaden dr tg`rn t`hj nur`eotgj nmy.
^gj amptm`e df FMI6:63 adenuatjn tgj mpprdmag ir`jf`eo mt =6=?<==. gj spjjns ir`jfjn wjrj
=19 (VYJF),:9
=1? (VYJF + :), men =>? (VYJF + =:). Qjj Mppjen`x V fdr m njsar`pt`de df tgjsjspjjns. ^gj ir`jf`eo wms `eadhpkjtj, ms `t n`n edt `eakunj tgj mpprdmag agmrt emhj dr nmtj, tgj`etjenjn emv-m`n adef`ourmt`de, dr h`e`huh mkt`tunjs dtgjr tgme tgj nja`s`de gj`ogt. Dtgjr`efdrhmt`de pjrt`ejet td tgj `etjenjn mpprdmag men kmen`eo wms sby aden`t`de, v`s`i`k`ty, mentgj tm`kw`en, iut edej df tgjsj `tjhs wjrj `eakunjn `e tgj mpprdmag ir`jf`eo. @t `s pdss`ikj tgmttgj p`kdts n`saussjn sdhj dr mkk df tgjsj `tjhs jmrk`jr `e tgj fk`ogt ijfdrj tgj AVY rjadrn`eoijome.
=.=?.9.9.9 Njsajet pkmee`eo
_gje mpprdmag`eo njst`emt`de, tgj arjw gmvj td adef`rh tgj tdp-df-njsajet (^DN) pd`et imsjnde aurrjet aden`t`des. De tgj I?1?, m agmrt td mss`st e pjrfdrh`eo tg`s amkaukmt`de s bjpt de tgj
okmrjsg`jkn men s rjmn`ky mvm`kmikj td fk`ogt arjws mt mkk t`hjs. :1 ^gj `evjst`omt`de usjn tgj F`rst M`r I?1?-933 Sjrfdrhmeaj ]u`ab Yjfjrjeaj Gmeniddb agmrt td amkaukmtj m ^DN, imsjn de tgjfdkkdw`eo `efdrhmt`de<
• Aru`sj FK1=3,
• Njsajet mt nkj tgrust,
• Qpjjn df 3.?3 Hmag/973 bedts midvj =3 333 fjjt /9:3 bedts ijkdw =3 333 fjjt (uppjr kjftdf agmrt),
• Qtrm`ogt-`e mpprdmag,
• ^rmes`t`de td ojmr ndwe,
• Kmen fkmp mt dutjr hmrbjr,
:9 VYJF rjfjrs td tgj mpprdmag rjfjrjeaj spjjn.
:1 ^gj agmrt `eakunjs m adrrjat`de fmatdr fdr jmag =3 bedts df w`en2 mt FK1=3, tgj adrrjat`de fmatdr s 9.7emut`amk h`kjs (F`rst M`r I?1?-933 Sjrfdrhmeaj ]u`ab Yjfjrjeaj Gmeniddb).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 54/215
- >6 -
• Dpjrmt`demk fk`ogt pkme (DFS) kmen`eo wj`ogt df =3: 333 pduens,
• DFS tm`kw`en adhpdejet mt ^DN df 61 bedts.
Imsjn de tgj n`stmeaj-td-tduagndwe agmrt, tgj ^DN `e amkh w`en aden`t`des wdukn gmvj ijje=33 eh. Gdwjvjr, ades`njr`eo m tm`kw`en adhpdejet df 61 bedts, me jxtrm =? h`kjs (9.7 eh x 6 8=6.7) ejjns td ij mnnjn, rjsukt`eo `e m ^DN df ==? eh frdh tduagndwe mt APYI. ^gj DFSprdv`njn m adhputjr-amkaukmtjn DN pd`et fdr FMI6:63 df ==? eh frdh tduagndwe mt APYI.
Mt =6=?<>=, w`tg tgj m`rarmft midut =:3 eh frdh tduagndwe mt APYI, tgj FD pd`etjn dut td tgjamptm`e tgmt tgj`r orduen spjjn wms g`og. _g`kj t adukn edt ij njtjrh`ejn jxmatky wgmt`efdrhmt`de tgj arjw usjn td amkaukmtj tgj DN, mt =6=?<>>, tgj amptm`e en`amtjn tgmt gjpkmeejn td adhhjeaj njsajet mt =3: eh frdh APYI.
=.=?.9.1 Kmen`eo nmtm amrn men m`rspjjn iuo sjtt`eos
^gj kmen`eo nmtm amrn (Mppjen`x V) `s usjn td sjt men vjr`fy kmen`eo nmtm. @t `s edrhmkkyadhpkjtjn iy tgj SEF ijfdrj tgj edrhmk prj-njsajet prdajnurjs. Edrhmkky, tgj SEF w`kk
rjv`jw tgj kmen`eo nmtm amrn `efdrhmt`de mftjr tgj m`rspjjn iuos mrj sjt men ijfdrj tgjmpprdmag ir`jf`eo.
^gj kmen`eo nmtm amrn fdr FMI6:63 wms edt rjadvjrjn. Gdwjvjr, mt =6=?<==.0, tgj amptm`eadenuatjn tgj mpprdmag ir`jf`eo, eakun`eo mpprdmag spjjns, men mt =69><>3, idtg p`kdtsrjfjrrjn td tgj m`rspjjn iuo sjtt`eo nur`eo tgj prj-njsajet agjab. gjsj jvjets en`amtj tgmt tgjkmen`eo nmtm amrn gmn k`bjky ijje prjpmrjn iy tgj FD.
=.=?.9.> Srj-njsajet
Mhpk`f`jn agjabk`st prdajnurjs mrj sgdwe e Mppjen`x Z. @e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj MDH :>, tgj
prj-njsajet agjabk`st, `eakun`eo m puik`a mnnrjss (SM) meedueajhjet td tgj pmssjeojrs, sgmkk ijmaadhpk`sgjn ijfdrj e`t`mt`eo f`emk njsajet.
^gj amptm`e adenuatjn tgj mpprdmag ir`jf`eo mt =6=?<==. gj FD hmnj m pmssjeojr SMmeedueajhjet mt =69=<36. Ms n`saussjn midvj, tgj kmen`eo nmtm amrn wms k`bjky adhpkjtjn.
^gj prj-njsajet same/fkdw s e`t`mtjn iy tgj SF amkk`eo fdr tgj prj-njsajet agjabk`st, men tgjdeky mat`de `tjh `s fdr tgj SEF td `en`amtj stmtus agmeoj w`tg 9 ami`e ag`hjs. ^wd ami`e ag`hjsdaaurrjn mt =69><1=, en`amt`eo td tgj ami`e arjw m agmeoj e m`rarmft stmtus.
Nur`eo tgj prj-njsajet agjab, mt =69><1? men =69><10 rjspjat`vjky, tgj amptm`e men FD
adef`rhjn tgmt tgj VYJF iuos wjrj sjt fdr =19 bedts. @e mnn`t`de td tgj V YJF iuo, jmag p`kdtsgdukn mksd gmvj sjt m iuo td =1? (VMSS, dr mpprdmag spjjn RVYJFX adrrjatjn fdr w`en) menmedtgjr iuo td =>? (VYJF + =:).
:> F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), SGMQJ df FK@OG^
OZ@NJK@EJQ, pmoj 31.93.?
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 55/215
- >? -
FMI6:63 adhhjeajn njsajet mt =691<>3. gj FMI6:63 p`kdts jxjautjn tgj prj-njsajet agjabk`stijo`ee`eo mt =69><9?. gj adhpmss pdrt`de df tg`s agjabk`st daaurrjn frdh =69><10.: td =69:<=1.?.Nur`eo tg`s jxagmeoj, tgj p`kdts vjr`f`jn tgmt tgj adhpmssjs wjrj e NO hdnj. Mt =69><>>, tgjamptm`e stmtjn, ‛… twjety-e`ej truj‘, men mt =69:<3>, tgj FD stmtjn, ‛… zjrd tgrjj zjrd.‘
Mt =69:<=>, tgj FD amkkjn tgj prj-njsajet agjab adhpkjtj.
=.=?.9.: Njsajet
=.=?.9.:.= Njsajet tjage`qujs
^gj edrhmk njsajet frdh aru`sj `s e m akjme adef`ourmt`de. Qpjjnirmbjs hmy ij jxtjenjn td`earjmsj tgj njsajet rmtj dr td rjnuaj spjjn. ^gjrj wms ed rjadrnjn `efdrhmt`de td `en`amtjwgjtgjr tgj amptm`e df FMI6:63 usjn tgj spjjnirmbj nur`eo njsajet. Mktgduog edt spja`f`jn etgj MDH, tgjrj mrj dtgjr hjmes df mnlust`eo m njsajet prdf`kj, suag ms earjms`eo tgj n`stmeajfkdwe iy ture`eo td m w`njr `etjrajpt meokj dr nd`eo m 163³ ture.
=.=?.9.:.9 @e-rmeoj agjab
Mhpk`f`jn agjabk`st prdajnurjs mrj sgdwe e Mppjen`x Z. gj amptm`e df FMI6:63 amkkjn fdrtgj `e-rmeoj agjabk`st mt =619<>6. ^gj FD amkkjn men rjspdenjn td tgj f`rst > `tjhs. ^gjrj wms edhjet`de df tgj mux`k`mry pdwjr ue`t (MSZ). Mt =611<30, tgj amptm`e estruatjn tgj FD td gdkn tgjrjhm`e`eo tjhs de tgj agjabk`st uet`k kmtjr e tgj mpprdmag. gj FD n`n edt stmtj, ‛@e-rmeojagjabk`st adhpkjtj ndwe td tgj k`ej.‘
Mt =616<91, tgj amptm`e `estruatjn tgj FD td prdajjn w`tg tgj `tjhs ijkdw tgj nmsgjn k`ej. Idtgp`kdts rjspdenjn td tgj EMV sw`tagjs agmkkjeoj (FD stmtjn ‛EMV estruhjets‘) w`tg ‛VGFEMV‘, men td tgj mkt`hjtjrs, estruhjets, men rmn`ds agmkkjeoj w`tg ‛^wd-e`ejr-j`ogt-dej`eagjs sjt, ardss-agjabjn.‘ gj FD tgje hjet`dejn tgj YI ENI frjqujeay (1:3 b`kdgjrtz), m
rjqu`rjhjet td bjjp tgj NHJ, men mnv`sjn tgj amptm`e tgmt tgj mkt`tunj mkjrtjr :: adukn ij sjt td9933 (9:-eh-sjatdr h`e`huh smfj mkt`tunj). gj amptm`e omvj me mff`rhmt`vj rjspdesj. gj VGFEMV rmn`ds wjrj edt hjet`dejn. Mt =61?<33, tgj FD amkkjn tgj e-rmeoj agjabk`st adhpkjtj.
=.=?.9.6 ^rmes`t`de td f`emk mpprdmag
Zsj df tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr s rjadhhjenjn wgjejvjr de me `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ)mpprdmag. Maadrn`eo td F`rst M`r mhpk`f`jn agjabk`st prdajnurjs, tgj mutdp`kdt men fk`ogtn`rjatdr, wgje usjn, sgdukn ij sjt ms fdkkdws< :6
@KQ< Mrh MZ^D MSS men stjjr m`rarmft us`eo GNO QJK men MK^ GDKN msrjqu`rjn. Hde`tdr MSN meeuea`mtdr fdr mpprdpr`mtj Mrhjn/Ampturj
@en`amt`des.
:: ^gj mkt`tunj mkjrtjr adhpmrjs tgj mkt`tunj sjkjatjn de tgj mkt`tunj mkjrt adetrdkkjr w`tg tgj mkt`tunjsgdwe `e tgj amptm`e‐s mkt`hjtjr. @t prdv`njs murmk men v`sumk mkjrts td tgj p`kdts =333 fjjt ijfdrj men9:3 fjjt mftjr tgj sjkjatjn mkt`tunj.
:6 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), Mutdp`kdt/Fk`ogtN`rjatdr Zsmoj (QS??), pmojs 31.63.13∙31.63.1=
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 56/215
- >7 -
AMZ^@DE< @F MIDVJ ^GJ OK@NJ QKDSJ, ND ED^ ZQJ MS HME OQ.@EQ^JMN ZQJ A_Q ^D AMS^ZYJ.
Edtj< @f Ok`nj Qkdpj s`oemks mrj jrrmt`a, usj KDA hdnj de tgj Mutdp`kdt deky.VDY/KDA (Frdet Adursj)< Mrh VDY/KDA men stjjr m`rarmft us`eo GNO QJK
men MK^ GDKN ms rjqu`rjn. Hde`tdr MSN meeuea`mtdr fdr mpprdpr`mtjMrhjn/Ampturj @en`amt`des.
F`ourj 6 prdv`njs m ormpg`amk fk`ogt prdf`kj njsar`pt`de fdr @KQ mpprdmagjs, wg`ag njp`atsadef`ourmt`de agmeojs.
F`ourj 6. Njp`at`de df `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) pmttjre (`hmoj< F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 R9= Luej 93==X, pmoj 31.73.1)
Vdkuhj = df tgj MDH prdv`njs ormpg`amk njp`at`des fdr mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de `e vmr`dus hdnjsmen pgmsjs df fk`ogt. gjrj mrj ormpg`as fdr dpjrmt`de e VDY/KDA hdnj fdr VDY emv`omt`de,
men fdr @KQ mpprdmag `e MZ^D MSS hdnj, iut tgjrj `s ed ormpg`a njp`at`eo me @KQ mpprdmag `eVDY/KDA hdnj. Mppjen`x Y prdv`njs m ^QI-prdnuajn ormpg`amk njp`at`de df mutdp`kdtdpjrmt`de fdr me @KQ mpprdmag e VDY/KDA hdnj. Mppjen`x Q prdv`njs m ^QI-prdnuajnormpg`amk njp`at`de df fk`ogt n`rjatdr dpjrmt`de fdr me @KQ mpprdmag e MZ^D MSS hdnj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 57/215
- >0 -
Mt =6=:<9>, ijfdrj adhhjea`eo tgj njsajet, tgj amptm`e gmn mnv`sjn tgj FD tgmt gj pkmeejn tdusj YEMV td emv`omtj td tgj kdamk`zjr men tgje sw`tag frdh OSQ td VGF EMV. :? Gdwjvjr,nur`eo tgj jxjaut`de df tgj e-rmeoj agjabk`st, tgj arjw stmtjhjets en`amtj tgmt tgjy sjkjatjnVGF EMV `e prjpmrmt`de fdr `etjrajpt`eo tgj @KQ kdamk`zjr fdr Yuewmy 1:^. ^gjrj wms edrjadrnjn n`sauss`de ijtwjje tgj p`kdts rjomrn`eo mutdp`kdt men fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj sjkjat`desmen agmeojs, edr wms tg`s rjqu`rjn mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet.
Dtgjr p`kdts wjrj msbjn gdw tgjy wdukn adenuat tg`s trmes`t`de frdh je rdutj td f`emkmpprdmag. gj etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn 9 hjtgdns fdr tgj trmes`t`de.
^gj f`rst hjtgdn wms ms njsar`ijn `e tgj MDH men njp`atjn `e Mppjen`ajs Y men Q. S`kdtsus`eo tg`s hjtgdn `e`t`mkky bjpt tgj OSQ adupkjn td tgj mutdp`kdt `e HME hdnj. ^gje tgj p`kdtswdukn sw`tag td VGF EMV, sjkjat tgj mutdp`kdt hdnj td VDY/KDA, men hm`etm`e tgj `etjrajptgjmn`eo uet`k tgj mutdp`kdt ampturjn tgj kdamk`zjr men turejn eiduen de f`emk mpprdmag. gjpds`t`de mt wg`ag p`kdts hmnj tgj sw`tag td VGF EMV vmr`jn frdh = td =3 h`kjs imab frdhHZQM^.
^gj sjaden hjtgdn wms td bjjp tgj OSQ adupkjn td tgj mutdp`kdt `e HME hdnj w`tg tgjmppk`amikj mrjm emv`omt`de (YEMV) mpprdmag kdmnjn, men mkkdw tgj OSQ/mutdp`kdt td hmbj tgjture detd f`emk mpprdmag. Deaj jstmik`sgjn eiduen de f`emk mpprdmag, tgj p`kdts wdukn sjkjatVGF EMV men mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA hdnj, men tgje mkkdw tgj mutdp`kdt td trmab tgj kdamk`zjr`eiduen. Adhpmey hmemojhjet stmtjn td `evjst`omtdrs tgmt tg`s wms edt me maajptmikj hjtgdn,men sdhj p`kdts en`amtjn tgmt tgjy n`sadurmojn usj df tg`s hjtgdn. S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjntgmt us`eo tg`s hjtgdn wdukn sdhjt`hjs rjsukt e e`t`mt`de df tgj kmen`eo agjab ijfdrjadhpkjt`de df tgj e-rmeoj agjab, ijamusj tgj `e-rmeoj agjab wms ij`eo gjkn uet`k tgj EMVsw`tagjs adukn ij agmeojn frdh OSQ td VGF.
_g`kj tgj adhpmey‐s I?1? s`hukmtdr trm`e`eo eakunjs etjrajpt prdajnurjs fdr adupkjn @KQ
mpprdmagjs, tgj s`hukmtdr `s edt jqu`ppjn w`tg OSQ dr FHQ (fk`ogt hmemojhjet systjh).^gjrjfdrj, trm`e`eo p`kdts wjrj uek`bjky td njet`fy tgmt tg`s ede-stmenmrn prmat`aj wms eadhhde usmoj. Mnn`t`demkky, p`kdts `etjrv`jwjn rjpdrtjn tgmt tgjy wdukn edt usj tg`s hjtgdnnur`eo trm`e`eo men p`kdt prdf`a`jeay agjabs.
S`kdts en`amtjn tgmt tgjy wdukn usj tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr MZ^D MSS hdnj, iut prjfjrrjn td mvd`nusj df tgj mutdp`kdt MZ^D MSS hdnj, ijamusj tgj mutdp`kdt tjenjn td dvjrsgddt tgj ok`njskdpjnur`eo ampturj. g`s dvjrsgddt wdukn rjsukt `e n`h`e`sg`eo dsa`kkmt`des midvj men ijkdw tgjok`njskdpj ms tgj mutdp`kdt ormnumkky maqu`rjn tgj ajetrj df tgj ijmh. gj`r prmat`aj wms td usjtgj mutdp`kdt `e VDY/KDA hdnj td trmab tgj kdamk`zjr, men td usj A_Q p`tag `eputs td ampturjmen hm`etm`e tgj ok`njskdpj.
:? ^gj amptm`e‐s hjet`de df YEMV hpk`js tgj usj df tgj ^r`hikj ^EK-7=33 OSQ `estmkkjn `e A-OE_E.Furtgjr n`sauss`de w`kk rjfjr td OSQ.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 58/215
- :3 -
=.=?.9.? @e`t`mk mpprdmag
^gj SF adhhmens adef`ourmt`de agmeojs, men tgj arjw hjhijr hmb`eo tgj sjkjat`de hde`tdrstgj `en`amt`des men mnv`sjs tgj SF wgje tgj m`rarmft `s `e tgj adhhmenjn adef`ourmt`de dr `f tgjsystjh ndjs edt dpjrmtj edrhmkky.
Mt =61?<9:, tgj amptm`e amkkjn fdr fkmps =. ^gj FD `en`amtjn tgmt tgj sjkjat`de gmn ijje hmnj,men mt =61?<>3, adef`rhjn tgmt fkmps = wjrj sjt men tgj kjmn`eo-jnoj njv`aj orjje k`ogt wms`kkuh`emtjn.
=.=?.9.?.= Kmen`eo agjabk`st (`e`t`mk)
Mhpk`f`jn agjabk`st prdajnurjs mrj sgdwe e Mppjen`x Z. gj kmen`eo agjabk`st smaadhpk`sgjn e 9 pgmsjs (`e`t`mk men f`emk). ^gj kmen`eo (`e`t`mk) same/fkdw s e`t`mtjn wgjefkmp : `s sjkjatjn (dr ture`eo imsj kjo dr jstmik`sgjn =: h`kjs f`emk, wg`agjvjr `s tgj hdstmpprdpr`mtj). Mat`de tjhs mrj jxjautjn iy tgj SEF men amptm`e ms fdkkdws< :7
SEF<
Qtmtus Agmeoj ..................................................................................................... 9 Ag`hjsJeo`ej Qtmrt Qw`tagjs .................................................................................................. DE Sds`t`de tgj Jeo`ej Qtmrt Qw`tagjs td ..................................................... KD_ @OE
Yjamkk ...................................................................................................................... AGJAB Srjss men rjkjmsj tgj meeuea`mtdr pmejk. Vjr`fy ed k`ogts rjhm`e `kkuh`emtjn
wgje tgj meeuea`mtdr s rjkjmsjn.
Amptm`e<Qpjjnirmbj .............................................................................. MYHJN, OYJJE K@OG^
Mt =61?<>9, tgj amptm`e amkkjn fdr fkmps : men tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st. ^gj FD stmtjn tgmt fkmps :gmn ijje sjkjatjn men `e`t`mtjn tgj kmen`eo agjab. gj e`t`mk kmen`eo same/fkdw wms adenuatjnadeaurrjetky w`tg tgj agjabk`st. ^wd ami`e ag`hjs wjrj rjadrnjn mt =61?<:1, men tgj f`rst 1`tjhs de tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st wjrj amkkjn dut iy tgj FD men vjr`f`jn iy tgj amptm`e. ^gj FDstmtjn tgmt tgj agjabk`st wms adhpkjtj td tgj ojmr men fkmps mt =617<3:. ^gj FD n`n edt vjrimkkymnv`sj tgmt tgj fkmps wjrj `e tgj sjkjatjn pds`t`de.
Ms n`saussjn `e sjat`de =.=?.=.9, tgj MDH prdv`njs ou`nmeaj fdr pmus`eo m agjabk`st mt tgjn`rjat`de df tgj amptm`e. Qpja`f`jn pgrmsjdkdoy fdr tgj amptm`e s ‛Gdkn tgj agjabk`st mt (tgj`tjh)‘ td e`t`mtj tgj pmusj, men ‛Adet`euj tgj agjabk`st‘ td rj`e`t`mtj tgj agjabk`st w`tg tgj tjhmt wg`ag t wms gjkn. gj pmusj e tgj FMI6:63 kmen`eo agjabk`st wms edt e`t`mtjn iy tgjamptm`e ms spja`f`jn `e tgj MDH, men tgj stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy wms edt usjn.
S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt tgj kmen`eo agjab wms frjqujetky gjkn ijtwjje tgj spjjnirmbj`tjh men tgj kmen`eo ojmr uet`k tgj SF amkkjn fdr tgj ojmr, ms n`rjatjn `e tgj pgmsj-df-fk`ogt
:7 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), KMEN@EO (@e`t`mk)QAME/FKD_, pmojs 31.63.6∙31.63.?
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 59/215
- := -
ou`njk`ejs. Gdwjvjr, tgjrj wms ed nmsgjn k`ej de tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st2 tgjrjfdrj, mey pmusj etgj agjabk`st sgdukn gmvj ijje e`t`mtjn iy tgj amptm`e us`eo tgj stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoynjsar`ijn midvj. S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt prmat`ajs wjrj akdsjr td tgj nmsgjn-k`ejagjabk`st-gdkn prdajnurj (`.j., e-rmeoj agjabk`st) tgme tgj mn gda agjabk`st pmusj prdajnurj.^g`s efdrhmt`de s en`amt`vj df me mnmptmt`de tgmt gmn ijadhj m edrh.
=.=?.9.?.9 @e`t`mk kdamk`zjr men ok`njskdpj `en`amt`des
^gj MDH :0 njsar`ijs stmenmrn amkkduts td njet`fy e`t`mk hdvjhjet df kdamk`zjr men ok`njskdpjadabp`t en`amtdrs. Mt tgj f`rst ewmrn hdt`de df tgj kdamk`zjr en`amtdr dr f`rst pds`t`vj hdt`de dftgj ok`njskdpj en`amtdr, tgj SEF s rjqu`rjn td amkk dut ‛Kdamk`zjr mk`vj‘ men ‛Ok`njskdpj mk`vj‘,rjspjat`vjky. Ed rjspdesj frdh tgj SF `s rjqu`rjn. gj FD amkkjn kdamk`zjr mk`vj mt =617<93, menok`njskdpj mk`vj mt =617<9:.
=.=?.9.?.1 Kmen`eo agjabk`st (F`emk)
^gj MDH njsar`ijs tgj kmen`eo (f`emk) same/fkdw, wg`ag s `e`t`mtjn wgje tgj kmen`eo ojmr ssjkjatjn ND_E. Mat`de `tjhs mrj jxjautjn iy tgj SEF ms fdkkdws< 63
Ojmr ...................................................................................................... ND_E, 1 OYJJEFKMSQ ................................................................................................. =:, OYJJE K@OG^
^gj amptm`e amkkjn fdr ojmr ndwe mt =617<17, men fkmps =: mt =617<>9. ^gj FD amkkjn ojmr ndwe, 1orjje mt =617<>7. ^gj FD amkkjn fkmps =:, orjje k`ogt mt =617<::. ^gj FD n`n edt amkk tgj kmen`eoagjabk`st adhpkjtj, k`bjky ijamusj f`emk kmen`eo fkmp gmn edt yjt ijje sjkjatjn.
=.=?.9.7 F`emk mpprdmag
=.=?.9.7.= @e`t`mk njv`mt`de frdh kdamk`zjr
^gj MDH 6= njsar`ijs stmenmrn amkkduts men tdkjrmeajs df vmr`dus pgmsjs df fk`ogt. De mpprdmag,tgj SEF s rjqu`rjn td amkk dut ‛Kdamk`zjr‘ wgjejvjr tgj kdamk`zjr adursj njv`mt`de s e jxajssdf = ndt frdh tgj ajetrj. ^gj SF rjspdesj `s ‛Adrrjat`eo.‘
Mt =610<=1, tgj FD hmnj m stmtjhjet rjomrn`eo m`rarmft kmtjrmk n`spkmajhjet frdh tgj njs`rjntrmab. Gj n`n edt usj tgj spja`f`jn pgrmsj en`amtjn midvj. ^gj amptm`e mabedwkjnojn, iut n`nedt usj tgj wdrn ‛Adrrjat`eo.‘ FNY nmtm sgdw tgmt tgjrj wjrj ed adetrdk eputs hmnj mt tg`st`hj. ^gj m`rarmft wms midut =¸ ndts r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrj mt tg`s t`hj. 69
Ijtwjje =610<=6 men =610<13, tgj FD hmnj > furtgjr stmtjhjets rjomrn`eo trmab n`spkmajhjet.^gj wdrn kdamk`zjr wms edt usjn `e mey df tgjsj stmtjhjets. FNY men rmnmr nmtm sgdw tgmt, mt
:0 @i`n., Q^MENMYN AMKKDZ^Q & ^DKJYMEAJQ, pmoj 31.19.=
63 @i`n., KMEN@EO (F`emk) QAME/FKD_, pmoj 31.63.?
6= @i`n., Q^MENMYN AMKKDZ^Q & ^DKJYMEAJQ, pmoj 31.19.>
69 M`rarmft pds t`de rjkmt`vj td tgj kdamk`zjr s imsjn de rmnmr pds`t`de df tgj m rarmft supjr`hpdsjn dvjrtgj amkaukmtjn kdamk`zjr ijmh w`ntg.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 60/215
- :9 -
=610<91, tgj m`rarmft wms 9 ndts r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr men =¸ ndts midvj tgj ok`njskdpj. 61 Mt=610<9>.9, tgj FD stmtjn, ‛Edw wj‐rj tgrduog t.‘
Mt =610<11 men =610<16, tgj amptm`e hmnj 9 stmtjhjets tgmt suoojst tgmt gj wms smt`sf`jn tgmt tgjmutdp`kdt wms trmab`eo prdpjrky, iut n`n edt usj tgj wdrn ‛adrrjat`eo‘ e j`tgjr df g`sstmtjhjets. Ad`ea`njet w`tg tgj sjaden stmtjhjet, m adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjet td tgj kjft
daaurrjn. gj hdvjhjet pjmbjn mt =3³ wgjjk-kjft, men tgje agmeojn n`rjat`de td tgj r`ogt,tgrduog tgj ejutrmk pds`t`de td 6³ wgjjk-r`ogt. gjsj hdvjhjets mrj ades`stjet w`tg hmeumkadetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eo (A_Q) rdkk eputs iy tgj SF.
@etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt F`rst M`r I?1? p`kdts wjrj mwmrj df tgj stmenmrn amkkduts fdr kdamk`zjradursj njv`mt`de `e jxajss df = ndt frdh tgj ajetrj.
=.=?.9.7.9 Fukk njfkjat`de df kdamk`zjr
Ojejrmk prdajnurmk ou`nmeaj fdr `estruhjet fky`eo e Amemnm 6> stmtjs tgmt, nur`eo @KQmpprdmagjs, m h`ssjn mpprdmag hust ij `e`t`mtjn f fukk-samkj njfkjat`de df tgj kdamk`zjr daaurs mt
mey t`hj de f`emk mpprdmag ijfdrj nja`s`de gj`ogt.
^g`s ou`nmeaj s jhpgms`zjn nur`eo ims`a`estruhjet fky`eo trm`e`eo. Ej`tgjr tgj FDH edr tgj MDH spja`f`js m amkkdut fdr fukk njfkjat`dedf tgj kdamk`zjr.
Mt =6>3<3?, tgj FD hmnj m stmtjhjet pgrmsjn ms m qujst`de midut fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de. Dvjrtgj ejxt 96 sjadens, tgj p`kdts n`saussjn m`rarmft pds`t`de rjkmt`vj td tgj kdamk`zjr, iut n`n edt`e`t`mtj m h`ssjn mpprdmag. Mt =6>3<13, tgj FD suoojstjn td tgj amptm`e tgmt tgjy mimende tgjmpprdmag, iut n`n edt usj tgj pgrmsj ‛od-mrduen‘ dr ‛h`ssjn mpprdmag.‘ Mt =6>3<11, tgjamptm`e stmtjn tgmt gj etjenjn td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag.
_gje msbjn wgjtgjr m od-mrduen wms rjqu`rjn w`tg fukk-samkj njfkjat`de df tgj kdamk`zjr, mkkp`kdts etjrv`jwjn stmtjn tgmt tg`s aden`t`de rjqu`rjn m od-mrduen. Gdwjvjr, mkk p`kdts`etjrv`jwjn morjjn tgmt me FD adukn edt adhhmen m od-mrduen, men adukn edt sjj me FDtmb`eo adetrdk frdh tgj amptm`e. ^gjy stmtjn tgmt tgj FD wdukn k`bjky hmbj m suoojst`de drejodt`mtj w`tg tgj amptm`e rjomrn`eo tgj ejjn fdr mat`de.
=.=?.9.7.1 M`rspjjn men f`emk mpprdmag f`x amkkduts
^gj MDH 6: spja`f`js tdkjrmeajs men m stmenmrn amkkdut fdr m`rspjjns de mpprdmag ijfdrj tgjf`emk mpprdmag f`x (FMF). ^gj SEF `s rjqu`rjn td amkk dut ‛M`rspjjn‘ `f tgj m`rspjjn `s `e jxajssdf +=3 dr ∙: bedts df tgj h`e`huh m`rspjjn (VMSS), men tgj SF rjspdesj s ‛Adrrjat`eo.‘
Frdh tgj t`hj wgje FMI6:63 rdkkjn dut df tgj ture detd f`emk (=610<3:) uet`k pmss`eo mijmh tgj
FMF (=6>3<93), tgj m`rspjjn rmeojn ijtwjje =67 men =?1 bedts en`amtjn m`rspjjn (B@MQ)2 tg`s
61 M`rarmft pds t`de rjkmt`vj td tgj ok`njskdpj s imsjn de rmnmr pds`t`de df tgj m rarmft men fk`ogt nmtmrjadrnjr (FNY) imrd-mkt`hjtjr supjr`hpdsjn dvjr tgj amkaukmtjn ok`njskdpj ijmh.
6> ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S 93?6 ‑ @estruhjet Srdajnurjs Hmeumk (>tg jn`t`de, Lmeumry 9333), sjat`de >.6.?
6: F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), Q^MENMYN
AMKKDZ^Q & ^DKJYMEAJQ, pmoj 31.19.>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 61/215
- :1 -
m`rspjjn wms 13 bedts orjmtjr tgme VMSS. Mt ed t`hj nur`eo tg`s pjr`dn n`n j`tgjr p`kdt hjet`detgj m`rspjjn.
^gj MDH 66 spja`f`js m stmenmrn amkkdut td ij hmnj iy tgj SEF mt tgj FMF `eiduen. ^gj SEF `srjqu`rjn td amkk dut ‛F`emk mpprdmag f`x, TTTTT fjjt (mkt`tunj), mkt`hjtjr men estruhjets ardss-agjab ed fkmos.‘
FMI6:63 pmssjn mijmh tgj FMF (SDBME) mt midut =6>3<93. ^gj FD n`n edt hmbj mey rjfjrjeajtd tgj FMF dr tgj rjqu`rjn mkt`hjtjr men `estruhjet stmtus mt tg`s dr mey dtgjr t`hj.
Deaj `es`nj tgj FMF, tgj SEF `s rjqu`rjn td amkk dut ‛Iuo ½ TTTT (spjjn n`ffjrjeaj)‘ `f tgjm`rspjjn `s `e jxajss df ½: bedts df tgj h`e`huh m`rspjjn (VMSS), men tgj SF rjspdesj `s‛Adrrjat`eo.‘
Frdh tgj t`hj wgje FMI6:63 pmssjn mijmh tgj FMF (=6>3<93) uet`k hpmat, tgj m`rspjjn rmeojnijtwjje =?7 men =16 B@MQ (VMSS +>= td ∙= bedts). Mt ed t`hj nur`eo tg`s pjr`dn n`n j`tgjr p`kdthjet`de tgj m`rspjjn.
=.=?.9.7.> Zestmikj mpprdmag
@e 93=9, tgjrj wjrj 9>.> h`kk`de njpmrturjs fdr m wdrknw`nj fkjjt df a`v`k-dpjrmtjn, adhhjra`mk,wjstjre-iu`kt ljt m`rpkmejs gjmv`jr tgme 63 333 pduens hmx`huh ordss wj`ogt. 6? Me mrt`akj `e MjrdQmfjty _drkn 67 stmtjn tgmt, wg`kj deky 1.:% td >% df mpprdmagjs mrj uestmikj, 0?% dfuestmikj mpprdmagjs mrj adet`eujn td m kmen`eo, w`tg deky 1% rjsukt`eo `e m od-mrduen.
Yjsjmrag gms sgdwe tgmt uestmikj mpprdmagjs prjsjet g`ogjr r`sb td smfj fk`ogt dpjrmt`des. 60 Adesjqujetky, hmey m`r trmespdrt dpjrmtdrs eadrpdrmtj stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag pdk`a`js menprdajnurjs w`tg`e tgj`r dpjrmt`des. g`s eadrpdrmt`de s `etjenjn td ij me mnh`e`strmt`vjnjfjeaj mom`est sjvjrmk ejomt`vj dutadhjs, suag ms ruewmy dvjrrues men adetrdkkjn fk`ogt etdtjrrm`e (AF@^).
Ms tg`s men dtgjr daaurrjeajs ?3,?=,?9,?1 sgdw, sdhj df tgjsj uestmikj mpprdmagjs adetr`iutj tdkmen`eo sgdrt df tgj ruewmy, ruewmy dvjrrues, AF@^, men tm`k str`bjs. ^gjsj dutadhjs w`kkpjr`dn`amkky rjsukt e amtmstrdpg`a maa`njets w`tg hukt`pkj fmtmk`t`js.
66 @i`n., Q^MENMYN AMKKDZ^Q, pmoj 31.19.=
6? Qtmt`st`amk Quhhmry df Adhhjra`mk Ljt M`rpkmej Maa`njets< _drknw`nj Dpjrmt`des =0:0‑93=9, Idj`eoAdhhjra`mk M`rpkmejs (Muoust 93=1)
67 Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de, ‛Fm`kurj td H`t`omtj,‘ MjrdQmfjty _drkn (Fjirumry 93=1)
60 Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de, Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de Mpprdmag men Kmen`eo Maa`njet Yjnuat`de (FQFMKMY), Ir`jf`eo Edtj ?.=< Qtmi`k`zjn Mpprdmag, Fk`ogt Qmfjty N`ojst (Muoust∙Edvjhijr 9333)
?3 ^QI mv`mt`de `evjst`omt`de rjpdrts M=9_333>, M=9]3=6=, M37D3111, M37D331:, M3?_333:,M3>D3=77, men M33G333>
?= Hmeomkdrj, @en`m, 99 Hmy 93=3, I?1?-733 (Yuewmy dvjrrue, m`rarmft njstrdyjn, =6? fmtmk`t`js),Odvjrehjet df @en`m, H`e`stry df A`v`k Mv`mt`de `evjst`omt`de rjpdrt (1= Datdijr 93=3)
?9 Frmebfurt, Ojrhmey, 3= Hmrag 933:, JYL=?3 (Kmen`eo sgdrt df ruewmy, h`edr m`rarmft nmhmoj, ed`elur`js), IFZ Ojrhmey rjpdrt JW33=-3/3: (Mpr`k 933?)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 62/215
- :> -
^gj FDH sjat`de 7.=1 njsar`ijs tgj adhpmey‐s pdk`ay rjomrn`eo stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag ar`tjr`m,men akjmrky stmtjs tgmt m od-mrduen s rjqu`rjn e tgj jvjet df me uestmikj mpprdmag. Qjat`de 7.=1rjmns ms fdkkdws< ?>
Mkk mpprdmagjs sgmkk ij stmi`k`zjn iy =,333 fjjt MFJ ?: `e `estruhjethjtjdrdkdo`amk aden`t`des (@HA) men iy :33 fjjt MFJ e v`sumk hjtjdrdkdo amkaden`t`des (VHA).
Me mpprdmag s ades`njrjn stmi`k`zjn wgje tgj fdkkdw`eo ar`tjr`m mrj hjt menhm`etm`ejn<
=. ^gj m`rarmft `s de tgj adrrjat fk`ogt pmtg2
9. Deky shmkk agmeojs e gjmn`eo men p`tag mrj rjqu`rjn td hm`etm`e tgj adrrjatfk`ogt pmtg2
1. ^gj m`rpkmej spjjn `s edt hdrj tgme VYJF + 93 bedts `en`amtjn m`rspjjn menedt kjss tgme VYJF2
>. ^gj m`rpkmej s e tgj adrrjat kmen`eo adef`ourmt`de2
:. Q`eb rmtj `s ed orjmtjr tgme =,333 fph2 ?6 `f me mpprdmag rjqu`rjs m s`eb rmtjorjmtjr tgme =,333 fph, m spja`mk ir`jf`eo sgmkk ij adenuatjn. Qtjjp QkdpjMpprdmag od-mrduen ar`tjr`m w`kk ij spja`f`amkky njf`ejn e tgj m`rarmftQtmenmrn Dpjrmt`eo Srdajnurjs2
6. ^grust sjtt`eo hust ij midvj fk`ogt nkj men mpprdpr`mtj fdr tgj m`rpkmejadef`ourmt`de2
?. @KQ mpprdmagjs sgmkk ij fkdwe w`tg`e dej ndt df tgj ok`nj skdpj men kdamk`zjr,dr w`tg`e tgj jxpmenjn kdamk`zjr samkj2
7. Nur`eo m a`rak`eo mpprdmag, w`eos sgdukn ij kjvjk de f`emk wgje tgj m`rarmft
rjmagjs 133 fjjt midvj m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de2 men
0. Mkk ir`jf`eos men agjabk`sts gmvj ijje adenuatjn.
Ze`quj mpprdmag prdajnurjs dr miedrhmk aden`t`des rjqu`r`eo m njv`mt`de frdhtgj midvj jkjhjets df m stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag rjqu`rj m spja`mk ir`jf`eo.
Me mpprdmag tgmt ijadhjs uestmikj ijkdw =,333 fjjt MFJ `e @HA dr ijkdw :33fjjt MFJ e VHA rjqu`rjs me hhjn`mtj od-mrduen.
?1 Qme Frmea`sad, Amk`fdre`m, 36 Luky 93=1, I??? (^m`kstr`bj, m`rarmft njstrdyjn, 13? de idmrn, 1 fmtmk`t`js,hukt`pkj sjr`dus elur`js), ZQ Emt`demk ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn (E^QI) Hjn`m Ir`jf`eos (3?∙==
Luky 93=1)
?> F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk (FDH), Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (== Hmy 93==), sjat`de 7.=1< Qtmi`k`zjnMpprdmag Ar`tjr`m, pmojs 7-=1 td 7-=>
?: Midvj f`jkn jkjvmt`de Rfddtedtj mnnjnX
?6 Fjjt pjr h`eutj Rfddtedtj mnnjnX
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 63/215
- :: -
Mt =33 fjjt GM^ ?? fdr mkk v`sumk mpprdmagjs, tgj m`rpkmej hust ij pds`t`dejn sdtgj fk`ogt njab s w`tg`e, men trmab`eo td rjhm`e w`tg`e, tgj kmtjrmk adef`ejs df tgjruewmy jnojs jxtjenjn.
Ms tgj m`rpkmej ardssjs tgj ruewmy tgrjsgdkn t sgmkk ij<
=. Qtmi`k`zjn de tmrojt m`rspjjn td w`tg`e +=3 bedts uet`k mrrjst`eo njsajet rmtj
mt fkmrj29. De m stmi`k`zjn fk`ogt pmtg us`eo edrhmk hmejuvjr`eo2 men
1. Sds`t`dejn td hmbj m edrhmk kmen`eo `e tgj tduagndwe zdej.
@e`t`mtj m od-mrduen `f mey df tgj prjajn`eo ar`tjr`m ameedt ij hjt.
^gj adhpmey wms mwmrj tgmt ts stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag pdk`ay gmn edt yjt ijje hpkjhjetjn w`tgprdajnurjs spja`f`a td m`rarmft typj. De =0 Hmy 93=3, tgj adhpmey stmenmrns adhh`ttjjprdpdsjn stmenmrn amkks td ij usjn td `hpkjhjet tgj pdk`ay. Gdwjvjr, mt tgj t`hj df tgjmaa`njet, tgj MDH n`n edt eakunj stmenmrn amkks fdr me uestmikj mpprdmag.
^gj MDH Vdkuhj =, pmoj 31.63.1=, n`saussjs kmen`eo prdajnurjs ms fdkkdws< ?7
Fdr m edrhmk mpprdmag, tgj kmen`eo adef`ourmt`de (ojmr ndwe men kmen`eo fkmps)`s jstmik`sgjn jmrky de f`emk mpprdmag. Qjkjat`de df kmen`eo fkmp hust ij hmnjpr`dr td =333' MOK. Qtmi`k`zj m`rarmft de spjjn men prdf`kj w`tg m`rpkmej `e tr`hiy =333' MOK.
Mt =6>3<>=, tgj FD stmtjn, ‛_j‐rj 1 h`kj f`emk2 wj‐rj edt adef`oojn.‘ Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj m`rarmftwms midut 033 fjjt midvj tgj tduagndwe zdej jkjvmt`de (Mppjen`x A), men tgj fdkkdw`eopmrmhjtjrs jxajjnjn tgj stmikj mpprdmag ar`tjr`m<
• @e jxajss df 9 ndts njv`mt`de frdh kdamk`zjr2
• Q`oe`f`amet agmeojs e gjmn`eo men p`tag rjqu`rjn td adrrjat td prdpjr fk`ogt pmtg2
• M`rspjjn df =?6 B@MQ, VYJF + >> bedts2
• M`rarmft edt adef`ourjn fdr kmen`eo2
• Kmen`eo agjabk`st edt adhpkjtj.
Mt =6>3<>:, tgj amptm`e rjspdenjn w`tg tgj f`rst df sjvjrmk `estruat`des td tgj FD td hmbj tgjrjhm`e`eo fkmp sjkjat`des fdr kmen`eo. @etjrh`xjn w`tg tgj fkmp adef`ourmt`de amkks wjrj sjvjrmkfurtgjr jxagmeojs ijtwjje tgj p`kdts rjomrn`eo m`rarmft pds`t`de. Ed od-mrduen wms `e`t`mtjn,men tgj mpprdmag wms adet`eujn.
^gj MDH Vdkuhj =, pmoj 31.93.=, ?0 stmtjs tgmt f`emk kmen`eo ojmr men fkmp pds`t`de sgmkk mkwmysij adef`rhjn iy tgj amptm`e. g`s rjqu`rjhjet s jhidn`jn e tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st njsar`ijn e
?? Gj`ogt midvj tgrjsgdkn Rfddtedtj mnnjnX
?7 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), KMEN@EO
SYDAJNZYJ, pmoj 31.63.1=
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 64/215
- :6 -
Mppjen`x Z, wgjrj`e idtg tgj SF men SEF hust rjspden td tgj f`emk ojmr men fkmp agmkkjeojs.Mt =6>=<37, tgj amptm`e amkkjn fdr fkmps >3. ^gj FD‐s rjspdesj adef`rhjn tgmt tgj ojmr wms ndwe,iut n`n edt hjet`de tgj fkmp pds`t`de. ^gj FD n`n edt hmbj j`tgjr df tgj f`emk kmen`eo agjabk`stojmr dr fkmp agmkkjeojs, men tgj amptm`e‐s rjspdesj rjkmtjn deky td tgj fkmp >3 pds`t`de men n`nedt eakunj adef`rhmt`de df tgj ojmr. gj FD n`n edt amkk tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st adhpkjtj.
Mkk p`kdts `etjrv`jwjn wjrj mwmrj df tgj adhpmey‐s stmikj mpprdmag pdk`ay men tgmt m od-mrduen wms rjqu`rjn `f uestmikj ijkdw =333 fjjt, iut edt mkk adukn stmtj tgj ar`tjr`m. Qdhj p`kdtswjrj uesurj wgjtgjr m QDS njsar`i`eo mat`de td tmbj `e tgj jvjet df me uestmikj mpprdmagjx`stjn. _gje msbjn gdw, ms SEF, tgjy wdukn e`t`mtj m od-mrduen wgje uestmikj ijkdw =333fjjt, p`kdt rjspdesjs vmr`jn< sdhj p`kdts tddb up td 03 sjadens td rjspden2 dtgjrs rjpdrtjn tgmttgjy wdukn amkk dut, ‛Zestmikj mpprdmag, od-mrduen‘, men dej p`kdt en`amtjn tgmt, ms m kmstrjsdrt, gj wdukn tmbj adetrdk men fky tgj od-mrduen g`hsjkf.
=.=?.9.7.: Qtmenmrn m`rarmft stmtj amkkduts `es`nj tgj f`emk mpprdmag f`x
^gj MDH Vdkuhj =, pmoj 31.19.>, spja`f`js stmenmrn amkkduts td ij usjn iy tgj p`kdts deaj
`es`nj tgj FMF (^mikj 0).^mikj 0. Qtmenmrn m`rarmft stmtj amkkduts men tdkjrmeajs `es`nj tgj f`emk mpprdmag f`x 73
^DKJYMEAJQ/Q@^ZM^@DE SEF AMKKDZ^ SF/SEF YJQSDEQJ
OK@NJQKDSJ @E JWAJQQ DF = ND^ ‛OK@NJQKDSJ‘ ‛ADYYJA^@EO‘
YM^J DF NJQAJE^ @E JWAJQQ DF =933 FSH ‛Q@EB YM^J‘ ‛ADYYJA^@EO‘
S@^AG MEOKJ MSSYDMAG@EO ½ :³ DFQ^MI@K@\JN S@^AG M^^@^ZNJ
‛S@^AG‘ AMZ^@DE< IJ MKJY^ ^D_@ENQGJMY @EN@AM^@DEQ
‛ADYYJA^@EO‘
^GYZQ^ KJQQ ^GME =.= JSY M^ MK^@^ZNJKJQQ ^GME =333' MOK
‛^GYZQ^‘ ‛ADYYJA^@EO‘
ED^J< _gje spja`f`a a`rauhstmeajs rjqu`rj m`rarmft dpjrmt`de duts`nj df tgj midvj tdkjrmeajs,
tgj SF sgdukn mnv`sj tgj SEF df g`s dr gjr `etjet`des men tgj spja`f`a rjmsde fdr nd`eo sd.
Frdh =6>3<:3 td `hpmat, tgj m`rarmft wms `e jxajss df = ndt midvj tgj ok`njskdpj. Nur`eo tg`spjr`dn, tgj ok`njskdpj wms hjet`dejn deky deaj, mt =6>=<96, wgje tgj amptm`e adhhjetjn detgj prjsjeaj df tgj ok`njskdpj `en`amtdr. Mt =6>=<97, tgj FD rjspdenjn tgmt `t wms fukkynjfkjatjn. gj spja`f`jn ‛Ok`njskdpj‘ men ‛Adrrjat`eo‘ amkkduts wjrj edt usjn.
^A prdv`njs ojejrmk prdajnurmk ou`nmeaj fdr estruhjet fky`eo. Ou`nmeaj fdr @KQ mpprdmagjsstmtjs tgmt ‛R`Xf tgj m`rarmft `s `eiduen de tgj kdamk`zjr midvj tgj ok`nj pmtg tgj p`kdt hust usjjxtrjhj amut`de,‘ ijamusj df me jxajss`vj rmtj df njsajet ejjnjn td rjom`e tgj ok`nj pmtg. 7=
^gj rmtj df njsajet wms rjkmt`vjky stmikj mt midut ?33 fjjt pjr h`eutj (fph) frdh =6>3<93 uet`k=6>3<>7. Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj rmtj df njsajet njarjmsjn, stmi`k`z`eo mt midut 933 fph uet`k =6>=<=6. Mttg`s t`hj, tgj rmtj df njsajet earjmsjn, jxajjn`eo =933 fph frdh =6>=<>9 uet`k =6>=<>7. Frdh
?0 @i`n., EDYHMK AGJABK@Q^ SGYMQJDKDOP, pmoj 31.93.=
73 @i`n., jxajrpt rjprdnuajn frdh Q^MENMYN AMKKDZ^Q & ^DKJYMEAJQ tmikj, pmoj 31.19.>
7= ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S 93?6 ∙ @estruhjet Srdajnurjs Hmeumk (>tg jn`t`de, Lmeumry 9333), sjat`de >.6.?
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 65/215
- :? -
tg`s t`hj uet`k hpmat mt =6>=<:=.7, tgj rmtj df njsajet njarjmsjn. Mt ed pd`et nur`eo tgj pjr`dnwgje tgj rmtj df njsajet jxajjnjn =933 fph n`n j`tgjr p`kdt hjet`de `t.
Mt =6>=<=7, tgj p`tag meokj ijome njarjms`eo frdh +9³, rjmag`eo ∙>.7³ mt =6>=<>9. Ej`tgjr p`kdtadhhjetjn de tg`s p`tag agmeoj.
Mt =6>3<>0, tgj m`rarmft wms ijkdw =333 fjjt mok, men tgrust de idtg jeo`ejs gmn ijje rjnuajnijkdw =.= jeo`ej prjssurj rmt`d (JSY). gj kjft jeo`ej tgrust earjmsjn midvj =.= JSY mt =6>3<:0,men tgj r`ogt jeo`ej tgrust n`n sd mt =6>=<36. Ej`tgjr p`kdt adhhjetjn de tgj kdw tgrust sjtt`eo.
^gj MDH Vdkuhj =, pmoj 31.19.=, 79 spja`f`js stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy td ij usjn iy tgj SEF td`en`amtj prdx`h`ty td nja`s`de gj`ogt de me @KQ mpprdmag. Mt =33 fjjt midvj nja`s`de gj`ogt, tgjSEF s rjqu`rjn td amkk dut ‛=33 fjjt td h`e`huhs.‘ FMI6:63 rjmagjn =33 fjjt midvj nja`s`degj`ogt mt =6>=<>7. ^gj FD n`n edt hmbj mey stmtjhjet rjomrn`eo gj`ogt midvj nja`s`de gj`ogt.
=.=?.9.0 Od-mrduen
=.=?.9.0.= Qtmenmrn amkkduts men od-mrduen prdajnurj
^gj MDH Vdkuhj =, pmoj 31.19.=, 71 spja`f`js tgmt tgj SEF `s rjqu`rjn td hmbj m amkkdut mtnja`s`de gj`ogt de me @KQ mpprdmag `njet`fy`eo tgmt tgj m`rarmft gms rjmagjn tgj h`e`huhmkt`tunj men njsar`i`eo wgjtgjr tgj ruewmy s e s`ogt. gj stmenmrn amkkduts mrj ‛H`e`huhs,ruewmy `e s`ogt‘ dr ‛H`e`huhs, ed adetmat.‘ ^gj stmenmrn rjspdesj iy tgj SF `s ‛Kmen`eo‘ dr,`f ed v`sumk adetmat `s jstmik`sgjn, ‛Od-mrduen tgrust, fkmp TTTT.‘ 7>
^g`s stmenmrn amkkdut iy tgj SEF prdv`njs `efdrhmt`de td tgj SF rjomrn`eo m`rarmft pds`t`de menv`sumk rjfjrjeaj stmtus. Fdkkdw`eo tgj SEF amkkdut, tgj SF tgje hmbjs m nja`s`de wgjtgjr tdadet`euj tgj mpprdmag dr e`t`mtj m od-mrduen.
^gj MDH Vdkuhj = njsar`ijs tgj od-mrduen prdajnurj fdr m`rarmft jqu`ppjn w`tg tgj QS??mutdp`kdt de pmoj 31.63.1:, ms rjprdnuajn `e F`ourj ?.
79 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), Q^MENMYN
AMKKDZ^Q, pmoj 31.19.=
71 @i`n.
7> Fkmp td rjqu`rjn h`ssjn mpprdmag pds`t`de
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 66/215
- :7 -
F`ourj ?. F`rst M`r I?1? od-mrduen prdajnurj Rrjprdnuajn frdh<F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk
,Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), OD-MYDZEN SYDAJNZYJ (QS??), pmoj 31.63.1:X
^gj prdajnurj `e F`ourj ? spja`f`js m amkkdut iy tgj SF td `e`t`mtj tgj od-mrduen. ^g`s amkkdut,‛Od-mrduen, fkmps =:‘, n`ffjrs frdh tgj stmenmrn amkkdut spja`f`jn de pmoj 31.19.=.
Ej`tgjr df tgjsj pdrt`des df tgj MDH prdv`nj fdr tgj SEF td hmbj m od-mrduen amkk.
=.=?.9.0.9 Ed-fmukt od-mrduen pdk`ay
Qjat`de 7.=9 df tgj FDH njsar`ijs tgj adhpmey‐s pdk`ay ou`nmeaj rjomrn`eo ‛ed-fmukt‘ od-mrduen (ijkdw). 7: ^gj pdk`ay wms `hpkjhjetjn ijfdrj 9337.
@e drnjr td jegmeaj smfjty men td rjnuaj tgj r`sb df mpprdmag men kmen`eomaa`njets, F`rst M`r hm`etm`es m ‛Ed Fmukt‘ od-mrduen pdk`ay.
7: F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk (FDH), Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (== Hmy 93==), sjat`de 7.=9< Ed Fmukt Od-Mrduen Sdk`ay, pmoj 7-=1
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 67/215
- :0 -
@e mnn`t`de td tgj rjqu`rjhjet td pjrfdrh m od-mrduen, e tgj jvjet tgmt mempprdmag s edt stmi`k`zjn, m p`kdt hmy adenuat m od-mrduen fdr mey rjmsde (`.j.kmab df mnjqumtj v`sumk rjfjrjeajs, wjmtgjr aden`t`des edt su`tmikj, adefk`at`eotrmff`a, men kdss df adetmat w`tg M^A) w`tgdut fjmr df n`sa`pk`emry mat`de frdh tgjAdhpmey.
=.=?.9.0.1 F`rst M`r orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh pdk`ay
Qjat`de 9.99.: df tgj FDH 76 stmtjs, ‛Qpja`f`a prdajnurjs td ij fdkkdwjn `e tgj jvjet df me`estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs (@FY) `e-fk`ogt mat`vmt`de df OS_Q/^M_Q 7? mrj adetm`ejn `e tgjmppk`amikj MDH.‘
^gj MDH Vdkuhj =, pmoj 3>.933.1=, spja`f`js m prdajnurj td ij usjn fdr tjrrm`e mvd`nmeaj. ^gjprdajnurj spja`f`js tgmt mat`vmt`de df tgj ‛pukk up‘ wmre`eo, dr dtgjr s`tumt`des rjsukt`eo euemaajptmikj fk`ogt tdwmrn tjrrm`e, mrj rjomrnjn ms prjsjet`eo m pdtjet`mk fdr tjrrm`e adetmat.^gj njsar`pt`de df tgj tjrrm`e mvd`nmeaj prdajnurj s rjprdnuajn e F`ourj 7.
*Hmx`huh tgrust `s njf`ejn ms hmx`huh ajrt`f`jn tgrust.
F`ourj 7. jrrm`e mvd`nmeaj prdajnurj (rjprdnuajn frdh< F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =,Mhjenhjet ed. 91 R9= Luej 93==X, pmoj 3>.933.1=)
=.=?.9.0.> FMI6:63 orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh mkjrts men od-mrduen `e`t`mt`de
^gj FMI6:63 arjw n`n edt e`t`mtj m od-mrduen mt j`tgjr tgj pd`et df fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de drmt 1 h`kjs wgje tgj FD `en`amtjn tgmt tgjy wjrj edt adef`ourjn (`e me uestmikj mpprdmag). Mt=6>=<>?.?, tgj OS_Q prdv`njn me murmk ‛s`eb rmtj‘ mkjrt. Mt =6>=<>0.3, tgj FD stmtjn, ‛Od fdr t.‘
76 @i`n., sjat`de 9.99.:< Orduen Srdx`h`ty _mre`eo Qystjh/^M_Q, pmoj 9-::
7? ^M_Q rjfjrs td tjrrm`e mwmrjejss men wmre`eo systjh Rfddtedtj mnnjnX.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 68/215
- 63 -
Mt =6>=<>0.9, tgj OS_Q stmrtjn td `ssuj me murmk ‛h`e`huhs…h`e`huhs‘ mkjrt. Ijtwjje tgj 9‛h`e`huhs‘ (=6>=<:3.=), tgj FD stmtjn, ‛Od mrduen.‘ Mt =6>=<:=.9, tgj amptm`e stmtjn, ‛Od-mrduen tgrust.‘ gj amptm`e n`n edt hjet`de fkmp sjkjat`de e g`s od-mrduen stmtjhjet. Mt=6>=<:=.7, FMI6:63 adkk`njn w`tg tjrrm`e.
=.=?.1 F`rst M`r smfjty hmemojhjet systjh smfjty dvjrs`ogt prdajssjs
=.=?.1.= K`ej rjpdrts
Qjat`de 0.6 df tgj FDH njsar`ijs k`ej rjpdrts. gj k`ej rjpdrt `s sjet td tgj p`kdt-`e-adhhmen(S@A) mt tgj stmrt df jmag nuty pjr`dn, mkdeo w`tg tgj DFS. ^gj k`ej rjpdrt `s tgj pr`hmry hjtgdndf prdv`n`eo fjjnimab frdh fk`ogt dpjrmt`des sd ms td dutk`ej prdikjhs. gj k`ej rjpdrt hust ijadhpkjtjn mftjr jmag fk`ogt. ^gj adetjets df tgj k`ej rjpdrt mrj rjmn iy fk`ogt dpjrmt`desmnh`e`strmt`de men tgj ag`jf p`kdt. Mey prdikjhs spja`f`jn mrj fdkkdwjn up rjomrnkjss df tgjnjpmrthjet evdkvjn. Zpde adhpkjt`de df mey nuty pjr`dn, tgj S@A s rjspdes`ikj fdr fmx`eo tgjadhpkjtjn k`ej rjpdrt td fk`ogt n`spmtag ms sdde ms pdss`ikj.
Mhdeo dtgjr `tjhs td ij `eakunjn de tgj k`ej rjpdrt `s m tgdrduog njsar`pt`de df mey ede-edrhmk dpjrmt`demk jvjets.
=.=?.1.9 M`r smfjty rjpdrts
Qjat`de 0.? df tgj FDH n`saussjs m`r smfjty rjpdrts. Me m`r smfjty rjpdrt hust ij adhpkjtjnwgje mey df tgj rjqu`rjhjets de tgj imab df tgj fdrh mrj hjt. ^gj S@A `s rjspdes`ikj fdrfdrwmrn`eo m`r smfjty rjpdrts td n`spmtag v`m tgj hdst jxpjn`t`dus hjmes pdss`ikj.
=.=?.1.1 Zerjpdrtjn ea`njets
=.=?.1.1.= Ojejrmk
^gj evjst`omt`de rjvjmkjn 9 prjv`dus ea`njets evdkv`eo AP\F-imsjn F`rst M`r I?1? arjws tgmtgmn s`h`kmr`t`js td tg`s daaurrjeaj. Qjj ijkdw fdr furtgjr njtm`ks midut tgj 9 ea`njets. Ej`tgjr dftgjsj ea`njets wms rjpdrtjn td tgj adhpmey, men adhpmey hmemojrs wjrj uemwmrj tgmt tgj`ea`njets gmn daaurrjn. gj `evjst`omt`de jxmh`ejn tgj F`rst M`r smfjty hmemojhjet systjh(QHQ) prdajssjs fdr etjremk rjpdrt`eo df gmzmrns, ea`njets, men maa`njets td njtjrh`ejwgjtgjr tgj nmtm adkkjatjn wjrj ij`eo trmabjn men usjn td mnvmeaj smfjty df tgj dpjrmt`de.
=.=?.1.1.9 @ea`njet dej
@e tgj wjjbs ijfdrj tgj APYI maa`njet, m F`rst M`r I?1? fk`ogt arjw jxpjr`jeajn prdikjhs w`tgemv`omt`demk `estruhjets wg`kj adenuat`eo me mpprdmag `e `estruhjet hjtjdrdkdo`amkaden`t`des (@HA) mt medtgjr m`rpdrt e Euemvut. _g`kj tgjsj jvjets daaurrjn de m n`ffjrjetm`rarmft tgme tgj dej evdkvjn e tgj APYI maa`njet, tgj amptm`e df FMI6:63 wms mksd tgj amptm`e`evdkvjn `e tg`s `ea`njet.
^gj fk`ogt arjw pkmeejn me YEMV mpprdmag td tgj m`rpdrt. Mt tgj t`hj, `t wms w`eny menrm`e`eo, men tgj sby wms dvjramst mt mpprdx`hmtjky 633 fjjt mok. gj amptm`e wms tgj SF. Ijamusjtgj m`rpdrt s w`tg`e tgj ENM, fk`ogt dpjrmt`des hust ij adenuatjn w`tg rjfjrjeaj td truj edrtg.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 69/215
- 6= -
Ijfdrj njsajet, tgj arjw sw`tagjn tgj adhpmssjs frdh hmoejt`a td NO `e prjpmrmt`de fdr tgjmpprdmag.
Hmoejt`a vmr`mt`de mt tgj m`rpdrt wms 19³ jmst. _g`kj tgj adhpmssjs wjrj sw`tagjn td NO, tadukn edt ij adef`rhjn wgjtgjr tgj adhpmssjs wjrj sjt td tgj truj gjmn`eo. ^gj gjmn`eo wmsedt rjmnlustjn mt =3 333 fjjt.
Nur`eo tgj f`emk pgmsj df tgj mpprdmag, tgj mutdp`kdt wms adupkjn td tgj FHQ men wmsfdkkdw`eo tgj f`emk mpprdmag trmab. gj gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de en`amtdr (GQ@) adursj pd`etjr,wg`ag gmn ijje sjt fdr tgj f`emk mpprdmag trmab, wms edt prdpjrky k`ejn up w`tg tgj n`rjat`de dffk`ogt. _g`kj jstmik`sgjn de f`emk, tgj gjmn`eo wms mpprdx`hmtjky 13³ dff tgj ruewmy gjmn`eo,rjsukt`eo e tgj adursj pd`etjr pd`et`eo mpprdx`hmtjky 13³ td tgj kjft. Ms tgj m`rarmft njsajenjnijkdw tgj akdun kmyjr, m ture wms `e`t`mtjn td k`ej up w`tg tgj adursj pd`etjr. Mt tgmt t`hj, w`tgtgj m`rarmft mpprdx`hmtjky =.: eh frdh tgj ruewmy tgrjsgdkn, v`sumk rjfjrjeaj w`tg tgj ruewmywms maqu`rjn, men tgj ture wms stdppjn.
^gj mpprdmag wms adet`eujn, men me uejvjetfuk kmen`eo fdkkdwjn. g`s jvjet wms edt rjpdrtjn
td tgj adhpmey v`m m amptm`e‐s k`ej rjpdrt, me m`r smfjty rjpdrt, dr m gmzmrn daaurrjeaj`evjst`omt`de rjpdrt.
=.=?.1.1.1 @ea`njet twd
Jmrk`jr `e tgj suhhjr df 93==, nur`eo m agmrtjr fk`ogt `e Euemvut, medtgjr F`rst M`r I?1? arjwmksd jxpjr`jeajn prdikjhs w`tg emv`omt`demk estruhjets wg`kj adenuat`eo me mpprdmag e@HA. ^gjsj jvjets daaurrjn de A-OE_E, mktgduog ej`tgjr p`kdt frdh FMI6:63 wms `evdkvjn.
De mrr`vmk mt njst`emt`de, tgjrj wms m akdun kmyjr imsjn mt mpprdx`hmtjky 933∙133 fjjt mok,rjqu`r`eo tgj arjw td adenuat me @FY mpprdmag. Ijamusj tgj m`rpdrt s kdamtjn e tgj QdutgjreNdhjst`a M`rspmaj, fk`ogt dpjrmt`des hust ij adenuatjn w`tg rjfjrjeaj td hmoejt`a edrtg. Mtsdhj pd`et ijfdrj mrr`vmk, tgj adhpmssjs wjrj sw`tagjn frdh NO td hmoejt`a.
^gj fk`ogt rjaj`vjn m`r trmff`a adetrdk (M^A) rmnmr vjatdrs fdr me @KQ/NHJ mpprdmag. ^gjm`rarmft wms ij`eo fkdwe us`eo tgj mutdp`kdt. Gdwjvjr, tgj m`rarmft fkjw tgrduog tgj kdamk`zjr,men tgj mutdp`kdt n`n edt ampturj tgj kdamk`zjr. ^gj arjw hmeumkky fkjw tgj m`rarmft imab td tgjkdamk`zjr, iut ijamhj adeajrejn wgje emv`omt`demk estruhjet en`amt`des n`n edt sjjh tdhmbj sjesj. _g`kj tgj m`rarmft wms jstmik`sgjn de tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj ijmr`eo td tgj ENI sjjhjntd ij dff iy =3³ td =:³, o`v`eo tgj mppjmrmeaj tgmt tgj fk`ogt wms jxpjr`jea`eo m strdeoardssw`en.
Dtgjr tgme tgj mutdp`kdt edt amptur`eo tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj arjw n`n edt edt`aj mey en`amt`de df
hmkfueat`des, suag ms adhpmrmtdr k`ogts. Gdwjvjr, mt mpprdx`hmtjky 1 h`kjs frdh tgj ruewmytgrjsgdkn, m h`ssjn mpprdmag wms adenuatjn nuj td tgj emv`omt`demk estruhjet en`amt`des.Deaj mt m smfj mkt`tunj, tgj arjw agjabjn tgj adhpmssjs men njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgjy wjrj sk`ogtkydff. gjy tgduogt tgmt tg`s n`sarjpmeay h`ogt gmvj pkmyjn m rdkj e tgj fm`kurj df tgj mutdp`kdt td`etjrajpt tgj kdamk`zjr. gj arjw rjmk`oejn tgj adhpmssjs us`eo m OSQ ijmr`eo td me ENI, menmksd adef`rhjn tgmt tgj emv`omt`demk rjaj`vjrs wjrj sjt up prdpjrky.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 70/215
- 69 -
^gj arjw tgje fkjw m sjaden @KQ/NHJ mpprdmag men kmenjn w`tgdut furtgjr ea`njet.Mktgduog tgj arjw tgduogt tgmt tgj adhpmssjs wjrj m k`ttkj skdw e syeagrde`z`eo mftjrsjkjat`de df hmoejt`a hdnj, tgjy wjrj edt njjhjn iy tgj arjw td ij uesjrv`ajmikj. ^gjrjfdrj,tgj arjw n`n edt rjadrn m njfjat fdr tgj adhpmssjs e tgj ldurejy kdo. Mnn`t`demkky, mktgduog mod-mrduen s m hmenmtdry rjpdrtmikj daaurrjeaj, ed hjet`de df tgj ea`njet wms hmnj de tgjamptm`e‐s k`ej rjpdrt fdr tgj nmy, men ed m`r smfjty rjpdrt dr gmzmrn daaurrjeaj `evjst`omt de
rjpdrt wms suih`ttjn. M sjmrag df tgj A AMNDYQ (A`v`k Mv`mt`de Nm`ky Daaurrjeaj Yjpdrt`eoQystjh) adukn edt `njet`fy tgj daaurrjeaj.
Gdwjvjr, tgj ea`njet fk`ogt wms n`saussjn w`tg tgj amptm`e df FMI6:63. @ea`njet wd wmshjet`dejn iy tgj FMI6:63 amptm`e sgdrtky ijfdrj hpmat.
=.=?.1.1.> F`rst M`r smfjty hmemojhjet systjh `hpkjhjetmt`de men dpjrmt`de
F`rst M`r dpjrmtjs uenjr Quipmrt ?3: 77 df tgj AMY, men wms rjqu`rjn td gmvj me QHQ s`eaj1= Hmy 933:, wgje tgj mppk`amikj rjoukmt`de 70 amhj `etd fdraj. @hpkjhjetmt`de df me QHQ tmbjsme jxtjenjn pjr`dn. K`bj mkk Quipmrt ?3: dpjrmtdrs, F`rst M`r dpjrmtjn uenjr m rjoukmtdry
jxjhpt`de pjrh`tt`eo m >-pgmsj hpkjhjetmt`de df tgj QHQ jxtjen`eo dvjr 1 yjmrs.
De adhpkjt`de df pgmsj > df QHQ hpkjhjetmt`de mt F`rst M`r, A adenuatjn me mssjsshjet dftgj QHQ e Qjptjhijr 9330. gj diljat`vj df tg`s mssjsshjet wms td vjr`fy tgmt tgj drome`zmt degmn jffjat`vjky hpkjhjetjn ts QHQ. gj sadpj df tgj mssjsshjet eakunjn mkk QHQ prdajssjsmen mssda`mtjn mat`v`t`js adenuatjn uenjr tgj mutgdr`ty df tgj adhpmey‐s m`r dpjrmtdr ajrt`f`amtjmen m`r hm`etjemeaj drome`zmt`de ajrt`f`amtj. gj mssjsshjet advjrjn tgj pjr`dn frdh Lmeumry9337 td Qjptjhijr 9330.
^mikj =3 dutk`ejs tgj 6 adhpdejets df tgj QHQ frmhjwdrb men tgj`r adrrjspden`eo jkjhjets.
77 Quipmrt ?3: df tgj AMY mppk`js td m`rk`ej dpjrmt`des.
70 AMY =3?.39
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 71/215
- 61 -
^mikj =3. Adhpdejets men jkjhjets df m smfjty hmemojhjet systjh frmhjwdrb (imsjn de ^rmespdrtAmemnm R^AX smfjty hmemojhjet systjh hdnukjs)
Adhpdejet Jkjhjet
=. Qmfjty hmemojhjet pkme =.=. Qmfjty pdk`ay
=.9. Ede-pue`t`vj smfjty rjpdrt`eo pdk`ay
=.1. Ydkjs, rjspdes`i`k`t`js, men jhpkdyjj evdkvjhjet
=.>. Adhhue`amt`de
=.:. Qmfjty pkmee`eo, diljat`vjs, men odmks
=.6. Sjrfdrhmeaj hjmsurjhjet
=.?. Hmemojhjet rjv`jw
9. Ndauhjetmt`de 9.=. @njet`f`amt`de men hm`etjemeaj df mppk`amikjrjoukmt`des
9.9. QHQ ndauhjetmt`de
9.1. Yjadrns hmemojhjet
1. Qmfjty dvjrs`ogt 1.=. Yjmat`vj prdajssjs
1.9. Srdmat`vj prdajssjs
1.1. @evjst`omt`de men memkys`s
1.>. Y`sb hmemojhjet
>. ^rm`e`eo >.=. ^rm`e`eo, mwmrjejss, men adhpjtjeaj
:. ]umk`ty mssurmeaj :.=. ]umk`ty mssurmeaj
6. Jhjrojeay prjpmrjnejss 6.=. Jhjrojeay prjpmrjnejss men rjspdesj
M ede-pue`t`vj smfjty rjpdrt`eo pdk`ay (jkjhjet =.9) s me `etjormk pdrt`de df me QHQ. gjmssjsshjet njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj F`rst M`r pdk`ay hjt tgj h`e`huh rjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjets, mendisjrvjn tgmt jhpkdyjjs etjrv`jwjn tgrduogdut tgj drome`zmt`de uenjrstddn tgj ede-pue`t`vjhjmsurjs men wjrj adhfdrtmikj w`tg tgj pdk`a`js. Hmey jhpkdyjjs stmtjn tgmt tgj rjpdrt`eopdk`ay wms stmtjn e adhpmey prdajnurjs men s adhpkjtjky jeorm`ejn e nm`ky dpjrmt`des.
@e ts mssjsshjet rjpdrt nmtjn 3: Datdijr 9330, 03 ^A stmtjn tgmt, nur`eo tgj jmrk`jr pgmsjs dfQHQ `hpkjhjetmt`de, tgj adhpmey struookjn sdhjwgmt w`tg njs`oe`eo m hmemojhjet systjhtgmt wms mpprdpr`mtj td ts drome`zmt`de. gj rjpdrt adeakunjn tgmt tgj adhpmey hjt tgjpr`ea`pkjs df m smfjty hmemojhjet systjh wgjrj`e mkk jhpkdyjjs mrj jhpdwjrjn td mat`vjkypmrt`a`pmtj e tgj prdmat`vj smfjty pjrfdrhmeaj df tgj adhpmey.
^gj F`rst M`r QHQ `s ndauhjetjn `e sjat`de =1 df tgj adhpmey‐s Adrpdrmtj ]umk`ty Mssurmeaj Hmeumk, wg`ag njsar`ijs ts qumk`ty hmemojhjet systjh, imsjn de tgj fdkkdw`eo pr`ea`pkjs<
03 Mssjsshjet Yjpdrt, Irmnkjy M r Qjrv ajs, Yjadrns Ndauhjets @efdrhmt`de Hmemojhjet Qystjh(YN@HQ), ed. :9?3730 (3: Datdijr 9330)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 72/215
- 6> -
• Austdhjr fdaus,
• Kjmnjrsg`p,
• Jhpkdyjj pmrt`a`pmt`de,
• Qystjh mpprdmag td hmemojhjet,
• Srdajss dr`jetjn,• Nmtm-nr`vje nja`s`de hmb`eo, men
• Adet`eudus `hprdvjhjet.
=.=?.1.> @ea`njet men gmzmrn rjpdrt`eo prdajss
^d hprdvj smfjty, F`rst M`r jhpkdyjjs mrj rjqu`rjn td rjpdrt mkk `ea`njets men gmzmrns. 0= ^gjadhpmey mats de smfjty rjpdrts w`tg m fdaus de hprdvjhjets men `hpkjhjetmt de df adrrjat`vjmat`de rmtgjr tgme pue`t`vj mat`de.
^gj adhpmey gms > fukk-t`hj jhpkdyjjs mss`oejn td tgj Qmfjty Hmemojhjet Njpmrthjet.Mnn`t`demkky, wgje rjqu`rjn, m tjage`amk evjst`omtdr s tmsbjn w`tg adenuat`eo evjst`omt`destd prdv`nj tgj efdrhmt`de rjqu`rjn td e`t`mtj smfjty mat`des.
Gmzmrn efdrhmt`de ame ij suih`ttjn td tgj adhpmey e hmey n`ffjrjet fdrhs, suag ms iy<
• M`r smfjty rjpdrt,
• Gmzmrn daaurrjeaj evjst`omt`de rjpdrt, dr
• Jhm`k.
^gj imab df tgj adhpmey‐s m`r smfjty rjpdrt fdrh k`sts mkk rjpdrtmikj daaurrjeajs, sjpmrmtjn etd
9 sjat`des. ^gj f`rst sjat`de k`sts daaurrjeajs tgmt hust ij rjpdrtjn td tgj ^QI. ^gj sjadensjat`de k`sts mkk daaurrjeajs tgmt hust ij rjpdrtjn td F`rst M`r iy jhpkdyjjs. @t s edtjwdrtgytgmt m od-mrduen s k`stjn ms m hmenmtdry adhpmey-rjpdrtmikj daaurrjeaj e tgj sjaden sjat`de.Mnn`t`demkky, tgj kmst iukkjt df tgj k`st df hmenmtdry rjpdrtmikj daaurrjeajs s ms fdkkdws< ‛Meydtgjr jvjet wgjrj smfjty stmenmrns mrj s`oe`f`ametky rjnuajn, dr mey jvjet wg`ag hmy prdv`njusjfuk efdrhmt`de fdr tgj jegmeajhjet df fk`ogt smfjty.‘
Mkk smfjty rjpdrts mrj rjadrnjn e me mv`mt`de qumk`ty nmtmimsj systjh, wg`ag wms puragmsjnmen `estmkkjn `e h`n-93==. Adesjqujetky, tgj ejw nmtmimsj ndjs edt adetm`e mkk nmtm adkkjatjns`eaj tgj ijo`ee`eo df tgj QHQ mt F`rst M`r.
Deaj m smfjty rjpdrt `s rjaj`vjn, me mssjsshjet `s adhpkjtjn, men m nja`s`de `s hmnj ms tdwgjtgjr me evjst`omt`de sgdukn tmbj pkmaj. gj pjrsde wgd gms suih`ttjn tgj rjpdrt s mnv`sjndf tgj nja`s`de.
0= F`rst M`r Gjmktg men Qmfjty Sdk`ay Qtmtjhjet, Adrpdrmtj ]umk`ty Mssurmeaj Hmeumk, Qjat`de =1,pmoj =1.=.=9
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 73/215
- 6: -
=.=?.> F`rst M`r hjtgdns df hde`tdr`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des
F`rst M`r jhpkdys sjvjrmk hjtgdns td hde`tdr fk`ogt arjw pjrfdrhmeaj men mngjrjeaj tdadhpmey pdk`a`js men prdajnurjs, `eakun`eo<
• @e`t`mk tjage`amk orduen trm`e`eo, wg`ag prdv`njs me dppdrtue`ty td endatr`emtj p`kdtsw`tg tgj adhpmey‐s dpjrmt`eo pg`kdsdpgy, pdk`a`js (fk`ogt dpjrmt`des hmeumk RFDHX),men prdajnurjs (m`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumk RMDHX)2
• @e`t`mk s`hukmtdr trm`e`eo, iy wg`ag p`kdts rjaj`vj trm`e`eo tgmt rj`efdrajs tgj adhpmey‐sdpjrmt`eo pg`kdsdpgy, pdk`a`js, men prdajnurjs2
• S`kdt prdf`a`jeay agjabs, wg`ag mrj pjrfdrhmeaj agjabs adenuatjn e m s`hukmtdr tdvjr`fy tgmt p`kdts gmvj hjt tgj rjqu`rjn stmenmrn men td vmk`nmtj tgj trm`e`eo prdajss2
• K`ej `endatr`emt`de, wg`ag `s adenuatjn iy trm`e`eo p`kdts td jxpdsj p`kdts td tgjadhpmey‐s dpjrmt`demk jev`rdehjet men td furtgjr rj`efdraj tgj adhpmey‐s dpjrmt`eopg`kdsdpgy, pdk`a`js, men prdajnurjs2
• K`ej agjabs, wg`ag mrj adenuatjn mt tgj adhpkjt`de df k`ej endatr`emt`de td vjr`fy tgmt
p`kdts‐ pjrfdrhmeaj hjjts tgj rjqu`rjn stmenmrn2
• Yjaurrjet trm`e`eo, wg`ag `evdkvjs meeumk orduen men s`hukmtdr rjaurrjet trm`e`eo tgmtprdv`njs dppdrtue`t`js td rj`efdraj tgj adhpmey‐s dpjrmt`eo pg`kdsdpgy, pdk`a`js, menprdajnurjs2
• Yjaurrjet p`kdt prdf`a`jeay agjabs men k`ej agjabs, wg`ag prdv`nj medtgjr dppdrtue`tymeeumkky fdr tgj adhpmey td vjr`fy tgmt p`kdts hjjt tgj rjqu`rjn stmenmrn men td vjr`fyadhpk`meaj w`tg adhpmey pdk`a`js men prdajnurjs2
• K`ej rjpdrts (sjat`de =.=?.1.=), wg`ag prdv`nj adhpmey hmemojhjet w`tg m k`h`tjndppdrtue`ty td hde`tdr fk`ogt dpjrmt`des ms rjpdrtjn iy amptm`es2 men
• Hmemojhjet fky`eo, wg`ag evdkvjs adhpmey fk`ogt dpjrmt`des hmemojrs fky`eopjr`dn`amkky w`tg k`ej p`kdts, men prdv`njs hmemojrs w`tg me dppdrtue`ty td n`rjatkydisjrvj p`kdt pjrfdrhmeaj.
=.=?.: Dtgjr hjtgdns df hde`tdr`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des
=.=?.:.= Fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo
F`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo (FNH) `s m prdormh td `hprdvj fk`ogt smfjty iy prdv`n`eo hdrj`efdrhmt`de midut, men orjmtjr `es`ogt `etd, tgj tdtmk fk`ogt dpjrmt`des jev`rdehjet tgrduogsjkjat`vj mutdhmtjn rjadrn`eo men memkys`s df diljat`vj nmtm ojejrmtjn nur`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des.FNH `s mksd bedwe ms fk`ogt dpjrmt`demk qumk`ty mssurmeaj (FD]M) dr fk`ogt nmtm memkys`s.
Me FNH prdormh s etjenjn td jemikj me dpjrmtdr td njet`fy, qumet`fy, mssjss, men mnnrjssdpjrmt`demk r`sbs tgrduog n`sarjjt men medeyhdus adkkjat`de df jkjatrde`a fk`ogt nmtm frdhrdut`ej dpjrmt`des. Srdmat`vj men ede-pue`t`vj memkys`s df tg`s nj-`njet`f`jn nmtm `s usjn td`hprdvj mv`mt`de smfjty tgrduog njvjkdphjet men upormnj df trm`e`eo prdormhs, pdk`ay, menprdajnurjs td mnnrjss tgj njet`f`jn r`sb mrjms men hjmsurj tgj rjsukts df tgjsj e`t`mt`vjs.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 74/215
- 66 -
FNH gms ijje hpkjhjetjn e hmey aduetr`js, men t `s w`njky rjadoe`zjn ms m adst-jffjat`vjtddk fdr hprdv`eo smfjty. @e tgj ZQ men Jurdpj ‚ tgmebs td @AMD ‚ hmey amrr`jrs gmvj gmn tgjprdormh fdr yjmrs. Qdhj gjk`adptjr dpjrmtdrs gmvj `t mkrjmny, men tgj FMM gms rjadhhjenjn`t.
@e Amemnm, amrr`jrs mrj edt rjqu`rjn td gmvj me FNH prdormh. Jvje sd, hmey dpjrmtdrs
rdut`ejky ndwekdmn tgj`r fk`ogt nmtm td adenuat FNH df edrhmk dpjrmt`des. M`r amrr`jrs w`tgFNH prdormhs gmvj usjn fk`ogt nmtm td `njet`fy prdikjhs suag ms uestmi`k`zjn mpprdmagjs menrusgjn mpprdmagjs2 jxajjnmeaj df fkmp k`h`t spjjns2 jxajss`vj imeb meokjs mftjr tmbj-dff2 jeo`ejdvjr-tjhpjrmturj jvjets2 jxajjnmeaj df rjadhhjenjn spjjn tgrjsgdkns2 OS_Q/^M_Q2 desjtdf stmkk aden`t`des2 jxajss`vj rmtjs df rdtmt`de2 ok`nj pmtg jxaurs`des2 men vjrt`amk maajkjrmt`de. 09
Fdkkdw`eo QI mv`mt`de evjst`omt`de M==_33>7, tgj Idmrn rjadhhjenjn tgmt tgj Njpmrthjetdf rmespdrt wdrb w`tg enustry td rjhdvj distmakjs td men njvjkdp rjadhhjenjn prmat`ajsfdr tgj `hpkjhjetmt`de df fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo (Yjadhhjenmt`de M=1-3=). 01
F`rst M`r gms me FNH prdormh wg`ag adhhjeajn dpjrmt`des e 93=3. Gdwjvjr, tgj adhpmey
jxpjr`jeajn prdikjhs w`tg nmtm qumk`ty men w`tg ditm`e`eo rjpdrts frdh tgj adetrmatjn sjrv`ajprdv`njr, men tjrh`emtjn ts adetrmat e 93==. Mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet, tgj adhpmey‐s FNHprdormh wms uenjrod`eo m trmes`t`de td m ejw sjrv`aj prdv`njr, men nmtm memkys`s wms edtij`eo adenuatjn. Nur`eo tgj trmes`t`de, nmtm ndwekdmns adet`eujn w`tg tgj `etjet df gmv`eo tgjnmtm mvm`kmikj fdr usj wgje tgj ejw systjh wms `e pkmaj.
=.=?.:.9 K`ej dpjrmt`des smfjty mun`t
M k`ej dpjrmt`des smfjty mun`t (KDQM) s m hjtgdn fdr m`r dpjrmtdrs td ijttjr uenjrstmen r`sbsprjsjet w`tg`e tgj`r fk`ogt dpjrmt`des. KDQM s< 0>
… m ar`t`amk drome`zmt`demk strmtjoy m`hjn mt njvjkdp`eo aduetjrhjmsurjs td
dpjrmt`demk jrrdrs. gj diljat`vj df tg`s hde`tdr`eo prdormhhj, iu`kt mrduen^grjmt men Jrrdr Hmemojhjet (^JH) frmhjwdrb, s td njet`fy tgrjmts tdmv`mt`de smfjty, h`e`h`zj tgj r`sbs suag tgrjmts hmy ojejrmtj men hpkjhjethjmsurjs td hmemoj guhme jrrdr e dpjrmt`demk adetjxts. KDQM jemikjsdpjrmtdrs td mssjss tgj`r kjvjk df rjs`k`jeaj td systjh`a tgrjmts, dpjrmt`demk r`sbsmen frdet-k`ej pjrsdeejk jrrdrs, tgus prdv`n`eo m pr`ea`pkjn, nmtm-nr`vjempprdmag td pr`dr`t`sj men hpkjhjet mat`des td jegmeaj smfjty.
09 Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de, ‛_jmktg df ou`nmeaj men jxpjr`jeaj jeadurmoj w`njr mndpt`de df FD]M,‘Fk`ogt Qmfjty N`ojst (Luej∙Luky 933>)
01 ^QI, Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Yjadhhjenmt`de M=1-3=< Yjqu`rjhjet fdr k`ogtwj ogt fk`ogt rjadrnjr systjh eadhhjra`mkky dpjrmtjn m`rarmft edt odvjrejn iy AMYQ 63:.11, mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.ist-tsi.oa.am/jeo/rjadhhmenmt`des-rjadhhjenmt`des/mv`mt`de/93=1/rja-m=13=.msp (kmst maajssjn de=9 Njajhijr 93=1)
0> JZYDADE^YDK QBPirmry, K`ej Dpjrmt`des Qmfjty Mun`t (KDQM), mvm`kmikj mtgttp<//www.sbyirmry.mjrd/`enjx.pgp/K`ejTDpjrmt`desTQmfjtyTMun`tT(KDQM) (kmst maajssjn de 30Njajhijr 93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 75/215
- 6? -
KDQM usjs g`ogky trm`ejn disjrvjrs td adkkjat nmtm midut fk`ogt arjw ijgmv`durmen s`tumt`demk fmatdrs de ‛edrhmk‘ fk`ogts. Iy hde`tdr`eo tgj fk`ogt frdh tgjadabp`t, tgj disjrvjr ame kjmre huag midut fk`ogt arjw ijgmv`dur men arjws‐strmtjo`js fdr hmemo`eo tgrjmts, jrrdrs men uenjs`rmikj stmtjs.
KDQM s akdsjky k`ebjn w`tg Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet (AYH) trm`e`eo. M
pmrt`aukmr strjeotg df KDQM s tgmt t `njet`f`js jxmhpkjs df supjr`dr pjrfdrhmeajtgmt ame ij rj`efdrajn men usjn ms hdnjks fdr trm`e`eo.
KDQM `s m vdkuetmry prdormh, men F`rst M`r gms edt pmrt`a`pmtjn `e KDQM.
=.=?.6 M`r trmff`a sjrv`ajs
=.=?.6.= Amemn`me m`rspmaj
^gj Amemn`me Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj`s n`v`njn etd kdw-kjvjk m`rspmaj,
ades`st`eo df mkk m`rspmaj ijkdw=7 333 fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk),men g`og-kjvjk m`rspmaj,ades`st`eo df mkk m`rspmaj frdh=7 333 fjjt msk men midvj.Adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj w`tg`e tgjg`og-kjvjk m`rspmaj s n`v`njn etd1 sjpmrmtj mrjms< tgj QdutgjreAdetrdk Mrjm, tgj EdrtgjreAdetrdk Mrjm men tgj Mrat`aAdetrdk Mrjm. gj kmtjrmk menvjrt`amk n`hjes`des mrj`kkustrmtjn e F`ourj 0 men F`ourj=3. ^gj Amemn`me Ndhjst`aM`rspmaj s mksd ojdormpg`amkkyn`v`njn `etd tgj Qdutgjre men tgjEdrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj(ENM). gj kmtjrmk iduenmr`js dftgj ENM jeadhpmss idtg tgjEdrtgjre men Mrat`a AdetrdkMrjms njp`atjn `e F`ourj 0. AMY639.1>(=)(i) rjqu`rjs tgmt aru`s`eomkt`tunjs ij njtjrh`ejn imsjn de
truj trmab `e tgj ENM. Mnn`t`demkky, trmabs njp`atjn de @FY fk`ogt `efdrhmt`de puik`amt`des mrjrjkmt`vj td truj edrtg.
AMY 639.19(=)(m) spja`f`js tgmt ed pjrsde sgmkk dpjrmtj me m`rarmft mt m spjjn orjmtjr tgme 9:3B@MQ ijkdw =3 333 fjjt msk. Mt =619<1:, FMI6:63 njsajenjn tgrduog =3 333 fjjt mt 1=3 B@MQ, menormnumkky njajkjrmtjn nur`eo tgj njsajet, rjmag`eo 9:3 B@MQ ms t njsajenjn tgrduog :>13 fjjtmsk. S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt tgj 9:3-B@MQ m`rspjjn k`h`t ijkdw =3 333 fjjt wmsdaams`demkky jxajjnjn td mnlust tgj njsajet prdf`kj.
F`ourj 0. G`og-kjvjk m`rspmaj kmtjrmk iduenmr`js (`hmoj<^rmespdrt Amemnm (^A), ^S =>1?= ∙ ^rmespdrt Amemnm Mjrdemut`amk@efdrhmt`de Hmeumk R^A M@HX, YMA‑ Yukjs df tgj M`r men M`r^rmff`a Qjrv`ajs R=? Datdijr 93=1X, sjat`de 9.6, F`ourj 9.1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 76/215
- 67 -
F`ourj =3. G`og-kjvjk m`rspmaj vjrt`amk iduenmr`js (sduraj< rmespdrt
Amemnm, ^S =>1?= ∙ ^rmespdrt Amemnm Mjrdemut`amk @efdrhmt`de Hmeumk R^A M@HX, YMA ∙ Yukjs df tgj M`r men M`r ^rmff`a Qjrv`ajs R=? Datdijr93=1X, sjat`de 9.6, F`ourj 9.>)
=.=?.6.9 Srdajnurjs e ueadetrdkkjn m`rspmaj
FMI6:63 njpmrtjn AP\F, s`tumtjn `e tgj Qdutgjre Adetrdk Mrjm, prdajjnjn de adursj tgrduogtgj Edrtgjre Adetrdk Mrjm, men jvjetumkky fkjw etd tgj Mrat`a Adetrdk Mrjm ms t mpprdmagjnAPYI. Nur`eo tgj ak`hi men aru`sj pgmsj (FK1=3) df fk`ogt, tgj m`rarmft wms `e adetrdkkjnm`rspmaj mt mkk t`hjs. Zpde njsajet etd APYI, tgj m`rarmft jetjrjn ueadetrdkkjn m`rspmaj ms tnjsajenjn ijkdw FK9?3. Zenjr edrhmk a`rauhstmeajs, tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde Mrjm
Adetrdk Ajetrj (MAA) wdukn akjmr tgj m`rarmft dut df adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj mt tg`s t`hj. ^gj arjwwdukn tgje adet`euj njsajet men adetmat tgj APYI Adhhue`ty Mjrdnrdhj Ymn`d Qtmt`de(AMYQ) 0: de tgj hmenmtdry frjqujeay (HF) wgje mpprdmag`eo tgj m`rpdrt. Fdr APYI, tg`shust ij ndej ijfdrj ij`eo w`tg`e 9: eh df tgj m`rpdrt men mt dr ijkdw :133 fjjt msk. 06 ^gjAMYQ disjrvjr/adhhue`amtdr ndjs edt prdv`nj trmff`a sjpmrmt`de sjrv`ajs. _`tg`e tgj HF mrjmdf me ueadetrdkkjn mjrdnrdhj, p`kdts hust adhhue`amtj w`tg dtgjr p`kdts de tgj HF td jesurjtgmt tgjrj `s ed trmff`a adefk`at.
^gj p`kdt df me m`rarmft dpjrmt`eo uenjr @FY prdajnurjs wgd etjens td adenuat me mpprdmagmen kmen`eo mt me ueadetrdkkjn mjrdnrdhj hust irdmnamst tgj etjet`des df tgj p`kdt-`e-adhhmen de tgj HF rjomrn`eo tgj dpjrmt`de df tgj m`rarmft. gj jst`hmtjn kmen`eo t`hj hust
ij adhhue`amtjn : h`eutjs ijfdrj adhhjea`eo tgj mpprdmag prdajnurj. Mnn`t`demkky,pds`t`de rjpdrts mrj rjqu`rjn mt tgj fdkkdw`eo pd`ets<
0: APYI s edrhmkky me ueadetrdkkjn m`rpdrt w`tg m hmenmtdry frjqujeay stmffjn iy m Adhhue`tyMjrdnrdhj Ymn`d Qtmt`de (AMYQ) disjrvjr/adhhue`amtdr, wgd prdv`njs dpjrmt`demk efdrhmt`de tdfk`ogt arjws.
06 EMV AMEMNM, Amemnm Fk`ogt Quppkjhjet, APYI, Adhhue`amt`des sjat`de
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 77/215
- 60 -
• wgje pmss`eo tgj f`x dutiduen, wgje tgj p`kdt-`e-adhhmen etjens td adenuat mprdajnurj ture, dr, f ed prdajnurj ture s etjenjn, wgje tgj m`rarmft f`rst etjrajpts tgjf`emk mpprdmag adursj2
• wgje pmss`eo tgj f`emk mpprdmag f`x, dr 1 h`eutjs ijfdrj tgj jst`hmtjn kmen`eo t`hjwgjrj ed f`emk mpprdmag f`x jx`sts2 men
• de f`emk mpprdmag.
=.=?.6.1 ED^MH fdrhmt
ED^MHs (edt`ajs td m`rhje) mrj njv`ajs hjmet td trmesh`t mjrdemut`amk efdrhmt`de td usjrs.EMV AMEMNM `s tgj mojeay tgmt puik`sgjs ED^MHs, men `s rjspdes`ikj deky fdr jesur`eotgmt tgj mpprdpr`mtj prdajnurjs wjrj fdkkdwjn e rjspjat df tgj `efdrhmt`de ij`eo trmesh`ttjn.^gj dr`o`emtdr df tgj efdrhmt`de s rjspdes`ikj fdr tgj maaurmay df tgj `efdrhmt`de ij`eosuppk`jn fdr puik`amt`de. @e tg`s amsj, tgj h`k`tmry wms tgj ED^MH adetjet dr`o`emtdr.
M ejw ED^MH `s `en`amtjn iy tgj kjttjr E fdkkdw`eo tgj wdrn ED^MH `e tgj k`ej tgmt`en`amtjs tgj ED^MH euhijr, men tgj mffjatjn mrjm. ^gj f`rst ED^MH `ssujn adeajre`eo tgjh`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm (H^AM) de 39 Muoust adetm`ejn tgj k`ej ‛===>3> ED^MHEA\JO Jnhdetde F@Y‘. ^gj kmst k`ej df tgj ED^MH `en`amtjn tgj pjr`dn nur`eo wg`ag tgjED^MH wdukn ij jffjat`vj< ‛==3736=133 @K ==37973=33‘. 0?
^gj f`rst rjv`s`de td tgj ED^MH wms njs`oemtjn ms fdkkdws< ‛===>9> ED^MHY ===>3> A\JOJnhdetde F@Y‘. De tg`s ED^MH, tgj kmst k`ej rjmn ‛==37=3=133 ^@K ==37973=33‘. Gjrj, tgjkjttjr Y fdkkdw`eo tgj wdrn ED^MH `en`amtjs m rjpkmajhjet df m prjv`dus ED^MH, iut ndjsedt g`ogk`ogt wg`ag df tgj hmey p`jajs df efdrhmt`de gms ijje rjv`sjn. Quisjqujetrjpkmajhjets mrj `en`amtjn iy tgj smhj kjttjr Y fdkkdwjn iy tgj euhijr df tgj prjv`dusED^MH tgmt s ij`eo rjpkmajn. gjrj s ed dtgjr en`amt`de df wgmt gms ijje agmeojn.
^gj kjttjr A fdkkdw`eo tgj wdrn ED^MH en`amtjs m ameajkkmt`de df m ED^MH.
Nur`eo tgj daaurrjeaj, edej df tgj p`kdts `eiduen td APYI wjrj mwmrj tgmt tgj H^AM wms edt`e jffjat. Ms wjkk, tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA adetrdkkjr wgd gmenkjn FMI6:63tgduogt tgmt tgj H^AM wms e jffjat ijamusj tgj adetrdkkjr mnv`sjn FMI6:63 tgmt tgjy wduknrj-jetjr adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj mt FK933 men `estruatjn tgjh td adetmat tgj H^AM tjrh`emkfrjqujeay.
ED^MHs k`stjn de tgj EMV AMEMNM mv`mt`de wjmtgjr _ji s`tj (M__Q) nd edt adetm`e tgjE dr Y njs`oemt`de td mss`st arjws e njtjrh`e`eo wgjtgjr ED^MHs k`stjn tgjrj mrj ejw dejsdr rjpkmajhjets. gj `evjst`omt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt sjvjrmk fk`ogts etjrprjtjn tgj ED^MH
`efdrhmt`de td hjme tgmt tgj H^AM wdukn ij `e jffjat.
^gj ED^MH ojejrmt`de systjh gms imaborduen adn`eo mssda`mtjn w`tg tgj Y, A, dr E tgmttr`oojrs mutdhmtjn mat`v`ty rjomrn`eo gdw m ED^MH w`kk ij gmenkjn iy tgj adhputjrsdftwmrj. Arjws tgmt rjaj`vj tgj`r ED^MHs tgrduog tg`s n`str`iut`de sduraj w`kk sjj tgj adnjs
0? 36 Muoust 93== mt =133 uet`k 97 Muoust 93== mt 3=33
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 78/215
- ?3 -
men rjmk`zj tgmt sdhjtg`eo gms agmeojn, iut hust same tgrduog td sjj wgmt gms agmeojn. ^g`sagmeoj ame ij n`ff`aukt td njtjrh`ej `f m s`eokj n`o`t `e tgj jffjat`vj nmtj k`ej `s mkk tgmt agmeojs.^gj M__Q ndjs edt gmvj m ejjn fdr tgjsj adnjs, men tgjrjfdrj tgj kjttjrs mrj edt usjn. JmagED^MH de M__Q hust tgjrjfdrj ij trjmtjn iy m`rarjw ms `f `t `s m ejw ED^MH.
=.=?.6.> Yjsdkutj Imy h`k`tmry m`r trmff`a adetrdk
^gj h`k`tmry mojeay rjspdes`ikj fdr prdv`n`eo tgj M^A jqu`phjet men fdr tgj M^A dpjrmt`de eAPYI fdr Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB `s 7 M`r Adetrdk men Adhhue`amt`des Qqumnrde (7MAAQ),imsjn e rjetde, Detmr`d. gj ue`t s jxpjr`jeajn e njpkdyjn dpjrmt`des men rdut`ejky sjts upprja`s`de mpprdmag rmnmr (SMY) ue`ts e suppdrt df Dpjrmt`de IDW^DS, tgj rjsuppky df tgj fmredrtgjre Mkjrt rjsjmrag stmt`de. Ms wjkk, jmag yjmr tgj ue`t sjts up m adhpkjtj m`rf`jkn dpjrmt`dede tgj h`k`tmry imsj `e _m`ewr`ogt, Mkijrtm. ^gj dpjrmt`de `e APYI wms td ij tgj f`rst suagadhpkjtj m`rf`jkn dpjrmt`de e m a`v`k jev`rdehjet.
7MAAQ gms ed njn`amtjn adetrdkkjr rjsdurajs dtgjr tgme SMY adetrdkkjrs. d fukf`kk tgj ejjn fdrtdwjr men tjrh`emk adetrdkkjrs, 7MAAQ prdv`njs ts ejjns td = Amemn`me M`r N`v`s`de e
_`ee`pjo, wg`ag tgje amevmssjs Amemn`me Fdrajs imsjs fdr edh`ejjs. Adetrdkkjrs mrj sjkjatjnmen sjet td 7MAAQ `e ^rjetde ijfdrj tgj njpkdyhjet fdr fmh`k`mr`zmt`de, men td ij ir`jfjn mentjstjn de tgj dpjrmt`de men kdamk prdajnurjs tgmt tgjy w`kk fmaj mt tgj s`tj. Adetrdkkjrs mrjjxpjatjn td hm`etm`e fukk bedwkjnoj df tgj adetjets df EMV AMEMNM M^A HMEDSQ men tgjAF M^A Qup.
Ms prjv`dusky edtjn, tgj h`k`tmry rmnmr estmkkjn fdr Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB gmn edt ijje fk`ogt-agjabjn men adukn edt ij usjn2 tgjrjfdrj, tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM wms rjpjmtjnkynjkmyjn. Ijamusj tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM wms njkmyjn, tgj m`rspmaj ijkdw FK9?3rjhm`ejn ueadetrdkkjn men tgjrj wms ed ampmi`k`ty dr ejajss`ty td prdv`nj mey sdrt df @FYsjpmrmt`de w`tg`e tgj m`rspmaj etjenjn fdr tgj H^AM.
EMV AMEMNM M^A HMEDSQ pjrh`ts tgj mppk`amt`de df @FY sjpmrmt`de sjrv`ajs td m`rarmft `em`rspmaj tgmt `s edt sjrvjn iy rmnmr. 07 Me jxmhpkj df gdw tg`s mppk`amt`de ame ij mag`jvjn `s iybjjp`eo suisjqujet mrr`v`eo m`rarmft duts`nj tgj zdej dr mt m g`ogjr mkt`tunj uet`k tgj m`rarmft dempprdmag gms kmenjn. _g`kj tgj Akmss N adetrdk zdej wms `e jffjat, tgjrj wjrj ed prdajnurjs `epkmaj td n`rjat adetrdkkjrs td mppky ede-rmnmr @FY sjpmrmt`de stmenmrns w`tg`e tgj Akmss Nadetrdk zdej, jvje tgduog suag sjrv`ajs mrj rjqu`rjn. @FY sjpmrmt`de stmenmrns wjrj edtjstmik`sgjn ijtwjje FMI6:63 men BIM030 de jetry td tgj adetrdk zdej.
Aurrjet APYI wjmtgjr efdrhmt`de wms mvm`kmikj td tgj tdwjr men tjrh`emk adetrdkkjrs tgrduogtgj usj df njn`amtjn adhputjr tjrh`emks usjn td hde`tdr tgj EMV AMEMNM mv`mt`de wjmtgjr_ji s`tj. gjrj wms ed mutdhmtjn tjrh`emk efdrhmt`de systjh (M^@Q) sjrv`aj sjt up e tgj
APYI M^A ue`t.
07 EMV AMEMNM, M`r ^rmff`a Adetrdk Hmeumk df Dpjrmt`des (M^A HMEDSQ) , Smrt >< Mrjm men ^jrh`emkAdetrdk, suipmrt >?3 ‑ Qjpmrmt`de
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 79/215
- ?= -
Kmen`eo efdrhmt`de tgmt hust ij prdv`njn iy tjrh`emk adetrdkkjrs td mrr`v`eo m`rarmft s k`stjn`e EMV AMEMNM M^A HMEDSQ ms fdkkdws< 00
>6=.9@eakunj tgj fdkkdw`eo tjhs, ms mpprdpr`mtj, e kmen`eo efdrhmt`de<
M. _`en.
I. V`s`i`k`ty.
A. Aj`k`eo.
N. Mkt`hjtjr sjtt`eo.
J. Sjrt`ejet rjhmrbs frdh tgj aurrjet wjmtgjr rjpdrt.
F. Adevjet`demk dr YEMV Q^MY, `eakun`eo mey trmes`t`de.
O. Yuewmy `e usj.
G. Mpprdmag m`n `e usj.
@. Sjrt`ejet m`rpdrt aden`t`des.
>6=.>Jxajpt nur`eo rmp`nky agmeo`eo aden`t`des, ydu ejjn edt ssuj efdrhmt`de`eakunjn e tgj aurrjet M^@Q (Mutdhmtjn jrh`emk @efdrhmt`de Qystjh)irdmnamst, prdv`njn tgj m`rarmft mabedwkjnojs rjaj`pt df tgj irdmnamst.
Mt =690, nur`eo e`t`mk adetmat ijtwjje tgj APYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr men FMI6:63, deky tjh Nmen trmff`a efdrhmt`de wms prdv`njn.
Mrt`akj 1>9.= df M^A HMEDSQ mppk`js td m`rpdrt dpjrmt`des men v`sumk fk`ogt rukjs (VFY)adetrdk. @t spja`f`js tgmt tdwjr adetrdkkjrs sgmkk ssuj me `e`t`mk akjmrmeaj e tgj fdkkdw`eofdrh< =33
M. (M`rarmft `njet`f`amt`de)2
I. (Ze`t `njet`f`amt`de `f rjqu`rjn)2
A. YZE_MP (euhijr)2
N. _@EN (n`rjat`de men spjjn)2
J. MK^@HJ^JY (sjtt`eo)2
F. AKJMYJN D ^GJ A@YAZ@^ (dtgjr spja`f`a pd`et)2
O. rmnmr `njet`f`amt`de (`f rjqu`rjn)2
G. (rjqujst fdr pds`t`de rjpdrts ms rjqu`rjn)2 men@. (dtgjr `efdrhmt`de, suag ms trmff`a, s`huktmejdus ardss`eo ruewmy dpjrmt`des
dr m`rpdrt aden`t`des).
00 @i`n., suipmrt >6= ‑ Kmen`eo @efdrhmt`de, mrt`akjs >6=.9 men >6=.>
=33 @i`n., Smrt 1< M`rpdrt men VFY Adetrdk, suipmrt 1>9 ∙ @e`t`mk Akjmrmeaj, mrt`akj 1>9.=
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 80/215
- ?9 -
^gj APYI tdwjr adetrdkkjr prdv`njn tgj rjqu`rjn efdrhmt`de jxajpt fdr tjh F, wg`ag wms edtmppk`amikj ijamusj estruhjet hjtjdrdkdo`amk aden`t`des prjvm`kjn, men tjh O, wg`ag wms edtmppk`amikj ijamusj rmnmr wms edt `e dpjrmt`demk usj.
=.=?.6.: ^jhpdrmry m`rspmaj fdr Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB
@e`t`mk pkmee`eo fdr Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB mhdeo tgj h`k`tmry, ^A, men EMV AMEMNM rjvdkvjnmrduen tgj n`hjes`des men typj df m`rspmaj rjqu`rjn iy tgj h`k`tmry men tgj hjmes df mkjrt`eotgj mv`mt`de adhhue`ty midut tgj dpjrmt`de. gj m`rspmaj wms jstmik`sgjn iy A iy hjmes dfmhjenhjets td tgj Njs`oemtjn M`rspmaj Gmeniddb, e maadrnmeaj w`tg h`k`tmry ejjns. Akmss Nm`rspmaj wms agdsje e drnjr tgmt tgj adetrdk mojeay h`ogt ij mikj td prdv`nj pds`t`vj adetrdksjrv`aj td dpjrmtdrs nur`eo tgj pjr`dn df Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB.
M adetrdk zdej s njs`oemtjn td jesurj tgmt @FY m`rarmft ame rjhm`e w`tg`e adetrdkkjn m`rspmajnur`eo mpprdmagjs men td fma`k`tmtj tgj adetrdk df VFY men @FY trmff`a. Adetrdk mrjm jxtjes`desmrj njs`oemtjn mrduen mjrdnrdhjs wgjrj tgj adetrdk zdej prdv`njn s esuff`a`jet td pjrh`t tgjrjqu`rjn sjpmrmt`de ijtwjje @FY mrr`vmks men njpmrturjs, men td adetm`e @FY m`rarmft w`tg`e
adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj. M tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm (^AM) s s`h`kmr td m adetrdk mrjm jxtjes`de, jxajpttgmt m AM hmy jxtjen up etd tgj g`og-kjvjk m`rspmaj. =3=
Me M^A akjmrmeaj hust ij ditm`ejn ijfdrj jetjr`eo adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj fdr fk`ogt uenjr @FY.Akmss N m`rspmaj s adetrdkkjn m`rspmaj w`tg`e wg`ag idtg @FY men VFY fk`ogts mrj pjrh`ttjn.M^A sjpmrmt`de s prdv`njn deky td @FY m`rarmft. M`rarmft w`kk ij prdv`njn w`tg trmff`a`efdrhmt`de.
^gj hjmes df mkjrt`eo tgj mv`mt`de adhhue`ty wms maadhpk`sgjn iy ED^MHs ssujn iy EMVAMEMNM de 39 Muoust 93==. ED^MHE ===>3> jstmik`sgjn m Akmss N H`k`tmry ^jrh`emkAdetrdk Mrjm, dr H^AM, w`tg`e me 73 eh rmn`us df APYI, frdh ?33 fjjt mok td FK933, jffjat`vj36∙97 Muoust 93== (Mppjen`x _). ED^MHE ===>3: jstmik`sgjn m Akmss N adetrdk zdej (A\)w`tg`e m =3 eh rmn`us df APYI frdh tgj surfmaj td 6333 fjjt msk, jffjat`vj 36∙97 Muoust 93==.
=.=?.6.6 ^jhpdrmry rmnmr fma`k`t`js
Ymnmr prdv`njs m pds`t`vj hjtgdn df `njet`fy`eo m`rarmft trmff`a men jesur`eo sjpmrmt`de.^jhpdrmry rmnmr fma`k`t`js wjrj pkmeejn td ij sjt up `e APYI ms pmrt df tgj h`k`tmry‐s Akmss Nm`rspmaj dpjrmt`de. g`s pkme eakunjn idtg mrjm survj`kkmeaj rmnmr (MQY) men SMY.
^gj njk`vjry df tgj m`r trmff`a adetrdk jqu`phjet wms njkmyjn, men hpkjhjetmt`de df idtg tgjA\ men H^AM wms adrrjspden`eoky njkmyjn. ^gj njkmys wjrj prdhukomtjn iy ED^MHY===>9> men ED^MHY ===>9:, `ssujn 3> Muoust 93==, wg`ag rjpkmajn tgj prjv`dus ED^MHs
men njkmyjn tgj jffjat`vj nmtjs df idtg tgj H^AM men tgj A\ uet`k =3 Muoust 93==. ^gjED^MHs mrj sgdwe `e Mppjen`x _.
=3= ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =>1?= ∙ ^rmespdrt Amemnm Mjrdemut`amk @efdrhmt`de Hmeumk (^A M@H), YMA ‑Yukjs df tgj M`r men M`r ^rmff`a Qjrv`ajs (=? Datdijr 93=1), sjat`des 9.?.9, 9.?.1, men 9.?.6, mvm`kmikj mtgttp<//www.ta.oa.am/hjn`m/ndauhjets/am-puik`amt`des/YMA-M@H-93=1-9TJEO-:.pnf (kmstmaajssjn de 30 Njajhijr 93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 81/215
- ?1 -
Mftjr mrr`vmk men sjtup df jqu`phjet, ED^MHE ==3=39 wms `ssujn de =9 Muoust, jstmik`sg`eotgj Akmss N adetrdk zdej jffjat`vj =3 Muoust 93== uet`k 97 Muoust 93== (Mppjen`x _). =39
Sddr wjmtgjr prjvjetjn tgj pjrfdrhmeaj df fk`ogt agjabs df tgj APYI rmnmr, men`hpkjhjetmt`de df tgj H^AM wms njkmyjn. M sjr`js df ED^MHs, ms fdkkdws, wjrj ssujn dvjr
tgj fdkkdw`eo nmys td njkmy tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM<
• M ED^MH `ssujn de =9 Muoust njkmyjn tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM uet`k =>Muoust.
• M ED^MH `ssujn de => Muoust njkmyjn tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM uet`k =:Muoust.
• M ED^MH `ssujn de =: Muoust njkmyjn tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM uet`k =6Muoust.
• M ED^MH `ssujn de =? Muoust njkmyjn tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM uet`k =0Muoust.
• M ED^MH `ssujn de =0 Muoust njkmyjn tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM uet`k 9=Muoust.
Mkk df tgj njkmys gmn ijje hmnj `e met`a`pmt`de tgmt tgj h`k`tmry rmnmr wdukn tgje ij fk`ogt-agjabjn iy tgj rjv`sjn nmtj2 gdwjvjr, tgjrj wms ed mssurmeaj tgmt m fk`ogt agjab wdukn ijsagjnukjn `e drnjr td hjjt tgj ejw nmtj men t`hj. Ijamusj ej`tgjr tgj MQY edr tgj SMY gmnijje fk`ogt-agjabjn, tgjy wjrj edt mvm`kmikj fdr usj e prdv`n`eo adetrdk sjrv`ajs. =31
Sdrtmikj trm`kjrs mt APYI gdusjn idtg tgj tdwjr men tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr wdrb stmt`des (Sgdtd 6).Idtg wdrb stmt`des wjrj jqu`ppjn w`tg adhhue`amt`de jqu`phjet men hukt`pkj efdrhmt`den`spkmy hde`tdrs. Dej hde`tdr `e tgj tdwjr prdv`njn rmnmr `efdrhmt`de. ^gj tjrh`emk adetrdk
wdrb stmt`de wms jqu`ppjn w`tg sjvjrmk n`spkmys fdr MQY men SMY.
=39 ^gj jffjat`vj nmtj wms h`stmbjeky k`stjn ms =3 Muoust vjrsus =9 Muoust 93==.
=31 Amemn`me Fdrajs, Fk`ogt @espjat`de Srdajnurjs Hmeumk, I-OM-=6>-33/MM-33=, Agmptjr 1, sjat`de =.1 mensjat`de 6
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 82/215
- ?> -
Sgdtd :. ^jhpdrmry h`k`tmry m`r trmff`a sjrv`ajs (M^Q) fma`k`ty mt Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI). ^gj tjrh`emk trm`kjr`s kdamtjn ijg`en tgj tjets.
Mktgduog tgj rmnmr gmn edt ijje fk`ogt-agjabjn, t wms dpjrmt`eo. Ymnmr nmtm wjrj ij`eorjadrnjn men fjn td idtg trm`kjrs. gj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr wms mt tgj adetrdk wdrb stmt`dehde`tdr`eo tgj mrr`vmk df m`r trmff`a men ssu`eo njpmrturj akjmrmeajs td njpmrt`eo fk`ogts. Ymnmr`efdrhmt`de wms n`spkmyjn, iut wms edt ij`eo usjn fdr adetrdk purpdsjs.
_gje FMI6:63 wms mpprdx`hmtjky =3 eh frdh APYI ture`eo detd f`emk mpprdmag, tgj tjrh`emkadetrdkkjr spdbj ir`jfky w`tg tgj tdwjr adetrdkkjr, men wms mnv`sjn tgmt tgj tdwjr rmnmr n`spkmywms edpjrmt`vj. gj tjage`a`me e tgj tjrh`emk trm`kjr wms edt mvm`kmikj. gj H^AM wms edt ejffjat, men tgj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr wms edt prdv`n`eo adetrdk sjrv`ajs. gj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr
gmn gmn me `ssuj prjv`dusky e tgj nmy w`tg tgj tjrh`emk rmnmr n`spkmy, wg`ag wms rjat`f`jnw`tg m s`hpkj rjsjt df tgj n`spkmy. ^gj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr dffjrjn td mss`st iy rjsjtt`eo tgj tdwjrrmnmr n`spkmy, men kjft tgj tjrh`emk trm`kjr men wjet td tgj tdwjr trm`kjr. gj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjrwms uemikj td rjsjt tgj tdwjr rmnmr n`spkmy men rjturejn td tgj tjrh`emk trm`kjr.
De rjture`eo td tgj tjrh`emk trm`kjr, tgj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr hdhjetmr ky okmeajn mt tgj rmnmrn`spkmys, iut n`n edt pmy tgjh huag mttjet`de, ijamusj tgj rmnmr adukn edt ij usjn fdr adetrdkpurpdsjs.
^gj tdwjr adetrdkkjr n`n edt gmvj m fueat`de`eo rmnmr n`spkmy fdr s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss, men tgjwjmtgjr prjvjetjn v`sumk maqu`s`t`de df m`r trmff`a.
=.=?.6.? @estruhjet mpprdmag prdajnurjs< h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm `e jffjat
Gmn tgj h`k`tmry survj`kkmeaj rmnmr ijje dpjrmt`demk men tgj H^AM ijje e jffjat, m`rarmftjetjr`eo tgj m`rspmaj wdukn adetmat tgj APYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr de tgj njs`oemtjn frjqujeaymen rjaj`vj estruat`des rjomrn`eo tgj njsajet men mpprdmag etd APYI. Ymnmr wdukn gmvjijje usjn td njet`fy m`rarmft men hm`etm`e sjpmrmt`de. gj arjw df me m`rarmft wdukn en`amtjmpprdmag men kmen`eo etjet`des td tgj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr, men wdukn rjaj`vj estruat`des
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 83/215
- ?: -
rjomrn`eo gjmn`eo men mkt`tunjs td hm`etm`e/fdkkdw men adursj njv`mt`des disjrvmikj td tgjtjrh`emk adetrdkkjr.
Ms tgj m`rarmft mpprdmagjn tgj m`rpdrt, tgj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr wdukn ssuj m akjmrmeaj tdadenuat me estruhjet mpprdmag. gj m`rarmft wdukn rjhm`e de tgj tjrh`emk frjqujeay uenjrtjrh`emk adetrdk uet`k sgdrt f`emk fdr tgj ruewmy. De sgdrt f`emk mpprdmag, tgj m`rarmft wdukn ij
trmesfjrrjn td tgj tdwjr frjqujeay td ojt m kmen`eo akjmrmeaj. gj arjw wdukn adet`euj w`tg tgj`estruhjet mpprdmag us`eo tgj m`rarmft‐s emv`omt`demk jqu`phjet uet`k maqu`r`eo v`sumkrjfjrjeajs fdr kmen`eo.
=.=?.6.7 @estruhjet mpprdmag prdajnurjs< h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm edt `e jffjat
_`tgdut tgj H^AM ij`eo dpjrmt`demk, @FY m`rarmft mpprdmag`eo APYI frdh g`og-kjvjkueadetrdkkjn m`rspmaj (ijkdw FK9?3) wdukn gmvj td jstmik`sg adhhue`amt`de w`tg tgj h`k`tmryadetrdk tdwjr ijfdrj jetjr`eo tgj zdej. M`rarmft wdukn o`vj tgj`r jst`hmtjn t`hj df mrr`vmk(J^M), en`amtj mpprdmag etjet`des, men rjhm`e de tdwjr frjqujeay td rjaj`vj trmff`a`efdrhmt`de men akjmrmeaj td jetjr tgj zdej. _gjejvjr me J^M s pmssjn, tgj p`kdt sgdukn
spja`fy tgj pd`et, f`x, dr fma`k`ty td wg`ag tgj J^M mppk`js. ^gj arjw wdukn tgje adenuat me`estruhjet mpprdmag, men upde rjaj`pt df m kmen`eo akjmrmeaj frdh tgj tdwjr, wdukn kmen dr`e`t`mtj m h`ssjn mpprdmag `f edt `e m pds`t`de td kmen.
Deaj es`nj tgj Akmss N adetrdk zdej, @FY sjpmrmt`de stmenmrns wjrj mppk`amikj. d prjvjettrmff`a adefk`ats, @FY m`rarmft ejjnjn td ij prdv`njn w`tg @FY adetrdk sjrv`ajs (`.j., sjpmrmt`de menmpprdmag akjmrmeajs) iy me @FY-ajrt`f`jn adetrdkkjr, rjomrnkjss df wgjtgjr rmnmr `s mvm`kmikj.
=.=?.? Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet
=.=?.?.= Diljat`vj df arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet
@e m hukt`-arjw m`rarmft suag ms tgj I?1?, p`kdts hust suaajssfukky etjrmat w`tg jmag dtgjr, tgj`rm`rarmft, men tgj`r jev`rdehjet, us`eo mssda`mtjn agjabk`sts men adhpmey QDSs td jffjat`vjkyhmemoj tgrjmts, jrrdrs, dr uenjs`rjn m`rarmft stmtjs tgmt hmy ij jeaduetjrjn. Ms m rjsukt, mey`evjst`omt`de evdkv`eo m hukt`-arjw adabp`t hust jxmh`ej arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet (AYH)fmatdrs td njtjrh`ej wgmt, f mey, irjmbndwes hmy gmvj daaurrjn. gj fdkkdw`eo sjat`des w`kkjxmh`ej tgj aurrjet rjoukmtdry jev`rdehjet ms t pjrtm`es td AYH, AYH estruatdrmaarjn`tmt`de, men AYH trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r.
^gj diljat`vj df AYH `s td rjnuaj guhme jrrdr `e mv`mt`de. M w`njky maajptjn njf`e`t`de dfAYH s tgj jffjat`vj usj df mkk guhme, gmrnwmrj, men `efdrhmt`de rjsdurajs mvm`kmikj td tgjfk`ogt arjw td jesurj smfj men jff`a`jet fk`ogt dpjrmt`des.
^g`s odmk s maadhpk`sgjn iy trm`e`eo fk`ogt arjws td jhpkdy m vmr`jty df strmtjo`js td gjkp`hprdvj jffjat`vjejss. Zek`bj m`rarmft gmenk`eo sb`kks, AYH trm`e`eo fdausjs de ar`t`amk adoe`t`vjmen etjrpjrsdemk sb`kks. @e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo rjaj`vjn iy fk`ogt arjws kmys tgj fduenmt`de fdrtgdsj adrj AYH sb`kks. Deaj m fduenmt`de df adrj AYH sb`kks gms ijje jstmik`sgjn, rjaurrjettrm`e`eo sjss`des gjkp rj`efdraj tgdsj ar`t`amk sb`kks men prdv`nj fk`ogt arjws w`tg dppdrtue`t`jstd gdej tgj sb`kks tgjy wjrj tmuogt nur`eo e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo. Yjsjmrag gms sgdwe tgmt fk`ogt
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 84/215
- ?6 -
arjws w`tg rjajet AYH trm`e`eo mrj ijttjr mikj td njmk w`tg edvjk s`tumt`des tgme fk`ogt arjwsw`tgdut rjajet AYH trm`e`eo. =3>
=.=?.?.9 Jvdkut`de df arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo rjoukmt`des
@e =00:, tgj ^QI `ssujn Yjadhhjenmt`de M0:-== =3: td ^A, amkk`eo fdr AYH men nja`s`de-
hmb`eo trm`e`eo td ij hmenmtdry fdr mkk dpjrmtdrs men m`rarjw evdkvjn e adhhjra`mk mv`mt`de.Gdwjvjr, A‐s rjspdesj td Yjadhhjenmt`de M0:-== en`amtjn tgmt t wdukn ij `etrdnua`eodeky rjoukmt`des rjqu`r`eo AYH trm`e`eo fdr AMY Quipmrt ?3: dpjrmtdrs. Ms m rjsukt, tgj ^QImssjsshjet df ^A‐s rjspdesj wms Qmt`sfmatdry `e Smrt. =36
De =3 Datdijr =006, ^A etrdnuajn AYH trm`e`eo rjqu`rjhjets fdr AMY ?3: m`rk`ej dpjrmtdrs.^gj rjqu`rjhjet amhj `etd jffjat ms Adhhjra`mk M`r Qjrv`aj Qtmenmrns (AMQQ) ?9:.=9>(10)< ArjwYjsduraj Hmemojhjet rm`e`eo. @e 933>, tgj t`tkj wms mhjenjn td ‛AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)< ArjwYjsduraj Hmemojhjet rm`e`eo fdr Arjw Hjhijrs‘ td irdmnje tgj sadpj ijyden p`kdts. gjrjhm`enjr df tg`s stmenmrn gms edt ijje mhjenjn s`eaj ts eajpt`de e =006.
^gj fdkkdw`eo s qudtjn n`rjatky frdh AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)<=3?
Me m`r dpjrmtdr sgmkk prdv`nj Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet rm`e`eo (AYH) emaadrnmeaj w`tg tgj fdkkdw`eo<
m) @e`t`mk trm`e`eo `s rjqu`rjn fdr mkk arjw hjhijrs men sgmkk advjr tgj suiljats`e idtg (m) men (i)<
(`) mtt`tunjs men ijgmv`durs2
(``) adhhue`amt`de sb`kks2
(```) prdikjh sdkv`eo2
(`v) guhme fmatdrs2
(v) adefk`at rjsdkut`de2
(v`) nja`s`de hmb`eo2
(v``) tjmh iu`kn`eo men hm`etjemeaj2 men
(v```) wdrbkdmn hmemojhjet.
i) Meeumk trm`e`eo `e smfjty men jhjrojeay prdajnurjs. @t sgmkk `eakunj, msmppk`amikj, ld`et pmrt`a`pmt`de df p`kdts men fk`ogt mttjenmets men advjr tgjfdkkdw`eo tjhs<
(`) rjkmt`desg`p df arjw hjhijrs2
(``) rjv`jw df maa`njets/`ea njets df m`r dpjrmtdrs2
=3> Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`de (FMM), Mnv`sdry A raukmr (MA) =93-:=J< Arjw YjsdurajHmemojhjet rm`e`eo (933>)
=3: ^QI, Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Yjadhhjenmt`de M0:-==
=36 M Qmt`sfmatdry `e Smrt rmt`eo `s mss`oejn f tgj pkmeejn mat`de dr tgj mat`de tmbje w`kk rjnuaj iut edtsuistmet`mkky rjnuaj dr jk`h`emtj tgj njf`a`jeay.
=3? Adhhjra`mk M`r Qjrv`aj Qtmenmrns (AMQQ) ?9:.=9>(10)< Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet rm`e`eo fdr ArjwHjhijrs
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 85/215
- ?? -
(```) prjsjetmt`de men n`sauss`de df sjkjatjn addrn`emtjn jhjrojeay
(`v) prdajnurjs (prmat`aj df AYH sb`kks)2 men
(v) arjw hjhijr jvmaumt`de nr`kks, eakun`eo njir`jf`eo.
^A M`r Amrr`jr Mnv`sdry A`raukmr ed. 3==? (nmtjn =: Mpr`k =00?), =37 prdv`njs akmr`f`amt`de df tgj
`etjrprjtmt`de df AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10).
Mktgduog tgj rjqu`rjn suiljats mrj dutk`ejn e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10), tgjrj mrj ed stmenmrns tgmtnjf`ej tgj rjqu`rjn adetjet dr h`e`huh adursj kjeotg, edr s tgjrj m rjqu`rjhjet tgmt tgjmatumk trm`e`eo hmtjr`mk ij mpprdvjn iy ^A. d sgdw adhpk`meaj w`tg AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10),AMY ?3: dpjrmtdrs mrj s`hpky rjqu`rjn td suih`t tgj`r e`t`mk men rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo pkmestd tgj rjo`demk ^A dff`aj fdr mpprdvmk.
Edrhmkky, tgj AYH trm`e`eo pkme `s suih`ttjn ms pmrt df tgj adhpmey dpjrmt`des hmeumk (ADH) dr dtgjr adhpmey hmeumk. Mftjr A rjaj`vjs tgj AYH trm`e`eo pkme, tgj prdpdsjnadetjet df tgj AYH trm`e`eo sjss`de `s adhpmrjn td tgj k`st df rjqu`rjn `tjhs `e AMQQ?9:.=9>(10). Deaj m AYH trm`e`eo pkme s mpprdvjn, A hm`etm`es vjry k`ttkj dvjrs`ogt dvjr tgjAYH trm`e`eo sjss`des, men tgjrj `s ed rjqu`rjhjet fdr ^A td mttjen m adhpmey‐s AYH adursjms pmrt df tgj mpprdvmk prdajss.
Mnn`t`demkky, AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(i) prdv`njs k`ttkj ou`nmeaj td dpjrmtdrs rjomrn`eo tgj h`e`huhrjqu`rjhjets fdr rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo, men edej df tgj adrj suiljats njet`f`jn e sjat`de (m)df AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10) mrj k`stjn. ^gjrj `s ed rjqu`rjhjet td rjv`s`t mey df tgj suiljats advjrjnnur`eo `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo. Adesjqujetky, dpjrmtdrs gmvj suistmet`mk kmt`tunj `e tjrhs df wgmt`s tmuogt nur`eo rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo sjss`des, gdw `t `s tmuogt, men tgj trm`e`eo t`hjmkkdamtjn.
Ijfdrj 9331, A wms mat`vjky evdkvjn e tjmag`eo AYH td n`ffjrjet drome`zmt`des men fk`ogt
arjws mardss tgj aduetry. g`s tjmag`eo wms ndej td mss`st dpjrmtdrs e hjjt`eo tgjrjqu`rjhjets df AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10). d mss`st w`tg tgj njk`vjry df tgj trm`e`eo, A njvjkdpjn m9-nmy e`t`mk AYH adursj (^S =1670< Arjw Yjsdurajs Hmemojhjet) `e tgj h`n-=003s, men hmnj `tmvm`kmikj fdr puragmsj. gj trm`e`eo pmabmoj ades`sts df 0 n`ffjrjet prjsjetmt`des, fdr m tdtmk df=7? sk`njs. gj A AYH adursj wms kmrojky etjenjn td earjmsj mwmrjejss df AYH adeajpts,rmtgjr tgme prdv`n`eo pmrt`a`pmets w`tg prmat`amk nja`s`de-hmb`eo men adhhue`amt de tddks(`.j., hdnjks men/dr strmtjo`js) tgmt adukn ij jms`ky trmesfjrrjn etd m prdajnurmkky struaturjnhukt`-arjw jev`rdehjet. Maadrn`eo td tgj ^A AYH `estruatdr gmeniddb, tgj prjsjetmt`des `etgj trm`e`eo pmabmoj hjjt tgj rjqu`rjhjets df AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10). Gdwjvjr, tgjrj s eddvjrmrag`eo frmhjwdrb tgmt njtjrh`ejs tgj drnjr `e wg`ag tgj ^A AYH trm`e`eo hmtjr`mk `sprjsjetjn. gj A AYH prjsjetmt`des hmy ij prjsjetjn e mey drnjr, imsjn de tgj prjfjrjeaj
df tgj `en`v`numk adenuat`eo tgj trm`e`eo. =30 Maadrn`eo td S=1670J, tgjrj `s m kdt df`efdrhmt`de td advjr e 9 nmys df trm`e`eo.
=37 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, M r Amrr`jr Mnv`sdry A`raukmr ed. 3==? ∙ Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet rm`e`eo(=: Mpr`k =00?), mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.ta.oa.am/jeo/a`v`kmv`mt`de/stmenmrns/adhhjraj-a`raukmrs-ma3==?-=?=0.gth (kmst maajssjn de =6 Njajhijr 93=1)
=30 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =1670 ∙ Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet ‑ Fma`k`tmtdr (933=)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 86/215
- ?7 -
^gj A AYH adursj gms dftje sjrvjn ms m tjhpkmtj fdr e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo. Gdwjvjr, tgjhmtjr`mk e tgj gmeniddb advjrs deky tgj `tjhs k`stjn e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(m). @t ndjs edtprdv`nj mey ou`nmeaj rjomrn`eo tgj rjqu`rjhjets dutk`ejn e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(i), men t ndjsedt mnnrjss hmey df tgj ue`quj agmkkjeojs tgmt m p`kdt hmy jeaduetjr wg`kj fky`eo m pmrt`aukmrdpjrmt`de.
Jffjat`vj 3= Mpr`k 9331, ^A n`sadet`eujn tgj njk`vjry df tgjsj wdrbsgdps, meeduea`eo e Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Kjttjr @ssuj =/9331 tgmt A wms rjfdaus`eo ts ‛rjsdurajs td tgdsj mat`v`t`js w`tgtgj orjmtjst smfjty ijejf`t.‘ gj mv`mt`de smfjty kjttjr furtgjr stmtjn tgmt tgj Qystjh Qmfjtyprdormh wms rjfdaus`eo ‛jejro`js men rjsdurajs td hjjt ejw pr`dr`t`js men mnnrjss jvdkv`eo`ssujs men n`rjat`des, suag ms smfjty hmemojhjet systjh (QHQ) men `e`t`mt`vjs td rjnuajruewmy eaurs`des.‘ ==3
@e Lmeumry 933?, m B`eo M`r M=33 armsgjn e Qmeny Imy, Qmsbmtagjwme. gj evjst`omt`de`njet`f`jn sjvjrmk smfjty ssujs rjkmtjn td AYH. gj Idmrn rjkjmsjn evjst`omt`de rjpdrtM3?A333= de => Datdijr 9330, men `e Yjadhhjenmt`de M30-39, rjadhhjenjn tgmt< ===
RtXgj Njpmrthjet df rmespdrt rjqu`rj adhhjra`mk m`r dpjrmtdrs td prdv`njadetjhpdrmry arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet (AYH) trm`e`eo fdr Amemn`me Mv`mt`deYjoukmt`des (AMYs) suipmrt ?31 m`r tmx` men AMYs suipmrt ?3> adhhutjr p`kdts.
^QI Mv`mt`de @evjst`omt`de Yjpdrt M30M33=6 g`ogk`ogtjn tgj r`sbs mssda`mtjn w`tg tgj aurrjetAYH rjoukmt`de men stmenmrn `e Amemnm. Ms m rjsukt df tgj `evjst`omt`de, tgj ^QI `ssujn mF`en`eo ms td Y`sb midut tgj aurrjet AYH rjoukmt`de men stmenmrns fdr AMY ?3: m`rk`ejdpjrmtdrs, stmt`eo tgmt ‛tgjrj `s m r`sb tgmt fk`ogt arjws hmy edt ij trm`ejn `e tgj kmtjst tgrjmtmen jrrdr hmemojhjet tjage`qujs.‘
^A‐s suisjqujet mat`de eakunjn m fdaus ordup adhpr`s`eo A men enustry rjprjsjetmt`vjs,
wg`ag hjt `e Lmeumry 93=9. Ms pmrt df `ts hmenmtj, tgj fdaus ordup wms n`rjatjn td njtjrh`ejme maajptmikj kjeotg fdr AYH trm`e`eo. gj ordup wms mksd msbjn td njtjrh`ej wg`ag estruatdrqumk`f`amt`des sgdukn ij rjqu`rjn td prdv`nj AYH trm`e`eo men gdw td hpkjhjet memaarjn`tmt`de prdormh.
^gj f`emk rjpdrt df tgj AYH rm`e`eo Fdaus Ordup, nmtjn 90 Fjirumry 93=9, prdpdsjnadhpdejets df m adetjhpdrmry AYH trm`e`eo stmenmrn. gj fdaus ordup suih`ttjnrjadhhjenmt`des td tgj A`v`k Mv`mt`de Yjoukmtdry Adhh`ttjj (AMYA) ==9 tgmt eakunjnmndpt`de df tgj @AMD-jendrsjn tgrjmt-men-jrrdr hmemojhjet (^JH) hdnjk men tgj mppk`amt`dedf sajemr`d-imsjn trm`e`eo. Gdwjvjr, tgj fdaus ordup rjpdrt en`amtjn tgmt ‛^rmespdrt Amemnmsgdukn edt hmenmtj spja`f`a estruatdr qumk`f`amt`des edr sgdukn t jhimrb de m AYH estruatdr
==3 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =7: ‑ Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Kjttjr , @ssuj =/9331
=== ^QI, Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Yjadhhjenmt`de M30-39< Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet ^rm`e`eo, mvm`kmikj mtgttp<//www.ist-tsi.oa.am/jeo/rjadhhmenmt`des-rjadhhjenmt`des/mv`mt`de/9330/rjaTm3039.msp(kmst maajssjn =3 Njajhijr 93=1)
==9 ^gj hmenmtj df AMYA s td rjadhhjen f`emk rjoukmtdry nja`s`des td tgj H`e`stjr.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 87/215
- ?0 -
maarjn`tmt`de prdormh.‘ @e mnn`t`de, tgj fdaus ordup mksd rjadhhjenjn mom`est jstmik`sg`eo msjt t`hj fdr AYH adursj nurmt`de.
^gj AMYA maajptjn tgj ^A fdaus ordup rjadhhjenmt`des, men de 9> Mpr`k 93=9, n`rjatjn tgmt madetjhpdrmry AYH trm`e`eo rjoukmt`de men stmenmrn sgdukn ij njvjkdpjn fdr AMY Quipmrts?39, ?31, ?3>, men ?3:. ^gj stmenmrn `s td `eakunj tgj ^JH hdnjk td jegmeaj fk`ogt arjws‐
mi`k`t`js td adhhue`amtj jffjat`vjky, mssjss aden`t`des, men hmbj mpprdpr`mtj nja`s`des ear`t`amk s`tumt`des. A gms mss`oejn m tjmh kjmnjr w`tg tgj tmsb df njvjkdp`eo m prdljat pkme. g`sprdljat gms yjt td ij adhpkjtjn.
^gjrj gmvj ijje s`h`kmr amkks fdr jxtjen`eo AYH trm`e`eo e tgj ZQ. @e 9330, tgj Emt`demk^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn (E^QI) njet`f`jn tgj ejjn td hprdvj AYH trm`e`eo ms dej df `tstdp mv`mt`de-rjkmtjn smfjty adeajres. ==1 De 3= Hmy 9330, tgj FMM rjspdenjn iy `ssu`eo m edt`ajdf prdpdsjn rukjhmb`eo (ESYH) tgmt wdukn rjqu`rj Smrt =1: dpjrmtdrs ==> td prdv`nj AYHtrm`e`eo td mkk arjw hjhijrs, eakun`eo p`kdts men fk`ogt mttjenmets. ==:
Njsp`tj tgj fmat tgmt tgj AYH rjoukmt`des e Amemnm gmvj edt ijje upnmtjn td rjfkjat hdnjre
AYH adeajpts, sdhj df tgjsj adeajpts gmvj mkrjmny ijje etjormtjn etd dtgjr A-kjnprdormhs. Fdr jxmhpkj, tgj Mnvmeajn ]umk`f`amt`de Srdormh, ==6 tgj Mpprdvjn Agjab S`kdtprdormh, ==? men tgj Hukt`-Arjw S`kdt K`ajeaj ==7 pkmaj ades`njrmikj jhpgms`s de tgrjmt-men-jrrdr hmemojhjet adeajpts men strmtjo`js. @e mnn`t`de, jmag df tgjsj prdormhs mksd g`ogk`ogtstgj hpdrtmeaj df ij`eo mikj td jvmkumtj tgjsj sb`kks ms pmrt df m prdf`a`jeay-imsjn trm`e`eoprdormh.
=.=?.?.1 @enustry-rjadoe`zjn pgmsjs df arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo
^gjrj mrj m vmr`jty df AYH stmenmrns men rjoukmt`des e pkmaj tgrduogdut tgj wdrkn. Njsp`tjtgjsj n`ffjrjeajs, tgjrj `s m ojejrmk adesjesus mhdeo tgj mv`mt`de adhhue`ty tgmt AYHprdormhs sgdukn ades`st df 1 n`st`eat pgmsjs df trm`e`eo. ==0
^gj f`rst pgmsj s `endatr`emt de men mwmrjejss trm`e`eo. g`s pgmsj etrdnuajs amen`nmtjs tdims`a AYH adeajpts men strmtjo`js. Qtun`js gmvj sgdwe tgmt AYH `endatr`emt`de trm`e`eo ame
==1 ZQ Emt`demk rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn (E^QI), Hdst _metjn K`st df ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty@hprdvjhjets 9330 ‑ Ar`t`amk agmeojs ejjnjn td rjnuaj trmespdrtmt`de maa`njets men smvj k`vjs (9330)
==> Zenjr tgj Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (FMYs), Smrt =1: mppk`js td m`r tmx` men adhhutjr dpjrmt`des.
==: Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`de (FMM), ESYH 30-39< Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet ^rm`e`eo fdr Arjwhjhijrs `e Smrt =1: Dpjrmt`des (`ssujn 3= Hmy 9330)
==6 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, Njvjkdphjet men @hpkjhjetmt`de df me Mnvmeajn ]umk`f`amt`de Srdormh (M]S), (93=3),
mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.ta.oa.am/jeo/a`v`kmv`mt`de/stmenmrns/adhhjraj-mqp-hjeu-=77?.gth (kmstmaajssjn de 30 Njajhijr 93=1)
==? ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S 6:11 ∙ Mpprdvjn Agjab S`kdt Hmeumk (933?)
==7 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, Hukt`-Arjw S`kdt K`ajeaj ^rm`e`eo Srdormh Hmeumk ‑ Fk`ogt ^rm`e`eo (`ssujn 3= Lmeumry 93=9)
==0 Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`de (FMM), Mnv`sdry A raukmr (MA) =93-:=J< Arjw YjsdurajHmemojhjet rm`e`eo (933>)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 88/215
- 73 -
rjsukt e s`oe`f`amet hprdvjhjets e mtt`tunjs tdwmrn arjw addrn`emt`de men fk`ogt njabhmemojhjet. =93
^gj sjaden pgmsj s prmat`aj, fjjnimab, men rjaurrjet trm`e`eo. Nur`eo tgj jmrky yjmrs df AYH,tgj sb`kks wjrj tmuogt sjpmrmtjky frdh tjage`amk bedwkjnoj men sb`kks. @e rjajet yjmrs, tgjrj gmsijje earjmsjn rjadoe`t`de tgmt AYH trm`e`eo wdukn ij hdrj jffjat`vj f t wms etjormtjn w`tg
tjage`amk trm`e`eo frdh tgj jmrk`jst stmojs df tgj m`rarjw trm`e`eo rjo`hj. =9= AYH trm`e`eoprdormhs tgmt eakunj rjaurrjet trm`e`eo men tgj matumk prmat`aj df AYH strmtjo`js gmvj ijjesgdwe td prdnuaj s`oe`f`amet agmeojs e fk`ogt arjw pjrfdrhmeaj nur`eo k`ej-dr`jetjn fk`ogttrm`e`eo sjss`des men nur`eo fk`ogts. =99
^gj tg`rn pgmsj `s adet`eu`eo rj`efdrajhjet. ^g`s pgmsj `evdkvjs hmb`eo AYH hdrj tgme lustme mspjat df fk`ogt arjw trm`e`eo, men stmrts w`tg hmemojhjet kjvjk iuy-`e df tgj AYH adeajpts.Me jffjat`vj wmy df adet`eumk rj`efdrajhjet s td jhijn ar`t`amk AYH sb`kks men ijgmv`dursw`tg`e adhpmey QDSs td hmbj AYH me etjormk mspjat df mkk trm`e`eo men dpjrmt`des. =91
=.=?.?.> Kmtjst njvjkdphjets `e tgj f`jkn df arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet
Jmrk`jr ojejrmt`des df AYH trm`e`eo wjrj vjry hdnukmr, men wjrj edt etjormtjn etd me dvjrmkktgjhj dr dvjrmrag`eo frmhjwdrb. Ms m rjsukt, dknjr AYH prdormhs typ`amkky ades`stjn dfprjsjetmt`des midut AYH tdp`as tgmt fdausjn hdrj de mwmrjejss trm`e`eo tgme de prdv`n`eofk`ogt arjw w`tg matumk AYH strmtjo`js tgmt adukn ij jhpkdyjn nur`eo trm`e`eo men dpjrmt`des.AYH trm`e`eo gms ijje adet`eumkky rjf`ejn td dpt`h`zj tgj jffjat`vjejss men rjkjvmeay df tgjtrm`e`eo. QI Mv`mt`de @evjst`omt`de Yjpdrt M30M33=6 prdv`njs me jxpkmemt`de df tgj jvdkut`dedf AYH men `ts vmr`dus ojejrmt`des.
^gj hdst rjajet njvjkdphjet `e AYH fdausjs de ^JH. ^JH mnvdamtjs tgj amrjfuk memkys`s dfpdtjet`mk gmzmrns men tmb`eo mpprdpr`mtj stjps td mvd`n, trmp, dr h`t`omtj tgrjmts men jrrdrsijfdrj tgjy kjmn td me uenjs`rjn m`rarmft stmtj. @e dtgjr wdrns, JH strjssjs met`a`pmt`de,rjadoe`t`de, men rjadvjry ms tgj bjy pr`ea`pkjs ijg`en tgrjmt men jrrdr hmemojhjet. =9> Iyus`eo matumk smfjty nmtm frdh me dpjrmtdr, aurrjet ojejrmt`des df AYH mrj mikj td tmrojt spja`f`amrjms df me dpjrmt`de tgmt pdsj tgj orjmtjst r`sb. JH mksd rjadoe`zjs tgj hpdrtmeaj dfuenjs`rjn m`rarmft stmtj hmemojhjet, ms t rjprjsjets tgj kmst dppdrtue`ty fdr fk`ogt arjws tdprjvjet me mnvjrsj dutadhj. =9:
=93 @i`n.
=9= Ydymk Mjrdemut`amk Qda`jty, AYH Qtmen`eo Ordup, Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet, (Kdende, ZB< =000)
=99 Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`de (FMM), Mnv`sdry A raukmr (MA) =93-:=J< Arjw YjsdurajHmemojhjet rm`e`eo (933>)
=91 ^.K. Qjmhstjr, F.M. Srjet ss, men J.Q. Jnjes, ‛@hpkjhjet`eo AYH sb`kks w`tg`e arjw trm`e`eoprdormhs,‘ e< Srdajjn`eos df tgj ^jetg @etjremt`demk Qyhpds`uh de Mv`mt`de Ssyagdkdoy (Adkuhius< Dg`dQtmtj Ze`vjrs`ty< =000), pmojs :33∙:3>
=9> M. Hjrr`tt men L. Bk`ejat, ‛Njfjes`vj Fky`eo fdr S`kdts< Me @etrdnuat`de td ^grjmt men JrrdrHmemojhjet,‘ ^gj Ze`vjrs`ty df ^jxms Guhme Fmatdrs Yjsjmrag Srdljat< ^gj KDQM Adkkmidrmt`vj(Must`e, ^jxms< 9336)
=9: N. Hmur`ed, ^grjmt men Jrrdr Hmemojhjet (^JH), Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Qjh`emr (AMQQ),(Vmeaduvjr< =7∙93 Mpr`k 933:)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 89/215
- 7= -
Sjrgmps tgj hdst hpdrtmet jkjhjet df aurrjet AYH trm`e`eo s tgmt t s n`rjatky trmesfjrmikj`etd tgj m`rarmft. Fk`ogt arjws mrj tmuogt spja`f`a sb`kks men strmtjo`js tgmt ame ij usjn menjvmkumtjn nur`eo trm`e`eo men dpjrmt`des. g`s mspjat hmbjs t jms`jr td o`vj men rjaj`vjfjjnimab rjomrn`eo m fk`ogt arjw‐s AYH nur`eo m fk`ogt.
^gjrj s ed rjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjet e Amemnm td tjmag tgj kmtjst ojejrmt`de df AYH trm`e`eo.Aurrjetky, tgj deky rjqu`rjhjets mrj tgdsj tgmt mrj njet`f`jn e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10).
=.=?.7 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet ijst prmat`ajs
=.=?.7.= Ojejrmk
^gjrj mrj m euhijr df AYH ijst prmat`ajs, wg`ag mrj n`saussjn e QI Mv`mt`de @evjst`omt deYjpdrt M30M33=6. ^g`s sjat`de w`kk g`ogk`ogt sdhj AYH ijst prmat`ajs ms tgjy mppky td QDSsmen agjabk`sts, prdikjh sdkv`eo men nja`s`de hmb`eo, arjw adhhue`amt`des men wdrbkdmnhmemojhjet.
=.=?.7.9 Q`tumt`demk mwmrjejss
Q`tumt`demk mwmrjejss s njf`ejn ms ‛tgj adet`eudus jxtrmat`de df jev`rdehjetmk efdrhmt`de,tgj etjormt`de df tg`s efdrhmt`de w`tg prjv`dus bedwkjnoj td fdrh m adgjrjet hjetmk p`aturj,men tgj usj df tgmt p`aturj e n`rjat`eo furtgjr pjrajpt`de men met`a`pmt`eo futurj jvjets.‘ =96
Fk`ogt arjw mat`des ejjn td ij imsjn de tgj smhj uenjrstmen`eo df tgj aurrjet stmtj df tgjm`rarmft, tgj `etjenjn fk`ogt pkme, men tgj tgrjmts td tgjsj mat`v`t`js `e drnjr td pjrfdrh `e maddrn`emtjn, jff`a`jet, men smfj hmeejr. g`s adhhde uenjrstmen`eo ijtwjje tgj arjwhjhijrs s rjfjrrjn td ms tjmh dr sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. =9?,=97
@en`v`numk s`tumt demk mwmrjejss njsar`ijs gdw m arjw hjhijr etjrprjts, prdljats men tmbjsmat`de de tgj hdhjet-td-hdhjet agmeojs e tgj m`rarmft stmtj. Qgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejssnjsar`ijs gdw jmag p`kdt‐s mwmrjejss df tgj s`tumt`de ejjns td ij ades`stjet w`tg tgmt df tgjdtgjr p`kdt wg`kj wdrb`eo de tgj smhj tmsbs. _gje tg`s uenjrstmen`eo s ades`stjet, arjws amejffjat`vjky met`a`pmtj men addrn`emtj tgj`r mat`des tdwmrn mag`jv`eo tgj`r adhhde odmk.
Qgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss s njvjkdpjn men hm`etm`ejn iy m arjw tgrduog m euhijr dfn`sarjtj men adet`eudus ijgmv`durs.
N`sarjtj ijgmv`durs eakunj fk`ogt pkmee`eo, e-fk`ogt ir`jf`eos, men njet`f`amt`de df bjy pd`ets`e tgj fk`ogt, suag ms mttm`e`eo h`e`huh mkt`tunjs. gjsj mat`v`t`js mrj pkmeejn agjabpd`ets td
=96 QBPirmry, ‛Q`tumt`demk Mwmrjejss,‘ mvm kmikj mt gttp<//www.sbyirmry.mjrd/`enjx.pgp/Q`tumt`demkTMwmrjejss (kmst maajssjn de 36 Njajhijr 93=1)
=9? H.Y. Jenskjy, ‛^dwmrn m tgjdry df s`tumt`de mwmrjejss e nyemh`a systjhs,‘ Guhme Fmatdrs (=00:i),1?(=), pmojs 19∙6>
=97 J. Qmkms, A. Sr`eaj, N.S. Imbjr, men K. Qgrjstgm, ‛Q`tumt`de mwmrjejss `e tjmh pjrfdrhmeaj<@hpk`amt`des fdr hjmsurjhjet men trm`e`eo,‘ Guhme Fmatdrs (=00:), 1?, pmojs =91‑=16
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 90/215
- 79 -
njsar`ij aurrjet stmtj men futurj pkmes men td prdv`nj me dppdrtue`ty fdr sjtt`eo, men agjab`eotgmt mkk arjw hjhijrs gmvj, tgj smhj uenjrstmen`eo.
Adet`eudus ijgmv`durs eakunj tgrjmt men jrrdr hmemojhjet, amkkduts df agmeojs df m`rarmftstmtj men estruhjet sjtt`eo/hdnj, men adhhue`amt`de df agmeojs td pkmes. gjsj ijgmv`dursjesurj tgmt efdrhmt`de men stmtj agmeojs mrj adhhue`amtjn ijtwjje arjw hjhijrs td upnmtj
tgj sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss de me deod`eo ims`s. Mkk df tgjsj mrj mspjats df AYH tgmtjemikj jffjat`vj arjw `etjrmat`des. Quag adet`eudus ijgmv`durs mrj efkujeajn iy tgj trm`e`eomen dpjrmt`demk mpprdmag tmbje iy dpjrmtdrs.
@e mnn`t`de td tgj ijgmv`durs njsar`ijn midvj, 9 dtgjr bjy mspjats df hm`etm`e`eo sgmrjns`tumt`demk mwmrjejss mrj<
• Hde`tdr`eo tgj rjmat`des men hddn df dtgjr arjw hjhijrs td njet`fy mey s`oes tgmttgjy mrj adefusjn, ueadhfdrtmikj, dr n`sjeomojn, wg`ag mrj pdtjet`mk en`amtdrs tgmt tgjsgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss `s irjmb`eo ndwe2 men
• ^mb`eo mpprdpr`mtj rjhjn`mk mat`de td rj-jeomoj tgj dtgjr arjw hjhijr men rjsdkvj
tgj`r adefus`de dr n`sadhfdrt.
=.=?.7.1 Srdikjh sdkv`eo men nja`s`de hmb`eo
QDSs rjprjsjet me hpdrtmet efdrhmt`de rjsduraj mvm`kmikj td p`kdts td mss`st w`tg prdikjhsdkv`eo men nja`s`de hmb`eo. QDSs mrj njs`oejn td gjkp p`kdts dpjrmtj w`tg`e drome`zmt`demkr`sb-hmemojhjet iduenmr`js men hm`etm`e s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss tgrduog tgj usj dfprjnjtjrh`ejn prdajnurjs men stmenmrn`zjn pgrmsjdkdoy.
Fk`ogt-arjw prdikjh sdkv`eo ame ij njsar`ijn ms m hukt`-stjp prdajss, wg`ag eakunjs nja`s`dehmb`eo ms me `etjormk pmrt. ^gj arjw hust f`rst rjadoe`zj tgmt tgjrj `s m prdikjh, omtgjr`efdrhmt`de midut `t, men tgje usj tgmt `efdrhmt`de td njf`ej tgj prdikjh. ^gjy hust tgjeprdnuaj pdss`ikj sdkut`des, nja`nj wg`ag sdkut`de `s ijst, men `hpkjhjet tgj sdkut`de. F`emkky,tgjy hust jvmkumtj tgj rjsukts df tgj sdkut`de usjn td njtjrh`ej wgjtgjr tgj prdikjh gms ijjesdkvjn. @f tgj prdikjh gms edt ijje sdkvjn, tgj arjw hmy ejjn td rjpjmt tgj prdajss. =90 Msjxpkm`ejn e me jmrk`jr ^QI mv`mt`de evjst`omt`de rjpdrt< =13
Jffjat`vj nja`s`de hmb`eo evdkvjs tgj maaurmtj uenjrstmen`eo df tgjs`tumt`de, me mpprja`mt`de df tgj `hpk`amt`des df tgj aurrjet s`tumt`de,fdrhukmt`de df m pkme(s) men adet`eojea`js, fdkkdwjn iy tgj `hpkjhjetmt`dedf tgj ijst adursj df mat`de. Jqumkky hpdrtmet s tgj arjw‐s mi`k`ty tdrjadoe`zj agmeojs e tgj`r s`tumt`de men td rj`e`t`mtj tgj nja`s`de-hmb`eoprdajss td jesurj tgmt agmeojs mrj maaduetjn fdr men pkmes hdn`f`jn
maadrn`eoky.
=90 ^rmespdrt Amemnm, ^S =7: ‑ Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Kjttjr , @ssuj >/=000, `tjh :
=13 ^QI Mv`mt`de @evjst`omt`de Yjpdrt M30M33=6, sjat`de =.=7.9.6.9 ‑ Nja s`de Hmb`eo
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 91/215
- 71 -
@emaaurmtj pjrajpt`de dr `emnjqumtj ades`njrmt`de df tgj pdtjet`mk `hpk`amt`des df m s`tumt`de`earjmsjs tgj r`sb tgmt m nja`s`de w`kk prdnuaj me mnvjrsj dutadhj tgmt hmy rjsukt `e meuenjs`rjn m`rarmft stmtj.
@earjmsjn strjss kjvjks ame mnvjrsjky hpmat m p`kdt‐s mi`k`ty td pjraj`vj men jvmkumtj aujs frdhtgj jev`rdehjet, men hmy rjsukt `e mttjet`demk emrrdw`eo. =1= @e hmey amsjs, tg`s mttjet`demk
emrrdw`eo ame kjmn td adef`rhmt`de i`ms, wg`ag amusjs pjdpkj td sjjb dut aujs tgmt suppdrt tgjnjs`rjn adursj df mat`de, td tgj pdss`ikj jxakus`de df ar`t`amk aujs tgmt hmy suppdrt me mktjremtj,kjss njs`rmikj gypdtgjs`s. =19 gj nmeojr tgmt tg`s pgjedhjede prjsjets s tgmt pdtjet`mkkysjr`dus dutadhjs hmy edt ij o`vje tgj mpprdpr`mtj kjvjk df ades`njrmt`de wgje njtjrh`e`eo tgjijst pdss`ikj adursj df mat`de. Ms m rjsukt, t s arua`mk tgmt p`kdts adet`eumkky rj-jvmkumtj tgj`rs`tumt`de td njtjrh`ej wgjtgjr tgjy maaurmtjky pjraj`vj tgj s`tumt`de men wgjtgjr tgj pkme swdrb`eo dut ms jxpjatjn dr m agmeoj `e tgj pkme `s rjqu`rjn.
Medtgjr hpdrtmet mspjat df tgj nja`s`de-hmb`eo prdajss s tgj adeajpt df sgmrjn hjetmkhdnjks. =11 Me en`v`numk‐s hjetmk hdnjk s kmrojky njpjenjet de tgj`r uenjrstmen`eo df tgja`rauhstmeajs, jxpjatmt`des midut tgj futurj, men pmst jxpjr`jeaj. gj jxpjr`jeaj, dr
bedwkjnoj, tgmt pjrsdes ir`eo td m s`tumt`de pkmys m s`oe`f`amet rdkj e tgj`r nja`s`de-hmb`eoprdajss.
@e m arjw jev`rdehjet, jvjry jffdrt sgdukn ij hmnj td mk`oe hjetmk hdnjks. @f tgj arjw `suemikj td mk`oe hjetmk hdnjks nuj td n`ffjrjeajs e pjrsdemk`ty dr adhhue`amt`de stykj, ar`t`amk`efdrhmt`de hmy edt ij maaduetjn fdr wgje ades`njr`eo tgj pdtjet`mk hpk`amt`des df m s`tumt`demen nur`eo tgj fdrhukmt`de df pkmes men adet`eojea`js. Frdh m AYH stmenpd`et, jffjat`vjadhhue`amt`de pkmys m ar`t`amk rdkj e tgj mk`oehjet df tgj arjw‐s hjetmk hdnjks. Gdwjvjr,tgjsj adhhue`amt`de sb`kks rjqu`rj prmat`aj men rj`efdrajhjet td ij jffjat`vj, pmrt`aukmrkynur`eo pjr`dns df g`og wdrbkdmn, suag ms nur`eo me `estruhjet mpprdmag dr me miedrhmks`tumt`de.
=.=?.7.> Arjw adhhue`amt`des
@e drnjr td mk`oe hjetmk hdnjks, hprdvj arjw s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss, men dpt`h`zj tgjnja`s`de-hmb`eo prdajss, arjws hust ij jffjat`vj adhhue`amtdrs. g`s rjqu`rjhjet ame ij magmkkjeoj e tgj adabp`t wgje fmajn w`tg t`hj prjssurj, miedrhmk s`tumt`des, men adhpjt`eopr`dr`t`js. d jemikj p`kdts td adhhue`amtj jffjat`vjky e g`og wdrbkdmn s`tumt`des, QDSsprdv`nj stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy, wg`ag jemikjs rmp`n adhhue`amt`de men uenjrstmen`eo.
Hdnjre AYH prdormhs g`ogk`ogt imrr`jrs td jffjat`vj adhhue`amt`de men prdv`nj hukt`pkjadhhue`amt`de strmtjo`js tgmt mkkdw en`v`numks td sjkjat tgj hdst mpprdpr`mtj strmtjoynjpjen`eo de tgj sjvjr`ty df tgj s`tumt`de, tgj t`hj mvm`kmikj, men tgj dtgjr pjrsde(s) evdkvjn
`e tgj adhhue`amt`de prdajss.
=1= Ydymk Mjrdemut`amk Qda`jty, AYH Qtmen`eo Ordup, Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet (Kdende, ZB< =000)
=19 A.N. _`abjes men L.O. Gdkkmens, Jeo`ejjr`eo Ssyagdkdoy men Guhme Sjrfdrhmeaj, 1rn jn`t`de (Srjet`ajGmkk, Ejw Ljrsjy< =000)
=11 ^.K. Qjmhstjr, Y.J. Yjnn`eo, men O.K. Bmjhpf, Mppk`jn Adoe`t`vj ^msb Memkys`s `e Mv`mt`de (MsgomtjSuik`sg`eo, Mknjrsgdt, ZB< =00?)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 92/215
- 7> -
Arjw hjhijrs hust fjjk adhfdrtmikj e prdv`n`eo eput td m amptm`e td mss`st nja`s`de hmb`eo.Hdnjre AYH trm`e`eo jeadurmojs FDs td mssjrt tgjhsjkvjs. Gdwjvjr, sjkf-mssjrt`de ame ij vjryn`ff`aukt fdr sdhj pjdpkj, men `ejffjat`vj mssjrt`de gms ijje m fmatdr `e dtgjr maa`njets. =1> Dftje`ejffjat`vj mssjrt`de s k`ebjn w`tg ejffjat`vj adhhue`amt`de. Hdnjre AYH trm`e`eospja`f`amkky mnnrjssjs tgjsj `ssujs.
@t s ojejrmkky maajptjn tgmt arjw hjhijrs sgdukn mssjrt tgjhsjkvjs wgje tgjy mrj uesurj dfsdhjtg`eo dr f tgjrj s m ojeu`ej adeajre midut tgj aurrjet adursj df mat`de. @njmkky, nd`eo sdijo`es w`tg ede-tgrjmtje`eo stmtjhjets dr qujst`des. @f tgdsj jffdrts fm`k td mnnrjss tgj adeajre,tgje m hdrj mssjrt`vj mpprdmag hust ij tmbje. Q. Njbbjr jxpkm`es, e Nr`ft `etd Fm`kurj, tgmt< =1:
… tgj adkkmidrmt`vj dpjrmt`de df hmag`ejry e t`hj ar`t`amk s`tumt`des mssuhjs tgjusj df ueh`t`omtjn kmeoumoj ‚ kmeoumoj tgmt ndjse‐t gjnoj, qumk`fy, wjmbje drsdftje, iut tgmt njk`vjrs uevmre`sgjn men uemhi`oudus hjssmojs. Sjdpkjojejrmkky gmvj m rjmkky gmrn t`hj nd`eo tgmt, ijamusj tgjy mrj edt tgj hmag`ejtgjy mrj dpjrmt`eo. gjy mrj pjdpkj, w`tg fjjk`eos men sda`mk jxpjatmt`des midut
rjkmt`desg`ps. Deky adestmet trm`e`eo men `endatr`emt`de, ms wjkk ms pds`t`vjrj`efdrajhjet, ame gjkp iu`kn adef`njeaj men maajptmeaj fdr tgj usj dfueh`t`omtjn kmeoumoj.
Jsamkmt`de e adhhue`amt`de strmtjo`js ame ij n`ff`aukt. @f FDs mrj jxpjatjn td mssjrt tgjhsjkvjs,tgjy hust ij prdv`njn w`tg tgj prdpjr kjvjk df trm`e`eo e adhhue`amt`de jsamkmt`de strmtjo`jsmen ij o`vje me dppdrtue`ty td prmat`sj tgdsj sb`kks.
=.=?.7.: Jsamkmt`de df mssjrt`de iy f`rst dff`ajrs
Dej suag AYH adhhue`amt`de tddk `s tgj Srdi`eo, Mkjrt`eo, Agmkkjeo`eo, men Jhjrojeay_mre`eo (SMAJ) Hdnjk. =16 ^gj SMAJ hdnjk prdv`njs p`kdts, jspja`mkky FDs, w`tg m sjr`js dfadhhue`amt`de strmtjo`js njs`oejn td mkkdw fdr m emturmk jsamkmt`de df mssjrt`de, njpjen`eo detgj a`rauhstmeajs mt tgj t`hj. Jsamkmt`de ame ij prdorjss`vj dr hhjn`mtj njpjen`eo de tgjtgrjmt kjvjk `njet`f`jn.
^gj SMAJ hdnjk stmrts w`tg tgj usj df prdi`eo men uemhi`oudus qujst`des wgje smfjty `s edt`e ljdpmrny men tgjrj `s t`hj td msb qujst`des. ^g`s stjp `s ndej td `hprdvj tgj arjw‐suenjrstmen`eo df tgj s`tumt`de men td gjkp mk`oe hjetmk hdnjks e m ede-tgrjmtje`eo wmy.
^gj ejxt stjp `e tgj prdajss `s td mkjrt tgj dtgjr p`kdt df tgj adeajre. Mt tg`s stmoj, tgj `en`v`numkvd`ajs m spja`f`a adeajre td hmbj surj tgmt tgj dtgjr pjrsde uenjrstmens tgj adeajre. g`s hmyij ndej j`tgjr mftjr prdi`eo dr hhjn`mtjky f tgj p`kdt stmt`eo tgj adeajre uenjrstmens tgmt tgj
=1> ^QI mv`mt`de `evjst`omt`de rjpdrts M3?A333= men M30M33=6
=1: Q. Njbbjr, Nr`ft @etd Fm`kurj (Msgomtj Suik`sg`eo< 93==), pmoj =:9
=16 Y.D. Ijsad, ‛^d @etjrvjej dr Edt ^d @etjrvjej4 ^gj Ad-S`kdt‐s Amtag 99,‘ (`e< Srdajjn`eos df tgj^wjety-F`ftg @etjremt`demk Qjh`emr df tgj @etjremt`demk Qda`jty df M`r Qmfjty @evjst`omtdrs fdruh, 9?(:), 0>-=3=, mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.arh-njvjk.dro/rjsdurajs/pmpjr/SMAJ.SNF (kmst maajssjn de 36Njajhijr 93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 93/215
- 7: -
aurrjet adursj df mat`de `s edt mpprdpr`mtj. Zemhi`oudus men n`rjat kmeoumoj `s jssjet`mk fdr mejffjat`vj mkjrt.
^gj tg`rn stjp e tgj jsamkmt`eo prdajss s m agmkkjeo`eo stmtjhjet. gj agmkkjeoj stmtjhjetuemhi`oudusky prjsjets tgj dtgjr pjrsde w`tg m akjmr njsar`pt`de df tgj adesjqujeajsmssda`mtjn w`tg adet`eu`eo de m pmrt`aukmr adursj df mat`de, men prdv`njs me mktjremt`vj adursj
df mat`de.
^gj f`emk stjp `s jhjrojeay etjrvjet`de, w`tg tgj SEF tmb`eo dvjr adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft es`tumt`des w`tg nmeojr dr wgjrj t`hj s ar`t`amk. mikj == prdv`njs me jxjhpkmr mppk`amt`de dftgj SMAJ hdnjk jsamkmt`eo td tgj pd`et df tmb`eo adetrdk.
^mikj ==. Jxjhpkmr mppk`amt`de df tgj SMAJ hdnjk jsamkmt`eo td tgj pd`et df tmb`eo adetrdk
S ∙ prdi`eo ‛Amptm`e, mrj ydu sgdw`eo us ijkdw tgj ok`njskdpj4‘
M ∙ mkjrt`eo ‛Amptm`e, @ sgdw us = ndt ijkdw tgj ok`njskdpj.‘
A ∙ agmkkjeo`eo‛Amptm`e, wj mrj njsajen`eo furtgjr ijkdw tgj ok`njskdpj. _j mrj mt r`sb df
armsg`eo. _j gmvj td od mrduen.‘J ∙ jhjrojeay ‛Amptm`e, @ gmvj adetrdk. Od mrduen, hmx pdwjr, fkmps =3.‘
_g`kj tgj SMAJ hdnjk prdv`njs m sjr`js df adhhue`amt`de strmtjo`js tgmt rmeoj frdh ede-tgrjmtje`eo td vjry n`rjat`vj, tgj en`v`numk ndjs edt gmvj td stmrt mt tgj ijo`ee`eo df tgj hdnjk`f tgj s`tumt`de n`atmtjs dtgjrw`sj. @f ejjnjn, me `en`v`numk ame od n`rjatky frdh prdij tdjhjrojeay, dr e sdhj nrmst`a s`tumt`des, n`rjatky td tgj jhjrojeay stmtjhjet. gj uenjrky`eopr`ea`pkj ijg`en tg`s hdnjk `s td jesurj tgmt mkk pmrt`js uenjrstmen tgj s`tumt`de men tgmtjvjrydej s tg`eb`eo e m s`h`kmr wmy rjomrn`eo tgj prdpdsjn adursj df mat`de.
@e jffjat, tgj hdnjk mkkdws tgj drome`zmt`de td o`vj tgj FD tgj rjspdes`i`k`ty td edt deky tmbj
adetrdk iut td mksd tmbj adhhmen df tgj m`rarmft frdh tgj amptm`e wgje ejajssmry. Mnn`t`demkky,men `hpdrtmetky, `t njkjomtjs td tgj FD tgj mutgdr`ty td nd sd.
@njmkky, tgj hdnjk sgdukn ij suppdrtjn iy adhpmey pg`kdsdpgy, mnnrjssjn `e me drome`zmt`de‐spdk`ay, men hpkjhjetjn iy prdajnurjs austdh`zjn td tgj dpjrmtdr‐s ejjns. Srmat`amk trm`e`eosjss`des mrj ejajssmry td rj`efdraj tgj pg`kdsdpg`amk, pdk`ay-rjkmtjn, men prdajnurmk adeajptsmen pgrmsjdkdoy tgrduog tgj`r mppk`amt`de `e rjmk`st`a dpjrmt`demk sajemr`ds.
@evjst`omt`des iy tgj QI men dtgjr etjremt`demk mojea`js gmvj ndauhjetjn ea`njets menmaa`njets wgjrj tgj FD h`ogt gmvj tmbje adetrdk frdh tgj amptm`e.
De 91 Luky 93==, m Q`bdrsby Q-09M gjk`adptjr njpmrtjn me dffsgdrj vjssjk. gj amptm`e‐s adetrdk`eputs rjsuktjn e m 91³ edsj-g`og, njajkjrmt`eo p`tag mtt`tunj. gj amptm`e, suitky `eampma`tmtjnpdss`iky nuj td spmt`mk n`sdr`jetmt`de, n`n edt mppky adetrdk `eputs td rjadvjr frdh tgj ueusumkmtt`tunj. g`s emat`de adetr`iutjn td tgj jxajss`vj mhduet df mkt`tunj tgmt wms kdst nur`eo tgj`emnvjrtjet njsajet. Adetrmry td wgmt `s stmtjn `e tgj twd-agmkkjeoj rukj `e tgj dpjrmtdr‐s QDSs,tgj f`rst dff`ajr n`n edt tmbj adetrdk df tgj gjk`adptjr wgje tgj mpprdpr`mtj mat`de wms edt tmbje
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 94/215
- 76 -
td rjadvjr frdh tgj `emnvjrtjet njsajet. ^gj njsajet wms mrrjstjn 17 fjjt midvj tgj surfmaj dftgj wmtjr. gj gjk`adptjr wms edt nmhmojn, men ed dej wms elurjn. =1?
De 99 Hmy 93=3, m I?1?-733 dvjrrme tgj ruewmy nur`eo kmen`eo mt Hmeomkdrj, @en`m. ^gjm`rarmft wms njstrdyjn2 tgjrj wjrj =:7 fmtmk`t`js men 7 surv`vdrs. gj f`rst dff`ajr gmn njet`f`jntgmt tgj mpprdmag wms uestmikj men mnv`sjn tgj amptm`e td od mrduen 1 t`hjs, iut tgj amptm`e
adet`eujn tgj mpprdmag td m kmen`eo. ^gj f`rst dff`ajr n`n edt tmbj adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft `e tgjnjtjr`drmt`eo s`tumt`de. ^gj `evjst`omt`de a`tjn mhi`ou`ty `e vmr`dus `estruat`des jhpdwjr`eotgj f`rst dff`ajr td e`t`mtj m od-mrduen ms m adetr`iutdry fmatdr td tgj maa`njet. =17
De 3? Hmrag 933?, m I?1?->33 m`rarmft dvjrrme tgj ruewmy nur`eo kmen`eo mt Pdoymbmrtm,@endejs`m. gj m`rarmft wms njstrdyjn2 tgjrj wjrj 9= fmtmk`t`js men ==0 surv`vdrs. gj amptm`ewms tgj p`kdt fky`eo men adet`eujn me uestmikj mpprdmag td m kmen`eo, njsp`tj adhpmeyprdajnurjs tgmt rjqu`rjn m od-mrduen. Adetrmry td adhpmey estruat`des, tgj f`rst dff`ajr n`nedt tmbj adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft frdh tgj amptm`e wgje tgj amptm`e rjpjmtjnky oedrjn wmre`eostd od mrduen. =10
=.=?.7.6
_drbkdmn hmemojhjet
_drbkdmn `s m fueat`de df tgj euhijr df tmsbs tgmt hust ij adhpkjtjn w`tg`e m o`vje mhduet dft`hj. @f tgj euhijr df tmsbs tgmt hust ij adhpkjtjn `earjmsjs, dr `f t`hj mvm`kmikj njarjmsjs,wdrbkdmn earjmsjs. gjrjfdrj, e drnjr td rjnuaj wdrbkdmn, dej hust j`tgjr rjnuaj tgj euhijrdf tmsbs tgmt hust ij adhpkjtjn dr earjmsj tgj t`hj mvm`kmikj td adhpkjtj tgdsj tmsbs. msbsmturmt`de `s m aden`t`de wgjrj`e tgj euhijr df tmsbs td ij adhpkjtjn `e m o`vje t`hj jxajjnstgj p`kdts‐ ampma`ty td pjrfdrh tgjh, men sdhj tmsbs mrj sgjn dr njfjrrjn.
^gj `enustry stmenmrn fdr hukt`-arjw m`rarmft `s td njs`oemtj = arjw hjhijr ms SF men tgj dtgjrp`kdt ms SEF dr p`kdt hde`tdr`eo (SH). g`s n`v`s`de df nut`js gjkps dpt`h`zj arjw jff`a`jeay,prjvjet tmsb smturmt`de, men jesurj tgmt jrrdrs mrj trmppjn ijfdrj tgjy kjmn td me uenjs`rjnm`rarmft stmtj dr mnvjrsj adesjqujeaj.
^gj SF s rjspdes`ikj fdr adetrdkk`eo tgj m`rarmft, men tgj SEF/SH s rjspdes`ikj fdr gmenk`eodtgjr arjw nut`js rjkmtjn td rmn`d adhhue`amt`des, agjabk`st hmemojhjet, hde`tdr`eo tgjmat`des df tgj SF, men hde`tdr`eo tgj prdorjss df tgj fk`ogt. _`tg`e tgj pmst njamnj, tgjrj gmsijje m sg`ft frdh tgj SEF njs`oemt`de td SH. ^gj rjmsde fdr tg`s sg`ft `s td jhpgms`zj tgjejajss`ty df hde`tdr`eo tgj m`rarmft stmtj men mat`des df tgj SF. =>3
^gj prdpjr mkkdamt`de df rjspdes`i`k`t`js e m adabp`t gjkps frjj up ar`t`amk hjetmk ampma`ty sdtgmt arjw hjhijrs mrj ijttjr mikj td prdajss aujs frdh tgj jev`rdehjet, hmb`eo `t jms`jr tdnjtjat njv`mt`des frdh tgj pkmeejn adursj df mat`de. @f m fk`ogt arjw stmrts td fmkk ijg`en, tgjy
=1? ^QI Mv`mt`de @evjst`omt`de Yjpdrt M==G333=
=17 Odvjrehjet df @en`m, H`e`stry df A`v`k Mv`mt`de `evjst`omt`de rjpdrt, 1= Datdijr 93=3
=10 Yjpuik`a df @endejs`m Emt`demk ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Adhh`ttjj rjpdrt BEB^/3?.36/39.39.1:
=>3 Y.K. Quhwmkt, Y.L. ^gdhms, men B. N shubjs, Jegmea`eo Fk`ogt-arjw Hde`tdr`eo Qb`kks Ame @earjmsjFk`ogt Qmfjty, Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de (9330)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 95/215
- 7? -
ame qu`abky f`en tgjhsjkvjs uenjr earjmsjn t`hj prjssurj. g`s s`tumt`de ame amusj wdrbkdmnkjvjks td rjmag ar`t`amk kjvjks. _gje tgmt gmppjes, tgj jxtrm hjetmk ampma`ty rjqu`rjn td amtag upw`tg wgmt‐s gmppje`eo ame kjmn td aujs frdh tgj jev`rdehjet od`eo uenjtjatjn.
Fdr jxmhpkj, `f m fk`ogt arjw `s rusgjn de f`emk mpprdmag, tgjy hmy f`en `t gmrnjr td njtjat menadrrjat fdr fk`ogt pmtg njv`mt`des. @f m fk`ogt arjw f`ens tgjhsjkvjs e me jxajss`vj wdrbkdmn
s`tumt`de, tgjy hust tmbj hjmsurjs td rjnuaj tgj`r wdrbkdmn, jspja`mkky wgje e m ar`t`amk pgmsjdf fk`ogt, suag ms nur`eo mpprdmag men kmen`eo. Dej df tgj tjage`qujs mvm`kmikj td fk`ogt arjwswgd f`en tgjhsjkvjs ejmr`eo tmsb smturmt`de, dr `e me uesmfj pds`t`de wg`kj de f`emk mpprdmag,`s td jxjautj m od-mrduen. Frdh m wdrbkdmn hmemojhjet stmenpd`et, jxjaut`eo m od-mrduenprdv`njs tgj fk`ogt arjw w`tg mnn`t`demk t`hj td ojt amuogt up, sd tgmt wdrbkdmn kjvjks ame ijrjnuajn td maajptmikj kjvjks ijfdrj mttjhpt`eo medtgjr mpprdmag. Medtgjr hjmes df hmemo`eowdrbkdmn s td earjmsj t`hj mvm`kmikj iy hdn`fy`eo tgj mpprdmag prdf`kj (`.j., rjnuaj spjjn,hmbj m 163³ ture, men etjrajpt f`emk mpprdmag furtgjr frdh tgj ruewmy).
Smoj 31.=:.= df tgj MDH Vdkuhj = n`rjats usjrs td tgj adhpmey FDH fdr m adhpkjtj dutk`ej dftgj nut`js men rjspdes`i`k`t`js df fk`ogt arjw hjhijrs. gj FDH njsar`ijs tgj nut`js men
rjspdes`i`k`t`js df tgj amptm`e men tgj FD e sjat`des =.:.? men =.:.7, rjspjat`vjky. F`rst M`rnjs`oemtjs arjw hjhijrs ms SF men SEF. Nut`js men rjspdes`i`k`t`js df tgj SF men SEF mrjnjsar`ijn `e njtm`k tgrduogdut tgj MDH Vdkuhj =.
=.=?.0 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r
=.=?.0.= Ojejrmk
@e maadrnmeaj w`tg rjoukmt`des, F`rst M`r prdv`njs e`t`mk men rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo td mkkfk`ogt arjw. F`rst M`r‐s e`t`mk AYH adursj s tmuogt nur`eo ejw-g`rj orduen sagddks, wg`kjrjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo s prdv`njn mt tgj vmr`dus F`rst M`r imsjs.
F`rst M`r‐s AYH trm`e`eo rjqu`rjhjets mrj dutk`ejn e tgj F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des rm`e`eo Hmeumk (FD^H), wg`ag wms mpprdvjn iy A. ^gjsj rjqu`rjhjets h`h`a tgdsj dutk`ejn eAMQQ ?9:.=9>(10), w`tg tgj jxajpt`de tgmt F`rst M`r mksd `eakunjs ld`et arjw hjhijr trm`e`eo ehmemo`eo de-idmrn sjaur`ty tgrjmts.
^gj FD^H stmtjs tgmt tgj diljat`vj df F`rst M`r‐s AYH trm`e`eo s td ‛jesurj tgmt smfj, jff`a`jetmen prd-mat`vj tg`eb`eo, adhhue`amt`des men mat`des mhdeo arjw hjhijrs mrj uenjrstddnmen prmat`ajn.‘ =>= _g`kj ^A `espjatdrs gmvj mttjenjn F`rst M`r orduen sagddk adursjs `e tgjpmst, tgjrj `s ed rjadrn df ^A `espjatdrs jvjr mttjen`eo dej df F`rst M`r‐s `e`t`mk AYH adursjsnur`eo tgdsj orduen sagddk adursjs. Ms m rjsukt, tgjrj s ed rjadrn df ^A gmv`eo vjr`f`jn tgmtF`rst M`r‐s AYH trm`e`eo prdormh hjt tgj mppk`amikj AMQQ.
M rjv`jw df tgj amptm`e‐s trm`e`eo rjadrn sgdwjn tgmt tgj amptm`e adhpkjtjn g`s e`t`mk AYHtrm`e`eo de => Fjirumry =00?. gj amptm`e‐s kmst rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r wmsadhpkjtjn de =0 Edvjhijr 93=3, w`tg me jxp`ry nmtj df 3= Njajhijr 93==.
=>= F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des ^rm`e`eo Hmeumk (FD^H), Mhjenhjet ed. :0 (9= Luej 93==), Smrt =, Agmptjr=3.93.=, Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet rm`e`eo, Diljat`vjs, pmoj =3.93.>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 96/215
- 77 -
M rjv`jw df tgj FD‐s trm`e`eo rjadrn sgdwjn tgmt tgj FD adhpkjtjn g`s e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo de97 Qjptjhijr 933? nur`eo g`s `e`t`mk orduen sagddk mt F`rst M`r. De tgj smhj nmy, tgj FD mksdadhpkjtjn me ‛@etrdnuat`de td QHQ‘ sjss`de, trm`e`eo de ld`et sjaur`ty, men trm`e`eo de sjaur`tyrjqu`rjhjets fdr trmvjkk`eo td tgj ZQ. ^gj FD‐s kmst rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r wmsadhpkjtjn de 30 Hmrag 93==, w`tg me jxp`ry nmtj df 3= Mpr`k 93=9.
=.=?.0.9 F`rst M`r `e`t`mk arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet adursj
^QI evjst`omtdrs rjv`jwjn men disjrvjn F`rst M`r‐s e`t`mk AYH adursj. gj adursj wmsadenuatjn w`tg m ordup df > ejw-g`rj p`kdts, wgd wjrj tmb`eo pmrt `e tgj M^Y->9 orduensagddk. gj trm`e`eo wms sagjnukjn fdr = nmy, men eakunjn tgj fdkkdw`eo tdp`as< arjw rjsdurajhmemojhjet, etjrfjrjeaj w`tg arjw hjhijrs, men ld`et sjaur`ty.
^gj e`t`mk AYH adursj nurmt`de wms >.: gdurs. gj adursj eakunjn prjsjetmt`des de sjkjatjnAYH tdp`as, v`njds, 9 amsj stun`js, 9 =:-h`eutj irjmbs, men m :3-h`eutj kueag irjmb. Dej amsjstuny mnnrjssjn m adhpmey daaurrjeaj, men tgj dtgjr mnnrjssjn m =00: daaurrjeaj. @e mnn`t`de,
9 v`njds wjrj sgdwe nur`eo tgj adursj. gj f`rst v`njd (mpprdx`hmtjky =7 h`eutjs kdeo) wmsrjkmtjn td fmt`ouj, men tgj sjaden v`njd (>? h`eutjs) fdrhjn tgj ims`s df tgj f`emk amsj stuny.Qjj ^mikj =9 fdr m adhpmr`sde df tgj AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10) rjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjets men tgj F`rst M`r`e`t`mk AYH adursj mttjenjn iy ^QI `evjst`omtdrs.
^gj `evjst`omt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj hmtjr`mk prjsjetjn nur`eo F`rst M`r‐s `e`t`mk AYH adursj,w`tg tgj jxajpt`de df tgj 9 amsj stun`js, dr`o`emtjn frdh ^A‐s ^S=1670J Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet trm`e`eo pmabmoj. F`rst M`r puragmsjn tgj ^A AYH trm`e`eo hmtjr`mk `e tgj jmrky9333s, men gms ijje us`eo tgmt hmtjr`mk s`eaj tgje fdr `ts `e`t`mk AYH adursj.
^mikj =9. Adhpmr`sde df AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10) AYH `e`t`mk trm`e`eo rjqu`rjhjets men F`rst M`r `e`t`mk AYHadursj
Yjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjet RAMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(m)) F`rst M`r `e`t`mk AYH adursj (31 Mpr`k 93=9)
Mtt`tunjs men ijgmv`durs Edt prjsjetjn
Adhhue`amt`des sb`kks Adhhue`amt`de
Srdikjh sdkv`eo Edt prjsjetjn
Guhme fmatdrs Guhme fmatdrs ‑ Fmt`ouj men strjss
Adefk`at rjsdkut`de Edt prjsjetjn
Nja`s`de hmb`eo Edt prjsjetjn
^jmh iu`kn`eo men hm`etjemeaj Kjmnjrsg`p men tjmh iu`kn`eo
Q`tumt`demk mwmrjejss (edt rjqu`rjn iy rjoukmt`de)
_drbkdmn hmemojhjet Edt prjsjetjn
Gdwjvjr, F`rst M`r ndjs edt mkkdamtj 9 nmys fdr tgj `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo, ms wms `etjenjn iy ^A.@e drnjr td hjjt dtgjr trm`e`eo rjqu`rjhjets, F`rst M`r‐s e`t`mk AYH adursj gms ijje rjnuajn tdm pdrt`de df = nmy. ^g`s prmat`aj gms ijje `e pkmaj fdr sjvjrmk yjmrs, men `s ades`stjet w`tg tgjdaaurrjeaj FD‐s trm`e`eo rjadrns, wg`ag sgdwjn tgmt gj rjaj`vjn trm`e`eo advjr`eo 1 dtgjrsuiljats de tgj smhj nmy ms g`s `e`t`mk AYH adursj. ^d rjhm`e w`tg`e tgj mkkdamtjn t`hj fdr
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 97/215
- 70 -
`e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo nur`eo tgj ejw-g`rj adursj, : df tgj suiljats rjqu`rjn iy AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)mrj edt tmuogt nur`eo F`rst M`r‐s `e`t`mk AYH adursj (^mikj =9).
Mktgduog tgj ^A AYH hmtjr`mk `s nmtjn, sjvjrmk adrj AYH sb`kks mrj mnnrjssjn iut wjrj edtprjsjetjn nur`eo F`rst M`r‐s `e`t`mk AYH adursj. @e pmrt`aukmr, tgj ‛Mtt`tunjs men Ijgmv`durs‘prjsjetmt`de n`saussjs mssjrt`vj ijgmv`dr men dffjrs m fdrhmt tgmt p`kdts ame usj td arjmtj me
mssjrt`vj stmtjhjet. gmt hdnukj mksd eakunjs = sk`nj tgmt ir`jfky dutk`ejs tgj SMAJ hdnjk. gj^A ‛Srdikjh Qdkv`eo men Nja`s`de Hmb`eo‘ hdnukj `eakunjs m nja`s`de-hmb`eo hdnjk menn`saussjs t`hj prjssurj men ts hpmat de wdrbkdmn. gj A ‛Adefk`at Yjsdkut`de‘ prjsjetmt`demnv`sjs tgmt mngjrjeaj td QDSs s dej wmy df prjvjet`eo adefk`at, men mnvdamtjs tgj usj df QDSstd rjsdkvj n`sarjpmea`js e tgj adabp`t. gj ‛_drbkdmn Hmemojhjet‘ prjsjetmt`de n`saussjs tgj`hpmat df wdrbkdmn de m fk`ogt arjw‐s mi`k`ty td mttjen td jev`rdehjetmk aujs, men t mnv`sjs tgmttgj fm`kurj td sgmrj `efdrhmt`de dr rjspden td equ`r`js men njv`mt`des frdh jstmik`sgjnprdajnurjs s m wmre`eo s`oe tgmt sdhjdej hmy ij mpprdmag`eo tmsb smturmt`de.
F`rst M`r‐s `e`t`mk AYH adursj `s tmuogt iy = df 9 orduen trm`e`eo `estruatdrs. Dej `estruatdrsjrvjs ms tgj pr`hmry AYH `estruatdr. ^gj dtgjr `en`v`numk adenuats `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo deky
wgje tgj pr`hmry `estruatdr `s edt mvm`kmikj. Idtg df tgj orduen trm`e`eo `estruatdrs mt F`rst M`rgmvj jxtjes`vj jxpjr`jeaj tjmag`eo tjage`amk adursjs td fk`ogt arjw men hm`etjemeaj pjrsdeejk.Ej`tgjr df tgj AYH estruatdrs gmn rjaj`vjn mey fdrhmk AYH fma`k`tmtdr/`estruatdr trm`e`eo drmaarjn`tmt`de td prdv`nj AYH trm`e`eo, edr wms t rjqu`rjn iy rjoukmt`de. Idtg estruatdrsnjhdestrmtjn m strdeo ijk`jf `e tgj vmkuj df AYH trm`e`eo ms m wmy df jegmea`eo dpjrmt`des mtF`rst M`r.
Nur`eo tgj e`t`mk AYH adursj mttjenjn iy tgj ^QI, pmrt`a`pmt`de frdh tgj adursj mttjenjjs wmsvjry kdw. gj `estruatdr hmnj sjvjrmk kdw-kjvjk fma`k`tmt`de =>9 mttjhpts td nrmw tgj ordup `etdtgj vmr`dus n`sauss`des, dftje iy msb`eo akdsjn-jenjn qujst`des. Njsp`tj g`s jffdrts, tgj`estruatdr jxpjr`jeajn n`ff`aukt`js ojtt`eo tgj mttjenjjs evdkvjn e tgj adursj, men tgj
n`sauss`de wms dftje hdvjn mkdeo iy tgj `estruatdr td mvd`n njkmy`eo tgj adursj.
=.=?.0.1 F`rst M`r rjaurrjet arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo
Ms njet`f`jn jmrk`jr e tgj rjpdrt, tgj rjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjets fdr rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo ndedt `njet`fy mey spja`f`a AYH suiljats tgmt hust ij tmuogt, men tgjrj `s ed rjqu`rjhjet tdrjv`jw mey df tgj AYH tdp`as advjrjn nur`eo `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo.
F`rst M`r‐s I?1? rjaurrjet ld`et AYH trm`e`eo `s njsar`ijn de pmoj 9:.13.6 df `ts FD^H (MKed. 1?, nmtjn 3= Mpr`k 9336). gj trm`e`eo t`hj mkkdamtjn s 9.9: gdurs fdr tgj AYH-rjkmtjnpdrt`de df tgj trm`e`eo, men medtgjr =.?: gdurs fdr tgj jvmaumt`de nr`kks. gj tdp`as njsar`ijnad`ea`nj w`tg tgj tjhs k`stjn uenjr AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(i).
Yjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r s typ`amkky ndej mt tgj vmr`dus adhpmey imsjs. _gjejvjrpdss`ikj, tgj pr`hmry AYH estruatdr tjmagjs tgj adursj. Gdwjvjr, dtgjr trm`e`eo p`kdts mt tgjrjhdtj imsjs w`kk rue rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo sjss`des f tgj pr`hmry AYH estruatdr s edtmvm`kmikj.
=>9 Qjj sjat`de =.=?.=3 fdr m njsar`pt`de df kdw-kjvjk fma`k`tmt`de.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 98/215
- 03 -
^gj QI mksd mttjenjn dej df F`rst M`r‐s rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo sjss`des mt tgj adhpmey‐s hm`eimsj `e Dttmwm. ^g`s sjss`de wms tmuogt iy tgj adhpmey‐s pr`hmry AYH `estruatdr, men wmspmrt df m fukk nmy df ld`et rjaurrjet trm`e`eo de ami`e jvmaumt`de, f`rjf`ogt`eo, AYH, etjrfjrjeajw`tg arjw hjhijrs, men ld`et sjaur`ty. F`vj M^Y->9 p`kdts men 1 fk`ogt mttjenmets pmrt`a`pmtjn`e tgj trm`e`eo.
^gj AYH trm`e`eo nurmt`de wms 9 gdurs ? h`eutjs, `eakun`eo m =:-h`eutj irjmb. ^dp`as ir`jfjn`eakunjn kjmnjrsg`p, tjmh iu`kn`eo, mtt`tunjs, adhhue`amt`de, nja`s`de hmb`eo, ordup aukturj,QDSs, men m amsj stuny df m F`rst M`r M^Y->9 daaurrjeaj. Nurmt`de mkkdamtjn td jmag tdp`armeojn frdh : td =: h`eutjs. QDSs wjrj njsar`ijn ms m hjmes td `njet`fy rdkjs, trmp jrrdrs menou`nj ordup pjrfdrhmeaj. ^gjy mrj mksd usjn ms m sduraj df stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy td jk`h`emtjh`sadhhue`amt`de men h`e`h`zj h`suenjrstmen`eo.
Zek`bj tgj e`t`mk AYH adursj adetjet, wg`ag nmtjs imab td tgj h`n-=003s, sdhj df tgj hmtjr`mkadvjrjn nur`eo tgj rjaurrjet AYH adursj eakunjn jkjhjets df hdrj rjajet ojejrmt`des dfAYH trm`e`eo, suag ms tgrjmt-men-jrrdr hmemojhjet adeajpts.
=.=?.=3 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo fma`k`tmt`de
@t s w`njky maajptjn tgmt tgj jffjat`vjejss df AYH trm`e`eo s kmrojky njpjenjet de tgj qumk`tydf tgj njk`vjry, men tgmt tgj usj df g`og-kjvjk fma`k`tmt`de `s dej df tgj bjys td tgj suaajss dfAYH trm`e`eo. =>1 Fma`k`tmt`de n`ffjrs frdh trmn`t`demk ‛`estruat`de‘ e tgmt fma`k`tmt`de s mtjage`quj ‛tgmt gjkps trm`ejjs td n`sadvjr fdr tgjhsjkvjs wgmt s mpprdpr`mtj men jffjat`vj, etgj adetjxt df tgj`r dwe jxpjr`jeaj men a`rauhstmeajs.‘ =>>
Fma`k`tmt`de s dftje njsar`ijn e tjrhs df g`og, hjn`uh, men kdw. G`og-kjvjk fma`k`tmt`de sjjs tgj`estruatdr s`hpky ou`n`eo tgj pmrt`a`pmets tgrduog tgj kjmre`eo prdajss. ^g`s ou`nmeaj `styp`amkky ndej us`eo dpje-jenjn qujst`des, jeadurmo`eo n`sauss`de, men mvd`n`eo meswjr`eoydur dwe qujst`des dr hdv`eo mkdeo tdd qu`abky. Mt kdwjr kjvjks df fma`k`tmt`de, tgj estruatdrhmbjs usj df spja`f`a qujst`des td try men ojt pmrt`a`pmet evdkvjhjet. Kdw-kjvjk fma`k`tmt`dewdukn ij agmrmatjr`zjn iy akdsj-jenjn qujst`des, s`eaj tgjsj nd edt emturmkky jeadurmojmnn`t`demk n`sauss`de men/dr dp`e`de.
@t hmy ij ejajssmry td pjr`dn`amkky jhpkdy kdw-kjvjk fma`k`tmt`de tgrduogdut m AYH adursj tdbjjp tg`eos hdv`eo. Gdwjvjr, jvjry jffdrt sgdukn ij hmnj td rjture td tgj g`ogjst kjvjk dffma`k`tmt`de pdss`ikj mt tgj jmrk`jst dppdrtue`ty sd tgmt stunjets ame adet`euj td kjmre tgrduogtgj`r dwe memkys`s men n`sauss`de. Fma`k`tmt`de sb`kks mrj edt jmsy td hmstjr, men k`bj hmey dtgjrsb`kks, tgjy rjqu`rj prmat`aj men fjjnimab.
=>1 Ze`tjn B`eondh A`v`k Mv`mt`de Mutgdr`ty (AMM), AMS ?1?< Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet (AYH)^rm`e`eo< Ou`nmeaj fdr Fk`ogt Arjw, AYH @estruatdrs men AYH @estruatdr-Jxmh`ejrs ( 9336)
=>> @i`n.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 99/215
- 0= -
=.=?.== Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet `estruatdr maarjn`tmt`de
@e Amemnm, AYH estruatdrs mrj edt rjqu`rjn td uenjrod mey maarjn`tmt`de prdajss, iut mrjsuiljat td AMQQ ?9:.=9>(>), wg`ag spja`f`js ojejrmk stmenmrns fdr trm`e`eo pjrsdeejk. QI`evjst`omt`de M30M33=6 njet`f`jn tgmt tgj misjeaj df AYH estruatdr maarjn`tmt`de pdsjs m r`sbtgmt fk`ogt arjws w`kk edt ij trm`ejn e tgj kmtjst AYH tjage`qujs.
Ms m hjmes df jesur`eo me maajptmikj stmenmrn fdr AYH `estruat`de men jvmkumt`de, tgj Ze`tjnB`eondh A`v`k Mv`mt`de Mutgdr`ty (AMM) gms jstmik`sgjn m sjr`js df str`eojet maarjn`tmt`derjqu`rjhjets fdr AYH estruatdrs (AYH@s) men fdr AYH estruatdr jxmh`ejrs (AYH@Js). =>: ^gjmaarjn`tmt`de prdajss ades`sts df m h`e`huh jxpjr`jeaj rjqu`rjhjet, adhpkjt`de df mempprdvjn AYH@ adursj, men m prmat`amk jvmkumt`de df me en`v`numk‐s bedwkjnoj men sb`kk td`estruat dr jvmkumtj AYH ijfdrj tgjy mrj pjrh`ttjn td amrry dut tgdsj nut`js. Ms pmrt df tgjmaarjn`tmt`de prdajss, qumk`f`jn AYH@s men AYH@Js hust rjejw tgj`r qumk`f`amt`de jvjry 1yjmrs e drnjr td adet`euj e tgdsj rdkjs. g`s rjejwmk s ndej td jesurj tgmt AYH@s menAYH@Js adet`euj td hjjt tgj rjqu`rjn stmenmrn ms AYH trm`e`eo adet`eujs td jvdkvj.
@e Amemnm, tgjrj mrj ed jxpjr`jeaj, trm`e`eo dr qumk`f`amt`de rjqu`rjhjets ejjnjn td tjmag AYH.^gj AYH fdaus ordup tgmt suih`ttjn rjadhhjenmt`des td tgj AMYA `e 93=9 (sjat`de =.=?.?.9)ades`njrjn tgj ssuj df AYH estruatdr qumk`f`amt`des men maarjn`tmt`de. gj ordup‐s mssjsshjetwms tgmt njf`e`eo men hpkjhjet`eo qumk`f`amt`des men maarjn`tmt`de ar`tjr`m fdr AYH`estruatdrs e Amemnm wdukn ij jxtrjhjky adhpkjx, ijamusj jmag sjatdr df tgj `enustry gms tsdwe ue`quj njhmens men gmzmrns. @t wms lunojn td ij ijyden tgj ampma`ty df ^A td njvjkdpmen hpkjhjet me maarjn`tmt`de sagjhj tgmt wdukn ij jffjat`vj men maajptmikj td ?39, ?31, ?3>,men ?3: dpjrmtdrs men fk`ogt arjw. gj AMYA maajptjn tgj fdaus ordup rjadhhjenmt`de tgmtAYH estruatdr maarjn`tmt`de edt ij pursujn.
=.=7 Mnn`t`demk `efdrhmt`de
=.=7.= Ijgmv`durmk i`msjs
@e tgj`r mrt`akj, ‛Srjss`eo tgj Mpprdmag‘, Ijrhme men N`shubjs en`amtj tgmt guhmes mrjsuiljat td i`msjs tgmt ame `efkujeaj fk`ogt arjw lunohjet men nja`s`de hmb`eo. =>6 ^gj mrt`akjn`saussjn tgj jffjats df pkme adet`eumt`de i`ms men jxpjatmt`de i`ms.
Skme adet`eumt`de i`ms s njsar`ijn ms m ‛njjp-rddtjn tjenjeay df en`v`numks td adet`euj tgj`rdr`o`emk pkme df mat`de jvje wgje agmeo`eo a`rauhstmeajs rjqu`rj m ejw pkme.‘ ^gj mutgdrs‐memkys`s suoojstjn tgmt tg`s i`ms ‛rjsukts frdh tgj etjrmat`de df 1 hmldr adhpdejets<sda`mk/drome`zmt`demk efkujeajs, tgj egjrjet agmrmatjr`st`as men k`h`tmt`des df guhme
adoe`t`de, men `eadhpkjtj dr mhi`oudus `efdrhmt`de.‛
=>: Ze`tjn B`eondh A`v`k Mv`mt`de Mutgdr`ty (AMM), Qtmenmrns Ndauhjet ed. 90, vjrs`de > ∙ ^gj ArjwYjsduraj Hmemojhjet @estruatdr (AYH@) men Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet @estruatdr Jxmh`ejr (AYH@J) Maarjn`tmt`de Frmhjwdrb (9330)
=>6 Ijelmh`e M. Ijrhme men Y. Bjy N`shubjs, ‛Srjss`eo tgj Mpprdmag,‘ Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de,
Mv`mt`de Qmfjty _drkn (Njajhijr 9336)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 100/215
- 09 -
Jxpjatmt`de i`ms s njsar`ijn iy tgj mutgdrs ms fdkkdws< =>?
… wgje sdhjdej jxpjats dej s`tumt`de, gj dr sgj s kjss k`bjky td edt`aj aujs`en`amt`eo tgmt tgj s`tumt`de `s edt qu`tj wgmt `t sjjhs… Jxpjatmt`de i`ms `swdrsjejn wgje arjws mrj rjqu`rjn td etjormtj ejw efdrhmt`de tgmt mrr`vjsp`jajhjmk dvjr t`hj e eadhpkjtj, sdhjt`hjs mhi`oudus, frmohjets.
=.=7.9 ^jrrm`e mwmrjejss njv`ajs
=.=7.9.= Orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh
M orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh (OS_Q) prdv`njs m wmre`eo td tgj fk`ogt arjw wgje tgjmjrdpkmej s e pdtjet`mkky gmzmrndus prdx`h`ty td tgj jmrtg‐s surfmaj. OS_Q wms etrdnuajn etgj =0?3s ms m hjmes td adhimt tgj g`og ea`njeaj df adetrdkkjn fk`ogt etd tjrrm`e (AF@^)maa`njets men ejmr-maa`njets.
Jmrky OS_Q usjn gj`ogt midvj orduen (hjmsurjn iy tgj rmn`d mkt`hjtjr) men rmtj df akdsurj tdnjtjrh`ej wgje tgj m`rarmft wms e m pdtjet`mkky gmzmrndus s`tumt`de. Quisjqujet
`hprdvjhjets eadrpdrmtjn mjrdpkmej adef`ourmt`de (j.o., kmen`eo ojmr stmtus) men estruhjetkmen`eo systjh (@KQ) ok`njskdpj njv`mt`de. Ijamusj tgj rmn`d mkt`hjtjr ndjs edt kddb mgjmn, tg`sjmrky-ojejrmt`de OS_Q s uemikj td prjn`at m sunnje agmeoj e tjrrm`e (fdr jxmhpkj, wgjehjjt`eo stjjpky r`s`eo orduen).
Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY) 63:.1?(=) rjqu`rjs mkk turid-ljt-pdwjrjn mjrdpkmejs w`tg mwj`ogt df hdrj tgme =: 333 bo (11 360 pduens) men fdr wg`ag m typj ajrt`f`amtj gms ijje `ssujnmutgdr`z`eo tgj trmespdrt df =3 dr hdrj pmssjeojrs, td ij jqu`ppjn w`tg m OS_Q.
@e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj rjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjet, A-OE_E wms jqu`ppjn w`tg m OS_Q msnjsar`ijn e sjat`de =.6.1.
=.=7.9.9 @etrdnuat`de df jegmeajn orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh
@e =00=, Gdejywjkk etrdnuajn ts jegmeajn orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh (JOS_Q),wg`ag wms njvjkdpjn e drnjr td dvjradhj tgj midvj k`h`tmt`de. g`s systjh adhi`ejs maaurmtjpds`t`demk bedwkjnoj (edrhmkky njtjrh`ejn frdh OSQ) w`tg m prja`sj 1-n`hjes`demk hmp df tgjtjrrm`e, td kddb mgjmn df tgj m`rarmft ms wjkk ms ndwewmrn. g`s adef`ourmt`de ojejrmtjswmre`eos td tgj p`kdt f ajrtm`e pmrmhjtjrs mrj irjmagjn. g`s ojejrmt`de df tjrrm`e mwmrjejssjqu`phjet prdv`njs me murmk ms wjkk ms v`sumk wmre`eo df tgj tjrrm`e `e frdet df tgj m`rarmft. Mhmp n`spkmy sgdw`eo tgj mpprdmag`eo tjrrm`e agmeojs frdh orjje td mhijr td rjn ms tgj m`rarmftojts prdorjss`vjky akdsjr td distmakjs (F`ourj ==).
^gj hmp n`spkmy edt deky prjsjets tgj arjw w`tg efdrhmt`de rjomrn`eo tgj tjrrm`e jkjvmt`demkdeo tgj fk`ogt pmtg, iut mksd prdv`njs mnn`t`demk s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss ms td m`rarmft pds`t`derjkmt`vj td distmakjs men tgj `etjenjn fk`ogt pmtg. @hprdvjhjets e tgj sdurajs df efdrhmt`deusjn td amkaukmtj men prjn`at orduen prdx`h`ty gmvj rjsuktjn e jmrk`jr wmre`eo edt`ajs men
=>? @i`n.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 101/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 102/215
- 0> -
RtXgj Njpmrthjet df rmespdrt rjqu`rj tgj estmkkmt`de df OS_Q de mkk turi`ej-pdwjrjn, @FY-mpprdvjn, adhhutjr men m`rk`ej m`rarmft ampmikj df amrry`eo =3 drhdrj pmssjeojrs.
Q`eaj tgj ssumeaj df ^QI Yjadhhjenmt`de M0:-=3, suaajss`vj mat`de iy rmespdrt Amemnm (^A)aukh`emtjn w`tg rjoukmtdry mhjenhjets, wg`ag amhj etd fdraj de 3> Luky 93=9, wgje tgjy
wjrj puik`sgjn `e tgj Amemnm Omzjttj, Smrt 9, Vdkuhj =>6, ed. =>< =:=
^gjsj rjoukmtdry mhjenhjets etrdnuaj rjqu`rjhjets fdr tgj `estmkkmt`de df^jrrm`e Mwmrjejss _mre`eo Qystjhs (^M_Q) jqu`ppjn w`tg me JegmeajnMkt`tunj Maaurmay (JMM) fueat`de e pr`vmtj turi`ej-pdwjrjn mjrdpkmejsadef`ourjn w`tg s`x dr hdrj pmssjeojr sjmts, jxakun`eo p`kdt sjmts, men eadhhjra`mk mjrdpkmejs adef`ourjn w`tg s`x dr hdrj pmssjeojr sjmts, jxakun`eop`kdt sjmts. Dpjrmtdrs w`kk gmvj twd yjmrs frdh tgj nmtj de wg`ag tgjYjoukmt`des adhj etd fdraj td jqu`p tgj`r mjrdpkmejs w`tg M_Q men f`vj yjmrstd jqu`p tgjh w`tg JMM.
^gj QI njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj rjoukmtdry mhjenhjet irduogt fdrwmrn iy A jxajjns tgj ar`tjr`m
df tg`s rjadhhjenmt`de, men w`kk suistmet`mkky rjnuaj tgj smfjty njf`a`jeay njet`f`jn eYjadhhjenmt`de M0:-=3. De 3: Qjptjhijr 93=9, tgj QI amtjodr`zjn tgj rjspdesj td tgjrjadhhjenmt`de ms Fukky Qmt`sfmatdry.
=.=7.1 ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn _mtagk`st
^g`s wms m AF@^ maa`njet, dej df tgj `tjhs de tgj ^QI _mtagk`st. ^gj _mtagk`st `s m k`st dftrmespdrtmt`de smfjty `ssujs tgmt pdsj tgj orjmtjst r`sb td Amemn`mes. @e jmag amsj, mat`des tmbjetd nmtj gmvj ijje `emnjqumtj, men adearjtj stjps hust ij tmbje de tgj pmrt df `enustry men tgjrjoukmtdr td jk`h`emtj tgjsj r`sbs.
^gj ^QI gms `evjst`omtjn euhjrdus adkk`s`des w`tg kmen men wmtjr, men gms `njet`f`jnnjf`a`jea`js, hmnj f`en`eos, men ssujn rjadhhjenmt`des td furtgjr rjnuaj AF@^ maa`njets.Adkk`s`des w`tg kmen men wmtjr maaduet fdr :% df maa`njets, iut ejmrky 9:% df mkk fmtmk`t`js.Ijtwjje 9333 men 9330, tgjrj wjrj =90 maa`njets df tg`s typj `e Amemnm, rjsukt`eo `e =97fmtmk`t`js. Q`eaj tgj QI f`rst pkmajn tg`s ssuj de ts _mtagk`st, tgj euhijr df maa`njets df tg`stypj jvjry yjmr gms edt odej ndwe. @e 93=3, tgjrj wjrj =12 `e 93==, tgjrj wjrj =>.
=.=7.> Qmfjty hmemojhjet systjhs
@hpkjhjetjn prdpjrky, smfjty hmemojhjet systjhs (QHQs) mkkdw mv`mt`de adhpme`js td`njet`fy gmzmrns, hmemoj r`sbs, men njvjkdp men fdkkdw jffjat`vj smfjty prdajssjs. Amemnm‐s
kmroj adhhjra`mk amrr`jrs gmvj ijje rjqu`rjn td gmvj me QHQ s`eaj 933:.
=:= Amemnm Omzjttj, Smrt 9, Vdkuhj =>6, ed. => (3> Luky 93=9), Yjoukmt`des Mhjen`eo tgj Amemn`meMv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (Smrts @, V@ men V@@), mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.omzjttj.oa.am/rp-pr/p9/93=9/93=9-3?-3>/gthk/sdr-ndrs=16-jeo.gthk (mrag`vjn adetjet2 kmst maajssjn =9 Njajhijr93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 103/215
- 0: -
^gj trmes`t`de td QHQ gms prdvjn td ij agmkkjeo`eo. Yjajet `evjst`omt`des iy tgj ^QI gmvjg`ogk`ogtjn n`ff`aukt js fmajn iy dpjrmtdrs e hmb`eo tgj trmes`t`de frdh trmn`t`demk smfjtyhmemojhjet td QHQ. =:9
=:9 ^QI mv`mt`de evjst`omt`de rjpdrts M==M331:, M==D331=, M==F33=9, M30M33=6 men M3?M3=1>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 104/215
- 06 -
9.3 Memkys`s
9.= @etrdnuat`de
Imsjn de mvm`kmikj rjadrns, tgj p`kdts wjrj ajrt`f`jn men qumk`f`jn fdr tgj fk`ogt `e maadrnmeaj
w`tg jx`st`eo rjoukmt`des. ^gj `evjst`omt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgjrj wms edtg`eo td `en`amtj tgmttgj pjrfdrhmeaj df tgj amptm`e dr tgj f`rst dff`ajr (FD) wms njormnjn iy fmt`ouj dr pgys`dkdo`amkfmatdrs.
De tg`s fk`ogt, tgj kdamk`zjr wms edt ampturjn, men tgj fk`ogt adet`eujn de m gjmn`eo tgmtprdorjss`vjky njv`mtjn td tgj r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr. Ms tgj m`rarmft njv`mtjn td tgj r`ogt, njsp`tj`estruhjet en`amt`des tgmt tgj fk`ogt wms suistmet`mkky dff tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej men m euhijrdf mttjhpts iy tgj FD td adhhue`amtj tgj gmzmrn, tgj amptm`e adet`eujn tgj mpprdmag.Mnn`t`demkky, tgj mpprdmag wms uestmikj e sjvjrmk pmrmhjtjrs, men tgj fk`ogt adet`eujn ijydentgj pd`et mt wg`ag m od-mrduen sgdukn gmvj ijje adenuatjn e maadrnmeaj w`tg adhpmeypdk`ay. M orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh (OS_Q) wmre`eo prdhptjn tgj arjw td `e`t`mtj m
od-mrduen, iut tg`s mat`de wms `e`t`mtjn tdd kmtj td mvd`n `hpmat w`tg tjrrm`e.
^g`s memkys`s w`kk fdaus de tgj fdkkdw`eo<
• _gy tgj m`rarmft n`n edt ampturj tgj kdamk`zjr men ok`njskdpj2
• ^gj jffjat df adhpmss jrrdrs2
• M`rarmft emv`omt`demk jqu`phjet2
• _gy tgj amptm`e ijk`jvjn tgmt tgj m`rarmft gmn ampturjn tgj kdamk`zjr2
• _gy tgj arjw wjrj uemikj td rjadea`kj tgj`r n`ffjr`eo mwmrjejss df tgj s`tumt`de2
• _gy tgj amptm`e adet`eujn tgj mpprdmag2 men• Mnmptmt`des df QDSs.
9.9 FMI6:63 mpprdmag pkmee`eo
Mftjr F`rst M`r fk`ogt 6:63 (FMI6:63) gmn njpmrtjn frdh Pjkkdwbe`fj (AP\F), tgj aj`k`eo menv`s`i`k`ty mt Yjsdkutj Imy (APYI) gmn fkuatumtjn ms kdw ms 933 fjjt men ¸ stmtutj h`kj (sh),mktgduog tgj =633 wjmtgjr disjrvmt`de rjpdrtjn =3 h`kjs v`s`i`k`ty men dvjramst aj`k`eo mt ?33fjjt. gj w`en wms frdh tgj sdutg, fmvdur`eo Yuewmy =?^. gj wjmtgjr aden`t`des mt APYInur`eo tgj mrr`vmk df FMI6:63 wjrj suag tgmt m v`sumk mpprdmag wms edt pdss`ikj men me`estruhjet mpprdmag wms rjqu`rjn.
Amrry`eo dut me mpprdmag td Yuewmy =?^ wdukn tmbj hdrj t`hj men fujk, ms wjkk ms rjqu`r`eo mede-prja`s`de mpprdmag rmtgjr tgme me `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) mpprdmag. gj tm`kw`enwms w`tg`e m`rarmft k`h`tmt`des, men tgj @KQ Yuewmy 1: ruj (1:^) wdukn smvj t`hj men fujkw`tg m strm`ogt-`e mpprdmag. Furtgjrhdrj, tgj @KQ s m prja`s`de mpprdmag, wg`ag evdkvjs kdwjrr`sb men kjss wdrbkdmn tgme m ede-prja`s`de mpprdmag. gj strm`ogt-`e @KQ 1:^ prdv`njn hmeyijejf`ts, w`tg deky me e-k`h`ts tm`kw`en ms m ejomt`vj fmatdr.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 105/215
- 0? -
Ijfdrj adhhjea`eo njsajet, tgj amptm`e mnv`sjn tgj FD tgmt gj pkmeejn td usj mrjm emv`omt`de(YEMV) =:1 td emv`omtj td tgj kdamk`zjr men tgje sw`tag frdh okdimk pds`t`de`eo systjh (OSQ) tdVGF EMV (vjry g`og frjqujeay emv`omt`de). gj evjst`omt`de njtjrh`ejn tgmt tgj pkme tdtrmes`t`de frdh je-rdutj emv`omt`de td mpprdmag ame ij etjrprjtjn e 9 n`ffjrjet wmys.
F`rst, tgj amptm`e hmy gmvj `etjenjn td jhpkdy m ede-stmenmrn hjtgdn td usj tgj OSQ td mk`oetgj m`rarmft w`tg tgj kdamk`zjr de f`emk mpprdmag, men tgje sw`tag td VGF EMV. Qjaden, tgjamptm`e hmy gmvj etjenjn td usj tgj OSQ td emv`omtj td m pd`et lust ijfdrj HZQM^ wmypd`et,wgjrj tgj sw`tag td VGF EMV wdukn daaur.
Mktgduog tgj amptm`e‐s mpprdmag ir`jf`eo prdv`njn efdrhmt`de ms td mpprdmag spjjns mensdhj h`e`huh mkt`tunjs, tgj ir`jf`eo n`n edt eakunj efdrhmt`de rjomrn`eo tgj `etjenjnemv-m`n adef`ourmt`de nur`eo tgj mpprdmag dr h`e`huh smfj mkt`tunjs nur`eo tgj mrr`vmk pgmsj.^gj amptm`e‐s mpprdmag ir`jf`eo wms ede-stmenmrn men eadhpkjtj.
^gj adesjqujeaj df me miirjv`mtjn mpprdmag ir`jf`eo `s tgmt m arjw hmy edt ij mnjqumtjky
prjpmrjn fdr tgj mpprdmag. Mnn`t`demkky, dej df tgj hm`e purpdsjs df ir`jf`eos s td jesurj tgmtidtg p`kdts gmvj tgj smhj jxpjatmt`des men fduenmt`de fdr sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss.
9.1 Njsajet `e`t`mt`de men hmemojhjet
Mt midut =:3 h`kjs td APYI, ijfdrj adhhjea`eo njsajet, tgj FD pd`etjn dut td tgj amptm`e tgmttgj`r orduen spjjn wms g`og. gj g`og orduen spjjn wms nuj td tgj tm`kw`en adhpdejet mtaru`s`eo mkt`tunj.
^gj amptm`e en`amtjn tgmt gj wdukn adhhjeaj njsajet mt =3: emut`amk h`kjs (eh) frdh APYI.^g`s adhhue`amt`de `en`amtjs tgmt tgj amptm`e wms mwmrj df tgj jffjat df tgj tm`kw`en men gmn
ades`njrjn `t `e g`s njsajet pkmee`eo (=33 eh w`tg zjrd w`en mt tdp df njsajet R^DNX, pkus madrrjat`de fdr w`en). Gdwjvjr, tgj :-eh adrrjat`de tgmt tgj amptm`e gmn mppk`jn wms kjss tgmetgj =?-eh mnlusthjet matumkky rjqu`rjn td adhpjesmtj fdr tgj 61-bedt tm`kw`en.
Mt =699<=6, tgj FD rjqujstjn njsajet akjmrmeaj. Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj m`rarmft wms midut ==9 eh frdhtduagndwe mt APYI. gj njsajet akjmrmeaj wms ssujn mt =691<90, mt wg`ag t`hj tgj m`rarmft wmsmidut =31 eh frdh tduagndwe. Njsajet ijome mt =691<>3 men =3= eh frdh tduagndwe, akdsjrtd APYI tgme tgj amptm`e gmn pkmeejn fdr men =6 eh akdsjr tgme rjqu`rjn fdr tgj w`en.
Zet`k adhhjea`eo njsajet, tgj mutdp`kdt p`tag hdnj sjkjatdr wms k`bjky e MK^ GDKN (mkt`tunjgdkn) td hm`etm`e tgj aru`sj mkt`tunj. d e`t`mtj njsajet, tgj amptm`e wdukn gmvj sjkjatjn tgj
mutdp`kdt p`tag hdnj sjkjatdr td DFF. ^gj mutdp`kdt p`tag agmeejk wdukn tgje dpjrmtj `e hmeumkp`tag A_Q (adetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eo) mt tgj kdw njtjet (: pduens). @e tg`s hdnj, tgj mutdp`kdtwdukn hm`etm`e tgj p`tag mtt`tunj sjt iy tgj p`kdt us`eo tgj adetrdk adkuhe.
=:1 ^gj amptm`e‐s hjet`de df YEMV hpk`js tgj usj df tgj ^r`hikj EK-7=33 OSQ `estmkkjn `e A-OE_E.Furtgjr n`sauss`de w`kk rjfjr td OSQ.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 106/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 107/215
- 00 -
^gj evjst`omt`de ades`njrjn wgjtgjr tgj adhpmss adetrdkkjrs wjrj sjt td hmoejt`a (HMO),ijamusj dpjrmt`de e HMO wdukn rjsukt e s`oe`f`amet gjmn`eo agmeojs ijamusj df tgjprdx`h`ty df tgj hmoejt`a edrtg pdkj td tgj trmab df FMI6:63. Ymnmr nmtm sgdw tgmt FMI6:63wms trmab`eo 31?³^ wgje tgj arjw rj-skmvjn tgj adhpmssjs mt =69:<3?. Amkaukmt des wjrj ndejtd njtjrh`ej tgj k`bjky sjtt`eo df tgj adhpmss adetrdkkjrs imsjn de tgj rjadrnjn adhpmss
gjmn`eo, rmnmr nmtm, men w`en nr`ft. ^gj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo s edt adeorujet w`tg tgj adhpmssadetrdkkjrs ij`eo sjt td HMO.
^gj fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr (FNY) nmtm sgdw deky tgj dej `estmeaj df adhpmss mnlusthjet, mt=69:<3?. Mt midut tgj smhj t`hj, nur`eo tgj prj-njsajet agjab, idtg p`kdts rjspdenjn w`tg‛NO‘ (`.j., n`rjat`demk oyrd) td tgj adhpmss agmkkjeoj. @t `s k`bjky tgmt tgj p`kdts sjkjatjn tgjsw`tag de idtg adhpmss adetrdkkjrs td tgj NO pds`t`de wgje tgj adhpmssjs wjrj e`t`mkkysw`tagjn frdh HMO td NO mt me uenjtjrh`ejn t`hj, ijfdrj tgj adhhjeajhjet df vmk`n FNYnmtm mt =>:7<:?.:.
9.>.1 Adhpmss adetrdkkjrs gjh`spgjrj sjkjat`de
_g`kj dpjrmt`eo e NO, emnvjrtjet sjkjat`de df tgj gjh`spgjrj sw`tag de dej adetrdkkjr td Emen de tgj dtgjr adetrdkkjr td Q wdukn rjsukt e tgj 9 adhpmssjs njvjkdp`eo m s`oe`f`ametgjmn`eo n`ffjrjeaj fm`rky qu`abky. Quag m gjmn`eo n`ffjrjeaj wdukn mksd qu`abky tr`oojr tgjgjmn`eo adhpmrmtdr. Ijamusj tgjrj wms ed n`sauss`de ijtwjje tgj p`kdts midut tgj adhpmrmtdr,`t `s k`bjky tgmt idtg gjh`spgjrj sw`tagjs wjrj sjt td tgj smhj pds`t`de.
F`rst M`r m`rarmft dpjrmtj e tgj edrtgjre gjh`spgjrj2 adesjqujetky, njk`ijrmtj sjkjat`de df Q detgj gjh`spgjrj sw`tag s jxtrjhjky uek`bjky. gjrjfdrj, t s vjry k`bjky tgmt idtg gjh`spgjrjsw`tagjs wjrj sjt td E.
9.>.>
Adhpmss adetrdkkjr kmt`tunj adhpjesmtdrs^gj adhpmssjs wjrj rjqu`rjn td ij sjt td NO wgje FMI6:63 jetjrjn tgj Edrtgjre Ndhjst`aM`rspmaj mt Y@IZE wmypd`et. _g`kj tgj evjst`omt`de adukn edt njtjrh`ej wgje tgj adhpmssjswjrj sjt td NO, furtgjr n`sauss`de w`kk ij imsjn de tgj prjh`sj tgmt `t daaurrjn mt Y@IZE.
FMI6:63 ardssjn idtg kmt`tunjs 66³ E men 67³ E ijfdrj rjmag`eo Amhir`noj Imy (AI). gjadhpmss adetrdkkjr kmt`tunj adhpjesmtdrs wjrj fduen sjt mt 67³ (ed. =) men 66³ (ed. 9). _g`kjpgys`amk jxmh`emt`de adukn edt njtjrh`ej tgj pds`t`de df tgj kmt`tunj adhpjesmtdrs mt hpmat,tgj`r pds`t`des ms fduen mrj rjmsdemikj o`vje tgj trmab df fk`ogt FMI6:63 men tgj adhpmey‐sdpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs men prmat`ajs. @t s k`bjky tgmt tgjsj sjtt`eos wjrj hmnj iy tgj FMI6:63arjw.
9.>.: Yjmk prjajss`de
O`vje tgj gjmn`eo agmeoj rmtjs rjadrnjn w`tg tgj w`eos kjvjk, t s k`bjky tgmt tgj gjmn`eoadhpmrmtdr wdukn gmvj kkuh`emtjn f dej NO gmn jxajss`vj rjmk prjajss`de. Gdwjvjr, tgjp`kdts n`n edt hjet`de dr n`sauss kkuh`emt`de df m gjmn`eo adhpmrmtdr. @t s vjry uek`bjky tgmtidtg NOs wdukn s`huktmejdusky jxpjr`jeaj rjmk prjajss`de df tgj smhj hmoe`tunj menn`rjat`de, tgjrjiy prjvjet`eo tgj adhpmrmtdr tgrjsgdkn frdh ij`eo jxajjnjn. gjrjfdrj, t s
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 108/215
- =33 -
ades`njrjn uek`bjky tgmt rjmk prjajss`de wms tgj sdkj amusj df tgj gjmn`eo nr`ft njet`f`jn e tgjFMI6:63 FNY nmtm. @t s hpdss`ikj td sdkmtj rjmk prjajss`de frdh mppmrjet prjajss`de e tgjrjadrnjn gjmn`eo nmtm2 tgjrjfdrj, furtgjr memkys`s w`kk ij imsjn de tgj prjh`sj tgmt tgj rjmkprjajss`de n`n edt jxajjn tgj ½=³ pjr-gdur tdkjrmeaj.
9.>.6 Jmrtg rmtj prjajss`de
_`tg tgj ed. 9 adhpmss adetrdkkjr sjt td NO men 66³ E kmt`tunj, tdrquj wdukn gmvj ijje mppk`jntd tgj ed. 9 NO td adrrjat fdr jmrtg rmtj mt 66³ E. Gdwjvjr, sdhj rjs`numk jmrtg rmtj (`.j.,n`ffjrjeaj ijtwjje jmrtg rmtj mt tgj aurrjet kmt`tunj men jmrtg rmtj mt tgj kmt`tunj sjkjatjn)wdukn jx`st. ^gj jffjat df jmrtg rmtj wms jxmh`ejn fdr 9 pjr`dns< =>:7<:?.: td =:>7<9:(adhhjeajhjet df vmk`n nmtm uet`k ture mt AI) men =:>0<=1 td =6=9<33 (ture mt AI uet`k ture mt?9³ E, =33³>:' _).
Nur`eo tgj 9 pjr`dns jxmh`ejn, wg`ag jxg`i`tjn rjadrnjn gjmn`eo nr`ft df 9:³ pjr gdur, tgjrjs`numk jmrtg rmtj vmr`jn frdh ∙3.:>³ pjr gdur td 3.99³ pjr gdur. @t `s vjry uek`bjky tgmtueadrrjatjn jmrtg rmtj prjajss`de wms tgj sdkj amusj df tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo nr`ft.
9.>.? Jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj prjajss`de
^gj A-==I adhpmss systjh ndjs edt eadrpdrmtj mey hjmes td adrrjat fdr jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj.^gj jffjat df jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj wms jxmh`ejn fdr 9 pjr`dns< =>:7<:?.: td =:>7<9: men =:>0<=1 td=6=9<33.
Nur`eo tgj 9 pjr`dns jxmh`ejn, wg`ag jxg`i`tjn rjadrnjn gjmn`eo nr`ft df 9:³ pjr gdur, tgjrjs`numk jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj vmr`jn frdh ∙7.:=³ pjr gdur td ∙0.1>³ pjr gdur. @t `s vjry uek`bjkytgmt ueadrrjatjn jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj prjajss`de wms tgj sdkj amusj df tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eonr`ft.
9.>.7 Srjajss`de suhhmry
^gj suh df tgj hmx`huh vmkujs n`saussjn midvj fdr rjmk prjajss`de (=³ pjr gdur), rjs`numkjmrtg rmtj (3.:>³ pjr gdur), men ueadrrjatjn jmrtg trmespdrt rmtj (0.1>³ pjr gdur) `s =3.77³ pjrgdur. Gdwjvjr, nur`eo tgj 9 pjr`dns n`saussjn midvj, tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo frdh tgj ed. 9adhpmss nr`ftjn mt 9:³ pjr gdur. gjrjfdrj, tgj rjadrnjn ed. 9 adhpmss nr`ft n`ffjrs suistmet mkkyfrdh tdtmk amkaukmtjn prjajss`de. gj n`ffjr`eo n`rjat`de men hmoe`tunj df tgj gjmn`eo nr`ftdisjrvjn, e adelueat`de w`tg tgj euhijr df tures hmnj iy tgj m`rarmft, hmbjs t hpdss`ikj tdnrmw adeakus`des rjomrn`eo tgj jffjat df rjmk men mppmrjet prjajss`de de tgj adhpmss systjhsnur`eo tgj f`emk =? h`eutjs df tgj fk`ogt.
9.>.0 Ed. = men ed. 9 adhpmss systjhs ijgmv`dur
Ijamusj df tgj misjeaj df mey p`kdt n`sauss`de midut tgj gjmn`eo adhpmrmtdr, t wms jmrk`jradeakunjn tgmt tgj hmx`huh gjmn`eo n`ffjrjeaj ijtwjje tgj adhpmss systjhs nur`eo fk`ogtk`bjky n`n edt jxajjn 7³ w`tg w`eos kjvjk. ^g`s hjmes tgmt idtg adhpmss systjhs wjrj `emorjjhjet w`tg`e adhpmrmtdr tdkjrmeajs, men wdukn gmvj ijje sd jvje nur`eo tgj pjr`dn wgjetgj rjadrnjn ed. 9 adhpmss gjmn`eo wms nr`ft`eo s`oe`f`ametky. gjrjfdrj, t s k`bjky tgmt tgj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 109/215
- =3= -
ed. = adhpmss systjh wms mksd nr`ft`eo, iut w`tg`e tgj adhpmrmtdr gjmn`eo n`ffjrjeajtgrjsgdkn.
^gj gjmn`eo nr`ft rjadrnjn de tgj FNY s edt ades`stjet w`tg edrhmk adhpmss dpjrmt`de.Njsp`tj jxtjes`vj adesuktmt`de w`tg Idj`eo, Gdejywjkk, _jstjre Mv`de`as, F`rst M`r, men tgjYdymk Amemn`me M`r Fdraj (YAMF) Qagddk df M`r Emv`omt`de, tgj evjst`omt`de wms uemikj td
njtjrh`ej wgy tg`s adhpmss ijgmv`dur daaurrjn.
9.>.=3 Adhpmss jrrdr
^g`s sjat`de adetm`es n`sauss`de df truj edrtg (^) gjmn`eos, ijmr`eos, men trmabs, ms wjkk ms tgjrjadrnjn jrrdejdus gjmn`eo men jxpjatjn rjsuktmet estruhjet en`amt`des. Vmkujs edtspja`f`amkky njet`f`jn ms truj edrtg rjkmtj td tgj jrrdejdus en`amt`des tgj adhpmss systjhprdv`njn.
^gj arjw mkhdst ajrtm`eky usjn tgj OSQ/ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade (ENI) hjtgdn df mnlust`eo tgjadhpmssjs. gj Yjsdkutj Imy ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade (YI ENI) wms tgj deky usmikj ijmade
w`tg`e rmeoj. Jetjr`eo tgj YI ENI `njet`f`jr `e tgj OSQ sgdukn gmvj rjsuktjn `e m ijmr`eo df390³^ frdh tgj aurrjet m`rarmft pds`t`de td YI ENI.
Ymnmr men w`en nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms trmab`eo 31?³^ td HZQM^ w`tg ed w`en nr`ft.^gj adrrjat pdst-prdajnurj rmn`d-hmoejt`a en`amtdr (YH@) en`amt`des, mssuh`eo ed ENI/MNF(mutdhmt`a n`rjat`de f`en`eo) jrrdr efkujeaj, sgdukn gmvj ijje MNF ijmr`eo pd`etjr gjmn mt390³^, w`tg tgj rjsuktmet truj gjmn`eo 31?³, uenjr tgj kuiijr k`ej (F`ourj =9).
Gdwjvjr, de adhpkjt`de df tgj prdajnurj, tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo frdh tgj ed. 9 adhpmss wms390³, wg`ag en`amtjs tgmt tgj YH@ kuiijr k`ej gjmn`eo sgdukn mksd gmvj ijje 390³. gjrjfdrj,tgj `en`amtjn ijmr`eo td tgj YI ijmade n`spkmyjn td tgj arjw de tgj FD‐s YH@ sgdukn gmvj ijje39=³ (F`ourj =1).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 110/215
- =39 -
F`ourj =9. =69:<3?< Jxjhpkmr df f`rst dff`ajr (FD)
rmn`d-hmoejt`a `en`amtdr (YH@) (ed. 9 adhpmss),sgdw`eo jxpjatjn truj `en`amt`des w`tg edgjmn`eo jrrdr
F`ourj =1. =69:<3?< FD YH@ (ed. 9 adhpmss)
sgdw`eo prjsuhjn en`amt`des w`tg ∙7³ gjmn`eojrrdr
De adhpkjt`de df tgj gjmn`eo sjtt`eo prdajnurj, tgj gjmn`eo sgdukn gmvj ijje 31?³^. ^gjrjadrnjn gjmn`eo wms 390³, me jrrdr df ∙7³. Mt kjmst 9 rjmsdes fdr tg`s jrrdr wjrj pdss`ikj. F`rst,`t s pdss`ikj tgmt tgj p`kdts eadrrjatky jxjautjn tgj f`emk stjp `e tgj prdajnurj, sjtt`eo tgjijmr`eo td YI ENI, 390³, uenjr tgj kuiijr k`ej rmtgjr tgme tgj gjmn df tgj MNF pd`etjr. Qjaden,`t s pdss`ikj tgmt tgj gjmn`eo sjtt`eo wms mffjatjn iy emaaurma`js egjrjet td tgj MNF/ENIsystjh. J`tgjr sajemr`d s ades`njrjn jqumkky k`bjky.
^gj adesjqujeaj df tgj gjmn`eo sjtt`eo jrrdr wms tgmt, hhjn`mtjky mftjr tgj prdajnurj wmsadhpkjtjn, tgj arjw gjmn`eo en`amt`de fdr tgj ed. 9 adhpmss wms eadrrjatky njp`atjn ms 390³rmtgjr tgme 31?³^.
_`en tr`meokj amkaukmt`des fdr =617<33 en`amtj tgmt tgj gjmn`eo rjqu`rjn fdr tgj m`rarmft td trmab317³^ =:> s 310³^, wg`kj tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo wms 39>³. ^g`s n`ffjrjeaj hjmes tgmt tgj gjmn`eojrrdr gmn earjmsjn td midut ∙=:³.
_`en tr`meokj amkaukmt`des fdr =6>3<1: sgdw tgmt tgj gjmn`eo rjqu`rjn fdr tgj m`rarmft td trmab1:=³^ =:: s 1>7³^, wg`kj tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo wms 11=³. ^g`s n`ffjrjeaj hjmes tgmt tgj gjmn`eojrrdr gmn earjmsjn td midut ∙=?³.
=:> Ijamusj df g`og kmt`tunj hjr`n`me adevjrojeaj, tgj truj trmab td HZQM^ agmeojn sk`ogtky msFMI6:63 trmvjkkjn mardss tgj hjr`n`mes df kdeo`tunj (frdh 31?³ td 317³).
=:: Ymnmr orduen trmab df FMI6:63 de f`emk mpprdmag
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 111/215
- =31 -
Me jrrdr etrdnuajn wgje tgj adhpmssjs wjrj e`t`mkky mnlustjn, adhi`ejn w`tg suisjqujetadhpmss nr`ft, rjsuktjn `e m adhpmss jrrdr df ∙=?³ nur`eo f`emk mpprdmag. Mt =6>3<1:, tgjamkaukmtjn matumk m`rarmft gjmn`eo wms 1>7³^, wg`kj tgj rjadrnjn ed. 9 gjmn`eo wms 11=³.
9.: @e-rmeoj agjab
Zet`k tg`s pd`et e tgj fk`ogt, tgj amptm`e k`bjky gmn tgj m`rarmft adef`ourjn fdr OSQ emv`omt`de.^g`s adef`ourmt`de rjqu`rjn tgj fdkkdw`eo sjkjat`des< =:6
• Amptm`e men FD HN->= ∙ de OSQ
• M/S QJKJA^ meeuea`mtdr/sw`tag ∙ OSQ sjkjatjn
• Mutdp`kdt `e HME hdnj
• Gjmn`eo sw`tag de GNO QJK
• Fk`ogt n`rjatdrs e GNO
• GQ@ adursj sjt td aurrjet OSQ trmab
Mt =616<91, tgj amptm`e amkkjn fdr tgj ijkdw-tgj-k`ej pdrt`de df tgj e-rmeoj agjabk`st. Fdkkdw`eotgj FD‐s agmkkjeoj fdr tgj EMV (emv`omt`de) sw`tagjs, idtg p`kdts rjspdenjn ‛VGF EMV.‘^gjrjfdrj, t s k`bjky tgmt idtg p`kdts sjkjatjn tgj`r rjspjat`vj HN->= td EMV mt tg`s t`hj. Nd`eosd wdukn agmeoj tgj GQ@ n`spkmy frdh OSQ td EMV, men wdukn mksd rjhdvj tgj OSQ s`oemksfrdh tgj mutdp`kdt. Dtgjr sjkjat`des tgmt wdukn edrhmkky ij hmnj iy tgj arjw mt tg`s t`hj mrj msfdkkdws< =:?
• Mutdp`kdt td VDY/KDA
• Mutdp`kdt p`tag hdnj sjkjatdr rjhm`es DFF
• M/S QJKJA^ meeuea`mtdr/sw`tag ∙ OSQ njsjkjatjn
• Gjmn`eo sw`tag td GNO QJK
• Fk`ogt n`rjatdrs td MZ^D MSS
• GQ@ adursj sjkjatdr turejn td 1>? (kdamk`zjr eiduen trmab)
Adhpmey p`kdts rmrjky usjn tgj mutdp`kdt MZ^D MSS dr HME O/Q (hmeumk ok`njskdpj) hdnjsfdr @KQ mpprdmagjs, estjmn prjfjrr`eo td usj VDY/KDA hdnj td trmab tgj kdamk`zjr men A_Qp`tag `eputs td fdkkdw tgj ok`njskdpj. Adesjqujetky, `t `s mkhdst ajrtm`e tgmt MZ^D MSS drHME O/Q wjrj edt sjkjatjn mt tg`s t`hj.
=:6 M/S rjfjrs td tgj mutdp`kdt2 HME rjfjrs td hmeumk2 GNO rjfjrs td gjmn`eo2 GNO QJK rjfjrs tdgjmn`eo sjkjat2 GQ@ rjfjrs td gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de `en`amtdr.
=:? VDY/KDA rjfjrs td VGF dhe`n rjat`demk rmeoj kdamk`zjr2 MZ^D MSS rjfjrs td mutd mpprdmag.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 112/215
- =3> -
9.6 Emv`omt`demk hdnjs nur`eo ture detd f`emk mpprdmag
9.6.= Ojejrmk
Ymnmr orduen spjjn de tgj `eiduen trmab td HZQM^ hhjn`mtjky ijfdrj tgj ture ijome wms990 bedts. @t `s uek`bjky tgmt tg`s spjjn prjvjetjn tgj mutdp`kdt frdh amptur`eo tgj kdamk`zjr2
gdwjvjr, t k`bjky amusjn tgj fk`ogt td dvjrsgddt tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej nur`eo tgj ture td f`emk.^gj kdamk`zjr etjrajpt meokj df :=³ wms w`tg`e tgj rjadhhjenjn rmeoj en`amtjn e tgj m`rarmftdpjrmt`des hmeumk (MDH). gjrjfdrj, t s uek`bjky tgmt tgj kdamk`zjr etjrajpt meokj prjvjetjntgj m`rarmft frdh amptur`eo tgj kdamk`zjr.
^gj evjst`omt`de adukn edt njtjrh`ej tgj prja`sj hjmes iy wg`ag tgj m`rarmft turejn mtHZQM^. Adesjqujetky, 9 pkmus`ikj sajemr`ds mrj n`saussjn `e sjat`des 9.6.9 men 9.6.1.
Ms FMI6:63 mpprdmagjn HZQM^, tgj arjw sw`tagjn frdh OSQ td VGF EMV. Mt tg`s pd`et, tgjfdkkdw`eo aden`t`des wjrj adhhde td idtg sajemr`ds n`saussjn ijkdw<
• VGF EMV ed. = ∙ @YI @KQ/NHJ ==3.13
• VGF EMV ed. 9 ∙ @YI @KQ/NHJ ==3.13
• OSQ ed. = ∙ YEMV 1:^ mpprdmag
• OSQ ed. 9 ∙ YEMV 1:^ mpprdmag
Fdr idtg sajemr`ds, mftjr adhpkjt`de df tgj e-rmeoj agjab, tgj fdkkdw`eo aden`t`des wjrj k`bjky<
• Mutdp`kdt gjmn`eo sw`tag ∙ GNO QJK
• Amptm`e men FD HN->= ∙ EMV
• Mutdp`kdt de OSQ ∙ njsjkjatjn
• Amptm`e men FD GQ@
• Adursj sjkjatdr 1>?³
• Gjmn`eo iuo ~39>³
• Amptm`e men FD fk`ogt n`rjatdr ∙ MZ^D MSS
• Amptm`e men FD MSN fk`ogt n`rjatdr ∙ mhijr VDY/KDA
• MNF ed. = ∙ YI ENI 1:3
• MNF ed. 9 ∙ YI ENI 1:3
9.6.9 VDY/KDA hdnj sjkjat`de mftjr ture (sajemr`d =)
Fdr tg`s sajemr`d, tgj fdkkdw`eo mnn`t`demk aden`t`des wjrj k`bjky upde adhpkjt`de df tgj e-rmeoj agjab<
• Mutdp`kdt ∙ HME hdnj
• Amptm`e men FD MSN mutdp`kdt ∙ k`ogts edt `kkuh`emtjn
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 113/215
- =3: -
O`vje tgj midvj aden`t`des, tgj fdkkdw`eo sjqujeaj sgdukn gmvj daaurrjn. Ms tgj m`rarmftmpprdmagjn tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj trmab imr de tgj GQ@ wdukn hdvj `ewmrn frdh tgj r`ogt s`nj df tgj`estruhjet. gj p`kdt wdukn ejjn td ture tgj GQ@ gjmn`eo sjkjatdr bedi td rdtmtj tgj gjmn`eoiuo td tgj njs`rjn ejw gjmn`eo (1>?³). gj mutdp`kdt wdukn tgje ture tgj m`rarmft td tgj sjkjatjngjmn`eo. Deaj jstmik`sgjn `eiduen de f`emk mpprdmag, tgj p`kdt wdukn sjkjat VDY/KDA de tgjmutdp`kdt hdnj adetrdk pmejk (HAS). ^gj mpprdmag prdorjss n`spkmy (MSN) mutdp`kdt
VDY/KDA k`ogt wdukn kkuh`emtj orjje wgje KDA s ampturjn. gj fk`ogt n`rjatdr n`spkmywdukn e`t`mkky sgdw m kjft-ture-rjqu`rjn en`amt`de men tgje w`eos-kjvjk en`amt`de deaj rdkkjndut de tgj kdamk`zjr. ^gj MSN fk`ogt n`rjatdr VDY/KDA k`ogt wdukn agmeoj td orjje updekdamk`zjr ampturj mt midut 9.:³ frdh tgj kdamk`zjr, men tgj ok`njskdpj k`ogt wdukn rjhm`e mhijr.
Q`hukmtdr tjst`eo sgdwjn tgmt usj df VDY/KDA hdnj rjsuktjn `e trmab`eo dr adevjro`eo w`tgtgj kdamk`zjr. Gdwjvjr, rmnmr nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj m`rarmft stjmn`ky n`vjrojn frdh tgj kdamk`zjr,`en`amt`eo VDY/KDA hdnj wms edt sjkjatjn fdkkdw`eo tgj ture. ^gjrjfdrj, tg`s hjtgdn wms edtusjn.
9.6.1 VDY/KDA hdnj sjkjat`de ijfdrj ture (sajemr`d 9)
Fdr tg`s sajemr`d, tgj fdkkdw`eo mnn`t`demk aden`t`des wjrj k`bjky upde adhpkjt`de df tgj e-rmeoj agjab<
• Mutdp`kdt ∙ VDY/KDA hdnj
• Amptm`e men FD MSN mutdp`kdt ∙ mhijr VDY/KDA k`ogt
O`vje tgj midvj aden`t`des, tgj fdkkdw`eo sjqujeaj sgdukn gmvj daaurrjn. Ms tgj m`rarmftmpprdmagjn tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj trmab imr de tgj GQ@ wdukn hdvj `ewmrn frdh tgj r`ogt s`nj df tgj`estruhjet tdwmrn tgj ajetrj. gj mutdp`kdt suihdnj ijadhjs VDY/KDA ampturj, men wdukn`e`t`mtj tgj ture td etjrajpt tgj kdamk`zjr (rjomrnkjss df tgj gjmn`eo iuo sjtt`eo de tgj GQ@)wgje tgj adursj njv`mt`de imr `en`amtjn midut 9 ndts frdh tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej. gj MSNmutdp`kdt VDY/KDA k`ogts wdukn agmeoj td orjje. ^gj gjmn`eo sw`tag wdukn rjture td GNOGDKN. @e MZ^D MSS, idtg fk`ogt n`rjatdrs wdukn e`t`mkky ij adhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk td fkytgj sjkjatjn gjmn`eo de tgj GQ@. Mt midut 9.:³ frdh tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs wduknagmeoj td ampturj hdnj, tgj adhhmen imrs wdukn adhhmen m kjft ture, men tgj MSN fk`ogtn`rjatdr VDY/KDA k`ogts wdukn agmeoj td orjje wg`kj tgj ok`njskdpj k`ogt wdukn `kkuh`emtjmhijr.
Ijtwjje 9 ndts men = ndt frdh tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej, wgje tgj ardss-ijmh rmtj nrdps td kjsstgme 9 h`kk`vdkts (hV) pjr sjaden men tgj imeb meokj s kjss tgme 6³, tgj mutdp`kdt suihdnjsgdukn sw`tag td VDY/KDA de adursj men tgj MSN mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA k`ogts wdukn rjhm`eorjje. gj fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs wdukn agmeoj frdh adhhmen`eo m kjft ture td
adhhmen`eo m rjture td w`eos-kjvjk deaj rdkkjn dut de tgj kdamk`zjr. gj p`kdt wdukn rdtmtj tgjgjmn`eo iuo td mk`oe w`tg tgj met`a`pmtjn gjmn`eo fdr rdkk`eo dut df tgj ture men rjmnlust tgjiuo deaj tgj m`rarmft gmn rdkkjn w`eos-kjvjk. gj amptm`e‐s GQ@ gjmn`eo iuo wms fduen sjt mt113³.
^gj mutdp`kdt sgdukn edw trmab tgj kdamk`zjr tdwmrn tgj ruewmy. Ms tgj mutdp`kdt men fk`ogtn`rjatdrs ampturj tgj ok`njskdpj, tgj MSN mutdp`kdt men fk`ogt n`rjatdr VDY/KDA k`ogts wduknrjhm`e orjje, men tgj MSN fk`ogt n`rjatdr ok`njskdpj k`ogt wdukn agmeoj td orjje. gj p`kdt
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 114/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 115/215
- =3? -
Gdwjvjr, f VDY/KDA gmn ijje jeomojn ijfdrj tgj ture men rjhm`ejn jeomojn tgrduogduttgj ture, tgj mutdp`kdt sgdukn gmvj ampturjn men trmabjn tgj kdamk`zjr. Q`hukmtdr tjst`eosgdwjn tgmt usj df mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA hdnj rjsuktjn `e j`tgjr `etjrajpt`eo men trmab`eo dradevjrojeaj w`tg tgj kdamk`zjr e jvjry amsj.
^gjrjfdrj, `e tg`s sajemr`d, `t `s k`bjky tgmt tgj mutdp`kdt rjvjrtjn frdh VDY/KDA hdnj td HMEhdnj mt sdhj pd`et nur`eo tgj ture. ^g`s rjvjrs`de adukn deky gmvj daaurrjn `f m fdrajjxajjn`eo tgj mppk`amikj njtjet wms mppk`jn td tgj adetrdk wgjjk.
^gj sajemr`d w`kk ij n`saussjn e rjkmt`de td 9 fk`ogt pgmsjs<
m) Frdh e-rmeoj agjab adhpkjt`de uet`k tgj fk`ogt rjmagjn tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej2
i) Mftjr ardss`eo tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej.
9.6.1.= @e-rmeoj agjab td kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej
_g`kj tgj m`rarmft wms orjmtjr tgme 9 ndts frdh tgj kdamk`zjr (VDY/KDA mrhjn iut edt yjtampturjn), tgj mutdp`kdt rdkk agmeejk wdukn ij e g`og njtjet, ijamusj tgj gjmn`eo sw`tag wmssjt td GNO QJK.
Deaj tgj m`rarmft wms midut 9 ndts frdh tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj mutdp`kdt wdukn sw`tag td VDY/KDAampturj suihdnj, men tgj gjmn`eo sw`tag wdukn rjvjrt frdh GNO QJK td GNO GDKN. gjmutdp`kdt rdkk agmeejk wdukn sw`tag td kdw njtjet ijamusj df tgj GNO GDKN hdnj. @f tgj kdwnjtjet fdraj wms jxajjnjn, tgj mutdp`kdt hdnj sjkjatdr sw`tag wdukn rjvjrt frdh VDY/KDA tdHME.
^gj m`rarmft adhhjeajn tgj ture frdh m truj gjmn`eo df 310³ (F`ourj =>, pd`et M), men ardssjntgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej mt =617<19 (pd`et A), rdkk`eo kjft tgrduog m truj gjmn`eo df 3=:³. @f tgj kdw
njtjet fdraj wms jxajjnjn ijfdrj ardss`eo tgj ajetrjk`ej, men `f tgj m`rarmft gmn kjss tgme :³imeb, tgj mutdp`kdt wdukn rdkk w`eos-kjvjk men hm`etm`e m stjmny gjmn`eo ijtwjje 3=:³^ men310³^, amus`eo tgj m`rarmft td trmab td tgj edrtgjmst. @f tgj m`rarmft gmn orjmtjr tgme :³ imeb, tgjmutdp`kdt wdukn hm`etm`e tgmt imeb meokj uet`k furtgjr eputs wjrj hmnj. Gdwjvjr, tgj rmnmrmen FNY nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj m`rarmft n`n ej`tgjr df tgjsj tg`eos. Mnn`t`demkky, tgj FNY sgdwstgmt tgjrj wjrj ed adetrdk wgjjk eputs hmnj uet`k mftjr tgj fk`ogt ardssjn tgj kdamk`zjrajetrjk`ej men tgj m`rarmft gmn rdkkjn mkhdst w`eos-kjvjk.
^gjrjfdrj, t s uek`bjky tgmt j`tgjr tgj njtjet fdraj wms jxajjnjn dr tgmt tgj mutdp`kdt rjvjrtjnfrdh VDY/KDA hdnj td HME nur`eo tgj ture ijfdrj ardss`eo tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej.
9.6.1.9 Kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej td rdkk-dut de f`emk
^gj mutdp`kdt rjhm`ejn jeomojn tgrduogdut tgj mpprdmag. ^rmab`eo tdwmrn HZQM^, ijfdrj tgjture detd f`emk mpprdmag, tgj mutdp`kdt wdukn gmvj e`t`mkky ijje e VDY/KDA mrhjn hdnj,w`tg tgj gjmn`eo sw`tag `e GNO QJK.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 116/215
- =37 -
FNY nmtm fdr adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjet men rdkk mtt`tunj sgdw tgmt tgj kjft ture ijome mt M(F`ourj =>). FNY nmtm nur`eo tgj ture (M td O) w`kk ij n`saussjn `e tg`s sjat`de. FNY nmtm fdr tgjpjr`dn fdkkdw`eo tgj ture (O td G) w`kk ij n`saussjn `e sjat`de 9.7.
^gj adetrdk wgjjk pds`t`de pkdt frdh M td I `s ades`stjet w`tg mutdp`kdt e`t`mt`de df tgj ture mstgj m`rarmft rjmagjn 9 ndts kjft df tgj kdamk`zjr mt M men tgj mutdp`kdt sw`tagjn frdh VDY/KDA
mrhjn td ampturj. Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj gjmn`eo sw`tag wdukn agmeoj frdh GNO QJK td GNOGDKN, men tgj MSN mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA k`ogts wdukn ij `kkuh`emtjn orjje. ^gj ture ijo`esw`tg m shddtg stjjp r`sj ms tgj mutdp`kdt ijome tgj ture iy rdkk`eo tgj m`rarmft td tgj kjft. ^gjrdkk rmtj `earjmsjn frdh 3 td m pjmb df :³ pjr sjaden, wg`ag wms ad`ea`njet w`tg tgj adetrdkwgjjk hdvjhjet pjmb mt I.
^gj adetrdk wgjjk pds`t`de pkdt frdh I td A `s mksd ades`stjet w`tg mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de. @t ijo`esw`tg m stjjp njak`ej ms tgj mutdp`kdt sjesjn tgj ejjn td rjnuaj rdkk rmtj ms tgj hmx`huh imebmeokj k`h`t df 9:³ wms mpprdmag`eo. Mt A, tgj imeb meokj pjmbjn mt 9>³ kjft men tgj adetrdkwgjjk rjturejn td tgj ejutrmk pds`t`de. g`s pd`et daaurrjn midut 9 sjadens mftjr tgj m`rarmftardssjn tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej.
^gj adetrdk wgjjk pds`t`de pkdt frdh A td N `s mksd ades`stjet w`tg mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de. Ms tgjmutdp`kdt sjesjn tgj ejjn td ijo`e rdkk`eo dut df tgj kjft ture mt A, tgj adetrdk wgjjk adet`eujntd hdvj frdh ejutrmk td tgj r`ogt. gj r`ogt adetrdk-wgjjk njfkjat`de pjmbjn mt N, mt wg`agpd`et tgj m`rarmft wms midut = ndt r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr.
^gj adetrdk wgjjk pds`t`de pkdt frdh N td J `s mksd ades`stjet w`tg mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de. Mt N, tgjmutdp`kdt sjesjn tgj ejjn td ijo`e rjnua`eo tgj r`ogt rdkk rmtj, men tgj adetrdk wgjjk ijomerjture`eo tdwmrn tgj ejutrmk pds`t`de.
^gj mutdp`kdt wms k`bjky st`kk e VDY/KDA ampturj suihdnj, men gmn edt yjt sw`tagjn td
VDY/KDA de adursj suihdnj, ijamusj ijtwjje N men J<• ^gj imeb meokj wms orjmtjr tgme 6³ uet`k =617<>?, midut 9 sjadens ijfdrj J2 men
• ^gj ardss-ijmh rmtj wdukn gmvj ijje orjmtjr tgme 9 hV pjr sjaden, ijamusj tgj m`rarmftwms midut = ndt r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr men n`vjro`eo.
Ijamusj tgj mutdp`kdt wms st`kk `e VDY/KDA ampturj suihdnj, tgj mutdp`kdt rdkk agmeejk wdukngmvj st`kk ijje dpjrmt`eo mt tgj kdw njtjet (> pduens).
Frdh M td J, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs wdukn gmvj ijje adhhmen`eo tures td ad`ea`njw`tg tgj tures hmnj iy tgj mutdp`kdt.
^gj adetrdk wgjjk pds`t`de pkdt frdh J td F `s edt ades`stjet w`tg mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de. Zek`bjtgj shddtg hdvjhjet df tgj adetrdk wgjjk frdh M td J, tgj nmtm pkdts sgdw sjvjrmk miruptadetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjets adhhjea`eo mt J men jen`eo mt F. @t `s k`bjky tgmt tgjsj hdvjhjetswjrj tgj rjsukt df hmeumk A_Q `eputs iy tgj amptm`e. @t `s k`bjky tgmt tgj adetrdk wgjjk `eput mtJ jxajjnjn tgj mutdp`kdt rdkk agmeejk kdw-njtjet fdraj, amus`eo tgj mutdp`kdt td rjvjrt frdhVDY/KDA td HME hdnj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 117/215
- =30 -
Mt J, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs sgdukn st`kk gmvj ijje e MZ^D MSS, w`tg tgj MSN orjje VDY/KDAmen mhijr ok`njskdpj k`ogts kkuh`emtjn. gj mutdp`kdt hdnj rjvjrs`de wdukn edt gmvj mffjatjntgj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs. Ms tgj mutdp`kdt (HME men GNO GDKN hdnj) rdkkjn tgj m`rarmft w`eos-kjvjk, idtg fk`ogt n`rjatdrs sgdukn gmvj adhhmenjn m kjft ture ijamusj tgj etjrajpt meokj imabtd tgj kdamk`zjr wms `esuff`a`jet.
^gj adetrdk wgjjk `eput mt J daaurrjn ms tgj m`rarmft wms ture`eo kjft tgrduog m rjadrnjngjmn`eo df 11>³ w`tg :³ df kjft imeb (=617<>0). _gje tgj adetrdk wgjjk eput ajmsjn, tgj imebmeokj wms 9³. @e HME hdnj men GNO GDKN, w`tg kjss tgme :³ imeb, tgj mutdp`kdt sgdukn gmvjrdkkjn w`eos-kjvjk men hm`etm`ejn m stjmny gjmn`eo deaj w`eos-kjvjk. gj rdkk men gjmn`eonmtm fdr F td O sgdw tgmt tgj m`rarmft ojejrmkky hm`etm`ejn m w`eos-kjvjk mtt`tunj. Mt F, tgj m`rarmft wms mpprdx`hmtjky =.: ndts r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr. Gmn tgj mutdp`kdt rjhm`ejn`e VDY/KDA e kdamk`zjr ampturj suihdnj, tgj m`rarmft sgdukn gmvj adet`eujn rdkk`eo furtgjr tdtgj kjft, td m gjmn`eo tgmt wdukn prdv`nj m su`tmikj `etjrajpt meokj imab td tgj kdamk`zjr frdh tgjr`ogt s`nj. Deaj tgj m`rarmft rjturejn td tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj m`rarmft sgdukn tgje gmvj turejnsk`ogtky imab td tgj r`ogt, td m gjmn`eo tgmt wdukn hm`etm`e tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej (F`ourj =:).
F`ourj =:. Jxmhpkj df VDY/KDA kdamk`zjr ampturj (samkj rjprjsjets h`kjs frdh tgj tgrjsgdkn)
^gj FNY nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj A_Q rdkk `eputs ajmsjn mt =617<:1. Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj rdkk mtt`tunjwms =³ kjft imeb, men rjadrnjn gjmn`eo wms 119³. gj m`rarmft adet`eujn rdkk`eo, men stmi`k`zjnmt =³ r`ogt imeb mt =610<3:, w`tg tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo df 113³. ^gj adhpmss jrrdr wms ∙=6³2tgjrjfdrj, tgj truj gjmn`eo wms 1>6³. Nur`eo f`emk mpprdmag, tgj w`en wdukn gmvj rjsuktjn e 1³df r`ogt nr`ft. _`tg tgj w`en nr`ft, tgj rjsuktmet rmnmr trmab df FMI6:63 n`vjrojn prdorjss`vjkyfurtgjr td tgj r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr, ms sgdwe `e F`ourj =:.
Ijamusj tgj m`rarmft n`n edt ture td tgj kjft imab tdwmrn tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj mutdp`kdt adukn edtgmvj ijje `e VDY/KDA hdnj.
^gj adetrdk wgjjk pds`t`de rjhm`ejn ueagmeojn frdh F uet`k medtgjr r`ogt `eput mt O. ^gj
gjmn`eo men rdkk efdrhmt`de ijtwjje F men O `s ades`stjet w`tg dpjrmt`de df tgj mutdp`kdt eHME men GNO GDKN.
9.6.1.1 Mwmrjejss df ue`etjet`demk mutdp`kdt hdnj agmeoj
V`sumk `en`amt`des `e tgj adabp`t df tgj hdnj rjvjrs`de wdukn ij tgj mutdp`kdt HAS hdnjsjkjatdr sw`tag rdtmt`eo frdh VDY/KDA td HME, men tgj orjje VDY/KDA k`ogts de tgjamptm`e men FD MSN mutdp`kdt adkuhes jxt`eou`sg`eo.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 118/215
- ==3 -
^gj hdnj sjkjatdr sw`tag hmbjs m ak`ab`eo sduen wgje hdv`eo frdh VDY/KDA td HME.Gdwjvjr, o`vje tgj mhi`jet ed`sj kjvjk df tgj adabp`t `e fk`ogt, men tgj fmat tgmt tgjrj wms mtrmesh`ss`de frdh APYI tdwjr mt tgj t`hj (=617<>0), t s uek`bjky tgmt tgj p`kdts wdukn edt`ajtg`s sduen.
^gj hdnj sjkjatdr sw`tag wdukn gmvj rdtmtjn aduetjr-akdabw`sj frdh =9 d‐akdab td midut ==d‐akdab nur`eo tgj hdnj agmeoj. @t s uek`bjky tgmt tgj p`kdts wdukn njtjat tg`s agmeoj mftjr `tgmn daaurrjn.
_g`kj `e VDY/KDA ampturj suihdnj, tgj MSN mutdp`kdt VDY/KDA k`ogt sgdukn ij`kkuh`emtjn orjje. _gje tgj hdnj agmeoj daaurrjn, tgj orjje k`ogt sgdukn gmvj jxt`eou`sgjn.Gdwjvjr, tgj MSN fk`ogt n`rjatdr orjje VDY/KDA men mhijr ok`njskdpj k`ogts sgdukn rjhm`e`kkuh`emtjn. @t `s uek`bjky tgmt tgj p`kdts wdukn njtjat tgj misjeaj df tg`s k`ogt, jspja`mkky `e tgjprjsjeaj df dtgjr kkuh`emtjn k`ogts de tgj MSN. gjrj wms ed rjadrnjn n`sauss`de ijtwjje tgjp`kdts rjomrn`eo mey df tgjsj en`amt`des. gjrjfdrj, t s k`bjky tgmt tgj arjw n`n edt njtjat tgjmutdp`kdt hdnj agmeoj.
9.6.> Quhhmry df ture memkys`s
Mt =617<:3, ms FMI6:63 wms rdkk`eo dut df tgj ture detd f`emk mpprdmag td tgj r`ogt df tgjkdamk`zjr, tgj amptm`e k`bjky hmnj m adetrdk wgjjk rdkk eput tgmt amusjn tgj mutdp`kdt td rjvjrtfrdh VDY/KDA ampturj td HME men GNO GDKN hdnj.
Deaj tgj mutdp`kdt wms `e GNO GDKN hdnj, tgj mutdp`kdt wdukn gmvj rdkkjn tgj m`rarmft td mw`eos-kjvjk mtt`tunj men hm`etm`ejn w`eos-kjvjk uekjss furtgjr A_Q eputs wjrj hmnj iy tgjp`kdt fky`eo (SF). FNY nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj fk`ogt rdkkjn mpprdx`hmtjky w`eos-kjvjk mt =610<3:,w`tg m rjadrnjn gjmn`eo df 113³. g`s gjmn`eo wdukn mksd gmvj ijje n`spkmyjn de tgj amptm`e‐sGQ@.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 119/215
- === -
F`ourj =6. =610<=3< Amptm`e‐s gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de
`en`amtdr (GQ@), `en`amt`eo =?³ `etjrajpt meokj (ed. 9adhpmss w`tg ∙=6³ gjmn`eo jrrdr)
F`ourj =?. Jxjhpkmr df amptm`e‐s GQ@ (ed. 9
adhpmss) `en`amt`des mt =610<=3, gmn tgjrj ijje edgjmn`eo jrrdr
Ms sgdwe e F`ourj =6, tgj en`amtjn gjmn`eo df 113³ wdukn gmvj o`vje tgj amptm`e tgjpjrajpt`de tgmt gj gmn m =?³ `etjrajpt meokj td rjture td tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej trmab df 1>?³.
^gj ed. = adhpmss gjmn`eo s n`spkmyjn de tgj FD‐s GQ@. Ijamusj tgjrj wms ed rjadrnjnn`sauss`de df tgj gjmn`eo adhpmrmtdr k`ogt, tgj ed. = adhpmss sgdukn gmvj ijje w`tg`e ½7³ dftgj ed. 9 adhpmss. gjrjfdrj, tgj gjmn`eo n`spkmyjn de tgj FD‐s GQ@ sgdukn gmvj ijje w`tg`e½7³ df tgj amptm`e‐s gjmn`eo. Adesjqujetky, tgj `etjrajpt meokj de tgj FD‐s GQ@ sgdukn gmvjijje ms k`ttkj ms 0³ men ms huag ms 9:³.
^gj GQ@ s tgj pr`hmry emv`omt`demk estruhjet fdr idtg p`kdts. gj meoukmr rjkmt`desg`pijtwjje gjmn`eo men kdamk`zjr (F`ourj =6) wdukn gmvj ijje m pdwjrfuk v`sumk adef`rhmt`de tdidtg p`kdts tgmt tgj etjrajpt meokj wms smt`sfmatdry, men tgmt `t sgdukn rjture tgj m`rarmft td tgjkdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej. Gdwjvjr, nuj td m ∙=6³ adhpmss jrrdr mt tg`s pd`et `e tgj fk`ogt, tgjm`rarmft‐s truj gjmn`eo wms 1>6³, ms sgdwe `e F`ourj =?. _`tg 1³ df w`en nr`ft td tgj r`ogt, tgjrjsuktmet m`rarmft trmab (1>0³^) n`vjrojn furtgjr td tgj r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr.
_`tg m =?³ `etjrajpt, tgj m`rarmft sgdukn gmvj trmabjn imab tdwmrn tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej. g`sadrrjat`de wdukn ij njp`atjn de idtg GQ@s iy tgj ewmrn hdvjhjet df tgj adursj njv`mt`deimr. Gdwjvjr, ijamusj df tgj adhpmss jrrdr, mutdp`kdt hdnj, men w`en nr`ft, tgj m`rarmft trmab
n`vjrojn furtgjr td tgj r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr. ^g`s n`vjrojeaj wdukn gmvj ijje njp`atjn de idtgGQ@s iy tgj adet`eujn dutwmrn hdvjhjet df tgj adursj njv`mt`de imr.
^gj trmab n`vjrojeaj wms `eadeorujet w`tg tgj pjraj`vjn etjrajpt meokj men tgj p`kdts‐jxpjatmt`de df rjom`e`eo trmab. g`s `eadeorujeay wdukn gmvj ejomt`vjky mffjatjn tgj p`kdts‐s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss men earjmsjn tgj`r wdrbkdmn ms tgjy mttjhptjn td uenjrstmen menrjsdkvj tg`s mhi`ou`ty.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 120/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 121/215
- ==1 -
9.7 Adhpkjt`de df ture men adet`eumt`de df mpprdmag
9.7.= M`rarmft stmtj mt adhpkjt`de df ture
Mt =610<3:, tgj m`rarmft rdkkjn dut df tgj ture =¸ ndts r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr men =¸ ndts midvj tgjok`njskdpj mt 1=33 fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk). Adef`ourmt`de wms kmen`eo ojmr ndwe men fkmps =:,
w`tg =67 B@MQ. ^gj mutdp`kdt hdnj wms k`bjky HME w`tg GNO GDKN.
9.7.9 @e`t`mk n`vjrojeaj frdh kdamk`zjr
9.7.9.= Fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr nmtm
Mt =610<=7 (k`ej O df F`ourj =>), m adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjet td tgj r`ogt daaurrjn. ^g`shdvjhjet `s ades`stjet w`tg m hmeumk A_Q rdkk `eput iy tgj SF rmtgjr tgme m rdkk `eput frdhtgj mutdp`kdt.
_gje tgj A_Q eput ajmsjn, tgj adetrdk wgjjk rjturejn td tgj ejutrmk pds`t`de, men tgj m`rarmft
rdkkjn w`eos-kjvjk. gj rjhm`e`eo etjrvmk ijtwjje O men G sgdws tgj adetrdk wgjjk ormnumkkyhdv`eo frdh ejutrmk td >³ r`ogt, men tgje imab td 9³ r`ogt mt G. Ydkk meokj, rdkk rmtj, men gjmn`eonur`eo tg`s pjr`dn en`amtj tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms w`eos-kjvjk, njsp`tj tgj adetrdk wgjjk meokj.Deaj mom`e, tg`s `efdrhmt`de `s ades`stjet w`tg tgj mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`eo `e HME men GNOGDKN.
Mt G, medtgjr adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjet daaurrjn, tg`s t`hj `e`t`mkky td tgj kjft. ^gj hdvjhjetpjmbjn mt =3³ wgjjk-kjft, men tgje agmeojn n`rjat`de td tgj r`ogt, tgrduog tgj ejutrmk pds`t`detd 6³ wgjjk-r`ogt. gjsj hdvjhjets mrj ades`stjet w`tg hmeumk A_Q rdkk eputs iy tgj SF. De rjkjms`eo tgj wgjjk prjssurj mt =610<10, tgj mutdp`kdt hdnj mkhdst ajrtm`eky rjturejn td
GNO GDKN. ^gj FNY nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj adetrdk wgjjk skdwky hdvjn frdh 6³ wgjjk-r`ogt tdejutrmk mt =610<:3. gj rdkk nmtm kmo tgj wgjjk pds`t`de nmtm sk`ogtky, w`tg tgj m`rarmft rjmag`eow`eos-kjvjk mt =6>3<3?. ^gj gjmn`eo nmtm hmtag tgj rdkk nmtm, w`tg tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eostmi`k`z`eo mt midut 113³.
9.7.9.9 Arjw hjetmk hdnjks fdkkdw`eo ture detd f`emk mpprdmag
Frdh =610<=1 td =610<13 (Mppjen`x M), tgj FD hmnj : stmtjhjets rjomrn`eo tgj m`rarmft‐sprdorjss`vj n`vjrojeaj td tgj r`ogt df tgj njs`rjn trmab, en`amt`eo tgmt gj wms akdsjkyhde`tdr`eo tgj m`rarmft pds`t`de. ^gj amptm`e mabedwkjnojn tgj FD‐s `e`t`mk stmtjhjet. Nur`eotg`s pjr`dn, mt =610<91, FMI6:63 rjmagjn m pds`t`de ad`ea`njet w`tg 9 ndts r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjrmen st`kk =¸ ndts midvj tgj ok`njskdpj. Mt =610<9>.9, tgj FD hmnj m stmtjhjet rjfjrr`eo td fukknjfkjat`de frdh tgj kdamk`zjr.
Mt =610<11 men =610<16, tgj amptm`e hmnj 9 stmtjhjets tgmt suoojst tgmt gj wms smt`sf`jn tgmt tgjmutdp`kdt wms trmab`eo prdpjrky. gjsj stmtjhjets ad`ea`njn w`tg tgj adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjetmt G n`saussjn `e tgj sjat`de midvj.
^gj amptm`e k`bjky ijk`jvjn tgmt tgj mutdp`kdt hdnj wms st`kk VDY/KDA, ijamusj tgjy gmnjetjrjn tgj ture e VDY/KDA men gmn rdkkjn dut df tgj ture w`tg m rjmsdemikj rj-`etjrajpt
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 122/215
- ==> -
meokj fdkkdw`eo tgj e`t`mk kdamk`zjr dvjrsgddt. gj amptm`e‐s stmtjhjets men tgj adetrdk wgjjkhdvjhjet mt G suoojst tgmt tgj amptm`e wms k`bjky pjrfdrh`eo m tjst td vjr`fy tgmt tgj mutdp`kdthdnj morjjn w`tg g`s hjetmk hdnjk.
^gj amptm`e‐s hjetmk hdnjk wms k`bjky tgmt tgj mutdp`kdt wdukn rj-`etjrajpt tgj kdamk`zjr frdhtgj r`ogt men m kmen`eo wdukn fdkkdw. Gdwjvjr, tgj FD‐s hjetmk hdnjk wms k`bjky tgmt tgj
m`rarmft wms st`kk n`vjro`eo td tgj r`ogt df tgj njs`rjn trmab, njsp`tj me mppmrjet etjrajpt meokj.^g`s n`ffjrjeaj e hjetmk hdnjks s tgj f`rst en`amt`de tgmt tgj p`kdts‐ sgmrjn s`tumt`demkmwmrjejss wms irjmb`eo ndwe.
^gj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs k`bjky sw`tagjn frdh MZ^D MSS etjrajpt td MZ^D MSS ampturj mt pd`et Mmt =617<9= ms tgj ture ijome. Mt pd`et J, tgj mutdp`kdt suihdnj agmeojn frdh VDY/KDAampturj td HME men GNO GDKN. Gdwjvjr, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs wdukn edt gmvj ijje mffjatjniy tgj adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjets, men wdukn gmvj rjhm`ejn e MZ^D MSS. Adesjqujetky, tgjadhhmen imrs wdukn gmvj ijje adhhmen`eo m kjft ture tdwmrn tgj kdamk`zjr, tgj MSN fk`ogtn`rjatdr VDY/KDA k`ogts wdukn gmvj rjhm`ejn orjje, men tgj ok`njskdpj k`ogts wdukn gmvjrjhm`ejn mhijr.
@f tgj KDA njv`mt`de s`oemk jxajjns tgj k`h`t (9.:³ fdr tgj kdamk`zjr) nur`eo tgj 03 sjadens mftjrKDA ampturj, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr MSN VDY/KDA meeuea`mtdr mhijr k`ogt w`kk `kkuh`emtj mentgj orjje k`ogt w`kk jxt`eou`sg, ms tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr rjvjrts frdh KDA ampturj td KDA etjrajpt.
Mt =610<:=, 03 sjadens mftjr tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs sw`tagjn td MZ^D MSS ampturj mt M, tgj m`rarmftwms orjmtjr tgme 9.:³ dff tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej. @t `s k`bjky tgmt idtg fk`ogt n`rjatdrs rjvjrtjn tdMZ^D MSS etjrajpt hdnj. gj adhhmen imrs wdukn tgje prdv`nj ou`nmeaj td fky td menhm`etm`e tgj sjkjatjn gjmn`eo de tgj GQ@.
^gj amptm`e‐s GQ@ gjmn`eo iuo wms fduen mt 113³. Mt =610<:=, wgje tgj 03-sjaden pjr`dn
jkmpsjn, tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo wms 190³. Mssuh`eo tgmt tgj amptm`e‐s gjmn`eo iuo wms sjt mt113³, tgjrj wdukn ij deky =³ n`ffjrjeaj ijtwjje en`amtjn gjmn`eo men sjkjatjn gjmn`eo, menmey fk`ogt n`rjatdr rdkk adhhmen wdukn ij mkhdst hpjrajpt`ikj. gjrjfdrj, t s k`bjky tgmt tgjamptm`e‐s fk`ogt n`rjatdr wms adhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk dr mkhdst w`eos-kjvjk mftjr rjvjrt`eo tdMZ^D MSS etjrajpt hdnj. g`s stmtj wdukn ij m pdwjrfuk rj`efdrajhjet fdr tgj amptm`e tgmttgj mppmrjet etjrajpt meokj imab td tgj kdamk`zjr wms suff`a`jet. Gdwjvjr, tgj GQ@ adursjnjv`mt`de imr wdukn gmvj rjhm`ejn mt `ts hmx`huh njfkjat`de, 9 ndts, njsp`tj furtgjrnjv`mt`des dff tgj kdamk`zjr ijyden 9 ndts.
@en`amt`des mvm`kmikj td tgj amptm`e tgmt m fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj agmeoj gmn daaurrjn wdukn gmvjijje m agmeoj e adhhmen imr pds`t`de frdh adhhmen`eo m kjft ture td adhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk, men tgj MSN fk`ogt n`rjatdr VDY/KDA k`ogt agmeo`eo frdh orjje td mhijr. ^gjadhhmen imrs mrj e tgj mtt`tunj n`rjatdr en`amtdr (MN@), men tgj MSN k`ogts mrj midvj tgjmkt`hjtjr, midut 6 `eagjs td tgj r`ogt df tgj MN@.
@f tgjsj agmeojs daaurrjn wg`kj tgj amptm`e‐s mttjet`de wms jksjwgjrj, t wdukn ij hdrj n`ff`aukttd njtjat tgj agmeojn stmtj df tgj estruhjets upde rjture`eo g`s mttjet`de td tgjh. gjrjfdrj, t`s pdss`ikj tgmt tgj amptm`e n`n edt njtjat tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj agmeoj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 123/215
- ==: -
@f tgj hdnj agmeoj gmn edt daaurrjn men tgj amptm`e‐s adhhmen imrs adet`eujn td adhhmen mkjft ture td tgj kdamk`zjr, t s jxtrjhjky uek`bjky tgmt tgj amptm`e wdukn oedrj tg`s auj w`tgdutadhhjet`eo de t. O`vje tgj FD‐s rjpjmtjn stmtjhjets midut hukt`pkj en`amt`des df njv`mt`defrdh tgj kdamk`zjr, `f g`s fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs gmn ijje adhhmen`eo m kjft ture, `t `smkhdst ajrtm`e tgmt gj wdukn gmvj hjet`dejn tg`s. gjrj wms ed n`sauss`de ijtwjje tgj p`kdtsmidut adhhmen imrs dr MSN k`ogts mt mey t`hj nur`eo tgj mpprdmag, suoojst`eo tgmt ej`tgjr
p`kdt wms mwmrj tgmt tgj hdnj agmeoj gmn daaurrjn.
^gj FD adet`eujn td vd`aj g`s adeajre tgmt tgjy wjrj prdorjss`vjky n`vjro`eo furtgjr td tgjr`ogt. Gj mksd en`amtjn tgmt m sjaden emv-m`n, tgj OSQ, adef`rhjn tgmt tgjy wjrj r`ogt df tgjnjs`rjn trmab. gj fk`ogt n`rjatdr rjvjrs`de k`bjky daaurrjn midut tgj smhj t`hj tgj FDhjet`dejn tgj OSQ. @t `s pdss`ikj tgmt tgj FD wms kddb`eo mt tgj OSQ, wg`ag wms kdamtjn de tgjajetrj adesdkj ejmr g`s kjft bejj. @f tgj agmeojs td tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs men MSNk`ogts daaurrjn wg`kj tgj FD‐s mttjet`de wms de tgj OSQ, `t wdukn ij hdrj n`ff`aukt td njtjat tgjagmeojn stmtj df tgj `estruhjets upde rjture`eo g`s mttjet`de td tgjh. ^gjrjfdrj, `t `s pdss`ikjtgmt tgj FD n`n edt njtjat tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj agmeoj.
^gj FD‐s GQ@ gjmn`eo iuo wms edt fduen, men `ts sjtt`eo `s uebedwe. Mssuh`eo tgmt tgj FDmksd sjt g`s gjmn`eo iuo td tgj gjmn`eo tgmt tgj m`rarmft rdkkjn dut de, g`s fk`ogt n`rjatdr, deaj `eMZ^D MSS etjrajpt hdnj, wdukn mksd ij adhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk dr mkhdst w`eos-kjvjk. gjFD‐s stmtjhjet mt =610<:? suoojsts tgmt g`s fk`ogt n`rjatdr wms `e MZ^D MSS, iut gj n`n edthjet`de tgj MSN k`ogts. @t s k`bjky tgmt tgj FD wms rjfjrr`eo td g`s fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj sjkjatdrsw`tag ij`eo `e tgj MZ^D MSS pds`t`de. Yjomrnkjss df wgjtgjr tgj FD wms mwmrj df tgj fk`ogtn`rjatdr hdnj agmeoj, g`s uenjrstmen`eo df tgj trmab njv`mt`de wms imsjn de tgj GQ@ adursjn`spkmajhjet imr men tgj OSQ. gjsj 9 en`amtdrs suppdrtjn g`s hjetmk hdnjk tgmt tgj m`rarmftwms r`ogt df trmab men tgjy ejjnjn td od mrduen, ms jv`njeajn iy g`s rjpjmtjn stmtjhjets tdtgmt jffjat.
Frdh =610<:= uet`k =6>=<3:, tgj rjadrnjn gjmn`eo wms w`tg`e tgj rmeoj df 190³ td 119³. _`tg tgjamptm`e‐s GQ@ gjmn`eo iuo sjt mt 113³, g`s fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs wdukn gmvj ijjeadhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk.
^gj p`kdts k`bjky n`n edt njtjat tgmt tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs gmn rjvjrtjn td MZ^D MSS etjrajpthdnj. @e tg`s hdnj, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs prdv`njn rdkk ou`nmeaj td tgj sjkjatjngjmn`eo (w`eos-kjvjk adhhmen) rmtgjr tgme td tgj kdamk`zjr (kjft-ture adhhmen). gj mppmrjetmorjjhjet ijtwjje tgj GQ@ (r`ogt df trmab) men tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr (w`eos-kjvjk) k`bjky mssurjntgj amptm`e tgmt tgj etjrajpt meokj wms suff`a`jet td rjture tgj m`rarmft td tgj sjkjatjn adursj.^gj FD k`bjky put hdrj wj`ogt de tgj pds`t`demk efdrhmt`de df tgj trmab imr men OSQ. g`ss`tumt`de rjprjsjetjn m n`vjrojeaj e hjetmk hdnjks tgmt njormnjn tgj arjw‐s mi`k`ty td rjsdkvjtgj emv`omt`demk `ssujs.
9.7.1 Fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de
^gj GQ@s gmn k`bjky ijje `en`amt`eo fukk-samkj kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de mftjr =610<91. Nur`eo tgjsuisjqujet >>-sjaden pjr`dn, tgj p`kdts wjrj jeomojn e m n`sauss`de df m`rarmft pds`t`de. Mt=610<9>.9, tgj FD stmtjn, ‛Edw wj‐rj tgrduog t.‘ g`s stmtjhjet wms k`bjky me mttjhpt td mkjrttgj amptm`e td fukk-samkj njfkjat`de. ^grduogdut tgj n`sauss`de, tgj FD adet`eujn td hde`tdrm`rarmft pds`t`de2 mt =6>3<3?, tgj FD stmtjn tgmt tgjy gmn fukk njfkjat`de (Mppjen`x N). gj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 124/215
- ==6 -
uttjrmeaj wms pgrmsjn ms m qujst`de sjjb`eo adef`rhmt de frdh tgj amptm`e. Mt tg`s t`hj, tgjm`rarmft wms >.? eh frdh tgj ruewmy tgrjsgdkn men midut 9733 fjjt r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr, wjkk `ejxajss df 9 ndts.
Fukk-samkj njfkjat`de s me uenjs`rjn m`rarmft stmtj, ijamusj smfjty hmro`es ame ed kdeojr ijmssurjn. Ijamusj tgj GQ@ s k`h`tjn td n`spkmy`eo m hmx`huh df 9 ndts njfkjat`de, mey furtgjr
n`spkmajhjet ijyden 9 ndts wdukn edt ij mppmrjet td tgj p`kdts. Ms njsar`ijn e sjat`de=.=?.9.7.9, p`kdts mrj tmuogt nur`eo e`t`mk estruhjet trm`e`eo tgmt fukk-samkj njfkjat`de df tgjkdamk`zjr rjqu`rjs m h`ssjn mpprdmag. ^gj MDH prdv`njn m amkk td ij hmnj wgjejvjr tgjkdamk`zjr adursj njv`mt`de jxajjnjn = ndt frdh tgj ajetrj, iut n`n edt prdv`nj m stmenmrn amkkmen rjspdesj fdr fukk-samkj njfkjat`de.
^gj amptm`e‐s rjspdesj, mt =6>3<37, mabedwkjnojn tgmt tgjy wjrj mt fukk njfkjat`de, men en`amtjntgmt gj adukn edt rjadea`kj tgj FD‐s stmtjhjet midut fukk njfkjat`de w`tg g`s dwe hjetmk hdnjktgmt tgjy wdukn rj-`etjrajpt tgj kdamk`zjr frdh tgj r`ogt.
^gj FD‐s stmtjhjet, mt =6>3<==, en`amtjs tgmt gj wms ajrtm`e tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms edt de tgj
kdamk`zjr. gj amptm`e‐s rjspdesj, mt =6>3<=>, en`amtjs tgmt gj wms st`kk adev`eajn tgmt tgjmutdp`kdt wms e VDY/KDA hdnj men gmn ampturjn tgj kdamk`zjr, men gj adef`rhjn tgmt tgjygmn sjkjatjn tgj adrrjat @KQ frjqujeay.
Mt =6>3<=?, tgj FD vd`ajn g`s n`smorjjhjet rjomrn`eo kdamk`zjr ampturj, men hjet`dejn tgj g`kktd tgj r`ogt df tgj m`rpdrt. g`s adhhue`amt`de en`amtjs tgmt tgj FD wms mwmrj tgmt tgjmutdp`kdt gmn edt ampturjn tgj kdamk`zjr, men uenjrstddn tgj g`kk td ij m gmzmrn.
Mt =6>3<91, tgj FD deaj mom`e stmtjn tgmt tgj OSQ sgdwjn r`ogt df trmab.
^gj arjw n`n edt hm`etm`e m sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. Ms tgj mpprdmag adet`eujn, tgj
p`kdts n`n edt jffjat`vjky adhhue`amtj tgj`r rjspjat`vj pjrajpt`de, uenjrstmen`eo, men futurjprdljat`de df tgj m`rarmft stmtj.
9.7.> Od-mrduen suoojst`de
Nur`eo tgj ture detd f`emk mpprdmag, tgj FD wms daaup`jn w`tg adef`ourmt`de menadhhue`amt`des tmsbs mt tgj t`hj tgj m`rarmft pmssjn = ndt r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr. Ms madesjqujeaj, tgj ‛kdamk`zjr‘ amkk n`n edt daaur.
Mftjr tgj m`rarmft rdkkjn dut df tgj ture, tgj FD `njet`f`jn tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms td tgj r`ogt df tgjkdamk`zjr men wms n`vjro`eo. Mktgduog tgj FD n`n edt usj tgj rjqu`rjn pgrmsjdkdoy df‛kdamk`zjr‘ td mkjrt tgj amptm`e td tgj njv`mt`de, gj n`n rjpjmtjnky mttjhpt td pd`et dut tgjprdikjh, ms gj wms rjqu`rjn td nd iy tgj agjabk`st pg`kdsdpgy njsar`ijn e MDH Vdkuhj =,pmoj 31.93.9. =:7 @e nd`eo sd, gj rjfjrrjn td idtg tgj kdamk`zjr men tgj YEMV Y_P 1: ^YZJ f`emkmpprdmag trmab.
=:7 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), SG@KDQDSGP MEN
YZKJQ FDY ZQJ DF AGJABK@Q^, pmoj 31.93.9
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 125/215
- ==? -
^g`s adhhue`amt`de daaurrjn nur`eo me 73-sjaden (=610<=1 td =6>3<11) n`sauss`de ijtwjje tgjp`kdts tgmt fdausjn jxakus`vjky de m`rarmft emv`omt`de. gj FD‐s stmtjhjets n`n edt efkujeaj tgjamptm`e‐s mat`des, k`bjky ijamusj tgjy njet`f`jn pmrmhjtjrs rmtgjr tgme adesjqujeajs menrjqu`rjn mat`de. Me jxmhpkj df kmeoumoj tgmt njet`f`js adesjqujeajs men rjqu`rjn mat`dewdukn ij< ‛_j mrj mt r`sb df g`tt`eo tgj g`kk2 wj hust od mrduen.‘
^gj p`kdts sg`ftjn etd sdkv`eo tgj emv`omt`demk prdikjh men njkmyjn adef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft fdrkmen`eo. g`s prdikjh sdkv`eo wms me mnn`t`demk tmsb, edt edrhmkky mssda`mtjn w`tg tg`s ar`t`amkpgmsj df fk`ogt, wg`ag jsamkmtjn tgj wdrbkdmn w`tgdut rjsdkv`eo tgj prdikjh.
Adhpk`amt`eo hmttjrs, jmag p`kdt wms try`eo td sdkvj m n`ffjrjet prdikjh. gj amptm`e wms try`eotd sdkvj tgj prdikjh df etjrajpt`eo tgj kdamk`zjr men kmen`eo tgj m`rarmft, men tgj FD wms try`eotd sdkvj tgj prdikjh df ojtt`eo tgj amptm`e td agmeoj g`s adursj df mat`de men `e`t`mtj m od-mrduen. g`s hjmet tgmt ej`tgjr p`kdt wms jffjat`vjky adhhue`amt`eo td rjsdkvj tgj s`tumt`de.
^gj n`sauss`de gmn edt rjmssurjn tgj FD midut tgj trmljatdry df tgj m`rarmft, men n`n edt rjsukt`e tgj amptm`e agmeo`eo g`s adursj df mat`de. Adesjqujetky, mt =6>3<13, tgj FD `efdrhmkky
suoojstjn tgmt tgjy nd m od-mrduen men tgje tmkb tgj medhmky tgrduog.
Gdwjvjr, tgj stmtjhjet wms vd`ajn ms me dp`e`de, men n`n edt eakunj tgj pgrmsj ‛od-mrduen‘.^g`s stmtjhjet en`amtjs tgmt tgj FD‐s hjetmk hdnjk wms edw tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms fukk-samkjnjfkjat`de frdh tgj kdamk`zjr men m od-mrduen wms rjqu`rjn. gj suoojst`de wms edt suff`a`jetkymssjrt`vj mt m t`hj wgje me jsamkmt`de df adhhue`amt`de wms ejjnjn, men n`n edt adev`eaj tgjamptm`e td n`sadet`euj tgj mpprdmag.
^gjrj mrj sjvjrmk pdss`ikj rjmsdes wgy tgj FD‐s od-mrduen suoojst`de hmy gmvj ijje pgrmsjnms t wms. Fukk-samkj kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de s sjkndh sjje e adetjhpdrmry m`r trmespdrt dpjrmt`des,men t s pdss`ikj tgmt tgj FD gmn edt jxpjr`jeajn fukk-samkj njfkjat`de s`eaj g`s e`t`mk
`estruhjet fky`eo trm`e`eo. Mnn`t`demkky, wg`kj tgj MDH spja`f`jn m amkkdut td `njet`fy mnjv`mt`de `e jxajss df = ndt, tgjrj wms ed ou`nmeaj ms td wgmt pgrmsjs td usj dr wgmt mat`dehust ij tmbje mt fukk njfkjat`de. Od-mrduen s m hmedjuvrj k`bjky sjje hdrj frjqujetky nur`eos`hukmtdr trm`e`eo tgme k`ej dpjrmt`des, men s typ`amkky e`t`mtjn mt tgj h`ssjn mpprdmag pd`et,rmtgjr tgme sjvjrmk h`kjs ijfdrj tgj h`ssjn mpprdmag pd`et.
Fdr me @KQ mpprdmag, tgj MDH spja`f`js pgrmsjs td ij usjn iy tgj SEF men SF mt nja`s`degj`ogt =:0 (sjj sjat`de =.=?.9.0.= `e tg`s rjpdrt). ^gj SEF stmenmrn amkkduts mrj ‛H`e`huhs,ruewmy e s`ogt‘ dr ‛H`e`huhs, ed adetmat.‘ gj pgrmsjs nd edt rjfjr td od-mrduen, iut`estjmn mkjrt tgj SF td tgj m`rarmft stmtj men rjqu`rj tgj SF td hmbj m nja`s`de. Imsjn de tgjm`rarmft stmtj efdrhmt`de prdv`njn iy tgj SEF, tgj SF en`amtjs tgmt gj s j`tgjr kmen`eo dr`e`t`mt`eo m od-mrduen. @e tgj jvjet df m od-mrduen nja`s`de, tgj SF stmtjs ‛Od-mrduen tgrust,fkmp =:.‘ gj od-mrduen prdajnurj (rjprdnuajn e sjat`de =.=?.9.0.=, F`ourj ?) spja`f`js msk`ogtky n`ffjrjet pgrmsj fdr tgj SF< ‛Od mrduen, fkmps =:.‘ =63
=:0 @i`n., Q^MENMYN AMKKDZ^Q, pmoj 31.19.=
=63 @i`n., OD-MYDZEN SYDAJNZYJ (QS??), pmoj 31.63.1:
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 126/215
- ==7 -
^gj QDS ou`nmeaj fdr tgj SEF wms deky td prdv`nj `efdrhmt`de td tgj SF. ^gj SF tgje hmbjstgj nja`s`de wgjtgjr td od mrduen, men `e`t`mtjs tgj od-mrduen iy stmt`eo me jxjaut`vjadhhmen< ‛Od mrduen, fkmps =:.‘
@e tgj misjeaj df stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy mppk`amikj td g`s aurrjet s`tumt`de, tgj FD gmn td`hprdv`sj g`s od-mrduen suoojst`de.
9.7.: Mpprdmag adet`eumt`de fdkkdw`eo fukk njfkjat`de
M od-mrduen mt fukk njfkjat`de s m njfjeaj mom`est tgj tgrjmt df adkk`s`de w`tg tjrrm`e duts`nj tgj@KQ prdtjatjn mrjm.
Mt =6>3<11, tgj amptm`e mabedwkjnojn tgj FD‐s suoojst`de, men `en`amtjn tgmt gj wduknadet`euj tgj mpprdmag. ^gj amptm`e‐s mabedwkjnojhjet df tgj FD‐s od-mrduen suoojst`de`en`amtjs tgmt tgj amptm`e gmn gjmrn tgj suoojst`de.
Quisjqujet pmrmormpgs njsar`ij tgj amptm`e‐s k`bjky hjetmk hdnjk men jxpkm`e wgy t hmnj
sjesj td g`h td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag o`vje g`s pjrajpt`de men uenjrstmen`eo df tgj s`tumt`de,njsp`tj tgj adhhue`amt`des frdh tgj FD.
^gj amptm`e k`bjky tgduogt tgmt gj wms adetrdkk`eo tgj m`rarmft tgrduog tgj mutdp`kdt men tgmt tgjmutdp`kdt wms emv`omt`eo imab td tgj kdamk`zjr men detd tgj ok`njskdpj. Adeaurrjetky, gj wmsk`bjky mttjhpt`eo td rjadea`kj g`s hjetmk hdnjk w`tg tgj hdvjhjet men pds`t`de df tgj adursjnjv`mt`de imr de g`s GQ@. ^gjsj tmsbs wjrj m g`og wdrbkdmn fdr tgj amptm`e mt tg`s t`hj.
^gjrj mrj m euhijr df jev`rdehjetmk aujs mvm`kmikj e tgj adabp`t td prdv`nj efdrhmt`de td tgjp`kdts midut mutdp`kdt mpprdmag hdnj prdorjss. Ms n`saussjn e sjat`de 9.6.1.1, tgj arjw k`bjkyn`n edt pjraj`vj tgjsj aujs dr adrrjkmtj tgjh w`tg tgj mutdp`kdt hdnj agmeoj frdh VDY/KDAtd HME.
Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj amptm`e‐s k`bjky njs`rjn adursj df mat`de wms td hm`etm`e tgj aurrjet gjmn`eo tdrj-`etjrajpt tgj kdamk`zjr men ukt`hmtjky td kmen mt APYI. G`s njs`rjn adursj df mat`de wms`efkujeajn iy tgj fdkkdw`eo<
• ^gj mutdp`kdt hdnj k`bjky sw`tagjn td HME men GNO GDKN nur`eo tgj rdkk-dut frdhtgj ture, men tgj amptm`e st`kk ijk`jvjn tgmt `t wms `e VDY/KDA men tgmt `t wms`etjrajpt`eo men wdukn trmab tgj kdamk`zjr.
• ^gj aurrjet jrrdejdus gjmn`eo rjsuktjn e me mppmrjet `etjrajpt meokj wgje, e fmat, tgjtruj gjmn`eo wms n`vjrojet. g`s pdwjrfuk suppdrt`eo auj wms n`spkmyjn n`rjatky efrdet df g`h de tgj GQ@.
• ^gj amptm`e‐s fk`ogt n`rjatdr wms k`bjky e MZ^D MSS etjrajpt hdnj, men wdukn gmvjijje adhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk.
• ^gj amptm`e gmn prjv`dus suaajssfuk jxpjr`jeajs kmen`eo e pddr wjmtgjr aden`t`des.
• ^gj amptm`e hmy gmvj jxpjatjn td irjmb dut df tgj akdun imsj men maqu`rj v`sumkrjfjrjeaj mt dr ijkdw ?33 fjjt mok. ^g`s jxpjatmt`de df maqu`r`eo v`sumk rjfjrjeaj wduknsuppdrt tgj amptm`e‐s njs`rjn adursj df mat`de td kmen tgj m`rarmft. (^gj arjw wjrj mwmrj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 127/215
- ==0 -
tgmt tgj wjmtgjr mt APYI gmn fkuatumtjn ijtwjje 933 fjjt mok men ¸ sh mt =:33 men ?33fjjt mok men =3 sh mt =633.)
• Od-mrduen s typ`amkky e`t`mtjn mt tgj h`ssjn mpprdmag pd`et rmtgjr tgme sjvjrmk h`kjsijfdrj tgj h`ssjn mpprdmag pd`et.
@earjmsjn strjss kjvjks hmy rjsukt e mttjet`demk emrrdw`eo (sjat`de =.=?.7.1), men ame mnvjrsjky`hpmat m p`kdt‐s mi`k`ty td pjraj`vj men jvmkumtj aujs frdh tgj jev`rdehjet. Mttjet`demkemrrdw`eo ame kjmn td adef`rhmt`de i`ms, wg`ag amusjs pjdpkj td sjjb dut aujs tgmt suppdrt tgjnjs`rjn adursj df mat`de, td tgj pdss`ikj jxakus`de df ar`t`amk aujs tgmt hmy suppdrt me mktjremtj,kjss njs`rmikj gypdtgjs`s.
^gj FD‐s suoojst`de tgmt tgjy nd m od-mrduen rjprjsjets tgj mktjremtj gypdtgjs`s. ^gjrj wjrjhukt`pkj aujs suppdrt`eo tg`s gypdtgjs`s<
• Adursj njv`mt`de imr hdvjhjet td tgj kjft td fukk njfkjat`de,
• OSQ `en`amt`des, men
• Hukt`pkj stmtjhjets frdh tgj FD.
O`vje tgj amptm`e‐s wdrbkdmn, gj wms k`bjky jxpjr`jea`eo earjmsjn strjss. g`s strjss wdukngmvj hmnj g`h susajpt`ikj td tgj efkujeaj df adef`rhmt`de i`ms men mttjet`demk emrrdw`eo. g`ssusajpt`i`k`ty wdukn hmbj t n`ff`aukt fdr tgj amptm`e td pjraj`vj men jvmkumtj dtgjr aujs suag mstgdsj dffjrjn iy tgj FD men iy tgj adursj njv`mt`de imr men OSQ. Mnn`t`demkky, ms tgj SF, tgjamptm`e‐s pr`hmry rdkj wms adetrdkk`eo tgj m`rarmft, wg`ag n`h`e`sgjn tgj t`hj mvm`kmikj td g`htd hm`etm`e me dvjrv`jw df tgj s`tumt`de men fdrhukmtj m strmtjoy.
@t `s k`bjky tgmt tgj amptm`e n`n edt fukky adhprjgjen `efdrhmt`de tgmt `en`amtjn tgmt g`s dr`o`emkpkme wms ed kdeojr v`mikj. Mktgduog gj k`bjky uenjrstddn tgj FD‐s od-mrduen suoojst`de, tgjsuoojst`de adefk`atjn w`tg tgj amptm`e‐s pkme td adhpkjtj tgj mpprdmag men kmen. gjrjfdrj, tgjFD‐s suoojst`de wdukn gmvj ijje kjss njs`rmikj td tgj amptm`e.
^gj amptm`e‐s rjspdesj td tgj FD adhhjeajn hhjn`mtjky mftjr tgj FD f`e`sgjn spjmb`eo2 tgjamptm`e n`n edt tmbj mey t`hj td jvmkumtj tgj FD‐s suoojst`de. ^gj misjeaj df mey jvmkumt`de dftgj FD‐s suoojst`de s en`amt`vj df tgj amptm`e ij`eo mffjatjn iy pkme adet`eumt`de i`ms (sjat`de=.=7.=). ^gj amptm`e k`bjky njfjrrjn mey nja`s`de td od mrduen, men njfmuktjn td g`s dr`o`emk pkmetd rj-`etjrajpt tgj kdamk`zjr men kmen.
^gj fuenmhjetmk n`smorjjhjet ijtwjje m suoojst`de td od mrduen men adet`eumt`de df tgjmpprdmag s m strdeo en`amtdr df furtgjr irjmbndwe e tgj p`kdts‐ sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss.^gj adesjqujeaj df tg`s furtgjr irjmbndwe wms tgmt `t adhprdh`sjn tgj p`kdts‐ mi`k`ty td
adhhue`amtj jffjat`vjky, men t ijamhj me mnn`t`demk prdikjh tgmt tgj arjw ejjnjn td sdkvj.
Mt =6>3<1:, tgj FD mabedwkjnojn tgj amptm`e‐s stmtjhjet men tgj mpprdmag wms adet`eujn.
9.7.6 Zestmikj mpprdmag men adet`eumt`de df mpprdmag
^gj QDSs rjqu`rjn tgj SEF td hmbj m amkkdut (pds`t`de, mkt`tunj, mkt`hjtjr, men `estruhjetardss-agjab) mt tgj f`emk mpprdmag f`x (FMF) men m amkkdut fdr pmrmhjtjrs jxajjn`eo tdkjrmeajs
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 128/215
- =93 -
wg`kj es`nj tgj FMF (sjat`des =.=?.9.7.1 men =.=?.9.7.:). gj FD n`n edt hmbj j`tgjr tgj amkkdutms FMI6:63 pmssjn mijmh SDBME FMF dr m amkkdut fdr jxajss`vj m`rspjjn.
^gj misjeaj df tgjsj amkkduts s en`amt`vj df tgj FD‐s g`og wdrbkdmn es`nj tgj FMF, ms wjkk msdf g`s pr`dr`t`zmt`de, e tgmt gj wms mkhdst ajrtm`eky hdrj adeajrejn w`tg ojtt`eo tgj amptm`e tdnd m od-mrduen tgme w`tg hmb`eo adrrjat`des td `en`v`numk mpprdmag pmrmhjtjrs.
^gj adhpmey‐s stmikj mpprdmag ar`tjr`m wjrj njsar`ijn e tgj F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk(FDH) =6= (sjat`de =.=?.9.7.> `e tg`s rjpdrt). Mktgduog tgj FDH prdv`njn pdk`ay ou`nmeaj, tgjrjwms ed adhpkjhjetmry prdajnurmk ou`nmeaj e tgj MDH njsar`i`eo gdw tgj pdk`ay wdukn ij`hpkjhjetjn, s`h`kmr td stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy men mat`des spja`f`jn fdr dtgjr jvjets suag msrjmag`eo nja`s`de gj`ogt. @e tgj misjeaj df m prdajnurmk frmhjwdrb fdr e`t`mt`eo m od-mrduen etgj jvjet df me uestmikj mpprdmag, p`kdts gmn td hprdv`sj.
^gj evjst`omt`de jxmh`ejn gdw F`rst M`r‐s AP\F-imsjn I?1? p`kdts wdukn, e tgj rdkj df SEF,mnv`sj tgj SF df me uestmikj mpprdmag men tgj ejjn td od mrduen. S`kdts wjrj mwmrj tgmt edQDSs jx`stjn fdr tg`s s`tumt`de, men p`kdt rjspdesjs vmr`jn. Qdhj p`kdts struookjn td meswjr tgj
qujst`de, tmb`eo up td 03 sjadens td rjspden td m s`tumt`de tgmt e tgj adabp`t wdukn rjqu`rj`hhjn`mtj mat`de.
Mt =6>3<>=.0, tgj FD stmtjn, ‛_j‐rj 1 h`kj f`emk2 wj‐rj edt adef`oojn.‘ gj m`rarmft wms de tgjok`njskdpj mt ==>3 fjjt msk (093 fjjt midvj m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de) w`tg kmen`eo ojmr ndwe men fkmps=:. Jeo`ej tgrust wms ij`eo rjnuajn td `nkj, k`bjky ijamusj tgj amptm`e ejjnjn td rjnuajm`rspjjn td jemikj furtgjr adef`ourmt`de agmeojs. M`rarmft pds`t`de wms 9.0 eh frdh tgj ruewmytgrjsgdkn, w`tg fukk-samkj kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de de tgj GQ@s.
^gj mkt`tunj tgrjsgdkn ijkdw wg`ag tgj adhpmey‐s stmikj mpprdmag pdk`ay mppk`jn men rjqu`rjnme hhjn`mtj od-mrduen f tgj mpprdmag wms edt stmikj wms =333 fjjt midvj m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de.
Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj FMI6:63 mpprdmag wms uestmikj e sjvjrmk pmrmhjtjrs<=69
• @t wms `e jxajss df 9 ndts‐ njv`mt`de frdh tgj kdamk`zjr2
• Q`oe`f`amet agmeojs e gjmn`eo men p`tag wjrj rjqu`rjn td adrrjat td prdpjr fk`ogt pmtg2
• M`rspjjn wms =?6 B@MQ, VYJF + >> bedts2
• ^gj m`rarmft wms edt adef`ourjn fdr kmen`eo2 men
• ^gj kmen`eo agjabk`st wms edt adhpkjtj.
O`vje tgj FD‐s rjpjmtjn adeajres vd`ajn jmrk`jr nur`eo tgj mpprdmag, t s mkhdst ajrtm`e tgmt, emnv`s`eo tgj amptm`e tgmt tgjy wjrj 1 h`kjs f`emk men edt adef`ourjn, g`s etjenjn hjssmoj wms
‛^gj mpprdmag `s uestmikj men wj hust od mrduen.‘
=6= F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk (FDH), Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (== Hmy 93==), sjat`de 7.=1< Qtmi`k`zjnMpprdmag Ar`tjr`m, pmoj 7-=1 td 7-=>
=69 VYJF rjfjrs td tgj mpprdmag rjfjrjeaj spjjn.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 129/215
- =9= -
Srdajnurjs fdr akjmr men ades`stjet adhhue`amt`des mrj etjenjn td prjvjet adefus`de ijtwjjetgj p`kdts. @e tg`s `estmeaj, tgj FD wms prdv`n`eo ades`stjet `efdrhmt`de td tgj amptm`e rjomrn`eom`rarmft pds`t`de men stmtj. Gdwjvjr, tgj ‛_j‐rj 1 h`kj f`emk2 wj‐rj edt adef`oojn‘ amkk wms`hhjn`mtjky fdkkdwjn iy tgj amptm`e‐s adhhmen fdr sjkjat`de df fkmps 9:. g`s sjqujeaj`en`amtjs tgmt tgj hjssmoj tgj amptm`e pjraj`vjn wms ‛_j ejjn td adef`ourj fdr kmen`eo.‘@hhjn`mtj mat`de td adhhjeaj m od-mrduen wms rjqu`rjn, men tgj FD‐s adhhue`amt`des midut
tgj uestmikj mpprdmag wjrj edt akjmr.
^gj FD gmn hmnj m prjv`dus od-mrduen suoojst`de us`eo ede-stmenmrn kmeoumoj, wg`ag wms`ejffjat`vj. Q`h`kmrky, tgj FD‐s stmtjhjet mt 1 h`kjs wms mksd ejffjat`vj, ijamusj t eakunjn`efdrhmt`de deky midut m`rarmft pds`t`de men stmtj. ^gj FD‐s `hpk`amt`de wms tgmt m od-mrduensgdukn ij e`t`mtjn, iut tg`s wms suiljat td h`s`etjrprjtmt`de.
Mt =6>3<>:, tgj amptm`e‐s rjspdesj td tgj FD‐s 1-h`kj amkk wms td amkk fdr fkmps 9:. ^g`s rjspdesjsuoojsts tgmt tgj amptm`e k`bjky h`s`etjrprjtjn tgj FD‐s stmtjhjet ms m prdhpt td f`e`sgadef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo rmtgjr tgme uenjrstmen`eo tgj FD‐s etjenjn hjssmoj tgmttgj mpprdmag wms uestmikj men m od-mrduen wms ejajssmry.
^gj amptm`e sg`ftjn fdaus frdh tgj trmab n`spkmajhjet td rmp`nky adef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft fdrkmen`eo. g`s sg`ft furtgjr suoojsts tgmt tgj amptm`e etjenjn td adet`euj g`s njs`rjn adursj dfmat`de, wg`ag wms td kmen mt APYI. @t `s k`bjky tgmt gj wms st`kk ij`eo mffjatjn iy mttjet`demkemrrdw`eo men pkme adet`eumt`de i`ms.
^gj fdkkdw`eo pmrmormpgs n`sauss tgj arjw‐s k`bjky hjetmk hdnjks men jxpkm`e wgy `t hmnjsjesj td tgj amptm`e td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag o`vje g`s pjrajpt`de men uenjrstmen`eo df tgjs`tumt`de.
Iy edw, tgj amptm`e‐s wdrbkdmn gmn earjmsjn furtgjr. Gj wms st`kk tgj SF men wms st`kk wdrb`eo
td ojt de adursj wg`kj gj `etjormtjn ejw `efdrhmt`de `etd g`s hjetmk hdnjk. Edw gj gmn tgjmnn`t`demk tmsb df rmp`nky adef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft e t`hj td kmen. gjrjfdrj, t s k`bjky tgmt tgjamptm`e wms jvje hdrj susajpt`ikj td pkme adet`eumt`de i`ms mt tg`s pd`et tgme gj gmn ijje deky=9 sjadens jmrk`jr.
O`vje tgj amptm`e‐s wdrbkdmn men hjetmk hdnjk, `t `s k`bjky tgmt deky akjmr men uemhi`oudus`efdrhmt`de wdukn gmvj suaajjnjn `e agmeo`eo g`s uenjrstmen`eo df tgj s`tumt`de men g`sadursj df mat`de. Ms n`saussjn e sjat`de 9.7.:, tgj amptm`e‐s njs`rjn adursj df mat`de wmssuppdrtjn iy tgj fdkkdw`eo<
• G`s ijk`jf tgmt tgj mutdp`kdt wms e VDY/KDA w`tg me etjrajpt td tgj kdamk`zjr2
• ^gj mppmrjet etjrajpt meokj n`spkmyjn de tgj GQ@2
• Fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs adhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk2
• Srjv`dus suaajssfuk jxpjr`jeajs e kmen`eo mftjr adenuat`eo me estruhjet mpprdmag2
• Jxpjatmt`de td maqu`rj v`sumk rjfjrjeaj2
• ^gj fmat tgmt m od-mrduen s typ`amkky e`t`mtjn mt tgj h`ssjn mpprdmag pd`et.
^gj FD‐s njs`rjn adursj df mat`de, m od-mrduen, wms suppdrtjn iy<
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 130/215
- =99 -
• Hdvjhjet df tgj adursj njv`mt`de imr td fukk njfkjat`de2
• @earjmsj e trmab n`vjrojeaj njsp`tj tgj mppmrjet etjrajpt meokj n`spkmyjn de tgj GQ@2
• OSQ `en`amt`des2
• Zestmikj mpprdmag2 men
• ^jrrm`e gmzmrn.
Ms ijfdrj, `t `s k`bjky tgmt tgj amptm`e n`n edt fukky adhprjgjen tgmt g`s pkme td adhpkjtj tgjmpprdmag men kmen`eo wms ed kdeojr v`mikj. gj amptm`e‐s rjspdesj td tgj FD adhhjeajnsjvjrmk sjadens mftjr tgj FD f`e`sgjn spjmb`eo, en`amt`eo tgmt tgj amptm`e gmn k`bjky tmbje t`hjtd jvmkumtj tgj FD‐s ‛1 h`kj‘ stmtjhjet. gj amptm`e k`bjky n`n edt ades`njr m od-mrduen, iutmom`e njfmuktjn td g`s pkme td kmen mt APYI. G`s pr`dr`ty edw ijamhj adef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft,men tgj emv`omt`demk prdikjh k`bjky ijamhj m kdwjr pr`dr`ty.
^gj ejffjat`vj stmtjhjet iy tgj FD men tgj h`suenjrstmen`eo iy tgj amptm`e mrj en`amtdrs dffurtgjr irjmbndwe e tgj p`kdts‐ sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. gj amptm`e‐s hjetmk hdnjk wms
k`bjky tgmt tgj mpprdmag men kmen`eo adukn ij smkvmojn, men tgj FD‐s hjetmk hdnjk wms mkhdstajrtm`eky tgmt tgjrj wms s`oe`f`amet r`sb td tgj smfjty df fk`ogt men tgmt m od-mrduen wms rjqu`rjn.^gjsj n`vjrojet hjetmk hdnjks adhprdh`sjn tgj p`kdts‐ mi`k`ty td adhhue`amtj men wdrbtdojtgjr jffjat`vjky td rjsdkvj tgj prdorjss`vjky njtjr`drmt`eo s`tumt`de.
^gj FD‐s stmtjhjet n`n edt jxpk`a`tky njet`fy tgj uestmikj mpprdmag, dr `eakunj mey od-mrduenadhhmen dr n`rjat`vj. Adesjqujetky, tgj amptm`e n`n edt etjrprjt tgj FD‐s ‛1 h`kj f`emk menedt adef`oojn‘ stmtjhjet ms ou`nmeaj td `e`t`mtj m od-mrduen, iut `estjmn `etjrprjtjn `t ms memnv`sdry tgmt tgjy ejjnjn td jxpjn`tj adef`ourmt`de df tgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo. gj amptm`eadet`eujn tgj mpprdmag men amkkjn fdr mnn`t`demk stjps td adef`ourj tgj m`rarmft.
9.7.?
F`emk adef`ourmt`de fdr kmen`eoMt =6>3<>:.0, tgj amptm`e `estruatjn tgj FD td sjkjat fkmps 9: (F`ourj =7), men tgj FD n`n sd. ^gjQDSs rjqu`rjn tgj FD td amkk dut adef`rhmt`de tgmt tgj rjqujstjn fkmp sjkjat`de wms hmnj, menmksd m adef`rhmt`de tgmt tgj fkmps gmn rjmagjn tgj sjkjatjn pds`t`de. Gdwjvjr, tgj FD n`n edthmbj j`tgjr df tgjsj amkks fdr tgj fkmps 9: sjkjat`de.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 131/215
- =91 -
F`ourj =7. FNY pkdt df tgj f`emk mpprdmag
Mt =6>3<>0.=, tgj FD mnv`sjn tgj amptm`e tgmt tgjy wjrj mksd jxpjr`jea`eo fukk njfkjat`de de tgjOSQ men tgmt tgjy ejjnjn td od kjft. g`s wms yjt medtgjr mttjhpt td efkujeaj tgj amptm`e‐sadursj df mat`de, men suoojsts tgmt tgj FD gmn hdhjetmr`ky stdppjn try`eo td adev`eaj tgjamptm`e td e`t`mtj m od-mrduen men wms `estjmn mttjhpt`eo td ojt tgj m`rarmft imab de tgjkdamk`zjr, wgjrj tgj r`sb df tjrrm`e wdukn ij jk`h`emtjn.
Mt =6>3<:>.1, tgj amptm`e rjspdenjn tgmt gj adukn edt od kjft. ^gj `en`amtjn gjmn`eo mt tgj t`hjwms 113³, wg`ag prdv`njn me mppmrjet =?³ etjrajpt meokj imab td tgj kdamk`zjr. O`vje tgmt tgjfk`ogt wms deky 1 h`kjs frdh tgj ruewmy, `t `s k`bjky tgmt tgj amptm`e wms rjkuatmet td ture furtgjrkjft men earjmsj tgj `etjrajpt meokj, wg`ag adukn gmvj rjsuktjn e dvjrsgddt`eo tgrduog tgjkdamk`zjr td tgj kjft `f tgj mppmrjet `etjrajpt meokj gmn ijje adrrjat. Mnn`t`demkky, e MZ^D MSS`etjrajpt hdnj, g`s fk`ogt n`rjatdr wms k`bjky adhhmen`eo w`eos-kjvjk td hm`etm`e tgj gjmn`eosjkjatjn w`tg tgj gjmn`eo iuo.
Nur`eo tgj pjr`dn df =6>3<:6 td =6>=<37, tgj FD hmnj sjvjrmk stmtjhjets rjomrn`eo m`rarmftpds`t`de men mv`de`as hdnj. gj amptm`e amkkjn fdr fkmps 13 men mksd mabedwkjnojn tgj FD‐sstmtjhjets, iut tddb ed mat`de imsjn de tgjh. ^gj QDSs rjqu`rjn tgj FD td amkk dutadef`rhmt`de tgmt tgj rjqujstjn fkmp sjkjat`de wms hmnj, men mksd m adef`rhmt`de tgmt tgj fkmpsgmn rjmagjn tgj sjkjatjn pds`t`de. Gdwjvjr, tgj FD n`n edt hmbj j`tgjr df tgjsj amkks fdr tgj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 132/215
- =9> -
fkmps 13 sjkjat`de. Mt =6>=<37.1, tgj FD stmrtjn td hmbj m suoojst`de, men tgj amptm`e `etjrruptjntgj stmtjhjet w`tg m amkk fdr fkmps >3.
^g`s n`sauss`de wms fmst-pmajn men adeaurrjet w`tg adef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft, men n`n edt gjkp tdrjsdkvj tgj emv`omt`demk dr mv`de`as ssujs. gj amptm`e etjrruptjn tgj FD‐s stmtjhjets w`tg tgjfkmps 13 men >3 amkks, wg`ag arjmtjn m nyemh`a ijtwjje tgjh df gmstj td adhpkjtj adef`ourmt`de
tmb`eo prjajnjeaj dvjr tgj FD‐s adeajres. gj FD‐s stmtjhjet wms k`bjky etjenjn td ij medtgjrsuoojst`de td nd m od-mrduen, iut wms edt adhpkjtjn ijamusj df tgj etjrrupt`de.
^gj kmst 9 `tjhs df tgj kmen`eo agjabk`st rjqu`rj idtg tgj SEF men SF td vjr`fy kmen`eo ojmr menfkmp `en`amt`des. Mt =6>=<=3.=, tgj FD stmtjn tgmt tgj ojmr wms ndwe w`tg 1 orjje k`ogts, msspja`f`jn e tgj agjabk`st, iut n`n edt hjet`de tgj fkmp pds`t`de. gj amptm`e rjspdenjn w`tg memabedwkjnojhjet df tgj fkmps mt >3 w`tg m orjje k`ogt, iut n`n edt vjr`fy tgj kmen`eo ojmrpds`t`de. Mftjr mkk mat`des gmvj ijje adhpkjtjn men vjr`f`jn, tgj SEF s jxpjatjn td meedueaj tdtgj SF ‛Kmen`eo agjabk`st adhpkjtj,‘ iut tgj FD n`n edt nd tg`s. Mktgduog tgj kmen`eo agjabk`stgmn edt ijje amkkjn adhpkjtj, tgj m`rarmft wms e tgj kmen`eo adef`ourmt`de.
^gj FD n`n edt hmbj : rjqu`rjn amkkduts ms tgj f`emk adef`ourmt`de agmeojs daaurrjn. ^g`sdh`ss`de wms ades`stjet w`tg tmsb sgjnn`eo df edrhmk SEF nut`js nur`eo m pjr`dn df vjry g`ogwdrbkdmn, td jemikj adhpkjt`de df dtgjr tmsbs mssda`mtjn w`tg adef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft,hde`tdr`eo m`rarmft pds`t`de, men mttjhpt`eo td adev`eaj tgj amptm`e td od mrduen. gj FD wmstmsb-smturmtjn. gj adesjqujeaj df tg`s tmsb smturmt`de wms tgmt tgj FD gmn kjss t`hj menadoe`t`vj ampma`ty td njvjkdp men jxjautj m adhhue`amt`de strmtjoy tgmt wdukn rjsukt e tgjamptm`e agmeo`eo g`s adursj df mat`de.
Ms n`saussjn midvj, tgrust gmn ijje rjnuajn td nkj mt =6>3<16, k`bjky ijamusj tgj amptm`eejjnjn td rjnuaj m`rspjjn frdh =?7 B@MQ td jemikj furtgjr adef`ourmt de agmeojs. Ms tgj fkmpswjrj sjkjatjn td 9:, 13, men >3, p`tag meokj rjhm`ejn mt 9³ edsj-up. Ms nrmo `earjmsjn, m`rspjjn
njarjmsjn td =16 B@MQ mt =6>=<==, m >9-bedt rjnuat`de e 1: sjadens. Mt =6>=<3:, tgrust ijome`earjms`eo frdh nkj men rjmagjn =.: jeo`ej prjssurj rmt`d (JSY) mt =6>=<=9. g`s earjmsj wmsk`bjky tgj rjsukt df tgj amptm`e rjspden`eo td tgj m`rspjjn rjnuat`de. Adeaurrjetky, tgj rmtj dfnjsajet njarjmsjn frdh midut ?33 fjjt pjr h`eutj (fph) td midut =:3 fph, men tgj m`rarmft wjetfrdh ij`eo de tgj ok`njskdpj td ij`eo `e jxajss df 9 ndts midvj.
^gj amptm`e‐s stmtjhjet mt =6>3<:>.1 tgmt gj adukn edt od kjft daaurrjn ijtwjje g`s amkks fdr fkmps9: men fkmps 13. Mt tg`s t`hj, g`s mttjet`de wms k`bjky ijadh`eo fdausjn de m`rarmft adef`ourmt`demen m`rspjjn adetrdk, td tgj njtr`hjet df dtgjr pmrmhjtjrs. Ms `en`amtjn iy tgj rmtj df njsajetagmeoj men imkkdde`eo midvj tgj ok`njskdpj, g`s mttjet`de td fky`eo tgj @KQ mpprdmag wmsejomt`vjky mffjatjn. g`s s`tumt`de s m strdeo en`amt`de tgmt tgj amptm`e wms mffjatjn iymttjet`demk emrrdw`eo.
^gj amptm`e gmn hm`etm`ejn tgj smhj gjmn`eo frdh wgje tgj m`rarmft rdkkjn dut df tgj ture, mt=610<3:, uet`k =6>3<:> (= h`eutj men :3 sjadens). Nur`eo tg`s pjr`dn, tgj m`rarmft trmvjkkjn frdh?.0 td 9.1 h`kjs frdh tgj tgrjsgdkn, men prdorjss`vjky n`vjrojn frdh tgj kdamk`zjr td fukk-samkjnjfkjat`de de tgj GQ@.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 133/215
- =9: -
^gj amptm`e gmn efdrhmt`de mvm`kmikj td g`h en`amt`eo tgmt tgj mppmrjet etjrajpt meokj wmsedt wdrb`eo. Gdwjvjr, adef`rhmt`de i`ms hmy gmvj njormnjn g`s mi`k`ty j`tgjr td pjraj`vj tg`s`efdrhmt`de dr td `etjormtj `t `etd g`s hjetmk hdnjk.
Nur`eo tg`s pjr`dn, tgj amptm`e wms daaup`jn w`tg sjvjrmk s`huktmejdus tmsbs. Gj ejjnjn tdn`rjat tgj f`emk adef`ourmt`de df tgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo, rjnuaj men stmi`k`zj m`rspjjn, rjsdkvj
tgj kdamk`zjr ssuj, men rjom`e tgj ok`njskdpj. Gj mksd ejjnjn td hmbj spja`f`jn amkkduts td vjr`fytgmt tgj adef`ourmt`de wms adrrjat. gj amptm`e h`ssjn mt kjmst = rjqu`rjn amkkdut, men wmsgmv`eo n`ff`aukty etjormt`eo adetrdk eputs td adrrjat fdr hukt`pkj pmrmhjtjrs s`huktmejdusky.^g`s n`ff`aukty s `en`amt`vj df tmsb smturmt`de.
Nuj td mttjet`demk emrrdw`eo men tmsb smturmt`de, tgj amptm`e k`bjky n`n edt gmvj m g`og-kjvjkdvjrv`jw df tgj s`tumt`de. g`s kmab df dvjrv`jw adhprdh`sjn g`s mi`k`ty td njet`fy men hmemojr`sb.
9.7.7 F`emk pdrt`de df mpprdmag
Frdh =6>=<3: uet`k hpmat, tgj FNY nmtm sgdw euhjrdus adetrdk wgjjk hdvjhjets mt tgj smhjt`hj ms tgj m`rarmft wms p`tag`eo edsj-ndwe. gjsj wgjjk hdvjhjets wjrj ades`stjet w`tg tgjamptm`e ue`etjet`demkky hdv`eo tgj wgjjk frdh s`nj td s`nj ms gj hdvjn tgj adetrdk adkuhefdrwmrn td adrrjat td tgj ok`njskdpj. Qhmkk rdkk men gjmn`eo agmeojs daaurrjn nur`eo tg`s pjr`dntgmt wjrj ad`ea`njet w`tg tgj wgjjk hdvjhjets. gj gjmn`eo agmeojs mrj uek`bjky td gmvj gmnme mpprja`mikj jffjat de fk`ogt n`rjatdr adhhmen imrs, wg`ag k`bjky adet`eujn td adhhmenw`eos-kjvjk.
Mt =6>=<=6, sjadens mftjr tgj f`emk kmen`eo adef`ourmt`de wms mag`jvjn, tgj m`rarmft pds`t`de wmsmpprdx`hmtjky >=33 fjjt r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej, =.: eh frdh tgj Yuewmy 1:^ tgrjsgdkn.GQ@ en`amt`des wdukn gmvj ijje fukk-samkj r`ogt kdamk`zjr men fukk-samkj midvj ok`njskdpj.M`rspjjn gmn stmi`k`zjn mt =16 B@MQ, men jeo`ej tgrust wms midut =.: JSY. Mkt`tunj wms 0>3 fjjtmsk (?93 fjjt midvj m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de). ^gj m`rarmft wms edw ejmr tgj mkt`tunj mt wg`ag tgj amptm`ek`bjky jxpjatjn td irjmb dut df tgj akdun imsj men maqu`rj v`sumk rjfjrjeaj.
Mt =6>=<=6, tgj amptm`e stmtjn tgmt sdhjtg`eo s`h`kmr gmn prjv`dusky gmppjejn td medtgjr p`kdt,men mom`e en`amtjn tgmt gj wms adet`eu`eo tgj mpprdmag. @t s pdss`ikj tgmt tgj amptm`e gmnh`suenjrstddn tgj rjaduet`eo df tgj prjv`dus daaurrjeaj, dr tgmt gj n`n edt fukky rjamkk tgjdaaurrjeaj, e wg`ag tgj arjw gmn ndej m od-mrduen men rjsdkvjn tgj adhpmss/emv`omt`demk`ssuj mt m smfj mkt`tunj. g`s adhhjet iy tgj amptm`e n`n edt adetr`iutj td tgj prdikjh sdkv`eo`e tgj adabp`t dr mkkjv`mtj tgj FD‐s adeajres midut tgj amptm`e‐s adursj df mat`de.
^gj amptm`e‐s stmtjhjet en`amtjs tgmt gj wms k`bjky mwmrj td sdhj jxtjet tgmt tgjrj wms mprdikjh w`tg tgj `en`amtjn gjmn`eo men emv`omt`demk en`amt`des. Njsp`tj tg`s, gj adet`eujn tgjmpprdmag, pdss`iky ijamusj gj jxpjatjn td sdde maqu`rj v`sumk rjfjrjeajs, ms wms g`s jxpjr`jeajnur`eo @ea`njet Dej (sjat`de =.=?.1.1.9).
^gj m`rarmft p`tag mtt`tunj rjhm`ejn rjkmt`vjky stmikj (9³ edsj-up) ijtwjje =6>3<=3 men =6>=<=7,dtgjr tgme m fjw h`edr jxaurs`des wg`kj tgrust wms njarjms`eo men tgj m`rarmft wms ij`eoadef`ourjn (F`ourj =7). ^gjsj jxaurs`des mrj ades`stjet w`tg mutdp`kdt p`tag hdnj DFF, hmeumkp`tag A_Q, men tgj mutdp`kdt hm`etm`e`eo tgj kmst p`tag mtt`tunj sjt iy tgj amptm`e (sjat`de 9.1).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 134/215
- =96 -
Mt =6>=<=7, tgj m`rarmft ijome p`tag`eo edsj-ndwe, rjmag`eo m p`tag mtt`tunj df ∙9³ mt =6>=<19.^gj amptm`e gmn k`bjky disjrvjn tgmt tgj rmtj df njsajet gmn fkmttjejn men tgmt tgjy gmnimkkddejn midvj tgj ok`njskdpj, men gmn put fdrwmrn prjssurj de tgj adetrdk adkuhe e jxajssdf tgj kdw njtjet fdraj. Deaj tgj adetrdk adkuhe prjssurj ijamhj kjss tgme tgj kdw njtjet, tgjmutdp`kdt hm`etm`ejn tgj ejw p`tag mtt`tunj df ∙9³.
Frdh midut =6>=<=0 td =6>=<9?, FNY nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj njsajet rmtj `earjmsjn frdh midut=33 fph td ?33 fph. ^gj edsj-ndwe p`tag agmeoj men `earjmsjn njsajet rmtj `en`amtj tgmt tgjamptm`e gmn sw`tagjn g`s pr`dr`t`js frdh adef`our`eo men m`rspjjn rjnuat`de imab td tgjok`njskdpj men wms hmedjuvr`eo td rj-`etjrajpt tgj ok`njskdpj.
Mt =6>=<96.1, tgj amptm`e hmnj m stmtjhjet midut tgj ok`njskdpj. ^gj FD mabedwkjnojn men`en`amtjn tgmt `t wms fukky njfkjatjn. FNY men rmnmr nmtm sgdw tgmt, mt tgj t`hj, tgj m`rarmft wmsmt 773 fjjt msk men wms wjkk midvj tgj ok`njskdpj men wjkk r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr. Ijamusj tgjm`rarmft pds`t`de wms sd fmr r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr men sd akdsj td tgj ok`njskdpj trmesh`ttjr, `t `spdss`ikj tgmt adabp`t ok`njskdpj en`amt`des wjrj uerjk`mikj.
Mt =6>=<13.7, tgj FD hmnj m VGF rmn`d trmesh`ss`de td APYI tdwjr rjpdrt`eo 1 h`kjs f`emk. Mttg`s t`hj, tgj m`rarmft wms 3.0 eh frdh tgj ruewmy tgrjsgdkn. ^gj njfjrhjet df tg`s amkk td tdwjr`s m furtgjr `en`amt`de df tgj FD‐s g`og wdrbkdmn men tmsb smturmt`de.
Mt =6>=<11, tgj tdwjr rjspdenjn w`tg w`en `efdrhmt`de men akjmrmeaj td kmen, men mt =6>=<10,tgj FD rjpk`jn. Mt =6<>=<>=.=, tgj FD stmtjn tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms lust dvjr tgj sgdrjk`ej. Mt tg`st`hj, tgj m`rarmft wms pmss`eo tgj edrtgjre jnoj df m pden midut 3.? eh td tgj sdutgjmst dfYuewmy 1:^. @t s k`bjky tgmt tgj FD gmn eadrrjatky njet`f`jn tg`s v`sumk fjmturj ms tgj admstk`ejmkdeo tgj sjm. gj FD‐s stmtjhjet en`amtjs tgmt gj k`bjky gmn sdhj ir`jf v`sumk adetmat w`tg tgjsurfmaj, wg`ag wdukn gmvj rj`efdrajn tgj amptm`e‐s jxpjatmt`de df maqu`r`eo v`sumk rjfjrjeajs.
FNY nmtm sgdw tgmt tgj rmtj df njsajet gmn `earjmsjn td =333 fph iy =6>=<>3, w`tg tgj m`rspjjn`earjms`eo td =:9 B@MQ. Mt =6>=<>1, ms tgj m`rarmft p`tagjn furtgjr edsj-ndwe td ∙:³, tgj FDuttjrjn me jxpkjt`vj. g`s wms mkhdst ajrtm`eky me jxprjss`de df g`s ormvj adeajre rjomrn`eo tgjm`rarmft pds`t`de men stmtj.
^gj rmtj df njsajet tgje furtgjr `earjmsjn td =:33 fph mt =6>=<>6 w`tg tgj m`rspjjn `earjms`eofurtgjr td =:7 B@MQ. Mkt`tunj wms :13 fjjt msk (1=3 fjjt midvj m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de). ^gj m`rarmft wmsmijmh tgj Yuewmy 1:^ tgrjsgdkn men >>33 fjjt td tgj r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej (F`ourj=0). Mt tg`s t`hj, tgj FD amkkjn tgj amptm`e iy g`s f`rst emhj men mom`e jxprjssjn g`s adeajremidut tgj s`tumt`de. ^g`s wms m agmeoj df mpprdmag iy tgj FD frdh prdv`n`eo `efdrhmt`de midutm`rarmft pjrfdrhmeaj men pds`t`de td hmb`eo m pjrsdemk mppjmk iy us`eo tgj amptm`e‐s f`rst emhjtd ampturj g`s mttjet`de men irjmb g`s f`xmt`de de tgj ok`njskdpj men kmen`eo.
^gj amptm`e‐s f`xmt`de de tgj ok`njskdpj s furtgjr jv`njeaj tgmt gj gmn kdst tgj g`og-kjvjkdvjrv`jw df tgj s`tumt`de, men n`n edt pjraj`vj dr uenjrstmen tgj adesjqujeajs df adet`eu`eotgj mpprdmag.
Mt =6>=<>?.?, tgj OS_Q ojejrmtjn me murmk ‛s`eb rmtj‘ mkjrt. ^g`s mkjrt prdv`njn enjpjenjet
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 135/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 136/215
- =97 -
s`tumt`de prjsjetjn m ue`quj prdikjh fdr tgj FD df FMI6:632 tgmt s, gdw fmr sgdukn gj mkkdwtgj m`rarmft td njv`mtj ijfdrj tmb`eo dvjr adetrdk frdh tgj amptm`e4
^gjrj `s m g`stdry df `ea`njets men maa`njets `e wg`ag tgj FD wms tgj SEF men wmrejn df mnjtjr`drmt`eo s`tumt`de, iut n`n edt tmbj adetrdk wgje tgj amptm`e adet`eujn me uesmfj adursj dfmat`de (sjat`de =.=?.7.:). @e mkk df tgjsj daaurrjeajs, tgj adhpmey gmn sdhj fdrh df
twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj, iut tgj njfjeaj fm`kjn ijamusj tgj FD n`n edt etjrvjej men tmbjadetrdk df tgj m`rarmft. Qdhj k`bjky rjmsdes fdr tg`s fm`kurj mrj n`ff`aukty e njet`fy`eo suitkj`eampma`tmt`de, mhi`ou`ty e tgj wdrn`eo df tgj prdajnurj, dr eg`i`t`des de tgj pmrt df FDs tdtmbj tgj nrmst`a hjmsurj df tmb`eo adetrdk frdh m amptm`e.
Mt tgj t`hj df tgj F`rst M`r maa`njet, tgjrj wms ed trm`e`eo dr ou`nmeaj w`tg`e tgj adhpmey degdw me FD wdukn jsamkmtj m adeajre td tgj pd`et tgmt m od-mrduen dr agmeoj df adetrdk adukn ijadhhmenjn. @e tgj misjeaj df pdk`a`js men prdajnurjs, suag ms SMAJ (prdi`eo, mkjrt`eo,agmkkjeo`eo, men jhjrojeay wmre`eo), jemik`eo tgj FD td jsamkmtj g`s adeajre ms wjkk msprdv`n`eo tgj mutgdr`ty td tmbj adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft frdh tgj amptm`e, tgj FD wms k`h`tjn td memnv`sdry rdkj. gj FD wms akjmrky mwmrj df tgj earjms`eo r`sb. gj mpprdmag gmn adet`eujn
ijyden 9 pd`ets mt wg`ag m od-mrduen wms rjqu`rjn< f`rst, wgje tgjrj `s fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de,men sjaden, e me uestmikj mpprdmag ijkdw =333 fjjt. Mt idtg df tgjsj pd`ets, tgj FD mttjhptjntd adhhue`amtj tgj ejjn td od mrduen td tgj amptm`e. _g`kj edt ms njf`e`t`vjky men akjmrkyjxprjssjn ms tgjy adukn gmvj ijje, tgjsj mttjhpts mrj en`amtdrs tgmt tgj FD wms adet`eu`eo g`sjffdrts td agmeoj tgj amptm`e‐s adursj df mat`de.
^gj FD gmn prjv`dusky fkdwe ms amptm`e de medtgjr m`rarmft typj w`tg tgj adhpmey. Gdwjvjr,gj wms ejw td tgj I?1?, men mktgduog div`dusky ueadhfdrtmikj w`tg tgj emv`omt`demk s`tumt`de,njfjrrjn td tgj amptm`e.
^gjrj wms ed pdk`ay spja`f`amkky mutgdr`z`eo me FD td jsamkmtj g`s rdkj frdh mnv`sdry td tmb`eo
adetrdk, men tg`s FD k`bjky fjkt `eg`i`tjn frdh nd`eo sd. ^gj FD hmnj hmey mttjhpts tdadhhue`amtj g`s adeajres men suoojst m od-mrduen, iut n`n edt tmbj adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft frdhtgj amptm`e.
^g`s maa`njet men tgj dtgjr 1 daaurrjeajs a`tjn (sjat`de =.=?.7.:) mrj en`amtdrs tgmt fm`kurj dfFDs td tmbj adetrdk e njtjr`drmt`eo s`tumt`des w`kk daams`demkky rjsukt e amtmstrdpg`aadesjqujeajs e tgj okdimk fkjjt df trmespdrt m`rarmft. _`tgdut pdk`a`js men prdajnurjs akjmrkymutgdr`z`eo jsamkmt de df etjrvjet`de td tgj pd`et df tmb`eo m`rarmft adetrdk, sdhj FDs hmy fjjk`eg`i`tjn frdh nd`eo sd.
9.=3 Mnmptmt`des men F`rst M`r I?1? stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs
9.=3.= Mnmptmt`des
Ms n`saussjn e sjat`de =.=?.9, tgjrj wjrj euhjrdus jxmhpkjs df gdw tgj FMI6:63 arjwnjv`mtjn frdh tgj adhpmey‐s dpjrmt`eo pdk`a`js men QDSs. @etjrv`jws w`tg dtgjr AP\F-imsjnI?1? p`kdts rjvjmkjn tgmt sdhj df tgj njv`mt`des wjrj edt ue`quj td tgj arjw df FMI6:63. ^gjsjpdk`ay men prdajnurmk njv`mt`des wjrj mnmptmt`des jhpkdyjn iy tgj p`kdts td om`e sdhjpjraj`vjn ijejf`t. Dvjr t`hj, tgj mnmptmt`des ijamhj edrhmk`zjn ms tgj wmy tgj p`kdts dpjrmtjn
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 137/215
- =90 -
tgj m`rarmft. Qdhj df tgj mnmptmt`des wjrj df m h`edr emturj2 gdwjvjr, dtgjr mnmptmt`des wjrjhdrj k`bjky td gmvj me `hpmat de smfjty df fk`ogt. Fdr jxmhpkj<
• Daams`demkky gmen s`oemks dr m tmp de tgj adetrdk wgjjk wjrj usjn td s`oe`fy tgj trmesfjrdf adetrdk.
• Mpprdmag ir`jf`eos wjrj adhhdeky miirjv`mtjn wgje fky`eo w`tg fmh`k`mr arjw
hjhijrs dr nur`eo oddn wjmtgjr.
• Mkt`tunj amkkduts wdukn ij hmnj us`eo ede-stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy, w`tg gmen s`oemkssdhjt`hjs usjn wgje tgj rmn`ds wjrj `e usj.
• OSQ dr FHQ (fk`ogt hmemojhjet systjh) wjrj sdhjt`hjs usjn td trmes`t`de frdh jerdutj td f`emk @KQ mpprdmag.
S`kdts wjrj mwmrj df wgje tgjy wdukn ij suiljat td tgj adhpmey‐s n`rjat hde`tdr`eo hjtgdnsn`saussjn `e sjat`de =.=?.>, men adukn hdn`fy tgj`r ijgmv`dur nur`eo tgjsj hde`tdr`eo pjr`dns.Mnn`t`demkky, tgj adhpmey gmn ed `en`rjat hde`tdr`eo hjtgdns, suag ms m fueat`de`eo fk`ogtnmtm hde`tdr`eo (FNH) prdormh dr k`ej dpjrmt`des smfjty mun`t (KDQM), mt tgj t`hj df tgj
maa`njet. Adesjqujetky, tgj adhpmey wms uek`bjky td njtjat tgj prjsjeaj dr pjrs`stjeaj df tgjmnmptmt`des.
F`rst M`r‐s supjrv`sdry mat`v`t`js n`n edt njtjat tgj QDS mnmptmt`des w`tg`e tgj AP\F I?1? arjwimsj, eakun`eo tgj arjw df FMI6:63. Ms n`saussjn e jmrk`jr sjat`des df tg`s memkys`s, tgjadesjqujeajs df tgj mnmptmt`des de FMI6:63 wjrj ejffjat`vj etrm-arjw adhhue`amt de,jsamkmtjn wdrbkdmn kjmn`eo td tmsb smturmt`de, men irjmbndwe e sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss.
9.=3.9 ^rmes`t`de td `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh mpprdmag
Ms n`saussjn e sjat`de 9.9, dej pdss`ikj etjrprjtmt`de df tgj FMI6:63 amptm`e‐s pkme tdtrmes`t`de frdh je rdutj td mpprdmag wms m ede-stmenmrn hjtgdn evdkv`eo usj df tgj OSQ tdmk`oe tgj m`rarmft w`tg tgj kdamk`zjr de f`emk mpprdmag. Adesjqujetky, tgj evjst`omt`de jxpkdrjntgj qujst`de df wgjtgjr tg`s mnmptmt`de jx`stjn.
S`kdt `etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt sdhj F`rst M`r I?1? p`kdts usjn tgj OSQ td ture tgj m`rarmft detd@KQ f`emk mpprdmag men wdukn tgje sw`tag td VGF EMV deaj jstmik`sgjn de tgj `eiduen trmab.Adhpmey hmemojhjet ades`njrjn tg`s prmat`aj uemaajptmikj, men sdhj p`kdts etjrv`jwjnn`sadurmojn `ts usj.
S`kdts wgd n`n edt usj tg`s hjtgdn wdukn hmbj tgj sw`tag td VGF EMV mt n`stmeajs imab frdhHZQM^, wg`ag vmr`jn frdh = td =3 h`kjs.
^gj MDH spja`f`js tgmt tgj `tjhs ijkdw tgj nmsgjn k`ej de tgj e-rmeoj agjabk`st mrjmaadhpk`sgjn mftjr emv-m`ns men fk`ogt n`rjatdrs gmvj ijje sjt up, ms ir`jfjn, fdr tgj etjenjnmpprdmag. Adesjqujetky, tgj agjabk`st ameedt ij adhpkjtjn uet`k tgj EMV sw`tag sjkjat`de gmsijje hmnj (HN->= EMV/OSQ sjkjat`de). g`s rjqu`rjhjet rjkmtjs td drnjr df tmsb adhpkjt`dermtgjr tgme m`rarmft pds`t`de rjkmt`vj td tgj f`emk mpprdmag trmab.
^gj vmry`eo n`stmeaj mt wg`ag tgj sw`tag td VGF EMV daaurrjn men tgj usj df m ede-stmenmrnhjtgdn mrj idtg mnmptmt`des. Dej fmatdr k`bjky adetr`iut`eo td njvjkdphjet df tgjsj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 138/215
- =13 -
mnmptmt`des wms tgj misjeaj df efdrhmt`de ms td wgjrj, e rjkmt`de td tgj f`emk mpprdmag trmab,tgj e-rmeoj agjab adhpkjt`de s td ij maadhpk`sgjn.
Me egjrjet r`sb mssda`mtjn w`tg njkmy`eo tgj agmeoj td VGF EMV s tgmt tgj kmen`eo agjabwdukn sdhjt`hjs ij e`t`mtjn ijfdrj tgj e-rmeoj agjab wms adhpkjtjn. g`s sjqujeaj`etrdnuajs tgj pdss`i`k`ty df sdhj agjabk`st tjhs ij`eo h`ssjn ms `tjhs mrj pjrfdrhjn dut df
drnjr. Mnn`t`demkky, njpjen`eo de tgj m`rarmft pds`t`de men gjmn`eo mt tgj t`hj df tgj HN->=EMV sjkjat`de, t s pdss`ikj tgmt tgj mutdp`kdt wdukn edt trmab tgj kdamk`zjr ijamusj tgj sw`tagdaaurrjn tdd kmtj men wms duts`nj df ampturj ar`tjr`m.
@f QDSs nd edt `eakunj spja`f`a ou`nmeaj rjomrn`eo wgjrj men gdw tgj trmes`t`de frdh je rdutjtd f`emk mpprdmag emv`omt`de daaurs, p`kdts w`kk mndpt ede-stmenmrn prmat`ajs tgmt hmy etrdnuajm gmzmrn td smfj adhpkjt`de df tgj mpprdmag.
9.== FMI6:63 arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet
9.==.= Ojejrmk
Ms n`saussjn e sjat`de =.=?.?.=, arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet (AYH) s tgj jffjat`vj usj df mkkguhme, gmrnwmrj, men efdrhmt`de rjsdurajs mvm`kmikj td tgj fk`ogt arjw td jesurj smfj menjff`a`jet fk`ogt dpjrmt`des. QDSs mrj me hpdrtmet efdrhmt`de rjsduraj mvm`kmikj td p`kdts, menprdv`nj stmenmrn`zjn pgrmsjdkdoy men struaturj fdr adhhue`amt`des td hm`etm`e sgmrjns`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. Mnn`t`demkky, tgjy prdv`nj prjnjtjrh`ejn sdkut`des td vmr`dus prdikjhs,men mss`st w`tg wdrbkdmn hmemojhjet men nja`s`de hmb`eo.
9.==.9 Qgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss
@e tg`s daaurrjeaj, tgjrj wjrj njf`a`jea`js e idtg tgj n`sarjtj mat`des (`eadhpkjtj mpprdmag
ir`jf`eo, mkt`tunj amkkduts, men m`rspjjn amkkduts) men adet`eudus mat`des (amkkduts df agmeojs em`rarmft stmtj men fk`ogt n`rjatdr / mutdp`kdt hdnjs) tgmt wjrj rjqu`rjn df tgj arjw td jstmik`sgmen hm`etm`e sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. Adesjqujetky, tgjrj wms m irjmbndwe e tgj`rmi`k`ty td ld`etky etjrprjt, prdikjh-sdkvj, men tmbj mat`de de tgj efdrhmt`de mvm`kmikj. Ms tgjysg`ftjn frdh fdkkdw`eo jstmik`sgjn prdajnurjs td prdikjh-sdkv`eo ijgmv`dur, tgj`r wdrbkdmn`earjmsjn, men tgj n`ffjrjeajs ijtwjje tgj`r en`v`numk mwmrjejss df tgj m`rarmft stmtj men dftgrjmts td smfj fk`ogt pdsjn me mnn`t`demk prdikjh tgmt tgj arjw ejjnjn td dvjradhj.
M irjmbndwe e sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss daaurrjn nur`eo tgj fk`ogt, ms en`amtjn iy tgjfdkkdw`eo<
• N`ffjr`eo pjrspjat`vjs ms td tgj r`sb prjsjetjn iy tgj m`rarmft trmab men tgj uestmikj
mpprdmag2
• N`ffjr`eo hjetmk hdnjks rjomrn`eo tgj m`rarmft pds`t`de men trmljatdry<
• ^gj amptm`e wms etjet de adet`eu`eo mpprdmag td m kmen`eo2
• ^gj FD wms mwmrj df tgj tjrrm`e gmzmrn men wms mttjhpt`eo td adev`eaj tgj amptm`etd od mrduen2
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 139/215
- =1= -
• ^gj kmab df adrrjat`vj mat`de iy tgj amptm`e e rjspdesj td tgj FD‐s od-mrduensuoojst`des men mnv`sdr`js midut tgj trmab njv`mt`de men uestmikj mpprdmag.
^gj fdkkdw`eo ijgmv`durs iy tgj arjw hjhijrs etjrfjrjn w`tg tgj hm`etjemeaj df sgmrjns`tumt`demk mwmrjejss<
• ^gj amptm`e prdv`njn me miirjv`mtjn mpprdmag ir`jf`eo, wg`ag rjnuajn tgj k`bjk`gddntgmt tgj p`kdts wdukn gmvj tgj smhj uenjrstmen`eo men wdrb jffjat`vjky tdojtgjr.
• ^gj p`kdts wjrj edt rjqu`rjn td hmbj amkkduts df systjh hdnj agmeojs, men n`n edt ndsd. g`s amkkdut efdrhmt`de s ar`t`amk fdr hm`etm`e`eo en`v`numk men sgmrjn s`tumt`demkmwmrjejss.
• Jmag p`kdt wms fdausjn de m n`ffjrjet mspjat df tgj emv`omt`demk systjh tgmt tgjy jmagstrdeoky ijk`jvjn td ij prdv`n`eo tgj hdst rjk`mikj `efdrhmt`de midut tgj`r s`tumt`de.^gj FD fdausjn de tgj kdamk`zjr men OSQ en`amt`des df trmab n`vjrojeaj, men tgj amptm`efdausjn de tgj mppmrjet etjrajpt meokj.
• Qtmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy fdr agmkkjeoj men rjspdesj s etjenjn td jstmik`sg m adhhde
uenjrstmen`eo men kjmn td aden`t`dejn, fmh`k`mr rjsukts. gj FD usjn ede-stmenmrnpgrmsjdkdoy rjomrn`eo tgj fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de, men n`n edt gmvj mvm`kmikj stmenmrnpgrmsjdkdoy td mkjrt tgj amptm`e td tgj uestmikj mpprdmag.
• ^gj amptm`e‐s rjspdesjs td tgj FD‐s stmtjhjets midut fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de wjrj ede-stmenmrn. Quag rjspdesjs wjrj m prdorjss`de frdh tgj FD‐s ede-stmenmrn kmeoumoj, menm hdvjhjet furtgjr mwmy frdh tgj QDSs men `etd arjw `etjrmat`des `e wg`ag sgmrjnjxpjatmt`des men addrn`emtjn mat`des wdukn ij n`ff`aukt td hm`etm`e.
• ^gj ede-stmenmrn kmeoumoj usjn iy tgj FD td suoojst m od-mrduen rjnuajn tgjk`bjk`gddn df akjmr adhhue`amt`de df g`s etjet td tgj amptm`e, men wms m imrr`jr td`e`t`mt`eo addrn`emtjn mat`de.
• Arjw wdrbkdmn earjmsjn ms tgj p`kdts mttjhptjn td uenjrstmen men rjsdkvj tgj`eadeoru`t`js e tgj`r en`v`numk hjetmk hdnjks, men mom`e ms tgjy rmp`nky adef`ourjntgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo. g`s earjmsj `e wdrbkdmn rjnuajn tgj`r mi`k`ty td sdkvj tgjadhpkjx emv`omt`demk prdikjh men tgj`r n`spmrmtj v`jws midut t.
Idtg tgj adetjet men emturj df tgj etrm-arjw adhhue`amt`de akjmrky sgdwjn s`oes dfirjmbndwe e sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. gj fmat tgmt ej`tgjr arjw hjhijr njet`f`jn td tgjdtgjr tgmt tg`s irjmbndwe wms daaurr`eo wms me mnn`t`demk prdikjh tgmt gmn td ij mnnrjssjn.Gdwjvjr, rmtgjr tgme jxpk`a`tky njet`fy`eo tgmt tgj irjmbndwe e sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejssgmn daaurrjn, jmag p`kdt adet`eujn td jhpgms`zj g`s dwe uenjrstmen`eo df tgj s`tumt`de `e memttjhpt td adev`eaj tgj dtgjr df ts vjrma`ty.
Ej`tgjr df tgj p`kdts wms n`sjeomojn frdh tgj s`tumt`de. Qdhj df tgj amptm`e‐s stmtjhjets`en`amtj tgmt gj wms adefusjn ms td tgj mutdp`kdt hdnj men tgj rjmsde wgy tgj m`rarmft wmsn`vjro`eo frdh tgj kdamk`zjr. Q`h`kmrky, sdhj df tgj FD‐s stmtjhjets akjmrky en`amtj tgmt gj wmsueadhfdrtmikj w`tg tgj m`rarmft pds`t`de men trmljatdry. Gdwjvjr, ej`tgjr tgj amptm`e edr tgj FDwms jffjat`vj e rjsdkv`eo tgj dtgjr‐s adefus`de dr n`sadhfdrt, men tgj irjmbndwe e sgmrjns`tumt`demk mwmrjejss wms edt rjsdkvjn uet`k tgj OS_Q s`eb rmtj mkjrt prdv`njn me `enjpjenjetwmre`eo.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 140/215
- =19 -
^gj arjw n`n edt hm`etm`e m sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. gj irjmbndwe df tg`s mspjat dfarjw addrn`emt`de wms jv`njet tgrduogdut tgj mpprdmag.
S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt dtgjr p`kdts mksd jhpkdyjn mnmptmt`des df QDSs. Mnmptmt`des dfQDSs ame `hpm`r sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss men AYH jffjat`vjejss.
9.==.1 Adhhue`amt`des
AYH ijst prmat`ajs mrj `etjenjn td jemikj arjw hjhijrs td fjjk adhfdrtmikj prdv`n`eo `eput tdmss`st e nja`s`de hmb`eo. @t s ojejrmkky maajptjn tgmt arjw hjhijrs sgdukn mssjrt tgjhsjkvjswgje tgjy mrj uesurj df sdhjtg`eo dr `f tgjrj `s m ojeu`ej adeajre midut tgj aurrjet adursj dfmat`de. gj usj df akjmr kmeoumoj s jssjet`mk e t`hj-ar`t`amk s`tumt`des. Gdwjvjr, usj df tg`s typjdf kmeoumoj ame ij vjry n`ff`aukt fdr sdhj pjdpkj, men `ejffjat`vj mssjrt`de gms ijje m fmatdr `edtgjr maa`njets.
@e tgj amsj df FMI6:63, hmey df tgj adhhue`amt`des ijtwjje tgj p`kdts wjrj `ejffjat`vj
ijamusj akjmr men uemhi`oudus kmeoumoj wms edt usjn. Fdr jxmhpkj<• ^gj amptm`e hmnj m stmtjhjet en`amt`eo tgmt gj wdukn usj YEMV td emv`omtj td tgj
kdamk`zjr. g`s hjssmoj adukn ij etjrprjtjn e hdrj tgme dej wmy.
• ^gj FD‐s mnv`sdry tgmt tgjy gmn rjmagjn fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de wms pgrmsjn ms mqujst`de, n`n edt eakunj mey prdpdsjn adrrjat`vj mat`de, men n`n edt jk`a`t tgjmpprdpr`mtj rjspdesj td e`t`mtj m od-mrduen. gj amptm`e rjspdenjn e ture w`tg mqujst`de rmtgjr tgme adrrjat`vj mat`de.
• ^gj FD‐s suoojst`de mt =6>3<13 tgmt tgjy nd m od-mrduen men tgje tmkb tgj medhmkytgrduog n`n edt jk`a`t tgj njs`rjn rjspdesj td e`t`mtj m od-mrduen. @estjmn, tgj amptm`eadet`eujn tgj mpprdmag.
• ^gj FD stmtjn tgmt tgjy wjrj mt 1 h`kjs men edt adef`ourjn. @t `s mkhdst ajrtm`e tgmt tgj`etjenjn hjssmoj wms tgmt tgj mpprdmag wms uestmikj men m od-mrduen wms rjqu`rjn.Gdwjvjr, tgj amptm`e‐s etjrprjtmt`de df tg`s stmtjhjet wms tgmt tgjy ejjnjn td f`e`sgadef`our`eo tgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo.
_gje tgj m`rarmft rjmagjn fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de, tgj FD prdijn w`tg m qujst`de midut tgjm`rarmft pds`t`de. Gj rjpjmtjnky mkjrtjn tgj amptm`e midut tgj prdorjss`vj njv`mt`de frdh tgjkdamk`zjr, men mksd hmnj me mkjrt midut tgj tjrrm`e td tgj r`ogt df tgj ruewmy. Mktgduog tgjrjwms ed akjmr agmkkjeoj frdh tgj FD stmt`eo tgj adesjqujeajs df adet`eu`eo tgj mpprdmag, gj n`nsuoojst me mktjremt`vj adursj df mat`de. Gdwjvjr, tgj FD‐s adhhue`amt`des n`n edt mag`jvj g`sodmk df adev`ea`eo tgj amptm`e td agmeoj g`s adursj df mat`de.
Jsamkmt`de e adhhue`amt`de strmtjo`js ame ij n`ff`aukt. gj SMAJ hdnjk (prdi`eo, mkjrt`eo,agmkkjeo`eo, men jhjrojeay wmre`eo) prdv`njs p`kdts w`tg m adhhue`amt`de strmtjoy njs`oejntd mkkdw fdr m emturmk jsamkmt`de df mssjrt`de, njpjen`eo de tgj a`rauhstmeajs mt tgj t`hj. ^gjFD‐s prdi`eo men mkjrt`eo stmtjhjets men suoojst`de df me mktjremt`vj adursj df mat`de wjrjades`stjet w`tg tgj e`t`mk pdrt`des df tgj SMAJ hdnjk. Gdwjvjr, tgj FD ejvjr n`n jsamkmtj tdtgj pd`et df me jhjrojeay `etjrvjet`de `e tgj fdrh df tmb`eo adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 141/215
- =11 -
^gj adhhue`amt`des ijtwjje tgj 9 p`kdts wjrj `ejffjat`vj. gj amptm`e wms tmsb-smturmtjn menwms k`bjky efkujeajn iy pkme adet`eumt`de i`ms. Njsp`tj tgj FD‐s adhhue`amt`de jffdrts,adeajres midut FMI6:63‐s fk`ogt pmtg wjrj edt eadrpdrmtjn etd tgj amptm`e‐s nja`s`de-hmb`eoprdajss.
9.==.> _drbkdmn hmemojhjet
AYH ijst prmat`ajs mrj `etjenjn td jemikj arjw hjhijrs td jffjat`vjky hmemoj wdrbkdmn._drbkdmn `s m fueat`de df tgj euhijr df tmsbs td ij adhpkjtjn `e m o`vje mhduet df t`hj mentgj mi`k`ty df m pjrsde td gmenkj tgdsj njhmens. Me `earjmsj `e tmsbs dr m njarjmsj `e t`hjmvm`kmikj rjsukts e earjmsjn wdrbkdmn. d rjnuaj wdrbkdmn, dej hust j`tgjr rjnuaj tgjeuhijr df tmsbs tgmt hust ij adhpkjtjn dr earjmsj tgj t`hj mvm`kmikj td adhpkjtj tgdsj tmsbs.
FMI6:63 fk`ogt arjw wdrbkdmn ijome td jsamkmtj ms tgj fk`ogt hmnj tgj ture detd f`emk mpprdmagmt HZQM^. Arjw wdrbkdmn jsamkmtjn furtgjr ms tgj mpprdmag adet`eujn. Ms en`amtjn iy tmsbsgjnn`eo de f`emk mpprdmag, idtg p`kdts ijamhj mffjatjn iy tmsb smturmt`de. gj jsamkmt`eowdrbkdmn adesuhjn hjetmk rjsdurajs men n`h`e`sgjn tgj mi`k`ty df tgj arjw td rjadoe`zj tgj
jxajss`vj wdrbkdmn men tmbj adrrjat`vj mat`de.
^gjrj wms ed `en`amt`de tgmt j`tgjr p`kdt rjadoe`zjn tgmt tgjy wjrj jxpjr`jea`eo g`og wdrbkdmn.Mktgduog tgj FD suoojstjn m od-mrduen sjvjrmk t`hjs, tgjsj suoojst`des wjrj prdhptjn iy fukkkdamk`zjr njfkjat`de men tgj uestmikj mpprdmag rmtgjr tgme wdrbkdmn. gj arjw n`n edt mttjhpttd usj dtgjr hjmes td earjmsj t`hj mvm`kmikj td adhpkjtj ejajssmry tmsbs. gj p`kdts n`n edtjffjat`vjky hmemoj wdrbkdmn.
9.==.: Srdikjh sdkv`eo men nja`s`de hmb`eo
Srdikjh sdkv`eo s m hukt`-stjp prdajss tgmt eakunjs nja`s`de hmb`eo. Jffjat`vj nja`s`dehmb`eo evdkvjs tgj maaurmtj uenjrstmen`eo df tgj aurrjet s`tumt`de men ts `hpk`amt`des,fdrhukmt`de df m pkme, men hpkjhjetmt`de df tgj ijst adursj df mat`de. S`kdts hust adet`eumkkyrj-jvmkumtj tgj`r s`tumt`de td njtjrh`ej wgjtgjr tgjy maaurmtjky pjraj`vj tgj s`tumt`de, menwgjtgjr tgj pkme `s wdrb`eo dut ms jxpjatjn dr m agmeoj `e tgj pkme `s rjqu`rjn.
Ms fk`ogt FMI6:63 prdorjssjn, tgj arjw wjrj fmajn w`tg sjvjrmk prdikjhs<
• Njsajet wms `e`t`mtjn kmtj, men tgj m`rarmft wms midut 633 fjjt midvj tgj ok`njskdpj ms tgjfk`ogt turejn detd f`emk mpprdmag.
• ^gj fk`ogt njv`mtjn frdh tgj kdamk`zjr, jvjetumkky rjmag`eo fukk njfkjat`de. g`s njv`mt`derjsuktjn `e m kjeotgy n`sauss`de tgmt nrjw tgj arjw‐s mttjet`de mwmy frdh adef`our`eotgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo.
• ^gj mpprdmag wms uestmikj, rjnua`eo tgj t`hj mvm`kmikj fdr tmsb adhpkjt`de men tgjrjiy`earjms`eo wdrbkdmn fdr idtg p`kdts.
• ^gj p`kdts gmn n`vjrojet hjetmk hdnjks. g`s n`vjrojeaj adhprdh`sjn adhhue`amt`desijtwjje tgjh.
Nur`eo tgj njsajet frdh aru`sj mkt`tunj, tgj amptm`e rjadoe`zjn tgmt tgjy wjrj midvj tgjedh`emk njsajet prdf`kj, men `earjmsjn tgj rmtj df njsajet `e me mttjhpt td rjom`e prdf`kj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 142/215
- =1> -
Gdwjvjr, tg`s strmtjoy wms uesuaajssfuk, men rjsuktjn e jxajss`vj m`rspjjn ijkdw =3 333 fjjtmen `e rjhm`e`eo 633 fjjt midvj prdf`kj mt tgj ture td f`emk mpprdmag. ^g`s dutadhj `s me`en`amt`de tgmt tgj amptm`e gmn edt hdn`f`jn g`s `e`t`mk pkme.
^gj arjw rjmk`zjn tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms njv`mt`eo td tgj r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr men spjetades`njrmikj t`hj n`sauss`eo t. gj FD hmnj euhjrdus mnv`sdr`js td tgj amptm`e midut tgj
trmab njv`mt`de, iut n`n edt suoojst adrrjat`vj mat`de. _gje tgj FD n`n suoojst m od-mrduen mt=6>3<13, g`s prdpdsmk wms hhjn`mtjky rjljatjn iy tgj amptm`e. g`s rjljat`de s me en`amt`detgmt tgj amptm`e gmn edt uenjrstddn tgj `hpk`amt`des df tgj s`tumt`de. Adesjqujetky, tgj amptm`ek`bjky n`n edt pjraj`vj mey ejjn td rj-jvmkumtj dr hdn`fy g`s pkme td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag td mkmen`eo.
^gj FD rjadoe`zjn tgmt tgj mpprdmag wms uestmikj, men mt =6>3<>=, hmnj m stmtjhjet tgmt tgjywjrj mt 1 h`kjs men edt adef`ourjn fdr kmen`eo. Gdwjvjr, tgj stmtjhjet n`n edt akjmrky njet`fytgmt tgj mpprdmag wms uestmikj dr prdpdsj adrrjat`vj mat`de. Adesjqujetky, tgj amptm`eh`suenjrstddn tgj stmtjhjet, men g`s adrrjat`vj mat`de wms td adef`ourj tgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo.^gj amptm`e‐s rjmat`de suoojsts tgmt gj gmn edt rjadoe`zjn tgmt tgj mpprdmag wms uestmikj2
tgjrjfdrj, gj k`bjky n`n edt pjraj`vj mey ejjn td rj-jvmkumtj dr hdn`fy g`s pkme td adet`euj tgjmpprdmag td m kmen`eo.
Ms prjv`dusky n`saussjn, tgj FD‐s hjetmk hdnjk wms tgmt m od-mrduen wms ejajssmry, wg`kj tgjamptm`e‐s hjetmk hdnjk wms tgmt tgj mpprdmag adukn ij smkvmojn men m kmen`eo adukn ij hmnj.^gjsj n`vjrojet hjetmk hdnjks adhprdh`sjn tgj`r mi`k`ty td adhhue`amtj, w`tg tgj rjsukt tgmttgj FD‐s suoojst`des tgmt tgj pkme ij rj-jvmkumtjn wjrj edt uenjrstddn dr hpkjhjetjn iy tgjamptm`e.
^gj arjw n`n edt jffjat`vjky sdkvj tgj prdikjhs tgjy jeaduetjrjn nur`eo tgj njsajet men f`emkmpprdmag.
@e tg`s daaurrjeaj, tgj FD matjn `e me mnv`sdry rdkj, prdv`n`eo tgj amptm`e w`tg efdrhmt`demidut m`rarmft stmtj men suoojst`des fdr mktjremt`vj mat`de. Gdwjvjr, tgj FD‐s adhhue`amt`deswjrj uemssjrt`vj men mhi`oudus. Mnn`t`demkky, tgj amptm`e‐s jsamkmt`eo wdrbkdmn gmn njormnjng`s mi`k`ty td pjraj`vj men uenjrstmen tgj `efdrhmt`de tgmt tgj FD wms prdv`n`eo. Mttjet`demkemrrdw`eo, adef`rhmt`de i`ms, men pkme adet`eumt`de i`ms mksd gmn ejomt`vj jffjats de tgjamptm`e. gj amptm`e wms prjsjetjn w`tg sjvjrmk dppdrtue`t js td rj-jvmkumtj men mktjr g`s pkme,iut n`n edt nd sd. gj amptm`e‐s nja`s`de hmb`eo wms ejffjat`vj.
9.==.6 Quhhmry df FMI6:63 arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet
Qgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss, adhhue`amt`de, wdrbkdmn hmemojhjet, prdikjh sdkv`eo, mennja`s`de hmb`eo mrj mkk etjormk adhpdejets df AYH. Ms n`saussjn midvj, tgj FMI6:63 fk`ogtarjw n`n edt suaajssfukky jhpkdy mey df tgjsj prmat`ajs. gjrjfdrj, tgj`r AYH wms ejffjat`vj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 143/215
- =1: -
9.=9 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo mt F`rst M`r
9.=9.= @e`t`mk arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo
^gj e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo dutk`ejn e tgj F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des ^rm`e`eo Hmeumk (FD^H)hjjts tgj rjqu`rjhjets df Adhhjra`mk M`r Qjrv`aj Qtmenmrns (AMQQ) ?9:.=9>(10), men s njk`vjrjn
iy 9 hdt`vmtjn estruatdrs wgd ijk`jvj e tgj hpdrtmeaj df AYH trm`e`eo. Gdwjvjr, F`rst M`rndjs edt mkkdamtj 9 nmys, ms wms etjenjn iy rmespdrt Amemnm (^A). ^d maadhhdnmtj dtgjrtrm`e`eo rjqu`rjhjets, F`rst M`r‐s `e`t`mk AYH adursj gms ijje rjnuajn td m pdrt`de df = nmy.Ijamusj df tgjsj t`hj adestrm`ets, tgj estruatdrs wjrj uemikj td tjmag mkk df tgj rjqu`rjnsuiljats spja`f`jn e idtg tgj FD^H men AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10) fdr e`t`mk trm`e`eo. Mnn`t`demkky, tgjywjrj us`eo tgj ^A AYH trm`e`eo pmabmoj, wg`ag ndjs edt `eakunj tgj kmtjst AYH adeajpts mentrm`e`eo hjtgdns.
Ms m rjsukt, adursj pmrt`a`pmets n`n edt rjaj`vj trm`e`eo e adhhue`amt`de strmtjo`js fdrjsamkmt`eo adeajres, e prdikjh-sdkv`eo men nja`s`de-hmb`eo strmtjo`js, men e strmtjo`js midutgdw ijst td mk`oe hjetmk hdnjks mhdeo mkk arjw hjhijrs. Mnn`t`demkky, tgj adursj pmrt`a`pmets
wjrj edt prdv`njn w`tg t`ps td mss`st w`tg wdrbkdmn hmemojhjet de tgj fk`ogt njab.
^gj amptm`e df FMI6:63 rjaj`vjn `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo `e =00? men tgj FD `e 933?. Ed`efdrhmt`de wms mvm`kmikj rjomrn`eo tgj trm`e`eo adetjet dr nurmt`de. gj amptm`e‐s e`t`mktrm`e`eo e =00? daaurrjn deky 6 hdetgs mftjr tgj rjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjet fdr trm`e`eo amhj etdfdraj. ^gj AYH trm`e`eo hmtjr`mk usjn iy F`rst M`r wms prdnuajn iy ^A mt midut tgj smhj t`hj.^gjrjfdrj, t s k`bjky tgmt tgj e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo adetjet tgmt tgj amptm`e men FD rjaj`vjn wmss`h`kmr td tgj adursj disjrvjn iy tgj ^QI.
^gj njf`a`jea`js njet`f`jn e tgj F`rst M`r e`t`mk AYH adursj mrj mspjats df AYH tgmt pkmyjn mrdkj e tg`s maa`njet, ms n`saussjn midvj. F`rst M`r‐s e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo n`n edt prdv`nj tgj
daaurrjeaj arjw w`tg suff`a`jet prmat`amk strmtjo`js td mss`st w`tg nja`s`de hmb`eo, prdikjhsdkv`eo, adhhue`amt`de, men wdrbkdmn hmemojhjet.
9.=9.9 Yjaurrjet arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo
Yjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjets fdr rjaurrjet trm`e`eo nd edt `njet`fy mey spja`f`a AYH suiljats tgmthust ij tmuogt, men tgjrj `s ed rjqu`rjhjet td rjv`jw mey df tgj AYH tdp`as advjrjn nur`eo`e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo. Gdwjvjr, tgj adhpmey‐s rjaurrjet trm`e`eo n`n advjr mtt`tunjs,adhhue`amt`de, men nja`s`de hmb`eo. gj rjaurrjet trm`e`eo njsar`ijn QDSs ms m hjmes td trmpjrrdrs, men ms m sduraj df stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy td jk`h`emtj h`sadhhue`amt`de men h`e`h`zjh`suenjrstmen`eo. gjsj QDS-rjkmtjn diljat`vjs mrj m fuenmhjetmk adrejrstdej df AYH.
Gdwjvjr, AP\F-imsjn I?1? p`kdts jhpkdyjn QDS mnmptmt`des, `en`amt`eo tgmt tg`s jhpgms`s deQDSs wms ejffjat`vj.
Zek`bj tgj e`t`mk AYH adursj adetjet, sdhj df tgj hmtjr`mk advjrjn nur`eo tgj rjaurrjet AYHadursj eakunjn jkjhjets df hdrj aurrjet AYH trm`e`eo, k`bj n`sauss`des rjkmtjn td tgrjmt-men-jrrdr hmemojhjet adeajpts. gj adetjet df F`rst M`r‐s rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo hjt tgjrjqu`rjhjets spja`f`jn e tgj adhpmey‐s FD^H men e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(i).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 144/215
- =16 -
AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(i) ndjs edt st`pukmtj m spja`f`a nurmt`de fdr rjaurrjet trm`e`eo. Q`eaj mt kjmst9336, tgj adhpmey gms mkkdamtjn > gdurs td advjr tgj rjaurrjet hmtjr`mk. gj nurmt`de df tgjrjaurrjet trm`e`eo disjrvjn iy tgj QI hjt tgj spja`f`jn t`hj rjqu`rjhjet e tgj FD^H.
Fdkkdw`eo `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo, tgj FMI6:63 amptm`e men FD rjaj`vjn meeumk rjaurrjet trm`e`eo2tgj amptm`e‐s hdst rjajet rjaurrjet trm`e`eo wms 0 hdetgs ijfdrj tgj maa`njet, men tgj FD‐s wms
: hdetgs ijfdrj tgj maa`njet. Gdwjvjr, nur`eo tgj maa`njet fk`ogt, ej`tgjr p`kdt jffjat`vjkymppk`jn tgj AYH adeajpts prdv`njn e tgj adhpmey‐s rjaurrjet trm`e`eo.
^gj meeumk rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo tgmt tgj daaurrjeaj p`kdts rjaj`vjn n`n edt mnjqumtjkyrj`efdraj tgj`r bedwkjnoj df AYH adeajpts dr tgj`r mi`k`ty td mppky tgdsj adeajpts nur`eo k`ejdpjrmt`des.
9.=1 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet rjoukmt`des `e Amemnm
Aurrjet rjoukmt`des rjqu`rj Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY) Quipmrt ?3: dpjrmtdrs tdadenuat AYH trm`e`eo, iut tgj rjoukmt`des gmvj edt bjpt pmaj w`tg mnvmeajs e AYH tgjdry
men mppk`amt`de, men mrj edw dutnmtjn.
^rmespdrt Amemnm (^A) gms tmbje stjps td mnnrjss hmey df tgj `ssujs w`tg tgj jx`st`eorjoukmt`de tgmt wjrj prjv`dusky njet`f`jn iy tgj rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn (^QI). Gdwjvjr,edej df tgjsj prdpdsjn agmeojs gmvj yjt ijje etrdnuajn etd rjoukmt`de. gj aurrjetrjoukmt`de men stmenmrn fdr AMY Quipmrt ?3: AYH trm`e`eo gmvj edt ijje upnmtjn td rjfkjatmnvmeajs `e AYH trm`e`eo. Ms m rjsukt, tgjrj `s m r`sb tgmt fk`ogt arjws hmy edt ij trm`ejn `e tgjkmtjst etjremt`demkky rjadoe`zjn prmat`ajs e tgrjmt-men-jrrdr hmemojhjet tjage`qujs.
Mnn`t`demkky, aurrjet AYH trm`e`eo rjoukmt`des nd edt `njet`fy mey h`e`huh nurmt`de fdr`e`t`mk men rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo. Ms m rjsukt, dpjrmtdrs mrj frjj td njtjrh`ej gdw huag t`hj
tgjy njn`amtj td AYH trm`e`eo. Ms kdeo ms dpjrmtdrs ame sgdw tgmt tgj`r AYH trm`e`eo hjjts tgjdutnmtjn rjqu`rjhjets df AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10), tgj AYH adursj ame ij ms sgdrt ms tgjy njjhmpprdpr`mtj.
M`r dpjrmtdrs mrj rjqu`rjn td prdv`nj hmey amtjodr`js df fk`ogt arjw trm`e`eo. Gdwjvjr, tgjrjame ij t`hj-rjkmtjn men f`emea`mk prjssurjs td sgdrtje trm`e`eo k`bj AYH. gj F`rst M`r e`t`mkAYH adursj disjrvjn iy QI `evjst`omtdrs wms adhpkjtjn e lust dvjr > gdurs, rmtgjr tgme tgj 9nmys `etjenjn iy ^A. @t `s edt rjmsdemikj td jxpjat tgmt mkk df tgj ^A AYH trm`e`eo pmabmojadukn ij jffjat`vjky tmuogt w`tg`e suag m sgdrt t`hj. @f emnjqumtj t`hj s mkkdamtjn fdr `e`t`mkAYH trm`e`eo, fk`ogt arjw hjhijrs mrj uek`bjky td njvjkdp suff`a`jet ar`t`amk AYH sb`kks.
^gj rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo rjqu`rjhjets, ms njf`ejn e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(i), nd edt prdv`njdpjrmtdrs w`tg akjmr n`rjat`de rjomrn`eo tgj h`e`huh rjqu`rjhjets fdr rjaurrjet AYHtrm`e`eo. @e pmrt`aukmr, tgjrj s ed rjqu`rjhjet td rjv`s`t mey df tgj adrj AYH suiljats dutk`ejn`e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10)(m). Frdh m trm`e`eo stmenpd`et, tg`s kmab df rj`efdrajhjet df adrj sb`kkstmuogt nur`eo `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo adukn rjsukt `e m rjture td prjv`dusky kjmrejn ijgmv`durs._`tgdut mnjqumtj rj`efdrajhjet df adrj AYH sb`kks nur`eo rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo, tgjrj `s`earjmsjn r`sb tgmt fk`ogt arjws w`kk jxpjr`jeaj n`ff`aukty jhpkdy`eo jffjat`vj AYH de tgj fk`ogtnjab.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 145/215
- =1? -
@e drnjr fdr me dpjrmtdr‐s AYH prdormh td ij mpprdvjn, tgj dpjrmtdr hust njhdestrmtj tgmt tsprdormh hjjts tgj rjqu`rjhjets dutk`ejn e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10). gj stmenmrn prmat`aj s fdr tgjdpjrmtdr td suih`t ts AYH trm`e`eo pkme, dftje jhijnnjn ms pmrt df tgj adhpmey dpjrmt`deshmeumk, td rjo`demk ^A dff`ajs fdr mpprdvmk. ^gj rjo`demk ^A dff`aj w`kk tgje adhpmrj tgjtrm`e`eo pkme td tgj Qtmenmrn td sjj wgjtgjr tgj rjqu`rjn jkjhjets mrj k`stjn.
F`rst M`r gmn m AYH trm`e`eo pkme tgmt gmn ijje mpprdvjn iy ^A. Gdwjvjr, tgjrj `s ed`en`amt`de tgmt A gms jvjr mttjenjn dej df F`rst M`r‐s `e`t`mk AYH adursjs. Ms m rjsukt, tgjadhpmey gms edt rjaj`vjn fjjnimab frdh tgj rjoukmtdr rjomrn`eo tgj qumk`ty df ts e`t`mk AYHtrm`e`eo men wgjtgjr tgj adursj, ms tmuogt, hjjts rjoukmtdry rjqu`rjhjets.
9.=> Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet `estruatdr maarjn`tmt`de
Fma`k`tmt`de s m spja`mk`zjn sb`kk tgmt hust ij njvjkdpjn. @f en`v`numks sjkjatjn td tjmag AYH ndedt pdssjss tgj ejajssmry fma`k`tmt`de sb`kks, tgjy hmy jxpjr`jeaj n`ff`aukt`js jffjat`vjky ou`n`eopmrt`a`pmets tgrduog tgj trm`e`eo hmtjr`mk. @ejffjat`vj fma`k`tmt`de adukn rjsukt `e pddr rjtjet`dedf tgj sb`kks tmuogt nur`eo tgj adursj.
@e Amemnm, tgjrj s ed rjqu`rjhjet fdr AYH fma`k`tmtdrs/`estruatdrs td adhpkjtj m fdrhmktrm`e`eo adursj dr td ditm`e mey typj df maarjn`tmt`de. Adesjqujetky, edej df tgj `estruatdrsadenuat`eo AYH trm`e`eo e Amemnm mrj rjqu`rjn iy rjoukmt`de td gmvj njhdestrmtjn mh`e`huh kjvjk df jxpjr`jeaj men/dr trm`e`eo qumk`f`amt`de. AMY ?3: arjw hjhijrs rjqu`rjn tdadhpkjtj AYH trm`e`eo euhijr `e tgj tgdusmens, men hmey AMY ?31 men ?3> dpjrmtdrsvdkuetmr`ky prdv`nj AYH trm`e`eo td mnn`t`demk arjw hjhijrs. Ej`tgjr df tgj adhpmey‐spr`hmry AYH estruatdrs gmn rjaj`vjn mey fdrhmk fma`k`tmtdr/`estruatdr trm`e`eo drmaarjn`tmt`de e tjmag`eo AYH. gj misjeaj df estruatdr maarjn`tmt`de rjqu`rjhjets earjmsjstgj r`sb tgmt fk`ogt arjws w`kk edt rjaj`vj jffjat`vj AYH trm`e`eo.
^gj hpdrtmeaj df gmv`eo qumk`f`jn AYH estruatdrs gms ijje rjadoe`zjn iy tgj Ze`tjnB`eondh A`v`k Mv`mt`de Mutgdr`ty (AMM), wg`ag gms m fukky njvjkdpjn AYH maarjn`tmt`deprdajss e pkmaj td jesurj tgmt fk`ogt arjws rjaj`vj tgj ijst pdss`ikj AYH trm`e`eo.
9.=: F`rst M`r smfjty hmemojhjet systjh `etjremk rjpdrt`eo prdajssjs
^gj F`rst M`r smfjty hmemojhjet systjh (QHQ) jemikjs jhpkdyjjs td rjpdrt smfjty ssujs us`eomey df sjvjrmk rjpdrt`eo hjtgdns. Gdwjvjr, tgj 9 prjv`dus jvjets evdkv`eo I?1? emv`omt`demkn`ff`aukt`js nur`eo estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs (@FY) mpprdmagjs wjrj edt rjpdrtjn iy F`rst M`r p`kdtstd hmemojhjet. ^gj misjeaj df rjpdrts df @ea`njets Dej men ^wd adest`tutjn h`ssjndppdrtue`t`js fdr drome`zmt demk kjmre`eo men njet`f`amt`de df pdtjet`mk smfjty ssujs. gmt tgj
od-mrduen `e @ea`njet ^wd (m hmenmtdry rjpdrt`eo `tjh) wms edt rjpdrtjn `en`amtjs tgmt tgjadhpmey‐s rjpdrt`eo systjhs wjrj edt fukky jffjat`vj.
Gmzmrndus s`tumt`des wg`ag mrj edt rjpdrtjn mrj uek`bjky td ij `njet`f`jn dr evjst`omtjn2adesjqujetky, adrrjat`vj mat`de ameedt ij tmbje td h`t`omtj mssda`mtjn r`sb.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 146/215
- =17 -
9.=6 APYI `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh fueat`demk`ty
^gjrj wms ed `etjrfjrjeaj w`tg tgj edrhmk fueat`demk`ty df tgj estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ)fdr Yuewmy 1:^ `e APYI.
9.=?
VDY sajemr`dMftjr tgj `eiduen ture mt HZQM^, tgj fk`ogt pmtg df FMI6:63 mppjmrs td ij m trmab n`rjatkytdwmrn tgj PYI VDY. Gdwjvjr, `t ame ij adeakunjn w`tg ajrtm`ety tgmt tgj arjw wjrj edtemv`omt`eo us`eo tgj VDY dr `etjet`demkky trmab`eo tdwmrn tgj VDY. ^gj fdkkdw`eo `efdrhmt`desuppdrts tg`s adeakus`de<
• Ej`tgjr p`kdt hjet`dejn tgj PYI VDY mt mey t`hj nur`eo tgj pjr`dn rjadrnjn de tgjadabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjr (AVY).
• Mt =6=:<9>.=, tgj amptm`e akjmrky ir`jfjn g`s `etjet`de td fky td tgj kdamk`zjr us`eo`estruhjet mpprdmag imsjn de mrjm emv`omt`de (YEMV).
• Mt =6=?<==.0, tgj amptm`e adenuatjn m ir`jf`eo fdr tgj @KQ Yuewmy 1:^.
• ^gj Hdrsj adnj njet`f`amt`de @YI wms rjadrnjn de tgj AVY jvjry 19.1 sjadens mftjr=6=?<37.:, en`amt`eo tgmt mt kjmst dej df tgj VGF EMV rjaj`vjrs wms ajrtm`eky tuejn tdtgj n`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet (NHJ) mssda`mtjn w`tg tgj @KQ fdr Yuewmy 1:^.
• N`sauss`de ijtwjje tgj p`kdts nur`eo f`emk mpprdmag eakunjn rjpjmtjn rjfjrjeajs tdnjv`mt`de r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr men tgj OSQ fk`ogt-pkmeejn trmab.
• Kmi memkys`s df tgj ed. = men ed. 9 VGF EMV adetrdk ue`ts akjmrky `en`amtj tgmt idtgue`ts wjrj tuejn td tgj @YI @KQ frjqujeay, ==3.13 hjomgjrtz (HGz).
• Kmi memkys`s df tgj VGF EMV trmesfjr sw`tag en`amtjs tgmt tgj sw`tag wms k`bjky e tgj
EDYHMK pds`t`de ijfdrj `hpmat. Adesjqujetky, `t `s k`bjky tgmt tgj ed. 1 VGF EMVrjaj`vjr wdukn gmvj ijje `e stmeniy hdnj men edt adetrdkkjn.
• Idtg OSQ ue`ts wjrj prdormhhjn w`tg tgj YEMV mpprdmag td Yuewmy 1:^ w`tgwmypd`ets HZQM^, D^EJK, men Y_1:. ^gj mat`vj wmypd`et wms D^EJK. ^gj PYIVDY wms edt `eakunjn `e tgj fk`ogt pkme de j`tgjr OSQ.
9.=7 Ou`nmeaj fdr fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr hm`etjemeaj
Ms njet`f`jn e tg`s daaurrjeaj, tgj JN-:: ou`nmeaj fdr fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr (FNY) hm`etjemeajwms esuff`a`jet td jesurj FNY sjrv`ajmi`k`ty, spja`f`amkky nuj td tgj sgdrt smhpkj df nmtm usjnfdr tgj adrrjkmt`de agjab (=: h`eutjs). @t s prdimikj tgmt tgjrj mrj dtgjr uesjrv`ajmikj FNYsystjhs estmkkjn de m`rarmft dpjrmt`eo e Amemnm.
FNY hm`etjemeaj ou`nmeaj (AMY Qtmenmrn 69:, Mppjen`x A) iy rmespdrt Amemnm (^A) ndjsedt rjfjr td tgj aurrjet Jurdpjme Drome`smt`de fdr A`v`k Mv`mt`de Jqu`phjet (JZYDAMJ) fk`ogtrjadrnjr spja`f`amt`de, men tgjrjfdrj prdv`njs esuff`a`jet ou`nmeaj td jesurj tgj sjrv`ajmi`k`tydf FNYs. g`s esuff`a`jeay earjmsjs tgj r`sb tgmt efdrhmt`de ejjnjn td njet`fy menadhhue`amtj smfjty njf`a`jea`js w`kk edt ij mvm`kmikj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 147/215
- =10 -
9.=0 ^jrrm`e mwmrjejss njv`ajs
^gj m`rarmft wms jqu`ppjn w`tg me dknjr-ojejrmt`de orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh (OS_Q),wg`ag prdv`njn deky me murmk mkjrt men k`ogt wgje tgj m`rarmft wms w`tg`e tgj prdx`h`typmrmhjtjrs df tgj njv`aj. gj njv`aj usjn rmn`d mkt`hjtjr efdrhmt`de td njtjrh`ej prdx`h`ty tdtjrrm`e ijkdw tgj m`rarmft, men tgjrjfdrj n`n edt prdv`nj m wmre`eo fdr r`s`eo tjrrm`e `e frdet dftgj m`rarmft.
M tjrrm`e mwmrjejss men wmre`eo systjh (^M_Q) prdv`njs idtg me murmk wmre`eo men hmpn`spkmy df tjrrm`e `e frdet df tgj m`rarmft. ^gj hmp n`spkmy edt deky prjsjets tgj arjw w`tg`efdrhmt`de rjomrn`eo tgj tjrrm`e jkjvmt`de mkdeo tgj fk`ogt pmtg, iut mksd prdv`njs mnn`t`demks`tumt`demk mwmrjejss ms td m`rarmft pds`t`de rjkmt`vj td distmakjs men tgj etjenjn fk`ogt pmtg.@hprdvjhjets e tgj sdurajs df efdrhmt`de usjn td amkaukmtj men prjn`at orduen prdx`h`tygmvj rjsuktjn `e jmrk`jr wmre`eo edt`ajs men `earjmsjn t`hj fdr arjw rjmat`de. ^gj ejwrjoukmtdry mhjenhjets rjqu`r`eo M_Q jqu`phjet de adhhjra`mk m`rarmft adef`ourjn w`tg 6dr hdrj pmssjeojr sjmts sgdukn suistmet`mkky h`t`omtj tgj r`sb df adetrdkkjn fk`ogt `etd tjrrm`e(AF@^) maa`njets.
@e tg`s daaurrjeaj, tgj arjw‐s s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss wdukn gmvj ijje jegmeajn men rjmat`det`hj td m orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo wdukn gmvj ijje earjmsjn gmn tgj m`rarmft ijje jqu`ppjnw`tg m ^M_Q.
9.93 Qurv`vmi`k`ty
^gj surv`vmi`k`ty df tgj daaurrjeaj wms rjkmtjn td tgj jxtjet df nmhmoj sustm`ejn iy tgjdaaupmets‐ rjstrm`et systjhs. Daaupmets wgdsj sjmts sjpmrmtjn frdh tgj fusjkmoj jmrky e tgjirjmbup sjqujeaj sustm`ejn hdrj sjvjrj elur`js, ades`stjet w`tg fdrajfuk adetmat w`tg tgjorduen. Daaupmets wgdsj sjmts rjhm`ejn kmrojky etmat, upr`ogt, men pmrt`mkky mttmagjn td tgjkjft pdrt`de df tgj ami`e fkddr, tgrduogdut dr uet`k kmtj `e tgj armsg sjqujeaj, ojejrmkky sustm`ejnkjss sjvjrj elur`js, ades`stjet w`tg kjss fdrajfuk adetmat w`tg `elur`dus surfmajs. Mkk df tgjsurv`vdrs ijkdeojn td tg`s kmttjr ordup.
9.9= ED^MH systjh
^gjrj wjrj euhjrdus ED^MHs (edt`ajs td m`rhje) ssujn td agmeoj tgj jffjat`vj pjr`dn df tgjh`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm (H^AM). gj adetjet df tgjsj ED^MHs wms tgj smhj, w`tg tgjjxajpt`de df tgj idttdh k`ej, wg`ag prdv`njn tgj rjv`sjn nmtj men t`hj ordups. @e sdhj`estmeajs, tgj deky agmeoj td tgj ED^MH adetjet wms 1 euhjr`a agmrmatjrs de tgj idttdh k`ej
df m adnjn =>-k`ej hjssmoj.
M ejw ED^MH s njs`oemtjn ms ED^MHE men prdv`njs ejw efdrhmt`de td m`rspmaj usjrs. Mssuag, `t `s k`bjky td jk`a`t usjrs‐ mttjet`de. ^gj f`rst ED^MHY (rjpkmajhjet ED^MH) `s mksdk`bjky td jk`a`t usjrs‐ mttjet`de. M sjaden ED^MHY, jvje w`tg tgj rjpkmajn ED^MH euhijrfdkkdw`eo tgj Y, hmy deky ij jxmh`ejn e m aursdry fmsg`de, ijamusj tgj p`kdt hmy gmvj sjjetgj Y njs`oemt`de prjv`dusky. gj p`kdt hmy tgjrjfdrj adeakunj tgmt tg`s s tgj smhj hjssmojrjmn prjv`dusky, jspja`mkky o`vje tgmt tgjrj `s ed hjtgdn df g`ogk`ogt`eo suitkj agmeojs.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 148/215
- =>3 -
ED^MHs `ssujn tgrduog tgj Mv`mt`de _jmtgjr _ji Q`tj (M__Q) nd edt `eakunj tgj Y, A, dr Enjs`oemt`des, men tgjrjfdrj, jvjry ED^MH hust ij trjmtjn ms m ejw ED^MH. Gdwjvjr, upde`e`t`mk same df m ejw ED^MH rjomrn`eo tgj Dpjrmt`de EMEDDB m`rspmaj, tgj rjmnjr hmytg`eb `t `s tgj smhj hjssmoj ms m prjv`dus dej, ijamusj tgj tjxt wms `njet`amk jxajpt fdr m fjwn`o`ts mt tgj idttdh en`amt`eo m agmeoj td tgj jffjat`vj nmtj.
^gj `ssumeaj df sd hmey mkhdst `njet`amk ED^MHs `e met`a`pmt`de df m suaajssfuk fk`ogt agjab,w`tgdut mey mssurmeaj tgmt m fk`ogt agjab wdukn ij sagjnukjn dr adukn ij amrr`jn dut, hmy gmvjkjn td adefus`de mhdeo tgj arjws men tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde Mrjm Adetrdk Ajetrj(MAA) adetrdkkjr ms td tgj stmtus df tgj m`rspmaj.
^gj arjws df FMI6:63 men BIM030, ms wjkk ms tgj Jnhdetde MAA adetrdkkjr gmenk`eoFMI6:63, mkk jxpjatjn tgmt tgj H^AM wdukn ij `e jffjat men tgmt adetrdk sjrv`ajs wdukn ijprdv`njn. gj ED^MHs ssujn adeajre`eo tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj H^AM n`n edt suaajjn eadhhue`amt`eo tgj `efdrhmt`de ejjnjn iy tgj m`rspmaj usjrs.
9.99 APYI m`r trmff`a adetrdk
Mkk rjfjrjeajs td m`r trmff`a sjrv`ajs mt APYI rjfjr td h`k`tmry jqu`phjet men pjrsdeejk, uekjssdtgjrw`sj stmtjn.
^gj APYI =633 rdut`ej mv`mt`de wjmtgjr rjpdrt (HJ^MY) wms tgj hdst rjajet rjpdrt mvm`kmikjtd adetrdkkjrs men p`kdts. Mktgduog tgj APYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr n`n edt prdv`nj kmen`eo`efdrhmt`de de e`t`mk adetmat w`tg FMI6:63, tgj fk`ogt arjw mkrjmny gmn tgj =633 APYIHJ^MY. Adesjqujetky, tgj fmat tgmt tgj APYI tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr n`n edt prdv`nj tg`s`efdrhmt`de n`n edt njtrmat frdh tgj arjw‐s hjetmk hdnjk men s edt adetr`iutdry td tgjmaa`njet. gj APYI tdwjr adetrdkkjr‐s rjspdes`i`k`t`js n`n edt eakunj prdv`n`eo aj`k`eo men
v`s`i`k`ty2 f tgjy gmn, tgj adetrdkkjr wdukn edt gmvj gmn mey hdrj rjajet `efdrhmt`de tgme tgjarjw mkrjmny gmn.
^gj tdwjr adetrdkkjr n`n edt gmvj rmnmr efdrhmt`de mvm`kmikj, men tgj wjmtgjr prjvjetjnv`sumk njtjrh`emt`de df tgj pds`t`de df FMI6:63. gjrjfdrj, tgj tdwjr adetrdkkjr n`n edt gmvjtgj `efdrhmt`de rjqu`rjn td njtjrh`ej wgjtgjr mey pds`t`de wmre`eo wms wmrrmetjn.
Mktgduog tgj rmnmr wms edt fk`ogt-agjabjn, t wms dpjrmt`eo nur`eo tgj mrr`vmk df FMI6:63, menrmnmr efdrhmt`de wms mvm`kmikj de idtg tgj mrjm survj`kkmeaj rmnmr (MQY) men prja`s`dempprdmag rmnmr (SMY) n`spkmys `e tgj tjrh`emk trm`kjr. ^gj rmnmr adukn edt ij usjn fdr prdv`s`dedf adetrdk sjrv`ajs, ijamusj t gmn edt ijje fk`ogt-agjabjn2 tgjrjfdrj, tgj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr wms
edt prdv`n`eo adetrdk sjrv`ajs men wms edt mat`vjky hde`tdr`eo tgj rmnmr n`spkmys.Adesjqujetky, tgj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr wms edt mwmrj df FMI6:63‐s prdx`h`ty td tjrrm`e.
Ej`tgjr tgj tdwjr edr tgj tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr gmn suff`a`jet vmk`n efdrhmt`de mvm`kmikj td amusjtgjh td `ssuj m pds`t`de mnv`sdry td FMI6:63.
^gj agd`aj df Akmss N m`rspmaj fdr idtg tgj H^AM men tgj APYI adetrdk zdej wms imsjn de tgjnjs`rj td jesurj tgmt mkk m`rarmft w`tg`e tgj m`rspmaj wdukn ij prdv`njn w`tg pds`t`vj adetrdk
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 149/215
- =>= -
sjrv`aj. _gje tgj rmnmr adukn edt ij usjn, tgj h`k`tmry njtjrh`ejn tgmt t adukn edt prdv`njsjrv`ajs e tgj H^AM, men rjpjmtjnky njkmyjn ts jstmik`sghjet. gj adetrdk zdej, gdwjvjr,wms e jffjat, iut ed ades`njrmt`de wms o`vje td tgj ejjn td prdv`nj ede-rmnmr estruhjet fk`ogtrukjs (@FY) sjrv`aj, wg`ag tgj sjkjat`de df m Akmss N adetrdk zdej rjqu`rjn.
_`tg`e m adetrdk zdej, @FY adetrdk sjrv`ajs wdukn edrhmkky ij prdv`njn iy me @FY adetrdkkjr e
tgj mssda`mtjn @FY adetrdk ue`t. Gdwjvjr, tgj APYI H^AM wms edt e jffjat2 tgjrjfdrj, tgjm`rspmaj surrduen`eo tgj adetrdk zdej wms Akmss O ueadetrdkkjn. _`tgdut tgj H^AM dr madetrdk mrjm jxtjes`de, esuff`a`jet m`rspmaj wms mvm`kmikj fdr prdv`n`eo @FY adetrdk sjrv`ajsw`tg`e tgj adetrdk zdej td mrr`v`eo dr njpmrt`eo m`rarmft. Ijamusj tgj H^AM wms edt e jffjat, edsjpmrmt`de stmenmrn dr mpprdmag akjmrmeajs wjrj prdv`njn td FMI6:63 men BIM030. g`ss`tumt`de rjsuktjn `e m kdss df @FY sjpmrmt`de ijtwjje FMI6:63 men BIM030 wgje BIM030jetjrjn tgj Akmss N adetrdk zdej mt =6>3<::.
^gjrj wms ed fdrhmk njakmrmt`de df me mkjrt pgmsj iy tgj APYI adetrdk tdwjr. Gdwjvjr, sdhjmojea`js tgmt wdukn edrhmkky ij mnv`sjn tgmt tgj m`rarmft wms `e tgj QMY mkjrt pgmsj wjrj hmnjmwmrj df tgj h`ss`eo m`rarmft nur`eo tgj adhhue`amt`de sjmrag fdr FMI6:63. Ld`et Yjsauj
Addrn`emt`de Ajetrj (LYAA) rjetde wms ukt`hmtjky edt`f`jn iy EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde m`radetrdk ajetrj (MAA). gj njkmy e edt`f`amt`de df tgj LYAA n`n edt njkmy tgj jhjrojeayrjspdesj td tgj armsg s`tj, ijamusj tgj f`rj gmkk rjsdurajs wjrj mkrjmny de stmeniy men njpkdyjn`hhjn`mtjky wgje tgj armsg s`tj ijamhj v`s`ikj.
9.91 M`rarmft hm`etjemeaj
9.91.= M`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjs
Ms m rjsukt df MN 933>-=0-=3 men MN 9336-=9-91 edt ij`eo fukky maadhpk`sgjn, tgj ajrt`f`amtj dfm`rwdrtg`ejss fdr A-OE_E wms edt `e jffjat mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet.
^gjrj wjrj ed medhmk`js jetjrjn etd tgj m`rarmft kdoiddbs rjkmtjn td adetrdkkmi`k`ty ssujs, mentgjrj wms ed en`amt`de e tgj fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr tgmt tgj arjw gmn mey adetrdkkmi`k`ty ssujw`tg tgj m`rarmft.
@t s tgjrjfdrj adeakunjn tgmt tgj ede-adhpk`meaj w`tg tgjsj 9 MNs n`n edt adetr`iutj td tgjmaa`njet.
9.91.9 Jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr
^gj jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr (JK^) wms estmkkjn w`tg tgj mat`vmt`de sw`tag e tgj DFF
pds`t`de. Gdwjvjr, jvje f t gmn ijje e tgj DE pds`t`de, t s uek`bjky tgmt tgj trmesh`ss`des`oemk wdukn gmvj ijje strdeo jeduog td ij njtjatjn, ms tgj metjeem amikj wms sjvjrjn mt`hpmat. gjrjfdrj, t s adeakunjn tgmt tgj mat`vmt`de sw`tag pds`t`de df tgj JK^ n`n edt njkmytgj rjsauj rjspdesj fdr tg`s maa`njet.
^gj njet`f`amt`de efdrhmt`de prdormhhjn de tgj m`rarmft `etjrfmaj hdnukj (ndeokj) wms frdhtgj m`rarmft tgmt tgj JK^ gmn prjv`dusky ijje estmkkjn de. Q`eaj tgj JK^ wms uemikj td trmesh`t,tgj eadrrjat njet`f`amt`de efdrhmt`de wms edt m fmatdr.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 150/215
- =>9 -
9.9> Fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo
Srdmat`vj men ede-pue`t`vj memkys`s df nj-`njet`f`jn nmtm ojejrmtjn nur`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des amegjkp td njet`fy men adetrdk r`sb prjsjet e m adhpmey‐s dpjrmt`des. g`s ampmi`k`ty prdv`njs mhjmes td hde`tdr p`kdt ijgmv`dur e mnn`t`de td fdrhmk mssjsshjet tddks, suag ms trm`e`eo menagjab r`njs. M`r amrr`jrs tgmt nd edt jhpkdy sdhj fdrh df fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo w`kk gmvj`emnjqumtj bedwkjnoj df r`sbs jx`st`eo w`tg`e tgj adhpmey. g`s emnjqumay ame hpm`r me m`ramrr`jr‐s mi`k`ty td njet`fy men h`t`omtj tgj r`sbs. @f m`r amrr`jrs nd edt hde`tdr fk`ogt nmtm td`njet`fy men adrrjat prdikjhs, tgjrj s m r`sb tgmt mnmptmt`des df stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjsw`kk edt ij njtjatjn.
Mktgduog F`rst M`r gms m fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo (FNH) prdormh, tgj adhpmey‐s FNH prdormhwms uenjrod`eo m trmes`t`de td m ejw sjrv`aj prdv`njr mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet, men nmtmmemkys`s wms edt ij`eo adenuatjn. g`s g`mtus njpr`vjn tgj adhpmey df me dppdrtue`ty td`njet`fy mnmptmt`des df QDSs, suag ms adet`eumt`de td kmen`eo fdkkdw`eo me uestmi`k`zjnmpprdmag.
9.9: _jmtgjr
^gj kmtjst APYI wjmtgjr disjrvmt`de mvm`kmikj td tgj arjw wms tgj =633 HJ^MY, wg`ag tgjyditm`ejn mt =630. gj ejxt rjadrnjn wjmtgjr disjrvmt`de wms m spja`mk wjmtgjr rjpdrt (QSJA@)mt =6>0. ^gj arjw df FMI6:63 gmn tgj hdst rjajet `efdrhmt`de mvm`kmikj.
^gj APYI v`s`i`k`ty njarjmsjn frdh =3 h`kjs mt =633 td : h`kjs mt =6>0. ^g`s njak`ej `e v`s`i`k`tywdukn edt gmvj tr`oojrjn m QSJA@. ^gj APYI aj`k`eo njarjmsjn frdh ?33 td 133 fjjt nur`eo tg`spjr`dn. Gdwjvjr, ed efdrhmt`de wms mvm`kmikj ms td wgje tgj agmeoj daaurrjn.
Mt =6>=<>=, tgj FD stmtjn tgmt gj smw tgj sgdrjk`ej. ^g`s stmtjhjet hjmes tgmt gj adukn ir`jfkysjj tgj surfmaj, men `en`amtjs tgmt tgj akdun imsj wms k`bjky rmoojn. gj APYI m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de`s 999 fjjt midvj sjm kjvjk (msk), men tgj jkjvmt`de df tgj wrjabmoj wms mpprdx`hmtjky >33 fjjtmsk. gj f`rj men shdbj dr`o`emt`eo frdh tgj ajetrmk fusjkmoj men w`eos wjrj edt v`s`ikj frdhtgj m`rpdrt frdh tgj t`hj df tgj armsg uet`k =?=0. ^g`s fmat `en`amtjs tgmt tgj akdun imsj `e tgmtsjatdr df tgj sby wms kjss tgme 933 fjjt midvj tgj m`rpdrt. Gdwjvjr, ijamusj tgjrj `s ed`efdrhmt`de midut tgj akdun imsj `e dtgjr sjatdrs df tgj sby, ed adeakus`de ame ij nrmwe ms tdtgj akdun aj`k`eo mt tgj m`rpdrt mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet.
Qjvje h`eutjs mftjr tgj maa`njet, tgj APYI =6>0 QSJA@ rjpdrtjn me disjrvjn aj`k`eo df133 fjjt mok, wg`ag wms =33 fjjt midvj mpprdmag h`e`huhs. Mnn`eo tg`s aj`k`eo gj`ogt td tgjm`rpdrt jkjvmt`de df 999 fjjt, tgj rjpdrtjn akdun imsj wdukn gmvj ijje mt :33 fjjt msk, wg`ag wms
midut =33 fjjt midvj tgj armsg s`tj. O`vje tgmt tgj s`tj n`n edt ijadhj v`s`ikj uet`k =?=0, tgjakdun imsj `e tgmt v`a`e`ty df tgj g`kks wms de tgj surfmaj. ^gj aj`k`eo mt tgj maa`njet s`tj n`ffjrjnsdhjwgmt frdh tgj aden`t`des disjrvjn n`rjatky dvjr tgj m`rpdrt.
Disjrvjn surfmaj v`s`i`k`ty wms =3 h`kjs mt =633, men : h`kjs mt =6>0. Mktgduog tgj v`s`i`k`ty mttgj m`rpdrt mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet `s uebedwe, `t k`bjky n`n edt njarjmsj ijkdw mpprdmagh`e`huhs mt mey t`hj nur`eo tgj mrr`vmk df FMI6:63.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 151/215
- =>1 -
9.96 Y`sb mssda`mtjn w`tg uestmikj mpprdmagjs
Yjsjmrag gms sgdwe tgmt uestmikj mpprdmagjs prjsjet m g`og r`sb td smfj fk`ogt dpjrmt`des. =6> Mssgdwe e prjv`dus evjst`omt`des iy QI men dtgjr fdrj`oe mojea`js, ejomt`vj dutadhjs eakunjtm`k str`bjs, ruewmy dvjrrues, men adetrdkkjn fk`ogt etd tjrrm`e (AF@^). _g`kj tgjrj mrj sdhjnjfjeajs `e pkmaj td h`t`omtj tgj r`sb df uestmikj mpprdmagjs, edt mkk njfjeajs mrj jhpkdyjn iymkk dpjrmtdrs. @e tg`s evjst`omt`de, tgj Idmrn jxmh`ejn e njtm`k tgj njfjeajs mvm`kmikj td m`ramrr`jrs td h`t`omtj tgj r`sbs mssda`mtjn w`tg uestmikj mpprdmagjs men tgj`r adesjqujeajs. gjsjhm`eky mnh`e`strmt`vj njfjeajs eakunj<
• M adhpmey stmi`k`zjn-mpprdmag pdk`ay, `eakun`eo m ed-fmukt od-mrduen pdk`ay2
• Dpjrmt`demk zjn stmikj mpprdmag ar`tjr`m men stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs (QDSs),`eakun`eo arjw pgrmsjdkdoy2
• Jffjat`vj arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet (AYH), eakun`eo jhpdwjr`eo df f`rst dff`ajrs tdtmbj adetrdk `e me uesmfj s`tumt`de2
• Zsj df fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo (FNH) prdormhs td hde`tdr QDS adhpk`meaj w`tg
stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag ar`tjr`m2
• Zsj df k`ej-dr`jetjn smfjty mun`ts (KDQM) dr dtgjr hjmes, suag ms prdf`a`jeay men k`ejagjabs, td mssjss AYH prmat`ajs men njet`fy arjw mnmptmt`des df QDSs2
• Ede-pue`t`vj rjpdrt`eo systjhs (td rjpdrt daaurrjeajs dr uesmfj prmat`ajs)2
• Zsj df tjrrm`e mwmrjejss men wmre`eo systjhs (^M_Q).
_g`kj F`rst M`r gmn sdhj df tgjsj njfjeajs e pkmaj, eakun`eo m stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag pdk`ay menar`tjr`m, m ed-fmukt od-mrduen pdk`ay, smfjty hmemojhjet systjh (QHQ) gmzmrn men daaurrjeajrjpdrt`eo, tgj twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj, men me dknjr-ojejrmt de OS_Q, tgjsj njfjeajs wjrjedt rdiust jeduog td prjvjet tgj adet`eumt de df tgj uestmikj mpprdmag dr adkk`s`de w`tgtjrrm`e. Dtgjr QI evjst`omt`des gmvj sgdwe tgmt ede-mngjrjeaj td adhpmey QDSs rjkmtjn tdstmi`k`zjn mpprdmagjs `s edt ue`quj td F`rst M`r. =6:
Aurrjet njfjeajs mom`est adet`eu`eo uestmikj mpprdmagjs gmvj prdvje kjss tgme mnjqumtj.Zekjss furtgjr mat`de s tmbje td rjnuaj tgj ea`njeaj df uestmikj mpprdmagjs tgmt adet`euj td mkmen`eo, tgj r`sb df AF@^ men df mpprdmag men kmen`eo maa`njets w`kk pjrs`st.
=6> Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de, Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de Mpprdmag men Kmen`eo Maa`njet Yjnuat`de (FQFMKMY), Ir`jf`eo Edtj ?.=< Qtmi`k`zjn Mpprdmag, Fk`ogt Qmfjty N`ojst (Muoust∙Edvjhijr 9333)
=6: ^QI `evjst`omt`de rjpdrts M=9_333>, M=9]3=6=, M37D3111, M37D331:, M3?_333:, M3>D3=77, menM33G333>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 152/215
- =>> -
1.3 F`en`eos
1.= F`en`eos ms td amusjs men adetr`iut`eo fmatdrs
=. ^gj kmtj e`t`mt`de men suisjqujet hmemojhjet df tgj njsajet rjsuktjn e tgj m`rarmft
ture`eo detd f`emk mpprdmag 633 fjjt midvj tgj ok`njskdpj, earjms`eo tgj arjw‐swdrbkdmn men rjnua`eo tgj`r ampma`ty td mssjss men rjsdkvj tgj emv`omt`demk ssujsnur`eo tgj rjhm`enjr df tgj mpprdmag.
9. _gje tgj gjmn`eo rjfjrjeaj frdh tgj adhpmss systjhs wms sjt nur`eo e`t`mk njsajet,tgjrj wms me jrrdr df ∙7³. Fdr uenjtjrh`ejn rjmsdes, furtgjr adhpmss nr`ft nur`eo tgjmrr`vmk men mpprdmag rjsuktjn `e adhpmss jrrdrs df mt kjmst ∙=?³ de f`emk mpprdmag.
1. Ms tgj m`rarmft rdkkjn dut df tgj ture detd f`emk mpprdmag td tgj r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr, tgjamptm`e k`bjky hmnj m adetrdk wgjjk rdkk eput tgmt amusjn tgj mutdp`kdt td rjvjrt frdhVDY/KDA ampturj td HME men GNO GDKN hdnj. ^gj hdnj agmeoj wms edt njtjatjn
iy tgj arjw.
>. De rdkk`eo dut df tgj ture, tgj amptm`e‐s gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de en`amtdr n`spkmyjn mgjmn`eo df 113³, prdv`n`eo m pjraj`vjn `e`t`mk etjrajpt meokj df =?³ td tgj eiduenkdamk`zjr trmab df 1>?³. Gdwjvjr, nuj td tgj adhpmss jrrdr, tgj m`rarmft‐s truj gjmn`eowms 1>6³. _`tg 1³ df w`en nr`ft td tgj r`ogt, tgj m`rarmft n`vjrojn furtgjr r`ogt df tgjkdamk`zjr.
:. ^gj arjw‐s wdrbkdmn earjmsjn ms tgjy mttjhptjn td uenjrstmen men rjsdkvj tgjmhi`ou`ty df tgj trmab n`vjrojeaj, wg`ag wms `eadeorujet w`tg tgj pjraj`vjn `etjrajptmeokj men jxpjatjn rjsukts.
6. Zenjtjatjn iy tgj p`kdts, tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdrs k`bjky rjvjrtjn td MZ^D MSS etjrajpthdnj ms tgj m`rarmft pmssjn tgrduog 9.:³ r`ogt df tgj kdamk`zjr, prdv`n`eo rdkk ou`nmeaj tdtgj sjkjatjn gjmn`eo (w`eos-kjvjk adhhmen) rmtgjr tgme td tgj kdamk`zjr (kjft-tureadhhmen).
?. M n`vjrojeaj e hjetmk hdnjks njormnjn tgj arjw‐s mi`k`ty td rjsdkvj tgj emv`omt`demk`ssujs. gj w`eos-kjvjk adhhmen de tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr k`bjky mssurjn tgj amptm`e tgmttgj etjrajpt meokj wms suff`a`jet td rjture tgj m`rarmft td tgj sjkjatjn adursj2 gdwjvjr,tgj f`rst dff`ajr k`bjky put hdrj wj`ogt de tgj pds`t`demk efdrhmt`de df tgj trmab imr menOSQ.
7. ^gj arjw‐s mttjet`de wms njvdtjn td sdkv`eo tgj emv`omt`demk prdikjh, wg`ag njkmyjntgj adef`ourmt`de df tgj m`rarmft fdr kmen`eo. g`s prdikjh sdkv`eo wms me mnn`t`demktmsb, edt edrhmkky mssda`mtjn w`tg tg`s ar`t`amk pgmsj df fk`ogt, wg`ag jsamkmtjn tgjwdrbkdmn.
0. ^gj f`rst dff`ajr `en`amtjn td tgj amptm`e tgmt tgjy gmn fukk kdamk`zjr njfkjat`de. @e tgjmisjeaj df stmenmrn pgrmsjdkdoy mppk`amikj td g`s aurrjet s`tumt`de, gj gmn td `hprdv`sj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 153/215
- =>: -
tgj od-mrduen suoojst`de. Mktgduog fukk njfkjat`de `s me uenjs`rjn m`rarmft stmtjrjqu`r`eo m od-mrduen, tgj amptm`e adet`eujn tgj mpprdmag.
=3. ^gj arjw n`n edt hm`etm`e m sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. Ms tgj mpprdmag adet`eujn,tgj p`kdts n`n edt jffjat`vjky adhhue`amtj tgj`r rjspjat`vj pjrajpt`de, uenjrstmen`eo,men futurj prdljat`de df tgj m`rarmft stmtj.
==. Mktgduog tgj adhpmey gmn m pdk`ay tgmt rjqu`rjn me `hhjn`mtj od-mrduen e tgj jvjettgmt me mpprdmag wms uestmikj ijkdw =333 fjjt midvj f`jkn jkjvmt`de, ed od-mrduen wms`e`t`mtjn. g`s pdk`ay gmn edt ijje dpjrmt`demk zjn w`tg mey prdajnurmk ou`nmeaj e tgjstmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs.
=9. ^gj amptm`e n`n edt `etjrprjt tgj f`rst dff`ajr‐s stmtjhjet df ‛1 h`kj men edt adef`oojn‘ms ou`nmeaj td e`t`mtj m od-mrduen. gj amptm`e adet`eujn tgj mpprdmag men amkkjn fdrmnn`t`demk stjps td adef`ourj tgj m`rarmft.
=1. ^gj f`rst dff`ajr wms tmsb-smturmtjn, men gj tgus gmn kjss t`hj men adoe`t`vj ampma`ty tdnjvjkdp men jxjautj m adhhue`amt`de strmtjoy tgmt wdukn rjsukt e tgj amptm`e
agmeo`eo g`s adursj df mat`de.
=>. Nuj td mttjet`demk emrrdw`eo men tmsb smturmt`de, tgj amptm`e k`bjky n`n edt gmvj m g`og-kjvjk dvjrv`jw df tgj s`tumt`de. g`s kmab df dvjrv`jw adhprdh`sjn g`s mi`k`ty td `njet`fymen hmemoj r`sb.
=:. ^gj arjw e`t`mtjn m od-mrduen mftjr tgj orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjh ‛s`eb rmtj‘mkjrt daaurrjn, iut tgjrj wms `esuff`a`jet mkt`tunj men t`hj td jxjautj tgj hmedjuvrjmen mvd`n adkk`s`de w`tg tjrrm`e.
=6. ^gj f`rst dff`ajr hmnj hmey mttjhpts td adhhue`amtj g`s adeajres men suoojst m od-
mrduen. Duts`nj df tgj twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj, tgjrj wms ed ou`nmeaj prdv`njn tdmnnrjss m s`tumt`de e wg`ag tgj p`kdt fky`eo s rjspdes`vj iut s edt agmeo`eo me uesmfjadursj df mat`de. @e tgj misjeaj df akjmr pdk`a`js dr prdajnurjs mkkdw`eo m f`rst dff`ajr tdjsamkmtj frdh me mnv`sdry rdkj td tmb`eo adetrdk, tg`s f`rst dff`ajr k`bjky fjkt `eg`i`tjn frdhnd`eo sd.
=?. ^gj arjw‐s arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet wms ejffjat`vj. F`rst M`r‐s e`t`mk men rjaurrjetarjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo n`n edt prdv`nj tgj arjw w`tg suff`a`jet prmat`amkstrmtjo`js td mss`st w`tg nja`s`de hmb`eo men prdikjh sdkv`eo, adhhue`amt`de, menwdrbkdmn hmemojhjet.
=7. Qtmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurj mnmptmt`des de FMI6:63 rjsuktjn e `ejffjat`vj arjw
adhhue`amt`de, jsamkmtjn wdrbkdmn kjmn`eo td tmsb smturmt`de, men irjmbndwe `esgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. F`rst M`r‐s supjrv`sdry mat`v`t`js n`n edt njtjat tgjstmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurj mnmptmt`des w`tg`e tgj Pjkkdwbe`fj I?1? arjw imsj.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 154/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 155/215
- =>? -
1.1 Dtgjr f`en`eos
=. @t s k`bjky tgmt idtg p`kdts sw`tagjn frdh OSQ td VGF EMV nur`eo tgj f`emk pdrt`de dftgj `e-rmeoj agjab ijfdrj tgj ture mt HZQM^.
9. ^gj fk`ogt arjw df FMI6:63 wjrj edt emv`omt`eo us`eo tgj PYI VDY dr `etjet`demkky
trmab`eo tdwmrn tgj VDY.
1. ^gjrj wms ed `etjrfjrjeaj w`tg tgj edrhmk fueat`demk`ty df tgj estruhjet kmen`eosystjh fdr Yuewmy 1:^ mt APYI.
>. Ej`tgjr tgj h`k`tmry tdwjr edr tgj h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdkkjr mt APYI gmn suff`a`jetvmk`n `efdrhmt`de mvm`kmikj td amusj tgjh td `ssuj m pds`t`de mnv`sdry td FMI6:63.
:. ^gj tjhpdrmry Akmss N adetrdk zdej jstmik`sgjn iy tgj h`k`tmry mt APYI wms dpjrmt`eow`tgdut mey ampmi`k`ty td prdv`nj estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs sjpmrmt`de.
6.
^gj njkmy e edt`f`amt`de df tgj ld`et rjsauj addrn`emt`de ajetrj n`n edt njkmy tgjjhjrojeay rjspdesj td tgj armsg s`tj.
?. ^gj ED^MHs ssujn adeajre`eo tgj jstmik`sghjet df tgj h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjmn`n edt suaajjn e adhhue`amt`eo tgj efdrhmt`de ejjnjn iy tgj m`rspmaj usjrs.
7. ^gj aj`k`eo mt tgj m`rpdrt mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet adukn edt ij njtjrh`ejn. ^gjv`s`i`k`ty mt tgj m`rpdrt mt tgj t`hj df tgj maa`njet k`bjky n`n edt njarjmsj ijkdw mpprdmagh`e`huhs mt mey t`hj nur`eo tgj mrr`vmk df FMI6:63. ^gj akdun kmyjr mt tgj armsg s`tjwms surfmaj-imsjn kjss tgme 933 fjjt midvj tgj m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 156/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 157/215
- =>0 -
De =0 Njajhijr 93==, tgj ^QI mnv`sjn EMV AMEMNM tgmt m rjv`jw df tgj APYI mpprdmagpkmtjs men mjrdnrdhj agmrt en`amtjn > n`ffjrjet hmoejt`a vmr`mt`de njp`at`des. M k`h`tjnrjv`jw df Amemnm M`r S`kdt, vdkuhj (AMS) =, =66 sgdwjn tgmt hmey dtgjr kdamt`des s`h`kmrky gmvjn`ffjrjet vmkujs fdr tgj hmoejt`a vmr`mt`de njp`atjn de n`ffjrjet pkmtjs. gj QI suoojstjn tgmtEMV AMEMNM hmy w`sg td tmbj mhjen`eo mat`de td njp`at ades`stjet `efdrhmt`de `e Amemnm M`r S`kdt, AMS =, men mhjen prdajssjs td jesurj tgmt futurj hmoejt`a vmr`mt`de njp`at`des mrj
ades`stjet.
De 37 Fjirumry 93=9, tgj ^QI `ssujn Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Mnv`sdry M==G3339-N=-M=, @FYQjpmrmt`de `e Akmss N M`rspmaj, td tgj Adhhmenjr df tgj = Amemn`me M`r N`v`s`de, YdymkAmemn`me M`r Fdraj. gj mnv`sdry stmtjn< =6?
Ijamusj h`k`tmry M^A adet`eujn td dpjrmtj tgj Akmss N adetrdk zdejw`tgdut tgj mi`k`ty td prdv`nj @FY sjpmrmt`de e `estruhjet hjtjdrdkdo`amkaden`t`des, tgjrj wms me earjmsjn r`sb df h`n-m`r adkk`s`de. Zekjss futurjJM^H dpjrmt`des eakunj tgj prdv`s`de fdr mkk tgj m`r trmff`a sjrv`ajsrjqu`rjn fdr tgj akmss df m`rspmaj, tg`s r`sb w`kk pjrs`st.
De =9 Mpr`k 93=9, tgj QI ssujn Mv`mt`de Qmfjty @efdrhmt`de kjttjr M==G3339-N9-K=,@emnjqumtj Ou`nmeaj fdr FNY Hm`etjemeaj, =67 td ^rmespdrt Amemnm. gj kjttjr en`amtjn tgmttgj Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY) Qtmenmrn fdr FNY hm`etjemeaj ndjs edt rjfkjat tgjaurrjet JZYDAMJ (Jurdpjme Drome`smt`de fdr A`v`k Mv`mt`de Jqu`phjet) spja`f`amt`des fdrfk`ogt rjadrnjr hm`etjemeaj, men tgjrjfdrj prdv`njs esuff`a`jet ou`nmeaj td jesurj tgjsjrv`ajmi`k`ty df FNYs.
De 96 Mpr`k 93=9, QI evjst`omtdrs prjsjetjn m ir`jf`eo td sje`dr F`rst M`r hmemojhjetpjrsdeejk rjomrn`eo tgj adhpmey‐s AYH trm`e`eo. F`rst M`r adenuats `ts `e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eonur`eo typj trm`e`eo fdr ejwky g`rjn p`kdts. ^QI `evjst`omtdrs mttjenjn m F`rst M`r `e`t`mk AYHtrm`e`eo adursj de 31 Mpr`k 93=92 tg`s wms tgj f`rst `e`t`mk AYH adursj adenuatjn s`eaj tgj
maa`njet. gj adursj wms t`hj-adhprjssjn, men n`n edt mnnrjss mkk df tgj hdnukjs rjqu`rjnuenjr AMY ?3:.=9> ∙ rm`e`eo Srdormh, =60 men Adhhjra`mk M`r Qjrv`aj Qtmenmrns (AMQQ)?9:.=9>(10) ∙ Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet rm`e`eo. =?3 Mnn`t`demkky, tgj adetjet df tgj hmtjr`mk
=66 EMV AMEMNM, Amemnm M`r S`kdt (AMS), AMS =< Pubde, Edrtgwjst jrr`tdr`js men Euemvut(jffjat`vj 13 Luej 93==)
=6? ^QI, Mv`mt`de Qmfjty Mnv`sdry M==G3339-N=-M=< @FY Qjpmrmt`de `e Akmss N M`rspmaj (37 Fjirumry93=9), mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.ist-tsi.oa.am/jeo/jequjtjs-`evjst`omt`des/mv`mt`de/93==/M==G3339/m==g3339-n9-m=.msp (kmst maajssjn de 97 Lmeumry 93=>)
=67 ^QI, Mv`mt`de Qmfjty @efdrhmt`de M==G3339-N9-K=< @emnjqumtj Ou`nmeaj fdr FNY Hm`etjemeaj (=9Mpr`k 93=9), mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.ist-tsi.oa.am/jeo/jequjtjs-`evjst`omt`des/mv`mt`de/93==
/M==G3339/m==g3339-n9-k=.msp=60 Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des (AMY), sjat`de ?3:.=9> ‑ ^rm`e`eo Srdormh, mvm`kmikj mt
gttp<//www.ta.oa.am/a`v`kmv`mt`de/rjosjrv/mffm`rs/amrs/pmrt?/?3:.gth (kmst maajssjn de 97 Lmeumry93=>)
=?3 Adhhjra`mk M`r Qjrv`aj Qtmenmrns (AMQQ), sjat`de ?9:.=9>, suisjat`de (10)< Arjw Yjsduraj Hmemojhjet^rm`e`eo fdr Arjw Hjhijrs (kmst rjv`sjn 93==/36/3=), mvm`kmikj mt gttp<//www.ta.oa.am/jeo/a`v`kmv`mt`de/rjosjrv/amrs/pmrt?-stmenmrns-?9:-9=?1.gth#?9:T=9>T10 (kmst maajssjn de 97 Lmeumry93=>)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 158/215
- =:3 -
prjsjetjn wms nmtjn men n`n edt eakunj prmat`amk tddks men strmtjo`js. @t wms suoojstjn tgmt tgjadhpmey hmy wmet td mkkdamtj hdrj t`hj td AYH trm`e`eo men upnmtj tgj adursj adetjet.
>.=.9 F`rst M`r
>.=.9.= Fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr adrrjkmt`de agjab
F`rst M`r adenuatjn me mun`t df `ts FNY adrrjkmt`de agjab prdajnurjs, men prjsjetjn tgj rjsuktstd QI evjst`omtdrs de 37 Njajhijr 93==. @t wms suisjqujetky njtjrh`ejn tgmt F`rst M`r wmsadenuat`eo tgj nmtm adrrjkmt`de agjab e k`ej w`tg tgj AMY. gj ue`njet`f`jn nmtm-nrdp prdikjhwms rjkmtjn td emnjqumtj ou`nmeaj fdr fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr hm`etjemeaj ms njsar`ijn e QIQmfjty @efdrhmt`de Kjttjr M==G3339-N9-K=.
>.=.9.9 Yjspdesj td tgj 37 Edvjhijr 93== men 96 Mpr`k 93=9 ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn ir`jf`eos
Fdkkdw`eo tgj 37 Edvjhijr 93== QI ir`jf`eo, F`rst M`r jetjrjn tgj smfjty ssujs prjsjetjn etd`ts smfjty hmemojhjet systjh f`kj. gj adhpmey jvmkumtjn tgj ssujs men njvjkdpjn m pkme tdmnnrjss tgjh. De 9: Luky 93=9, F`rst M`r adhhue`amtjn `ts adrrjat`vj mat`de td tgj ^QI. De 3=Muoust 93=1, tg`s `efdrhmt`de wms furtgjr upnmtjn td `en`amtj tgj stmtus df mat`des tmbje. ^gdsjmat`des mrj njsar`ijn ijkdw.
>.=.9.9.= Qtmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs
F`rst M`r adhpkjtjn m rjv`jw df I?1?, I?6?, M^Y>9, M^Y?9, men K179 stmenmrn dpjrmt`eoprdajnurjs (QDSs) td njet`fy mnmptmt`des df QDSs. Bedwkjnoj men prdajnurmk njf`a`jea`jswjrj `njet`f`jn ms mrjms fdr rjv`jw men `hprdvjhjet.
@hhjn`mtj mat`des
^gj fdkkdw`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des hjhdrmenm (FDSHs) wjrj `ssujn<
m) FDSH-==-:: wms ssujn td prdv`nj arjws w`tg m adhprjgjes`vj hjssmoj frdh sje`drhmemojhjet adeajre`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des men w`tg ir`jf`eo `estruat`des fdr tgj ag`jfp`kdts. Mkk fk`ogt arjw hjhijrs wjrj `en`v`numkky ir`jfjn iy tgj`r rjspjat`vj ag`jf p`kdtstd rj`tjrmtj tgj rjqu`rjhjet men `hpdrtmeaj df fdkkdw`eo tgj pdk`a`js e tgj fk`ogtdpjrmt`des hmeumks men stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs. g`s hmemojhjet n`rjat`de wms`est`tutjn td jesurj tgmt mkk arjw hjhijrs uenjrstmen tgj`r rdkjs e hm`etm`e`eo m smfjdpjrmt`de.
i) FDSH-==-3?9 ∙ Jsamkmt`eo frdh me Mnv`sdry Ydkj td mb`eo Adetrdk (9> Edvjhijr93==) wms ssujn, men tgj njtm`ks df tg`s n`rjat`de wjrj `eakunjn e mhjenhjets td tgjfk`ogt dpjrmt`des hmeumk ms fdkkdws<
• Mey arjw hjhijr ame adhhmen m od-mrduen us`eo tgj amkk ‛Od mrduen.‘
• Ar`tjr`m fdr jstmik`sg`eo m stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag wjrj jegmeajn.
• ^gj ed-fmukt od-mrduen pdk`ay wms rj`efdrajn.
• Mftjr rjv`jw`eo enustry ijst prmat`aj, tgj ‛twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj‘ wmsrj`efdrajn.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 159/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 160/215
- =:9 -
>.=.9.9.1 Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet
^gj arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo wms rjv`jwjn men upnmtjn w`tg hdrj hdnjreadetjet. gj kjeotg df tgj e`t`mk adursj wms `earjmsjn td dej fukk nmy.
>.=.9.9.>
Yjpdrt`eo systjh
M rjv`jw df tgj rjpdrt`eo systjh men rjqu`rjhjets wms adenuatjn. Ms pmrt df tgj rjv`jw, `twms njet`f`jn tgmt ajrtm`e pdk`a`js e fdraj hmy gmvj adetr`iutjn td rjpdrt`eo fmt`ouj e k`h`tjnmrjms. Qjvjrmk pdk`a`js `e pkmaj rjqu`rjn `tjhs tgmt wjrj pmrt df edrhmk dpjrmt`des td ijrjpdrtjn rjoukmrky, suag ms m edrhmk n`vjrs`de nuj td wjmtgjr. O`vje tgj adhpkjx emturj df tgjdpjrmt`eo jev`rdehjet, dtgjr `tjhs hmy edt gmvj ijje rjpdrtjn nuj td tgj wdrbkdmn men tgjadhpkjx`ty df tgj pdk`ay men fdrh usjn. ^gj m`r smfjty rjpdrt gms ijje mhjenjn td rjhdvj tgjrjqu`rjhjets td rjpdrt jxpjatjn edrhmk dpjrmt`des tjhs, njakuttjr`eo t td prdv`nj hdrjdppdrtue`ty td njsar`ij mey jvjets tgmt rjqu`rj mttjet`de. gj `hpdrtmeaj df deod`eo rjpdrt`eodf gmzmrns wms `eakunjn w`tg`e tgj edt`f`amt`de td tgj arjws df tgj m`r smfjty rjpdrt fdrh menpdk`ay agmeojs. gjsj mat`des wjrj adhpkjtjn e Datdijr 93=9.
Mnn`t`demkky, tgj hmemojr df fk`ogt smfjty puik`sgjn 9 mrt`akjs e tgj adhpmey ejwskjttjrprdhdt`eo rjpdrt`eo e mkk mspjats df fk`ogt dpjrmt`des.
>.=.9.9.: ^rm`e`eo stmenmrns
M rjv`jw men rjv`s`de df tgj K`ej Agjab S`kdt Adursj wms adhpkjtjn. ^gj m`h df tg`s adursj `std jesurj tgmt mkk trm`e`eo men agjab pjrsdeejk gmvj m adhhde stmenmrn iy wg`ag td vmk`nmtjtgj trm`e`eo men td jesurj tgmt mkk adhpmey prdajnurjs mrj uenjrstddn men fdkkdwjn. gj f`rstadursj wms njk`vjrjn de 9> Luky 93=9.
>.=.9.9.6 @e`t`mk men rjaurrjet trm`e`eo
F`rst M`r s adenuat`eo m rjv`jw df mkk `e`t`mk trm`e`eo. M rjv`jw df s`hukmtdr trm`e`eo, k`ej`endatr`emt`de, men rjaurrjet trm`e`eo w`kk fdkkdw. Jmag df tgjsj prdormhs w`kk adetm`e jkjhjetstgmt rj`efdraj arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet tjage`qujs.
>.=.9.9.? Hm`etjemeaj
Hm`etjemeaj Qjrv`ajs gms e`t`mtjn m prdormh td njtjrh`ej tgj nr`ft rmtj df tgj n`rjat`demk oyrdswg`kj de tgj orduen. @f jxajss`vj nr`ft rmtjs mrj njtjatjn, me jegmeajn hm`etjemeaj prdormhw`kk ij put `e pkmaj td prdv`nj maajptmikj pjrfdrhmeaj. Adupkjn w`tg tg`s prdormh w`kk ijfjjnimab td fk`ogt arjws td `earjmsj mwmrjejss df tgj dpjrmt`de df tg`s systjh men df tgj rjpdrts
rjqu`rjn td hm`etm`e rjk`mi`k`ty.
>.=.9.9.7 Fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo prdormh
F`rst M`r‐s fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo (FNH) prdormh gms ijje rjv`jwjn, men me duts`nj adhpmeygms ijje adetrmatjn td prdv`nj mss`stmeaj men ou`nmeaj e njtjat`eo QDS mnmptmt`des men dtgjrmrjms rjqu`r`eo trm`e`eo jegmeajhjet. gj hmemojr df tgj prdormh prdnuajs qumrtjrky rjpdrts,wg`ag mrj rjv`jwjn mt tgj jxjaut`vj smfjty hmemojhjet hjjt`eos de m qumrtjrky ims`s. g`s
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 161/215
- =:1 -
`e`t`mt`vj gms prdv`njn nmtm fdr hprdvjhjets e trm`e`eo men nmy-td-nmy dpjrmt`des fdr mkkm`rarmft typjs `e tgj F`rst M`r fkjjt.
>.=.9.1 Hm`etjemeaj sgdrtfmkk rjomrn`eo m`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjs
Quisjqujet td tgj n`sadvjry tgmt M`rwdrtg`ejss N`rjat`vjs MN 933>-=0-=3 men MN 9336-=9-91
gmn edt ijje fukky maadhpk`sgjn, F`rst M`r `e`t`mtjn m smfjty hmemojhjet systjh (QHQ)`evjst`omt`de td njtjrh`ej wgy tg`s gmn gmppjejn men td vjr`fy wgjtgjr tgj smhj sgdrtfmkk gmndaaurrjn w`tg tgj dtgjr I?1? m`rarmft `e `ts fkjjt.
M`rwdrtg`ejss N`rjat`vj 933>-=0-=3
^gj adhpmey‐s evjst`omt`de rjvjmkjn tgmt : df tgj rjhm`e`eo Idj`eo ?1? fkjjt m`rarmft wjrj mksddvjrnuj fdr espjat`des df tgj gdr`zdetmk stmi`k`zjr p`vdt g`eoj p`es rjqu`rjn iy MN 933>-=0-=3.^gj sgdrt-tjrh adrrjat`vj mat`de pkme orduenjn tgj mffjatjn m`rarmft uet`k tgj rjqu`rjn`espjat`des df tgj gdr`zdetmk stmi`k`zjr p`vdt g`eoj p`es wjrj adhpkjtjn. Ed medhmk`js wjrj`njet`f`jn ms m rjsukt df tgjsj `espjat`des, men tgj m`rarmft wjrj rjturejn td sjrv`aj.
^gj adrrjat`vj mat`de pkme hpkjhjetjn tgrduog tgj QHQ eakunjn tgj mrrmeojhjet df mtg`rn-pmrty e-njptg mun`t df mkk m`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjs pjrtm`e`eo td adhpmey Idj`eo ?1?,M^Y (Mv`des nj trmespdrt rào`demk) men Kdabgjjn A-=13 Gjraukjs m`rarmft. ^gj adhpmey gmsarjmtjn m ejw pds`t`de tgmt s pr`hmr`ky rjspdes`ikj fdr pjrfdrh`eo m sjpmrmtj men enjpjenjetrjv`jw df mkk futurj adhpmey jvmkumt`des df m`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjs. gj adhpmey gms mksd`e`t`mtjn njvjkdphjet df m sykkmius fdr hmenmtdry m`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vj trm`e`eo (`e`t`mk menrjaurrjet) fdr mkk stmff evdkvjn e tgj jvmkumt`de df m`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjs.
M`rwdrtg`ejss N`rjat`vj 9336-=9-91
_gje tgj dpjrmtdr wms mnv`sjn df tgj njfjrrjn frjj pkmy jetjrjn de m njfjrrjn hm`etjemeaj`tjh (NH@) amrn, me mun`t df tgj rjadrns df `ts rjhm`e`eo Idj`eo ?1? fkjjt m`rarmft wms`hhjn`mtjky uenjrtmbje. @t wms adef`rhjn tgmt edej df tgjsj m`rarmft wjrj dpjrmt`eo w`tg meynjfjrrmks frdh tgj adhpkjt`de df MN 9336-=9-91.
Qgdrt-tjrh adrrjat`vj mat`de wms tmbje td rjhdvj tgj jrrmet sjrv`aj hm`etjemeaj prdajnurjfrdh tgj hm`etjemeaj nmtmimsj men rjv`sj t td rjhdvj tgj eadrrjat njfjrrmk `estruat`des. gjadhpmey gms adhh`ttjn td rjv`jw mkk sjrv`aj hm`etjemeaj prdajnurjs fdr ts fkjjt nur`eo`hpkjhjetmt`de df tgj ejwky maqu`rjn YMW sdftwmrj.
>.=.9.> Jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr
Zpde edt`f`amt`de frdh tgj QI tgmt tgj jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjr (JK^) estmkkjn deA-OE_E gmn edt ijje mrhjn, F`rst M`r e`t`mtjn me QHQ evjst`omt`de. Me hhjn`mtj fkjjt-w`nj espjat`de adef`rhjn tgmt mkk df tgj rjhm`e`eo I?1? m`rarmft gmn fueat`de`eo JK^s.
^gj QHQ `evjst`omt`de njtjrh`ejn tgj fdkkdw`eo<
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 162/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 163/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 164/215
- =:6 -
Mkk df tgj mpprdmag agmrts w`kk ij rjv`jwjn men upnmtjn us`eo tgjsj tddks frdh Lmeumrytgrduog Muoust 93=1.
• ^gj hmoejt`a vmr`mt`de mt APYI men mkk dtgjr edrtgjre s`tjs gms ijje upnmtjn. EMVAMEMNM s agmeo`eo frdh m nmtj-nr`vje upnmtj systjh td m systjh tgmt s tr`oojrjn iym hmoejt`a vmr`mt`de tdkjrmeaj vmkuj.
>.9 Qmfjty mat`de rjqu`rjn
>.9.= Zestmikj mpprdmagjs
@e tg`s maa`njet, tgj m`rarmft mrr`vjn g`og men fmst de f`emk mpprdmag, wms edt adef`ourjn fdrkmen`eo de m t`hjky ims`s, gmn edt etjrajptjn tgj kdamk`zjr men wms n`vjro`eo td tgj r`ogt. g`smpprdmag wms edt ades`njrjn stmi`k`zjn e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj adhpmey‐s stmi`k`zjn mpprdmagar`tjr`m, men tgj s`tumt`de rjqu`rjn m od-mrduen. @estjmn, tgj mpprdmag wms adet`eujn. _gje tgjarjw e`t`mtjn m od-mrduen, t wms tdd kmtj td mvd`n tgj hpmat w`tg tjrrm`e. Zestmikj mpprdmagjsadet`euj td ij m g`og r`sb td smfj fk`ogt dpjrmt`des `e Amemnm men wdrknw`nj.
Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de rjsjmrag adeakunjn =?9 tgmt 1.:% td >% df mpprdmagjs mrj uestmikj. Dftgjsj, 0?% mrj adet`eujn td m kmen`eo, w`tg deky 1% rjsukt`eo e m od-mrduen. d put tgjsjf`ourjs e adetjxt, tgjrj wjrj, e 93=9, 9>.> h`kk`de fk`ogts wdrknw`nj e m fkjjt df a`v`k`me,adhhjra`mk, wjstjre-iu`kt ljt m`rpkmejs gjmv`jr tgme 63 333 pduens. g`s hjmes tgmt ijtwjje7:> 333 men 0?6 333 df tgdsj fk`ogts tjrh`emtjn w`tg me uestmikj mpprdmag, men mpprdx`hmtjky797 333 td 0>: 333 adet`eujn td m kmen`eo. ^gj pdtjet`mk ejomt`vj adesjqujeajs df adet`eu`eo meuestmikj mpprdmag td m kmen`eo eakunj adetrdkkjn fk`ogt etd tjrrm`e (AF@^), ruewmy dvjrrues,kmen`eo sgdrt df tgj ruewmy, men tm`k-str`bj maa`njets.
Daaurrjeajs e wg`ag me uestmikj mpprdmag wms m adetr`iut`eo fmatdr njhdestrmtj tgmt tgjsjvjr`ty ame rmeoj frdh ed `elur`js dr nmhmoj td hukt`pkj fmtmk`t`js men m`rarmft njstruat`de. @eYjsdkutj Imy, tgj adet`eumt`de df me uestmikj mpprdmag kjn td m AF@^ maa`njet men tgj kdss df =9k`vjs. _`tgdut hprdvjhjets e stmikj mpprdmag pdk`ay adhpk`meaj, hdst uestmikj mpprdmagjsw`kk adet`euj td m kmen`eo, `earjms`eo tgj r`sb df AF@^ men mpprdmag men kmen`eo maa`njets.
@e tg`s evjst`omt`de, tgj Idmrn jxmh`ejn e njtm`k tgj njfjeajs mvm`kmikj td m`r amrr`jrs tdh`t`omtj tgj r`sbs mssda`mtjn w`tg uestmikj mpprdmagjs men tgj`r adesjqujeajs. gjsj hm`ekymnh`e`strmt`vj njfjeajs eakunj<
• M adhpmey stmi`k`zjn-mpprdmag pdk`ay, `eakun`eo ed-fmukt od-mrduen pdk`ay2
• Dpjrmt`demk`zjn stmikj mpprdmag ar`tjr`m men stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs (QDSs),`eakun`eo arjw pgrmsjdkdoy2
• Jffjat`vj arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet (AYH), eakun`eo jhpdwjr`eo df f`rst dff`ajrs tdtmbj adetrdk e me uesmfj s`tumt`de2
• Zsj df fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo (FNH) prdormhs td hde`tdr QDS adhpk`meaj w`tgstmi`k`zjn mpprdmag ar`tjr`m2
=?9 Fk`ogt Qmfjty Fduenmt`de, ‛Fm`kurj td H`t`omtj,‘ MjrdQmfjty _drkn (Fjirumry 93=1)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 165/215
- =:? -
• Zsj df k`ej-dr`jetjn smfjty mun`ts (KDQM) dr dtgjr hjmes, suag ms prdf`a`jeay men k`ejagjabs, td mssjss AYH prmat`ajs men njet`fy arjw mnmptmt`des df QDSs2
• Ede-pue`t`vj rjpdrt`eo systjhs (td rjpdrt daaurrjeajs dr uesmfj prmat`ajs)2
• Zsj df tjrrm`e mwmrjejss men wmre`eo systjhs (^M_Q).
_g`kj F`rst M`r gmn sdhj df tgjsj njfjeajs e pkmaj, eakun`eo m stmi`k`zjn mpprdmag pdk`ay menar`tjr`m, m ed-fmukt od-mrduen pdk`ay, smfjty hmemojhjet systjh (QHQ) gmzmrn men daaurrjeajrjpdrt`eo, tgj twd-adhhue`amt`de rukj men me dknjr-ojejrmt`de orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eosystjh (OS_Q), tgjsj njfjeajs wjrj edt rdiust jeduog td prjvjet tgj adet`eumt`de df tgjuestmikj mpprdmag dr adkk`s`de w`tg tjrrm`e. Dtgjr QI evjst`omt`des gmvj sgdwe tgmt ede-mngjrjeaj td adhpmey QDSs rjkmtjn td stmi`k`zjn mpprdmagjs s edt ue`quj td F`rst M`r.
@e mnn`t`de, tgj usj df ejwjr-ojejrmt`de M_Q w`tg fdrwmrn-kddb`eo tjrrm`e mvd`nmeajfjmturjs w`kk jegmeaj m fk`ogt arjw‐s s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss men prdv`nj earjmsjn t`hj fdr arjwrjmat`de. Gdwjvjr, f tgj r`sb `e tgj systjh s td ij rjnuajn s`oe`f`ametky, tgj enustry hust tmbjdtgjr stjps men edt rjky de purjky tjagedkdo`amk sdkut`des.
^gj f`rst stjp `s fdr dpjrmtdrs td gmvj prmat`amk men jxpk`a`t pdk`a`js, ar`tjr`m, men QDSs fdrstmi`k`zjn mpprdmag tgmt mrj jesgr`ejn e tgj adhpmey dpjrmt`eo aukturj.
^gj sjaden stjp s fdr adhpme`js td gmvj adetjhpdrmry e`t`mk men rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eoprdormhs njk`vjrjn iy qumk`f`jn trm`ejrs men td hde`tdr men rj`efdraj jffjat`vj AYH sb`kks enmy-td-nmy fk`ogt dpjrmt`des. Jffjat`vj AYH s m njfjeaj mom`est r`sbs prjsjet e mkk pgmsjs dffk`ogt, `eakun`eo uestmikj mpprdmagjs.
^gj tg`rn stjp `evdkvjs hde`tdr`eo df QDS adhpk`meaj tgrduog prdormhs suag ms fk`ogt nmtmhde`tdr`eo (FNH) men k`ej-dr`jetjn smfjty mun`ts (KDQM). @e Amemnm, A rjqu`rjs kmroj
adhhjra`mk amrr`jrs td gmvj QHQ, adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjrs (AVYs), men fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjrs(FNYs). Gdwjvjr, tgjsj amrr`jrs mrj edt rjqu`rjn td gmvj me FNH prdormh. Jvje sd, hmey dftgjsj dpjrmtdrs rdut`ejky ndwekdmn tgj`r fk`ogt nmtm td adenuat FNH df edrhmk dpjrmt`des. M`ramrr`jrs w`tg fk`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eo prdormhs gmvj usjn fk`ogt nmtm td `njet`fy prdikjhs suag msuestmi`k`zjn mpprdmagjs men rusgjn mpprdmagjs, jxajjnmeaj df fkmp k`h`t spjjns, jxajss`vjimeb meokjs mftjr tmbj-dff, jeo`ej dvjr-tjhpjrmturj jvjets, jxajjnmeaj df rjadhhjenjn spjjntgrjsgdkns, OS_Q/^M_Q wmre`eos, desjt df stmkk aden`t`des, jxajss`vj rmtjs df rdtmt`de, ok`njpmtg jxaurs`des, men vjrt`amk maajkjrmt`de.
FNH gms ijje hpkjhjetjn e hmey aduetr`js, men t `s w`njky rjadoe`zjn ms m adst-jffjat`vjtddk fdr hprdv`eo smfjty. @e tgj Ze`tjn Qtmtjs men Jurdpj„tgmebs td @AMD„hmey amrr`jrsgmvj gmn tgj prdormh fdr yjmrs. Qdhj gjk`adptjr dpjrmtdrs gmvj `t mkrjmny, men tgj FjnjrmkMv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`de (FMM) gms rjadhhjenjn t.
_drknw`nj, FNH gms prdvje td ijejf`t smfjty iy o`v`eo dpjrmtdrs tgj tddks td kddb amrjfukky mt`en`v`numk fk`ogts men, ukt`hmtjky, mt tgj dpjrmt`de df tgj`r fkjjts dvjr t`hj. g`s rjv`jw dfdiljat`vj nmtm, jspja`mkky ms me `etjormk men ede-pue`t`vj adhpdejet df m adhpmey smfjtyhmemojhjet systjh, gms prdvje ijejf`a`mk e prdmat`vj njet`f`amt`de men adrrjat`de df smfjtynjf`a`jea`js men e prjvjet`de df maa`njets.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 166/215
- =:7 -
Aurrjet njfjeajs mom`est adet`eu`eo uestmikj mpprdmagjs gmvj prdvje kjss tgme mnjqumtj. @eAmemnm, wg`kj hmey AMY ?3: dpjrmtdrs gmvj vdkuetmr`ky hpkjhjetjn FNH prdormhs, tgjrj sed rjqu`rjhjet td nd sd. F`rst M`r wms edt adenuat`eo FNH mt tgj t`hj df tg`s maa`njet.Furtgjrhdrj, FNH prdormhs hust spja`f`amkky kddb mt wgy uestmikj mpprdmagjs mrj daaurr`eo,gdw arjws gmenkj tgjh, wgjtgjr dr edt arjws adhpky w`tg adhpmey stmi`k`zjn-mpprdmagar`tjr`m men prdajnurjs, men wgy arjws adet`euj me uestmikj mpprdmag td m kmen`eo. Zekjss
furtgjr mat`de s tmbje td rjnuaj tgj ea`njeaj df uestmikj mpprdmagjs tgmt adet`euj td m kmen`eo,tgj r`sb df mpprdmag men kmen`eo maa`njets w`kk pjrs`st.
^gjrjfdrj, tgj Idmrn rjadhhjens (M=>-3=) tgmt<
^rmespdrt Amemnm rjqu`rj AMYs Quipmrt ?3: dpjrmtdrs td hde`tdr men rjnuajtgj `ea`njeaj df uestmikj mpprdmagjs tgmt adet`euj td m kmen`eo.
>.1 Qmfjty adeajre
>.1.= Arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet trm`e`eo stmenmrns
@e tg`s maa`njet, tgj arjw ijamhj tmsb-smturmtjn nur`eo tgj f`emk mpprdmag, men n`n edthm`etm`e m sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss. Ms tgj uestmikj mpprdmag adet`eujn, tgj arjw‐s AYHwms ejffjat`vj. gj f`rst dff`ajr hmnj hmey mttjhpts td adhhue`amtj g`s adeajres men suoojstm od-mrduen. @e tgj misjeaj df akjmr pdk`a`js dr prdajnurjs mkkdw`eo m f`rst dff`ajr td tmbjadetrdk, tg`s f`rst dff`ajr k`bjky fjkt `eg`i`tjn frdh nd`eo sd.
F`rst M`r‐s AYH trm`e`eo prdormh gmn ijje mpprdvjn iy A e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj jx`st`eoAYH trm`e`eo stmenmrn. Gdwjvjr, fdkkdw`eo tgj maa`njet, QI evjst`omtdrs mttjenjn m F`rst M`r`e`t`mk AYH trm`e`eo adursj men njet`f`jn tgmt tgj matumk trm`e`eo njk`vjrjn n`n edt adetm`e mkkdf tgj suiljats dutk`ejn e AMQQ ?9:.=9>(10). gj AYH trm`e`eo hmtjr`mk wms njk`vjrjn e mpjr`dn df sjvjrmk gdurs df dej nmy, mkdeo w`tg dtgjr suiljats. ^gj A ou`nmeaj hmtjr`mk dewg`ag F`rst M`r‐s AYH trm`e`eo wms imsjn wms `etjenjn td ij njk`vjrjn `e 9 nmys. Ej`tgjr df tgjadhpmey‐s pr`hmry AYH estruatdrs gmn rjaj`vjn mey fdrhmk fma`k`tmtdr/`estruatdr trm`e`eo drmaarjn`tmt`de e tjmag`eo AYH.
F`rst M`r‐s e`t`mk men rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo n`n edt prdv`nj tgj arjw df FMI6:63 w`tgsuff`a`jet prmat`amk strmtjo`js td mss`st w`tg nja`s`de hmb`eo men prdikjh sdkv`eo,adhhue`amt`de, men wdrbkdmn hmemojhjet. ^g`s `evjst`omt`de fduen tgmt `f `e`t`mk AYHtrm`e`eo ndjs edt njvjkdp jffjat`vj AYH sb`kks, men f tgjrj s emnjqumtj rj`efdrajhjet df tgjsjsb`kks nur`eo rjaurrjet trm`e`eo, fk`ogt arjws hmy edt mnjqumtjky hmemoj r`sb de tgj fk`ogt njab.Furtgjrhdrj, f dpjrmtdrs nd edt tmbj stjps td jesurj tgmt fk`ogt arjws rdut`ejky mppky jffjat`vjAYH prmat`ajs nur`eo fk`ogt dpjrmt`des, r`sb td mv`mt`de smfjty w`kk pjrs`st.
^gj evjst`omt`de mksd njet`f`jn m euhijr df arjw mnmptmt`des df adhpmey QDSs jv`njet edtdeky mhdeo tgj maa`njet arjw, iut mksd w`tg`e tgj Pjkkdwbe`fj I?1? arjw imsj, men wg`ag F`rstM`r‐s supjrv`sdry mat`v`t`js gmn edt njtjatjn. QDS mnmptmt`des de FMI6:63 rjsuktjn `e`ejffjat`vj arjw adhhue`amt`de, jsamkmtjn wdrbkdmn kjmn`eo td tmsb smturmt`de, men irjmbndwe`e sgmrjn s`tumt`demk mwmrjejss.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 167/215
- =:0 -
Nur`eo jvjry fk`ogt, p`kdts hust suaajssfukky etjrmat w`tg jmag dtgjr, tgj`r m`rarmft, men tgj`rjev`rdehjet, us`eo mssda`mtjn agjabk`sts men adhpmey QDSs td jffjat`vjky hmemoj tgrjmts,jrrdrs, dr uenjs`rjn m`rarmft stmtjs tgmt hmy ij jeaduetjrjn. g`s odmk s maadhpk`sgjn iytrm`e`eo fk`ogt arjws td jhpkdy m vmr`jty df strmtjo`js td gjkp hprdvj jffjat`vjejss. AYH s mnjfjeaj mom`est r`sbs prjsjet e mkk pgmsjs df fk`ogt, eakun`eo uestmikj mpprdmagjs. Qdhj p`kdtshmy edt mnjqumtjky hmemoj dpjrmt`demk r`sb ms m rjsukt df `ejffjat`vj AYH sb`kks.
^gjrj mrj m vmr`jty df AYH stmenmrns men rjoukmt`des e pkmaj tgrduogdut tgj wdrkn. Njsp`tjtgjsj n`ffjrjeajs, tgjrj s m ojejrmk adesjesus e tgj mv`mt`de adhhue`ty tgmt AYH prdormhssgdukn ades`st df 1 n`st`eat pgmsjs. gj f`rst pgmsj s endatr`emt`de men mwmrjejss trm`e`eo. gjsjaden pgmsj s prmat`aj, fjjnimab, men rjaurrjet trm`e`eo. @e rjajet yjmrs, tgjrj gms ijje`earjmsjn rjadoe`t`de tgmt AYH trm`e`eo wdukn ij hdrj jffjat`vj f `t wms etjormtjn w`tgtjage`amk trm`e`eo frdh tgj jmrk`jst stmojs df tgj m`rarjw trm`e`eo rjo`hj. AYH trm`e`eoprdormhs tgmt eakunj rjaurrjet trm`e`eo men tgj matumk prmat`aj df AYH strmtjo`js gmvj ijjesgdwe td prdnuaj s`oe`f`amet agmeojs e fk`ogt arjw pjrfdrhmeaj nur`eo k`ej-dr`jetjn fk`ogttrm`e`eo sjss`des men nur`eo fk`ogts. ^gj tg`rn pgmsj `s adet`eu`eo rj`efdrajhjet. Me jffjat`vjhjtgdn df adet`eumk rj`efdrajhjet s td jhijn ar`t`amk AYH sb`kks men ijgmv`durs w`tg`e
adhpmey QDSs td hmbj AYH me `etjormk pmrt df mkk trm`e`eo men dpjrmt`des. @e suhhmry, tgjmaqu`s`t`de men hm`etjemeaj df jffjat`vj AYH sb`kks njpjens de rjaj`v`eo adetjhpdrmry e`t`mkmen rjaurrjet AYH trm`e`eo njk`vjrjn iy su`tmiky qumk`f`jn trm`ejrs, men deod`eo pjrfdrhmeajhde`tdr`eo men rj`efdrajhjet nur`eo rdut`ej fk`ogt dpjrmt`des.
^gj QI gms prjv`dusky rjkjmsjn m rjadhhjenmt`de (M30-39) men ssujn F`en`eos ms td Y`sb =?1 rjkmtjn td tgj prdv`s`de df AYH trm`e`eo td Smrt V@@ adhhjra`mk dpjrmtdrs, AYH trm`e`eostmenmrns, men estruatdr qumk`f`amt`des. @e Amemnm, tgj aurrjet AYH trm`e`eo stmenmrn ndjs edt`eadrpdrmtj tgj hdrj hdnjre adeajpts df tgrjmt men jrrdr hmemojhjet. ^gjrj mrj edjxpjr`jeaj, trm`e`eo, dr qumk`f`amt`de rjqu`rjhjets ejjnjn td tjmag AYH. @e adetrmst, tgj Ze`tjnB`eondh A`v`k Mv`mt`de Mutgdr`ty (AMM) gms jstmik`sgjn m sjr`js df str`eojet maarjn`tmt`de
rjqu`rjhjets fdr AYH estruatdrs men `estruatdr jxmh`ejrs.
Njsp`tj tgj fmat tgmt tgj AYH rjoukmt`des e Amemnm gmvj edt ijje upnmtjn td rjfkjat hdnjreAYH adeajpts, sdhj df tgjsj adeajpts gmvj mkrjmny ijje etjormtjn etd dtgjr A-kjnprdormhs. Fdr jxmhpkj, tgj Mnvmeajn ]umk`f`amt`de Srdormh, tgj Mpprdvjn Agjab S`kdtprdormh, men tgj Hukt`-Arjw S`kdt K`ajeaj pkmaj ades`njrmikj jhpgms`s de tgrjmt-men-jrrdrhmemojhjet adeajpts men strmtjo`js. @e mnn`t`de, jmag df tgjsj prdormhs mksd g`ogk`ogts tgj`hpdrtmeaj df ij`eo mikj td jvmkumtj tgjsj sb`kks ms pmrt df m prdf`a`jeay-imsjn trm`e`eo prdormh.
^A gms `e`t`mtjn sdhj mnn`t`demk h`t`omt`de hjmsurjs. M fdaus ordup ades`st`eo df ^A men`enustry rjprjsjetmt`vjs hjt e Lmeumry 93=9 men suih`ttjn m f`emk rjpdrt e Fjirumry 93=9. gjrjpdrt prdpdsjn adhpdejets df m adetjhpdrmry AYH trm`e`eo stmenmrn fdr Smrt V@@ adhhjra`mkdpjrmtdrs iut rjadhhjenjn mom`est m sjt t`hj fdr AYH adursj nurmt`de men mey fdrhmkmaarjn`tmt`de fdr AYH estruatdrs. gj A`v`k Mv`mt`de Yjoukmtdry Adhh`ttjj (AMYA) maajptjntgj A fdaus ordup rjadhhjenmt`des (sjj sjat`de =.=?.?.1), men de 9> Mpr`k 93=9, n`rjatjn tgmt m
=?1 ^QI Mv`mt`de @evjst`omt`de Yjpdrt M30M33=6
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 168/215
- =63 -
adetjhpdrmry AYH trm`e`eo rjoukmt`de men stmenmrn sgdukn ij njvjkdpjn fdr AMY Quipmrts?39, ?31, ?3>, men ?3:.
@t s edt yjt bedwe gdw njtm`kjn A‐s ejw trm`e`eo stmenmrn men ou`nmeaj hmtjr`mk w`kk ijadhpmrjn td tgj jx`st`eo stmenmrn, dr wgje tgj ejw stmenmrn w`kk adhj `etd jffjat. Edr `s `tbedwe gdw A w`kk jesurj tgmt dpjrmtdrs mppky tgj ejw trm`e`eo stmenmrn td jesurj tgmt fk`ogt
arjws maqu`rj men hm`etm`e jffjat`vj AYH sb`kks.
^gjrjfdrj, tgj Idmrn s adeajrejn tgmt, w`tgdut m adhprjgjes`vj men etjormtjn mpprdmag tdAYH iy A men mv`mt`de dpjrmtdrs, fk`ogt arjws hmy edt rdut`ejky prmat`sj jffjat`vj AYH.
^g`s rjpdrt adeakunjs tgj ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn‐s `evjst`omt`de `etd tg`s daaurrjeaj. ^gj Idmrnmutgdr`zjn tgj rjkjmsj df tg`s rjpdrt de 3: Hmrag 93=>.
V`s`t tgj ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn‐s wjis`tj (www.ist-tsi.oa.am) fdr `efdrhmt`de midut tgj^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn men `ts prdnuats men sjrv`ajs. Pdu w`kk mksd f`en tgj _mtagk`st, wg`ag
`njet`f`js tgj trmespdrtmt`de smfjty `ssujs tgmt pdsj tgj orjmtjst r`sb td Amemn`mes. @e jmag amsj, tgj ^QIgms fduen tgmt mat`des tmbje td nmtj mrj `emnjqumtj, men tgmt `enustry men rjoukmtdrs ejjn td tmbjmnn`t`demk adearjtj hjmsurjs td jk`h`emtj tgj r`sbs.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 169/215
- =6= -
Mppjen`ajs
Mppjen`x M ‑ FMI6:63 sjqujeaj df jvjets
(Skjmsj rjfjr td Mppjen`x W ‑ K`st df mardeyhs men miirjv`mt`des.)
Z^A Jvjet
=1::<:1 EMV AMEMNM M^A `ssujs tgj fdkkdw`eo @FY akjmrmeaj td FMI6:63< Akjmrjn td APYI
v`m tgj AP\F Q@N = njpmrturj, fk`ogt pkmeejn rdutj, squmwb >69:.
=>>3 FMI6:63 njpmrts frdh AP\F.
=>:3 FMI6:63 jetjrs Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj mpprdx`hmtjky mt Y@IZE.
=>:: FMI6:63 fk`ogt arjw rjaj`vjs APYI =>:3 QSJA@ frdh adhpmey n`spmtagjr.
=>:6<:= FMI6:63 kjvjks mt FK1=3.
=>:7<:? Ijo`ee`eo df vmk`n nmtm de FNY
=:=3 FMI6:63 fk`ogt arjw rjaj`vjs APYI =:33 HJ^MY frdh adhpmey n`spmtagjr.
=:== Ld`et fk`ogt arjw men n`spmtagjr nja`s`de fdr fk`ogt td prdajjn td APYI
=:>7<9: FMI6:63 tures kjft frdh AI td ?9³ E, =33³>:' _.
=630<93 FMI6:63 fk`ogt arjw rjaj`vjs APYI =633 HJ^MY.
=6=3<>1 Ijo`ee`eo df AVY rjadrn`eo
=6=><:0 td=6=6<9>
S`kdts n`sauss kdmn`eo APYI YEMV 1:^ mpprdmag `etd OSQ fk`ogt pkmes, sjkjat`eoJQ^MS `e`t`mk mpprdmag f`x, men fky`eo n`rjat td HZQM^ wmypd`et.
=6=:<9> Amptm`e njsar`ijs g`s pkme td trmes`t`de detd tgj kdamk`zjr us`eo YEMV men tgje sw`tagdvjr td @KQ.
=6=:<9? FD adeaurs w`tg amptm`e‐s pkme.
=6=6<>: S`kdts sjkjat n`rjat td HZQM^ de OSQ2 FMI6:63 tures r`ogt td fky n`rjat td HZQM^.
=6=?<37 AVY ijo`es td rjadrn @YI NHJ Hdrsj adnj `njets, rjpjmtjn jvjry 19.1 sjadens.
=6=?<== Amptm`e adenuats mpprdmag ir`jf`eo.
=6=?<>= FD hmbjs adhhjet midut g`og orduen spjjn.
=6=?<>> Amptm`e stmtjs gj pkmes td adhhjeaj njsajet =3: h`kjs frdh APYI.
=6=7<>3 FD amkks APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk2 ndjs edt rjaj`vj m rjspdesj.
=699<=6 FD amkks tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA, rjqujsts njsajet akjmrmeaj, ndjs edtrjaj`vj m rjspdesj.
=699<>? FD amkks tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA, stmtjs rmn`d frjqujeay usjn, ndjs edtrjaj`vj m rjspdesj.
=691<=9 FD amkks tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA, stmtjs rmn`d frjqujeay usjn.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 170/215
- =69 -
=691<=? EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA rjspdens, estruats FMI6:63 td mnv`sj wgjerjqujst`eo njsajet.
=691<9= FD mnv`sjs tgj EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA tgmt FMI6:63 rjqujst`eo njsajet.
=691<90 EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA akjmrs FMI6:63 td njsajen dut df adetrdkkjn g`og-kjvjkm`rspmaj `e v`a`e`ty df APYI, `estruats arjw td rjpdrt tgrduog FK9?3.
=691<>3 Amptm`e adhhjeajs njsajet frdh FK1=3.
=691<>= FD rjmns imab njsajet akjmrmeaj men mabedwkjnojs estruat`de td rjpdrt tgrduog FK9?3.
=691<:= EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA mnv`sjs FMI6:63 df h`k`tmry mat`v`ty e tgj mrjm mentgmt tgjy ame met`a`pmtj sw`tag`eo td APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk mftjr kjmv`eo FK9?3.
=69><39 FD mabedwkjnojs mnv`sdry, stmtjs frjqujeay fdr APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk.
=69><== EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA adef`rhs tgmt frjqujeay fdr APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk `sadrrjat, mnv`sjs FMI6:63 tgmt APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk `s adetrdkk`eo m`rspmaj FK933 menijkdw, men tgmt m`rspmaj ijtwjje FK9?3 men FK933 `s ueadetrdkkjn.
=69><9? Amptm`e amkks fdr prj-njsajet agjab.
=69><1= FD hmbjs 9 ami`e ag`hjs.
=69><19 FD adhhjeajs prj-njsajet agjab.
=69> <1? Amptm`e ir`jfs iuos sjt fdr VYJF =19 bedts fdr fkmps >3.
=69><10 FD ir`jfs iuos sjt fdr VYJF =19 fdr fkmps >3, amkks adhpmss agmkkjeoj frdh agjabk`st.
=69><>9 Amptm`e rjspdens td adhpmss agmkkjeoj w`tg ‛Qyea hmo ardss-agjab.‘
=69><>1 FD pd`ets dut amptm`e stmtjn ‛hmo‘.
=69><>1 Amptm`e rjspdens w`tg ‛Qyea NO ardss-agjab,‘ stmtjs tgmt gj `s nd`eo m agjab mensgdws ‛twjety e`ej truj‘.
=69:<3= Amptm`e qujr`js FD ms td g`s rjmn`eo.
=69:<3> FD rjspdens w`tg ‛\jrd tgrjj zjrd.‘
=69:<3? Ed. 9 adhpmss mnlustjn.
=69:<=1 FD stmtjs ‛Qyea NO ardss-agjabjn.‘
=69:<=> FD amkks prj-njsajet adhpkjtj.
=696<31 FD amkks EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA, rjpdrts tgrduog FK963.
=696<== EMV AMEMNM Jnhdetde MAA mabedwkjnojs, estruats FMI6:63 td adetmat APYIh`k`tmry tjrh`emk.
=696<9? FD hmbjs `e`t`mk amkk td APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk.
=696<>9 APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk rjspdens td amkk, rjqujsts tgmt m`rarmft amkk`eo rjpjmttrmesh`ss`de.
=696<>6 FD rjpjmts amkk td APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk.
=69?<3= APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk rjspdens.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 171/215
- =61 -
=69?<30 FD amkks APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk, mnv`sjs tgmt rjajpt`de pddr men tgjy w`kk amkk akdsjr tdAPYI. Srdv`njs APYI J^M =6>1 men mnv`sjs pkmee`eo Yuewmy 1:.
=69?<1: APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk mabedwkjnojs trmesh`ss`de, `estruats FMI6:63 td try mom`e `e mfjw h`kjs wgje adhhue`amt`de w`kk ij ijttjr.
=697<>1 Amptm`e mnv`sjs FD tgmt tgjy mrj njsajen`eo tgrduog FK933.
=697<>0 Amptm`e stmtjs mkt`hjtjr sjtt`eo 90.7=.
=690<9= FD mnv`sjs APYI adhpmey imsj tgmt tgj`r J^M fdr tgj rmhp `s =6>: men tgmt tgjy w`kkejjn fujk.
=690<>0 FD amkks APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk.
=690<:? APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk rjspdens.
=613<39 FD qujr`js APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk ms td wgjtgjr tgjy rjaj`vjn FMI6:63 J^M menpkmeejn ruewmy.
=613<30 APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk mnv`sjs FMI6:63 tgmt tgjy rjaj`vjn tgj prjv`dus efdrhmt`demen tgmt h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk ue`t `s edt dpjrmt`demk men prdv`n`eo deky akjmrmeaj
njk`vjry.
=613<== APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk prdv`njs trmff`a `efdrhmt`de midut m sjaden fk`ogt :3 h`kjssdutgjmst df APYI mt =3 333 fjjt `eiduen td APYI.
=613<=: APYI h`k`tmry tjrh`emk `estruats FMI6:63 td adetmat APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr.
=613<1= FD mabedwkjnojs trmff`a men `estruat`de td adetmat APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr.
=613<:3 FD amkks APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr.
=613<:6 APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr rjspdens, prdv`njs mkt`hjtjr sjtt`eo 90.7=.
=61=<>: APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr `estruats FMI6:63 td rjpdrt f`emk fdr Yuewmy 1:^, mnv`sjs w`en
jst`hmtjn =63³ mt =3 bedts.
=61=<:1 FD rjqujsts APYI ruewmy aden`t`de rjpdrt frdh APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr.
=619<3= APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr mnv`sjs FMI6:63 tgmt tgj ruewmy `s m k`ttkj wjt, men ed dtgjrm`rarmft gmvj usjn `t nur`eo tgj hdre`eo.
=619<3? FD mabedwkjnojs ruewmy aden`t`de rjpdrt.
=619<1: FMI6:63 njsajens tgrduog =3 333 fjjt.
=619<>6 Amptm`e amkks fdr `e-rmeoj agjab.
=619<>7 FD vjrimk`zjs< sjmtijkt s`oes de, met`-`aj de, ormvjk prdtjat de, m`r aden`t`de`eo men
prjssur`zmt`de sjt fdr kmen`eo. =611<30 Amptm`e `estruats FD td gdkn tgj rjhm`e`eo tjhs de tgj agjabk`st.
=611<=> Dej df tgj p`kdts amkks tgrduog =3 333 fjjt.
=616<91 Amptm`e `estruats FD td adet`euj `e-rmeoj agjab ijkdw tgj k`ej.
=616<11 FD amkks EMV `estruhjets.
=616<1: Amptm`e rjspdens ‛VGF EMV.‘
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 172/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 173/215
- =6: -
=610<:9 Mkt`tunj mkjrtjr tdej mt =0:3 fjjt msk
=610<:? FD stmtjs tgjy mrj edt de mutd mpprdmag, lust de tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr.
=6>3<3> ^grust ijo`es td `earjmsj frdh `nkj td =.> JSY.
=6>3<3? FD qujr`js amptm`e td adef`rh fukk njfkjat`de.
=6>3<37 Amptm`e adeaurs, men qujst`des wgy fukk njfkjat`de wgje tgjy mrj de tgj kdamk`zjr.
=6>3<== FD stmtjs tgjy mrj edt de tgj kdamk`zjr.
=6>3<=> Amptm`e stmtjs ‛@t‐s ampturjn2 tje tgrjj `s tgj kdamk`zjr4‘
=6>3<=? FD n`smorjjs de kdamk`zjr ampturj men rjh`ens amptm`e midut tgj g`kk td tgj r`ogt df tgjruewmy.
=6>3<91 FD stmtjs OSQ `s mksd sgdw`eo td tgj r`ogt.
=6>3<9: FD qujst`des amptm`e ms td wgjtgjr tgjy n`n sdhjtg`eo wrdeo.
=6>3<13 FD stmtjs dp`e`de tgmt tgjy sgdukn mimende tgj mpprdmag men tgje sdkvj tgj
emv`omt`demk prdikjh.
=6>3<11 Amptm`e `en`amtjs tgmt gj pkmes td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag.
=6>3<1: FD mabedwkjnojs amptm`e‐s pkme td adet`euj tgj mpprdmag.
=6>3<16 FMI6:63 njsajens tgrduog =333 fjjt midvj f`jkn jkjvmt`de. Qtmi`k`zjn mpprdmag ar`tjr`mijadhj mppk`amikj.
=6>3<>= FD stmtjs, ‛_j‐rj 1 h`kj f`emk2 wj‐rj edt adef`oojn.‘
=6>3<>: Amptm`e amkks fdr fkmps 9:.
=6>3<>0 FD rjpdrts fukk njfkjat`de de tgj OSQ tdd.
=6>3<:9 FD rjadhhjens adrrjat`vj mat`de„od kjft. =6>3<:> Amptm`e `en`amtjs tgmt gj ame‐t od kjft.
=6>3<:: BIM030 jetjrs APYI Akmss N adetrdk zdej frdh sdutgjmst.
=6>3<:6 FD ijo`es td hmbj mnv`sdry stmtjhjet rjomrn`eo trmab.
=6>3<:? Amptm`e `etjrrupts FD stmtjhjet iy amkk`eo fdr fkmps 13.
=6>3<:0 td=6>=<37.1
Amptm`e men FD n`sauss adef`ourmt`de men n`spkmys df fk`ogt n`rjatdr, OSQ, menmutdp`kdt.
=6>=<3: ^grust ijo`es td `earjmsj frdh midut =.37 JSY td =.>? JSY.
=6>=<37.1 FD stmtjs ‛Qd kjt‐s lust …‘ =6>=<37.? Amptm`e `etjrrupts FD stmtjhjet iy amkk`eo fdr fkmps >3.
=6>=<=3.= FD amkks orjje k`ogt, ojmr ndwe, 1 orjje.
=6>=<==.9 Amptm`e amkks fkmps >3, orjje k`ogt.
=6>=<=6.1 Amptm`e hmbjs stmtjhjet `en`amt`eo s`h`kmr s`tumt`de gmppjejn td medtgjr p`kdtprjv`dusky.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 174/215
- =66 -
=6>=<=7 S`tag ijo`es td njarjmsj frdh +9³ td ∙>.7³.
=6>=<96.1 Amptm`e hmbjs stmtjhjet rjomrn`eo prjsjeaj df tgj ok`njskdpj en`amtdr.
=6>=<97.1 FD stmtjs ok`njskdpj s fukky njfkjatjn.
=6>=<13.7 FD mnv`sjs APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr tgmt FMI6:63 `s 1 f`emk.
=6>=<11.= APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr mnv`sjs tgmt w`en `s jst`hmtjn =:3³ mt ? bedts, akjmrs FMI6:63 tdkmen Yuewmy 1:^.
=6>=<10.> FD hmbjs `eadhpkjtj trmesh`ss`de td APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr.
=6>=<>=.= FD stmtjs ‛Lust dvjr tgj sgdrjk`ej.‘
=6>=<>1.9 FD uttjrs jxpkjt`vj.
=6>=<>6 S`tag ijo`es td `earjmsj frdh ∙:³.
=6>=<>6.6 FD amkks amptm`e iy f`rst emhj, stmtjs ‛@ nde‐t k`bj tg`s.‘
=6>=<>?.= APYI h`k`tmry tdwjr rjqujsts tgmt FMI6:63 rjpjmt kmst trmesh`ss`de.
=6>=<>?.? OS_Q< ‛Q`eb rmtj‘
=6>=<>0.3 FD stmtjs ‛Od fdr `t.‘
=6>=<>0.9 OS_Q< ‛H`e`huhs‘
=6>=<:3.= FD stmtjs ‛Od mrduen.‘
=6>=<:3.? OS_Q< ‛H`e`huhs‘
=6>=<:=.9 Amptm`e amkks ‛Od-mrduen tgrust.‘
=6>=<:=.7 FMI6:63 adkk`njs w`tg tjrrm`e.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 175/215
- =6? -
Mppjen`x I ‑ Mpprdmag prdajnurj agmrt fdr `estruhjet mpprdmag imsjn demrjm emv`omt`de us`eo okdimk emv`omt`de smtjkk`tj mt Yuewmy 1: ^YZJ
ED^ FDY EMV@OM^@DE
Frdh EMV AMEMNM, Amemnm M`r S`kdt (AMS), AMS =< Pubde, Edrtgwjst jrr`tdr`js men Euemvut(jffjat`vj 13 Luej 93==)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 176/215
- =67 -
Mppjen`x A ‑ Mpprdmag prdajnurj agmrt fdr estruhjet kmen`eo systjh w`tgn`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet mt Yuewmy 1: ^YZJ
ED^ FDY EMV@OM^@DE
Frdh EMV AMEMNM, Amemnm M`r S`kdt (AMS), AMS =< Pubde, Edrtgwjst jrr`tdr`js men Euemvut(jffjat`vj 13 Luej 93==)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 177/215
- =60 -
Mppjen`x N ‑ Mpprdmag pmtg df FMI6:63
(Skjmsj rjfjr td Mppjen`x W ‑ K`st df mardeyhs men miirjv`mt`des.)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 178/215
- =?3 -
Mppjen`x J ‑ A-OE_E adhpmss systjhs< mnn`t`demk `efdrhmt`de
Adhpmss trmesfjr sw`tag
@e tgj jvjet df m adhpmss fm`kurj, usj df tgj adhpmss trmesfjr sw`tag jemikjs tgj rjhm`e`eoadhpmss td prdv`nj gjmn`eo efdrhmt`de td idtg p`kdt‐s estruhjets. g`s sw`tag s kdamtjn de
tgj amptm`e‐s s`nj df tgj dvjrgjmn pmejk, mnlmajet td tgj VGF EMV (vjry g`og frjqujeayemv`omt`de) sjkjatdr sw`tag.
A-OE_E adhpmss systjh gjmn`eo n`str`iut`de
_`tg tgj adhpmss trmesfjr sw`tag `e tgj EDYHMK pds`t`de, gjmn`eo `efdrhmt`de n`str`iut`de `sms fdkkdws<
• Gjmn`eo efdrhmt`de frdh ed. = n`rjat`demk oyrd (NO) s n`spkmyjn de tgj amptm`e‐srmn`d-hmoejt`a en`amtdr (YH@), wg`ag tgje rjpjmts tg`s efdrhmt`de td tgj f`rst dff`ajr‐s(FD‐s) gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de `en`amtdr (GQ@) men td tgj VGF emv`omt`de systjh. ^gj`efdrhmt`de suppk`jn iy ed. = NO tgrduog tgj amptm`e‐s YH@ adetrdks tgj FD‐s GQ@gjmn`eo n`spkmy men tgj ‛sjt adursj‘ men ‛sjt gjmn`eo‘ s`oemks. ^gj sjt-adursj men sjt-gjmn`eo s`oemks mrj tgje fjn td tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr‐s stjjr`eo adhputjr 9.
• Gjmn`eo `efdrhmt`de frdh ed. 9 NO `s n`spkmyjn de tgj FD‐s YH@, wg`ag tgje rjpjmtstg`s efdrhmt`de td tgj amptm`e‐s GQ@ men td tgj fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjr. gj `efdrhmt`desuppk`jn tgrduog ed. 9 NO tgrduog tgj FD‐s YH@ adetrdks tgj n`spkmy de tgj amptm`e‐sGQ@ gjmn`eo n`spkmy, men `s mksd usjn iy tgj amptm`e‐s GQ@ fdr tgj sjt-adursj men sjt-gjmn`eo s`oemks. ^gj sjt-adursj men sjt-gjmn`eo s`oemks mrj tgje fjn td tgj mutdp`kdt mentd tgj fk`ogt n`rjatdr‐s stjjr`eo adhputjr =.
Fkux vmkvj men adhpmss adetrdkkjr
Fkux vmkvjs sjesj tgj n`rjat`de df tgj jmrtg‐s hmoejt`a f`jkn. _`tg tgj adhpmss adetrdkkjr(F`ourj 93) HMO/NO sw`tag `e tgj HMO (hmoejt`a) pds`t`de, tgj fkux vmkvjs mrj usjn td mk`oe
=?> Yjprdnuajn frdh< F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk Vdkuhj 9, Mhjenhjet ed. 1 (3= Hmrag 933>),Fk`ogt @estruhjets< Adetrdks men @en`amtdrs, pmoj 1>.=3.7
F`ourj 93. Jxjhpkmr adhpmss adetrdkkjr =?>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 179/215
- =?= -
tgj NO dutput w`tg hmoejt`a edrtg men prdv`nj m stmikj hmoejt`a adhpmss systjh. @e tg`shdnj, tgj adhpmss systjh adhpjesmtjs fdr rjmk men mppmrjet oyrd prjajss`de.Gdwjvjr, e tgj v`a`e`ty df tgj jmrtg‐s hmoejt`a pdkjs, hmoejt`a adhpmss systjhs mrjsusajpt`ikj td jrrdr men mrj edt su`tmikj fdr emv`omt`de. _gje dpjrmt`eo e tgjsj mrjms dfadhpmss uerjk`mi`k`ty, mktjremtj hjtgdns df emv`omt`de hust ij usjn. gjsj hjtgdns eakunjdpjrmt`eo tgj m`rarmft‐s NOs `e m frjj oyrd hdnj w`tg rjfjrjeaj td truj rmtgjr tgme hmoejt`a
edrtg.
_`tg tgj HMO/NO sw`tag `e tgj NO pds`t`de, tgj fkux vmkvj `eput `s rjhdvjn frdh tgj A-==Iadhpmss systjh. ^gj NO gjmn`eo dutput `s ed kdeojr skmvjn td hmoejt`a edrtg, men tgjadhpmss systjh rjvjrts td m frjj oyrd. @e frjj oyrd hdnj, tgj systjh `s suiljat td tgj rjmk menmppmrjet prjajss`de df tgj NO.
^gj adhpmss adetrdkkjr eakunjs me mnlustmikj kmt`tunj adhpjesmtdr. d ejutrmk`zj jmrtg rmtjprjajss`de, p`kdts hust sjt tgj adrrjat kmt`tunj de tg`s adhpjesmtdr ms tgj fk`ogt prdorjssjs. gjadhpmss adetrdkkjr mksd gms m kmt`tunj trmesfjr sw`tag td mnlust njpjenjet de wgjtgjr tgjm`rarmft s fky`eo e tgj edrtgjre dr sdutgjre gjh`spgjrj.
@estruhjet adhpmrmtdr
Me estruhjet wmre`eo systjh s estmkkjn wg`ag adhpmrjs tgj amptm`e‐s men FD‐s adhpmssgjmn`eos, p`tag men rdkk mtt`tunj en`amt`des, men kdamk`zjr men ok`njskdpj njv`mt`de dutputsfrdh tgj ed. = men ed. 9 VGF EMV ue`ts. Me estruhjet adhpmrmtdr meeuea`mtdr (Sgdtd 6) skdamtjn midvj jmag p`kdt‐s estruhjet n`spkmy.
Fdr gjmn`eo `efdrhmt`de, tgj adhpmrmtdr w`kk `kkuh`emtj mhijr k`ogts de idtg meeuea`mtdrswgje tgj n`ffjrjeaj ijtwjje tgj ed. = men ed. 9 adhpmssjs jxajjns tgj fdkkdw`eo tdkjrmeajs<
• _`eos kjvjk 6³ ½ 9³
• 93³ imeb =3³ ½ 9.:³
• Ok`njskdpj ampturjn >.:³ ½ =³
Sgdtd 6. A-OE_E amptm`e‐s estruhjet adhpmrmtdr
Ymn`d-hmoejt`a `en`amtdr
^gj uppjr r`ogt bedi de jmag YH@ s tgj adhpmss syeagrde`z`eo adetrdk, wg`ag pjrh`ts tgjp`kdt td syeagrde`zj tgj YH@ w`tg tgj mppk`amikj adhpmss systjh (F`ourj 9=).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 180/215
- =?9 -
F`ourj 9=. Jxjhpkmr rmn`d-hmoejt`a en`amtdr(YH@)
=< Qyeagrde`z`eo meeuea`mtdr9< MNF/VDY ijmr`eo pd`etjrs
1< MNF/VDY ijmr`eo pd`etjr sw`tagjs>< Qyeagrde`z`eo adetrdk =< NHJ h`kjs w`endw9< Kuiijr k`ej1< Gjmn`eo hmrbjr (iuo)>< Ok`njskdpj pd`etjr men samkj:< GQ@ gjmn`eo sjkjatdr6< Adursj aduetjr?< Adursj pd`etjr7< Adursj njv`mt`de imr0< M`rarmft syhidk=3< GQ@ adursj sjkjatdr
Gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de `en`amtdr^gj GQ@ n`spkmys m`rarmft pds`t`de men gjmn`eo w`tg rjspjat td hmoejt`a dr truj edrtg, sjkjatjngjmn`eo, NHJ (n`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjet), kmtjrmk njv`mt`de td dr frdh m sjkjatjn VDY(VGF dhe`n`rjat`demk rmeoj) dr kdamk`zjr adursj, men vjrt`amk njv`mt`de frdh tgj ajetrj df mok`njskdpj ijmh (F`ourj 99).
^gj f`xjn m`rarmft syhidk n`spkmys m`rarmft pds`t`de men gjmn`eo e rjkmt`de td tgj mz`hutgamrn, adursj njv`mt`de imr, men sjkjatjn gjmn`eo. gj rdtmt`eo mz`hutg amrn n`spkmysgjmn`eo efdrhmt`de frdh tgj adhpmss systjh. M`rarmft gjmn`eo s rjmn de tgj amrn ijejmtg tgjkuiijr k`ej mt tgj tdp ajetrj df tgj `estruhjet.
^gj gjmn`eo iuo `s sjt td tgj njs`rjn gjmn`eo de tgj mz`hutg amrn. Deaj sjt, tgj gjmn`eo iuordtmtjs w`tg tgj mz`hutg amrn. ^gj adursj pd`etjr `s sjt td tgj njs`rjn VDY rmn`mk dr kdamk`zjradursj de tgj mz`hutg amrn. Deaj sjt, tgj adursj pd`etjr rdtmtjs w`tg tgj mz`hutg amrn.
^gj adursj njv`mt`de imr rjprjsjets tgj ajetrj df tgj sjkjatjn VDY dr kdamk`zjr adursj, menn`spkmys adursj njv`mt`de. gj adursj njv`mt`de imr s rjmn w`tg rjspjat td tgj m`rarmft rjfjrjeajsyhidk, prdv`n`eo tgj p`kdt w`tg efdrhmt`de rjomrn`eo kmtjrmk njv`mt`de frdh tgj sjkjatjnadursj men wg`ag n`rjat`de td ture fdr adrrjat`des td adursj njv`mt`des.
F`ourj 99. Jxjhpkmr gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de`en`amtdr (GQ@)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 181/215
- =?1 -
_gje tgj emv`omt`de rjaj`vjr s tuejn td m kdamk`zjr frjqujeay, e`t`mk hdvjhjet df tgj adursjnjv`mt`de imr ijo`es mt meoukmr njv`mt`des frdh 9.>³ td >.3³ frdh tgj ajetrj df tgj kdamk`zjradursj, njpjen`eo de ijmh w`ntg fdr m pmrt`aukmr estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ) `estmkkmt`de.^gj 9-ndt k`ejmr pdrt`de df tgj adursj njv`mt`de samkj rjprjsjets 9.:³ meoukmr njv`mt`de,njpjen`eo de tgj pmrt`aukmr @KQ estmkkmt`de. =?:
=?: Ydabwjkk @etjremt`demk, FN-==3 Fk`ogt N`rjatdr Qystjh S`kdt‐s Ou`nj (=0?7)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 182/215
- =?> -
Mppjen`x F ‑ A-OE_E mutdp`kdt systjh< mnn`t`demk `efdrhmt`de
Mutdp`kdt hdnj adetrdk pmejk
^gj mutdp`kdt gms 9 agmeejks< = p`tag agmeejk men = rdkk agmeejk. gj p`tag men rdkk fueat`des mrjsjpmrmtj men mrj gdusjn e sjpmrmtj memkdo jkjatrde`a idxjs e tgj jkjatrde`as imy.
Mutdp`kdt jeomoj sw`tagjs
^gj mutdp`kdt hdnj adetrdk pmejk (MS HAS) gms 9 jeomoj pmnnkj sw`tagjs< = fdr tgj rdkkagmeejk men = fdr tgj p`tag agmeejk (Sgdtd ?). Jmag pmnnkj sw`tag `s spr`eo-kdmnjn td tgjn`sjeomoj pds`t`de, men s sdkjed`n-gjkn e tgj jeomojn pds`t`de wgje ajrtm`e aden`t`des mrjhjt. gj p`tag men rdkk agmeejks hmy ij dpjrmtjn enjpjenjetky df dej medtgjr. gj njfmuktjeomoj stmtj `s hmeumk A_Q (adetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eo) hdnj fdr idtg p`tag men rdkk. ^gj m`rarmftw`kk hm`etm`e tgj p`tag mtt`tunj mt tgj t`hj df jeomojhjet. Mutdhmt`a stmi`k`zjr tr`h, wg`ag s mfueat`de df tgj p`tag agmeejk, adhpjesmtjs fdr agmeojs e m`rarmft tr`h.
Sgdtd ?. Mutdp`kdt hdnj adetrdk pmejk (MS HAS)
Mutdp`kdt p`tag hdnj sjkjatdr
^gj mutdp`kdt p`tag hdnj sjkjatdr `s m rdtmry sw`tag kdamtjn de tgj r`ogt s`nj df tgj MS HAS,w`tg 1 pds`t`des< ^ZYI, DFF, men MK^ GDKN. ^gj sw`tag `s spr`eo-kdmnjn td tgj DFF pds`t`de,men s sdkjed`n-gjkn e tgj dtgjr pds`t`des f systjh etjrkdabs mrj hm`etm`ejn. Jmag df tgj p`tagsuihdnjs s njsar`ijn ijkdw.
• DFF ∙ dpjrmtjs e hmeumk p`tag A_Q.
• ^ZYI ∙ fdr usj `e turiukjet aden`t`des td rjnuaj oust kdmns.
• MK^ GDKN ∙ hm`etm`es tgj prjssurj mkt`tunj de tgj amptm`e‐s mkt`hjtjr mt tgj t`hj tg`shdnj `s sjkjatjn.
Mutdp`kdt hdnj sjkjatdr
^gj mutdp`kdt hdnj sjkjatdr `s m rdtmry sw`tag kdamtjn de tgj kjft s`nj df tgj MS HAS, w`tg >pds`t`des< HME, VDY/KDA, MZ^D MSS men HME O/Q. ^gj sw`tag `s spr`eo-kdmnjn td tgjHME pds`t`de men s sdkjed`n-gjkn e tgj 1 dtgjr pds`t`des f systjh etjrkdabs mrj hm`etm`ejn._gje tgj rdkk agmeejk agmeojs hdnj frdh tgjsj 1 pds`t`des, tgj sw`tag w`kk mutdhmt`amkky
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 183/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 184/215
- =?6 -
Adetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eo
^gj m`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumk (MDH) Vdkuhj 9 njsar`ijs A_Q ms fdkkdws< =?6
A_Q dpjrmtjs `e kdw dr g`og njtjet kjvjk, njpjen`eo de wg`ag hdnjs drsuihdnjs mrj mat`vj<
HME HdnjA_Q p`tag men rdkk mrj kdw njtjet uekjss vmr`dus suihdnjs mrj mat`vj (sjjijkdw)
VDY/KDA HdnjA_Q p`tag men rdkk mrj kdw njtjet uet`k VDY dr kdamk`zjr DE ADZYQJ. A_Q rdkktgje ijadhjs g`og njtjet, men A_Q p`tag rjhm`es kdw njtjet uekjss MK^ GDKN`s mat`vj. A_Q rdkk hmy ij usjn td dvjrr`nj nur`eo tgj ampturj pgmsj uet`k DEADZYQJ. Jxajjn`eo g`og njtjet `e rdkk rjvjrts tgj mutdp`kdt td HME.R…X
MK^ GDKN QuihdnjA_Q p`tag s g`og njtjet. Jxajjn`eo g`og njtjet w`kk rjvjrt tgj S`tag HdnjQjkjatdr Qw`tag td DFF.
GNO GDKN/GNO DFF QuihdnjsA_Q rdkk `s kdw njtjet.
GNO QJK QuihdnjA_Q rdkk s g`og njtjet. Jxajjn`eo g`og njtjet amusjs tgj gjmn`eo sw`tag tdhdvj td tgj ajetjr (GJMN@EO GDKN) pds`t`de.
=?6 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk Vdkuhj 9, Mhjenhjet ed. 1 (3= Hmrag 933>), Adetrdk _gjjkQtjjr`eo (A_Q), pmojs 99.93.? td 99.93.7
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 185/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 186/215
- =?7 -
Mppjen`x G ‑ FN-=37 fk`ogt n`rjatdr systjh< mnn`t`demk `efdrhmt`de
Fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk pmejk
^gjrj wjrj 9 fk`ogt n`rjatdr (FN) hdnj adetrdk pmejks (HASs) estmkkjn de tgj okmrjsg`jkn< dejfdr tgj amptm`e‐s FN systjh men tgj dtgjr fdr tgj FD‐s FN systjh. Jmag FN HAS adetm`es
adetrdks fdr tgj rdkk agmeejk men tgj p`tag agmeejk v`m m HDNJ QJK (hdnj sjkjat`de) sw`tag,MK^ GDKN (mkt`tunj gdkn) sw`tag, men S@^AG AHN (p`tag adhhmen) bedi (Sgdtd 7). ^gj rdkkmen p`tag adetrdks sjkjat tgj s`oemks prdv`njn td tgj adhhmen imrs e tgj mtt`tunj n`rjatdr`en`amtdr (MN@).
Sgdtd 7. Fk`ogt N`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk pmejk
Fk`ogt n`rjatdr hdnj adetrdk ∙ rdkk
^gj adhhmen imrs e tgj MN@ n`spkmy tgj adhputjn adhhmens td hm`etm`e tgj sjkjatjn rdkkmeokj. ^gj FN rdkk HDNJ QJK sw`tag gms tgj fdkkdw`eo pds`t`des men dpjrmt`eo k`h`tmt`des<
• OM (od mrduen) prdv`njs w`eos-kjvjk rdkk adhhmen w`tg =>³ p`tag adhhmen uet`kmedtgjr hdnj s sjkjatjn.
• DFF rjhdvjs tgj adhhmen imrs frdh MN@.
• GNO prdv`njs adhhmen imr ou`nmeaj td fky tgj sjkjatjn gjmn`eo de tgj GQ@. @e GNOhdnj, tgj stjjr`eo adhhmen `s k`h`tjn td 13³ `e rdkk men =9³ `e p`tag.
• VDY/KDA `s usjn td ampturj men trmab m VDY rmn`mk dr kdamk`zjr. VDY/KDA gms 1suihdnjs<
• @etjrajpt ‑ Mhijr MSN (mpprdmag prdorjss n`spkmy) VDY/KDA k`ogt `kkuh`emtjn,adhhmen imrs prdv`nj ou`nmeaj td fky td men hm`etm`e tgj sjkjatjn gjmn`eo de tgjGQ@.
• Ampturj ‑ Orjje MSN VDY/KDA k`ogt `kkuh`emtjn, adhhmen imrs prdv`njou`nmeaj td fky td men hm`etm`e tgj VDY rmn`mk dr kdamk`zjr adursj sjkjatjn de tgjGQ@. g`s ou`nmeaj s n`spkmyjn e tgj fdrh df adhhmenjn imeb meokjs. gjadhhmen imrs rjture td w`eos-kjvjk deaj tgj FN njtjrh`ejs tgj rjsuktmet gjmn`eoprdv`njs m suff`a`jet etjrajpt meokj td tgj sjkjatjn adursj. Fdr kdamk`zjr, tg`s hdnjagmeoj daaurs mt 9.:³ frdh kdamk`zjr ajetrjk`ej. Imeb meokj adhhmen k`h`t s ½13³.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 187/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 188/215
- =73 -
• OD MYDZEN
• @kkuh`emtjs orjje wgje OM hdnj s sjkjatjn.
Mutdp`kdt hdnjs mrj meeuea`mtjn de tgj r`ogt s`nj df tgj MSN. De tgj maa`njet m`rarmft, tgjfdkkdw`eo MSN meeuea`mtdrs wjrj mppk`amikj td tgj mutdp`kdt<
• VDY/KDA
• @kkuh`emtjs mhijr wgje VDY/KDA dr MZ^D MSS sjkjatjn de tgj HAS men VDY drKDA edt ampturjn
• @kkuh`emtjs orjje wgje VDY/KDA dr MZ^D MSS sjkjatjn de tgj HAS men VDY drKDA s`oemk s ampturjn (kjss tgme 9 ndts)
• OK@NJ QKDSJ
• @kkuh`emtjs mhijr wgje MZ^D MSS hdnj s sjkjatjn de tgj HAS men ok`njskdpjedt ampturjn
• @kkuh`emtjs orjje wgje MZ^D MSS hdnj `s sjkjatjn de tgj HAS men ok`njskdpj
s`oemk s ampturjn (kjss tgme 9 ndts)
• @kkuh`emtjs orjje `f HME O/Q sjkjatjn de tgj HAS
• @f kkuh`emtjn orjje, agmeojs td mhijr f tgj m`rarmft kdamk`zjr njv`mt`de jxajjns 9ndts
• OSQ
• @kkuh`emtjs orjje wgje idtg HN->= meeuea`mtdr adetrdk ue`t ed. = s sjkjatjn td OSQmen tgj OSQ mutdp`kdt sjkjat sw`tag `s sjt td M/S DE OSQ
• Jxt`eou`sgjs f j`tgjr df tgjsj sw`tagjs s njsjkjatjn
F`ourj 9>. Jxjhpkmr mpprdmag prdorjssn`spkmy (MSN)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 189/215
- =7= -
Mppjen`x @ ∙ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =691 td =611
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 190/215
- =79 -
Mppjen`x L ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =616 td =617
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 191/215
- =71 -
Mppjen`x B ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =617 td =6>3
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 192/215
- =7> -
Mppjen`x K ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =6>3 td =6>=
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 193/215
- =7: -
Mppjen`x H ‑ Qjqujeaj df jvjets< =6>= td =6>=<>:
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 194/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 195/215
- =7? -
Mppjen`x D ‑ Mkt`tunj men ok`nj pmtg
ED^J< O`vje tgmt tgj m`rarmft kjft tgj kdamk`zjr ijmh, tgj rjsukts ditm`ejn frdh tgj ok`njskdpjamkaukmt`de mrj hmtgjhmt`amk, wjrj usjn fdr kkustrmt`vj purpdsjs deky, men hmy edt ij wgmt tgjm`rarmft estruhjets wdukn gmvj sgdwe (ms tgj m`rarmft hmy edt gmvj ijje w`tg`e rjaj`v`eormeoj df tgj metjeem‐s s`oemk).
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 196/215
- =77 -
Mppjen`x S ‑ Fk`ogt pmtg men kdamk`zjr
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 197/215
- =70 -
Mppjen`x ] ‑ F`rst M`r prdajnurjs fdr mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de `e HME hdnj
F`rst M`r prdajnurjs fdr mutdp`kdt dpjrmt`de e HME hdnj mrj ms fdkkdws e tgj fk`ogtdpjrmt`des hmeumk< =?7
^d Hmejuvjr `e S`tag men Ydkk
Zsj A_Q mt m fdraj orjmtjr tgme kdw njtjet kjvjk. _gje A_Q p`tag fdraj `srjkmxjn ijkdw kdw njtjet kjvjk, m`rpkmej w`kk hm`etm`e jx`st`eo p`tag mtt`tunj._gje A_Q rdkk fdraj `s rjkmxjn ijkdw kdw njtjet kjvjk, `f imeb meokj kjss tgme :³,m`rpkmej w`kk rdkk w`eos kjvjk men hm`etm`e gjmn`eo. @f imeb meokj orjmtjr tgme :³,m`rpkmej w`kk hm`etm`e imeb meokj.
^d Hm`etm`e Imeb Meokjs Kjss tgme :³ Mutdp`kdt Gjmn`eo Qw`tag .............................................................................. GNO DFF
_gje A_Q rdkk fdraj `s rjkmxjn ijkdw kdw njtjet kjvjk, tgj m`rpkmej hm`etm`es
tgj jx`st`eo imeb meokj. Yjture tgj Mutdp`kdt Gjmn`eo Qw`tag td ajetjr tdrjhdvj tg`s suihdnj.
^d Hmejuvjr `e Ydkk men Gdkn Mkt`tunjS`tag Hdnj Qjkjatdr ...................................................................................... MK^ GDKN
Zsj A_Q td `enuaj rdkk mt kdw njtjet kjvjk fdraj. Mkt`tunj s hm`etm`ejn iy eputfrdh tgj m`r nmtm adhputjr mt tgj t`hj S`tag Hdnj Qjkjatdr `s pds`t`dejn td MK^GDKN pds`t`de. A_Q p`tag `eput orjmtjr tgme g`og njtjet kjvjk w`kk tr`p S`tagHdnj Qjkjatdr td DFF.
^d Hmejuvjr @e S`tag men Gdkn Gjmn`eoMutdp`kdt Gjmn`eo Qw`tag .............................................................................. GNO QJK
Zsj A_Q td adetrdk p`tag mtt`tunj mt kdw njtjet kjvjk. ^gj m`rpkmej tures td menhm`etm`es tgj gjmn`eo sjkjatjn de GQ@ w`tg tgj Mutdp`kdt Gjmn`eo Qw`tag `eGNO QJK. A_Q rdkk `eput orjmtjr tgme g`og njtjet kjvjk tr`ps tgj Mutdp`kdtGjmn`eo Qw`tag td tgj ajetrj pds`t`de.
=?7 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), MZ^DS@KD^
DSJYM^@DEQ, pmoj 3>.13.>
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 198/215
- =03 -
Mppjen`x Y ‑ @estruhjet kmen`eo systjh `etjrajpt fdr mutdp`kdt VDY/KDAhdnj
(Skjmsj rjfjr td Mppjen`x W ‑ K`st df mardeyhs men miirjv`mt`des.)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 199/215
- =0= -
Mppjen`x Q ‑ @estruhjet kmen`eo systjh `etjrajpt fdr fk`ogt n`rjatdr `e MZ^D MSS
(Skjmsj rjfjr td Mppjen`x W ‑ K`st df mardeyhs men miirjv`mt`des.)
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 200/215
- =09 -
Mppjen`x ^ ‑ F`rst M`r adhpmss dpjrmt`eo pdk`ay men prdajnurjs fdrEdrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj
Sdk`ay fdr dpjrmt`des `e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj
F`rst M`r‐s pdk`ay fdr Edrtgjre Ndhjst a M`rspmaj (ENM) dpjrmt`des s stmtjn ms fdkkdws e tgjfk`ogt dpjrmt`des hmeumk< =?0
Emv`omt`de e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj< Ydutjs men mpprdmag prdajnurjsadenuatjn e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj mrj puik`sgjn njorjjs truj.Arjws hust emv`omtj e maadrnmeaj w`tg tgj rjoukmt`des men dpjrmt`eoprdajnurjs dutk`ejn `e tg`s hmeumk.
Arjws w`kk njet`fy tgj`r trmabs ms ‛truj‘ wgje irdmnamst`eo rjqu`rjn HFRhmenmtdry frjqujeayX rjpdrts e ueadetrdkkjn m`rspmaj.
Ij mwmrj tgmt dtgjr m`rarmft hmy dr hmy edt ij mngjr`eo td tgj rjqu`rjndpjrmt`eo prmat`aj.
Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des rjqu`rj m`rarmft dpjrmt`eo e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`aM`rspmaj td ij jqu`ppjn w`tg m hjmes df jstmik`sg`eo n`rjat`de tgmt s edtnjpjenmet de m hmoejt`a sduraj. Jvje tgduog F`rst M`r M`rarmft mrj jqu`ppjnw`tg OSQ, tg`s mkdej s edt ampmikj df jstmik`sg`eo n`rjat`de.
^gjrj mrj deky 9 rjk`mikj hjmes df jstmik`sg`eo n`rjat`de. gjsj mrj<
=. Zsj df OSQ e adhi`emt de w`tg me MNF/ENI ijmr`eo2 dr, wgjrj tg`s `s edt
pdss`ikj2 men
9. Zsj df me Mstrd Adhpmss men M`r Mkhmema td ditm`e m sue/stmr sgdt.
Edtj< Zsj df tgj Mstrd Adhpmss /M`r Mkhmema sgdukn deky ij ejajssmry wgje`e me mrjm w`tgdut suff`a`jet ENI advjrmoj dr wgje idtg OSQ (dej `e GQ?>7)mrj uesjrv`ajmikj.
Srdajnurjs fdr ditm`e`eo truj gjmn`eo us`eo OSQ men ede-n`rjat`demk ijmade
^gj m`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumk prdv`njs spja`f`a prdajnurmk ou`nmeaj td I?1? arjws fdrdpjrmt`de df tgj adhpmss men emv`omt`demk systjhs. gj hmeumk mnv`sjs, ‛_gje dpjrmt`eo e^YZJ t s rjadhhjenjn tgmt vjr`f`amt`de df YZJ gjmn`eo ij maadhpk`sgjn dvjr jmagwmypd`et, ijfdrj njsajet, men wgjejvjr vjr`f`amt`de s ades`njrjn mpprdpr`mtj,‘ =73 men
=?0 F`rst M`r Fk`ogt Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk (FDH), Mhjenhjet ed. 9 (== Hmy 93==), sjat`de 9.99.9< Dpjrmt`des`e Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmaj (ENM), pmoj 9-:1
=73 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), GJMN@EO AGJABQ,pmoj 3>.=97.9
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 201/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 202/215
- =0> -
Mppjen`x Z ‑ F`rst M`r mhpk`f`jn agjabk`st prdajnurjs
Mhpk`f`jn prj-njsajet agjabk`st
^gj mhpk`f`jn prj-njsajet agjabk`st prdv`njn e F`rst M`r‐s m`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumk (MDH) sms fdkkdws< =71
Kmen`eo Nmtm & Ir`jf`eo ......................... YJV@J_JN, IZOQ QJ^ SF/SEF
* Adhpkjtj tgj kmen`eo nmtm amrn, adenuat arjw men mpprdmag pkmtjir`jf`eos men sjt mkk iuos fdr kmen`eo.
JSY & @MQ Iuos .....................................AGJABJN & QJ^ VYJFTTT SF/SEF
* Vjr`fy tgj m`rspjjn `enjx hmrbjrs men tgj JSY aursdrs mrj sjt td tgjkmen`eo nmtm amrn vmkujs.
Adhpmssjs ..............................QPEA, HMO/NO & W AGJABJN SF/SEF
* Vjr`fy mkk adhpmss systjhs gmvj ijje agjabjn, mrj syeagrde`zjn men
gmvj ijje ardss-agjabjn. Vjr`fy tgmt adhpmss systjhs mrj e HMO.(Hmoejt`a dr Qkmvjn Sds`t`de) dr NO (frjj Oyrd).
ED^J< =3,333 fjjt - Kmen`eo/^uredff k`ogts De.
Nur`eo Nmyk`ogt dpjrmt`des, tgj Yuewmy ^uredff men @eidmrnKmen`eo k`ogts sgdukn ij de puksj hdnj.
Zsj df dutidmrn kmen`eo k`ogts mrj mt tgj Amptm`e‐s n`sarjt`de. Nuj tdtgj `earjmsjn nrmo men fujk iure, tgj`r usj sgdukn ij k`h`tjn td tgjtrmff`a pmttjre mt e`ogt men/dr td spjjns ijkdw 9:3 bedts.
Nur`eo e`ogt dr disaurjn wjmtgjr dpjrmt`des, ^uredff, @eidmrn menDutidmrn Kmen`eo K`ogts sgdukn ij usjn fdr kmen`eo. ^gj @eidmrnmen Dutidmrn Kmen`eo K`ogts sgdukn ij turejn de ed kmtjr tgme tgjFMF.
Mhpk`f`jn `e-rmeoj agjabk`st
@tjhs midvj tgj nmsgjn k`ej mrj edrhmkky maadhpk`sgjn njsajen`eo tgrduog =3 333 fjjt, men`tjhs ijkdw tgj nmsgjn k`ej mrj maadhpk`sgjn mftjr emv`omt`demk m`ns men fk`ogt n`rjatdrs gmvjijje sjt up, ms ir`jfjn, fdr tgj `etjenjn mpprdmag.
^gj mhpk`f`jn e-rmeoj agjabk`st prdv`njn e tgj MDH s ms fdkkdws< =7>
=71 Yjprdnuajn frdh< F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==),MHSK@F@JN SYJ NJQAJE^ AGJABK@Q^, pmoj 31.?3.?
=7> @i`n., MHSK@F@JN @E YMEOJ AGJABK@Q^, pmoj 31.?3.7
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 203/215
- =0: -
Qjmt Ijkt ...............................................................................................DE SEF
Met`-@aj (ms rjqu`rjn) ..............................................................DE/DFF SEF
Ormvjk Srdtjat Qw`tag.........................................................................DE SEF
M`r Aden & Srjssur`zmt`de ............................….QJ^ FDY KMEN@EO SEF
* Agjab ami`e tjhpjrmturj edrhmk. @f kmen`eo m`rpdrt tjhpjrmturj sg`ogjr dr kdwjr tgme edrhmk, ami`e sgdukn ij prj-aden`t`dejn denjsajet td hm`etm`e mpprdpr`mtj ami`e tjhpjrmturjs de tgj orduen.
Agjab tgmt tgj DFF QAGJN NJQAJE^ meeuea`mtdr `s jxt`eou`sgjn.
Agjab tgmt tgj ami`e s njsajen`eo td tgj mrr`vmk m`rpdrt jkjvmt`de.
♦ MSZ.......................................................................................... Q^MY^
* @f rjqu`rjn, stmrt MSZ. Adef`ourj tgj prjssur`zmt`de systjh fdrJeo`ej Ikjjns DFF fdr kmen`eo<
Y`ogt Smab Qw`tag............................................................... DE @sdkmt`de Vmkvj ...........................................................AKDQJN Kjft Smab Qw`tag .............................................................….DE Euhijr = Jeo`ej Ikjjn Qw`tag........................................DFF MSZ Ikjjn Qw`tag (63 sjadens mftjr MSZ stmrt) ............ DE Euhijr 9 Jeo`ej Ikjjn Qw`tag........................................ DFF
---------------------------------------------------------
Emv Qw`tagjs ............................................................ VGF/FHQ EMV SF/SEF
Mkt`hjtjrs @estruhjets & Ymn`ds ..... " TTT " QJ^ & AYDQQ-AGJABJN SF/SEF
* Vjr`fy tgj mkt`hjtjr aursdrs men imrdhjtr`a adrrjat`des mrj sjt mt tgj
adrrjat sjtt`eos, men tgj mkt`hjtjrs ardss-agjab.
Mhpk`f`jn kmen`eo agjabk`st
^gj mhpk`f`jn kmen`eo agjabk`st prdv`njn `e tgj MDH `s ms fdkkdws< =7:
Jeo`ej Qtmrt Qw`tagjs ................................................................... DE SF
Yjamkk .............................................................................. AGJABJN SF
* ^gj SEF w`kk prjss men rjkjmsj tgj meeuea`mtdr pmejk. Agjab tgmt tgjmeeuea`mtdr pmejk k`ogts men HMQ^JY AMZ^@DE k`ogts `kkuh`emtj.Ed k`ogts sgdukn rjhm`e kkuh`emtjn wgje tgj meeuea`mtdr s rjkjmsjn.
Qpjjn Irmbj ..............................................MYHJN, OYJJE K@OG^ SF
* Ym`sj kjvjr, hdvj sk`ogtky mft td NJ^JE^ (MYH) pds`t`de men disjrvjQSJJNIYMBJ MYHJN meeuea`mtdr `kkuh`emtjn.
=7: @i`n., MHSK@F@JN KMEN@EO AGJABK@Q^, pmoj 31.?3.0
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 204/215
- =06 -
* @f tgj mhijr QSJJNIYMBJ ND ED^ MYH k`ogt `kkuh`emtjs, dr tgjorjje QSJJNIYMBJ MYHJN k`ogt ndjs edt `kkuh`emtj, rjture tgjkjvjr td NJ^JE^ men hmeumkky njpkdy tgj orduen spd`kjrs mftjrtduagndwe.
Ojmr ND_E, 1 OYJJE...................................................................... SF/SEF
* Vjr`fy tgj kmen`eo ojmr kjvjr `s pds`t`dejn ndwe men tgj 1 orjjekmen`eo ojmr ndwe men kdabjn en`amtdr k`ogts mrj kkuh`emtjn.
Fkmps ............................................................... TTT OYJJE K@OG^ SF/SEF
• Jesurj fkmp en`amt`de morjjs w`tg rjqu`rjn kmen`eo fkmp.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 205/215
- =0? -
Mppjen`x V ‑ Mnn`t`demk stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs men mnmptmt`des iyF`rst M`r arjws
^rmesfjr df adetrdk
^gj m`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumk (MDH) njsar`ijs tgj adhpmey‐s trmesfjr df adetrdk prdajnurj ms
fdkkdws< =76
_gje trmesfjrr`eo adetrdk df tgj m`rarmft, tgj SF =7? w`kk stmtj ‛Pdur Adetrdks‘.^gj SEF w`kk stmtj ‛Hy Adetrdks‘ men mssuhj SF nut`js. gj SEF w`kk ormsp tgjadetrdk adkuhe pr`dr td meeduea`eo ‛Hy Adetrdks‘ `f tgj mutd-p`kdt `s edtjeomojn mt t`hj df adetrdk trmesfjr.
S`kdt etjrv`jws rjvjmkjn tgmt adhpk`meaj w`tg tg`s prdajnurj wms ojejrmkky oddn, mktgduogmnmptmt`des sdhjt`hjs n`n daaur nur`eo aru`sj, w`tg gmen s`oemks dr m tmp de tgj adetrdk wgjjkusjn td s`oe`fy tgj trmesfjr df adetrdk. Nur`eo fk`ogt FMI6:63, m trmesfjr df adetrdk daaurrjnnur`eo aru`sj, iut tgjrj wjrj ed vjrimk stmtjhjets rjomrn`eo tgj adetrdk trmesfjrs.
Kmen`eo nmtm amrn men m`rspjjn iuo sjtt`eos
^gj kmen`eo nmtm amrn (F`ourj 9:) `s usjn td sjtmen vjr`fy kmen`eo nmtm. @t s edrhmkky adhpkjtjniy tgj SEF ijfdrj tgj edrhmk prj-njsajetprdajnurjs. Edrhmkky, tgj SEF w`kk rjv`jw tgjkmen`eo nmtm amrn efdrhmt`de mftjr tgj m`rspjjniuos mrj sjt men ijfdrj tgj mpprdmag ir`jf`eo.
F`rst M`r stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurj fdr tgjI?1? `s td fky tgj rjadhhjenjn f`emk mpprdmag
spjjn (VMSS), wg`ag `s VYJF adrrjatjn fdr w`en._`en adrrjat`de s tgj stjmny gjmnw`enadhpdejet pkus mkk df tgj oust vmkuj, imsjn detdwjr-rjpdrtjn w`ens. gj hmx`huh w`enadrrjat`de sgdukn edt jxajjn 93 bedts. g`s w`enadrrjat`de `s mnnjn td tgj VYJF. @e k`ogt w`en drtm`kw`en aden`t`des, m h`e`huh df : bedts smnnjn td tgj VYJF td ditm`e tgj VMSS.
=76 F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==), ADHHZE@AM^@DEQ
MEN AYDQQAGJAB DF AYJ_ MA^@DEQ, pmoj 31.13.=
=7? SF rjfjrs td tgj p`kdt fky`eo2 SEF rjfjrs td tgj p kdt edt fky`eo. RFddtedtj mnnjn.X
=77 Yjprdnuajn frdh< F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==),KMEN@EO NM^M AMYN, pmoj 31.1>.>
F`ourj 9:. Kmen`eo nmtm amrn =77
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 206/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 207/215
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 208/215
- 933 -
met`a`pmtjn. FMI6:63 njsajenjn tgrduog =: 333 fjjt mt =613<=6. gjrj wjrj ed rjadrnjnstmtjhjets rjomrn`eo stmrt`eo tgj MSZ.
^gj =3 333-fddt same/fkdw s `e`t`mtjn wgje njsajen`eo tgrduog =3 333 fjjt. Mat`de tjhs mrjjxjautjn iy tgj SEF ms fdkkdws< =01
Kdod K`ogt…………………………………………………………………….DE
Omspjr Fme……………………………………………………………………DE
M`r Aden & Srjssur`zmt`de ……………………………..QJ^ FDY KMEN@EO @f rjqu`rjn, adef`ourj tgj prjssur`zmt`de systjh fdr Jeo`ej Ikjjns DFF
fdr kmen`eo. =0> Jesurj tgmt tgj MSZ gms ijje dpjrmt`eo fdr mt kjmst 63sjadens ijfdrj adhpkjt`eo tg`s prdajnurj.
Y`ogt Smab Qw`tag………………………………….DE
@sdkmt`de Vmkvj………………………………AKDQJN
Kjft Smab Qw`tag…………………………………...DE
Euhijr = Jeo`ej Ikjjn Qw`tag…………………DFFMSZ Ikjjn Qw`tag…………………………………DE
Euhijr 9 Jeo`ej Ikjjn Qw`tag…………………DFF
Qjmt Ijkt Q`oe…………………………………………………………………DE
Ormvjk Srdtjat Qw`tag (`f `estmkkjn) ………………………………………..DE
Kmen`eo K`ogts…………………………………………………MQ YJ]Z@YJN
FMI6:63 njsajenjn tgrduog =3 333 fjjt mt =619<1:. Mt tgj adhhjeajhjet df tgj e-rmeoj agjabmt =619<>7, tgj FD adef`rhjn tgj sjmtijkt s`oes DE, ormvjk prdtjat DE, men m`r aden`t`de`eo
prjssur`zmt`de sjt fdr kmen`eo. g`s adef`rhmt`de en`amtjs tgmt tgj =3 333 fddt same/fkdw gmnijje adhpkjtjn.
Mvm`kmikj efdrhmt`de ndjs edt akjmrky en`amtj wgjtgjr tgj p`kdts stmrtjn tgj MSZ. Gdwjvjr,tgjy turejn de tgj ormvjk prdtjat sw`tag, `en`amt`eo tgmt tgjy wjrj mwmrj df tgj ormvjkdpjrmt`eo rjqu`rjhjets. @t s k`bjky tgmt tgjy n`n stmrt men usj tgj MSZ.
Mkt`tunj mkjrtjr
^gj SEF w`kk mabedwkjnoj mkk mkt`tunj mss`oehjets w`tg M^A men rjpjmt tgjh mkdun td tgj SF.Mkk mss`oejn mkt`tunjs ndwe td tgj mkt`tunj mt tgj f`emk mpprdmag f`x (FMF) w`kk ij prjsjkjatjn detgj mkt`tunj mkjrtjr. De ok`njskdpj ampturj, tgj mkt`tunj mkjrtjr w`kk ij prjsjt td tgj h`ssjn
=01 Yjprdnuajn frdh< F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk Vdkuhj =, Mhjenhjet ed. 91 (9= Luej 93==),=3,333 FDD^ QAME/FKD_ (njsajen`eo), pmoj 31.63.6
=0> Quppkjhjetmry Srdajnurjs (F`rst M`r I?1? Dpjrmt`des Hmeumk, Vdkuhj =, pmoj 3>.=3.?) stmtj tgmtjeo`ej ikjjn m`r hust ij DFF fdr kmen`eo de ormvjk ruewmy.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 209/215
- 93= -
mpprdmag mkt`tunj. gjrj wms ed rjqu`rjhjet fdr p`kdts td mabedwkjnoj murmk dr v`sumk mkt`tunjmkjrts.
S`kdts etjrv`jwjn wjrj msbjn deky midut mabedwkjnohjet df murmk mkt`tunj mkjrts ijkdw tgjsjkjatjn mkt`tunj wg`kj de f`emk mpprdmag. gjy en`amtjn tgmt suag murmk mkjrts wjrjmabedwkjnojn iy mnv`s`eo tgj dtgjr p`kdt tgmt tgj mkt`tunj mkjrtjr wms sjt td tgj h`ssjn
mpprdmag mkt`tunj.
De FMI6:63, tgj SEF n`n edt rjpjmt mkdun tgj `etjenjn mkt`tunj wgje `e`t`mkky rjaj`v`eo tgjnjsajet akjmrmeaj frdh M^A mt =691<90. ^gjrj wjrj ed mkt`tunj mkjrtjr tdejs rjadrnjn uet`k tgjm`rarmft njsajenjn tgrduog 1933 fjjt mt =610<=3, wg`ag wms ades`stjet w`tg tgj mkt`tunj mkjrtjrij`eo sjt td 9933 fjjt. M suisjqujet mkjrt daaurrjn mt =610<:9, wgje tgj m`rarmft wms njsajen`eotgrduog midut =0:3 fjjt msk.
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 210/215
- 939 -
Mppjen`x _ ∙ ED^MHQ
@e`t`mk ED^MH =0: td jstmik`sg tgj Akmss N H^AM men Adetrdk \dej, `ssujn 39 Muoust=.93==<
@ssujn 39 Muoust 93== mt =?13\< SEQ3:36 39=?1319 OO AP\\D\JO 39=?13 APG]PEPW ===>3> ED^MHE A\JO JNHDE^DE F@Y A\JO NMG @Q MHJENJN MQ FK_< AKMQQ N YJQDKZ^J H^AM @Q JQ^MIK@QGJN MQ FK_< ^GJ M@YQSMAJ _@^G@E 73 EH YMN@ZQ ?>>13=E 0>:7=3_ ?33 F^ MOK ^D FK933. FDY DSQ EMEDDB. FYJ] FDY DSQ EMEDDB< YJQDKZ^J ^HK< 997.:333 HG\ < =91.3?: HG\
OKD__DYH (H@K SMY)< 9>1.>333 HG\ < =97.7:3 HG\ YJQDKZ^J ^_Y< 916.:333 HG\ < =91.19: HG\ YJQDKZ^J OEN< 9>0.0333 HG\ < =97.0?: HG\ < =>0.=:3 HG\ ==3736=933 @K ==37973=33
@ssujn 39 Muoust 93== mt =?1:\< SEQ3:=9 39=?1:91 OO AP\\D\JO 39=?1: APG]PEPW
===>3: ED^MHE A\JO JNHDE^DE F@Y A\JO NMG @Q MHJENJN MQ FK_< AKMQQ N YJQDKZ^J A^K \DEJ @Q JQ^MIK@QGJN MQ FK_< ^GJ M@YQSMAJ _@^G@E =3 EH YMN@ZQ ?>>13=E 0>:7=3_ QFA ^D 6333 F^ HQK. FDY DSQ EMEDDB ==3736=933 @K ==37973=33
Yjv`sjn ED^MH td jstmik`sg tgj Akmss N H^AM men Adetrdk \dej, `ssujn 3> Muoust9.93==<
@ssujn 3> Muoust 93== mt 9333\<
SEQ3616 3>93333= OO AP\\D\JO 3>=0:0 APJOPFPW ===>9> ED^MHY ===>3> A\JO JNHDE^DE F@Y A\JO NMG @Q MHJENJN MQ FK_< AKMQQ N YJQDKZ^J H^AM @Q JQ^MIK@QGJN MQ FK_<
=0: ED^MHs rjaj`vjn frdh EMV AMEMNM
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 211/215
- 931 -
^GJ M@YQSMAJ _@^G@E 73 EH YMN@ZQ ?>>13=E 0>:7=3_ ?33 F^ MOK ^D FK933. FDY DSQ EMEDDB. FYJ] FDY DSQ EMEDDB< YJQDKZ^J ^HK< 997.:333 HG\ < =91.3?: HG\ OKD__DYH(H@K SMY)< 9>1.>333 HG\
< =97.7:3 HG\ YJQDKZ^J ^_Y< 916.:333 HG\ < =91.19: HG\ YJQDKZ^J OEN< 9>0.0333 HG\ < =97.0?: HG\ < =>0.=:3 HG\ ==37=3=133 @K ==37973=33 . . . . @ssujn 3> Muoust 93== mt 9336\< SEQ36>> 3>9336=1 OO AP\\D\JO 3>9336 APJOPFPW ===>9: ED^MHY ===>3: A\JO JNHDE^DE F@Y
A\JO NMG @Q MHJENJN MQ FK_< AKMQQ N YJQDKZ^J A^K \DEJ @Q JQ^MIK@QGJN MQ FK_< ^GJ M@YQSMAJ _@^G@E =3 EH YMN@ZQ ?>>13=E 0>:7=3_ QFA ^D 6333 F^ HQK. FDY DSQ EMEDDB ==37=3=133 @K ==37973=33
Yjv`sjn ED^MH td jstmik`sg tgj Akmss N Adetrdk \dej, `ssujn =9 Muoust 93==< 1.
@ssujn =9 Muoust 93== mt 911=\< SEQ37=3 =9911=:? OO AP\\DPYI =9911= APG]PEPW ==3=39 ED^MHE APYI YJQZKZ^J IMP
APYI NMG @Q MHJENJN MQ FK_< AKMQQ N YJQDKZ^J A^K \DEJ @Q JQ^MIK@QGJN MQ FK_< ^GJ M@YQSMAJ _@^G@E =3 EH YMN@ZQ ?>>13=E 0>:7=3_ QFA ^D 6333 F^ HQK. FDY DSQ EMEDDB ==37=3=133 @K ==37973=33
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 212/215
- 93> -
Mppjen`x W ‑ K`st df mardeyhs men miirjv`mt`des
7MAAQ 7 M`r Adetrdk men Adhhue`amt`des QqumnrdeMAA mrjm adetrdk ajetrjMN m`rwdrtg`ejss n`rjat`vjMNF mutdhmt`a n`rjat`de f`en`eoMN@ mtt`tunj n`rjatdr `en`amtdrmok midvj orduen kjvjkMK^ GDKN mkt`tunj gdknMDH m`rarmft dpjrmt`des hmeumkMS mutdp`kdt (sw`tag rjfjrrjn td ms M/S)MSN mpprdmag prdorjss n`spkmyMSZ mux`k`mry pdwjr ue`tMYFF m`rarmft rjsauj men f`rjf`ogt`eomsk midvj sjm kjvjkMQY mrjm survj`kkmeaj rmnmr
M^A m`r trmff`a adetrdkM^A HMEDSQ m`r trmff`a adetrdk hmeumk df dpjrmt`desM^@Q mutdhmtjn tjrh`emk `efdrhmt`de systjhM^V mkk-tjrrm`e vjg`akjMZ^D MSS mutd mpprdmagM__Q mv`mt`de wjmtgjr _ji s`tj
IAYQ imab adursj
³A njorjjs ajet`ormnjAMM Ze`tjn B`eondh A`v`k Mv`mt`de Mutgdr`ty
AMNDYQ A`v`k Mv`mt`de Nm`ky Daaurrjeaj Yjpdrt`eo QystjhAMY Amemn`me Mv`mt`de Yjoukmt`des
AMYA A`v`k Mv`mt`de Yjoukmtdry Adhh`ttjjAMYQ adhhue`ty mjrdnrdhj rmn`d stmt`deAMQQ Adhhjra`mk M`r Qjrv`aj QtmenmrnsAI Amhir`noj ImyANZ adetrdk n`spkmy ue`tAF@^ adetrdkkjn fk`ogt etd tjrrm`eAVFY adetrdkkjn v`sumk fk`ogt rukjsADH adhpmey dpjrmt`des hmeumkAYH arjw rjsduraj hmemojhjet
AYH@ AYH `estruatdrAYH@J AYH `estruatdr jxmh`ejrAVY adabp`t vd`aj rjadrnjrA_Q adetrdk wgjjk stjjr`eoAPYI Yjsdkutj Imy M`rpdrt (@etjremt`demk A`v`k Mv`mt`de Mssda`mt`de R@AMDX
kdamt`de njet`f`jr)APZW Gmkk IjmagAP\F Pjkkdwbe`fj M`rpdrt
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 213/215
- 93: -
A\ adetrdk zdej
NO n`rjat`demk oyrd (frjj oyrd)NHJ n`stmeaj hjmsur`eo jqu`phjetNH@ njfjrrjn hm`etjemeaj tjh
JM^H jxpjn`t`demry m`r trmff`a hmemojhjetJOS_Q jegmeajn orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjhJK^ jhjrojeay kdamtdr trmesh`ttjrJSY jeo`ej prjssurj rmt`dJQ^MS emhj df m OSQ emv`omt`demk wmypd`etJ^M jst`hmtjn t`hj df mrr`vmkJZYDAMJ Jurdpjme Drome`smt`de fdr A`v`k Mv`mt`de Jqu`phjet
FMM Ze`tjn Qtmtjs Fjnjrmk Mv`mt`de Mnh`e`strmt`deFMI6:63 F`rst M`r fk`ogt 6:63FMF f`emk mpprdmag f`x
FN fk`ogt n`rjatdrFNH f`ogt nmtm hde`tdr`eoFNY fk`ogt nmtm rjadrnjrFK fk`ogt kjvjkFHQ fk`ogt hmemojhjet systjhFD f`rst dff`ajrFDH fk`ogt dpjrmt`des hmeumkFD]M fk`ogt dpjrmt`demk qumk`ty mssurmeajFD^H fk`ogt dpjrmt`des trm`e`eo hmeumk fph fjjt pjr h`eutj
OM od-mrduenOEQQ okdimk emv`omt`de smtjkk`tj systjhOSQ okdimk pds`t`de`eo systjhOS_Q orduen prdx`h`ty wmre`eo systjhOQ ok`njskdpj (sw`tagjs usj O/Q)
GNO GDKN gjmn`eo gdknGNO DFF gjmn`eo dffGNO QJK gjmn`eo sjkjatGQ@ gdr`zdetmk s`tumt`de `en`amtdr
@AMD@FY
@etjremt`demk A`v`k Mv`mt`de Drome`zmt`de`estruhjet fk`ogt rukjs
@KQ `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh@HA `estruhjet hjtjdrdkdo`amk aden`t`des`e. Go `eagjs df hjraury@YI 1-kjttjr `njet`f`jr fdr tgj Yjsdkutj Imy `estruhjet kmen`eo systjh (@KQ)
trmesh`ttjr
LYAA ld`et rjsauj addrn`emt`de ajetrj
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 214/215
- 936 -
B@MQ bedts en`amtjn m`rspjjnB^MQ bedts truj m`rspjjn
KDA kdamk`zjrKDQM k`ej dpjrmt`des smfjty mun`t
HMO hmoejt`aHME hmeumkHAS hdnj adetrdk pmejk³H njorjjs hmoejt`aHJ^MY rdut`ej mv`mt`de wjmtgjr rjpdrtHF hmenmtdry frjqujeayHDNJ QJK hdnj sjkjat`deH^AM h`k`tmry tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjmHZQM^ emhj df m OSQ emv`omt`demk wmypd`et
emv-m`n emv`omt`demk m`nENM Edrtgjre Ndhjst`a M`rspmajENI ede-n`rjat`demk ijmadeeh emut`amk h`kjsED^MH edt`aj td m`rhjeED^MHA ED^MH ameajkkmt`deED^MHE ejw ED^MHED^MHY rjpkmajhjet ED^MHE^QI Ze`tjn Qtmtjs Emt`demk ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn
DFS dpjrmt`demk fk`ogt pkme
D^EJK emhj df m OSQ emv`omt`demk wmypd`et
SM puik`a mnnrjssSMY prja`s`de mpprdmag rmnmrSMAJ M arjw adhhue`amt`de strmtjoy wgjrjiy p`kdts jhpkdy prdi`eo, mkjrt`eo,
agmkkjeo`eo, men jhjrojeay wmre`eo hjssmojs td tgj dtgjr arjw hjhijr.SF p`kdt fky`eoS@A p`kdt-`e-adhhmenS@^AG AHN p`tag adhhmenSH p`kdt hde`tdr`eoSEF p`kdt edt fky`eo
YI ENI Yjsdkutj Imy ede-n`rjat`demk ijmadeY@IZE emhj df m OSQ emv`omt`demk wmypd`etYH@ rmn`d-hmoejt`a en`amtdrYEMV mrjm emv`omt`de
sh stmtutj h`kjsQHQ smfjty hmemojhjet systjhQDSs stmenmrn dpjrmt`eo prdajnurjs
7/22/2019 Resolute plane crash result of complex series of events: transportation board
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/resolute-plane-crash-result-of-complex-series-of-events-transportation-board 215/215
- 93? -
QSJA@ spja`mk wjmtgjr rjpdrt
³^ njorjjs truj^MF mjrdnrdhj fdrjamst^M_Q tjrrm`e mwmrjejss men wmre`eo systjh^A ^rmespdrt Amemnm
^AM tjrh`emk adetrdk mrjm^JH tgrjmt men jrrdr hmemojhjet^DN tdp df njsajet^QI ^rmespdrtmt`de Qmfjty Idmrn
Z^A ue`vjrsmk addrn`emtjn t`hj
VMSS mpprdmag spjjn (VYJF) adrrjatjn fdr w`enVFY v`sumk fk`ogt rukjs