Research Report - International Water Management Institute · Research Report 7 nter aio l Water Management Institute. ... are minimized, while fishponds within the command area could

ISSN 1391-9407ISBN 92-9090-591-3

Postal Address: IWMI, P O Box 2075, Colombo, Sri Lanka Location: 127 Sunil Mawatha, Pelawatte, Battaramulla, Sri LankaTelephone: +94-11 2787404, 2784080 Fax: +94-11 2786854

Email: [email protected] Website: www.iwmi.org/assessment

Impacts of Irrigation on Inland Fisheries:Appraisals in Laos and Sri Lanka

Sophie Nguyen-Khoa, Laurence Smith and Kai Lorenzen

Research Report 7

I n t e r n a t i o n a lWater ManagementI n s t i t u t e

&-* "2034*-*15.8* !55*550*16 2+ ’(6*4 #(1(,*0*16 .1 !,4.)7/674* ZGQKYYZUIQ UL ZNK IUYZY# HKTKLOZY GTJ OSVGIZY UL ZNK VGYZ +’ _KGXY UL ]GZKX JK\KRUVSKTZLUX GMXOI[RZ[XK# ZNK ]GZKX SGTGMKSKTZ INGRRKTMKY IUSS[TOZOKY GXK LGIOTM ZUJG_#GTJ YUR[ZOUTY VKUVRK NG\K JK\KRUVKJ% @NK XKY[RZY UL ZNK .YYKYYSKTZ ]ORR KTGHRKLGXSOTM IUSS[TOZOKY# MU\KXTSKTZY GTJ JUTUXY ZU SGQK HKZZKX$W[GROZ_ OT\KYZSKTZGTJ SGTGMKSKTZ JKIOYOUTY ZU SKKZ LUUJ GTJ KT\OXUTSKTZGR YKI[XOZ_ UHPKIZO\KY OTZNK TKGX L[Z[XK GTJ U\KX ZNK TK^Z (+ _KGXY%

&-* $*5*(4)- $*3246 %*4.*5 IGVZ[XKY XKY[RZY UL IURRGHUXGZO\K XKYKGXIN IUTJ[IZKJ[TJKX ZNK .YYKYYSKTZ% 6Z GRYU OTIR[JKY XKVUXZY IUTZXOH[ZKJ H_ OTJO\OJ[GR YIOKTZOYZYGTJ UXMGTO‘GZOUTY ZNGZ YOMTOLOIGTZR_ GJ\GTIK QTU]RKJMK UT QK_ .YYKYYSKTZW[KYZOUTY% 2GIN XKVUXZ [TJKXMUKY G XOMUXU[Y VKKX$XK\OK] VXUIKYY% @NK XKYKGXINVXKYKTZKJ OT ZNK YKXOKY LKKJY OTZU ZNK .YYKYYSKTZ Y VXOSGX_ U[ZV[Z G ?ZGZK ULZNK CUXRJ XKVUXZ GTJ YKZ UL UVZOUTY HGIQKJ H_ N[TJXKJY UL RKGJOTM ]GZKX GTJJK\KRUVSKTZ VXULKYYOUTGRY GTJ ]GZKX [YKXY%

>KVUXZY OT ZNOY YKXOKY SG_ HK IUVOKJ LXKKR_ GTJ IOZKJ ]OZN J[KGIQTU]RKJMKSKTZ% 2RKIZXUTOI IUVOKY UL XKVUXZY IGT HK JU]TRUGJKJ LXUS ZNK.YYKYYSKTZ ]KHYOZK !]]]%O]SO%UXM&GYYKYYSKTZ"%

6L _U[ GXK OTZKXKYZKJ OT Y[HSOZZOTM G XKVUXZ LUX OTIR[YOUT OT ZNK YKXOKY# VRKGYKYKK ZNK Y[HSOYYOUT M[OJKROTKY G\GORGHRK UT ZNK .YYKYYSKTZ ]KHYOZK UX YKTJ G]XOZZKT XKW[KYZ ZU- ?KVGRO 4UUTGXGZTK# =%<% /U^ (’,+# 0URUSHU# ?XO 9GTQG%

0USVXKNKTYO\K .YYKYYSKTZ U[ZV[ZY IUTZXOH[ZK ZU ZNK 1OGRUM[KUT CGZKX# 3UUJ GTJ 2T\OXUTSKTZ 8TU]RKJMK /GYK%

S

’<:=>363;?7B3 &??3??:3;@ -3?30>16 -3=<>@ $

%25()87 4, %66/-(8/43 43 %31(3* $/7.+6/+7!"556(/7(17 /3 &(47 (3* ’6/ &(30(

.<=673 ,5AD3;!*6<0+0A>3;13 .:7@6 0;2*07 +<>3;E3;

7YWZ\OROX]S‘O 5]]O]]WOX^ YP JKÔ\ AKXKQOWOX^ SX 5Q\SM_V^_\O

GRO 7YWZ\OROX]S‘O 5]]O]]WOX^ S] Y\QKXSdON ^R\Y_QR ^RO 7;=5E ] Fc]ÔW%JSNO =XS^SK^S‘O YX JKÔ\AKXKQOWOX^ "FJ=A#$ aRSMR S] MYX‘OXON Lc ̂ RO =XÔ\XK^SYXKV JKÔ\ AKXKQOWOX^ =X]^S^_Ô& GRO 5]]O]]WOX^S] MK\\SON Y_^ aS^R SXZ_^] P\YW Y‘O\ 1( XK^SYXKV KXN SXÔ\XK^SYXKV NO‘OVYZWOX^ KXN \O]OK\MR Y\QKXSdK^SYX]SXMV_NSXQ 7;=5E 7OXÔ\] KXN :5C& :SXKXMSKV ]_ZZY\^ PY\ ^RO 5]]O]]WOX^ MYWO] P\YW K \KXQO YP NYXY\]$SXMV_NSXQ ̂ RO ;Y‘O\XWOX^] YP ^RO BO^RO\VKXN]$ FaS^dO\VKXN$ >KZKX$ GKSaKX KXN 5_]^\SK3 ^RO CD97 :_XN3:5C3 KXN ^RO EYMUOPOVVO\ :Y_XNK^SYX&

/63 0A@6<>?% FYZRSO BQ_cOX%?RYK S] K EO]OK\MRO\ K^ =JA=$ F\S @KXUK3 @K_\OXMO FWS^RS] K FOXSY\ @OM^_\O\ SX 5Q\SM_V^_\KV 9MYXYWSM] SX ̂ RO 8OZK\^WOX^ YP 5Q\SM_V^_\KV FMSOXMO]KXN ?KS @Y\OXdOX S] K FOXSY\ @OM^_\O\ SX :\O]RaKÔ\ :S]RO\SO] SX ^RO 8OZK\^WOX^ YP9X‘S\YXWOX^KV FMSOXMO KXN GOMRXYVYQc$ \O]ZOM^S‘OVc$ K^ ^RO =WZO\SKV 7YVVOQO @YXNYX&

&18;<C9325:3;@?2 GRO aY\U \OZY\ÔN RO\O S] ̂ RO \O]_V̂ YP K MYVVKLY\K^S‘O Z\YTOM^ SX‘YV‘SXQ=WZO\SKV 7YVVOQO @YXNYX$ =G58%JKÔ\ @^N&$ =JA=$ ̂ RO EOQSYXKV 8O‘OVYZWOX^ 7YWWS^ÔOPY\ @S‘O]^YMU KXN :S]RO\SO] SX FY_^RO\X @KY]$ ^RO HXS‘O\]S^c YP ?OVKXcSK& GRO K_^RY\]^RKXU 7K\YVSXO ;K\KaKc$ AK\^SX 6_\^YX$ 8K‘SN AYVNOX$ =KX AKUSX$ @&E& DO\O\K$ FRcKWKVSO8O FSV‘K$ A&A&7& ?_WK\K$ EKXTS^R 5\ScK\K^XO$ F_\OX JOQYNKZYVK$ 5]R\K :O\XKXNY$HZKVS 5WK\K]SXQRO$ A&;& ?_VK\K^XO$ 7RKXNKXK 6KXNK\K$ 8Y_KXQMRS^R @S^NKWVYXQ$GRYXQVKS IKXXS‘YXQ$ FYXO‘SVKS BKWZRKXcK KXN DRO^]Y_VKZRYX >Y_VK^RSNK PY\ ^ROS\MYX^\SL_^SYX] ^Y ^RO ]^_NSO] ]_WWK\SdON RO\O& GRO \OZ\O]OX^K^S‘O] YP ^RO NSPPO\OX^]^KUORYVNO\ Q\Y_Z] "‘SVVKQO\]$ 8S]^\SM^$ D\Y‘SXMSKV KXN BK^SYXKV VO‘OV YPPSMO\]$ OXQSXOO\SXQMYWZKXc# K\O KV]Y ^RKXUON PY\ ^ROS\ ‘KV_KLVO MYX^\SL_^SYX ^Y ^RO ]O\SO] YP aY\U]RYZ]MYXN_MÔN SX @KY] KXN F\S @KXUK&

:_XNSXQ aK] Z\Y‘SNON Lc ̂ RO H? 8OZK\^WOX^ PY\ =XÔ\XK^SYXKV 8O‘OVYZWOX^$ ?XYaVONQOKXN EO]OK\MR SX 9XQSXOO\SXQ FOM^Y\] D\YQ\KW$ KXN ^RO 7;=5E 7YWZ\OROX]S‘O5]]O]]WOX^ PY\ 5Q\SM_V^_\O&

BQ_cOX%?RYK$ F&3 FWS^R$ @&3 @Y\OXdOX$ ?& *((-& ):=01@? <4 )>>750@7<; <; );90;2 (7?63>73?%&==>07?09? 7; +0<? 0;2 .>7 +0;80" 7YWZ\OROX]S‘O 5]]O]]WOX^ EO]OK\MR EOZY\^ /&7YVYWLY$ F\S @KXUK2 7YWZ\OROX]S‘O 5]]O]]WOX^ FOM\O^K\SK^&

# 47?63>73? # 7>>750@7<; 34431@? # ?<1709 0?=31@? # 0??3??:3;@ # :3@6<2<9<5D # 7>>750@7<;=><5>0:? # 6<A?36<92? # >713 # C0@3> :0;053:3;@ # 90;2 :0;053:3;@ # 3;B7><;:3;@0934431@? # +0<? # .>7 +0;80

=FFB )+1) 1,(/=F6B 1* 1(1( -1) +

7YZc\SQR^ *((-$ Lc 7YWZ\OROX]S‘O 5]]O]]WOX^ FOM\O^K\SK^& 5VV \SQR^] \O]O\‘ON&

7Y‘O\ DRY^YQ\KZR] Lc GRYXQVKS IKXXS‘YXQ "ZRY^YQ\KZR YX ̂ RO VOP^# KXN A&A&7& ?_WK\K"ZRY^YQ\KZR YX ^RO \SQR^# ]RYa F^KUORYVNO\ aY\U]RYZ] SX @KY] KXN F\S @KXUK&

DVOK]O ]OXN SX[_S\SO] KXN MYWWOX^] ^Y2 MYWZ&K]]O]]WOX^4MQSK\&Y\Q

SSS

SSS

#438+387

F_WWK\c &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&‘

=X^\YN_M^SYX &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& )

GRO =WZY\^KXMO YP 5ZZ\KS]SXQ ^RO =WZKM^] YP =\\SQK^SYX YX

=XVKXN :S]RO\SO] &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& *

5ZZ\YKMR KXN AO^RYNYVYQc &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& +

EO]_V^] YP ^RO =WZKM^ 5]]O]]WOX^] &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& 0

=WZKM^] YP =\\SQK^SYX YX =XVKXN :S]RO\SO] KXN E_\KV @S‘OVSR=YYN]2

@O]]YX] KXN BOa DO\]ZOM^S‘O] &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& *0

7YXMV_]SYX] &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& +)

@SÔ\K^_\O 7SÔN &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& ++

‘

’922(6:

GRO\O S] KX SXM\OK]SXQ \OMYQXS^SYX YP ^RO XOONPY\ SWZ\Y‘ON KZZ\YKMRO] PY\ SXÔQ\KÔN aKÔ\\O]Y_\MO] WKXKQOWOX^ "=JEA#& =X WKXc \S‘O\LK]SX] S\\SQK^SYX S] ^RO VK\QO]^ aKÔ\ _]O$ KXNK^ÔX^SYX W_]^ LO ZKSN ^Y S^] ]YMSYOMYXYWSM KXNOX‘S\YXWOX^KV SWZKM^]$ KXN ^Y ^RO ZYÔX^SKV PY\W_V^SZVO%_]O YP S\\SQK^SYX ]c]ÔW]& GRS] \O[_S\O]SWZ\Y‘ON KZZ\YKMRO] PY\ ^RO ZVKXXSXQ$ SWZKM^K]]O]]WOX^ KXN WKXKQOWOX^ YP S\\SQK^SYXZ\YTOM^]$ KXN KX SWZY\^KX^ MYWZYXOX^$ ^ROK]]O]]WOX^ KXN WKXKQOWOX^ YP SWZKM^] YXSXVKXN PS]RO\SO]& F_MR PS]RO\SO] MKX LO YP ]YMSKVKXN OMYXYWSM SWZY\^KXMO$ L_^ RK‘O YPÔX LOOXXOQVOMÔN SX ^RO ZVKXXSXQ KXN SWZVOWOX^K^SYX YPS\\SQK^SYX ]MROWO]& =\\SQK^SYX NO‘OVYZWOX^$RYaO‘O\$ MKX WYNSPc \S‘O\ RcN\YVYQc KXN K[_K^SMRKLS^K^]$ KXN SWZKM^ YX K[_K^SM LSYNS‘O\]S^c$ ^ROZ\YN_M^S‘S^c YP PS]RO\SO]$ KXN ^RO VS‘OVSRYYN] YP\_\KV RY_]ORYVN]&

5V^RY_QR K]]O]]SXQ ^RO SWZKM^] YP S\\SQK^SYXYX PS]RO\SO] S] SWZY\^KX^$ ^RO MY]^ YPK]]O]]WOX^] W_]^ \OWKSX \OK]YXKLVO SX \OVK^SYX^Y ^RO WKQXS^_NO YP ObZOMÔN SWZKM^] KXN ^RO^Y^KV Z\YTOM^ MY]^& 5ZZ\KS]KV WO^RYN] K\OXOONON$ KXN W_]^ LO Z\KM^SMKV KXN VYa%MY]^$aRSVO ]^SVV KLVO ^Y QOXO\KÔ SXPY\WK^SYX PY\]MROWO MYX]^\_M^SYX$ \ORKLSVS^K^SYX Y\WKXKQOWOX^ YP S\\SQK^SYX& =WZKM^ K]]O]]WOX^]PY\ ^RS] Z_\ZY]O aO\O MYXN_MÔN SX @KY] KXN F\S@KXUK$ _]SXQ KX SXÔQ\KÔN KXN ZK\^SMSZK^Y\cKZZ\YKMR ^Y OX‘S\YXWOX^KV SWZKM^ K]]O]]WOX^&

=X @KY] KX Ob%KXÔ KZZ\KS]KV YP ^RO ZY]]SLVOSWZKM^] aK] WKNO _]SXQ K XOa )$((( ROM^K\OS\\SQK^SYX NO‘OVYZWOX^ Z\YTOM^ SX KX K\OK aS^R\SMR PS]RO\c \O]Y_\MO]$ KXN aRO\O PS]RSXQ ZVKc]KX SWZY\^KX^ \YVO SX ^RO NS‘O\]SPSON ]_L]S]ÔXMOVS‘OVSRYYN] YP ^RO WKTY\S^c YP RY_]ORYVN]& BSXO^cZO\MOX^ YP \_\KV RY_]ORYVN] SX ^RO \OQSYX \OQ_%VK\Vc OXQKQON SX PS]RSXQ$ YL^KSXSXQ KX K‘O\KQOMK^MR YP .( UQ ZO\ RY_]ORYVN ZO\ cOK\& GRS] aK]]OMYXN YXVc ^Y \SMO Z\YN_M^SYX SX Ô\W] YP PYYN]OM_\S^c KXN SXMYWO QOXO\K^SYX$ Z\Y‘SNSXQKZZ\YbSWKÔVc )- ZO\MOX^ YP RY_]ORYVN SXMYWO&

GRO KZZ\KS]KV ]RYaON ^RK^ 1( ZO\MOX^ YP PS]RZ\YN_M^SYX MKWO P\YW \KSX%PON \SMO PSOVN] KXN^RK^ ^RS] MY_VN LO ]_]^KSXON aS^RSX ^RO S\\SQK^SYX]c]ÔW aRSMR Z\Y‘SNON ^RO aO^ ]OK]YX \SMO M\YZaS^R KNO[_KÔ aKÔ\ VO‘OV] SX ^RO PSOVN] KXNOMYVYQSMKV MYXXOM^S‘S^c YP \SMO PSOVN] KXNWKSX^KSXON ZO\OXXSKV aKÔ\ LYNSO]& EON_M^SYX SX\SMO PSOVN aKÔ\ ]^Y\KQO aS^R S\\SQK^SYX$ SXM\OK]ON_]O YP KQ\YMROWSMKV] KXN LK\\SO\] ^Y PS]RWSQ\K^SYX M\OKÔN Lc S\\SQK^SYX SXP\K]^\_M^_\OMY_VN ^R\OKÔX PS]RO\SO] Z\YN_M^SYX& 5Q\SM_V^_\KVZ\YN_M^S‘S^c QKSX] P\YW ]_MR Z\KM^SMO] aY_VNXOON ^Y YPP]O^ ^RO MYXMYWS^KX^ VY]] YP PS]RO\SO]^Y LO LOXOPSMSKV SX KQQ\OQKÔ Ô\W]& 5]]_WSXQ^RK^ Z\YN_M^SYX P\YW \SMO PSOVN] aY_VN LO]_]^KSXON ^RO KZZ\KS]KV KV]Y Z\ONSMÔN K WYNO]^SXM\OK]O SX KQQ\OQKÔ PS]RO\SO] Z\YN_M^SYX SX ^ROMK^MRWOX^ KWY_X^SXQ ^Y KLY_^ ), ^YXXO] ZO\cOK\$ LOMK_]O M\OK^SYX YP K \O]O\‘YS\ PS]RO\caY_VN Y_âOSQR ^RO NOQ\KNK^SYX YP ^RO ObS]^SXQ\S‘O\ KXN PVYYNZVKSX PS]RO\c NYaX]^\OKW& :S]RSXQOPPY\^ MY_VN LO ObZOMÔN ^Y NOMVSXO ]VSQR^Vc "LcKLY_^ )( *( ZO\MOX^# LOMK_]O YP ^RO SWZKM^ YPS\\SQK^SYX NO‘OVYZWOX^ YX PK\W VKLY\\O[_S\OWOX^] KXN K^^\KM^S‘O OWZVYcWOX^YZZY\^_XS^SO]$ KXN ^Y LO ZK\^SKVVc \ONS]^\SL_ÔNP\YW \S‘O\%PVYYNZVKSX KXN \SMO PSOVN VYMK^SYX] ^Y^RO \O]O\‘YS\&

GRO Y‘O\KVV SWZKM^ YX VS‘OVSRYYN] aK]ObZOMÔN ^Y LO ZY]S^S‘O LOMK_]O ^RO WKTY\S^caY_VN QKSX LOXOPS^] P\YW S\\SQKÔN PK\WSXQ$ aRSVOLOSXQ KLVO ^Y ]_]^KSX PS]RSXQ K] ^ROS\ ]OMYXNWY]^ SWZY\^KX^ KM^S‘S^c& <YaO‘O\$ ^RO\O aY_VN LOK XOON ^Y WYXS^Y\ SWZKM^] NSPPO\OX^SKÔN LcVYMK^SYX SX ^RO MK^MRWOX^$ ]YMSYOMYXYWSM ]^K^_]KXN QOXNO\ YP ‘_VXO\KLVO Q\Y_Z] aRY]O SXÔ\O]^W_]^ ^RO\OLc LO ]KPOQ_K\NON& GRY]O aRY aY_VNLO WY]^ K^ \S]U K\O ^RO VKXNVO]] Y\ VKXN%NOPSMSOX^RY_]ORYVN] KXN ^RY]O aRY K\O ROK‘SVcNOZOXNOX^ YX PS]RSXQ L_^ WY\O \OWYÔ P\YW ^RO\O]O\‘YS\$ ZK\^SM_VK\Vc SP ^ROc K\O VO]] KLVO ^YObZVYS^ XOa VKLY\ WK\UO^ YZZY\^_XS^SO] YX aRSMR^ROc MY_VN \OVc&

‘S

:Y\ Z\YTOM^ SWZVOWOX^K^SYX ^RO UOc SWZKM^WS^SQK^SYX Y\ OXRKXMOWOX^ WOK]_\O] ^Y Z\YÔM^PS]RO\SO] aSVV ^R_] LO ^RY]O XOONON ^Y ]_]^KSX ^ROPS]RO\SO] Z\YN_M^SYX YP ^RO \KSX%PON aO^ ]OK]YX\SMO M\YZ& AKSXÔXKXMO YP VKÔ\KV MYXXOM^S‘S^cKM\Y]] ^RO PVYYNZVKSX S] SWZY\^KX^ PY\ ^RS] KXNWKc \O[_S\O PS]R%P\SOXNVc M\Y]]%N\KSXKQOM_V‘O\^]$ aRO\O MKXKV] Y\ KMMO]] \YKN] M\OKÔLK\\SO\]& 5_QWOX^K^SYX YP \S‘O\ PVYa aS^ROX‘S\YXWOX^KV \OVOK]O] P\YW ^RO NKW N_\SXQ

UOc WSQ\K^Y\c ZO\SYN] WKc KV]Y LO \O[_S\ON SXY\NO\ ^Y KVVYa PS]R WSQ\K^SYX SX^Y \SMO PSOVNRKLS^K^]& 8\KSXKQO MRKXXOV] MKX KV]Y LOMYWOUOc WSQ\K^Y\c ZK^RaKc] K] VYXQ K] PKVV ]^\_M^_\O]K\O WSXSWSdON$ aRSVO PS]RZYXN] aS^RSX ^ROMYWWKXN K\OK MY_VN Z\Y‘SNO KNNS^SYXKV N\c]OK]YX RKLS^K^ K] VYXQ K] ^ROc K\O ZO\OXXSKV&:\YW K ZYVSMc ZO\]ZOM^S‘O$ QS‘OX ^RK^ ^RO^\KNS^SYXKV KXN ]_L]S]ÔXMO XK^_\O YP ^RO \_\KVOMYXYWc aSVV ZO\]S]^ PY\ ]YWO ^SWO$ ^RO YLTOM^S‘O]RY_VN LO ^Y WKSX^KSX ^RO MYX^\SL_^SYX WKNO LcPS]RSXQ ^Y ^RO NS‘O\]SPSON VS‘OVSRYYN] YP WY]^ \_\KVRY_]ORYVN]$ K] aOVV K] S^] \YVO K] K ]KPO^c%XO^Y\ KM^S‘S^c YP VK]^ \O]Y\^ PY\ ^RO WY]^ ‘_VXO\KLVO&

=X F\S @KXUK$ KX Ob%ZY]^ O‘KV_K^SYX aK]WKNO YP KX O]^KLVS]RON )($(((%ROM^K\O S\\SQK^SYXKXN ]O^^VOWOX^ Z\YTOM^ ^RK^ \O‘OKVON K MYWZVObZSM^_\O YP LY^R ZY]S^S‘O KXN XOQK^S‘O SWZKM^] K^NSPPO\OX^ VYMK^SYX] aS^RSX ^RO MK^MRWOX^& GROZ\YTOM^ MYX]^\_MÔN K XOa ROKN \O]O\‘YS\ KXNSXMY\ZY\KÔN Z\O%ObS]^SXQ \O]O\‘YS\] KXNMYWWKXN K\OK] aS^RSX K MK]MKNO ]c]ÔW& =XMYX^\K]^ ^Y @KY] ^RO \S‘O\%PVYYNZVKSX KXN \SMO PSOVNRKLS^K^] RKN KX SXXKÔVc VYa Z\YN_M^SYX ZYÔX^SKV")( *( ZO\MOX^# KXN PS]RO\SO] Z\YN_M^SYX aK]MYXMOX^\KÔN SX ^RO \O]O\‘YS\] KXN MYK]^KVVKQYYX]& 5ZZ\YbSWKÔVc / ZO\MOX^ YP RY_]ORYVN]SX ^RO Z\YTOM^ K\OK OXQKQON SX PS]RSXQ K] K\OQ_VK\ KM^S‘S^c$ Z\YN_MSXQ )+ ZO\MOX^ YP ^RO ^Y^KVSXMYWO P\YW ^RO ]MROWO "KZZ\YbSWKÔVc HF!)&,WSVVSYX ’cOK\#& AY]^ PS]RSXQ aK] OS^RO\ K P_VV%^SWO]ZOMSKVSdK^SYX Y\ KX YZZY\^_XS]^ KM^S‘S^c PY\ ^ROZYY\ KXN VKXNVO]] KWYXQ Y^RO\ KM^S‘S^SO] ]_MR K]PS\OaYYN MYVVOM^SYX KXN MK]_KV VKLY\SXQ& DK\^%^SWOPS]RSXQ Lc PK\WSXQ RY_]ORYVN] SX ‘SVVKQO] XOK\\O]O\‘YS\] Y\ VKQYYX] NSN ^KUO ZVKMO$ L_^ aK]W_MR VO]] MYWWYX ^RKX SX @KY]& :S]RSXQ RKNZ\Y‘SNON KLY‘O K‘O\KQO SXMYWO] SX ^RO ZK]^ L_^

K^ ^RO ^SWO YP ^RO O‘KV_K^SYX SXMYWO] RKNNOMVSXON LOMK_]O YP ^RO MYWLSXON OPPOM^] YPY‘O\ ObZVYS^K^SYX$ \OMOX^ N\Y_QR^] KXN XOQK^S‘OSWZKM^] YP ]MROWO aKÔ\ WKXKQOWOX^&

GRO O‘KV_K^SYX ]RYaON ^RK^ ^RO Z\YTOM^ RKN]SQXSPSMKX^Vc SXM\OK]ON Y‘O\KVV PS]R Z\YN_M^SYXZYÔX^SKV ^R\Y_QR ^RO M\OK^SYX YP ^RO VK\QO XOaROKN \O]O\‘YS\& GRS] WY\O ^RKX MYWZOX]KÔN SXKQQ\OQKÔ Ô\W] PY\ KXc NOMVSXO SX Y_^Z_^ P\YW^RO NYaX]^\OKW PVYYNZVKSX& <YaO‘O\$ ^RO VO‘OVKXN ]_]^KSXKLSVS^c YP Z\YN_M^SYX P\YW ^RO Z\O%ObS]^SXQ \O]O\‘YS\] RK] LOOX KN‘O\]OVc KPPOMÔNLc VYa aKÔ\ VO‘OV] N_\SXQ ZO\SYN] YP aKÔ\]MK\MS^c$ aROX Z\SY\S^c aK] QS‘OX ^Y S\\SQK^SYX\OVOK]O]& 8\KSXKQO PVYa] P\YW ^RO Z\YTOM^ RK‘OKV]Y KPPOMÔN ^RO ]KVSXS^c$ aKÔ\ VO‘OV] KXNP\O[_OXMc YP WK\SXO ObMRKXQO SX ^RO MYK]^KVVKQYYX]& GRO Y‘O\KVV MK^MRWOX^ Z\YN_M^SYXZYÔX^SKV RK] SXM\OK]ON Lc KLY_^ /- ZO\MOX^ SXY_^Z_^ Ô\W]$ L_^ Lc YXVc )( *- ZO\MOX^ SX ‘KV_OÔ\W] QS‘OX K NOMVSXO SX ^RO Z\OWS_W ]R\SWZPS]RO\c SX ^RO VKQYYX]&

<YaO‘O\$ aRSVO ^RO SWZKM^ YP MYX]^\_M^SYXRK] LOOX ^Y SXM\OK]O ^RO KQQ\OQKÔ ZYÔX^SKVZ\YN_M^S‘S^c YP PS]RO\SO] SX ^RO MK^MRWOX^$]MROWO YZO\K^SYX KXN aKÔ\ WKXKQOWOX^ RK]RKN K XOQK^S‘O SWZKM^ YX ^RO KM^_KV Z\YN_M^SYXYP ^RO Z\O%ObS]^SXQ \O]O\‘YS\] KXN VKQYYX]& =XMYWLSXK^SYX aS^R PKSV_\O ^Y OPPOM^S‘OVc OXPY\MOKMMO]] \O]^\SM^SYX]$ \O]_V^SXQ Y‘O\PS]RSXQ KXN ^ROOPPOM^] YP \OMOX^ N\Y_QR^$ ^RS] RK] NOQ\KNON PS]R]^YMU] KXN N\S‘OX PS]RSXQ ^YaK\N] LOSXQ VS^^VOWY\O ^RKX KX YZZY\^_XS]^SM KXN \O]SN_KV ]Y_\MOYP VS‘OVSRYYN PY\ RY_]ORYVN] aS^R POa Y^RO\KVÔ\XK^S‘O]& ;S‘OX VYMKV ZYZ_VK^SYX Q\Ya^R KXN_XOWZVYcWOX^ \KÔ] ^RS] RK] Z\Y‘SNON KXSWZY\^KX^ ]YMSKV ]KPO^c%XO^$ KVLOS^ K^ VYa%SXMYWOVO‘OV]& 5VÔ\XK^S‘O VS‘OVSRYYN] PY\ ^ROOMYXYWSMKVVc WK\QSXKVSdON$ ]_MR K] PS\OaYYNMYVVOM^SYX$ ]ROVV WSXSXQ KXN VSWO WKUSXQ ÔXN ^YLO WY\O OX‘S\YXWOX^KVVc NKWKQSXQ&

=WZ\Y‘OWOX^] SX aKÔ\ WKXKQOWOX^ KM\Y]]^RO ?S\SXNK CcK =\\SQK^SYX KXN FO^^VOWOX^ D\YTOM^"?C=FD# MK^MRWOX^ ^R_] RK‘O ^RO ZYÔX^SKV ^YNOVS‘O\ K \KXQO YP OX‘S\YXWOX^KV$ ]YMSKV KXNOMYXYWSM LOXOPS^]& D\YN_M^S‘O PS]RO\SO] MKX LO\O]^Y\ON SX \O]O\‘YS\] SP ]K‘SXQ] MKX LO WKNO SX^RO aKÔ\ XOON] YP PK\WSXQ$ KXN WKXKQOWOX^

‘SS

\OQSWO] MKX ^KUO KMMY_X^ YP WSXSW_W VO‘OV]XOONON ^Y MYX]O\‘O ]_]^KSXKLVO PS]R ]^YMU]&AY\O \O]OK\MR S] \O[_S\ON YX ^RO OMYVYQc YP ^ROMYK]^KV VKQYYX]$ L_^ ]SWSVK\Vc K Z\YN_M^S‘O PS]RO\cMKX ZYÔX^SKVVc LO \O]^Y\ON& 5X KZZ\YZ\SKÔ ZYVSMcWSb S] XOONON$ aRSMR MKX WKSX^KSX ^RO \YVO YPPS]RO\SO] K] K ]YMSKV ]KPO^c%XO^ KVYXQ aS^RZ\YWY^SYX YP ]WKVV%]MKVO MYWWO\MSKV PS]RO\SO] SX^RO VK\QO\ \O]O\‘YS\]$ KXN \OQ_VK^SYX PY\OX‘S\YXWOX^KV M\SÔ\SK YP K \ORKLSVS^KÔN PS]RO\c SX^RO VKQYYX]&

G\KX]PO\KLVO VO]]YX] MKX LO N\KaX P\YW^RO]O MK]O] PY\ W_V^SZVO%_]O WKXKQOWOX^ YPS\\SQK^SYX ]c]ÔW] "ZK\^SM_VK\Vc$ S\\SQKÔN \SMO]c]ÔW]# aS^RSX ^RO MYXÔb^ YP SXM\OK]SXQ aKÔ\]MK\MS^c KXN XOON PY\ SXÔQ\KÔN aKÔ\ \O]Y_\MOWKXKQOWOX^ "=JEA#& GRO ]^_NSO] ]RYa ^RK^K[_K^SM ]c]ÔW] WYNSPSON Lc S\\SQK^SYX MKX ]^SVV]_ZZY\^ PS]RO\SO] Z\Y‘SNON K^ÔX^SYX S] ZKSN ^Y ^ROUOc MRK\KMÔ\S]^SM] YP Z\O%ObS]^SXQ RKLS^K^] KXN ^Y^RO NO]SQX KXN YZO\K^SYX YP S\\SQK^SYXSXP\K]^\_M^_\O& =XÔQ\K^SYX YP VKXN$ aKÔ\ KXNPS]RO\c WKXKQOWOX^ S] M\_MSKV ^Y KMRSO‘SXQYZ^SWKV _]O YP aKÔ\ PY\ PK\W KXN PS]RZ\YN_M^SYX$ KXN PY\ VS‘OVSRYYN YLTOM^S‘O]&

<YaO‘O\$ aRSVO SWZKM^] YX LSYNS‘O\]S^c KXNOMYVYQSMKV SXÔQ\S^c "YPÔX ^RO PYM_] YPOX‘S\YXWOX^KV SWZKM^ K]]O]]WOX^]# MKX LOMVY]OVc VSXUON aS^R Z\YN_M^SYX KXN VS‘OVSRYYN]SWZKM^]$ ^RS] S] XY^ XOMO]]K\SVc ^RO MK]O& =X ^ROâY MK]O] SX‘O]^SQKÔN PS]RO\SO] Z\YN_M^SYX KXNVS‘OVSRYYN YZZY\^_XS^SO] MKX LO SWZ\Y‘ON LcS\\SQK^SYX NO‘OVYZWOX^ NO]ZSÔ XOQK^S‘O SWZKM^]YX LSYNS‘O\]S^c KXN OMYVYQSMKV SXÔQ\S^c&

GRO ]^_NSO] KV]Y ]RYa ^RK^ SWZKM^K]]O]]WOX^] MKX N\Ka YX ObS]^SXQ UXYaVONQO ^YSNOX^SPc WOK]_\O] ^Y WS^SQKÔ Y\ OXRKXMO SWZKM^]YX PS]RO\SO]$ KV^RY_QR VYMK^SYX KXN ]c]ÔW%]ZOMSPSMUXYaVONQO QKZ] KXN \O]OK\MR \O[_S\OWOX^] WKc\OWKSX& GRO SWZY\^KXMO YP \OMYQXSdSXQ ^RONS‘O\]S^c YP P_XM^SYX] ^RK^ PS]RSXQ WKc ZO\PY\WaS^RSX ^RO VS‘OVSRYYN ]^\KÔQSO] YP \_\KV RY_]ORYVN]S] NOWYX]^\KÔN$ K] aOVV K] ^RO XOON PY\ KXKXKVc]S] ^RK^ S] NS]KQQ\OQKÔN Lc VYMK^SYX KXN Lc]YMSYOMYXYWSM Q\Y_Z& =^ S] ]RYaX SX F\S @KXUK^RK^ S^ S] aY\^R MYXN_M^SXQ K]]O]]WOX^] PY\YZO\K^SYXKV K] aOVV K] ZVKXXON ]MROWO]& :SXKVVc$K \KXQO YP LOXOPS^] NO\S‘ON P\YW QOX_SXO]^KUORYVNO\ SX‘YV‘OWOX^ SX ZVKXXSXQ KXN SWZKM^K]]O]]WOX^ S] NOWYX]^\KÔN&

,

*AFDB7G6F<BA

@‘UdWSe[‘Y SffW‘f[a‘ [e TW[‘Y bS[V fa fZWeaU[aWUa‘a_[U S‘V W‘h[da‘_W‘fS^ [_bSUfe aX fZWVWhWâb_W‘f’ WjbS‘e[a‘ ad Ua‘f[‘gSf[a‘ aX[dd[YSfWV SYd[Ug^fgdW $[‘U^gV[‘Y SeeaU[SfWV VS_e’dWeWdha[de S‘V afZWd [‘XdSefdgUfgdW% i[fZ[‘ fZWUa‘fWjf aX Za^[ef[U S‘V [‘fWYdSfWV _S‘SYW_W‘f aXiSfWd dWeagdUWe S‘V d[hWd TSe[‘e) JZ[e ZSeW_bZSe[lWV fZW ‘WWV Xad _g^f[b^W(geW_S‘SYW_W‘f aX [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_e’ S‘V [_bdahWVSbbdaSUZWe Xad fZW b^S‘‘[‘Y’ [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fS‘V _S‘SYW_W‘f aX [dd[YSf[a‘ bda\WUfe) 8‘[_badfS‘f bSdf aX fZ[e [e fZW SeeWee_W‘f S‘V_S‘SYW_W‘f aX [dd[YSf[a‘ [_bSUfe a‘ [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We’ iZ[UZ US‘ TW bSdf[Ug^Sd^k UZS^^W‘Y[‘YY[hW‘ TafZ fZW dS‘YW S‘V Ua_b^Wj[fk aX [eegWefZSf _Sk ‘WWV fa TW SVVdWeeWV’ S‘V fZWUa__a‘ VWX[U[W‘U[We [‘ ]‘ai^WVYW aX fZWZkVdaâYk S‘V WUaâYk aX _S‘k XdWeZiSfWdekefW_e S‘V fZW ^[hW^[ZaaVe fZSf SdW VWbW‘VW‘fa‘ fZW_)

JZW ^WhW^ aX Ua_b^Wj[fk S‘V’ fZWdWXadW’ fZWUaef aX [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f _gef TW dWSea‘ST^W[‘ dW^Sf[a‘ fa fZW _SY‘[fgVW aX fZW WjbWUfWV[_bSUf S‘V fZW fafS^ bda\WUf Uaef) 8e SUa‘eWcgW‘UW’ fZW f[_W S‘V dWeagdUWe ShS[^ST^WXad X[eZWd[We [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe SdW ^[]W^k fa TW^[_[fWV’ UWdfS[‘^k Xad [‘[f[S^ SeeWee_W‘fe’ S‘V_adW YW‘WdS^^k Xad S^^ Tgf fZW ^SdYWef bda\WUfeS‘V _aef e[Y‘[X[US‘f USeWe) JZ[e _WS‘e fZSfSbbdS[eS^ _WfZaVe SdW ‘WWVWV’ S‘V fZWk eZag^V

TW bdSUf[US^ S‘V âi(Uaef’ iZ[^W ef[^^ USbST^W aXYW‘WdSf[‘Y dWeg^fe fZSf XSU[^[fSfW [‘Xad_WVVWU[e[a‘(_S][‘Y a‘ eUZW_W Ua‘efdgUf[a‘’dWZST[^[fSf[a‘ ad _S‘SYW_W‘f) JZ[e dWbadfbdWeW‘fe fZW dWeg^fe aX [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘feUa‘VgUfWV Xad fZ[e bgdbaeW [‘ CSae S‘V Id[CS‘]S)

8‘ Wj(S‘fW SbbdS[eS^ aX S ,’+++ ZWUfSdW[dd[YSf[a‘ bda\WUf [‘ CSae’ S‘V S‘ Wj(baefWhS^gSf[a‘ aX S ,+’+++ ZWUfSdW [dd[YSf[a‘ S‘VeWff^W_W‘f eUZW_W [‘ Id[ CS‘]S iWdWUa_b^WfWV) 9afZ Ua‘UWd‘WV [dd[YSf[a‘VWhWâb_W‘f [‘ d[UW(TSeWV XSd_[‘Y ekefW_eiZWdW _S‘(_SVW ZST[fSfe ^[]W dS[‘(XWV d[UWX[W^Ve [‘ CSae S‘V S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de [‘ Id[CS‘]S Ua‘fd[TgfWV egTefS‘f[S^^k fa fZW fafS^ScgSf[U ZST[fSf S‘V X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ WSUZUag‘fdk) JZW [_bSUfe fZWdWXadW aUUgddWV i[fZ[‘Ug^fgdS^ ^S‘VeUSbWe fZSf iWdW S^dWSVkegTefS‘f[S^^k _aV[X[WV Xda_ fZW[d bd[ef[‘W efSfW)JZW XaUge iSe a‘ [_bSUfe aX [dd[YSf[a‘ a‘ fZWT[abZke[US^ W‘h[da‘_W‘f’ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[h[fkS‘V dgdS^ ^[hW^[ZaaVe dSfZWd fZS‘ T[aV[hWde[fk)JdS‘eXWdST^W ^Weea‘e SdW [VW‘f[X[WV Xad fZW_g^f[b^W(geW _S‘SYW_W‘f aX [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_e$bSdf[Ug^Sd^k’ [dd[YSfWV d[UW ekefW_e% i[fZ[‘ fZWUa‘fWjf aX [‘UdWSe[‘Y iSfWd eUSdU[fk S‘V fZW‘WWV Xad @MHD’ S‘V Xad fZW bdSUf[UW aXW‘h[da‘_W‘fS^ [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f Xad [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We)

$14’(76 3+ $55.,’7.32 32 $20’2) #.6-*5.*6! "445’.6’06.2 %’36 ’2) &5. %’2/’

EZ[STP @R‘dPY%=SZL$ >L‘]PYNP EXT_S LYO =LT >Z]PYePY

-

=[eZWd[We SdW fZW Wjbâ[fSf[a‘ aX ‘SfgdS^ ^[h[‘YScgSf[U dWeagdUWe ZW^V [‘ ea_W Xad_ aX Ua__a‘bdabWdfk dWY[_W’ [‘ Ua‘fdSef fa ScgSUg^fgdW’iZ[UZ [_b^[We SUf[hW ZgeTS‘Vdk S‘V bd[hSfWai‘WdeZ[b aX efaU]e) @‘ fZ[e efgVk’ [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We dWXWd fa XdWeZiSfWd ekefW_e $[‘U^gV[‘Y Si[VW dS‘YW aX ZST[fSfe egUZ Se d[hWde’ ^S]We S‘ViWf^S‘Ve% Se iW^^ Se ^SUgefd[‘W S‘V WefgSd[‘WekefW_e) Ja fZW WjfW‘f fZSf SUUWee [e abW‘ fa S^^S‘V X[eZ[‘Y dWcg[dWe XWi dWeagdUWe’ X[eZWd[We US‘TW S e[Y‘[X[US‘f eagdUW aX ^[hW^[ZaaV’ WebWU[S^^kXad fZW baad bWab^W) C[hW^[ZaaV Xg‘Uf[a‘e US‘dS‘YW Xda_ S‘ SUf[h[fk aX ^Sef dWeadf fZdagYZ bSdfaX S fdSV[f[a‘S^ S‘V V[hWde[X[WV egTe[efW‘UWefdSfWYk $gegS^^k [‘fWYdSfWV i[fZ XSd_[‘Y S‘VUa^^WUf[a‘ aX afZWd i[^V XaaVe%’ fa S Xg^^(f[_W S‘V_Sd]Wf(ad[W‘fWV aUUgbSf[a‘ $CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^)-++/6 I_[fZ Wf S^) -++0%)

JZW [_badfS‘UW aX [‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We fa^[hW^[ZaaVe [‘ VWhWâb[‘Y Uag‘fd[We’ S‘V [‘bSdf[Ug^Sd fZW SUUWee[T[^[fk S‘V [_badfS‘UW aXfZWeW X[eZWd[We fa fZW dgdS^ baad’ ZSe a‘^kdWUW‘f^k TWW‘ Xg^^k dWUaY‘[lWV) HgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve[‘ âUSf[a‘e Se V[hWdeW Se fZW âiWd DW]a‘Y$>gff_S‘‘ ,4446 CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++6 AW‘eW‘-++,%’ fZW 8_Sla‘ $8^_W[VS Wf S^) -++-% S‘VfZW CS]W :ZSV TSe[‘ [‘ 8Xd[US $9m‘m S‘VEW[^S‘V -++.% fkb[US^^k aTfS[‘ TWfiWW‘ ,+bWdUW‘f S‘V .+ bWdUW‘f aX fZW[d fafS^ [‘Ua_WXda_ [‘^S‘V X[eZ[‘Y) ;Web[fW fZ[e Sdf[eS‘S^X[eZWd[We SdW aXfW‘ ‘WY^WUfWV Tk ba^[Uk_S]WdeS‘V b^S‘‘Wde’ iZa dWYSdV fZ[e [_badfS‘f^[hW^[ZaaV fa TW _WdW^k S‘ SUf[h[fk aX ^Sef dWeadfS‘V S dWXgYW Xad fZW WUa‘a_[US^^k S‘V eaU[S^^k_SdY[‘S^[lWV) =[eZ[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve SdW Ua__a‘^kbWdUW[hWV Se TW[‘Y bSdf aX S V[ef[‘Uf eaU[S^Ydagb’ fkb[US^^k S_a‘Y fZW baadWef S‘V _aefVWbd[hWV $Se VW_a‘efdSfWV Tk dWh[Wie aX fZW^[fWdSfgdW Tk 8^^[ea‘ S‘V <^^[e -++,6 9m‘m -++.%’S‘V W‘YSYWV a‘^k [‘ X[eZ[‘Y) @‘ Ua‘fdSef’ bWab^WiZaeW ^[hW^[ZaaVe [‘ha^hW X[eZ[‘Y’ Tgf ‘af Se fZW[dbd[_Sdk ad [‘Ua_W(VWX[‘[‘Y SUf[h[fk’ SUUag‘f XadfZW ^SdYWef eZSdW aX [‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We USfUZWe)MW^^ ahWd 4+ bWdUW‘f aX fZW USfUZ [‘ CSae’ Xad

WjS_b^W $CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++%’ S‘V WhW‘ [‘ fZWâiWd 8_Sla‘’ iZWdW fZWdW [e S iW^^(VWhWâbWVUa__WdU[S^ X[eZWdk’ bSdf(f[_W egTe[efW‘UW X[eZ[‘Yef[^^ SUUag‘fe Xad Sf ^WSef fia(fZ[dVe aX fZWX[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ $8^_W[VS Wf S^& -++-%)

8UUadV[‘Y fa ‘Wf dWfgd‘ Xâie’ [dd[YSf[a‘ [e SUa‘eg_bf[hW geW aX iSfWd’ S‘V Se [f [e fZW^SdYWef geW aX iSfWd Tk ha^g_W [‘ _aefVWhWâb[‘Y Uag‘fd[We’ [f [_bSUfe a‘ WUaekefW_eS‘V fZW X[eZWd[We fZWk egbbadf _adW efda‘Y^kfZS‘ _aef afZWd Zg_S‘ SUf[h[f[We) @dd[YSf[a‘[‘fW‘f[a‘S^^k V[efgdTe fZW ‘SfgdS^ ZkVdaâY[USêkefW_ fa [‘UdWSeW SYd[Ug^fgdS^ bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘VUS‘ ZShW _g^f[b^W V[dWUf S‘V [‘V[dWUf WXXWUfe a‘fZW ‘SfgdS^ S‘V eaU[aWUa‘a_[U W‘h[da‘_W‘f [‘fZW USfUZ_W‘f SdWS) @‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We US‘ TWSXXWUfWV bae[f[hW^k ad ‘WYSf[hW^k’ S‘V fZdagYZUa_b^Wj S‘V hSd[WV _WS‘e) 9k UZS‘Y[‘Y fZWahWdS^^ ShS[^ST[^[fk S‘V WUaâY[US^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk aX‘SfgdS^ ScgSf[U ZST[fSfe [‘ fZW d[hWd TSe[‘’[dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_e $bSdf[Ug^Sd^k’ VS_e% SXXWUf fZWbdaVgUf[h[fk S‘V V[hWde[fk aX [‘^S‘V ScgSf[UdWeagdUWe $=8G,2 ,4406 GWfd ,4436 ?S^ê Wf S^),4446 CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++6 M:; -+++’EYgkW‘(BZaS Wf S^) -++.6 8dfZ[‘Yfa‘ Wf S^)-++/%) @_bSUfe a‘ fZW da^W aX X[eZ[‘Y [‘ dgdS^^[hW^[ZaaVe _Sk Sd[eW Se S Ua‘eWcgW‘UW aX fZWeWUZS‘YWe’ ad Se S dWeg^f aX UZS‘YWe [‘ bZke[US^SUUWee[T[^[fk ad d[YZfe aX SUUWee fa iSfWd TaV[We$X[eZ[‘Y Ydag‘Ve%’ S‘V [‘ WUa‘a_[U abbadfg‘[f[We$CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++6 I_[fZ Wf S^) -++,%)

8^fZagYZ dWUaY‘[f[a‘ aX fZW [_badfS‘UW aX[‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We ZSe Ydai‘ S‘V ]‘ai^WVYW STagffZW_ [e [_bdah[‘Y $Xad WjS_b^W’ fZSf Ua_b[^WV TkfZW Mad^V :a__[ee[a‘ a‘ ;S_e’ M:; -+++%’_S‘k YSbe dW_S[‘’ S‘V S ^SU] aX âUSf[a‘(ebWU[X[UTSeW^[‘W VSfS [e ^[]W^k fa TW S Ua‘efdS[‘f fa fZW[_bdahWV b^S‘‘[‘Y S‘V [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aX [dd[YSf[a‘bda\WUfe) I[_[^Sd^k’ fZW ShS[^ST[^[fk aX [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ faYg[VW fZW SeeWee_W‘f aX fZW _WUZS‘[e_e S‘V_SY‘[fgVWe aX baee[T^W [_bSUfe aX [dd[YSf[a‘VWhWâb_W‘f [e ^[_[fWV) H[Yadage S‘V cgS‘f[X[WV[_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe SdW ShS[^ST^W a‘^k Xad S XWiekefW_e’ ‘afST^k XâaV Ua‘fda^ S‘V [dd[YSf[a‘

3;8 *@CBDF5A68 B9 %CCD5<E<A: F;8 *@C56FE B9 *DD<:5F<BA BA *A?5A7(<E;8D<8E

.

eUZW_We [‘ 9S‘Y^SVWeZ $?S^̂ e Wf S^) ,444% S‘Ve_S^^*_WV[g_(eUS^W [dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We [‘ CSae$CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++6 EYgkW‘(BZaS Wf S^) -++.%)8bSdf Xda_ fZWeW WjUWbf[a‘e’ _aef SeeWee_W‘feUa‘VgUfWV fa VSfW ZShW XaUgeWV a‘ T[abZke[US^S‘V WUaâY[US^ [_bSUfe $eWW Xad WjS_b^W’ CSd[‘[Wd-+++6 9[lWd -+++6 ASU]ea‘ S‘V DSd_g^^S -++,%’S‘V fZWdW ZShW TWW‘ XWi SffW_bfe Sf S _adW

[‘fWYdSfWV SeeWee_W‘f fZSf fS]We [‘fa SUUag‘f fZWXg^^ dS‘YW aX [_bSUfe a‘ bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V fZWeaU[aWUa‘a_k [‘ SVV[f[a‘ fa T[abZke[US^ [_bSUfe)JZ[e VWSdfZ ZSe bda_bfWV dWeWSdUZ [‘ fZ[e SdWS fa[_bdahW fZW Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘e [f i[^^ _S]W fa fZWg‘VWdefS‘V[‘Y aX X[eZWd[We S‘V baee[T^W UZS‘YWeidagYZf gba‘ fZW_ Tk fZW VWhWâb_W‘f aX[dd[YSf[a‘)

%CCDB56; 5A7 -8F;B7B?B:J

0D<A6<C?8E

:^WSd^k’ [_bSUfe a‘ [‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We eZag^V TWUa‘e[VWdWV [‘ fZW b^S‘‘[‘Y S‘V _S‘SYW_W‘f aX[dd[YSf[a‘’ Tgf fZW V[hWde[fk S‘V Ua_b^Wj[fk aX[_bSUfe _S]We fZ[e V[XX[Ug^f) JZ[e dWeWSdUZXaUgeWV a‘ fZW dW^Sf[a‘eZ[b TWfiWW‘ [dd[YSf[a‘S‘V X[eZWd[We S‘V Zai [f [_bSUfe a‘ X[eZbdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V ^[hW [̂ZaaVe’ iZWdWSe _aefWj[ef[‘Y efgV[We ZShW Ua‘UW‘fdSfWV a‘^k a‘[_bSUfe a‘ X[eZ WUaâYk) 8 dS‘YW aX SbbdaSUZWeZShW TWW‘ geWV’ _aef^k XaUge[‘Y a‘ fZWWUaâY[US^ [_bSUfe aX _aV[X[USf[a‘e fa d[hWd XâieS‘V â‘Y[fgV[‘S^ ZST[fSf Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk $9[lWd -+++6ASU]ea‘ S‘V DSd_g^^S -++,6 8dfZ[‘Yfa‘ Wf S^)-++.%’ Tgf iZ[^W geWXg^ Xad SVVdWee[‘Y [eegWe aXT[aV[hWde[fk Ua‘eWdhSf[a‘ S‘V WUaâY[US^ [‘fWYd[fk’fZWeW dSdW^k SVWcgSfW^k USbfgdW fZW [_bSUfe a‘bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaVe) @‘VWWV’ V[dWUf[‘XWdW‘UWe Xad bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaVe US‘‘afSîSke TW _SVW Se fZW âee aX UWdfS[‘ ZST[fSffkbWe ad ZST[fSf Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk US‘ USgeW S âee aXT[aV[hWde[fk ad WUaâY[US^ [‘fWYd[fk i[fZagfefda‘Y^k SXXWUf[‘Y ahWdS^^ bdaVgUf[a‘ ^WhWê):a‘hWdeW^k S cgS‘f[fSf[hW dWVgUf[a‘ [‘ fZW WjfW‘faX ZST[fSf _Sk USgeW S bdabadf[a‘S^ VWU^[‘W [‘X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ i[fZagf YdWSf âee aXV[hWde[fk) I[_[^Sd^k’ [_bSUfe a‘ ^[hW [̂ZaaVe US‘ TWhSd[WV S‘V V[XX[Ug^f fa bdWV[Uf’ S‘V fZW Wj[ef[‘Y]‘ai^WVYW aX ^[hW^[ZaaVe [_bSUfe [e dW^Sf[hW^kiWS] $W)Y)’ 8VS_e -+++6 I_[fZ Wf S^) -++,%) @‘^[hW^[ZaaV fWd_e’ SUUWee fa X[eZWd[We dWeagdUWe Sf

Ud[f[US^ f[_We aX fZW kWSd’ UâeW fa fZW ViW^^[‘Y ad[‘ f[_We aX ZSdVeZ[b’ _Sk TW _adW [_badfS‘ffZS‘ ahWdS^^ ^WhWê aX bdaVgUf[a‘ ad fZW ebWU[WeUa_bae[f[a‘ aX USfUZWe)

8e ‘afWV fZW Uaef aX [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f_gef TW ]Wbf i[fZ[‘ Sbbdabd[SfW ^[_[fe) @VWS^^k’d[Yadage SeeWee_W‘f aX fZW bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V^[hW^[ZaaV [_bSUfe aX [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘fdWcg[dWe TWXadW hWdege SXfWd S‘V*ad [_bSUfWVhWdege Ua‘fda^ SdWS efgV[We’ i[fZ SVWcgSfWdWb^[USf[a‘ aX e[fWe S‘V*ad eS_b^[‘Y aX SXXWUfWVZageWZa^Ve) ;SfS Xda_ egUZ efgV[We SdWShS[^ST^W Xad a‘^k S XWi ekefW_e’ ‘afST^k XâaVUa‘fda^ S‘V [dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We [‘ 9S‘Y^SVWeZ$?S^ê Wf S^) ,444% S‘V e_S^^( S‘V _WV[g_(eUS^W[dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We [‘ CSae $CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++6EYgkW‘(BZaS Wf S^) -++.%) JZW f[_W S‘VdWeagdUWe ‘WWVWV Xad egUZ [‘hWef[YSf[a‘e SdWe[Y‘[X[US‘f’ S‘V [‘ fZW Ua‘fWjf aX b^S‘‘[‘Y [f [eS^_aef SîSke ‘WUWeeSdk fa SbbdS[eW [_bSUfeTWXadW egUZ d[Yadage SeeWee_W‘fe SdW ShS[^ST^W)

8e S dWeg^f’ WhW‘ fZagYZ âUSf[a‘(ebWU[X[UVSfS i[^^ gegS^^k TW ^SU][‘Y’ [‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We[_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe i[^^ ZShW fa dW^k a‘dW^Sf[hW^k e[_b^W _WfZaVe S‘V ^[_[fWV bd[_SdkVSfS Ua^^WUf[a‘) Ja SVVdWee fZ[e’ W_bZSe[e iSeb^SUWV a‘ fZW \gV[U[age geW aX Ua_bSdSf[hWW_b[d[US^ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ S‘V fZW g‘VWdefS‘V[‘Y aX_WUZS‘[e_e’ i[fZ[‘ S bdaUWee TSeWV a‘ WjbWdf\gVY_W‘f’ âUS^ ]‘ai^WVYW S‘V efS]WZa^VWdbSdf[U[bSf[a‘) JZW S[_ iSe S‘ [‘fWYdSfWVSeeWee_W‘f aX bZke[US^’ eaU[aWUa‘a_[U S‘V

/

afZWd USgeS^ XSUfade aX [_bSUfe$ S‘V USbfgdW aXfZW âUS^ ]‘ai^WVYW’ bWdebWUf[hWe S‘V hS^[VSf[a‘fZSf US‘ TW VWd[hWV Xda_ YW‘g[‘W bSdf[U[bSf[a‘ TkefS]WZa^VWde) JZ[e W‘ST^WV S dW^Sf[hW^k dSb[VSeeWee_W‘f aX Ydaee bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaVe[_bSUfe fa TW _SVW’ ^WSV[‘Y fa fZW [VW‘f[X[USf[a‘aX abbadfg‘[f[We Xad fZW _[f[YSf[a‘ aX ‘WYSf[hW’ adfZW W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f aX bae[f[hW [_bSUfe)

JZ[e UaddWeba‘Ve fa fZW bd[‘U[b^We S‘VbdSUf[UW aX <‘h[da‘_W‘fS^ @_bSUf 8eeWee_W‘f$<@8% $MaaV ,440% S‘V fZ[e bdah[VWV SXdS_Wiad] Xad fZW iad] dWbadfWV ZWdW) ;[ef[‘Uf[hWXWSfgdWe [‘U^gVWV fZW W_bZSe[e b^SUWV a‘5 [% SZa^[ef[U S‘V [‘fWYdSfWV SeeWee_W‘f $ZkVdaâYk’WUaâYk’ [‘ef[fgf[a‘e’ eaU[aWUa‘a_[Ue S‘V^[hW^[ZaaVe%6 [[% fZW YW‘g[‘W bSdf[U[bSf[a‘ aXefS]WZa^VWde6 S‘V [[[% SVSbfSf[a‘ S‘V [fWdSf[a‘i[fZ[‘ S eWcgW‘f[S^ bdaUWee) >[hW‘ fZWbSdf[U[bSfadk S‘V SVSbf[hW ‘SfgdW aX fZWSbbdaSUZ’ fZW [VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ aX ]Wk [eegWe S‘VeW^WUf[a‘ aX _WS‘e Xad fZW[d SeeWee_W‘fW_WdYWV Xda_ S VW^[TWdSfW^k [fWdSf[hW bdaUWeedSfZWd fZS‘ Se W^W_W‘fe aX S VWfS[^WV bd[addWeWSdUZ VWe[Y‘)

JZW SbbdaSUZ SVabfWV [e XgdfZWd VaUg_W‘fWV[‘ S >g[VS‘UW DS‘gS^ Xad fZW DS‘SYW_W‘f aX@_bSUfe aX @dd[YSf[a‘ ;WhWâb_W‘f a‘ =[eZWd[We$CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -++/%’ S‘V [e Sêa VWeUd[TWV S‘VWhS^gSfWV [‘ YdWSfWd VWfS[^ [‘ EYgkW‘(BZaS Wf S^)$-++0%) @f iSe Ua‘e[VWdWV Sbbdabd[SfW Xad fZWSbbdS[eS^ aX [dd[YSf[a‘ bda\WUfe aX fZW eUS^WUa‘e[VWdWV ZWdW) DgUZ ^SdYWd bda\WUfe _Sk TWWjUWbf[a‘e’ Xad iZ[UZ egTefS‘f[S^ bd[_Sdk VSfSUa^^WUf[a‘ S‘V fZW geW aX _adW W^STadSfWS‘S^kf[US^ _aVWê _Sk TW \gef[X[WV) @‘ SVV[f[a‘V[dWUf S‘V dWbdWeW‘fSf[hW efS]WZa^VWd bSdf[U[bSf[a‘_Sk TW _adW V[XX[Ug^f fa SUZ[WhW Sf ^SdYWd eUS^Wead _Sk dWcg[dW S V[XXWdW‘f SbbdaSUZ)

2F5:8E B9 F;8 0DB68EE

JZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe [‘ha^hWV V[ef[‘Uf efSYWeaX eUdWW‘[‘Y’ eUab[‘Y’ SeeWee_W‘f’ S‘V[VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ aX _[f[YSf[a‘ ad W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f

abf[a‘e) ;WU[e[a‘e fa [_b^W_W‘f S bda\WUf’ S‘V*ad[_bSUf _[f[YSf[a‘ S‘V W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f _WSegdWe’iag^V TW Xa^âiWV Tk fZW [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aX fZWbda\WUf S‘V fZWdWSXfWd’ _a‘[fad[‘Y S‘V WhS^gSf[a‘aX [fe abWdSf[a‘)

JZW SeeWee_W‘fe iWdW USdd[WV agf [‘ fZ[eeWcgW‘f[S^ bdaUWee’ Tg[^f Sdag‘V S eWd[We aXefS]WZa^VWd iad]eZabe) JZWeW iad]eZabe iWdW[‘fWdebWdeWV i[fZ bWd[aVe aX X[W^Viad] [‘U^gV[‘YfZW Ua^^WUf[a‘ S‘V dWh[Wi aX eWUa‘VSdk[‘Xad_Sf[a‘’ dSb[V egdhWke S‘V Ua‘eg^fSf[a‘ i[fZ]Wk [‘Xad_S‘fe) =ad WSUZ SeeWee_W‘f’ S]‘ai^WVYW TSeW iSe SeeW_T^WV Tk S _g^f[(V[eU[b^[‘Sdk fWS_ aX ebWU[S^[efe $X[eZWd[We WUaâYkS‘V _S‘SYW_W‘f’ [dd[YSf[a‘ W‘Y[‘WWd[‘Y S‘V_S‘SYW_W‘f’ SYd[Ug^fgdS^ WUa‘a_[Ue’ S‘V[‘ef[fgf[a‘S^ S‘S^ke[e% S‘V fZWeW iWdW geWV faegbbadf fZW S‘S^keWe Ua‘VgUfWV i[fZefS]WZa^VWde Sf fZW iad]eZabe)

Screening and scoping

@‘[f[S^ eUdWW‘[‘Y S‘V eUab[‘Y iWdW USdd[WV agf faSeeWee iZWfZWd [_bSUfe a‘ X[eZWd[We iWdW ^[]W^k’S‘V iZSf fZW UZSdSUfWd aX egUZ [_bSUfe _[YZfTW) =ad fZ[e S bdW^[_[‘Sdk SeeWee_W‘f iSe _SVWTSeWV a‘ S dWh[Wi aX Wj[ef[‘Y [‘Xad_Sf[a‘’dWUa‘‘S[eeS‘UW egdhWke’ [‘fWdh[Wie i[fZ ]Wk[‘Xad_S‘fe $YahWd‘_W‘f aXX[UWde’ âUS^dWeWSdUZWde S‘V Ua__g‘[fk ^WSVWde% S‘V [‘[f[Sîad]eZabe i[fZ efS]WZa^VWde) IUdWW‘[‘Y fZW‘[‘ha^hWV fZW VWfWd_[‘Sf[a‘ aX iZWfZWd S‘ [_bSUfSeeWee_W‘f iSe \gef[X[WV’ TSeWV a‘ [VW‘f[X[USf[a‘aX fZW ‘SfgdW S‘V bafW‘f[S^ [_badfS‘UW aXbaee[T^W [_bSUfe a‘ X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘’ ^[hW^[ZaaVeS‘V T[aV[hWde[fk) JZ[e iSe Xa^âiWV Tk eUab[‘Y’iZ[UZ S[_WV fa VWX[‘W iZSf ‘WWVWV fa TW_WSegdWV S‘V Zai [f iag^V TW _WSegdWV Y[hW‘ShS[^ST^W dWeagdUWe $f[_W’ TgVYWf S‘V Zg_S‘dWeagdUWe%) IUab[‘Y bd[_Sd[^k dW^[WV a‘ fZWdWeg^fe aX fZW bdW^[_[‘Sdk SeeWee_W‘f’ TgfUa‘f[‘gWV fZdagYZagf fZW bdaUWee’ ea fZSf fZWeUabW aX fZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f Uag^V TWSV\gefWV fa fS]W SUUag‘f aX ‘Wi [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ adUZS‘Y[‘Y U[dUg_efS‘UWe)

0

Impact Assessment

JZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f XaUgeWV a‘ fZW ]Wk[eegWe [VW‘f[X[WV Vgd[‘Y eUab[‘Y’ S‘V [‘ha^hWVXagd SUf[h[f[We)

[%) JZW VWeUd[bf[a‘ aX fZW bda\WUf)

[[%) JZW VWeUd[bf[a‘ aX fZW UgddW‘f $TSeW^[‘W%e[fgSf[a‘) 8‘S^ke[e iSe _S[‘^k VWeUd[bf[hWS‘V eg__Sf[hW Se fZW S[_ iSe fa VaUg_W‘fS‘V g‘VWdefS‘V fZW UgddW‘f e[fgSf[a‘ Se STSe[e Xad WhS^gSf[‘Y bda\WUf [_bSUfe)

[[[%) JZW SeeWee_W‘f aX bda\WUf [_bSUfe) JZ[edWcg[dWe S Ua_bSd[ea‘ aX fZW i[fZ hWdegefZW i[fZagf [dd[YSf[a‘ eUW‘Sd[ae ahWd SebWU[X[WV bWd[aV aX f[_W Xad S Y[hW‘[‘fWdhW‘f[a‘ ad [‘hWef_W‘f) @‘ fZW USeW aX fZWWj(S‘fW SeeWee_W‘f fZ[e faa] fZW Xad_ aX SUa_bSd[ea‘ TWfiWW‘ fZW UgddW‘f bdW(bda\WUfe[fgSf[a‘ i[fZ S bdWV[UfWV baef(bda\WUfe[fgSf[a‘) @‘ fZW USeW aX fZW Wj(baefSeeWee_W‘f’ S Ua_bSd[ea‘ iSe _SVWTWfiWW‘ fZW UgddW‘f baef(bda\WUf e[fgSf[a‘S‘V S dWUa‘efdgUfWV bdW(bda\WUf e[fgSf[a‘) @‘TafZ USeWe fZW _S[‘ Sffd[TgfWe aX fZW ekefW_iWdW VWeUd[TWV S‘V fZW[d [‘fWddW^Sf[a‘eZ[beiWdW WjS_[‘WV [‘ adVWd fa [VW‘f[Xk baee[T^W[‘fWdSUf[a‘e S‘V [_bSUfe) FTeWdhST^WUZS‘YWe S‘V [VW‘f[X[ST^W fdS\WUfad[We aXUZS‘YW iWdW SeeWeeWV Xad fZW ]Wk hSd[ST^WeaX Ua‘UWd‘)

[h%) @VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ aX _[f[YSf[a‘ S‘V W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f_WSegdWe) 8‘ [_badfS‘f W^W_W‘f aX S‘k[_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f [e fZW [VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ aXabf[a‘e fa _[f[YSfW fZW ‘WYSf[hW S‘V W‘ZS‘UWfZW bae[f[hW [_bSUfe aX S eUZW_W)

2C86<9<6 -8F;B7B?B:<8E

Logistics and Stakeholder Participation

@‘ CSae’ fZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f iSe USdd[WV agfVgd[‘Y fZW WSd^k Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ bZSeW aX fZWeUZW_W’ iZ[UZ iSe ahWd ,+ iWW]e Xda_ FUfaTWdfa ;WUW_TWd -++,) 8 eWcgW‘UW aX W[YZf

iad]eZabe iSe SddS‘YWV’ UaddWeba‘V[‘Y fa fZWefSYWe aX fZW SeeWee_W‘f bdaUWee VWeUd[TWVSTahW) 8‘ [‘[f[S^ ^[ef aX efS]WZa^VWde iSe VWX[‘WV[‘ Ua‘eg^fSf[a‘ i[fZ âUS^ bSdf‘Wd adYS‘[lSf[a‘e$fZW HWY[a‘S^ ;WhWâb_W‘f :a__[ffWW S‘V fZW8Yd[Ug^fgdS^ S‘V =adWefdk ;[h[e[a‘%) JZ[e [‘U^gVWVh[^^SYWe TW‘WX[f[‘Y V[dWUf^k Xda_ ad SXXWUfWV TkfZW [dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_W’ VdSi‘ Xda_ SUdaee fZWbda\WUf SdWS) @f Sêa [‘U^gVWV ;[efd[Uf S‘VGdah[‘U[S^ ^WhW^ aXX[UWde $Xad b^S‘‘[‘Y’ [dd[YSf[a‘’^[hWefaU] S‘V X[eZWd[We’ SYd[Ug^fgdW S‘V XadWefdk%’S‘V fZW W‘Y[‘WWd[‘Y Ua_bS‘k dWeba‘e[T^W Xadbda\WUf VWe[Y‘ S‘V Ua‘efdgUf[a‘) F‘W ad fiadWbdWeW‘fSf[hWe aX WSUZ Ydagb aX efS]WZa^VWdeiWdW [‘h[fWV fa fZW X[def iad]eZab’ iZWdW SXad_S^ efS]WZa^VWd S‘S^ke[e iSe USdd[WV agf) JZ[eS[_WV fa hS^[VSfW fZW eW^WUf[a‘’ [VW‘f[Xk S‘k ‘a‘(dWbdWeW‘fWV Ydagbe’ S‘V fa dS‘] fZW [‘fWdWefe’[_badfS‘UW S‘V [‘X^gW‘UW aX WSUZ Ydagb) @‘SVV[f[a‘ efS]WZa^VWd Ydagbe egUZ Se h[^^SYWdeiWdW [‘fWdh[WiWV Vgd[‘Y X[W^V h[e[fe Se VWeUd[TWVTWâi’ S‘V fZWeW dWeg^fe iWdW dWbadfWV Vgd[‘YfZW iad]eZabe) JZW Ua‘VgUf aX fZW iad]eZabS‘V fZW agfUa_We iWdW Ua‘f[‘gS^^k _a‘[fadWVS‘V WhS^gSfWV fZdagYZ fZW geW aX [‘V[h[VgS^ baef(iad]eZab bSdf[U[bS‘f cgWef[a‘‘S[dWe S‘V V[dWUfaTeWdhSf[a‘ Tk fZW dWeWSdUZ fWS_)

@‘ Id[ CS‘]S’ fZW SeeWee_W‘f iSe USdd[WVagf ahWd 4 iWW]e Xda_ =WTdgSdk fa 8bd[^ -++-’,1 kWSde SXfWd fZW Ua_b^Wf[a‘ aX fZW [dd[YSf[a‘S‘V eWff^W_W‘f eUZW_W) JZW _WfZaV aX eW^WUf[a‘S‘V hS^[VSf[a‘ aX efS]WZa^VWd bSdf[U[bS‘fe Xad SeWcgW‘UW aX X[hW iad]eZabe Xa^âiWV S e[_[^SdbdaUWee fa fZSf geWV [‘ CSae’ Tgf [‘U^gVWV âUS^bSdf[U[bSf[a‘ Xda_ fZW W‘f[dW d[hWd TSe[‘ [‘ adVWdfa W‘egdW TWffWd UahWdSYW aX S^^ baee[T^W[_bSUfe) <[YZf h[^^SYWe iWdW dWbdWeW‘fWV’ a‘WXda_ WSUZ aX fZW Xa^âi[‘Y la‘We5 STahW fZWZWSV dWeWdha[d6 UâeW fa fZW dWeWdha[d S‘V i[fZ[‘fZW ‘Wi Ua__S‘V SdWS6 Vai‘efdWS_ a‘ fZWTS‘]e aX fZW B[d[‘V[ FkS6 S‘V fia WSUZ Xda_ fZWa^V Ua__S‘V SdWSe S‘V fZW UaSefS^ la‘W UâeWfa fZW ^SYaa‘e) IfS]WZa^VWde Xda_ dW^WhS‘f‘Sf[a‘S^’ bdah[‘U[S^ S‘V V[efd[Uf SYW‘U[We SêabSdf[U[bSfWV)

1

Secondary Data Sources

@‘ CSae’ ]Wk eagdUWe aX eWUa‘VSdk VSfS [‘U^gVWVfZW dWeg^fe aX S cgS‘f[fSf[hW’ S‘V dWb^[USfWVX[eZWd[We [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f aX e_S^^( fa_WV[g_(eUS^W VS_ [dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We $CadW‘lW‘Wf S^) -+++6 EYgkW‘(BZaS Wf S^) -++.%’ S‘VVWfS[^WV S‘S^keWe aX fZW da^W aX X[eZWd[We [‘^[hW^[ZaaVe $>SdSiSk ,4446 I_[fZ Wf S^) -++,%)<SUZ aX fZWeW efgV[We iSe USdd[WV agf [‘ fZWIShS‘‘S]ZWf b^S[‘ ‘WSd fZW USeW efgVk e[fW’bdah[V[‘Y cgS‘f[fSf[hW [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ TSeWV a‘ â‘Y(fWd_ S‘V ebSf[S^^k dWb [̂USfWV egdhWke) IbWU[X[U[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xad fZW bda\WUf e[fW S‘V Ua‘UWd‘WVh[^^SYWe iSe VdSi‘ Xda_ V[efd[Uf S‘V bdah[‘U[S^dWUadVe $W)Y)’ babg^Sf[a‘’ dS[‘XS^^’ b^S‘‘WV[dd[YSfWV SdWS’ Udab SdWS S‘V bdaVgUf[a‘ bWdh[^^SYW S‘V bWd ZageWZa^V% S‘V Udaee(UZWU]WVi[fZ VSfS Xda_ fZW fWUZ‘[US^ XWSe[T[^[fk dWbadf aXfZW ?gSk JZagSf bda\WUf $8‘a‘ -+++%)

@‘ Id[ CS‘]S’ ]Wk eagdUWe [‘U^gVWVcgS‘f[fSf[hW Wef[_SfWe aX dWeWdha[d S‘V ^SYaa‘X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ $;W I[^hS ,43368_SdSe[‘YZW ,4436 AakWgj S‘V MSdV ,443%’SebWUfe aX X[eZWde ^[hW^[ZaaVe [‘ fZW ,44+e $baef(bda\WUf% $HW‘i[U] -++,6 ASkS]aVk ,44.6Bg^SdSf‘W ,444% S‘V bdW(bda\WUf efgV[We$IW‘S‘SkS]W S‘V M[\Wfg‘YS ,4326 :ZS‘VdSe[d[,431%) @‘Xad_Sf[a‘ a‘ ZkVdaâYk S‘V [dd[YSfWVSYd[Ug^fgdW iSe bdah[VWV Tk bda\WUf SeeWee_W‘fefgV[We USdd[WV agf e[‘UW fZW [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aXBF@IG $W)Y)’ @@D@ ,440%’ S‘V egbb^W_W‘fWV Tk[‘fWdh[Wie i[fZ @MD@ X[W^V aXX[UWde S‘VdWeWSdUZWde)

Reconnaissance Surveys

@‘[f[S^ X[W^V h[e[fe Ua‘fd[TgfWV fa fZW bdW^[_[‘SdkSeeWee_W‘f S‘V bdah[VWV [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xad fZWeUdWW‘[‘Y efSYW aX fZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f) @‘CSae’ Xagd h[^^SYWe iWdW h[e[fWV’ bgdbae[hW^keW^WUfWV fa TW ebSf[S^^k dWbdWeW‘fSf[hW TkV[efS‘UW Xda_ fZW VS_ e[fW) ;gd[‘Y WSUZ h[e[fX[W^V iS^]e S‘V V[dWUf aTeWdhSf[a‘e iWdW _SVW’S‘V eW_[(efdgUfgdWV Ydagb S‘V ]Wk [‘Xad_S‘f[‘fWdh[Wie Yg[VWV Tk bdW(bdWbSdWV UZWU]^[efeiWdW Ua‘VgUfWV) JZWeW UZWU]^[efe bda_bfWVWjb^[U[f [‘hWef[YSf[a‘ aX fZW [VW‘f[fk S‘V

Ua‘V[f[a‘e aX fZW baadWef S‘V _aef _SdY[‘S^[lWV_W_TWde aX fZW eW^WUfWV Ua__g‘[f[We’ Se iW^^Se S i[VW dS‘YW aX ^[hW^[ZaaV Xg‘Uf[a‘ebWdXad_WV Tk fZaeW iZa W‘YSYW [‘ X[eZ[‘Y) @‘ Id[CS‘]S’ S bgdbae[hW eW^WUf[a‘ aX ,, h[^^SYWeebSf[S^^k dWbdWeW‘fSf[hW aX la‘We i[fZ[‘ fZW d[hWdTSe[‘ iSe h[e[fWV S‘V e[_[^Sd^k egdhWkWV) JZ[eiSe egTeWcgW‘f^k dWVgUWV fa S eW^WUf[a‘ aX W[YZfh[^^SYWe \gVYWV fa SVWcgSfW^k dWbdWeW‘f fZW _S[‘[eegWe aX Ua‘UWd‘’ S‘V fZWeW bdah[VWVefS]WZa^VWde dWbdWeW‘fSf[hWe S‘V âUSf[a‘e Xad_adW VWfS[^WV [‘hWef[YSf[a‘ aX [_bSUfe)

Impacts on the Biophysical Environment

=ad TafZ eUZW_We S TSeW^[‘W e[fgSf[a‘ _Sb aXScgSf[U ZST[fSfe S‘V ^S‘V geW iSe Ua‘efdgUfWVge[‘Y [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xda_ fabaYdSbZ[U _Sbe Se iW^^Se bSdf[U[bSfadk _Sbb[‘Y WjWdU[eWe $[‘[f[S^^kbdWbSdWV fZdagYZ Ydagb [‘fWdh[Wie [‘ eW^WUfWVh[^^SYWe’ i[fZ Udaee(Ua_bSd[ea‘ S‘V hS^[VSf[a‘ SffZW iad]eZabe%) HW^WhS‘f XWSfgdWe aX fZWbafW‘f[S^^k [_bSUfWV SdWS S‘V fZW i[VWdUSfUZ_W‘f iWdW [VW‘f[X[WV S‘V _SbbWV’ W)Y)’iSfWd dWeagdUWe $efdWS_e’ d[hWde Tk USfWYadkadVWd’ ^S]We’ ba‘Ve’ WfU)’% S‘V ^S‘V geW fkbWe$XadWefe’ SYd[Ug^fgdS^’ gdTS‘’ WfU)%) B‘ai‘_aV[X[USf[a‘e fa fZW ‘SfgdS^ d[hWd UagdeW’ egUZ SedWeWdha[de’ W_TS‘]_W‘fe’ iW[de’ WfU)’ iWdW[‘V[USfWV a‘ fZW _Sb) 8e S eWUa‘V efWb’ S _SbaX fZW bdWV[UfWV $Wj(S‘fW SeeWee_W‘f% addWUa‘efdgUfWV $Wj(baef SeeWee_W‘f% e[fgSf[a‘iSe bdaVgUWV Tk SVV[‘Y ad Z[YZ^[YZf[‘Y UZS‘YWedW^SfWV fa fZW bda\WUf egUZ Se ‘Wi dWeWdha[de’US‘Sê’ S‘V [dd[YSfWV X[W^Ve) JZ[e S^âiWV[VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ aX ScgSf[U ZST[fSfe âef ad YS[‘WV’Se iW^^ Se baee[T^W WXXWUfe a‘ fZW WUaâY[USÛa‘‘WUf[h[fk aX ZST[fSfe $[)W)’ UZS‘YWe fZSf iag^V[_bWVW ad XSU[^[fSfW _[YdSf[a‘e aX ScgSf[UadYS‘[e_e%)

Fisheries Production

@‘Xad_Sf[a‘ a‘ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ Xda_ fZWZST[fSfe [VW‘f[X[WV a‘ fZW bdW( S‘V baef([dd[YSf[a‘bda\WUf _Sbe iSe VWd[hWV Xda_ âUS^ egdhWkeiZWdW baee[T^W) >[hW‘ fZW eWSea‘S^[fk aX

2

X[eZWd[We S‘V fZW[d V[ebWdeWV S‘V [‘Ua‘eb[Ugage‘SfgdW’ [f [e aXfW‘ [_bdSUf[US^ fa Wef[_SfWbdaVgUf[a‘ Vgd[‘Y eZadf [_bSUf efgV[We) ?aiWhWd’Ua_bSdSf[hW W_b[d[US^ VSfS a‘ X[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[a‘ SdW ShS[^ST^W Xad _aef ZST[fSf fkbWeS‘V YWaYdSbZ[US^ SdWSe’ S‘V _Sk TW geWV [‘[_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe iZWdW âUSf[a‘(ebWU[X[U VSfSSdW ^SU][‘Y) <_b[d[US^ VSfS dW^WhS‘f fa fZW USeWefgV[We SdW eg__Sd[lWV [‘ fST^W ,) GdaVgUf[h[fkaX d[hWd(XâaVb^S[‘ ekefW_e ZSe TWW‘ Tda]W‘Vai‘ [‘fa d[hWd S‘V XâaVb^S[‘ $[‘U^gV[‘Y ‘SfgdS^XâaVb^S[‘ S‘V dS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve% Ua_ba‘W‘feTSeWV a‘ S Ua_bSd[ea‘ aX k[W^Ve SUZ[WhWV Xda_d[hWd TSe[‘e i[fZ V[XXWdW‘f ^WhWê aX XâaVb^S[‘VWhWâb_W‘f) @‘ fZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe’ S^^bdaVgUf[a‘ Wef[_SfWe iWdW Udaee(UZWU]WV i[fZUa‘eg_bf[a‘ S‘V _Sd]Wf Wef[_SfWe S‘VV[eUgeeWV i[fZ efS]WZa^VWde)

Impacts on Rural Livelihoods

JZW IgefS[‘ST^W C[hW [̂ZaaVe 8bbdaSUZ $;=@;,444% S‘V S USfWYad[lSf[a‘ aX ^[hW^[ZaaV Xg‘Uf[a‘efZSf US‘ TW bdah[VWV Tk X[eZ[‘Y i[fZ[‘ ^[hW^[ZaaVefdSfWY[We $I_[fZ Wf S^) -++0% bdah[VWV SUa‘UWbfgS^ XdS_Wiad] Xad fZW SeeWee_W‘f)

@‘ CSae’ fZW dWUa‘‘S[eeS‘UW egdhWke ZSVeZai‘ fZW SdWS S‘V SXXWUfWV babg^Sf[a‘ fa TWdW^Sf[hW^k Za_aYW‘Wage S‘V Ua_bSdST^W fa fZaeW[‘hWef[YSfWV Tk bd[ad efgV[We [‘ fZW eS_Wbdah[‘UW Se ^[efWV STahW) >[hW‘ fZW bdWV[UfWVagfUa_We Xad fZW baef bda\WUf T[abZke[US^ S‘VX[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘ [_bSUfe’ fZ[e eWUa‘VSdk

[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ iSe geWV Se fZW TSe[e Xad bdWV[Uf[a‘eaX fZW _aef ^[]W^k ^[hW^[ZaaV [_bSUfe aX fZW kWf faTW Ua_b^WfWV eUZW_W) JZWeW bdWV[Uf[a‘e iWdWhS^[VSfWV fZdagYZ bdWeW‘fSf[a‘’ V[eUgee[a‘ S‘VdWX[‘W_W‘f Sf fZW efS]WZa^VWd iad]eZabe)8VV[f[a‘S^ X[W^V h[e[fe UahWd[‘Y fZW eW^WUfWVh[^^SYWe iWdW USdd[WV agf Tk V[efd[Uf aXX[UWde faXgdfZWd SeeWee ebWU[X[U [eegWe $W)Y)’ _S[‘ ScgSf[UebWU[We USgYZf Tk X[eZWde S‘V fdSV[f[a‘S^]‘ai^WVYW a‘ X[eZ _[YdSf[a‘%)

@‘ Id[ CS‘]S’ [f iSe VWU[VWV fZSf S dSb[VSbbdS[eS^ aX ^[hW^[ZaaV [_bSUfe Ua_b^WfWV _S[‘^kfZdagYZ S‘ [‘Xad_S^ h[^^SYW egdhWk iag^V TW fZWSbbdabd[SfW _WS‘e aX [‘hWef[YSf[a‘) JZWWUa‘a_[U S‘V eaU[S^ [_badfS‘UW aX [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We [‘ fZW SdWS [‘V[USfWV fZSf ea_W bd[_SdkS‘V âUSf[a‘(ebWU[X[U VSfS Ua^^WUf[a‘ eZag^V TWUa‘VgUfWV Xad ]Wk hSd[ST^We’ iZ[^W fZW cgS^[fk aXefS]WZa^VWd e bd[ad ]‘ai^WVYW STagf fZW e[fgSf[a‘S‘V fZW ShS[^ST[^[fk aX dW^WhS‘f eWUa‘VSdk[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ egbbadfWV fZW UZa[UW aX dSb[V S‘V[‘Xad_S^ egdhWk _WfZaVe) @‘ fZW S‘S^ke[eW_bZSe[e iSe b^SUWV a‘ fd[S‘Yg^Sf[a‘ aX[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xda_ fZWeW hSd[WV eagdUWe)

JZW bd[_Sdk VSfS Ua^^WUf[a‘ Xad [_bSUfSeeWee_W‘f Ua‘e[efWV aX fZW Xa^âi[‘Y SUf[h[f[We)BWk [‘Xad_S‘f [‘fWdh[Wie iWdW Ua‘VgUfWV [‘ fZWW[YZf eW^WUfWV h[^^SYWe) JZW dWeba‘VW‘f iSe SUa__g‘[fk ^WSVWd S‘V [‘ _aef USeWe fZWbdWe[VW‘f ad afZWd aXX[UW TWSdWd [‘ fZW h[^^SYW=[eZ[‘Y IaU[Wfk) @‘Xad_Sf[a‘ iSe Ua^^WUfWV STagffZW h[^^SYW WUa‘a_k’ [‘U^gV[‘Y5 ‘SfgdS^’ eaU[S^S‘V bZke[US^ USb[fS^6 X[‘S‘U[S^ USb[fS^ $[‘ fWd_e aX

J89C< ,) <_b[d[US^ Wef[_SfWe aX X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[h[fk $_WS‘ S‘V dS‘YW% aX V[XXWdW‘f ScgSf[U ZST[fSfe)

?ST[fSf 8dWS _WSegdW GdaVgUf[h[fk $]Y*ZS% HWXWdW‘UW

H[hWd i[fZagf XâaVb^S[‘e :SfUZ_W‘f SdWS +). Q+)+1 +)02R MWÛa__W ,421

H[hWd(XâaVb^S[‘ DSj[_g_ XâaVWV SdWS 3+ Q2 ,31R 9Sk^Wk ,433

HS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve $CSae% H[UW X[W^V SdWS 1+ Q/ -.+R CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++

<efgSd[We S‘V ^SYaa‘e 8hWdSYW iSfWd SdWS ,++ Q/ -’-++R AakWgj S‘V MSdV ,443

HWeWdha[de $Id[ CS‘]S% 8hWdSYW iSfWd SdWS --+ Q/+ 0++R ;W I[^hS ,433

I_S^^ dWeWdha[de $CSae% 8hWdSYW iSfWd SdWS >SdSiSk ,444Ea‘(_S‘SYWV ,++ Q.1 ,21R<‘ZS‘UWV S‘V _S‘SYWV -0+ Q0+ 00+R

"%)&#$ 2FH<EP<E <J 8C% (&&)

!%($- /@==<H<EJ 8H<8 D<8IKH<I ?8L< 9<<E KI<; =FH ;@==<H<EJ ?89@J8JI

3

SUUWee fa UdWV[f S‘V _S[‘ [‘Ua_W*W_bâk_W‘feagdUWe%6 fZW âUS^ ^STad _Sd]Wf S‘V dW^Sf[hW^STad egdb^ge ad eUSdU[fk) 8ffW‘f[a‘ XaUgeWV a‘fZW bdabadf[a‘ aX ZageWZa^Ve W‘YSYWV [‘ X[eZ[‘YS‘V [fe dW^Sf[hW [_badfS‘UW Ua_bSdWV fa afZWd^[hW^[ZaaVe) @‘ SVV[f[a‘ SV ZaU [‘fWdh[Wie aX X[eZfdSVWde S‘V X[eZWde iWdW Ua‘VgUfWV Vgd[‘Y WSd^k_ad‘[‘Y h[e[fe fa e[fWe iZW‘ X[eZ USfUZWe iWdWUa__a‘^k TW[‘Y dWfgd‘WV fa fZW eZadW)

=da_ fZW W[YZf h[^^SYWe egdhWkWV [‘ fZ[e iSk’X[hW iWdW [VW‘f[X[WV Se dWbdWeW‘fSf[hW aX fZWSdWSe i[fZ[‘ fZW d[hWd TSe[‘ fZSf ZSV fZW _aef[_badfS‘f X[eZWd[We S‘V*ad fZW _aef e[Y‘[X[US‘fbda\WUf [_bSUfe) JZWeW SdWSe iWdW fZW eUZW_WZWSV S‘V S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de $fZdWW h[^^SYWe% S‘VUaSefS^ ^SYaa‘e [_bSUfWV Tk eUZW_W VdS[‘SYW[‘Xâie $fia h[^^SYWe%) @‘ WSUZ aX fZWeW X[hWh[^^SYWe ZageWZa^V [‘fWdh[Wie iWdW Ua‘VgUfWV fa[‘Xad_ S _adW V[eSYYdWYSfWV SeeWee_W‘f aX fZWda^W aX X[eZ[‘Y [‘ ^[hW^[ZaaVe S‘V fa bdah[VWVWfS[^WV ZageWZa^V USeW efgV[We) Jia baad’ fia_[VV^W([‘Ua_W S‘V fia d[UZ ZageWZa^Ve iWdW[‘fWdh[WiWV [‘ WSUZ aX fZW X[hW h[^^SYWe)?ageWZa^Ve iWdW eW^WUfWV Tk Se][‘Y fZW ]Wk[‘Xad_S‘f fa ‘a_[‘SfW fia ZageWZa^Ve Xad iZa_X[eZ[‘Y iSe S e[Y‘[X[US‘f Xg^^(f[_W ad bSdf(f[_WSUf[h[fk [‘ WSUZ aX fZW fZdWW iWS^fZ USfWYad[We):^WSd^k’ fZ[e iSe TSeWV a‘ S egT\WUf[hWSeeWee_W‘f’ S‘V fZW iWS^fZ USfWYad[We iWdWUa‘e[VWdWV a‘^k [‘V[USf[hW) ?aiWhWd’ aTeWdhSf[a‘aX SeeWfe’ WUa‘a_[U abbadfg‘[f[We S‘V Zage[‘YUa‘V[f[a‘e Vgd[‘Y fZW [‘fWdh[Wie egYYWefe fZSffZW eW^WUf[a‘e iWdW YW‘WdS^^k Sbbdabd[SfW)GdaYdWee[a‘ Xda_ dW^Sf[hW^k baad fa dW^Sf[hW^k d[UZ

iSe Ua‘e[efW‘f Xad fZW e[j ZageWZa^Ve [‘ WSUZh[^^SYW’ S^fZagYZ Udaee Ua_bSd[ea‘e Tk iWS^fZUSfWYadk SUdaee h[^^SYWe iag^V ‘af ‘WUWeeSd[^kTW Ua‘e[efW‘f) JZW ZageWZa^V [‘fWdh[Wie XaUgeWVa‘ ZageWZa^V Ua_bae[f[a‘’ bdaVgUf[hW SeeWfe’[‘Ua_W eagdUWe S‘V V[hWde[fk’ fZW ^[hW^[ZaaV da^Wb^SkWV Tk X[eZ[‘Y S‘V fZW [_bSUf aX TafZ fZW[dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_W S‘V S dWUW‘f VdagYZf a‘X[eZ[‘Y)

FTeWdhSf[a‘e S‘V fZW ]Wk [‘Xad_S‘f[‘fWdh[Wie dWhWS^WV fZSf bda\WUf [_bSUfe a‘X[eZWd[We [‘ fia aX fZW dW_S[‘[‘Y h[^^SYWe $S‘VfZge la‘We i[fZ[‘ fZW TSe[‘% iWdW ‘af e[Y‘[X[US‘f)JZWeW iWdW fZW gbbWd USfUZ_W‘f S‘V d[hWd(XâaVb^S[‘’ gbefdWS_ S‘V Vai‘efdWS_ aX fZW ZWSVdWeWdha[d’ dWebWUf[hW^k) >[hW‘ f[_W Ua‘efdS[‘fe \geffia X[eZWd ZageWZa^V [‘fWdh[Wie iWdW Ua‘VgUfWV[‘ WSUZ aX fZWeW h[^^SYWe) JZWeW bdah[VWVZageWZa^V ^WhW^ bWdebWUf[hWe S‘V Ua‘X[d_WV fZWdW^Sf[hW ^SU] aX [_badfS‘UW aX X[eZ[‘Y [‘ fZWeWla‘We) JZW X[‘S^ h[^̂ SYW iSe âUSfWV ‘WSd fZWUaSefS^ ^SYaa‘e S‘V iSe ‘af egdhWkWV XgdfZWdTWUSgeW aX f[_W Ua‘efdS[‘fe’ S‘V Sêa TWUSgeWfZW UahWdSYW bdah[VWV Tk fZW fia ^SYaa‘h[^^SYWe dWXWddWV fa STahW iSe VWW_WV SVWcgSfW)

IWUa‘VSdk VSfS Ua^^WUf[a‘ S‘V S‘S^ke[e iSeTSeWV a‘ S dWh[Wi aX Wj[ef[‘Y bda\WUf WhS^gSf[a‘dWbadfe’ afZWd dW^WhS‘f efgV[We S‘V ShS[^ST^WefSf[ef[Ue $eWW eWUf[a‘ STahW S‘V ^[fWdSfgdW U[fWV%)@‘Xad_Sf[a‘ iSe Sêa YS[‘WV Xda_ _WWf[‘Ye i[fZâUS^ aXX[UWde aX fZW ;[h[e[a‘S^ IWUdWfSd[Sf’M[^V^[XW ;WbSdf_W‘f’ =[eZWd[We ;WbSdf_W‘f S‘V@dd[YSf[a‘ ;WbSdf_W‘f’ S‘V Xda_ fZW[d bSdf[U[bSf[a‘[‘ fZW iad]eZabe)

18EG?FE B9 F;8 *@C56F %EE8EE@8AFE

)G5J 3;BG5F *DD<:5F<BA 0DB=86F# ,5BE

Background

M[fZ S‘ Wef[_SfWV >EG $Ydaee ‘Sf[a‘S^ bdaVgUf%bWd USb[fS aX KI".-+ [‘ -++, $Mad^V 9S‘]-++.S%’ CSae [e fZW baadWef S‘V ^WSef VWhWâbWV

Uag‘fdk [‘ fZW <Sef 8e[S dWY[a‘) DadW fZS‘ fZdWW(cgSdfWde aX fZW babg^Sf[a‘ ^[hW a‘ ^Wee fZS‘ KI"-bWd VSk S‘V eaU[S^ [‘V[USfade SdW S_a‘Y fZWiadef [‘ fZW dWY[a‘ $Mad^V 9S‘] -++.T%)CS‘VâU]WV’ fZW Uag‘fdk UahWde -.1’3++ ]_- i[fZS babg^Sf[a‘ aX 0)/ _[^^[a‘’ S‘V i[fZ S Ydai[‘Y

4

dSfW aX -)1 bWdUW‘f S‘‘gS^^k) 8Yd[Ug^fgdW dW_S[‘efZW _S\ad Vd[hWd aX fZW WUa‘a_k’ Ua‘fd[Tgf[‘Y 0.bWdUW‘f aX Ydaee Va_Wef[U bdaVgUf S‘VW_bâk[‘Y ahWd 3+ bWdUW‘f aX fZW ^STad XadUW) @‘fZW kWSd -+++’ d[UW SUUag‘fWV Xad STagf 3/bWdUW‘f aX fZW fafS^ Ug^f[hSfWV SdWS aXSbbdaj[_SfW^k 3-+’+++ ZS bWd kWSd’ S‘V STagf,1 bWdUW‘f aX fZW d[UW SdWS iSe [dd[YSfWV$ESf[a‘S^ IfSf[ef[US^ :W‘fdW -+++%)

JZW USeW efgVk iSe Ua‘VgUfWV [‘IShS‘‘S]ZWf bdah[‘UW $eagfZWd‘ CSae%’ a‘W aXfZW e[j b^SfWSg bdah[‘UWe SV\SUW‘f fa fZW d[hWdDW]a‘Y) HW^Sf[hW^k âi ^k[‘Y $W^WhSf[a‘ Xda_ 0+_ fa -++ _ STahW eWS ^WhW^%’ fZW SdWS [e XWdf[^WS‘V eg[fST^W Xad S hSd[Wfk aX Udabe [‘U^gV[‘Y d[UW’hWYWfST^We’ _S[lW’ S‘V USeeShS)

JZW e[fW aX fZW bdabaeWV bda\WUf iSe ?gSkJZagSf’ S e_S^^ iSfWdeZWV Sf fZW WVYW aX fZW NW:ZS_bZa‘W iWf^S‘V SdWS $:^Sd[VYW ,441%) GdW(bda\WUf’ fZWdW iWdW ,’-/+ ZWUfSdWe aX XSd_WV^S‘V i[fZ[‘ fZW bda\WUf SdWS’ aX iZ[UZ 44+ ZSiWdW geWV Xad iWf eWSea‘ d[UW Ug^f[hSf[a‘ i[fZ

k[W^Ve aX ,)4 fa -)0 fa‘‘We bWd ZWUfSdW) JZWdWiSe ^[ff^W Vdk eWSea‘ Udabb[‘Y) Igdb^ge ^STad iSeUa‘e[VWdWV fa TW ShS[^ST^W [‘ fZW SdWS S‘V ST^Wfa Ua‘fd[TgfW fa fZW VWhWâb_W‘f aX [dd[YSfWVSYd[Ug^fgdW)

JZW [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_ iSe VWe[Y‘WV Xad SUa__S‘V SdWS aX ,’+-+ ZS’ V[efd[TgfWV ahWd ,0h[^^SYWe) @f i[^^ eWdhW 33+ ZageWZa^Ve’ i[fZ S fafS^babg^Sf[a‘ aX 0’3.+) JZW USfUZ_W‘f aX fZWJZagSf d[hWd ZSe S fafS^ SdWS aX 1. ]_- [‘U^gV[‘Y/. ]_- STahW fZW VS_’ iZ[UZ i[^^ TW âUSfWVgbefdWS_ Xda_ fZW Ua‘X^gW‘UW i[fZ fZW:ZS_bZa‘W d[hWd) JZW dWeWdha[d iSe VWe[Y‘WV fadWfS[‘ ,. _[^^[a‘ _. $STagf 2+ bWdUW‘f aX fZWfafS^ ShS[^ST^W ha^g_W aX iSfWd% S‘V fa ZShW SegdXSUW SdWS aX /2/ ZS Sf Xg^^ efadSYW ^WhW^$8‘a‘ -+++%) JZW S[_ aX fZW bdabaeWV bda\WUfiSe fa [‘UdWSeW SYd[Ug^fgdS^ bdaVgUf[a‘ TkWjfW‘V[‘Y fZW XSd_WV SdWS S‘V Tk VWhWâb[‘Y SVdk eWSea‘ Udab) :a‘efdgUf[a‘ Ua__W‘UWV [‘^SfW -+++ S‘V iSe [‘ bdaYdWee Vgd[‘Y fZW [_bSUfSeeWee_W‘f)

=@>KH< ,)I]WfUZ aX fZW bdabaeWV [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_ S‘V [_bSUfWV SdWS’ ?gSk JZagSf’ CSae)

,+

Screening and Scoping

@f iSe ]‘ai‘ Xda_ bdWh[age iad] [‘ fZW NW:ZS_bZa‘W iWf^S‘V SdWS $>SdSiSk ,4446CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++% fZSf X[eZWd[We Ua‘fd[TgfWVhWdk e[Y‘[X[US‘f^k fa ^[hW^[ZaaVe’ S‘V fZ[e iSeUa‘X[d_WV Tk fZW dWUa‘‘S[eeS‘UW egdhWke)8‘S^ke[e aX fZW Ua_bSdSf[hW VSfS Xda_ fZW dWY[a‘$eagdUWe VWeUd[TWV STahW%’ dWh[WiWV S‘VhS^[VSfWV Tk fZW [‘[f[S^ efS]WZa^VWd iad]eZabe’Ua‘U^gVWV fZSf fZW [_bSUfe aX fZW bda\WUf a‘X[eZWd[We iag^V TW bae[f[hW [‘ SYYdWYSfW’ _S[‘^kTWUSgeW fZW eUZW_W iag^V [‘UdWSeW Vdk eWSea‘iSfWd ShS[^ST[^[fk S‘V’ fZWdWTk’ bdah[VW TWffWdabbadfg‘[f[We fa X[eZ [‘ fZW dWeWdha[d’ d[hWd S‘VUS‘Sê) JZ[e iag^V agfiW[YZ fZW baee[T^W‘WYSf[hW [_bSUfe Xda_ dWVgUWV iWf eWSea‘ XâieS‘V aTefdgUf[a‘ aX X[eZ _[YdSf[a‘) JZW ahWdS^^TW‘WX[fe Xda_ [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f iag^V TWbae[f[hW Xad bWab^W e ^[hW^[ZaaVe S‘V XWiUa‘UWd‘e STagf baee[T^W ‘WYSf[hW [_bSUfe iWdWWjbdWeeWV) CaeeWe aX bSVVk ^S‘V fa [dd[YSf[a‘[‘XdSefdgUfgdW iWdW _S[‘^k _W‘f[a‘WV)Ea‘WfZW^Wee fZW efS]WZa^VWde egbbadfWV S Xg^^SeeWee_W‘f aX X[eZWd[We [_bSUfe’ ^SdYW^k i[fZ Sh[Wi fa [VW‘f[Xk[‘Y _WSegdWe fZSf Uag^V XgdfZWdW‘ZS‘UW fZW WjbWUfWV TW‘WX[fe) JZW dWeg^f[‘YSeeWee_W‘f _S[‘fS[‘WV S TdaSV eUabW S‘VSbbdS[eWV [_bSUfe aX fZW bda\WUf a‘ ScgSf[UZST[fSfe’ fZW[d bdaVgUf[h[fk’ X[eZ[‘Y bdSUf[UWe S‘VWXXadf’ S‘V ^STad geW S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaV abbadfg‘[f[Wei[fZ[‘ fZW SXXWUfWV SdWS)

Baseline Situation

FSP @L_‘]LW DP^Z‘]NP Ed^_PX& GSdf[U[bSfadk_Sbb[‘Y S‘V V[dWUf aTeWdhSf[a‘ eZaiWV fZSf_gUZ aX fZW gbbWd ?gSk JZagSf USfUZ_W‘f [eXadWefWV’ iZ[^W fZW SdWS [__WV[SfW^k STahW S‘VTWâi fZW VS_ [e SYd[Ug^fgdS^ ^S‘V) MSfWddWeagdUWe [‘ fZW SdWS SdW WjfW‘e[hW Tgf Z[YZ^keWSea‘S^) @‘ fZW iWf eWSea‘’ fZW iSfWddWeagdUWe [‘U^gVW 44+ ZS aX dS[‘(XWV bSVVkX[W^Ve’ fZW JZagSf d[hWd’ S‘V fZW _gUZ ^SdYWd:ZS_bZa‘W d[hWd S‘V [fe SeeaU[SfWV ajTai ^S]WeS‘V VWbdWee[a‘e) @‘ fZW Vdk eWSea‘’ a‘^k fZW:ZS_bZa‘W d[hWd S‘V [fe ajTai ^S]We dWfS[‘iSfWd S‘V fZge bdah[VW X[eZ[‘Y abbadfg‘[f[We)

L[^^SYWe S‘V Ug^f[hSfWV ^S‘V SdW Ua‘UW‘fdSfWV [‘fZW âiWd JZagSf USfUZ_W‘f’ S‘V SdW i[fZ[‘ WSekdWSUZ aX fZWeW X[eZWd[We)

HS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve b^Sk S _S\ad da^W [‘X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘) @‘ dS[‘(XWV ad XâaVdWUWee[a‘ fkbW d[UW XSd_[‘Y ekefW_e’ d[UW X[W^VeUS‘ efadW iSfWd S‘V UdWSfW ScgSf[U WUaekefW_ei[fZ _S‘k e[_[^Sd[f[We fa ‘SfgdS^ XâaVb^S[‘e$?WU]_S‘ ,4246 MWÛa__W ,4306 CSi^Wd-++,%) JZWk US‘ aXfW‘ Va_[‘SfW fZW ahWdS^^ScgSf[U ZST[fSf S‘V X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘$>dWYadk S‘V >gff_S‘ -++-%’ S‘V fZ[e _Sk TW_S[‘fS[‘WV Se â‘Y Se XSd_[‘Y bdSUf[UWe fZSfefadW iSfWd [‘ d[UW X[W^Ve Xad WjfW‘VWV bWd[aVeSdW Ua‘f[‘gWV’ S‘V fZW WUaâY[US^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fki[fZ bWdW‘‘[S^ ZST[fSfe [e egXX[U[W‘f fa S^âiUaâ‘[lSf[a‘ Tk X[eZ)

>TaPWTSZZO^& JZW âUS^ WUa‘a_k iSeUZSdSUfWd[lWV Tk S dW^Sf[hW^k Za_aYW‘Wagebabg^Sf[a‘ aX ZageWZa^Ve’ U^gefWdWV [‘ ^SdYW^k[‘VWbW‘VW‘f h[^^SYWe W‘YSYWV bd[_Sd[^k [‘egTe[efW‘UW SYd[Ug^fgdS^ bdaVgUf[a‘) JZW SUf[h[f[WeiWdW UW‘fWdWV a‘ bSVVk d[UW Ug^f[hSf[a‘ TgfZg‘f[‘Y’ X[eZ[‘Y’ S‘V YSfZWd[‘Y aX ‘a‘(f[_TWdXadWef bdaVgUfe iWdW Sêa b^Sk[‘Y S‘ [_badfS‘fda^W [‘ fZW[d ^[hW [̂ZaaV) FUUgbSf[a‘SêbWU[S^[lSf[a‘ [‘ h[^^SYWe iSe âi’ S‘V [‘Ua_WXda_ XSd_[‘Y [e gegS^^k egbb^W_W‘fWV Tk afZWdbdaVgUf[hW SUf[h[f[We egUZ Se _[Uda(W‘fWdbd[eW’USegS^ ^STad’ S‘V bWd_S‘W‘f ad bSdf(f[_WYahWd‘_W‘f W_bâk_W‘f $I_[fZ Wf S^) -++,%)Ma_W‘ TWSd S e[Y‘[X[US‘f TgdVW‘ aX SYd[Ug^fgdSîad] Se iW^^ Se afZWd ZageWZa^V fSe]e) MWS^fZdS‘][‘Y WjWdU[eWe Ua‘VgUfWV [‘ fZW eS_W SdWSXag‘V fZSf ^S‘V ai‘WdeZ[b’ SVWcgSfW ZageWZa^V^STad fa Ug^f[hSfW fZSf ^S‘V S‘V SUZ[WhW_W‘f aX SeWUgdW ^WhW^ aX d[UW eW^X(egXX[U[W‘Uk ad egdb^geiWdW dWYSdVWV Tk h[^^SYWde Se fZW _aef [_badfS‘fVWfWd_[‘S‘fe aX iWS^fZ S‘V hg^‘WdST[^[fk $I_[fZWf S^& -++,%) ;dagYZf ad XâaVe S‘V fZW[d [_bSUfea‘ fZW iWf eWSea‘ d[UW Udab SdW fZW _S[‘eagdUWe aX hg^‘WdST[^[fk Xad ZageWZa^Ve’ i[fZ fZWWXXWUfe aX V[eWSeW Xad ^[hWefaU] S‘V fZW Zg_S‘^STad XadUW ‘Wjf [‘ [_badfS‘UW $?ab][‘e ,4406I_[fZ Wf S^) -++,%) JST^W - eg__Sd[lWe fZWefSfge aX ZageWZa^V ^[hW^[ZaaV SeeWfe)

,,

J89C< -)?ageWZa^V ^[hW^[ZaaV SeeWfe [‘ fZW ?gSk JZagSf USfUZ_W‘f)

8eeWfe IfSfge S‘V ]Wk [eegWe

ESfgdS^ · ^S‘V hSd[age^k VWhWâbWV Se d[UW bSVVk S‘V ei[VVW‘ X[W^Ve $eZ[Xf[‘Y Ug^f[hSf[a‘%’ ad _S[‘fS[‘WV Se XadWef Xad YSfZWd[‘Yi[^V b^S‘fe S‘V S‘[_Sê’ XgWîaaV’ S‘V aUUSe[a‘S^^k f[_TWd

· X[eZWd[We bdah[VWV Tk efdWS_e S‘V d[hWde’ eWSea‘S^^k XâaVWV d[UW X[W^Ve S‘V VWbdWee[a‘e S‘V bWdW‘‘[S^ ba‘Ve S‘V^S]We

· Ua_bdWZW‘e[hW SeeWee_W‘f aX Zai i[VWd fdW‘Ve [‘ babg^Sf[a‘ YdaifZ’ SYd[Ug^fgdS^ VWhWâb_W‘f S‘V Ua__WdU[S^âYY[‘Y SdW SXXWUf[‘Y egefS[‘ST[^[fk aX ^S‘V geW’ XadWefe S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaV eWUgd[fk [e ^SU][‘Y

GZke[US^ · SUUWee fa [‘XdSefdgUfgdW S‘V bgT^[U eWdh[UWe [e Z[YZ^k hSd[ST^W Tgf YW‘WdS^^k baad· [‘ :ZS_ba‘W V[efd[Uf 02# aX h[^^SYWe ZShW kWSd dag‘V daSV SUUWee’ -0# ZShW a‘^k Vdk eWSea‘ SUUWee’ S‘V ,2# ZShW

‘a daSV SUUWee6 0/# ZShW S‘ [_bdahWV iSfWd eagdUW $KE;G*@CF ,444%

?g_S‘ · ^WhWê aX ZWS^fZ S‘V WVgUSf[a‘ SdW baad’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k Xad ia_W‘ $Mad^V 9S‘] -++.T%· ‘Sf[a‘S^^k’ fZW dgdS^ ^[fWdSUk dSfW Xad fZaeW ,0 kWSde S‘V a^VWd [e 24# Xad _W‘ S‘V /4# Xad ia_W‘6 [‘ dgdS^ SdWSe fZW

ShWdSYW ‘g_TWd aX kWSde aX eUZaa^[‘Y Xad fZaeW SYWV ,0(/4 [e 0 Xad _W‘ S‘V / Xad ia_W‘ $ESf[a‘S^ IfSf[ef[US^ :W‘fdW,444%

· [‘ :ZS_bZa‘W V[efd[Uf 02# aX h[^^SYWe ZShW S bWd_S‘W‘f ZWS^fZ ha^g‘fWWd S‘V .# S bWd_S‘W‘f VaUfad6 -3# ZShW SUa_b^WfW bd[_Sdk eUZaa^6 2+# dWUW[hW h[e[fe Xda_ SYd[Ug^fgdS^ WjfW‘e[a‘ iad]Wde S‘V ,/# Xda_ hWfWd[‘Sd[S‘e $KE;G*@CF ,444%

· e[Y‘[X[US‘f [‘V[YW‘age fWUZ‘[US^ ]‘ai^WVYW aX X[eZWd[We Se iW^^ Se aX afZWd i[^V XaaVe S‘V ‘a‘(f[_TWd bdaVgUfe Xda_XadWef SdWSe

IaU[S^ · efda‘Y [‘fWd(ZageWZa^V UaabWdSf[a‘ S‘V egbbadf’ WebWU[S^^k i[fZ[‘ ][‘eZ[b Ydagbe S‘V [‘ dWU[bdaUS^ ^STad WjUZS‘YW XadbWS] XSd_ fSe]e $HS‘VS^^ @dWea‘ ,440%

· Ugefa_Sdk SUUWee S‘V ai‘WdeZ[b d[YZfe gegS^^k Wj[ef Xad X[eZWd[We S‘V XadWefe’ S^fZagYZ V[ebgfWe S‘V g‘UWdfS[‘fk ahWdd[YZfe _Sk Wj[ef

· dW^Sf[hW^k âi eaU[aWUa‘a_[U V[XXWdW‘f[Sf[a‘ TWfiWW‘ ZageWZa^Ve S‘V Ua__a‘ dW^[S‘UW a‘ eZSdWV X[eZWd[We S‘V XadWefeUdWSfWe fZW bafW‘f[S^ Xad WXXWUf[hW Ua__g‘[fk _S‘SYW_W‘f aX fZWeW $>SdSiSk ,444%

=[‘S‘U[S^ · âi ZageWZa^V eSh[‘Ye· ^[_[fWV SUUWee fa UdWV[f· eS^W aX egdb^ge X[eZ USfUZWe US‘ TW a‘W aX XWi dWSV[^k ShS[^ST^W eagdUWe aX USeZ [‘Ua_W Xad baad ZageWZa^Ve

"%)&#$ 6D@J? <J 8C% (&&’

âiWd S‘V ^Wee dWYg^Sd fZS‘ fZSf fZW [‘Ua_WYW‘WdSfWV Tk fZW eS^W aX egdb^ge [‘ d[UWbdaVgUf[a‘) JZge’ fZW eS^W aX X[eZ fW‘Ve fa TW_aef [_badfS‘f Xad baad ZageWZa^Ve i[fZ[‘SVWcgSfW ^S‘V fa _WWf egTe[efW‘UW ‘WWVe’ Tgfi[fZ egXX[U[W‘f _S‘baiWd fa TW geWV Xad X[eZ[‘Y’S‘V SUcg[dW _adW e][^ê fZdagYZ WjbWd[W‘UW [‘fZW fdSVW) @‘ fZW eS_W dWY[a‘ >SdSiSk $,444%Xag‘V fZSf f[_W [‘hWefWV [‘ X[eZ[‘Y S‘V fZW USfUZaTfS[‘WV iWdW dW^Sf[hW^k e[_[^Sd Xad S^^ eaU[S^Ydagbe’ Tgf VWU^[‘WV e^[YZf^k i[fZ [‘UdWSe[‘YiWS^fZ efSfge) 8hS[^ST[^[fk S‘V UZSdSUfWd[ef[Ue aXX[eZWd[We i[fZ[‘ iS^][‘Y V[efS‘UW aX fZW h[^^SYW’S‘V*ad dWefd[Uf[a‘e a‘ geW’ iWdW [_badfS‘f[‘X^gW‘UWe a‘ fZW USfUZ aX X[eZ S‘V SdW _gUZ_adW [_badfS‘f fZS‘ fZW eaU[aWUa‘a_[UV[XXWdW‘UWe TWfiWW‘ Ydagbe)

E[‘Wfk bWdUW‘f aX dgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve [‘ fZWdWY[a‘ dWYg^Sd^k W‘YSYWV [‘ X[eZ[‘Y’ aTfS[‘[‘Y S‘ShWdSYW USfUZ aX 1+ ]Y*ZageWZa^V*kWSd$CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++’ EYgkW‘ BZaS -++.%)=[eZ[‘Y iSe eWUa‘V [‘ [_badfS‘UW fa d[UWbdaVgUf[a‘ Se S ^[hW^[ZaaV SUf[h[fk’ bdah[V[‘YSbbdaj[_SfW^k ,0 bWdUW‘f aX fafS^ ZageWZa^V[‘Ua_W a‘ ShWdSYW) =[eZ[‘Y fZge Xad_WV S‘W^W_W‘f aX S fdSV[f[a‘S^ V[hWde[X[WV egTe[efW‘UW^[hW^[ZaaV efdSfWYk) ?ageWZa^Ve X[eZWV fZdagYZagffZW kWSd’ i[fZ XaaV eWUgd[fk TW[‘Y bd[_Sd[^k TSeWVa‘ a‘W e ai‘ d[UW bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V USfUZ aX X[eZ)H[UW S‘V X[eZ SdW Sêa bgdUZSeWV [‘ f[_We aX‘WWV) JZW baadWef aXfW‘ dWUW[hWV ea_W SebSdf[U[bS‘fe [‘ h[^^SYW eaU[S^ egbbadf ‘Wfiad]e’ ad[‘ WjUZS‘YW Xad ^STad) IS^W aX X[eZ [e Sêa SeagdUW aX [‘Ua_W Xad ea_W ZageWZa^Ve’ fZagYZ

,-

@‘ fZW bda\WUf SdWS X[eZ[‘Y SUf[h[fk iSeUa‘UW‘fdSfWV [‘ fZW NW :ZS_bZa‘W XâaVb^S[‘$TWâi fZW ?gSk JZagSf USfUZ_W‘f% S‘V [‘ dS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve) MWf eWSea‘ X[eZ[‘Y iSe _S[‘^k [‘d[UW bSVV[We ad ‘WSdTk VdS[‘SYW UZS‘‘Wê adVWbdWee[a‘e) ;dk eWSea‘ X[eZ[‘Y iSe ^[_[fWV fabWdW‘‘[S^ efdWS_e ad ba‘Ve’ S‘V fZge aXfW‘[‘ha^hWV YdWSfWd fdShW^[‘Y S‘V iSe _adWbdSUf[UWV Tk _W‘) =[eZ[‘Y iSe ‘af afZWdi[eWYW‘VWd(ebWU[X[U S‘V iSe i[VW^k bdSUf[UWV Tk_W‘’ ia_W‘ S‘V UZ[^VdW‘) JZW ShS[^ST^WX[eZWd[We iWdW iW^^ eg[fWV Xad ZageWZa^Ve iZaiWdW Sêa XSd_Wde) =ad egUZ ZageWZa^Ve X[eZ[‘YiSe S dWYg^Sd $aXfW‘ VS[^k% SUf[h[fk’ USdd[WV agf [‘SeeaU[Sf[a‘ i[fZ XSd_ iad] ad iZW‘ fdShW^[‘Y faS‘V Xda_ fZW X[W^Ve) JZ[e bSdf[Ug^Sd^k Sbb^[WV fafZW geW aX bSee[hW X[eZ[‘Y _WfZaVe egUZ Se Y[^^‘Wfe ad X[eZ fdSbe)

Daef X[eZWd[We iWdW abW‘ SUUWee S^fZagYZâUS^ Ua__g‘[f[We ZShW VW XSUfa ai‘WdeZ[b S‘V_Sk UZaaeW fa dWefd[Uf SUUWee W[fZWd a‘ SUa__g‘S^ TSe[e ad Tk dW‘f[‘Y agf iSfWd TaV[Wefa bd[hSfW [‘fWdWefe $CadW‘lW‘ S‘V >SdSiSk,4436 >SdSiSk ,444%) IgUZ _S‘SYW_W‘f_WSegdWe SdW gegS^^k Sbb^[WV [‘ a‘^k S e_S^^bdabadf[a‘ aX iSfWd TaV[We ShS[^ST^W Xad X[eZ[‘Y)@‘ d[UW X[W^Ve’ efSf[a‘Sdk X[eZ[‘Y YWSde egUZ SefdSbe SdW VWbâkWV a‘^k [‘ fZW XSd_Wd e ai‘X[W^Ve iZ[^W _aT[^W YWSde egUZ Se ZSdbaa‘e _SkTW geWV S‘kiZWdW) 8cgSUg^fgdW iSe ^[ff^WVWhWâbWV [‘ fZW SdWS’ Ua‘fd[Tgf[‘Y ^Wee fZS‘ ,+bWdUW‘f aX fZW fafS^ X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘)

Predicted Project Impacts

;X[LN_^ ZY L\‘L_TN SLMT_L_^ LYO _SPT] NZYYPN_TaT_d&:ZS‘YWe [‘ ScgSf[U ZST[fSf ShS[^ST[^[fk S‘VUa‘‘WUf[h[fk iWdW SeeWeeWV a‘ fZW TSe[e aX fZWScgSf[U ZST[fSf S‘V [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_ _Sb’ S‘Viad]eZab V[eUgee[a‘e) JZW _S[‘ UZS‘YWebdWV[UfWV iWdW5

[%) FhWdS^^ dWVgUf[a‘ [‘ S‘‘gS^ V[eUZSdYW aX fZWVS__WV d[hWd VgW fa WhSbafdS‘eb[dSf[a‘ aX[dd[YSf[a‘ iSfWd’ S‘V eWSea‘S^ dWV[efd[Tgf[a‘aX Xâie dWeg^f[‘Y [‘ âiWd iWf eWSea‘ S‘VZ[YZWd Vdk eWSea‘ Xâie $Xda_ [dd[YSf[a‘dWfgd‘ Xâie S‘V eWWbSYW%)

[[%) HW^Sf[hW^k ^[ff^W UZS‘YW [‘ fZW eWSea‘S^^kXâaVWV SdWS Ua_bd[eWV aX dS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve$44+ ZS% S‘V d[hWd JZagSf XâaVb^S[‘ $STagf/3 ZS%) JZ[e [e Ua‘f[‘YW‘f a‘ fZWUa‘f[‘gSf[a‘ aX dS[‘(XWV bSVVk Ug^f[hSf[a‘ [‘fZW iWf eWSea‘’ Se S‘k dWVgUf[a‘ [‘ bSVVkiSfWd efadSYW iag^V dWVgUW fZW[d hS^gW SeScgSf[U ZST[fSf)

[[[%) :dWSf[a‘ aX S ‘Wi Vdk eWSea‘ ScgSf[U ZST[fSf[‘ fZW Xad_ aX S dWeWdha[d S‘V [dd[YSfWV d[UWX[W^Ve)

[h%) JZW NW :ZS_bZa‘W d[hWd S‘V SeeaU[SfWViWf^S‘Ve’ iZ[UZ Va_[‘SfW fZW UgddW‘f VdkeWSea‘ ZST[fSf’ i[^^ TW ^SdYW^k g‘SXXWUfWV)JZW Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘ aX fZW ?gSk JZagSf d[hWd faNW :ZS_bZa‘W V[eUZSdYW TWâi fZWUa‘X^gW‘UW iSe Wef[_SfWV Se ^Wee fZS‘ -bWdUW‘f TSeWV a‘ dW^Sf[hW USfUZ_W‘f SdWSe)

h%) Caee aX â‘Y[fgV[‘S^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk aX fZW ?gSkJZagSf d[hWd Sf fZW VS_ e[fW) Gaee[T^k SdWVgUf[a‘ [‘ ^SfWdS^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk VgW fa dS[eWV[dd[YSf[a‘ US‘Sê’ iZ[UZ _Sk UdWSfW TSdd[Wdefa X[eZ _[YdSf[a‘ [‘fa bSVV[We e[fgSfWV STahWfZW Ua__S‘V SdWS’ S‘V S dWVgUf[a‘ aX fZWiWf eWSea‘ d[hWd Xâi)

8T^SP]TP^ []ZO‘N_TZY& Gda\WUf[a‘e aX [_bSUfe a‘X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ iWdW aTfS[‘WV Tk _g^f[b^k[‘YbdW( S‘V baef(bda\WUf ScgSf[U ZST[fSf SdWSe i[fZW_b[d[US^ bdaVgUf[h[fk Wef[_SfWe $fST^W .%)

=[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ fZW ?gSk JZagSfUSfUZ_W‘f Se Wef[_SfWV Xda_ ZST[fSf S‘VW_b[d[US^ bdaVgUf[h[fk VSfS [e Ua_bSdST^W fa fZWWjbWUfWV Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ Tk âUS^ ZageWZa^Ve $0. f*kWSd’ 33+ ZageWZa^Ve j 1+ ]Y*ZS*kWSd%) FhWdS^^ZST[fSf S‘V bdaVgUf[a‘ SdW Va_[‘SfWV Tk dS[‘(XWVd[UW X[W^Ve’ S‘V fZ[e bdaVgUf[a‘ [e ^[]W^k fa TWegefS[‘WV g‘^Wee Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk [e âef TWfiWW‘bWdW‘‘[S^ ZST[fSfe S‘V d[UW X[W^Ve’ ad iSfWddWfW‘f[a‘ [‘ fZW iWf eWSea‘ [e dWVgUWV) =[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[h[fk aX Vdk eWSea‘ [dd[YSfWV d[UW X[W^Ve [eSeeg_WV fa TW ‘WY^[Y[T^W’ VgW fa âi iSfWd^WhWê S‘V ^SU] aX ‘SfgdS^ gb _[YdSf[a‘ aX X[eZXda_ bWdW‘‘[S^ iSfWd TaV[We)

MZ[^W [f [e g‘U^WSd fa iZSf WjfW‘f fZW UZS‘YW[‘ d[hWd Xâie S‘V â‘Y[fgV[‘S^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk i[^^

,.

dWVgUW X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ Xda_ fZW d[hWd S‘V [feeWSea‘S^ XâaVb^S[‘’ Wef[_Sf[a‘ eZaie fZSfbdaVgUf[a‘ Xda_ fZW d[hWd [feW^X [e a‘^k STagf 1 f*kWSd [‘ fafS^) JZge’ WhW‘ S Ua_b^WfW âee [e ^[]W^kfa TW agfiW[YZWV Tk S YS[‘ aX STagf -+ f*kWSdXda_ fZW ‘Wi dWeWdha[d) JZW ‘Wf WXXWUf aX[dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f a‘ bdaVgUf[a‘ aX X[eZ [efZge ^[]W^k fa TW e^[YZf^k bae[f[hW)

IgefS[‘[‘Y ‘SfgdS^ X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ fZW?gSk JZagSf USfUZ_W‘f a‘ fZW UgddW‘f eUS^W [efZge Z[YZ^k VWbW‘VW‘f a‘ fZW Ua‘f[‘gWV da^W aXd[UW X[W^Ve Se eWSea‘S^ X[eZ ZST[fSf) JZW _S[‘fZdWSfe fa fZ[e da^W aX d[UW X[W^Ve SdW UZS‘YWe [‘SYd[Ug^fgdS^ bdSUf[UWe fZSf dWVgUW iSfWd dWfW‘f[a‘’S‘V âee aX WUaâY[US^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk aX fZWeW X[W^Vei[fZ bWd_S‘W‘f iSfWd TaV[We) 8hS[^ST[^[fk aX[dd[YSf[a‘ iSfWd dWVgUWe fZW ‘WWV fa efadW iSfWd[‘ d[UW X[W^Ve’ S‘V S^âie [‘fW‘e[X[USf[a‘ aX iWfeWSea‘ d[UW bdaVgUf[a‘ i[fZ Ua‘Ua_[fS‘f [‘UdWSeW[‘ fZW geW aX SYdaUZW_[USê) HWVgUf[a‘ [‘ d[UWX[W^V iSfWd efadSYW S‘V*ad WjfW‘e[hW geW aXbWef[U[VWe i[^^ VdSef[US^^k dWVgUW’ [X ‘af W^[_[‘SfWX[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ Xda_ d[UW X[W^Ve) 8 eW‘e[f[h[fkS‘S^ke[e eZaie fZSf fZW ‘Wf WXXWUf aX [dd[YSf[a‘Uag^V TW efda‘Y^k ‘WYSf[hW [‘Ugdd[‘Y S âee aXbdaVgUf[a‘ gb fa /0 f*kWSd [‘ fZW iadef USeWeUW‘Sd[a iZWdW d[UW X[W^V ZST[fSfe iag^V ‘afegbbadf S‘k X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘k_adW) ?W‘UW’WjbWUfWV SYd[Ug^fgdS^ bdaVgUf[h[fk YS[‘e Xda_

fZWeW bdSUf[UWe _gef aXXeWf fZW Ua‘Ua_[fS‘f âeeaX X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ fa TW TW‘WX[U[S^ ahWdS^^)

@dd[YSf[a‘ [‘XdSefdgUfgdW S‘V iSfWd_S‘SYW_W‘f _Sk dWefd[Uf X[eZ _[YdSf[a‘e Xda_bWd_S‘W‘f iSfWd TaV[We fa d[UW X[W^Ve’ VgW fa âiiSfWd ShS[^ST[^[fk [‘ Ud[f[US^ ZST[fSfe Sâ‘Y fZW_[YdSf[a‘ dagfWe’ ad bZke[US^ aTefSU^We fa_[YdSf[a‘ egUZ Se dS[eWV US‘Sê) 9afZ ‘WYSf[hW[_bSUfe US‘ TW _[f[YSfWV $eWW TWâi%) 8‘WjfW‘e[hW egdhWk aX [_bSUfe a‘ X[eZWd[We [‘[dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We iSe USdd[WV agf’ iZWdW SfdSV[f[a‘S^ iWf eWSea‘ d[UW Udab iSe _S[‘fS[‘WV)Ea Wh[VW‘UW iSe Xag‘V aX fZW WXXWUfe a‘ fZW k[W^VTWka‘V fZaeW Wjb^S[‘WV Tk UZS‘YWe [‘ XâaVWVSdWS S‘V X[eZ[‘Y WXXadf $CadW‘lW‘ Wf S^) -+++6EYgkW‘(BZaS Wf S^) -++.%) JZ[e egYYWefe fZSf[_bSUfe a‘ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk SdW ‘af YW‘WdS^^k eWhWdW)

JZW SXadW_W‘f[a‘WV [_bSUf efgVk [‘ CSae[‘V[USfWV e^[YZf^k âiWd $Tk ,+ -+#% X[eZ[‘Y WXXadfS‘V k[W^Ve [‘ [dd[YSfWV SdWSe Se Ua_bSdWV fa‘a‘([dd[YSfWV Ua‘fdaê) HWfgd‘e fa X[eZ[‘Y WXXadfiWdW e^[YZf^k’ Tgf ‘af e[Y‘[X[US‘f^k Z[YZWd [‘[dd[YSfWV SdWSe) JZ[e egYYWefe fZSf X[eZ[‘Y [‘[dd[YSfWV SdWSe VWU^[‘We e^[YZf^k Se S dWeg^f aXeaU[aWUa‘a_[U dSfZWd fZS‘ T[abZke[US^ SUfade)8êa’ X[eZ[‘Y WXXadf iSe bSdf[S^^k dWV[efd[TgfWVXda_ d[hWd(XâaVb^S[‘ S‘V d[UW X[W^V âUSf[a‘e fafZW dWeWdha[d) <ef[_SfWV WXXWUfe aX [dd[YSf[a‘eUZW_We a‘ X[eZ[‘Y WXXadf S‘V USfUZ eZaiWV S

J89C< .)<ef[_SfWV [_bSUf a‘ X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ fZW ?gSk JZagSf USfUZ_W‘f’ Seeg_[‘Y _S[‘fW‘S‘UW aX dS[‘(XWV d[UW Ug^f[hSf[a‘ [‘fZW iWf eWSea‘ S‘V Ua_b^WfW âee aX _S[‘efdWS_ d[hWd S‘V SeeaU[SfWV XâaVb^S[‘ bdaVgUf[a‘) IWW fST^W , Xad ad[Y[‘ aXbdaVgUf[h[fk Wef[_SfWe)

9WXadW Gda\WUf 8XfWd Gda\WUf

?ST[fSf :SfUZ_W‘f 8dWS GdaVgUf[h[fk GdaVgUf[a‘ 8dWS GdaVgUf[h[fk GdaVgUf[a‘8dWS $ZS% $ZS% $]Y*ZS*kWSd% $f*kWSd% $ZS% $]Y*ZS*kWSd% $f*kWSd%

H[UW X[W^Ve& 44+ 1+ 04 44+ 1+ 04

JZagSf H[hWd 1’.++ + + - + + +

=âaVb^S[‘ /3 3+ / + 1+ +

HWeWdha[d + ,++ + -++ ,++ -+

JafS^ ,’+.3 10 ,’,4+ 24

:ZS‘YW ,0- ,/

!%($ # 5@:< =@<C;I :FEJH@9KJ< JF =@I? GHF;K:J@FE FECO ;KH@E> J?< M<J I<8IFE I@E:< M8J<H C<L<CI 8H< CFM 8E; E8JKH8C H<:HK@JD<EJ FEJF J?@I 8H<8@I E<>C@>@9C< !EF D@>H8J@FE" ;KH@E> J?< ;HO I<8IFE%

,/

e[Y‘[X[US‘f dWVgUf[a‘ aX fZW X[eZ[‘Y WXXadf $(1+#%S‘V USfUZWe $(0.#% [‘ fZW XâaVb^S[‘ S‘V d[UWX[W^V SdWSe) JZWeW WXXWUfe iWdW bSdf[S^^kUa_bW‘eSfWV Tk fZW [‘UdWSeW aX X[eZ[‘Y WXXadfS‘V USfUZWe [‘ afZWd iSfWd TaV[We S‘VbSdf[Ug^Sd^k [‘ fZW ‘Wi^k UdWSfWV dWeWdha[d)

@_bSUfe a‘ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ agfe[VW fZW?gSk JZagSf USfUZ_W‘f SdW ^[]W^k fa TW[‘e[Y‘[X[US‘f Y[hW‘ fZW âi Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘ aX fZW?gSk JZagSf fa ahWdS^^ ZST[fSf S‘V V[eUZSdYW [‘fZW NW :ZS_bZa‘W TSe[‘ $- .#%) ?aiWhWd’[dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We SdW TW[‘Y VWhWâbWV [‘ _S‘kâUSf[a‘e aX fZW TSe[‘ S‘V Ug_g^Sf[hW [_bSUfe_Sk TW e[Y‘[X[US‘f [‘ fZW XgfgdW S‘V eZag^V TWSeeWeeWV)

>TaPWTSZZO ;X[LN_^& @_bSUfe Xad [‘V[h[VgS^ZageWZa^Ve i[^^ VWbW‘V a‘ S dS‘YW aX hSd[ST^We[‘U^gV[‘Y fZW âUSf[a‘ S‘V X[eZ[‘Y UZSdSUfWd[ef[UeaX iSfWd TaV[We h[e[fWV’ fZW X[eZ[‘Y _WfZaVegeWV’ fZW [_badfS‘UW aX X[eZ[‘Y [‘ S ^[hW^[ZaaVefdSfWYk’ ZageWZa^V dWeagdUW W‘Vai_W‘fe’ S‘VfZW ^WhW^ aX eaU[S^ S‘V WUa‘a_[U VWhWâb_W‘f aXfZW SdWS) JZW ^SU] aX ebWU[X[U VSfS Xad fZW bda\WUfSdWS _SVW VWfS[^WV bdWV[Uf[a‘ aX ^[hW^[ZaaV[_bSUfe V[XX[Ug^f’ Tgf [f Xa^âie Xda_ fZW dW^Sf[hWZa_aYW‘W[fk aX fZW dgdS^ babg^Sf[a‘ S‘V’YW‘WdS^^k’ bae[f[hW UZS‘YWe [‘ bdaVgUf[a‘bafW‘f[S^ V[eUgeeWV STahW fZSf’ VS_SY[‘Y^[hW^[ZaaV [_bSUfe iWdW ‘af WjbWUfWV Xad fZW_S\ad[fk aX ZageWZa^Ve)

JZW _S\ad[fk aX ZageWZa^Ve [‘ fZW bda\WUfSdWS bdSUf[UWV X[eZ[‘Y Se bSdf aX S V[hWde[X[WVegTe[efW‘UW ^[hW^[ZaaV S‘V iWdW WjbWUfWV faTW‘WX[f Xda_ [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f ahWdS^^) 8eXSd_Wde ad XSd_ ^STadWde fZWk iag^V YS[‘ fZWTW‘WX[fe aX [dd[YSf[a‘’ S‘V Se X[eZWde _aef iag^VTW‘WX[f Xda_ fZW ‘Wi dWeWdha[d X[eZWdk S‘V afZWd[_bdahWV abbadfg‘[f[We Xad X[eZ[‘Y [‘ fZW VdkeWSea‘) @‘ SYYdWYSfW’ X[eZ[‘Y WXXadf iSeWjbWUfWV fa VWU^[‘W $Se aTeWdhWV Tk CadW‘lW‘ WfS^) -+++ S‘V I_[fZ Wf S^) -++,%’ TWUSgeW aX fZW[‘UdWSeWV ^STad dWcg[dW_W‘fe aX [dd[YSfWV XSd_[‘YS‘V [‘UdWSeWV iSYW dSfWe S‘V VW_S‘V Xad ^STad[‘ âUS^ XSd_ S‘V ‘a‘(XSd_ ^STad _Sd]Wfe)

@‘UdWSeWV SUUWee fa ‘Wi S‘V _adW bWdW‘‘[SîSfWd TaV[We iag^V Ua_bW‘eSfW Xad fZW

dWVgUf[a‘ aX XâaVb^S[‘ SdWS’ S^fZagYZ fZWdW i[^^TW V[XXWdW‘f[Sf[a‘ [‘ fZ[e dWeg^f TWfiWW‘ âUSf[a‘eS‘V ZageWZa^Ve) FhWdS^^’ SUUWee i[^^ TW[_bdahWV’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k Vgd[‘Y fZW Vdk eWSea‘’ S‘V[_badfS‘f^k SUUWee fa X[eZWd[We Xad fZW ^S‘V^WeeS‘V _SdY[‘S [̂lWV eZag^V TW _S[‘fS[‘WV) I_[fZ WfS^) $-++,% egYYWefWV fZSf fdShW^ fa dWeWdha[dX[eZWd[We US‘ TW XSU[^[fSfWV Tk eWdh[UW daSVeUa‘efdgUfWV Sâ‘Y [dd[YSf[a‘ US‘Sê’ Tgf Se _W‘SdW YW‘WdS^^k _adW _aT[^W fZS‘ ia_W‘ fZ[e[_bSUf _Sk TW V[XXWdW‘f[SfWV Sâ‘Y YW‘VWd ^[‘We)HWVgUf[a‘ aX f[_W ebW‘f fdShW^[‘Y’ S‘V*adUa‘UW‘fdSf[a‘e aX _[YdSf[‘Y X[eZ UdWSfWV Tk fZW[dd[YSf[a‘ [‘XdSefdgUfgdW’ i[^^ [_bdahW fZWWXX[U[W‘Uk aX fZW X[eZ[‘Y WXXadf’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k XadZageWZa^Ve e[fgSfWV [‘ UâeW bdaj[_[fk fa fZWdWeWdha[d) @dd[YSf[a‘ dWfgd‘ Xâie S‘V eWWbSYW i[^^Sêa XSU[^[fSfW Vdk eWSea‘ SUUWee fa X[eZWd[We Xadia_W‘ iZa YW‘WdS^^k X[eZ ‘WSdWd fZW[d Za_We)

Opportunities for Mitigation and Enhancement

8 dS‘YW aX _[f[YSf[a‘ _WSegdWe iWdW Ua‘e[VWdWV[‘ fZW SeeWee_W‘f iad]eZabe5

· DS[‘fW‘S‘UW aX S dS[‘(XWV iWf eWSea‘ d[UWUdab [e ^[]W^k fa TW _aef Ud[f[US^ XadegefS[‘[‘Y X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ fZW SdWS)

· DS[‘fW‘S‘UW aX ^SfWdS^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk fZdagYZVWe[Y‘ aX X[eZ(Xd[W‘V^k Udaee(VdS[‘SYWUg^hWdfe [e S e[_b^W S‘V bafW‘f[S^^k [_badfS‘f_WSegdW) :daee(VdS[‘SYW Ug^hWdfe aX ?gSkJZagSf [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_ ZSV TWW‘ VWe[Y‘WVXad S Xâi aX , - _WfWde bWd eWUa‘V iZ[UZWjUWWVWV fZW _Sj[_g_ eZadf(fWd_ei[__[‘Y ebWWV aX _aef X[eZ ebWU[We$_aef^k TWâi +)0 _*e’ :^Sk ,440% iZW‘_[YdSf[‘Y gbefdWS_ Sf f[_We aX Z[YZ dS[‘XS^^S‘V Xâi) CSdYWd Ug^hWdfe iag^V dWVgUW XâihWâU[fk S‘V [_bdahW Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk’ Tgf SdW_adW WjbW‘e[hW S‘V dWcg[dW dWYg^Sd_S[‘fW‘S‘UW fa dW_ahW VWTd[e)

· DS[‘fW‘S‘UW aX â‘Y[fgV[‘S^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fkSUdaee fZW 4 _WfWd Z[YZ VS_ [e V[XX[Ug^f faSUZ[WhW) @f [e Sêa VagTfXg^ iZWfZWd fZ[eiag^V bdah[VW e[Y‘[X[US‘f bdaVgUf[a‘ TW‘WX[feSe _S‘k ebWU[We SdW ^[]W^k fa _S[‘fS[‘

,0

eWbSdSfW eW^X(egefS[‘[‘Y babg^Sf[a‘e STahWS‘V TWâi fZW VS_) JZ[e iSe dWYSdVWV Se Sâi bd[ad[fk) ?aiWhWd’ fZWdW _Sk TW fdSVW(aXXe TWfiWW‘ _S[‘fS[‘[‘Y iSfWd Xad dWeWdha[dX[eZ babg^Sf[a‘e S‘V dW^WSe[‘Y iSfWd Xad_S[‘fS[‘[‘Y ZST[fSfe [‘ fZW d[hWd Vai‘efdWS_fZW VS_)

· 8gY_W‘fSf[a‘ aX d[hWd Xâi i[fZW‘h[da‘_W‘fS^ dW^WSeWe Vgd[‘Y ]Wk

_[YdSfadk bWd[aVe _Sk TW dWcg[dWV fa S^âiX[eZ _[YdSf[a‘ [‘fa d[UW X[W^V ZST[fSfe) JZ[e[eegW eZag^V TW SeeWeeWV a‘UW fZW eUZW_W[e abWdSf[a‘S^)

· ;dS[‘SYW UZS‘‘Wê _Sk TWUa_W ]Wk_[YdSfadk bSfZiSke i[fZ[‘ fZW [dd[YSfWV d[UWX[W^V ekefW_’ Se â‘Y Se UZS‘‘Wê SdWVWe[Y‘WV i[fZagf XS^^ efdgUfgdWe) @‘ SVV[f[a‘’X[eZba‘Ve Xad bd[hSfW ScgSUg^fgdW SdW ^[]W^k faTW UdWSfWV [‘ fZW Ua__S‘V SdWS S‘V i[^^bdah[VW SVV[f[a‘S^ Vdk eWSea‘ ZST[fSf Xad i[^VX[eZ’ g‘^Wee fZWk SdW VdS[‘WV Ua_b^WfW^k)

Summary of the Lao Case Study

JZW USeW [e S‘ WjS_b^W iZWdW [dd[YSf[a‘ [e TW[‘Y[‘fdaVgUWV [‘ S‘ SdWS i[fZ d[UZ X[eZWdk dWeagdUWe’S‘V iZWdW X[eZ[‘Y b^Ske S‘ [_badfS‘f da^W [‘ fZW^[hW^[ZaaVe aX _aef dgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve) JZW ‘Wf[_bSUf aX fZW [dd[YSf[a‘ bda\WUf a‘ X[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[a‘ iSe bdWV[UfWV fa TW e^[YZf^k bae[f[hW)JZ[e g‘WjbWUfWV S‘V bWdZSbe Uag‘fWd([‘fg[f[hWdWeg^f [e fZW dWeg^f aX fia _S[‘ XSUfade)

[%) ESfgdS^ X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘ [e fa S ^SdYW WjfW‘fVWd[hWV Xda_ dS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve’ S‘V US‘ TWegefS[‘WV i[fZ[‘ fZW [dd[YSfWV ekefW_bdah[VWV fZSf fZW dS[‘(XWV iWf eWSea‘ d[UWUdab [e _S[‘fS[‘WV)

[[%) JZW dWeWdha[d X[eZWdk fZSf i[^^ TW UdWSfWVeZag^V TW egXX[U[W‘f fa Sf ^WSef Ua_bW‘eSfWXad bdaVgUf[a‘ âeeWe Sd[e[‘Y Vai‘efdWS_ [‘fZW d[hWd S‘V [fe SeeaU[SfWV XâaVb^S[‘)

JZW ahWdS^^ [_bSUf a‘ fZW ^[hW^[ZaaVe aXbWab^W ^[h[‘Y [‘ fZW bda\WUf SdWS [e Sêa bdWV[UfWVfa TW bae[f[hW) JZW _S\ad[fk i[^^ YS[‘ TW‘WX[feXda_ [dd[YSfWV XSd_[‘Y S‘V fZW ef[_g^ge fZ[e

bdah[VWe fa fZW âUS^ WUa‘a_k’ iZ[^W X[eZ[‘Y’iZ[UZ [e fZW[d eWUa‘V _aef [_badfS‘f SUf[h[fk’ i[^^‘af TW SVhWdeW^k SXXWUfWV [‘ SYYdWYSfW S‘V _SkTW W‘ZS‘UWV) ?aiWhWd’ fZWeW SYYdWYSfWVbae[f[hW dWeg^fe Z[VW baee[T^W V[XXWdW‘f[Sf[a‘ aXfZW [_bSUfe S_a‘Y eWUf[a‘e aX fZW Ua__g‘[f[WeSXXWUfWV) @X fZW bda\WUf bdaUWWVe’ egUZV[XXWdW‘f[Sf[a‘ Tk âUSf[a‘ [‘ fZW USfUZ_W‘f’eaU[aWUa‘a_[U efSfge S‘V YW‘VWd eZag^V TW_a‘[fadWV fa W‘egdW fZSf fZW [‘fWdWefe aXhg^‘WdST^W Ydagbe SdW eSXWYgSdVWV) Daef Sf d[e]i[^^ TW fZW ^S‘V^Wee ad ^S‘V(VWX[U[W‘f ZageWZa^Ve’iZa SdW _adW ZWSh[^k VWbW‘VW‘f a‘ X[eZ[‘Y TgfSdW S â‘Y V[efS‘UW SiSk Xda_ fZW dWeWdha[d’bSdf[Ug^Sd^k [X fZWk SdW ^Wee ST^W fa Wjbâ[f ‘Wi^STad _Sd]Wf abbadfg‘[f[We)

8^fZagYZ [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f _Sk ZW^b faef[_g^SfW fZW dgdS^ WUa‘a_k ^WSV[‘Y fa ‘Wi^[hW^[ZaaV abbadfg‘[f[We’ fZW egTe[efW‘UW S‘VTSU]iSdV ‘SfgdW aX fZW dgdS^ WUa‘a_k i[^^bWde[ef Xad ea_W f[_W’ _S][‘Y [f WeeW‘f[S^ fZSffZW ^[hW^[ZaaV Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘e aX X[eZ[‘Y SdWegefS[‘WV) @‘VWWV X[eZ[‘Y US‘ Ua‘f[‘gW fa TW bSdfaX fZW V[hWde[X[WV ^[hW^[ZaaVe aX _aef dgdS^ZageWZa^Ve’ iZ[^W Sêa b^Sk[‘Y fZW da^W aX SeSXWfk(‘Wf $Ag^(CSdeW‘ S‘V hS‘ Pi[WfW‘ -++-6

9m‘m -++.% Xad fZW baadWef eWUf[a‘e aX fZW dgdS^babg^Sf[a‘)

+<D<A7< /J5 *DD<:5F<BA 5A7 28FF?8@8AF0DB=86F !+/*20"# 2D< ,5A>5

Background

I[‘UW ^[TWdS^[lSf[a‘ aX fZW WUa‘a_k Xda_ ,422’WUa‘a_[U YdaifZ [‘ Id[ CS‘]S ZSe TWW‘dW^Sf[hW^k efda‘Y $a‘ ShWdSYW 0 bWdUW‘f bWdS‘‘g_ Xda_ ,44+ fa -+++’ :W‘fdS^ 9S‘] aX Id[CS‘]S -++,% SbSdf Xda_ XdWcgW‘f eâi(Vai‘edWeg^f[‘Y Xda_ fZW [‘fWd‘S^ Ua‘X^[Uf ad [‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^WUa‘a_[U eZaU]e) @‘ -++, fZW >;G dWSUZWVKI"343 T[^^[a‘’ Wcg[hS^W‘f fa KI"0.1 bWd USb[fS’Tgf g‘W_bâk_W‘f dW_S[‘WV S bWde[efW‘fbdaT^W_) JZW SYd[Ug^fgdS^ eWUfad’ [‘U^gV[‘YXadWefdk S‘V X[eZWd[We’ iSe fZW _S[‘efSk aX fZW‘Sf[a‘S^ WUa‘a_k’ Ua‘fd[Tgf[‘Y -+ bWdUW‘f aX fZW>EG [‘ -++,’ bdah[V[‘Y V[dWUf W_bâk_W‘f fa .0

,1

bWdUW‘f aX fZW iad]XadUW’ S‘V dW_S[‘[‘Y S‘[_badfS‘f eagdUW aX [‘Ua_W Xad STagf 2+ bWdUW‘faX fZW babg^Sf[a‘ $:W‘fdS^ 9S‘] aX Id[ CS‘]S-++,%) ;Web[fW efda‘Y YdaifZ [‘ ea_W eWUfade’ SYdai[‘Y _[VV^W [‘Ua_W U^See [‘ gdTS‘ SdWSe S‘VYaaV bdaYdWee a‘ eaU[S^ [‘V[USfade Sf fZW‘Sf[a‘S^ ^WhW^’ _gUZ bahWdfk dW_S[‘WV [‘ dgdS^SdWSe’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k [‘ fZW ‘adfZ(iWef S‘V fZWeagfZ(WSef Vdk la‘W aX fZW Uag‘fdk)

@‘ fZ[e Ua‘fWjf’ TafZ _Sd[‘W S‘V [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We ZShW b^SkWV S‘ [_badfS‘f da^W [‘egbbadf[‘Y fZW ^[hW^[ZaaVe aX S e[Y‘[X[US‘f ‘g_TWdaX dgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve’ S‘V Se S eagdUW aX S‘[_S^bdafW[‘’ VWeb[fW fZW[d _aVWef eZSdW [‘ fZW >EG$-)2 bWdUW‘f’ :W‘fdS^ 9S‘] aX Id[ CS‘]S -++-%):aSefS^’ VWWb eWS S‘V aXXeZadW’ S‘V [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We Ua‘fd[TgfWV 02’ .+ S‘V ,. bWdUW‘f’dWebWUf[hW^k’ aX fafS^ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ $:W‘fdS^9S‘] aX Id[ CS‘]S -++-%) 8^fZagYZ [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We iWdW ^Wee [_badfS‘f fZS‘ _Sd[‘WX[eZWd[We [‘ fWd_e aX Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘ fa fZW >;G S‘VW_bâk_W‘f Sf fZW ‘Sf[a‘S^ ^WhW^’ fZ[e VaWe ‘afV[_[‘[eZ fZW[d [_badfS‘UW Se S eagdUW aX^[hW^[ZaaV Xad dgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve’ _S‘k aX iZa_SdW S_a‘Y fZW baadWef [‘ dgdS^ SdWSe’ ‘ad fZW[d[_badfS‘UW Se S eagdUW aX bdafW[‘ [‘ dgdS^ V[Wfe)

=[eZWd[We iWdW TW^[WhWV fa V[dWUf^k egbbadffZW ^[hW^[ZaaVe aX ahWd ,+ bWdUW‘f aX fZWbabg^Sf[a‘ [‘ _S‘k UaSefS^ SdWSe’ Tgf ‘a bdWU[eWX[YgdWe Wj[efWV Xad fZW [‘^S‘V eWUfad $DgddSk WfS^) -+++%) 8‘ Wef[_SfWV 41 bWdUW‘f aX fZWbabg^Sf[a‘ dWYg^Sd^k Ua‘eg_WV ea_W Xad_ aXX[eZ’ iZ[^W [‘ ,441 X[eZ bdaVgUfe Ua‘ef[fgfWV S‘Wef[_SfWV 04 bWdUW‘f aX fZW ‘Sf[a‘ e fafS^ ‘a‘(hWYWfST^W bdafW[‘ Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ $E8H8 ,442%)@‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We SdW _aef^k Ua‘UW‘fdSfWV [‘bWdW‘‘[S^ dWeWdha[de iZWdW fZW SUf[h[fk ZSe TWW‘bda_afWV e[‘UW ,40- fZdagYZ fZW [‘fdaVgUf[a‘ aXWjaf[U f[^Sb[S ebWU[We $A]PZNS]ZXT^ XZ^^LXMTN‘^LYO A& YTWZ_TN‘^% S‘V fZW YahWd‘_W‘f bdaYdS_eegTe[V[l[‘Y X[eZ[‘Y UdSXf S‘V YWSd $8_SdSe[‘YZW,443%) JZW dWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We SdW _S‘SYWV_aef^k Xad fZW [‘fdaVgUWV f[^Sb[Se’ TWUSgeWX[eZWde S‘V Ua‘eg_Wde bdWXWd fZW_) ?aiWhWd’

f[^Sb[Se ef[^^ SUUag‘f Xad a‘^k STagf ,+ bWdUW‘f aXfZW X[eZ T[a_See [‘ fZWeW dWeWdha[de’ S‘V ‘Sf[hWX[eZ ebWU[We dW_S[‘ [_badfS‘f [‘ TafZ bdaVgUf[a‘S‘V T[aV[hWde[fk fWd_e $GWf Wf S^) ,441%)

HWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We ZShW bdah[VWV e[Y‘[X[US‘f[‘Ua_W’ W_bâk_W‘f S‘V V[WfSdk TW‘WX[fe) @‘ Id[CS‘]S’ Xad dgdS^ S‘V gdTS‘ babg^Sf[a‘e [‘ YW‘WdS^’Vd[WV X[eZ ZSe â‘Y TWW‘ S‘ [_badfS‘f Ua_ba‘W‘faX fZW V[Wf’ VgW fa SVhS‘fSYWe [‘ ZS‘V^[‘Y S‘VefadSYW) ?aiWhWd’ dWUW‘f VSfS eZaie S‘ [‘UdWSeW[‘ XdWeZiSfWd X[eZ Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ b^ge Z[YZWd ^WhWêaX Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ [‘ fZW [dd[YSfWV $ad Vdk% la‘W) JZW[dd[YSfWV SdWSe SdW _aef^k [‘^S‘V S‘V aXfW‘ ^SU]fdS‘ebadf XSU[^[f[We) JZge’ [f US‘ TW WjbWUfWV fZSfUa‘eg_bf[a‘ aX XdWeZiSfWd X[eZ [e Z[YZ dW^Sf[hW fa_Sd[‘W X[eZ Ua‘eg_bf[a‘’ i[fZ bd[UWe dW^Sf[hW^k_adW SXXadVST^W Xad fZW baadWef ZageWZa^Ve) JZ[eZSe TWW‘ dW[‘XadUWV Tk fZW eWUgd[fk bdaT^W_e [‘fZW ‘adfZ S‘V WSef’ iZ[UZ dWVgUWV egbb^[We aX_Sd[‘W’ XdWeZ S‘V Vd[WV X[eZ’ Ua‘fd[Tgf[‘Y fa Z[YZWdbd[UWe) =dWeZiSfWd X[eZ ZShW fZge TWW‘ [_badfS‘fSe S eagdUW aX bdafW[‘ Xad âi([‘Ua_W ZageWZa^Ve’TW[‘Y dW^Sf[hW^k STg‘VS‘f S‘V SXXadVST^W i[fZ[‘[dd[YSf[a‘ V[efd[Ufe iZWdW fZWdW SdW bdaVgUf[hWdWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We $MW^[YS_SYW -++,%)

JZW B[d[‘V[ FkS @dd[YSf[a‘ S‘V IWff^W_W‘fGda\WUf $BF@IG% [e S _S\ad SYd[Ug^fgdS^VWhWâb_W‘f bda\WUf’ iZ[UZ iSe [_b^W_W‘fWV [‘,431 [‘ fZW WSefWd‘ bSdf aX fZW eagfZWd‘ bdah[‘UWS‘V Vdk la‘W $X[YgdW -%) JZW bda\WUf dWZST[ [̂fSfWVS‘V [‘UadbadSfWV S‘ S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[d(TSeWV[dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_ $Sêa US^̂ WV fS‘] , ekefW_%’iZ[UZ iSe dWb^SUWV Tk S‘ abW‘ USeUSVW [dd[YSf[a‘ekefW_ VdS[‘[‘Y [‘fa fZW @‘V[S‘ FUWS‘ fZdagYZ S‘Wfiad] Ua‘e[ef[‘Y aX S ZWSViSfWd dWeWdha[d aX-++ _[^^[a‘ UgT[U _WfdWe’ X[hW S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[deS‘V Ua__S‘V SdWSe) JZW S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[dekefW_ egbb^[WV S Ua__S‘V SdWS aX /’-++ ZS’iZ[UZ ZSe TWW‘ egbb^W_W‘fWV Tk S ‘WiUa__S‘V SdWS aX 0’/++ ZS’ [‘ iZ[UZ S egTefS‘f[S^babg^Sf[a‘ iSe dWeWff^WV) JZW ‘Wi d[YZf TS‘]Ua__S‘V SdWS WjfW‘Ve S‘V VdS[‘e [‘fa S‘W[YZTad[‘Y iSfWdeZWV) JZW bda\WUf iSe VWe[Y‘WVXad S V[hWde[X[WV Udabb[‘Y bSffWd‘ Tgf e[‘UW

,@‘ Id[ CS‘]S’ fS‘]e dWXWd fa [dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We i[fZ e_S^^(eUS^W $TWâi -++ SUdWe ad 3, ZS% S‘V _WV[g_( eUS^W $TWfiWW‘ -++ ,’+++ SUdWead 3, /+0 ZS% Ua__S‘V SdWSe)

,2

IfS]WZa^VWde Ua‘e[VWdWV fZSf fZW BF@IG ZSV[_bSUfWV a‘ X[eZWd[We S‘V [VW‘f[X[WV fZW Xa^âi[‘Y]Wk [eegWe5

,% HWVgUf[a‘ [‘ d[hWd Xâi S‘V XâaV[‘Y

-% ;WU^[‘[‘Y Vdk eWSea‘ iSfWd dWfW‘f[a‘ [‘e_S^^( S‘V _WV[g_(eUS^W dWeWdha[de

.% @‘Xâi aX VdS[‘SYW iSfWd [‘fa fZW ^SYaa‘e

/% :a‘X^[Ufe TWfiWW‘ X[eZWde S‘V XSd_Wde

0% MWS] ^[‘]SYWe TWfiWW‘ X[eZWd[We [‘ef[fgf[a‘eS‘V [dd[YSf[a‘ [‘ef[fgf[a‘e

@eegW , $dWVgUf[a‘ [‘ d[hWd Xâi% iSe dS[eWV TkeU[W‘f[efe Sf fZW iad]eZab’ iZ[^W [eegWe - fa 0iWdW [VW‘f[X[WV Tk âUS^ efS]WZa^VWde) MZ[^W S^^

abWdSf[a‘ Ua__W‘UWV’ d[UW ZSe TWW‘ fZW _S[‘Udab $@@D@ ,440%) 8e S dWeg^f fZW VW_S‘V Xad[dd[YSf[a‘ iSfWd ZSe TWW‘ Z[YZWd fZS‘ WjbWUfWV’S‘V ahWdS^^ WUa‘a_[U bWdXad_S‘UW ea_WiZSfâiWd) Ea‘WfZW^Wee’ fZW bda\WUf [e Ua‘e[VWdWV fa_S]W S‘ [_badfS‘f Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘ fa fZW WUa‘a_k aXfZW IagfZWd‘ Gdah[‘UW $@@D@ ,440%)

Screening and Scoping

JZW dWUa‘‘S[eeS‘UW egdhWk S‘V dWh[Wi aXeWUa‘VSdk [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ dWhWS^WV fZSf fZWdW iSe Se[Y‘[X[US‘f [‘^S‘V X[eZWdk [‘ fZW B[d[‘V[ FkS TSe[‘’i[fZ X[eZ[‘Y bdWVa_[‘S‘f^k bdSUf[UWV [‘ fZWdWeWdha[de S‘V [‘ UaSefS^ ^SYaa‘e)

=@>KH< -)DSb aX fZW B[d[‘V[ FkS iSfWdeZWV S‘V fZW B[d[‘VS FkS @dd[YSf[a‘ S‘V IWff^W_W‘f Gda\WUf $BF@IG% [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_)

"%)&#$ 38JIKEF <J 8C% ’,,+

,3

[eegWe [VW‘f[X[WV iWdW dW^SfWV fa [dd[YSf[a‘(X[eZWd[We[‘fWdSUf[a‘e’ _aef ZSV Sêa TWW‘ [‘X^gW‘UWV TkVdagYZf Ua‘V[f[a‘e bdWhS[ [̂‘Y Xad . kWSde Sf fZWf[_W aX efgVk S‘V’ iZ[UZ ZSV ^WV fa S YW‘WdSîSfWd eUSdU[fk’ [‘UdWSeWV dgdS^ g‘VWdW_bâk_W‘f’S‘V dWUWee[a‘ [‘ fZW dWY[a‘S^ WUa‘a_k) JZ[e[_b^[WV S ‘WWV fa V[XXWdW‘f[SfW TWfiWW‘ UgddW‘f$VdagYZf([‘X^gW‘UWV% S‘V _adW ‘ad_S^ baef(bda\WUf Ua‘V[f[a‘e [‘ fZW SeeWee_W‘f’ S‘V fZSf SUa_b^WfW eWbSdSf[a‘ aX [dd[YSf[a‘ S‘V VdagYZf[_bSUfe _[YZf ‘af TW baee[T^W)

@_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f [‘ha^hWV UZSdSUfWd[lSf[a‘aX fZW UgddW‘f $baef(bda\WUf% e[fgSf[a‘’[VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ aX UgddW‘f X[eZWd[We bdaT^W_e dW^SfWVfa [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f’ S‘V S‘ SeeWee_W‘f aXfZW ahWdS^^ [_bSUf TSeWV a‘ S dWUa‘efdgUf[a‘ aXfZW bdW(bda\WUf e[fgSf[a‘)

Baseline Situation

JZW TSeW^[‘W e[fgSf[a‘ Ua‘e[efWV aX fZW baef(bda\WUf Ua‘V[f[a‘e Se aTeWdhWV Vgd[‘Y fZW[‘hWef[YSf[a‘e VWeUd[TWV STahW)

@L_‘]LW ]P^Z‘]NP ^d^_PX& CS‘V geW [‘ fZW B[d[‘V[FkS USfUZ_W‘f [e bdWVa_[‘S‘f^k SYd[Ug^fgdS^’S^fZagYZ fZW gbbWd USfUZ_W‘f [e bSdf[S^̂ k XadWefWVS‘V S‘ SdWS aX fZW âiWd USfUZ_W‘f [e eWf Se[VWSe S ESf[a‘S^ GSd]) MSfWd dWeagdUWe [‘U^gVW fZWB[d[‘V[ FkS d[hWd [feW^X’ fZW ^SdYW Cg‘gYS_iWZWdSdWeWdha[d Ua‘efdgUfWV Tk fZW BF@IG’ S ‘g_TWd aX^SdYW S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de’ S‘V UaSefS^ ^SYaa‘e) 8^^d[UW X[W^Ve [‘ TafZ fZW a^V S‘V fZW ‘Wi SdWS SdW[dd[YSfWV’ Se fZW USfUZ_W‘f [e faa Vdk fa egbbadfdS[‘(XWV d[UW Ug^fgdW) :a‘eWcgW‘f^k iSfWd ^WhWê [‘fZW d[UW X[W^Ve SdW âi a‘ ShWdSYW S‘V fkb[US^^kX^gUfgSfW TWfiWW‘ + S‘V ,+ U_ ahWd eZadf f[_WeUS^We $VSke%)

=[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ [e S^_aef W‘f[dW^kUa‘UW‘fdSfWV [‘ fZW dWeWdha[de S‘V ^SYaa‘e) JZWB[d[‘V[ FkS d[hWd [feW^X ZSe S‘ [‘‘SfW^k âibdaVgUf[a‘ bafW‘f[S^ VgW fa efWWb YdSV[W‘fe S‘VdSb[V S‘V eWSea‘S^ d[hWd Xâie’ i[fZ XâaV[‘Y^[_[fWV [‘ VgdSf[a‘ S‘V WjfW‘f $;W I[^hS ,433’8dfZ[‘Yfa‘ Wf S^) -++/%) C[]Wi[eW’ fZW [dd[YSfWVd[UW X[W^Ve egbbadf ^[ff^W X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘) FXfZW fafS^ [‘^S‘V $[‘U^gV[‘Y ^SYaa‘% X[eZWd[We

bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ fZW iSfWdeZWV $eWW fST^W 1 XadVWfS[ê%’ fZW d[hWd’ XâaVb^S[‘ S‘V d[UW X[W^Ve iWdWWef[_SfWV fa Ua‘fd[TgfW ^Wee fZS‘ ,1+ f*kWSd$,+ -+#%) CSYaa‘ X[eZWd[We ZShW TWW‘ _aefVdSef[US^^k SXXWUfWV Tk fZW dWUW‘f VdagYZf’ S‘VZSV h[dfgS^^k UWSeWV Sf fZW f[_W aX [_bSUfSeeWee_W‘f) HWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We iWdW TSeWV_aef^k a‘ [‘fdaVgUWV f[^Sb[S’ Tgf Sêa ea_W‘Sf[hW ebWU[We) CSYaa‘ X[eZWd[We iWdWVa_[‘SfWV Tk f[^Sb[Se $iZ[UZ US‘ fa^WdSfWTdSU][eZ iSfWd%’ Tgf ZSV bdWh[age^k [‘U^gVWV S^SdYW ZSdhWef aX eZd[_b)

>TaPWTSZZO^& 8Yd[Ug^fgdW’ XadWefdk S‘V X[eZWd[WeVa_[‘SfWV fZW âUS^ WUa‘a_k) 8bSdf Xda_ S_[‘ad[fk iZa ebWU[S [̂lWV [‘ X[eZ[‘Y’ _aefUa__g‘[f[We VWbW‘VWV a‘ SYd[Ug^fgdW Se fZW_S[‘ eagdUW aX [‘Ua_W) FfZWd fZS‘ XSd_[‘Y’ fZW_S[‘ e][^ê S‘V WjbWd[W‘UW [‘ fZW SdWS iWdW [‘X[eZ[‘Y’ S‘V [‘ afZWd ‘SfgdS^ dWeagdUW(TSeWVSUf[h[f[We $W)Y)’ eZW^^ _[‘[‘Y’ X[dWiaaV Ua^^WUf[a‘’^[_W _S][‘Y%’ YahWd‘_W‘f eWdhS‘fe $eUZaa^fWSUZWde’ U^Wd]e’ WfU)% S‘V afZWd aUUgbSf[a‘eegUZ Se Vd[hWde’ USdbW‘fWde’ S‘V _Sea‘e)IfSf[ef[Ue Tk V[efd[Uf eZaiWV fZSf g‘W_bâk_W‘f’S‘V fZW bdabadf[a‘ aX W_bâk_W‘f [‘ SYd[Ug^fgdWS‘V X[eZWd[We Xad TafZ _W‘ S‘V ia_W‘’ iWdWe[Y‘[X[US‘f^k Z[YZWd [‘ fZW dWY[a‘ fZS‘ ‘Sf[a‘S^ShWdSYWe $;WbSdf_W‘f aX :W‘ege S‘V IfSf[ef[Ue,444%) F‘W aX fZW UZSdSUfWd[ef[Ue aX fZW ^STad_Sd]Wf [‘ fZW dWY[a‘ iSe fZW ‘WWV Xad ‘Wi \aTeXad fZW eWUa‘V YW‘WdSf[a‘ aX fZaeW ZageWZa^VeiZa _[YdSfWV S‘V eWff^WV [‘ fZW Vdk la‘W’ Y[hW‘fZW eUSdU[fk aX ^S‘V S‘V iSfWd Xad XSd_[‘Y) 8f fZWf[_W aX fZW SeeWee_W‘f [f iSe Sêa Wh[VW‘f fZSffZW dWY[a‘S^ WUa‘a_k iSe hWdk VWbdWeeWV TkfZW bdaâ‘YWV VdagYZf) JZ[e V[dWUf^k SXXWUfWVW_bâk_W‘f [‘ SYd[Ug^fgdW’ [‘ dWeWdha[d S‘V^SYaa‘ X[eZWd[We’ S‘V [‘ fZW dWY[a‘S^ WUa‘a_k SeVW_S‘V Xda_ XSd_[‘Y S‘V X[eZ[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve XadâUS^ YaaVe S‘V eWdh[UWe e^SU]W‘WV)I[_g^fS‘Wage^k Id[ CS‘]S iSe egXXWd[‘Y Xda_ SdWUWee[a‘ [‘ fagd[e_ dWeg^f[‘Y Xda_ Va_Wef[U S‘V[‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ eWUgd[fk Ua‘UWd‘e)

JZW dWeWdha[d S‘V ^SYaa‘ X[eZWd[We iWdW[_badfS‘f Se S eagdUW aX ^[hW^[ZaaV Xad Se[Y‘[X[US‘f ‘g_TWd aX dgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve)

,4

8bbdaj[_SfW^k ,’-.+ ZageWZa^Ve iWdW W‘YSYWV[‘ X[eZ[‘Y $2 # aX fZW fafS^%’ S‘V fZW Ydaee[‘Ua_W Xda_ X[eZ[‘Y iSe Wef[_SfWV Sf KI",)/_[^^[a‘*kWSd’ iZ[UZ dWbdWeW‘fe ,. bWdUW‘f aX fafS^[‘Ua_W [‘ fZW SdWS)

=[eZ USfUZWe Xda_ ^SYaa‘e S‘V S‘U[W‘fdWeWdha[de iWdW geWV Tk X[eZ[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve XadfZW[d ai‘ Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ S‘V Sêa Xad eS^W) =ad X[eZXda_ fZW dWeWdha[de’ fZW _S[‘ _Sd]Wfe iWdW[‘^S‘V gdTS‘ UW‘fWde) DgddSk Wf S^) $-+++%dWbadfWV fZSf [‘ dgdS^ [‘^S‘V SdWSe aX fZW Vdkla‘W VW_S‘V iSe bdWVa_[‘S‘f^k Xad UZWSbWd’âUS^^k ShS[^ST^W [‘^S‘V X[eZ$ dSfZWd fZS‘ Xad XdWeZad Vd[WV _Sd[‘W X[eZ fZSf ZSV fa TW fdS‘ebadfWV Sâ‘Y V[efS‘UW) I_S^^Wd eWSea‘S^ dWeWdha[de [‘ fZWUSfUZ_W‘f iWdW Sêa geWV Xad X[eZ[‘Y’ Tgf fZWSUf[h[fk iSe gegS^^k Ua‘X[‘WV fa aUUSe[a‘S^ adegTe[efW‘UW X[eZ[‘Y) C[ff^W Wf S^) $-++,% ‘afW fZSffZW baadWef’ _aef _SdY[‘S^ _W_TWde aXUa__g‘[f[We YS[‘WV TW‘WX[fe Xda_ Ua‘eg_bf[a‘aX X[eZ USgYZf [‘ eWSea‘S^ dWeWdha[de)

HWeWdha[d S‘V ^SYaa‘ X[eZ[‘Y Se S bd[_SdkaUUgbSf[a‘ Xad_S^^k dWcg[dWe _W_TWdeZ[b aX S=[eZWd_W‘ e :aabWdSf[hW IaU[Wfk $=:I%’ Tgf ]Wk[‘Xad_S‘f [‘fWdh[Wie [‘ S^^ dW^WhS‘f âUSf[a‘e[‘V[USfWV fZSf fZ[e [e dSdW^k WXXWUf[hW^k W‘XadUWV)DW_TWdeZ[b aX S =:I [e YW‘WdS^^k abW‘ a‘^k fafZaeW ^[h[‘Y [‘ fZW h[U[‘[fk aX fZW iSfWd TaVk’ TgffZ[e aXfW‘ ^WSVe fa Ua‘X^[Ufe S‘V [‘ _aef USeWeafZWde Ua‘f[‘gW fa X[eZ i[fZagf TW[‘Y _W_TWde aXfZW =:I) JZWdW SdW Sêa YahWd‘_W‘f dWYg^Sf[a‘ea‘ Y[^^ ‘Wf _WeZ e[lW Xad dWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We’ TgfSYS[‘ W‘XadUW_W‘f [e [‘WXXWUf[hW) JZW _WfZaVegeWV [‘ dWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We SdW e[_b^W S‘V hSdk^[ff^W) =[eZWde dWe[VW‘f ‘WSd fZW dWeWdha[d Xad iZa_X[eZ[‘Y [e fZW _S[‘ WUa‘a_[U SUf[h[fk $gegS^^k =:I_W_TWde% S^_aef WjU^ge[hW^k geW Y[^^ ‘Wfe eWfXda_ ‘Sddai X[TdWY^See agfd[YYWd US‘aWe) EWfe SdWbdWVa_[‘S‘f^k eWf [‘ fZW WSd^k WhW‘[‘Y S‘V fZWUSfUZ [e ZSg^WV [‘ Sf WSd^k _ad‘[‘Y) JZW X[eZWdedW_S[‘ bdWeW‘f S^^ ‘[YZf iZWdW fZWdW [e S d[e] aXfZWXf ad VS_SYW fa ‘Wfe Xda_ UdaUaV[^We) JZW‘ad_S^ bdSUf[UW [e fa ZShW fia X[eZWde [‘ WSUZTaSf fZW ai‘Wd S‘V S dWYg^Sd UdWi(_W_TWdbdaUWWVe TW[‘Y eZSdWV SXfWd eWff[‘Y Se[VW SUWdfS[‘ bdabadf[a‘ Se dW‘f aX fZW TaSf S‘V ‘Wfe$fkb[US^^k -+ .+ #% $:ZS‘VdSe[d[ ,431%) =[eZWde

[‘ TafZ S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de S‘V ^SYaa‘e US‘ fZgeTW USfWYad[lWV Se5 [% ai‘Wd(abWdSfade aX TaSfeS‘V YWSd’ [[% Z[dWde $bSk[‘Y S eZSdW aX fZW USfUZXad fZW geW aX TaSfe S‘V YWSd%’ S‘V[[[% UdWi_W_TWde iad][‘Y Xad S eZSdW aX fZWUSfUZ) >W‘WdS^^k’ fZW ^SffWd SdW S âi([‘Ua_WYdagb’ i[fZ fZW YdWSfWef g‘UWdfS[‘fk aXW_bâk_W‘f $Bg^SdSf‘W ,444%) Ma_W‘ gegS^^kZShW ^[ff^W V[dWUf [‘ha^hW_W‘f [‘ [‘^S‘V X[eZ[‘YSbSdf Xda_ See[ef[‘Y i[fZ fZW _W‘V[‘Y aX X[eZ[‘YYWSd W)Y)’ Y[^^ ‘Wfe) 8â‘Ye[VW egUZ Xg^^(f[_WX[eZ[‘Y S i[VWd ebWUfdg_ aX afZWd X[eZWde S‘VX[eZ[‘Y _WfZaVe US‘ TW aTeWdhWV’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k [‘e_S^^Wd S‘V _adW SUUWee[T^W dWeWdha[de) ;SkX[eZ[‘Y i[fZ USef(‘Wfe ad Zaa] S‘V ^[‘W [eUa__a‘’ Xad ai‘ Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ ad bSdf(f[_W faegbb^W_W‘f XSd_ ad afZWd [‘Ua_W) 8YS[‘ fZ[e [ebdWVa_[‘S‘f^k S _S^W SUf[h[fk’ S‘V XSd_Wde S‘VXSd_ ^STadWde US‘ W‘YSYW [‘ fZ[e SUf[h[fk _S[‘^k [‘fZW e^SU] bWd[aV TWfiWW‘ bSVVk eai[‘Y S‘VZSdhWef)

JZW h[^^SYW egdhWke Ua‘VgUfWV Se bSdf aX fZW[_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f Xag‘V fZSf 0 fa ,0 bWdUW‘f aXZageWZa^Ve [‘ h[^^SYWe’ iZ[UZ SdW [‘ UâeWbdaj[_[fk fa fZW dWeWdha[de dWYg^Sd^k X[eZWV XadfZW[d ai‘ Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ S‘V fa YW‘WdSfW S‘SVV[f[a‘S^ [‘Ua_W Tk iSk aX eW^^[‘Y $fST^W /%)8^fZagYZ S _[‘ad[fk’ ahWd ZS^X aX fZWeW iWdW^S‘V^Wee ad _SdY[‘S^ XSd_[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve’ XadiZa_ X[eZ[‘Y iSe fZW bd[_Sdk eagdUW aX ^[hW^[ZaaV$Se Sêa aTeWdhWV Tk :ZS‘VdSe[d[ ,4316 HW‘i[U]-++,%’ Xad afZWde egUZ Se XSd_Wde S‘V X[eZWde’ XadiZa_ XSd_[‘Y iSe fZW _S[‘ ^[hW^[ZaaV’ X[eZ[‘YiSe S‘ [_badfS‘f egbb^W_W‘fSdk eagdUW aX XaaVS‘V [‘Ua_W) @f iSe ‘afST^W fZSf S e[Y‘[X[US‘f‘g_TWd aX dWeWdha[d X[eZWde iWdW kag‘Y _W‘ S‘VfZSf fZWk TWâ‘Y fa fZW eWUa‘V YW‘WdSf[a‘ aXeWff^Wde g‘VWd fZW BF@IG eUZW_W) M[fZagf V[dWUfSUUWee fa [dd[YSfWV ^S‘V Xad XSd_[‘Y S‘V i[fZ^[_[fWV S^fWd‘Sf[hW W_bâk_W‘f abbadfg‘[f[We’fZWeW kag‘Y _W‘ dW^[WV a‘ X[eZ[‘Y S‘V afZWdSUf[h[f[We egUZ Se USegS^ ^STad[‘Y’ S‘V fZW dW‘f[‘Yad eZSdW(Udabb[‘Y aX e_S^^ bâfe iZW‘ ShS[^ST^W)FhWdS^̂ [‘ fZW BF@IG USfUZ_W‘f’ _aef [‘^S‘VX[eZ[‘Y [e USdd[WV agf W[fZWd Se S Xg^^(f[_WebWU[S^[lSf[a‘’ ad Se S‘ abbadfg‘[ef SUf[h[fk Tk fZWbaad S‘V ^S‘V^Wee iZa Sêa W‘YSYW [‘ afZWd

-+

J89C< /)Gdabadf[a‘ aX ZageWZa^Ve W‘YSYWV [‘ X[eZ[‘Y’ [‘ fZW egdhWkWV h[^^SYWe [‘ -++-)

L[^^SYW CaUSf[a‘ [‘ USfUZ_W‘f =[eZWdk Eg_TWd aX Ea) aX X[eZWd # aXZageWZa^Ve ZageWZa^Ve ZageWZa^Ve

$Xg^^ S‘V W‘YSYWV [‘bSdf(f[_W% X[eZ[‘Y

HS‘SiSdS‘WiWiS gbbWd USfUZ_W‘f e_S^^ dWeWdha[de ,41 ,0 3#

BgVSYS_S , ‘Wi Ua__S‘V SdWS ‘Wi dWeWdha[d -/+ ,0 1#

9S‘VSY[d[kS a^V Ua__S‘V SdWS S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[d ,’0++ Sbbdaj) -++ Sbbdaj) ,0#

DS^S]SbgbSfZS‘S a^V Ua__S‘V SdWS S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[d -3- ,2 1#

ESV[YS‘i[^S TS‘]e aX B[d[‘V[ FkS S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de S‘V -10 .+ Sbbdaj)& ,,#d[hWd Vai‘efdWS_ aX dWeWdha[d

GS^^W_S^S^S ‘WSd UaSef ^SYaa‘ .0+ .33 ,+- && -0#

KVS_S^S^S ‘WSd UaSef ^SYaa‘ /.0 .+ 2#

I[bb[]g^S_S ‘WSd UaSef ^SYaa‘ /0+ ,/+ && .+#

"%)&#$ 7@CC8>< IKHL<O$ 0<9HK8HO (&&(

!%($’ #38@ECO FGGFHJKE@IJ@: 8E; C<@IKH< =@I?@E> @E J?< H@L<H

##2<II =@I?@E> ;KH@E> J?< GH<L8@C@E> ;HFK>?J%

[ddWYg^Sd SUf[h[f[We egUZ Se X[dWiaaV Ua^^WUf[a‘’^STad[‘Y S‘V eZSdW(Udabb[‘Y iZW‘ ST^W) GSdf(f[_Wegbb^W_W‘fSdk X[eZ[‘Y Tk XSd_[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve SêaaUUgde Se VWeUd[TWV STahW’ Tgf [f [e _gUZ ^WeeUa__a‘ fZS‘ [‘ CSae’ iZWdW fZW bdSUf[UW [eS^_aef g‘[hWdeS^)

8f fZW f[_W aX fZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fdWbadfWV [‘Ua_We Xda_ X[eZ[‘Y Ua_bSdWV baad^kfa afZWd ‘a‘(e][^^WV W_bâk_W‘f’ S‘V _aefX[eZ[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k fZaeW X[eZ[‘YXg^^(f[_W’ iWdW S_a‘Y fZW âiWef [‘Ua_W Ydagbe[‘ fZW dWY[a‘ $fST^W 0%) ?aiWhWd’ X[eZ[‘YZageWZa^Ve dWbadfWV fZSf bd[ad fa fZW dWUW‘fVdagYZf dWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We ZSV bdah[VWV Z[YZWd[‘Ua_We fZS‘ afZWd ShS[^ST^W ‘a‘(e][^^WVW_bâk_W‘f) JZ[e [e egbbadfWV Tk fZW [‘X^Sf[a‘(SV\gefWV Wef[_SfWe [‘ fST^W 0) HW‘i[U] $-++,%e[_[^Sd^k dWbadfe ShWdSYW bdW(VdagYZf [‘Ua_WeXad dWeWdha[d X[eZ[‘Y [e Sbbdaj[_SfW^k He .++bWd VSk S‘V Wef[_SfWe fZSf fZW S‘‘gS^ [‘Ua_WXda_ Xg^^(f[_W X[eZ[‘Y iag^V WjUWWV fZW S‘‘gS^[‘Ua_W Xda_ [dd[YSfWV SYd[Ug^fgdW) @‘Ua_We Xda_X[eZ[‘Y SdW’ ZaiWhWd’ [‘Wh[fST^k hSd[ST^W S‘VVWbW‘VW‘f a‘ WjbWd[W‘UW S‘V SUUWee fa TaSfeS‘V X[eZ[‘Y YWSd)

@‘ fZW h[^^SYWe ‘WSd fa fZW ^SYaa‘eSbbdaj[_SfW^k -0 .+ bWdUW‘f aX ZageWZa^Ve ZSVTWW‘ dWYg^Sd^k W‘YSYWV [‘ X[eZ[‘Y $fST^W /%) 8efZW ^SYaa‘ X[eZWd[We ZSV h[dfgS^^k UWSeWV g‘VWdfZW bdWhS[^[‘Y VdagYZf fZW SeeWee_W‘f aX fZW[dUa‘fd[Tgf[a‘e fa ^[hW^[ZaaVe g‘VWd _adW ‘ad_SÛa‘V[f[a‘e iWdW SeUWdfS[‘WV TSeWV a‘ fZW[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ ShS[^ST^W Xda_ fZW bdW(VdagYZfegdhWke’ iZ[UZ iWdW Ua‘VgUfWV [‘ WSd^k ,44+ fa_[V(,44+e’ S‘V Sêa Xda_ afZWd ]Wk [‘Xad_S‘fe)9WfiWW‘ -0+ S‘V /++ ZageWZa^Ve SbbWSd faZShW dW^[WV bd[_Sd[^k a‘ eZd[_b X[eZ[‘Y [‘ fZW^SYaa‘ [‘ fZW WSd^k ,44+e’ dWVgU[‘Y fa ,++ -++ZageWZa^Ve Tk ,441 $@@D@ ,4406 Bg^SdSf‘W ,444%)=[eZ[‘Y iSe fZW _S[‘ eagdUW aX [‘Ua_W Xad 33bWdUW‘f aX S^^ fZW X[eZ[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve [‘ fZWdW^WhS‘f SV_[‘[efdSf[hW V[efd[Uf’ [)W)’ GS^^W_S^S^S9]LXL @TWLOSL]T ;[h[e[a‘’ i[fZ SYd[Ug^fgdW S‘VX[eZ dWfS[^[‘Y TW[‘Y fZW _S[‘ S^fWd‘Sf[hWe) @‘SVV[f[a‘ ea_W ZageWZa^Ve W‘YSYWV [‘ X[eZ[‘Y a‘S bSdf(f[_W TSe[e’ S‘V _S‘k ‘a‘(X[eZ[‘YZageWZa^Ve X[eZWV [‘ fZW ^SYaa‘ Xad fZW[d ai‘Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ a‘^k) JZW ShWdSYW _a‘fZ^k [‘Ua_W[‘ ,441*,442 Xad Xg^^(f[_W ^SYaa‘ X[eZ[‘YZageWZa^Ve iSe dWbadfWV fa TW fZdWW f[_We _adW

-,

fZS‘ fZSf aX ‘a‘(X[eZ[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve [‘ fZW eS_WSdWS $Bg^SdSf‘W ,444%) @‘fWdh[Wie i[fZ ^SYaa‘X[eZ[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve [‘V[USfWV fZSf Vgd[‘Y fZWbdWhS[^[‘Y VdagYZf fZW _aef Ua__a‘ S^fWd‘Sf[hWefa X[eZ[‘Y W‘YSYWV [‘ Tk _W‘ iWdW dWfS[^[‘Y$gegS^^k Tk T[UkU^W% aX _Sd[‘W S‘V dWeWdha[d X[eZUSgYZf Tk afZWde’ Ua^^WUf[a‘ aX X[dWiaaV S‘VUSegS^ ^STad[‘Y [‘ eS^f bS‘e’ iZ[UZ iWdW SêaâUSfWV [‘ ea_W aX fZW UaSefS^ ^SYaa‘e) 8^fZagYZdW^Sf[hW^k dW_g‘WdSf[hW a‘ S b[WUW dSfW TSe[e XadfZaeW bZke[US^^k X[f $fST^W 0%’ fZW SdVgage ‘SfgdWaX iad] [‘ fZW eS^f bS‘e _WS‘f fZSf iZW‘WhWdShS[^ST^W’ _aef S^fWd‘Sf[hW SUf[h[f[We iWdWbdWXWddWV) :ZS‘YWe [‘ fZW eZd[_b X[eZWdk S‘VfZW[d dW^Sf[a‘ fa [dd[YSf[a‘ SdW V[eUgeeWV [‘ _adWVWfS[^ [‘ fZW Xa^âi[‘Y eWUf[a‘)

:a‘X^[Ufe TWfiWW‘ X[eZWde S‘V XSd_Wde STagfiSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f [eegWe iWdW Xag‘V fa TWUa__a‘) @‘ fZW S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de fZWeWUa‘X^[Ufe UW‘fdWV a‘ ^WhWê aX _Sj[_g_VdSiVai‘’ i[fZ X[eZWde U^S[_[‘Y fZSf âi iSfWddWfW‘f[a‘ [‘ fZW Vdk eWSea‘ dWVgUWV S‘‘gSÛSfUZWe aX X[eZ) 8^fZagYZ _Sj[_g_ [dd[YSf[a‘dW^WSeWe iWdW eWf Sf fZW TWY[‘‘[‘Y aX WSUZeWSea‘’ fZW ‘WWVe aX X[eZWd[We iWdW ‘af Y[hW‘iW[YZf [‘ fZW b^S‘‘[‘Y bdaUWee’ S‘V [‘ bdSUf[UWXSd_Wde fW‘VWV fa VW_S‘V S‘V geW _adW iSfWd

fZS‘ [‘[f[S^^k S^âUSfWV) JZ[e Ua‘X^[Uf iSeWebWU[S^^k eWhWdW g‘VWd fZW a‘Ya[‘Y VdagYZfUa‘V[f[a‘e) @‘ fZW ^SYaa‘e’ X[eZWd(XSd_WdUa‘X^[Ufe UW‘fdWV a‘ fZW abW‘[‘Y aX fZW UaSefSêS‘V TSd) Gd[ad fa fZW VdagYZf XSd_Wde abW‘WVfZW eS‘V TSd XdWcgW‘f^k fa dWVgUW iSfWd ^WhWêS‘V Sha[V XâaV[‘Y aX SYd[Ug^fgdS^ ^S‘V’ iZ[^WX[eZWde Ua‘e[VWdWV fZSf fZ[e S^âiWV eZd[_b faW_[YdSfW S‘V fZWdWTk dWVgUW fZW cgS‘f[fk aX fZWUSfUZ S‘V fZW [‘Ua_W YW‘WdSfWV) @‘ef[fgf[a‘S^SddS‘YW_W‘fe fa VWS^ i[fZ X[eZWd[We S‘V iSfWd_S‘SYW_W‘f [eegWe S‘V dW^SfWV Ua‘X^[Ufe iWdWiWS]’ S‘V fZ[e iSe eWW‘ Se S _S\ad bdaT^W_Tk fZW X[eZWde)

Evaluation of Project Impacts

<hS^gSf[a‘ aX bda\WUf [_bSUfe dW^[WV a‘ fZWUa_bSd[ea‘ aX fZW TSeW^[‘W i[fZ S bdW(bda\WUfe[fgSf[a‘ dWUa‘efdgUfWV a‘ fZW TSe[e aX egdhWkeUa‘VgUfWV [‘ fZW WSd^k ,43+e’ S‘V SêabSdf[U[bSfadk SeeWee_W‘f [‘ha^h[‘Y efS]WZa^VWdeiZa Uag^V Ua_bSdW bdW( S‘V baef(bda\WUfUa‘V[f[a‘e) MZW‘ SeeWee[‘Y [dd[YSf[a‘ [_bSUfe [fiSe fZge [_badfS‘f fa Ua‘e[VWd fZSf fZW bdW( S‘Vbaef(bda\WUf Ua_bSd[ea‘e ebS‘‘WV S bWd[aV aXS^_aef -+ kWSde) ;gd[‘Y fZ[e bWd[aV _S‘k eaU[S^

J89C< 0)@‘Ua_W Xda_ X[eZ[‘Y S‘V S^fWd‘Sf[hW _S^W W_bâk_W‘f’ He bWd VSk $Wef[_SfWe Xda_ ZageWZa^V [‘fWdh[Wie S‘V h[^^SYWegdhWk’ =WTdgSdk -++-%)

<_bâk_W‘f @‘Ua_W bWd VSk’ He

9WXadW VdagYZf $^SfW ,44+e% ;gd[‘Y VdagYZf $-++-%

HWeWdha[d X[eZ[‘Y -++ 3++ 0+ ,0+

CSYaa‘ X[eZ[‘Y $X[eZ% -++ 3++ E[^

CSYaa‘ X[eZ[‘Y $eZd[_b% 2++ 0’+++ & E[^

=[eZ dWfS[^[‘Y $XdWeZiSfWd a‘^k% .++ ,’+++ ,++ -++

=Sd_ ^STad ,/0 ,3+ ## -++ -0+

:a‘efdgUf[a‘ eWUfad5:aâ_Ta ,30 && -00

CaUS^^k ,,+ ,/0 && ,0+ -++

IS^f bS‘ ,1+ && --+

"%)&#$ .FCFD9F .FEIKD<HI 0FF; 4H@:< 1E;<N$ /<G8HJD<EJ F= .<EIKI 8E; 6J8J@IJ@:I

!%($’ # 5<GFHJ<; @E:FD< H8E>< GH@FH JF ;<:C@E< F= I?H@DG =@I?<HO

## 1E=C8J@FE 8;AKIJ<; <IJ@D8J<I =FH ’,,* =HFD (&&(

--

S‘V WUa‘a_[U UZS‘YWe SdW ^[]W^k fa ZShWaUUgddWV fZSf iWdW ‘af V[dWUf^k dW^SfWV fa[dd[YSf[a‘) DadWahWd’ fZW BF@IG [feW^X ZSe ZSV[_bSUfe fZdagYZ [fe eWff^W_W‘f bdaYdS_ fZSfWjUWWVe Tk XSd fZaeW WjbWUfWV Xda_ [fe [dd[YSf[a‘Ua_ba‘W‘f Sâ‘W) =ad WjS_b^W’ babg^Sf[a‘VW‘e[fk [‘ fZW B[d[‘V[ FkS iSfWdeZWV ZSe[‘UdWSeWV Tk S XSUfad aX X[hW Xda_ /-’.+/ [‘ ,43+$IW‘S‘SkS]W S‘V M[\Wfg‘YS ,432% fa -+,’2,+ [‘,443 $PZa‘b[‘Y Wf S^) -++,%) JZ[e VdS_Sf[U[‘UdWSeW dWX^WUfe fZW eWff^W_W‘f aX ZageWZa^Ve [‘fZW ‘Wi Ua__S‘V SdWS Se iW^^ Se fZW ‘SfgdS^babg^Sf[a‘ YdaifZ)

;X[LN_^ ZY L\‘L_TN SLMT_L_^ LYO _SPT] NZYYPN_TaT_d&:ZS‘YWe [‘ ScgSf[U ZST[fSf ShS[^ST[^[fk S‘VcgS^[fk ZShW TWW‘ SeeWeeWV ge[‘Y S Ua_bSd[ea‘aX bdW( S‘V baef(bda\WUf iSfWd dWeagdUWe _Sbe’[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xda_ bdWh[age egdhWke S‘VUa_bSdSf[hW VSfS’ S‘V efS]WZa^VWd Ua‘eg^fSf[a‘e)JZW _S[‘ bZke[US^ UZS‘YWe iWdW [VW‘f[X[WV Se5

· HWVgUf[a‘ [‘ d[hWd Xâi S‘V fZW XdWcgW‘UkS‘V WjfW‘f aX XâaVb^S[‘ [‘g‘VSf[a‘ TWâi fZWVS_) =âaV[‘Y ZSe’ ZaiWhWd’ SîSke TWW‘ SeZadf(fWd_ bZW‘a_W‘a‘)

· 8 ^SdYW $.’-++ ZS% S‘V eZS^âi ZWSViSfWddWeWdha[d $Cg‘gYS_iWZWdS% ZSe TWW‘Ua‘efdgUfWV’ UdWSf[‘Y egTefS‘f[S^ S‘V hWdkT[aâY[US^^k bdaVgUf[hW ScgSf[U ZST[fSf) JZWdWeWdha[d ZSe [‘g‘VSfWV STagf -’+++ ZS aX‘SfgdS^ XâaVb^S[‘ $iZ[UZ iag^V ZShW TWW‘[‘g‘VSfWV a‘^k Xad eZadf bWd[aVe S‘V fZgedW^Sf[hW^k g‘bdaVgUf[hW% S‘V ea_W ,++ ZS aXe_S^^ S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de)

· JZW bda\WUf ZSe dWVgUWV ‘SfgdS^ [‘Xâi [‘fafZW S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de [‘ fZW B[d[‘V[ FkSTSe[‘’ Tgf aXXWde fZW bafW‘f[S^ fa dWUZSdYWfZWeW iSfWd TaV[We Xda_ fZW ZWSViSfWddWeWdha[d S‘V dWVgUW eWSea‘S^ hSd[Sf[a‘ [‘iSfWd ^WhWê) JZW [_bSUf a‘ S‘U[W‘fdWeWdha[de [e fZge Ua_b^Wj S‘V VWbW‘VW‘f a‘iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f VWU[e[a‘e) JZ[e [eegW [eXgdfZWd V[eUgeeWV TWâi)

· JZW d[YZf TS‘] Ua__S‘V WjfW‘Ve S‘VbSdf[S^^k VdS[‘e [‘fa fZW ‘W[YZTad[‘Y DS^S^SFkS USfUZ_W‘f) @dd[YSf[a‘ VdS[‘SYW XâieW‘fWd fZW DS^S^S S‘V <_T[^[]S^S ^SYaa‘e’dS[e[‘Y iSfWd ^WhWê S‘V dWVgU[‘Y eS^[‘[fk$Xda_ ,+(/, bbf)’- [‘ fZW _[V(,43+e fa ^WeefZS‘ 2 bbf)’ S VWUSVW ^SfWd%) H[e[‘Y iSfWd^WhWê baeWV S XâaV d[e] fa SYd[Ug^fgdS^ ^S‘VS‘V ViW^^[‘Ye Sdag‘V fZW ^SYaa‘’ XadU[‘Y S‘WWV fa TdWSUZ fZW UaSefS^ eS‘V TSd _adWXdWcgW‘f^k fZS‘ TWXadW fa V[eUZSdYW WjUWeeiSfWd fa fZW eWS)

· ;dS[‘SYW Xâie US‘ TW‘WX[f fZW i[^V^[XW S‘V^[hWefaU] [‘ fZW ESf[a‘S^ GSd] $9S]]Wd Wf S^),444% Se â‘Y Se fZW cgS^[fk aX VdS[‘SYWiSfWd [e _S[‘fS[‘WV Sf eSXW ^WhWê Xad ^[h[‘YadYS‘[e_e)

8T^SP]TP^ []ZO‘N_TZY& 8 X[eZWd[We TS^S‘UW_WfZaVaâYk iSe geWV fa Wef[_SfW fZW ‘Wf WXXWUf$fST^W 1%) HWUW‘f Wef[_SfWe aX X[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[h[fk [‘ Cg‘gYS_iWZWdS S‘V fia aX fZWS‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de $/-+ 31+ ]Y*ZS*kWSd% aTfS[‘WVTk HW‘i[U] $-++,% iWdW egTefS‘f[S^^k Z[YZWdfZS‘ fZW ShWdSYW $--+ ]Y*ZS*kWSd% dWbadfWV XadId[ CS‘]S‘ dWeWdha[de Tk ;W I[^hS $,433%) JiaV[XXWdW‘f TS^S‘UW fST^We iWdW’ fZWdWXadW’ VdSi‘gb fa SeeWee fZW eW‘e[f[h[fk aX ‘Wf X[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[a‘ UZS‘YWe fa g‘UWdfS[‘fk [‘ dWeWdha[dbdaVgUf[h[fk) =[eZWde abWdSf[‘Y [‘ S‘U[W‘fdWeWdha[de Ua‘e[efW‘f^k dWbadfWV S VWU^[‘W [‘USfUZWe Xad dWUW‘f kWSde’ S‘V ^[‘]WV fZWeW faiSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f [eegWe $eWW eUdWW‘[‘Y*eUab[‘Y S‘V _[f[YSf[a‘ eWUf[a‘e%) @f [e ‘af W‘f[dW^kU^WSd fa iZSf WjfW‘f fZWeW bdaT^W_e SdW ^[‘]WV fafZW Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ aX fZW BF@IG’ ad fa fZW dWUW‘fVdagYZf) ?aiWhWd’ fafS^ USfUZWe aX X[eZ Wef[_SfWV[‘ ,444 Tk HW‘i[U] $-++,% Ua_bSdW XShadST^ki[fZ hS^gWe Wef[_SfWV [‘ fZW _[V(,43+e Tk ;WI[^hS $,433%’ TafZ a‘ ShWdSYW S‘V i[fZ[‘ ebWU[X[US‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de UahWdWV [‘ TafZ efgV[We) JZ[eegYYWefe fZSf dWUW‘f bdaVgUf[h[fk VWU^[‘We [‘ fZWiS]W aX âi iSfWd dWfW‘f[a‘ SdW bd[_Sd[^k ^[‘]WVfa fZW VdagYZf dSfZWd fZS‘ fZW BF@IG bWd eW)

-bbf5 bSdfe bWd fZageS‘V)

-.

JZWdWXadW’ fZW X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[h[fk aX S‘U[W‘fdWeWdha[de iSe Seeg_WV fa TW fZW eS_W TWXadWS‘V SXfWd BF@IG) IW‘e[f[h[fk S‘S^ke[e eZaie fZSfWhW‘ [X S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We ZSV TWW‘ âefUa_b^WfW^k’ fZW [_bSUf aX BF@IG iag^V dW_S[‘bae[f[hW ad ‘WgfdS^ $fST^W 1%)

JZW ^SYaa‘e ZSV TWW‘ fZW âUSf[a‘ aX SebWU[S^[lWV eZd[_b X[eZWdk fZSf ZSV TWW‘ hWdkbdaX[fST^W [‘ fZW bSef $fST^W 0%) <Sd^k \ghW‘[^WedWUdg[fWV fa fZW ^SYaa‘ Xda_ fZW eWS iZW‘ fZWeS‘V TSd iSe ‘SfgdS^^k TdWSUZWV Tk eWSea‘S^f[VWe S‘V iShW SUf[a‘’ S‘V dW_S[‘WV fdSbbWV [‘fZW ^SYaa‘ g‘f[^ S TdWSUZ dWUgddWV STagf S kWSd^SfWd) JZW eZd[_b X[eZWdk ZSe VWU^[‘WV VdSef[US^^ke[‘UW fZW Ua_b^Wf[a‘ aX fZW BF@IG S‘V Se SdWeg^f aX S Ua_T[‘Sf[a‘ aX W‘h[da‘_W‘fS^ UZS‘YWS‘V ahWdWjbâ[fSf[a‘) @‘UdWSeWV XdWeZiSfWd [‘XâiZSe dWVgUWV eS^[‘[fk S‘V _SVW fZW ^SYaa‘e ^Weeeg[fST^W Se ZST[fSf Xad _Sd[‘W BPYLPTO eZd[_b’iZ[^W _adW XdWcgW‘f TdWSUZ[‘Y aX fZW eS‘V TSdXad iSfWd ^WhW^ dWYg^Sf[a‘ S^âie eZd[_b faW_[YdSfW Xda_ fZW ^SYaa‘ WSd^[Wd S‘V _adWXdWcgW‘f^k fZS‘ TWXadW) 8f fZW eS_W f[_W’[‘UdWSeWV Wjbâ[fSf[a‘ Tk _gUZ Z[YZWd ‘g_TWdeaX X[eZWde abWdSf[‘Y i[fZ [‘UdWSe[‘Y^k e_S^^(_WeZ‘Wfe iSe i[VW^k eWW‘ Tk afZWd X[eZWde Se ^WSV[‘Yfa ahWdX[eZ[‘Y S‘V fZW Ua‘eWcgW‘f VWU^[‘W [‘USfUZWe aX X[eZ bWd X[eZWd S‘V Sêa S‘ ahWdS^^VWU^[‘W) @f SbbWSde fZSf Tk fZW _[V(,44+e fZWeZd[_b X[eZWdk ZSV TWW‘ ^SdYW^k dWb^SUWV Tk SX[‘X[eZ $_aef^k f[^Sb[S% X[eZWdk aX e[_[^SdbdaVgUf[h[fk’ Tgf _gUZ âiWd [‘ hS^gW) 8Ua_bSdSf[hW [‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ efgVk aX k[W^Ve Xda_^SYaa‘ X[eZWd[We Tk AakWgj S‘V MSdV $,443%Ua‘U^gVWV fZSf S ^SYaa‘ e Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk i[fZ fZWeWS [e fZW _S\ad VWfWd_[‘S‘f aX [fe bdaVgUf[h[fk’iZ[^W eS^[‘[fk ^WhWê ZShW ^[ff^W [_bSUf a‘ fafS^bdaVgUf[h[fk) ?aiWhWd’ âi eS^[‘[fk _Sk dWVgUWfZW bdabadf[a‘ aX _Sd[‘W eZd[_b $fZW _aefhS^gST^W ebWU[We [‘ fZ[e âUSf[a‘% [‘ fafS^bdaVgUf[a‘) =ad ^SYaa‘e aX fZ[e fkbW fZWkWef[_SfWV S‘ ShWdSYW fafS^ X[eZWd[We k[W^V aX ,++]Y*ZS*kWSd’ [‘U^gV[‘Y -0 ]Y*ZS*kWSd aX eZd[_b)JZ[e ShWdSYW [e Ua_bSdST^W fa S‘ [‘VWbW‘VW‘fWef[_SfW aX ,-+ ]Y*ZS*kWSd Xad fZWeW ebWU[X[U^SYaa‘e $ASkS]aVk ,44.%) @f iSe fZge VWU[VWV fa

Seeg_W Ua‘efS‘f ahWdS^^ bdaVgUf[h[fk’ Tgf Z[YZWdbWd g‘[f hS^gW aX ^SYaa‘ USfUZWe [‘ fZW bdW(BF@IG bWd[aV $fST^W 1%)

JZWdW SdW ‘a cgS‘f[fSf[hW X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘Wef[_SfWe Xad fZW [dd[YSfWV d[UW X[W^Ve bd[ad fa fZW[_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aX fZW BF@IG’ Tgf [f [e U^WSd fZSffZW bdaVgUf[a‘ iag^V ZShW TWW‘ XSd âiWd fZS‘fZW 1+ ]Y*ZS*kWSd ShWdSYW Xad dS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve$fST^W ,%) MW Seeg_WV -+ ]Y*ZS*kWSd’ Tgf fZ[e [e^[]W^k fa TW S‘ ahWdWef[_SfW Y[hW‘ fZSf h[dfgS^^k ‘aX[eZ[‘Y [‘ ad Sdag‘V d[UW X[W^Ve iSe dWbadfWV TkefS]WZa^VWde ad [‘ h[^̂ SYW egdhWke W[fZWd TWXadW adSXfWd fZW [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aX fZW BF@IG)

FhWdS^^ dWeg^fe $fST^W 1% egYYWef fZSf fZWUSfUZ_W‘f(eUS^W aX X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ ZSe[‘UdWSeWV Tk STagf 20 bWdUW‘f SXfWd fZW[_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aX fZW BF@IG) JZW hS^gW aXX[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘’ ZaiWhWd’ ZSe [‘UdWSeWV Tka‘^k STagf ,+ -0 bWdUW‘f’ VgW fa fZWdWb^SUW_W‘f aX fZW bSdf[Ug^Sd^k hS^gST^W eZd[_bX[eZWdk Tk S e[_[^Sd^k bdaVgUf[hW Tgf _gUZ ^WeehS^gST^W f[^Sb[S X[eZWdk [‘ fZW ^SYaa‘e) Gaee[T^WWXXWUfe a‘ UaSefS^ X[eZWd[We agfe[VW fZW ^SYaa‘eZShW ‘af TWW‘ SeeWeeWV $fZWeW _Sk iW^^ TWWcg[haUS^’ Y[hW‘ fZSf XdWeZiSfWd agfXâie SdWâiWd ahWdS^^ Tgf ^[]W^k fa TW d[UZWd [‘ ‘gfd[W‘feSe S dWeg^f aX SYd[Ug f̂gdS^ [‘fW‘e[X[USf[a‘%)

JZW USfUZ_W‘f eUS^W TS^S‘UW’ aX UagdeW’‘WY^WUfe V[efd[Tgf[a‘S^ S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaV [_bSUfe fZSf_Sk ZShW Sd[eW‘ i[fZ[‘ fZW USfUZ_W‘f) @f [e U^WSdfZSf fZW YdWSfWef TW‘WX[fe ZShW TWW‘ YW‘WdSfWV[‘ fZW gbbWd USfUZ_W‘f Sdag‘V Cg‘gYS_iWZWdS’iZ[^W fZW YdWSfWef âee [‘ WUa‘a_[U hS^gW ZSeaUUgddWV [‘ ^SYaa‘e agfe[VW fZW USfUZ_W‘f Se SdWeg^f aX [‘UdWSeWV VdS[‘SYW iSfWd [‘Xâi)

>TaPWTSZZO ;X[LN_^& Gd[ad fa fZW [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aXfZW BF@IG fZW SdWS Ua‘ef[fgfWV S VWbdWeeWVdWY[a‘ [‘ fZW Uag‘fdk’ WUa‘a_[US^^k’ eaU[S^^k S‘VSYda(WUaâY[US^^k $IW‘S‘SkS]W S‘V M[\Wfg‘YS,432%’ S‘V STagf fia(X[XfZe aX ZageWZa^Ve iWdWTWâi fZW bahWdfk ^[‘W $MS‘Se[‘YZW Wf S^) ,43.6JgVSiW ,431%) IW‘S‘SkS]W S‘V M[\Wfg‘YS $,432%W_bZSe[lWV a‘ fZW ^[_[fWV bdaVgUf[hW ^[hW^[ZaaVS‘V W_bâk_W‘f abbadfg‘[f[We’ bdWVa_[‘S‘f^kTSeWV a‘ fZW âUS^ ‘SfgdS^ dWeagdUWe) JZWk

-/

J89C< 15 BF@IG =[eZWd[We TS^S‘UW fST^W [‘ fWd_e aX bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V hS^gW)

J89C< 1) $8%HWeWdha[d bdaVgUf[h[fk TSeWV a‘ S dWUW‘f egdhWk)

9WXadW BF@IG

MSfWd TaVk :SfUZ_W‘f 8dWS GdaVgUf[h[fk GdaVgUf[a‘ LS^gW*]Y JafS^ LS^gW

=âaVb^S[‘ 1’-++ -+ ,-/ +)/ 0+

CSYaa‘e ,’0++ ,++ ,0+ ,)0 --0

?WSV dWeWdha[d + + + +)/ +

8‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de ,’1+3 1.+ ,’+,. +)/ /+0

I_S^^ dWeWdha[de .++ 1.+ ,34 +)/ 21

H[hWd ,,2’3++ +). .0 +)/ ,/

JafS^ 4’1+3 ,’.3+). ,’0,, .)0 22+

8XfWd BF@IG


=âaVb^S[‘ + -+ + +)/ +

CSYaa‘e ,’0++ ,++ ,0+ +)/ 1+

?WSV dWeWdha[d .’-++ /-+ ,’.// +)/ 0.3

8‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de ,’1+3 1.+ ,’+,. +)/ /+0

I_S^^ dWeWdha[de -++ 1.+ ,-1 +)/ 0+

H[hWd ,,2’3++ + +)/ +

JafS^ 1’0+3 -’1.. ,’+0.

:ZS‘YW (.’,++ ,’,-- -3.

"%)&#$ 5<EM@:B (&&’

J89C< 1) $9%HWeWdha[d bdaVgUf[h[fk TSeWV a‘ ShWdSYW Xad Id[ CS‘]S‘ dWeWdha[de)

9WXadW BF@IG


=âaVb^S[‘ 1’-++ -+ ,-/ +)/ 0+

CSYaa‘e ,’0++ ,++ ,0+ ,)0 --0

?WSV dWeWdha[d + --+ + +)/ +

8‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de ,’1+3 --+ .0. +)/ ,/,

I_S^^ dWeWdha[de .++ -0+ 20 +)/ .+

H[hWd ,,2’3++ +). .0 +)/ ,/

JafS^ 4’1+3 2.2 /1+

8XfWd BF@IG


=âaVb^S[‘ + -+ + +)/ +

CSYaa‘e ,’0++ ,++ ,0+ +)/ 1+

?WSV dWeWdha[d .’-++ --+ 2+/ +)/ -3-

8‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de ,’1+3 --+ .0. +)/ ,/-

I_S^^ dWeWdha[de -++ -0+ 0+ +)/ -+

H[hWd ,,2’3++ + +)/ +

JafS^ 1’0+3 ,’-02 0+/

:ZS‘YW (.’,++ 0-+ //

"%)&#$ /< 6@CL8 ’,++

-0

Wef[_SfWV g‘W_bâk_W‘f fa TW STagf -+ bWdUW‘faX fZW ^STad XadUW $S_a‘Y fZW Z[YZWef [‘ fZWUag‘fdk% S‘V Xda_ fZW bdWhS[̂ [‘Y Udabb[‘Y bSffWd‘eS‘V [‘fW‘e[f[We fZWk VWVgUWV fZSf fZW ^WhW^ aXg‘VWdW_bâk_W‘f iSe Sêa Z[YZ)

JZW BF@IG ZSe [‘UdWSeWV ahWdS^^ SYd[Ug^fgdS^S‘V X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ fZW USfUZ_W‘f’ TgfUdWSf[a‘ aX ‘Wi W_bâk_W‘f abbadfg‘[f[We ZSe‘af ]Wbf bSUW i[fZ fZW babg^Sf[a‘ YdaifZ) JZW[‘Vgefd[S^ S‘V eWdh[UW eWUfade ZShW ‘af WjbS‘VWVegXX[U[W‘f^k fa STeadT egdb^ge ^STad’ iZ[^W[‘UdWSeW [‘ SYd[Ug^fgdS^ W_bâk_W‘f ZSe TWW‘Ua‘efdS[‘WV Tk fZW âi ShS[^ST[^[fk aX ^S‘V S‘V[dd[YSf[a‘ iSfWd) 8e S dWeg^f’ [‘V[USfade aX fZWahWdS^^ eaU[aWUa‘a_[U efSfge aX ZageWZa^Ve [‘fZW USfUZ_W‘f Ua‘f[‘gW fa Ua_bSdW baad^k i[fZ‘Sf[a‘S^ ShWdSYWe)

GSdf[U[bSf[a‘ [‘ X[eZ[‘Y SbbWSde fa ZShW[‘UdWSeWV dagYZ^k [‘ bdabadf[a‘ fa ahWdS^^babg^Sf[a‘ YdaifZ) Eg_TWd aX TaSfe Wef[_SfWVa‘ Cg‘gYS_iWZWdS S‘V fia S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de[‘ ,444 $HW‘i[U] -++,% [e Sbbdaj[_SfW^k Xagdf[_We Z[YZWd fZS‘ fZaeW Wef[_SfWV [‘ fZW _[V(,43+e $;W I[^hS ,433%) :ZS‘VdSe[d[ $,431%Wef[_SfWV fZSf [‘ ,431’ -1. X[eZWde Xda_ X[hWS‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de $H[V[kSYS_S’ 9S‘VSY[d[kS’M[dSi[^S’ J[eeS MWiS S‘V OaVS MWiS% iWdW_W_TWde aX fZW =[eZWd_W‘ e :aabWdSf[hWIaU[Wfk’ S‘V fZSf S egTefS‘f[S^ Tgf ‘a‘(cgS‘f[X[WVbabg^Sf[a‘ aX ‘a‘(adYS‘[lWV X[eZWde Sêa Wj[efWV)

;Web[fW S egTefS‘f[S^ [‘UdWSeW [‘ fZW‘g_TWd aX X[eZWde’ fafS^ USfUZWe S‘V USfUZWebWd TaSf [‘ fZW S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de SbbWSd faZShW [‘UdWSeWV SXfWd fZW Ua_b^Wf[a‘ aX fZWBF@IG) JZ[e Ua‘U^ge[a‘ [e egbbadfWV[‘VWbW‘VW‘f^k Tk fZW BF@IG WhS^gSf[a‘ efgVk$@@D@ ,440% S‘V HW‘i[U] $-++,%) JZ[e egYYWefe[‘UdWSe[‘Y Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘e aX dWeWdha[d X[eZWd[We fa^[hW^[ZaaVe [‘ fWd_e aX TafZ fZW ‘g_TWd aXTW‘WX[U[Sd[We S‘V fZW ShWdSYW _SY‘[fgVW aXTW‘WX[fe YS[‘WV) 9k Ua‘fdSef’ X[eZWde abWdSf[‘Y[‘ ^SYaa‘e ZShW egXXWdWV egTefS‘f[S^ dWVgUf[a‘[‘ [‘Ua_W TWfiWW‘ ,432 S‘V ,442’ i[fZ fZWbdabadf[a‘ aX X[eZWde WSd‘[‘Y _adW fZS‘ KI"-1*_a‘fZ ZSh[‘Y VWU^[‘WV Xda_ 0- bWdUW‘f fa .0bWdUW‘f $Bg^SdSf‘W ,444%)

L[dfgS^^k S^^ X[eZWde [‘ fZW bda\WUf SdWSegXXWdWV Xda_ VWU^[‘[‘Y X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[h[fkVgd[‘Y fZW bWd[aV aX fZW VdagYZf) FfZWd ‘SfgdS^dWeagdUW(TSeWV SUf[h[f[We egUZ Se eZW^^ _[‘[‘Y’^[_W _S][‘Y’ X[dWiaaV Ua^^WUf[a‘’ dWfS[^[‘Y aX_Sd[‘W X[eZ S‘V ^STad[‘Y [‘ fZW eS^f bS‘e[‘UdWSe[‘Y^k dWb^SUWV X[eZ[‘Y Se S _WS‘e aXegbbadf Xad S e[Y‘[X[US‘f ‘g_TWd aX fZW ^S‘V^WeeS‘V g‘W_bâkWV iZa ZSV bdWh[age^k W‘YSYWV [‘X[eZ[‘Y) JZW [_bSUf aX fZW VdagYZf iSe _aefeWhWdW [‘ fZW ^SYaa‘e’ iZWdW X[eZ[‘Y TWUS_Wh[dfgS^^k g‘egefS[‘ST^W Se S eagdUW aX ^[hW^[ZaaV)

FX fZW X[eZWd(XSd_Wd Ua‘X^[Ufe Sf fZW f[_W aX[_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f’ a‘^k fZaeW dW^Sf[‘Y fa iSfWd_S‘SYW_W‘f S‘V eS‘V TSd abW‘[‘Y [‘ fZW^SYaa‘e iWdW V[dWUf^k Sffd[TgfST^W fa[_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aX fZW BF@IG) :a‘X^[Ufe ahWddWeWdha[d iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f SdaeW Xda_ YW‘WdSîSfWd eUSdU[fk VgW fa âi dS[‘XS^^ S‘V [‘UdWSe[‘Y[dd[YSf[a‘ VW_S‘V) JZW BF@IG ZSe ea_W bafW‘f[S^fa S^^Wh[SfW fZW bdaT^W_ fZdagYZ [fe ST[^[fk fadWUZSdYW fZW S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de’ Tgf WjbS‘e[a‘ aXfZW Ua__S‘V SdWSe’ ^[ff^W V[hWde[X[USf[a‘ SiSkXda_ d[UW Ug^f[hSf[a‘ S‘V iSfWd S^âUSf[a‘ dWY[_WeVa_[‘SfWV Tk XSd_Wd [‘fWdWefe ZShW fW‘VWV faWjSUWdTSfW [f) C[‘]SYWe TWfiWW‘ X[eZWd[We S‘V[dd[YSf[a‘ [‘ef[fgf[a‘e ZShW ‘WhWd TWW‘ efda‘Y [‘fZW bda\WUf SdWS’ Tgf [‘UdWSe[‘Y Ua‘fda^ ahWd iSfWddWeagdUWe ZSe _SVW fZ[e ^SU] aX ^[‘]SYWe S _adWbdWee[‘Y bdaT^W_)

Opportunities for Mitigation and Enhancement

MZ[^W USfUZ_W‘f eUS^W [_bSUfe aX fZW BF@IG a‘X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V dW^SfWV ^[hW^[ZaaVeabbadfg‘[f[We ZShW S^_aef UWdfS[‘^k TWW‘ bae[f[hW[‘ SYYdWYSfW’ fZWdW SdW U^WSd^k [eegWe fZSf eZag^VTW SVVdWeeWV Tk iSk aX _[f[YSf[a‘ S‘VW‘ZS‘UW_W‘f) @_bdah[‘Y dWeWdha[d iSfWd_S‘SYW_W‘f i[fZ dWebWUf fa X[eZWd[We [e TWefVWeUd[TWV Se S‘ W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f _WSegdW TWUSgeW[f _Sk XgdfZWd [_bdahW X[eZWd[We fZSf aiW fZW[dWj[efW‘UW fa [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f [‘ fZW X[defb^SUW) 8VVdWee[‘Y fZW bdaT^W_e UdWSfWV TkVdS[‘SYW iSfWd [‘Xâi [‘fa fZW ^SYaa‘e a‘ fZWafZWd ZS‘V [e U^WSd^k S _[f[YSf[a‘ _WSegdW) 9afZ

-1

[eegWe _Sk TW ZW^bWV Tk _adW WXX[U[W‘f geW aX[dd[YSf[a‘ iSfWd’ S‘V fZ[e iSe [VW‘f[X[WV Se S‘ahWdS^^ â‘Y(fWd_ bd[ad[fk)

;X[]ZaTYR DP^P]aZT] IL_P] ?LYLRPXPY_& IfS]W(Za^VWde [VW‘f[X[WV fZSf [‘ fZW eUdWW‘[‘Y*eUab[‘YbZSeW fZW dWUgddW‘f’ ea_Wf[_We WjfdW_W VdSi(Vai‘ aX iSfWd ^WhW^ iSe USge[‘Y ahWdS^^ VWU^[‘W[‘ bdaVgUf[h[fk S‘V bdaX[fST[^[fk aX dWeWdha[dX[eZWd[We) IgUZ Wb[eaVWe ZShW TWUa_W [‘UdWSe([‘Y^k Ua__a‘ Vgd[‘Y fZW bWS] Vdk eWSea‘_a‘fZe iZW‘ iSfWd ^WhWê iWdW ‘af egXX[U[W‘f faeSf[eXk fZW ‘WWVe aX X[eZWde S‘V egefS[‘ fZWX[eZWdk)

JZW dW^Sf[a‘eZ[b TWfiWW‘ VdSiVai‘ S‘VX[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ [e Ua_b^Wj S‘V egT\WUf faUa‘e[VWdST^W Ua‘fdahWdek) ;dSiVai‘Ua‘UW‘fdSfWe X[eZ efaU]e S‘V fZge [‘UdWSeWe fZWWXX[U[W‘Uk aX X[eZ[‘Y YWSd S‘V WXXadf) @‘ SVV[f[a‘bWd[aV[U Vdk[‘Y aX fZW dWeWdha[d Taffa_ _SkXSU[^[fSfW fZW TdWS]Vai‘ aX adYS‘[U _SffWd [‘eWV[_W‘fe S‘V [‘UdWSeW T[aâY[US^ bdaVgUf[h[fk)JZWeW bae[f[hW WXXWUfe aX VdSiVai‘ a‘ X[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[a‘ SdW Uag‘fWdSUfWV Tk dWVgUf[a‘e [‘efaU] STg‘VS‘UW g‘VWd Ua‘V[f[a‘e aX Z[YZVW‘e[fk dWeg^f[‘Y Xda_ ‘SfgdS^ XSUfade Se iW^^ SeX[eZ[‘Y) ;k‘S_[U _aVWê aX X[eZ babg^Sf[a‘e [‘iSfWd TaV[We egT\WUf fa ^SdYW X^gUfgSf[a‘e [‘iSfWd ^WhW^ S‘V SdWS $?S^ê Wf S^) -++,6 CadW‘lW‘Wf S^) -++.% [‘V[USfW S efda‘Y^k ‘a‘(^[‘WSd

dW^Sf[a‘eZ[b TWfiWW‘ â‘Y(fWd_ X[eZWd[We k[W^VS‘V VdSiVai‘ aX fZW Xad_ [^^gefdSfWV [‘ X[YgdW .)JZ[e egYYWefe fZSf fZW k[W^V [e XS[d^k [‘eW‘e[f[hWfa _aVWdSfW VdSiVai‘’ Tgf VWU^[‘We efWWb^k SeVdk eWSea‘ SdWS [e dWVgUWV fa S âi bdabadf[a‘aX Xg^^ efadSYW SdWS) CaUSf[a‘(ebWU[X[U W_b[d[US^VSfS $f[_W eWd[We aX X[eZWd[We S‘V ZkVdaâY[US^VSfS% SdW dWcg[dWV fa cgS‘f[Xk fZW dW^Sf[a‘eZ[b’iZ[UZ VWbW‘Ve a‘ UZSdSUfWd[ef[Ue aX fZW dWeWdha[dS‘V [fe X[eZ babg^Sf[a‘) @f [e ‘af baee[T^W SfbdWeW‘f fa Y[hW YW‘WdS^ eSXW ^WhWê aXVdSiVai‘’ Tgf fZW YW‘WdS^ eZSbW aX fZWdW^Sf[a‘eZ[b [e geWXg^ [‘ fZSf [f XaUgeWe SffW‘f[a‘a‘ fZW ^[]W^[ZaaV aX dSb[V UZS‘YW Sf Z[YZWd ^WhWêaX VdSiVai‘)

Ca‘Y(fWd_ dWUadV[‘Y aX X[eZ[‘Y WXXadf S‘V fZWdWeg^fS‘f USfUZ ebS‘‘[‘Y S bWd[aV aX eWhWdS^kWSde _Sk TW dWcg[dWV fa WefST^[eZ fZW bdWU[eWdW^Sf[a‘eZ[b TWfiWW‘ VdSiVai‘ S‘V X[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[a‘) ?aiWhWd’ Z[efad[US^ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ _SkiW^^ S^âi S VWX[‘[f[a‘ aX Sbbdaj[_SfW _[‘[_g_iSfWd dWfW‘f[a‘ fSdYWfe)

@f US‘ TW eWW‘ fZSf fZW [eegW [e bd[_Sd[^k SUa‘X^[Uf aX [‘fWdWefe TWfiWW‘ Ua_bWf[‘Y iSfWdgeWde XSd_Wde S‘V X[eZWde S‘V fZagYZ fZ[e_Sk ZShW aUUgddWV Xad fZW dWeWdha[d X[eZWd[Webd[ad fa fZW Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ aX fZW BF@IG’ ‘W[fZWdfZW [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘ aX fZW eUZW_W ‘ad [feegTeWcgW‘f abWdSf[a‘ ZShW SVWcgSfW^kdWea^hWV [f)

=@>KH< .)>W‘WdS^ dW^Sf[a‘eZ[b TWfiWW‘ dW^Sf[hW Vdk eWSea‘ iSfWd SdWS S‘V X[eZWd[We k[W^V)

"%)&#$ 2FH<EP<E <J 8C% (&&)

-2

IfS]WZa^VWde Sf fZW iad]eZab SYdWWV fZSfX[eZWd[We [‘fWdWefe eZag^V TW Ua‘e[VWdWV [‘[dd[YSf[a‘ iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f ba^[U[We) JZWk SêaegYYWefWV fZSf X[eZWde eZag^V TW dWbdWeW‘fWV [‘fZW eWSea‘S^ b^S‘‘[‘Y _WWf[‘Ye) =gdfZWdSiSdW‘Wee UdWSf[a‘ S‘V SUUa_bS‘k[‘Y[‘ef[fgf[a‘S^ _WSegdWe iag^V TW dWcg[dWV faegbbadf fZ[e [‘fWYdSf[a‘ S‘V fa [_bdahW fZWb^S‘‘[‘Y’ Ua‘fda^ S‘V _S‘SYW_W‘f aX [dd[YSf[a‘)<efST^[eZ_W‘f aX [_bdahWV iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘fXad X[eZWd[We [‘ fZW dWeWdha[de i[^^ Sêa UdWSfWabbadfg‘[f[We S‘V [‘UW‘f[hWe Xad afZWd X[eZWdkW‘ZS‘UW_W‘f _WSegdWe egUZ Se efaU][‘Y S‘V‘gdeWdk ZST[fSf UdWSf[a‘)

6]LTYLRP ?LYLRPXPY_ TY _SP>LRZZY 3]PL& JZdWW baee[T^W _[f[YSf[a‘_WSegdWe Xad VdS[‘SYW [‘Xâie fa fZW ^SYaa‘eiWdW Ua‘e[VWdWV Tk efS]WZa^VWde)

$,% ;[hWde[a‘ aX VdS[‘SYW iSfWd Sdag‘V fZW^SYaa‘e i[fZ fZW UdWSf[a‘ aX S UZS‘‘W^)

$-% HWVgUf[a‘ aX VdS[‘SYW Xâie fZdagYZdWZST[^[fSf[a‘ aX [dd[YSf[a‘ [‘XdSefdgUfgdW S‘VdWgeW aX VdS[‘SYW iSfWd)

$.% 9WffWd _S‘SYW_W‘f aX eS‘V TSd abW‘[‘YfZdagYZ fZW UaadV[‘Sf[a‘ aX XSd_Wd S‘VX[eZWdk [‘fWdWefe)

;YN]PL^TYR ;]]TRL_TZY 7QQTNTPYNd& @f iSe bdabaeWVfZSf [‘UdWSeWV WXX[U[W‘Uk aX [dd[YSf[a‘ iSfWd geWiag^V ZW^b fa S^^Wh[SfW X[eZWd[We bdaT^W_e dW^SfWVfa iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f) JZW aT\WUf[hW iag^V TW fa[‘UdWSeW fZW dSf[a TWfiWW‘ Udab WhSbafdS‘eb[dS(f[a‘ S‘V dWeWdha[d dW^WSeWe) 8‘ [‘UdWSeW [‘ UdabWhSbafdS‘eb[dSf[a‘ iag^V dWVgUW fZW VdS[‘SYWXâie fa fZW ^SYaa‘e) 8 VWUdWSeW [‘ dWeWdha[ddW^WSeWe iag^V ZW^b ]WWb _adW iSfWd efadWV [‘fZW dWeWdha[de fa _S[‘fS[‘ X[eZWd[We)

Summary of the Sri Lankan Case Study

JZW BF@IG ZSV S _aVWef bae[f[hW [_bSUf a‘bdW(Wj[ef[‘Y X[eZWd[We [‘ fWd_e aX SYYdWYSfWbdaVgUf[h[fk S‘V SUfgS^ bdaVgUf[a‘) 8e ‘W[fZWdegTe[efW‘UW ‘ad Ua__WdU[S^ X[eZWd[We VWhWâbWV[‘ fZW d[hWd(XâaVb^S[‘ ekefW_ aX fZW bda\WUf SdWS’

fZW dWVgUf[a‘ aX Xâi S‘V XâaV[‘Y iSe ‘af[_badfS‘f [‘ fWd_e aX X[eZWd[We S‘V [fe ^[hW^[ZaaVXg‘Uf[a‘e) JZW ^SdYW ‘Wi dWeWdha[d UdWSfWV TkfZW bda\WUf egTefS‘f[S^^k [‘UdWSeWV SYYdWYSfW X[eZbdaVgUf[a‘ Xda_ fZW USfUZ_W‘f’ Ua_bW‘eSf[‘Y XadâeeWe Vai‘efdWS_ S‘V [‘ fZW ^SYaa‘e)

?aiWhWd’ iZ[^W fZW [_bSUf aX Ua‘efdgUf[a‘ZSe TWW‘ fa [‘UdWSeW fZW SYYdWYSfW bafW‘f[S^bdaVgUf[h[fk aX X[eZWd[We [‘ fZW USfUZ_W‘f’eUZW_W abWdSf[a‘ S‘V iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f ZSeZSV S ‘WYSf[hW [_bSUf a‘ fZW SUfgS^ bdaVgUf[a‘aX X[eZWd[We [‘ fZW bdW(Wj[ef[‘Y dWeWdha[de S‘V^SYaa‘e) @‘ Ua_T[‘Sf[a‘ i[fZ XS[^gdW faWXXWUf[hW^k W‘XadUW SUUWee dWefd[Uf[a‘e’ dWeg^f[‘Y[‘ ahWdX[eZ[‘Y S‘V Sêa fZW WXXWUfe aX fZW dWUW‘fVdagYZf ZSe VWYdSVWV X[eZ efaU]e S‘V Vd[hW‘X[eZ[‘Y faiSdVe TW[‘Y S ^[ff^W _adW fZS‘ S‘abbadfg‘[ef[U S‘V dWe[VgS^ eagdUW aX ^[hW^[ZaaVXad ZageWZa^Ve’ iZ[UZ SdW ^WXf i[fZ XWi afZWdS^fWd‘Sf[hWe) >[hW‘ âUS^ babg^Sf[a‘ YdaifZ S‘Vg‘W_bâk_W‘f dSfWe’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k S_a‘Y^S‘V^Wee eWUa‘V YW‘WdSf[a‘ eWff^Wd ZageWZa^Ve’fZ[e ZSe bdah[VWV S‘ [_badfS‘f !eaU[S^ eSXWfk‘Wf’! S^TW[f Sf âi [‘Ua_W ^WhWê) 8^fWd‘Sf[hW^[hW^[ZaaVe Xad fZW WUa‘a_[US^^k _SdY[‘S^[lWV’egUZ Se X[dWiaaV Ua^^WUf[a‘’ eZW^^ _[‘[‘Y S‘V^[_W _S][‘Y fW‘V fa TW _adW W‘h[da‘_W‘fS^^kVS_SY[‘Y)

@_bdahW_W‘fe [‘ iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f SUdaeefZW BF@IG USfUZ_W‘f fZge ZShW fZW bafW‘f[S^ faVW^[hWd S dS‘YW aX W‘h[da‘_W‘fS^’ eaU[S^ S‘VWUa‘a_[U TW‘WX[fe) GdaVgUf[hW X[eZWd[We US‘ TWdWefadWV [‘ dWeWdha[de [X eSh[‘Ye US‘ TW _SVW [‘fZW iSfWd ‘WWVe aX XSd_[‘Y’ S‘V _S‘SYW_W‘fdWY[_We US‘ fS]W SUUag‘f aX _[‘[_g_ ^WhWê‘WWVWV fa Ua‘eWdhW egefS[‘ST^W X[eZ efaU]e) JZWTW‘WX[fe aX fZ[e i[^^ [‘U^gVW Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘e fa‘Sf[a‘S^ X[eZ agfbgf’ W_bâk_W‘f S‘V [_bdahWV‘gfd[f[a‘ Xad baad ZageWZa^Ve) DadW dWeWSdUZ [e‘WWVWV a‘ fZW WUaâYk aX fZW UaSefS^ ^SYaa‘e’Tgf e[_[^Sd^k $fZagYZ egT\WUf fa i[^V^[XWUa‘eWdhSf[a‘ bd[ad[f[We Y[hW‘ dWUW‘f VWe[Y‘Sf[a‘aX fZW SdWS Se S ESf[a‘S^ GSd]% S bdaVgUf[hW S‘VhS^gST^W X[eZWdk US‘ bafW‘f[S^^k TW dWefadWV)?WdW’ T[aV[hWde[fk S‘V Ua‘eWdhSf[a‘ aT\WUf[hWeUS‘ bafW‘f[S^^k TW dWS^[lWV’ Se iW^^ Se eaU[S^ S‘VWUa‘a_[U TW‘WX[fe)

-3

*@C56FE B9 *DD<:5F<BA BA *A?5A7 (<E;8D<8E 0DB7G6F<BA 5A7 1GD5?,<H8?<;BB7E$ ,8EEBAE 5A7 .8I 08DEC86F<H8E

[_bSUfe _[f[YSfWV’ [‘ ekefW_e S^dWSVkabWdSf[a‘S^’ TWUSgeW iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘f S‘VXSd_[‘Y bdSUf[UWe US‘ ZShW S YdWSfWd [_bSUf a‘X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[h[fk fZS‘ [‘XdSefdgUfgdWUa‘efdgUf[a‘) =ad WjS_b^W’ [‘ CSae’ egefS[‘[‘YX[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ VWbW‘Ve a‘ _S[‘fS[‘[‘Y SdS[‘(XWV iWf eWSea‘ d[UW Udab) 8‘k _aV[X[USf[a‘[‘ fZW Udabb[‘Y UkU^W fZSf dWVgUWe iSfWddWfW‘f[a‘ [‘ d[UW X[W^Ve [e ^[]W^k fa USgeW S VdSef[UdWVgUf[a‘ [‘ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘) @‘ Id[ CS‘]S’WjfdW_W VdSiVai‘ aX dWeWdha[d ^WhWê Xad[dd[YSf[a‘ VdS_Sf[US^^k dWVgUWe X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘ aXdWeWdha[de fZSf SdW Z[YZ^k bdaVgUf[hW g‘VWdUa‘V[f[a‘e aX _aVWdSfW VdSiVai‘)

JZWeW dWeg^fe SdW e[_[^Sd fa fZaeW aTfS[‘WVXad XâaV Ua‘fda^ eUZW_We [‘ 9S‘Y^SVWeZ) =âaVdWUWee[a‘ d[UW XSd_[‘Y ekefW_e i[fZ[‘ XâaVUa‘fda^ eUZW_We US‘ Ua‘f[‘gW fa egbbadfbdaVgUf[hW X[eZWd[We’ S‘V e_S^^ SV\gef_W‘fe [‘fZW VWe[Y‘ S‘V abWdSf[a‘ aX XâaV Ua‘fdaêfdgUfgdWe’ i[fZ fZW UdWSf[a‘ aX ea_W bWdW‘‘[S^ScgSf[U ZST[fSf’ US‘ [_bdahW bdaVgUf[a‘ $Ig^fS‘SS‘V JZa_bea‘ ,4426 ?S^ê Wf S^) ,444%)

=ad S^^ egUZ e[fgSf[a‘e’ W_b[d[US^ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘S‘V S‘S^kf[US^ faaê Wj[ef’ ad US‘ TW VWhWâbWV’Xad fZW WhS^gSf[a‘ S‘V _S‘SYW_W‘f aX S‘k fdSVW(aXXe) JZW S[_ TW[‘Y fa abf[_[lW fZW SYYdWYSfWWUa‘a_[U hS^gW aX bdaVgUf[a‘ $Udabe S‘V X[eZ%Xda_ fZW ekefW_’ ad W‘ZS‘UW fZW ^[hW^[ZaaV S‘VeaU[S^ TW‘WX[fe $Xad WjS_b^W’ W_bâk_W‘fUdWSf[a‘%)

The Diverse Livelihood Functions of Fisheries

JZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe dWbadfWV ZWdW SêaeZaiWV fZSf [f US‘ TW S‘afZWd _[ebWdUWbf[a‘ fadWYSdV X[eZ[‘Y a‘^k Se S‘ SUf[h[fk aX ^Sef dWeadf’iZWdWSe [f US‘ dS‘YW Xda_ fZ[e’ fZdagYZUa‘fd[Tgf[‘Y fa S V[hWde[X[WV ^[hW^[ZaaV efdSfWYk’ faS ebWU[S^[lWV S‘V dW_g‘WdSf[hW aUUgbSf[a‘) @‘CSae’ fZW _S\ad[fk aX dgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve X[eZWV SebSdf aX S fdSV[f[a‘S^ S‘V V[hWde[X[WV ^[hW^[ZaaVefdSfWYk fZSf Sêa [‘ha^hWV XSd_[‘Y’ Ua^^WUf[a‘ aXafZWd i[^V XaaVe S‘V XadWef bdaVgUfe’ S‘V

8 ‘g_TWd aX [_bdahWV [‘e[YZfe S‘V ‘WibWdebWUf[hWe US‘ TW VdSi‘ Xda_ fZWeWSeeWee_W‘fe aX fZW [_bSUfe aX fZW VWhWâb_W‘faX [dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We [‘ CSae S‘V Id[ CS‘]S)JdS‘eXWdST^W ^Weea‘e Xad [dd[YSf[a‘ S‘V iSfWddWeagdUW _S‘SYW_W‘f SdW V[eUgeeWV X[def’ S‘VfZWeW Z[YZ^[YZf fZW bafW‘f[S^ TW‘WX[fe aX[‘fWYdSfWV _S‘SYW_W‘f aX ^S‘V geW’ [dd[YSf[a‘S‘V X[eZWd[We) JZ[e [e Xa^âiWV Tk [eegWe dW^WhS‘ffa _WfZaVe aX [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f Xad [‘^S‘VX[eZWd[We’ S‘V X[‘S^ Ua‘U^ge[a‘e)

&8A89<FE 9DB@ *AF8:D5F87 ,5A7 5A745F8D -5A5:8@8AF

Modified Aquatic Systems can SupportSignificant Fisheries Production

@dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f _aV[X[We ScgSf[U ZST[fSfeS‘V ZkVdaâYk S‘V gegS^̂ k ZSe S ‘WYSf[hW [_bSUfa‘ Sf ^WSef ea_W Ua_ba‘W‘fe aX ScgSf[UT[aV[hWde[fk) ?aiWhWd’ [f [e S _[ebWdUWbf[a‘ faSeeg_W fZSf [_bSUfe a‘ X[eZWd[We i[^^ ‘WUWeeSd[^kTW ‘WYSf[hW) ;WbW‘V[‘Y a‘ âUS^ Ua‘V[f[a‘e S‘V[‘XdSefdgUfgdW VWe[Y‘ S‘V abWdSf[a‘’ S‘ [dd[YSf[a‘eUZW_W _Sk W‘ZS‘UW ahWdS^^ X[eZWd[WebdaVgUf[a‘ ^WhWê) @‘ fZW fia USeWe dWbadfWVZWdW’ [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f UdWSfWV ‘Wi ScgSf[UZST[fSfe i[fZagf egTefS‘f[S^^k SXXWUf[‘Y fZW WjfW‘fad bdaVgUf[a‘ USbSU[fk aX fZW _S[‘ Wj[ef[‘YX[eZWd[We5 dS[‘(XWV d[UW X[W^Ve [‘ CSae S‘V e_S^^S‘U[W‘f dWeWdha[de [‘ Id[ CS‘]S)

Managing Water for Irrigation and Fisheries

JZWdW US‘ TW eUabW Xad _g^f[(geW _S‘SYW_W‘faX iSfWd dWeagdUWe Xad [dd[YSf[a‘ S‘V X[eZWd[We’S‘V [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe ge[‘Y fZW SbbdaSUZVWeUd[TWV ZWdW SdW USbST^W aX [VW‘f[Xk[‘Y S‘VSVVdWee[‘Y abbadfg‘[f[We Xad fZ[e bgdbaeW)@dd[YSf[a‘ b^S‘‘Wde eZag^V Ua‘e[VWd abbadfg‘[f[Wefa bdafWUf S‘V egefS[‘ X[eZWd[We’ ad fa VWhWâbfZW_ [‘ ‘Wi ad _aV[X[WV ZST[fSfe) I[_[^Sd^k’X[eZWd[We TW‘WX[fe US‘ TW W‘ZS‘UWV’ ad ‘WYSf[hW

-4

aUUSe[a‘S^ iSYW ^STad) @‘ Id[ CS‘]S’ X[eZ[‘Y ZSVTWW‘ W[fZWd S ebWU[S^[lWV aUUgbSf[a‘ ad S _WS‘eaX V[hWde[X[USf[a‘ Xad XSd_[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve’ Tgf i[fZ[‘UdWSe[‘Y babg^Sf[a‘ bdWeegdW Sâ‘Y i[fZg‘W_bâk_W‘f S‘V VWYdSVSf[a‘ aX X[eZWd[We [fZSV TWUa_W S dWe[VgS^ SUf[h[fk Xad fZW baad S‘Vhg^‘WdST^W $dWUaY‘[l[‘Y fZSf _S‘k ebWU[S^[lWVX[eZWde ZSV TWW‘ [_bahWd[eZWV Tk fZW VWU^[‘W [‘bdaVgUf[h[fk%)

@dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f _Sk dS[eW fZWabbadfg‘[fk Uaef aX X[eZ[‘Y S‘V VdSi ^STad SiSkfa XSd_[‘Y ad SeeaU[SfWV ‘a‘(XSd_ W_bâk_W‘ffZSf ZSe TWUa_W _adW bdaVgUf[hW S‘V _adWUa‘f[‘gage fZdagYZagf fZW kWSd) 8^fWd‘Sf[hW^k’ [f_Sk V[edgbf fdSV[f[a‘S^ ^[hW^[ZaaV SUf[h[f[We addW[‘XadUW Wj[ef[‘Y bSffWd‘e aX WUa‘a_[U’ eaU[S^S‘V ba^[f[US^ [‘Wcg[fk’ XgdfZWd _SdY[‘S^[l[‘Y fZWhg^‘WdST^W S‘V’ aXfW‘ ^WSV[‘Y fa [‘UdWSeWVdW^[S‘UW a‘ X[eZ[‘Y) @‘Xad_Sf[a‘ [e fZge ‘WWVWVa‘ fZW da^W b^SkWV Tk X[eZ[‘Y Xad V[XXWdW‘f YdagbeS‘V Zai fZ[e [e ^[]W^k fa UZS‘YW ahWd f[_W) Ga^[UkdWeba‘eWe ‘WWV fa TW iW^^ SVSbfWV fa âUSÛa‘V[f[a‘e S‘V fa fZW dS‘YW aX ^[hW^[ZaaVXg‘Uf[a‘e bWdXad_WV Tk X[eZWd[We)

@‘ USeWe egUZ Se CSae’ b^S‘‘Wde eZag^VeWW] fa Sha[V ad _[f[YSfW ‘WYSf[hW [_bSUfe a‘X[eZ[‘Y Y[hW‘ [fe [_badfS‘UW [‘ fZW ^[hW^[ZaaVe aX_aef dgdS^ bWab^W’ S‘V Sêa [fe bafW‘f[S^ da^W SeS eaU[S^ eSXWfk ‘Wf Xad fZW eaU[S^^k S‘VWUa‘a_[US^^k WjU^gVWV) @‘ CSae’ X[eZWd[We SdW^[]W^k fa VWU^[‘W [‘ dW^Sf[hW eaU[S^ S‘V WUa‘a_[U[_badfS‘UW Se fZW dgdS^ WUa‘a_k g‘VWdYaWe SfdS‘e[f[a‘ fa S _adW _Sd]Wf(ad[W‘fWV bdaVgUf[a‘ekefW_) JZ[e [e VW_a‘efdSfWV Sf fZW ZageWZa^V^WhW^’ iZWdW X[eZ[‘Y fW‘Ve fa VWU^[‘W [‘[_badfS‘UW i[fZ [‘UdWSe[‘Y iWS^fZ) ;Web[fW fZ[e’X[eZWd[We i[̂ ^ Ua‘f[‘gW fa bdah[VW S‘ [_badfS‘f_WS‘e aX egbbadf Xad ^S‘V VWX[U[W‘f S‘V ^STadegdb^ge dgdS^ ZageWZa^Ve [‘ fZW XadWeWWST^WXgfgdW) JZWk Sêa ZShW bafW‘f[S^ Xad ea_WUa__WdU[S^[lWV’ fZagYZ ef[^^ e_S^^(eUS^W’VWhWâb_W‘f)

@‘ Id[ CS‘]S’ b^S‘‘Wde eZag^V eWW] fa bdafWUfS‘V egefS[‘ Wj[ef[‘Y X[eZWd[We’ iZ[^W SêaVWhWâb[‘Y ‘Wi ad _aV[X[WV ZST[fSfe) JZW S[_TW[‘Y fa bdah[VW W_bâk_W‘f S‘V [‘Ua_We fa^S‘V^Wee ad _SdY[‘S^ XSd_[‘Y ZageWZa^Ve’ Se

W[fZWd S Xg^^(f[_W ad bSdf(f[_W SUf[h[fk) @‘ S dWY[a‘VWbdWeeWV Tk dWUgddW‘f VdagYZfe’ S efSY‘S‘fWUa‘a_k S‘V Z[YZ g‘W_bâk_W‘f’ bdaVgUf[hWX[eZWd[We iag^V TW hS^gST^W [‘ TafZ eaU[S^ S‘VWUa‘a_[U fWd_e)

The Need for Integrated Land and WaterManagement

JZW efgV[We dWbadfWV ZWdW egYYWef fZSf[‘fWYdSf[a‘ aX ^S‘V’ iSfWd S‘V X[eZWdk_S‘SYW_W‘f US‘ TW UdgU[S^ fa SUZ[Wh[‘Y abf[_S^geW aX iSfWd Xad XSd_ S‘V X[eZ bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V^[hW^[ZaaVe) JZ[e [e _adW ^[]W^k fa TW SUZ[WhWV TkS‘ [‘fWYdSfWV’ [fWdSf[hW S‘V bSdf[U[bSfadk_S‘SYW_W‘f SbbdaSUZ fZS‘ fZW bdWhS[^[‘YeWUfadS^ SbbdaSUZ) @‘ fZW ^SffWd dWeba‘e[T[^[f[WeXad XSd_[‘Y’ [dd[YSf[a‘’ S‘V X[eZWd[We aXfW‘ ^[W i[fZV[XXWdW‘f SYW‘U[We fZSf ZShW XWi’ [X S‘k’[‘ef[fgf[a‘S^ ^[‘]SYWe) ?a^[ef[U S‘V [‘fWYdSfWV_S‘SYW_W‘f [e ‘WWVWV fa egefS[‘ ad W‘ZS‘UWX[eZWd[We’ SVV[‘Y fa fZW TW‘WX[fe YW‘WdSfWV Tk S‘[dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_W’ S‘V aXfW‘ _SfUZ[‘Y fZW ‘WWVeaX baad S‘V hg^‘WdST^W Ydagbe afZWdi[eW‘WY^WUfWV ad SVhWdeW^k SXXWUfWV) @‘ fgd‘’ fZ[e_gef TW eWf [‘ fZW Ua‘fWjf aX fZW _g^f[b^W S‘VaXfW‘ Ua_bWf[‘Y iSfWd geWe i[fZ[‘ S d[hWd TSe[‘’Se SVVdWeeWV [‘ S‘ [‘fWYdSfWV iSfWd dWeagdUWe_S‘SYW_W‘f $@MHD% XdS_Wiad])

0?5AA<A: 5A7 *@C56F %EE8EE@8AF 9BD(<E;8D<8E

Biodiversity, Production and LivelihoodsObjectives

<‘h[da‘_W‘fS^ [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe aX [dd[YSf[a‘VWhWâb_W‘f fZSf ZShW Ua‘e[VWdWV [_bSUfe a‘X[eZWd[We ZShW fW‘VWV fa XaUge a‘ [eegWe aXT[aV[hWde[fk S‘V WUaâY[US^ [‘fWYd[fk) MZ[^W fZWeWUS‘ TW UâeW^k ^[‘]WV i[fZ [_bSUfe a‘ bdaVgUf[a‘S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaVe’ fZW efgV[We dWbadfWV ZWdW ZShWUa‘X[d_WV fZSf fZ[e [e ‘af ‘WUWeeSd[^k fZW USeW [‘S^^ dWebWUfe) @‘VWWV’ [‘ CSae’ S‘V [‘ Id[ CS‘]S’[dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f iSe VWW_WV fa [‘UdWSeWahWdS^^ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V dW^SfWV ^[hW^[ZaaVabbadfg‘[f[We Xad fZW âUS^ babg^Sf[a‘’ VWeb[fW

.+

‘WYSf[hW [_bSUfe a‘ T[aV[hWde[fk S‘V WUaâY[US^[‘fWYd[fk)

@‘ TafZ CSae S‘V Id[ CS‘]S’ fZW WUaâY[US^[‘fWYd[fk aX ScgSf[U ZST[fSfe ZSV TWW‘ ZWSh[^k_aV[X[WV bd[ad fa _aVWd‘ [dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f)8e S dWeg^f fZW d[hWd’ fZW Va_[‘S‘f ScgSf[UZST[fSf bd[ad fa Zg_S‘ [‘fWdXWdW‘UW’ SUUag‘fWVXad a‘^k S e_S^^ bdabadf[a‘ aX X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘$fZ[e bSdf[Ug^Sd^k Sbb^[WV fa Id[ CS‘]S%) @‘ egUZUSeWe’ Y[hW‘ S‘ aT\WUf[hW aX bdWeWdh[‘Y ad[Y[‘S^ScgSf[U T[aV[hWde[fk’ dWefadSf[a‘ aX fZW d[hWd e‘SfgdS^ Xâi bSffWd‘e S‘V ^SfWdS^ Ua‘‘WUf[h[fkiag^V TW fZW bdWXWddWV abf[a‘) 9gf Ua‘eWdh[‘Y addWefad[‘Y fZW d[hWd _Sk ‘af TW S bd[ad[fk aX âUSêfS]WZa^VWde $Se [‘ CSae S‘V Id[ CS‘]S% S‘V_Sk ‘af k[W^V e[Y‘[X[US‘f bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V^[hW^[ZaaV TW‘WX[fe) @X fZWeW SdW fZW YaSê fZW‘_S‘SY[‘Y fZW X[eZWd[We [‘ fZW _S‘(_SVW ad_aV[X[WV ZST[fSfe fa [‘UdWSeW bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘VW_bâk_W‘f eZag^V TW fZW bd[ad[fk)

JZWdWXadW’ V[XXWdW‘f bWdebWUf[hWe S‘V faaê SdW‘WWVWV fa SeeWee fZW [_bSUfe a‘ T[aV[hWde[fk S‘V^[hW^[ZaaV’ S‘V V[XXWdW‘f _WSegdWe _Sk TW ‘WWVWVfa _[f[YSfW S‘k ‘WYSf[hW [_bSUfe aX [dd[YSf[a‘VWhWâb_W‘f) JZW SbbdaSUZ fS]W‘ fa [_bSUfSeeWee_W‘f _gef UWdfS[‘^k TW TdaSVWd [‘ eUabWfZS‘ S Ua‘hW‘f[a‘S^ SeeWee_W‘f aX fZW WUaâY[USÛZS‘YWe dWeg f̂[‘Y Xda_ STefdSUf[a‘ Xda_’ adV[hWde[a‘ aX S d[hWd’ Xad [dd[YSf[a‘ ad afZWd geWe)

Assessment of Livelihood Impacts

@_bSUfe a‘ ^[hW^[ZaaVe VWbW‘V a‘ fZW aT\WUf[hWeaX ZageWZa^Ve fZSf X[eZ’ fZW Xg‘Uf[a‘e X[eZ[‘YbWdXad_e [‘ fZW[d ^[hW [̂ZaaV efdSfWY[We’ fZW[dSUUWee fa X[eZWd[We S‘V fZW[d S^fWd‘Sf[hW ^[hW^[ZaaVabbadfg‘[f[We) 8eeWee_W‘fe _gef âa] TWka‘V[‘Ua_We S‘V Ua‘e[VWd fZW i[VWd TW‘WX[febdah[VWV Tk X[eZ[‘Y Se bSdf aX S V[hWde[X[WV^[hW^[ZaaV efdSfWYk) JZWeW US‘ [‘U^gVW TgXXWd[‘YSYS[‘ef eZaU]e’ _S‘SY[‘Y [‘Ua_W d[e]’ S‘Ve_aafZ[‘Y Ua‘eg_bf[a‘ S‘V ^STad geW) =[eZ SdWSêa hS^gST^W Se S bd[_Sdk eagdUW aX bdafW[‘ S‘V_[Uda(‘gfd[W‘fe’ S‘V Se S‘ SUUWee[T^W USeZ[‘Ua_W) =[eZ[‘Y US‘ Sêa Xad_ fZW TSe[e XaddWU[bdaUS^ WjUZS‘YW’ bSdf[U[bSf[a‘ [‘ eaU[S^‘Wfiad]e ad e[_b^k Xad dWUdWSf[a‘ $I_[fZ Wf S^)-++0%)

=[eZ[‘Y US‘ b^Sk V[hWdeW Tgf WcgS^^k[_badfS‘f da^We Xad V[XXWdW‘f Ydagbe) @f US‘ TW Segbb^W_W‘fS^ SUf[h[fk Xad S e[Y‘[X[US‘f bdabadf[a‘aX S Ua__g‘[fk Se iW^^ Se S Ud[f[US^ Ua_ba‘W‘f[‘ fZW ^[hW [̂ZaaV efdSfWY[We aX ea_W ZageWZa^Ve$Se [‘ Id[ CS‘]S%’ ad [f _Sk TW S‘ [‘fWYdS^ bSdf aXfZW ^[hW^[ZaaVe aX fZW iZa^W Ua__g‘[fk $Se [‘CSae%) JZge’ WhW‘ iZWdW SYYdWYSfW ‘Wf [_bSUfea‘ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[h[fk SdW ‘WgfdS^ ad bae[f[hW’ [f[e [_badfS‘f fa _S]W S‘ SeeWee_W‘f aX [_bSUfefZSf [e V[eSYYdWYSfWV ebSf[S^^k SUdaee SUSfUZ_W‘f S‘V Tk eaU[aWUa‘a_[U Ydagb S‘VYW‘VWd) JZW V[efd[Tgf[a‘ aX [_bSUfe _Sk ‘af TWWcg[fST^W S‘V S‘k SeeWee_W‘f’ bSdf[Ug^Sd^k [‘^SdYW(eUS^W ekefW_e’ _gef âa] TWka‘VSYYdWYSfW bdaVgUf[a‘ UZS‘YWe S‘V W‘Ua_bSeebZke[US^’ fW_badS^ S‘V [‘ef[fgf[a‘S^ VWfWd_[‘S‘feaX fZW bdaVgUf[h[fk S‘V SUUWee[T[^[fk aX X[eZWd[WeXad S^^ SXXWUfWV Ydagbe)

The Value of Stakeholder Involvement

JZW SbbdaSUZ fa [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f SVabfWV [‘CSae S‘V Id[ CS‘]S [‘ha^hWV bSdf[U[bSf[a‘ Tk S^^dW^WhS‘f efS]WZa^VWde’ S‘V fZW geW aX e[_b^W S‘VfdS‘ebSdW‘f faaê egUZ Se _Sbb[‘Y ZST[fSfe S‘VTgVYWf[‘Y X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ a‘ fZW TSe[e aXUa_bSdSf[hW k[W^V [‘Xad_Sf[a‘) 8f âi Uaef fZWSbbdaSUZ SUZ[WhWV dSb[V [VW‘f[X[USf[a‘ aX ]Wk[eegWe’ Wef[_Sf[a‘ aX fZW _SY‘[fgVW aX ^[]W^k[_bSUfe’ S‘V bd[ad[f[lSf[a‘ aX dWeba‘eWe) @fVW_a‘efdSfWV fZSf [‘ha^h[‘Y efS]WZa^VWde [‘ fZWbdaUWee US‘ ZW^b eUabW fZW SeeWee_W‘f TkdSb[V^k [VW‘f[Xk[‘Y ]Wk [eegWe S‘V bd[ad[f[We Xad_[f[YSf[a‘ ad W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f) JZ[e [e bSdf[Ug^Sd^kgeWXg^ iZW‘ Xg‘Ve S‘V f[_W SdW ^[_[fWV)IfS]WZa^VWd [‘ha^hW_W‘f US‘ Sêa ZW^b SVVdWeeUa__g‘[fk Ua‘UWd‘e S‘V bafW‘f[S^ Ua‘X^[Ufe’WefST^[eZ YdWSfWd ai‘WdeZ[b S‘V Ua__[f_W‘f faS‘k _WSegdWe g^f[_SfW^k SYdWWV a‘’ S‘V UdWSfWS Xag‘VSf[a‘ Xad S‘ a‘(Ya[‘Y V[SâYgW S‘V‘WYaf[Sf[a‘)

HWbdWeW‘fSf[a‘ Xda_ V[XXWdW‘f efS]WZa^VWdYdagbe’ [‘U^gV[‘Y dW^WhS‘f U[h[^ eaU[Wfk S‘VYahWd‘_W‘f SYW‘U[We’ [e ‘WUWeeSdk’ ‘af \gef Xda_fZW efS‘Vba[‘f aX ai‘WdeZ[b S‘V Wcg[fk [eegWe’Tgf Sêa TWUSgeW ]‘ai^WVYW S‘V bWdUWbf[a‘ aX[_bSUfe V[XXWd TWfiWW‘ Ydagbe) JZWdW [e S d[e]

.,

fZSf efS]WZa^VWde i[^^ [‘fdaVgUW T[Se ad_[e[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ [‘fa fZW SeeWee_W‘f’ TgfUa_T[‘[‘Y fWUZ‘[US^ WjbWdf[eW i[fZ âUS^]‘ai^WVYW Xda_ _g^f[b^W efS]WZa^VWd Ydagbe US‘ZW^b _[‘[_[lW fZ[e S‘V W‘egdW SVWcgSfW S‘VaT\WUf[hW UahWdSYW aX [eegWe)

Limitations of Fisheries Impact Assessments

;Web[fW fZW gf[^[fk aX fZW SbbdaSUZ fa [_bSUfSeeWee_W‘f geWV [‘ CSae S‘V Id[ CS‘]S’ ea_Wg‘UWdfS[‘fk [‘Wh[fST^k dW_S[‘e [‘ZWdW‘f [‘ fZWbdWV[Uf[a‘ ad WhS^gSf[a‘ aX Ua_b^Wj S‘V hSd[ST^WbZW‘a_W‘S) >Sbe dW_S[‘ [‘ agd ]‘ai^WVYW aXXdWeZiSfWd X[eZWd[We S‘V Zai fZWk _Sk dWeba‘Vfa fZW dS‘YW aX UZS‘YWe [‘fdaVgUWV Tk [dd[YSf[a‘VWhWâb_W‘f) =ad WjS_b^W’ [_bdahWV ]‘ai^WVYW[e ‘WWVWV aX fZW WUaâYk aX UaSefS^ ^SYaa‘eSXXWUfWV Tk VdS[‘SYW [‘Xâie’ Se [‘ Id[ CS‘]S’S‘V aX fZW[d _S‘SYW_W‘f ‘WWVe Se TafZX[eZWd[We S‘V i[̂ V^[XW dWeWdhWe)

MZWdW g‘UWdfS[‘fk Wj[efe’ Sbbdabd[SfW geW aXeW‘e[f[h[fk S‘S^ke[e US‘ TW ZW^bXg^’ Tgf ahWdS^^ [f[e [_badfS‘f fa dWeba‘V i[fZ S‘ [fWdSf[hW S‘VSVSbf[hW SbbdaSUZ fa W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f S‘V_[f[YSf[a‘ _WSegdWe’ iW^̂ [‘Xad_WV Tk _a‘[fad[‘YS‘V WhS^gSf[‘Y fZW[d [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘) DadW f[_W

S‘V dWeagdUWe iag^V ZShW XSU[^[fSfWV _adWd[Yadage SeeWee_W‘f aX fZW ‘SfgdW’ VWfWd_[‘S‘feS‘V V[efd[Tgf[a‘ aX fZW ]Wk [_bSUfe [‘ CSae S‘VId[ CS‘]S’ Tgf fZW Uaefe aX egUZ [‘Xad_Sf[a‘_gef SîSke TW iW[YZfWV SYS[‘ef [fe [‘UdW_W‘fS^gf[^[fk Xad VWU[e[a‘ _S][‘Y)

F‘W XgdfZWd ^[_[fSf[a‘ aX bda\WUf(TSeWV [_bSUfSeeWee_W‘fe [e fZSf fZWk _Sk ‘WY^WUf [_badfS‘fUg_g^Sf[hW $ad Uag‘fWdSUf[‘Y% [_bSUfe aX[dd[YSf[a‘ ad afZWd iSfWd dWeagdUW VWhWâb_W‘fe’a‘ ‘SfgdS^ dWeagdUWe S‘V ^[hW^[ZaaVe Sf fZW d[hWd(TSe[‘ eUS^W) =gdfZWd efgVk [e ‘WWVWV aX baee[T^WUg_g^Sf[hW S‘V ek‘WdY[ef[U [_bSUfe aX [dd[YSf[a‘eUZW_We S‘V afZWd iSfWd dWeagdUWVWhWâb_W‘fe i[fZ[‘ S d[hWd TSe[‘) JZ[e ba[‘f [edW^WhS‘f fa fZW ^WhW^ S‘V WjfW‘f aX efS]WZa^VWdbSdf[U[bSf[a‘) @‘ Id[ CS‘]S’ baee[T^W [_bSUfe iWdW[VW‘f[X[WV SUdaee fZW iZa^W d[hWd TSe[‘ S‘V fZ[e[‘X^gW‘UWV fZW eW^WUf[a‘ aX efS]WZa^VWde fabSdf[U[bSfW [‘ fZW [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f) @‘ CSae’ SegT(TSe[‘ iSe efgV[WV Xad iZ[UZ Vai‘efdWS_[_bSUfe a‘ fZW _S[‘ d[hWd iWdW WjbWUfWV fa TW‘WY^[Y[T^W) @f [e [_badfS‘f fa ‘afW fZSf fZ[e _Sk‘af SîSke TW fZW USeW’ S‘V S X[eZWdk Uag^V TWSVhWdeW^k SXXWUfWV Vai‘efdWS_ iZWdW fZWdW [e‘a baee[T[^[fk aX Ua_bW‘eSf[‘Y TW‘WX[fe Xda_ fZW[dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_W)

’BA6?GE<BAE

8eeWee_W‘fe ZShW TWW‘ _SVW aX fZW [_bSUfe aX[dd[YSf[a‘ VWhWâb_W‘f a‘ X[eZWd[We Xad S ‘Wi[dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_W [‘ CSae S‘V Xad S‘ WefST^[eZWVeUZW_W [‘ Id[ CS‘]S) JZWeW XaUgeWV a‘ [_bSUfea‘ X[eZWd[We bdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V dgdS^ ^[hW^[ZaaVe) JZWSeeWee_W‘fe iWdW _SVW fZdagYZ S‘ [‘U^ge[hWbSdf[U[bSfadk S‘V [fWdSf[hW bdaUWee fZSf iSeZa^[ef[U S‘V [‘fWdV[eU[b^[‘Sdk [‘ [fe ad[W‘fSf[a‘)JZ[e eagYZf fa bdaUWWV Xda_ TdaSV S‘V dSb[VSbbdS[eS^’ fZdagYZ _adW [‘(VWbfZ fWUZ‘[US^S‘S^ke[e aX ]Wk [eegWe’ fa bdah[e[a‘ aX[‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xad VWU[e[a‘ _S][‘Y a‘ bda\WUf(ebWU[X[U W‘ZS‘UW_W‘f ad _[f[YSf[a‘ _WSegdWe)JZW dWeg^fe ZShW SVVWV S ‘g_TWd aX ‘Wi

bWdebWUf[hWe fa fZW ^[_[fWV Wj[ef[‘Y ^[fWdSfgdW a‘fZW [_bSUfe aX [dd[YSf[a‘ a‘ [‘^S‘V X[eZWd[We)

;WbW‘VW‘f a‘ Ua‘V[f[a‘e’ bdaVgUf[hWX[eZWd[We US‘ UaWj[ef i[fZ [dd[YSf[a‘ eUZW_We’ [‘_S‘k USeWe SVV[‘Y fa fZW SYYdWYSfW bdaVgUf[h[fkaX fZW ekefW_) @‘ Ua‘fdSef [_bSUfe a‘ fZWT[aV[hWde[fk aX XdWeZiSfWd ScgSf[U dWeagdUWe SdWS^_aef SîSke ^[]W^k fa TW ‘WYSf[hW’ TWUSgeW fZWUZSdSUfWd[ef[Ue S‘V Ua‘‘WUf[h[fk aX ‘SfgdS^ZST[fSfe i[^̂ [‘Wh[fST^k TW _aV[X[WV Tk [dd[YSfWVSYd[Ug^fgdW S‘V [fe [‘XdSefdgUfgdW) GdaVgUf[a‘ S‘V^[hW^[ZaaV aT\WUf[hWe _Sk ‘af’ fZWdWXadW’ Ua[‘U[VWi[fZ T[aV[hWde[fk Ua‘UWd‘e’ dWcg[d[‘Y V[XXWdW‘fSbbdaSUZWe Xad [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘f S‘V iSfWd

.-

_S‘SYW_W‘f) @_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe Xad [dd[YSf[a‘bda\WUfe S‘V afZWd VWhWâb_W‘fe fZSf SXXWUf fZWZkVdaâYk aX [‘^S‘V iSfWd TaV[We eZag^V Ua‘e[VWdfZW X[eZWd[We fZSf Wj[ef [‘ _S‘(_SVW S‘V_aV[X[WV ScgSf[U ZST[fSfe Se iW^^ Se fZaeW ef[^^ [‘fZW[d ‘SfgdS^ Ua‘V[f[a‘)

=Sd_[‘Y bdSUf[UWe S‘V iSfWd _S‘SYW_W‘fUS‘ ZShW [_bSUfe a‘ X[eZWd[We fZSf SdW Sf ^WSefSe e[Y‘[X[US‘f’ [X ‘af YdWSfWd’ fZS‘ [_bSUfe Sd[e[‘YXda_ Ua‘efdgUf[a‘) 8‘ [‘fWYdSfWV iSfWd dWeagdUWe_S‘SYW_W‘f SbbdaSUZ [e ‘WWVWV fa abf[_[lW fZWbdaVgUf[h[fk S‘V ^[hW [̂ZaaV Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘e aXX[eZWd[We S‘V [dd[YSf[a‘ ekefW_e’ [‘ fZW Ua‘fWjf aX_g^f[b^W S‘V Ua_bWf[‘Y iSfWd geWe i[fZ[‘ S d[hWdTSe[‘) GdaUWeeWe aX b^S‘‘[‘Y S‘V [_b^W_W‘fSf[a‘SdW ‘WWVWV fZSf US‘ dWUaY‘[lW S‘V dWea^hWfdSVW(aXXe TWfiWW‘ Ua_bWf[‘Y [‘fWdWef Ydagbe)JZWeW bdaUWeeWe ‘WWV fa [‘ha^hW efS]WZa^VWde

S‘V fa [_bdahW a‘ eWUfadS^ SbbdaSUZWe’ iZWdW[dd[YSf[a‘ S‘V X[eZWd[We SdW _S‘SYWV Tk V[XXWdW‘fSYW‘U[We i[fZ iWS] [‘ef[fgf[a‘S^ ^[‘]SYWe’ S‘ViZ[UZ US‘ XS[^ fa SVWcgSfW^k dWUaY‘[lWUa__g‘[fk [‘fWdWefe S‘V ‘WWVe)

=[eZWd[We US‘ b^Sk V[hWdeW da^We [‘^[hW^[ZaaV efdSfWY[We i[fZ[‘ Ua__g‘[f[We S‘V’ faSVWcgSfW^k USbfgdW ^[hW [̂ZaaV [eegWe’ [dd[YSf[a‘[_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe _gef TW V[eSYYdWYSfWVebSf[S^^k $W)Y)’ STahW S‘V Vai‘efdWS_ aX SVS_%’ TWfiWW‘ V[XXWdW‘f fkbWe aX iSfWd TaV[We$W)Y)’ d[hWd(XâaVb^S[‘’ d[UW X[W^Ve’ dWeWdha[de’ S‘V^SYaa‘e% S‘V TWfiWW‘ V[XXWdW‘f eaU[aWUa‘a_[UYdagbe) @f [e [_badfS‘f fa Ya TWka‘V efWdWafkbWeaX X[eZWd[We Se fZW ^Sef dWeadf aX fZW baadWef’ S‘VXad [_bSUf SeeWee_W‘fe fa âa] [‘ VWbfZ Sf fZWSUfgS^ Ua‘fd[Tgf[a‘e _SVW Tk X[eZWd[We fabWab^W e ^[hW^[ZaaVe)

..

,<F8D5FGD8 ’<F87

8VS_e M) -+++) 6ZbY^_]PLX ;X[LN_^ ZQ 6LX^) GdWbSdWV Xad fZW M:; JZW_Sf[U HWh[Wi @),5 IaU[S^ @_bSUfe aX CSdYW;S_e <cg[fk S‘V ;[efd[Tgf[a‘S^ @eegWe) K‘[hWde[fk aX :S_Td[VYW’ KB)

8^^[ea‘’ <) ?)6 <^^[e =) -++,) JZW C[hW [̂ZaaVe 8bbdaSUZ S‘V DS‘SYW_W‘f aX I_S^^(eUS^W =[eZWd[We) ?L]TYP BZWTNd *,5.22 .33)

8^_W[VS’ F)J)6 CadW‘lW‘’ B6 DU>dSfZ ;)>) -++-) FSP ]ZWP ZQ _SP QT^SP]TP^ ^PN_Z] TY _SP ]PRTZYLW PNZYZXd ZQ _SP4]LeTWTLY 3XLeZY) GSbWd bdWeW‘fWV Sf fZW -‘V @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ CSdYW H[hWd Ik_bae[g_’ Ha_W5 =aaV S‘V 8Yd[Ug^fgdWFdYS‘[lSf[a‘ $=8F%)

8_SdSe[‘YZW’ K)I) ,443) HWeWdha[d =[eZWd[We DS‘SYW_W‘f [‘ Id[ CS‘]S5 8UZ[WhW_W‘fe’ D[efS]We S‘V CWeea‘e Xad=gfgdW) ;Y_P]YL_TZYLW DPaTPb ZQ :dO]ZMTZWZRd’ 3. $IbWU[S^ @eegW%5 0-. 0.+)

8‘a‘) -+++) FPNSYTNLW DP[Z]_ ZQ _SP :‘Ld FSZ‘L_ ;]]TRL_TZY B]ZUPN_) =WSe[T[^[fk IfgVk) @‘ef[fgfW aX @dd[YSf[a‘JWUZ‘aâYk’ @dd[YSf[a‘ ;WbSdf_W‘f’ ?S‘a[)

8dfZ[‘Yfa‘’ 8)?)6 HS^^’ A)C)6 BW‘‘SdV D)A)6 GgeWk’ 9)A) -++.) <‘h[da‘_W‘fS^ Xâi dWcg[dW_W‘fe aX X[eZ [‘ CWeafZa d[hWdege[‘Y fZW ;H@=J _WfZaVaâYk) DTaP] DP^PL]NS LYO 3[[WTNL_TZY^ ,45 1/, 111

8dfZ[‘Yfa‘ 8)?)6 CadW‘lW‘ B)6 GgeWk 9)A)6 8TW^^ H)6 ?S^ê’ 8)6 M[‘W_[^^Wd B)F)6 8dd[‘Yfa‘ ;)8)6 9SdS‘’ <) -++/) DTaP]QT̂ SP]TP^0 PNZWZRTNLW ML^T^ QZ] XLYLRPXPY_ LYO NZY^P]aL_TZY& @‘ B]ZNPPOTYR^ ZQ _SP *YO ;Y_P]YL_TZYLW >L]RP DTaP]ÊdX[Z^T‘X’ WV) H)C) MWÛa__W Ha_W) =aaV S‘V 8Yd[Ug^fgdW FdYS‘[lSf[a‘ aX fZW K‘[fWV ESf[a‘e $=8F%)

9S]]Wd D)6 9Sd]Wd H)6 DW[‘lW‘(;[U] H)6 Ba‘dSVeW‘ =) $<Ve)% ,444) ?‘W_T[WP ‘^P^ ZQ bL_P] TY T]]TRL_PO L]PL^0 L NL^P^_‘Od Q]ZX E]T >LYVL& IM@D GSbWd 3) :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 @=GH@(@MD@

9Sk^Wk’ G)9) ,433) 8UUag‘f[‘Y Xad WXXadf iZW‘ Ua_bSd[‘Y fdab[US^ X[eZWd[We [‘ ^S]We’ d[hWd(XâaVb^S[‘e S‘V ^SYaa‘e)>TXYZWZRd LYO ANPLYZR]L[Sd’ ..5 41. 42-)

9m‘m’ :) -++.) MZW‘ =[eZWdk HZk_We i[fZ GahWdfk5 8 =[def IfWb 9Wka‘V fZW F^V GSdSV[Y_ a‘ GahWdfk [‘ I_S^^(IUS^W =[eZWd[W^& IZ]WO 6PaPWZ[XPY_ .,5 4/4 420)

9m‘m’ :)6 EW[̂ S‘V 8)<) -++.) 5ZY_]TM‘_TZY ZQ ;YWLYO 8T^SP]TP^ _Z D‘]LW >TaPWTSZZO^ TY 3Q]TNL0 7X[T]TNLW 7aTOPYNP Q]ZX_SP >LVP 5SLO 4L^TY 3]PL^) -‘V @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ Ik_bae[g_ a‘ fZW DS‘SYW_W‘f aX CSdYW H[hWde Xad =[eZWd[We’GZ‘a_ GW‘Z)

9[lWd A)H) -+++) ;Y_P]YL_TZYLW ?PNSLYT^X^ QZ] 3aZTOTYR$ ?T_TRL_TYR LYO 5ZX[PY^L_TYR _SP ;X[LN_^ ZQ >L]RP 6LX^ZY 3\‘L_TN LYO DPWL_PO 7NZ^d^_PX^ LYO E[PNTP^& GdWbSdWV Xad @K:E * KE<G * M:;)$=[‘S^ VdSXf ZSe TWW‘bgT^[eZWV%)

:W‘fdS^ 9S‘] aX Id[ CS‘]S -++,) 3YY‘LW DP[Z]_ *(()& :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S)

:W‘fdS^ 9S‘] aX Id[ CS‘]S -++-) 7NZYZXTN LYO EZNTLW E_L_T^_TN^ ZQ E]T >LYVL *((*) La^g_W NN@L’ @IIE ,.4, .1,,):aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 IfSf[ef[Ue ;WbSdf_W‘f)

:ZS‘VdSe[d[’ A) B) ,431) EZNTZ%7NZYZXTN 5ZYOT_TZY^ ZQ ;YWLYO 8T^SP]XPY TY E]T >LYVL0 3 B]P%B]ZUPN_ E_‘Od ZQ 8TaP?LUZ] DP^P]aZT]^ TY _SP :LXMLY_Z_L 6T^_]TN_& :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 8YdSd[S‘ HWeWSdUZ S‘V JdS[‘[‘Y @‘ef[fgfW) Ea)2.’ b 40)

:^Sd[VYW’ >) ,441) 3Y ;YaPY_Z]d ZQ IP_WLYO^ ZQ _SP >LZ B&6&D) :a_b[^Sf[a‘ Tk >) :^Sd[VYW) @K:E Mad][‘Y GSbWd)9S‘Y]a]’ JZS[^S‘V5 @K:E) b) -32)

:^Sk’ :)?) ,440) 6P^TRY ZQ 8T^SbLd^ LYO Z_SP] 8T^S 8LNTWT_TP^’ WV)9aUS HSfa‘’ CWi[e)=âd[VS’ KI8 5 :H: GdWee)

;W I[^hS’ I) I) ,433) DP^P]aZT]^ ZQ E]T >LYVL LYO _SPT] 8T^SP]TP^) Ha_W) =aaV S‘V 8Yd[Ug^fgdW FdYS‘[lSf[a‘ $=8F%))

;WbSdf_W‘f aX :W‘ege S‘V IfSf[ef[Ue ,444) 6T^_]TN_ B]ZQTWP ZQ >LMZ] 8Z]NP TY E]T >LYVL )//-& :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5;WbSdf_W‘f aX :W‘ege S‘V IfSf[ef[Ue’ D[‘[efdk aX =[‘S‘UW S‘V G^S‘‘[‘Y)

;=@; $;WbSdf_W‘f Xad @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ ;WhWâb_W‘f% ,444) E‘^_LTYLMWP >TaPWTSZZO^ 9‘TOLYNP ESPP_^ Ca‘Va‘)&;WbSdf_W‘f Xad @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ ;WhWâb_W‘f) Ca‘Va‘)

./

=8G ,2) ,440) =âaV 8Uf[a‘ G^S‘) =[‘S^ HWbadf DS[‘ La^g_W)’ Ca‘Va‘’ KB) FhWdeWSe ;WhWâb_W‘f 8V_[‘[efdSf[a‘)

>SdSiSk’ :)A) ,444) EXLWW bL_P] MZOd QT^SP]TP^ LYO _SP [Z_PY_TLW QZ] NZXX‘YT_d%WPO PYSLYNPXPY_0 5L^P ^_‘OTP^TY >LZ B6D& ) GZ; JZWe[e’ K‘[hWde[fk aX Ca‘Va‘) bb /,/)

>dWYadk’ H)6 >gff_S‘’ ?) -++-) JZW d[UWX[W^V USfUZ S‘V dgdS^ XaaV eWUgd[k) @‘ D‘]LW 3\‘LN‘W_‘]P’ WV) G)<ViSdVe’ ;):)C[ff^W S‘V ?) ;W_S[‘W) MS^ [̂‘YXadV’ KB5 :89@ GgT^[eZ[‘Y)

>gff_S‘ ,444) H[UW X[W^V X[eZWd[We5 8 dWeagdUW Xad :S_TaV[S) @393 _SP ;5>3D? C‘L_P]Wd --$-%5 ,, ,0)

?S^ê’ 8)I)6 ?aYYSdfZ’ ;);)6 ;WT‘SfZ’ B) ,444) @_bSUfe aX ZkVdSg^[U W‘Y[‘WWd[‘Y a‘ fZW Vk‘S_[Ue S‘V bdaVgUf[a‘bafW‘f[S^ aX XâaVb^S[‘ X[eZ babg^Sf[a‘e [‘ 9S‘Y^SVWeZ& 8T^SP]TP^ ?LYLRPXPY_ LYO 7NZWZRd 15 -1, -30)

?S^ê’ 8)I)6 B[d]iaaV’ >)G)6 GSk‘W’ 8)@) -++,) 8 Vk‘S_[U baa^ _aVW^ Xad XâaVb^S[‘ d[hWd X[eZWd[We) 7NZSdO]ZWZRd LYO:dO]ZMTZWZRd ,5 .-. ..4)

?WU]_S‘’ :)M) ,424) DTNP 8TPWO 7NZWZRd TY YZ]_SPL^_P]Y FSLTWLYO0 FSP PQQPN_ ZQ bP_ LYO O]d ^PL^ZY^ ZY L N‘W_TaL_POL\‘L_TN PNZ^d^_PX& JZW ?SYgW’ JZW EWfZWd^S‘Ve5 Ag‘] GgT^[eZWde

?ab][‘e’ I) ,440) JZW <Ua‘a_k) @‘ >LZ^0 3 5Z‘Y_]d E_‘Od’ WV)’ 8)D) IShSVS’) MSeZ[‘Yfa‘ ;):)’ =WVWdS^ HWeWSdUZ;[h[e[a‘’ C[TdSdk aX :a‘YdWee)

@@D@ $@‘fWd‘Sf[a‘^ @dd[YSf[a‘ DS‘SYW_W‘f @‘ef[fgfW%) ,440) =T]TYOT AdL ;]]TRL_TZY LYO EP__WPXPY_ B]ZUPN_0 B]ZUPN_ ;X[LN_7aLW‘L_TZY E_‘Od) La^g_W @@ $X[‘S^ dWbadf%) :aâ_Ta’ @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ @dd[YSf[a‘ DS‘SYW_W‘f @‘ef[fgfW)

PZa‘Yb[‘Y P)6 ?W_S]g_SdS’ D)6DS][‘ @)6 9Sd]Wd H) $<Ve%) -++,) 6L_L 4ZZV FSP D‘S‘YL 4L^TY0 ;I?; 4PYNSXL]V4L^TY TY E]T >LYVL& :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ MSfWd DS‘SYW_W‘f @‘ef[fgfW $@MD@%)

ASU]ea‘’ ;):)6 DSd_g^^S’ >) -++,) JZW [‘X^gW‘UW aX VS_e a‘ d[hWd X[eZWd[We) @‘ 83A 8T^SP]TP^ FPNSYTNLW BL[P] /,45//)

ASkS]aVk’ ;)I) ,44.) 5L‘^P^ Z] 6PNWTYP ZQ 8TYQT^S LYO ESPWWQT^S 5L_NSP^ ZQ FS]PP EPWPN_PO >LRZZY^0 ?LWLWL$DPVLbL LYO ?LbPWWL ZY _SP EZ‘_S 5ZL^_ ZQ E]T >LYVL LYO _SP N‘]]PY_ E_L_‘^& 8‘‘gS^ IU[W‘f[X[U IWee[a‘e)ESf[a‘S^ 8cgSf[U HWeagdUW 8YW‘Uk’ Id[ CS‘]S) bb ,, ,.)

AW‘eW‘’ A)>) -++,) DS‘SY[‘Y X[eZ’ XâaVb^S[‘e S‘V XaaV eWUgd[fk [‘ fZW CaiWd DW]a‘Y 9Se[‘) IL_P] ENTPYNP LYOFPNSYZWZRd /. $4%5 ,02 ,1/’ @M8 GgT^[eZ[‘Y

AakWgj’ A):)6 MSdV’ 8)9) ,443) :a‘efdS[‘fe a‘ UaSefS^ ^SYaa‘ X[eZWd[We& 3OaLYNP^ TY ?L]TYP 4TZWZRd ./5 2. ,44)

Ag^(CSdeW‘’ <)6 hS‘ Pi[WfW‘ G) -++-) 8Xd[US‘ =dWeZiSfWd =[eZWd[We5 MZSf EWWVe fa TW DS‘SYWV7 @LRL$ IZ]WOQT^S5PY_P] C‘L]_P]Wd -0$. S‘V /%’ .0 /+)

Bg^SdSf‘W’ D)>) ,444) 8T^SP]XPY IT_SZ‘_ 8T^S & FSP 7QQPN_^ ZQ B]ZO‘N_TaT_d 6PNWTYP TY >LRZZY 8T^SP]TP^ ZY L8T^STYR LYO 8L]XTYR 5ZXX‘YT_d LYO T_^ G^P ZQ @L_‘]LW DP^Z‘]NP^0 3 5L^P E_‘Od ZQ ?LWLWL >LRZZY$ :LXMLY_Z_L$E]T >LYVL& @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ @‘ef[fgfW Xad 8WdaebSUW IgdhWk S‘V <SdfZ IU[W‘UWe) <‘eUZWVW’ JZW EWfZWd^S‘Ve)

CSi^Wd’ I)G) -++,) H[UW X[W^Ve Se fW_badSdk iWf^S‘Ve) ;^]LPW <Z‘]YLW ZQ KZZWZRd /25 0,. 0-3)

C[ff^W’ ;):)6 DgddSk =)A)6 BaV[fZgiS]]g I)I) -++,) GYOP]^_LYOTYR 6PXLYO :Zb _SP BZZ] 4PYPQT_ Q]ZX FTWL[TLB]ZO‘N_TZY TY _SP @Z]_SbP^_ 6]d KZYP ZQ E]T >LYVL& <(Ua‘XWdW‘UW GdaUWWV[‘Ye5 8cgSf[U HWeagdUWe DS‘SYW_W‘fXad IgefS[‘ST^W C[hW^[ZaaVe aX Gaad GWab^W $;=@;*@:C8HD%)

CadW‘lW‘’ B)6 >SdSiSk’ :)A) ,443) ?ai bdWV[UfST^W [e fZW agfUa_W aX efaU][‘Y2 ;Y ;YWLYO 8T^SP]d 7YSLYNPXPY_’ WV)’J) GWfd) =8F =[eZWd[We) JWUZ‘[US^) GSbWd) Ea) .2/’ Ha_W) =aaV S‘V 8Yd[Ug^fgdW FdYS‘[lSf[a‘ $=8F%)

CadW‘lW‘ B)6 EYgkW‘(BZaS I)6 >SdSiSk :)6 :ZS_e[‘YZ 9)6 C[fVS_â‘Y’ ;)6 I[WTWdf’ ;) @‘‘We(JSkâd’ E) -+++) ;X[LN_^ZQ ;]]TRL_TZY LYO 3\‘LN‘W_‘]P 6PaPWZ[XPY_ ZY EXLWW%ENLWP 3\‘L_TN DP^Z‘]NP^& =[‘S^ JWUZ‘[US^ HWbadf’ ;=@;Gda\WUf H224.’ Ca‘Va‘5 @_bWd[S^ :a^^WYW Ca‘Va‘)

CadW‘lW‘’ B)6 ;W >dSSX’ >)6 ?S^ê’ 8)I) -++.) 3 MTZXL^^ OdYLXTN^ XZOPW QZ] L^^P^^TYR TY_P]LN_TZY^ MP_bPPY QT^SP]TP^LYO bL_P] XLYLRPXPY_ TY STRSWd ^PL^ZYLW bL_P] MZOTP^& HWbadf) Ca‘Va‘5 @_bWd[S^ :a^^WYW)

.0

CadW‘lW‘’ B)6 I_[fZ’ C)<);)6 9gdfa‘’ D)6 EYgkW‘(BZaS’ I)6 >SdSiSk’ :) -++/) 9‘TOLYNP ?LY‘LW ZY _SP ?LYLRPXPY_ZQ ;]]TRL_TZY 6PaPWZ[XPY_ ;X[LN_^ ZY 8T^SP]TP^& Ca‘Va‘5 @_bWd[S^ :a^^WYW)

DSfeg‘a’ O)6 hS‘ VWd ?aW]’ M)6 HS‘SiS]W’ D) $<Ve)% ,443) ;]]TRL_TZY bL_P] XLYLRPXPY_ LYO _SP 4‘YOLWL @L_TZYLWBL]V1 B]ZNPPOTYR^ ZQ _SP bZ]V^SZ[ ZY bL_P] \‘LWT_d ZQ _SP 4‘YOLWL >LRZZY^$ SPWO L_ _SP ;Y_P]YL_TZYLW IL_P]?LYLRPXPY_ ;Y^_T_‘_P!;I?;"$ 5ZWZXMZ$ E]T >LYVL) :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 @MD@)

DgddSk =)6 BaVV[fZgiS]]g I)6 C[ff^W ;):) -+++) =[eZWd[We DSd]Wf[‘Y IkefW_e [‘ Id[ CS‘]S S‘V JZW[d HW^WhS‘UW faCaUS^ HWeWdha[d =[eZWdk ;WhWâb_W‘f) @‘ DP^P]aZT] LYO 5‘W_‘]P%ML^PO 8T^SP]TP^0 4TZWZRd LYO ?LYLRPXPY_ WV)’$I)I) ;W I[^hS GdaUWWV[‘Ye aX S‘ @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ Mad]eZab ZW^V [‘ 9S‘Y]a]’ JZS[^S‘V’ Xda_ ,0 ,3 =WTdgSdk -+++)

E8H8 $ESf[a‘S^ 8cgSf[U HWeagdUWe HWeWSdUZ ;WhWâb_W‘f 8YW‘Uk%) ,442) E]T >LYVL 8T^SP]TP^ JPL] 4ZZV& IaU[a(WUa‘a_[U S‘V DSd]Wf[‘Y S‘V HWeWSdUZ ;[h[e[a‘’ ESf[a‘S^ 8cgSf[U HWeagdUWe HWeWSdUZ ;WhWâb_W‘f 8YW‘Uk’:aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S)

ESf[a‘S^ IfSf[ef[US^ :W‘fdW ,444) FSP :Z‘^PSZWO^ ZQ >LZ B6D0 EZNTLW LYO 7NZYZXTN ;YOTNL_Z]^$ >LZ 7c[PYOT_‘]P LYO5ZY^‘X[_TZY E‘]aPd )//-’/.) L[W‘f[S‘W’ IfSfW G^S‘‘[‘Y :a__[ffWW)

ESf[a‘S^ IfSf[ef[US^ :W‘fdW -+++) 4L^TN E_L_T^_TN^ ZQ _SP >LZ B6D )/-, *(((& L[W‘f[S‘W’ IfSfW G^S‘‘[‘Y :a__[ffWW5,1-)

EYgkW‘(BZaS’ I)6 CadW‘lW‘’ B)6 >SdSiSk’ :)A)6 :ZS_e[‘YZ’ 9) -++.) ;X[LN_^ ZQ ;]]TRL_TZY 6PaPWZ[XPY_ ZY 5L[_‘]P8^SP]TP^ TY DTNP%ML^PO 8L]XTYR Ed^_PX^ ZQ EZ‘_SP]Y >LZ^& IWUa‘V @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ Ik_bae[g_ a‘ fZW DS‘SYW_W‘faX CSdYW H[hWde Xad =[eZWd[We’ GZ‘a_ GW‘Z’ B[‘YVa_ aX :S_TaV[S’ ,,(,/ =WTdgSdk -++.))

EYgkW‘(BZaS I)6 I_[fZ’ C)<);) -++/) @dd[YSf[a‘ S‘V =[eZWd[We5 @ddWUa‘U[^ST^W :a‘X^[Ufe ad GafW‘f[S^ Ik‘WdY[We7 ;]]TRL_TZYLYO 6]LTYLRP 0.5 /,0 /-2

EYgkW‘(BZaS’ I)6 I_[fZ’ C)<);)6 CadW‘lW‘’ B) $-++0%) 3OL[_TaP$ BL]_TNT[L_Z]d LYO ;Y_PR]L_PO 3^^P^^XPY_ ZQ _SP;X[LN_^ ZQ ;]]TRL_TZY ZY 8T^SP]TP^& 7aLW‘L_TZY ZQ _SP 3[[]ZLNS TY E]T >LYVL& @MD@ Mad][‘Y GSbWd 34) :aâ_Ta’Id[ CS‘]S5 @MD@*:8MD8*@_bWd[S^ :a^^WYW Ca‘Va‘)

EYgkW‘(BZaS’ I)6 I_[fZ’ C)<);)6 CadW‘lW‘’ B)6 9gdfa‘’ D6 >SdSiSk’ :)A) -++-) ?LYLRPXPY_ ZQ T]]TRL_TZYOPaPWZ[XPY_ TX[LN_^ ZY QT^SP]TP^0 E]T >LYVL NL^P ^_‘Od) =[‘S^ JWUZ‘[US^ HWbadf’ ;=@; Gda\WUf H224.’ Ca‘Va‘5@_bWd[S^ :a^^WYW Ca‘Va‘)

GWf’ A)I)6 >WhWde’ >)A)D)6 ;W‘eW‘’ M)C)J)6 L[\hWdTWdY’ A) ,441) DS‘SYW_W‘f abf[a‘e Xad S _adW Ua_b^WfW gf[^[eSf[a‘aX fZW T[aâY[US^ bdaVgUf[a‘ [‘ Id[ CS‘]S‘ dWeWdha[de) 7NZWZRd ZQ 8]P^SbL_P] 8T^S$ 05 , ,/)

GWfd’ J) ,443) =[eZWd[We [‘ dWeWdha[de [‘ fZW Sd[V S‘V eW_[(Sd[V la‘We aX 8e[S) ;Y_P]YL_TZYLW DPaTPb ZQ :dO]ZMTZWZRd3. $IbWU[S^ @eegW%5 04, 043)

HS‘VS^^ @dWea‘’ M) ,440) JZW IaU[Wfk S‘V [fe <‘h[da‘_W‘f) @‘ >LZ^0 3 5Z‘Y_]d E_‘Od) <V)’ 8)D)IShSVS)MSeZ[‘Yfa‘;):)’ =WVWdS^ HWeWSdUZ ;[h[e[a‘’ C[TdSdk aX :a‘YdWee)

HW‘i[U]’ D) <) -++,) HLW‘TYR IL_P] TY ;]]TRL_PO 3R]TN‘W_‘]P LYO DP^P]aZT] 8T^SP]TP^0 3 ?‘W_T[WP%G^P ;]]TRL_TZY Ed^_PXTY E]T >LYVL& :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ MSfWd DS‘SYW_W‘f @‘ef[fgfW $@MD@%))

IW‘S‘SkS]W’ I)D)G)6 M[\Wfg‘YS’ C);)A) ,432) 3 ^_‘Od ZY _SP PX[WZdXPY_ RPYP]L_TZY TY =T]TYOT AdL T]]TRL_TZY LYO^P__WPXPY_ L]PL& 8HJ@ HWeWSdUZ IfgVk Ea)24 :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 8YdSd[S‘ HWeWSdUZ JdS[‘[‘Y @‘ef[fgfW $8HJ@%)

I_[fZ C<);)6 EYgkW‘(BZaS’ I)6 >SdSiSk :)A)6 CadW‘lW‘ B) -++,) FSP ;X[LN_ ZQ FPNSYTNLW 5SLYRP ZY D‘]LW>TaPWTSZZO^ TY L EPXT%E‘M^T^_PYNP 7NZYZXd0 ;]]TRL_TZY 6PaPWZ[XPY_^ LYO 3\‘L_TN DP^Z‘]NP G^P TY >LZ^& 2/fZIW_[‘Sd aX fZW <gdabWS‘ 8eeaU[Sf[a‘ aX 8Yd[Ug^fgdS^ <Ua‘a_[efe’ C[hW^[ZaaVe S‘V HgdS^ GahWdfk5 JWUZ‘aâYk’Ga^[Uk S‘V @‘ef[fgf[a‘e’ ,- ,0 IWbfW_TWd’ Ca‘Va‘5 @_bWd[S^ :a^^WYW Ca‘Va‘

I_[fZ C)<);)6 EYgkW‘(BZaS’ I)6 CadW‘lW‘ C) $-++0%) C[hW^[ZaaV =g‘Uf[a‘e aX @‘^S‘V =[eZWd[We5 Ga^[Uk @_b^[USf[a‘e [‘;WhWâb[‘Y :ag‘fd[We’ IL_P] BZWTNd’ 2’ /)

Ig^fS‘S’ F)6 JZa_bea‘’ G)D) ,442) <XXWUfe aX XâaV Ua‘fda^ S‘V VdS[‘SYW a‘ X[eZWd[We [‘ 9S‘Y^SVWeZ S‘V fZW VWe[Y‘aX _[f[YSf[a‘ _WSegdWe& DPR‘WL_PO DTaP]^0 DP^PL]NS LYO ?LYLRPXPY_ ,.5 /. 00)

.1

JgVSiW’ @) ,431) 6TP_L]d TY_LVP LYO Y‘_]T_TZY ^_L_‘^ ^‘]aPd& 8HJ@ HWeWSdUZ IfgVk Ea) 2+) :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S58YdSd[S‘ HWeWSdUZ JdS[‘[‘Y @‘ef[fgfW $8HJ@%)

KE;G*@CF $K‘[fWV ESf[a‘e ;WhWâb_W‘f GdaYdS_* @‘fWd‘Sf[a‘S^ CSTad FdYS‘[lSf[a‘% ,444) 3NNP^^ _Z 4L^TN @PPO^LYO EP]aTNP^ TY ELaLYYLVSP_ B]ZaTYNP0 B]ZaTYNTLW E‘XXL]d& IShS‘‘S]ZWf’ KE;G*@CF @‘fWYdSfWV HgdS^8UUWee[T[^[fk G^S‘‘[‘Y5 /2)

MS‘Se[‘YZW’ 8)6 Ig_S‘SeW]WdS’ ?);)6 M[\Wfg‘YS’ ;)D)8) ,43.) =T]TYOT AdL ;]]TRL_TZY LYO EP__WPXPY_ B]ZUPN_0 B]P%[]ZUPN_ ^ZNTZPNZYZXTN NZYOT_TZY^& 8HJ@ HWeWSdUZ IfgVk Ea) 04) :aâ_Ta’ Id[ CS‘]S5 8YdSd[S‘ HWeWSdUZJdS[‘[‘Y @‘ef[fgfW)$8HJ@% )

MWÛa__W H)C) ,421) Ia_W YW‘WdS^ S‘V fZWadWf[US^ Ua‘e[VWdSf[a‘e a‘ fZW X[eZ k[W^V aX 8Xd[US‘ d[hWde) Aagd‘S^ aX=[eZWd[We 9[aâYk)’ 35.0, .1/

MWÛa__W’ H)C) ,430) DTaP] 8T^SP]TP^) =8F =[eZWd[We JWUZ‘[US^ GSbWd -1-) Ha_W5 =aaV S‘V 8Yd[Ug^fgdWFdYS‘[lSf[a‘ $=8F%)

MW^[YS_SYW’ G) -++,) ;]]TRL_TZY LYO ;YWLYO 8T^SP]TP^ TY E]T >LYVL0 ?‘_‘LWWd 5ZPcT^_TYR Ed^_PX^ QZ] 8ZZO LYO>TaPWTSZZO A[_TZY^ QZ] >ZNLW BPZ[WP& 3fZ Id[ CS‘]S IfgV[We :a‘XWdW‘UW’ 2 ,+ EahW_TWd -++,’ AS[bgd’ @‘V[S)

MaaV’ :) ,440) 7YaT]ZYXPY_LW ;X[LN_ 3^^P^^XPY_0 3 5ZX[L]L_TaP DPaTPb) ?Sdâi’ KB5 Ca‘Y_S‘’

Mad^V 9S‘] -++.S) >LZ B6D 5Z‘Y_]d 4]TPQ) HWY[a‘e S‘V :ag‘fd[We’ <Sef 8e[S S‘V GSU[X[U) MSeZ[‘Yfa‘’ ;):)5JZWMad^V 9S‘])

Mad^V 9S‘] -++.T) IZ]WO 6PaPWZ[XPY_ ;YOTNL_Z]^ *((+) MSeZ[‘Yfa‘ ;):)5 JZW Mad^V 9S‘])

M:; $Mad^V :a__[ee[a‘ a‘ ;S_e%) -+++& 6LX^ LYO 6PaPWZ[XPY_0 3 @Pb 8]LXPbZ]V QZ] 6PNT^TZY ?LVTYR) JZWHWbadf aX fZW Mad^V :a__[ee[a‘ a‘ ;S_e) Ca‘Va‘ S‘V IfWd^[‘Y5 <SdfZeUS‘ GgT^[USf[a‘ CfV)

!$)$"(#% !$’&(*)

$# 3KQCEO?QCB 4?KB ?KB =?QCO 5?K?ECJCKQ DLO 1LLB ?KB 0KSGOLKJCKQ?I 9CAROGQU#3%C%@% =KTTOTM JK BXOKY# 5% .IW[G_# 1% :URJKT# ?%7% ?INKXX# 0% BGRKTZOT GTJ<% 0ULOK% (’’)%

%# :?HGKE GKQL ,AALRKQ 0KSGOLKJCKQ?I =?QCO 8CNRGOCJCKQP GK 2IL@?I"PA?IC =?QCO8CPLROACP ,PPCPPJCKQP# BRGJOSOX ?SGQNZOT# 0GXSKT >K\KTMG GTJ =KZXG 1bRR%(’’*%

&# =?QCO 5?K?ECJCKQ GK QFC >CIILT 8GSCO -?PGK* -?AHEOLRKB! .ROOCKQ .OGQGA?I 3PPRCP?KB 1RQROC 8CPC?OAF 6CCBP# :GXQ 4OUXJGTU# FNUTMVOTM FN[# DOSOTM 0GO# ?NGTMWO5UTM# D[KINKTM FNGTM GTJ E[TVKTM D[K% (’’*%

’# /LCP 3KQCOK?QGLK?I .COC?I :O?BC 9?SC =?QCO+ :FC 3JM?AQ LD <GOQR?I =?QCO :O?BCLK 2IL@?I =?QCO ;PC# 0NGXRUZZK JK 3XGOZ[XK# 1G\OJ :URJKT# :GXQ >UYKMXGTZ#DOSOTM 0GO GTJ AVGRO .SGXGYOTMNK% (’’*%

(# 0SLIRQGLK LD 3OOGE?QGLK GK 9LRQF ?KB 9LRQFC?PQ ,PG?# >GTJURVN /GXQKX GTJ 3XGTaUOY:URRK% (’’*%

)# 5?AOL 7LIGAGCP ?KB 3KSCPQJCKQ 7OGLOGQGCP DLO 3OOGE?QCB ,EOGARIQROC GK <GCQK?J#>GTJURVN /GXQKX# 0RG[JOG >OTMRKX# ;M[_KT :OTN @OKT GTJ :GXQ >UYKMXGTZ% (’’*%

,% 3JM?AQP LD 3OOGE?QGLK LK 3KI?KB 1GPFCOGCP* ,MMO?GP?IP GK 4?LP ?KB 9OG 4?KH?# ?UVNOK;M[_KT$8NUG# 9G[XKTIK ?SOZN GTJ 8GO 9UXKT‘KT% (’’+%

ISSN 1391-9407ISBN 92-9090-591-3

Postal Address: IWMI, P O Box 2075, Colombo, Sri Lanka Location: 127 Sunil Mawatha, Pelawatte, Battaramulla, Sri LankaTelephone: +94-11 2787404, 2784080 Fax: +94-11 2786854

Email: [email protected] Website: www.iwmi.org/assessment

Impacts of Irrigation on Inland Fisheries:Appraisals in Laos and Sri Lanka

Sophie Nguyen-Khoa, Laurence Smith and Kai Lorenzen

Research Report 7

I n t e r n a t i o n a lWater ManagementI n s t i t u t e

Documents

Research Report - International Water Management Institute · Research Report 7 nter aio l Water Management Institute. ... are minimized, while fishponds within the command area could