Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
REPORT
COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY
2018 – 2022
FOR
SHIRE OF COLLIE
DATE: November 2018
REFERENCE: Q23062017-004_I
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 2
DOCUMENT CONTROL RECORD
Prepared By: Murali Mahendran & Mark Jumeaux
Approved By: Glen Flood
Position: Associate Team Members Position: Managing Director
Signed:
Murali & Mark Signed:
Date: 8 Nov 2018 Date: 8 Nov 2018
REVISION STATUS
Revision No. Description of Revision Date Approved
A Draft Report 14 November 2017
B Draft Report 19 November 2017
C Draft Report 30 November 2017
D Draft Report 3 December 2017
E Draft Report 20 March 2018
F Draft Report 12 April 2018
G Draft Report
H Draft Report 4 October 2018
I Final Report 8 November 2018
Recipients are responsible for eliminating all superseded documents in their possession.
DISCLAIMER
This document is published in accordance with and subject to an agreement between Glen Flood Group
Pty Ltd (trading as GFG Consulting) and the Shire of Collie (Client). It is confined to the issues that have
been raised by the Client in the Client’s engagement of GFG Consulting and is prepared using the
standard of skill and due care ordinarily exercised by management and business consultants in preparing
such documents.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 3
Any person or organisation that relies on or uses the document for reasons or purposes other than those
agreed by GFG Consulting and the Client without first obtaining the prior written approval of GFG
Consulting, does so entirely at their own risk. To the extent permitted by law, GFG Consulting excludes
any liability, including any liability for negligence, for any loss, including indirect or consequential
damages arising from or in relation to any reliance on this document for any purpose other than that
agreed with the Client.
The final plan, appendices and mapping, including all data, analysis, information and images will become
the property of the Shire of Collie.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
GFG would like to thank the following people for their contributions, assistance and opinions during the course of the project.
Members of the Shire of Collie Weeds and Waterways Advisory Committee
Tom Wood (Public Member)
Neil Martin (Councillor)
Glyn Yates (Councillor)
Nola Green (Councillor and Public Member)
Dennis True (Public Member)
Ed Riley (Public Member)
James Khan (Ngalang Boodja Aboriginal Council)
Peter Piavanini (Public Member)
Brett King (Councillor)
Gary Faries (Councillor)
Jo Italiano (Councillor)
Troy Morton (Public Member) Shire of Collie
Andrew Dover
Tracey Vogel
Steve Cruickshank
Invited Guests
Donna Davies (Friends of Collie River Rotary Club Subcommittee) James Sheehan (Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development) Colm Harkin (Premier Coal Mining Co Ltd) Paul Richardson (Griffin Coal Mining Co Ltd) Andrew Colley (Leschenault Catchment Council)
GFG would also like to thank the following people, business, and organisations:
Department of Water and Environmental Regulation
Andrew Creswell.
Brendon Kelley
Adam Maskew
Collie Water
Monique Warnock
Hon Michael (Mick) Murray MLA for the continued support on the Collie River Revitalisation Project.
The shire would like to thank the residents that provided input into the Plan.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 5
TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ....................................................................................................................................... 5
1 Executive Summary ...................................................................................................................................... 8
2 Recommendations Summary Table ........................................................................................................... 9
3 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................... 12
4 Purpose and Scope .................................................................................................................................... 13
5 Vision ............................................................................................................................................................. 14
6 Background .................................................................................................................................................. 15
6.1 Catchment Description ....................................................................................................................... 15
6.2 Geomorphic Setting ............................................................................................................................. 15
6.3 Climate .................................................................................................................................................. 15
6.4 Climate change .................................................................................................................................... 16
6.5 Aboriginal Heritage .............................................................................................................................. 16
6.6 Vegetation ............................................................................................................................................. 17
7 Existing Condition of the River .................................................................................................................. 19
7.1 Dredging ................................................................................................................................................ 19
7.2 Retention ............................................................................................................................................... 20
7.3 Salinity ................................................................................................................................................... 21
7.4 Nutrients ................................................................................................................................................ 22
7.5 Weeds ................................................................................................................................................... 23
7.6 Fauna .................................................................................................................................................... 25
7.6.1 Macroinvertebrates ......................................................................................................................... 25
7.6.2 Fish and Crayfish ............................................................................................................................ 26
7.7 Ground Water ....................................................................................................................................... 27
7.8 Pools ...................................................................................................................................................... 28
7.9 River Flow ............................................................................................................................................. 28
7.10 Collie Water Proposal ......................................................................................................................... 29
8 Implementation of recommendations from Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008 ............................. 30
8.1 Establishment of environmental flows .............................................................................................. 30
8.2 Sediment Control ................................................................................................................................. 30
8.3 Mechanical or chemical removal of Nardoo .................................................................................... 30
8.4 Seasonal management of river stop-boards ................................................................................... 30
8.5 Permanent removal of stop-boards and installation of riffles ........................................................ 31
8.6 Restoration of riparian vegetation ..................................................................................................... 31
8.7 Monitoring .............................................................................................................................................. 32
9 Current State and Management ................................................................................................................ 33
9.1 River Flow ............................................................................................................................................. 33
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 6
9.2 Water Quality ........................................................................................................................................ 34
9.3 Current Restoration of Riparian Vegetation .................................................................................... 34
9.4 Public access and erosion ................................................................................................................. 37
9.5 Drainage management ....................................................................................................................... 39
9.6 Review ................................................................................................................................................... 40
10 Recommendations ...................................................................................................................................... 41
10.1 Water Level Management .................................................................................................................. 41
10.1.1 Public Consultation ......................................................................................................................... 41
10.1.2 River gates....................................................................................................................................... 41
10.1.3 Construction of Riffles .................................................................................................................... 41
10.2 Restoration of Riparian Vegetation ................................................................................................... 42
10.3 Drainage management ....................................................................................................................... 42
10.4 Access and erosion management ..................................................................................................... 42
10.5 Community engagement and support .............................................................................................. 42
10.6 Community Education ......................................................................................................................... 42
10.7 Nutrient Management ......................................................................................................................... 43
10.8 Monitoring ............................................................................................................................................. 43
10.9 Advocate for the health of Collie River ............................................................................................. 44
11 Recreational and Tourism Opportunities ................................................................................................. 45
11.1 Paddle Trail........................................................................................................................................... 45
11.2 Cycle Trail ............................................................................................................................................. 45
11.3 Fishing ................................................................................................................................................... 46
12 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................................... 47
13 References ................................................................................................................................................... 48
14 Appendices ................................................................................................................................................... 50
TABLES
Table 1: Nutrient concentrations found at the various sample sites (from CENRM 2016). ................... 23
Table 2: Nutrient concentrations found at the various sample sites (from CENRM 2016) .................... 23
Table 3: Weeds commonly found in the study area, from SWCC 2017. ............................................... 25
Table 4: Representative macroinvertebrate taxa previously recorded from Reach 1a from (WRM 2009). ............................................................................................................................................................ 25
Table 5: Monitoring regime recommended in CRRP 2008. .................................................................. 32
Table 6: Recommended monitoring regime ......................................................................................... 43
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 7
FIGURES
Figure 1: Map showing the location of the upper Collie River catchment. ............................................ 12
Figure 2: Layout of Study Area ........................................................................................................... 13
Figure 3: Annual rainfall at the Collie rainfall site (Bureau of Meteorology rainfall station 9628 from DWER 2018) ....................................................................................................................................... 16
Figure 4: River Bed Profile from SOC 2010b ....................................................................................... 19
Figure 5: Venn Street Stop Boards ...................................................................................................... 20
Figure 6: Roberts Rocks Stop Boards .................................................................................................. 20
Figure 7: Riffle near Soldiers Park ....................................................................................................... 21
Figure 8 Average annual salinity at Mungalup Tower from DWER 2018 .............................................. 22
Figure 9: Mine dewatering from Premier Coal entering the Collie River. .............................................. 29
Figure 10 Annual stream flow at Mungalup Tower on the Collie River ................................................. 33
Figure 11: Monthly average flow modelled at the Collie town site ........................................................ 34
Figure 12: Shire proposed rehabilitation stages ................................................................................... 36
Figure 13: Coral Vine Kennedia coccinea (Curtis) Vent ....................................................................... 36
Figure 14: Purple Enamel Orchid Caladenia brunonis and West Australian Kangaroo Paw Anigozanthos manglesii ....................................................................................................................... 37
Figure 15: Mungalup Bridge exposed bank .......................................................................................... 38
Figure 16: Mungalup Bridge exposed bank .......................................................................................... 38
Figure 17: ‘Sandy’ exposed bank ......................................................................................................... 39
Figure 18: ‘Sandy’ exposed bank ......................................................................................................... 39
Figure 19: Biofiltration basin ................................................................................................................ 40
APPENDICES
Appendix 1 Collie River Revitalisation Strategy Report On Public Information Session Meeting Held On 8 August 2018 for Shire of Collie. ........................................................................................................ 51
Appendix 2 Riparian Revegetation Suggestion .................................................................................... 52
Appendix 3 Further Information on Collie Water Project ...................................................................... 53
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 8
1 Executive Summary
The Collie River is a major river system flowing through the town of Collie in southwest of Western
Australia (Figure 1 and Figure 2). After a major flood event in 1963/64 an 8km stretch of the Collie River
which runs through the town, was dredged, deepened, widened and fringing vegetation removed. The
river has been impacted by a range of land-uses (CENRM 2008) and significantly modified over the past
120 years. The river has significant environmental and cultural value for the people of Collie.
The vision for the Collie River is to develop and implement strategies to improve the health and amenity
of the river including; enhancing community experience, reducing nutrient runoff, increasing biodiversity,
managing weed species and improving water quality. These strategies benefit not only the local
community but also those accessing water further downstream, whilst increasing public amenity to the
river.
The Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008 (CRRP 2008) was updated to reflect the changes impacting
the river and banks since the CRRP2008 and to create a shared vision for the river into the future at a
strategic level. This strategy focused on the changes impacting the river since the CRRP 2008 and any
anticipated changes over the next 5 years. The strategy included gathering and collation of information
from a wide variety of stakeholders, wide community consultation, and field investigations. This strategy
particularly focused on the stretch of retrained river within the town just below Lynn Street Bridge to
Roberts Rocks.
The Shire of Collie has been successfully managing Nardoo with the herbicide Reglone. Continuing this
program will be beneficial in long-term management of Nardoo. In addition, a rehabilitation strategy for
the study area is recommended to be established and implemented.
There are several areas within the Shire of Collie where vehicular access is causing erosion of the river
bank. It is recommended that the Shire identify and prioritise these areas and implement management
strategies to reduce the impact of vehicular access in these areas. It is also recommended that the Shire
establish a river monitoring program.
With the cessation of mine dewatering and decreasing rainfall, the river flow is likely to reduce. To ensure
existing pools are retained, it is recommended that the Shire consider interventions that assist in retaining
water and raising the river levels during dry periods.
A decline in water quality has been an issue in the Collie River study area. There is a lack of a structured
quality controlled (QA/QC) monitoring program in the study area. The Shire of Collie have built a
biofiltration basin system and network to improve water quality of the river.
In order to manage the water level, river gates will be constructed and used at Venn Street. Once the
river gates are installed it can be determined whether riffles are viable to be constructed. The cost of
construction, operation, and maintenance must be assessed and factored into the final design.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 9
2 Recommendations Summary Table
Item Section of the strategy
Area Category Action Timeline Achieve Vision
1 10.1.1 Engineering Options
Water Level Management
In order to manage the water level,
river gates will be constructed and
used at Venn Street. Once the river
gates are installed it can be
determined whether riffles are viable
to be constructed.
The cost of construction, operation, and maintenance of the chosen design must be factored into the project consideration.
Completed by 2019
Ongoing
Improve the health and amenity of the river
Ensure the
identified
sections of
the river
remain
aesthetically
appealing
which
recognises
and
promotes
the river as a
community
asset.
2 10.3 Nutrient Management
Drainage management
Undertake installation of
biofiltration basins in accordance
with the recommendation from
CENRM 2016.
Once these have been
constructed carry out another
review of nutrient and pollutant
levels from drains and prioritise
actions accordingly.
Completed by June 2020
Improve the health and amenity of the river
10.8 Monitoring
Monitor nitrogen, phosphorus, salinity, and Reglone spray at Lynn Street Bridge and Roberts Rocks boards (see monitoring table below).
Monitor water level in mAHD at the following locations:
o Just below Lynn Street bridge
o Venn St River Boards o Minningup Pool o Roberts Rocks
Monitoring program to be commenced by March 2019, then ongoing
Improve the health and amenity of the river
3 10.2 Restoration of Riparian Vegetation
Restoration of Riparian Vegetation
Continue Nardoo control with
Reglone Hydrogel. Renew clearing
permit from the DWER for Nardoo
control.
Develop and implement the Shire
rehabilitation strategy for the study
area.
Integrate the strategy into the
Shire five year works programme.
Annually within the first two weeks of autumn.
July 2019 depending on funding availability.
Ongoing
Improve the health and amenity of the river
Develop and
implement
the Shire
river
foreshore
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 10
Ensure that the section of the river
foreshore where weeds are
removed are replanted with native
seedlings and maintained
regularly.
Start once weed removal is completed then ongoing
rehabilitation
strategy.
4 10.5 Community engagement and education
Community engagement and support
Support Friends of Collie River group in the implementation of the strategy.
Regularly inform the community of the progress of the implementation of the CRRS. This can be achieved by using various communication mediums such as social media, print media, radio interviews, the Shire website and on-site signage.
Engage with the indigenous community on progress of the implementation of the CRRP.
Completed by June 2019
Ongoing, at least once a Quarter
Enhancing
community
experience
Recognise
and
conserve
the
Aboriginal
cultural
history
associated
with the
river.
10.6 Community Education
It is recommended that the Shire carry out a community education campaign to reduce community nutrient input into the river.
Start 2019 and ongoing on a 6 monthly basis
Improve the health and amenity of the river including; enhancing community experience
10.7 Consideration is required by the Shire to review and reduce fertiliser load into the river. It is recommended that the Shire also work with the Collie Golf Course and other large businesses to reduce nutrient input into the river.
Completed by July 2019
Improve the health and amenity of the river
5 10.4 Access and erosion management
Investigate access and erosion issues in the study area such as ‘Sandy’ and Mungalup Bridge.
Prioritise and manage issues accordingly.
Completed by July 2019
Improve the health and amenity of the river
6 10.9 Advocate for the health of Collie River
The Collie Shire to work with other Local Government Agencies, Industry, Government Agencies, and Community groups on river management issues.
It is recommended that the Shire also advocate to ensure that the values of the river are protected in any future developments.
Quarterly meetings, ongoing
Improve the health and amenity of the river
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 11
Monitoring Frequency
Parameter Methodology Frequency
River Flow Gauging Station installed by DWER Monthly
Water Quality:
Nitrogen and Phosphorus
Salinity
Grab sample
Send to chemical analysis laboratory (P&N)
Portable in situ salinity meter
Quarterly
Potential Impact of Reglone To be assessed, The Shire should carry this out in partnership with SWCC, DWER, or academic institutions currently studying impacts of herbicide monitoring.
To be assessed
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 12
3 Introduction The Collie River is a major river system flowing through the town of Collie in southwest of Western Australia (Figure 1 and Figure 2). After a major flood event in 1963/64 an 8km stretch of the Collie River which runs through the town, was retrained, deepened, widened and fringing vegetation removed. The river has been impacted by a range of land-uses (CENRM 2008) and significantly modified over the past 120 years. The river has significant environmental and cultural value for the people of Collie. The Shire of Collie (Shire) commissioned GFG Consulting (GFG) to update the Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008 to a strategic document.
Figure 1: Map showing the location of the upper Collie River catchment.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 13
4 Purpose and Scope
The purpose of the update of the Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008 (CRRP 2008) was to reflect the
changes impacting the river and banks and to create a shared vision for the river into the future. The
primary focus of CRRP 2008 was the establishment of environmental flows and management of nardoo.
This update focuses on the changes impacting the river since the CRRP 2008 and any anticipated
changes over the next 5 years. The update included gathering and collation of information from a wide
variety of stakeholders, wide community consultation, and field investigations. The update particularly
focuses on the stretch of dredged river within the town just above Lynn Street Bridge to Robert’s Rocks,
a distance of around 12 km, (referred to as the Study Area hereafter). The reference to the 8km stretch
of the river in the CRRP 2008 is from just above the Lynn Street bridge to South of the Collie Golf Club.
The vision and five year strategy was developed in conjunction with stakeholders including the Shire of
Collie, Weeds and Waterways Advisory Committee (WWAC), Department of Water and the community
of Collie. The development of this strategy consisted of literature review, field investigation, stakeholder
engagement as well as extensive public consultation.
Figure 2: Layout of Study Area
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 14
5 Vision The vision for the Collie River is to develop and implement strategies to improve the health and amenity
of the river including; enhancing community experience, reducing nutrient runoff, increasing biodiversity,
managing weed species and improving water quality. These strategies benefit not only the local
community but also those accessing water further downstream, whilst increasing public amenity to the
river.
Develop and implement the Shire river foreshore rehabilitation strategy.
Acknowledge and preserve the various recreational pursuits associated with the river (fishing,
canoeing etc).
Ensure the identified sections of the river remain aesthetically appealing which recognises and
promotes the river as a community asset.
Recognise and conserve the Aboriginal cultural history associated with the river.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 15
6 Background
6.1 Catchment Description
The Collie River, upstream from the Wellington Dam, is a Water Resource Recovery Catchment area
described in the Western Australian State Salinity Strategy and covers an area of 2827 square km’s
(Mauger et al. 2001b). Upper Collie surface water area is within the proclaimed Collie River Irrigation
District and includes the main stream of the Collie River, the Collie River south and east branches and
the Bingham and Harris rivers. The Collie and Harris rivers have been dammed to create the Wellington
and Harris reservoirs (DOW 2009).
The majority of the upper catchment is forested and in the 2002 National Land and Water Resources
Audit (NLWRA 2002 in Macgregor et al 2010) the catchment is described as in a ‘moderate’ condition
compared with other catchments in Australia (Macgregor et al. 2010).
Land clearing in the eastern and southern portion of the catchment has led to dry land salinity, this has
led to increased saline water flowing into streams. As a result, water quality in the Collie River and in the
Wellington Reservoir has deteriorated. The Collie River East Branch contributes the highest salt load to
the Wellington Reservoir. The Harris and Bingham rivers provide a valuable, seasonal input of fresh water
to the Collie River system. Land clearing also increased flows in comparison to fully forested catchments.
Higher flows have led to erosion of river channel and the sedimentation of river pools downstream. This
is particularly evident along the Collie River East Branch (DOW 2009).
The major mining activity in the catchment is the extraction of coal and power generation. The Collie Coal
Basin is a declared Groundwater Management Area and the groundwater from this basin discharges into
the Collie River and tributaries (Macgregor et al. 2010).
6.2 Geomorphic Setting The study area is located in the Collie Coal Basin which lies within the Darling Plateau, a physiographic
unit on the Yilgarn Block of Archean age, consisting of extensive dissected uplands. Geologically, the
Darling Plateau consists mainly of ancient crystalline and metamorphic rocks (Macgregor et al 2010).
The Collie Coal Basin has two distinct sub-areas, the Cardiff and the Premier, separated by the Stockton
Ridge formation (DOW 2009). The hydrogeology of the Collie Coal Basin is complex, with multiple
aquifers separated by shale and coal seams with numerous faults throughout (DOW 2009)
The Upper Collie Catchment can be described by considering the description of the Lowden Valleys
landform. The landform is made up of deeply incised valleys. The dominant geology is colluvium over
metasediments and granite rocks. The soils are friable red/brown loam earths, brown loamy earths, loamy
gravels, brown deep loamy duplexes, duplex sandy gravels and stony soils (DOW 2009).
6.3 Climate The climate of the Collie region is Mediterranean with hot dry summers and cool wet winters (Seddon
1972 in Macgregor et al 2010). Mean annual rainfall is approximately 836.41mm (BOM 2018). The
mean annual rainfall has fallen to 722.9mm for years between 2003 to 2017 (BOM 2018). Maximum
rainfall generally occurs between May and September.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 16
6.4 Climate change Streams in south west Western Australia have been experiencing declining rainfall and increasing
temperatures in the last four decades. The decline in rainfall has caused decrease surface water flow in
rivers and less recharge to groundwater systems. Research from across Australia has found that typically
a one per cent change in mean annual rainfall would result in a two to three per cent change in mean
annual runoff (DOW 2010).
Since the Upper Collie Water Allocation Plan 2009 was released, annual average rainfall has decreased
by four per cent compared to the 1975 to 2008 average (Figure 3). Using the Department of Water
Environment and Regulation (DWER) climate guidelines it is expected to decline a further three per cent
compared to the 2009 to 2017 average by 2030 (DWER 2018).
Over the past 10 years, the majority of surface water sub catchment areas in the upper Collie region
experienced changes in stream flow much greater than the changes in rainfall resulting in flows much
less than the long term average. Climate modelling carried out by DWER show that declining rainfall and
subsequently lower stream flow, will continue into the future (DWER 2018).
Figure 3: Annual rainfall at the Collie rainfall site (Bureau of Meteorology rainfall station 9628 from DWER 2018)
6.5 Aboriginal Heritage The rivers and wetlands of the south west, their surrounding landscapes and story lines are significant to
the cultural and spiritual beliefs of Aboriginal people. The Collie River is a registered Aboriginal Heritage
site (DOW 2009). Aboriginal people believe that the Collie River, the surrounding creeks and waterholes
were formed by the Ngarngungudditj Walgu which now rests at Minninup Pool (DOW 2008).
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 17
6.6 Vegetation The Darling Plateau is vegetated by an array of vegetation complexes with Jarrah (Eucalyptus marginata)
as the dominant species. Collectively known as the Northern Jarrah Forest, these complexes cover an
area extending from Perth to Collie and bounded by the coastal plain to the west and by the wheatbelt to
the east.
The lateritic soils of the Collie River catchment region of the Darling Range overlay granitic bed-rock and
support a dry sclerophyll forest which is dominated by Jarrah (Eucalyptus marginata), with Marri
(Corymbia calophylla) in some valleys (Shea et al. 1975). This over-storey can also be composed of
eucalyptus species such as Blackbutt (E. patens), Bullich (E. megacarpa) and Flooded-Gum (E. rudis)
(Bell and Heddle 1989). Some woodland areas are severely affected by Jarrah dieback (Phytophthora
sp.). Blackbutt and flooded gum are common along less degraded watercourses (Macgregor et al 2010).
The Interim Biogeographic Regionalisation for Australia (Thackway & Cresswell 1995) categorised the
Australian continent into 85 regions of similar geology, landforms, vegetation, fauna and climate. The
study area occurs in the Jarrah Forest IBRA region. This bioregion is described as "duricrusted plateau
of the Yilgarn Craton characterised by Jarrah-Marri forest on laterite gravels and, in the eastern part,
Marri-Wandoo woodlands clayey soils. Eluvial and alluvial deposits support Agonis shrublands. In areas
of Mesozoic sediments, Jarrah forests occur in a mosaic with a variety of species-rich shrublands.
Heddle et al. (1980) used landform - soil units mapped by Churchward and McArthur (1980) to define
and map vegetation complexes for the Collie Basin at a scale of 1:250,000. Three vegetation complexes,
Collie, Cardiff and Muja, were defined for the Collie Basin in which the study area is located (Heddle et
al. 1980).
The vegetation of the Collie Basin reflects the underlying geology, landforms and soils. The Collie
Complex consists of an open forest of Jarrah-Marri-Sheoak with a range of understorey species that
reflect the relative proportion of sand and gravel in the soils. Those species commonly associated with
gravely soils include Banksia grandis, Persoonia longifolia, Hibbertia hypericoides, Leucopogon
capitellatus, Bossiaea ornata, Acacia browniana, Hakea lissocarpha and Astroloma pallidum. On sandier
soils common plant species include Xylomelum occidentale, Daviesia incrassata, Bossiaea eriocarpa,
Lyginia barbata, Dasypogon bromeliifolius and species of Calytrix.
The understorey plants in the past have been described as being dominated by white-myrtle (Hypocalym
maangustifolium), Trymalium ledifolium and Astartea fascicularis. However, very little of this understorey
remains and the riparian understorey was characterised by dense sclerophyllous shrubs (e.g. Agonis
linearfolia, Hypocalymma angustfolium, Calytrix glutinosa and Hakea costata) and sedges. Wetland and
riparian vegetation on the Coastal Plain typically includes flooded-gum (Eucalyptus rudis), Melaleuca
preissiana and M. Rhaphiophylla over heath (e.g. Astartea fasicularis, Pericalymma ellipticum var.
ellipticum, Regelia ciliata, Hypocalymma angustifolium) and sedge lands (Macgregor et al 2010).
Vegetation growing in or in association with the river is referred to as riparian vegetation. Riparian
vegetation is protected under the Environmental Protection Act 1986. Therefore, to clear vegetation in
the study area a Clearing Permit under Part V of the Environmental Protection Act 1986 is required.
Flora and fauna surrounding the study has been largely disturbed by mining, farming and timbering
activities over the past century. Extensive, natural vegetation is confined to State forests, specifically the
Northern Jarrah Forest in the Collie region (Western Collieries 1991).
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 18
The Collie Basin has been an active coal-mining centre since 1898 and is still the only commercial coal-
field in Western Australia. The area has been aggressively explored for the past 25 years (Western
Collieries 1991).
The region supported a variety of land-uses, other than the dominant coal-mining component, including
agriculture, hardwood milling, pine plantations, wildflower harvesting seed collection, water catchments,
apiculture, recreation, conservation holdings, power production, tourism, quarrying, light industry and
townships (Western Collieries 1991).
The vegetation in the study area is riparian vegetation. Vegetation growing in or in association with the
river is referred to as riparian vegetation. Riparian vegetation is protected under the Environmental
Protection Act 1986. Therefore, to clear vegetation in the study area a Clearing Permit under Part V of
the Environmental Protection Act 1986 is required.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 19
7 Existing Condition of the River
7.1 Dredging Due to flooding in the 1960s, the river has been dredged through the town site, removing the historical
series of pools and replacing them with a steep-sided channel between 15m and 40m wide with a
relatively flat base. This section of the river has been significantly modified.
The Centre of Excellence in Natural Resources Management of the University of Western Australia
carried out a survey for the Shire of the river water height and river bed spot heights from Venn Street
river stops through to the Ewington Weir, a distance of about 4,200m (SOC 2010b).
The surveyed river bed level is stated below and presented in figure 4.
Venn St boards to East End Bridge (0-1090m) The Venn St boards is at 173.8m AHD. The first section from 0 to about 450m upstream has a steep eastern bank and the river bed about 173.4 to 173.6m AHD which then slopes gently up to the western bank.
East End Bridge to Energy West (1090-1750m) This area consists of a sandy river bed level of about 173.7m AHD.
Soldiers Park (Energy West to Coombe St Bridge) (1750-2140m) The river bed levels in the channel were 173.5 to 173.7m AHD.
Commbes St Bridge to upstream of the Swinging Bridge (2140-2720m) The river bed levels were at 172.9m AHD.
Upstream of Swinging Bridge to Robb St (2720-3380m) This section is characterised by a sandy bottom and the river bed is about 2850m upstream to 3060m.
Robb St to Ewington Weir (3380-4300m) This section of river predominantly has a rocky bottom, and river bed is generally 10-15m wide up to 25-30m wide in some small sections with 172.9m AHD.
Figure 4: River Bed Profile from SOC 2010b
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 20
7.2 Retention Boards (or stops) have been constructed at Venn St Weir (figure 5) raising water levels about 2.2m above
the river bed, creating a 4.3 km upstream backwater with water covering the channel to each steep sided
bank. Venn St Weir was in a dilapidated condition and no longer has the structural integrity to be used at
full capacity. Similarly, boards have been constructed at Roberts Rocks Weir raising water levels by about
0.8m and backing water up to the Venn St Weir. These boards seem to replicate a natural pool at Roberts
Rocks (figure 6).
Figure 5: Venn Street Stop Boards
Figure 6: Roberts Rocks Stop Boards
It is likely that the boards have contributed to the maintenance of water level in especially Minninup Pool
which has enhanced the amenity of the site and improved popularity of the site for recreation purposes.
The boards seemed to have protected the upstream pools and habitats with increased retention of water.
In times of high water velocity, the increased water depths of the upstream areas caused by the river
boards have reduced velocities which would have contributed to reduced erosion.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 21
In addition to the boards, riffles have been placed in the river in accordance with the recommendations
of the CRRP 2008 (figure 7). There is a constructed riffle around 200 meters downstream of the Lynn
Street Bridge. The Shire constructed a second riffle in the river in 2013 between Solders Park and the
Synergy Building in Lefroy Street. It is recommended that the performance of the riffles be monitored and
assessed before considering additional riffles.
Figure 7: Riffle near Soldiers Park
7.3 Salinity Salinity of the steam flow from the Collie Catchment began to increase before 1960 due to clearing of native forest for pasture development (Loh 1985 in Mauger et al 2001a). Deep-rooted native vegetation were replaced with shallow-rooted annual crops and pastures on deeply weathered soil profiles of Archaean origin, which contain high concentrations of salt and relatively low rainfall. This replacement vegetation has a lower capacity for transpiration, it therefore uses less groundwater. In addition, the shallow-rooted vegetation does not have roots deep enough to maintain a deep “dry” soil profile compared to the previous native vegetation. This results in the recharge from rain exceeding the rate of losses and the groundwater level rises. Which brings previously dissolved salts. This can cause salt scalds where the saline groundwater approaches the soil surface in severe cases. In other cases the saline drainage of the area and the salinity of the streams increases (DOW 2009).
The Government of Western Australia (WA government) legislated to control the release of Crown land,
in 1961, and in 1976. The WA government legislated to control the clearing of native forest (Country
Areas Water Supply Act, 1947, Part 11A). However, by this stage the clearing was already causing the
stream salinity of the Collie River just upstream of the Wellington Reservoir to increase by 42 mg/L/yr
(Scofield et al 1988 in Maugeret al 2001b). It was estimated that if no further action was taken, the stream
salinity would raise to a flow-weighted mean value of 1500 mg/L, resulting in 1150 mg/L in the reservoir
(Loh1985 in Mauger et al 2001b).
With Wellington Reservoir becoming excessively saline the Harris Dam was built to replace it as the
source for the Great Southern Town Water Supply scheme. An environmental commitment made as a
condition of approval to build Harris Dam, was that the water supplied from Wellington Reservoir would
be suitable for domestic purposes (EPA, 1987). Another condition made was for the release of sufficient
water to meet environmental water provisions (EPA, 1987).
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 22
Salinity has continued to increase at Mungalup Tower monitoring station on the Collie River since 2009.
The highest recorded average annual salinity concentrations coinciding with the low flow years (figure 8).
Compared to the 1975 to 2008 period, average annual salinity from 2009 to 2017 has increased by 20
per cent, to 1549 mg/L (DWER 2018).
Historic land clearing in the southern and eastern portions of the Collie catchment has caused dry land
salinity. It has also led to the reduction in stream flow especially in tributaries like the Bingham River that
contribute fresh water to the Collie River, which are the main causes of increased salinity. East branch
of the Collie River has the highest salinity levels, reaching 16 000 mg/L during the first flush winter flows.
The east branch contributes around 70 per cent of the salt in Wellington Dam (DWER 2018).
Figure 8 Average annual salinity at Mungalup Tower from DWER 2018
7.4 Nutrients Nutrient levels have been measured below and above the town site by Dr Peter Cook, UWA (CENRM
2016). The measurements taken downstream below the town site had significantly higher levels of
Nitrogen when compared with the measurements taken above the town site (tables 1&2) (CENRM 2016).
This suggests that these pollutants entering the river originate in the town site.
Nutrient concentrations were assessed at the following locations:
Johnson Street Drain - upstream (samples 1 and 2) and downstream (samples 3 and 4) from
the township.
The Energy West Drain (samples 5 and 6),
A drain immediately below the Bowling Club (samples 7 and 8)
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 23
Table 1: Nutrient concentrations found at the various sample sites (from CENRM 2016).
Sample Location Mean Total Nitrogen Mg/L Mean Nitrate levels Mg/L
Johnson Street Drain – upstream of township
1.80 0.12
Johnson Street Drain – downstream of township
0.87 0.23
Energy West Drain 1.18 0.79
Drain below Bowling Club 2.12 1.77
At all sites, total phosphate levels were low and relatively constant (mean 0.344 mg per litre). Free
reactive phosphate levels were also low and, in some cases, were below detectable levels (mean 0.007
mg per litre).
For nitrogen however, there was some considerable variation in levels between sites.
Table 2: Nutrient concentrations found at the various sample sites (from CENRM 2016)
Sample Location TP (mg/L) TN (mg/L) FRP (mg/L) NOx-N (mg/L)
1 0.382 2.794 0.008 0.113
2 0.335 0.797 0.012 0.116
3 0.335 0.838 nd 0.223
4 0.331 0.898 0.005 0.246
5 0.342 1.219 nd 0.809
6 0.343 1.148 nd 0.777
7 0.346 2.373 0.006 1.978
8 0.335 1.874 nd 1.556
Nitrogen is a contributing factor to the dense aquatic weed growth found in the river (SOC 2010a). An
evaluation has been made of these sites, with priorities being developed for the installation of nutrient
stripping basins and sculptured drains to capture nutrients before it reaches the river ecosystem (CENRM
2016).
The Shire has built a number of biofiltration basins and is implementing other strategies to reduce/remove
these nutrients. One of these biofiltration basin is located between Soldiers Park and the Synergy Building
in Lefroy Street in 2017. Work is being continued to progress the biofiltration basin to full operational
capacity. There is also a network of biofiltration basins built between 2012 and 2017 around Forrest
Street. The biofiltration network is regularly maintained. It is recommended that the Biofiltration basins be
monitored to assess their performance.
Biofiltration systems have been found to out perform conventional piped stormwater systems with respect
to water quality improvements (suspended solids, total nitrogen and phosphorus) due to flow reduction
and filtration of the flow into the underlying soils (DOE 2006).
7.5 Weeds The reshaped banks within the town site (formed at the same time as the dredging) have been colonised
by weeds. There is also some native regrowth along these banks. Some of the weeds have been cleared
in areas and replaced with native species.
Other weeds found in the study area included in Table 3.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 24
The river channel has been colonised by Nardoo (Marsilea mutica), a native plant which acts as a weed
in this location. Nardoo forms in shallow, warm, slow moving, nutrient rich environments and has been
thriving in the Collie River. The Nardoo is gradually slowing the flow of the main channel and colonising
it until the entire river is congested. This prevents recreation activities, is considered unattractive and is
a symptom of the health of the river. Nardoo has been reduced through a successful Shire spraying
program.
Previously the Shire has trialled various mechanical methods to reduce the nardoo in the river. These
include, manual control methods such as grappling hooks, floating weed harvesters, adjusting water
levels, covering the area with plastic, and removal by hand. The methods outlined above had limited
success or were not practically viable considering the large cover of Nardoo in the river (Observations
from the Shire of Collie Parks and Gardens Department).
The chemical spraying of the nardoo with Reglone Hydrogel has proven to be the most successful method
of controlling Nardoo. The Shire was able to control large areas of weed infested areas in a relatively
short period of time. As Nardoo is an aquatic weed the application of the Reglone, Hydrogel and aquatic
dye to the full extent of the infestation was very difficult. A combination of boat mounted spray tanks,
wading applicators and bank based spraying is used to apply the chemical (Observations from the Shire
of Collie Parks and Gardens Department).
From visual observation of the Shire staff it is estimated that there has been a 70% reduction in areas of
Nardoo infestation in the study area. Annual weed control spraying is carried out to ensure that outbreaks
of nardoo do not establish to a level prior to the commencement of the chemical control program. The
follow up applications are targeted at controlling small difficult to access locations with remaining Nardoo
and regrowth (Observations from the Shire of Collie Parks and Gardens Department).
Other steps undertaken to limit the regrowth of Nardoo are:
Building riffles to oxygenate the water
Controlling nutrients placed on Shire land
Educating the community to limit nutrients on private land
Planting trees to shade the river (depriving the weeds of sunlight)
Increasing the depth of water in the river using Venn Street Boards
Constructing and planting nutrient stripping basins at inlet points
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 25
Table 3: Weeds commonly found in the study area, from SWCC 2017.
Scientific Name Common Name Common Name
Acacia longifolia Sydney golden wattle
Avena fatua Wild oat
Cytisus proliferus Tagasaste
Cynodon dactylon Green couch
Eragrostuscurvula African love grass
Gomphocarpus fruticosus Cottonbush
Hypochaeris radicata Flatweed
Lathyrus tingitanus Tandier pea
Paspallum sp. Paspallum
Pennisetum clandestinum Kikuyu
Rubus anglocandicans Blackberry
Typha orientalis Bulrush
Watsonia meriana Watsonia
Cortaderia selloana Pampas Grass
7.6 Fauna
7.6.1 Macroinvertebrates
Aquatic macroinvertebrates are small animals that live for all or part of their lives in water. There are
many types of macroinvertebrates such as dragonfly larvae, mosquito larvae, and aquatic beetles. Some
of these animals are sensitive to pollution, whereas others can live in very polluted waters. Due to the
variability in sensitivity to pollution, macroinvertebrates make good biological indicators. Sampling
macroinvertebrates communities for the types and numbers of animals present can indicate the health of
a river.
Representative macroinvertebrates previously recorded in the study area is presented in table 4. Reach
1a, Harris River below the Harris Dam from (WRM 2009) was used as the fauna representative node for
the study area.
Table 4 represents a typical distribution of macro invertebrate fauna that could be found in the study site. This list should be updated with site specific surveys conducted in the future.
Table 4: Representative macroinvertebrate taxa previously recorded from Reach 1a from (WRM 2009).
Macroinvertebrate Number
MOLLUSCA
Gastropoda (Glacidorbis, Ferrisia, Glyptophysa) 1
Bivalvia (Westralunio) 1
CRUSTACEA
Ostracoda (brine-shrimps) >2
Copepoda (shield shrimp) >2
Isopoda (phreatoicids) 1
Amphipoda (Perthia, Austrochiltonia) 2
Decapoda (Cherax, Palaemonetes) 1
INSECTA
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 26
Ephemeroptera (mayflies)
Leptophlebiidae (Nyungara, Bibulmena, Neboissophlebia) 3
Baetidae (Baetis, Cloeon) 2
Caenidae (Tasmanocoenis) 1
Odonata (dragonflies & damselflies)
Zygoptera (Austroagrion, Austrolestes, Ischnura) 3
Anisoptera (Hesperocordulia, Lathrocordulia, Synthemis) 8
Plecoptera (stoneflies)
Griptopterygidae (Leptoperla, Newmanoperla, Riekoperla) 3
Coleoptera (aquatic beetles)
Dytiscidae (Sternopriscus) 1
Hydrophilidae (Paracymus, Berosus, Enochrus) 1
Gyrinidae (Macrogyrus, Aulonogyrus) 1
Diptera (two-winged flies)
Chironomidae (non-biting midges) 32
Simulidae (black-flies) 2
Tipulidae (crane flies) 1
Empididae (dance flies) 1
Trichoptera (caddis-flies)
Ecnomidae (Ecnomina, Ecnomus) 2
Leptoceridae (Triplectides, Notolina, Condocerus) 4
Hydrobiosidae (Taschorema, Apsilochorema) 2
Hydroptilidae (Acritoptila, Oxyethira) 4
Hydroropsychidae (Smicrophylax, Cheumatopsyche) 1
Pilopotamidae (Hydrobiosella) 1
7.6.2 Fish and Crayfish
Fish and crayfish species are not only of recreational significance to the people of Collie they are also good indicators of river conditions. These species are often top predators and important species within the ecosystem. This means that these species are closely linked with the overall health of the river ecosystem. Monitoring the species dynamics, such as change in species composition, abundance, diversity, health and condition can provide valuable information on the health of the river. Fish species identified at the study area from Department of Fisheries, Freshwater Fish website (DOF 2017).
Common Carp (Cyprinus carpio) – introduced species
Freshwater Cobbler (Tandanus bostocki)
Freshwater Shrimp (Palaemonetes australis)
Gilgie (Cherax quinquecarinatus)
Koonac (Cherax plebejus)
Mosquitofish (Gambusia holbrooki) – introduced species
Nightfish (Bostockia porosa)
Redfin Perch (Perca fluviatilis) – introduced species
Smooth Marron (Cherax cainii)
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 27
Western Minnow (Galaxias occidentalis)
Western Pygmy Perch (Nannoperca vittata)
Yabby (Cherax destructor albidus)
7.7 Ground Water Historically, in the Collie Basin the river was a system of interconnected pools watered from upstream
springs and aquifers. Groundwater discharges into the Collie River and its tributaries, maintaining
numerous river pools and wetlands. Pools in the Collie River that previously contained water throughout
the year, have at times become dry (Varma 2002).
Permian sediments control groundwater flow directions. The natural groundwater flow pattern in the Collie
Basin has been altered because of mine dewatering and large-scale groundwater abstraction for power
generation. As a result of mine dewatering the flow is directed mainly towards the areas of mining (Varma
2002).
Abstraction in excess of annual recharge has led to a basin-wide decline in groundwater levels across
the Collie Coal Basin below pre-mining state. This has resulted in alterations to groundwater flow
patterns, induced recharge to the confined aquifers and reduced discharge to the Collie River (DOW
2009).
With large scale dewatering groundwater levels will continue to decline (DOW 2009). As a result, some
river pools that were maintained by natural groundwater discharge in the pre-mining period continue to
be dry in summer (Varma 2007).
The upper Collie River catchment and Collie Basin groundwater resources are already subject to
significant impacts from existing land uses in the area. Historic land clearing and a long history of coal
mining (since 1898) have resulted in degraded surface water and groundwater quality, changes to
surface water–groundwater connectivity, altered surface water hydrology, groundwater drawdown and
impacts on associated water-dependent resources.
The impacts of mining include:
Long-term groundwater drawdown affecting groundwater dependent ecosystems.
The accumulation of saline, acidic, metalliferous groundwater in mine voids.
Altered hydrology and water quality in the re-aligned Chicken Creek.
The loss of some flood areas.
Long-term impacts of mine water discharge to the hydrology, geomorphology, water quality,
riparian vegetation communities and in stream fauna of the river and associated permanent
pools.
Substantial contribution to cumulative groundwater and surface water impacts in the region
(ICSC 2014).
Current mining and power generation activities in the Collie area include:
Blue Water Power Station is a 416 Megawatts capacity power station located 8 km northeast of Collie.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 28
Muja Power Station was a 1094 Megawatts capacity power station located 22km east of Collie. Muja A and B comprising of 220 Megawatts was shut down in September 2017. Muja C and D comprising of 854 Megawatts remains operational
Collie Power Station is a 340 Megawatts capacity power station located 10km east of Collie.
Griffin Coal’s Muja Mine 18 kilometres south east of Collie which stopped mining in 2010.
Griffin Coal’s Ewington 1 and 2 coal mines 10 kilometres east of Collie.
Premier Coal mine is 15km east of Collie.
The DOW Upper Collie plan aimed for the recovery of groundwater levels in the Cardiff subarea as mining
slowed and major dewatering ceased. The most up to date groundwater monitoring data review and use
of the groundwater model by the DWER suggest that water levels are not recovering at the rate expected
and will take significantly longer than anticipated during the release of the Upper Collie plan (DWER
2018).
7.8 Pools The potential negative effects on the pools were initially obscured by the coal companies disposing their
mine water to the rivers along with saline water from the Muja Power Station (Beckwith Environmental
2007). Mine dewatering started impacting on the groundwater levels since the 1950s as a result of
increased coal mining in 1952 from those seams of the Muja Coal Measures at Western 2 that lie beneath
the river pools (Varma 2002).
A study by Morgan et al. (1995) in (Varma 2002) on freshwater fish fauna in pools of the Collie River
South Branch found the drying of a number of pools to have “enormous ramifications” on the ecology of
the system and many fish deaths. A macro invertebrates survey carried out by Halse et al. (1999) in
(Varma 2002) showed that the population in most river pools in the basin has lessened, and that the low
pH of pool water may be a cause of this reduction (Varma 2002).
Duderling and Buckingham Bridge pools on the Collie River East branch had been historically
groundwater dependent. As a result of nearby dewatering for mining these pools have become
disconnected from groundwater in the Premier subarea. This resulted in saline surface water intruding
into groundwater systems (saltwater intrusion). The pools are currently supplemented during summer
months to maintain social and environmental values (DWER 2018).
7.9 River Flow Factors which are anticipated to reduce the volume of water flowing in the river are climate change (see
section 6.4) and changes in available water due to farming. Saline water runoff has increased with the
historic deforestation of the upper reaches of the catchment.
The disposal of surplus mine dewater to the Collie River has increased the amount of water in the river
system over a number of years (see figure 9). Dewater destined for pool supplementation and disposal
is treated for pH and metals however, it is expected that the disposal volume will be redirected for power
station use. This will reduce flows in the river, particularly over the summer period where a large portion
of current flow originates from disposal.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 29
Figure 9: Mine dewatering from Premier Coal entering the Collie River.
The Collie Water proposal will also have an impact upon the quantity of water available in the river.
7.10 Collie Water Proposal
The Collie Water Proposal is a public-private partnership driven by Collie Water which proposes to take
saline water from the Collie River, retain it in a mine void, treat it in a desalination plant and sell the
potable water to Watercorp. This will improve the quality of water flowing down the river, as the more
saline water will be removed and increase the supply of potable water. This is anticipated to have an
impact on the volumes of water in the river.
A secondary proposal is to replace the upstream pasture areas with plantations and forest to further
reduce the salinity of the water. New plantation forest areas would be created downstream below the
Wellington Dam. Replacing the upstream pasture areas will reduce surface water runoff in the river, if
done on a broad scale. It is proposed to thin existing upstream forests to counter this effect (see Appendix
3 for further information).
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 30
8 Implementation of recommendations from Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008
8.1 Establishment of environmental flows The following options were recommended for the establishment of environmental flows and the
management of Nardoo in the Collie River in the CRRP 2008:
1. restoration of environmental flow
2. mechanical or chemical removal
3. seasonal management of stop-boards
4. removal of river stop-boards
5. installation of riffles
6. restoration of riparian vegetation
7. monitoring
8.2 Sediment Control There was a recommendation from the CRRP 2008 to use scouring of the sediment to control Nardoo
growth. Three possible options were provided in CRRP 2008 for the scouring of the sediment, (1)
mechanical removal, (2) seasonal management of river stop-boards (3) permanent removal of stop-
boards and/or installation of riffles. The Nardoo has been successfully controlled with Reglone.
8.3 Mechanical or chemical removal of Nardoo The Shire undertook a Nardoo Control Trial Program (SOC 2014); the trials tested the effectiveness of a
range of strategies including the application of Herbicide, Plastic Solarisation, Mechanical Excavation,
Mechanical Harvester and the use of a Grappling Hook. The test sites were monitored over an eighteen
month period, with the final evaluation revealing that the use of herbicide would achieve the best
outcomes.
Following the determination that the use of herbicide would be the most effective means of treatment of
Nardoo, the Shire sought native vegetation clearing approval to undertake larger trials to test the
effectiveness of using the prescribed herbicide Reglone to control Nardoo. In 2012-2013 the small area
was treated with Reglone. From this trial the use of Reglone to control Nardoo was found to be very
effective. The Shire has since been using Reglone to successfully control Nardoo through an annual
Nardoo control program.
8.4 Seasonal management of river stop-boards The CRRP 2008 recommended the seasonal removal of the stop-boards over winter as a trial to allow
scouring of the sediments over the period when the rivers flow is greatest. Replacement of river stop-
boards over summer would maintain pool level over this period. The “pulsed” flows required to remove
Nardoo during summer/autumn could be delivered by stop-board management. If the seasonal removal
was successful it was recommended to permanently remove the stop boards.
The stop-boards have been replaced however not to full capacity (figures 3 & 4).
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 31
The Shire carried out a study from the Venn St Boards through to the Ewington Weir (SOC 2010b). The
study assessed feasibility of retaining water by management and/ or removal of stop-boards.
The study found that it was feasible to establish environmental flow by management of stop-boards. In
the study it was also suggested that shallow water areas be planted with rushes, sedges and a low
density of trees. The suggested species list is in Appendix 2.
8.5 Permanent removal of stop-boards and installation of riffles The CRRP 2008 recommended the permanent removal of stop-boards to control Nardoo and for
ecological reasons. The CRRP also recommended building riffles and prior to the construction of riffles,
a site survey be undertaken to establish the profile, slope, geometry and alignment of the river channel.
As previously mentioned the use of the herbicide Reglone was found to be the most effective means of
treatment of Nardoo at the study area. As it was found that establishing environmental flow through
seasonal management of environmental flow was possible permanent removal of the stop boards was
not considered.
8.6 Restoration of riparian vegetation Since the release of the CRRP 2008 the Shire have carried out various restoration programs. These
include:
Revegetation of some areas along the river has taken place. This includes the planting of 20,000
reeds, sedges and rushes close to the riverbanks and at Minninup Pool where larger tree stocks
were planted with the help of community groups.
Weed management along the river bank has occurred at targeted areas. Large sections of
Blackberry and Watsonia were controlled.
The Preston Rd Revegetation Project involves rehabilitating three areas around the Preston Rd
Bridge. Considerable weed management was undertaken over a period of time, prior to the area
being revegetated with local species. This was a collaborative project between the South West
Catchment Council and involved a range of community groups including; Collie Rotary, Collie
Scout Group, Ngalang Boodja Aboriginal Corporation, Community Garden Group, Shire of Collie
elected members and community members.
The Jack Mears Spring Site Project is a collaborative project between the Shire and the Ngalang
Boodja Aboriginal Corporation to restore a heavily weed impacted natural spring site within the
study area, which has cultural significance to Indigenous people (SWCC 2017). An important
aspect of the site was the discovery of a previously unidentified species of invertebrate which is
found only at the site.
Snap Shot Water Quality Testing undertaken. This has identified a large number of drains with
significantly higher levels of Nitrogen (CENRM 2016). See section 7.4 for further detail.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 32
8.7 Monitoring The following monitoring regime was recommended in the CRRP 2008 (table 5).
Table 5: Monitoring regime recommended in CRRP 2008.
Parameter Methodology Sites/Frequency
Hydrology Gauging station Daily flows
Physical Water quality sampling Pool aggradation Channel morphology
Annually at the downstream “node”.
Annually at areas within the “nodes” (both banks).
Biological Nardoo areal coverage Aquatic macroinvertebrates Fish recruitment
Riparian assessment
During summer/autumn(weekly)
Twice yearly (wet and dry seasons at the three nodes).
Annually at the three “nodes”(coincide with breeding).
Annually (summer) at the three “nodes”.
Snap shot monitoring has occurred, part of this is presented in section 8.6 and the full results are in
SOC 2010b, however to date continuous monitoring has not occurred.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 33
9 Current State and Management
9.1 River Flow The average annual stream flow at the Mungalup Tower monitoring station on the Collie River from 2009
to 2017 was 56.5 GL/ year (figure 10). This is a 41 per cent reduction compared to the 1975 to 2008
average of 95.7 GL/year (DWER 2018).
Since the release of the Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008 there have been two unusually low flow
years, 2010 and 2015. Flows of 7 GL and 15 GL were recorded in these years at Mangalup Tower
respectively (DWER 2018).
Mine dewatering has contributed an average of 9.9 GL/year to stream flow since 2010. This has artificially
increased stream flow in the Collie River, particularly through the Collie town site (DWER 2018).
Figure 10 Annual stream flow at Mungalup Tower on the Collie River
As discussed, the Collie River is important to the Collie people for social amenity and cultural values and
the river is the sole source of water used to irrigate public open spaces. A review by DWER of potential
impacts of climate change and changes in the amount of surplus dewater shows that river flow through
the Collie town site may reduce by around 36 per cent (figure 10). DWER also predicted that winter flows
will decline with the diversion of the Collie River East Branch for the Collie Water proposal (DWER 2018).
The DWER modelling also suggests that monthly average river flow may be especially low during the
summer months coinciding with peak irrigation demand (figure 11). DWER predicts that the removal of
surplus dewater and salinity diversion is likely to reduce the surface water available for existing public
purposes, such as irrigation of parks and ovals, and amenity of the river (DWER 2018). The Shire and
DWER are in negotiations to identify alternative water source options to meet shortfalls in supply.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 34
Figure 11: Monthly average flow modelled at the Collie town site
9.2 Water Quality Decline in water quality in the Collie River study area has been an issue. There has been various
monitoring carried out within the study area by various organisations. However, there is a lack of a
continuous structured quality controlled (QA/QC) monitoring programs in the study area. Furthermore,
the monitoring program is required to be consistent and carried out for a significant time period.
Quality Assurance consists of a system of documented procedures and plans established to ensure that
the water monitoring program produces data of known precision and bias. This includes staff training
programs, calibration process, written procedures and record keeping. In addition, this also includes a
quality control program.
Quality Control in monitoring refers to operational activities that confirm the quality assurance methods
are functional and that information collected is accurate, precise and properly recorded. Therefore,
consistent QA/ QC activities produce data of known quality.
It is recommend that the Shire develop and implement a monitoring program for salinity, water level,
Phosphors, and Nitrogen (see section 10.8 recommendations).
9.3 Current Restoration of Riparian Vegetation Nardoo Control
Since the release of CRRP 2008 the Shire has been successfully managing Nardoo within the study
area. Reglone Hydrogel is used annually in autumn to control Nardoo along the entire stretch of river
within the town. Spraying is conducted twice within two weeks to ensure maximum effectiveness.
Reglone has been found to be the most suitable herbicide to control Nardoo in the study area for the
following reasons (SoC 2014):
Reglone is authorised by the Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority for use
on Nardoo in aquatic areas in all states.
Reglone is considered to be non-residual with minimal biological consequence because it is
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 35
inactivated by attachment to soil particles.
Reglone is rapidly absorbed and deactivated by soil. Reglone is rapidly and completely
deactivated by soil by a reaction between the double positively charged diquat ions and clay
minerals present in soils to form complexes. Most soils have sufficient capacity in the top 2 - 5
cm to bind many hundred times the normal field rates of diquat.
Reglone does not leach, so there is little chance of groundwater infiltration, and while there is a
high likelihood of runoff in waterways due to attachment to clay particles, Reglone is inactive in
this form and therefore has little biological consequence.
Bioaccumulation of Reglone in an aquatic species is low.
There is no effective mobility of Reglone in soil or water
If spills occur, Reglone can be deactivated by absorption with earth, sand, clay or absorbent
material such as vermiculite.
In the event of a chemical spill, the spill site can be deactivated, and then decontaminated with
detergent and small volumes of water.
Riparian Restoration The Shire is implementing several environmental rehabilitation management plans including, Jack Mears Spring Rehabilitation Landscape Management Plan.
The Shire is also currently working on a priority section of the river in the main town of Collie targeting
the removal of weeds and the replanting of the foreshore with native seedlings. The priority weeds
targeted are nardoo, Watsonia and Bulrush which out compete native vegetation and in turn impact the
water quality, environmental diversity and native fauna.
The Shire has established a rehabilitation strategy for the CBD area (figure 12). Part one of the strategy
is listed below.
Part one of the rehabilitation of this foreshore will occur in five stages over five years:
1. The first stage (4.4ha) covers the foreshore on both sides from the Swinging Bridge to the
Coombes Street Bridge;
2. The second stage (2Ha) covers the area between the Coombes Street Bridge up to the riffle
(Western Riders and Skate Park);
3. The third stage (0.7Ha) covers the area on the Southern bank from the biofiltration basin up to
the railway bridge;
4. The fourth stage (0.8Ha) covers the area on the Northern bank from the Western Riders up to
the railway bridge; and
5. The fifth stage (0.25Ha) covers the area from the skate park to the biofiltration basin on the
Southern side of the river and will include infill planting of stages 1-4 to replace seedling
mortality.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 36
Figure 12: Shire proposed rehabilitation stages
Good quality remanent vegetation still exists in the study area (figures 13 &14). Revegetation of degraded
areas will enhance the ecological value of the study area.
Figure 13: Coral Vine Kennedia coccinea (Curtis) Vent
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 37
Figure 14: Purple Enamel Orchid Caladenia brunonis and West Australian Kangaroo Paw Anigozanthos manglesii
9.4 Public access and erosion There were two areas found within the study area that have been impacted by erosion caused by
vehicular access (figures 17 to 18). A bank next to the Mungalup Bridge has been eroded (figure 16 &
17). It is recommended that access be managed so as to reduce large exposed sandy areas and create
narrower tracks for the Public to access the bank. Another river bank at the area known as ‘Sandy’ near
Minningup Pool also had erosion impacts caused by vehicular access. The access to It is recommended
that area known as “Sandy” be managed to reduce the width of the access track to the water’s edge, to
a narrower access track. It is recommended the Shire monitor the use of the access track and take further
action if required.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 38
Figure 15: Mungalup Bridge exposed bank
Figure 16: Mungalup Bridge exposed bank
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 39
Figure 17: ‘Sandy’ exposed bank
Figure 18: ‘Sandy’ exposed bank
9.5 Drainage management
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 40
Nutrient levels have been measured below and above the town site (CENRM 2016) (see section 7.5).
The Shire has built a series of Biofiltration basins (figure 19). Biofiltration basins are a good solution for
stripping pollutants from drains.
Figure 19: Biofiltration basin
9.6 Review The Collie River Revitalisation Strategy 2018 to 2022 should be reviewed annually for progress to
measure the recommendation and performance against the strategy. The strategy should be fully
reviewed in 2022.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 41
10 Recommendations
10.1 Water Level Management
10.1.1 Public Consultation
There were three options for water level management to consider. These included construction of a river
gate, construction of additional riffles, and using the ‘living’ river concept to transform the river back to a
functional ecosystem.
The Shire carried out consultation with stakeholders, including the Shire of Collie Weeds and Waterways
Advisory Committee and the public. The Shire held a public information session on Wednesday 8th August
2018 at the Collie Ridge Motel located at 185 – 195 Throssell Street in Collie. The Shire also had a
display of the Collie Revitalisation Strategy at the Collie Central Shopping Centre at 56 Forrest Street,
Collie on Friday 28 of September 2018 between 10.00 am and 2.00 pm. The purpose of these public
information sessions was to present a summary of the draft Collie River Revitalisation Strategy and
outline the outcomes and recommendations form the strategy. Detail of the information session and
display can be found in Appendix 1 Collie River Revitalisation Strategy Report On Public Information
Session Meeting. In addition, the Shire of Collie Weeds and Waterways Advisory Committee have
reviewed and commented on the Draft Collie River Revitalisation Strategy.
The majority of stakeholders from the engagement were in favour of river gates and riffles. The river
gates such as Sluice gates can be installed at Venn Street. The river gates will be become more
significant for maintaining water levels with the cessation of mine dewatering input and the predicted
reduction of rainfall. The river gates will also help maintain pool levels in the summer.
10.1.2 River gates
With the installation of river gates the Shire will have the ability to manage the water levels to desired
outcome, depending on the seasonal flow in the river.
If river gates are to be installed they are to be suitably designed and constructed to ensure their structural
integrity and safe operation. Functional and economically designed gates can be sourced and may use
manual operation to avoid the higher cost of computer controlled systems. It is recommended that
appropriate type and design of river gate is investigated. The cost of construction, operation, and
maintenance of the chosen design must be factored into the project consideration. The existing board
infrastructure may need structural assessment if a new system is to utilise the current infrastructure.
The gates can be opened during winter, water depending on rainfall and the heavier flows between May
and September. The risk with gates is that the can become stratified and the stillness of this water can
lead to deterioration of water quality. The quality of this water in the retained area should be monitored
and managed accordingly. The river gates are considered a solution for managing river levels until
progressive restoration of the river occurs in the longer term which can be a 20 to 30 year process. The
gate will also enable rehabilitation trials in the river to occur.
10.1.3 Construction of Riffles
Once the river gates have been installed. Appropriate flow data is recommended to be collected with the
operation of the gates, reduced flow caused by the cessation of mine dewatering input, and reduced
rainfall. From the analysis of the flow data it can be determined whether riffles are viable. Riffles create
pools, which can be habitat for fish and are typically a refuge for aquatic fauna during the dry season.
Riffles can also aerate flows which assists in the rivers water quality (DOE 2004). There should be
sufficient water flowing in the river for this to occur. It is recommended that if the riffle are to be constructed
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 42
that they are suitably designed incorporating future predicted river flow as well as providing a suitable
grade for vegetation establishment, access for maintenance, and public safety (DOE 2004).
It is recommended that any design be integrated with the Shire of Collie rehabilitation strategy. The cost
of construction and maintenance of the riffle must be factored into the project consideration.
10.2 Restoration of Riparian Vegetation Continue Nardoo control with Reglone Hydrogel annually within the first two weeks of autumn or as
weather and conditions allow. Renew clearing permit from the DWER for Nardoo control.
Develop and implement the Shire rehabilitation strategy for the study area. Integrate the strategy into the
Shire five year works programme. Ensure that the section of the river where removal of weeds and the
replanting of the foreshore with native seedlings is maintained regularly to improve the success of the
restoration work. This will involve Shire ensuring rehab weed control is followed by planting and 2-3 year
establishment program. It is recommended that establishment program include watering, maintenance,
weed control. Capital and maintenance budgeting and planning to allow for this cycle.
10.3 Drainage management Undertake installation of biofiltration basins in accordance with the recommendation from CENRM 2016.
Once these have been constructed carry out another review of nutrient and pollutant levels from drains
and prioritise actions accordingly.
10.4 Access and erosion management It is recommended that the Shire investigate access and erosion issues in the study areas such as ‘Sandy’
and Mungalup Bridge. Consideration is required by the Shire to prioritise and manage these issues
accordingly.
10.5 Community engagement and support It is recommended that the Shire continue to support community groups such as Friends of Collie River,
Collie Rotary Club, Collie High School, and Scouts for involvement in restoration work. Friends of Collie
River in conjunction with the Shire coordinating training of volunteers in restoration.
Regularly inform the community of the progress of the implementation of the CRRS. This can be
achieved by using various communication mediums such as social media, print media, radio
interviews, The Shire website and on-site signage.
It is recommended that the Shire engage with the indigenous community on the progress of this
strategy.
10.6 Community Education It is recommended for the Shire to carry out a community education campaign to reduce nutrient input
into the river.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 43
10.7 Nutrient Management Consideration is required by the Shire to review the fertiliser program used in parks and gardens and
reduce nutrient load into the river. It is recommended that the Shire also work with the Collie Golf Course
and other large businesses to reduce their nutrient load.
10.8 Monitoring River Flow and River Water Level
The Shire monitor water level in mAHD at the following locations:
a. Just below Lynn Street bridge
b. Venn St Boards
c. Minninup Pool
d. Roberts Rocks
The water level and flow monitoring will provide information that will inform the Shire on the status of river
flow and level and enable the shire to carry out suitable management actions.
Water Quality
It is recommended that the water quality monitoring be completed as the monitoring information will guide
the Shire in implementing the appropriate management action. The monitoring results can be used to
pinpoint any changes or trends that appear in the river over a period of time. This can include short and
long term issues.
Recommended monitoring for the study area include: nitrogen, phosphorus, salinity, and Reglone spray
at Lynn Street Bridge and Roberts Rocks river boards.
The monitoring can be done by existing Shire staff after undergoing training or external resources.
Develop a water quality monitoring program. This will be an operational program designed to provide
direction to staff or contractors carrying out water sampling.
Portable in-situ salinity meter can be used to measure salinity. It is recommended that to test levels of
nitrogen and phosphate, collected water samples be sent to a chemical analysis laboratory.
Consideration is required to monitor the potential impact of Reglone assessing any impact to:
Invertebrates
Fish
Water fowl and birds
Other non-targeted vegetation
Water Quality, including oxygen levels, sedimentation and turbidity
Aquatic mammals
Table 6: Recommended monitoring regime
Parameter Methodology Frequency
River Flow and River Water Level Gauging Station installed currently by DWER
Monthly
Water Quality Grab sample Quarter
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 44
Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and
salinity
Send to chemical analysis laboratory (P&N)
Portable in situ salinity meter
Potential impact of Reglone Monitor detrimental impact on:
Invertebrates
Fish
Water fowl and birds
Other vegetation
Water quality
Oxygen levels
Sediment and turbidity
before and after treatment with Reglone.
The Shire should continue to carry this out in partnership with SWCC, DWER, or academic institutions currently carrying out impacts of herbicide monitoring.
Before and after treatment
To be assessed
10.9 Advocate for the health of Collie River
Although the 12 km stretch of the river running through the town was investigated in this strategy, what
occurs upstream of the river impacts the health of the study area. Similarly, activities that occur within
the study area will impact down steam areas. Therefore, it is recommended that the Shire work with the
managers of the upstream section of the study area (Shires of Williams and West Arthur), and
downstream section of the river (Shire of Dardanup) to improve the overall health of the study area.
Consideration is required by the Shire also to maintain collaboration with the DWER, Leschenault
Catchment, and South West Catchment Council on river management issues.
It is recommended that the Shire also advocate in relation to future projects:
Sufficient public consultation occurs.
The opportunity for Collie employment through future projects
The impact of the future projects on the Collie River both environmentally and socially from a
community perspective.
Consideration is required by the Shire to work with other Local Government Agencies, Industry,
Government Agencies, and Community groups on river management issues.
It is recommended that the Shire also advocate ensuring that the values of the river are protected in any
future developments.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 45
11 Recreational and Tourism Opportunities
The Collie River, and more particularly the study area, has great potential for passive recreation for Collie
residents and visitors to the town.
The Western Australian Strategic Trails Blueprint 2017–2021 (the Blueprint) is an overarching guide for
consistent and coordinated planning, development and management of quality trails and trail experiences
across Western Australia. It provides a vision, guiding principles, strategic directions and actions for
consideration across the State for government, trail managers, landholders, trail support groups, tourism
operators and the community.
Given the level of existing infrastructure within town, Collie has potential to develop other adventure
tourism activities such as bush walking trails and formalisation and development of camping areas along
the river. River pools created by the existing and future rivers weirs could be developed with access areas
to cater for day use canoeing activity.
11.1 Paddle Trail The Shire of Collie is currently planning a paddle trail that will pass through the Town and connect with
the recreation sites detailed for development elsewhere within this report.
11.2 Cycle Trail West Cycle is the Governing body responsible for the development of cycling and the distribution of
Federal and State Government funding for the sports development. West Cycle’s Southwest West
Mountain Bike Master Plan (2015), which identifies Collie as one of three potential high priority regions to
develop a national standard trail network that interconnects with local businesses such as breweries,
restaurants and accommodation. It is recommended that opportunities are explored and developed further
for funding opportunities.
The Shire of Collie is in the process of applying for a Building Better Regions Fund (BBRF) Grant from the
Federal Government, for future cycle pathway connections that will improve the current access to both the
Munda Biddi track (mountain biking) and the Bibbulmun track (bushwalking) from the Visitors Centre,
through Collie CBD.
The development of a more connected trail network along the Collie River will enhance tourism and
encourage the economic development of the accommodation and hospitality industries, as well as the
other attractions within the town. The proposed trail projects will provide direct trail connections with the
existing long-distance walking and mountain bike trails and will provide the community of Collie with a
number of benefits. Users of the Bibbulmun Track and Munda Biddi trail, will be more likely to divert to
Collie, which will benefit local business. The Collie Community will be provided with a new recreation
opportunity that displays the Collie river environment and strengthens the connection between the town
Minninup pool area. The path will connect the proposed Minninup Camp Ground (see South West
Development Commission) to Collie CBD.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 46
The precedent for mountain bike tourism already exists in Margaret River and Pemberton. These towns
have recently constructed much longer mountain trail networks that are now contributing to increased
levels of tourism and overnight stays. In addition, the trails are of a standard that both towns attract regular
large mountain bike competition and community events. Collie is well placed to take advantage of similar
tourism benefits given its location to the population centres of Bunbury and Perth as recommended in the
South West mountain bike Masterplan. The semi degraded or altered state of some bushland surrounding
the river within the study area is ideal for further development for mountain bike trails.
11.3 Fishing The Collie River is a valuable fresh water fishing location within the region. The implementation of the
Collie River Revitalisation Strategy will improve the health of the river and can lead to an increase in fish
stock. Fishing in the Collie River is mainly for Black Bream, the odd Mulloway and further upstream for
Trout and Redfin Perch. The Collie River is also stocked with Trout and around 45,000 triploid rainbow
trout that were released into the Collie River below Wellington Dam early 2014. Redfin Perch also
dominate in the fresh water parts of both the Collie River and Brunswick River. They can fish all year
around however, during the warmer months they tend to be more active, taking almost anything that lands
in the water.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 47
12 Conclusion Channel morphology and flows have been altered significantly due to river training. A deep channel now flows which would have flooded the flats at one time (WRM 2009). Mine dewatering discharge into the river and groundwater abstraction has altered water levels and flows. Returning the river system to pre-European state or even to pre-dredging condition is an unrealistic aim given the competing needs of ecology, community, and industry. However, with strategic focus, effort, resources, and time the river study area can be greatly enhanced by increasing public amenity, water quality, ecological diversity, and recreational opportunities.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 48
13 References
Beckwith Environmental 2007. Upper Collie Water Management Plan, Issue Scoping Report.Beckwith
Environmental Planning Pty Ltd, Prepared for Department of Water, Government of Western Australia,
June 2007.
BOM 2018. Bauru Of Meteorology Website (2018)
http://www.bom.gov.au/jsp/ncc/cdio/weatherData/av?p_nccObsCode=139&p_display_type=dataFile&p_
startYear=&p_c=&p_stn_num=009994 [Accessed 19 February 2017]
CENRM 2008 Collie River Revitalisation Project. Peter Davies, Peter Speldewinde and Colin Macgregor.
Centre of Excellence in Natural Resource Management, The University of Western Australia. Albany. June
2008.
CENRM 2016. Report on potential nutrient stripping sites. Unpublished report to the Shire of Collie by the
Centre of Excellence in Natural Resource Management. The University of Western Australia. September
2016.
Churchward, H.M. and McArthur, W.M. (1980). Landforms and Soils of the Darling System, Western
Australia. In Atlas of Natural Resources, Darling System Western Australia. Maps and explanatory text.
Department of Conservation and Environment, Western Australia.
DOE 2004. Department of Environment 2004, Introduction, Stormwater Management Manual for Western Australia, Department of Environment, Perth, Western Australia. DOE 2006 Department of Environment and Swan River Trust 2006, Retrofitting, Stormwater Management Manual for Western Australia, Department of Environment and Swan River Trust, Perth, Western Australia. DOF 2017. Department of Fisheries, Freshwater Fish Website. (2017).
http://freshwater.fish.wa.gov.au/MapCatchments.aspx?Catchment_id=182
[Accessed 2 November 2017]
DOW 2009. Upper Collie Water Allocation Plan. Water resource allocation and planning series. Report number 20. Department of Water, Perth. August 2009. DOW 2008. West regional water plan: Workshops held with the Nyungar community. Department of Water, Perth. April 2008. DOW 2010. Department of Water. The effects of climate change on stream flow in south-west Western Australia Projections for 2050. Surface water hydrology series Report no. HY34. September 2010. DWER 2018. Department of Water and Environmental Regulation. Upper Collie Water Allocation Plan, Evaluation Statement 2009-2007. EPA 1987. Environmental Protection Authority, 1987, Harris River Dam Project: Water Authority of Western Australia, Report and Recommendations of the Environmental protection Authority, EPA Bulletin 272. Hart 2014. Independent Review of the Current and Future Management of Water Assets in the Geographe Catchment, WAFinal Report. Barry T Hart, Water Sciences Pty ltd. 2014.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 49
Heddle, E.M., Loneragan, O.W. and Havel, J.J. (1980). Vegetation Complexes of the Darling System,
Western Australia. In Atlas of Natural Resources, Darling System Western Australia. Maps and
explanatory text. Department of Conservation and Environment, Western Australia.
ICSC 2014, Information Guidelines for Independent Expert Scientific Committee advice on coal seam gas
and large coal mining development proposals. 2014.
Mauger et al 2001a, Macgregor et al 2010. Macgregor, C., Speldewinde, P., Farrell, C., Tunbridge, D. and
Janicke, G. River Action Plan for the Upper Collie Catchment, Report prepared by the Centre of Excellence
in Natural Resource Management, University of Western Australia, for the Department of Water, Bunbury.
2010.
Mauger et al 2001b, Mauger G.W., Bari M., Boniecka L., Dixon R.N.M., Dogramaci S.S. and Platt J. 2001,
Salinity Situation Statement: Collie River, Water and Rivers Commission, Water Resources Technical
Series No WRT 29.
SERCUL 2014. Urban Waterways Renewal Project Final Report, A report prepared by The South East
Regional Centre for Urban Landcare for the Department of Water. January 2014.
SERCUL 2018. SERCUL Website (2018) http://www.sercul.org.au/bccg/ (Accessed 13 February 2018).
SOC 2010a. Shire of Collie. Control of Nardoo (Marsilea mutica) in the Collie River. 2010.
SOC 2010b. Shire of Collie. ‘There’s a river under there’ Report on the feasibility of establishing
environmental flows by management or removal of stop-boards at Venn Street. 2010.
SOC 2014. Shire of Collie. Collie River Revitalisation Plan: Weed Removal Management Plan. October
2014.
SWCC 2017. Jack Mears Spring Rehabilitation Landscape Management Plan. Prepared forShire of Collie.
South West Catchment Council Consulting 2017.
Thackway, R. and Cresswell, I.D. 1995. An Interim Biogeographic Regionalisation for Australia. Australian
Nature Conservation Agency, Canberra.
VARMA, S., 2002, Hydrogeology and Groundwater Resources of the Collie Basin, Western Australia, Water and Rivers Commission, Hydrogeological Record Series, Report HG 5, 80p. Varma, 2007, Hydrogeology of the Collie basin, Western Australia. Sunil Varma, 2007. Curtin University of Technology. Dept. of Applied Geology. Published.
Western Collieries 1991. Consultative Environmental Review, Premier Mine Expansion 1991. Western
Collieries Ltd
WRM 2009. Collie River Ecological Values Assessment 2008. Unpublished report to the Department of
Water, Perth, by Wetland Research & Management. April 2009.
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 50
14 Appendices
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 51
Appendix 1 Collie River Revitalisation Strategy Report On Public
Information Session Meeting Held On 8 August 2018 for Shire of
Collie.
COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY
REPORT ON PUBLIC INFORMATION SESSION
MEETING HELD ON
8 AUGUST 2018
FOR
SHIRE OF COLLIE
DATE: October 2018
REFERENCE: Q23062017-005-01-C
-
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 2
DOCUMENT CONTROL RECORD
Prepared By: Murali Mahendran & Mark Jumeaux
Approved By: Glen Flood
Position: Associate Team Members Position: Managing Director
Signed: Murali & Mark Signed:
Date: 8 Nov 2018 Date: 8 Nov 2018
REVISION STATUS
Revision No. Description of Revision Date Approved
A Draft Report 17 September 2018
B Draft Report 4 October 2018
C Final Report 8 November 2018
Recipients are responsible for eliminating all superseded documents in their possession.
DISCLAIMER
This document is published in accordance with and subject to an agreement between Glen Flood Group
Pty Ltd (trading as GFG Consulting) and the Shire of Collie (Client). It is confined to the issues that have
been raised by the Client in the Client’s engagement of GFG Consulting and is prepared using the
standard of skill and due care ordinarily exercised by management and business consultants in preparing
such documents.
Any person or organisation that relies on or uses the document for reasons or purposes other than those
agreed by GFG Consulting and the Client without first obtaining the prior written approval of GFG
Consulting, does so entirely at their own risk. To the extent permitted by law, GFG Consulting excludes
any liability, including any liability for negligence, for any loss, including indirect or consequential
damages arising from or in relation to any reliance on this document for any purpose other than that
agreed with the Client.
The final plan, appendices and mapping, including all data, analysis, information and images will become
the property of the Shire of Collie.
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS ....................................................................................................................... 3
1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 4
2 Public Presentation ....................................................................................................................... 4
3 Information Session Recorded Discussion .................................................................................... 5
4 Public Comment Form .................................................................................................................. 8
5 Display at Central Shopping Centre ............................................................................................ 10
6 Public Comment Form, Collie Central Display............................................................................. 10
7 Appendices ................................................................................................................................. 12
APPENDICES
Appendix 1 Public Information Session Presentation ........................................................................... 12
Appendix 2 Public Comments .............................................................................................................. 13
Appendix 3 Public Comments Collie Central Shopping Centre ............................................................ 14
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 4
1 Introduction
A public information session was held on Wednesday 8th August 2018 at the Collie Ridge Motel located
at 185 – 195 Throssell Street in Collie. The purpose of the public information session was to present a
summary of the draft Collie River Revitalisation Strategy and outline the outcomes and recommendations
form the strategy. The information session was opened at 6:08 by the Collie Shire President Ms Sarah
Stanley and was closed at 8:00pm. The information session was attended by 23 people. The public
information session was advertised on the Collie Mail on 2nd of August 2018, the Shire of Collie Website,
and the Shire of Collie Facebook page.
2 Public Presentation
GFG delivered a presentation to the attendees at the information session that outlined the content and
main recommendations of the draft Collie River Revitalisation Strategy. This was followed by a question,
answer, and discussion with GFG and the attendees. The record of the discussion from this session is
presented in section three. A copy of the presentation is provided in Appendix 1.
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 5
3 Information Session Recorded Discussion
The following information captures the questions from the public meeting attendees and responses by
GFG, following the public presentation.
Norm Weise, Buckingham – In the Strategy there was no mention of planting vegetation in the River
itself only on the banks.
GFG Response – The strategy did not address rehabilitation and revegetation in detail. This will be
included in the Shire of Collie Rehabilitation Strategy. We envisage that the vegetation planting for both
the riparian areas and inundated areas will be included in the rehabilitation strategy.
Peter Piavanini, WWAC Member – There was no mention of silt build up and management in the
strategy.
GFG Response – Although monitoring is addressed in the strategy, monitoring of silt was not specifically
addressed in the strategy. When a water level management option is chosen, monitoring should also be
implemented to monitor the level of water and silt.
Ed Riley, WWAC Member – Why wasn’t floating pond weed addressed in the report, it is a major aquatic
concern.
There has been concerted effort in recent time in Collie to increase tourist to the town. In order to maintain
the aesthetic experience of the river for residents and tourists the river needs to be full. When upgrading
the aging Venn Street stops the aging Roberts Rocks should also be assessed and repaired or restored
as required. The boards need to be removed or lifted in winter to stop further damage to the boards.
GFG Response – The strategy did not address weed issues, this was a broad, higher level strategy. The
Shire of Collie Rehabilitation Strategy should address rehabilitation and revegetation in more detail.
Ed Riley, WWAC Member – River stops, construction, and upgrade need to be maintained and included
in the budget.
GFG Response – There was no costings in this report. The next stage from the strategy will include
engineering designs and budget estimates.
Dennis True, WWAC Member – Why recommend more riffles? How many more will you recommend?
— Man made riffles at Booth Street river crossing to Soldiers Park are under water at the moment.
— Refer to section 7.1 ‘Dredging’ in the report. Venn Street stops now backs water to riffle in Soldiers
Park.
— Venn Street only half full.
— Not possible to build more.
— What purpose will they have?
GFG Response – The strategy does not recommend riffles. One water level management method will
be selected from the following options;
1) river gates at Venn Street and/or construct riffles, or
2) a ‘living’ river concept that over time will rehabilitate and reshape the river banks to a more natural
form.
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 6
If the riffle option is chosen, it is recommended in the strategy that sufficient water flowing in the river
shall be present for riffles to work correctly and be suitably designed to accommodate future predicted
river flow.
Gary Faries, Councillor – As the Shire monitors the river, would it be possible to do some modelling –
with options? Why not use what we have with today’s technology?
GFG Response – Modelling can be used to validate one of the options above. Modelling was not within
the scope of the current strategy.
Ed Riley, WWAC Member – Is GFG in favour of the Shire to take up strategy to rehab?
GFG Response – We have recommended to develop and implement a rehabilitation strategy.
Norm Weise, Buckingham – In 1940 East Branch didn’t flow, from Muja up there is large areas of water,
but very low and full of silt.
— When the mines dewatering stops there will be no flow between one pool to another, from Bucks
to Collie
GFG Response – Taken as comment
Mick Murray – WA Government
— The width of the river was cleared, is there any thoughts to bringing the River back to a smaller
width?
— Has any modelling been carried out on bringing the width of the river in?
— The “Sandy” recreational area on the river, has been damaged by public taking sand. At Griffin
Bridge there is not a lot of change. Silt is definitely coming down. Major damage by four wheel
drive vehicles and camping on the river.
GFG Response – Access management was addressed in the strategy. Modelling has not been carried
out on revegetating and reducing the width of the river in the current scope of the strategy. The Lower
flow option has been considered and discussed in the strategy as the ‘living’ river concept. This will
involve carrying out engineering civil works, weed control, and planting. Under the “living river” concept
Engineering works are used to modify the current slope and width of the river. This will be a relatively
long process. The current rehabilitation practice needs to be maintained and efforts need to be increased.
The rehabilitation aspect of the Collie River, is best to be addressed in the Shire of Collie Rehabilitation
Strategy document.
Tate Oden, Public –
— Who of the Aboriginal people are GFG working with over the strategy?
— No consult to Joe Northover.
— Minningup Pool is a sacred site.
— What will GFG do to protect sacred sites?
GFG Response – Vision recognises site and we envisage that there will be consultation with Aboriginal
representatives for the implementation of the relevant stages.
David Blurton Response – Money has been made available from the State Government to look at
Minningup Pool as a separate project and Ngalang Boodja will be consulted as part of the project.
Dennis True, WWAC Member – Let Tate Oden and Phil Ugle know that there is a voting position in the
Weeds and Waterways Advisory Committee for Ngalang Boodja member.
Mick Murray, MLA, Minister for Seniors and Ageing; Volunteering; Sport and Recreation WA Government – Jack Mears Springs Rehabilitation Landscape Management Plan has been completed
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 7
and implementation is underway. Attended Minningup Pool with James Khan. Suggestions made to drill a hole in the cut down sacred tree and plant another tree inside.
Joe Italiano, WWAC Member / Councillor – Offered an invitation to Tate Oden and Phil Ugle to attend
the WWAC meeting and represent the local Aboriginal groups.
Ed Riley – WWAC Member – Asked for a show of hands of everyone that wanted more water in town?
Joe Heatherington, Public – If the River stops are removed at Venn Street, what level of water will be
at Soldiers Park?
GFG Response – In summer, there will be very low water level.
David Blurton, Shire of Collie CEO – What is silt? Is it natural? Where does it come from? How do you
get rid of it or will it move on?
GFG Response – In a relatively undisturbed river system silt will be flushed out after the first rains. In
disturbed rivers such as the Collie River with steep banks and little vegetation retaining and binding the
soil, there is greater chance for erosion and deposition of silt into the river. With lower winter river flushes
expected, silt will build up especially in the lower areas and the situation will compound in the following
seasons.
Norm Weise, Buckingham – Pools upstream from Muja are stilted up now. Pool at Buckingham Bridge,
going down stream. The silt level visible at River at the Buckingham Hall. Is there a place for silt to be
collected?
Peter Piavanini, WWAC Member – With the last 15 years of massive coal dumps, the silt cannot escape.
What will we do in another 30 years? Agrees with Norm Weise
GFG Response – Asked if the catchment has been changed?
Ed Riley – said yes.
Mick Murray, WA Government – Bluegum tree planting, soaked up a lot of water. Win and lose in this.
GFG Response – Agree with all the comments, need to manage and stabilise the erosion and silting.
Gary Faries, Councillor – The build-up must be a common thing. Other rivers have same issues. Have
GFG seen anything else like this?
GFG Response – Stabilising the banks and revegetating is a solution. Another method is fencing the
banks until natural revegetation occurs (but only a temporary measure). Revegetating the areas will
contribute to stabilising of silt. This is an issue for the whole of river and catchment.
Sarah Stanley, Shire of Collie President – Do you see value in layers of streams along the river? Is
there any value in putting in more riffles or just rehabilitating?
GFG Response – Weeds are an ongoing problem. An immediate strategy might be to install gates and
hold back water. Monitor the new water regime and install riffles only if needed.
Dennis True, WWAC Member – Do something about steepness of banks.
Joe Hetherington, Public – What sort of vegetation would you have in the river? Salt tolerant?
GFG Response – Reeds and sedges, would be selected and planted, to accommodate the expected
river water levels. The Shire of Collie Rehabilitation Strategy should inform this.
Ed Riley, WWAC Member – Asked for a show of hands for replacing or refurbishing the Venn Street
stops.
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 8
4 Public Comment Form At the completion of the presentation and discussion, a Public Comment form was handed out to the
attendees. The Public Comment form was also available on the Shire’s website. Five people completed
the Public Comment form. These forms are provided in Appendix 2.
There were three questions on the Public Comment forms to assist the public to think about the types
of issues they could comment on.
Question 1: Interventions to manage river water levels
With the cessation of mine de-watering and decreasing rainfall, the river flow is likely to reduce. To
ensure water is retained, it is recommended that the Shire consider interventions that assist in retaining
water during dry periods.
In order to manage the water level there are three options available to the Shire. These include 1)
construction of river gates at Venn Street and/or 2) construct riffles, or 3) a ‘living’ river concept to
regenerate the river back to a more functioning riverine ecosystem.
Do you have a preference on which of the above methods is used to retain flow?
Summary of comments received:
Restoring the river to a more natural system may take longer but should provide better
outcomes overall.
Lift the river level from Soldiers Park to Venn street river stop.
Do not install any river riffles through the town to Venn street river stop.
There is only one sensible option to take and lift water levels in the river through town during
summer. That is to duplicate the previous function of the Venn street river stops.
My preference is for a flexible river stop at Venn street to retain a higher depth of water
during summer. Flexible gates or sluice will be ideal because the river level could be
adjusted according to circumstances. I am opposed to riffles because they primarily
oxygenate the water (only when the river flows). Elements of the living river have merit but
long term. We need action now.
Question 2: The vision for Collie River
The vision for the Collie River outlines a number of strategies that will benefit not only the local
community but also those accessing water further downstream, whilst increasing public amenity to the
river.
These strategies include:
• Develop and implement the Shire river foreshore rehabilitation strategy.
• Acknowledge and preserve the various recreational pursuits associated with the river
(fishing, canoeing etc.).
• Ensure the identified sections of the river remain aesthetically appealing which recognises
and promotes the river as a community asset.
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 9
• Recognise and conserve the Aboriginal cultural history associated with the river.
Do you wish to make comments on this vision?
Summary of comments received:
Great vision
I support the foreshore rehabilitation, start by protecting river foreshore at Minninup pool.
Aboriginal cultural and history should be told to the children and the Collie population.
I agree with all of the strategies and would support actions that address these goals.
Question 3 Any other comments?
Summary of comments received:
Concentrate on upgrading Venn street river stop and give urgent attention to maintaining and
preventing further deterioration to the aging Roberts road river stop structure.
Water will become number one priority and the river requires large amount of money allocated
to it.
Upgrade Roberts Rocks River Stop
Inform Collie residence the need to carry out major work on the river and vegetation.
Apply for grants
The Shire to take politics out of issue
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 10
5 Display at Central Shopping Centre
A display of the Collie River Revitalisation Strategy was set up at the Collie Central Shopping Centre at
56 Forrest Street, Collie on Friday 28 of September 2018 between 10.00 am and 2.00 pm.
The Public Comment form from the public information session was handed out to the visitors of the
display.
The three questions on the Public Comment forms are below. In all 16 people made comments on the
forms.
6 Public Comment Form, Collie Central Display Question 1: Interventions to manage river water levels
With the cessation of mine de-watering and decreasing rainfall, the river flow is likely to reduce. To ensure
water is retained, it is recommended that the Shire consider interventions that assist in retaining water
during dry periods.
In order to manage the water level there are three options available to the Shire. These include 1)
construction of river gates at Venn Street and/or 2) construct riffles, or 3) a ‘living’ river concept to
regenerate the river back to a more functioning riverine ecosystem.
Do you have a preference on which of the above methods is used to retain flow?
Summary of comments received:
Option 1 and 2
A ‘living’ River concept sounds good- at least it sounds like the best option.
The riffles and the river gates
Do what is best for the long term health of the river system
Living river concept
Do what is best for the long term health of the river system.
Living river concept
1 and 2
Fix dam
Option 1
Construct riffles
3
3
1 and 2
1 and 2
3
3
Fix it
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 11
Question 2: The vision for Collie River
The vision for the Collie River outlines a number of strategies that will benefit not only the local community
but also those accessing water further downstream, whilst increasing public amenity to the river.
These strategies include:
• Develop and implement the Shire river foreshore rehabilitation strategy.
• Acknowledge and preserve the various recreational pursuits associated with the river (fishing,
canoeing etc.).
• Ensure the identified sections of the river remain aesthetically appealing which recognises
and promotes the river as a community asset.
• Recognise and conserve the Aboriginal cultural history associated with the river.
Do you wish to make comments on this vision?
Summary of comments received:
Agreed
I think the strategies suggest would be great
Perhaps educating children and adults about river - safety
- swimming
- currents
- fishing with the local school
Priority to river health
Second to look nice
Do the lot
Very good vision and appreciate the thoughts and planning and future implementation of
such
Yes
I would like to know what impact the Harvey River Group will have on the Collie River.
Leave the trees alone don’t cut them down on the flood plain (McAlinden).
Agree
All the above strategies should be implemented
Question 3 Any other comments?
Summary of comments received:
Long term benefits over short term cheap/ quick fixes
Appreciate Andrew’s work and explanation of this great project
Stop the government cut down the trees at McAlinden on the flood plain for the Collie River.
Government salinity program 30 years ago.
What happen to the salinity 30 years ago.
Fantastic initiative, should be done before it is too late.
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 12
7 Appendices Appendix 1 Public Information Session Presentation
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Presentation format
The Site
Scope
Background to the site
Current state & management Recommendations
Existing conditions
Existing conditions Vision
Public comment
Questions
2008 ReportVision
BACKGROUND ACTIONS
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Introduction
The Site The Collie River is a major river system flowing through the town of Collie in southwest of Western Australia.
After a major flood event in 1963/64 an 8km stretch of the Collie River which runs through the town, was retrained, deepened, widened and fringing vegetation removed.
The river has been impacted by a range of land-uses and significantly modified over the past 120 years.
The river has significant environmental and cultural value for the people of Col-lie.
The Shire of Collie (Shire) commis-sioned GFG Consulting (GFG) to update the Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008 to a strategic document.
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Purpose and Scope
The purpose of the update of the Collie River Revitalisation Plan 2008 (CRRP 2008) was to reflect the chang-es impacting the river and banks and to create a shared vision for the river into the future.
The primary focus of CRRP 2008 was the establishment of environmental flows and management of nardoo. This update focuses on the changes impacting the river since the CRRP 2008 and any anticipated changes over the next 5 years.
The update included gathering and collation of information from a wide variety of stakeholders, wide commu-nity consultation, and field investiga-tions. The update particularly focuses on the stretch of dredged river with-in the town just above Lynn Street Bridge to Robert’s Rocks, a distance of around 12 km,
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Vision for the River
The Vision for the Collie River is to develop and implement strategies to improve the health and amenity of the river including; enhancing community experience, reducing nutrient runoff, increasing biodiversity, managing weed species and improving water quality. These strategies benefit not only the local community but also those accessing water further downstream, whilst increasing public amenity to the river.
The Vision will be achieved by:
• Developing and implementing the Shire river foreshore rehabilitation strategy.• Acknowledging and preserving the various recreational pursuits associated with the river (fishing, canoeing etc).• Ensure the identified sections of the river remain aesthetically appealing which recognises and promotes the river as a community asset.,• Recognise and conserve the Aboriginal cultural history associated with the river.
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Background to site
Catchment Description
Climate Change
Geomorphic Setting
Aboriginal Heritage Vegetation
Climate
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Existing Condition of the River
DredgingDue to flooding in the 1960s, the river has been dredged through the town site, removing the historical series of pools and replacing them with a steep-sided channel
NutrientsNitrogen levels higher downstream of town
Phosphates levels low and constant
Shire has built some biofilter basins and should be monitered for performance
RetentionVenn Street weir Roberts Rocks weir Mininup pool created by weirRiffles near Lynn Street and Soldiers Park
WeedsThe rivers reshaped banks have become colonised with weeds
The river channel has been colonised by Nardoo (Marsilea mutica)
Nardoo has been reduced through a successful Shire spraying program.
FaunaDue to the variability in sensitivity to pollution, macroinvertebrates, fish and crayfish make good biological indicators.
Sampling macroinvertebrates com-munities for the types and numbers of animals present can indicate the health of a river.
SalinityLand clearing in the eastern and southern portion of the catchment has led to dry land salinity, this has led to increased saline water flowing into to streams.
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Existing Condition of the River
Ground waterHistorically, in the Collie Basin the river was a system of interconnected pools watered from upstream springs and aquifers.
PoolsThe potential negative effects on the pools were initially obscured by the coal companies disposing their mine water to the rivers along with saline water from the Muja Power Station Mine dewatering started impacting on the groundwater levels since the 1950s as a result of increased coal mining in 1952 from those seams of the Muja Coal Measures at Western 2 that lie beneath the river pools.
Collie Water ProposalThe Collie Water Proposal is a public-private partnership driven by Collie Water which proposes to take saline water from the Collie River, retain it in a mine void, treat it in a desalination plant and sell the potable water to Wa-tercorp. This will improve the quality of water flowing down the river, as the more saline water will be removed and increase the supply of potable water. This is anticipated to have an impact on the volumes of water in the river.
A secondary proposal is to replace the upstream pasture areas with plan-tations and forest to further reduce the salinity of the water. New planta-tion forest areas would be created downstream below the Wellington Dam. Replacing the upstream pasture areas will reduce surface water runoff in the river, if done on a broad scale. It is proposed to thin existing upstream forests to counter this effect.
River FlowFactors which are anticipated to reduce the volume of water flow-ing in the river are climate change and changes in available water due to farming. Saline water runoff has increased with the historic deforest-ation of the upper reaches of the catchment.
Dewater flow to be redirected for power station use within six months.
Mine dewatering from Premier Coal entering the Collie River.
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Recommendations from 2008 report
Establishment of environmental flows - Nardoo control
Seasonal River Stop management
Water monitoring
Sediment control
Pemanent removal of stop boards - use riffles
Restoration of riparian vegeta-tion
Mechanical or Chemical control of Nardoo
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Current State and Management
The results show that the reduction in summer flows from current with mine dewater input and no diversion of the Collie River East Branch to the projected scenario of no mine dewater input with diversion of the Collie River East Branch is around 71%. This suggests that the large portion of the flow is directly attributable to dewater dis-posal during summer. In contrast the reduction in winter is less significant with a 34% reduction. Mine dewatering has artificially increased the monthly average flow over this time. Once the mine dewatering ceases the river will revert to seasonal conditions that occurred prior to dis-charge of mine dewatering. The results do not consider aquifer recharge.
River Flow
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Current State and Management
Decline in water quality in the Collie River study area has been an issue. There has been various monitoring carried out within the study area by various organisations. However, there is a lack of a continuous structured quality con-trolled (QA/QC) monitoring programs in the study area. Furthermore, the monitoring program is required to be con-sistent and carried out for a significant time period.
It is recommended that the Shire develop and implement a monitoring program for salinity, water level, Phosphorus, and Nitrogen
Water Quality
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Current State and Management
Since the release of plan in 2008 the Shire has been successfully managing Nardoo within the study area. Reglone Hydrogel is used annually in autumn to con-trol Nardoo along the entire stretch of river within the town. Spraying is conducted twice within two weeks to ensure maximum effectiveness.
The Shire is implementing several environmental re-habilitation management plans including, Jack Mears Spring Rehabilitation Landscape Management Plan. The Shire is also currently working on a priority sec-tion of the river in the main town of Collie targeting the removal of weeds and the replanting of the fore-shore with native seedlings. The priority weeds tar-geted are nardoo, Watsonia and Bulrush which out compete native vegetation and in turn impact the wa-ter quality, environmental diversity and native fauna
Nardoo Control Riparian Restoration
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Current State and Management
It is recommended that access be managed so as to reduce large exposed sandy areas and create narrower tracks for the Public to access the bank.
Public access and erosion
‘Sandy’ exposed bank Munglup Bridge exposed bank
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Current State and Management
Good quality remanent vegetation still exists in the study area.
Revegetation of degraded areas will enhance the ecological value of the study area.
Remnant vegetation
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Nutrient levels have been measured below and above the town site.
The Shire has built a series of Biofiltration basins, which are a good solution for stripping pollutants from drains
Drainage management
Current State and Management
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
The Collie River Revitalisation Strategy 2018 to 2022 should be reviewed annually for progress to measure the recommendation and performance against the strategy.
The strategy should be fully reviewed in 2022.
Review
Current State and Management
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Recommendations
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Recommendations
WATER LEVEL
DRAINAGE
RESTORATION
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND EDUCATION
LIAISON
ACCESS AND EROSION MANAGEMENTWATER
QUALITY
WATER LEVEL
ACTIONCATEGORY OUTCOME
Improve the health and amenity of the river. Ensure the identified sections of the river remain aesthetically appealing which recognises and promotes the river as a community asset.
DRAINAGE
RESTORATION
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND EDUCATION
LIAISON
ACCESS AND EROSION MANAGEMENT
Improve the health and amenity of the river.
Improve the health and amenity of the river.
Improve the health and amenity of the river.
Enhancing community experience Improve the health and amenity of the river.
Recognise and conserve the Aboriginal cultural history associated with the river.
Improve the health and amenity of the river.
Improve the health and amenity of the river.
Three possible options exist. The construction and use of river gates at Venn Street and/or con-struct riffles, or a ‘living’ river concept to regenerate the river back to a more functioning riverine ecosystem.
• Undertake installation of biofiltration basins in accordance with the recommendation from CENRM 2016.• Once these have been constructed carry out another review of nutrient and pollutant levels from drains and prioritise actions accordingly.
• Monitor nitrogen, phosphorus, salinity, and Reglone spray at Lynn Street Bridge and Roberts Rocks boards (see monitoring table below).• Monitor water level in mAHD at the following locations:• Just below Lynn Street bridge • Venn St River Boards• Minningup Pool• Roberts Rocks
• Continue Nardoo control with Reglone Hydrogel. Renew clearing permit from the DWER for Nardoo control.• Develop and implement the Shire rehabilitation strategy for the study area. • Integrate the strategy into the Shire five year works programme. • Ensure that the section of the river foreshore where weeds are removed are replanted with native seedlings and maintained regularly.
• Support Friends of Collie River group in the implementation of the strategy.• Regularly inform the community of the progress of the implementation of the CRRS. This can be achieved by using various communication mediums such as social media, print media, radio interviews, the Shire website and on-site signage.• Engage with the indigenous community on progress of the implementation of the CRRS. • Consideration is required by the Shire to review and reduce fertiliser load into the river. It is recommended that the Shire also work with the Collie Golf Course and other large businesses to reduce nutrient input into the river.
• Investigate access and erosion issues in the study area such as ‘Sandy’ and Mungalup Bridge. • Prioritise and manage issues accordingly.
• The Collie Shire to work with other Local Government Agencies, Industry, Government Agencies, and Community groups on river management issues.
• It is recommended that the Shire also advocate to ensure that the values of the river are protected in any future developments.
WATER QUALITY
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Draft Report - Public comment
Q.1 Interventions to manage river water levels
Do you have a preference on which of the above methods is used to retain flow?
With the cessation of mine de-watering and decreasing rainfall, the river flow is likely to reduce. To ensure water is retained, it is recommended that the Shire consider interventions that assist in retaining water during dry periods.
In order to manage the water level there are three options available to the Shire. These include 1) construction of river gates at Venn Street and/or 2) construct riffles, or 3) a ‘living’ river concept to regenerate the river back to a more functioning riverine ecosystem.
Q.2 The vision for Collie River
Do you wish to make comments on this vision?
The vision for the Collie River outlines a number of strategies that will benefit not only the local community but also those accessing water further downstream, whilst increasing public amenity to the river.
These strategies include:
• Develop and implement the Shire river foreshore rehabilitation strategy.• Acknowledge and preserve the various recreational pursuits associated with the river (fishing, canoeing etc.).• Ensure the identified sections of the river remain aesthetically appealing which recognises and promotes the river as a community asset.• Recognise and conserve the Aboriginal cultural history associated with the river.
Q.3 Any other comments?
THE DRAFT COLLIE RIVER REVITALISATION STRATEGY 2018 -2022
Questions
All questions directed to the presenters by, show of hand.
Only person to speak at any time.
State your name and any relevant organisation you may represent.
Limit of 1 minute to each questioner.
Questions directly related to the study area, only.
Thanks for your input!
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 13
Appendix 2 Public Comments
GFGCONSULTING
ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-005_C 14
Appendix 3 Public Comments Collie Central Shopping Centre
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 52
Appendix 2 Riparian Revegetation Suggestion
From SOC 2010b
Common name Scientific name Wetland zone Depth below summer water level (m)
Sparse Twig Rush Baumea arthrophylla
Damp zone to 1minto emergent zone
1.0
JointedTwig Rush Baumea articulata Damp zone to 1minto emergent zone -can tolerate low water levels.
1.0
Native Bullrush Typha domingensis Damp zone to inundation of 1m
1.0
Sharpleaf Club Rush(1)
Schoenoplectus pungens
Damp zone to 40cminto emergent zone
0.4
Sheath Twig Rush Baumea vaginalis Damp zone to 40cminto emergent zone
0.4
Spike Rush Eleocharis acuta Damp zone to 30cminto emergent zone
0.3
Shore Rush Juncus kraussii Damp zone to 30cminto emergent zone
0.3
Broad Twig Rush Baumea preissii Damp zone to 30cminto emergent zone
0.3
Bare Twig Rush Baumea juncea Ephemeral zone to 30cm into emergent zone
0.3
Tassell Sedge Carex fasicularis Ephemeral zone to 20cm into emergent zone
0.2
River Twig Rush Baumea rubiginosa Ephemeral zone to 20cm into emergent zone
0.2
Marsh Club Rush Bolboschoenus caldwellii Ephemeral zone to 20cm into emergent zone
0.2
Pithy Sword Sedge Lepidosperma longitundinale
Ephemeral zone to 20cm into emergent zone
0.2
Tall Sedge Carex appressa Damp zone to 10cm into submergent zone
0.1
GFGCONSULTING ABN 94 156 452 050
Unit 22A, 7 The Esplanade Website: www.glenfloodgroup.com.au
Mount Pleasant WA 6153 Phone: (08) 9367 3074 Document No: Q23062017-004_I 53
Appendix 3 Further Information on Collie Water Project
Further information on the Collie Water Project can be found on https://www.colliewater.com.au or contact
Collie Water at [email protected].