52
DevelopmentPlan SOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE May 2013 Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

1

South Worcestershire Development Plan

Regulation 22 (1)(c)(v) Statement of Representations

Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004

The Town and Country Planning (Planning) (England) Regulations 2012

May 2013

2

Contents

1 Introduction 3

2 Publication under Regulation 19 of the 2012 Regulations 3

3 The Representations 4

31 Number of Representations Received 4

32 Nature of the Representations 4

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations 7

Appendices

1 Regulation 19 Notification Letter

2 Pre Submission Notice under Regulation 19 and Statement of Representations

3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

4 List of Locations where the DPD and associated documents were held

5 List of Representors

3

1 Introduction

11 The three partner authorities Malvern Hills District Council Wychavon District Council and Worcester City submitted the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) to the Secretary of State on 28 May 2013

12 The SWDP has been prepared in accordance with the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 (SI 7672012) and the 2004 Act (as amended) Stages prior to the commencement of the 2012 Regulations were prepared in accordance with legislation pertaining at that time 13 This statement has been prepared in accordance with Regulation 22 (1) (c) (v) of the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 This Statement sets out details of the publication of the SWDP This includes how the publication was undertaken how many representations were received and the main issues that were raised 14 Regulation 22 (1) (c) also requires a statement setting out the representations made at the Regulation 19 stage This requirement is met by the SWDP Consultation Report (May 2013) which was published as a draft alongside the SWDP Proposed Submission Document in January 2013

2 Publication under Regulation 19 of the 2012 Regulations

21 The SWDP Proposed Submission Document was approved by the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo respective Council meetings in December 2012 for publication for the proposed submission consultation from 11 January to 22 February 2013

22 Notification of the publication was sent by post and e-mail to all 3200 bodies and individuals on the SWDP database including all the extant specific and general consultation bodies listed in the Statements of Community Involvement This set out how copies of the relevant documentation submission forms and explanatory notes could be accessed and how to submit and the deadline for submission of representations A copy of the text in the lettere-mail to the consultees is provided at Appendix 1

23 A notice was placed in the Worcester News Droitwich Advertiser Malvern Gazette Tenbury Advertiser and Evesham Journal on 10 January 2013 setting out the Statement of Representations Procedure (Appendix 2) The notice was also placed on the councilsrsquo and SWDP website A press statement was sent to local newspapers and the local press published articles from the week ending 11 January 2013 An example from the Worcester Standard (11113) is reproduced in Appendix 3 which provides details about the document and by when representations should be received

24 Copies of the Proposed Submission Document and other supporting material were placed on deposit at the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo council offices local libraries and customer contact centres across the SWDP area Representation forms and

4

guidance notes for their completion were also made available in the locations listed at Appendix 4 All of the relevant documents were published on the SWDP website linked to the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo websites Opportunity was also provided to make comments on-line via the consultation portal on the SWDP website

3 The Representations

31 The Number of Representations Received

592 bodies or individuals made representations (Appendix 5) A number of bodies and individuals responded after the deadline including the Environment Agency and English Heritage

Of the 5921 representors 1751 separate representations (or individual comments) were made Of these 234 were received via the web 485 by letter and 1031 by e-mail with 11 through lsquootherrsquo means A number of representors did not use the representation forms (or on-line facility) and these representors tended not to indicate whether they considered the Proposed Submission Document to be legally compliant sound or if they wished to attend the Examination Hearings

32 The Nature of the representations

321 The 592 Representors

Although it is difficult to categorise the responses the following breakdown gives a general indication of the profile of those submitting representations

Overall picture

381 representors were individuals including a small number of district and county councillors (8)

20 representors were community groups

144 representors were developers landowners and businesses

16 representors were statutory agencies

13 representors were townparish councils

18 representors were interest groupsorganisations

370 or 625 of representors indicated they wish to participate at the hearing sessions of the Examination

1 The overall numbers of responses differs slightly to that given in the Consultation Report (May 2013) due to

further refinement of the database between publication of the documents

5

Representor Type

6

322 Legal Compliance

Of the 1751 individual representations

727 representations stated that they found the Plan to be legally compliant

463 representations stated that they did not find the Plan to be legally compliant

561 did not state whether they considered the Plan legally compliant or not

323 Test of Soundness

Of the 1751 individual representations

144 representations stated that they considered the Plan sound

1415 representations stated that they considered the Plan unsound

192 representations did not state whether they considered the Plan sound or not

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 2: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

1

South Worcestershire Development Plan

Regulation 22 (1)(c)(v) Statement of Representations

Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004

The Town and Country Planning (Planning) (England) Regulations 2012

May 2013

2

Contents

1 Introduction 3

2 Publication under Regulation 19 of the 2012 Regulations 3

3 The Representations 4

31 Number of Representations Received 4

32 Nature of the Representations 4

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations 7

Appendices

1 Regulation 19 Notification Letter

2 Pre Submission Notice under Regulation 19 and Statement of Representations

3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

4 List of Locations where the DPD and associated documents were held

5 List of Representors

3

1 Introduction

11 The three partner authorities Malvern Hills District Council Wychavon District Council and Worcester City submitted the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) to the Secretary of State on 28 May 2013

12 The SWDP has been prepared in accordance with the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 (SI 7672012) and the 2004 Act (as amended) Stages prior to the commencement of the 2012 Regulations were prepared in accordance with legislation pertaining at that time 13 This statement has been prepared in accordance with Regulation 22 (1) (c) (v) of the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 This Statement sets out details of the publication of the SWDP This includes how the publication was undertaken how many representations were received and the main issues that were raised 14 Regulation 22 (1) (c) also requires a statement setting out the representations made at the Regulation 19 stage This requirement is met by the SWDP Consultation Report (May 2013) which was published as a draft alongside the SWDP Proposed Submission Document in January 2013

2 Publication under Regulation 19 of the 2012 Regulations

21 The SWDP Proposed Submission Document was approved by the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo respective Council meetings in December 2012 for publication for the proposed submission consultation from 11 January to 22 February 2013

22 Notification of the publication was sent by post and e-mail to all 3200 bodies and individuals on the SWDP database including all the extant specific and general consultation bodies listed in the Statements of Community Involvement This set out how copies of the relevant documentation submission forms and explanatory notes could be accessed and how to submit and the deadline for submission of representations A copy of the text in the lettere-mail to the consultees is provided at Appendix 1

23 A notice was placed in the Worcester News Droitwich Advertiser Malvern Gazette Tenbury Advertiser and Evesham Journal on 10 January 2013 setting out the Statement of Representations Procedure (Appendix 2) The notice was also placed on the councilsrsquo and SWDP website A press statement was sent to local newspapers and the local press published articles from the week ending 11 January 2013 An example from the Worcester Standard (11113) is reproduced in Appendix 3 which provides details about the document and by when representations should be received

24 Copies of the Proposed Submission Document and other supporting material were placed on deposit at the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo council offices local libraries and customer contact centres across the SWDP area Representation forms and

4

guidance notes for their completion were also made available in the locations listed at Appendix 4 All of the relevant documents were published on the SWDP website linked to the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo websites Opportunity was also provided to make comments on-line via the consultation portal on the SWDP website

3 The Representations

31 The Number of Representations Received

592 bodies or individuals made representations (Appendix 5) A number of bodies and individuals responded after the deadline including the Environment Agency and English Heritage

Of the 5921 representors 1751 separate representations (or individual comments) were made Of these 234 were received via the web 485 by letter and 1031 by e-mail with 11 through lsquootherrsquo means A number of representors did not use the representation forms (or on-line facility) and these representors tended not to indicate whether they considered the Proposed Submission Document to be legally compliant sound or if they wished to attend the Examination Hearings

32 The Nature of the representations

321 The 592 Representors

Although it is difficult to categorise the responses the following breakdown gives a general indication of the profile of those submitting representations

Overall picture

381 representors were individuals including a small number of district and county councillors (8)

20 representors were community groups

144 representors were developers landowners and businesses

16 representors were statutory agencies

13 representors were townparish councils

18 representors were interest groupsorganisations

370 or 625 of representors indicated they wish to participate at the hearing sessions of the Examination

1 The overall numbers of responses differs slightly to that given in the Consultation Report (May 2013) due to

further refinement of the database between publication of the documents

5

Representor Type

6

322 Legal Compliance

Of the 1751 individual representations

727 representations stated that they found the Plan to be legally compliant

463 representations stated that they did not find the Plan to be legally compliant

561 did not state whether they considered the Plan legally compliant or not

323 Test of Soundness

Of the 1751 individual representations

144 representations stated that they considered the Plan sound

1415 representations stated that they considered the Plan unsound

192 representations did not state whether they considered the Plan sound or not

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 3: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

2

Contents

1 Introduction 3

2 Publication under Regulation 19 of the 2012 Regulations 3

3 The Representations 4

31 Number of Representations Received 4

32 Nature of the Representations 4

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations 7

Appendices

1 Regulation 19 Notification Letter

2 Pre Submission Notice under Regulation 19 and Statement of Representations

3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

4 List of Locations where the DPD and associated documents were held

5 List of Representors

3

1 Introduction

11 The three partner authorities Malvern Hills District Council Wychavon District Council and Worcester City submitted the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) to the Secretary of State on 28 May 2013

12 The SWDP has been prepared in accordance with the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 (SI 7672012) and the 2004 Act (as amended) Stages prior to the commencement of the 2012 Regulations were prepared in accordance with legislation pertaining at that time 13 This statement has been prepared in accordance with Regulation 22 (1) (c) (v) of the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 This Statement sets out details of the publication of the SWDP This includes how the publication was undertaken how many representations were received and the main issues that were raised 14 Regulation 22 (1) (c) also requires a statement setting out the representations made at the Regulation 19 stage This requirement is met by the SWDP Consultation Report (May 2013) which was published as a draft alongside the SWDP Proposed Submission Document in January 2013

2 Publication under Regulation 19 of the 2012 Regulations

21 The SWDP Proposed Submission Document was approved by the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo respective Council meetings in December 2012 for publication for the proposed submission consultation from 11 January to 22 February 2013

22 Notification of the publication was sent by post and e-mail to all 3200 bodies and individuals on the SWDP database including all the extant specific and general consultation bodies listed in the Statements of Community Involvement This set out how copies of the relevant documentation submission forms and explanatory notes could be accessed and how to submit and the deadline for submission of representations A copy of the text in the lettere-mail to the consultees is provided at Appendix 1

23 A notice was placed in the Worcester News Droitwich Advertiser Malvern Gazette Tenbury Advertiser and Evesham Journal on 10 January 2013 setting out the Statement of Representations Procedure (Appendix 2) The notice was also placed on the councilsrsquo and SWDP website A press statement was sent to local newspapers and the local press published articles from the week ending 11 January 2013 An example from the Worcester Standard (11113) is reproduced in Appendix 3 which provides details about the document and by when representations should be received

24 Copies of the Proposed Submission Document and other supporting material were placed on deposit at the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo council offices local libraries and customer contact centres across the SWDP area Representation forms and

4

guidance notes for their completion were also made available in the locations listed at Appendix 4 All of the relevant documents were published on the SWDP website linked to the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo websites Opportunity was also provided to make comments on-line via the consultation portal on the SWDP website

3 The Representations

31 The Number of Representations Received

592 bodies or individuals made representations (Appendix 5) A number of bodies and individuals responded after the deadline including the Environment Agency and English Heritage

Of the 5921 representors 1751 separate representations (or individual comments) were made Of these 234 were received via the web 485 by letter and 1031 by e-mail with 11 through lsquootherrsquo means A number of representors did not use the representation forms (or on-line facility) and these representors tended not to indicate whether they considered the Proposed Submission Document to be legally compliant sound or if they wished to attend the Examination Hearings

32 The Nature of the representations

321 The 592 Representors

Although it is difficult to categorise the responses the following breakdown gives a general indication of the profile of those submitting representations

Overall picture

381 representors were individuals including a small number of district and county councillors (8)

20 representors were community groups

144 representors were developers landowners and businesses

16 representors were statutory agencies

13 representors were townparish councils

18 representors were interest groupsorganisations

370 or 625 of representors indicated they wish to participate at the hearing sessions of the Examination

1 The overall numbers of responses differs slightly to that given in the Consultation Report (May 2013) due to

further refinement of the database between publication of the documents

5

Representor Type

6

322 Legal Compliance

Of the 1751 individual representations

727 representations stated that they found the Plan to be legally compliant

463 representations stated that they did not find the Plan to be legally compliant

561 did not state whether they considered the Plan legally compliant or not

323 Test of Soundness

Of the 1751 individual representations

144 representations stated that they considered the Plan sound

1415 representations stated that they considered the Plan unsound

192 representations did not state whether they considered the Plan sound or not

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 4: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

3

1 Introduction

11 The three partner authorities Malvern Hills District Council Wychavon District Council and Worcester City submitted the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) to the Secretary of State on 28 May 2013

12 The SWDP has been prepared in accordance with the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 (SI 7672012) and the 2004 Act (as amended) Stages prior to the commencement of the 2012 Regulations were prepared in accordance with legislation pertaining at that time 13 This statement has been prepared in accordance with Regulation 22 (1) (c) (v) of the Town and Country Planning (Local Development) (England) Regulations 2012 This Statement sets out details of the publication of the SWDP This includes how the publication was undertaken how many representations were received and the main issues that were raised 14 Regulation 22 (1) (c) also requires a statement setting out the representations made at the Regulation 19 stage This requirement is met by the SWDP Consultation Report (May 2013) which was published as a draft alongside the SWDP Proposed Submission Document in January 2013

2 Publication under Regulation 19 of the 2012 Regulations

21 The SWDP Proposed Submission Document was approved by the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo respective Council meetings in December 2012 for publication for the proposed submission consultation from 11 January to 22 February 2013

22 Notification of the publication was sent by post and e-mail to all 3200 bodies and individuals on the SWDP database including all the extant specific and general consultation bodies listed in the Statements of Community Involvement This set out how copies of the relevant documentation submission forms and explanatory notes could be accessed and how to submit and the deadline for submission of representations A copy of the text in the lettere-mail to the consultees is provided at Appendix 1

23 A notice was placed in the Worcester News Droitwich Advertiser Malvern Gazette Tenbury Advertiser and Evesham Journal on 10 January 2013 setting out the Statement of Representations Procedure (Appendix 2) The notice was also placed on the councilsrsquo and SWDP website A press statement was sent to local newspapers and the local press published articles from the week ending 11 January 2013 An example from the Worcester Standard (11113) is reproduced in Appendix 3 which provides details about the document and by when representations should be received

24 Copies of the Proposed Submission Document and other supporting material were placed on deposit at the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo council offices local libraries and customer contact centres across the SWDP area Representation forms and

4

guidance notes for their completion were also made available in the locations listed at Appendix 4 All of the relevant documents were published on the SWDP website linked to the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo websites Opportunity was also provided to make comments on-line via the consultation portal on the SWDP website

3 The Representations

31 The Number of Representations Received

592 bodies or individuals made representations (Appendix 5) A number of bodies and individuals responded after the deadline including the Environment Agency and English Heritage

Of the 5921 representors 1751 separate representations (or individual comments) were made Of these 234 were received via the web 485 by letter and 1031 by e-mail with 11 through lsquootherrsquo means A number of representors did not use the representation forms (or on-line facility) and these representors tended not to indicate whether they considered the Proposed Submission Document to be legally compliant sound or if they wished to attend the Examination Hearings

32 The Nature of the representations

321 The 592 Representors

Although it is difficult to categorise the responses the following breakdown gives a general indication of the profile of those submitting representations

Overall picture

381 representors were individuals including a small number of district and county councillors (8)

20 representors were community groups

144 representors were developers landowners and businesses

16 representors were statutory agencies

13 representors were townparish councils

18 representors were interest groupsorganisations

370 or 625 of representors indicated they wish to participate at the hearing sessions of the Examination

1 The overall numbers of responses differs slightly to that given in the Consultation Report (May 2013) due to

further refinement of the database between publication of the documents

5

Representor Type

6

322 Legal Compliance

Of the 1751 individual representations

727 representations stated that they found the Plan to be legally compliant

463 representations stated that they did not find the Plan to be legally compliant

561 did not state whether they considered the Plan legally compliant or not

323 Test of Soundness

Of the 1751 individual representations

144 representations stated that they considered the Plan sound

1415 representations stated that they considered the Plan unsound

192 representations did not state whether they considered the Plan sound or not

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 5: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

4

guidance notes for their completion were also made available in the locations listed at Appendix 4 All of the relevant documents were published on the SWDP website linked to the 3 partner authoritiesrsquo websites Opportunity was also provided to make comments on-line via the consultation portal on the SWDP website

3 The Representations

31 The Number of Representations Received

592 bodies or individuals made representations (Appendix 5) A number of bodies and individuals responded after the deadline including the Environment Agency and English Heritage

Of the 5921 representors 1751 separate representations (or individual comments) were made Of these 234 were received via the web 485 by letter and 1031 by e-mail with 11 through lsquootherrsquo means A number of representors did not use the representation forms (or on-line facility) and these representors tended not to indicate whether they considered the Proposed Submission Document to be legally compliant sound or if they wished to attend the Examination Hearings

32 The Nature of the representations

321 The 592 Representors

Although it is difficult to categorise the responses the following breakdown gives a general indication of the profile of those submitting representations

Overall picture

381 representors were individuals including a small number of district and county councillors (8)

20 representors were community groups

144 representors were developers landowners and businesses

16 representors were statutory agencies

13 representors were townparish councils

18 representors were interest groupsorganisations

370 or 625 of representors indicated they wish to participate at the hearing sessions of the Examination

1 The overall numbers of responses differs slightly to that given in the Consultation Report (May 2013) due to

further refinement of the database between publication of the documents

5

Representor Type

6

322 Legal Compliance

Of the 1751 individual representations

727 representations stated that they found the Plan to be legally compliant

463 representations stated that they did not find the Plan to be legally compliant

561 did not state whether they considered the Plan legally compliant or not

323 Test of Soundness

Of the 1751 individual representations

144 representations stated that they considered the Plan sound

1415 representations stated that they considered the Plan unsound

192 representations did not state whether they considered the Plan sound or not

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 6: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

5

Representor Type

6

322 Legal Compliance

Of the 1751 individual representations

727 representations stated that they found the Plan to be legally compliant

463 representations stated that they did not find the Plan to be legally compliant

561 did not state whether they considered the Plan legally compliant or not

323 Test of Soundness

Of the 1751 individual representations

144 representations stated that they considered the Plan sound

1415 representations stated that they considered the Plan unsound

192 representations did not state whether they considered the Plan sound or not

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 7: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

6

322 Legal Compliance

Of the 1751 individual representations

727 representations stated that they found the Plan to be legally compliant

463 representations stated that they did not find the Plan to be legally compliant

561 did not state whether they considered the Plan legally compliant or not

323 Test of Soundness

Of the 1751 individual representations

144 representations stated that they considered the Plan sound

1415 representations stated that they considered the Plan unsound

192 representations did not state whether they considered the Plan sound or not

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 8: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

7

Break down of the Test of Soundness

Of the 1415 individual representations that considered the Plan unsound

1057 found the Plan content to be not Justified

885 found the Plan content to be not Effective

986 found the Plan content to be not Consistent with national policy

772 found the Plan content to be not Positively prepared

33 The Main Issues Raised in the Representations

The summaries below indicate the main issues raised in the representations These do not attempt to cover all the issues raised or the detailed comments made Copies of representations are available to view in full separately or via the following link [httpwwwswdevelopmentplanorgpage_id=5804]

Consultation Process

A number of representors raised concerns about the consultation process

A number of representors suggested the consultation process was not genuine as matters had been ldquopre-determinedrdquo

The partner authorities wholly reject the claims that consultation has not been undertaken correctly They are strongly of the view that they have met the consultation commitments of their adopted Statements of Community Involvement and the legislation prevailing now and at the time This included full and ample opportunities for the public to engage in the plan-making process enabling them to feedback views to the Councils Those views were

Representations that considered the Plan

unsound because it is not

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 9: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

8

reported to the Councils in a timely way throughout the plan-making stages This enabled the Councils to take those representations into account when making decisions about the plan

Furthermore the partner authorities consider that the consultation has been genuine and reject the claim that matters have been pre-determined Not only have the Councils examined alternative options and consulted on those but has they also actively invited alternative options for consideration The Councils have objectively assessed and considered alternatives The carry forward of options through the plan making stages and the rejection of other options has been undertaken in accordance with wholly appropriate democratic decision making processes consistent with the Councilsrsquo

constitutions

A number of representors felt that the Proposed Submission SWDP did not take account of the view of majority of people in Malvern

A number of representors felt that their representations at earlier plan-making stages had not been properly responded to

There were a small number of representations which could be seen to suggest improper conduct on the part of officers or members in Malvern Hills District

Some representors suggested that the decision process by Malvern Hills District Council in approving the proposed submission document for publication and subsequent examination was legally flawed Specifically these representations considered that the decision-making process at Malvern Hills District Council was legally flawed

The South Worcestershire Councils and specifically Malvern Hills District Council consider there is no merit in these claims in legal terms and the Council stands by the process undertaken The correct avenue for a challenge to the way this decision was made would have been through judicial review no such application was made within the deadline for making such a claim The Council also notes that a small number of representors have raised questions around officer and Councillor conduct and objectivity Although the Council is concerned with the content of these representations it does not consider that legalisation and guidance permit it to regard these representations as worded as inadmissible and would not wish to deny these representors the opportunity to have their representations on the SWDP considered by the inspector As such these representations have been accepted as duly made The Council has not received any formal complaints regarding officer or councillor handling of the SWDP as part of its own internal complaints procedure regarding these matters

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 10: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

9

Vision and Objectives

Broad support however differing views expressed that it should be delivering either a more detailed location specific approach or that it should be more uplifting

Spatial Context

Broad support with no substantial issues identified

A new Plan for South Worcestershire

No substantial issues identified

Strategic Policies (SWDP 1-7)

SWDP1 Overarching Sustainability Principles

Several representations that the policy wording is not supportive of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)

SWDP2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy

A balance of representations arguing that either more or less residential development should be directed to the rural areas

Promotion of Throckmorton Airfield (near Pershore) as a free standing settlement

Promotion of a site at Mitton near Tewkesbury to meet the neighbouring local authorities (Tewkesbury Borough Council) housing need along with the identification of the town of Tewkesbury as a main town in the development hierarchy

SWDP3 Employment Housing and Retail Provision Requirements and Delivery

1 Scale of housing provision

RSS conformity ndash whether it should or should not conform Should plan use locally derived target or rely on West Midlands RSS Panel

Report or evidence Does the Strategic Housing Market Area (SHMA) and plan make use of

national projections (CLG household projections - 2008 based or 2011 based) ONS 2010 population projections2011 mid year estimates 2011 census

Will migration patterns change as the result of future lifting of restrictions on EU members (Romanian Bulgarian) or economic up-turn

Why not use alternative methodologies models

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 11: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

10

Is the SHMA (2012) robust eg use of AWM economic projections use of local housing data

Why choice of SHMA Sensitivity Scenario 2 o is there a lack of evidence to justify assuming higher economic activity

rates in older age groups o what are the implications eg are there sufficient economically active

available to fill job growth forecast Is the proportion of housing growth in the 3 Sub Areas correct Is there a lack of evidence of impact on housing development on Malvern Hills

AONB (questioning the reason to justify redirection of displaced demand - from Malvern Hills need to Wider Worcester Area and Wychavon)

What scale of unmet housing need is there in other areas outside the plan area and should this be met in south Worcestershire and are there Framework compliant grounds for not meeting this need

Should plan period start in 2011 or later (instead of 2006) Is plan review an admission that the policy provision and supply is

inadequate Should housing target be much higher 27000 to 36000 (instead of 23200) Is provision consistent with the Framework Is forecast of market housing and of affordable housing target robust Will improvement in the economy lead to higher rate of social relets (or are

there other reasons why relets will stay at a low level) Should housing allocations be phased (generally or site specific eg the latter

in step with employment land development) Will infrastructure delivery constrain housing development

2 Supply Supply components

o Should not include empty homes or release of C3 housing when C2 extra care (high care package) accommodation is first occupied

o Is there compelling evidence of future windfall delivery o Has sufficient discount for commitments been made ndash should be 10 o Queries on delivery of allocations (various reasons cited) ndash should these

also have a 10 discount Supply forecast

o Housing trajectories are too optimistic or too pessimistic o 5 year supply ndash should use Sedgefield approach (address previous

delivery gap in first 5 years) not residual method (Liverpool approach) and should buffer be 5 or 20

Is provision consistent with the Framework ie boosting supply

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 12: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

11

Affordable Housing Supply forecast o What qualifies as affordable housing

3 Employment What is the appropriate basis for the employment land target (forecasts

before or during the recent challenging economic circumstances Have the targets been justified Is the employment land supply adequate does it provide too much

flexibility and choice Will the employment land particularly the Worcester Technology Park

result in adverse impact on job creation in the West Midlands conurbation (including the Black Country)

Should employment sites be far more flexible eg no constraints on the type of employment

Should key sectors be targeted eg High Tech Is the balance of employment between the Sub Areas correct Should employment land be phased (generally or site specific) Will infrastructure development constrain employment development

4 Retail Should the plan area and in particular Worcester aim to try to increase its

market share and draw trade from a wider arearecapture lost expenditure Is the retail evidence sufficiently up to date ndash does it take account of

changes to retailing and the High Street Forecasts are only to 2026 should more provision be included to take plan

to 2030 and additional sites allocated or allowed Should retail site allocations be more flexible should retail be allowed on

employment sites (existing and allocated) Does supply amp target constrain the ability to strengthen the centres or to

support regeneration elsewhere or promote growth will there be sufficient choice

Should improvement be qualitative

SWDP4 Moving Around South Worcestershire

Reliance in the policy on the Local Transport Plan and elevation of this document to policy status also reference to requirements of transport assessments rather than relying on national guidance Wellbeck and St Modwen

Numerous comments submitted on SWDP4 relate to SWDP7 and the Infrastructure Delivery Plan

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 13: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

12

SWDP5 Green Infrastructure

Broad support for the principle of green infrastructure planning however some developers consider the 40 (plus gardens) threshold is nonviable

SWDP6 Historic Environment

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

Object to inclusion of local list without supporting justification and indication of weight that should be accorded to them in decision making

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits that may outweigh harm or loss of the heritage asset

Wording of Criterion C is vague and overly restrictive

Greater emphasis needs to be placed on enabling development than that given

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

SWDP7 Infrastructure

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

Economic Growth (SWDP 8-12)

SWDP8 Providing the Right Land and Buildings for Jobs

B1b restriction on development at Malvern Hills Science Park Malvern Hills Science Park

Restriction on retail development on allocated employment sites St Modwen and Spetchley Estate

SWDP9 Creating and Sustaining Vibrant Centres

Policy is in adequate to control the night time economy West Mercia Police

SWDP10 Protection and Promotion of Shopping Choice

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 14: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

13

In flexibility in primary shop fronts St Modwen

No vision for capturing retail expenditure that leaks elsewhere Spetchley Estate (688 693) RCA RegenerationMaximus and Hill and Smith Holdings

SWDP11 Vale of Evesham Heavy Goods Vehicle Control Zone

No significant issues identified

SWDP12 Rural Employment

The policy imposes a requirement to market a site for 2 years in order to prove that the site has become redundant for employment uses Given many smaller rural facilities are not economically viable they should be allowed to revert back to becoming a residential use without having to demonstrate marketing and requiring submission of a planning application SWDP is in conflict with para 22 of the Framework

Criterion (F) lsquoReuse of Rural Buildingsrsquo is not consistent with national policy

The emphasis of this policy to prioritise the reuse and conversion of rural buildings for employment tourism leisure or recreational purposes whenever appropriate is clearly at odds with what the Framework says on this matter The employment policies do not provide sufficient support for proposals that are not within or adjacent to settlements The nature of the existing employment sites in the area do not conform to this pattern (They are promoting a rural employment site)

Housing (SWDP 13-20)

Policy SWDP13 Effective Use of Land

Do the first parts of the policy give sufficient flexibility when considering the application of the standards within the policy

Justification of density standards Are the density standards too high inflexible Impact of density standards combined with the 40 Green Infrastructure

target Is brownfield target onerous and constraining ability to deliver 5 year supply Does lack of Framework policy on prioritising brownfield land means that

policy is inconsistent Best and Most Versatile Land ndash have the councils provided evidence to

differentiate between 3a and 3b Implications of using BMV for food production and security

SWDP14 Housing Mix

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 15: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

14

Findings of SHMA should not be overly relied upon Policy should not be too prescriptive

SWDP15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs

Contrary to Framework - 40 target is not supported by the evidence base is not deliverable and will impact on mix of market homes inhibiting inclusion of smaller properties

Evidence base is out of date and do not take into account the cost implications of all policies now contained in the development plan ndash reliance upon individual site negotiations is unsound

Presumption should not be for social rented ndash contrary to evidence base ndash should be more flexible to allow other affordable housing tenures

SWDP16 Rural Exception Sites

Contrary to Framework ndash does not state that rural exception sites are exceptional cases (1300 1498)

SWDP17 Travellers and Travelling Showpeople

Several respondents highlighted that specific sites had not been identified to meet all of the unmet need for traveller pitches in Malvern Hills and Worcester Whilst others suggested a cautious approach to identifying sites in advance of the Traveller and Travelling Showpeople Site Allocations DPD

The robustness of the Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment (GTAA) was questioned by several respondents

A respondent questioned whether restricting sites within or on edge of settlements was realistic Another respondent suggested that the proximity of Traveller sites to large residential developments could have an adverse impact on housing development viability

A respondent suggested a possible inconsistency between the policy relating to Significant Gaps in SWDP2 and the exception being made for Traveller sites in SWDP 451

SWDP18 Replace Dwellings in the Open Countryside

There were no representations on this policy

SWDP19 Dwellings for rural workers

Planning regulations requiring prospective builders of agricultural dwellings to live in an unsustainable and possibly unhealthy mobile home or similar construction is socially unacceptable and legally suspect

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 16: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

15

The proposed SWDP document contains no precise definition of the economic test discussed in Annex G clause 22 The SWDP should explain why an economic test is needed although the Framework includes no such requirement and has also deleted and revoked PPS7 which was the previous document requiring this test

SWDP20 Housing to Meet the Needs of Older People

C2 sites should be identified

Contrary to Framework and virtually impossible to assess undersupply due to lack of evidence

C2 should count towards affordable housing contribution

Environmental Enhancement and Protection (SWDP 21-25)

SWDP21 Design

Concern that policy imposes a lsquocontemporaryrsquo approach to architecture in preference to any other styles

The policy should not be requiring sustainable build or renewable approaches above and beyond the building regulations

Unrealistic to expect applicant meet all the criteria in the policy

SWDP22 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Policy too restrictive and would prevent development from coming forward

SWDP23 Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty

No significant issues identified

SWDP24 Management of the Historic Environment

Need for the policy wording to recognise that development may achieve substantial public benefits outweighing harm or loss of the heritage asset

Question as to whether two separate policies are required

Inclusion of local lists within the evidence base

SWDP25 Landscape Character

No significant issues identified

Resource Management (SWDP 26-33)

SWDP26 Telecommunications and Broadband

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 17: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

16

No significant issues identified

SWDP27 Renewable and Low Carbon Energy

The aim to reduce CO2 emissions through renewable and low carbon technology was generally supported Several respondents highlighted that building regulations requirements are set to become increasingly challenging over the next few years ultimately demanding ldquozero carbon statusrdquo

The approach of a target based on CO2 reduction was generally supported although some respondents suggested that the policy should simply adopt Building Regulations The use of associated emissions savings towards building regulations compliance was supported

The consideration of technical and financial viability was supported However practical difficulties of producing long-term viability tests for complex major developments were highlighted

Some respondents considered that the same percentage (either 10 or 15) should be applied to all development Some respondents considered the justification to apply a 20 target on urban extensions and large-scale development proposals to be unclear

A respondent highlighted that the Viability Study indicated that strategic sites were worst placed to deliver higher standards

While specific targets for onsite renewable energy were considered quantifiable for residential development several respondents considered the application of targets to commercial uses to be less easy to assess

References to contributions to a carbon offset fund were generally supported in principle but further clarification on the ldquotariffrdquo level and mechanism for receiving and re-investing funds was suggested It was also suggested that contributions to the carbon offset fund should be subject to viability testing - SWDP28 Management of Flood Risk

The Environment Agency expressed concerns regarding a number of housing allocations in areas of higher flood risk

SWDP29 Sustainable Drainage Systems

Several representations suggesting that the SUDs policy should be incorporated into SWDP28

SWDP30 Water Resources Efficiency and Treatment

No significant issues identified

SWDP31 Pollution

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 18: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

17

No significant issues identified

SWDP32 Minerals

Minor amendments were suggested to make it clearer that the policy is not proposing a blanket protection of mineral resources and to make reference to the legacy of coal mining activities in the northern part of Malvern Hills district

SWDP33 Waste

SWDP 33 generally supported

SWDP 33 states that the Waste Core Strategy prepared by Worcestershire County Council is part of the Development Plan SWDP 33 is consistent with the Waste Core Strategy

Tourism amp Leisure (SWDP 34 - 42)

SWDP34 ndash 37 Tourist Development Visitor Accommodation Static and Touring Caravans Chalets and Camping Sites Indoor Leisure and Community Facilities

No significant issues identified

SWDP38 Local Green Network

Issue raised as to the application of the policy on private gardens and implications for lsquopermitted developmentrsquo rights

SWDP39 Provision for Outdoor Community Uses in New Development

No significant issues identified

SWDP40 ndash 42 Waterfronts Marinas and Moorings Residential Moorings

No significant issues identified

Allocations Policies

Worcester City (SWDP 43-45)

Respondent raised doubts over deliverability of specific allocations which would reduce potential housing supply eg SWDP 431 - Lyppard Hill 432 - Gregory Bank 433 - Ribble Close 435 - Wyvern Service Station 436 - Albert Road 437 - Sansome Walk Swimming Pool 439 - Old Brewery Service Station 4313 - Claines Recreation Ground 4316 - Whittington Road 4317 - Cedar Avenue 4321 - Masonic Lodge

SWDP 432 Gregorys Bank ndash extend site area and increase no of dwellings to match planning permission reduce affordable housing

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 19: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

18

SWDP434 Old Northwick Farm

Support for site development

Several representations raising concerns over site boundary (at Old Northwick Farmhouse and it access omission of land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane changes to boundary before Reg 19 stage) loss of agricultural land loss of green infrastructure flood risk access impact on heritage assets loss of biodiversityimpact on habitats proximity to pylons

SWDP 4313 Claines Recreation Ground ndash representation on uses ndash should retain as recreation use

SWDP4315 Worcester Woods ndash extend range of employment uses

SWDP 4318 Grove Farm ndash extend range of uses to match planning permission

SWDP 4323 South of Warndon Woods ndash change the use of the allocated site from employment (B1) to housing

SWDP4320 Nunnery Way ndash more restriction over scale and standard of stadium and related enabling development evidence needed about viability

Omission sites

Middle Battenhall Farm

Representation on omission - up to 200 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation on site (issues of local green network landscape heritage assets views)

Church Farm

Representation on omission - up to 400 dwellings

Support for lack of allocation of development in the green belt

Droitwich Road Nursery

Representation on omission ndash for redevelopment of the site for mixed use (site is in green belt)

Land at Battenhall Road

Representation on omission for about 15 dwellings

Land to rear of 20 Old Northwick Lane

Representation on omission for residential development as part of SWDP434

Land at Whittington Road

Representation on omission for mixed use ndash housing hotel fast food drive thru petrol filling station auto dealership

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 20: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

19

Land at Whittington Hall

Request removal of the Significant Gap designation across the site If designation remains SWDP2 should identify development on existing business parks as one of the forms of acceptable development that may be allowed within the area

Key issues SWDP 44 and SWDP 45

SWDP44 Shrub Hill Opportunity Zone

SWDP444

o Support for extension of land east of railway (Sherriff Gate) to be included in Opportunity Zone ndash accord with Stage One Vision Masterplan for Worcester city centre

o Representation on restricting retail and leisure to ancillary uses ndashproposes policy reflects sequential approach of Framework towards centre uses issue over approach to heritage assets having regard to the need of existing businesses ndash new premisesrelocation wants Shrub Hill area (west of railway) phased first

SWDP444 (should be listed under policy SWDP 10)

o Define and extend lsquoSecondary Shopping Frontage along north side of

George Street and St Martins Gate to include the Retail Park within Primary Shopping Area

SWDP 45

Supports urban extensions ndash and should not replace these urban extensions with site allocation at Middle Battenhall Farm

Objects to urban extensions ndash contrary to view of Council Policy Group at Malvern that suggested a reduced area of houses and that the developments are spread about

Supports the inclusion of requirements around GI

SWDP451 Worcester South urban extension

Support for development (developers ndash Welbeck St Modwens)

Deliverability

o Should consider all landowners in the site not just the largest developers - Masterplan for the proposed urban extension which is agreed by all the landowners

Housing target

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 21: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

20

o Support for number of dwellings

o Representations on number of dwellings

Should reduce scale of development at Worcester South and have corresponding increase at Worcester West ndash to better match planning merits of the sites

Control of scale of housing development east of Norton Road

o Support for minimum of 35 dwellings (developer)

Affordable housing percentage

o Concern over impact on viability ndash either reduce percentage target in or assess SUEs separately and have more realistic targets

o Delete 40 target in SWDP451 and rely instead on SWDP 15

Gypsy and traveller

o Challenges to the evidence of need and the justification of this location

o Should identify location of traveller sites - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

o Should be identifying where the sites will be within Malvern Hills or Worcester City

Development in Significant Gap south of the Garden Centre

o Limit to specified list of uses (not lsquoincludingrsquo)

Designate centre as a Local Centre not as a Neighbourhood Centre (policy and Policies Map)

Crossing facilities (over A4440) between new community and existing Worcester community

o premature to require they are to be ldquograde-separatedrdquo before the

completion of the detailed design work

o masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners ndash otherwise delivery of crossing facilities is compromised

Parking hub

o Lack of substantive evidence in terms of location operation or future demand viability (Respondent asserts they have evidence indicating a lack of demand to sustain a Park and Ride facility and unlikely to sustain a parking hub)

o Any masterplan should have support of all the necessary landowners no specific location identified for the parking hub ndash it to be agreed through masterplanning

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 22: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

21

o Should identify location of parking - concerned that there may be pressure to use other areas for development not currently allocated or suitable

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police post

Green infrastructure(GI)

o Supports for GI network and Local Green Network as proposed ndash as multifunctional landscape framework to the urban extension

o Means to integrate urban extension with city ndash GI restricts integration effectively creating a separate settlement

o Inconsistency regarding no road traffic in zone west of Norton Road ndash but key access from Norton Road to centre and to A38

o In the consultations for Broomhall map showed a gap between the proposed development and Broomhall Cottages of one field -147 yards The proposed map now shows no gap Should reinstate the one field gap and reduce number of houses

Level of detail

o Insufficient detail ndash where will identified elements of the development be located

Flood risk

Impact of the government oil pipe line

Existing uses occupiers within the urban extension

o Insufficient consideration of occupants within the area eg Clerkenleap A38

Exclude land at the Ketch Viewpoint at the north-west corner of the urban extension from development and ensure that run-off into the Severn is not such that it impacts on the registered battlefield or associated footpath

SWDP452 Worcester West urban extension

Supports size of urban extension (Hallam ndash developer) ndash deliverable amp sustainable ndash formal prendashapplication process has commenced with Malvern Hills DC Worcester focussed development rather than orientated towards the M5 establishes of a robust western boundary to Worcester should not increase size of urban extension ndash to avoid the issues raised at earlier stage when 3500 dwellings were proposed

Increase size of urban extension to meet housing shortfall (higher provision target needed amp supply identified in plan is unlikely to be delivered or insufficient to meet provision targets) developer (Bloor Homes ndash developer)

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 23: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

22

Should increase the area of the allocation and maximise the optimum development capacity ndash additional housing refers to WMRSS Panel Report -3500 dwellings west of Worcester sustainable location access to Worcester integrates well with Worcester City retain gap between urban extension and Lower Broadheath

Deliverability

o Need for masterplan to be prepared in conjunction with all interested parties including the minority landowners (minority landowner on Oldbury Road)

Site boundary

o Increase the area ndash Bloor Homes

o Western boundary is arbitrary masterplan should provide for development of local GI network amp measures to maintain separation from Crown East amp Lower Broadheath ndash western amp development boundaries defined by natural physical boundaries

Phasing

o Amend phasing - 600 dwelling completions by 2019 (rather than the 345) ndash Hallam

Affordable housing

o Delete SWDP policy for 40 affordable housing rely instead on SWDP 15 policy

Infrastructure ndash inadequate infrastructure in Worcester ndash to cope with additional traffic use of the river crossing inadequate health infrastructure Preserve land for provision of North West Flood Relief Road Bring forward completion of NWFRR together with additional road crossing no later than 2020

Delete Gypsy and traveller provision (10 pitches) - uncertain policy context (RS revocation) no evidence that Councils have explored other options not well related to need ndash on north and east side of city no evidence to suggest that urban extensions are appropriate for accommodating additional pitches ndash site of 10 pitches is too big in relation to many preferences amp as policy SWDP45 proposes sites at largest urban extension there is no need for site at the West urban extension Use is not compatible with gateway location and landscape qualities of the area amenity impacts associated in particular with high employment amp residential uses

Extend range of uses to include Garden Centre - to be located on land between A44 Bromyard Road to the north A4440 to the west and south and open land to the east

Community facilities

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 24: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

23

o Policy should require provision of contribution to emergency services

Parking hub

o Lack of justification for locating a parking hub at this site ndash delete proposal

Transport Traffic

o Impact of development ndash adding to congestion on roads into and out of Malvern

Green Infrastructure

o Lack of evidence to justify green corridors to manage transition from urban to rural and regarding minimum of 40m width ndash plan should not be prescriptive

SWDP453 Worcester East urban extension

Support for development (developer) ndash current application for 256 dwellings

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

SWDP454 Worcester North urban extension

Support for development (developer builder landowners)

Oppose development

o Site should be undeveloped remain rural

Urban extension of the city settlement status

o Should not be an urban extension if there is development it should be designated a small rural settlement separated from the city

o Scale of development (250) is too great if developed should be only 68 dwellings ndash impact of site constraints including pylons utilities easements

Better sites elsewhere (at Church Farm east of A449 in green belt ndash developer)

Affordable housing

o Site too remote ndash should located affordable housing instead at Worcester Swimming site Sansome Walk close to city centre shopsfacilities

Housing mix

o incorporate larger bungalows

Heritage Assets

o Adverse impact on the character and appearance of the wider area

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 25: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

24

with the city effectively adjoining Bevere

o Adverse impact on heritage assets and settings (Bevere Conservation Area listed buildings) and rural context links to Claines lead to the despoliation and complete obliteration of the historic fabric setting and character of Bevere

Character

o Erosion of local distinctiveness of Claines area and Worcester

Agricultural land

o Loss of Best and Most Versatile Land (grade 2)

Green infrastructure

o Loss of valued green open space

o Loss of green infrastructure

o Loss of views eg of the Malvern Hills and to Claines

o Unacceptable risks to future generations - irreversible permanent land-take causing loss of BMV agricultural land (Grade 2 amp 3a) needed for food-growing effects of traffic congestion in relation to M5 likely failure to provide proper infrastructure contrary to Statement of Community Involvement

Community facilities

o Policy should require provision of police station

Transport Traffic

o Impact on M5 junctions impact on Claines Island (roundabout on A449) concerns about traffic on local lanes

SWDP455 Worcester Technology Park

Supports allocation (Spetchley Estates) ndash supporting national policy towards economy site well related to primary road network well related to east side of city ndash and extend public transport links It is a critical employment allocation for the City and South Worcestershire Opportunity for clustering of economic activities as well as providing for other local needs This will be attractive to both local and inward investors

Adverse impact of development on Birmingham and the Black Country employment sites

Should restricted to local indigenous businesses competition for footloose industries

SWDP 45 ndash Omission Sites

o Land to east of SWDP453 (east of A4440 Swinesherd Way) as additional

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 26: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

25

land as part of an urban extension

Wychavon (SWDP 46 - 51)

SWDP46 ndash Pershore Allocations

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP47 Pershore Urban Extension

Provision of link road is essential

Link road is not essential infrastructure

SWDP48 Droitwich Allocations

Concern that Ladywood Water Treatment plant does not have capacity for the level of development proposed

Given Droitwich Spa is the largest town in Wychvon proposed housing supply is to low Several omission sites identified - Hill End Tagwell Road Yew Tree Hill Raven Hotel Chateau Impney Salwarpe Road

SWDP49 Droitwich Urban Extensions

Additional allocations proposed considered unsound to rely on a single allocation SWDP491 at Copcut Lane Omission sites include Yew Tree Hill Tagwell Road Chateau Impney Chawson Lane (extension to Copcut Lane site)

Employment allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) should be removed from the phasing policy (SWDP62)

Allocation at Stonebridge Cross (SWDP492) has an adverse impact on the listed parkland and buildings of Westwood House

SWDP50 Evesham Allocations

Numerous representations on the principle and scale of the housing allocation at Abbey Road

SWDP51 Evesham Urban Extensions

Inadequate consultation process that did not encompass the rigorous approaches to ensure effective participation and engagement in the process in accordance with the Localism Act

Concerns about loss of agricultural land (Grade 1) on the Abbey Road allocation

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 27: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

26

Concerns regarding flooding traffic loss of greenfield land impact on the Ancient Monument on the Abbey Road allocation

Omission sites suggested at Inches Lane for housing land at Offenham Road east ndash enlarge and allocate for mixed use Kings Road enlarge and allocate for mixed use land to south of Pershore Road ndash west of Fairfield for housing

Concerns regarding the level of specific infrastructure required for the Abbey Road allocation

Strong concerns about the impact that the Evesham allocations may have on the Abbey Bridge junction

Malvern Hills (SWDP 52-58)

SWDP 52 ndash 58 Malvern Allocations

Degree of support for several of the allocations mainly from the landowners

Representation based around ldquoomission sitesrdquo- mainly promoted by landowner developers

Some suggestions that the decision process was flawed as regards the MHDC councillors signing off the SWDP proposed submission document and suggestion of ldquopre-determinationrdquo

Suggestion that the SWDP does not take account of the majority of people in Malvern

Support that Malvern is a sustainable location for further growth

Suggestions that housing numbers should be higher for Malvern

SWDP 53 Malvern Technology Centre (QinetiQ)

The policy should include provision for a mixed use hall for social events

QinetiQ supports the principle of a mixed-use (employment and housing) allocation at MTC under Policy SWDP53 but they object to two elements of the proposed allocation

- the housing allocation is unjustified and should be increased to ldquoat

least 300 dwellingsrdquo

- the housing allocation of ldquoapproximately 250 dwellingsrdquo is

insufficient as it does not reflect QinetiQrsquos indicative masterplan

Clarification required that the delivery of affordable housing at 40 will be subject to development viability

It has not been clearly demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure issues which previously ruled out residential use of the site have been resolved

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 28: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

27

SWDP54 Blackmore Park

Insufficient sustainable transport measures - no cycling facilities and limited walking - needs to be addressed

Support from landowners

Landowner wishes additional employment land to be allocated here

SWDP55 Three Counties Showground

No significant issues identified

SWDP 56 Development at north east Malvern

The SWDP appears to ignore the wishes of the residents of Malvern as indicated at the public meeting in October 2011

It has not been demonstrated that the significant highway infrastructure requirements that the site requires can be delivered

More development in Malvern will cause traffic congestion in the town and at the Southern Link Road at Worcester

Reference is made to the park and ride at Malvern Link railway station This is misleading as it does not operate as a standard park and ride facility

There has been no proper response to representations and the process is biased to landowners rather than local people

No evidence of need for homes in Malvern or proper alternatives considered to this site that is on prime agricultural land

The planned development should not go ahead until the Worcester northern by-pass has been delivered

The allocation should be reduced and other sites on the edge of Malvern promoted

The large strategic sites at Malvern and Worcester should be removed in favour of more dispersed development reducing pressure on transport infrastructure

SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells

Alternative sites promoted by 2 landowners

Alternatives not properly assessed by planners

Support for level of development proposed in Tenbury Wells

SWDP 58 Upton upon Severn

Several alternative sites promoted in Holly GreenRyall and Tunnel Hill

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 29: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

28

Holly Green not considered suitable for a location to take Uptons growth It has no services and can be subject to flooding Tunnel Hill is a more suitable location

Tunnel Hill should not be assessed as a Category 3 settlement as it does not have the required services

Flood defences in Upton not yet tested but may mean an increase in urban capacity there

No evidence to support the need for 100 dwellings in Upton area

Natural England considers that the policy should refer to GI requirements to be consistent with the other SWDP allocations

Support for allocation at Holly Green but numbers can be increased to 50 dwellings

Support for level of development at Upton upon Severn

Villages (SWDP 59-61)

General points on the three village allocation policies (SWDP 59 60 and 61)

These three policies attracted approximately 480 representations However the three policies cover 70 site allocations in the villages

There are representations opposed to and in support of the allocations from local residents and from landowners some of whom wish to promote their sites instead of the suggested allocations

Category 1

SWDP 59 Category 1 Village Allocations

There are approximately 139 representations on this policy

There are few representations on the policy wording - most representations are in respect of specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

A few representations suggest that the allocation of sites should be left to the neighbourhood plan process (most notable Martley and Clifton upon Teme Parish Councils) and that no allocation should be made until this is done (although no indication of timescales to progress neighbourhood plans is given)

There is a representation from the Cotswold Conservation Board (AONB) to development in the AONB at Broadway further Broadway Parish Council Broadway Trust and other residents groups residents object on this ground

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 30: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

29

that it is against the Framework There are approx 40 representations on the sites in Broadway (ref SWDP 5917 5918 5919)

There are approx 28 representations concerning the proposed Clifton upon Teme allocation some representations on the allocated site and some in support of it with the residents divided over their preferred site (ref SWDP 593)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 60 Category 2 Village Allocations

There are approximately 300 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

A few residents have queried the category of settlement their village is in based on local services and facilities

The largest number of representations mainly representations is to the allocation at Fernhill Heath (SWDP 6016)

There are representations promoting alternative ldquoomissionrdquo sites in some

areas

SWDP 61 Category 3 Village Allocations

There are approximately 40 representations on this policy

There are few representations to the policy wording - most representations are against specific site allocations

The largest number of representations (6) concern the site at Bishampton (SWDP 612)

Implementation amp Monitoring (SWDP 62-63)

Questions about the adequacy of infrastructure to serve the new development

Questions about the viability of new development given the scale of infrastructure required plus other policy requirements

Questions about the inter-relationship with CIL

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 31: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

30

Appendix 1 Letter to consultees

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 32: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

31

hellip Cont

a) The draft SWDP Submission document and accompanying response form b) The Test of Soundness and Legal Compliance as set out in the guidance notes which

accompany the response form on the website c) Supporting information including the Proposals Map that is available on the website

All of the documents and supporting information are available electronically from the SWDP website Hard copies of the draft Plan are available for inspection at local libraries and Customer Contact Centres across the three local authorities where small supplies of the response form will also be available Hard copies of these documents can be obtained on request Although you may have made previous representations to the process to date should you wish to have the chance to appear at the Examination in Public (EIP) in the summer of 2013 it is essential that you make a response (based on the Tests of Legal Compliance andor Soundness) at this stage Please note however that participation at the EIP is at the discretion of the Inspector

If you have any queries on this please see the website wwwswdevelopmentplanorg or e-mail contactswdevelopmentplanorg or telephone the SWDP team on 01905 722233 You can also write to The South Worcestershire Development Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BB

Further contact regarding the SWDP is likely to be by e-mail so that best use of limited resources can be achieved

Yours faithfully

Paul Bayliss SWDP Project Manager

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 33: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

32

Appendix 2 Regulation 19 Advertisement

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 34: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

33

Appendix 3 Press article on Proposed Submission Consultation

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 35: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

34

Appendix 4 Locations where Proposed Submission Plan was placed on

deposit

Council Offices LibrariesCustomer Contact Centres

Malvern Hills District Council

NA Malvern Upton and Tenbury Wells Customer Contact Centres (local libraries)

Worcester City NA The Hive Worcester

Warndon library

St Johns library

Wychavon District Council Planning Reception Civic Centre Pershore

Evesham Customer Contact Centre and library

Droitwich Customer Contact Centrelibrary

Broadway library

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 36: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

35

Appendix 5 List of Representors

ID Name Organisation

742919 A G Hall 689203 A J Marshall 738992 A Philpott 738626 Barry amp Rebecca Bennett 411823 Bernard Pound 677688 Bob and Jan Hollis 740594 C E Snowdon 688898 C Merrett 678015 Catherine Francis 738166 Charles and Maura Lee 426707 Chris Greatbatch 679206 Clive Downey 737224 Cllr Tony Miller 738513 Codrington and Styles Families 679104 Colin Futrill 743001 D A Willis 742668 D Baker 687533 D Grima 742531 D K Stevenson 685338 D P Street 742555 Davinia Hughes 742259 Dr A J Leach 742867 Dr C Lander 603477 Dr Clive Studd 675656 Dr David Pegg 739533 Dr Eric H Jones 742922 Dr J A Humphries 694995 Dr Robert Vernon 736744 Dr Thomas Bloch 744733 Duncan Westbury 678184 E N Ruddle 742562 E Penwarden 620760 E R Hoban 742251 Elizabeth Buchanan 739562 Elizabeth Tucker 621107 Eur Ing Howard Brennan 744750 Executors of E J Burnham

Deceased

742663 F A Johnson

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 37: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

36

679336 Freda Keeling 742550 G Faulkner 742915 G H Grinnell 742438 G M Hickman 694986 Gillian Ritchie 685876 Gordon Franks 743005 H Allen 742193 H Franklin 740543 H Wills 677653 Heather Knight 734991 Helen Peacop 605897 HRA Hotdesk 742748 I Churchill 742528 I T Roberts 740537 J Hodgkins 740976 J S Hemming 742561 J Yeomans 688141 Jane King 744624 Jeremy Sumner 677258 Jo Sandalls 679105 Kay Futrill 694982 Leonard amp Sheila Riddell 607581 Linda and John Pugh 744078 Lynn Sivill 216293 M B Rees 750244 Messrs L Righton amp W D Jones 619147 Messrs Stratton amp Humphreys

and the Hale and Cronin family

739011 Milada amp Zbigniew Tarka 675821 Miss Amanda Jarrard 740549 Miss Ellen Rogers 739239 Miss Emma Rice 678532 Miss Glynis Betteridge 739292 Miss Julie Wollaston 742174 Miss L Tilt 738044 Miss Sarah Millin 689528 Miss W Sharples 678032 Morwenna Francis 417724 Mr amp Mrs A Eden 742692 Mr amp Mrs Franks 264417 Mr amp Mrs Gwilliam

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 38: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

37

740982 Mr amp Mrs Helen amp Malcolm Harle 740024 Mr amp Mrs J Swindall 746347 Mr amp Mrs JM amp JH Walsh 740533 Mr amp Mrs M Clarke 742878 Mr amp Mrs Oakley 742556 Mr amp Mrs Pitt 740891 Mr amp Mrs PN amp KA MacBryde 742890 Mr amp Mrs R Smith 742548 Mr amp Mrs Rinaldi 688971 Mr amp Mrs Stych 743093 Mr amp Mrs Tracey and Terry Mills 743146 Mr amp Mrs Walsh 742232 Mr amp Mrs Weston 742883 Mr A Cole 742685 Mr A Eyre 742167 Mr A Wright 739014 Mr AH Bradley 684991 Mr AN Howes 737417 Mr Alan Arthur 672839 Mr Alan Busby 738650 Mr Alastair Catherwood 738181 Mr and Mrs Carl and Clare Shaw 678183 Mr and Mrs M Evans Ryall House Ltd 604830 Mr and Mrs M Skinner 738232 Mr and Mrs Mathew and Louisa

Grizzell

739002 Mr and Mrs Pauline and Norman Heathcock

744080 Mr and Mrs Phillips 677735 Mr and Mrs Stow 739150 Mr and Mrs Wall 604573 Mr Andrew Belcher 604317 Mr Andrew Menzies 737630 Mr Andy Lyon 738029 Mr Anthony Chidgey 740600 Mr Anthony Davies 739213 Mr Anthony Dipple

7798 Mr Anthony Warburton 739176 Mr Arthur Wardle 743009 Mr B Bell 678105 Mr B Mordue

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 39: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

38

75518 Mr BJ Fishwick 731298 Mr Bill Simpson 742902 Mr Brian Eglesfield

8304 Mr Brian J Woolley 56515 Mr Brian Orme

737278 Mr Brian Venables 736208 Mr Brian Yates 688688 Mr C Egerton 742197 Mr C Stuart 742570 Mr Charles Penwarden 736075 Mr Chris Hurley and Heather

Hurley

736204 Mr Christopher Roper 619501 Mr Cliff Hayes 607544 Mr Clive Conyers 605424 Mr Colin Merriman 742995 Mr Colin Skyrme 742546 Mr Colin Wheeler 742778 Mr D J Crook 742536 Mr D Moss-Horton 738885 Mr D Orme 668915 Mr David Ashley 628608 Mr David Eaton 523298 Mr David Hibbitt 203962 Mr David Higgs 620425 Mr David Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 607585 Mr David John Oseman 739052 Mr David Jones 721662 Mr David Powis

9108 Mr David T Harrison 735708 Mr Denis Compton 606068 Mr Derek Jackson 732810 Mr Derek Purnell 736298 Mr Donald Maclean 675560 Mr Douglas Whitgrove 585347 Mr Duncan Branchett 619133 Mr E Holloway amp Mrs C Orgee 586363 Mr Eddie Vickers 689021 Mr Ernest Power 743019 Mr F H Briggs 619442 Mr Frederick Pointer

8277 Mr G E Jones

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 40: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

39

608609 Mr Gary Smith 673334 Mr Geoff Gent 686120 Mr Geoffrey Alan John Ellis

(Junior)

737886 Mr George Higgins 355394 Mr Graham Parker PJP Planning 587196 Mr Graham Price 630859 Mr Green amp Mrs Gusterson 741148 Mr Haines 742573 Mr Harry Penwarden 689244 Mr Hemming David 739565 Mr Howard Nicholls 740016 Mr Hugh Francis 694195 Mr I Keetley 275519 Mr Iain Broadhurst 293174 Mr Ian Cutbill 738647 Mr Ian Fenton 736037 Mr Ian Jallands 742257 Mr Ian Shovlin 674156 Mr J R Brereton 742711 Mr Jaime Rodriguez 738633 Mr James Mansfield 260848 Mr James Richard Saunders 694984 Mr James Ritchie 721915 Mr Jeremy Johns 675795 Mr Jeremy Taber Directly Affected Residents of

Bishampton 603101 Mr John Brass 737384 Mr John Cottrill 740915 Mr John Fletcher 739312 Mr John Garbett 689980 Mr John Hallett 605845 Mr John Jeffrey 735926 Mr John Jordan 736304 Mr John Morgan 595411 Mr John Simms 738841 Mr K Grima 742238 Mr K J Adams 667603 Mr K Joynes 675512 Mr Keith Lewis 736264 Mr Ken Ashman 739622 Mr Ken Carpenter

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 41: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

40

736303 Mr Kevin Fincher 742141 Mr Lee Parkes 670761 Mr Lloyd Buffery 678468 Mr M J Raymond 739158 Mr M K Wong 404729 Mr M L Oakes 742906 Mr M P Evans 689039 Mr Malcolm Sykes 604780 Mr Mark Billen 742266 Mr Mark Lawson 375786 Mr Mark Tredwell 428260 Mr Martin Osborne 735711 Mr Matt Crawford 737309 Mr Michael Brockington 603948 Mr Michael Hardwick 721713 Mr Mike Heath 605620 Mr Mike Oakley 742224 Mr N V Kimberley 740027 Mr N Woollatt 678277 Mr Neil MacDonald 675409 Mr Nick Blundell 742709 Mr Nick Upton 588819 Mr Nigel Bruen 606644 Mr Nigel Cant 742738 Mr Nigel Rutter 738026 Mr Nigel Turner 690313 Mr P Cockle 742107 Mr P J Payne 742100 Mr P S Broadbent 739111 Mr PL Hill 737271 Mr Paul Boness 675734 Mr Paul Brown 739222 Mr Paul Essenhigh 742170 Mr Paul Radburn 739641 Mr Paul Tainty

8912 Mr Paul Tuthill 734257 Mr Peter Cresswell 201907 Mr Peter Francis 604144 Mr Peter Huntington 722287 Mr Peter Luff 738813 Mr Peter Street

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 42: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

41

742234 Mr R Ball 741562 Mr R Heming and Mrs J

Gisbourne

604910 Mr R Hollis 738390 Mr R Kemp 65030 Mr R M Yolland

742433 Mr R Mercik 742408 Mr R W Woollatt 739529 Mr Richard Bray 676176 Mr Richard Hathway 742874 Mr Richard Nokes 695070 Mr Richard Walsh 738914 Mr Robert Keates 742263 Mr Robert Standfield 684913 Mr Robert Stanley 743975 Mr Roger Moss 737585 Mr Ron Millard Member Tunnel Hill Action Group 731115 Mr Roy Pendleton 742539 Mr S Moss-Horton 742153 Mr Scott Bytheway 200007 Mr Shane Cusack 736666 Mr Shaun Owen 694878 Mr Stephen Gregory 665594 Mr Steve Foster 618177 Mr Steve Taylor 743013 Mr T J Brewer 740546 Mr Tom Rogers 744740 Mr W A Arnold 604604 Mr Walter Everitt 378279 Mr William Ball 590729 Mr Wilson 737665 Mr Clive Maulden 738002 Mr Martin OBrien 663253 Mrs A J Rice 739182 Mrs Alison Chedzoy 676773 Mrs Amanda Buffery 742767 Mrs B Cottrill 739168 Mrs BA Wardle 689656 Mrs Barbara Rees 750466 Mrs Barbara Uggeri 740527 Mrs C Dixon 684805 Mrs C E Bonham

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 43: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

42

219029 Mrs CR Jones 605813 Mrs Carrie Oakley 681572 Mrs Coralie J M Rogers 742659 Mrs D A Yeomans 742138 Mrs D Parish 678622 Mrs E A Howes 742201 Mrs Elizabeth Stuart 736418 Mrs Elizabeth Zdanko 688807 Mrs Esme Rice 676684 Mrs G L Chambers 740018 Mrs G Parkes 689908 Mrs J Cragg 742673 Mrs J Eyre 742223 Mrs J M Kimberley 742413 Mrs J M Lightfoot 674745 Mrs Jan Hollis 738529 Mrs Jean Davis 679963 Mrs Jean Glover 619554 Mrs Jennifer MacDonald 684902 Mrs JL Hanley 677806 Mrs Joan Jackson 736697 Mrs Linda Corbett 736982 Mrs Linnet Waghorn 607972 Mrs Liz Smith 693018 Mrs Lynda Standfield 743017 Mrs M Brodie-Jenkins 742899 Mrs M Davis 743016 Mrs M E Brewer 631646 Mrs M Fancutt 738780 Mrs M Greenway 742893 Mrs M R Dowling 678537 Mrs M E Betteridge 735273 Mrs Maria Masters 742916 Mrs Marlene Grinnell 278172 Mrs Mary H Anton 737640 Mrs Megan Farmer 738578 Mrs Michelle Salisbury 688715 Mrs Monica Kelly 743000 Mrs P A Webb 742242 Mrs P D Rogers 742158 Mrs P K Belton

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 44: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

43

740980 Mrs P R Balch 428518 Mrs Patricia Petri 693984 Mrs Pauline Brown 627528 Mrs Penelope Wesner 692989 Mrs Rebecca Griffiths 675241 Mrs Rosalind Townsend-Hope Fernhill Heath Residents Association 603374 Mrs Ruth Haines 205996 Mrs S Philpott 679351 Mrs S Raymond 677903 Mrs Sally Brain 204047 Mrs Sally Shovlin 738638 Mrs Sally Tebbutt 738919 Mrs Samantha Keates 619477 Mrs Sandra Pointer 694543 Mrs Sheila Slater 603959 Mrs Stephanie Smith Cooper 742909 Mrs Susan Evans 740931 Mrs Susan Johns 736205 Mrs Sylvia Partridge 670597 Mrs Valerie Hibbitt 738853 Mrs Valerie Rosendorff 604621 Mrs Vanessa Briggs 743008 Ms Ann Bell 742143 Ms Ann Billen 740129 Ms Ann Goddard 738611 Ms BM Whitgrove 739492 Ms Booan Temple 742704 Ms Celia Upton 737757 Ms Dawn Oliver Residents of Holly Green 738844 Ms Debra May 738620 Ms Dinah Budd 742252 Ms Eleanor Shovlin 235260 Ms Elizabeth Owens 742722 Ms Elizabeth Upton 742254 Ms Gabrielle Shovlin 740100 Ms HT Sandison 740173 Ms Heather Williams 695501 Ms Helen Cusack 742564 Ms Holly Penwarden 742905 Ms Janet G Eglesfield 739025 Ms Joe Morgan

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 45: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

44

740520 Ms Joy Young 742442 Ms June R Hickman 604890 Ms Karen Worboys 738511 Ms Kate Shrubb 619507 Ms Kathleen Simmons 738900 Ms Leah Dainty 738906 Ms MW Back 740615 Ms Maria Skyrme 742752 Ms Phillipa Wright 739165 Ms Rosemary Hall 742853 Ms Sally Cakebread 742144 Ms Sara J Parkes 298221 Ms Stefania Kennedy 740563 Ms Susan Higgs 742270 Ms Susan M Lawson 742165 Ms Tara Squires 691347 Ms Tessa Meek 668724 Ms Val Pullee 677886 Ms Val Walsh 734754 Ms Vera Jelfs 690062 Ms Wendy Filby 677951 P Blackburn 684817 P Cusack 739058 P M Harris 679357 P M Roberts 677976 P S Churchill 679265 Paul Griffiths 679192 Pauline Woolley 723473 Professor John Raine 734706 R J H amp L M Owen 740591 R S E Haswell 679366 R V Grand 742268 R W Bonham 70292 RA Amor

597968 Rev Robert Barlow 742533 S E Stevenson 686078 S Egerton 595270 S J Cottrill 743011 S L Biggart 689210 S R Marshall 261631 SW Price

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 46: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

45

676768 Sally Chestnutt 742761 Sean and Angela Flanagan 742875 Shampa Hazra 679151 Stephanie Raymond 694985 Stuart Ritchie 677505 Susan Leach 742868 Susnata China 626498 The Gwilt Family 603330 Trevor Rickard 687971 Action St Peters 628582 Antringham Developments 678391 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers

and Stoford Developments Ltd

8482 AXA Real Estate Investment Managers and Stoford Developments Ltd Ltd

626494 BAE Systems 627208 Barberry (Droitwich) Limited 742394 Barratt amp North Tewkesbury Land

Consortium

695101 Barratt David Wilson (BDW ) 677684 Barratt Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 742756 Barratt Homes WM Bovis Homes WM

Taylor Wimpey WM

627057 Bellway Homes (West Midlands) Ltd 606194 Bevere Development Opposition Group

(BDOG)

742746 BFP Developments LLP 689970 Birmingham City Council 736617 Bishampton Parish Council 740411 Black Country Local Authorities 432058 Blackmore Park Limited 617416 Bloor Homes 742588 Bloor Homes Western 743124 Blue Cedar Homes 677515 Boughton Butler LLP 611973 Bovis Homes Ltd 736309 Bretforton Community Alliance

8683 Broadway Trust 612691 Cala Homes (Midlands) Ltd 757944 Cala Homes and Bellway Homes Ltd 680155 Centro 742992 Chapman Taylor and Taylor

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 47: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

46

741220 Churchfields Farm 239180 Ciel Properties Ltd 738061 Claines Action Group 723114 Claines Green Belt Association

7357 Cleeve Prior Parish Council 756332 Client of Arthur Griffiths and Mumford 757837 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 2 743231 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758022 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 758010 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 3 758046 Client of Gregory Gray Associates 5 757404 Client of Hamptons International 757454 Client of Hamptons International 2 757459 Client of Hamptons International 3 759266 Clients of Roger Tym amp Partners 618672 Clifton upon Teme Parish Council 685243 Comparo Ltd 740535 Comparo Ltd 613199 Consolidated Rank Properties Ltd

8764 Cotswolds AONB Conservation Board 683245 Countrywide Project Management Ltd 256016 Crest Nicholson (South West) Limited 628632 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects 743284 Crest Nicholson Strategic Projects and

Castle Town Estates

695097 Crowle Properties Two Ltd 612968 David Wilson Homes 743145 Davids Nurseries 632276 Deloitte LLP 625392 Diageo Pension Trust Ltd 619048 Elgar Properties Ltd 744006 Elim International 743114 Estate of the landowner of The Oaks

Bell Lane Lower Broadheath

671876 Evesham Baptist Church 681858 Evesham Cycling Forum 723494 Evesham District Scout Council 680626 Evesham Estates Ltd 742247 Festival Housing Association 196223 Geodiversity Herefordshire amp

Worcestershire Earth Heritage Trust

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 48: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

47

694808 Gladman Developments 755941 Gleeson amp Welbeck Strategic Land

8459 Gloucestershire County Council 747593 Gordon Close Residents Association

(represents 51 residents)

604286 Hallam Land Management Ltd 7365 Hampton Lovett amp Westwood Parish

Council

7849 Herefordshire and Worcestershire Chamber Of Commerce

744089 Highways Agency 628535 Hill amp Smith Holdings 737872 Hindlip Martin Hussingtree amp Salwarpe

Parish Council

742428 Home Builders Federation 741133 Homes and Communities Agency 603655 Inkberrow Consortium Ltd 738857 J amp J Byrd Family Trust 86445 Kensington and Edinburgh Estates

606282 Kler Developments 627394 Knarsboro Homes Ltd 737858 Land Fund Limited 739235 Landseer Homes and Properties 739549 Leigh Sinton Farm amp Nurseries Ltd 680670 Linden Homes 629240 Lioncourt Homes

7402 Lower Broadheath Parish Council 639801 Mactaggart and Mickel 694661 Madresfield Estate 664277 Malvern Civic Society 739125 Malvern Hills AONB Unit

7902 Malvern Hills Science Park 8556 Malvern St James 7434 Malvern Town Council

620429 Martley Parish Council 606174 Maximus Limited 605648 McCarthy and Stone Retirement

Lifestyles Ltd

736735 Mercia Region Battlefields Trust 741357 Merton College Oxford 744093 Messrs WJ Bullock amp Partners 742183 Middle Battenhall Farm Land Action

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 49: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

48

Group 685899 Miller Homes

7702 Mister Brothers 677978 Mobile Operators Association 677405 MWH Projects 740435 National Federation of Gypsy Liaison

Groups

7479 Natural England 67365 Newland Parish Council

739200 Nigel J Teale 695102 North Oak Homes Ltd 741625 Northoak Homes Ltd 743099 Norton Parkway Developments Ltd 216129 Norton-Juxta-Kempsey Parish Council 233389 Offenham Cricket Club 744377 Owners of land at Hanbury 744465 Paramount Land amp Property Consultants

8486 Pemberstone Group Ltd 723449 Pershore Market Town Partnership 737525 Pershore Town Council

8066 QinetiQ 740107 Residents of Saxon CloseHope Lane

7447 Ripple Parish Council 8888 Robert Hitchins Ltd

742139 Rosconn Group 625928 Roxel Rocket Motors (UK) Ltd 636325 S E Davis and Son Ltd 62376 S Guy amp Sons

744326 Sainsbury Supermarkets Ltd 631976 Sedgeberrow Nominees Ltd 738576 Sedgeberrow Parish Council 618513 Selbourne Homes 737275 Seven Capital amp Landowners - Letham

Agincourt Associates and the Derby Family

740986 Shakespeare Line Promotion Group 618265 Sherriffs Gate Ltd 602889 Shorey Family Trust 739261 SOGOS Save Our Green Open Spaces

7119 South Worcestershire Cycle Group 678141 Southall Trustees - Land owners 737435 Spitfire Properties LLP

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 50: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

49

678088 Sport England 740989 Springfield Lane Association

7726 St Modwen Properties Plc 742657 Summix Limited 683640 Taylor Wimpey UK Limited 607789 Tesco Stores Ltd 688247 The Broadway Trust 743140 The Brockhill Estate 741296 The Coal Authority 743446 The Dean and Chapter of Christchurch

Oxford

625769 The Garden Centre Group 743793 The Garden Centre Group 741585 The Ombersley Conservation Trust 604457 The Overbury Estate 631277 The Potter Group 743731 The Russells Management Company

Limited (represents 58 residents of Broadway)

620025 The Spetchley Estate 738142 The Springfield Lane Association

7099 The Theatres Trust 735709 Tisdall Associates 739431 University of Worcester and Wrenbridge

LLP

605054 Velcourt plc 605053 Welbeck Strategic Land LLP 678119 Welbeck Strategic LandPersimmon

Homes 607704 West Mercia Police and Hereford and

Worcester Fire and Rescue Service

678202 West Midlands Canal amp River Trust 685993 West Midlands HARP Planning

Consortium 625837 Western Power Distribution 742321 WM Morrison Supermarkets plc 549174 Woodland Trust 739545 Worcester Diocesan Board of Finance

Ltd 626523 Worcester Diocese 626331 Worcester Warriors 694466 Worcestershire County Council

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 51: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

50

745683 Worcestershire County Council (Waste and Minerals)

738709 Worcestershire Regulatory Services 7601 Worcestershire Wildlife Trust

357726 Worcestershire Historic Environment amp Archaeology Service

690175 Wyre Forest District Council

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation

Page 52: Regulation Section · Urdu SOURCE (English) TARGET (Urdu) x 3RGQXPHUHP &HQWUXP2EVáXJL.OLHQWDIf you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

DevelopmentPlanSOUTH WORCESTERSHIRE

May 2013

South Worcestershire Development Plan Team Orchard House Farrier Street Worcester WR1 3BBT 01905 722233 E contactswdevelopmentplanorgwwwswdevelopmentplanorg

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on request

Call 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 180001905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer ServiceCentre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Arabic )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

لمساعدة في التخاطب معنا باللغة اإلنجليزية ل أنت بحاجة إذا 722 233خدمة العمالء على هاتف رقم مركزيرجى اإلتصال ب

أو بواسطة البريد األلكتروني 01905customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

إستخدام عاهة يرجى الستفسارات لجويع اإللطلب الوساعدة أو 2233الهاتف واإلتصال بخدهة العوالء على رقن

هررححححـححاا

كاتدرائية وهدينة جاهعية هن الدرجة األولى غايتنا

Arabic

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

Bengali

Portuguese

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Portuguese)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Se necessitar de ajuda para comunicar em Inglecircs por favor contacte o Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes do 01905 722 233 ou atraveacutes do e-mail customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Para assistecircncia e todas as questotildees em geral por favor ligue para Serviccedilo de Apoio a Clientes atraveacutes da extensatildeo 2233

Bem-vindo

A nossa ambiccedilatildeo Ter uma catedral de primeira categoria e ser uma cidade universitaacuteria o que significa querer ser o melhor dos melhores

Punjabi

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Punjabi)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

ਜ ਤਹਾਨ ਅਗਰਜ਼ੀ ਵ ਿਚ ਗਿਬਾਤ ਕਰਨ ਵ ਿਚ ਮਦਦ ਦੀ ੜ ਹ ਤਾ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨਾ 01905 722 233 ਤ ਜਾ customerservicecentreworcestergovuk ਤ ਸ ਪਰਕ ਕਰ

ਸਹਾਇਤਾ ਈ ਅਤ ਸਾਰੀਆ ਆਮ ਪਿ ਛਵਗਿਛਾ ਈ ਵਕਰਪਾ ਕਰਕ ਟੀਨ ਚਿ ਕ ਅਤ ਕਸਟਮਰ ਸਰਵ ਸ ਸਟਰ ਨ 2233 ਤ ਨ ਕਰ

ਜੀ ਆਇਆ ਨ

ਸਾਡੀ ਅਵਿਾਸ਼ਾ ਪਵਹ ਦਰਜ ਦੀ ਕਥਡਰ ਅਤ ਯਵਨ ਰਵਸਟੀ ਵਸਟੀ

Urdu

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Urdu)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

اگر انگریزی میں گفتگو کرنے میں آپ کو مدد کی ضرورت ہے توپر یا 01905 722 233براہ کرم

customerservicecentreworcestergovuk پر کسٹمر سروس سے رابطہ کریں

مدد اور تمام عام پوچھ تاچھ کے لئے براہ کرم ٹیلی فون اٹھائیں اور پر کسٹمر سروس سینٹر کو ڈائل کریں 2233

خوش آمدید

ر یونیورسٹی سٹیاول رینک کی کتھیڈرل او ہماری خواہش

Polish

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (Polish )

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

Jeżeli potrzebują Państwo pomocy w porozumiewaniu się w języku angielskim prosimy o kontakt z Centrum Obsługi Klienta pod numerem 01905 722 233 lub na adres customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

Pod numerem 2233 Centrum Obsługi Klienta udzieli pomocy i odpowie na wszystkie pytania o charakterze ogoacutelnym

Zapraszamy

Nasza ambicja Katedra i miasteczko uniwersyteckie pierwszej klasy

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at

SOURCE (English)

TARGET (BENGALI)

If you need help communicating in English please contact the Customer Service Centre on 01905 722 233 or at customerservicecentreworcestergovuk

For assistance and for all general enquiries please pick up the telephone and dial the Customer Service Centre on 2233

Welcome

Our Ambition a First Rank Cathedral and University City

যদি ইংরাজীতে কথা আিানপরিাতনর জনয আনার াাতযযর পরত াজন োত অনগর কতর 01905 722 233 এই নমবতর অথফা customerservicecentreworcestergovuk এখাতন গরাক দরতফা ককতের তে কযাগাতযাগ করন

া ো এফং ম- াধারণ অননধাতনর জনয অনগর কতর কেদতপানটি েন আর 2233 এই নমবতর গরাক দরতফা ককতে ডা া করন

সবাগেম

আমাতির কষয একটি পরথম াদরর কযাদথডরা এফং দফশবদফিযা লর

This information is available in large print Braille PC CD-Rom and audio tape on requestCall 01905 722 230 or Typetalk (text telephone for people who are hearing impaired) 1800 01905 722233 or Email worcestershirehubworcestergovuk for your copy

SWDP Submission Pack ndash document 7 of 9

Regulation Section 22 (1)(c)(v) Report

Summary of Issues Raised at Proposed Submission Consultation