-
7/25/2019 Rana Digest - Property
1/6
G.R. No. 192861; June 30, 2014
LINDA RANA vs. TERESITA LEEWONG, SS. S!IRLE" LEE ONG #n$
R%&EN ANG ONG
' ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( '
G.R. No. 192862
SS. ROSARIO #n$ WILSON %",WILSON %" #s #))o*ne+(n(-#) o-TERESITA
LEE WONG, #n$ SS.
S!IRLE" LEE ONG #n$ R%&EN ANGONG vs. SS. RE"NALDO #n$
LINDA
RANA
Do)*ne/
It is a standingjurisprudential rule that unless anuisance is a
nuisance per se, itmay not be summarily abated.Aside from the
remedy of summaryabatement which should be takenunder the
parameters stated inArticles 704 (for public nuisances
and 70! (for pri"ate nuisances ofthe #i"il #ode, a pri"ate
personwhose property right was in"adedor unreasonably interfered
with bythe act, omission, establishment,business or condition of
theproperty of another may $le a ci"ilaction to reco"er
personaldamages. Abatement may bejudicially sought through a
ci"ilaction therefor if the pertinent
re%uirements under the #i"il #odefor summary abatement, or
there%uisite that the nuisance is anuisance per se, do not concur.
&onote, the remedies of abatementand damages are
cumulati"e'hence, both may be demanded.#)s/
Te*es)# Lee Won #n$ SousesS*e+ #n$ Ru5en An On Won,e). #7 #*e
o(one*s *o(n$vso o-# *es$en)# #n$ s)u#)e$ n e#e
#e+ Su5$vson, L#u, :e5u:)+, #5u))n # 10(e)e* $esu5$vson *o#$
su5
-
7/25/2019 Rana Digest - Property
2/6
su5 s. . o- )e* *oe*)+.!ene, )e+ os)e$ )#) )e+ #$
-
7/25/2019 Rana Digest - Property
3/6
# 5e* #use )#n )#) o- Ss.R#n# n so -#* #s en*o#en) sone*ne$.
Ao*$n+, )e+*#+e$ -o* )e $sss# o- Ss.R#n#Bs o#n) ) oun)e*#
-o* $##es, #))o*ne+Bs -ees, #n$)#)on e'enses.
Te RT: -oun$ )#)/ #7 Ss. R#n#,)ou) *o* onsu)#)on ) )esu5$vson
one* o* )e*ne5o*s, $eveoe$ )o )e* soe#$v#n)#e )e su5
-
7/25/2019 Rana Digest - Property
4/6
Te e))ons #*e #*)+
e*)o*ous.
or Abatement of )uisance and*amages.
%n$e* A*)e 694 o- )e :v :o$e,# nus#ne s $e?ne$ #s #n+ #),osson,
es)#5sen), 5usness,on$)on o- *oe*)+, o* #n+)nese / 17 In06 -o**v#)e
nus#nes7 o- )e :v:o$e, # *v#)e e*son ose*oe*)+ *) #s nv#$e$
o*un*e#son#5+ n)e*-e*e$ ) 5+ )e#), osson, es)#5sen),5usness o*
on$)on o- )e*oe*)+ o- #no)e* #+ ?e # v#)on )o *eove* e*son#
$##es. A5#)een) #+ 5e
-
7/25/2019 Rana Digest - Property
5/6
#n$ $##es #*e uu#)ve;ene, 5o) #+ 5e $e#n$e$.W) *ese) )o )e
eev#)e$ #n$een)e$ su5
-
7/25/2019 Rana Digest - Property
6/6
:e#*+, no vo$ o* ne's)en)on)*#) s e*en #) ssue.
As -o* )e su5
