8
Contents Graphics – Isometric View with 2D sprites / 3D Backgrounds ...................................................................................................... 2 The UI ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 The Artstyle ................................................................................................................................................................................ 3 Classes ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 4 Gameplay ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Fixed drop rate and XP rate ....................................................................................................................................................... 5 Market ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 7 Skill and Stat System .................................................................................................................................................................. 8

Ragnarok Anaylsis

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Contents Graphics Isometric View with 2D sprites / 3D Backgrounds ...................................................................................................... 2

    The UI ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 2

    The Artstyle ................................................................................................................................................................................ 3

    Classes ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 4

    Gameplay ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 5

    Fixed drop rate and XP rate ....................................................................................................................................................... 5

    Market ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 7

    Skill and Stat System .................................................................................................................................................................. 8

  • Over the years of playing many MMOs and many other types of online games I've always yearly come back to

    Ragnarok Online, one day I started wondering why? Why is it that I'm drawn to this 10+ year old game even with

    new games out today such as WildStar, Tera, Elder Scrolls Online, Guild Wars 2 and so on... Now a lot of this might

    be me using nostalgia to explain why things are good or bad but I did ask around of forums and people do seem to

    share my sentiment of what made Ragnarok Online what it is. I'm actually writing this because theres a spiritual

    sequel coming out called Tree of Savior and people told me Hey you seem to get it why not explain it a bit more

    indepth so I'm going to try and do just that. Excuse my writing, spelling and other errors I'm not a native English

    speaker.

    Graphics Isometric View with 2D sprites / 3D Backgrounds

    The first thing you see when you come into the game obviously. What made Ragnarok online the game it is. It has 2D

    sprites for most of the interactive objects in the game such as players and monsters. Some trigger objects in the

    background were 3D. Less is more is the name of the game here.

    The UI It was minimalistic and you had a clear view of the battlefield, your sprites and the monsters sprites where clear. All

    the necessary information was there. Unlike modern MMOs that literally flood you with useless information. Now a

    part of this is because Ragnarok Online really had no quest system but it still today looks sleeker if we compared it to

    some modern ones.

  • The Artstyle Ragnarok Online is what many in the west would refer to as an Anime MMO it has

    this cutesy Japanese looking art style, everything is made out of sprites and the

    only way to customize your character was to color the sprite or get a headgear but

    more on that later. What made Ragnarok attractive to a lot of people was exactly

    that art style. Anime fans flocked to it. It was their first online anime game. People

    looked the same (classes), while some would argue it was a lack of customization.

    I would say it simplified things and I'm glad Tree of Savoir is sticking to that.

    Naturally we need to talk about the monsters and the humble poring. Really it's

    just a cuter version of a slime from Dragon Quest but boy did it become iconic. It

    was cute, it was easy to kill and it was found everywhere. And they simply

    changed to color or added cute wing and they had a new monster or boss. I don't

    know who came up wit the idea but it was awesome. And the idea was

    consistent. Low level mobs were cute little fuzzy things. You could usually tell

    by the look of a monster how strong it was. There was no "Monster levels"

    above their heads or even HP bars. People in the old days had to use Monster

    Property/Sense to get the monsters stat. And that skill was limited to the

    Wizard but the party could see it. This made the game a lot more mysterious

    and encouraged exploration, but also punished it because well you could die

    and lose XP if you wandered too far or made a wrong corner in a dungeon.

    Anyways on track. The fact that you could tell monsters strength by their looks

    also made a twist late game were a cute monster would rape you in 2 seconds.

    I always remember going down into Payon Dungeon and seeing a cute

    pantiless catgirl only to get raped by it and it's horde of summoned ninetails.

    The point is the art style knew a great balance. How to make things scary, how

    to make things cute and how to make things deceptively cute before you're

    raped.

  • Classes While this could be considered art style too I wanted to touch on it some more. Every class had a unique sprite. That

    made a long leap in recognizability of players and what function they served. When I first started playing I went into

    town and saw all these people. It was clear who was a knight, who was a priest and who was a mage just by one

    glance. When I was in a dungeon and I saw an acolyte I could ask for a buff. The point is unlike 3D MMOs you knew

    who was what, look at this WOW picture of armors and you'll instantly know what I mean plus the armors changes

    every few levels and they all mostly have the same looks. The fact that the when you're playing you're zomed all the

    way out in any MMO. Also what made things worse for 3D MMOs is that recognizability falls off with distance

    drastically. Also while you were a novice you could have something to look forward to. These was a lot of class

    mobility and back tracking but later on that. It really enabled a lot of communication between people and made

    cosmetics stand out even more!

  • Gameplay

    Fixed drop rate and XP rate Now this is by far the biggest difference in my opinion except for the graphics between Ragnarok online and every

    other MMO out there ever. Now I'm going to have to touch on a lot of points here so please bare with me.

    While this might seem to some to be insignificant to some, it's actually one of the biggest gameplay features in

    Ragnarok online. While other similar games like let's say Diablo had totally randomized loot tables with randomized

    items, other MMOs like WoW had drop tables randomized so you couldn't hunt anything specific in general. You had

    a change that something uncommon or common would drop depening on your level there was no control. They also

    had these silly limitations placed on them because of that system where you wouldn't get any drops or XP if you

    were above a certain monsters level. For all intents and purposes all the gray monsters 5 levels below you were

    basically irrelevant removed gameplay elements and so were the areas you visited. Once somethings was done and

    you were above it's level it was useless and that in my eyes that was a big mistake because it leads to a huge

    decrease in "class mobility" . To this day a lot of MMOs continue this trend and I fear Tree of Savoir might go in this

    direciton but no info has shown up yet. Basically in a modern MMO you start at point A and go to point B. The

    designers designed areas and monsters for you to fight. Like a map in Ragnarok Online where it says from level 1 - 10

    after that it's useless. Anyways on to the main point to make you understand while fixed XP and Loot a great force in

    the "class mobility".

    So whats this "class mobility" I keep talking about. Well it's the interactions of low level players with high level

    players and replayability of content in low level areas. In Ragnarok Online as you know monsters have a fixed drop

    rate. If you kill this thing a certain number of times this will drop. Now what this system enabled was making content

    relevant to everyone at all levels.

    A Pupa would drop a Guard [1] or a Pupa card. While being low drop numbers these two

    items were used by medium/high tier players. Same with a lot of starting area monsters.

    Fabre cards, Peco Egg Cards, Picky cards and so on, they were cheap alternatives or

    actually required equipment for some high tier classes. This would lead to high level

    characters farming in low level areas for items and cards. Low level players would get to

    see the higher classes, they would see high level spells and could if wanted interact with

    high level players and that would lead new players to this feeling of "I wanna be that one

    day" or I wanna play that class next plus it enabled an economy for new players if they

    were smart, naturally this also lead to a lot of stealing and unfair prices but that was to m

    also one of the charms of it... If you just started the game and found a Pupa card. You

    could sell it depending on what server you were on for at least 100k or more. That was very valuable starting money

    that enabled you to buy items, consumables, travel or simply having the security of money. This made interaction

    between players a lot more exciting in the lower levels and it made content of low level areas replayable to higher

    levels. If you farmed low level monsters you would still get the XP and the loot. You were still doin something

    relevant. Even if your XP meter was moving along 0.01% per Pupa.

  • And let's not forget the fact that a fixed drop rate basically gave you a meaningful grocery list. You knew what items

    you needed, you knew where to get them. You went out there and you knew what you had to do. It was a really

    good time waster and the game knew how to make grind seem fun.

    The combination of this fixed drop rate, fixed Base XP and fixed JobXP gave rise to content replayability and farming

    different areas. Like I mentioned before Modern MMOs are all about hand holding while RO was an exploreative

    sandbox type of game. So you had basically 4 types of farming spots. And then these was a mix of these depending

    on the area.

    *Good Base XP, Okay JobXP, No loot, No money making

    *Good JobXP, Okay BaseXP, No loot, No money making

    *Really good low drop change loot, no money making, okayish JobXP and BaseXP

    *Tons of good money making items, okay JobXP and BaseXP but no good low drop chance loot.

    This system also forced you to think. How fast am I killing these monsters whats my hourly XP average, what is my

    gold average, how efficient is this area. The game had depth and a lot of things needed to be considered, if you were

    in a high level area and you were a VIT character there was always the question of how much am I spending and how

    much am I earning to level in this high level area compared to a more safer place. In modern MMOs this never comes

    up because healing items are always highly limited to prevent "spam" and most monster combat is at most 5-10 vs 1

    while in RO by draging creeps around you could easily end up in a 40 vs 1 situation if you weren't careful.

    In a modern MMO the designers design 2~3 areas for your level range and later maybe just one. They hand hold you

    with quests give you gear to progress while you kill monsters for irrelevant quest aka "Bring me 5 Wolf Hairs and you

    get these boots" and then the funny thing is only every 3rd wolf drops "wolf hair". But what this system does it is it

    eliminates the class mobility seen in RO. Content becomes irrelevant and obsolete as you complete it because even if

    you haven't completed that one boots quest you know that in the next area you will find another one just like that.

    This leads to a lack of replayability at high levels and makes high level characters never want go to the starting areas

    ever again.

    What RO did was tell you: "Hey NPCs sell basic gear, want better gear HUNT FOR IT. Where? Heres the map and what

    drops what." You were encouraged to go out to the wilderness and hunt and survive. And after your adventure was

    complete your gear while not visible would show were you have been. Kind of like Monster Hunter really. Now

    naturally this system is more grind prone and it also user unfriendly if these is no interface in game to tell you what

    drops what. Ro solved this by having websites and you could easily alt+tab to them to see things. So this area

    became at first was a huge mountain to climb but after a while the community developed to fix things and then later

    an actual map ingame was made.

    So basically the combination of NPCs selling okayish items but no where near the droped ones, the fact that fixed

    loot and XP gave you things to hunt and the fact that even if you came home with nothing you still maybe got money

    and you could buy the thing you wanted on the market. All this lead to more communication betwen players, more

    replayability and more incentive to make grind actually fun. Honestly to this day RO is the only game where I can just

    go into the wild and grind. I don't care about quests or anything and it's still damn fun!

  • Market Now this is a low point for Ragnarok online and it's mostly because the game was made such a long time ago. As you

    probably know Ragnarok Online had a dedicated class just for well marketing. They had a great idea together with it

    and thats the DC/OC system where you could sell loot for more and buy NPC items for less. If you wanted to play and

    make money effectively a merchant at least with OC/DC maxed was a mandatory thing. While a very interesting class

    to consider and it's advanced classes the blacksmith and alchemist are fun and I'm nostalgic we're losing them in

    Tree of Savior I'm also kind of glad because this system was in place for the sole reason of technical limitations of the

    time. Now on the the real market. Anyone that played Ragnarok online knows what a horrible market system it had.

    First at in the beginning you had to basically leave your PC on with the merchant to sell things while you weren't

    there. Then the fact that each shop can only contain a certain number of items. Then the fact that items had weights

    so you actually had to have that too to sell them. Then the fact that there was no search system. Then the fact that

    there was multiple markets around the server. Then the fact that you had to click and visit each one individually and

    that could take around like from 2~20 minutes to do. Basically RO had a horrible outdated market system and I know

    we'll get a normal auction house in Tree of Savior. Thank god for that too. I mean look at that picture.

    But still this was one of the charms of RO and it's probably nostalgia speaking here. It's interesting to note that a lot

    of korean MMOs sufered from this too. Maple story as an example but there was a lot more.

  • Skill and Stat System