Quantitative systematic review of the associations between ......2015/05/01 · 1 Quantitative systematic review of the associations between short‐term exposure to nitrogen dioxide

1

Quantitativesystematicreviewoftheassociationsbetweenshort‐termexposure

tonitrogendioxideandmortalityandhospitaladmissions

ICMills1,RWAtkinson2,SKang2,HWalton3,4,HRAnderson2,3

1‐PublicHealthEngland,CentreforRadiation,ChemicalandEnvironmentalHazards,UK

2‐PopulationHealthResearchInstituteandMRC‐PHECentreforEnvironmentandHealth,St

George’s,UniversityofLondon,London,UK

3‐MRC‐PHECentreforEnvironmentandHealth,King’sCollegeLondon,UK

4‐NIHRBiomedicalResearchCentreatGuy’sandStThomas’NHSFoundationTrustand

King’sCollegeLondon,London,UKandNIHRHealthProtectionResearchUniton

EnvironmentalHazardsatKing’sCollegeLondoninpartnershipwithPublicHealthEngland

SupplementaryMaterial

Contentslist1. MethodsLiteraturesearchcriteriaProtocolforselectingestimatesformeta‐analysis2. ListofcountriesbyWHORegionandmortalitystrata

3. ListofTablesTableS1:Randomeffectsestimatesforthepercentageincreaseincausespecificmortalityinallagesper

10µg/m3increaseinNO2

TableS2:Randomeffectsestimatesforthepercentageincreaseinrespiratoryhospitaladmissionsper10µg/m3increaseinNO2

TableS3:Randomeffectsestimatesforthepercentageincreaseincardiovascularhospitaladmissionsper10µg/m3increaseinNO2

4. ListofFiguresFigureS1:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforall‐causemortality,allages,

24houraverageNO2.FigureS2:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforall‐causemortality,allages,

1houraverageNO2.FigureS3:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallcardiovascular

mortality,allages,24houraverageNO2.

2

FigureS4:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallcardiovascular

mortality,allages,1houraverageNO2.FigureS5:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallrespiratorymortality,all

ages,24houraverageNO2.

FigureS6:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallrespiratorymortality,allages,1houraverageNO2.

FigureS7:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforcardiacmortality,allages,24houraverageNO2.

FigureS8:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforischaemicheartdiseasemortality,allages,24houraverageNO2.

FigureS9:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforstrokemortality,allages,24houraverageNO2

FigureS10:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforCOPDincludingasthmamortality,allages,24houraverageNO2

FigureS11:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallrespiratoryhospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2


FigureS13:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallrespiratoryhospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2


FigureS15:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallrespiratoryhospitaladmissions,children,24houraverageNO2


FigureS17:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforasthmahospitaladmissions,children,24houraverageNO2


FigureS19:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforCOPDincludingasthmahospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2

FigureS20:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforCOPDhospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

FigureS21:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallcardiovascularhospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

3


FigureS23:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallcardiovascularhospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2


FigureS25:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforcardiachospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2


FigureS27:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforcardiachospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2


FigureS29:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforheartfailurehospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

FigureS30:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforheartfailurehospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2


FigureS32:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforischaemicheartdiseasehospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

FigureS33:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforischaemicheartdiseaseadmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2


FigureS35:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforstrokeadmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

FigureS36:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforstrokeadmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2


FigureS38:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisfordysrhythmiahospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

FigureS39:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisfordysrhythmiahospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2

5. Listofreferencesincludedinthereview

4

METHODSLiteraturesearchcriteriaBibliographicdatabasesweresearchedtoidentifypeer‐reviewedtime‐series(andcasecrossover)papersofdailyconcentrationsofNO2anddailymortalityandhospitaladmissions.Bibliographicdatabasessearched:PubMed,EMBASEorWebofScience(whichincludestheScienceCitationIndex)Thesearchstringused:

(airpollutionORpollutionORnitricoxide*ORnitrogendioxide?)AND(timeseriesORtimeseriesORtime‐seriesORdailyORcase‐crossover)AND(mortalityORdeath*ORdyingORhospitaladmission*ORadmission*ORemergencyroomORvisit*ORattendance*OR‘a&e’OR‘aande’ORaccidentandemergencyORgeneralpract*ORphysician*ORconsultation*ORemergencydepartment*)

Norestrictiononlanguagewasapplied.Thedatabasesweresearchedforpeer‐reviewedpaperspublisheduptoMay2011.Inaddition,theliteraturesearchwassupplementedwithpapersidentifiedbytheUSEPA4–thiswasthemostcomprehensivenarrativeassessmentoftheNO2evidenceavailableatthetimeofthisreview.Protocolforselectingestimatesformeta‐analysisWeappliedanaprioriprotocolfortheselectionofestimatesformeta‐analysistoavoidselectionbiasandduplicationofstudiesfromthesamepopulation.Wegaveprioritytoestimatesfrommulti‐citystudiesoverestimatesfromsingle‐citystudiesandtheresultsfromanyonecityappearedonlyonceinameta‐analysis.Ifresultsfrommorethanonemulti‐citystudywithinaWHOregionwereavailableweselected,inorderofpriority,themulti‐cityestimatefromthestudy:

(i) withthemostcities/greatestgeographicalcoverage(ii) themostrecentlypublished(iii) themostrecentstudytimeperiod.

Ifamulti‐citystudydidnotreportasummaryestimateacrossthecitiesexamined,foranalysis,wetreatedestimatesfromthesestudiesinthesamemannerasestimatesfromsingle‐citystudies.Weselectedestimatesfromsingle‐citystudiesonlyiftheydidnotappearinmulti‐citystudies.Forcitiesnotincludedinamulti‐citystudysummaryresult,weselected,inorderofpriority:

(i) themostrecentlypublished(ii) themostrecentstudytimeperiod.

5

ListofcountriesbyWHORegionandmortalitystrataReproducedfromTheWorldHealthReport2002(http://www.who.int/whr/2002/en/,accessed7thFebruary2015)

6

7

TableS1:Randomeffectsestimatesforthepercentageincreaseincausespecificmortality*inallagesassociatedwitha10µg/m3increaseinNO2WHOregion

NO224hour NO21hour

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb

RandomEffects(95%CI)c

I2(%)d

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb


I2(%)d

Cardiacmortality,allages

Overalle 12/4 4/2 1.00(0.36,1.66) 79.1 2/1 1/1 0.19(0.00,0.39) 0AMRA 3/0 3/0 0.73(0.50,0.97) ‐ ‐ EURA 4/4 2/2 1.23(‐0.66,3.15) 1/1 0/1 0.20(0.00,0.40)WPRA 1/0 1/0 ‐0.80(‐2.81,1.25) 1/0 1/0 ‐0.02(‐1.04,1.01)WPRB 4/0 3/0 1.76(1.22,2.31) ‐ ‐ Ischaemicheartdisease,allages

Overalle 5/0 3/0 1.61(0.24,2.99) 0 Noestimates EURA 2/0 2/0 2.38(‐1.39,6.30) SEARB 1/0 1/0 1.50(‐0.70,3.75) WPRB 2/0 2/0 1.49(‐0.46,3.47) Strokemortality,allages

Overalle 16/1 4/1 1.35(0.74,1.97) 50.5

Noestimates EURA 2/1 2/1 2.47(0.66,4.31) SEARB 1/0 1/0 2.80(0.70,4.94) WPRA 1/0 1/0 0.78(0.16,1.41) WPRB 12/0 6/0 1.34(0.80,1.89) COPDincludingasthmamortality,allagesf

Overalle 12/0 4/0 1.11(0.72,1.50) 0

Noestimates AMRA 3/0 3/0 1.07(0.59,1.55) EURA 3/0 2/0 4.19(‐3.44,12.42) SEARB 1/0 1/0 ‐1.40(‐5.00,2.34) WPRB 5/0 2/0 1.25(0.56,1.94)

*Insufficientestimatesformeta‐analysisofmortalitycombinationsforheartfailureanddysrhythmiaa‐Numbersofsingle‐city(SC)/multi‐city(MC)estimatesavailablefromallstudiesb‐Numbersofsingle‐city(SC)/multicity(MC)estimatesselectedformeta‐analysisc‐Randomeffectssummaryestimate(95%confidenceinterval)per10μg/m3increaseinNO2d‐I2statisticforheterogeneitybetweenWHOregionse‐Estimatenumbersfor‘Overall’referto:(i)thenumberofsingle‐city(SC)/multi‐city(MC)estimatesavailablefromallstudies;(ii)forselectedestimates,itisthenumberofpooled(fromsingle‐cityestimates)andmulti‐cityestimatesusedtocalculatetheoverallsummaryestimateacrossWHOregionsf–noestimatesforCOPDmortalityinallagesareavailableformeta‐analysisAMR,RegionoftheAmericas;EUR,EuropeanRegion;SEAR,SouthEastAsianRegion;WPR,WesternPacificRegion.

8

TableS2:Randomeffectsestimatesforthepercentageincreaseinrespiratoryhospitaladmissionsper10µg/m3increaseinNO2WHOregion NO224hour NO21hour

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb


I2(%)d

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb


I2(%)d

Allrespiratory,allages

Overalle 19/3 5/2 0.57(0.33,0.82) 0 6/0 3/0 0.34(‐0.02,0.70) 76AMRA 1/1 1/1 0.61(0.13,1.09) ‐ ‐ ‐EURA 8/2 4/1 0.52(0.09,0.95) 3/0 3/0 0.21(0.07,0.36)SEARD 1/0 1/0 0.40(‐0.80,1.61) ‐ ‐ ‐WPRA 1/0 1/0 0.96(‐0.41,2.34) 2/0 2/0 ‐0.13(‐0.99,0.74)WPRB 8/0 6/0 0.58(0.16,1.01) 1/0 1/0 0.63(0.37,0.89)Allrespiratory,elderly

Overalle 16/1 4/1 0.69(0.17,1.21) 53.8 6/2 2/2 0.63(‐0.01,1.27) 82.7AMRA 3/0 2/0 1.43(0.45,2.42) ‐ ‐ ‐EURA 7/1 2/1 0.17(‐0.43,0.78) 4/1 1/1 0.15(‐0.25,0.56)WPRA 2/0 2/0 ‐1.12(‐8.86,7.28) 1/1 0/1 1.42(0.79,2.06)WPRB 4/0 2/0 0.93(0.61,1.24) 1/0 1/0 0.89(0.00,1.79)Allrespiratory,children

Overalle 14/4 4/2 1.20(0.35,2.05) 86.1 7/3 3/1 1.16(0.28,2.04) 94.6AMRA 1/0 1/0 4.69(1.88,7.57) ‐ ‐ ‐AMRB 5/0 1/0 0.79(0.41,1.18) 1/0 1/0 0.19(0.00,0.39)EURA 5/1 1/1 0.18(‐0.12,0.48) 2/0 2/0 0.33(0.03,0.62)WPRA 0/3 0/1 5.95(1.74,10.33) 2/3 0/1 2.70(0.93,4.51)WPRB 3/0 2/0 2.91(1.14,4.71) 2/0 1/0 2.37(1.79,2.96)Asthma,childrenf

Overalle 17/4 4/3 1.27(0.28,2.27) 86.5

8/3 1/2 0.37(‐0.08,0.82) 0AMRB 1/0 1/0 ‐0.40(‐1.00,0.20) ‐ ‐ ‐EURA 7/2 2/2 1.72(‐0.36,3.83) 5/1 2/1 0.38(‐0.18,0.94)WPRA 3/2 1/1 5.87(2.23,9.65) 3/2 0/1 1.50(‐1.28,4.37)WPRB 6/0 2/0 1.33(0.52,2.15) ‐ ‐ ‐COPDincludingasthma,elderlyg

Overalle 8/0 3/0 1.42(1.07,1.76) 30.8 1/1 1/1 0.63(0.18,1.07) 14.8AMRA 4/0 4/0 1.28(0.99,1.58) ‐ ‐ ‐EURA 3/0 2/0 3.14(0.76,5.58) 1/0 1/0 0.51(0.09,0.92)WPRA ‐ ‐ ‐ 0/1 0/1 1.05(0.16,1.95)WPRB 1/0 1/0 1.52(1.09,1.95) ‐ ‐ ‐COPD,allagesh

Overalle 6/2 2/2 1.24(‐0.01,2.50) 93.4 3/1 0/1 0.26(0.06,0.46) ‐AMRA 1/0 1/0 0.45(‐0.38,1.29) ‐ ‐ ‐EURA 4/2 0/2 0.81(0.03,1.59) 3/1 0/1 0.26(0.06,0.46)WPRB 1/0 1/0 2.60(2.20,3.00) ‐ ‐ ‐

a‐Numbersofsingle‐city(SC)/multi‐city(MC)estimatesavailablefromallstudiesb‐Numbersofsingle‐city(SC)/multicity(MC)estimatesselectedformeta‐analysisc‐Randomeffectssummaryestimate(95%confidenceinterval)per10μg/m3increaseinNO2d‐I2statisticforheterogeneitybetweenWHOregionse‐Estimatenumbersfor‘Overall’referto:thenumberofsingle‐city(SC)/multi‐city(MC)estimatesavailablefromallstudies;(ii)forselectedestimates,itisthenumberofpooled(fromsingle‐cityestimates)andmulti‐cityestimatesusedtocalculatetheoverallsummaryestimateacrossWHOregionsf–insufficientestimatesformeta‐analysisofasthmahospitalisationinadultsandelderly.g–insufficientestimatesformeta‐analysisofCOPD(includingasthma)hospitalisationinallagesfor24hourNO2andnonefor1hourNO2h‐insufficientestimatesformeta‐analysisofCOPDhospitalisationintheelderly.AMR,RegionoftheAmericas;EUR,EuropeanRegion;SEAR,SouthEastAsianRegion;WPR,WesternPacificRegion.

9

TableS3:Randomeffectsestimatesforthepercentageincreaseincardiovascularhospitaladmissionsper10µg/m3increaseinNO2

WHOregion

NO224hour NO21hour

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb


I2(%)d

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb


I2(%)d

Allcardiovascular,allages

Overalle 6/3 3/2 0.66(0.32,1.01) 87.8 6/0 3/0 0.36(‐0.16,0.89) 43.9EURA 1/3 1/2 0.42(0.23,0.62) 3/0 3/0 0.19(0.04,0.33)WPRA 1/0 1/0 1.96(0.65,3.30) 2/0 2/0 0.01(‐1.33,1.36)WPRB 4/0 3/0 1.00(0.75,1.24) 1/0 1/0 1.00(0.16,1.84)Allcardiovascular,elderly

Overalle 5/3 2/2 1.54(0.75,2.35) 86.9 5/0 3/0 0.49(‐0.25,1.24) 0EURA 1/2 1/1 1.02(0.08,1.97) 2/0 2/0 1.19(‐0.73,3.15)WPRA 1/1 0/1 3.08(2.15,4.01) 2/0 2/0 0.17(‐1.19,1.55)WPRB 3/0 2/0 1.18(0.88,1.48) 1/0 1/0 0.47(‐0.52,1.47)Cardiac,allages

Overalle 6/5 4/3 1.10(0.76,1.43) 84.3 3/2 ½ 0.98(0.43,1.54) 79.4AMRA 1/0 1/0 0.73(0.53,0.94) 0/1 0/1 1.34(0.89,1.79)EURA 3/5 2/3 0.93(0.66,1.20) 2/0 2/0 0.36(‐0.14,0.86)WPRA 1/0 1/0 2.26(1.57,2.94) 1/1 0/1 1.21(0.84,1.58)WPRB 1/0 1/0 1.20(0.70,1.70) ‐ ‐ ‐Cardiac,elderly

Overalle 8/3 2/2 1.65(1.02,2.29) 74.3 3/1 2/1 1.44(0.71,2.18) 64.2AMRA 4/0 4/0 1.31(1.04,1.57) 1/0 1/0 0.29(‐0.89,1.49)EURA 3/2 2/1 1.54(0.97,2.10) 1/0 1/0 2.02(1.22,2.82)WPRA 1/1 0/1 3.49(1.95,5.05) 1/1 0/1 1.58(1.16,2.00)Heartfailure,allages

Overalle 4/1 3/1 1.41(‐0.01,2.86) 84.7 Noestimates AMRA 2/0 2/0 1.20(‐0.13,2.55) EURA 1/1 1/1 0.41(‐0.64,1.47) WPRB 1/0 1/0 4.40(2.50,6.34) Heartfailure,elderly

Overalle 2/2 1/2 1.99(0.54,3.46) 79.8 8/1 1/1 0.51(0.13,0.89) ‐AMRA 2/1 2/1 1.56(0.80,2.32) 8/1 7/1 0.51(0.13,0.89)WPRA 0/1 0/1 7.08(2.26,12.13) ‐ ‐ ‐Ischemicheartdisease,allages

Overalle 16/4 4/2 0.86(0.52,1.20) 0 1/1 1/1 1.06(0.58,1.54) 0AMRA 3/0 2/0 1.34(0.17,2.52) ‐ ‐ ‐EMRB 1/0 1/0 0.62(0.26,0.98) ‐ ‐ ‐EURA 7/4 2/2 0.96(0.25,1.68) 1/0 1/0 1.11(‐0.04,2.27)WPRA ‐ ‐ ‐ 0/1 0/1 1.05(0.52,1.58)WPRB 5/0 3/0 0.90(‐0.08,1.89) ‐ ‐ ‐Ischemicheartdisease,elderly

Overalle 7/4 3/2 2.42(1.71,3.13) 0 3/1 2/1 0.70(0.17,1.22) 57.8AMRA 2/0 2/0 2.18(‐0.63,5.08) ‐ ‐ ‐AMRB ‐ ‐ ‐ 1/0 1/0 0.51(‐0.69,1.71)EURA 4/2 2/1 2.28(1.34,3.22) 2/0 2/0 0.44(0.15,0.73)WPRA 0/2 0/1 2.56(1.03,4.12) 0/1 0/1 1.16(0.58,1.74)WPRB 1/0 1/0 2.79(1.06,4.55) ‐ ‐ ‐Stroke,allages

Overalle 10/3 3/2 0.30(0.02,0.57) 0 Noestimates AMRA 3/0 2/0 0.27(‐0.06,0.61) EURA 4/3 4/2 0.28(‐0.51,1.07) WPRB 3/0 2/0 0.66(‐0.32,1.65) Stroke,elderly

Overalle 2/1 2/1 0.26(‐0.48,1.01) 0 1/2 1/2 0.50(‐0.54,1.56) 58.3AMRA 1/0 1/0 ‐0.11(‐1.45,1.24) 0/2 0/2 0.91(‐0.12,1.94)EURA 1/1 1/1 0.43(‐0.46,1.33) 1/0 1/0 ‐0.16(‐1.05,0.72)

10

TableS3(continued):Randomeffectsestimatesforthepercentageincreaseincardiovascularhospitaladmissionsper10µg/m3increaseinNO2

WHOregion

NO224hour NO21hour

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb


I2(%)d

AllSC/MCa

SelectedSC/MCb


I2(%)d

Dysrhythmia,allages

Overalle 3/1 2/1 0.50(0.15,0.86) 0 Noestimates AMRA 2/0 2/0 0.49(‐0.14,1.12) EURA 1/1 1/1 0.51(0.08,0.94) Dysrhythmia,elderly

Overalle 2/1 2/1 1.73(0.16,3.33) 26.9 Noestimates AMRA 1/0 1/0 1.82(‐0.05,3.74) EURA 1/0 1/0 3.65(0.56,6.84) WPRA 0/1 0/1 0.41(‐1.84,2.72)

a‐Numbersofsingle‐city(SC)/multi‐city(MC)estimatesavailablefromallstudiesb‐Numbersofsingle‐city(SC)/multicity(MC)estimatesselectedformeta‐analysisc‐Randomeffectssummaryestimate(95%confidenceinterval)per10μg/m3increaseinNO2d‐I2statisticforheterogeneitybetweenWHOregionse‐Estimatenumbersfor‘Overall’referto:(i)thenumberofsingle‐city(SC)/multi‐city(MC)estimatesavailablefromallstudies;(ii)forselectedestimates,itisthenumberofpooled(fromsingle‐cityestimates)andmulti‐cityestimatesusedtocalculatetheoverallsummaryestimateacrossWHOregionsAMR,RegionoftheAmericas;EUR,EuropeanRegion;SEAR,SouthEastAsianRegion;WPR,WesternPacificRegion.

11

FigureS1:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforall‐causemortality,allages,24houraverageNO2.1

1RMIDreferstotheReferenceIDforeachstudyinourReferenceManagerdatabase.AccessIDreferstoanIDgiventoeachestimateextractedfromastudyandenteredinourMicrosoftAccessdatabase.TheestimatefromRMID1494inFigureS1wassourcedfromTable1(page7‐33)oftheTechnicalSupportDocumentbytheCaliforniaEnvironmentalProtectionAgency(2007)becausetheestimatewasonlypresentedgraphicallyinRMID1494.

12

FigureS2:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforall‐causemortality,allages,1houraverageNO2.

13

FigureS3:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallcardiovascularmortality,allages,24houraverageNO2.

14

FigureS4:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallcardiovascularmortality,allages,1houraverageNO2.

15


16


17

FigureS7:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforcardiacmortality,allages,24houraverageNO2.

18

FigureS8:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforischaemicheartdiseasemortality,allages,24houraverageNO2.

19

FigureS9:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforstrokemortality,allages,24houraverageNO2

20

FigureS10:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforCOPDincludingasthmamortality,allages,24houraverageNO2

21


22


23


24


25


26


27


28


29

FigureS19:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforCOPDincludingasthmahospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2

30

FigureS20:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforCOPDhospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

31


32


33

FigureS23:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforallcardiovascularhospitaladmissions,elderly,24hoursaverageNO2

34


35


36


37


38


39

FigureS29:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforheartfailurehospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

40


41


42

FigureS32:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforischaemicheartdiseasehospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

43


44


45

FigureS35:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisforstrokeadmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

46


47


EstimatesfromRMID1929inFigureS37relatetotwotypesofstroke(hemorrhagicandischemic)

48

FigureS38:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisfordysrhythmiahospitaladmissions,allages,24houraverageNO2

49

FigureS39:Forestplotofstudiesandestimatesselectedformeta‐analysisfordysrhythmiahospitaladmissions,elderly,24houraverageNO2

50

Listofreferencesusedinthereview(ListedinorderofReferenceManagerID(RMID))

OstroBD,HurleyS,LipsettMJ.AirpollutionanddailymortalityintheCoachellaValley,California:AstudyofPM10dominatedbycoarseparticles.EnvironRes1999;81(NO‐3):231‐8.RMID:3

DiazJ,AlberdiJC,PajaresMS,etal.Amodelforforecastingemergencyhospitaladmissions:Effectofenvironmentalvariables.JournalofEnvironmentalHealth2001;64(3):9‐15.RMID:29

FungKY,LuginaahI,GoreyKM,etal.AirpollutionanddailyhospitaladmissionsforcardiovasculardiseasesinWindsor,Ontario.CanadianJournalofPublicHealth‐RevueCanadiennedeSantePublique2005;96(1):29‐33.RMID:36

PetroeschevskyA,SimpsonRW,ThalibL,etal.AssociationsbetweenoutdoorairpollutionandhospitaladmissionsinBrisbane,Australia.ArchEnvironHealth2001;56(1):37‐52.RMID:49

YangCY,HsiehHJ,TsaiSS,etal.Correlationbetweenairpollutionandpostneonatalmortalityinasubtropicalcity:Taipei,Taiwan.JournalofToxicologyandEnvironmentalHealth‐PartA‐CurrentIssues2006;69(22):2033‐40.RMID:58

PolonieckiJD,AtkinsonRW,DeLeonAP,etal.Dailytimeseriesforcardiovascularhospitaladmissionsandpreviousday'sairpollutioninLondon,UK.Occupational&EnvironmentalMedicine1997;54(8):535‐40.RMID:64

AndersonHR,BremnerSA,AtkinsonRW,etal.ParticulatematteranddailymortalityandhospitaladmissionsinthewestmidlandsconurbationoftheUnitedKingdom:associationswithfineandcoarseparticles,blacksmokeandsulphate.OccupEnvironMed2001;58(8):504‐10.RMID:69

ThompsonAJ,ShieldsMD,PattersonCC.AcuteasthmaexacerbationsandairpollutantsinchildrenlivinginBelfast,NorthernIreland.ArchEnvironHealth2001;56(3):234‐41.RMID:70

KanH,ChenBC.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinShanghai:Atime‐seriesstudy.ArchEnvironHealth2003;58(6):360‐7.RMID:76

WietlisbachV,ArdenP,III,Ackermann‐LiebrichU.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinthreeSwissurbanareas.SozPraventivmed1996;41(2):107‐15.RMID:83

SunyerJ,CastellsagueJ,SaezM,etal.AirpollutionandmortalityinBarcelona.JournalofEpidemiology&CommunityHealth1996;50(Suppl.1):76‐80.RMID:85

BallesterF,IniguezC,SaezM,etal.Short‐termrelationshipbetweenairpollutionandmortalityin13Spanishcities.MedClin2003;121(18):684‐9.RMID:92

Granados‐CanalDJ,ChardonB,LefrancA,etal.AirpollutionandrespiratoryhospitaladmissionsingreaterParis:Exploringsexdifferences.ArchivesofEnvironmental&OccupationalHealth2005;60(6):307‐13.RMID:97

51

ZanobettiA,SchwartzJ.AirpollutionandemergencyadmissionsinBoston,MA.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth2006;60(10):890‐5.RMID:105

HongY‐C,LeeJ‐T,KimH,etal.Effectsofairpollutantsonacutestrokemortality.EnvironHealthPerspect2002;110(2):187‐91.RMID:112

GalanI,TobiasA,BanegasJR,etal.Short‐termeffectsofairpollutionondailyasthmaemergencyroomadmissions.EurRespirJ2003;22(5):802‐8.RMID:123

ChenRJ,ChuC,TanJG,etal.AmbientairpollutionandhospitaladmissioninShanghai,China.JournalofHazardousMaterials2010;181(1‐3):234‐40.RMID:124

LeeSL,WongWHS,LauYL.AssociationbetweenairpollutionandasthmaadmissionamongchildreninHongKong.ClinExpAllergy2006;36(9):1138‐46.RMID:126

KanH,JiaJ,ChenBH.Acutestrokemortalityandairpollution:NewevidencefromShanghai,China.JournalofOccupationalHealth2003;45(5):321‐3.RMID:130

SimpsonR,WilliamsG,PetroeschevskyA,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutionondailymortalityinfourAustraliancities.AustNZJPublicHealth2005;29(3):205‐12.RMID:133

SimpsonR,WilliamsG,PetroeschevskyA,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononhospitaladmissionsinfourAustraliancities.AustNZJPublicHealth2005;29(3):213‐21.RMID:134

BurnettRT,BrookJ,DannT,etal.Associationbetweenparticulate‐andgas‐phasecomponentsofurbanairpollutionanddailymortalityineightCanadiancities.InhalToxicol2000;12:15‐39.RMID:135

MoolgavkarSH.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforchronicobstructivepulmonarydiseaseinthreemetropolitanareasintheUnitedStates.InhalToxicol2000;12:75‐90.RMID:136

OstroBD,BroadwinR,LipsettMJ.CoarseandfineparticlesanddailymortalityintheCoachellaValley,California:afollow‐upstudy.JExpoAnalEnvironEpidemiol2000;10(5):412‐9.RMID:144

SimpsonR,DenisonL,PetroeschevskyA,etal.EffectsofambientparticlepollutionondailymortalityinMelbourne,1991‐1996.JExpoAnalEnvironEpidemiol2000;10(5):488‐96.RMID:148

KanH,JiaJ,ChenBH.TheassociationofdailydiabetesmortalityandoutdoorairpollutioninShanghai,China.JournalofEnvironmentalHealth2004;67(3):21‐5.RMID:150

WongTW,TamWS,YuTS,etal.AssociationsbetweendailymortalitiesfromrespiratoryandcardiovasculardiseasesandairpollutioninHongKong,China.OccupEnvironMed2002;59(1):30‐5.RMID:153

CendonS,PereiraLAA,BragaALF,etal.Airpollutioneffectsonmyocardialinfarction.RevSaudePublica2006;40(3):414‐9.RMID:157

52

PenttinenP,TittanenP,PekkanenJ.MortalityandairpollutioninmetropolitanHelsinki,1988‐1996.ScandinavianJournalofWorkEnvironment&Health2004;30:19‐27.RMID:161

MoolgavkarSH.AirpollutionanddailymortalityintwoU.S.counties:Season‐specificanalysesandexposure‐responserelationships.InhalToxicol2003;15(9):877‐907.RMID:162

MoolgavkarSH.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinthreeUScounties.EnvironHealthPerspect2000;108(8):777‐84.RMID:163

HoekG,BrunekreefB,VerhoeffA,etal.DailymortalityandairpollutionintheNetherlands.JAirWasteManageAssoc2000;50(8):1380‐9.RMID:175

KlemmRJ,MasonRM.AerosolResearchandInhalationEpidemiologicalStudy(ARIES):Airqualityanddailymortalitystatisticalmodeling‐Interimresults.JAirWasteManageAssoc2000;50(8):1433‐9.RMID:176

ChockDP,WinklerSL.AstudyoftheassociationbetweendailymortalityandambientairpollutantconcentrationsinPittsburgh,Pennsylvania.JAirWasteManageAssoc2000;50(8):1481‐500.RMID:177

LipfertFW,MorrisSC,WyzgaRE.DailymortalityinthePhiladelphiametropolitanareaandsize‐classifiedparticulatematter.JAirWasteManageAssoc2000;50(8):1501‐13.RMID:178

RossiG,VigottiMA,ZanobettiA,etal.Airpollutionandcause‐specificmortalityinMilan,Italy,1980‐1989.ArchEnvironHealth1999;54(3):158‐64.RMID:181

BremnerSA,AndersonHR,AtkinsonRW,etal.Short‐termassociationsbetweenoutdoorairpollutionandmortalityinLondon1992‐4.Occupational&EnvironmentalMedicine1999;56(4):237‐44.RMID:182

TobiasGarcesA.,SunyerDeuJ.,CastellsaguePiqueJ.,etal.ImpactofairpollutiononthemortalityandemergenciesofchronicobstructivepulmonarydiseaseandasthmainBarcelona(seecomments).[Spanish].GacSanit1998;12(5):223‐30.RMID:183

Ocana‐RiolaR,Daponte‐CodinaA,Gutierrez‐CuadraP,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality.TheresultsoftheEMCAMprojectinthecityofSeville,1992‐1996.EstudioMulticentricoEspanolsobrelaRelacionentrelaContaminacionAtmosfericaylaMortalidad.[Spanish].RevEspSaludPublica1999;73(2):259‐65.RMID:190

GalanL,I,AranguezRE,GandarillasGA,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality:theresultsoftheEMECAMprojectinthemunicipalityofMadrid,1992‐1995.EstudioMulticentricoEspanolsobrelaRelacionentrelaContaminacionAtmosfericaylaMortalidad.[Spanish].RevEspSaludPublica1999;73(2):243‐52.RMID:192

DaponteCA,Gutierrez‐CuadraP,OcanaRR,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality:theresultsoftheEMECAMprojectinthecityofHuelva,1993‐96.EstudioMulticentricoEspanolsobrelaRelacionentrelaContaminacionAtmosfericayla

53

Mortalidad.[Spanish].RevEspSaludPublica1999;73(2):233‐42.RMID:193

CambraCK,AlonsoFE.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality:theresultsoftheEMECAMprojectingreaterBilbao.EstudioMulticentricoEspanolsobrelaRelacionentrelaContaminacionAtmosfericaylaMortalidad.[Spanish].RevEspSaludPublica1999;73(2):209‐14.RMID:196

SaurinaC,BarceloMA,SaezM,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality.TheresultsoftheEMECAMprojectinthecityofBarcelona,1991‐1995.EstudioMulticentricoEspanolsobrelaRelacionentrelaContaminacionAtmosfericaylaMortalidad.[Spanish].RevEspSaludPublica1999;73(2):199‐207.RMID:197

CanadaMA,GarciaGonzalezJV,RodriguezS,V,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality:theresultsoftheEMECAMprojectin2citiesofAsturias.EstudioMulticentricoEspanolsobrelaRelacionentrelaContaminacionAtmosfericaylaMortalidad.[Spanish].RevEspSaludPublica1999;73(2):187‐97.RMID:198

MorganG,CorbettS,WlodarczykJ,etal.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinSydney,Australia,1989through1993.AmJPublicHealth1998;88(5):759‐64.RMID:206

GouveiaN,FletcherT.RespiratorydiseasesinchildrenandoutdoorairpollutioninSaoPaulo,Brazil:atimeseriesanalysis.Occupational&EnvironmentalMedicine2000;57(7):477‐83.RMID:207

LoomisDP,CastillejosM,GoldDR,etal.AirpollutionandinfantmortalityinMexicoCity.Epidemiol1999;10(2):118‐23.RMID:210

PetersA,SkorkovskyJ,KotesovecF,etal.AssociationsbetweenmortalityandairpollutioninCentralEurope.EnvironHealthPerspect2000;108(4):283‐7.RMID:212

Borja‐AburtoVH,CastillejosM,GoldDR,etal.MortalityandambientfineparticlesinsouthwestMexicoCity,1993‐1995.EnvironHealthPerspect1998;106(12):849‐55.RMID:214

PrescottGJ,CohenGR,EltonRA,etal.Urbanairpollutionandcardiopulmonaryillhealth:a14.5yeartimeseriesstudy.Occupational&EnvironmentalMedicine1998;55(10):697‐704.RMID:216

MichelozziP,ForastiereF,FuscoD,etal.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinRome,Italy.Occupational&EnvironmentalMedicine1998;55(9):605‐10.RMID:219

ZmirouD,SchwartzJ,SaezM,etal.Time‐seriesanalysisofairpollutionandcause‐specificmortality.Epidemiol1998;9(5):495‐503.RMID:222

BurnettRT,CakmakS,RaizenneME,etal.TheassociationbetweenambientcarbonmonoxidelevelsanddailymortalityinToronto,Canada.JAirWasteManageAssoc1998;48(8):689‐700.RMID:224

BurnettRT,CakmakS,BrookJR.Theeffectoftheurbanambientairpollutionmixondailymortalityratesin11Canadiancities.CanadianJournalofPublicHealth1998;89(3):152‐

54

6.RMID:225

PonkaA,SavelaM,VirtanenM.MortalityandairpollutioninHelsinki.ArchEnvironHealth1998;53(4):281‐6.RMID:226

PereiraLA,LoomisD,ConceicaoGM,etal.AssociationbetweenairpollutionandintrauterinemortalityinSaoPaulo,Brazil.EnvironHealthPerspect1998;106(6):325‐9.RMID:228

SpixC,AndersonHR,SchwartzJ,etal.Short‐termeffectsofairpollutiononhospitaladmissionsofrespiratorydiseasesinEurope:aquantitativesummaryofAPHEAstudyresults.AirPollutionandHealth:aEuropeanApproach.ArchEnvironHealth1998;53(1):54‐64.RMID:229

SimpsonRW,WilliamsG,PetroeschevskyA,etal.AssociationsbetweenoutdoorairpollutionanddailymortalityinBrisbane,Australia.ArchEnvironHealth1997;52(6):442‐54.RMID:233

FarhatSCL,PauloRLP,ShimodaTM,etal.Effectofairpollutiononpediatricrespiratoryemergencyroomvisitsandhospitaladmissions.BrazilianJournalofMedicalandBiologicalResearch2005;38(2):227‐35.RMID:235

KelsallJE,SametJM,ZegerSL,etal.AirpollutionandmortalityinPhiladelphia,1974‐1988.AmJEpidemiol1997;146(9):750‐62.RMID:236

HalonenJI,LankiT,Yli‐TuomiT,etal.ParticulateAirPollutionandAcuteCardiorespiratoryHospitalAdmissionsandMortalityAmongtheElderly.Epidemiol2009;20(1):143‐53.RMID:238

TouloumiG,KatsouyanniK,ZmirouD,etal.Short‐termeffectsofambientoxidantexposureonmortality:acombinedanalysiswithintheAPHEAproject.AirPollutionandHealth:aEuropeanApproach.AmJEpidemiol1997;146(2):177‐85.RMID:240

BragaALF,SaldivaPHN,PereiraLAA,etal.HealtheffectsofairpollutionexposureonchildrenandadolescentsinSaoPaulo,Brazil.PediatrPulmonol2001;31(2):106‐13.RMID:242

DabW,MedinaS,QuenelP,etal.Shorttermrespiratoryhealtheffectsofambientairpollution:resultsoftheAPHEAprojectinParis.JournalofEpidemiology&CommunityHealth1996;50(Suppl1):s42‐s46.RMID:253

OstroBD,SanchezJM,ArandaC,etal.Airpollutionandmortality:resultsfromastudyofSantiago,Chile.JExpoAnalEnvironEpidemiol1996;6(1):97‐114.RMID:256

ZmirouD,BarumandzadehT,BalducciF,etal.ShorttermeffectsofairpollutiononmortalityinthecityofLyon,France,1985‐90.JournalofEpidemiology&CommunityHealth1996;50(Suppl1):s30‐s35.RMID:258

SpixC,WichmannHE.Dailymortalityandairpollutants:findingsfromKoln,Germany.JournalofEpidemiology&CommunityHealth1996;50(Suppl1):s52‐s58.RMID:264

55

AndersonHR,PoncedL,BlandJM,etal.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinLondon:1987‐92.BMJ1996;312(7032):665‐9.RMID:268

DockeryDW,SchwartzJ,SpenglerJD.Airpollutionanddailymortality:associationswithparticulatesandacidaerosols.EnvironRes1992;59(2):362‐73.RMID:312

WongCM,Vichit‐VadakanN,KanHD,etal.PublicHealthandAirPollutioninAsia(PAPA):Amulticitystudyofshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality.EnvironHealthPerspect2008;116(9):1195‐202.RMID:313

KanH,JiaJ,ChenB.Atime‐seriesstudyontheassociationofstrokemortalityandairpollutioninZhabei,Shanghai.JournalofHygieneResearch2006;33(1):36‐8.RMID:349

CakmakS,DalesRE,JudekS.Dogender,education,andincomemodifytheeffectofairpollutiongasesoncardiacdisease?JournalofOccupationalandEnvironmentalMedicine2006;48(1):89‐94.RMID:358

WongTW,LauTS,YuTS,etal.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforrespiratoryandcardiovasculardiseasesinHongKong.Occupational&EnvironmentalMedicine1999;56(10):679‐83.RMID:364

SaezM,TobiasA,MunozP,etal.AGEEmovingaverageanalysisoftherelationshipbetweenairpollutionandmortalityforasthmainBarcelona,Spain.StatMed1999;18(16):2077‐86.RMID:365

BurnettRT,Smith‐DoironM,StiebD,etal.Effectsofparticulateandgaseousairpollutiononcardiorespiratoryhospitalizations.ArchEnvironHealth1999;54(2):130‐9.RMID:368

MorganG,CorbettS,WlodarczykJ.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsinSydney,Australia,1990to1994.AmJPublicHealth1998;88(12):1761‐6.RMID:373

MorrisRD,NaumovaEN.Carbonmonoxideandhospitaladmissionsforcongestiveheartfailure:Evidenceofanincreasedeffectatlowtemperatures.EnvironHealthPerspect1998;106(10):649‐53.RMID:376

TsaiSS,ChenCC,HsiehHJ,etal.Airpollutionandpostneonatalmortalityinatropicalcity:Kaohsiung,Taiwan.InhalToxicol2006;18(3):185‐9.RMID:377

AndersonHR,PoncedL,BlandJM,etal.Airpollution,pollens,anddailyadmissionsforasthmainLondon1987‐92.Thorax1998;53(10):842‐8.RMID:380

HinwoodAL,DeKlerkN,RodriguezC,etal.TherelationshipbetweenchangesindailyairpollutionandhospitalizationsinPerth,Australia1992‐1998:Acase‐crossoverstudy.InternationalJournalofEnvironmentalHealthResearch2006;16(1):27‐46.RMID:388

KoopG,ToleL.Measuringthehealtheffectsofairpollution:towhatextentcanwereallysaythatpeoplearedyingfrombadair?JournalofEnvironmentalEconomicsandManagement2004;47(1):30‐54.RMID:396

56

SunyerJ,SpixC,QuenelP,etal.UrbanairpollutionandemergencyadmissionsforasthmainfourEuropeancities:TheAPHEAproject.Thorax1997;52(9):760‐5.RMID:398

AndersonHR,SpixC,MedinaS,etal.Airpollutionanddailyadmissionsforchronicobstructivepulmonarydiseasein6Europeancities:ResultsfromtheAPHEAproject.EurRespirJ1997;10(5):1064‐71.RMID:404

BurnettRT,DalesRE,BrookJR,etal.Associationbetweenambientcarbonmonoxidelevelsandhospitalizationsforcongestiveheartfailureintheelderlyin10Canadiancities.Epidemiol1997;8(2):162‐7.RMID:409

PonkaA,VirtanenM.Low‐levelairpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforcardiacandcerebrovasculardiseasesinHelsinki.AmJPublicHealth1996;86(9):1273‐80.RMID:414

PoncedeLeonA,AndersonHR,BlandJM,etal.EffectsofairpollutionondailyhospitaladmissionsforrespiratorydiseaseinLondonbetween1987‐88and1991‐92.JournalofEpidemiology&CommunityHealth1996;50(Suppl.1):s63‐s70.RMID:417

PonkaA,VirtanenM.Chronicbronchitis,emphysema,andlow‐levelairpollutioninHelsinki,1987‐1989.EnvironRes1994;65(2):207‐17.RMID:442

BellML,LevyJK,LinZ.Theeffectofsandstormsandairpollutiononcause‐specifichospitaladmissionsinTaipei,Taiwan.OccupEnvironMed2008;65(2):104‐11.RMID:458

SchwartzJ.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforcardiovasculardiseaseinTucson.Epidemiol1997;8(4):371‐7.RMID:472

NeubergerM,RabczenkoD,MoshammerH.ExtendedeffectsofairpollutiononcardiopulmonarymortalityinVienna.AtmosphericEnvironment2007;41(38):8549‐56.RMID:475

SchoutenJP,VonkJM,DeGraafA.Shorttermeffectsofairpollutiononemergencyhospitaladmissionsforrespiratorydisease:resultsoftheAPHEAprojectintwomajorcitiesinTheNetherlands,1977‐89.JournalofEpidemiology&CommunityHealth1996;50(Suppl1):s22‐s29.RMID:480

MorrisRD,NaumovaEN,MunasingheRL.AmbientairpollutionandhospitalizationforcongestiveheartfailureamongelderlypeopleinsevenlargeUScities.AmJPublicHealth1995;85(10):1361‐5.RMID:484

BrookJR,BurnettRT,DannTF,etal.FurtherinterpretationoftheacuteeffectofnitrogendioxideobservedinCanadiantime‐seriesstudies.JournalofExposureScienceandEnvironmentalEpidemiology2007;17:S36‐S44.RMID:485

HongYC,LeemJH,HaEH.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinInchon,Korea.JKoreanMedSci1999;14(NO‐3):239‐44.RMID:501

AndersenZJ,WahlinP,Raaschou‐NielsenO,etal.AmbientparticlesourceapportionmentanddailyhospitaladmissionsamongchildrenandelderlyinCopenhagen.JournalofExposure

57

ScienceandEnvironmentalEpidemiology2007;17(7):625‐36.RMID:519

FischerPH,MarraM,AmelingCB,etal.TrendsinrelativeriskestimatesfortheassociationbetweenairpollutionandmortalityinTheNetherlands,1992‐2006.EnvironRes2011;111(1):94‐100.RMID:551

GiovanniniM,SalaM,RivaE,etal.HospitaladmissionsforrespiratoryconditionsinchildrenandoutdoorairpollutioninSouthwestMilan,Italy.ActaPaediatrica2010;99(8):1180‐5.RMID:554

KoFWS,TamW,WongTW,etal.EffectsofairpollutiononasthmahospitalizationratesindifferentagegroupsinHongKong.ClinExpAllergy2007;37(9):1312‐9.RMID:567

HajatS,ArmstrongB,WilkinsonP,etal.Outdoorairpollutionandinfantmortality:analysisofdailytime‐seriesdatain10Englishcities.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth2007;61(8):719‐22.RMID:573

JimenezE,LinaresC,RodriguezLF,etal.Short‐termimpactofparticulatematter(PM2.5)ondailymortalityamongtheover‐75agegroupinMadrid(Spain).ScienceoftheTotalEnvironment2009;407(21):5486‐92.RMID:576

JimenezE,LinaresC,MartinezD,etal.RoleofSaharandustintherelationshipbetweenparticulatematterandshort‐termdailymortalityamongtheelderlyinMadrid(Spain).ScienceoftheTotalEnvironment2010;408(23):5729‐36.RMID:577

PetersA,BreitnerS,CyrysJ,etal.TheinfluenceofimprovedairqualityonmortalityrisksinErfurt,Germany.2009:5‐77.RMID:621

MoolgavkarSH,LuebeckEG,AndersonEL.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforrespiratorycausesinMinneapolisSt.PaulandBirmingham.Epidemiol1997;8(4):364‐70.RMID:635

JayaramanG,Nidhi.AirpollutionandassociatedrespiratorymorbidityinDelhi.HealthCareManagementScience2008;11(2):132‐8.RMID:739

SamoliE,NastosPT,PaliatsosAG,etal.Acuteeffectsofairpollutiononpediatricasthmaexacerbation:Evidenceofassociationandeffectmodification.EnvironRes2011;111(3):418‐24.RMID:872

FairleyD.DailymortalityandairpollutioninSantaClaraCounty,California:1989‐1996.EnvironHealthPerspect1999;107(8):637‐41.RMID:889

UedaK,NittaH,OdajimaH.Theeffectsofweather,airpollutants,andAsiandustonhospitalizationforasthmainFukuoka.EnvironmentalHealthandPreventiveMedicine2010;15(6):350‐7.RMID:918

LinCA,Martins.M.A.,FarhatSC,etal.AirpollutionandrespiratoryillnessofchildreninSaoPaulo,Brazil.Pediatric&PerinatalEpidemiology1999;13(4):475‐88.RMID:1006

58

AtkinsonRW,BremnerSA,AndersonHR,etal.Short‐termassociationsbetweenemergencyhospitaladmissionsforrespiratoryandcardiovasculardiseaseandoutdoorairpollutioninLondon.ArchEnvironHealth1999;54:398‐411.RMID:1053

HongYC,LeemJH,HaEH,etal.PM10exposure,gaseouspollutants,anddailymortalityinInchon,SouthKorea.EnvironHealthPerspect1999;107(11):873‐88.RMID:1070

HagenJA,NafstadP,SkrondalA,etal.Associationsbetweenoutdoorairpollutantsandhospitalizationforrespiratorydiseases.Epidemiol2000;11(2):136‐40.RMID:1071

GwynnRC,BurnettRT,ThurstonGD.Atime‐seriesanalysisofacidicparticulatematteranddailymortalityandmorbidityintheBuffalo,NewYork,region.EnvironHealthPerspect2000;108(2):125‐33.RMID:1073

Garcia‐AymerichJ,TobiasA,AntoJM,etal.Airpollutionandmortalityinacohortofpatientswithchronicobstructivepulmonarydisease:atimeseriesanalysis.JournalofEpidemiology&CommunityHealth2000;54(1):73‐4.RMID:1079

CadumE,RossiG,MirabelliD,etal.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinTurin,1991‐1996.EpidemiolPrev1999;23(4):268‐76.RMID:1094

LinnWS,SzlachcicY,GongH,etal.AirpollutionanddailyhospitaladmissionsinmetropolitanLosAngeles.EnvironHealthPerspect2000;108:427‐34.RMID:1105

MarTF,NorrisGA,KoenigJQ,etal.AssociationsbetweenairpollutionandmortalityinPhoenix,1995‐1997.EnvironHealthPerspect2000;108:347‐53.RMID:1120

TeniasBurilloJM,Perez‐HoyosS,Molina,etal.Theshort‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortality.TheresultsoftheEMECAMprojectinthecityofValencia,1994‐96.EstudioMultcentricoEspanolsobrelaRelacionentrelaContaminacionAtmosfericaylaMortalidad.[Spanish].RevEspSaludPublica1999;73(2):267‐74.RMID:1140

CifuentesL,VegaJ,KopferK,etal.EffectofthefinefractionofparticulatematterversusthecoarsemassandotherpollutantsondailymortalityinSantiago,Chile.JAirWasteManageAssoc2000;50(8):1287‐98.RMID:1152

LippmannM,ItoK,NadasA,etal.Associationofparticulatemattercomponentswithdailymortalityandmorbidityinurbanpopulations.HealthEffectsInstitute2000:5‐72.RMID:1181

BallesterF,TeniasJM,Perez‐HoyosS.AirpollutionandemergencyhospitaladmissionsforcardiovasculardiseasesinValencia,Spain.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth2001;55(1):57‐65.RMID:1184

ChoB,ChoiJ,YumYT.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforrespiratorydiseaseincertainareasofKorea.JournalofOccupationalHealth2000;42(4):185‐91.RMID:1185

59

GouveiaN,FletcherT.Timeseriesanalysisofairpollutionandmortality:effectsbycause,ageandsocioeconomicstatus.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth2000;54(10):750‐5.RMID:1187

MoolgavkarSH.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsfordiseasesofthecirculatorysysteminthreeUSmetropolitanareas.JAirWasteManageAssoc2000;50(7):1199‐206.RMID:1196

WichmannHE,SpixC,TuchT,etal.DailyMortalityandFineandUltrafileParticlesinErfurt,GermanyPartI:RoleofParticleNumberandParticleMass.HealthEffectsInstitute2000.RMID:1205

EilsteinD,QuenelP,HedelinG,etal.Airpollutionandmyocardialinfarction.StrasbourgFrance,1984‐89.RevEpidemiolSantePublique2001;49(1):13‐25.RMID:1253

FuscoD,ForastiereF,MichelozziP,etal.AirpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforrespiratoryconditionsinRome,Italy.EurRespirJ2001;17(6):1143‐50.RMID:1265

HoekG,BrunekreefB,FischerP,etal.Theassociationbetweenairpollutionandheartfailure,arrhythmia,embolism,thrombosis,andothercardiovascularcausesofdeathinatimeseriesstudy.Epidemiol2001;12(3):355‐7.RMID:1275

MichelozziP,ForastiereF,PerucciCA,etal.AcuteeffectsofairpollutioninRome.[Italian].AnnIstSuperSanita2000;36(3):297‐304.RMID:1299

WongCM,MaS,HedleyAJ,etal.EffectofairpollutionondailymortalityinHongKong.EnvironHealthPerspect2001;109(4):335‐40.RMID:1327

WongGWK,KoFWS,LauTS,etal.TemporalrelationshipbetweenairpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforasthmaticchildreninHongKong.ClinExpAllergy2001;31(4):565‐9.RMID:1328

ZeghnounA,EilsteinD,SaviucP,etal.Monitoringofshort‐termeffectsofurbanairpollutiononmortality.Resultsofapilotstudyin9Frenchcities.RevEpidemiolSantePublique2001;49(1):3‐12.RMID:1332

BiggeriA,BelliniP,TerraciniB,etal.Meta‐analysisoftheItalianstudiesonshort‐termeffectsofairpollution.[Italian].EpidemiolPrev2001;25(2:Suppl):Suppl‐71.RMID:1337

KwonH‐J,ChoS‐H,NybergF,etal.Effectsofambientairpollutionondailymortalityinacohortofpatientswithcongestiveheartfailure.Epidemiol2001;12(4):413‐9.RMID:1354

RoemerWH,VanWijnenJH.DailymortalityandairpollutionalongbusystreetsinAmsterdam,1987‐1998.Epidemiol2001;12(6):649‐53.RMID:1360

ZeghnounA,CzernichowP,BeaudeauP,etal.Short‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortalityinthecitiesofRouenandLeHavre,France,1990‐1995.ArchEnvironHealth2001;56(4):327‐35.RMID:1374

SaezM,BallesterF,BarceloMA,etal.Acombinedanalysisoftheshort‐termeffectsofphotochemicalairpollutantsonmortalitywithintheEMECAMproject.EnvironHealth

60

Perspect2002;110(3):221‐8.RMID:1416

WongCM,AtkinsonRW,AndersonHR,etal.Ataleoftwocities:EffectsofairpollutiononhospitaladmissionsinHongKongandLondoncompared.EnvironHealthPerspect2002;110(1):67‐77.RMID:1429

HongY‐C,LeeJ‐T,KimH,etal.Airpollution:Anewriskfactorinischemicstrokemortality.Stroke2002;33(9):2165‐9.RMID:1448

LeTertreA,QuenelP,EilsteinD,etal.Short‐termeffectsofairpollutiononmortalityinnineFrenchcities:Aquantitativesummary.ArchEnvironHealth2002;57(4):311‐9.RMID:1465

LeeJT,KimH,SongHY,etal.AirpollutionandasthmaamongchildreninSeoul,Korea.Epidemiol2002;13(4):481‐4.RMID:1466

Revisedanalysesoftime‐seriesstudiesofairpollutionandhealth.HealthEffectsInstitute2003.RMID:1494

HaEH,LeeJT,KimH,etal.InfantsusceptibilityofmortalitytoairpollutioninSeoul,SouthKorea.Pediatrics2003;111(2):284‐90.RMID:1495

D'IppolitiD,ForastiereF,AnconaC,etal.AirpollutionandmyocardialinfarctioninRome‐Acase‐crossoveranalysis.Epidemiol2003;14(5):528‐35.RMID:1509

FischerP,HoekG,BrunekreefB,etal.AirpollutionandmortalityintheNetherlands:aretheelderlymoreatrisk?EurRespirJ2003;21:34S‐8S.RMID:1517

GoldbergMS,BurnettRT,ValoisMF,etal.Associationsbetweenambientairpollutionanddailymortalityamongpersonswithcongestiveheartfailure.EnvironRes2003;91(1):8‐20.RMID:1520

KanHD,ChenBH.Acase‐crossoveranalysisofairpollutionanddailymortalityinShanghai.JournalofOccupationalHealth2003;45(2):119‐24.RMID:1531

MannJK,TagerIB,LurmannF,etal.Airpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforischemicheartdiseaseinpersonswithcongestiveheartfailureorarrhythmia.EnvironHealthPerspect2002;110(12):1247‐52.RMID:1547

OftedalB,NafstadP,MagnusP,etal.TrafficrelatedairpollutionandacutehospitaladmissionforrespiratorydiseasesinDrammen,Norway1995‐2000.EurJEpidemiol2003;18(7):671‐5.RMID:1556

TsaiSS,HuangCH,GogginsWB,etal.RelationshipbetweenairpollutionanddailymortalityinaTropicalCity:Kaohsiung,Taiwan.JournalofToxicologyandEnvironmentalHealth‐PartA2003;66(14):1341‐9.RMID:1583

VilleneuvePJ,BurnettRT,ShiYL,etal.Atime‐seriesstudyofairpollution,socioeconomicstatus,andmortalityinVancouver,Canada.JExpoAnalEnvironEpidemiol2003;13(6):427‐35.RMID:1587

61

DalesR,BurnettRT,Smith‐DoironM,etal.Airpollutionandsuddeninfantdeathsyndrome.Pediatrics2004;113(6):E628‐E631.RMID:1600

EilsteinD,DeclercqC,ProuvostH,etal.Theimpactofairpollutiononhealth.PresseMedicale2004;33(19):1323‐7.RMID:1603

KlemmRJ,LipfertFW,WyzgaRE,etal.DailymortalityandairpollutioninAtlanta:TwoyearsofdatafromARIES.InhalToxicol2004;16:131‐41.RMID:1610

LinCA,PereiraLAA,NishiokaDC,etal.AirpollutionandneonataldeathsinSaoPaulo,Brazil.BrazilianJournalofMedicalandBiologicalResearch2004;37(5):765‐70.RMID:1612

LeeJT,KimH,ChoYS,etal.Airpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforischemicheartdiseasesamongindividuals64+yearsofageresidinginSeoul,Korea.ArchEnvironHealth2003;58(10):617‐23.RMID:1622

HosseinpoorAR,ForouzanfarMH,YunesianM,etal.AirpollutionandhospitalizationduetoanginapectorisinTehran,Iran:Atime‐seriesstudy.EnvironRes2005;99(1):126‐31.RMID:1629

YangQY,ChenY,KrewskiD,etal.Effectofshort‐termexposuretolowlevelsofgaseouspollutantsonchronicobstructivepulmonarydiseasehospitalizations.EnvironRes2005;99(1):99‐105.RMID:1638

KwonH‐J,ChoS‐H.AirpollutionanddailymortalityinSeoul.KoreanJournalofPreventativeMedicine1999;32(2):191‐9.RMID:1643

ChangJH,etal.EffectofairpollutionondailyclinictreatmentsforrespiratorycardiovasculardiseaseincentralTaiwan,1997‐1999.ZhonghuaOccupationalMedicineJournal2002;9(2):111‐20.RMID:1645

BallesterF,RodriguezP,IniguezC,etal.AirpollutionandcardiovascularadmissionsassociationinSpain:resultswithintheEMECASproject.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth2006;60(4):328‐36.RMID:1646

BarnettAG,WilliamsGM,SchwartzJ,etal.TheeffectsofairpollutiononhospitalizationsforcardiovasculardiseaseinelderlypeopleinAustralianandNewZealandcities.EnvironHealthPerspect2006;114(7):1018‐23.RMID:1647

ChanCC,ChuangKJ,ChienLC,etal.UrbanairpollutionandemergencyadmissionsforcerebrovasculardiseasesinTaipei,Taiwan.EurHeartJ2006;27(10):1238‐44.RMID:1650

FungKY,KhanS,KrewskiD,etal.AssociationbetweenairpollutionandmultiplerespiratoryhospitalizationsamongtheelderlyinVancouver,Canada.InhalToxicol2006;18(13):1005‐11.RMID:1656

LankiT,PekkanenJ,AaltoP,etal.Associationsoftrafficrelatedairpollutantswithhospitalisationforfirstacutemyocardialinfarction:theHEAPSSstudy.OccupEnviron

62

Med2006;63(12):844‐51.RMID:1659

SamoliE,AgaE,TouloumiG,etal.Short‐termeffectsofnitrogendioxideonmortality:ananalysiswithintheAPHEAproject.EurRespirJ2006;27(6):1129‐37.RMID:1671

WelleniusGA,BatesonTF,MittlemanMA,etal.ParticulateairpollutionandtherateofhospitalizationforcongestiveheartfailureamongMedicarebeneficiariesinPittsburgh,Pennsylvania.AmJEpidemiol2005;161(11):1030‐6.RMID:1924

WelleniusGA,SchwartzJ,MittlemanMA.Airpollutionandhospitaladmissionsforischemicandhemorrhagicstrokeamongmedicarebeneficiaries.Stroke2005;36(12):2549‐53.RMID:1929

KoFW,TamW,WongTW,etal.TemporalrelationshipbetweenairpollutantsandhospitaladmissionsforchronicobstructivepulmonarydiseaseinHongKong.Thorax2007;62(9):780‐5.RMID:1939

KimSY,KimH,KimJ.EffectsofairpollutiononAsthmainSeoul:Comparisonsacrosssubjectcharacteristics.JPrevMedPublicHealth2006;39:309‐16.RMID:1941

LeeJT,SonJY,ChoYS.AcomparisonofmortalityrelatedtourbanairparticlesbetweenperiodswithAsiandustdaysandwithoutAsiandustdaysinSeoul,Korea,2000‐2004.EnvironRes2007;105(3):409‐13.RMID:1942

LeeJ‐T.AssociationsbetweenairpollutionandasthmarelatedhospitaladmissionsinchildreninSeoul,Korea:Acasecrossoverstudy.KoreanJournalofPreventativeMedicine2003;36:47‐53.RMID:1943

QianZ,HeQ,LinHM,etal.Short‐termeffectsofgaseouspollutantsoncause‐specificmortalityinWuhan,China.JAirWasteManagAssoc2007;57(7):785‐93.RMID:1945

YangCY,ChangCC,ChuangHY,etal.Relationshipbetweenairpollutionanddailymortalityinasubtropicalcity:Taipei,Taiwan.EnvironInt2004;30(4):519‐23.RMID:1947

AndersenZJ,WahlinP,Raaschou‐NielsenO,etal.SizedistributionandtotalnumberconcentrationofultrafineandaccumulationmodeparticlesandhospitaladmissionsinchildrenandtheelderlyinCopenhagen,Denmark.OccupEnvironMed2008;65(7):458‐66.RMID:1950

BreitnerS,StolzelM,CyrysJ,etal.Short‐TermMortalityRatesduringaDecadeofImprovedAirQualityinErfurt,Germany.EnvironHealthPerspect2009;117(3):448‐54.RMID:1954

ChenGH,SongGX,JiangLL,etal.Short‐termeffectsofambientgaseouspollutantsandparticulatematterondailymortalityinShanghai,China.JournalofOccupationalHealth2008;50(1):41‐7.RMID:1956

KanHD,LondonSJ,ChenGH,etal.Season,sex,age,andeducationasmodifiersoftheeffectsofoutdoorairpollutionondailymortalityinShanghai,China:ThePublicHealthandAir

63

PollutioninAsia(PAPA)study.EnvironHealthPerspect2008;116(9):1183‐8.RMID:1973

LarrieuS,JusotJF,BlanchardM,etal.ShorttermeffectsofairpollutiononhospitalizationsforcardiovasculardiseasesineightFrenchcities:ThePSASprogram.ScienceoftheTotalEnvironment2007;387(1‐3):105‐12.RMID:1976

MukamalKJ,WelleniusGA,SuhHH,etal.Weatherandairpollutionastriggersofsevereheadaches.Neurology2009;72(10):922‐7.RMID:1990

RenYJ,LiXY,ChenK,etal.[Acase‐crossoverstudyonairpollutantsandthemortalityofstroke].ZhonghuaLiuXingBingXueZaZhi=ZhonghuaLiuxingbingxueZazhi2008;29(9):878‐81.RMID:2001

SauerzapfV,JonesAP,CrossJ.EnvironmentalfactorsandhospitalisationforchronicobstructivepulmonarydiseaseinaruralcountyofEngland.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth2009;63(4):324‐8.RMID:2007

StoelzelM,BreitnerS,CyrysJ,etal.DailymortalityandparticulatematterindifferentsizeclassesinErfurt,Germany.JournalofExposureScienceandEnvironmentalEpidemiology2007;17(5):458‐67.RMID:2014

WongCM,OuCQ,ChanKP,etal.TheeffectsofairpollutiononmortalityinsociallydeprivedurbanareasinHongKong,China.EnvironHealthPerspect2008;116(9):1189‐94.RMID:2026

BlanchardM,BorrelliD,ChardonB,etal.AnalysisofshorttermlinksbetweenurbanairpollutionandmortalityinnineFrenchcities;Analysedesliensacourttermeentrepollutionatmospheriqueurbaineetmortalitedansneufvillesfrancaises.Programmedesurveillanceairetsante2008.RMID:2037

BarnettAG,WilliamsGM,SchwartzJ,etal.Airpollutionandchildrespiratoryhealth‐Acase‐crossoverstudyinAustraliaandnewZealand.AmericanJournalofRespiratoryandCriticalCareMedicine2005;171(11):1272‐8.RMID:2039

LinM,StiebDM,ChenY.Coarseparticulatematterandhospitalizationforrespiratoryinfectionsinchildrenyoungerthan15yearsinToronto:Acase‐crossoveranalysis.Pediatrics2005;116(2):E235‐E240.RMID:2040

AlvesCA,ScottoMG,FreitasMD.AirpollutionandemergencyadmissionsforcardiorespiratorydiseasesinLisbon(Portugal).QuimicaNova2010;33(2):337‐44.RMID:2047

ChenRJ,PanGW,KanHD,etal.AmbientairpollutionanddailymortalityinAnshan,China:Atime‐stratifiedcase‐crossoveranalysis.ScienceoftheTotalEnvironment2010;408(24):6086‐91.RMID:2052

ColaisP,SerinelliM,FaustiniA,etal.AirpollutionandurgenthospitaladmissionsinnineItaliancities.ResultsoftheEpiAirProject.Epidemiologia&Prevenzione2009;33(6):77‐94.RMID:2054

GuoYM,BarnettAG,ZhangYS,etal.Theshort‐termeffectofairpollutiononcardiovascularmortalityinTianjin,China:Comparisonoftimeseriesandcase‐crossoveranalyses.

64

ScienceoftheTotalEnvironment2010;409(2):300‐6.RMID:2055

LeeD,ShaddickG.Spatialmodelingofairpollutioninstudiesofitsshort‐termhealtheffects.Biometrics2010;66(4):1238‐46.RMID:2060

LefrancA,PascalL,LarrieuS,etal.Airpollutionandcardiovasculardiseases:InsightsfromtheFrenchairpollutionandhealthsurveillanceprogram.ArchivesdesMaladiesProfessionnellesetdelEnvironnement2009;70(3):339‐45.RMID:2062

Lopez‐VillarrubiaE,BallesterF,IniguezC,etal.AirpollutionandmortalityintheCanaryIslands:atime‐seriesanalysis.EnvironmentalHealth2010;9.RMID:2064

ParkAK,HongYC,KimH.EffectofchangesinseasonandtemperatureonmortalityassociatedwithairpollutioninSeoul,Korea.JEpidemiolCommunityHealth2011;65(4):368‐75.RMID:2067

SerinelliM,GianicoloEAL,CervinoM,etal.AcuteeffectsofairpollutioninBrindisi(Italy):acase‐crossoveranalysis.Epidemiologia&Prevenzione2010;34(3):100‐7.RMID:2070

StafoggiaM,FaustiniA,RognoniM,etal.AirpollutionandmortalityintenItaliancities.ResultsoftheEpiAirProject.Epidemiologia&Prevenzione2009;33(6):65‐76.RMID:2072

ThachTQ,WongCM,ChanKP,etal.Airpollutantsandhealthoutcomes:Assessmentofconfoundingbyinfluenza.AtmosphericEnvironment2010;44(11):1437‐42.RMID:2074

TsaiDH,WangJL,ChuangKJ,etal.Traffic‐relatedairpollutionandcardiovascularmortalityincentralTaiwan.ScienceoftheTotalEnvironment2010;408(8):1818‐23.RMID:2075

VigottiMA,SerinelliM,MarchiniL.UrbanairpollutionandchildrenrespiratoryhospitaladmissionsinPisa(Italy)atimeseriesandacase‐crossoverapproach.Epidemiologia&Prevenzione2010;34(4):143‐9.RMID:2076

YorifujiT,KawachiI,SakamotoT,etal.Associationsofoutdoorairpollutionwithhemorrhagicstrokemortality.JournalofOccupationalandEnvironmentalMedicine2011;53(2):124‐6.RMID:2077

BurnettRT,StiebD,BrookJR,CakmakS,DalesR,RaizenneM,VincentR,DannT.Associationsbetweenshort‐termchangesinnitrogendioxideandmortalityinCanadiancities.ArchEnvironHealth.2004;59(5):228‐36.

RMID:3000CakmakS,DalesRE,JudekS.Respiratoryhealtheffectsofairpollutiongases:modificationby

educationandincome.ArchEnvironOccupHealth.2006;61(1):5‐10.RMID:3001

YangQ,ChenY,ShiY,BurnettRT,McGrailKM,KrewskiD.AssociationbetweenozoneandrespiratoryadmissionsamongchildrenandtheelderlyinVancouver,Canada.InhalToxicol.2003;15(13):1297‐308.RMID:3002

65

HEIPublicHealthandAirPollutioninAsiaProgram.(2010)PublicHealthandAirPollutioninAsia(PAPA):CoordinatedStudiesofShort‐TermExposuretoAirPollutionandDailyMortalityinFourCities.HEIResearchReport154.HealthEffectsInstitute,Boston,MA.RMID:3003

Documents

Quantitative systematic review of the associations between ......2015/05/01 · 1 Quantitative systematic review of the associations between short‐term exposure to nitrogen dioxide