9
Journal of Geological Resource and Engineering 1 (2015) 28-36 doi:10.17265/2328-2193/2015.01.004 Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions Takashi Sasaoka 1 , Akihiro Hamanaka 1 , Hideki Shimada 1 , Kikuo Matsui 1 , Nay Zar Lin 2 and Budi Sulistianto 3 1. Department of Earth Resources Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka 819-0395, Japan 2. Mine Planning Section, Ministry of Mines, Nay Pyi Taw, Myanmar 3. Department of Mining Engineering, Institute Technology Bandung, Bandung 40116, Indonesia Abstract: Most of coal is produced from open-cut mines in Southeast Asian countries. However, the conditions of their surface mines are worsening each year: the stripping ratio is increasing, approaching economic ratio and the regulation of environmental protection. To meet the demand for coal, underground mines have to be developed in the near future. Under these circumstances, the development of new coal mines from open-cut highwalls are being planned in Southeast Asian Countries. Moreover, some of the Southeast Asian mines have thick coal seams. However, if the conventional mining systems and designs introduced in US, Australia and European Countries are applied, several geotechnical issues can be expected due to the mines’ weak geological conditions. From these backgrounds, this paper proposed a punch multi-slice mining system with stowing for thick coal seam under weak geological conditions and discussed its applicability and suitable design by means of numerical analysis. Key words: Punch multi-slice longwall mining, thick coal seam, weak strata, stability of highwall. 1. Introduction The surface mining method is generally considered to be more advantageous than the underground method, especially in recovery, grade control, production capacity, economics, flexibility, safety and working environments. Therefore, the surface mining method is common in major coal producing countries [1, 2]. Most of coal is produced from open-cut mines in Southeast Asian countries. However, the conditions of their surface mines are worsening each year: the stripping ratio is increasing, approaching economic ratio, the regulation of environmental protection, and poor infrastructure for coal from inland mining areas [3]. To meet the demand for coal in Southeast Asian Countries and the rest of the world, underground mines have to be developed in the near future. Under these circumstances, the development of new coal mines from open-cut highwalls are being planned in several Corresponding author: Takashi Sasaoka, assistant professor, research fields: ground control in mining, blasting and mining system. E-mail: [email protected]. mines in Southeast Asian Countries including Thailand, Indonesia, etc. Moreover, some of the Southeast Asian mines have thick coal seams [4, 5]. However, if the conventional mining systems and designs introduced in US, Australia and European Countries are applied, several geotechnical issues can be expected due to the mines’ weak geological conditions [6]. From these backgrounds, a punch multi-slice top coal caving method with stowing was proposed as a mining system for thick coal seam and weak geological conditions. This paper discusses the applicability of punch multi-slice top coal caving method to the mines in South-East Asian Countries and its suitable design and measures by means of numerical analysis. 2. Punch Mining System One of the major mining system for final highwall of surface coal mine is highwall mining system. Conventional highwall mining systems extract coal with an auger machine or continuous miner. However, less coal recovery is a problem in these systems, D DAVID PUBLISHING

Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

  • Upload
    builien

  • View
    225

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Journal of Geological Resource and Engineering 1 (2015) 28-36 doi:10.17265/2328-2193/2015.01.004

Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick

Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions

Takashi Sasaoka1, Akihiro Hamanaka1, Hideki Shimada1, Kikuo Matsui1, Nay Zar Lin2 and Budi Sulistianto3

1. Department of Earth Resources Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka 819-0395, Japan

2. Mine Planning Section, Ministry of Mines, Nay Pyi Taw, Myanmar

3. Department of Mining Engineering, Institute Technology Bandung, Bandung 40116, Indonesia

Abstract: Most of coal is produced from open-cut mines in Southeast Asian countries. However, the conditions of their surface mines are worsening each year: the stripping ratio is increasing, approaching economic ratio and the regulation of environmental protection. To meet the demand for coal, underground mines have to be developed in the near future. Under these circumstances, the development of new coal mines from open-cut highwalls are being planned in Southeast Asian Countries. Moreover, some of the Southeast Asian mines have thick coal seams. However, if the conventional mining systems and designs introduced in US, Australia and European Countries are applied, several geotechnical issues can be expected due to the mines’ weak geological conditions. From these backgrounds, this paper proposed a punch multi-slice mining system with stowing for thick coal seam under weak geological conditions and discussed its applicability and suitable design by means of numerical analysis. Key words: Punch multi-slice longwall mining, thick coal seam, weak strata, stability of highwall.

1. Introduction

The surface mining method is generally considered

to be more advantageous than the underground method,

especially in recovery, grade control, production

capacity, economics, flexibility, safety and working

environments. Therefore, the surface mining method is

common in major coal producing countries [1, 2]. Most

of coal is produced from open-cut mines in Southeast

Asian countries. However, the conditions of their

surface mines are worsening each year: the stripping

ratio is increasing, approaching economic ratio, the

regulation of environmental protection, and poor

infrastructure for coal from inland mining areas [3]. To

meet the demand for coal in Southeast Asian Countries

and the rest of the world, underground mines have to be

developed in the near future. Under these

circumstances, the development of new coal mines

from open-cut highwalls are being planned in several

Corresponding author: Takashi Sasaoka, assistant

professor, research fields: ground control in mining, blasting and mining system. E-mail: [email protected].

mines in Southeast Asian Countries including Thailand,

Indonesia, etc. Moreover, some of the Southeast Asian

mines have thick coal seams [4, 5]. However, if the

conventional mining systems and designs introduced in

US, Australia and European Countries are applied,

several geotechnical issues can be expected due to the

mines’ weak geological conditions [6]. From these

backgrounds, a punch multi-slice top coal caving

method with stowing was proposed as a mining system

for thick coal seam and weak geological conditions.

This paper discusses the applicability of punch

multi-slice top coal caving method to the mines in

South-East Asian Countries and its suitable design and

measures by means of numerical analysis.

2. Punch Mining System

One of the major mining system for final highwall of

surface coal mine is highwall mining system.

Conventional highwall mining systems extract coal

with an auger machine or continuous miner. However,

less coal recovery is a problem in these systems,

D DAVID PUBLISHING

Page 2: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punc

because man

maintain the

mined length

of the sy

introduction

alternative.

concept [7].

Archveyor s

shown in Fi

leave a lot o

Rapid ac

practiced in

mining oper

conventiona

blocks deve

highwall [8

longwall min

Beltana is

which achie

producing 6

considered

operation in

system of m

requires no t

ventilation sy

Fig. 1 Punch

ch Multi-Slice

ny coal pilla

e highwall/mi

h is limited b

stems. Con

n of undergrou

The punch m

. The first pu

system was pr

ig. 1. Howev

f coal as pilla

ccess punch

Australia. Au

ration comme

al longwall e

eloped direc

]. Fig. 2 sho

ning system.

s a highwall

ved its first f

6 Mt (ROM

to be the m

n Australia

mining are: h

transport, con

ystems or mai

h mining syste

Longwall Mi

ars have to be

ined openings

by the inhere

nsidering the

und mining s

mining syste

unch mining

roposed and t

ver, this minin

ars.

longwall m

ustralia’s firs

enced in the

equipment to

ctly from an

ows the sche

access longw

full year of op

M: Run-of-M

most cost-ef

[9]. The adv

high producti

nveyor drifts

in headings as

em.

ning System

e left in orde

s stability and

ent characteri

ese issues,

systems is als

em is not a

system using

tried in the U

ng system ha

mining has b

st punch long

late 1990s u

mine coal f

n open-cut f

ematic of pu

wall punch m

peration in 2

Mine) coal. I

fficient long

vantages in

ivity; the sys

, shafts, com

s in conventio

for Thick Co

er to

d the

stics

the

o an

new

g an

US as

as to

been

gwall

using

from

final

unch

mine,

004,

It is

gwall

this

stem

mplex

onal

Fig.

und

prov

com

requ

reta

thro

its

pro

high

incr

How

the

slop

con

3. MSto

W

min

less

leng

may

extr

divi

mul

arou

stab

bee

issu

con

oal Seam und

. 2 Punch lon

derground m

vides cheap

mmencement

uired proper

ain and maint

oughout the l

advantages

ductivity, an

hwall mining

reasingly imp

wever, the de

mining pane

pe and the m

ndition have n

Multi-slice owing

While conside

nes, an applic

s potential du

gths. It is see

y be conside

raction of the

iding the sea

lti-slicing me

und the mini

bility of slop

en made clea

ues such as hi

nventional thi

er Weak Geo

ngwall mining s

mining metho

per, faster,

of longwall

mine plann

tain the open

life of underg

of high p

nd competit

g system, this

plemented in

esign and the

el/face and its

mining opera

not been made

Top Coal

ering the situ

cability of hig

ue to their l

en that punch

ered for the

e thick coal s

ms into mult

ethod is appl

ing panel/fac

pe and the m

arly yet. In

ighwall instab

ck seam mini

ological Cond

system.

ods, hence

simpler

l mining. Ho

ning and min

cut surface i

ground operat

production c

tively lower

s system is ex

n Australian

e ground beh

s impact of th

ation in wea

e clearly.

Caving M

uation of Sou

ghwall mining

limitations in

highwall min

mines. How

eam, it must

ti-slicing. Ho

lied, the grou

e and their im

mining operati

case, the gro

bility can be

ing method is

ditions 29

this benefit

access and

owever, it is

ne design to

infrastructure

tions. Due to

capacity and

r cost than

xpected to be

coal mines.

havior around

he stability of

ak geological

ethod with

utheast Asian

g systems are

n penetration

ning systems

wever, as for

be mined by

wever, when

und behavior

mpact of the

ion have not

ound control

expected if a

s introduced.

9

t

d

s

o

e

o

d

n

e

.

d

f

l

h

n

e

n

s

r

y

n

r

e

t

l

a

Page 3: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punch Multi-Slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions 30

A new multi-slice top coal caving mining method

based on the concept of punch longwall and top coal

caving methods is proposed. The concept of the new

multi-slice top coal caving mining method is illustrated

in Fig. 3. First, the coal seam is developed along the

mine roof with conventional cut. Then stowing

material is injected into gob area in order to have better

mine roof condition. After the stowing material is

consolidated, the next slice is begun by leaving

appropriate thickness of coal parting beneath the first

slice and it is recovered by applying a top coal caving

method in the second slice. After the second slice is

extracted using a top coal caving method, stowing

material is injected into the gob area in the second slice.

Next slices are also extracted by applying a top coal

caving method and stowing is conducted after each

slice is mined out and mining and stowing are repeated

until the whole coal seam is mined out as the same

manner. By applying this method, the number of slices

required for the extra-thick coal seam and the burden

for excessive costs for development of gate roads

required for extra-thick seam can also be overcome

compared with an application of the conventional

multi-slice mining method. It will be also useful to

reduce the impact on ground/slope due to extraction of

extra-thick coal seams and can also be useful to

minimize the amount of waste rocks managed on

surface.

4. Numerical Analysis

When an underground mine is developed from an

open-cut highwall, the design of panels and safety

pillars such as boundary pillar and inter-panel pillar in

the transition area have great influenced on the

highwall stability as well as the amount of resource

recovery around the final highwall. If the pillar and

panel sizes are inadequate, it is possible for slope

instability or sliding of slope due to insufficient support

to the highwall. On the other hand, if the pillars are

over-sized, the amount of resource recovery around the

highwall will be decreased. Therefore, careful planning

and designing of panels and pillars around the final

highwall. In order to make the criteria for the

applicability and the design of a punch multi-slice top

coal caving method around the final highwall, the

response of ground/slope under weak geological

conditions and different operational conditions are

investigated by means of FLAC3DVer.5.

4.1 Numerical Model

In surface mining, as the bench design is usually

based on economic reach of the mining equipment used

in the mine, characteristics of deposit, production

strategy and geological and geotechnical condition of

the mine. In this study, therefore, the following

assumptions are made based on the typical bench

design for open-cut coal mining practices [10]. The

height of the each single bench is designed as 20 m, and

the bench slope angle is 65 degrees. The width of the

bench is set as 36 m whereas the safety berm is 6 m

wide in the models. The angle of overall slope is 37

degrees. The geometry, meshes and group of zones and

dimension of the 200 m deep pit model employed in the

analyses are illustrated in Fig. 4. In this study,

mechanical properties of rock obtained from one

Indonesian surface coal mine are used in this study as

represented in Table 1.

The design of panels and pillars in transition area

from surface to underground mine for thick seam

under weak and strong geological condition are

discussed. Due to the advantages of highest efficiency

Fig. 3 Concept of multi-slice top coal caving with stowing method (longwall mining system).

Page 4: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punch Multi-Slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions 31

Fig. 4 Numerical model (Pit depth = 200 m).

Table 1 Mechanical properties of rock mass and coal used in this analyses.

Rock mass Coal

Density (kg/m3) 1,950 1,430 UCS (Uniaxial compressive strength) (MPa)

11.36 5.0

Bulk modulus (MPa) 6.67 × 103 3.79 × 102

Shear modulus (MPa) 4.0 × 104 1.95 × 102

Tensile strength (MPa) 0.1 0.1

Cohesion (MPa) 1.75 0.5

Friction angle (deg.) 25 22.3

and productivity among the methods available for thick

seam, a longwall top coal caving method is primarily

considered in this study. In longwall top caving

practices, although the method allows for more than 10

m thick seam in one pass and up to 80-90% recovery of

additional coal, coal recovery is less than expected in

practical situation due to coal seam and strata

conditions, about 70-80% of coal can be recovered in

practical situation. Operational issues also limit top

coal recovery and can often account for a greater

percentage of the reduce recovery than geological

conditions alone. In this study, therefore, two slice

system is considered for the 10 m thick coal seam,

where the first slice is cut conventionally and next slice

is extracted by top coal caving method. Basically, the

height of mining for conventional cut for the first slice

was considered as 3 m and next slice is set as 7 m,

where 3 m thick of coal is cut along the floor of coal

seam and 4 m thick of coal is recovered. The scheme of

multi-slice top coal caving mining method performed

in the analyses is illustrated in Figs. 5a-5b.

The panels and pillars were initially designed based

on the results of preliminary analysis that the

conventional longwall mining system is applied for the

extraction of 3 m thickness of coal under weak

geological condition. The panel of 100 m width and the

inter-panel pillar of 60 m width are initially taken and

the ground behavior is investigated. The boundary

pillar of 100 m width for 200 m and 300 m deep pit and

that of 150 m width for 400 m deep is initially taken.

Layout of the initial mining panel is shown in Fig. 6.

4.2 Results and Discussions

4.2.1 Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System

without Stowing System

Figs. 7a-7b and 8a-8b show failure states and contours

of induced displacement after extracting second slice in

Page 5: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punc32

Fig. 5 Schem(without stow

Fig. 6 Layou

200 m and 3

case of 200

slope is ob

boundary pil

can be said

maintained u

other hand, i

the vertical d

in both ca

boundary pil

ch Multi-Slice

(a) The Firs

(b) The secome of multi-sl

wing).

ut of panel mo

300 m deep p

0 m pit depth

bserved 6.5-7

llar is also in

that the stab

under these p

in the cases of

displacement

ses, large f

llars. In this s

Longwall Mi

st slice extractio

nd slice extractlicing perform

delled in the a

pit slopes, res

h, as the disp

7 cm in ma

stable condit

bility of over

anel and pilla

f 300 m pit de

at the slopes

failures are

situation, if th

ning System

on

tion med in the ana

nalyses.

spectively. In

placement at

aximum and

tion. Therefor

rall slope can

ar designs. On

epth, even tho

is about 6.5-7

occurred at

he condition a

for Thick Co

alyses

n the

t the

the

re, it

n be

n the

ough

7 cm

the

at the

toe

who

Con

incr

larg

F

con

m d

con

slop

of 4

and

slop

mai

mod

pan

T

m t

100

and

of d

disp

Fig.extrpillawidt

oal Seam und

of the slope

ole slope inst

nsequently, t

reased into 2

ger than 300 m

Figs. 9a-9b an

ntours of displ

deep pits. In

ndition of bou

pe can be mai

400 m deep p

d the large di

pe, the stabi

intained. Th

deling with

nel width is di

The width of

to 100 m and

0 m to 60 m.

d Figs. 12a-12

displacement

placement at

. 7 Failure stracting 2nd slar width = 100th = 100 m).

er Weak Geo

is worsen an

tability and/or

the widths

00 m in the c

m.

nd 10a-10b sh

lacement in th

the case of 3

undary pillar

intained. On t

pit, as the bou

isplacement

ility of over

herefore, the

larger inter-

iscussed in th

inter-panel p

d the width o

Fig. 11 illus

2b shows the f

in this condi

the slope is

(a) Failure

(b) Displactates and conlices in 200 m0 m, inter-pane

ological Cond

nd the pillar

r slide would

of boundary

cases that the

how the failu

he cases of 30

300 m deep p

can be impro

the other han

undary pillar

can be recog

all slope sti

e ground b

-panel pillar

he case of 400

pillar is increa

f panel is dec

strates the lay

failure states

itions. It is fo

decreased fro

e state

cement tours of displ

m deep pit sloel pillar width

ditions

is failed, the

d be occurred.

y pillars are

e pit depth is

ure states and

00 m and 400

pit depth, the

oved and the

nd, in the case

is still failed

gnized in the

ll cannot be

behavior by

and smaller

0 m pit depth.

ased from 60

creased from

yout of panel

and contours

ound that the

om 4.5-5 cm

lacement afterope (boundary

= 60 m, panel

e

.

e

s

d

0

e

e

e

d

e

e

y

r

.

0

m

l

s

e

m

r y l

Page 6: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punc

Fig. 8 Failuextracting 2npillar width =width = 100 m

Fig. 9 Failuextracting 2npillar width =width = 100 m

into 3.5-4 c

boundary pi

ch Multi-Slice

(a) F

(b) Diure states and nd slices in 30= 100 m, inter-m).

(a) F

(b) Diure states and nd slices in 30= 200 m, inter-m).

cm. In addit

illar is impro

Longwall Mi

ailure state

isplacement contours of d

00 m deep pi-panel pillar w

ailure state

isplacement contours of d

00 m deep pi-panel pillar w

tion, the failu

oved and its

ning System

displacement it slope (boun

width = 60 m, p

displacement it slope (boun

width = 60 m, p

ure condition

stability can

for Thick Co

after dary

panel

after dary

panel

n of

n be

mai

ord

400

4

A

that

also

prop

larg

Fig.extrpillawidt

Fig.deep60 m

oal Seam und

intained. How

er to maintai

0 m deep pit.

4.2.2 Applicat

According to

t punch mul

o be applica

per panel an

ge amount of

. 10 Failure sracting 2nd slar width = 200th = 100 m).

. 11 Layout op pit slope (boum, inter-panel

er Weak Geo

wever, a plent

in the stabilit

tion of Stowi

the results di

lti-slice top

able around

nd pillar des

coal have to

(a) Failure

(b) Displacstates and conlices in 400 m0 m, inter-pane

of panel modelundary pillar wpillar width =

ological Cond

ty of coal hav

ty of slope in

ing System

iscussed abov

coal caving

the final hig

sign. Howeve

be left as the

e state

cement ntours of displm deep pit sloel pillar width

led in the analywidth = 200 m,100 m).

ditions 33

ve to be left in

n the case of

ve, it is found

method can

ghwall by a

er, since the

pillars, coal

lacement afterope (boundary

= 60 m, panel

yses for 400 m, panel width =

3

n

f

d

n

a

e

r y l

m =

Page 7: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punc34

Fig. 12 Failextracting 2npillar width =width = 60 m)

Fig. 13 Sche(with stowing

ch Multi-Slice

(a) F

(b) Diure states and

nd slices in 40= 200 m, inter-p).

(a)The Firs

(b) The secoeme of multi-sg).

Longwall Mi

ailure state

isplacement d contours of d00 m deep pipanel pillar wi

st slice extractio

nd slice extractslicing perform

ning System

displacement it slope (bounidth = 100 m, p

on

tion med in the ana

for Thick Co

after dary

panel

alyses

reco

of

stow

T

with

gob

slic

app

top

seco

adv

Fig

In

des

bou

pit,

is ta

T

use

rati

0.5

resp

A

in th

con

with

foun

to

dec

sub

effe

or s

F

disp

dee

and

3-3

from

60

syst

but

oal Seam und

overy will be

multi-slice t

wing method

The first slice

h 3 m mining

b immediately

e, next slic

plying longwa

coal 4 m th

ond slice. S

vance as the s

s. 13a-13b).

n the analyse

igned as 100

undary pillar w

whereas 200

aken as the sl

The mechanic

d in the analy

o 0.23, Youn

MPa, cohesi

pectively.

At first, the p

he 200 m dee

ntours of disp

h multi-slice

nd that failur

be small dr

reased from

sidence at th

ect of subside

sliding of slop

Figs. 15a-15b

placement af

ep pit. No fai

d the displace

.5 cm after s

m 60 m to 10

m to 100 m

tem can not o

also increase

er Weak Geo

e decreased. T

top coal cav

is investigate

is also extrac

g height and s

y. After extrac

ce extraction

all top coal ca

hickness and

Stowing is f

same manner

s, the panel a

m and 60 m a

width is taken

0 m for 400 m

lurry stowing

cal properties

yses are: densi

ng’s modulus

on 0.5 MPa,

performance o

ep pit. Fig. 14

placement aft

e top coal ca

re zone aroun

ramatically a

6.5-7 cm in

he slope is ve

ence at the sl

pe will not be

b show failur

fter extracting

lures are fou

ement at the

stowing even

00 m and the

m. Hence, th

only improve

e coal recover

ological Cond

Therefore, th

ving in conju

ed and discus

cted with con

towing is inje

cting and stow

ns were co

aving method

cutting heigh

followed afte

r as in the fi

and pillar size

as shown in F

n as 100 m fo

m deep pit. A f

g material.

s of this stow

ity 1,000 kg/m

617 MPa, ten

friction angle

of stowing is

4 shows failu

er extracting

aving with st

nd the mine r

and the disp

nto 2.5-3 cm

ery small, th

ope such as f

e expected.

re states and

g second slic

und in the bou

slope is sma

n the panel s

panel size in

e application

e the stability

ry.

ditions

he application

unction with

ssed.

nventional cut

ected into the

wing the first

onducted by

d with leaving

ht of 3 m in

er each face

irst slice (see

es are initially

Fig. 6 and the

r 200 m deep

flyash cement

wing material

m3, Poisson’s

nsile strength

e 26 degrees,

s investigated

ure states and

second slice

towing. It is

roof becomes

placement is

m. Since the

e subsequent

failure, crack

d contours of

ce in 400 m

undary pillar

all and about

ize increases

ncreases from

n of stowing

of slope and

n

h

t

e

t

y

g

n

e

e

y

e

p

t

l

s

h

,

d

d

e

s

s

s

e

t

k

f

m

r

t

s

m

g

d

Page 8: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punc

Fig. 14 Failextracting 2npillar width =width = 100 m

Fig. 15 Failextracting 2npillar width =width = 100 m

From the

the stowing

ch Multi-Slice

(a) F

(b) Dilure states andnd slices in 20= 100 m, inter-m).

(a) F

(b) Diure states and

nd slices in 40= 200 m, inter-m).

above discus

is effective m

Longwall Mi

ailure state

isplacement d contours of 00 m deep pi-panel pillar w

ailure state

isplacement d contours of d00 m deep pi-panel pillar w

sions, it can b

method for pr

ning System

displacement it slope (boun

width = 60 m, p

displacement it slope (boun

width = 60 m, p

be concluded

revent the fai

for Thick Co

after dary

panel

after dary

panel

d that

ilure

of p

com

bou

be i

pit.

100

inte

eve

has

can

dee

pill

How

pan

whe

extr

be h

5. C

T

cav

dep

app

pill

pap

cav

seam

coa

is f

pill

at t

imp

H

of p

wea

con

stow

sequ

Re

[1]

oal Seam und

pillars and co

mparison with

undary pillar w

in stable and

If stowing is

0 m is enou

er-panel pillar

en though the

to be left, the

n be increased

ep pit, the rat

ar is approxim

wever, if stow

nel to inter-p

en stowing i

raction length

higher.

Conclusion

The applicab

ving method

pths under

propriate des

ars and panel

per. Moreover

ving in conjun

m is proposed

al recovery an

found that sto

ar failure and

the slope. As

proved.

However, in o

punch multi-

ak geological

nducted includ

wing materi

uence, etc.

ferences

Oya, J., ShimPertiwi, R., a

er Weak Geo

ontrol the disp

h previous res

width 200 m

to have safe

s applied, the

ugh although

r sizes are the

e boundary p

e panel width

d. For examp

io of the wid

mately 0.60 :

wing is applie

anel pillar is

is applied. I

h can be set,

ns

bility of pun

for thick co

weak geol

ign of boun

ls are investig

r, the applicat

nction with st

d and discuss

nd improveme

owing is quit

d to control th

s the results,

order to devel

-slice top co

l condition, th

ding the cont

ial, sizes o

mada, H., Sasaokand Fajrin, A. M

ological Cond

placement at

sults without

need to be le

e operation in

e boundary pi

h the size o

e same. In 40

illar of 200 m

to inter-pane

ple, in the ca

dth of panel t

: 1 when with

ed, the ratio of

s approximat

In addition,

the productiv

nch multi-sli

oal seams in

logical con

ndary pillars

gated and disc

tion of multi-

towing for we

sed in order to

ent of stabilit

te effective to

he stability an

the coal reco

lop the appro

oal caving m

he more stud

trol of top coa

of panel/pil

ka, T., Ichinose,M. 2009. “Fund

ditions 35

the slope. In

stowing, the

eft in order to

n 300 m deep

illar width of

of panel and

0 m deep pit,

m width still

el pillar ration

ase of 400 m

to inter-panel

hout stowing.

f the width of

ely 1.67 : 1

since longer

vity will also

ice top coal

different pit

nditions and

, inter-panel

cussed in this

slice top coal

eak and thick

o increase the

ty of slope. It

o prevent the

nd subsidence

overy can be

opriate design

method under

dy have to be

al caving, the

llar, mining

, M., Matsui, K.damental Study

5

n

e

o

p

f

d

,

l

n

m

l

.

f

r

o

l

t

d

l

s

l

k

e

t

e

e

e

n

r

e

e

g

., y

Page 9: Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal ... · Punch Multi-slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions ... Institute Technology

Punch Multi-Slice Longwall Mining System for Thick Coal Seam under Weak Geological Conditions 36

on AMD-prevention by Compacted Waste Rocks at Berau Coal Mine, Indonesia.” In Proceedings of the 2nd International Symposium on Novel Carbon Resource Science, IV19-IV24.

[2] Inoue, N., Hamanaka, A., Matsumoto, S., Shimada, H., Sasaoka, T., and Matsui, K. 2014. “Effective Assessment Methods of Soil Erosion Control in Indonesian Open Pit Mine.” In Proceedings of 18th Conference on Environment and Mineral Processing, 221-7.

[3] Matsui, K., Sasaoka, T., Shimada, H., Furukawa, H. Takamoto, H., and Ichinose, M. 2010. “Some Consideration in Underground Mining Systems for Extra-thick Coal Seam.” In Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium on Mineral Resources and Mine Development, 355-68.

[4] Hamanaka, A., Sasaoka, T., Shimada, H., Matsui, K., and Takamoto, H. 2011. “Application of Punch Mining System to Indonesian Coal Mining Industry.” In Proceedings of the 20th International Symposium on Mine Planning and Equipment Selection, 187-97.

[5] Shibata, S., Lin, N. Z., Shimada, H., Hamanaka, A., Sasaoka, T., Matsui, K., and Lawowattanabandit, P. 2013. “Preliminary Study on Design of Longwall Mining from Final Highwall at Mae Moh Lignite Mine in Thailand.” In

Proceedings of the 22nd Mine Planning and Equipment Selection, 227-34.

[6] Sasaoka, T., Shimada, H., Takamoto, H., Hamanaka, A., and Matsui, K. 2012. “Development of Underground Coal Mine from Open Cut Highwall in Indonesia.” In Proceedings of 5th International Symposium on High Performance Mining, 495-510.

[7] Robertson, B. W., O’ Regan, G., and McKew, M. 1988. “Longwall Punch Mining from Open Cut Highwalls.” In Proceedings of the AUSIMM Illawara Branch 21st Century Higher Production Coal Mining Systems, 215-20.

[8] Macdonald, S., and Hill, D. 2008. “Practical Strata Management, Beltana No. 1 Mine, Australia.” In Proceedings of 27th International Conference on Ground Control in Mining, 275-83.

[9] Hill, D., and MacKinnon, M. 2011. “Case Study of Roof Behavior and Conditions for Longwall Face Recoveries at Beltana No. 1 Mine, Australia.” In Proceedings of 30th International Conference on Ground Control in Mining, 265-70.

[10] Hem, P. 2012. “Pits & Quarries.” In Techno Mine. Accessed October 25, 2014.http://technology.infomine.com/reviews/pitsandquarries/welcome.asp?view=full.