View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 1/12
‘‘‘ Gmref‘q Eamdmlx
2::>
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 2/12
AMDPEDPQ
Zfrp H; Msershew fd` Lfarmeamdmlha
Hqqueq
Gmref‘q Eamdmlha Fanheseledpq fd` Zrmqzeapq
Zxm Nfg,ghi $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 6
Pne Orfxhdo mc Gmref; F``reqqhdo pne
Anfiiedoeq mc Fohdo
Kerfi` Qanhcc fd` Lurpf{f Qxe` $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ ?
Zfrp HH; Chdfdahfi Hdqphpuphmdq fd` Lfrgepq
Chdfdahfi Fqhf Rhqhdo; Fqhfd Qpmag Lfrgepq hdpne Dew Lhiieddhul
Gfrhl Zfgrfsfd $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 65
Gmref‘q Lmdex Lfrgep
@mlhdhvue @wmr,Crèafup $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 26
Hdore`hedpq cmr f _eii,Cudaphmdhdo Afzhpfi
Lfrgep
Kmnd Buroer ) Crfdahq _frdmag )
Sermdhaf Afa`fa _frdmag $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 16
Pne Afzhpfi Lfrgep Amdqmih`fphmd Fap fd` pne
Gmrefd Chdfdahfi Lfrgep
Ghl @mdo,nwfd $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 18
Zfrp HHH; Qpruapurfi Recmrl
Zrmoreqq hd Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae
Qphkd Aifeqqedq $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 05
Pf~ Hqqueq Fcceaphdo Cmrehod,Hdseqpe` Amlzfdheq
fd` Cmrehod Hdseqpmrq
Nedrx Fd fd` @fsh` Khd,Xmudo Iee $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 50
Zfrp HS; E~perdfi Hqqueq
U$Q$,Gmref Eamdmlha Reifphmdq;
Shew crml Qemui
Nfd @mdolfd $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 36
F _fqnhdopmd Zerqzeaphse
Kmr`fd Nehber $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 38
Zeerhdo hdpm pne Cupure; Gmref‘q Reqzmdqe pm pne
Dew Prf`hdo Ifd`qafze
Prmx Qpfdofrmde $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ ?0
Zfrp S; Dmrpn Gmref‘q Eamdmlha
@eseimzledp fd` E~perdfi Reifphmdq
Dmrpn Gmref‘q E~perdfi Reqmuraeq fd`
Amdqprfhdpq
Qpeznfd Nfoofr` fd` Lfrauq Dmifd` $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ >1
Pne Rmieq mc Anhdf fd` Qmupn Gmref hd Dmrpn
Gmrefd Eamdmlha Anfdoe
Lhgf Lfrulmpm $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $82
Refihqpha E~zeapfphmdq mc pne Cupure Rmie mc pne
HCHq md pne Gmrefd Zedhdquif
Brf`iex Bfbqmd $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 6:3
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 3/12
QPRUAPURFI RECMRL 05
QPRUAPURFI RECMRL
ZRMOREQQ HD AMRZMRFPE OMSERDFDAE
Bx Qphkd Aifeqqedq
Hdprm`uaphmd
Pnhq frphaie hdseqphofpeq pne zrmoreqq hd amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae recmrl hd Gmref qhdae 688? fq weii fq
aurredp amrzmrfpe omserdfdae anfiiedoeq$ Hp cmauqeq
md amrzmrfpe omserdfdae hqqueq fd`) fq quan) `meq
dmp fdfix{e mpner fqzeapq‐mserfii recmrl fd` aml,
zephphsedeqq mc pne amrzmrfpe qeapmr) lfarmeamdmlha
zmihaheq) fd` stdfdahfi qeapmr recmrlq‐pneqe nfsefiqm beed aruahfi pm Gmref‘q reamserx pm fpe fd` whii
relfhd eqqedphfi pm quqpfhd ormwpn omhdo cmrwfr`$ Hp
amdaiu`eq pnfp luan zrmoreqq nfq beed fanhese` hd
amrzmrfpe omserdfdae recmrl) whpn lfdx mc pne lfhd
amrzmrfpe omserdfdae estahedaheq amdprhbuphdo pm pne
arhqhq nfshdo beed eihlhdfpe`$ Amrzmrfpe qeapmr zer,
cmrlfdae nfq hlzrmse`) whpn amrzmrfpe qeapmr zrmstp,
fbhihpx oederfiix reqpmre` fd` hdseqpledp beamlhdo
lmre rfphmdfi$ Chdfdahfi suiderfbhihpheq nfse `eaihde`)
fq ieserfoe nfq cfiied fd` lfpurhpx fd` aurredax lhq,
lfpaneq nfse beed re`uae`$
Hlzrmseledpq pm amrzmrfpe omserdfdae hd Gmref afd
be fpprhbupe` pm f amlbhdfphmd mc luiphzie cfapmrq) lmqp
hlzmrpfdpix mwderqnhz anfdoeq) hdaiu`hdo orefper
mupqh`e .cmrehod( mwderqnhz) fd` `eez hdqphpuphmdfi
recmrlq hdaiu`hdo qpredopnedhdo mc lhdmrhpx rhonpq fd`
revuhrhdo orefper rezreqedpfphmd mc mupqh`e `hreapmrq$
Buppreqqhdo pneqe anfdoeq nfse beed omserdledp,ie`
hdhphfphseq) eqzeahfiix lefqureq fhle` fp ifroe fd`
`hqpreqqe` amrzmrfphmdq) fd` f phonp crflewmrg cmr amr,
zmrfpe stdfdahfi reqpruapurhdo7 f brmf` qep mc mpner hd,
qphpuphmdfi recmrlq amserhdo) flmdo mpner zrmae`ureq)
faamudphdo fd` fu`hphdo) hdaiu`hdo hdarefqe` ihfbhihpx
cmr zrmzer stdfdahfi rezmrphdo) hlzrmse` bfdgruzpax
reqpruapurhdo) fd` mpner cmrlq mc stdfdahfi reqpruapurhdo
zrmae`ureq7 stdfdahfi qeapmr recmrl) hdaiu`hdo bfdghdo
qxqpel reafzhpfih{fphmd fd` reqpruapurhdo7 fd` anfdoeq
hd mwderqnhz qpruapureq hd pne stdfdahfi qeapmr$
Pne vueqphmd hq wnepner amrzmrfpe omserdfdae dee`q
pm be curpner ednfdae` mr lm`hste` hd ihonp mc zfqp e~,
zerhedaeq) oimbfi ieqqmdq) mr anfdohdo ahraulqpfdaeq$
Qmle mc pne amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrmbielq zreae`hdo
pne arhqhq qphii relfhd pm`fx$ Hd qzhpe mc lfdx recmrlq)
pne amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrfaphaeq mc Gmrefd amrzmrf,phmdq fre qphii zeraehse` pm be beimw pnmqe mc strlq hd
lfdx amlzfrfpmr amudprheq$ Mwderqnhz qpruapureq re,
lfhd anfrfaperh{e` bx nhon we`oeq bepweed afqn,flmw
rhonpq fd` amdprmi rhonpq) whpn f`serqe amdqevuedaeq
cmr lhdmrhpx qnfrenmi`erq fd` reqmurae fiimafphmd$ Bfr,
rherq pm edprx cmr qlfii, fd` le`hul,qh{e edperzrhqeq
.QLEq() quan fq pne phle fd` amqp pm mzed uz f buqh,
deqq) fre qphii ifroe) fd` pnex nhd`er ec stahedp ormwpn$
Lmre oederfiix) Gmref‘q reifphseix imw iesei mc hdseqp,
ledp amuzie` whpn oederfiix udhlzreqqhse zrmstpfbhihpx
fd` imw zrm`uaphshpx ormwpn rfhqe qmle mubpq fbmup
pne vufihpx mc amrzmrfpe omserdfdae$ Fd` pne f`sedp mc lmre gdmwie`oe,hdpedqhse zrm`uaphmd) whpn ieqq dee`
cmr hdseqpledp hd st~e` fqqepq) zupq f orefper elznfqhq
md nhon,vufihpx amrzmrfpe omserdfdae$ Curpner amrzm,
rfpe omserdfdae recmrlq whii be deaeqqfrx pm fqqure
pne rhonp iesei fd` pxze mc hdseqpledpq) whpn f zrmzer
rhqg,repurd bfifdae$
Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae becmre 688? fd`
Recmrl qhdae 688?
Zrmbielq becmre 688?
Gmref‘q amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrmbielq becmre pne
688? stdfdahfi arhqhq pnfp ie` pm ifroe stdfdahfi suider,
fbhihpheq fd` wefg zercmrlfdae nfse beed weii mau,
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 4/12
03 PNE GMREF EAMDMLHA HDQPHPUPE
ledpe`$6 Lfdx mc pne amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrmbielq
frmqe crml f nhon amdaedprfphmd mc mwderqnhz amdprmi
zfrphauifrix flmdo pne ifroe anfebmi) pne zre`mlh,
dfdae mc buqhdeqq ormuzq hd Gmref) fd` pne sfrhmuq
hdperihdgq flmdo amrzmrfphmdq$ Pneqe cefpureq lefdp
zmmr prfdqzfredax fd` wefg amrzmrfpe omserdfdae)
wnhan hd purd mcped cfahihpfpe` fd hdec stahedp fiimafphmdmc reqmuraeq fd` luan rhqg pfghdo$
Pne wefg omserdfdae qpruapure wfq curpner foorfsfpe`
bx pwm cfapmrq$ Mde wfq pne oederfiix zfqqhse dfpure
mc pne Gmrefd bfdghdo qxqpel) whpn hpq ihlhpe` rhqg
lfdfoeledp fd` are`hp fdfixqhq qghiiq fd` pne qphii
serx ifroe rmie mc pne omserdledp) bmpn `hreapix fq
fd mwder fd` hd`hreapix fq fd mserqeer mc bfdgq$ Pne
qeamd` cfapmr wfq pne e~hqpedae mc lfdx ihdgq bepweed
pne amrzmrfpe fd` stdfdahfi qeapmrq) lmqp dmpfbix pne
amdprmi bx pne anfebmi mser lfdx leranfdp bfdgq
fd` mpner dmdbfdg stdfdahfi hdqphpuphmdq$ Pne requip,hdo ifag mc mserfii lfrgep `hqahzihde wfq refleape` hd
pne ihlhpe` e~hp mc wefg amrzmrfphmdq$ Hd pne afzhpfi
lfrgepq) zmmr amrzmrfpe omserdfdae prfdqifpe` hpqeic
hdpm e~zrmzrhfphmd) imw qpmag lfrgep sfiufphmd) fd`
imw rfpeq mc repurd cmr lhdmrhpx qnfrenmi`erq$
Hlzrmseledpq qhdae 688?
Hd nhd`qhonp pneqe zrmbielq nfse beed h`edphste` fd`
`mauledpe` e~pedqhseix fq hlzmrpfdp cfapmrq benhd`
pne 688? arhqhq) bup fp pne phle mc pne arhqhq pmm ihppie
elznfqhq wfq ohsed pm pnel$ Pnfdgq pm shomrmuq zmihax faphmdq cmiimwhdo pne arhqhq) nmweser) luan
nfq beed fanhese` hd perlq mc hlzrmshdo pne amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae reohle$ Faphmdq nfse hdaiu`e` f lh~pure
mc omserdledp,hqque` ouh`eihdeq quan fq pne revuhre`
eihlhdfphmd mc armqq,oufrfdpeeq) pne cmrae` re`uaphmd
hd stdfdahfi ieserfoe) qzeahfi revueqpq cmr pne ifroer
anfebmi pm re`uae pnehr hdseqpledpq fd` amdqmih`fpe
pnehr mzerfphmdq) f qzeahsta zrmaeqq cmr ifroe,qafie
amrzmrfpe stdfdahfi reqpruapurhdo) reafzhpfih{fphmd fd`
stdfdahfi reqpruapurhdo mc pne bfdghdo qxqpel) stdfdahfi
qeapmr recmrl) fd` hdarefqe` lfrgep zreqqureq cfahih,
pfpe` bx f dulber mc hdqphpuphmdfi recmrlq$
Farmqq f wh`e qzeaprul) `fpf amdstrl pnfp lefqureq
nfse ie` pm re`uae` stdfdahfi suiderfbhihpheq fd` hl,
zrmse` amrzmrfpe zercmrlfdae$ Ieserfoe nfq eaihde`)
`ebp lfpurhpx zrmstieq nfse iedopnede`) fd` afqn bfi,
fdaeq nfse qnfrzix hdarefqe`$ Bmpn zrmstpfbhihpx fd`
hdseqpledp benfshmr nfse hlzrmse`) eqzeahfiix flmdo
pne anfebmi$ Hlzmrpfdp pm fii pnhq nfq beed pne ifroe
e~hp mc wefger strlq$ Pnhq reqpruapurhdo nfq beed fa,
amlzfdhe` bx qmlewnfp hlzrmse` `hreap mwderqnhzqpruapureq) hdaiu`hdo ifroer cmrehod mwderqnhz fd`
re`uaphmd hd armqq,mwderqnhz flmdo reifpe` zfrpheq)
wnhan nfse cfahihpfpe` nhoner prfdqzfredax hd lfd,
foeledp fd` fiimwe` cmr lmre ec stahedax hd reqmurae
fiimafphmd$ Nmweser) qhodq mc wefgdeqq fd` udstdhqne`
reqpruapurhdo dee`q qphii relfhd$
Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Recmrlq
Hp wfq dmp kuqp amrzmrfpe omserdfdae recmrlq) bup
fiqm mpner cfapmrq pnfp fiimwe` cmr pne rfzh` zrmoreqq
hd pne amrzmrfpe qeapmr$ Pneqe f``hphmdfi cfapmrq hd,aiu`e` ifroe omserdledp,ie hdhphfphseq hlle`hfpeix
cmiimwhdo pne stdfdahfi arhqhq7 `rfqpha reqpruapurhdo mc
pne stdfdahfi qxqpel7 fd` lfdx hlzrmseledpq hd pne
hdqphpuphmdfi edshrmdledp) dmpfbix amserhdo pne crfle,
wmrgq cmr amrzmrfpe stdfdahfi `hqpreqq fd` pne `hqaim,
qure fd` vufihpx mc hdcmrlfphmd$ Amrzmrfpe omserdfdae
anfdoeq nfse beed ue pm pnree cmraeq; omserdledp,ie`
hdhphfphseq) hlzrmseledpq hd pne mserfii hdqphpuphmdfi
edshrmdledp) fd` anfdoeq hd mwderqnhz qpruapureq$
Hlle`hfpeix cmiimwhdo pne arhqhq) f dulber mc lef,
qureq) quan fq pne eihlhdfphmd mc armqq,oufrfdpeeq fd`pne zrmnhbhphmd md mwderqnhz ihdgq) fhle` `hreapix
fp hlzrmshdo stdfdahfi fd` oederfi prfdqzfredax fd`
amrzmrfpe omserdfdae qpruapureq hd pne ifroe anfebmi$
Pnrmuon ieofi fd` reouifpmrx anfdoeq) pnere nfse beed
lfdx hlzrmseledpq hd pne hdqphpuphmdfi crflewmrg
cmr amrzmrfpe omserdfdae7 fiqm zfrp mc pne stdfdahfi
reqpruapurhdo fd` recmrlq were amdqh`erfbie anfdoeq
hd pne mwderqnhz qpruapureq mc lfdx amrzmrfphmdq;
• Lhdmrhpx qnfrenmi`er rhonpq qpredopnede` bx
imwerhdo pne pnreqnmi` cmr sfrhmuq qnfrenmi`er
hdhphfphseq)
• Mupqh`e bmfr` mc `hreapmrq hdprm`uae`)
6$ Rezubiha mc Gmref; Eqpfbihqnhdo f Dew Cmud`fphmd cmr Quqpfhde` Ormwpn) smi$ 6) Rezmrp dm$ 68585,GM ._fqnhdopmd) @$A$; _mri`Bfdg) Dmselber 6888(7 ’Rezubiha mc Gmref; Frphaie HS Amdquipfphmdq)“ HLC Qpfcc Rezmrp ._fqnhdopmd) @$A$; Hdperdfphmdfi LmdepfrxCud`) 688>(7 Eamdmlha Qursex; Gmref .Zfrhq; Mrofdh{fphmd cmr Eamdmlha Ammzerfphmd fd` @eseimzledp) 6888($
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 5/12
QPRUAPURFI RECMRL 0?
• Ch`uahfrx upx mc amrzmrfpe `hreapmrq hdprm`uae`)
• Auluifphse smphdo cmr `hreapmrq fiimwe`)
• @ebp oufrfdpeeq bepweed anfebmi qubqh`hfrheq
zrmnhbhpe`)
• E~perdfi fu`hpmrq fd` amrzmrfpe faamudphdo mc staerq
qubkeap pm qphccer zedfipheq)
• Fzzrmsfi bx pne bmfr` mc `hreapmrq revuhre` cmr
reifpe`,zfrpx prfdqfaphmdq)
• Hdprm`uaphmd mc eamdmlha arhperhf cmr esfiufphdo
fzzihafphmdq cmr amrzmrfpe remrofdh{fphmd)
• Aehihdo md cmrehod qnfrenmi`hdoq hd hd`hsh`ufi
amlzfdheq fbmihqne` hd 688>)
• Fii cmrlq mc leroerq fd` favuhqhphmdq) hdaiu`hdo
nmqphie pfgemserq bx cmrehoderq) zerlhppe`)
• Aifqq faphmd quhpq hdprm`uae` cmr fii ihqpe` amlzf,
dheq)
• Fbhihpx mc anfebmi pm e~erahqe zmwer mser stdfdahfi
fc stihfpeq reqprhape`) fd`
• Fled`ledp pm pne Amllerahfi Am`e pm lfge
lfdfoerq fd` amdprmiihdo qnfrenmi`erq lmre fa,
amudpfbie pm lhdmrhpx qnfrenmi`erq$
Fqqeqqledpq mc Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Pm`fx
Pne hlzrmseledpq hd amrzmrfpe omserdfdae fd`
qnfrenmi`er afzhpfihql nfse lf`e pne lfdfoeledp
mc anfebmi lmre prfdqzfredp fd` fre beihese` pm nfse
amdprhbupe` pm fiieshfphdo pne ’Gmrefd `hqamudp“ hd
pne qpmag lfrgep$1 Pnhq hd purd nfq ie` pm pne bepper
cudaphmdhdo mc evuhpx lfrgepq fd` fd hlzrmseledp
hd pne fiimafphmd mc reqmuraeq$ Fipnmuon hd pne zfqp
evuhpx repurdq were serx imw) whpn hsh`ed`q imw fd`
mserfii repurdq mcped beimw pnmqe md omserdledp fd`amrzmrfpe bmd`q esed pnmuon evuhpx smifphihpx wfq
nhoner) evuhpx repurdq nfse beed luan nhoner qhdae
pne arhqhq$ Lmqp hlzmrpfdp) pne evuhpx amqp mc afzhpfi
nfq beamle f bepper ouh`e cmr amrzmrfphmdq‘ hdseqp,
ledp mzzmrpudhpheq) fd` pne fiimafphmd mc reqmuraeq
nfq pnerecmre beed hlzrmse`$
Hp hq `hc stauip pm qfx `estdhphseix) nmweser) nmw luanmc pne anfdoe hq `ue pm pne uzorf`e mc pne amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae reohle) nmw luan pm cfapmrq quan fq
hdarefqe` amlzephphmd fd` curpner oimbfih{fphmd) fd`
nmw luan pm anfdoeq hd mwderqnhz qpruapureq fwfx
crml hdqh`erq fd` pmwfr` luan lmre `elfd`hdo
hdseqpmrq$ Mde refqmdfbix mbkeaphse wfx pm fqqeqq
pne amdprhbuphmd mc pne hdqphpuphmdfi crflewmrg pm pne
hlzrmse` zercmrlfdae hq pm qamre pne cmrlfi amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae reohle hd Gmref reifphse pm pnfp mc mpner
amudprheq .Pfbie 6($ Gmref qamreq vuhpe weii amlzfre`
whpn mpner Mrofdh{fphmd cmr Eamdmlha Ammzerfphmd
fd` @eseimzledp .MEA@( fd` Fqhfd amudprheq$ Cmr e~flzie) pne `hqaimqure fd` qnfrenmi`er quhp hd`e~eq
2$ Eamdmlha Qursex; Gmref .Zfrhq; MEA@) 6888) 2::6) 2::1) 2::5) fd` 2::?(7 Rezmrp md pne Mbqersfdae mc Qpfd`fr`q fd` Am`eq.RMQA() Rezubiha mc Gmref; Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae ._fqnhdopmd) @$A$; _mri` Bfdg) Qezpelber 2::1($
1$ Iee Kmdo,wnf fd` Rnee Anfdo,xmdo) ’Arhqhq fd` Reamserx; _nfp _e Nfse Iefrde` crml pne Qmupn Gmrefd E~zerhedae)“ Fqhfd Eamdmlha Zmihax Reshew 2 .2::?($
Pfbie 6; Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Ruieq) 2::3
Reohmd mr
eamdmlx
@hqaimqure
hd`e~
@hreapmr
ihfbhihpx
hd`e~
Qnfre,
nmi`er
quhpq
hd`e~
Hdseqpmr
zrmpeaphmd
hd`e~
Fqhf fd`
Zfahcha
5$2 0$0 3$6 5$2
MEA@ 3$1 5 3$3 3
Brf{hi 5 ? 0 5$1
Anhdf 6: 6 0 5Oerlfdx 5 5 5 5
Hd`hf ? 0 ? 3
Hd`mdeqhf > 5 1 5$1
Kfzfd ? 3 > ?
Gmref ? 2 ? 5$1
Lfifxqhf 6: 8 ? >$?
Znhihzzhdeq 6 2 ? 1$1
Pnfhifd` 6: 2 3 3
Udhpe`Qpfpeq
? 8 8 >$1
Qmurae; @mhdo Buqhdeqq 2::?; Nmw pm Recmrl=._fqnhdopmd) @$A$; _mri` Bfdg) 2::3($
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 6/12
0> PNE GMREF EAMDMLHA HDQPHPUPE
fre bepper pnfd pne MEA@ fserfoe$ Bup hreapmr ihfbhihpx
relfhdq cfr beimw pnfp fserfoe) lfghdo pne mserfii
qnfrenmi`er hd`e~ beimw fserfoe$
Bup hp hq fiqm aiefr pnfp) fq eiqewnere) f hseroedae e~,
hqpq bepweed pne reouifpmrx edshrmdledp fd` .lfrgep
zeraezphmdq fbmup( amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrfaphaeq hdGmref$0 Flmdo pne dhde qflzie` amudprheq hd Efqp
Fqhf) Gmref hq rfdge` cfr fnef` mc Nmdo Gmdo fd`
Qhdofzmre hd perlq mc zrhdahzieq fd` ruieq mc amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae .Pfbie 2($ Hd amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrfa,
phaeq) nmweser) Gmref hq zeraehse` bx cud` lfdfoerq
fd` fdfixqpq pm be qhodhstafdpix benhd` pneqe pwm
amudprheq .fipnmuon qphii fnef` mc lmqp mpner Efqp Fqhfd
amudprheq($ _hpn f reouifpmrx c rflewmrg cmr amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae dmw ifroeix qep hd zifae) hp hq pnerecmre
hlzmrpfdp pm amdaedprfpe eccmrpq md hlzieledphdo fd`
edcmrahdo ruieq fd` reouifphmdq$
Curpner amdstrlfphmd mc pne `hcceredaeq bepweed ruieq
fd` amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrfaphaeq amleq crml pne
fddufi 2::5 Are`hp Ixmddfhq Fqhf Zfahsta qursex
.Pfbie 1() wnere Gmref hq rfdge` hd pne lh``ie mc
fii Efqp Fqhfd amudprheq hd bmpn ruieq fd` amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae zrfaphaeq$ Pne wefg amrzmrfpe omserdfdae
zrfaphaeq mc amrzmrfphmdq fre curpner amdstrle` hd pnerfphdoq mc amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrfaphaeq bx aml,
lerahfi foedaheq quan fq OmserdfdaeLeprhaq Hdperdf,
phmdfi .OLH($ Mup mc 08 amudprheq) pne fserfoe OLH
amrzmrfpe omserdfdae qamre cmr Gmrefd amrzmrfphmdq
wfq mdix 2$16) wnhan rfdgq Gmref fq cmurpn crml pne
wmrqp$ Amrzmrfphmdq hd fii Fqhfd amudprheq rfpe` bep,
per) fd` dm MEA@ amudprheq rfpe` wmrqe pnfd Gmref
.Pfbie 0($ Fiqm) f qpu`x md pne esmiuphmd mc amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae zrfaphaeq hd sfrhmuq lfrgepq quooeqpq ieqq
hlzrmseledp hd Gmref$
Amrzmrfpe omserdfdae hq qphii wefg hd zrfaphae beafuqeqmle mc pne zre,arhqhq `eezer ud`erixhdo refqmdq cmr
pne zrmbielq relfhd$ Lmqp mc pne amrzmrfpe omser,
dfdae zrmbielq hd Gmref aedper‐fq pnex `m hd lmqp
elerohdo lfrgepq fd` lfdx eseimze` amudprheq‐md
pne amdflhapq bepweed lhdmrhpx fd` amdprmiihdo qnfre,
nmi`erq) pne ifpper mcped qphii rezreqedpe` hd lfdfoe,
ledp$ Cmr lmqp Gmrefd amrzmrfphmdq) pnere e~hqpq ifroe
muprhonp amdprmi bx hdqh`erq‐mdix f nfd`cui mc qnfre
mr qlfii,afqn,flmw mwderq fre hdsmise`‐fiimwhdo
hdqh`erq pm ced` mcc lfrgep zreqqureq$ Fd` anfebmi
whpn f imwer rfphm mc mwderqnhz amdphdue pm e~zimhp
pne prefqurx qpmag nmi`hdo qxqpel fq fd ecceaphse pmmipm `eced` fofhdqp pfgemser fppelzpq$ Amdserqeix)
pnmqe strlq wnmqe qnfreq fre ifroeix nei` bx lfkmr
qnfrenmi`erq mpner pnfd pne amdprmiihdo qnfrenmi`erq
fd` pnehr fc stihfpeq ped` pm lfhdpfhd nhoner rfphmq mc
prefqurx qpmag$ Hp lfx esed be pne afqe pnfp `urhdo
pne zfqp `eaf`e hdqh`erq nfse hdarefqe` pnehr amdprmi
qpfgeq fd` favuhre` lmre fqqepq) fd` qmle froue pnfp
pne reouifphmdq md ahrauifr hdseqpledpq were fd` qphii
0$ Qmle mc pnhq hq amdstrle` bx Qpezned X$ I$ Aneudo fd` Nfqudo Kfdo) ’Qamreafr` md Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae hd Efqp Fqhf)“ _mrghdoZfzer dm$ 61 ._fperimm) Mdpfrhm; Aedper cmr Hdperdfphmdfi Omserdfdae Hddmsfphmd) @eaelber 2::3($
5$ Uqhdo lfrgep fpf) O$ @e Dhamim) I$ Ifesed) fd` G$ Ue`f) hd ’Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Vufihpx; Pred`q fd` Refi Ecceapq)“ _mrghdoZfzer dm$ :3-281 ._fqnhdopmd) @$A$; HLC) 2::?( qnmw pnfp) whpn pne uqe mc f amrzmrfpe omserdfdae vufihpx hd`e~ pnfp amdqhqpq mc faamudphdo qpfd`fr`q) efrdhdoq mzfahpx) fd` qpmag zrhae qxdanrmdhahpx) Gmref hq rfdge` dmp mdix vuhpe benhd` eseimze` amudprheq bupfiqm beimw pne fserfoe Fqhfd amudprx$ Fipnmuon pne faamudphdo qpfd`fr` hd`hafpmr hq pne nhoneqp) efrdhdoq qeel pm be lfdhzuifpe`fd` qpmag zrhaeq `m dmp refleap amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrmbielq vuhpe rfzh`ix$ Pnhq requip hq amdqhqpedp whpn pne qursex std`hdoq mc Aneudo fd` Kfdo) ’Qamreafr` md Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae hd Efqp Fqhf$“
3$ Xmud Pfe,nmmd) ’Fdfixqhq md pne Pfgemser @ecedqe fd` Prefqurx Qpmag Nmi`hdoq Whd Gmrefd\)“ hd Qpu`heq md pne Lfrgep cmr Amrzmrfpe Amdprmi hd Gmref) e`$ Xmud Pfe,nmmd) Reqefran Lmdmorfzn dm$ 338 .Qemui; Gmref @eseimzledp Hdqphpupe) 2::5($
Pfbie 2; Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Ruieq fd` Zrfaphaeq
Amudprheq
Ruieq fd`
reouifphmdq
Hdseqpmrq‘
zeraezphmdq
Hd`e~ Rfdghdo Hd`e~ Rfdghdo
Znhihzzhdeq 1$36 6 2$:> ?
Anhdf 1$50 2 6$?2 >
Gmref 1$1> 1 2$3> 1
Pnfhifd` 1$2: 0 2$3: 0
Pfhwfd 2$8> 5 2$5: 3
Hd`mdeqhf 2$82 3 6$5? 8
Lfifxqhf 2$32 ? 2$3: 0
Qhdofzmre 2$5? > 0$:: 6
NmdoGmdo
2$0> 8 1$>> 2
Qmurae; Qpezned X$ I$ Aneudo fd` Nfqudo Kfdo)’Qamreafr` md Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae hd Efqp Fqhf)“
_mrghdo Zfzer dm$ 61 ._fperimm) Mdpfrhm; Aedper cmr
Hdperdfphmdfi Omserdfdae Hddmsfphmd) @eaelber 2::3($
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 7/12
QPRUAPURFI RECMRL 08
fre behdo ahraulsedpe` pm`fx$
Fiqm hd pne hlle`hfpefcperlfpn mc pne stdfdahfi arhqhq) fipnmuon ruieq were
hd zifae pm zresedp pnhq crml nfzzedhdo) pne ifroe amr,
Pfbie 1; Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Qamre; F Lfrgep Zerqzeaphse
Eamdmlx
Ruieq fd`
reouifphmdq Edcmraeledp
Zmihphafi fd`
reouifpmrx HOFFZ
Amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae
auipure
Eamdmlx
qamre
Anhdf 5$1 0$2 5 ?$5 2$1 0$>
Nmdo Gmdo 3$3 5$> ?$5 8 0$3 3$?Hd`mdeqhf 5$1 2$? 1$> 3 2$? 0
Gmref 3$6 5 5 > 5 5$>
Lfifxqhf ?$6 5 5 8 0$3 3
Znhihzzhdeq 5$> 1$6 5 >$5 1$6 5
Qhdofzmre ?$8 3$5 >$6 8$5 5$> ?$0
Pnfhifd` 3$6 1$> 5 >$5 1$5 5$1
Qmuraeq; Efqp Fqhfd Chdfdae; Pne Rmf` pm Rmbuqp Lfrgepq ._fqnhdopmd; _mri` Bfdg) 2::3(7 Are`hp IxmddfhqQeaurhpheq Fqhf) Elerohdo Lfrgepq Qursex .Nmdo Gmdo; Fqhfd Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Fqqmahfphmd) 2::5($ Dmpe; HOFFZ < hdperdfphmdfi oederfiix faaezpe` faamudphdo zrhdahzieq$
?$ Ihl Xmudo,kfe fd` Kud Qudo,hd) ’Ahrauifpmrx Qnfrenmi`hdo mc pne Ormuz Amlzfdheq; Rmieq mc Lfrgep @hqahzihde fd` Quzershqmrx@hqahzihde Whd Gmrefd\)“ G@H Zmihax Cmrul .Qemui; Gmref @eseimzledp Hdqphpupe) 2::3($
zmrfphmdq were flmdo pne cew fbie pm favuhre fqqepq)pnerebx hdarefqhdo pnehr fqqep bfqe$
Fdea`mpfi e~flzieq amdstrl pne `hc stauipheq pnfp mup,
qh`e hdseqpmrq nfse hd fcceaphdo lfdfoeledp fd` amd,
prmiihdo qnfrenmi`erq$ Nxud`fh Lmpmrq) cmr e~flzie)
nfq nf` zerhm`ha elfd`q crml ifbmr udhmdq cmr wfoe
nhgeq) pm wnhan lfdfoeledp nfq mcped favuheqae` fp
pne amqp mc lhdmrhpx qnfrenmi`erq‘ hdpereqpq$ Mde refqmd
hq pnfp) whpnmup f lfrgep cmr amrzmrfpe amdprmi fd` whpn
pne zre`mlhdfdae mc amdprmiihdo qnfrenmi`erq) Nxud,
`fh Lmpmrq fd` mpner amrzmrfphmdq ihge hp `m dmp cfae
edmuon lfrgep zreqqure$ Fipnmuon `hreap mwderqnhzqpruapureq anfdoe` fcper pne arhqhq) hdaiu`hdo pnrmuon
ifroer cmrehod mwderqnhz) udphi amdprmi anfdoeq crml f
qlfii ormuz mc hdqh`erq pm f ifroer ormuz mc `hqzerqe`
qnfrenmi`erq) lfdx mc pne amrzmrfpe omserdfdae
zrmbielq whii relfhd$ Hlzmrpfdpix) pne sfiufphmd mc
Gmrefd strlq) wnhie hlzrmse`) hq qphii beimw pnfp hd
lfdx mpner f`sfdae` amudprheq$ Fq mc pne ed` mc 2::5)
Gmrefd strlq were sfiue` whpn f Pmbhd‘q V mc 6$:2)
qhodhstafdpix imwer pnfd strlq mc lmqp mpner MEA@
fd` Efqp Fqhfd amudprheq .Pfbie 5($
Cmr pne QLEq) fq hd lfdx mpner amudprheq) amrzmrfpeomserdfdae hq uqufiix esed wefger pnfd cmr pne ifroer
ihqpe` amrzmrfphmdq$ Fp pne qfle phle) fd` zernfzq
qurzrhqhdoix ohsed pne fppedphmd lmqp mcped zfh` pm pne
Pfbie 0; OLH Amudprx Rfdghdo Bfqe` md Hd`hsh`ufi
Amrzmrfphmdq‘ Rfphdoq) Qeieape` Amudprheq) 2::3
Amudprx .dm$
mc chrlq hd
zfredpneqeq(
Fserfoe
mserfii
rfphdo
Rfdg hd
pnhq
ormuz
Rfdg hd
fii OLH
UQF .6)?18( ?$22 6 0
Pnfhifd` .>( 5$?5 2 65
Oerlfdx .33( 5$33 1 63Znhihzzhdeq .2( 5$5: 0 26
MEA@
fserfoe
5$05 5 d$f$
Lfifxqhf .63( 0$?2 3 28
Hd`hf .20( 0$3? ? 16
Kfzfd .0:8( 0$:6 > 1>
Hd`mdeqhf .3( 1$>1 8 06
Brf{hi .21( 1$21 6: 02
Anhdf .6?( 2$80 66 01
Gmref .56( 2$16 62 03
Pmpfi dulber
mc amudprxmbqersfphmdq
62 08
Qmurae; OmserdfdaeLeprhaq Hdperdfphmdfi) Qezpelber 6>) 2::3
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 8/12
5: PNE GMREF EAMDMLHA HDQPHPUPE
ifroeqp amrzmrfphmdq) QLEq fre f ifroe zfrp mc Gmref‘q
eamdmlx) uz pm 5: zeraedp mc lfducfapurhdo mupzup
fd` fzzrm~hlfpeix 12 zeraedp mc e~zmrpq$ Pm hlzrmse
QLE omserdfdae‐f `hc stauip pfqg‐Gmrefd aml,
lerahfi bfdgq whii nfse pm zifx f ifroe rmie beafuqe
pnex) fq ied`erq) nfse f ifroe qpfge hd pne omserdfdaemc pnehr bmrrmwerq$ Fdmpner hlzmrpfdp reqzmdqhbhihpx hd
hlzrmshdo amrzmrfpe omserdfdae mc pne qlfiier strlq
whii cfii pm pne faamudphdo fd` fu`hphdo zrmceqqhmd$ Be,
afuqe wefgdeqqeq hd amrzmrfpe omserdfdae flmdo pne
ifroe strlq hd Gmref ped` pm qzhii mser pm QLEq‐lfdx
QLEq fre `mleqpha quzziherq fd` qubamdprfapmrq‐
hlzrmseledpq hd ifroe strlq‘ amrzmrfpe omserdfdae
whii om f imdo wfx pmwfr` fh`hdo QLEq‘ amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae$
Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae Anfiiedoeq
Lfdx mbqerserq foree pnfp hd qzeahsta frefq amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae recmrl eccmrpq qphii dee` pm be hdpedqhste` pm
fqqure fd ec stahedpix fd` zru`edpix mzerfphdo amrzmrfpe
qeapmr hd Gmref$ Fp pne qfle phle) dew anfiiedoeq cfa,
hdo pne amrzmrfpe qeapmr nfse amle uz reaedpix$
Relfhdhdo Anfiiedoeq
Lfdx eccmrpq amdphdue pm be qzedp md hlzrmshdo fd``eezedhdo amrzmrfpe omserdfdae ruieq$ Pne mserfii
`hreaphmd mc pneqe zmihaheq hq hd curpner ednfdahdo pne
rmie mc pne lfrgep fd` hd pne uqe mc lfrgep,bfqe` lepn,
m`q pm eperlhde nmw amrzmrfphmdq fre lmdhpmre` fd`
omserde` fd` nmw stdfdahfi `hc stauipheq fre reqmise`$
Amdqevuedpix) lfdx anfdoeq nfse hdsmise` eieofphdo
pm pne lfrgep‐hdqpef` mc pm reouifphdo fupnmrhpheq) fq
wfq pne afqe hd pne zfqp‐lmre mc pne pfqgq mc edqurhdo
amlzihfdae whpn pne dew ruieq$
Pnhq `eieofphmd nfq beed f iefrdhdo e~zerhedae cmr
lfdx lfrgep zfrphahzfdpq fd` fupnmrhpheq$ Fq hd lfdxmpner amudprheq) pne cuii bedestpq fre xep pm beed qeed)
wnhie rhqgq nfse frhqed hd pne lefdphle$ Cmr e~flzie)
fdfixqhq qnmwq pnfp mupqh`e hreapmrq m dmp xep zifx f
ifroe edmuon rmie hd hlzrmshdo amrzmrfpe omserdfdae)
fd` mupqh`e `hreapmrq md lfdfoeledp bmfr`q nfse
xep pm fap hd`ezed`edpix mc pne e~eauphse `hrea,
pmrq$ Fipnmuon pne reqzmdqhbhihpheq fd` hdaedphseq cmr
mupqh`e `hreapmrq fre vuhpe weii eqpfbihqne`) mupqh`e
`hreapmrq nfse beed ifaghdo hd pnehr reqzmdqhbhihpheq
fd` amrreqzmd`hdo faphshpheq pm hlzrmse amrzmrfpe
prfdqzfredax$ Mupqh`e hreapmrq nfse ped`e` dmp pm fp,
ped` reouifr bmfr` leephdoq fd` mcped nfse edpruqpe`pnehr smphdo rhonpq pm pne e~eauphse `hreapmrq wnm
ecceaphseix fzzmhdpe` pnel$8 Mpner esh`edae zmhdpq
pm amdphdue` amrzmrfpe omserdfdae wefgdeqqeq fd`
qesere foedax amqpq$
Lmre pnuq dee`q pm be `mde) ohsed oimbfi pred`q hd
amrzmrfpe omserdfdae fd` afzhpfi lfrgepq$ Pne eq,
pfbihqnledp mc f qmud`er amrzmrfpe benfshmr revuhreq
dmp mdix hlzrmshdo pne mserfii amrzmrfpe omserdfdae
fd` reqpruapurhdo crflewmrgq bup fiqm `hihoedpix
lfhdpfhdhdo pne aurredp ruieq mr hdprm`uahdo dew hreap
zrmnhbhphmdq fd` hdpersedphmdq$ Phonper reouifphmdqmd pne ahrauifr qnfrenmi`hdo mc amdoimlerfpeq fre
dee`e`) cmr e~flzie) fq pnere qphii e~hqp amdaerdq pnfp
Pfbie 5; Hdperdfphmdfi Amlzfrhqmd mc Pmbhd‘q V)
Qeieape` Amudprheq) 6885) 2:::) fd` 2::5
Amudprx 6885 2::: 2::5
Hd`hf 2$53 1$36 2$22
Udhpe` Qpfpeq 6$86 1$2: 6$>1
Hd`mdeqhf 2$28 6$26 6$5:
Brf{hi :$0? :$0> 6$11
Pnfhifd` 6$5> :$81 6$11
MEA@ fserfoe 6$:? 2$:2 6$12
Lfifxqhf 6$>1 6$65 6$6?
Anhdf 6$05 1$:8 6$60
Oerlfdx :$?3 6$28 6$62
Znhihzzhdeq 2$:1 :$8: 6$:8
Kfzfd 6$:: 1$6? 6$:5
Gmref :$>2 :$81 6$:0
Qmurae; Hdperdfphmdfi Lmdepfrx Cud`) Amrzmrfpe Qeapmr Suiderfbhihpx Uphihpx) fq bfqe` md Pnmlqmd Chdfdahfi‘q_mri`qamze `fpfbfqe$ Dmpe; Pmbhd‘q V rfphm hq fzzrm~hlfpe` fq pne lfrgepafzhpfih{fphmd wehonpe` fserfoeq mc pne lfrgep sfiue mc evuhpx ziuq bmmg sfiue mc `ebp) `hsh`e` bx pne bmmg sfiuemc fqqepq$
>$ Anm Qudo,bhd) ’F Qpu`x md Foedax Amqpq mc Gmrefd Chrlq Whd Gmrefd\)“ G@H Reqefran Lmdmorfzn dm$ ?6? .Qemui; Gmref@eseimzledp Hdqphpupe) 2::3($
8$ Aneudo fd` Kfdo) ’Qamreafr` md Amrzmrfpe Omserdfdae hd Efqp Fqhf$“
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 9/12
QPRUAPURFI RECMRL 56
pne anfebmi ahraulsedp pneqe ruieq$ Qeserfi amdprmiihdo
qnfrenmi`erq‘ `mlhdfdp amdprmi mser fc stihfpe` aml,
zfdheq pnrmuon armqq,qnfrenmi`hdo orefpix hdarefqe`
bepweed 688> fd` 2::6 wned pne omserdledp) hd
mr`er pm cfahihpfpe amrzmrfpe reqpruapurhdo) relmse`
pne reouifphmd md pne pmpfi flmudp mc qnfrenmi`hdo hd
mpner amlzfdheq$6:
Fq f requip) pne amdprmiihdo qnfre,nmi`erq‘ smphdo rhonpq nfse hdarefqe` shf pnehr fc stihfpe`
amlzfdheq vuhpe rfzh`ix$ Hd f``hphmd) qmle beihese pnfp
ahrauifpmrx qnfrenmi`hdo arefpeq smphdo rhonpq flmdo
fc stihfpeq whpnmup revuhrhdo fdx afqn mupifxq mr mpner
amqpq mr e~zedqeq$66 Pnhq hq fd hdcrhdoeledp md lhdmr,
hpx qnfrenmi`erq‘ rhonpq bx frphstahfiix re`uahdo pnehr
reifphse smphdo qnfreq$
Fdmpner hlzmrpfdp zmihax hqque hq pne rmie mc amrzmrf,
phmdq hd pne mwderqnhz mc stdfdahfi hdqphpuphmdq$ Lfdx
mbqerserq‐hdaiu`hdo) cmr e~flzie) Qpfd`fr` # Zmmr‘q
hd 2::5 wned hp wfq uzorf`hdo Gmref‘q qmserehodrfphdo‐nfse dmpe` pnfp zresedphdo amdprmi mc pne
stdfdahfi qxqpel bx ifroe amrzmrfphmdq fd` buqhdeqq
ormuzq hq aruahfi pm zresedphdo pne reaurredae mc f
stdfdahfi arhqhq$ Reaedpix) nmweser) pne hdfbhihpx mc
dmdstdfdahfistrlq pm favuhre qpmag hd Gmref‘q amller,
ahfi bfdgq‐pne ihlhpfphmd wfq f 0 zeraedp lf~hlul
mwderqnhz qpfge‐nfq beed reif~e`$ Pne reif~fphmd mc
bfdg mwderqnhz ruieq fd` fiimwhdo lmre mwderqnhz bx
amrzmrfphmdq lhonp ief`) nmweser) pm lhqfiimafphmdq
fd` hdprm`uae qxqpelha rhqgq) eqzeahfiix beafuqe Gm,
ref nfq luan ifroer buqhdeqq ormuzq pnfd lmqp mpner
.f`sfdae`( amudprheq$ Beqh`eq pne amdaerdq fbmupqxqpelha rhqgq) wmrrheq fbmup eamdmlha zmwer amd,
aedprfphmd fd` amdaerdq fbmup cfhr amlzephphmd nfse hd
lfdx amudprheq ie` pm ihlhpq md pne mwderqnhz mc bfdgq
bx dmdstdfdahfi amrzmrfphmdq$62 Beafuqe mwderqnhz
nfq firef`x beed qmlewnfp ihberfih{e`) hp hq aruahfi
pnfp e~hqphdo lefqureq fre edcmrae` fp pne qfle phle)
eqzeahfiix pnmqe ruieq omserdhdo amdflhapq mc hdpereqp
fd` prfdqzfredax) fd` pnfp f``hphmdfi lefqureq be
pfged) quan fq hdarefqe` `hqaimqure md reifpe`,zfrpx
prfdqfaphmdq$
Qmle mc pne aurredp zmihaheq behdo amdqh`ere` bx pne
hdamlhdo Iee Lxudo,Bfg omserdledp wmui` hlzfap
md amrzmrfpe omserdfdae$ Hd zfrphauifr) pne zrmzmq,
fiq pm efqe reqprhaphmdq md pne hdseqpledpq bx ifroeamdoimlerfpeq hd reifpe` mrofdh{fphmdq) pne curpner
reif~fphmd mc reqprhaphmdq md hdseqpledpq hd mpner
amrzmrfphmdq fd` stdfdahfi edphpheq) pne relmsfi mc
pne 2:: zeraedp ihlhp md ieserfoe) fd` pne re`uaphmd
hd pf~eq md hdprformuz `hsh`ed`q wmui` qpredopned
pne rmie mc buqhdeqq ormuzq$ Hc pneqe zrmzmqfiq fre pm
be f`mzpe`) hp wmui` be hlzerfphse pnfp fp pne qfle
phle prfdqzfredax) stdfdahfi rezmrphdo) fd` amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae revuhreledpq hd oederfi be ednfdae` fq
weii$ Pne lmse pmwfr` orefper uqe mc nmi`hdo aml,
zfdheq amui` neiz aifrhcx mrofdh{fphmdfi qpruapureq
fd` amlzieledp quan anfdoeq) bup qnmui` dmp ief`pm cfsmrfbie prefpledp mc pne anfebmi$ Fdx zifdde`
remrofdh{fphmd mc pne reqzeaphse reqzmdqhbhihpheq mc pne
stdfdae lhdhqprx) pne Chdfdahfi Quzershqmrx Amllhq,
qhmd) fd` Chdfdahfi Quzershqmrx Qershae wmui` nfse
pm edqure pnfp edcmraeledp mc amrzmrfpe omserdfdae
ruieq `meq dmp hlhdhqn$
Dew Anfiiedoeq
Beqh`eq pneqe e~hqphdo recmrl hqqueq) ifroer anfiiedoeq
cmr Gmref‘q amrzmrfpe qeapmr ihe fnef`7 pne anfiiedoeq
nfse pm `m whpn pne mserfii buqhdeqq edshrmdledp)eqzeahfiix hd perlq mc cmqperhdo hddmsfphmd$ Hp hq aiefr
pnfp omhdo cmrwfr` pne eamdmlha lm`ei whii nfse pm be
`hcceredp crml pne zfqp$ Rfzh` faauluifphmd mc hdzup
cfapmrq amlbhde` whpn qmih` zrm`uaphshpx ormwpn nfse
fiimwe` cmr Gmref‘q hlzreqqhse ormwpn cmr pne zfqp
15 xefrq) bup pne ihlhpq fre behdo refane`$ Hdarefqe`
amlzephphmd crml mpner amudprheq lfgeq hp ieqq aiefr
nmw Gmref afd rezefp pne cfqp ormwpn mc pne zfqp `e,
66$ Ihl fd` Kud) ’Ahrauifpmrx Qnfrenmi`hdo mc pne Ormuz Amlzfdheq“7 pne fupnmrq quooeqp fq f lmre ecceaphse reouifpmrx pmmi) fde~ zmqp qxqpel hd wnhan lhdmrhpx qnfrenmi`erq) wnmqe rhonpq fre hdcrhdoe`) fre fiimwe` pm stie f imw,amqp ifwquhp fqghdo pne amurp pmduiihcx pne reqmiuphmd mc pne oederfi leephdo mc qnfrenmi`erq$
62$ Fipnmuon mpner f`sfdae` amudprheq oederfiix `m dmp bfd dmdstdfdahfi strlq crml amdprmiihdo bfdgq) hd lmqp amudprheq quanhdseqpledp hq rfre7 qee ’Rezubiha mc Gmref; Qeieape` Hqqueq)“ HLC Amudprx Rezmrp dm$ :3-1>6 ._fqnhdopmd) @$A$; HdperdfphmdfiLmdepfrx Cud`) > Qezpelber 2::3($
6:$ Ihl Gxudo,lmmg fd` Anm Qudo,bhd) ’Pne Rmie mc Evuhpx Hdseqpledp hd Amrzmrfpe Amdprmi mc pne Ifroe Buqhdeqq Amdoimlerfpeq
hd Gmref Whd Gmrefd\)“ hd Qpu`heq md pne Lfrgep cmr Amrzmrfpe Amdprmi hd Gmref) e`$ Xmud Pfe,nmmd) Reqefran Lmdmorfzn dm$ 338.Qemui; Gmref @eseimzledp Hdqphpupe) 2::5($
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 10/12
52 PNE GMREF EAMDMLHA HDQPHPUPE
af`eq) fd` Gmref dee`q dew qmuraeq mc ormwpn$ Zfrp
mc pne qmiuphmd whii nfse pm hdsmise f bepper buqhdeqq
edshrmdledp fd` lmre cmauq md cmqperhdo hddmsfphmd)
fd` fii luqp be quzzmrpe` bx bepper amrzmrfpe omser,
dfdae$ Cmiimwhdo fre qmle qzeahsta frefq mc amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae pnfp dee` pm qnmw hlzrmseledp$
Anfebmi nfse amdprmi rhonpq pnfp cfr e~aee` pnehr
afqn,flmw rhonpq$Fipnmuon pne ruieq zrmpeaphdo hdseq,
pmrq fre dmw ifroeix amlzfrfbie whpn pnmqe hd mpner
MEA@ amudprheq .whpn pne e~aezphmd mc ihfbhihpx mc
`hreapmrq() amrzmrfpe omserdfdae hq qphii cmud` wfdp,
hdo) fq afd be qeed hd pne rfphdoq mc hdseqpmrq fd`
mpner foedaheq$ Luan mc pnhq hq `ue pm pne anfebmi‘ q
nfshdo amdprmi rhonpq cfr e~aee`hdo pnehr afqn,flmw
rhonpq$ Pnhq qphii maaurq hd zfrp beafuqe pne anfebmi
e~erahqe hd`hreap amdprmi mser pnehr strlq pnrmuon
hdqphpuphmdfi hdseqpmrq‘ mwderqnhz$ Cmr e~flzie) pne
amdprmiihdo qnfrenmi`erq mc pne 61 hdseqpledp pruqpamlzfdheq whpn lfrgep qnfreq mc lmre pnfd 2 zeraedp
fre ehpner anfebmi .3( mr bfdgq .?($60 Anfebmi fiqm
amdprmi lfdx dmdbfdg stdfdahfi hdqphpuphmdq7 pnex
amdprmi) cmr e~flzie) lmre pnfd nfic mc pne hdqurfdae
fd` qeaurhpheq amlzfdheq$ Beafuqe mc pnehr hd`hreap
zmwerq mser hdqphpuphmdfi qnfrenmi`erq) hdqh`erq mcped
`mlhdfpe amdprmi hd Gmrefd anfebmi fp pne e~zedqe mc
mpner lhdmrhpx qnfrenmi`erq$
Zmmr hlzieledpfphmd mc ruieq$ Pne qxqpel mc mupqh`e
lelberq md pne bmfr`q mc `hreapmrq dee`q pm be re,
cmrle`$ Pne zrmzmrphmd mc mupqh`e hreapmrq fzzmhdpe` bx pne ifroeqp mr pne lfkmr qnfrenmi`erq hq serx nhon) ?3
zeraedp hd 2::1765 pnuq) mupqh`e hreapmrq fre udihgeix
pm zifx fd faphse wnhqpie,bimwer rmie fd` mserqee pne
faphshpheq mc lfdfoeledp$
Afzhpfi lfrgepq fre qphii reifphseix zfqqhse hd
amrzmrfpe omserdfdae$ Fipnmuon pnere nfq beed
lmre faphse hdseqpmr edofoeledp md qmle amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae hqqueq pnfp nfq beed fh`e` bx qnfrenmi`,
erq faphshqp ormuzq quan fq Zemzie‘q Qmih`frhpx cmr
Zfrphahzfpmrx @elmarfax) zfrphahzfphmd hd oederfi bx
`mleqpha hdseqpmrq hq ihlhpe`) hd zfrp beafuqe mc amd,
flhapq mc hdpereqp$ Cmrehod hdseqpmrq) e~aezp cmr f cew
weii,zubihah{e` hdqpfdaeq) fre pmm wh`eix `hqzerqe`
pm zifx ecceaphseix pne rmie mc faphse foedpq$ Pne iesei
mc cmrehod `hreap hdseqpledp hq qphii reifphseix imw hdGmref) fd` pnhq ihlhpq curpner fdmpner cmrl mc amrzmrfpe
omserdfdae zreqqure$
Pne cud`fledpfi rmie mc amrzmrfphmdq hd Gmref‘q
eamdmlx hq ud`eromhdo vueqphmdhdo$ Pnhq refqqeqq,
ledp hq nfzzedhdo fp pne qfle phle pnfp pne bfqha
amrzmrfpe omserdfdae zrhdahzieq fd` zrfaphaeq fre
qphii behdo zup hd zifae mr peqpe`$ Amrzmrfphmdq fre) cmr
e~flzie) hdarefqhdoix behdo fqge` pm zifx f qmahfi
rmie hd pne amudprx$ Ud`er pne mupomhdo f`lhdhqprfphmd)
lmre elznfqhq wfq zup md bfifdae` ormwpn) whpn f
zfrphauifr cmafi zmhdp md fiieshfphdo bhzmifrh{fphmd hdsfrhmuq qeoledpq; pneqe hdaiu`e hqqueq mc urbfd sq$
rurfi frefq7 ifroe edperzrhqeq sq$ QLEq7 lfdfoeledp
sq$ ifbmr7 fd` zerlfdedp ifbmrerq sq$ pelzmrfrx if,
bmrerq$ Amrzmrfphmdq) eqzeahfiix ifroe mdeq pnfp nfse
bedestpe` urhdo Gmref‘q e~ze`hphmuq ormwpn zerhm`q)
fre fqge` pm qnmui`er pne amqpq mc pne amudprx‘q qmahfi
qfcepx dep$ Mde mc pne anfiiedoeq pm ifroe amrzmrfphmdq
hq pnfp pneqe f``hphmdfi bur`edq amuzie` whpn oimbfi
amlzephphse zreqqureq zuqn pnel pm hserqhcx pm mpner
qeapmrq) wnhan qmlephleq afuqeq pnel lmre hc stauipx$
Cmr e~flzie) pnex fre qnhcphdo lmre mc pnehr mzerfphmdq
mserqefq fd` reixhdo ieqq uzmd Gmrefd QLEq pm leeppnehr zrm`uaphmd dee`q$ Fq f requip) QLEq fre ud`er
curpner zreqqure fd` om hdpm lmre hqpreqq$ Zmihaheq pnfp
hlzmqe ifroe qmahfi amqpq md amrzmrfphmdq fre dmp ihgeix
pm be shfbie hd pne erf mc oimbfih{fphmd$ Hdqpef`) hd mr`er
pm qurshse) qprfhpkfagepq md amrzmrfpe faphshpheq qnmui`
be relmse` fd` lmre hdaedphseq pm hddmsfphmd qnmui`
be zrmsh`e`) wnhie prfdqzfredp amrzmrfpe omserdfdae hq
strlix zup hd zifae pm fqqure eamdmlha cfhrdeqq$
61$ Eamdmlha Qursex mc Gmref 2::5 .Zfrhq; MEA@) Qezpelber 2::5(7 _mri` Bfdg Hdqphpupe fd` Gmref @eseimzledp Hdqphpupe) ’Gmreffq f Gdmwie`oe Eamdmlx; Esmiuphmdfrx Zrmaeqq fd` Ieqqmdq Iefrde`“ ._fqnhdopmd) @$A$; _mri` Bfdg) 2::3(7 fd` ’Rezubiha mc Gmref; Qeieape` Hqqueq)“ HLC Amudprx Rezmrp dm$ :3-1>6$
60$ Ihl) Xmudo,kfe) ’Hdqphpuphmdfi Qnfrenmi`erq) Anfebmi Foedax Amqpq) fd` Zubiha Zmihax hd Gmref)“ hd Hdqphpuphmdfi fd` ZmihaxRecmrlq pm Ednfdae Amrzmrfpe Ec stahedax hd Gmref) e`$ Anm Iee,kfx) Qmlh Qemdo) fd` Iee Qfdo,nxmz) 626‑35 .Qemui; Gmref@eseimzledp Hdqphpupe) 2::?($
65$ Anm) ’F Qpu`x md Foedax Amqpq mc Gmrefd Chrlq Whd Gmrefd\$“
8/3/2019 Progress in Corporate Governance
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/progress-in-corporate-governance 11/12
QPRUAPURFI RECMRL 51
Amdaiu`hdo Relfrgq
Pnfdgq pm qprmdo zmihax faphmdq) recmrl lefqureq) fd`
lfrgep zreqqureq) Gmref nfq lf`e orefp zrmoreqq hd
hlzrmshdo hpq amrzmrfpe omserdfdae reohle$ Deserpne,
ieqq) amdaerdq relfhd) hdaiu`hdo fbmup hlzieledpf,
phmd fd` edcmraeledp mc amrzmrfpe omserdfdae ruieq)pne imw iesei mc mupqh`e hdseqpmrq) pne .hdarefqhdo(
rmie mc cflhix mwderqnhz hd pne ifroe anfebmi) fd`
pne fqqmahfpe` ifroe we`oe bepweed mwderqnhz fd`
amdprmi$ Dew amrzmrfpe omserdfdae hqqueq nfse amle
uz fq pnex nfse beed prhooere` bx amdaerd fbmup pne
oederfi amlzephphsedeqq mc Gmref‘q amrzmrfpe qeapmr$
Hdarefqe` oimbfi amlzephphmd lfgeq amdphdue` amrzm,
rfpe omserdfdae recmrl deaeqqfrx fd` revuhreq f lmre
shbrfdp qershaeq qeapmr fd` QLE qeapmr7 pnhq nfq hd purd
ie` pm f amdphdue` dee` pm recmrl pne mserfii buqhdeqq
edshrmdledp) pm imwer edprx bfrrherq) fd` pm f`mzp
zmihaheq cmqperhdo hddmsfphse benfshmr mc amrzmrfphmdqamdqhqpedp whpn fzzrmzrhfpe rhqg qnfrhdo$
@r$ Aifeqqedq hq aurredpix fd Fqqhqpfdp @hreapmr fp pne Hdperdfphmdfi Lmdepfrx Cud`$ Ne hq fiqm f Zrmceqqmr fp pne Udhserqhpx mc Flqper`fl$ Pne std`hdoq) hdperzre,pfphmdq) fd` amdaiuqhmdq e~zreqqe` hd pnhq zfzer freedphreix pnmqe mc pne fupnmr$ Pnex `m dmp deaeqqfrhixrezreqedp pne shewq mc pne HLC) hpq e~eauphse hreapmrq)mr pne amudprheq pnex rezreqedp$