Progress and Plans: Annex 1 Global Smart Grid Inventory

Eric Lightner, Annex 1 Lead (U.S. DOE)

October 2012

Australia Korea

Belgium The Netherlands

Canada Russia

China Spain

Finland Sweden

France Switzerland

Ireland United Kingdom

Italy United States

Japan

Operating Agent (as of August 2011)

All 22 ISGAN signatories

contributing data and information

to Annex 1

Annex 1 Participants

Task 1: Unified ISGAN framework for assessment of national-level motivating drivers and technology priorities for smart grids

(completed with delivery of summary report)

Task 2: Development and population of the initial project inventory with data content exchangeable with those in other

existing smart grid databases (in progress)

Task 3: Quantitative analysis on select inventory projects, using key performance indicators

(to start in Q4 2012)

Annex 1 Tasks

>24 drivers in 7 categories >50 technologies in 5 categories

>400 combinations of driver/technology pairs to select and prioritize

Template for Annex 1 Assessment Framework

Web-based survey tool for use by each country: Top 1-6 motivating drivers

Top 1-5 smart grid technologies contributing to each top-ranked driver

Up to 5 surveys allowed to reflect stakeholder/geographic diversity

Using survey results to identify driver and technologies that are top-ranked by countries for cooperation in

qualitative and quantitative assessments

Developed a Web-based Survey Tool for Prioritized Assessment Framework

Status, as of September 30

7 countries with multiple surveys (5 validated surveys being the most from a country)

Survey Status # of Surveys # of ISGAN Countries

Completed 35 21

Validated 27 19

To be validated 3 3

Rejected 5 3

Survey Completion and Validation

Excel Macros

From each survey • 6 Drivers • 30 Driver-

technology pairs

National Surveys

Code national results by • Economies • Continent

Apply weighting schemes to drivers

and driver-technology pairs

Multinational Assessment Results • All • By economies • By continent

Perform functions of • Filtering • Summing • Sorting • Ranking

Developed an Excel Tool for Survey Analysis

24

16 15 13

9 9

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

System EfficiencyImprovements

ReliabilityImprovements

Power RestorationImprovements

Enabling CustomerChoice and

Participation

Enhanced PowerSystem Resiliency toNatural and Human

Threats

RegulatoryCompliance

Top 6 Ranked Drivers

National-Level Assessment Results from the U.S.: Composite results of 5 surveys

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Dist

ribut

ion

man

agem

ent s

yste

ms a

nd…

Res

ourc

e pl

anni

ng, a

naly

sis, a

nd…

Dist

ribut

ion

feed

er c

ircui

t aut

omat

ion

Dem

and

resp

onse

Bui

ldin

g en

ergy

man

agem

ent a

nd…

Dist

ribut

ion

man

agem

ent s

yste

ms a

nd…

Adv

ance

d m

eter

ing

infr

astr

uctu

re (A

MI)

Sys

tem

wid

e m

onito

ring,

mea

sure

men

t,…

Too

ls fo

r pla

nnin

g, o

pera

tion,

ana

lysis

Dist

ribut

ed e

nerg

y re

sour

ces i

nteg

ratio

n

Dist

ribut

ion

man

agem

ent s

yste

ms a

nd…

Adv

ance

d m

eter

ing

infr

astr

uctu

re (A

MI)

Sys

tem

wid

e m

onito

ring,

mea

sure

men

t,…

Fau

lt de

tect

ion,

iden

tific

atio

n, a

nd…

Too

ls fo

r pla

nnin

g, o

pera

tion,

ana

lysis

Dem

and

resp

onse

Adv

ance

d m

eter

ing

infr

astr

uctu

re (A

MI)

Res

iden

tial c

onsu

mer

ene

rgy…

Ent

erpr

ise b

ack

offic

e sy

stem

Cyb

er se

curit

y

Res

ourc

e pl

anni

ng, a

naly

sis, a

nd…

Vol

tage

& V

AR c

ontr

ol

Sta

ndar

ds a

nd c

onfo

rman

ce te

stin

g

Sub

stat

ion

& tr

ansm

issio

n lin

e se

nsor

s

Lar

ge si

ze v

aria

ble

rene

wab

les e

nerg

y…

Sta

ndar

ds a

nd c

onfo

rman

ce te

stin

g

Dem

and

resp

onse

Dist

ribut

ed e

nerg

y re

sour

ces i

nteg

ratio

n

Cyb

er se

curit

y

Regulatory compliance

System efficiency improvements

Reliability improvements

Power restoration improvements

Enabling customer choice and participation

Enhanced power system resiliency to natural/human threats

National-Level Assessment Results from the U.S.: Composite results of 5 surveys

Documented prioritized assessment of smart grid motivating drivers and technologies by 19 ISGAN countries

Documented multinational-level analysis results of all 19 countries, developed and developing economies, and 4 continents

Top 6 Ranked Drivers of 19 Countries Top 5 Ranked Technologies of 19 Countries

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80

Energy efficiency improvements

Enabling new products, services, andmarkets

Enabling customer choice andparticipation

Reliability improvements

System efficiency improvements

Renewable energy standards or targets

0 100 200 300 400 500

Distributed energy resources

Wind

Demand response

Large size variable renewables energysources integration

Advanced metering infrastructure(AMI)

Completed Task 1 with Delivery of Summary Report of Analysis Results

Top 6 Ranked Drivers 15 developed economies 4 developing economies

Common motivating drivers: Renewable energy standards or targets, System efficiency improvements, and Reliability improvements

Other motivating drivers of priority: – Developing: lean toward current operational improvements – Developed: lean toward enabling characteristics of smart grid

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

Reliability improvements

Energy efficiency improvements

Enabling new products, services, andmarkets

Enabling customer choice andparticipation

System efficiency improvements

Renewable energy standards or targets

0 5 10 15 20

Revenue collection and assuranceimprovements

Renewable energy standards or targets

Optimizing asset utilization

Reducing operating and maintenancecosts

System efficiency improvements

Reliability improvements

Clustering of Validated Survey Results: by economies

Top 5 Ranked Technologies across All Drivers 15 developed economies 4 developing economies

Common technology of priority: AMI

Other technologies of priority: – Developing: supporting current operational improvements – Developed: supporting enabling characteristics of smart grid

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350

Large size variable renewables energysources integration

Residential consumer energymanagement

Distributed energy resourcesintegration

Demand response

Advanced metering infrastructure(AMI)

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140

System wide monitoring,measurement, and control

Tools for planning, operation, analysis

Distribution management systems andoutage management systems

Advanced metering infrastructure(AMI)

Condition-based monitoring andmaintenance

Clustering of Validated Survey Results: by economies

ID of Inventory Projects

Selection criteria

List of ≤10 projects from each country

Build and Management of ISGAN Project Inventory

Template for inputting project data & information

Input of project information

Analysis and reporting

Task 2: Web-based Project Inventory

Developed Project Selection Criteria

• Demonstration and/or deployment

• Supported by Government or regulator

• Supporting drivers and technologies of national priority

• Addressing ISGAN focus areas • Near term

(w. c/b analysis by 2017)

Compiling lists of projects

• Project lists from 12 countries received

• Lists from the remaining 10 countries to be submitted

ID of Inventory Projects

Application of Analysis Results

Task 3: 2 Smart Grid Projects tracked and reported on by each

member country

Task 2: Up to 10 projects with data/information housed in a sharable data

repository in each country

All Smart Grid

Projects in a

Country

1st filter using the individual country’s

prioritized assessment framework

Up to 10 Smart Grid

Projects 2nd filter using the clusters of driver/technology pairs

of high priority to many ISGAN countries

Eric M. Lightner Director, Smart Grid Task Force Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability U.S. Department of Energy +1-202-586-8130 eric.lightner@hq.doe.gov

Questions & Contact Information