Professionalising knowledge and data products It works!! Data –> Information flow for MSFD

Professionalising knowledge and data products

It works!!

Data –> Information flow for MSFD


Agreed under TGDATA and WGDIKE


Additional Biodiversity‘headache’

More ‘lines’Not making the same thing


EU Process governance

Operators

Methodology

Operationalbasis

Data Collection

Data Assembly

Indicator provision

Assessment

Data –> Information flow for MSFDSTRUCTURAL PROCESS COMPONENT

Data Collection Data Assembly Indicator (in reference to COM decision and on-going RSC indicator activities)

Assessment

EU process Governance

MSFD CIS/WG-DIKE (ultimately MS Marine Directors)Data from Member state monitoring programme(s) (art 19.3 and art 11)that provide linkage and reference to MSFD monitoring provision

MSFD CIS/WG-GES (ultimately MS Marine Directors) Common understanding approach MSFD indicators derived or adapted from Regional sea and Member state indicators that provide basis for common implementation

MS art 8 assessments,Regional assessments,EEA MSFD baseline assessment

Methodology Regional sea and member state monitoring guidelines manuals related to specific parameter(s)

Specific guidelines/Manuals on indicator production methodology, including reference to MSFD marine unit and assembly method of data

Assessment methodology as agreed in MSFD or regional context

Operational basisLinked to monitoring guidelines and indicator methodology

Member State data provision mechanism(s) Availability Access rights Temporal coverage Observation frequency Usage rights Update frequency Format/Outputs Metadata Spatial unit(s)

Specifications for assembled data (input and output) Location/Availability Operational portal/web service Usage rights Update frequency Format/Outputs Metadata MSFD Spatial unit: INSPIRE area

mapping QC applied

Mechanisms to publish indicators: Location/Availability New/Existing provision Supporting metadata Frequency of provision Spatial unit (related to MSFD

units) Context of use (consistency with

MSFD scope)

Definition of assessment product : Appropriateness for MSFD

output Adaptations needed Assessment scale Temporal scale

Potential Operators

MS MS, RSC, ICES, Emodnet, Copernicus, EEA, others

MS, RSC, ICES, Emodnet, Copernicus, EEA, others

MS, RSC, EEA , others

TG Data workshop(s) on D5 and D8Overview of data flows relevant to MSFD

eutrophication indicators

MSFD art 8, 9, 10 reporting from Palialexis et al. 2014

MSFD 5.3.2 Dissolved oxygen, i.e. changes due to increased organic matter decomposition and size of the area concerned

X denotes reporting

% of CPs reporting 100-81% 80-61% 60-41% 40-21% 20-1% no reporting

Parameters used in MSFD art 8, 9, 10 reporting

DO Organic content

BOD5 BQI M-AMBI

Anoxia

COD Benthic mortality

OSPAR xMSFD art 8,9, 10 x x x x xHELCOM xMSFD art 8,9, 10 x x xUNEP/MAPMSFD art 8,9, 10 x x x x xBSC xMSFD art 8,9, 10 x x xWiSe SoE [WFD, EEA]x

TG Data workshop(s) on D5 and D8Overview of data flows relevant to MSFD

eutrophication indicators MS information Regional Sea Convention info

Data flow information** MS Reporting EIONET # of parameters

# of stations (BSC,UNEP/MAP) or # of measurements (HELCOM, OSPAR)

# of stations (BSC,UNEP/MAP) or # of measurements (HELCOM, OSPAR)

Annual observation frequency

Name of RSC reporting programme

Reporting frequency

Latest reporting year

Starting year for data flow

Who provides data (institution)

Which national body reports to the RSC

Where are data provided to? (Organisation)

Name of RSC database

Holder of database

Access rights to database

Responsible for Q/A

Indicator(s) (reference)

HELCOM DK/2011 none 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 187 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2011 1979 National Environmental Research Institutenot knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)http://helcom.fi/Lists/Publications/BSEP136.pdfEE different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 94 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2012 1999 Estonian Marine Institutenot knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)FI none 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 536 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2012 1979 Finnish Environment Institutenot knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)DE none 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 598 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2012 1990 multiple not knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)LV different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 41 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2012 1990 University of Latvianot knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)LT different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 24 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2012 1992 Center of Marine Researchnot knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)PL different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 115 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2012 1990 Institute of Meteorology and Water Managementnot knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)SE different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 381 not known HELCOM COMBINE1/yr 2012 1979 Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institutenot knownHELCOM ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen concentration (HELCOM, 2013a)

BSC BG different 1 DO 25 6/yr BSIMAP 1/yr 2012 not knownBlack Sea Basin DirectorateMinistry of Environment and WaterBSC Regional database on pollutionRegional Activity Center for Pollution Monitoring and Assessment (PMA RAC), Odessa, UkraineDifferent users categories are defined (Public, BSC member, Data provider, AG member, BSC PS, RAC PMA) not all categories have acces to the raw dataRegional Activity Center for Pollution Monitoring and Assessment (PMA RAC), Odessa, UkraineHypoxic situations, expansion of zones of hypoxia (BSC, 2010)http://www.blacksea-commission.org/_publ-BSDiagnosticReport2010.aspRO different 1 DO 37 2/yr BSIMAP 1/yr 2012 2012 National Institute for Marine Research & Development Grigore AntipaMinistry of the EnvironmentBSC Regional database on pollutionRegional Activity Center for Pollution Monitoring and Assessment (PMA RAC), Odessa, UkraineDifferent users categories are defined (Public, BSC member, Data provider, AG member, BSC PS, RAC PMA) not all categories have acces to the raw dataRegional Activity Center for Pollution Monitoring and Assessment (PMA RAC), Odessa, UkraineHypoxic situations, expansion of zones of hypoxia (BSC, 2010)

OSPAR FI none 0 CEMP 2009 1990FR different 0 CEMP 2013 1982IC 0 CEMP 2003 1978PT none 0 CEMP 1990 1985ES different 0 CEMP 2010 1985BE different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 28 not known CEMP 1/yr 2012 1987 MUMM not knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR,2013) OSPAR 2013 Common Procedure for the Identification of the Eutrophication Status of the OSPAR Maritime Area(Reference number: 2013-8)DK none 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 209 not known CEMP 1/yr 2012 1978 NERI not knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR,2013) www.ospar.org/documents/.../13-08e_common_proc_eutrophication.docDE none 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 50 not known CEMP 1/yr 2012 1978 BSHG not knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR,2013)IE different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 158 not known CEMP 1/yr 2012 2009 ? not knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR,2013)NO none 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 66 not known CEMP 1/yr 2012 1978 NIVA not knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR,2013)SE different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 118 not known CEMP 1/yr 2012 1978 ? not knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR,2013)NL different 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 539 not known CEMP 1/yr 2012 1986 RWSW not knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR,2013)UK none 1 Dissolved oxygen concentration 426 not known CEMP 1/yr 2013 1978 BODC/MARLABnot knownOSPAR ICES OceanographicICES no restrictions ICES Oxygen(OSPAR, 2013)


(coordinated) Monitoring

Data provision

Ingestion

Data assembly (products)

Indicator provision

Assessment product(s)

data information knowledge


(coordinated) Monitoring

Data provision

Ingestion

Data assembly (products)

Indicator provision



D3: 1.3.1 fisheries population demographics

IBTSWG/DCF

National Fisheries

Institutes

DATRAS (trawl survey

regional database)

CPUE age/subarea

Indicator provision



D8: Hazardous substances

Data –> Information flow for MSFD examples

D5: Eutrophication


Regional cohesion

Rationalisation of reporting across instruments

Making best use of what is already in place

Understanding what is not in place


We have a lot of knowledge to gain

MS information

Data flow information**MSReporting EIONET# of parameters# of stations (BSC,UNEP/MAP) or # of measurements (HELCOM, OSPAR)

Annual observation frequency

Name of RSC reporting programme

Reporting frequency

Latest reporting year Starting year for data flow

Who provides data (institution)

Which national body reports to the RSC

Where are data provided to? (Organisation)

Regional Sea Convention info

Name of RSC databaseHolder of databaseAccess rights to databaseResponsible for Q/AIndicator(s) (reference)

Operational basisLinked to monitoring guidelines and indicator methodology

Member State data provision mechanism(s) Availability Access rights Temporal

coverage Observation

frequency Usage rights Update

frequency Format/

Outputs Metadata Spatial unit(s)

Specifications for assembled data (input and output) Location/

Availability Operational

portal/web service

Usage rights Update

frequency Format/

Outputs Metadata MSFD Spatial

unit: INSPIRE area mapping

QC applied

Mechanisms to publish indicators: Location/

Availability New/Existing

provision Supporting

metadata Frequency of

provision Spatial unit

(related to MSFD units)

Context of use (consistency with MSFD scope)

Definition of assessment product : Appropriaten

ess for MSFD output

Adaptations needed

Assessment scale

Temporal scale

Documents

Professionalising knowledge and data products It works!! Data –> Information flow for MSFD