PROCEEDINGS OF 239th MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE · Sh. Om Prakash Tiwary - State Representative of Jharkhand State Shri Pradeep Kumar Yadav - Regional Director (I/C), ERC & Convener

Proceedings of 239th Meeting (Part-1) of ERC-NCTE held on 28th April – 2nd May, 2017

Shri Pradeep Kumar Yadav (RD/Convener, ERC, NCTE) Prof. Shukla Mahanty (Chairperson ERC, NCTE)

1

PROCEEDINGS OF 239th

MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE

HELD ON 28th

April – 2nd

May, 2017

The 239th Meeting of the Eastern Regional Committee (ERC), National Council for Teacher Education

(NCTE) was convened on 28th

April – 2nd

May, 2017 at Conference Hall, ERC, NCTE, 15, Neelakantha Nagar,

Nayapalli, Bhubaneswar. The Chairperson, Members and Convener as listed below were present at the time of

the 239th ERC Meeting.

Prof. Shukla Mahanty - Chairperson

Sh. Manoj Kumar Mohanty - State Representative of Odisha State

Dr. Deva Kumar Dutta - State Representative of Assam State

Ms. J. Ch. Momin - State Representative of Meghalaya State

Sh. Om Prakash Tiwary - State Representative of Jharkhand State

Shri Pradeep Kumar Yadav - Regional Director (I/C), ERC & Convener

At the outset, the Regional Director welcomed all the members of Committee and apprised them about

the provisions of the NCTE Act, Rules, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time. With the

permission of Chairperson, Shri Pradeep Kumar Yadav (Convener) presented the Agenda before the Committee

for its due consideration and appropriate decision.

Sl.No. Item No. Content

ER-239.1

Confirmation of the Proceedings of 238th

meeting held on 18th

- 20th

April,

2017 at Bhubaneswar.

Confirmed.

ATTENTION!

1. The committee unanimously decided that the institution may reply in

response to the decision of the committee uploaded on the ERC website

without waiting for formal letters from the office of ERC. The replies so

received will also be considered by the committee.

2. The Endowment Fund / Reserve Fund (5 Lakhs + 7 Lakhs) is 12 Lakhs per

programme. (See ERC website: www.ercncte.org for detail).

3. The institution needs to submit list of 10 schools for internship and school

based activities duly approved by District Education Officer.

4. Institutions must give the affidavit for consent / willingness for number of

units either one or two if it was not submitted earlier.

5. As per provisions u/s 17(4) of the NCTE Act, 1993, if an institution offers

any course or training in Teacher Education without obtaining recognition

or permission under this Act, the qualification in teacher education obtained

pursuant to such course or training or after undertaking a course or training

in such institution, shall not be treated as a valid qualification for purposes

of employment under the Central Government, any State Government or

University, or in any school, college or other educational body aided by the

Central Government or any State Government.

6. The Committee suggested to prepare Data Bank for the teachers.

7. The institution needs to install Fire Safety equipment and submit

the Fire Safety Certificate if not submitted earlier.

8. The cutoff date for granting/refusal of recognition for the session

2017-18 was 3rd

March, 2017 and now Hon’ble Supreme Court of India

extended the time for getting recognition/refusal up to 2nd

May, 2017,

hence, the institution may submit the compliance on the basis of

proceedings uploaded in the ERC NCTE website.

http://www.ercncte.org/



2

ER-239.3 Circular / Guidelines received from NCTE Hqrs.

1. 239.3.1

Decision o f the General Body of NCTE in its 46th

Meeting held on 28th March 2017

in the matter of relaxation of land requirement for new TEIs in Hilly,

Metropolitan/Urban areas (File No. F.3-17/NCTE/ERC/REG./2017)

The NCTE Hqrs. vide its letter No. F. NCTE-CDN011(11)/1/2017-MS(NCTE)-HQ dated 12.04.2017 has

conveyed the decision of the General Body of the NCTE in its 46th meeting held on 28

th March, 2017 in the

matter of relaxing the land requirement i.e. flxibility in requirement of land for new TEIs in Hilly,

Metropolitan/Urban areas and such cases may be placed before the Regional Committee for final recognition,

or refusal thereon, only after Gazette Notification of Regulations in this regard has taken place.

The Committee noted for further compliance.

2. 239.3.2 Compliance of Appellate Orders. (File No. 18-1/NCTE/ERC/Appeal/2017).

The NCTE Hqrs. vide its letter No. 92-08/2016/Corres.ERC/Appeal/52545 dated 13th April, 2017 has

conveyed the decision of Appeal Committtee to refer all 16 cases as per list enclosed which have been

forwarded by ERC to the Appeal Committee with requested to re-visit the cases as per decision of the

Appellate Authority as contained in the Appellate Orders pertaining to the institutions.

The Committee noted that it has already considered these 16 cases in its previous meeting and taken decision.

ER-239.6 Reply to LOI / SCN after LOI

3. 239.6.1

Arunachal University of Studies, Plot No. - NH-52, Street No- NH-52, Vill- Namsai,

PO.- Namsai, Tehsil/Taluka – Namsai, Town/City – Namsai, Dist- Lohit, Arunachal

Pradesh- 792103 (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (ERCAPP2650)

After considering and examining the application along with the documents submitted by the institution, the

agenda note, the NCTE Act, the NCTE Regulations 2014 including Norms and Standards, guidelines received

from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to LOI, the Committee discussed the

matter in detail and decided as under:

Formal recognition order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation 2014 for applied D.El.Ed. programme

with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session 2017-18 be issued to the institution.

4. 239.6.2

Acharya Narendra Dev College, Plot no-504, Vill-Chaksalem, Shahpur Patory,

PO-Patory, Tehsil/Taluka-Patory, Town/City-Shahpur Patory, Dist-Samastipur,

Bihar-848504 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Lalit Narayan Mithila University) (ERCAPP3369)



from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee

discussed the matter in detail and decided as under:

Formal recognition order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation 2014 for applied B.Ed. programme

with an intake 50 (one basic unit) from the academic session 2017-18 be issued to the institution.

ER-239.8 Reply to SCN before VT

5. 239.8.1

Chanakya College of Education, Vill - Tithpukur, Street/Road - NH 34,

Taluka/Mandal - Karandighi, Town/City - Tithpukur, Dist - Uttar Dinajpur, West

Bengal – 733125. (B.Ed. & D.El.Ed.)(Private)(ERCAPP201646286) (ID No.11069)



from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under:

a. Show cause Notice was issued on 02.03.2017. In response, the institution submitted representation

dated 21.03.2017 without any supporting documents, hence, reply is not satisfactory as per

requirement of SCN. The institution is still deficient on the following grounds:

(i) NOC for the applied B.Ed. course by the affiliating Unviersity issued on 15.07.2015.

The institution is required to submit NOC for the academic session 2017-2018 or duly



3

countersigned by the concerned affiliating body.

(ii) Submitted building plan is not approved by Govt. Engineer/authority.

(iii) Building completion certificate issued from Govt. Engineer/Authority is not submitted.

(iv) Non-encumbrance certificate issued from Land Registering Authority is not submitted.

In view the above, the committee decided as under:

The institution be directed to submit the compliance on or before 2nd

May, 2017 as the cut of date for

granting/refusal of recognition for the session 2017-2018 is 2nd

May, 2017.

Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application applied for recognition be not refused

on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE

Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within the stipulated time as mentioned above before the

Committee takes final decision.

6. 239.8.2

Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Vill - Guwahati, Street/Road - 14-A, Bhuban Road,

Uzanbazar, Taluka/Mandal - GMC, Town/City - Guwahati, Dist - Kamrup, Assam –

781001. [(B.A. B.Ed. / B.Sc. B.Ed. - 4 Year Integrated) and (B.Ed. M.Ed.- 3 Year

Integrated)] (Private) (ERCAPP201646186) (ID No.10540)


agenda note, the NCTE Act., the NCTE Regulations 2014 including Norms and Standards, guidelines received


(i) The institution has not submitted consolidated blue print of building plan demarcating the teacher

education programme and mentioning the details of plot number, total land area, total built up area

etc. duly approved by Govt. Engineer.

(ii) Building completion certificate duly approved by Govt. Engineer/Authority is not submitted.





May, 2017.





7. 239.8.3

Bhavnath Chaudhary College of Education, Street/Road - NH 32 (Near Chas College

Chas), VillMaganpur, Durgapur (Diwanganj), PO. - Koora, PS. - Pindrajora,

Taluka/Mandal - Chas, Town/City - Maganpur, Durgapur (Diwanganj), Dist -

Bokaro, Jharkhand – 827013. (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (ERCAPP201646386)

(ID No.8176)




a. Show Cause Notice was issued on 03.04.2017 on the following ground:

b. In response, the institution submitted reply vide letter dated 28.03.2017 with copy of No Objection

Certificate issued by Director, Directorate of Primary Education, Jharkhand, Ranchi on 09.08.2016

i.e. after 15th July, 2016 as per Regulation, 2014 which is not accepted by the Committee.

In view the above, the Committee decided as under:

The committee is of the opinion that application bearing No. ERCAPP201646386 of the institution regarding

recognition of D.El.Ed. Programme is hereby refused under section 14(3)(b) of NCTE Act 1993.



4

ER-239.12 Non-Conduct of VT

8. 239.12.1

Primary Teacher Education College (upgraded BITE), Dariyapur, Purvi Champaran,

Plot No-2261, Street No.- Dariyapur, Vill/Po-Dariyapur, Tehsil/Taluka/Town/City-

Areraj, Dist-Purba Champaran, Bihar-845417 (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Intake) (Government)

(Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP2408)



from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under:

VT be constituted.

ER-239.5 VTR U/S 14/15

9. 239.5.1

Mahesh Singh B.Ed. College, Vill:- Kendua Street/Road: Bodhgaya

Road,Taluka/Mandal: Chandauti, Town/City:Kendua, Dist: Gaya, Bihar-823001.

[D.El.Ed. -Addl. Course)] (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board & Magadha

University) (ERCAPP201646101) (ID No.9354)



from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as

under:

Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution. The institution which

is already recognized for B.Ed./D.El.Ed course(s) and sought recognition/permission for additional

course/additional intake are required to furnish the previous faculty list along with compliance of the Letter of

Intent.

The institution be asked to submit the FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs. 7.00 lakh towards endowment fund and

reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply of letter of intent.

ER-239.8 Reply to SCN before VT

10. 239.8.4

Kamleshwari Prasad Singh Teacher Training College, Vill:- Teka Bigha, Street /

Road:- NH-31, Taluka/ Mandal:- Bakhtiyarpur, Town/City :- Teka Bigha, Dist:-

Patna, Bihar-803202 [B.Ed.(Addl. Intake)] (Private) (Magadha University)

(ERCAPP201646122) (ID No.9394)




VT be constituted.

ER-239.2 Court Case

11. 239.2.1

Mahabodhi Teacher Training College, Plot No. 399, Vill Belaru, PO-Tetar, Tehsil-

Mohara Prakhand, Town City-Tapowan, Gaya, Bihar-823311 (M.Ed.-Addl. Course)

(Private) (ERCAPP2492)



from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time and Order dated 13.04.2017 passed by Hon’ble High Court of Patna

in CWJC No. 11749 of 2016, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under:

VT be constituted.

The institution is directed to submit LOI from NAAC to the VT Members during inspection.



5

12. 239.2.2

Bhagawan Prasad Sheonath Prasad B.Ed College, Plot No. 336 to 945, Street No –

Ptana Road, Vill- Kera, P.o-Bhakharuan More, Daud Nagar, Tehsil /Taluka, Tehsil-

DaudNagar, Town City-DaudNagar, Dist-Auraganbad, Bihar-824113 (B.Ed.-

Additional Intake) (Private) (ERCAPP3478)

The institution was granted recognition for B.Ed. course with an additional intake 50 (existing 100 intake +

additional 50 intake), thus making the total intake of 150 (one hundred fifty) vide Order No. 46318 dated

02.05.2016 from the academic session 2016-2017 as decided in 213th ERC Meeting.

The institution, being aggrieved with the decision of ERC, filed Writ Petition bearing No. W.P.(C) No. 8762

of 2016 before the Hon’ble High Court of Orissa and the same matter was placed in 225th ERC Meeting held

on 16-18 November, 2016. The Committee decided that the prayer of the Petitioner to accord revised

recognition for the required another one unit is not at all possible at present as the cut of date for grant of

recognition is over for the session 2016-2017 and in no circumstances, the same can be taken for

consideration. As such the application of the petitioner for grant of recognition/permission for another one unit

stands disposed of and it is open for the applicant to make afresh application as per NCTE Regulation, 2014

for the next academic session for consideration.

The institution has submitted representation dated 25.04.2017 along with D.D. of Rs. 1,50,000/- and a copy of

the Order passed in Writ Petition bearing W.P. No. 22417(w) of 2016 by the Hon’ble High Court of Orissa.

The Hon’ble High Court disposed of the matter on 17.04.2017 with a direction interalia:

“We dispose of this writ petition with the direction that although the time for filing of the application for the academic session 2017-18 has already expired, but in case the said application, along with requisite

fees and necessary documents, is filed by the petitioner with the opposite party No. 1-NCTE along with

certified copy of this order on or before 25.04.2017, the same shall be treated as fresh application filed within time, and shall be decided on its own merit and necessary orders for intake of students in the

institution of the petitioner for the academic session 2017-18 shall be passed in accordance with Law.”

In view of the above, the Committee decided as under:

In addition to 150 intake already granted up till academic session 2016-2017 earlier, the Committee decided

that formal recognition Order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation, 2014 for applied B.Ed. programme

with another 50 intake from the session 2017-2018 be issued to the institution, thus making the sum total

grant of 200 intake.

13. 239.2.3

Vidya College of Professional Studies, Plot No. 410 & 411, Vill.- Rasulpur Varuna,

PO. - Chipura, Tehsil/Taluka- Sampatchak, Town/City-Patna, Dist.- Patna, Bihar-

804453 (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP3171)

The institution was granted recognition for D.El.Ed. course with an intake 50 (One basic unit) vide Order No.

44316 dated 03.03.2016 from the academic session 2016-2017 as decided in 207th ERC Meeting.


of 2016 before the Hon’ble High Court of Orissa and the same matter was placed in 225th ERC Meeting held




consideration. As such the application of the petitioner for grant of recognition/permission for another one unit

stands disposed of and it is open for the applicant to make afresh application as per NCTE Regulation, 2014

for the next academic session for consideration.

The institution has submitted representation dated 25.04.2017 along with D.D. of Rs. 1,50,000/- and a copy of

the Order passed in Writ Petition bearing W.P. No. 22418(w) of 2016 by the Hon’ble High Court of Orissa.

The Hon’ble High Court disposed of the matter on 18.04.2017 with a direction interalia:

“We dispose of this writ petition with the direction that although the time for filing of the application for the academic session 2017-18 has already expired, but in case the said application, along with requisite

fees and necessary documents, is filed by the petitioner with the opposite party No. 1-NCTE along with



6

certified copy of this order on or before 25.04.2017, the same shall be treated as fresh application filed within time, and shall be decided on its own merit and necessary orders for intake of students in the

institution of the petitioner for the academic session 2017-18 shall be passed in accordance with Law.”

In view of the above, the Committee decided as under:

In addition to 50 intake already granted from the academic session 2016-2017 earlier, the Committee decided

that formal recognition Order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation, 2014 for applied D.El.Ed.

programme with another 50 intake from the session 2017-2018 be issued to the institution, thus making the

sum total grant of 100 intake.

ER-239.5 VTR U/S 14/15

14. 239.5.2

Millat Teachers' Training College, Vill:- Bhowara, Street / Road:-Stadium Road,

Taluka/ Mandal:- Madhubani, Town/City :- Bhowara, Dist:- Madhubani, Bihar-

847212 (M.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (Lalit Naryan Mithila University)

(ERCAPP201646110) (ID No.8882)




under:




Intent.



15. 239.5.3

Sarif College of Education, Vill - Baxipara, Street/Road - NH-31, Taluka/Mandal -

Jalpaiguri Sadar, Town/City - Baxipara, Dist - Jalpaiguri, West Bengal -735101

(B.Ed. & D.El.Ed.) (Private) (ERCAPP201646254) (ID No.9163)




under:

Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution.

The institution be asked to submit two separate FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs. 7.00 lakh for each applied course

towards endowment fund and reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply

of letter of intent.

16. 239.5.4

Kamakhya Institute of Education, Plot No.3, 5, 6, 7(LR)239, Vill - Debipur, PO.-

Badu, Tehsil/ Taluka/ Town/ City - Barasat, Dist - North 24 Parganas, West Bengal -

700128. (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Intake) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary

Education) (ERCAPP3904)




under:




Intent.





7

17. 239.5.5

Gimageria Welfare Primary Teachers Training Institute, Vill - Krishnachak,

Taluka/Mandal - Raipur Paschim Barh Gram Panchayet, Town/City - Krishnachak,

Dist - Medinipur, West Bengal - 721401 (B.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private)

(ERCAPP201645148) (ID No.9878)




under:




Intent.



18. 239.5.6

Rameshwar Singh Teachers Training College, Vill:- Pandey Parasawan, Street/

Road:- Village Road, Taluka / Mandal:- Town Block Gaya, Town / City:- Pandey

Parasawan, Dist: Gaya, Bihar-823004 (B.Ed. -Addl. Intake) (Private) (Magadha

University (ERCAPP201645092) (ID No.8456)




under:




Intent.



19. 239.5.7

Jaspuria B.Ed. College, Plot no - 155, Vill- Bisa, Po/Tehsil/Taluka - Angara,

Town/City - Ranchi, Dist - Ranchi, Jharkhand - 835103 (D.El.Ed. -Addl. Course)

(Private) (Jharkhand Academic Council) (ERCAPP3650)




under:




Intent.





8

20. 239.5.8

Taiyab Memorial Teachers' Training Institute, Vill - Barhadih, Machamahul,

Street/Road - Sarkardih Vill. Road, Taluka/Mandal - Sarkardih, Town/City -

Barhadih, Machamahul, Dist - Dhanbad, Jharkhand – 828109. (B.Ed. & D.El.Ed.-

Addl. Intake) (Private) (ERCAPP201646289) (ID No.9149)




under:




Intent.




21. 239.5.9

S.T. College of Education, Vill:-Ahmad Raza Nagar, Street/Road: Kurkuri,

Taluka/Mandal: Phulwarisharif, Town/City:-Ahmad Raza Nagar, Dist: Patna, Bihar-

801505 (D.El.Ed. & B.Ed.) (Private) (Maulana Mazharul Haque Arabic and Persian

University & Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP201646155) (ID No.

10508)




under:




22. 239.5.10

Binoy Sadan B.Ed. College of Women in Social Action, Plot No.- 158/194,

Vill- Jangal Khas, Po./Town./City- Jhargram, Tehsil/Taluka- Nedabora, Dist-

Midnapore, West Bengal - 721507 (D.El.Ed. -Addl. Course) (Private) (West Bengal

Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP2134)




under:




Intent.





9

23. 239.5.11

Katihar Teachers Training College, Vill - Sirsa, Street/Road - P. No. 3660, Street -

Zafar Bagh, Mouza/Po - Dalan, Taluka/Mandal - Katihar, Town/City - Sirsa, Dist -

Katihar, Bihar - 854106 (D.El.Ed. -Addl. Course)) (Private) (Bihar School

Examination Board) (ERCAPP201645067) (ID No.8893)




under:




Intent.



24. 239.5.12

Dharikshan Singh Teachers Training College, Vill:- Kulharia, Street / Road:- NH-30,

Taluka/ Mandal:- Ara, Town/City :- Kulharia, Dist:- Bhojpur, Bihar-802160

(D.El.Ed. -Addl. Intake) (Private) Bihar School Examination Board

(ERCAPP201646277) (ID No.11283)




under:




Intent.



25. 239.5.13

Jalpaiguri Dooars PTTI, Vill - Plot No.- 338, Ghagra, Street/Road - Ghagra,

Taluka/Mandal - Alipurduar, Town/City - Plot No.- 338, Ghagra, Dist - Jalpaiguri,

West Bengal - 736122 (B.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (ERCAPP201646264)

(ID No.10568)




under:




Intent.





10

ER-239.4 Appeal Remand Back Cases

26. 239.4.1

Aryan College of Education, Plot No- 247/313, Vill- Shitoljor, Dhansimla, PO-

Sonamukhi, Tehsil/Taluka/Town/City- Sonamukhi, Dist- Bankura, West Bengal-

722207 (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Burdwan) (ERCAPP2972)

The institution was granted recognition for B.Ed. course with an intake 50 (One basic unit) vide Order No.


The institution preferred an appeal to the NCTE Hqrs. against the ERC’s order dated 02.05.2016.

The Appellate Authority vide Order No. 89-840/2016 Appeal/6th Meeting-2017 dated 18.04.2017 remanded

back the case to ERC for suitably modifying the impugned recognition order dated 02.05.2016 on the

submission of the additional list of faculty by the appellant institution.

The ERC re-viewed the matter in accordance with the appeal order and decided as under:-





27. 239.4.2

Sarat Chandra Teacher Training Institute, Plot No.39, St. No./ Vill/ P.O. - Rosna,

Tehsil/ Taluka/ Town/ City - Pandua, Dist - Hooghly, West Bengal - 712149. (B.Ed.)

(Private) (University of Burdwan) (ERCAPP3970)


back the case to ERC with a direction to conduct another inspection of the appellant institution, on payment of

the prescribed fee by the appellant, and take further action as per the NCTE Regulations, 2014. The appellant

is directed to forward all the relevant documents to the ERC within 15 days of receipt of the order on the

appeal and make payment of the inspection fee as per the directions of the ERC.


Re-inspection of the institution be conducted on payment of inspection fee of Rs.1,50,000/-.

28. 239.4.3

Gayatri Devi Institute Of Education, Plot No- 427, Vill- Radhanagar, PO- Gopinagar,

Tehsil/Taluka – Dhaniakhali, Town/City – Dhaniakhali, Dist- Hooghly, West

Bengal- 712402 (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Burdwan) (ERCAPP2938)


back the case to ERC with a direction to conduct another inspection of the institution, on payment of the

inspection fee by the appellant, so as to obtain a correct picture of the building of the appellant institution and

its infrastructure, and take further action as per the NCTE Regulations, 2014.


Re-inspection of the institution be conducted on payment of inspection fee of Rs.1,50,000/-.

29. 239.4.4

ABS Academy, Plot No.9594, 9595, 9596, 9597, 1612(p),Street No.-Sagarbhang,

Vill/Po-Sagarbhang, Town/ City - Durgapur, Tehsil/ Taluka - Gopinathpur,

Dist - Bardhaman, West Bengal - 713211 (B.Ed. -Addl. Intake) (Private) (University

of Burdwan) (ERCAPP3944)






back the case to ERC for suitably modifying the impugned order dated 02.05.2016.








11

30. 239.4.5

Birhambir Teachers Training Institute, Plot Number : 338, Vill- Kankila, PO-

Banradhanagar, Tehsil/Taluka - Bishnupur, Town/City – Bishnupur, Dist- Bankura,

West Bengal- 722157 (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Burdwan) (ERCAPP2986)

The institution was granted recognition for B.Ed. course with an intake 50 (One basic Unit) vide Order No.




back the case to ERC for granting recognition for two units of B.Ed. programme instead of one.






31. 239.4.6

Genex B.Ed College, Plot No- 711, 712, 713, 719, 704, 747, 747, 748, Street No-

NH2, Vill/PO.- Sugandha, Tehsil/Taluka- Sugandha, Town/City- Chinsurah, Dist-

Hooghly, West Bengal- 712102 (B.Ed. -Addl. Intake) (Private) (University of

Burdwan) (ERCAPP2548)





of 2016 before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi and the same matter was placed in 225th ERC Meeting held




consideration. As such the application of the petitioner for grant of recognition for another one unit stands

disposed of and it is open for the applicant to make afresh application as per NCTE Regulation, 2014 for the

next academic session for consideration.



back the case to ERC for granting recognition for two additional units of B.Ed. programme instead of one

additional unit. Appellant is required to submit the list of two faculty members (one each in Math and

Science) to ERC within 15 days of the issue of appeal order. In compliance of Appeal Order, the institution

submitted reply vide letter dated 20.04.2017 along with requisite list of faculty approved by the concerned

affiliating body.






32. 239.4.7

B.N. Saha DAV Teachers Training College, At-Sarisia, Near Giridih Block, Giridih,

Madhupur Road, Dist.- Giridih, Jharkhand-815301. (B.Ed.) (Private) (Vinoba Bhave

Unviersity) (ERCAPP00581)

The institution was granted recognition for B.Ed. course with an intake 100 vide Order dated 10.12.2008.

Recognition to B.Ed. course was withdrawn under section 17(1) of NCTE Act, 1993 from the academic

session 2015-2016 vide Order dated 04.02.2015. The institution preferred an appeal and directed by Appeal

Committee vide order dated 15.01.2016, Inspection was conducted on 11.05.2016. Show Cause Notice was

issued on 26.08.2016 as decided in 220th ERC Meeting. The reply received from the institution was considered

by ERC in 223rd

meeting and decided that the withdrawal Order dated 04.02.2015 remains unchanged as the



12

land and building of the institution is still in the name of DAV College of Management Committee. The land

and building is not in the name of B.N.Saha DAV Teachers Training Institute.

Being aggrieved with the decision of ERC, the institution preferred an appeal to the NCTE Hqrs.

The Appellate Authority vide Order No. 89-758/2016 Appeal/4th Meeting-2017/52431 dated 07.04.2017

remanded back the case to ERC with a direction to consider the submissions of the appellant and issue

appropriate order as per the NCTE Regulations. The appellant is directed to submit all the relevant documents

in this regard to the ERC within 15 days of receipt of the order on the appeal.

The ERC re-viewed the matter in accordance with the appeal order and observed as under:-

(i) The institution is required to submit the land transfer certificate in the name of institution duly signed

by the competent Govt. authority.

(ii) Building completion certificate in the name of institution duly signed by the Govt. Engineer/Authority

is required to be submitted.





May, 2017.

Show Cause Notice u/s 14(3)(b) be issued to the institution to submit its reply within the stipulated time as

mentioned above before the Committee takes final decision.

ER-239.8 Consideration of Cases before VT

33. 239.8.5

Pailan College of Education, Vill - Kolkata, Street/Road - Bengal Pailan Park, Sector

1, Phase 1, Amgachia Road, Taluka/Mandal - PO -Pailan, PS- Bishnupur, Town/City

- Kolkata, West Bengal - 7000104 (M.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private)

(ERCAPP201646329) (ID No.10857)




VT be constituted.

34. 239.8.6

Indira Gandhi Memorial B Ed College, Plot NO- 623, 624, Street- Amta Dihibhursut

Road, Village- Sonatala, PO.- Sonatala, Tehsil- Uluberia, Town/City-

Udaynarayanpur, Dis- Howrah, West Bengal- 711412 (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course)

(Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP4061)




a. Show Cause Notice was issued on 31.03.2017 on the following grounds:

(i) Inspection to the institution as well as VT experts were issued on 24.12.2016.

(ii) The institution vide letter dated 23.12.2016 has stated that they are not yet ready for conducting

the inspection due to unavoidable circumstances.

(iii) Dr. Sakti Ranjan Mishra, VT expert vide letter dated 29.12.2016 reported that the institution is

not ready for inspection.

(iv) Dr. Ram Pratap Jangu, VT expert vide E-mail dated 29.12.2016 also informed that the institution

is not ready for inspection.

(v) As per NCTE Regulation 2014, inspection of the institution is not conducted as per the consent

of the institution.

b. In response, the institution vide letter dated 18.04.2017 has requested to conduct inspection after

31st March, 2018, which is not accepted by the Committee.


The committee is of the opinion that application bearing Code No. ERCAPP4061 of the institution regarding




13

35. 239.8.7

Mathura Singh Teacher Training College, Vill:- Jalalpur, Street / Road:- Mathura

Road, Taluka/ Mandal:- Chapra Sadar, Town/City :- Jalalpur, Dist:- Saran, Bihar-

841211. [B.Ed. (Addl. Intake) & D.El.Ed. (Addl. Course)] (Private) (Bihar School

Examination Board & Jai Prakash Narain University) (ERCAPP201645094) (ID

No.7361)




For B.Ed.(Additional Intake):

a. Show Cause Notice was issued on 18.03.2017 on the following grounds:

(i) NOC for the applied B.Ed.(addl. Intake) and D.El.Ed. Course issued from concerned affiliating

body is not submitted.

(ii) Building completion certificate is not submitted.

b. In response, the institution vide letter dated 07.04.2017 has requested to withdraw their application for

B.Ed.(Additional Intake) as they have not obtained NOC from J.P. University, Chapra.


As requested by the institution, the application/file for B.Ed.(Additional Intake) be closed.

For D.El.Ed.:

(i) Building completion certificate duly approved by Govt. Engineer/Authority is not submitted.





May, 2017.





36. 239.8.8

Grizzly College of Education, Vill - Jhumri Telaiya, Street/Road - AT- Gumo, Near-

Satpulia, Taluka/Mandal - Koderma, Town/City - Jhumri Telaiya, Dist - Koderma,

Jharkhand - 825409 (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private) (ERCAPP201646169) (ID

No.10589)




VT be constituted.

37. 239.8.9

Rajeev Gandhi Memorial Teachers' Training, Vill - Digwadih No. 12, Street/Road -

Digwadih, Taluka/Mandal - Dhanbad, Town/City - Digwadih No. 12, Dist -

Dhanbad, Jharkhand - 828119 (M.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private)

(ERCAPP201646299) (ID No.11112)




VT be constituted.



14

38. 239.8.10

Sevabharati Institute of Education, Street/Road - Beragari-Road, Vill - Kapgari,

Taluka/Mandal - Kapgari, Town/City - Kapgari, Dist - Medinipur, West Bengal -

721505 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Vidyasagar University) (ERCAPP201646372)

(ID No. 9296)




(i) NOC for the applied B.Ed. course issued from the affiliating University on 22.06.2015. The institution

is required to submit NOC for the academic session 2017-2018 or duly countersigned by the concerned

affiliating body.

(ii) Building completion certificate in prescribed format duly approved by the Govt. Engineer/Authority is

not submitted.

(iii) Land use certificate from the Land Revenue/concerned Govt. Deptt. is not submitted.





May, 2017.





ER-239.6 Reply to LOI / SCN reply after LOI

39. 239.6.3

Uday Memorial B.Ed College, Street/Road - B.I.T. Road, Vill - Kedal,

Taluka/Mandal - Sadar, Town/City - Kedal, Dist - Ranchi, Jharkhand - 835217

(D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private) (ERCAPP201646166) (ID No.10069)







40. 239.6.4

Karim City College, Plot No. 3586, 3600, Vill- Zakirnagar West, Po- Azadnagar

Mango, Tehsil/Taluka- Pardih, Town/City- Jamshedpur, Dist.- Purba Singhbhum,

Jharkhand- 832012 (D.El.Ed. -Addl. Course) (Private) (Kolhan University)

(ERCAPP3117)







41. 239.6.5

Siksha Bikash Seba Foundation, D.El.Ed., Plot No.604, 628, Street No. - G T Road,

Vill - Nudipur More, P.O. - Chotikhanda, Tehsil/ Taluka - Memari, Town/ City -

Burdwan, Dist - Bardhaman, West Bengal - 713146. (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course)

(Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP4168)









15

42. 239.6.6

Bhuvanmalti Teachers Training College, Plot No. 21, Street No. 1, Vill- Basatpur

Badatola, Po- Rupdih, Tehsil/Taluka- Mothari, Town/City- Motihari, Dist.- Purba

Champaran, Bihar-845408 (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private) (Bihar School

Examination Board) (ERCAPP2465)







43. 239.6.7

Hope Institute of Bengal D.El.Ed. Section, Plot No.630, 631, St. No./ Vill/ P.O.-

Beldubi, Tehsil/ Taluka - Sub. Div. Howrah Sadar, Town/ City - Howrah, Dist -

Howrah, West Bengal - 711322. (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private) (West Bengal

Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP3715)







44. 239.6.8

Bhagawan Budh Primary Teachers Education College, Plot No.-14566, Vill-

Bajrahia, PO- Bajrahia Via Maharajganj, Tehsil/Taluka/ Town/City-Maharajganj,

Dist-Siwan, Bihar-841238 (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Private) (Bihar School

Examination Board) (ERCAPP2641)




matter in detail and observed as under:

(i) In the statement of marks of Shri Awanindra Kumar, Dr. Jay Prakash Srivastav, Shri Khurshid Anwar,

Shri Dharmendra Singh, Shri Ravi Shankar, Shri Krisankant Singh, legible seal and signature of the

issuing authority is required.

(ii) In respect of Shri Subodh Kumar Singh and Amrita Kumari, the statement of marks does not reflect

the course.





May, 2017.







16

45. 239.6.9

Maa Vidya Maa Kushum Teachers Training College, Plot No.426, 431, 495, 430,

Street/Road-Ijarta, Vill-Ijarta, PO-Paipura, Tehsil-Paliganj, Town/City-Patna, Dist-

Patna, Bihar-801110 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Magadh University) (ERCAPP2730)





(i) As per submitted faculty list, the institution has appointed three Part-time faculities namely

Shri Avinash Kumar, Shri Puroshttam Chandra and Shri Sanjay Kumar Sinha. As per NCTE

Regulation 2014, the institution is required to submit faculty list of full time teachers rather than

part-time teachers.





May, 2017.





46. 239.6.10

Kingway Technical Institute, Vill - G.T.Road, Kulharia, St./ Road - NH 2, Taluka/

Mandal - Mohania, Town/City - G.T. Road, Kulharia, Dist. - Kamur, Bihar - 821105.

(D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private) Bihar School Examination Board

(ERCAPP201645045) (ID No.7969)







47. 239.6.11

Greet Teacher Training College, Street/Road - Railway Station Road,

Vill. - Panchrukhi, Taluka/Mandal - Dhanwar, Town/City - Panchrukhi, Dist -

Giridih, Jharkhand - 825412 (D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private)

(ERCAPP201646127) (ID No.9151)





(i) The institution is required to submit individual affidavit Rs. 10/- non-judicial stamp paper in original of

each appointed and approved faculty.





May, 2017.







17

48. 239.6.12

PT Iswarchandra Vidyasagar PTT & B.Ed. College, Plot No.1482/ 1490, Vill -

Marichya, P.O. - Dondipur, Tehsil/ Taluka/ Town/ City - Ghatal, Midnapore, West

Bengal - 721222. (D.El.Ed.-New proposal) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary








49. 239.6.13

PT Iswarchandpa Vidyasagar PTT & B.Ed College, Plot No- 1482/1490, Vill-

Marichya, PO- Dondipur, Tehsil/Taluka/Town/City- Ghatal, Dist- Medinapore, West

Bengal- 721222 (B.Ed.-New proposal) (Private) (Vidyasagar University)

(ERCAPP3550)







50. 239.6.14

Maharshi Paramhansh College of Education, Vill - Huhua, Street/Road - NH 23,

Taluka/Mandal - Ramgarh, Town/City - Huhua, Dist - Hazaribagh, Jharkhand -

829122 (D.El.Ed. -Addl. Intake) (Private) (ERCAPP201646300) (ID No.11395)






with an additional intake 50 (one basic unit) from the academic session 2017-18 be issued to the institution.

51. 239.6.15

Yeaqub Ali B.Ed College, Plot No- RS 61, 547, 59, 60, 80, Vill- Hayat Nagar

Rajarhat, PO- Sirakole, Tehsil/Taluka- Usthi, Town/City- Kolkata, Dist- South 24

Parganas, West Bengal- 743513 (B.Ed.) (Private) (The West Bengal University of

Teachers Training, Education Planning and Administration) (ERCAPP3674)







52. 239.6.16

Yeaqub Ali B.Ed College, Plot No- RS 61, 547, 59, 60, 80, Vill- Hayat Nagar

Rajarhat, PO- Sirakole, Tehsil/Taluka- Usthi, Town/City- Kolkata, Dist- South 24

Parganas, West Bengal- 743513 (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary










18

ER-239.12 MISC. CASES

53. 239.12.2

Uday Narayan Singh B.Ed. College, Vill:- Mirjapur, P.O.+ P.S.- Risiup, Street/

Road:- Back of Risiup Police Station, Taluka / Mandal:- Kutumba, Town / City:-

Mirjapur, P.O.+ P.S.- Risiup, Dist:- Aurangaabad, Bihar- 824102 (B.Ed. & D.El.Ed.)

(Private) (Bihar School Examination Board & Maulana Mazharul Haque Arabic &

Persian University) (ERCAPP201646318) (ID No.11424)




(i) The Director, Bihar School Examination Board, Patna vide letter No. 774 dated 16.03.2017

informed that they did not issue No Objection Certificate for D.El.Ed. course to the institution.

In view the above, the committee decided as under: The institution be directed to submit the compliance on or before 2

nd May, 2017 as the cut of date for


May, 2017.





54. 239.12.3

National College, Plot No- 605, 606, 607, Street No- NH-34, Vill/PO- Sargachhi,

Tehsil/Taluka- Beldanga, Town/City- Berhampore, Dist- Murshidabad, West

Bengal- 742134 (B.Ed.-New proposal) (Private) (The West Bengal University of

Teachers Training, Education Planning and Administration) (ERCAPP3808)




a. The institution submitted NOC vide No. IC/B.Ed./NOC related/365/M(61)/2015 dated 22.06.2015

issued by Dr. Subrata Kumar Ray, Inspector of Colleges, University of Kalyani instead of Registrar,

University of Kalyani.

b. A letter was issued to the institution on 01.09.2016 regarding submission of NOC with countersignature

of Registrar, Unviersity of Kalyani after which composite VT for ERCAPP3853 and ERCAPP3808 may

be constituted.

c. No reply received from the institution till date and the time limit has already been over.

In view the above, the Committee decided as under: The committee is of the opinion that application bearing Code No. ERCAPP3808 of the institution regarding

recognition of B.Ed. Programme is hereby refused under section 14(3)(b) of NCTE Act 1993.

55. 239.12.4

National College, Plot No.605, 606, 607, St. No.NH-34, Vill/PO. - Sargachhi, Tehsil/

Taluka - Beldanga, Town/ City - Berhampore, Dist - Murshidabad, West Bengal -

742134. (D.El.Ed.-New proposal) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary





a. The institution submitted NOC vide No. IC/B.Ed./NOC related/365/M(61)/2015 dated 22.06.2015

issued by Dr. Subrata Kumar Ray, Inspector of Colleges, University of Kalyani instead of Registrar,

University of Kalyani.

b. A letter was issued to the institution on 01.09.2016 regarding submission of NOC with countersignature

of Registrar, Unviersity of Kalyani after which composite VT for ERCAPP3853 and ERCAPP3808 may



19

be constituted.

c. No reply received from the institution till date and the time limit has already been over.

In view the above, the Committee decided as under: The committee is of the opinion that application bearing Code No. ERCAPP3853 of the institution regarding


ER-239.5 VTR U/S 14/15

56. 239.5.14

North East Frontier Technical University, Street/ Road - Darka, Vill -Darka,

Taluka/Mandal - Darka, Town / City - Darka, Dist - West Siang, Arunachal Pradesh -

791001 (B.Ed.-New proposal) (Private) (North East Frontier Technical University)

(ERCAPP201646121) (ID No.9245)




under:




57. 239.5.15

Dharikshan Singh Teachers Training College, Vill:- Kulharia, Street / Road:- NH-30,

Taluka/ Mandal:- Ara, Town/City :- Kulharia, Dist:- Bhojpur, Bihar-802160.

[B.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Private) (Veer Kunwar Singh University)

(ERCAPP201646276) (ID No.11324)




under:




Intent.



58. 239.5.16

Gautam Budh Teachers Training College, Vill - Baba Bakhtaur Banboriya Dham,

Street/Road - Gautam Budh Nagar, Taluka/Mandal - Nagarnausa, Town/City - Baba

Bakhtaur Banboriya Dham, Dist - Nalanda, Bihar - 801305 (B.Ed.-New proposal)

(Private) (Maulana Mazharul Haque Arabic & Persian University

(ERCAPP201646362) (ID No.7681)




under:






20

59. 239.5.17

Shanti Memorial College of Education, Vill - Plot No.- 1258, 1230, Pirpar,

begumpur, Street/Road - near by kundalpur jain mandir, Taluka/Mandal - Noorsarai,

Town/City - 1258, 1230, Pirpar, begumpur, Dist - Nalanda, Bihar - 803111

(D.El.Ed.- Addl. Course) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board)

(ERCAPP201645034) (ID No.7958)




under:




Intent.



60. 239.5.18

Sri Shravan Kumar B.Ed. and D.El.Ed. College, Plot no - 151, Street No. Kanpa,

Vill/Po - Kanap, Tehsil/Taluka- Daudnagar, Town/City - Daudnagar, Dist -

Aurangabad, Bihar - 824120 (B.Ed.) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board)

(ERCAPP3553)




under:




61. 239.5.19

Sri Shravan Kumar B.Ed. and D.El.Ed. College, Plot no - 151, Street No. Kanpa,

Vill/Po - Kanap, Tehsil/Taluka- Daudnagar, Town/City - Daudnagar, Dist -

Aurangabad, Bihar - 824120 (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board)

(ERCAPP3554)




under:




62. 239.5.20

Government Teachers Training College, Deoghar, Vill - Williams Town, Street/Road

- Sarkar Bhawan Road, Taluka/Mandal - Deoghat, Town/City - Deoghar, Dist -

Deoghar, Jharkhand - 814112 (B.Ed.) (Government) (Sido Kanhu University)

(ERCAPP201645012) (ID No.7137)




under:




21

63. 239.5.21

Millia Teachers Training College, Vill:- Radha Nagar, Kasba, Street / Road:-NH-57,

Taluka/ Mandal:- Kasba, Town/City :- Radha Nagar, Kasba,Dist:- Purnia, Bihar-

854330 (B.Ed. & D.El.Ed.) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board &

B.N.Mandal University) (ERCAPP201646085) (ID No.7855)




under:





64. 239.5.22

Arunachal University of Studies, Vill - Deobeel, Street/Road - NH-52,

Taluka/Mandal - Namsai, Town/City - Deobeel, Dist - Lohit, Arunachal Pradesh -

792103 (M.Ed.) (Private) (Arunachal University of Studies) (ERCAPP201646205)

(ID No.10825)




under:





ER-239.8 SCN Reply before VT / MISC. CASES

65. 239.8.11

Bankim Behari Teachers' Training Institute, Vill - Markandachak, PO. -

Bishnupurbazar, Taluka/Mandal - Sabong, Town/City - Markandachak, Dist -

Medinipur, West Bengal – 721144. [B.Ed. (Addl. Intake) & D.El.Ed. (Addl. Intake)]

(Private) (ERCAPP201646015) (ID No.9663)




VT be constituted.

The meeting ended with vote of thanks to the Chair.

Documents

PROCEEDINGS OF 239th MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE · Sh. Om Prakash Tiwary - State Representative of Jharkhand State Shri Pradeep Kumar Yadav - Regional Director (I/C), ERC & Convener