Principles of Public Law

nisrr~~ngnuiubmu~.a"~faniua~n~nu~u~~ubnmb~~uni~bb~i~u"u

muian~~lj~ngnuiuoan~ilu 2 ds:~nn ?in d dsi Y n. nawaJ7ums$su$6 (Substantive law) C ~ J L ~ U ~ ~ M U I unu bun

nibi luni~~inwmim%~~n:nri id~~~~nnnbmum~~ b$u d~:uaenpnuiuuw~ d.r:uaang

u luoly l qm.ru;y bilPa6~ dd 'Y a. ngwu7u%nik@ (Procedural Law) !6bbn ngMU1LIYIuLuQ

w u 8 u a t ~ r 4 w b o n ~ ~ n n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n D ~ ~ ~ u P p d ~ n o ~ ~ u u i u l $ ~ m r i u n i ~ n g n u i u ~ i l u n ~ t r n u ~ ~ ~

d' l u n i s a ~ i n ~ ~ ~ z n ~ i ~ ~ n i w U j 6 u u o ~ n ~ ~ u i u A M 0

~ n i l i u n 1 ~ n g n u i u n u o i ~ i o ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ u 7 n ~iruorn'nsdiin~iu

h&$unisfiirrun ~ ~ a e g m d o ~ i i ~ u o ~ h u n n ~ i u ~ 1 ~ ~ o ~ u u o d ~ n l u i n l d n ~ n u l u ~ d

$ ~ ~ ' , ~ ~ d ~ n i ~ d ~ U ~ 3 i ~ n i 3 ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ i ~ n i ~ d l 9 7 LL~L~DJL(~IHJIC("U~J~~ B ~ i i ~ i l ~ o d i ~ dn a ~~n"otn'o~l$8nisCm~do~6nauo~t7ni~i(ni~n~~uiu . (0~6nsnauQtill$uim) IRLIL~FI

IonidGiausianissii~ q u o ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ r ~ d i ~ ~ i 6 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I f i n s i u i i d 1 * 6 p P ~ u w v o d ~ 7 5 ~ ' ~ ~ u ~ *

LH 61 {u$i3 LI ~ w n : d i i C o ~ u r ~ F i i u " ~ o i a ~ ~ u m ~ ~ ~ i i < y ~ f l i l $ ~ a u ~ n ~ ~ u i e r m s

fiqy? (Substantive law) nrJiu~~wn~~~1uC(l%"d~z6w^aniw u~nnmwnis$wafid<u A DQ oisrii~RnnaiuKuau ~ ~ a r ~ ~ n n ~ i u ! u i ~ u ~ ~ u n i s d ~ ~ m a i a n i a u o ~ ~ 4 i ~ J i w d u o ~ ~ ' ~ ~

, 1.2 i115GyG8'~11~ngosm1u~ona~ msuiyyTni~ng~uiu~anau ~ " a o ~ i f i ~ i u o d n g ~ u i u ~ o n

t: vPI w

awuu~nurawimg~uiubbvid~muw~~iniad~bd~duib~u~a~iuiu~r~a nisQfli Corpus d r r: Y t :

Juris Civilis ~ ~ ~ o L d ~ d 5 : 1 1 2 ~ n g ~ ~ i ~ b b ~ d ~ f i ~ b b 3 n 9 1 ~ d b ~ ~ ~ n l 3 & ~ i ~ ~ ~ J b i d ~ ~ ~

ITCU luianu'tluod<nsws3A<~Gbfiuu ~ s r u ~ ~ n g ~ u i u ~ ~ n ~ ~ a f l ~ i i j n i s ~ n w i anis u d ' a

i w i n ~ o i s d ~ u r ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ n % " o e i i d d ~ b ~ o d u i b ~ ~ b ~ ~ i u i u ~ ~ w u d odri~~$ng~uiurbvi~ dd.d f j ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ d i d ~ i n ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ i ~ ' b . a " b ~ ~ b b ~ ~ ~ ' b ~ n i ~ ~ ~ f l i d ~ tuaang~u iuwuao~~u~

n i ~ o ' n l l i d s : u ~ ~ n ~ ~ u i u d o ~ m i a ~ ~ .8n 4 ~ d n ~ ~ ~ : n i ~ < m f i d . r : u ~ n n g ~ u i u ~ ~ ~ ~ t u o ~ ~ u (EJ n.n. 1900) U 1 ~ ~ o i i ~ f l u n ? i u ~ u ~ s d u a ~ m n i a ~ ~ n i u m f b u n i a n ~ ~ u i u ~ ~ w a .

&616n;,hquilwunriou~~~a~ji i w u ~ d n ~ ~ u i u ~ o n a w ~?ong~uiui~dal6iu u dd ni.ranw dm~uounitodian-iia~~id1uu~i^3nui~~unu~o~~uaoaqbd~u nganiu

u ~ i a u ~ o ~ n $ u l ~ i i n i ~ u ~ l 0 ~ n ~ l ~ ~ i ~ : : d ~ i l u n ~ ~ u i u b m u n 3 ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ u ~ l q o ~ ~ ~ j a o d c r v

d.r~n1.r;~ daznlausn n g ~ u i u u ~ i a u ~ f l u n g ~ u i ufldi6mdi uio?; ~~s:$dnnsoc .(a~flu

d c, & o ~ h n n u n o : n n w l u ~ n n ~ ~ i a d ~ ~ o ~ ~ ~ o a J dszn,mno~ ~ ~ u n ~ i u ~ i i ~ n " s s d ~ l n u n n o ~ i i d ~ a n i ~ $ ~ a n i l n n ~ ~ a u " ~ ~ d ~ . d .

&oangcruiu ad~ildadtuoanidnnsoa da i in i r r i i unon~u~u~~$n~~~~v i iu "w~

&u"u w i u l u i n i m o ~ m ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ i ~ u ~ i a d a u i n n ? i u s i o ~ d ~ a lnuiawitdaa m u bd C Y qnnaia ( Mlddle ages ) ~u~nR'n~ui~nunnmradiui~~uni3dn~f oauu~uo~n"9~9~ffmi

~di$dnn.rotduun-iw 1~nkndia~n1umna1~~niang~~i~ut r ( iau~~~iuv i iu1"run i i

~ ~ u q n d n g ~ u i u ~ o n a w n ~ ~ u ~ i n a ~ ~ i u u ~ i a ~

ounstka u i f i ~ ~ n t r ( ~ j n i s ~ f i ~ Z ~ ~ c l ' + a ~ n u ( n.n.1789 ) E n t ~ n m w Y O J I J ~ ~ ~ I

a u ~ a ~ f i n i ~ k i n ~ i ~ h 6 ~ u " u u 1 0 t l i d u ~ n a~:~$nlu&oaiii?; M?~?~ddnn30dbW v$nnismung~wu n'~ilduauiho13odsr~n~1kqId 6aZu n g ~ ~ u i o u ~ i ~ d a d diaqi hniyo~dni~d3::muwnd~tbu'11M'~oa~onau n'u d.rduahmsmt ~awiuuiodia

C d ' a d sqnh nau n~wonn~unsoa~m'rt~iniwu~~d~::aiau~u~a~

LW 'ldi

(1) na~mu7e 66 Ilnbv~d17m3rur ~ J u i m ~ d n n ~ d (but mio t ~ n a ~ ~ t e ) a o ~

n 7 3 ~ 7 6 ~ ~ n 7 3 B ~ d ~ w d ~ ~ D ~ I ~ 0 ~ ~ 3 7 ~ l & ~ d n ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ p b s d a p b ! ~ ~ daui7u7vuw7aob d h a

(puissance pubI1que) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d 7 6 ~ ~ n 7 ~ ! ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ d 7 ~ d 7 ~ 6 ~ ~ ~ ~ Q 6 Q n ~ p b 6 w d ~ d 7 6 ~ 0 d n 7 3 ! ~

d 7 ~ b ~ W d 1 7 E 7 7 ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 3 ~ ~ 6 3 d 7 6 ~ ~ 7 ~ 1 6 ~ 7 ~ ~ 1 3 ~ ~ "

, nis1Kn~iu~uiuuot ilnbe~d1707rmz~ luni~n~nuiufuiroiorii1K~u'i2~1 d Y l6flin u d f i i u n & o d b l t o d ~ u d u u u i ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ odidb~iiio:~~uniw ~bn:bu'ilo~&ditl#u oifi

bdu ,n~si lo~&drmn ~ u n ~ s ~ o d ~ ~ ~ ( ~ ~ $ o : $ o d d ~ o f i u ~ a i u d ~ : n i f fin d a n i q ~ ~ m h h n ~ ~ o ~ n ' n s P~d~ci2u~iuYuknaou sioadynainsdd6~~iuri not%&vns &'addif

hlu'unls do n'od~diuiocnm~nni~ 11s:nimgKunisin &oi?a 6o~dinqdzzrr~n'

fio ~ l a t n ' w n ~ i u ~ u n ~ u o ~ d ~ = : b n ~ ~ ~ K ~ n ~ n t i u ~~a:dn'~nssu An nilat flodi ~Punir

k f u ~ ~ ~ o u o d n g ~ u i u u ~ i a u d d o ~ ~ %nd7rnd (but H ~ Q nna11t6) U O U ~ V ~ T ~ U

~ ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ M ~ ~ L ~ Q ~ D u I P ~ D ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ & D ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ D ~ R ~ ~ ~ $ ~ H ! w d~di~oiniionnuua~~onau

(Odent) 3oddrmwRJlllb~d?y n h 2 i i

'flincl~lai.r&v~dbliuni~ ~n'anarutdolhin~rRudu ( $ h i ~ i ~ i r o ~ ) ~duno'n" (activite de plus grand service) 3

LW 101 365

(2) $ ~ ~ ~ ~ v Q J ~ T z ~ ~ ~ ~ E ~ T ~ , Y I ~ ~ ~ ) D ~ J ~ u B J ) D ~ s w

~ ~ Z ~ D T ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ N ~ ~ M ~ ~ M U I L I U M I ' I I M ~ ~ ~ ~ W N : : &d drzbdn7a7rms Fio ni~nounuo~n~iu&a'o~nimo~nududau~)~$d\dld$

11 ~~lwninfu q lo4 rinilu~'nwnrkfi~io: LAMIG~I dsdsacitnmsm:li 2 PR drzn~nrm s38ol7~dmSnu7 " ' - ~ T ~ I N : L L A ~ J ~ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ & Q J ~ ~ T

PI

(besoln) ~ Q J A W ~~dnaiu6a~ni1u~~nu q L @ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' H ? H ~ w M ) ? C ~ ~ \ ~ ~ M I J L O M ~ T : : I L I ~ ~ Y d d mm3nrrldU u o i ~ ~ r r ~ ~ u . ' o J n ~ r a o ~ a ~ ~ r o i ~ ) z n ~ I u ~ n u m ~ ~ n ' w ~ n ~ ~ r ~ o u 9 rfic~~~ntno:

f l l ~ ~ ? l ~ d i o d n l 3 r l ? ~ ~ ? ~ ~ d L ~ d ~ : ~ ~ n ~ l t l l ~ ~ ~ 3 l ~ 6 ~ d n l 3 d 3 ~ 3 3 ~ u " ~ \ 6 ~ ' I ~ L M ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ I ~

iJo~nird3e~n~n"l ni.rdnwliil ~ l ? u ~ ~ l u n ~ i u ~ ~ ~ n i ~ ~ s a ~ n n n ~ n 3 ~ < u ~ ~ u ~ u I ~ ~31;~ I

" X sn.rmuuu~~lun~iu6o~ni~i~~~~un"~~snii~~d~:lsadmm~nrz~~ ~unidnsdni$iu 61nw~~~in:nu~d~flunuH~uin~~"uiiddw"u\dd-~~~u k~fui i ' ld~d

d~dondmm.mrr ~ ~ s ~ w ~ d d ~ d u n d m m 3 m t (inter& public) btdiroindx~rrarlrhu

qnnn (inter6t prive) M$~d3:lsahotndu (int6ret collectii) ni.rfloi3miii o:\6on?lu

&~ni.ruo~nun ~u~nk~ilurdrod #8i"S$u88 (Subjective) udmui~ofliWUu"n~ayr'~ur16 Z d Y lnofioji ~Y'gq~ng~uiu~$o?;rrai ~ ~ n z f l i n d n n ~ o d ~ ~ i u u n o : : n ~ ~ n ~ ~ u " u ~ n ~ r ~ s i ~ k

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ? I ~ & ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M T ? u M " ~ ~ L o M ~ T ~ T ~ ~ ' I I ~ ~ ~ ~ N : M ~ ~ \ ~ Dma:IA+udoW t: d d r s n 7 r h l o r 7 6 n ~ ~ & ~ n n a ~ i n ? , e r ~ o ~ n ~ ~ n'i.i$fli&uu~vvomounwo~

na7uto~n7rtro~igtoJ ~ 4 u ~ i o ~ i n r i l 8 ~miunfion~~uuo~?~~s::~nndii .fion.rru~Aa

f i i \ ~ ~ ~ ' u i n d -ipt8 (activites de plus grand ddlnudn~~~th \ J6oi1 flunaiu

6a io~nimo~nud?u~ 4jlrlfio~Oufini.rmm1nr~ ~iuudo:~ilunimirl~~\~ui~~ofli

u~ni.rmmsnr:~4onou m o ~ f i 3 i u ~ o ~ n i ~ ueirilijp+~ ~ i i u n i ~ ~ i ~ ~ u " u ~ A o m o u n ~ ~ a n a ~ u . ' o ~ n ~ r a o ~ n ~ d ~ ( d ~ u I m ~ (d\dld~'~visoari~o~iuuo~?;~o~) ~3iisonno

I

service) ddu~nt~~u~n~d~t~d6bdod~~buvdmm~ar .a"mbo~u1n

(3) %ni?ll?n7 wnroddaz2f72fpd (droit des Individus)

n. naiu~uiuuodRw3 uazifiniw

TI. n i n ' u r o ~ ~ n 5 ~ ~ ~ n ~ w k i u u ~ I J " y y ~ ~ o ~ T " ~ n . r . r u ~ y 1 .I

n. r .r~uHu&mdna' nrnnln,w

i n 5 (droit) v u i ( l ~ d ~ ~ h r i l P d d ~ n ~ ~ u 7 ~ a " ~ 1 ~ 0 ~ r r a ~ ~ u ~ a 0 ~ ! ~ - .n

mi%nw (libertb) ~aJ?yq,j rmufinszdwnnari ln lr p?odrr?unsri-tn?s

Tjps~uyyotflq wui~llsmi~uocynnal?"Iui"~naau~ybmu

oiafi~uam~duafiubdaodu"bmu s r s u y g ~ ~ d ~ n n o i ~ i Q n ~ l w u~IJ"u0o~flu ua d

(2540) ZGIJ"yyn~.ro ~ ' n 5 ua iahul?"Iu nuamd 3 uimn 26 - uinn .ad IJ"ud~~uuIJ"yqn1.ro~~n5~~n~wla"uinni i~

n n u y y ~ o ~ h n a ~ u i u 7 ~ u d s r ? 7 i u o ~ n i 3 d i " ~ n . r ~ u y ~ ~ o ~ d a ~ ~ ~ ~ [ ~ n u . ."LO

baukaldrrh i "~~~~u~~arby~3rauf iun"~Rn%~~at~~4n iw nunCJdo~h5 ,d-gT: [ > I <

uylruvu afltfinkabfiod ~aduuniabunoonoinn"u n"J6bwnr Rn5werfio~$~l6~~ri~a4

n i w n i ~ n i ~ ~ f i o ~ (bdu nin~on8dj ~au~ll1~;odi~~i;Pio~~o~n5uywuvu1$T"uni~

~ idsm'u ~duduan'u 'mli3niwk7 7 hJ ~nii lunaiu~un~daonn"u~a~~^am i i ~ n i u

du& ori1a~~~niui"~sr.ru~~91o~1~dati"~~~ioIJ"~q~i"u.ro~~n5~~~niw'ba"lu~t~3~~ d:d' dY bbancii~nir ndu u u o ~ f i u w ' ~ u i n i ~ o ~ u u a n a i u 6 n ~ o a ~ o ~ ~ n ~ b ~ " ~ n i w u ~ ~ ~ c i ~ : k n u

rilwhcy

1 anamno7sd ns.myn uaaq& \&~~~3~6~kdJnlflM'Hn'ndf ::n'u~"ros"u~a~bnb tdniwl? 3 d r r~nn 4o

n. n7srureaanb^66aaia?n7w!.I"ou'?a66n~~a (libertii absolute) %I n i 3 l d ~ mJl$hQn .ad- np~u iub in 'mbnb~~in i~~au ~ d u u n u i y y n n . r u s o ~ i i ~ ~ ~ " ~ n 1 ~ ~ 6 0 ~ n ' u ~ i ~ ~ i u o ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ u

tylnsqnacu v?~d i g a r ~ u r ? ~ f i i a u m u i ~ i i u ~ i i n i ~ ~ $ ~ d n i w k n d i ~ ~ o ~ "bit flu I I ~ ~ ~ ~ G ~ ~ M J I ~ ~ Q J ~ R L ~ ~ J ~ ~ o ~ r i r f i u n i ~ ~ m i o n ~ i u ~ ~ u f i u u ~ o u kofiannuoitii uo~d.r:.aiopu

TI. Fus~aanE u~zra?n~wf.I"au'7~i5un~7a 6o ni.ruaulM'dni3Kmbnb L L ~ Z L H ~ ~ I W

n i u 6 i ~ a n u c ? y l ~ ~ ~ u i ~ d ~ : n i ~ ~nuni . roanng~uiu~a~i :ui ~ h r c n n ~!?o~awi:ui~

n ~ f i ~ " r u ~ ~ i J o r $ l u ~ d u ~ t f i i~ud1%i l6 ' % ~ u o i < u i i u i ~ ~

miuunuiyry?d~ng~uiu~awi: kdod~:~uruknis~o~~mn'sdu%m~~f~:~udui~~u

nisgnthu ~ ~ o ~ m s o i & b i u i a m i u u n Y ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ v i ~ n ~ ~ u i u d ~ ~ $ n 3 r $ i ~ u ~ : ~ i i ~ ~ q a i 6 d 3 ~ L ~ f l ~ $ ~ n i ? ~ n l 5 H J ~ visoni3.r~ I ~ ~ O ~ S ~ M ~ I J L ~ R I ~ ~ ~ T ~ ~ I R R ~ I ~ ~ I ~ & ~ ~ L ~ ~

~!?od3:niRlhpiYunidn ( n i o r i i ~F ;mu~yav i~~ i . ao im i~n~ lnu W.R. 2492 UIRSI

32, W.R. 2517 ulfl3l 37, W.R. 2521 U I R 3 1 31)

fil6~kH"rnlW!~L~~~o 6 q 0 d l J ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l H " r ~ l W ~ ~ n l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n ' ~ ~ f l ~ H ~ l ~ ~ HHnlW STH

Kud ~ ~ n f &

n i s b i n ' m ~ ~ n i l m j n d i ~ ~ : ~ i l ~ m u o i < u i i u ~ ~ ~ i u u n ~ y y A ~ ~ v i ~ n ~ ~ ~ i u do ~unso~dsrIu.aM'pi~u3quuo~d.rt.ai.a~ ~dninwin~iurr~ut~uuios visoianssuoitiiuor d3tm.a~ v i s a ~ d o l l o ~ n i r ~ ~ i n i ~ ~ n u i ~ ~ m m o u ' b u n i ~ ~ g

' u?~kn<nfininn~nuiaonru triu 3. u'iinr~u, ndi 357

'Intiu nnpn un: airy%" 'u~fl?.r#n( nfinnanuiuu~lau ~n'u 1, u'~nr~u. n.k 2540. ndi 34- 42

G d rl njzu rnna :nhdn t i~~d l t$? n7s~na7i?~~u7~io1rn'~aodd7~7wnrnan ,

d ~r&mh&ludrz117a~bd6n7m&7~7~ 1m;d7~7oR'oJldlk~i~m~d~u7~6dooz~r aadi nou fido ~ d o d f t h n h o ~ ~~fluv"To;unu ua:nnl~ddiu~a~~lrfld~dodf:~~nM'~$~u"

%:&~fli~zIf" ("What is to be done?" Y ~ D "Que faire?" $1 1'a~uoua~6nird8% o ~ 6 nimd~Ifi~~riurim ufl:rnadi1fldfem61~a~~tl~nu'u~~ r*o nifda??iuoc Lnuia 01.1

ad d ~ n o h u)i~?sii vfn nscuoc roarmrd ud~na a t l i ~ $ ~ n i l n n . r o ~ ~ ~ ~ f i n i ~ d ~ j d a d i ~ u u i d v ~ a v ~ i ~ Y n.w.1970 - 1873 M ? ~ ~ S & ~ ~ J U ~ L I W A rmornn LLAJC~~JLRAIWE~ A.61.1958 d~~~~n"2~~~mfu~6~1~~n"4vun~dod~'~d~~1~'1~~i~uoddiuiammfmz "\

~ v i ~ ~ : m n 1 n o i i I ~ i ~ ~ r i n i ~ ~ ~ 1 0 u r i i ~ ~ ~ n ~ f ~ n ~ 1 f o ~ ~ i a ~ W.R. 2475 ~ i ~ u ~ u adidlffiniu hu1hlditT3 i?ud~:m~daniu'udi~ 7 di~Chddo d i d

dnR rdnnmr~dnnsa~n~lb:~val~u' iui~di~i~ ~ n w m : u o ~ n ~ s d n Q w n i ~ d n ~ f o ~ n " ~ : : dnnglfi~fiulG-Zn d~ri~ilunrfini~~dd6~7'~uia~o~df:~n~1di~ 7 dt0uldudiodnRlu r?niud

h u ~ w n ~ n i o ~ & d a ~ uZ+7arsouarrudqm ~ i o l i f " u n a 7 u ~ ~ u o u d ~ m G 4 I W rl n n ~ ~ u w u n w z r d ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ u n U H ~ = ~ j ~ ~ n ~ r n r ~ u J ~ ~ ~ ~ & ~ ~ ~ m ~ u n ~ ~ u ~ o (Competence)

lrifi{dnnro~lnd!dfiA3iu~~~uitldi):~1f o u ~ i ~ " r o ~ r i ~ o ~ n i ~ ~ n n ~ f aolnlt$di?h v"Tak~iudiuiouo~nuei3tlfii~~ v"Tondi?8n~uvd~ b.@$nn.ro~lnd

1.2 ~ n ~ m o r r a w 7 r a ~ ~ d ~ u 7 w ? j aa 2

f1i7pr7w?jn d ' n n o ~ ~ d i n h n i i 11S7pr7wa7a~mrn M ~ F 11d7pr70rrmapr-

(puissance publique) ~ ~ I u d ~ z ~ ~ d ~ : ~ i ~ d ~ f l u ~ ~ ~ u r n ~ ? ' ~ b a n Lj~nnWm:~~vhzdi~ q & r: -0

Q 6dprd7%7~66ddn~%8aprfipr66$~~~niftarrq%dna7~ , rd~ot%?on7dn7rr&d , ri?prhtim

n?d~as%~pr 16as6dprd7pr7~~17~~7m7$na

' u i n n 2 ~ ~ J T " ~ F T T ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ S ~ ~ Y ' ~ Y Q J G ~ P J L B I I (n.w. 1958) uiy$ii md~z~n~cl~'~~m~ilumm~m ~ ~ ~ L L L ~ J L L U ~ B I ~ ' ~ i lummrmJ'~ni~oimi<n~ - s ( M ~ I ~ $ J ~ ~ ~ ~ I J B I ~ ~ $ ~ J ) ~~ummrm; r J r z s i M m u ~ ~ z k n u m m ~ m ? ~ X i d ~ ~ ~ ~ n a i ~ ~ L ~ ~ o n i n n i ~ n ~ I r ( u i u ~ a ~ ~ ~ J z s i u n n u bu I r i

LW 101 373

1 d (centrsliaation) un:dnisdnn~a~~un'nwmtn~~siunif~au~uu"diuio vrounisuJo

w ' n ~ ~ h d bilwih&~u'wh6q! $il$dk tddnaiu tilubn~~d~b~nra~~ugiu::n"~nii,onii

~ ~ < d n d l a l d l ~ ~ ? ~ ~ R c l 3 3 1 3 6 17 u d c hu3~nLdu?~rautun"bilub$ub~uan'u ~ru*iq~ui~ndio 7 otd

naiu~ i lw~w~~~oonwIu . r t<~~v i l~ L L ~ t oliuiufi t ~ ~ n i n a u ~ u & i u i ~ I ~ 6 ~ a w n a i ~ u ~ n

wu1%6; (confederation) Gldin~oo unsho q d~ilw~m:: fiwni Diete wmbluabilu

Jsuiu~aswzfia New Deal oonui ~ n s d u ~ i n i n l ~ m ~ n ' w ~ ~ l d b81sw;fi~u~~ai~a:~il~

~d~kr i?u i~~non is~ i~ f lun isuodd?~nf l i~ lfldun'~rYpiwnudi~vSi lnsdnis New

Deal ( f i ~ a ~ ~ ~ n n i s w ' s r u i d i u i a ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ j i ~ n ? ' i ~ u ~ i ~ ~ ~ o ~d?pbnai~'b\ab?nioi oui 1-150

n i s s l w s ~ M o ~ i s ~ I - I ~ s n f i ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g ~ o t ~ ~ ~ s i l 5 ~ < ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ F i ~ ~ u ~ o ~ ~ s m u i % u ~ oadu ~ o r l ~nwtwR un:Swnow ii oofiwriw Iu~a~ireio q uirilun'u

wonaind u u ~ w n i s s ~ u a w f i i ~ w i a u ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ o i ~ u o ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ o u 9

u dd Iuds:~nal~ndmu d ~ ~ ? u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a e ~ ~ w ~ ~ ~ ~ n ? i u ~ ~ i ~ ~ u ~ s s l b " k ? ~ n i s w ~ i u i u s ? u

~wJ,nrua'n~nwlw:nis~~Li~~B~au~wi~i~ q lw?'nwlriRnrioaac *:.@kJrr[ ,

. ( 3

1.2.2 hu7auo~~t~ud;u7wn7an7osd~a

u ~ n w 7 n d ~ u 7 w n ~ a s ~ ~ ~ n ^ w ~ ~ o ~ ? ~ ~ n ~ ( ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~ d l ~ l ~ ~ ~ n l ~ I

n?u?unisw~n~~flznisnfraiun?w uins) !uuda~~h3d~~~on~an7~s~oada!b~~m~usHd~a u u 2 a

u7o7nn7o nauqubn7ussroagL hoioo^rmiu~nntu no

do~n-rosson s~ud~~.rwssdan7otihspd (pouvoir d'srbitrsge) ni l?

t o nis:I-Iriiduo~?;t~ib'~'?'~n"~~b~un?uin'"u~~%bb63:%,~?iu~u.a'i]w n-aiulii?I-IJilw

&nuriiwFiie q Jiilri~finn?iun'o~nisl~al q ua:!udozinmlrikuumrL.n Gw~oflrr

p~w;[$miu~o;s~nhs~un70 d~w~na%ndi?l?ii di~an i~n is r io~uo~?;b i r~b f lu~

n i s ~ i u d u o ~ d i w i ~ n i ~ b a f w ; ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 a 0 ~ ~ n sau$wnsqufi ~ I I A I ~ & ~ $ ~ ~ I ~ J Q ! ~ M

~inwlw:drriidu5nib'n ~wnc?;aiar~nniouh~non~ubasw~fiadnso~~inis~do ~ ~ d w k

~iaso~voen~unnnitni~~asw;~odw 7 ~dw ~ ~ n i a u s e ~ i u I - I ~ o n ~ u ~ ~ s w ~ f i a d s I s i o ~ ~ u

nw:~souhni~nirtdo~ fio:6~nio~doao~n'un~~~~asw;~ad~udiwian1~nis~do~ k Y

u u CI d h ofin 7 igOrpn w ~ n ~ ~ ~ f l u ~ ? n f l i ~ ~ ! o ~ n n ~ ~ f l f l o n ~ a a i A~Fu?~dasn~lranu d 3.u m~wn~m[o;umnd~an'uiw~~~wi~!~n~o~a'm u ~ ~ n i s ~ n ~ d w 7 ~i luuo~hw

t: nu~!nuoo?; ~dnsouh~~dw?nauauns~~uf i ~~dtUii-an~nnlw~~nn ~ d u C~I-IJI

nd?owi?n $immis Y R Y w ~ ~ L v B I ~ ~ ; ~ I H u ~ ~ L R M ~ I ~ ~ J ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : c ~ ? I B J G ~ ~ 6 ~ n ' q l w

nicuswjfia ~ d n ' n ~ u i i a d i 1 - 1 ! o ~ d ~ o ? ~ 6 ~ n i ~ ~ 3 i u ~ i l ~ ~ ~ ~ n " ~ k ~ ~ r i w s s n ~ o u ~ 3 f l ~ 6 l u

dsebn81gln~fli~?sd~niswi?n ~ilw~nwru:dlionii "~uto~&tion" I-I!Q nisuf1-11 J~-J~?LIRU

LQJ ;€I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U ~ I - I I ~ ~ ~ J J I M M ! Q M ~ ? L ~ W ~ ~ ~ Q ~ ~ I ~ ~ Q S ~ ~ ~ ~ U Y Q J ? $ O J ~ ~ I ~

K n l w d i ~ f u n i ~ n i u ~ a ~ ~ ~ o u o ~ f ~ l f ~ i s d ~ ~ ? ~ i u r ~ o n a i n n ~ ~ u n ~ l u ~ d ~ ~ n i ~ i 7

n i s ~ ~ d i w i a k ' r w b d u ~ o ~ ? ~ ~ o n i ~ ~ . a " d i ~ i a n i ~ n i ~

vd d ~ ~ u h d u t n~dfil~d3tbnfl~tiuflnf9bgtb~nbvafi~ bb~t~ai~dw'6~Bu'h U a didsfiniu

n a ~ n ' w l u d . r ~ ~ n ~ n ~ i u n n ~ ~ f i o t l ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ n i ~ ~ B a ~ l n ~ m ~ ~ utifi~iluniunnnitni~nis

~ i i o ~ d ~ l i Y ~ l 6 Ldu l u ~ ~ i z o ~ u 5 n ~ b ~ ~ i u g n m ~ n ~ ~ u w f i n o ~ ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ ~ ~ d Z n % w a o d i ~

g ~ i ~ i l i ~ u i ~ i ~ l u n i s r l i ~ u n ~ ~ u l u ~ ~ n ~ l o ~ n i t d r r ~ n ~ ~ ~ a ~ u l ~ u i s T i i ~ d ~ t ~ n ~ d'd d.rtaiui%u8~onuai?f ~6dstuiumiwtduu buabuiaonoindiu~rir uat'bugo?cujw~

r ~ ~ a u i i ~ n 9 w a n ~ u ~ n ~ i ~ n ~ ~ u w ~ n 0 ~ ~ ~ ' b u ~ ~ i ~ a ~ u 5 n i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u " u t$kpiinim~i3

~ b ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ ~ ? ~ l 3 d ~ l R ~ 3 3 ~ ~ t ~ l ~ ~ M l 3 ~ ~ 9 ~ ~ b b ~ t w " ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ l ~ 9 ~ t b ~ ~ 3 0 9 ~ ~ b ~ ~ fll'bc iinin~u~udxuimnimni~~1atb~uni~6~m?"ioi~a'b~d q hni~ri~aiuRSil~~uywuvit

uintcu"u KuCulCiii~~uo'wnnsiol~nnaroiod~~vi^anJlnuua~o~u5niro~

osdnaziosfq

I. osbm~sdnfiaos Icil~ri 55 nis?qsz~d s u u i ~ i s n i uIu?; 2. osbmun~srflos lfl~cri 5jjani ua:ntu:f'ywni 3. o s b m u m ~ R l n ( R I R ? ~ S U % ~ f l i ~ d f l ~ 1 o 4 , ~ i n ~ R n ~ s u . R1n

1. ~udnrniudn~.rau (Administrative Organization)

u a ~ d n m 7 ~ d n n s a ~ w t o n7~nad6nmsdd7udnnf~drau~

odhmrnu3~uuud8~rr'wdn'w ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ n ~ d @ Z J d 6 6 ~ ~ ~ Z 6 H B J 7 Z ~ B J n ' ~ n 7 ~ f i ~ 6 6 6 ~ n d 7 d n ' ~

unrvi7~l(7l~w~7wl6nw ~ $ g ~ ~ 1don7s~n~nwrlnrudd-dwnu H% q ' u n s o u d s ~ ~ u a h o ~ 6 0 naw u Y 2 '4 ni.rqm o ~ ~ n . r ~ f l ~ i ~ i u r r n u ? ~ oiodirrunlm mJu no 51ani.rdaunaiJ n a n i . r d w q b n i n

n a n i . r h u r i n t f h i d a u ~ i u B m : nmen.r.rani.r r d i i ~ i i l d ~ ~ ~ ? ~ ?fimiAo L L R L L O ~ ~ U ~

f i u o u i u i u ( 1 ) n a n ~ s d a w n a 7 ~ l6rt.n h$nuiun?~uumf n.r:ns?J

d d nu?J n.ru did q .r?ufi~hu~i~i.rdfiun6o0di~ou~1rflu~d?u~iu'imt~d~~n'm

n.r:nne n u % n.rulm ~ r a : i i ~ i u ~ ~ f i u u ~ ~ i n . r u L ~ u ~ I ~ ~ w ~ : ~ T I ? J hCn inna ra~ ibn i s naY'm4mumiu h$n~ iuns?o f iuudwlu h ~ ~ J i ~ ~ ~ Y i ' r m i ~ ~ l ~ ~ b ~ ~ 3 i ~ . ~ ~ h C n J I ~ L ~ ? I I ' ~ ~ I . ~ ? ~ R ~ I h C n ~ i w o ' t l n i r g ~ h r i n ~ i u d i n a n v i ~ a i ~ t q u h

(2) nan1sd-dwgfln7n ~nu~niwo:rUunisrr~~diui~11o J

n a n i . r i t ~ u n a i t d o d m r i i o ~ i s ~ f l n i s u d ~ h u n a n i ~ o o n ~ f l u G n Q hrno L L R : ~

d l ~ n o diUa i d l j i u (3) n a n d a w n ' o i h ~i?uni.ro'n ~ r l i ~ d m n a n i . r l m u

iR'nni~n.r:aiudi%ia r ~ ' u I u ~ o ~ u o ~ n i . r ~ n n ~ o ~ m u ~ o ~ i l n n . r o ~ s o ~ i ; u u o ~ n u ~ d o ~ r i ni . r~~ui~~u~dm.r~n 'unaiu6o~ni . r~ ocd.rtaiau d ~ i ~ n n i m . r : o i u d i u i o d p ~ u n i i Self

Government M ~ D Local Government ~ f l ~ i R ' n n i ~ d n n > ~ J ~ i a ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ d 3 ~ . a 7 ' f d ~ ~ u m t n i 3 ~ ? i i ~ k u h ~ 6 u I u i l o g ~ u ii 5 p t u u u tio 1. €I J ~ " ~ I ~ ~ ~ M I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J M ? ' ~ (0.U.a)

~ ~ o ' b ~ ~ i l u o s n ' n s d ~ i i i ~ i ~ ~ ~ b ~ i ~ ~ s ~ n ~ u n i n i ~ ~ i ~ s ~ ~ n ~ ' b u s : ' ~ u d s z n i ~ d ~ ~ u PI q ~ J J E L L . ~

rii~sino~dnnldu 7 dD16Cn~s#u~nuf l~n~s~uiu~$~u"u ~dwuiliniiih Liluordnsv'or

~onaud~onaui?u~u~Cn~sY"ubnuf i~n~s~uiu ~~ou~?s~ i r i i ~su ibb~ is~un"u ~ ? o " o, dw w 8.4'

d?usianisu fi~iluo~dn'moss;ns;snntvuTnu~~usuds:uimuns~wu~u Tiudgn;s ~aiuL6na'nriiuinisflinismz (Service public) I$<ud3:~1au

~ n ~ i u ~~osn'nmii~iios~' f u n i s ~ ~ o n b ~iluidnisdii

otn'ns~isnisiosfih6~ 1A1ri i;rcni aa:mru:iy~un5

(n) igani

dc~n~~not~wds:m~ddnmsos'b~s:uu?;~ni Ins$

2 nni W D ~ni$~nusiwgs u a r ~ P ~ n i

. "

4 I .

7 ' - 1

' ou.r o'wnlnuy.rd, nawn~t?$u1iun8nd(~onst~tutionallsm) nisoanua~d~wnalns, noiriuufuuiuanm, w.a. 2537 ndi 40

380 LW 101

d. f I d

w ~ n n ~ ~ s B ~ ~ ~ ~ o s n ~ ~ d n ~ ~ o ~ ~ t ' u ~ u d ~ c ~ ~ 8 d 1 u rruu Q ~ n l h m n v q o u u s r d a s ( s d ? ~ 3 ~ $ ~ ~ ~ ~ & ~ 1 n ' ~ (Checks and Balancer) nmiwhuu3nnr

LU~ufiAfigqXi d ~ n ~ l n n i n l i v l w v o s d i u i ~ ^ s ~ 7 ~ l 6 ~ ~ r i ~:uunanis&s:uu luseuu%$mi ~ I ~ ~ ~ J ~ R ~ I ~ I Q T : M ~ I J ~ I ~ Y ~ M I I ~ " ~

diufiluiyq3 ~ 6 4 6 0 1

I. % R ~ I imb~~u~ondnlilil5q7~I~gJd1tlnTz uwnt uamru:i2uwn3t%mu:

2. uitlnf~uwn5 ( ( i l iuuf~i~) Zifmtqu ~ n i Q ~ n w nag' (huffl17qq3) ~ ~ o ~ $ i n i s f i o n & ~ ~ J

(a) mmsguuni L O ~ Q J ~ ~ ~ Q J ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ U ' Q J ~ Y n i ~

~^3~1ss?nni~~d~Gw < q u ' o # L ? ( h 6 J < U n ~ : r ' ~ ~ ~ f l " r &lRltl$'2u'o bdun77

& ndnwijuuni d ~ : h ~ o n r j i d u a ~ ~ u n ~ ~ Y w & nqiuiuknaou

Y o~nru:iguwni n~iuhqnua~nfi:Tguu~F d~nufln~unsiid 7 rin~nwirnui~n 1 ~nwdoldlwfining~u1 uizmsugq ~ T o l u 5 a i n ~ ~ u i u ~ : ~ d u ~ ~ ^ r ~ ~ s n ~ n i s ~ ~ E i u l u l u d & ~ ~ n ~ ~ d ~ a w i z r n a h 6 ~ u i ~ d ~ ~n13~diu"w

~ ~ l l s ~ u ~ d ~ n a o i ~ i ~ n s l n t l a ~ u ~ ~ ~ ~ ' ~ (w.R.

2540) U l R n 201 Uib(~??il?dl & d h s d u c i ~ n ~ u ~ u n i g l l ~ n " r f l u ~ w ~ bbR:

ad d u d ~ ~uun3ouon~ibfiwrnu~u~iflu2]~2:nou~ilufi~=:r'f UM& ~ M u I ~ ~ J ~ M I ~ ~ ~ I ~ L L ~ M ~ M

u 1 o n ~ ~ u u ~ 5 ~ ~ ~ u d ~ ~ ~ ~ i n ~ u i Q n ~ n i ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ i w . ~ ~

~ S o $ n u t ~ u n u ~ ~ n ~ n i ( ~ ~ n ~ ~ i w ~ s usifiuqinnuienniw niuuinn i 1s (7)"' I w o i y uo~~n7$~~nunwgqnt6u3fiw

u~unalo~niruci~ buiunfIuwn"r,l

3. u i u n ? ~ u ~ n S ~ o ~ i id~$~oin~u13nnni$unu

nags ~ f o i ~ n u ~ f l u ~ u i l n ~ n i $ ~ ~ n u i~sirluain~ui3nniw~iu uisln 1 18 (7)

4. d ~ t s i ~ ~ n i ~ ~ ~ n u ~ i o g s ~ ~ u ~ a ~ u i u ? u ~ u o ~ w s ~

usunn~otnisu~~k~uiun?~uun~ , ,

u~noin$ulu?~srru~q~1J"ufio~~'u fiGunuiyy3

S i u ~ u i ~ n m i {~~nununogs~ilu?suusliiinn'a u 1uqrmbnt&7~~~7~nan7~unum~fis &r 1, d" $1 *urn NUM no

1. ~ilunisuun$;nnauqu~onoin~nauqu nhado

ynnnnu~fis?l~nas~:li~iu:~ilu~nauqu ua:$;nnauqu~uum:fisan'u d~f imdn~dlf l

~ u i ~ n ~ n i ~ ~ ~ n u s i a ~ s l i ~ r i i d n a u ~ u ? ~ u i a n a i u ~ ~ u ~ ~ n n a u ~ u ~ w s i ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ 8 u ? ~

uun5 I

2. rl i l~nisrli~iulidst~nEniwuinb;t iia' wn3n Y d - rmi~~~nunapsrli~t6'idfii1J"qq3 ?jpian"rli~uinurnisds:~n~

3. ~~unisi~n'5y~inisli~~fltl~niwuo~?guia L L ~ :

n i ~ i n n i s ~ ~ u ~ d i u o ~ n ~ : ? ~ a u n " r ~wn:d~iuuis:uui~uia w~udm'o~~~~uw~snfau

~m&?~ui~u"uv~ i~~~mnisr ioso~ ~RnsruuI~an'i matnis~ilu@iuo~uiunifuun"r~~

Mllailzi d'

4. I:Y uuu~n~ai~nnCu"~~o~wrsnnis~do~ Llatnaiu t d ' d nnniuo~iunr~on$~ (n~u~uo~ainnaiu$nyo~Rulan (R.a.) doucjnwi5uwads:h.d

~ o t n ~ ~ r d ~ d o n n u u i usinaiu$n~a~?~uuni~u~ nw'un"uwads~Iun~f~a 7 l d u o ~

dsttnasii a:$% ~ J ~ ~ u ~ J d ~ d u ~ ~ I l i ~ ~ d ~ n n a n u L ~ u ~ ~ u o : f i n a i u $ n $4 2 ilrenirlw - u d t - ~q ~fU:dQu~M~lYl ynnnuu ~ : h o J L ~ ~ n d Q ~ ~ ~ d l J ~ d l ~ l l d ~ d ~ ~ u ~ u t d ~ ~ u ~ u i ~ n (R.

R.) M:o?suumi

u d.4 (3) i jauinuuCq$unn~mu~is~iw 611.4 l~n:aa

Awvo~~w dnuw ~~n:~nsd&!dun~Ginix donm:nnunisfloth~~n:d~iudsiunis p f n i ~ d ~ v i l (d.ll.n.) (U.291)

(4) isuuniijimt~4'ids:;u ~~fittmaeu'o~fiaof~

a~ounn~n?iu~nt~uludr~~:~unni ~~6!d!'RWtoonL'RuJ~Jn:l~~~

(5) 4 ~ ~ ~ ? 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ u ' l ~ ^ r ~ l ~ ~ l ~ n l ~ bldMfi~fi0~

Ilonr duu iuc ia ignn i~au~ddn7~n~a~n~7u~? '? i~~o (u.211)

(6) ~un i~ 'M immisuduRu ?p~un i P ~ i u f i n

rcudonni$tnwnwgslI.ba JI#II~J~M s?u$~6ot?u knaouf~un'uio Gani~uuIuuiu

h ? ~ d l I ~ ~ n t X ~ ? ~ u M ~ ~ ? (u.212)

(7) 6 1 ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ n l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ l l W t b 3 7 ~ ~ ~ (U.116)

A 2. ~ I ~ I Q M ~ I ~ Q ~ I ~ ~ ~ M ~ I L I ~ H

(I) d l u i 0 t ~ d ~ ~ ~ a3alfln~iu~AunouI~nifldJ t IJ(~IU~ILLMJJ~IJ q a30 n~ l 'nssun is~ i~ngau iod i~ q

(2) d i u i o l u n i s a y l r i s a l ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ M * ~ v a u nis

AitkuAonisdi J q uoad?unanis a~o?,~?mafio ~$unis$.3w nisdiariiuniwfiw

LrluQYl.4

(3) 61~10~uniflGo(i~1&1(1ui ~ d u nsfiuiunig

uunild~Auaoucun?iu~M*uuo~ n.w. ~unisfloismignmd ~fhfiu a% ns6hiuni3

u u ~ i ~~~~vauvi3o~ri~kuvoun'udi^?~06011a~nm:n~sunis~'u~o~n~~'o~~nu' LCIM~YM

3. d ~ u ~ o ~ ~ ~ d a i u d ~ n u ~ ~ u ~ ~ ^ s ~ i y ~ ~ ~ ~ ? "

(1) L :a~n~iu fuw'u$d i~dst~h~

(2) j l ~ w s t ~ a i i & $ i , fiws:nanqw~ni, +IJ

ws:sia~iaun, ii~nans:nsw

(3) XL~~~U~IIL~R:CQCJKU~I~~.~'L~~I.~~~~I.~~~UH~O sioo~6nmaJig

(4) n i s ~ ~ w s ~ n a n i u ~ n ~ a ~ s i a ^ o n ~ u i n ~ d (5) n~mows:nvniua~bduiuw nuYuld

(6) nis~do~$wfiu~nw~~~nsfifl~~~w

winni;uuni niuuinn 215,216 (niu, moan, u i n ~ m s u ~ , ~o~diFiwinwidi~n)

(2) mi $ ~ ~ ~ u i i u ~ W i l ~ ~ i ~ 2 ~ n i ~ u u i n s i 185 M%

JJIGITI 186

(3) 01 qml$~~n~~ lWa3&Tf l f l~ (4 9) U.215 (2)

(4) Gnis~n~ni@rnunups U.215 (2)

(5) F ~ ~ E ? ~ ~ . J ~ ~ ~ R I Q Q ~ ~ UlDlTl 215 (3)

(6) ~Enainnisd 8% (R6volution) fin?;ds:~i.~ (Coup dYEtat)

3. o~dnsn3dsrm c d norlnmr ~ u 1 3 u s o ~ n r n h i i ~ d i p !uh.;mddn~fw!u

mmud?ar,?d!flu &uiam, - !u f~uuu '~~ &&npu~~ur&c!uy' o J h s f l i R duo J tinsdii

nqiuffiiYqd!n rwnt~~ua~cinsdo~ho3I1in ilofiwinsiic 7 Iunpauiu~onau idolan

a u h ronau nn~~riiriryryin'wni~las.dJ'~s~unis~u'if ~ufliCGnssutv'qqi na i f i nSq~1

oe6'a~Cinisujn'u~iutv'tgtgi iin'o~lflaadns~ia~flu$n'atu u n Y i u 8.r &$u a ~ h s f l i ~ ~ ~ o a ~ t i n s d ~ ~ 1 u i a n n ~ u ' d u i n n ~ 1 ~ n d u ~

I ~ ~ n i u ~ ~ s n u y ~ r r v i ~ s i ~ o i m i ~ n s I n u a ~ u i l o g u i i l ~ i ~ ~ ~ i l ~ l u ~ u 7 a 8 $JLLO/ uinsi

233 - UISlTl 281 L ~ U RIRS~TU~Q flI~dnfll€IJ ~ ~ ~ O ~ n r k l M ~ n l 5 ~ 0 1 ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ 7 M?o

bGi win lun i~np~u i u u ~ i a u tUu&

Uls131233 C ~ q ' j l l

~ ' n i ~ f i P l ~ ~ f i ~ i T l ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ f l ~ ~ ~ J & J

@,, dir$unisniu$msutv niungwuicl rrrrrluws:dsuiiiln~ws:u~inwn~u

f l l R I ~ M ~ 3 6 l 8 ~~ IMU~IG~~UUOJA nsfiinsioill~if

(1) RIR~~JFTSU~Q

(2) flindnnso~

3.3 ~ ~ n i ~ ~ # 6 i ~ i l o ~ $ i ~ a ~ d ~ ~ i ~ ~ i d a ~ ~ ~ ~ n~ag58n~.inm~qunid#

di~ilo~~ddiudnnsas - w e ms:G/ 3 Y ~ ~ ~ ~ d F d ~ l ~ i ~ n p ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ lu~?~aqhnisldijiuiqv$i

6und?j$u i l a w i : ~ w ~ o ~ f i m ~ ' n 7 9 f # d 7 ~ 7 ~ ~ ~ ~ 6 ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ u ~ 1~'uriho~"diuia~nwir"

rra: u d i u i a q ~ f l ~ ~ M h u ~ h ~ n ~ ~ m u ~ ~ ? # d 7 u 7 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ & ~ 7 d w ~ u f crfo di~dnn3oJ 83% nerd d nisn?u~uni~~#diu i~1a(~n i~^?% rdu qancrw n73f l7Uq~hf lQUh3f l7~ fUd7~Us"~3 rdu

' ~ I ~ ? Q ~ ~ J ~ U % ~ Q ~ Q Q ~ A I ~ J ~ F I L I ( ~ ~ T J M?Q n l 7 f ~ J ~ S L I ~ ~ O ~ U J C ~ Y I J " ~ C ~ ~ I I D ~ ~ Q Q ~ A ~ # J ner .l rflufiu URL: ? ~ R Q J 80 n73mu?&w~~dnvnl~w)n d ~ l 6 ~ ~ r i ain'nsna donismuqu

n i ~ n i r r i i o ~ l a a i ~ ~ m ~ d u nis~~nrrfniu n is~~nof idn~~la . l ' lSa i~ l ~flw#i'u n i~~ .a"d iu ioa~ iduo~ra ' i~~ ' i 6~odr"~ #M n$nnir 8a idia$iduo~i~

~ ~ 6 ~ 4 ~ # 8 i ~ i ~ ~ ~ n ' n ~ f ; l b ~ ~ ~ Y ' i ~ ~ ~ 0 : ~ i ~ l ~ ~ d f ~ ~ i ~ k 0 3 d ~ ~ ' I 0 ~ d ~ i % 1 3 ~ ~ ~ ~ d 7 ~ ~ ~ ' ~ 1 d

4.1 ~ ~ n R a i M % o ~ s i ? ~ n ~ l ~ ~ i a (Principe de la legalit&)

nqwa.j tni i iuu

n iuuu~n~iu f i~~ iQouf l~za i^bd~muu"~ 6 o i n ~ r i i l ~ o : i i d ~ w i a

o'ndlao ad5~~dio~~mrwngnulu nqufi~Riduu filnunlJir;ndniul6ngnuiu d d d d ' U d ~ w s i : n ~ u g u ~ u u ~ r a ~ ~ ~ i w " u n ~ ~ o ~ ~ ' ~ % u . d a i i o i l i;orriolG~finn7iu~Ge~~iu vPIo

~ i f i ~ ~ f i n i w u o ~ y nnaniudi~nolo!d!irn' n ' n ~ ~ i l w I d n i u n ~ ~ n m X ~ ~ v i ~ n g ~ u ~ u d d ~ ~ nq~~f ld i iu6n 'aw~odi~u ino in~bu~na~uUi in"u~~u~~~a i ibuo (Montesquieu) <ufilaM'

1finuu7n7iuAal~i~o~niulding~uiu $~oiaoTrrniuuu7n7iu~n 2 nqafinsSn q i i o

(I) ~ ~ w ~ ~ ~ & ~ ~ I ~ ~ I ~ ~ I M I ~ ) Q I w L o ~ ~ ~ ~ n a i u n ~ r ~ i ) ' (auto-limitation)

dd', I nqagu~miu~nu~nng~u iubuor s J "~ Bn Ihering (LBLI~J) bbRr Jellinek (LORBLUR) ~ ~ d b L ~ 1 ~ 7 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ l ~ f d l ~ ~ ~ a " ~ l ~ ~ ~ z 6 l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ l J n g ~ a J l u

I 6 n"udsi?un71uDuunu(~sJ"nr'bo)"ua~3";bo~ ndi7tio nirbin'n8ilu1d~wn:~n~~aJiu v i m n ~ b n n r d n w ~ d ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ n ~ ~ p b b ~ ~ ~ b ~ : ~ d ~ ~ ! ~ 1 1 1 ~ ~ n 7 ~ ! # n i 7 5 6 7 ~ n 7 ~ f ~ ~ $JLY/I~IJ

bbun~.r~i~nnirnrtii"u~~?;'b~jib~u~dniun~bnmbMdw"u q ~ d u diuionitmndo~a{6

o~6nrln 6o~T .a "oe i i ~1~ d+o4if% o r i i ~ l i ~,Bu$u

d C L C L U

(2) nqWgMQI52 CEtat de Droit)

tj~~uouw7n7iuln d a d QGi; nubnn iin rindiaryirirytp d d~tZl7nulI210 Jean Jacque ROUSSEAU doul t o ~ J b ~ R f i b ~ ~ l ,( Montesquieu )

~ ~ n ~ h ' r d k ~ d u u 7 ~ 7 l u ~ n d 0 ~ u % 7 " a ~ o ~ l ~ . a ' ~ 1 b ~ t o nibs bno Cnuuf ( Care de Malberg

) rin~Gim~niail7~lkIRR

n q a j ~ ~ i i r u u miiolli~fin~~u7n71utml~d0;1f G i i 2 n l j i~t io

ijjlunaiu Kuw'u8<udrza7au ~ n t d o t0u~~ 'nd. i :n"~~~ri~n"a~~"~n~w"uo~drzniau ?;%J

' Max Govnelle, Introduction au Droit Public Franqais, editions montchrestien, 1979, p.68

IJW l b l 389

o~niul6ngrnm6uo~ngnuiu ngnuiudn rn~o~iio1wnisdnn.r~~ um:riovi'uiirQw~~

~ ~ i d . r : ~ u t m i r l u r ~ ~ n i ~ u ~ ~ d ~ : n i ' ~ ~ u ~ i n n i ~ d i ~no~ouo~?;

?;~:lli'lwngrnmn'~?;di~u"u~?'1~~3~d~6 clinnpinru6u"u

\tirclui:au ?;~ho>~rn%rll~ouulln~n~rnmd~u"u oa:tr%ni~~uni.r~d~our~dn~rrflu 6

n'o~rilwldniungtnmn"1u~o~ni.r~d~ourrdn~rrn"lu r.du $srru!qj fiiclunnisnnwm

nlnikpjAl?nriirb ii&n~v!~niungrnmn'u"u a: lddinluuu~uldl~ U n?or~~r~cini~rrf lu

i;srru!q ro~iiniu iiiitiinufl$uaou i"rmiduni.run"lu~anu!qdY'qq%l?rur";n.r.ru !q rdu i;sr.r yqr r~~n.no i tu i~n. r Inu w .R. 2540 u inn 31 3 f i i n ~ n l i ~ d

u inn 31 3 n i . r u f l u ~ F ; u ~ u ~ s n ~ ~ q ~ z n ~ : ~ * ~ I o i riudIas

nA'mnmn'rrn:?5ni.r kdo ldd

(1) ~nfiuoun%r~urfiu~n~ui~innm:?;uum3 n3osin

~ u i d n ~ n i ( r r n w n l r g d i u a ~ n i i n d ~ l u r i i u o ~ d i w?u~ui~nn"~~uf l~v i i f ! ! o $ uotmi@munag.r cl~oainnuiQn~ni(r~nu.rilrg.r uamuidn?9mi ii6iuqdrlrio e

niicld~1urii~o~6iu~~1uiQnn"~~u~1~vii~!a$uo~~~1n~1ni : ~aJibnwi(~r'ununap.r U D W 8 U U d a:~~uocltoi~m~uo~nnn~nn'i~l6~~owssnn1~~lin~c(~uidnmi~munu~~u~~~n~u

u filflrRuol6

@JIRY orrflu~6urfiui~a~~uuqelfi Il - wn~11un~~~11ijou~111n~ni.r u - 6 - ~ n n . r o ~ ~ ~ u ~ u 1 1 ~ : ' 1 1 i t ~ ~ n s 0 ' u d ~ ~ : u ~ i n n n ~ ~ u ~ M ~ Q L ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ I J R J ~ Y Q J ? ;

O,"LIMQ~\~

a (2) $ ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ R ~ K Q J L ~ Q L u M ~ ~ J ~ " ~ % T T u ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ I I L ~ ~

hRu un:kiig~niGioi.rmi~ilumu31.r: d d

(3) n i ~ o o n r ~ s ~ n ~ n : ~ ~ u u l u 3 i ~ : n ~ ~ ~ u"u?un~'nni~lrild DPI d ~nr.ron~oun:n~n:uuuIno~~n~wu an:6n~dntuu~~~u'11ou6~okuni~rrflu~du~fi~u"u ~ ~ ( ~ , ~ ~ ~ I ~ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ I ~ ~ ~ " J H ~ ~ ~ ~ V ~ I ~ % I Q $ ~ Q J ~ " J R ~ J I ~ ~

(4) n i . r o o n ~ s ~ n ~ n ~ m u l u ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ u " ~ f i ~ i ~ m i ~ e ~ d i ~ u

u i n ~ i ~ M ~ ~ L E ~ I L ~ U J " U V ~ J ~ I ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ T : ~ I ~ (5) r~on~rfioi.rmi~i.rrdao~~~~ofu~rh1ri~o1%ur;l'i3"u

I: ~ w ' ~ ~ i ~ ~ f l d ~ ~ n ' 3 1 ~ ? ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ 0 7 ~ ~ 7 1 ~ 3 7 ~ : ~ ~ b ] d ~ ~ d

r i lu i2n~~ur?euinni~d~~dduoddiu~~r%~75inn"d~uwbvi iMd~~~uod~d~od~ni

(7) rdan7r~4u6\6rUuldii~dndi~rrdi ic i r i i i t igsrru~ry r r n T u ~ d u ~ $ u ~ u ~ n r n h ~ n n ~ : ~ d o ~ n ~ i ~ ns:l.iunCqq% u i n n 93 rrn: 94 uil$

rid~ulmsoylnu vil - u u ? n n u 6 ~ ~ 5 ~ i ~ m i u ~ n i i ~ u i ~ r n ' ~ u ' 1 ~ 6 ~ ~nfinuiuun:

$ ~ ~ ~ u o d i d ~ m r o u d ~ ~ n v i i ~ ~ ~ d i " r ~ n l r i ino rr?auu$ (Cam4 de MALBERG) ' rin d d ' u a ng~uiuai?didrcln r d % l ~ ~ M u f i ? i u ~ f l n d i d 3 : ~ i i d ''f%?zn (Etat de droit) 63 "?z613?o"

U Y d' (Etat de police) l ? m d ~

"igAnoW ~ ~ u ? ~ d d ~ d i ~ ~ i d i l i u d n ( ; 1 3 ~ ~ 6 9 7 u i ~ ~ ~ i roi?$ni3

~ I J 7 d ~ u r ~ u i i r ~ u d d u a ~ % n i ~ d i ~ ~ ~ n i f n i d d ~ n ~ ~ ~ u i ~ ~ n " u df,"~iaul6 lu e a d ~nwm:dddiuio~uni~~li'~~ufl~oodi~r~~~6 mu rworcri~n"umiuni3N' uatdoW

unl~m~~~uiu~mu~dd3:~dfl"b6y1n~?ni ~ u ~ u i ~ d i ~ ? ~ d ~ d o ~ u u n ? i u ~ m i ; t i i U L A O ~ I ~ ~ ~ u i s d n ~ d ~ r ~ d $ ( m ' o ~ n i ~ ) f i r ~ u d w ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' i ] : f i i ~ ~ " s n i f e i i ~ 7 C(nufi'luil$an6od U

I C a d de MALBERG, ~ o n t i b u t l b n s ~ B Is thtoric de I'Efat, Tome 1, Paris, Sirey. 1920 8 1 ~ l n ~ t n f f ~ wnqn , ndi 86

u ~ ~ f i n i ~ ? ~ > a t a r . nfinn~]nlnuuniru miu 2 iitarru, w.n, 2537, n~'148.

~ u n i s n a $ i u o ~ i l i u d n n s o ~ ~ ~ u ~ R ' n

\

niiou~idonirnau~ungnuiunnumdi;nnioan~~~~~mio ~~ns3a,1 ;rMtfimu"u Iun; Marbury V. Madison lug n.R. 1803 lnuoo6.4 ul$iiaa (John Marshall) ~ f i w i n ~ 1

I ni.rn.rsdiwoaip.uin miu~ioiuiuwo~iii.rin~nuiudnn.ro~d1~1~nh~1d nlnuiiq ni~n.rrdi~~ii~loinn?iuduw'ui.rrn~i~diui~uninudi~ 7 ~ b u

- diuiouini~fiudiuiau^tu'yr(l1

- ni.rnr:diIunirn?iuduw'ui~rnii~d~r~nff

h o d i ~ n i ~ n . r : d i v o ~ d i u i ~ w ~ n i . r ~ o d i u i ~ u " ~ u ' ~ ~ ~ ~ b u lurffou~uinu I960 umwn rnolnn drraiuiiwivoqdi'qlrrn ~uwar iu

Iduouriund~:gu?gnni n~uini~egid 1 itlrnul r8uqbituinl#foqwo i ~ ~ d ~ n i ~ v ' p l i o i ~ a ~ ~ u r j c y n.rr. 1958 uimn 29 ~ l n d n f l ~ ~ ~ l d i i d i ~ l ~ - ?uon'u ~vc~irldu

Ifoqni~n~ediwotiyuin r m a ~ r i i i f f l n ~ ~ i i d i ~ i ~ i u ' ~ r ~ u ~ u ~ o ~ n l ' i n ~ r d i w o ~ i y u i n (didwinlnwo~ Canseil d' Etat) 19 fivncr 1875. PRMCE

NAPOLEON, Rcc, 155, concl., DAVtD lln: C.E.2mars 1962, RUBM DE SERVENS ET AUTRES, Rcc.,143)

u?.r8niq?.r~tu~fu, nQnuwuninu ~du 3 : dlnr~nsu"~i, d~~n~uw'iiGa.r~u, du&fqll.rn, vc.ff.2538 nlh 275 - 276.

n. n i s m ~ u q u b u n s t u ~ ~ n ~ s m s i n g ~ u i u

n~tu~unismnnpau1udoi'3u6un"~rr6ni~r~u~hon~~uit~lmu~~uin~rnt~~i%n kni~rrnunaps ~rmofiongauiuiiar60~6ai~ min kunf ~ d ~ a ~ ~ r i o u i i i i o n ~ ~ u i u d m u

imotuar&4oigmu2q~ioId oi~iluhonpauiuuo~ifuin ii0~diuni~m52a

6aismilmuncutnnunifnqwfini (nnunisfionpwuiu) uirrik

?'mil6 riidr:mui5uflri~Aua UILIZVI fi~:$iO~d~nnULluiu'~~niy nio 'lu 10 ?'u n'7ldSnisd~nnUuuinio nd i? f i6aa~oi i~ f lung~uio~~n '~

~~d81?3Rnidu~~i~np! t: a u LLMMLRLIJ fii~lrfitng~ui ouunma3'l.a' C,I<Y aU'1idstq~ua~T~o:lai~Auaauii~~51 A

ds:~n~ilnrrfldi:uukndi3b~in".~xtdcf udi3nssuVq fitwsmauiyq2'lmws: u~inGm31J"lrinr~~Auaau&3 o~~a:w~:maniuiiuui ~?a~iiuTfilrlum 90 ?UU ~~hiiJldl6 - t: iuws:nanidwui i~anio:&a~rl ip~~~~:naY'qqmuu' l~d rii2Jn1stuCu63 o

n:u~~~'r~31driounii10~'lumu21a~d7~3urrui~ann"~1a~~1ni u~uni~uw~ia:Jifi~bu

ga~n#i~o?iufinnfd~d~ ud'lunkdrro~d~~riwstu~in~m5~'~:1dn~~a~~~:dsuifi1~o d U u ur t: uiun?~uunmna~JiwcnaY'qqmutld~:ni~~Zusiaii~oi~~unwi

i r h n ~ s n ~ u ~ u ~ n e ~ i n k W G j a i ~ m i u " u i ~ u n i ~ "decentralized judiclal reviewv *in\m!

Gj~ismiilq~in~~ui~u'm~a?~m~u;qldi~iu~aniu~~vi~ni~~ai~mi

~~u~n~iu~i~dlll~i~fl~~~ia~~~~un~'t?u"~tluornnifilfiCmdai~m~a~~~~fi~~~ ~um?Jaru?nilun8 Marbury v.s. Madison hfl S1.R 1803 htl ooqv alf~andtrmu

~inpm?;aiu?ni S(iacirdi ~ ~ f ~ u i a u a ~ m r ' ~ ~ ~ o i i ~ ~ u r ' ~ u i n ~ i u n ~ ~ ~ i t l ~ ~ ~ : : ~ l $ r ' ~ UIRY adInsn ~fi~?~ms~g~l~.r::c~~fl"Ififzms ~ ~ J " ~ & ' C ~ ~ U ~ Q H U I D ~ ~ J ~ P Q ~ U 1 no~auuoomicl

C ~ d o i ~ a s s u r t r y ~ ~ ~ O ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ U 1 ~ n ~ r i G

witar&~d~dtriu~Sitlqn'u n ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ i d u o d c u 6 n ~ ~ 1 i ~ d 0 " ~ ~ ~ i ~ h b i ~ i n ~ ~ u i 1 ~ 1 ~ u

o d i ~ l t ku"u lunisl#nprruiu ~ i ~ S ~ G j w i n w ~ c r s ~ d i n ~ ~ ~ i u d u ' m t i o ? ~ ~ ~ ~ u ; ~ i ~ u ruqcr6 I

(3) nir~auquT~uo~6nnsli~aw

~ ~ d b ~ u ~ ~ n i r n u n a w n i ~ n ~ w ~ i u ~ ~ (cerllralized judicial review)

luu~.r j 1 t ~ u h i i n i s d ~ i a ~ i ~ ~ i u n ~ ~ u i ~ ~ t ~ t f i " i l i r ~ l b i ~ f i n ~ ~ u i t l ~ m d ~ ? ~ ~ ~ s ~

rgq~~u~uur$u ~ ~ u n i m ~ r ~ i n i d n i n i i o J (political ad) OIU~flumrfh~tntld~uiOQSi s 2

\

396 LW 101

(4) fiaisminisns:fli~im%o~~~~u~~id (impeachment) 1184

rr n 7 ~ 7 f i f l f (Plem ~ a l a m a n d r e i f ~ u r r ' l n ~ l ~ ~ ~ u (Hanb Kelsen) BuCwitlinlfi&rill ~ I ~ ~ M ~ I ~ I ~ I ~ $ ~ J ~ Y ~ ~ \ ~ L W ~ ~ : : ~ ' ~ ~ ~ D ~ ' ~ I S X ~ ~ ~ ~ u " ~ L ~ ~ b n l ~ ~ $ d l ~ b l ~ ~ ~ w ' S a d

winnna i f6 Geston J6ze ndia~1niro:flaismiji f i o n r r ~ l f l l e ) ~ C '~393) "%A *

u ~ n ~ ~ m m : ~ : ~ ~ n ' ~ d ~ n ~ c ~ u i u u ~ c n i r r i ~ n c a c n n r & . arananr ruzu , # >

# ~ f < "

Q111mn~1ird Jean de Soto ndia;ji R ~ f i u i u ~ a e u ? n i r m m r w a i a

, a d ' ?

1 1 u 3 n 7 ~ ~ 7 m ~ ~ (saewlcr Public) i ~ u fionnudd~ udnn3o~41 * > ?".'Or, , T l , i

n i . n d o d 3 t ~ u m m rdo~uo~n~iucio~nisd3~~3u11o~d~::aiau ( ~ a ~ u n i m ) du

l Q 4 & J ~ l ~ % a ~ l c n l D (adoptatlon de service publl

4.4 n8nQqynn~~dnnsm (Contrat Adminlstratlf) C P

M a ' n n * r y ~ i n i d d n f l ~ D 4 ~ f l u f l ~ ~ h i ~ f l ~ ~ ~ ~ n l l ~ n n i ~ ~ d d 1 1 ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ b l i ~