45
Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best practices and challenges. Dr. Marianna Simões Researcher & Curator Coleoptera Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI) [email protected] @beetler785 msimoes123

Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Primary data and Entomological collections:

utility, best practices and challenges.

Dr. Marianna SimõesResearcher & Curator Coleoptera

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

[email protected] @beetler785 msimoes123

Page 2: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Beetles

Source: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/161777811592282012/

Page 3: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Leaf-beetles

Page 4: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels
Page 5: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Macroevolution

Simões et al, 2018

Page 6: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Macroevolution

Simões et al., 2016

40°

Macroecology

Simões et al, 2018

Page 7: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Collection-basedResearch

Morphology

DistributionEcology

Page 8: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Biological collections

USNM

MfN, Berlin

SNG, Gorlitz

Page 9: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Source: Erica Kistner 2017, in Environmental Entomology)

Montemayor et al 2017 Gurgel Gonçalves et al 2012 Larson et al 2010

Entomology and distributional ecology

Bhatta, Simões et al., 2019

Page 10: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Space: The Final Frontier

Page 11: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Entomology: The Final Frontier

Page 12: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Entomological collections

Page 13: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

CeNak, Hamburg

Entomological collections

Page 14: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

CeNak, Hamburg

Entomological collections

Page 15: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Entomological collections

Page 16: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Digitization

Page 17: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

German UnificationGerman Entomological Institute

1920

1886

Beck, L. A. (Ed.). (2018). Zoological collections of Germany: The animal kingdom in its amazing plenty at museums and universities. Springer.

Deutsches Entomologisches

Nationalmuseum (DENM)

Deutsches Entomologisches Museum (DEM)

1911

Deutsches Entonomologisches Institut (DEI)German Entomological Institute

German Academy of Agricultural Sciences

WW2: *Mecklenburg

Post-WW2: *Eberswalde

Division of Taxonomy of Insects

1943

1951

1963

1971

1989

WW2: *Friedrischhagen

1950

Page 18: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Project Group in EntomologyUniversity of Applied Science Eberswalde

1992-1

993

3 million pin. Insect.

+ alcohol collection

25,000 type specimens

>100 collections

Project Group in KAIGerman Entomological Institute

1994

Coleoptera (40%)

1,7 million spec.

160,000 sp.

~14,000 types

Became part of

Senckenberg : SDEI

Beck, L. A. (Ed.). (2018). Zoological collections of Germany: The animal kingdom in its amazing plenty at museums and universities. Springer.

2000

Registered Assoc. German

Entomological Institute (DEI)

Became Department of the Center of

Agricultural Sciences

1997

2009

Evaluation from ZALKF

2008

Page 19: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

EdiCall: CARAB project

Pilot Project

Digitization and standardization in

Senckenberg (SNG)

Create Workflow

Maximize Accessibility

Dresden, Müncheberg, Frankfurt am Main

Types

Page 20: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Collections:

Col. Lucas von Heyden (Coll. L. v. Heyden, ded. DEI 1915)

Col. Otto Leonhard (Coll. O. Leonhard, ded. DEI 1929)

Col. B. Rensch(Coll. B. Rensch, via F. Weber, ded. SDEI

2011)

Col. Dieter Hülbert(Coll. D. Hülbert, ex ZALF, LSA; ded. DEI

2006)

Col. F. Weber (Coll. F. Weber; ded. SDEI 2011)

Col. M. Moeck(Coll. M. Moeck, ded. SDEI 2014)

Col. Peter Jaros

(Coll. P. Jaros, ded. SDEI 2015)

Page 21: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Digitization process “Inventory 2009”

Page 22: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Digitization process “Inventory 2009”

Specimens

Biological Fossils

Page 23: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Assembling Collections

• Creation of location labels

• Creation of determination labels

• Preparation

• Systematic sorting and classification

Page 24: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Number of types Number of specimens

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Digitization process

Number of species

Page 25: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Synonym

Taxonomic assessment: Lutz Behne

Page 26: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Type

subspecies

Taxonomic assessment: Lutz Behne

Page 27: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Taxonomic assessment: Lutz Behne

Taxonomic

Corrections

Page 28: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Paradox

Database

Code + Class

..If types are present

Code for synonyms

Code for

species

Code for

species

Page 29: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Paradox

Labels followDatabase structure

Valid

Genus

Synonymus

Database

Page 30: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

"Section" (provides help with the installation)

Bottom label (s)(top view of the box)

Author & Year

Vertical label(view from the front into the box)

Indication of collection (number of individuals);here Hauptlg. (58 copies)

Zoogeographic Region

Page 31: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Collection Organization

• Unit-tray system

• Creation of determination labels

• Preparation

• Systematic sorting and classification

Page 32: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Type pictures

Which is the type…

….or, which type is it?

Page 33: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Photos!

Type pictures

Which is the type…

….or, which type is it?

Page 34: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Type pictures

• Leica System (<1 cm)

• Workstation Nikon (>1cm)

• Labels are scanned

•Photos and labels – SNG Drive

Page 35: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Type pictures

• Leica System (<2 mm)

• Workstation Nikon (>2mm)

• Labels are scanned

•Photos and labels – SNG Drive

301410_Cylindera_mesoepisternalis_male_dorsal_2-stacked-final

Quality!

Stacking

Rename photos

Add scalebar

Clean specimens…

Page 36: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

Not easy. Not cheap

SDEI: 250,000 Euros

260,000 spec.

~3,000 types

1 person ~7 boxes/week + label - spec.

1 person ~50 spec./week - photos

1+1/2 technitians*

+2 years

1. Identification & Taxonomic update

2.Unit tray organzation

3.Photogtaph types (quality pictures)

4.Photograph labels

5.Transcription of the label

6.Clean specimen

7.Transfer specimens from boxes….

Page 37: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

OUTPUT…

•Misidentification

•Non -specific record

•Species status not updated

•“Database miscrossing”

• USNM >34 million insect specimens - only 421,698 records in GBIF

• SDEI ~3 million insect specimens - 0 records in GBIF

• Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF)

Page 38: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

GBIF

Page 39: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Web of Science (08/06/2020)

2000-2010 = 225

Entomology* -

bioclim OR Species distribution modeling OR Ecological niche modeling OR macroecology OR spatial ecology

2010-2020 = 487

Page 40: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Web of Science (08/06/2020)

2000-2010 = 521

Evolutionary Biology* -

bioclim OR Species distribution modeling OR Ecological niche modeling OR macroecology OR spatial ecology

2010-2020 = 1,707

Page 41: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels
Page 42: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Diversity Total Investiment

per taxonAverage funding

per species

Cardoso et al 2011. Biological Conservation.

GigaPan

Unique identifiers

What we need...

+Investment

+ New tools

+ Database

+ Space

+Workforce!

Page 43: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

What we need..

+Investment

+ New tools

+ Database

+ Space

Page 44: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

+Investment

+ New tools

+ Database

+ Space

1:3…

1:10…

1:20…

Page 45: Primary data and Entomological collections: utility, best ... · Research Morphology Distribution Ecology. Biological collections USNM MfN, Berlin ... • Creation of location labels

Questions?

Dr. Marianna SimõesResearcher & Curator Coleoptera

Senckenberg Deutsches Entomologisches Institut (SDEI)

[email protected] @beetler785 msimoes123