61
N Sp ANGGORO WISESO (1206212514) MIRANTI (1206242523) MUHAMMAD RIDWAN (0906640854) RAMADHAN ISKANDAR (1206212400) SABRINA ZAHRA FITRIANI(1206249391) SHARIMA UMAYA (1206212325) Grp 6 – 1 A Pr Urb Fr K

Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Chemical Product Design

Citation preview

Page 1: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

N!!"# $%" Sp!&'(&$)'*%

ANGGORO WISESO (1206212514) MIRANTI (1206242523)

MUHAMMAD RIDWAN (0906640854) RAMADHAN ISKANDAR (1206212400)

SABRINA ZAHRA FITRIANI(1206249391) SHARIMA UMAYA (1206212325)

 

Gr*+p 6 – 1#) A##',%-!%) Pr!#!%)$)'*% Urb$% F$r-'%, K')

Page 2: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Presentation Outline

• Introduction • Literature Review

• Identifying Consumer Needs

• Product Specification • Conclusion

Page 3: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

INTRODUCTION

Page 4: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Background

•  According to the United Nations Centre for Human Settlements, more than half of humanity will live in cities by the year 2015.

•  Urban farming is done in an urban centre, a city or metropolis. Urban residents across the globe are trying to grow plants, for reasons ranging from food security to

environmental and health reason

Page 5: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

“H*w )* &r!$)! $% '%)!r!#)'%, +rb$% f$r-'%, .') )/$) '# #'-p0! $%" &$% b! p0$%)!" b1 p!*p0! '% +rb$% $r!$?”

Problem Formulation

Page 6: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

•  There are already a lot of urban farming kit, we have to uplift our urban farming kit from its advantages and decrease its disadvantages thus people would buy our urban farming kit

•  People’s need of fresh air that comes out from planting plants, especially in big cities that have less amount of land

•  Not a lot of people love to do gardening/planting activity – we have to make our urban farming kit into an interesting one

Problem Identification

Page 7: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

•  We will be creating an urban farming kit in one package that can be bought and planted easily by the consumers

•  The data required to make urban farming kit are advantages, disadvantages from an existing product and needs of consumers regarding their preferences on an urban farming kit they are willing to buy

•  This chemical product design is just a prototype

Problem Limitation

Page 8: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

REVIEW

L i t e r a t u r e  

Page 9: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Urban Farming?

Urban  :    “In,  rela-ng  to,  or  characteris-c  of  a  town  or  city,”  

Farming  :  “The  ac-vity  or  business  of  

growing  crops  and  raising  livestock.”    

Urban  farming  :  ac-vi-es  of  growing  plants  to  be  

consumed,  that  perform  in  urban  area  by  exploi-ng  

unused  land.  For  examples  :  roof  garden,  

community  garden.  

Page 10: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

History of Urban Farming •  Solu-on  for  hunger  problems  during  war  -mes.    •  Victory   gardens   sprouted   during   World   War   and   were  fruit,  vegetable,  and  herb  gardens  in  US,  Canada,  and  UK.    

•  This  effort  was  undertaken  by  ci-zens  to  support  the  war  effort.    

World  war  I  &  II  

•  Ci-es   quickly   became  overcrowded  because   people   from  the  countryside  came  to  the  town  for  occupa-ons  in.    

•  Agriculture  was  pushed  further  and  further  away  from  the  city   edge.   The   harmonious   rela-onship   between  agriculture  and  urban  environment  became  severed.    

Industrial  revolu-on  

era  

•  In   1898,   Ebenezer   Howard   began   the   Garden   City  Movement.   At   its   essence,   the   urban   theory   focused   on  bringing  the  city  to  the  farm  by  u-lizing  agricultural  land  as  the  site  for  his  garden  ci-es.    

Garden  Ci-es  of  

To-­‐morrow  (1989)  

•  People  in  the  world  slowly  realize  about  how  important  to  keep  the  harmony  between  humans  and  the  nature.    

•  There  are  a  lot  of  movements  about  small  ac-on  that  can  help  the  city  back  to  harmony  with  the  nature,  by  plan-ng  some  plants.  

Now  and  Then  

Page 11: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Perspective of Urban Farming

Environmental  urban  farm  :  

•  U r b a n   f a r m i n g   t o  increase   environmental  health,  and  remedia-on.    

•  Phy t o r emed i a-on   :  plants   that   have   their  chem i ca l   ab i l i t y   t o  degrade,   absorb,   convert  to   an   inert   form,   and  remove  toxins.  

•   Growing  plants   can  also  freshen   the   air   and  reduce  pollu-ons.  

Food  and  herbs  medical  security  :  

• Urban   farming   can  become   a   solu-on  for   healthy   living  n e e d e d   b y   t h e  concept   of   growing  people   own   healthy  foods   or   herbs   by  themselves.  

Social  and  relaxing  :  

• Urban  farming  are  thought  to   be   relaxing,   calming,  improved   emo-onal   well-­‐being,   and   prevent   from  “urban-­‐stress”.   That   is   a  report   about   how   people  interac-on   with   nature  through   a   garden   can  decreased   levels   of   stress  and   beZer   overall   mental  health.    

Page 12: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Benefits of Urban Farming

Noise  pollu<on  

•  Adding  plants  that  can  absorb  sound  waves  has  the  poten-al  to  lead  to  a  vast  reduc-on  in  noise  pollu-on  

Nutri<on  and  quality  of  food  and  medical  herbs  

•  Harves-ng  produce  from  one’s  own  community  garden  cuts  back  on  storage  -mes  significantly  and  keep  nutrient  that  can  be  lost  in  shipping  process.  

• Medical  herbs  is  difficult  to  found  in  supermarket.  That’s  why  most  of  urban  people  choose  to  consume  drugs,  beside  drugs  have  some  bad-­‐  side  effect.  Plan-ng  they  own  herbs  plants  on  their  own  farms  can  increase  medical  herbs  uses  than  drugs.  

Educa<on  

More  Green  Space,    reduc<on  of  temperature  and  pollu<on  

Page 13: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Implementation of Urban Farming in Indonesia

•  INDONESIA  BERKEBUN,  TUNAS  HIJAU  (Surabaya)  Communi<es  

•  Ver-minaponik   (Balai   Pengkajian   Teknologi   Pertanian   (BPTP)):  Cul-va-on   of   plants   and   fish   simultaneously.   Fish   provide  residual  feed  and  fish  feces  that  contain  a  high  concentra-on  of  nutrients  for  the  plants.  Plants  filter  the  water  and  maintain  the  quality  of  irriga-on  water  for  the  fish.    

•  Hydroponic,  sistem  sky  farming,  etc  

Technology  

•  RW  03  Sukapada  Bandung,  farming  vegetables  in  the  walls  of  the  street  so  that  residents  can  enjoy  its  beauty  and  harvest  the  product  together  

Area  

Urban  Farming  

Kit  

Page 14: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Types of Plants •  A   small,   seed   bearing   plant   with   fleshy,   rather  than  woody,  parts.  

•  In   general   use,   herbs   are   any   plants   used   for  food,   flavoring,   medicine,   or   perfume,   some  plants  contain  phytochemicals.  

•  Most   herbs   prefer   a   well   drained,   friable   soil.  Herbs   can  also  be  grown  via   vegeta-ve  means,  roo-ng   cudngs,   division  of   the  plant,   bulbs,   or  -ssue  culture.    

Herbs  

•  The   non-­‐biological   defini-on   of   a   vegetable   is  largely  based  on  culinary.    

•  Some  must  be  cooked  to  destroy  certain  natural  toxins  or  microbes  in  order  to  be  edible.  

•  Overall   requirements   for   the   vast   majority   of  vegetable   plants   are   deep,   rich   soil   with   a  neutral  or  slightly  alkaline  composi-on,  plenty  of  sunshine,  water,  regular  feeding,  and  weeding  .  

Vegetables  

Page 15: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Types of Plants •  A   part   of   a   flowering   plant   that   derives   from  specific  -ssues  of  the  flower.    

•  Many   fruits   eaten   both   fresh,   as   jams,  manufactured   foods   (like   cakes),   beverages  (fruit  juices),  alcoholic  beverages  (wine),  etc.  

•  Fruits  are  generally  high  in  fiber,  water,  vitamin  C   and   sugars,   some-mes   contain   various  phytochemicals.    

•  Regular   consump-on  of   fruit   is  associated  with  reduced  risks  of  many  chronical  disease.  

Fruits  

• We   defined   flowering   plant   as   the   plants   that  growing   beau-ful   flower   that   has   a   benefit   to  beau-fy  surrounding.  

•  Every   kind   of   flowering   plants   has   it’s   own  condi-on  to  be  grown  up  perfectly.    

•  Examples   :   sunflower,   tulips,   marigold,   lily,  jasmine,  rose,  etc.  

Flowers  

Page 16: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Components of Planting Plants

Seeds   Medium  

Nutrients  

Page 17: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Components of Planting Plants (Cont’d)

Grains  

Plant  crop  that  are  used  to  be  consumed  or  processed  as  substance  

Seed

s   Grains  from  plant  that  are  used  to  replan<ng  

Seeds  

Maturity   Colour      Seeds  drop  off  

Smell      Content  of  water  

Peel  Hardness    

Page 18: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Components of Planting Plants (Cont’d)

• Usually  made  from  organism  components  (leaf,  trunk,  flower,  fruit,  wood)  

Organic  Material  

• Material  that  contain  high  mineral  from  rock  molding  Anorganic  

Material  

Medium  

Page 19: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Components of Planting Plants (Cont’d)

No   Organic  Material   Characteris<c  

1   Charcoal   Buffer,  hard  to  mold,  used  at  areas  that  has  high  humidity,  mostly  lack  of  nutrients  

2   Trunk  of  vegetable  fern   Easy  to  bind  with  water,  has  a  good  aera-on  and  drainage  

3   Compost   Soil  condi-oner,  soil  ameliorater  

4   Moss   Easy  to  bind  with  water,  has  a  good  drainage  

5   Manure   Has  nutrients  in  large  amounts  

6   Coco  peat   Bind  with  water  strongly,  contains  essen-al  nutrients  (Ca,  Mg,  K,  N,  P)  

7   Rice  Husk   Easy  to  bind  with  water,  source  of  potassium,  hard  to  mold  

8   Humus   High  ion  exchanger,  low  porosity  

source  :  Dinas  Pertanian  Tanaman  Pangan  Provinsi  Jawa  Barat    

Page 20: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Components of Planting Plants (Cont’d)

No   Anorganic  Material   Characteris<c  

1   Gel   Good  looking,  prac-cal,  bad  drainage  

2   Sand   Good  aera-on  and  drainage,  high  porosity  

3   Pebble   Very  high  porosity,  hard  to  bind  with  water  

4   Piece  of  concrete  brick   Lack  of  nutrients,  good  aera-on  and  drainage  

5   Spons   High  binding  with  water  power,  easy  to  moldy  

6   Clay   Lack  of  Nutrients  

7   Styrofoam   High  porosity  source  :  Dinas  Pertanian  Tanaman  Pangan  Provinsi  Jawa  Barat  

 

Page 21: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Components of Planting Plants (Cont’d)

Macronutrient   Carbon    Phosporus  

Hydrogen  Potassium  

Nitrogen  Calcium  

Magnesium  Sulphur  

Nutrients  

Micronutrient   Boron    Zinc  

Manganase  

Copper  

Iron  

Page 22: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Conditions to Grow the Plants

Nutri-on   Light   pH  

Humidity   Temperature  

Page 23: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Conditions to Grow the Plants (Cont’d)

Supplied  by  the  soil  and  addi-on  of  fer-lizers  (compost,  manure,  etc)  

Divided  into  two  :  Macronutrients  and  Macronutrients  

Nutri-on  

Page 24: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Conditions to Grow the Plants (Cont’d)

All  plants  need  at  least  8-­‐10  hours  to  direct  sunlight  each  day.  

Incandescent  lamps  can  be  used  to  grow  plants,  but  are  not  adequate  the  crop  to  maturity  

Light  

Page 25: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Conditions to Grow the Plants (Cont’d)

In  general,  the  most  favourable  pH  range  for  vegetable  is  between  5.5  to  6.5  in  mineral  soil  and  5.0  to  6.0  in  organic  soil  

Acidic  soil  ooen  causes  the  stun-ng  and  yellowing  of  leaves,  resul-ng  in  the  decrease  in  growth  and  yield  of  crops  as  the  pH  levels  falls  

pH  

Page 26: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Conditions to Grow the Plants (Cont’d)

Humidity  Low  Humidity  (dew  points  are  in  50s)  

Moisture  Evaporates  from  plant  very  quickly  

Plants  can    wilt  quickly  

Page 27: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Conditions to Grow the Plants (Cont’d)

Warm-­‐season  vegetables  and  most  flowers  grow  well  between  15  to  25ºC  

Cool-­‐season  vegetables  suchas  leZuce  and  spinach  grow  between  10  to  20ºC.    

Temperature  

Page 28: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Methods of Planting Plants

Conven-onal   Modern  

Page 29: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Methods of Planting Plants (Cont’d)

Conven-onal  

Most  prac-sed  form  of  agriculture  around  the  world  

Focus  on  methods  that  maintain  soil  fer-lity,  prevent  the  loss  of  topsoil,  hold  water  in  the  soil  and  produce  stable  harvest  

One  of  the  biggest  problems  with  conven-onal  agricultue  is  that  it  kills  off  life  in  the  topsoil  and  subsoil  

Page 30: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Methods of Planting Plants (Cont’d)

Modern  

Aeroponic   Hydroponic   Tissue  Culture   Ver-culture  

Page 31: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

NEEDS

i d e n t i f y c o s t u m e r  

Page 32: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Respondents’ Data

63 Female 43 Male

7%

76%

13% 3% 1%

15-18 18-21 21-24 25-30 > 30

Age 32%

23% 19%

10%

9% 7%

Jakarta Depok Bogor Bekasi Tangerang Others

City

Page 33: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

38%

62%

Yes

No

“Do you like gardening?”  

3%

54% 28%

15%

hobby

beautify the environtment

get the product (ex: vegetables, fruits)

others

Reason of gardening

Result : Gardening

Page 34: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Difficulties of gardening

Time to do gardening

28%

38%

21%

13%

dislike gardening don't have land to do gardening don't know how to do gardening don't have equipments and seeds

Result : Gardening

84%

13%

2% 1% 0%

5-15 minutes 16-30 minutes 31-45 minutes 46-60 minutes > 60 minutes

Page 35: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

14%

86%

Yes No

Result : Urban Farming

“Have you ever heard about Urban Farming?”  

Preferred plants for urban farming

21%

15%

27%

32%

5% Herbs

Vegetables

Fruits

Flowers

Other

Page 36: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Reasons to buy a product 17%

23%

26%

25%

9%

Unique packaging

Afforable price

Main benefit

Other benefit

Promotion (buy 1 get 1, discount)

Result : Urban Farming

Price preferred for urban farming kit

70%

22%

6% 2%

Rp. 75.000,00-Rp. 100.000,00 Rp. 101.000,00-Rp. 125.000,00 Rp. 126.000-Rp. 150.000,00 Rp. 151.000-Rp. 200.000,00

Page 37: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Seeds Medium

Pot Fertilizer

Shovel Water mist

User's manual Other

Equipments in urban farming kit

Result : Urban Farming

Form of plant in urban farming kit

36%

64%

Seeds Starter plant

Page 38: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

No Needs

1 Urban farming kit that can beautify surroundings

2 Urban farming kit that can be done without land

3 Urban farming kit that has clear explanation

4 Urban farming kit that can be maintained in 5-15 minutes each day

5 Urban farming kit that grows either flowers, fruits herbs

6 Urban farming kit that is affordable, between Rp. 75.000,00-Rp.

100.000,00

7 Urban farming kit plant that has various benefits

8 Urban farming kit that consists of medium

9 Urban farming kit that consists of container

List of Needs

Page 39: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

10 Urban farming kit that consists of fertilizer

11 Urban farming kit that consists of shovel

12 Urban farming kit that consists of water mist

13 Urban farming kit that consists of user’s manual

14 Urban farming plant in a form of starter plant

15 Urban farming kit that has description of composition

16 Urban farming kit that uses safety material for packaging

17 Urban farming kit that has an interesting packaging

18 Urban farming kit that contains pesticide

19 Urban farming kit which is light

Page 40: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Classification and Ranking

1 = undesired 2 = unimportant 3 = nice to have 4 = highly desired 5 = essential

The rank of needs based on the category:

Page 41: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

No. Needs Rank

PRODUCT PERFORMANCE

2 Urban farming kit that can be done without land 5

4 Urban farming kit that can be maintained in 5-15 minutes each day 5

5 Urban farming kit that grows either flowers, fruits herbs 4

PRODUCT PERCEPTION

1 Urban farming kit that can beautify surroundings 4

3 Urban farming kit that has clear explanation 4

9 Urban farming kit plant that has various benefits 5

19 Urban farming kit that has lightweight 3

PRODUCT COMPOSITION

8 Urban farming kit that consist of medium 5

9 Urban farming kit that consist of container 4

10 Urban farming kit that consist of fertilizer 4

Page 42: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

11 Urban farming kit that consist of shovel 3

12 Urban farming kit that consist of water mist 2

13 Urban farming kit that consist of user’s manual 4

14 Urban farming plant in a form of starter plant 5

18 Urban farming kit that contains pesticide 3

REGULATION

15 Urban farming kit that has description of composition 4

16 Urban farming kit that uses safety material for packaging 5

RETAILING

6 Urban farming kit that is affordable, between Rp. 75.000,00-Rp.

100.000,00 5

17 Urban farming kit that has an interesting packaging 4

Page 43: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Diagram of Needs

Page 44: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

SPECIFICATION P r o d u c t  

Page 45: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

List of Metrics Needs

Number Needs Description Specifications

Metric

Unit Rank

Product Perfomance

2 Can be done without land Medium in mobile container Y/N 5

4 Maintained in 5-15 minutes

each day Maintenance time (watering,

fertilizing, etc) minute 5

5 Grows either flowers, fruits,

or herbs Type of plant (fruits, herbs,

vegetables) Y/N 4

Product Perception

1 Beautiful kit appearance Type of plant and container

design Subj. 4

3 Has clear explanation User’s manual or guidebook Y/N 4

9 Has various benefits Type of plant (fruits, herbs,

vegetables) Y/N 5

Page 46: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

19 Kit that lightweight Weight kg 3 Product Composition

8 Consists of medium Medium availability Y/N 5 9 Consists of container Container availability Y/N 4 10 Consists of fertilizer Fertilizer availability Y/N 4 11 Consists of shovel Shovel availability Y/N 3 12 Consists of water mist Water mist availability Y/N 2 13 Consists of user’s manual User’s manual availability Y/N 4

14 Plant in a form of starter plant Plant in starter phase (shoot, sprout,

etc.) Y/N 5

18 Contains pesticide Pesticide availability Y/N 3 Regulation

15 Has description of composition Description of composition Y/N 4

16 Uses safe material for packaging Container and packaging material

composition is safe Y/N 5

Retailing

6 Affordable price, between Rp.

75.000,00-Rp. 100.000,00 Price Rp 5

17 Has a great packaging Packaging design and

performance Subj. 4

Page 47: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Needs Description

Metric Unit

%

weight Subj. Y/N minute Rp kg

2 Can be done without land •

4 Can be maintainede in 5-15

minutes each day •

5 Grows either flowers,

fruits, or herbs •

1 Beautiful kit appearance •

3 Has a clear explanation •

9 Has various benefits •

19 Kit that lightweight •

8 Consists of medium •

9 Consists of container •

10 Consists of fertilizer •

Metrics Matrix

Page 48: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Needs Description

Metric Unit

%

weight Subj. Y/N minute Rp kg

11 Consists of shovel •

12 Consists of water mist •

13 Consists of user’s manual •

14 Plant in a form of starter

plant •

18 Contains pesticide •

15 H a s d e s c r i p t i o n o f

composition •

16 Uses safe material for

packaging •

6

Affordable price, between

R p . 7 5 . 0 0 0 , 0 0 - R p .

100.000,00 •

17 Has a great packaging •

Page 49: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Benchmarking •  There are some existing products of urban farming kit. In

order to design new innovation of an urban farming kit, four existing products are compared to make benchmarking for our new product.

Notes: ● (dot) refers to subjective value ● Poor ●● Acceptable ●●● Expectable ●●●● Highly expectable ●●●●● Outstanding

Page 50: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Needs Rank

Scores

Own Grow

Box

Paris

Garden

Smith &

Hawken

UF

Seeds

Product Perfomance

2 Can be done without land 5 ••••• ••••• ••••• ••••• •••••

4 Can be maintained in 5-15

minutes each day 5

••••• ••••• ••• ••• ••••

5 Grows either flowers, fruits, or

herbs 4

••••• ••••• ••••• ••••• •••••

Product Perception

1 Beautiful kit appearance 4 ••••• ••• ••••• •••• •••••

3 Has a clear explanation 4 ••••• • ••••• ••••• ••

9 Has various benefits 5 ••••• ••••• ••••• ••••• •••••

19 Kit that lightweight 3 ••••• ••••• ••• •••• ••••

Product Composition

8 Consists of medium 5 ••••• ••••• ••••• ••••• •••••

9 Consists of container 4 ••••• ••••• ••••• ••••• •••••

10 Consists of fertilizer 4 ••• • • • •

11 Consists of shovel 3 • • • • •

Page 51: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Needs Rank

Scores

Own Grow

Box

Paris

Garden

Smith &

Hawken

UF

Seeds

12 Consists of water mist 2 ••• ••••• • • •

13 Consists of user’s manual 4 ••••• • ••••• ••••• •

14 Plant in a form of starter plant 5 ••••• • • ••••• •

18 Contains pesticide 3 ••• • • • •

Regulation

15 Has description of composition 4 ••••• • ••••• ••••• •

16 Uses safe material for packaging 5 ••••• ••• •• •••• •••••

Retailing

6 Affordable price, between Rp.

75.000,00-Rp. 100.000,00 5

••••• ••••• •••• • •

17 Has a great packaging 4 ••••• •• ••• ••• ••••

Page 52: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Existing Products Grow Box Paris Garden

UF Seeds Smith & Hawken

Page 53: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Specifications Rank

Metrics

Unit

Scores

Own Grow

Box

Paris

Garden

Smith &

Hawken

UF

Seeds

Product Perfomance

2 Medium in mobile container 5 Y/N Y Y Y Y Y

4 Maintenance time (watering,

fertilizing, etc) 5 minute 7-10 10 12 12 10

5 Type of plant (fruits, herbs,

vegetables) 4 Y/N Y Y Y Y Y

Product Perception

1 Type of plant and container

design 4 Subj.

••••• ••• ••••• •••• •••••

3 User’s manual or guidebook 4 Y/N Y N Y Y N

Benchmarking of Existing Products with Metrics

Page 54: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Specifications Rank

Metrics

Unit

Scores

Own Grow

Box

Paris

Garden

Smith &

Hawken

UF

Seeds

9 Type of plant (fruits, herbs,

vegetables) 5 Y/N Y Y Y Y Y

19 Weight 3 kg 1,5 1,5 2,25 2 2

Product Composition

8 Medium availability 5 Y/N Y Y Y Y Y

9 Container availability 4 Y/N Y Y Y Y Y

10 Fertilizer availability 4 Y/N Y N N N N

11 Shovel availability 3 Y/N N N N N N

12 Water mist availability 2 Y/N N Y N N N

13 User’s manual availability 4 Y/N Y N Y Y N

14 Plant in starter phase (shoot,

sprout, etc.) 5 Y/N Y N N Y N

18 Pesticide availability 3 Y/N Y N N N N

Page 55: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Specifications Rank

Metrics

Unit

Scores

Own Grow

Box

Paris

Garden

Smith &

Hawken

UF

Seeds

Regulation

15 Description of composition 4 Y/N Y N Y Y N

16 Container and packaging

material composition is safe 5 Y/N Y Y N Y Y

Retailing

6 Price 5 Rp R p .

75.000

R p .

45.000-7

5.000

R p

79.500

R p .

150.000

R p .

200.00

0

17 P a c k a g i n g d e s i g n a n d

performance 4 Subj.

••••• •• ••• ••• ••••

Page 56: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Specifications Rank Metric Unit

Marginal

Value Ideal Value

Product Perfomance

2 Medium in mobile container 5 Y/N Y Y

4 Maintenance time (watering, fertilizing,

etc) 5 minute 7-12 5

5 Type of plant (fruits, herbs, vegetables) 4 Y/N Y Y

Product Perception

1 Type of plant and container design 4 Subj. •••• •••••

3 User’s manual or guidebook 4 Y/N Y Y

9 Type of plant (fruits, herbs, vegetables) 5 Y/N Y Y

19 Weight 3 kg 1,5-2,25 1,5

Product Composition

8 Medium availability 5 Y/N Y Y

9 Container availability 4 Y/N Y Y

Marginal and Ideal Values

Page 57: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Needs

Number Specifications Rank Metric Unit

Marginal

Value Ideal Value

10 Fertilizer availability 4 Y/N N Y

11 Shovel availability 3 Y/N N Y

12 Water mist availability 2 Y/N N Y

13 User’s manual availability 4 Y/N Y Y

14 Plant in starter phase (shoot, sprout,

etc.) 5 Y/N

Y Y

18 Pesticide availability 3 Y/N N Y

Regulation

15 Description of composition 4 Y/N Y Y

16 Container and packaging material

composition is safe 5 Y/N

Y Y

Retailing

6 Price 5 Rp Rp 45.000 –

200.000 Rp 75.000

17 Packaging design and performance 4 Subj. •••• •••••

Page 58: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

CONCLUSION

Page 59: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

Conclusion 1.  We have conducted a survey concerning about gardening and gardening kit

with 109 respondents, with varieties of age, job, and gender. 2.  Amongst the entire respondent, only 38% of them like to do gardening, with

the reasons ranging from solely because of a hobby, enhance the aesthetic value of their yard, or to get a functional product from the crops. The group of people who don’t like to do it mostly have a difficulty to provide the space to garden. The others dislike gardening because they don’t know how to garden, don’t have the equipment, or simply because they disliked it. Aside the difficulties, time is also the limiting factor for the unpopularity of gardening. 84% of the respondents would do it if it only takes 5-15 minutes daily. But then only 86% of all of the respondents know about urban farming, which gives us advantage to promote our product.

3.  For the urban farming kit, a lot of varieties of plants or herbs preferred by the respondents, with the specifications ranging from unique packaging, affordable price, along with the main and other benefit.

4.  The specifications of our product will concern about its performance (extra medium in container, low maintenance time, and type of plant), perception (light and beautiful), composition (ingredients of the product), regulation and retailing. The elaboration is: The maintenance time will be 7-12 minutes, the weight will weigh about 1.5-2.25 kg, with complete set of composition and affordable price of Rp.75.000, and nice package.

Page 60: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6

References    •  Anonim.  Indoor  Herb  Kit  Item.  Available  at  hZp://www.ufseeds.com/Indoor-­‐Herb-­‐Kit.item  (last  accessed:  February  

16  2015)  •  Anonim.  Grow  Box  Mushroom  Kit.  Available  at  www.halogrowbox.com  (last  accessed:  February  15  2015)  •  Anonim.  Oregano  Grow  Kit  from  Smith  &Hawken.  Available  at  hZp://www.gardeners.com  (last  accessed:  February  

17  2015)  •  Anonim.  Paris  Garden  Sunflower  Kit.  Available  at  hZp://www.acehardware.co.id/product/product_detail/596  (last  

accessed:  February  17  2015)  •  Anonime.  1997.  Ensiklopedi  kehutanan  Indonesia.  Badan  peneli-an  dan  pengembangan  kehutanan.  Departemen  

kehutanan.  Jakarta  •  Dinas  Pertanian  Tanaman  Pangan  Provinsi  Jawa  Barat.  2011.  Macam-­‐macam  media  tanam.  Available  at  hZp://

www.diperta.jabarprov.go.id/index.php/subMenu/informasi/ar-kel/detailar-kel/95.  (last  accessed  17  Februari  2015)  

•  George,  Evan.  2013.  Urban  Agriculture  Movement.  Available  at  hZp://www.law.msu.edu/clinics/food/UrbanAgMvmnt.pdf  (last  accessed:  February  18  2015)  

•  Hendaryani,  Koes.  2013.  Macam-­‐macam  bercocok  tanam.  Available  at  hZp://www.teenage-­‐corner.com/2013/07/macam-­‐macam-­‐bercocok-­‐tanam.html.  (last  accessed  17  februari  2015)  

•  Johnson,  Fiona.  2011.  EssenHal  requirements  for  plant  growth.  Available  at  hZp://www.vellag.com/index.php/ar-cles/what-­‐plants-­‐require-­‐for-­‐growth/  (last  accessed  17  Februari  2015)  

•  North  Carolina  State  University.  2010.Humidity  relaHon  to  agriculture/K-­‐12.  available  at  hZp://www.nc-­‐climate.ncsu.edu/edu/k12/Humidity/ag.  (last  accessed  18  February  2015)  

•  PhilphoZ,  Tom.  2010.  Food  the  History  of  Urban  Agriculture  Should  Its  Future.  Available  at  hZp://grist.org/ar-cle/food-­‐the-­‐history-­‐of-­‐urban-­‐agriculture-­‐should-­‐inspire-­‐its-­‐future/full/  (last  accessed:  February  15  2015)  

•  Seider.  2009.  Product  and  Process  Design  Principles.  Synthesis,  Analysis,  and  Evalua-on.  Wiley  &  Sons  Inc.  •  Singapore  Gardening  Society.  n.d.  Effects  of  soil  pH  on  plant  growth.  Available  at  hZp://

www.gardeningsingapore.org/index.php?op-on=com_content&view=ar-cle&id=52:effects-­‐of-­‐soil-­‐ph-­‐on-­‐plant-­‐growth&ca-d=35:plant-­‐care&Itemid=53.  (last  accessed  18  februari  2015)  

•  Univeritas  Hasanudin.  n.d.  PengerHan  Benih,  ruang  lingkup,  dan  permasalahan  perbenihan.  Available  at  hZp://lms.unhas.ac.id/kursus/123456_022/document/kuliah_2.html.  (last  accessed  17  Februari  2015)  

•  University  of  Illinois  at  Urbana-­‐Champaign.  n.d.  requirements  for  plant  growth.  Available  at  hZp://www.aces.uiuc.edu/vista/html_pubs/hydro/require.html.  (last  accessed  17  Februari  2015)    

•  Wesselingh.  2007.  Design  and  Development  of  Biological,  Chemical,  Food,  and  Pharmaceu-cal  Products.  John  Wiley  &  Sons,  Ltd.  

Page 61: Presentasi Assignment 1_Kelompok 6