92
PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference Rooms A & B State Board for Community & Technical Colleges 1300 Quince Street SE, Olympia 98504 January 26, 2012 9:00 Welcome and Introductions Ethelda Burke, Chair, Higher Education Coordinating Board Charlie Earl, Executive Director, State Board for Community & Technical Colleg Tab Approval of November 2011Meeting Minutes 1 9:15 Roadmap for 2012 (January to June) Don Bennett, executive director, will present an overview and timeline for Board activities over the next several months, including: 2012 Legislative Session Strategic Master Plan – Next Steps Transition to Office of Student Achievement Council (or other successor) 2 10:00 Annual Update: Student Financial Aid Programs The Annual Report of State Financial Aid Programs describes recent changes and trends in student financial aid and includes several program briefs. The report will be presented by Rachelle Sharpe, HECB Director of Student Financial Assistance. Carla Idohl-Corwin, Dean of Student Financial Services, South Puget Sound Community College, will provide institutional perspective regarding recent trends in student aid. 3 11:00 Joint Report: “A Skilled and Educated Workforce” This is the third in the series of biennial reports published jointly by the HECB, SBCTC and WTECB to identify high employer demand occupations and further target growth to meet the needs of the economy. The report is required under 28B.76.230 to assess “the number of forecasted net job openings at each level of higher education and training and the number of credentials needed to match the forecast of net job openings.” The joint report will be presented by staffs from the three agencies: Randy Spaulding, Director, Academic Affairs, HECB Tina Bloomer, Policy Research Associate, SBCTC Bryan Wilson, Deputy Director, WTECB 4 12:00 Board lunch

PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference Rooms A & B

State Board for Community & Technical Colleges 1300 Quince Street SE, Olympia 98504

January 26, 2012

9:00 Welcome and Introductions • Ethelda Burke, Chair, Higher Education Coordinating Board • Charlie Earl, Executive Director, State Board for Community & Technical Colleg

Tab

Approval of November 2011Meeting Minutes 1 9:15 Roadmap for 2012 (January to June)

Don Bennett, executive director, will present an overview and timeline for Board activities over the next several months, including:

• 2012 Legislative Session • Strategic Master Plan – Next Steps • Transition to Office of Student Achievement Council (or other successor)

2

10:00 Annual Update: Student Financial Aid Programs

The Annual Report of State Financial Aid Programs describes recent changes and trends in student financial aid and includes several program briefs. The report will be presented by Rachelle Sharpe, HECB Director of Student Financial Assistance. Carla Idohl-Corwin, Dean of Student Financial Services, South Puget Sound Community College, will provide institutional perspective regarding recent trends in student aid.

3

11:00 Joint Report: “A Skilled and Educated Workforce”

This is the third in the series of biennial reports published jointly by the HECB, SBCTC and WTECB to identify high employer demand occupations and further target growth to meet the needs of the economy. The report is required under 28B.76.230 to assess “the number of forecasted net job openings at each level of higher education and training and the number of credentials needed to match the forecast of net job openings.” The joint report will be presented by staffs from the three agencies:

• Randy Spaulding, Director, Academic Affairs, HECB • Tina Bloomer, Policy Research Associate, SBCTC • Bryan Wilson, Deputy Director, WTECB

4

12:00 Board lunch

Page 2: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

January 26, 2012 Board Meeting Agenda Page 2

Meeting Accommodations: Persons who require special accommodation for attendance must call the HECB at 360.753.7800 as soon as possible before the meeting.

2012 HECB MEETING CALENDAR

DATE LOCATION

February 29, Wed

9:00 – 4:00

ESD 113 Thurston Room, Capital Event Center

Tumwater

March 29, Thurs

9:00 – 4:00

South Puget Sound Community College Bldg 35, Room 151

April 26, Thurs

9:00 – 4:00

Olympic College

HSS 119/121

May 31, Thurs

9:00 – 4:00

WSU Tri-Cities

CIC, Room 120/120A

June 28, Thurs

9:00 – 4:00

Cherberg Bldg, SHR 4

Capitol Campus

1:00 Status Report on Program Database Washington received a US Department of Education grant in 2009 to develop a Statewide Longitudinal Data System (SLDS). A key component of that project is a complete database of approved programs of study and authorized degree programs. Jan Ignash, Deputy Director for Policy, Planning and Research, will brief the Board on the project and explain its relationship to planning and system design efforts. Staff will also present a summary of degree program approval activities in the past year.

5

1:45 Information: Key Facts

The Key Facts book, which is updated annually, covers a wide range of data about higher education, including information on both public and private postsecondary institutions. Its purpose is to address questions and concerns that higher education stakeholders typically pose.

6

2:30

Public Comment - A sign-in sheet is provided for public comment on any of the items above. Adjournment

Page 3: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

January 2012 Draft Minutes of November 2011 Board Meeting Board members present Charley Bingham Ethelda Burk, Chair Roberta Greene Jesus Hernandez Addison Jacobs Sam Shaddox Sam Smith Welcome and Introductions HECB Chair Ethelda Burke opened the meeting at 9:00 a.m. and asked members of the audience and the Board to introduce themselves. She thanked Chancellor Kenyon Chan and his staff for hosting dinner the previous evening. Chancellor Chan offered a few words of welcome. He said UW Bothell is bursting at the seams. Built for 1,800 students, its current enrollment is at 3,700. UWB’s biggest issue is facilities. Developing a capital budget is a significant challenge, Chan said. The Science Tech building is ready to go, but the school needs $63 million to build it. Despite tight budgets, he said the school would continue to grow. He thinks a case can be made for growing the Bothell campus rather than building a new university near Everett. Consent Agenda Items Approved Action: Jesus Hernandez moved for approval of the consent agenda, which included:

• The September Board Meeting Minutes • HECB 2012 Board Officials, Resolution 11-22 • HECB 2012 Meeting Calendar, Resolution 11-23; and a • New degree program for Bellevue College: Bachelor of Applied Science in Healthcare

Technology and Management, Resolution 11-26

Sam Shaddox seconded the motion, which was unanimously approved.

Page 4: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Minutes of November 2011 Board Meeting Page 2

2012 Strategic Master Plan Update Don Bennett, Executive Director, provided an overview of the master plan update process and a summary of how current fiscal conditions are likely to impact public higher education through 2018. Jan Ignash, Deputy Director for Policy, Planning and Research, provided a more detailed presentation on the plan update, including a progress report on degree completion goals, the probable effect of additional budget cuts on achieving those goals, and recommendations from the Master Plan Update Advisory Committee on the most critical next steps for higher education. A panel of education leaders who have worked on the plan update discussed the top areas on which the state should focus to increase educational attainment. Panel members included:

• Mike Reilly, Executive Director, Council of Presidents; • Charlie Earl, Executive Director, State Board for Community and Technical Colleges; • Kathe Taylor, Policy Director, State Board of Education; and • Chris Thompson, Director of Government and Public Relations, Independent Colleges of

Washington.

Riley said the first three “next steps” outlined in the plan update reflect the goals of the four-year institutions: increase system capacity, strengthen efforts to increase transitions and completion, and maintain commitment to access for low-income students. Keeping the master plan’s original, longer-term degree goals on the table is also important, he said, but we need to focus on what can be done right now.

Making progress toward the longer-term goals means that many new groups of students will need to enroll and complete degree programs at the four-year institutions. With state funding at an all-time low, the four-year institutions wonder to what extent the state will help them in this endeavor, which will require expanded capacity.

Earl said conditions are challenging for the state’s community and technical colleges as well. Budget cuts have already forced enrollment reductions in professional/technical and job skills programs. And next year, when the first cohort of College Bound students arrives, things will be even more constrained, especially if funding cuts in the second half of this biennium are enacted. College Bound students have a contract guaranteeing admission. A large percentage of these students are expected to attend community and technical colleges.

However, Earl agreed the state should not abandon its longer-term master plan goals. Continuing to demonstrate the strong linkage between higher levels of education and more robust economic development might encourage a change in the state mindset, he suggested.

Taylor said working to reduce or eliminate conflicting goals between and among the education sectors should continue to be a priority. Students need to obtain education credentials beyond high school and “we want to think there will be capacity for them in higher education.” Citing the College Bound Scholarship program, she said access is important in all levels of education.

Page 5: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Minutes of November 2011 Board Meeting Page 3

The State Board of Education remains interested in and committed to efforts to increase transitions and dual credit opportunities across the system.

Speaking for the independent colleges, Thompson cited the first three goals of the master plan update as the most important facing the state. The independent institutions want to continue to be seen as partners with the public institutions in achieving state goals. There are 40,000 students enrolled in the 10 major independent colleges of Washington. Transfer students are vital to their mission, as a third of their students come from the two-year public colleges.

Thompson said the state needs to move in the right direction without worrying too much about specifics. Where does it make the most sense to put limited state dollars? Where do you have the opportunity to leverage more? What are most needed? He said if independents do not receive financial aid for their students as proposed by some legislators, a few of the colleges may have to close. Those that remain may be forced to raise their price significantly, which will reduce the diversity of their student bodies.

Board member comment focused on the need to step up advocacy for higher education in face of dwindling state dollars and much-needed public support.

Jacobs – Mobilize K-12 parents and students. Help them understand the possibilities that are worth seeking. Be passionate about the message.

Shaddox - We have a plan in place. What we don’t have is the “why.” This is the message we need to bring to the Legislature and the public.

Bingham – We need to get the community to realize that education is what distinguishes us from the rest of the world. We need to have a significantly higher number of people understand that the public really wants them to have a good education.

Action: Sam Smith made a motion to approve the Master Plan Update (Resolution 11-24). Ethelda Burke seconded the motion, which was unanimously approved.

Passport to College Promise Program Rachelle Sharpe, Director of Student Financial Assistance, was joined by campus and non-profit organization student support managers and service providers:

• Kristi Jewell, Education Support Program Manager, Centralia College • Colleen Montoya-Barbano, Fostering Scholars Program Director, Seattle University • Lisa Predovich, Program Officer, College and Alumni Services, College Success

Foundation

Sharpe provided a brief summary of the report, which covered the first three years of the six-year pilot of the Passport to College Promise Scholarship program. The Passport program was created to increase the number of foster youth participating and succeeding in postsecondary education. Specifically, the program:

Page 6: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Minutes of November 2011 Board Meeting Page 4

• provides former foster youth with financial assistance beyond other state, federal, private and institutional financial aid for which they are eligible;

• provides incentive funding to postsecondary institutions that designate campus support staff, and take other steps to recruit and retain former foster youth; and

• establishes additional student intervention and retention services to foster youth through the College Success Foundation.

The report recommended the Legislature make Passport a permanent state financial aid program with a sustainable funding source.

The panelists described a wide range of support services they provide in working directly with Passport students to increase foster youth access and retention. They talked about barriers and challenges and shared success stories of students who have been helped.

Action: Jesus Hernandez moved for adoption of Resolution 11-25, accepting the Passport to College report and its recommendations. Roberta Green seconded the motion, which was unanimously approved.

Proposed Rules for the Degree-Granting Institutions Act Randy Spaulding, Academic Affairs Director, described the proposed rules change on the Degree-granting Institutions Act, which included various fees charged to authorized schools, adding an exemption category for schools recognized by the Legislature, and providing other clarifying language. Action: Addison Jacobs made a motion to approve Resolution 11-27, authorizing staff to engage in the formal rule-making process. Sam Smith seconded the motion, which was unanimously approved.

Guaranteed Education Tuition Program (GET) Betty Lochner, director of the state’s Guaranteed Education Tuition program, provided an update on the GET program and its future outlook. Lochner’s presentation included an overview of the program, helpful statistics (135,000 total GET accounts with a total fund balance of 1.9 billion as of 6/30/11), and program demographics. She also talked about the current status of the GET program and the issues and directives impacting GET that came out of the 2011 legislative session. Providing tuition-setting flexibility to institutions has direct impact on the pricing of GET units. Another change is the establishment of a GET legislative oversight group made up of four members each from the House and the Senate.

The meeting adjourned at 2 p.m.

Page 7: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Washington Higher Education Coordinating Board • 917 Lakeridge Way SW • PO Box 43430 • Olympia, WA 98504-3430 • 360-753-7800 • www.hecb.wa.gov

greater percentage of K-12 students earn diplomas, and continue to further education.

A high school diploma simply will not prepare one to earn a living wage in today’s knowledge-based economy. A postsecondary certificate, apprenticeship, or degree is essential — as well as improved access to lifelong learning opportunities.

Our higher education institutions — public and private — make a tremendous collective contribution to our economic progress and to our society.

Failing to support increased access and affordability is short-sighted public policy that will produce serious negative longer-term consequences.

Washington’s commitment to educate many more of its citizens to higher levels has taken on added importance in the four years since the state approved its first 10-year Strategic Master Plan for Higher Education.

Students are seeking access in record numbers… and far too many are being turned away. There continues to be a shortage of graduates in the fields of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. College costs — and college debt — are rising rapidly.

Maintaining progress toward the goals established in the 2008 plan is essential to our current and future success as a state. But will we have the resolve to find a way forward in these difficult times?

In 2011, the Higher Education Coordinating Board, working with institutions and education stake-holders throughout the state, assessed the progress being made toward achieving the central goals of the 2008 plan.

The 2012 Update to the Strategic Master Plan outlined here suggests we can and must continue on the path to improvement.

Those who participated agreed, the state needs to fund additional system-wide capacity to produce more degrees, as well as increase access and success among under-represented students.

Like the original plan, the 2012 Update also recognizes the need to improve our entire education system — early learning through graduate school — so that a much

Seven steps to more successful higher education outcomes in Washington State IV. Provide a simple funding initiative to increase the number of graduates; quality of education. Align incentives with statewide

goals for educational attainment. Recognize institutional and sector

missions. Reward improvements rather

than goals or targets. Align higher education with state

needs by providing accountability with other partners, including the Legislature.

V. Define and develop K-12 to post-secondary program pathways. Focus on high employer demand

majors and careers, including the STEM fields.

Provide incentives in STEM and other areas of critical state need.

I. Increase capacity of higher education to serve more students. Expand institutional enrollment capacity in existing institutions, branches, centers, and through online options. Grow capacity in high employer demand areas of study, recognizing they carry higher costs.

II. Maintain commitment to access for low-income students. Renew commitment to and the value of the State Need Grant program.

III. Build on efforts to increase transitions and completion. Fulfill the state’s promise to College Bound Scholars by providing the financial assistance and mentoring services these students need to succeed.

Raising educational attainment during challenging economic times

Strategic Master Plan Update 2012

Charts on pages two and three demonstrate the depth of the cuts to higher education over the last two biennia. They make it clear that continuing to rely on tuition to replace state investment is a short-range strategy at best.

Two things are readily apparent.

1. Unless the state stabilizes higher education funding and begins to reinvest in students, degree goals that can be realized in 15 years will take decades longer to achieve.

2. Without additional state invest-ment, our institutions soon will not be able to enroll enough students to keep up proportionally with population growth — let alone educate a greater percentage of those who are from under-represented groups.

Leverage the state’s investment through the Opportunity Scholarship Fund.

Encourage business and industry leaders to assist in innovation.

VI . Promote accelerated learning programs for high school students and adult learners. Strengthen Launch Year efforts, Prior Learning Assessment, CTC Alternate Math Pathways, I-BEST, and pre-college reform programs.

VII . Maintain commitment to the original 2008 degree goals. Clearly track progress on the degree goals, showing the gap between the master plan goals, progress to date, and the future trajectory. Continue to track Washington’s progress com-pared to the Global Challenge States.

The Evergreen State College

Page 8: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

The 2008 Strategic Master Plan, the state’s first 10-year comprehensive plan for higher education, focused on the need to raise educational attainment significantly.

To measure progress, the plan proposed ambitious degree goals based on an analysis of future work-force needs, and recommended additional state investment to accomplish these goals.

Degree Goals The plan estimated that by 2018, the state’s higher education institu-tions would need to increase degree production as follows.

Mid-Level Degrees: 26,800 to 36,200 annually

Bachelor’s Degrees: 28,600 to 39,000 annually

Graduate, Professional Degrees: 11,200 to 19,800 annually

To achieve the appropriation levels necessary to realize these goals, the plan recommended funding benchmarks based on Global Chal-lenge State comparisons.

It also proposed:

Expanding facilities, distance learning, and technology.

Increasing State Need Grant and State Work Study appropriations to maintain affordability.

Providing incentive funding for achieving key master plan objectives such as increased STEM degree production.

Student Preparation, Success The 2008 plan also proposed:

Strategies to improve early out-reach, preparation, and support for under-represented students.

More programs enabling students to earn early college credit.

Washington’s strategic plans have addressed common objectives over time

2012 Master Plan Update Advisory Committee Violet Boyer, President, Independent Colleges of Washington Ethelda Burke, HECB Chair, Tukwilla School Superintendent Heather Cope, League of Education Voters Randy Dorn, Superintendent of Public Instruction Charlie Earl, Executive Director, State Board for Community and Technical Colleges Chris Endresen, Prosperity Partnership David Fisher, Washington Roundtable

2008 Master Plan: Raise educational attainment Increase degree production, improve student preparation, support economic innovation

Strategic Master Plan Update 2012

Improved support for student transitions to and among postsecondary programs.

Economic Growth, Innovation To strengthen economic vitality, the plan proposed new strategies to interest students in entering high-demand fields such as tech-nology, engineering, science, mathematics, and health care.

And it focused on the need to expand basic and applied research efforts, focus on research commercialization, and adopt a more coherent approach to work-force education.

Since the late 1980s, strategic planning for the state’s higher education institutions has served a set of common objectives.

Expanding system capacity to educate growing numbers of students and increase statewide educational attainment.

Maintaining and expanding affordable access to public higher education.

Holding institutions accountable for high levels of student retention, on-time graduation, and transfer completion, among other measures of success.

Developing new, innovative modes of course delivery for higher education.

Producing more graduates in high-employment fields such as science, technology, engineering, and mathematics.

Emphasizing basic and applied research and research commercialization.

10-year plan needed to increase educational attainment Washington is a leading Global Challenge State — one of a handful of U.S. states with extra potential to succeed in the global economy.

Despite this potential, Washington has fallen behind its peers — and behind many developed nations — in educating its younger citizens.

In establishing a 10-year master plan framework, the Governor and Legislature recognized that raising statewide educational attainment would take many years of sustained funding increases.

The longer planning cycle also was approved to allow for greater latitude to test new initiatives and respond to changing conditions.

Many other states and nations have continued to support postsecondary education during the current economic downturn. They know demand for educated workers will soar once a full economic recovery is under way.

Meanwhile, Washington has cut higher education funding deeply, transferring the cost to students and families.

Rex Fuller, Provost and VP for Academic Affairs, Eastern Washington University Jean Floten, President, Western Governors University—Washington John Gardner, Dean, Bainbridge Graduate Institute Leslie Goldstein, Executive Policy Advisor, Governor’s Office Bill Grinstein, HECB Member Jesus Hernandez, HECB Member, Latino Community Representative Sen. Derek Kilmer, Senate Ways & Means Committee David Mitchell, President, Olympic College

(continued on next page)

Page 2

Page 9: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Strategic Master Plan Update 2012

Tuition alone will not enable our colleges and universities to raise degree production over the longer-term.

The chart at left shows how, with a modest investment, the state can meet its original bachelor’s degree production goal by 2025.

The ascending line represents projected bachelor’s degree production if a +1.7% annual degree production growth rate is maintained. Modest new state investment on an annual basis would be needed to achieve this growth. Continued state budget cuts will halt progress, keeping degree production in the green zone.

Projected bachelor’s degree growth using 2006-10 rate

2012 Master Plan Update Advisory Committee (cont.) Steven Olswang, Provost, City University Eleni Papadakis, Executive Director, Workforce Training & Education Coordinating Board Mike Reilly, Executive Director, Council of Presidents Rep. Larry Seaquist, Chair, House Higher Education Committee Sam Shaddox, HECB Student Member Kathe Taylor, Policy Director, State Board of Education

Doug Wadden, Executive Vice Provost for Academic Affairs, University of Washington Jill Wakefield, Chancellor, Seattle Community Colleges Gena Wikstrom, Executive Director, Northwest Career Colleges

Leadership Group Jan Ignash, HECB Deputy Director for Policy, Planning & Research Jan Yoshiwara, SBCTC Deputy Executive Director of Education Vi Boyer, Eleni Papadakis, Mike Reilly, Kathe Taylor

State budget cuts transfer costs to students, families The chart at the right shows how tuition has been used to replace declining state funding.

Washington is not unique in this respect. Tuition hikes are being imposed across the nation. But they have been particularly acute here, ranging from 14 to 20 percent a year since FY 2009.

Sustained tuition increases of this magnitude coupled with cuts in financial aid will be felt most by those at the lowest income levels.

Page 3

Modest state investment needed to achieve 2008 degree goals

Page 10: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

The consequences of continued budget cutting HECB members register deep concerns about the impact of recent funding decisions

Reduce enrollment to maintain total FTE funding rate. 2011-13 FTE 265,542

7% budget cut FY13 ($160m) - 19,010

New FTE total: 246,532

Impact on Degree Production

Degree production drops due to decreased volume.

Absorb 15% state cut in FY 13

FTE funding drops by $612 per student.

Impact on Degree Production

Degree production drops due to decreased efficiency.

Over-enroll to recapture some revenue from increased tuition.

Impact on Degree Production Indeterminate

Maintain current funding level. Increase tuition another 7%, change student mix, or both.

Impact on Degree Production

Neutral - No Gain

The tables at left show how future state funding levels might impact the number of degrees being produced.

For example, a 15% across-the-board budget reduction for higher education in the second half of the 2011-13 biennium would equate to about $160 million. A cut of this magnitude could produce the types of results shown.

In approving the 2012 strategic plan update at their November 2011 meeting, HECB members registered deep concerns about the impact of recent policy decisions on students, families and the future of public higher education.

One member noted that Mississippi, for decades one of the country’s lowest-performing states educationally, is now referring to Washington as an example of what not to do in the current economy.

An additional proposed across-the-board cut of 15 percent —or $160 million — in FY 2013, and further cuts to financial aid programs also are possible.

These cuts, if enacted, will make it far more difficult for students to complete degree programs and may force many low-income students to withdraw.

The Board Resolution approving the plan updated stated:

“Failure to make progress on all seven recommendations, including a commitment to improve levels of state support for enrollment and student financial aid, will result in significant losses for Washington, not only in talented workers for business and industry, but also in lower median annual household income, a greater percentage of the population unemployed fewer tax revenues for state and local public services, and greater reliance on human and social services.”

Strategic Master Plan Update 2012

Higher Education Coordinating Board PO Box 43430 – 917 Lakeridge Way SW Olympia, WA 98504-3430

Phone: 360-753-7800 www.hecb.wa.gov

Page 4

Potential impact of proposed $160 million cut to higher education in 2012-13

Page 11: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

January 2012

Access, Affordability, Achievement: Annual Report on State Financial Aid Programs Executive Summary The role of financial aid in helping students enroll and succeed in college becomes increasingly important as college prices continue to rise more rapidly than family incomes. The state of Washington has a longstanding commitment to postsecondary education opportunities for all students—regardless of income. The Annual Report of State Financial Aid Programs provides members of the Higher Education Coordinating Board (HECB) and the Legislature with an overview of the previous year’s state aid and college access programs, while highlighting trends in policy and programs. Specifically, the report describes recent state and federal legislative changes in financial aid, explains notable trends in student aid, and details the amount of aid disbursed to needy students in 2010-11. Also included are program briefs for the State Need Grant, State Work Study, GEAR UP, College Bound Scholarship, TheWashBoard.org, and Passport to College for Foster Youth programs. An implementation update for the Aerospace Student Loan Program also is included. Highlights of the report include:

• 4,000 more students received $207 million more in financial aid in 2010-11, than in the previous academic year.

• Average annual loan amounts are increasing for all students.

• Aid for resident, undergraduate students has increased 34 percent over the previous two years.

• The growth in applications for need-based aid has begun to stabilize, but still constitutes a 64 percent rise over a three-year period.

• The number of unserved State Need Grant-eligible students continued to grow for a third year, reaching more than 25,000 unserved in 2010-11. A similar increase is projected for 2011-12.

Page 12: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

DRAFT: Annual Report on State Financial Aid Programs - Executive Summary Page 2

• Significant developments in the State Need Grant program include:

Mid-year funding reduction of $25 million in 2010-11 meant public institutions served more than 3,000 eligible students with their own funds.

The Legislature appropriated an additional $107 million to allow lowest income students to keep pace with public sector tuition increases for 2011-13.

Changes to private award amount policies result in lower award amounts for students attending private institutions.

• Several state student aid programs underwent budget reductions and suspensions, including continued funding reductions and policy changes to the State Work Study program.

• The Legislature appropriated new funding to create the Aerospace Loan and Opportunity Scholarship programs.

There is little doubt that the Great Recession that began in late 2007 has had profound and far reaching impacts on the higher education system in Washington. With demand surging as resources decline and costs grow, policymakers face an unprecedented challenge in maintaining the access and affordability levels necessary to produce enough college graduates to sustain future economic growth. Continuing Washington’s longstanding commitment to the vitality of its financial aid system remains an essential component of any effective strategy for achieving the state’s higher education attainment goals. This report aims to provide decision makers with up-to-date policy context and performance information. The goal is to help ensure that upcoming policy decisions concerning financial aid and higher education generally benefit from a comprehensive picture of the student financial aid program as it exists today.

Page 13: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

1

Keeping college affordable: Annual report on student financial aid

January 26, 2012

Rachelle Sharpe, Director of Student Financial Assistance, HECB Carla Idohl-Corwin, Dean of Student Financial Services, SPSCC

Page 14: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Topics

• Context of the Annual Report on State Aid

• Trends in Student Financial Aid

• Key Program Briefs

• Notable Issues at the Campus Level

2

Page 15: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

3

Context

Even in the great recession, the Legislature has maintained the commitment to keep pace with tuition in SNG funding • In 2011, the program experienced a mid-year cut of $25+ million • Significant growth of eligible student enrollments outstripped funding • The 2011-13 SNG appropriation included an additional $107 million • Made reductions in SNG to student awards at private institutions

State Work Study was reduced by 2/3 from previous levels

Suspended funding for new students in merit and conditional scholarship programs; maintained funding for previous recipients

New funding for Opportunity Scholarships & Aerospace loans

Current interest in “SNG Reform”

Page 16: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Aid to needy students in 2010-11

$2.40 billion expended on 186,800 need-based recipients in 2010-11

4

Federal 70%

State 10%

Other 20%

By Source

Total: $2.40 Billion Federal: $1.67 billion State: $251 million Other: $479 million

Grant 48% Loan

50%

Work 2%

By Type

Total: $2.40 Billion Grant: $1.17 billion Loan: $1.2 billion Work: $41 million

This represents an increase of $200 million and 4,000 students compared to 2009-10, and a 33% increase in a two-year period.

State aid was 10% of total, including $232 million administered by HECB that served 78,600 students.

Page 17: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

State aid budgets 2011-12

5

Public Purpose Program Est. Expenditures

Students Served

Need-Based State Need Grant $267 m 70,000 State Work Study $7.8 m 3,500 Passport to College $1.4 m 432

Merit-Based

WA Scholars $2.3 m 268 WAVE $1 m 188 GEAR UP Scholarships $.4 m 150 American Indian Endowed Scholarship $14,800 14

Targeted Workforce

Future Teachers Conditional Scholarship $40,000 8

Alternative Routes to Teaching $1.5 m 450 GET Ready Math & Science $.97 m 99 Health Professionals $3 m 218 WICHE Professional Student Exchange $71,000 4

Total State Funding $285 m 75,300

Page 18: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Student demand

The number of students filling out the FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid) has increased significantly during the economic downturn. • Total applications received for 2010-11

were 494,000 – a 61% increase from 2007-08.

• Total applications for 2011-12 are 474,000 – 7% above this time last year.

About 51% of need-based students attended community and technical colleges in 2010-11.

6

Page 19: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Student annual debt

About 113,000 needy students borrowed.

Average loan amounts were slightly higher for non-needy students.

Resident Undergraduate Borrowing 2010-11

7

Note: The HECB began collecting data from campuses on ALL federal loans, not just need-based recipients, for 2008-09 and beyond.

Sector

Needy Borrowers

Average Annual Loan

Non Needy Borrowers

Average Annual Loan

4-Year Public 36,900 $8,400 8,000 $11,200 2-Year Public 34,100 $5,500 3,500 $4,900 4-Year Private 10,400 $11,100 2,300 $8,300 Private Career 6,300 $9,100 400 $10,000 Total 87,700 $7,600 14,100 $9,100

Page 20: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Borrowing levels increasing for lowest income

$-

$2,000

$4,000

$6,000

$8,000

$10,000

$12,000

$14,000

2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11

Average Annual Loan Award by Income Level 2006-07 to 2010-11

0-70 % MFI 71-125 % MFI 125+ % MFI

n=41

,090

n=16

,237

n=3,

820

n=59

,928

n=41

,090

n=16

,237

n=20

,592

n=41

,090

n=16

,237

n=6,

197

Source: HECB Unit Record Report submitted by 68 SNG participating institutions Notes: Washington resident undergraduates students receiving need based aid.

n=41

,090

n=16

,237

n=3,

820

n=39

,711

n=16

,801

n=4,

606

n=42

,833

n=17

,843

n=4,

553

n=53

,532

n=19

,673

n=5,

484

8

Page 21: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

9

State Need Grant demand remains high

The enrollment of students qualifying for a State Need Grant has increased sharply, outpacing the available SNG funding.

The number of eligible students increased 26% in a two-year period, creating a four-fold increase of un-served students.

The served students in 2010-11 below includes the “local fund” replacement required of public institutions due to a mid-year $25 M rescission.

65,328 66,364 70,085 72,511 70,376 72,338

3,118 3,583 1,880

1,601 5,498

21,948 25,677

0

20,000

40,000

60,000

80,000

100,000

120,000

2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11

Elig

ible

Stu

dent

s

Year

SNG unserved Served with local funds SNG Served

68,911 68,224 71,686 78,009

92,324

101,133

Page 22: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

10

Differences in the un-served students

The un-served students filed their FAFSAs later (May/August versus Feb./March for two and four-year students respectively).

The un-served start attendance later in the year and attend fewer terms.

The served students are receiving two times the amount of grant aid.

The un-served students borrow $2,500 more per year.

The un-served students attend two-year colleges in greater proportions:

• 75% attend community and technical colleges • 18% attend public four-year • 4% attended private four-year

Page 23: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

11

SNG Historical View

2006-07 Funding 2010-11 Funding Variance Research $ 46,503,800 28.2% $ 75,572,356 32.8% 4.6%

Comprehensive $ 31,879,350 19.4% $ 42,365,151 18.4% -1.0%

Private Four Yr $ 19,958,130 12.1% $ 24,582,877 10.7% -1.4%

CTC $ 62,562,959 38.0% $ 82,597,514 35.8% -2.2%

Private Career $ 3,812,831 2.3% $ 5,372,370 2.3% 0%

Total $164,717,070 $230,490,268

2006-07 FTE 2010-11 FTE Variance Research 11,429 17.0% 13,519 16.5% -0.5%

Comprehensive 10,048 14.9% 10,510 12.3% -2.6%

Private Four Yr 4,461 6.6% 4,833 5.5% -1.1%

CTC 39,267 58.3% 41,879 61.6% 3.3%

Private Career 2,145 3.2% 2,991 4.2% 1.0%

Total 67,348 73,731

Page 24: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

12

SNG expenditures by sector over time

0

20,000,000

40,000,000

60,000,000

80,000,000

100,000,000

120,000,000

140,000,000 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11

Public 4-Yr Private 4-Yr CTC Priv Voc

Page 25: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

13

SNG recipients by sector over time

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

40,000

45,000

50,000

2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11

Public 4-Yr Private 4-Yr CTC Private Career

Page 26: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

14

SNG web-based portal

• Requires campuses to address ineligible edits • Recommends replacement award amounts when applicable

Page 27: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

15

College Bound Scholarship

Offers early promise of financial aid to middle school aged students from low-income families.

Scholarship combines with SNG to cover tuition (@ public rates) plus a small book stipend.

More than 92,000 students have applied.

Expected Graduation Year 2012 2013 2014 2015

Eligible Students 28,093 28,600 29,856 30,549

Complete applications 15,941 15,840 20,376 22,922

Percentage of eligible 57% 55% 68% 75%

Page 28: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

State Work Study (SWS)

Second-oldest state program in the country – serving students and employers for more than 35 years.

Research correlates part-time work experiences with improved retention, persistence, and completion.

Requires positions that relate to students’ academic and career interests whenever possible – real world learning while in college improves the quality of career choices.

Nearly 2,000 participating employers provide matching funds that leverage state assistance to working students.

In 2010-11, employer contributions provided $6.3 million in additional aid to resident students.

16

Page 29: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

SWS earnings 2010-11

17

Sector Amount Earned State Share Employer

Share #

Students Avg.

Earnings

Public Four-Year $6,812,000 $4,818,000 $1,994,000 2,712 $2,500

Private Four-Year $5,888,000 $3,949,000 $1,939,000 1,968 $3,000

Community & Tech. $7,885,000 $5,492,000 $2,392,000 2,874 $2,700

Total $20,585,000 $14,259,000 $6,325,000 7,546 $2,700

7,546 students earned State Work Study in 2010-11.

Employer contributions provided $6.2 million in additional aid to resident students last year (40% of total wages).

Page 30: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Impact of Governor’s Proposal on SWS in 2012-13

Funding was reduced by 66% from FY 2009-11. • About 5,000 fewer students provided work opportunities

in 2010-11 compared to 2009-10. • An estimated 3,500 students will earn $11 million in wages

in 2011-2012.

Governor’s budget proposal suspends SWS in 2012-13. • Would mean that nearly 2,000 Washington employers

would lose productivity generated by SWS student employees.

18

Page 31: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Employer perspective

Survey of employers indicates:

Many graduates hired full-time with same organization.

Employers value and prioritize past work experience when making hiring decisions.

Organizations who partner with and contribute to State Work Study.

• Provide vital community services • Achieve growth as a business • Employ hundreds of students • Provide opportunity to future educators • Offer opportunities for students to gain

significant skills and experiences

19

Page 32: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Aerospace Loan Program Funding

20

• Fiscal Year 2011-12: $250,000 Funds about 51 loans at $4,800 per recipient.

Initial funding is fully committed.

First cohort began training on January 3, 2012.

Interested applicants being told to apply for 2012-13 funding cycle.

• Fiscal Year 2012-13: $1,250,000 Will cover approximately 250 loans.

Page 33: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

January 2012 Joint Report: A Skilled and Educated Workforce Information Item The Master Plan for Higher Education sets aggressive goals for degree production. The Plan acknowledges a need for growth in STEM and Health related programs as the system grows overall to meet the needs of students and Washington. This report is designed to identify high employer demand occupations and further target growth to meet the needs of the economy. The report is required under 28B.76.230 to assess “the number of forecasted net job openings at each level of higher education and training and the number of credentials needed to match the forecast of net job openings.” The Higher Education Coordinating Board “shall produce, jointly with the State Board for Community and Technical Colleges and the Workforce Training and Education Coordinating Board, an assessment of the number and type of higher education and training credentials required to match employer demand for a skilled and educated workforce.” This is the third in the series of biennial reports published by the three agencies in response to the 2004 statute. The results of this report indicate that looking over the long range, gaps between current degree production and employer demand are expected. The analysis looks at current numbers of completers entering the labor force and average annual demand in 2014-2019. The analysis does not make any adjustment to account for net in-migration of educated workers. The report finds that:

• To meet the projected needs of employers, we will need an additional 9,000 completers at the mid level, 10,000 at the bachelor’s level, and 9,000 at the graduate level annually by 2019.

• At the mid level, high demand fields are identified as health shortage occupations; installation, maintenance and repair; manufacturing and production; accounting and bookkeeping; human and protective services; and science technology.

• At the baccalaureate level, high demand fields are identified as computer science, engineering, and health, life sciences and agriculture, and physical science occupations.

• At the graduate level, high demand fields are identified as computer science, engineering, health, life science and agriculture, physical science, and human and protective service occupations.

• Further analysis is required of education fields at all levels. In addition, it appears there may be shortages within the social science and media and communication occupation groups.

Page 34: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

A Skilled and Educated Workforce 2011 Update

Randy Spaulding, Higher Education Coordinating Board Tina Bloomer, State Board for Community and Technical Colleges

Bryan Wilson, Workforce Training and Education Coordinating Board

Higher Education Coordinating Board January 26, 2012

1

Page 35: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Purpose of this report

The report is required under 28B.76.230 to assess “the number of forecasted net job openings at each level of higher education and training and the number of credentials needed to match the forecast of net job openings.”

The report addresses this mandate using the long range occupational forecast and estimates of program graduates who would likely be entering the workforce. It should be noted that: The report does not fully address the impact of new and emerging

occupations and industries (due to limitations of the forecast). The report looks at the post-recessionary period expected during

2014-2019. The report assumes no net in-migration into Washington of

certificate and degree holders. 2

Page 36: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

The report addresses two major issues

1) Identification of High Employer Demand Occupations

2) Aggregate Demand for higher

education degrees and certificates

3

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Page 37: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Education Level

4

Workers with higher levels of education tend to earn more and experience lower rates of unemployment.

At each level there is a range of earnings that varies by field of study and occupation.

20,152 30,229

34,259 36,274 40,305

52,396

65,496

Unemployment

0%

2%

4%

6%

8%

10%

12%

14%

16%

18%

-

20,000

40,000

60,000

80,000

100,000

120,000

Less than High School

High School Graduate

Less than 1 Year College

1+ years college, no

degree

Associate Degree

Bachelor's Degree

Graduate Degree

2010 Wages and Unemployment by Education Level

Unem

ployment Rate

Wag

es

(20t

h Pe

rcen

tile,

Med

ian,

80t

h Pe

rcen

tile)

Source: 2010 American Community Survey. Wages Include civilian employed WA residents age 25-64. Unemployed rate reflects civilian labor force for WA residents age 25-64.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Page 38: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Gap Analysis

• Gaps are calculated based on current supply and anticipated annual demand by education level in 2014-2019.

• For occupations the analysis looks at the size of the gap and occupations with unique education and training requirements.

• The analysis recognizes that training at a variety of levels is required for some occupations.

5

Page 39: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Supply and Demand

6

11,000

26,000

34,000

9,000

10,000

9,000

- 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 45,000 50,000

Graduate / Professional Degree

Bachelor's Degree

Mid-Level / Associate Degree

Annual Supply and Demand of Workers by Education Level 2010 Supply and Annual Average Openings 2014-2019

2010 Completers Entering the Laborforce Additional Degrees Needed Annually by 2019 to Meet Employer Demand

Page 40: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Mid Level Gap Analysis

7

44

584

759

758

1,164

3,186

135

759

602

1,117

1,770

369

- 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 3,500 4,000

Science Technology

Protective Services

Accounting & Bookkeeping

Manufacturing, Production

Installation, Maintenance, Repair

Health Occupations in Shortage*

High Employer Demand Occupations at the Mid Level 2010 Supply compared to 2014-2019 Demand

2010 Completers Entering the Laborforce Additional Supply needed each year to meet demand 2014-2019

*includes only mid-level health occupations with projected shortages

Page 41: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Baccalaureate Gap Analysis

8

105

191

856

2,006

1,560

158

111

719

528

1,276

- 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000

Physical sciences

Life Sciences and Agriculture

Engineering, Software Eng, and Architecture

Health Professions

Computer Science

High Employer Demand Occupations at the Baccalaurate Level. 2010 Supply compared to 2014-2019 Demand

2010 Completers Entering the Laborforce Additional Supply needed each year to meet demand 2014-2019

Page 42: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Graduate Gap Analysis

9

273

526

913

753

1,181

1,987

201

355

220

428

681

718

- 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000

Physical sciences

Life Sciences and Agriculture

Human and Protective Service

Engineering, Software Eng, and Architecture

Computer Science

Health Professions

High Employer Demand Occupations at the Graduate Level. 2010 Supply compared to 2014-2019 Demand

2010 Completers Entering the Laborforce Additional Supply needed each year to meet demand 2014-2019

Page 43: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Where have we made progress?

958 995 1,105 1,318 1,419

1,695 1,696 1,695

734 796 851

925 1,001

1,058 1,190 1,155

-

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

3,000

3,500

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

Annual Registered Nursing Program Completions 2003-2010

Associate Baccalaureate

Source: Health Professions Education In Washington State: 2003—2010 Completion Statistics. Workforce Training and Education Coordinating Board, 2011

10

Page 44: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

• A higher share of the workforce is employed by the Aerospace industry in Washington than in any other state – and we rank second to California in overall aerospace employment.

• Recent increases in the Boeing orders have yet to be reflected in detailed labor market forecasts for the aerospace industry.

• However, employer surveys and Census data, allow us to identify the general mix of occupations used in Washington’s aerospace industry.

Aerospace Workforce Requirements

11

Page 45: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Key Aerospace Occupational Groups

Occupational Group

Approximate Recent Labor

Force

Primary Education Level(s)

Engineers & Engineering Managers (primarily Aerospace & Industrial ) 14,000 BA, some grad

Aircraft Assembly & Maintenance Specialties 8,000 Certificates, some AA & OJT

IT – Primarily Programmers, Engineers and Scientists 6,000 BA

Procurement, Budget, Logistics, Operations Research 4,000 BA, some certificates

Drafting & Engineering Technicians 3,500 AA, Certificate, BA

Machinists 3,000 Certificates

General Production & Assembly Occupations 3,000 Certificates, OJT

Inspectors, testers, samplers, incl. transportation inspectors 3,000 Certificates, OJT

Computer & Numerical Controlled Manufacturing 2,000 Certificates

Production Supervisors 1,600 BA to OJT

12

Page 46: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Next Steps

Work on final printed report is in progress. Series of follow-up briefs:

• Aerospace industry • Education and related occupations • Healthcare occupations

13

Page 47: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Contact: Randy Spaulding, Higher Education Coordinating Board,

[email protected].

Tina Bloomer, State Board for Community and Technical Colleges, [email protected].

Bryan Wilson, Workforce Training and Education Coordinating Board, [email protected].

14

Questions?

Page 48: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

January 2012 Academic Program Database Information Item Proactive planning that identifies where growth is needed in the higher education system depends upon solid research and planning tools. In 2011, the U.S. Department of Education Institute of Education Sciences awarded Washington $17.3 million to build the Evergreen State P-20 Program, a state longitudinal data system (SLDS) that will incorporate education and workforce data from multiple state agency partners to better inform statewide and regional policy and planning. The system will provide a wider array of data, improved analytic capability, and greater access while continuing to include protections for individual privacy and confidentiality in compliance with state and federal regulations. A portion of these U.S. Department of Education fund dollars, $586,000, was awarded to the Higher Education Coordinating Board (HECB) to build a program database to provide an accurate listing of all academic programs that fall under HECB responsibility. Until now, the HECB has maintained three disparate sources of data regarding authorization of the following:

1. New degree programs offered by the public baccalaureate institutions.

2. Degree programs offered to veterans through GI Bill benefits.

3. Institutions of higher education authorized to operate in Washington, including the degrees they offer.

Because the HECB data for public and private programs have resided in different data locations that are not aligned, it is not currently possible to provide a picture of where there may be gaps in program offerings to students throughout the state. To conduct effective statewide strategic planning for higher education in Washington, questions such as “How many and what types of programs are available to the residents of Snohomish County?” must be addressed. To answer such a simple question today, HECB staff would need to individually contact more than 60 public and private institutions. One of the most important uses of the new database is to provide a critical tool in the state coordination and planning “tool kit.” For example, the System Design Plan provides structure and a process for the expansion of programs, facilities and technology to improve access to higher education in Washington.

Page 49: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Academic Program Database Page 2

In 2010, the Legislature passed SSB 6355, which established the System Design Plan as state law. The System Design Plan complements and carries forward the goals of the Strategic Master

Plan for Higher Education—most importantly the goal to significantly increase degree production. But without strong planning tools, such as the program database, it is difficult to implement the System Design Plan without huge demands upon both HECB and institutional staff time. The new academic program database will consolidate existing disparate information on academic programs into a single program database to provide fast, accurate electronic information. The database will include all institutions operating in Washington and all programs available by location—main campus, branch campus, teaching site, university center, and distance learning. When combined with other components of the P-20 Evergreen Data System, the HECB program database will allow staff to add information about enrollments, completions and other variables to programs to address policy questions such as whether completion rates in the same or similar programs vary by location, delivery mode, or institutions. It also will allow the HECB to institute a new systematic program review process that tracks student enrollment patterns across sectors, identifies gaps in regional program delivery, and helps expand program diversity in targeted regions of the state. A systematic program review process is an important tool in the tool kit to implement the System Design Plan. Another important feature of the new program database is that it will provide up-to-date information to institutions and to students. For institutions, the database will enhance the user interface and data quality for the existing database of all currently approved degree programs—public and private. For students, it will provide a list of institutions, by location, that offer programs in areas of interest. Building a comprehensive academic program database has been attempted three times before over the past 15 years. Efforts failed because of a lack of resources and key employee turnover. The current effort has adequate resources and staff devoting significant time and attention to the project. Twelve HECB staff members from both the information technology and policy divisions are involved in building the database. The target date for completion of the program database is June 30, 2012. As of the date of this report, the project is on track to meet that target deadline. (The Project Schedule is attached to this Information Item.) The November 2011 Quality Assurance Report for the HECB program database, required by the Office of Financial Management to ensure that each portion of the SLDS grant is successful, was positive and made no additional recommendations. The report noted that the HECB project is making good progress. It has strong project leadership, project management, technical support, and user participation. Its objectives are clear and well supported by its leaders and users. Internal staff and contractor capacity appear sufficient to support and complete the project as scheduled. To date, the project has completed its data and functional requirements and has moved into development. 1 1 “Quality Assurance Report. Washington State Higher Education Coordinating Board Academic Data System. Part of the OFM P20 Program.” (November 11, 2011). Author: Briskin Consulting for the Office of Financial Management, State of Washington.

Page 50: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Academic Program Database Page 3

Academic program databases are tools that a number of states routinely use to help make wise decisions regarding the development of new programs and overall system-wide coordination. The HECB academic program database will allow the state to be more proactive in identifying where programs are needed and in providing a listing of current programs to students, parents, institutions, and other stakeholders. Consolidation of public and private program information into a single database is a necessary tool for Washington to track progress on its goals to increase educational attainment.

__________________________________________________________________________

Appendix A

P20 HECB Project Schedule

Major Activity Projected Start Date

Projected End Date

Data Requirements & Documentation 09/19/11 06/29/12

Analysis & Requirements 09/20/11 11/04/11

User Stories 09/20/11 11/04/11

Data Clean-up & Input 11/04/11 03/20/12

Data Verification (by institutions) 12/27/11 03/01/12

Document Scanning 12/19/11 04/23/12

System Documentation 04/23/12 06/29/12

Phase 1 (Internal HECB Functionality) Analysis, Code & Test

Iteration 1 09/14/11 11/10/11

Iteration 2 12/08/11 01/18/12

Iteration 3 01/19/11 02/16/12

Phase 2 (External Access) Analysis, Code & Test

Iteration 1 02/17/12 03/15/12

Iteration 2 06/16/12 04/19/12

Iteration 3 04/20/12 05/17/12

Iteration 4 05/18/12 06/18/12

Page 51: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Higher Education Coordinating Board

January 26, 2012 Jan Ignash, Deputy Director, HECB

Academic Program Database: A Key Tool in the Toolkit

1

Page 52: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

2

Hand-out

(The HECB Academic Programs Database within the context of the larger SLDS Grant.)

The P-20 Evergreen State Longitudinal Data System (SLDS)

Page 53: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

3

1. Provide a comprehensive listing of all programs —public and private.

2. Improve accuracy and consistency of current program information for HECB staff, institutions and students.

3. Enhance user access and interface.

4. Allow proactive planning to implement System Design.

5. Implement systematic program review without unduly burdening institutions.

Proactive Strategic Planning: A Key Tool in the Toolkit

Page 54: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

4

Currently the HECB maintains three academic program databases regarding authorization of:

1. New degree programs at the public baccalaureates

2. Degree programs offered to veterans through GI Bill benefits

3. Institutions of higher education to operate in Washington state, including the degrees they offer

One Database to Consolidate All Programs

Page 55: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

5

Logistics

Building a comprehensive database requires: • Staff:

a dozen HECB staff 2 developers 1 web designer ~2,000 hours in 2011

• Resources: $586K of the $17.3M SLDS grant funds

• Deadline: June 30, 2012 completion

Page 56: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

6

Phase One • Revise the existing web pages used by SAA & Program Approval

staff to enhance usability and improve reporting and analytical capabilities.

• Create comparable web pages for the Degree Authorization staff. • Revise the existing program business layer and database to

increase efficiency and improve data quality.

Phase Two • Create a web-based submission process for degree program

proposals from the public baccalaureates and the State Board for Community and Technical Colleges (SBCTC).

• Create a web-based mechanism for approved institutions to review program information.

• Make the program data available and searchable via the web for external stakeholders.

Flow of Work

Page 57: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

7 7

Wireframe of Program List

7

Page 58: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

8

Page 59: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

9

Page 60: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

10

Page 61: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

11

Questions?

Jan Ignash, Deputy Director Policy Planning and Research

Higher Education Coordinating Board [email protected] (360) 704-4168

Page 62: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

January 2012 Status Report on Program Approvals January through December 2011 Information Item This report has been developed to provide the Higher Education Coordinating Board (HECB) a summary of 2011 program approval activity and outcomes. It lists programs and program extensions in each stage of the approval process as of December 31, 2011. No Board action is necessary at this time. Introduction During 2011, nine new degree programs and six moderate degree changes were approved. This is down somewhat from 2010, when 11 new degree programs and six moderate degree changes were approved. In addition, 10 program extensions to new locations or by distance delivery were approved, up from seven in 2010. New Degree Programs: The new degree programs approved in 2011 were designed to serve 363 FTE students at full enrollment, including 123 undergraduate and 240 graduate FTE students.

Two new degree programs are STEM programs: Central Washington University’s (CWU) M.S. in Computational Science and UW’s Master of Sustainable Transportation.

One program fits both STEM and health categories: Bellevue College’s (BC) B.A.S. in Healthcare Technology and Management.

One program is STEM-related: University of Washington’s (UW) Master of Computational Finance and Risk Management

One program is health-related: Washington State University’s (WSU) Ph.D. in Prevention Science (which includes an M.A. as a stepping stone).

Four programs feature hybrid delivery: CWU’s M.S. in Law and Justice, UW’s Master of Sustainable Transportation, UW Bothell’s M.F.A. in Creative Writing and Poetics, and WSU’s Ph.D. in Prevention Science.

One program features simultaneous face-to-face and online delivery: UW’s M.S. in Computational Finance and Risk Management.

Page 63: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 2

Seven programs are self-supporting: BC’s B.A.S. in Healthcare Technology and Management; CWU’s M.S. in Computational Science and M.S. in Law and Justice; UW’s M.S. in Computational Finance and Risk Management and Master of Sustainable Transportation; UW Bothell’s M.F.A. in Creative Writing and Poetics; and UW Tacoma’s Master of Accounting. This is a departure from prior years, when most programs were state-funded.

Moderate Degree Changes: Seven degree titles were added and five were eliminated. Six program options were converted into four degrees (two of which have two options each); two degrees were consolidated into a single degree; and two degrees were upgraded from master’s to specialist. Program Extensions: Nine extensions of existing programs were approved to serve students at new locations in Washington or by distance delivery. At full enrollment, these program extensions will serve 214 FTE students, including 170 undergraduate and 44 graduate FTE students. Eight of nine use distance delivery, one uses a teaching site at Lake Washington Technical College, and eight are self-supporting. A tenth program extension will serve 71 undergraduate FTE students in Abu Dhabi in the United Arab Emirates. These students are not included in the totals above because they are not Washington students. This program extension is self-supporting. Self-Supporting Programs: As noted, seven of the nine new degree programs approved in 2011 are self-supporting, as are nine of the 10 program extensions. This represents a sharp increase from 2010, when only one new degree program and two program extensions were self-supporting. In 2012, the number of self-supporting master’s programs is expected to remain high as institutions respond to demand while working within budget constraints. Background The HECB is charged with approving academic programs and off-campus facilities, including teaching sites and centers. In September 2005, the Board adopted revised Program and Facility

Approval Policies and Procedures, which define criteria for approving programs and off-campus facilities, and provide opportunities for interested parties to give feedback. In March 2009, the Board approved a revision introducing moderate degree change proposals to accommodate programs that evolve but differ only moderately from existing programs. In November 2009, the Board approved the System Design Plan, which was endorsed by the Legislature in SSB 6355. The Plan calls for an “expand on demand” focus for both short- and long-term growth in higher education, representing a philosophy that is responsive to student, community, and employer demand. In June 2011, the Board approved a policy revision to align program approval and review more closely with the provisions of the Plan. A revised Program

and Facility Approval Policies and Procedures has not been released, pending clarification from the Legislature on the role of the HECB’s successor agency in program approval and review.

Page 64: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 3

RCW 28B.76.230(5) gives the HECB approval authority in the following areas:

New degree programs developed by a public four-year college or university, new applied baccalaureate degree programs developed by a community or technical college (CTC),1 and moderate changes to existing programs. Concentrations, specializations, or certificate programs of a depth and/or length that approach or exceed the requirements of an undergraduate major or a master’s degree are subject to the same approval process as degree programs.

Creation of off-campus programs by a public four-year college or university.

New degree programs and creation of off-campus programs by an independent college or university in collaboration with a community or technical college.

Purchase or lease of major off-campus facilities by a public four-year college or university or a community or technical college.

Creation of higher education centers and consortia. The rest of this report documents activity in each of these approval authority areas in the order listed above. New Degree Programs Developed by a Public Four-Year College or University, New Applied Baccalaureate Degree Programs Developed by a Community or Technical College, and Moderate Changes to Existing Programs RCWs 28B.76.230(5)(a) and 28B.76.230(5)(f) authorize the HECB to approve graduate and baccalaureate degree programs, including applied baccalaureate degree programs. The approval process for new degree programs involves two applications. First, a planning notice of intent is submitted by four-year institutions for baccalaureate and graduate degree programs; or a statement

of need is submitted by community and technical colleges for applied baccalaureate programs. If a planning notice of intent or statement of need is approved, the institution is granted permission to develop a full proposal, which it later submits for review. The approval process for moderate changes to existing programs generally involves a single application called a moderate degree change proposal; however, HECB staff may determine during the course of moderate degree change review that a full proposal is required. Programs in each stage of the approval process are listed in appendices as follows:

Appendix A – Planning Notices of Intent (PNOIs) and Statements of Need under Review as of 12/31/11

Appendix B – Programs with Permission to Develop Full Proposals as of 12/31/11

1 In 2005, the Legislature passed HB 1794, which allowed four CTCs to offer a limited number of applied baccalaureates on a pilot project basis. SSSB 6355 moved CTC applied baccalaureate programs from pilot to regular status effective June 10, 2010. Proposals are subject to approval by both the State Board for Community and Technical Colleges (SBCTC) and the HECB.

Page 65: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 4

Appendix C – Full and Moderate Degree Change Proposals under Review as of 12/31/11

Appendix D – Programs Approved in 2011

Appendix E – Approvals Modified or Sunset in 20112

Creation of Off-Campus Programs by a Public Four-Year College or University RCW 28B.76.230(5)(b) authorizes the HECB to approve the extension of existing degree programs to new locations or via distance delivery. Program extensions approved during 2011 are listed in Appendix F. There were no program extensions in process as of 12/31/11. New Degree Programs and Creation of Off-Campus Programs by an Independent College or University in Collaboration with a Community or Technical College RCW 28B.76.230(5)(e) authorizes the HECB to approve new degree programs and creation of off-campus programs by an independent college/university in collaboration with a community or technical college. There was no approval activity during 2011. Purchase or Lease of Major Off-Campus Facilities by a Public Four-Year College or University or a Community or Technical College Subparagraphs (b) through (d) of RCW 28B.76.230(5) authorize the HECB to approve major new off-campus instructional facilities within the following categories: teaching site, center, system campus, or new four-year institution. The HECB approves the acquisition of major off-campus instructional facilities (those in excess of 6,000 square feet and/or with an annual lease cost in excess of $60,000 and/or those with unimproved property of one-half acre or more). There was no approval activity during 2011. Creation of Higher Education Centers and Consortia RCW 28B.76.230(5)(d) authorizes the HECB to approve the creation of higher education centers and consortia. There was no approval activity during 2011.

2 Occasionally the HECB modifies prior approvals, or approval expires (sunsets) before an institution is able to complete certain steps in development of a proposal or implementation of a program.

Page 66: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 5

Appendix A

Planning Notices of Intent (PNOIs) and Statements of Need under Review as of 12/31/11

University of Washington Bothell

Bachelor of Science in Computer Engineering Anticipated enrollment: 20 FTE first year (2013-14); 40 FTE at full enrollment (2017-18). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period ends 1/6/12). This hybrid delivery program would serve students seeking to become engineers with expertise in the intersection of computer hardware and software design.

University of Washington Tacoma

Bachelor of Arts in Hispanic Studies Anticipated enrollment: 12 FTE first year (2012-13); 62 FTE at full enrollment (2017-18). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period ends 1/20/12). This hybrid delivery program would serve students seeking to develop oral, reading, and writing proficiency in Spanish while learning about the complexity of cultures in the Spanish-speaking world.

Page 67: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 6

Appendix B

Programs with Permission to Develop Full Proposals as of 12/31/11

Central Washington University

Bachelor of Arts in Education in Business and Marketing Education Anticipated enrollment: 5 FTE first year (2012-13); 45 FTE at full enrollment (2015-16). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 11/7/11; expires 11/7/13. This self-supporting program would serve students interested in teaching business and marketing in secondary schools.

Bachelor of Arts in Education in Global Literacy Development

Anticipated enrollment: 5 FTE first year (2012-13); 30 FTE at full enrollment (2014-15). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 12/20/11; expires 12/20/13. This self-supporting program would serve students interested in working with communities and educational, government, or international organizations to develop, implement, and administer literacy programs. The degree would be offered online as well as face-to-face in Ellensburg.

Master of Education in Higher Education

Anticipated enrollment: 5 FTE first year (2011-12); 12 FTE at full enrollment (2015-16). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 12/10/10; expires 12/10/12. This self-supporting, hybrid delivery program would serve students interested in administrative positions in institutions of higher education, civic organizations, non-profit organizations, or government organizations.

Eastern Washington University

Bachelor of Arts in Music Informatics Anticipated enrollment: 5 FTE first year (2010-11); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2014-15). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 2/18/10; expires 2/18/12. This program would serve students interested in interdisciplinary study of music, engineering, and computer science, providing them with a combined music and technology degree.

Page 68: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 7

University of Washington Bachelor of Science in Integrated Sciences

Anticipated enrollment: 25 FTE first year (2012-13); 60 FTE at full enrollment (2013-14). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 10/28/11; expires 10/28/13. This program would serve undergraduates interested in teaching, science writing, science policy, or technology law.

Master of Health Informatics and Health Information Management

Anticipated enrollment: 23 FTE first year (2012-13); 40 FTE at full enrollment (2017-18). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 12/10/10; expires 12/10/12. This self-supporting, hybrid delivery program in Bellevue would prepare individuals for leadership positions in health informatics and health information management practice.

Master of Industrial and Systems Engineering

Anticipated enrollment: 12 FTE first year (2012-13); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2016-17). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 12/20/11; expires 12/20/13. This self-supporting program would serve working professionals seeking to develop systems engineering and strategic management skills relevant in complex manufacturing and service system environments. It would be offered simultaneously at the Seattle campus and online.

Master of Science in Global Supply Chain Management

Anticipated enrollment: 20 FTE first year (2012-13); 30 FTE at full enrollment (2013-14). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 11/29/11; expires 11/29/13. This self-supporting, hybrid delivery program would prepare working professionals for the complexities of managing inter-national trade and transportation.

Ph.D. in Hispanic Studies

Anticipated enrollment: 6 FTE first year (2010-11); 18 FTE at full enrollment (2018-19). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 1/16/09; extended 1/14/11; further extended 7/13/11; expires 1/16/12. This program would serve students seeking to work as professors or in non-academic careers in social services, non-governmental organizations, or the Hispanic business community.

Page 69: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 8

University of Washington Bothell

Bachelor of Arts in Global and Public Health Studies Anticipated enrollment: 30 FTE first year (2012-13); 50 FTE at full enrollment (2016-17). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 8/20/10; expires 8/20/12. This program would serve students interested in laying the groundwork for career paths in fields such as health practice, social work, psychology, epidemiology, public service, research, education, international public health, and health policy.

Bachelor of Arts in Interactive Media and Technology

Anticipated enrollment: 50 FTE first year (2009-10); 100 FTE at full enrollment (2011-12). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 9/21/09; extended 11/1/11; expires 3/1/12. This program would serve students wishing to pursue careers in fields such as game development, digital media, visual arts and communications, and information technology. UW Bothell has indicated the full proposal will be submitted under a different name: Bachelor of Arts in Interactive Media and Design.

Bachelor of Science in Climate Science and Policy

Anticipated enrollment: 24 FTE first year (2010-11); 60 FTE at full enrollment (2015-16). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 10/29/09; extended 11/1/11; expires 4/1/12. This program would serve students wishing to pursue careers or enter graduate school in the climate change field. UW Bothell has indicated the full proposal will be submitted under a different name: Bachelor of Science in Climate Science, Energy, and Policy.

Bachelor of Science in Mathematics

Anticipated enrollment: 15-20 FTE first year (2013-14); 25-30 FTE at full enrollment (2015-16). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 10/28/11; expires 10/28/13. This program would serve students interested in pursuing graduate studies or careers related to mathematics.

Page 70: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 9

University of Washington Tacoma

Bachelor of Arts in Law and Policy Anticipated enrollment: 30 FTE first year (2012-13); 80 FTE at full enrollment (2014-15). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 6/2/11; expires 6/2/13. This program would serve students seeking a solid liberal arts foundation for thinking analytically about public policy on current topics such as health care, social policy, and international development.

Doctor of Education in Educational Leadership

Anticipated enrollment: 24 FTE first year (2011-12); 48 FTE at full enrollment (2014-15). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 4/6/11; expires 4/6/13. This self-supporting program would serve educators in administrative positions requiring teaching expertise, leadership skills, policy knowledge, and the ability to promote positive organizational change. It would employ hybrid delivery. In April 2011, the Legislature passed HB 1586, which granted research universities authority to develop doctoral degree programs at their branch campuses.

Master of Arts in Community and Metropolitan Studies

Anticipated enrollment: 10 FTE first year (2010-11); 30 FTE at full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 5/18/09; extended 5/27/11; further extended 11/24/11; expires 5/18/12. This program would serve students seeking to study metropolitan communities using a comprehensive approach that covers a wide range of social and economic policies and problems.

Washington State University

Professional Science Master’s Anticipated enrollment: 16 FTE first year (2012-13); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2014-15). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 6/2/11; expires 6/2/13. HECB staff provided guidance on whether to offer tracks as concentrations within a single parent degree or as separate degrees, depending on the extent of curricular overlap among tracks. This self-supporting program would serve students interested in obtaining graduate training in business and a quantitative or scientific field. Students could choose from tracks in molecular biosciences, computational financial mathematics, environmental sustainability, and bioproducts. The program would be offered online and/or by hybrid delivery at the Pullman, Vancouver, and Tri-Cities campuses.

Page 71: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 10

Western Washington University

Bachelor of Arts in Business Sustainability Anticipated enrollment: 15 FTE first year (2011-12); 50 FTE at full enrollment (2015-16). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 8/20/10; expires 8/20/12. This program would serve students interested in analyzing environmental and social issues (e.g., climate change, waste, and pollution) from multiple perspectives and choosing and implementing action steps to deal with those issues successfully.

Professional Science Master’s in Environmental Science

Anticipated enrollment: 20 FTE first year (2010-11); 20-30 FTE at full enrollment (2013-14). HECB staff action: permission to develop a full proposal granted 5/24/10; expires 5/24/12. This self-supporting program would serve students interested in obtaining graduate training in business and environmental science. It would employ hybrid delivery at Peninsula College, Olympic College, and the University Center of North Puget Sound.

Page 72: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 11

Appendix C

Full and Moderate Degree Change Proposals under Review as of 12/31/11

Central Washington University

Educational Specialist in School Psychology Moderate Degree Change

Anticipated enrollment: 11 FTE first year (2012-2013); 11 FTE at full enrollment (2012-2013). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period ends 1/8/12). CWU proposes to change the level of its existing graduate School Psychology degree from Master of Education to Educational Specialist because the Specialist degree level more accurately conveys the length and depth of the curriculum. The change would be contingent on the Legislature granting CWU authority to offer the Educational Specialist degree.

Centralia College

Bachelor of Applied Science in Applied Management Anticipated enrollment: 25 FTE first year (2012-13); 45 FTE at full enrollment (2013-14). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period not applicable).

This program would serve students with strong technical skills developed while earning an Associate in Technical Arts or Associate in Applied Science degree who wish to augment their education and work experience by deepening their understanding of management principles.

University of Washington

Master of Human-Computer Interaction and Design Anticipated enrollment: 30 FTE first year (2012-2013); 30 FTE at full enrollment (2012-2013). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period ended 7/30/11). This program would serve students interested in creating devices and systems that help people with everyday activities that computing can enhance.

Page 73: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 12

Ph.D. in Global Health: Metrics and Implementation Science

Anticipated enrollment: 3-5 FTE first year (2012-2013); 12-16 FTE at full enrollment (2015-2016). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period ended 12/28/11).

This program would serve student interested in measuring health problems and intervention effectiveness across countries and applying scientific methods to improve intervention and program implementation.

Ph.D. in International Studies Anticipated enrollment: 4 FTE first year (2012-2013); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2016-2017). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period ended 12/28/11). This program would equip students to use problem-focused research to address some of the most pressing global challenges facing academics, practitioners, governments, businesses, and non-governmental organizations.

Western Washington University

Bachelor of Arts in Education: General Science – Middle Level Anticipated enrollment: 5 FTE first year (2012-2013); 10 FTE at full enrollment (2014-2015). HECB staff action: currently under review (public comment period ends 1/12/12). This program would serve students interested in teaching science at middle schools.

Page 74: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 13

Appendix D

Programs Approved in 2011

Baccalaureate Bellevue College – Bachelor of Applied Science in Healthcare Technology and Management

Board approval granted 11/17/11, Resolution 11-26.

Central Washington University – Bachelor of Science in Aviation Management Moderate Degree Change (included in same proposal as B.S. Professional Pilot)

Board approval granted 3/31/11, Resolution 11-04.

Central Washington University – Bachelor of Science Professional Pilot Moderate Degree Change (included in same proposal as B.S. in Aviation Management)

Board approval granted 3/31/11, Resolution 11-04. Eastern Washington University – Bachelor of Arts in Education in Early Childhood Education Moderate Degree Change

Board approval granted 1/27/11, Resolution 11-02. University of Washington – Bachelor of Design Moderate Degree Change

Staff approval granted 11/29/11.3 University of Washington Tacoma – Bachelor of Arts in History

Board approval granted 6/30/11, Resolution 11-19.

Master’s Central Washington University – Master of Science in Computational Science

Board approval granted 6/30/11, Resolution 11-15. Central Washington University – Master of Science in Law and Justice

Board approval granted 1/27/11, Resolution 11-01. University of Washington – Master of Science in Computational Finance and Risk Management

Board approval granted 5/19/11, Resolution 11-07.

3 In June 2011, the Board delegated general moderate degree change approval authority to HECB staff. Subsequently, HECB staff exercised this authority by approving UW’s Bachelor of Design program. The Bachelor of Design program is designed to serve students interested in industrial design, interaction design, or visual communication design.

Page 75: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 14

University of Washington – Master of Science in Computational Linguistics Moderate Degree Change Proposal

Board approval granted 6/30/11, Resolution 11-18.

University of Washington – Master of Sustainable Transportation Board approval granted 3/31/11, Resolution 11-05.

University of Washington Bothell – Master of Fine Arts in Creative Writing and Poetics Board approval granted 5/19/11, Resolution 11-06.

University of Washington Tacoma – Master of Accounting Board approval granted 9/29/11, Resolution 11-21.

Washington State University – Master of Arts in Prevention Science (The proposal included both M.A. and Ph.D. The M.A. is a stepping stone to the Ph.D.)

Board approval granted 5/19/11, Resolution 11-08.

Specialist Eastern Washington University – Educational Specialist in School Psychology Moderate Degree Change

Board approval granted 6/30/11, Resolution 11-16. In April 2011, the legislature passed HB 1477, which granted EWU authority to offer educational specialist degrees.

University of Washington – Educational Specialist in School Psychology Moderate Degree Change

Board approval granted 9/29/11, Resolution 11-20.

Doctoral Washington State University – Ph.D. in Prevention Science (The proposal included both M.A. and Ph.D. The M.A. is a stepping stone to the Ph.D.)

Board approval granted 5/19/11, Resolution 11-08.

Page 76: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 15

Appendix E

Approvals Modified or Sunset in 2011

University of Washington

Bachelor of Science in Integrated Sciences Approval to develop a full proposal sunset 6/15/11; however, UW submitted a new planning notice of intent on 9/19/11.

University of Washington Bothell

Bachelor of Science in Electrical Engineering Original conditional approval (7/28/09, Resolution 09-14) was revised 6/30/11, Resolution 11-17.

Page 77: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 16

Appendix F

Program Extensions Approved in 2011

Central Washington University

Bachelor of Arts in Law and Justice Online (Included with four other social science programs in a single location notice of intent).

Anticipated enrollment: 10 FTE first year (2011-12); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: approval granted 8/5/11.

This online, self-supporting program extension will prepare students for professional employment in the criminal justice system or entry into graduate or law school.

Bachelor of Arts in Psychology Online (Included with four other social science programs in a single location notice of intent).

Anticipated enrollment: 10 FTE first year (2011-12); 20 at FTE full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: approval granted 8/5/11. This online, self-supporting program extension will serve students interested in studying behavior and its mental, physiological, and social causes.

Bachelor of Arts in Sociology Online (Included with four other social science programs in a single location notice of intent).

Anticipated enrollment: 10 FTE first year (2011-12); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: approval granted 8/5/11. This online, self-supporting program extension will serve students interested in studying social life, social change, and the social causes and consequences of human behavior.

Bachelor of Science in Information Technology and Administrative Management Online

Anticipated enrollment: 20 FTE first year (2011-12); 40 FTE at full enrollment (2013-14). HECB staff action: approval granted 11/29/11. This online, self-supporting program extension will prepare students for careers in information technology or retail management and technology.

Page 78: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 17

Bachelor of Science in Interdisciplinary Studies: Social Sciences Online (Included with four other social science programs in a single location notice of intent).

Anticipated enrollment: 10 FTE first year (2011-12); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: approval granted 8/5/11. This online, self-supporting program extension will serve students wishing to specialize their study with different course selection options than those available within a traditional departmental major.

Bachelor of Science in Social Services Online (Included with four other social science programs in a single location notice of intent)

Anticipated enrollment: 10 FTE first year (2011-12); 20 FTE at full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: approval granted 8/5/11. It would be extended via online delivery. This online, self-supporting program extension will serve students interested in working in the human services delivery system.

Master of Education in School Administration Online

Anticipated enrollment: 10 FTE first year (2011-12); 20 at FTE full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: approval granted 8/24/11. This online program extension will serve teachers interested in becoming principals. It would not be self-supporting.

Eastern Washington University Bachelor of Science in Dental Hygiene Lake Washington Institute of Technology in Kirkland

Anticipated enrollment: 15 FTE first year (2011-12); 30 FTE at full enrollment (2012-13). HECB staff action: approval granted 7/18/11. This self-supporting program extension will serve students interested in pursuing dental health careers for which preparation beyond a dental hygiene certificate or associate degree is required or desirable. With this extension, the EWU discontinued the program at Shoreline Community College. EWU has not previously offered programs at Lake Washington Institute of Technology’s Kirkland facility.

Page 79: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Status Report on Program Approvals – January through December 2011 Page 18

Business and Marketing Education Add-On Endorsement Online

Anticipated enrollment: 15 FTE first year (2011-12); 24 FTE at full enrollment (2014-15). HECB staff action: approval granted 5/4/11. This online, self-supporting program extension will serve students interested in teaching business and marketing in secondary schools. Although the endorsement is not a degree program, its 58-credit curriculum was extensive enough to trigger HECB staff review of the program’s extension.

University of Washington Bachelor of Science in Aerospace Engineering United Arab Emirates University (in the city of Abu Dhabi in the United Arab Emirates)

Anticipated enrollment: 36 FTE first year (2013-14); 71 FTE at full enrollment (2018-19). Board action: approval granted 6/8/11. This self-supporting program is designed to serve United Arab Emirates students interested in working in the aerospace industry. It would be modeled after the B.S. Aeronautical and Astronautical Engineering program offered by the UW’s Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics in Seattle. However, it would include significantly less astronautics content and would not share UW’s ABET accreditation. Therefore, it would be extended under a different name than its parent program. These content and accreditation issues caused this program extension to be subject to Board, rather than staff approval.

Page 80: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

January 2012 Key Facts about Higher Education Information Item “Key Facts about Higher Education” in Washington provides vital data to chart higher education’s progress and challenges. First published in 2002 by the Higher Education Coordinating Board, this annual report highlights Key Facts about Washington’s postsecondary institutions, including faculty, students, budgets, and financial aid.

The report provides basic information about the state’s higher education system, including institutions, enrollment figures, and budget information. It also provides comparisons with other states on important statistics, offers information showing how the state benefits from higher education, and provides data on some of the current challenges facing higher education in Washington.

Page 81: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Higher Education Coordinating Board

January 26, 2012 Jan Ignash, Deputy Director, HECB

Key Facts: Another Tool in the Toolkit

1

Page 82: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Overview

• Re-tooled four years ago

• 10 chapters from “Quick Facts” to “Next Steps”

• Reader-friendly—typically one graphic per page with simple narrative

• Geared toward legislators and their staff, and external stakeholders

• Not intended to duplicate OFM’s Fact Book

2

Page 83: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Headcount Enrollments Fall 2010

Fall 2010 Student Headcounts

Public community and technical colleges 270,573

Public baccalaureate undergraduate 96,194

Public baccalaureate graduate/professional 22,129

Private baccalaureates 51,740

Total system headcount 440,636

3

Page 84: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Degrees Awarded

Award Level Number % Change

from 2008-09

Associates 22,195 5% ↑

Bachelor’s 22,851 4% ↑

Master’s 5,138 8% ↑

Doctorate 916 No change

Professional 717 5%↑

Degrees Awarded by Public Institutions, 2009-10

4

Page 85: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Degree production has grown over the past decade

5

Page 86: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

State baccalaureate institutions producing degrees at faster pace

6

Page 87: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Graduation rate for transfer students has improved

Washington Public Baccalaureate Three-Year Graduation Rate for Transfer Students with an Associate Degree from a Washington Community College

Baseline (Annual Average of 1997-98 to 2001-02) to 2009-10

7

Page 88: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Large majority of Washington freshmen at four-year public institutions return for the sophomore year

Freshmen to Sophomore Retention, Washington Public Baccalaureate Baseline (Annual Average of 1997-98 to 2001-02) to 2009-10

8

Page 89: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

Moderate Growth in Graduate Degree Production

Graduate Degrees Awarded in Washington by Type, 2002-2010 All Public and Private Institutions

9

Page 90: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

High Demand Degree Awards, 2002-2010

Program Area 2002-03 2005-06 2009-10

Allied Health 5,018 6,995 8,867

Computer Sciences 1,877 1,222 1,597

Engineering Tech. 1,936 1,821 2,844

Engineering (4-yr.) 1,264 1,293 1,263

Math, Biol./Physical Sciences 1,974 2,215 2,619

Transfer STEM (2 yr.) 1,056 1,059 1,187

Total Public Higher Ed. 13,169 14,730 18,709

10

Page 91: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

11

Page 92: PRELIMINARY BOARD MEETING AGENDA Cascade Conference … · 2012. 2. 1. · Cascade Conference Rooms A & B . State Board for Community & Technical Colleges : ... The Annual Report

A Darker Tone in Key Facts

We are not on track • Washington is faced with a deep dilemma. How can it

make the investment in students it needs to make when revenue desperately needed to provide basic social and health support to our most vulnerable populations is being reduced? To date, there does not appear to be an answer to this question.

• However, one thing is for certain. If we continue down the current path, our higher education institutions will become far less accessible and affordable, more narrowly focused, and less capable of meeting future economic and societal needs. And this is exactly the opposite direction we should be heading . . .

12