8/13/2019 Pp v Salanguit

1/2

8/13/2019 Pp v Salanguit

2/2

"MASK

85 /IIR7MS H77H@AMS JVM XHA@S@J2 6T JVM UH??HLJ 6L JV?MM Q?6RLS7K f8g JVHJ JVM?M UH7 L6 >?6OHOAM IHR7M J6 7MH?IV T6? S?RQ

>H?H>VM?LHA@Hj f:g JVHJ JVM 7MH?IV UH??HLJ UH7 @77RMS T6? N6?M JVHL 6LM 7>MI@\I 6eML7Mj HLS f9g JVHJ JVM >AHIM J6 OM

7MH?IVMS UH7 L6J SM7I?@OMS U@JV 7RkI@MLJ >H?[IRAH?@J25

l &L JVM \?7J Q?6RLS, @J UH7 JM7[\MS O2 +%&8 #SNRLS .HSRH, JVM @LJMAA@QMLIM 6kIM? UV6 HIJMS H7 H >67MR?=OR2M?

JVHJ UVML VM UMLJ @L7@SM JVM V6R7M 6T JVM HIIR7MS, VM 7HU JVM HIIR7MS QMJ JVM 7VHOR @L JVM IHO@LMJ UV@IV @7 @L JV

?66N 6T JVM HIIR7MS5 "MLIM, JVM?M UH7 >?6OHOAM IHR7M H7 J6 JVM 7VHOR ORJ L6 JM7[N6L2 UH7 6eM?MS @L ?MQH?S7 J

JVM S?RQ >H?H>VM?LHA@H5 !V@7 S6M7 L6J NMHL V6UMXM? JVHJ JVM 7MH?IV UH??HLJ H7 H UV6AM @7 X6@S 6? @LXHA@S5

/II6?S@LQA2, @J UH7 VMAS JVHJ JVM \?7J >H?J 6T JVM 7MH?IV UH??HLJ, HRJV6?@Z@LQ JVM 7MH?IV 6T HIIR7MS=H>>MAAHLJ^7

V6R7M T6? HL RLSMJM?N@LMS mRHL[J2 6T -3#40, @7 XHA@S, MXML JV6RQV JVM 7MI6LS >H?J, U@JV ?M7>MIJ J6 JVM 7MH?IV T6

S?RQ >H?H>VM?LHA@H, @7 L6J5

l &L JVM 7MI6LS Q?6RLS, JVM HIIR7MS HXM?7 JVHJ 6LM UH??HLJ 7V6RAS OM @77RMS T6? 7VHOR, 6LM UH??HLJ 7V6RAS OM

@77RMS T6? NH?@bRHLH HLS 6LM UH??HLJ 7V6RAS OM T6? S?RQ >H?H>VM?LHA@H5 !VM E6R?J VMAS JVHJ 6LM UH??HLJ U6RAS

7RkIM 7@LIM HAA HIJ7 UM?M I6XM?MS RLSM? -M>ROA@I /IJ *65 PMI@HA AHU JVHJ SMHA7 7>MI@\IHAA2 U@JV SHLQM?6R

S?RQ7 UV@IV H?M 7RO7RNMS @LJ6 n>?6V@O@JMSo HLS n?MQRAHJMSo S?RQ7 HLS SM\LM7 HLS >MLHA@ZM7 IHJMQ6?@M7 6T

6eML7M7 UV@IV H?M IA67MA2 ?MAHJMS 6? UV@IV OMA6LQ J6 JVM 7HNM IAH77 6? 7>MI@M75

l &L JVM JV@?S Q?6RLS, UV@AM JVM HSS?M77 7JHJMS @L JVM UH??HLJ @7 NM?MA2 n.@LVHQHL +J5, +HL _67M, YRMZ6L E@J2,o JVM

J?@HA I6R?J J66] L6JM 6T JVM THIJ JVHJ JVM ?MI6?S7 6T +MH?IV dH??HLJ I6LJH@LMS 7MXM?HA S6IRNMLJ7 UV@IV @SML[\MSJVM >?MN@7M7 J6 OM 7MH?IVMS, J6 U@JK 8g JVM H>>A@IH[6L T6? 7MH?IV UH??HLJ UV@IV 7JHJMS JVHJ JVM >?MN@7M7 J6 OM

7MH?IVMS UH7 A6IHJMS @L OMJUMML *65 i HLS 88 HJ .@LVHQHL +J?MMJ, +HL _67M, YRMZ6L E@J2j :g JVM SM>67@[6L 6T

U@JLM77 UV@IV SM7I?@OMS JVM >?MN@7M7 H7 nH V6R7M U@JV6RJ H LRNOM? A6IHJMS HJ .@LVHQHL +J5, +HL _67M, YRMZ6L E@J

HLS 9g JVM >MLI@A 7]MJIV 6T JVM A6IH[6L 6T JVM >?MN@7M7 J6 OM 7MH?IVMS5 )L THIJ, JVM >6A@IM 6kIM?7 UV6 ?H@SMS

H>>MAAHLJ^7 V6R7M RLSM? JVM AMHSM?7V@> 6T %6A@IM +ML@6? )L7>MIJ6? -6S6AT6 /QR@AH? I6RAS L6J VHXM OMML N@7JH]ML H

)L7>MIJ6? /QR@AH? ?M7@SM7 @L JVM 7HNM LM@QVO6?V66S @L .@LVHQHL UVM?M H>>MAAHLJ A@XM7 HLS @L THIJ /QR@AH?^7 >AHIM @7

HJ JVM MLS 6T H>>MAAHLJ^7 >AHIM @L .@LVHQHL5 p6?M6XM?, JVM V6R7M ?H@SMS O2 /QR@AH?^7 JMHN @7 RLSML@HOA2 JVM V6R7

6T JVM HIIR7MS HLS @J UH7 ?MHAA2 JVM HIIR7MS UV6 UH7 JVM JH?QMJ5 !VM ?H@S@LQ JMHN MXML \?7J H7IM?JH@LMS JV?6RQV

JVM@? @LT6?NHLJ JVHJ H>>MAAHLJ UH7 @L7@SM V@7 ?M7@SMLIM OMT6?M JVM2 HIJRHAA2 7JH?JMS JVM@? 6>M?H[6L5

:5 !VM NH?@bRHLH T6RLS UH7 I6XM?MS U@JV LMU7>H>M? HLS JVR7 S6M7 L6J THAA RLSM? JVM S6IJ?@LM 6T >AH@L X@MU5 dVHJ UH7 @L

>AH@L X@MU UM?M JVM LMU7>H>M? HLS L6J JVM NH?@bRHLH5 /II6?S@LQA2, JVM NH?@bRHLH @7 @LHSN@77@OAM @L MX@SMLIM ORJ JVM

I6L\7IH[6L @7 XHA@S HLS NR7J OM R>VMAS595 !VM 6IIR>HLJ7 6T JVM V6R7M, M7>MI@HAA2 HIIR7MS=H>>MAAHLJ, ?MTR7MS J6 6>ML JVM S66? SM7>@JM JVM THIJ JVHJ JVM 7MH?IV@LQ

>H?J2 ]L6I]MS 6L JVM S66? 7MXM?HA [NM75 (R?JVM?N6?M, JVM HQMLJ7 7HU JVM 7R7>@I@6R7 N6XMNMLJ7 6T JVM >M6>AM @L7@SM JV

V6R7M5 !VM7M I@?IRN7JHLIM7 bR7[\MS JVM 7MH?IV@LQ >H?J2^7 T6?I@OAM MLJ?2 @LJ6 JVM V6R7M, T6RLSMS H7 @J @7 6L JVM

H>>?MVML7@6L JVHJ JVM MaMIR[6L 6T JVM@? N@77@6L U6RAS OM T?R7J?HJMS RLAM77 JVM2 S6 765 (R?JVM?N6?M, L6 JM7[N6L@M7

T?6N S@7@LJM?M7JMS >H?[M7 UM?M 6eM?MS J6 I6??6O6?HJM JVM 7J6?2 6T JVM HIIR7MS JVHJ JVM >6A@IM R7MS MaIM77@XM T6?IM @L

MLT6?I@LQ JVM UH??HLJ5

!"#$#%&$#, @L E?@N@LHA EH7M *65 Y=B;=P>MAAHLJ -6OM?J6 +HAHLQR@J 2 36 QR@AJ2 6T >677M77@6L 6T @AAMQHA S?RQ7 RLSM? q8P 6T -5/5 *65 P?@76L JM?N ?HLQ@LQ T?6N 7@a fPg N6LJV7 6T #55)-26 7#865, H7 N@L@NRN, HLS T6R

fH2 H

\LM 6T %iCC,CCC5CC @7 VM?MO2 -#G#-+#F HLS +#! /+)F# HLS HIIR7MS=H>>MAAHLJ @7 /EY1)!!#F 6T JVM I?@NM IVH?QMS5 "6UMXM?, JVM

I6L\7IH[6L 6T JVM 8,:;< Q?HN7 6T NH?@bRHLH, H7 UMAA H7 JVM 8858< Q?HN7 6T NMJVHN>VMJHN@LM V2S?6IVA6?@SM, HLS @J7 S@7>67@[6L H7

6?SM?MS O2 JVM J?@HA I6R?J @7 /(()-p#F5

Page 2 o