Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Poster 8B-31IUPAC
Seventh International Congress of Pesticide ChemistryHamburg, Federal Republic of Germany
August 5-10, 1990
DESIGN OF AN HPLC SYSTEMUSING POST-COLUMN DERIVATIZATION
and FLUORESCENCE DETECTIONOPTIMIZED FOR THE HIGH SENSITWITY ANALYSIS
of CARBAMATE PESTICIDES
McDonald, P.D.*; Sims, A.E.; Leveille, W; Wildman, W.J.;Hansen, J.; Zener, V.; Morawski, J.
Waters Chromatography Divivision, Millipore Corporation34 Maple St., Milford, MA 01757 USA
Use of liquid chromatography with post-column derivatization andfluorescence detection for the analysis of carbamate pesticides was firstreported by Moye and co-workers in 1977 (1). More recentlv thistechnique has formed the basis for U.S.E.P.A. Methods 531 and 531.1 fordrinking water analysis as well as the A.O.A.C method for crop residueanalysis.
We will describe the design and development of an integrated system forcarbamate analysis. Some special features of this system include:
O a special column and separation conditions which yieldoptimum selectivity, for the eleven analytes specified in theEPA methods;
[3 new post-column derivatization hardware componentsincluding a proprietary reaction coil and patentedcountercurrent heat exchanger designed for maximumsensitivity and reliability;
[J a new, highly sensitive fluorescence detector with a xenonsource.
The ability of this newly developed chromatographic system to exceed theEPA performance standards and lower detection limits forN-methylcarbamate and N-methylcarbamoyloxime pesticide analysis byan order of magnitude will be demonstrated (2).
(1) Moye, HA; Scherer, S.J.; St. John, P.A., Anal. Lett., 10, 1049-1073 (1977).(2) McDonald, PD; Leveille, W; Sims, AE; Wildman, WJ; Zener, V; Scarchilli, AD,
Advances in Water Analysis and Treatment, Proceedings Volume, Water QualityTechnology Conference, Philadelphia, PA, November 12-16, 1989, American WaterWorks Association, Denver, CO, 1990, pp. 631-649.
i
. GoalI II I
To increase the sensitivity
and the reliabilityof an HPLC method
with on-line post-columnderivatization and
fluorescence detection
for the high sensitivity analysis
of carbamate pesticides.
ApproachI
Improve reversed phase
gradient LC separation.
Optimize post-column reactionconditions
Integrate improvements in
post-column reactor design into
a complete analytical system.
Optimize detection parameters.
ExperimentalCarbamate Analysis System
including:WatersModel 600EMultisolventDeliverySystemController;
Fluid Handling Unit with integral post-col'un_ reaction system;Post-column Reagent Delivery. System;
Temperature Control Module & Column Heating Chamber;Model 470 Scanning Fluorescence Detector
Carbamate Analysis Column3.9 x 150 ram, 4gin spnerical
octadec'ylsilyl-bonded silica packing
Milli-Q ®Water System
HPLC grade solvents, highpurity reagents & standards
LC SeparationCompare EPA Method 531 &
NPS Method 5 separations withour improved ternary gradient.
Baseline resolution of all analytesusing small volume, high efficiencycolumn with optimum selectivity;
Resolution maintained with sampleinjections of one milliliter of water;
Two-fold increase in sensitivity withternary gradient using acetonitrile;
Twenty-two minute analysis permits' two sample-per-hour throughput.
EPAMethod 531IIII I I IIIIIII IIII I I IIII
DeuteriumSource235 nmex _./419 nm em_.
5 Methanol/Acetonitrile [4:1]20% to 70% in water
Lineargradientt_Bondapak"rMC18packing in
23 RadiaI-Pak®Cartri_dge7 9
6 1- Aldicarb sulfoxide2 - Aldicarb sulfone
' 3 - Oxamyl
L 4 Methomyl
5 3-Hydroxycarbofuran6 Aldicarb7- Carbofuran8 - Carbaryl
k._., _, . _ .., 9 1-NaphtholI I I I
0 S I0 Ib
M_nule2$
EPA-NPSMethod 5
DeuteriumSource230 nm ex _./418 nmem _.
Methanol/Water15:85 to 100:0 in 32 min
, LineargradientUltrasphere®ODS 5 _m
4.6 x 250 mm
2 _ 1 - Aldicarb sulfoxide2 - Aldicarb sulfone
Decomp. Product of 13-Hgdroxycarbofuran
7 - Aldicarb8- Propoxur
I 9 Carbofuran_ 10 - Carbaryl
,o,_.,._,._,,...,e,i 11 1-Naphthol12 Methiocarb13 - Internal Std.
@1990M_o_e Co_o_rallon
Analytes in EPA Method 531.1 "II III I IIIIII IIIII III IIIII
| O CH 3 2 O CH 3 3 O 4II I 11 I II
CH3-S-C-CH=N-ORI CHa-IIS-?-CH:N-OR (CH3)2N-C--C:N--OR, CH3-? :N-OR
CH3 O CH 3 SCH 3 SCH 3
Aldicarb sulfoxide Aldicarb sulfone Oxamyl Methomyl[Standak_) (Vydate_) (Lannate_)
H 0 CHa-S--C-CH:N-OR O O
3 CH3-/xCH3 C 3
3-Hydroxycorbofuran Aldicarb Propoxur Carbofuran[Temik®) (Baygorx_) (Furadarx_)
H3 --C-NH--CH 3
Carbaryl 1-Naphthol Methiocarb(Sevin_) (Mesurol_)
Optimized HPLC Separation-- - IIIIIIIII I II I IIII III I IIII ||1111 I I II III III III I II I
Carbamate Analysis Column Model 470 FluorescenceDetector0.39 x 15 cm 339 nm ex _/445 nmem
Water/Methanol/AcetonitrileComplexgradient
9 25 ppb Standards400 IlL Injection Volume
2 5 10 ng of each analyte oncolumn34 6 7 ] 11 1 - Aldicarb sulfoxide
2 - Aldicarb sulfone3 - Oxamyl
10 4 - Methomyl5 - 3.Hydroxycarbofuran6 - Aldicarb
__ 78- PropoxurCarbofuran
L _ L_ 9 - Carbary!, _ -" -- _- 10 - 1-Naphthol
0 5 10 15 20 min 11 - Methiocarb
" One mL Sample CapabilityI II I I IIIIII IIII II III IIII I
CarbamateAnalysis Column Model 470 FluorescenceDetector0.39 x 15 cm 339 nmex _./445 nmem
Water/ Methanol/AcetonitrileComplexgradient
1 ppb Standards1000 I_LInjectionVolume
9 1 ng of each analyteon column
: 2 - Aldicarb sulfone
- OxamylMethomyl- 5 - 3-Hydroxycarbofuran........ "-- -- -- -- 6 Aldicarb0 5 10 15 20 min 7 - Propoxur
8 Carbofuran9 - Carba.o,I
10 - 1.Naphthol11 - Methiocarb
Higher Sensitivity with Ternary Gradient
Water/Methanol/Acetonitrile Water/Methanol only
5 Compareresponsefor last
9 sevenanalytes.6
3 1 1 2
Post-Column ReactionConditions have been
optimized for two-stepsequence.
Hydrolysis is done at lowertemperature & reagent concentrationthan previously published methods:
0.0125 M. NaOH30 seconds at 80° C.
OPA/ME: "more is not better"
OPA/ME mixed with analyte streamat 80° C.; cooled to ambient
temperature in < one second prior todetection.
Reaction SequenceIIIII III II IIIIIIII III I II IIII I II I II II II I
Step 1" Hydrolysis
0it Aq. alkali
R-O-C-NH-CH3 A _ CH3NH2 + R-OH + H2CO 3N-Methylcarbamate Methylamine
Step 2: Derivatization of methylamine with 2-mercaptoethanol ando-phthalaldehyde
O + HS-CH2CH2OH S-CH 2CH2OH
"C-H Aq. alkaliC-H + H2NCH3 " -CH3IIO
ImprovementsLower OPA concentration &
rapid reaction reducesbackground noise &
fluorescence quenching.
Lower temperature reducesdegradation of OPA reagent &
isoindole product-background noise is lessened &
higher amount of derivativereaches detector cell.
Reactor DesignHigher flow rate- 1.5 mL/min
3:1 & 4:1 dilution ratios of
first & second step reagentsolutions, respectively.
Proprietary knitted opentubular hydrolysis coil.
Patented countercurrent heat
exchanger used to preheatreactant & reagent streams, cool
derivative stream- consistent
reactions; less degradation ofOPA & isoindole once formed.
RXNTM1000Reaction CoilI I IIIIIIIII IIII II II I I
[3 Proprietary knitted open tubular design
CI Compact linearshape
El 30-second reaction time ~1'80°turns, l..90_ _Jout-of-plane
[3 Minimal bandspreading
- typical crfor entire system < 50 _L
CHEXTMCountercurrent Heat Exchanger*
Solder sheathover gent #1
Copperplate
gent #2
Steel wire wraover
Stainless steeltubing imn out
ictor out
"US Patent No 4,284352
: Fluid Path SchematicI1| I I IIIII II II II
Two-StageSystem Controller Post-Column
v r.............................., Reactor ... RXN1000ReactionCoil..... ".....( II [ _..+,,,,,,,.-.+.._.....,,..,..,,,,,,,,,,,._;,,.+MUlllSOlVenl" I _ _ _ / I_ _ _.- i_--CHEX Heat ExchangerDelivery 12,_I_ [
syst"e_ ' ' f_ h ,_ *_"_"_ DataF,u,_.o_.n0i co,umn''_oo.'' r.....S*o.on
Unit _'i _-_ /'"°"1/I"OPA t _ Waste
water--_d VJI I:ft_.__,,,o,ib--11' _IMeOH__l "r I I t ! _ _ I I "'1
ACN_ Injector ; Reagent Fluorescence
I-Joeve°.te.,oTemperature SystemControl
Detection Parameters
Xenon source for higherintensity at optimum ;_.
Excitation at --340 nrn is more
selective, gives less interferencethan--230 nrn exc. used with
deuterium & pulsed Xe sources.
On-line, stop-flow ;_scans usedto select best compromise inemission & excitation _,'s for
maximum sensitivity.
Detector Optimization
Emission
Begin WavelengthScan : Scan
, / _,maxh,V 447 nm \
il i/ _J _ End
ih _ _.____LLSconI I I I I _
Inject 349 400 500 600 nm
Detector Optimization
ExcitationI Wavelength! Scan
i 't '
i
BeginScan
_,max
J 337 nm EndScan
_j L__J ,..
I I I I
210 300 400 440 nm
Method Results
Excellent reliability &reproducibility.
Precision & limits of detection
superior to standard methods -LOD's lowered by as much as
30-40x.
Signal-to-noise measured byinjecting one mL of
10 part-per-trillion standardmixture.
System PerformanceII
Waters CAS Linearity & Retention Time ReproducibiltyRetention Time
Unearity Retention Time ReproducibilityPeak #/Analyte (R 2 ) (min) (% RSD)
1. Aldicarb sulfoxide 1.000 4.42 0.272. Aldicarb sultone 1.000 5.35 0.21
3. Oxamyl 1.000 6.04 0.254.Methomyl 1.000 6.87 0.23
5.3-Hydroxycarbofuron 0.996 11.37 0.076.Aldlcarb 0.998 13.13 0.09
7.Propoxur 0.998 16.31 0.118.Carbofuran 0.999 16.92 0.I0
9. Carbaryl 1.000 19.03 0.0810. 1-Naphthol 0.999 20.19 0.041I. Methiocarb 1.000 2_2.09 0.03
l.ineartty: Peak area vs. ng on column. All linesintersect origin: 400 I_Linjection volume, 0.25 to100nanograms of each analyte Injected on column.Retention times: Average of 16 replicates, 1000 I_Linjection volume, I ppb: 24 hour systemshutdown inbetween each set of 8 runs.
Comparison with EPA Method i
IIH |lJll Jl II IIIIII Bill
Typical Recovery, Precision & Detection Limits
Recovery Precision Detection Limit% % RSD i_g/L (ppb)
Peak #/Analyte EPA Waters EPA Waters EPA Waters
1. Aldicarb sulfoxide 47 101 21 3.2 2.0 0.22. Aldicarb sulfone 83 100 20 1.3 2.0 0.2
3. Oxamyl 82 106 17 2.7 2.0 0.254. Methomyl 102 100 18 3.5 0.5 0.35. 3-Hydroxycarbofuran 108 100 29 1.9 2.0 0.26. Aldicarb 107 102 7 2.9 1.0 0.3
7. Propoxur 101 99 32 1.1 1.0 0.38. Carbofuran 90 99 12 1.9 1.5 0.3
9. Carbaryl 97 102 23 1.9 2.0 0.210, 1-Naphthol -- 106 -- 6.6 - 0.6
1I. Methiocarb 82 103 19 2.2 4.0 0.3
Samcxe:SpkeaReagentWaterLoll3).ConcJflo_: EPA/NPSMe_ 5: Spike ieve_ at EDL.range from 0.5 to 4.0 v,g/f,..:7 or 8 repllcat_; Inlectton volume: 400 _LL:SIN - 5: I.Waters CAS: Solke levelsall 1,0Izgli-: 8 reDllcates: Inlectlon volume: 1000Id-:470 detector: ex-339 nmlem-445 nm:SIN - 15:1at cletectton llmlt llsteclalDove.NOTE: Resultssr_ownare for a single operatorllaOoratoqy: your resultsmay van/. clepenalng upon operatlng concllttoas.Refer to EPAmetrK)cl fo_acceptance criteria.
Acknowledgments| II
We would like to thank the
following individuals for theirhelp and encouragement:
Uwe Neue, William Carson,Tad Dourdeville- Waters;
and especially:Prof. H. Anson Moye- Univ. of
Florida, GainesviUe,Richard Krause- US FDA,
Washington, DC,Prof. Heinz Engelhardt- Univ.
of Saarbriicken, FRG, uponwhose pioneering work this
method is based.