45
Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Genetics Head of Reproductive Genetics Rutgers-Robert Wood Jonson Medical School , NJ, USA “How genetic variation are analyzed to improve health care”

Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age”

Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhDProfessor of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Genetics

Head of Reproductive Genetics

Rutgers-Robert Wood Jonson Medical School , NJ, USA

“How genetic variation are analyzed to improve health care”

Page 2: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Cause of Death Newcastle London

Chromosomal 2.5% 12.0%

Single gene 8.5% 25.5%

Polygenic 31.0% 25.5%

Nongenetic/unknown 58.0% 62.5%

Total deaths 1041 200

Empiric data

Childhood Mortality, UK 1998 Gelernter, Collins and Ginsburg. Principles of Medical Genetics, 1998

Childhood Mortality in London attributed to genetic causes:1914 (14%) and 1954 (25%) (Rimoin DI, et al 1997)

Page 3: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Genetic Screening, NJ 2014

• Tandem mass spectrometry to screen for 31 metabolic disorders

• Hearing loss

Newborn Screening has

spared 1000s from

suffering through pre-

symptomatic diagnosis

and therapy

Goals: Early recognition of individuals with a

disease causing mutation allows for interventions

that improve health and for consideration of

alternative reproductive options

4-Basic principles of screening:1) Disease characteristics, frequency, clinical relevance and

treatment are known (+ cost/benefit ratio)

2) The test is acceptable, easy to perform, inexpensive,

statistically efficient and clinically efficacious

3) Strategy in place for informative consent, efficient

communication of results and alternative clinical strategies with

realistic positivism, avoiding technical overload, listening

carefully and based on current medical standards

4) Refer family to the appropriate multispecialty resources early

Page 4: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Genetic history “sweeps”

• 8 general questions will elicit information indicative of Genetic Consultation�Family history of MR/Autism�Family history of birth defects/infant surgery�Family history of stillbirth, recurrent SAB, infant

death�Family history of genetic conditions�Family history of cancer�Consanguinity�Teratogens�Positive genetic screening test

Page 5: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Society Norms In the 1980s sense of moral obligation to screen/te st?

Good parents test – “doing what’s best” in spite of limited understanding of limits of tests or options. Belief medically required

Desire for control and reassurance?Implied values simply in offering the test to promote a sense ofknowledge as power: some desire for “quality control”

�Fear of liability led to ACOG alert: “Imperative” to advise every OB patient of MSAFP screening in 1985 with a National goal to screen 90% of patients. This created a new standard of care in spite of the uncertain value and with a very limited discussion of meaning/purpose

�Very general description of conditions screened for and with little explanation of options/decisions if positive; Many patients didn’t understand it was voluntary

Page 6: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Recommended Genetic Screening (ACOG)

African-

American

Sickle CellCystic Fibrosis

Beta-Thalassemia

Natural selectionGene flow with

population migration

Ashkenazi

Jewish

Gaucher diseaseCystic Fibrosis

Tay-Sachs diseaseDysautonomia

Canavan disease

Bottle neck

Asian Alpha-ThalassemiaBeta-Thalassemia

Natural selection

European-

American

Cystic Fibrosis Natural selection

French-

Canadian, Cajun

Tay Sachs disease Founder Effect

Hispanic Cystic FibrosisBeta-Thalassemia

Gene flow

Mediterranean Beta-ThalassemiaCystic Fibrosis

Sickle Cell

Natural selection

Chromosomal &

Congenital anomalies

Page 7: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Human Genome Sequence Medical genetic analysis to determine disease risk profile

DNA Library 2, Individual 2

DNA Library 1, Individual 1

DNA Library 3, Individual 3

Next-generation sequencing: Computerized alignment process of parallel reads of thousands of pieces of DNA

“Omics platforms” , including array Comparative Genomic Hybridization (aCGH), Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) genotyping, and Next-generatio n sequencing are allowing for determination of

Position of DNA Variants and Frequencies

Page 8: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Personal Genome Project (PGP)2008: Announcement of the $5,000 Genome

Scientific American, 2006

Launch Platform List Cost Counselor

deCODEme Nov-07 Illumina $985 Referrals

23andMe Nov-07 Illumina $399 No

Navigenics Apr-08 Affymetrix $2500+$250 annual sub

On staff

SeqWright Jan-08 Affymetrix $998 No

Bio-IT World November, 2008

Page 9: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Genetic predisposition

for Carcinogenesis

BRCA1/2 Involved in DNA repair

Autosomal dominant breast cancer (~10% of cases):

Familial aggregation due to genetic predisposition

for early-onset breast and ovarian cancerBRCA1 and 2; p53 (Li-Fraumeni syndrome; PTEN (Cowden disease with

hamartomas and breast cancer); AT (ataxia telangiectasia); MSH2 and

MLH1 (HNPCC and breast cancer)

Page 10: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Clinical Genetics -Updates in the “Omics-Age”

Q. Can we assign a risk for a genetic disorder to a consultand

that has no symptoms? A. Yes

Objectives is to review how we can calculate genetic risks:

1. Analysis of allele frequency in a population in Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium and the forces behind genetic variations in distinct populations

2. Analysis of the Pedigree

3. How to apply Bayesian analysis to refine Mendelian risk

Page 11: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Gene flow• Gene flow refers to the diffusion of different configurations of a gene

(allele) across cultural, ethnic, or geographical barriers. Alleles from

migrants gradually merge into the gene pool of the population into which

they have migrated. The rate at which an allele migrates into a

population does not equal the rate at which alleles migrates out of the

population. Until the equilibrium between alleles is reached the

population is stratified

• Changes in base pair sequence convert one allele into another. The rates

of inter-conversion of alleles are seldom equal: Rate of A a ≠ a A

leading to changes in allele frequencies over time

• Alleles highly deleterious or affecting the capacity to reproduce are

“genetically lethal”, mostly occur “di novo” and are rare in the population

Page 12: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Using information from the population for

individual risk estimates ”The chance that a genetic disorder will occur using observed frequency of the disease in the population”

Hardy-Weinberg calculation:

The frequencies for 2 alleles (A and B)* in a population

in equilibrium can be calculated:

Types of Genotypes in the population: AA = p2, BB = q2, AB = 2pq . ( p + q = 1)

Remember: For X-linked recessive traits males are hemizygous for A or B; Females can be AA,BB or AB!

Assumptions for a Population in H-W Equilibrium!Random mating: e.g. Allele contribution from AA mother and Aa father = p2 x 2pq

(similar calculations could be done for all possible combinations of parental genotypes

No changes in population due to large migration

No random fluctuations in allele frequency caused by: Natural selection/ genetic drift/

founder effect/ bottleneck/ inbreeding

No positive or negative selection: all 3 Genotypes reproduce equally well

* For simplicity we have considered only 2 alleles with frequencies p and q. HWE holds regardless of the number of alleles although the algebra must be calculated with a computer!

Page 13: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Applications of HWE: Q. What is the probability for a

child with Cystic Fibrosis in this family?

1. The probability that the mother is a carrier fo r A.R. disease can be estimated from Mendel’s Laws using this pedigree analysis = 2/32. The probability that the father is a carrier can be estimated from the population frequency (HW) 3. Molecular analysis: Affected family, genetic panel /or sequence of the entire gene can be offered to husband 4. Reproductive options: CVS/ Amniocentesis/ NIPT?/ IVF-Pre-implantation analysis for CF testing

Ireland 1 per 1,700

Caucasian 1 per 2,500

Sweden 1 per 7,000

Mexico 1 per 8,500

US Black 1 per 17,000

Native Hawaiians 1 per 90,000

C.R. Scriver et al. The Metabolic and Molecular Bas es of Inherited Disease 7 th Ed p. 3848

CF Disease Frequency?

18 yo CF 26yo 27yo

??Consultand AA Spanish

AAGerman

The frequency of the disease in the population is known

Hardy-Weinberg: p + q =1; normal allele = p; disease-producing allele = q

q2 = 1/2500; (q) = 1/50 = 0.02; (p) = 1-0.02 = 0.98

Husband carrier (Htz = 2pq) = 2(0.02)(0.98) = 0.039 = 4% (~1/25)

A1. Fetus = 2/3 x 1/25 = 2/75 = 1/40 CF risk!

Page 14: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Applications of HWE: Q. What is the probability for

an affected child in this family after genetic screening?

1. The probability that the mother is a carrier can be estimated from Mendel’s Laws using this pedigree analysis2. The probability that the father is a carrier can be estimated from the population frequency (HW) 3. Molecular analysis: Affected family, genetic panel /or sequence of the entire gene can be offered to husband 4. Reproductive options: CVS/ Amniocentesis/ NIPT/ IVF-Pre-implantation analysis for CF testing

18 yo CF 26yo 27yo

??Consultand AA NJ- Italian

A2. After molecular testing the adjusted risk to

the Fetus = 1 x 1/250 = 1 in 250 CF risk!

Efficiency of CF test by Ethnic background

Ethnicity Carrier Frequency Detection%

Caucasian 1:25 88.2%

Ashkenazi

Jewish 1:26 94%

African

American 1:65 64.5%

Hispanic 1:46 71.2%

Asian American 1:90 48.9%

non-Ashkenazi J Varies by country of origin

Mixed ancestry Varies by country of origin

. N

The frequency of the disease in the population is known

Hardy-Weinberg: p + q =1; normal allele = p; disease-producing allele = q

q2 = 1/2500; (q) = 1/50 = 0.02; (p) = 1-0.02 = 0.98

Husband carrier (Htz = 2pq) = 2(0.02)(0.98) = 0.039 = 4% (~1/25)

A1. Fetus = 2/3 x 1/25 x 1/4 = 2/300 = 1/40 CF risk!

We use CF genetic platforms for 98 mutations

Page 15: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Caution with Pedigree Risk analysis

1. Pleiotropy and Variable Expression, 2. Penetrance, 3. Heterogeneity, 4. Phenocopies, and 5. Imprecise

definitions of the disease or trait

For all of these reasons + sample size + quality of controls GWAssociation studies for

potential risk factors must be interpreted cautiously!

Phenotypic patterns that could have

Multifactorial, Dominant, Recessive,

Chromosomal or Mitochondrial

familial transmission

Although pattern analysis can be used to determine

probability of recurrence remember these concepts

Page 16: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Hemophilia A: X-linked recessiveF-VIII gene pathogenic mutation: most common intron 22-A and intron-1 inversion

The incidence of the disease is 1 in 4,000 males/rare in females (10-15% de novo)

Penetrance is 100% in males / 10% in females

The consultand’s mother is informative in only one of these 2 pedigrees

Severe deficiency in the factor-VIII clotting activity assay is associated with

spontaneous joint or deep tissue bleeding; Moderate/mild deficiency is

associated with prolonged bleeding after tooth extractions, surgery or injuries

1/2 risk for carrier?Mendelian risk for carrier 1/4?Bayesian analysis?

Page 17: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Bayesian terminology• Prior probability: Mendelian probabilities that mother is or is

not a carrier

• Conditional probability: other information: in this family is the daughter a carrier considering that her 4 brothers are unaffected

• Joint probability: product of prior and conditional probabilities

• Posterior probability: ratio of the joint probability of one outcome to the sum of all joint probabilities

Formulas for Calculating Probabilities:* When 2-events are independent (p1) and (p2) the probability for both occurring

together is P1 x P2.

* When one event can happen in 3-ways with individual probabilities of p1, p2, and

p3, then the overall probability is P1 + P2 + P3 and the probability that the event

will happen by way #1 is P1/(P1 + P2 + P3)

Page 18: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Bayesian estimation

of risk

Alternatives (A) (B) (C)

Mother carrier Y Y N

Consultand carrier Y N N

Prior Prob. Mother 1/2

carrier

1/2

carrier

1/2

non-carrier

Condit Prob. P(4 sons)

x P (consultand)

(1/2)4 (1/2) (1/2)4(1/2) (1)4(1)

Joint Probability (1/2)(1/2)4(1/2)

= 1/64 = 0.01

(1/2)(1/2)4(1/2)

= 1/64 = 0.01

(1/2) (1)4(1)

= ½ = 0.5

Posterior probability 0.01/(0.01+0.01+0.5)

= 2%

0.01/(0.01+0.01+0.5)

= 2%

0.5/(0.01+0.01+0.5)

= 96%

P(A) + P(B) + P(C) = 1

In this case Mendelian analysis would suggest that the mother of the

consultand has 50% risk and the consultand 25% risk (1/4) to carry

the F-VIII mutation. However, the

consultand has 4-unaffected brothers which should modify the 25% risk of being

a carrier

Hemophilia AX-linked Recessive

Page 19: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Huntington Disease

• His grandmother died of Huntington's disease. His 60-year-old father is (so far) disease-free. The consultand would like to know the risk to have a HD child and reproductive options to avoid the odds of this outcome?

• For known carriers of HD, ages of manifestation of the disease have been tabulated: Probability of remaining asymptomatic by age 60 = ~10%; Probability of being asymptomatic by age 35 = ~80%

• Mutation analysis?

Founder effect: HD frequency in a region close to Maracaibo was ~17 in 100

HD (Chr4) A.D. disorder affecting 1 in 20,000 individuals is a classical example of age dependent penetrance of a devastating

neurologic deterioration disorder with very few individuals manifesting signs during childhood and 100% by age 80 - no signs of being

affected at childbearing age. There is an insidiously progressive development of personality changes, memory loss, abnormal body

movements “chorea” together with loss of cognitive skills and psychiatric depression until death with loss of the basal ganglia of the

brain specially the caudate nucleus. In HD there were no chromosomal abnormalities that could help with a functional mapping and

cloning approach. HD was 1 of the first disorders subjected to “ large family genome polymorphic markers scan and positional cloning ”

making in 1981 for linkage-based diagnosis using haplotype analysis in pre-symptomatic patients. Today there is direct molecular

testing for HD obviating the need for a family analysis. However, HD DNA-testing has brought increasing number of social and ethical

concerns because there is no cure for HD and the Dx. has the risk for discrimination for Jobs or health/life Insurance as well as for

other psychological hurdles – e.g. in non affected there is the guilt for escaping a fate their siblings may still face!

Page 20: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Bayesian estimation

of risk

Alternatives (A) (B) (C)

Father Father not a carrier and

asymptomatic at age 60

Father is a carrier and

asymptomatic at age 60

Father is a carrier and

asymptomatic at age 60

Consultand Not a carrier Not a carrier Carrier and asymptomatic

at age 35

Prior Prob. father carrier &

without Sx at age 60

(1/2)(1) (1/2)(1/5) (1/2)(1/5)

Condit Prob. Son is/is not

carrier & Sx at age 35

(1)(1) (1/2)(1) (1/2)(8/10)

Joint Probability (1/2)(1)(1)(1)

= ½ = 0.50

(1/2)(1/5) (1/2)(1)

= 1/20 = 0.05

(1/2)(1/5)(1/2)(8/10)

= 0.04

Posterior Probability 0.50/(0.50+0.08+0.04)

= 0.81

0.08/(0.50+0.08+0.04)

= 0.13

0.04/(0.50+0.08+0.04)

= 0.06

P(A) + P(B) + P(C) = 1

Huntington’s

Page 21: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

1. Conventional population reproductive screening tests

2. How is the analysis of allele frequency in a population in

HWE is done and which are the forces behind genetic

variations in distinct

3. How to interpret the genetic information contained in a

family pedigree

4. How to apply Bayesian analysis to refine Mendelian risk

In summary we have reviewed

Page 22: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Physician’s have Scientific and Economic responsibilities

to Patient’s and to the Health Care system

• Physicians provide consultations, order tests, interpret

tests, offer management plans and treat patients

• Considerations for an Ethic-basedpractice in the “Omics” age world

Page 23: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Innovation and the order to conquer Innovation and the order to conquer

Information is not knowledgeInformation is not knowledge

Opinion is not scientific evidenceOpinion is not scientific evidence

Genes affect disease dynamics,

but the environment

determines how!

Page 24: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Genomics & Informatics applied Genomics & Informatics applied

for enhancing screening, diagnosis for enhancing screening, diagnosis

and to define the gene pathways and to define the gene pathways

and networks governing biological and networks governing biological

processes and diseases processes and diseases

Human Genome: Instruction manual for assembling the molecules that make different cells and also keep them alive and healthy!

Page 25: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Population Genetic Screening

in the “Omics-age”

Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhDProfessor of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Genetics

Section Head of Reproductive Genetics

RWJMS & JSUMC-Meridian Health Care System

Rutgers- Robert Wood Jonson Medical School

Page 26: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics
Page 27: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Cystic Fibrosis Carrier ScreeningGenetic variations affects the efficiency of Population genetic screening tests

(Platforms for 23 vs 32 vs 98 mutations; 23 are recommended by ACMG)

Mutation Rates of CF by Ethnic background: Heterogeneity

Ethnicity Carrier Frequency Detection%

Caucasian 1:25 88.2%

Ashkenazi Jewish 1:26 94%

African American 1:65 64.5%

Hispanic 1:46 71.2%

Asian American 1:90 48.9%

Jewish, non-Ashkenazi Varies by country of origin

Other or Mixed ancestry Varies by country of origin

CF is multisystem genetic disease in which abnormal chloride metabolism across membranes causes dehydrated

secretions (thick sticky mucous in lungs & pancreas) and high sweat chloride. Over 1300 mutations in CF

transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene that maps to chr7. Median survival: 40 years. Treatment with

pancreatic enzymes, high fat, high carb diet, respiratory therapy with chest percussion/ inhaled therapy/DNAse and

antibiotics. Males can be infertile due to congenital bilateral absence of the vas deferens (CBAVD).

Page 28: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics
Page 29: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Recurrence of Multifactorial disorders:

(Empiric data)

Recurrence Risk

Future Males Future Females

Normal Parents of

Defects 1 Affected Child

Cleft lip with or without cleft palate 4-5%

Cleft palate alone 2-6%

Cardiac defect (common types) 3-4%

Pyloric stenosis 3% 4% 2.4%

Hirschsprung anomaly 3-5%

Clubfoot 2-8%

Dislocation of hip 3% 0.5% 6.3%

NTD/ Meningomyelocele 3-5%

Scoliosis 0-15%

Page 30: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

e.g. Congenital Rubellae.g. Congenital Rubella

Gestation (weeks) % affected fetuses overall risk of defects (% of those infected) Main manifestations

<11 100 90 brain, eye, heart

11-12 67 33 Deafness

13-14 67 11 Deafness

15-16 47 24 Deafness

17-36 37 0 None

>36 100 0 None

Phenocopies & Teratogenesis

COUNSELING!

Page 31: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Alpha Thal

Carrier

Beta Thal

Carrier

Sickle Cell

Carrier

MCV <80 <80 <80

Hb Type AA AA AS

Hb A2 <3% >4% >4%

Hb F Normal Elevated Elevated

Inherited Hemoglobin DisordersQuantitative α or β globin synthesis (Thalassemia's)

Qualitative β globin function due to aa substitution (SCD)

In USA: 60.000 individuals with SCD. 1/400 African-American newborn has SCD

Page 32: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Hb SS, Hb CC & Hb SC (Monogenic, A.R. Hemoglobin Disorders)

=+

Hb S Hb C-Harlem Hb SC

+=

ββββ6 Glu-LysWestern Africa

�Billiard ball cells�Folded cells

�Mitten shape

ββββ6 Glu-ValEastern Africa

�Sickle-like cells�Folded cells

Notes: ββββ6(A3) parentheses designate the helical segment and amino acid sequence in that segment affected

�Hb E (ββββ26 Glu-Lys) moves with Hb A2 in Hb Electrophoresis field (false high Hb A2)

Page 33: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Site of

Sickling

Clinical Features Symptomatic Management

Bone Painful crises Opiates and hydration,

Hydroxyurea

Lung Acute chest syndrome Blood Transfusions, folate, iron

chelation, Opiates and

hydration

Brain Stroke Blood Transfusions

Heart Myocardial infarction Blood Transfusions, Opiates and

hydration

Spleen Acute splenic sequestration Blood Transfusions, Opiates and

hydration

Spleen Hyposplenism Pneumococcal vaccination

(pneumovax)

Retina Proliferative retinopathy Retinal surveillance, Laser

Sickle Cell Anemia – Management

Hemopoietic cell based therapy using UCB banks: Celocentesis Vs. Post partum treatment

Page 34: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Malaria

Protozoan infection of the genus Plasmodium which

enters the bloodstream via the saliva of mosquito and

is captured by liver cells. After 1-week of proliferation

they are released and enter Red Cells through

receptor-mediated endocytosis and create vacuoles

(trophozoites) and feed on hemoglobin excreting

brownish ferri-heme

Page 35: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

6 12 18 24 30 36

Birth

6 12 18 24 30 36 42 48

Spleen

Liver

Yolk Sac

10

20

30

40

50

Post-conception age (weeks ) Post-natal age (weeks)

% o

f t

ota

l glo

bin

sy n

thes

isE

ryth

ro-

po

i es i

s

ββββ

αααα

ϒϒϒϒ

εεεεςςςς

δδδδ

Bone Marrow

97% HbA (αααααααα2ββββββββ22) ; 3% ) ; 3% HbA2 (αααααααα2δδδδδδδδ2) ; HbF (αααααααα2ϒϒϒϒϒϒϒϒ2)

HbE: Gower I (ςςςςςςςς2εεεεεεεε2); II ((αααααααα2εεεεεεεε2); Portland (ςςςςςςςς2ϒϒϒϒϒϒϒϒ2)

Inherited Hemoglobin Disorders

Joint Center for Sickle Cell and Thalassemia Disorders: http://www-

rics.bwh.harvard.edu/sickle/ (Overview of sickle cell disease, thalassemia

and iron kinetics). The Sickle Cell Information Center, Emory University:

http://www.emory.edu:80/PEDS/SICKLE/

(Includes PowerPoint presentations on sickle cell disease)

Page 36: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Fragile X Syndrome (FXS): Screening?

In a 2009 survey of physician geneticists and genetic counselors, about 60% supported newborn screening for FXS but were less

supportive of identifying carriers. When asked to choose the best screening model, 29% selected pre-conception, 43% high-risk

populations and 28% did not endorse screening at this time

Acharya K, Ross LF. Fragile X screening: attitudes of genetic health professionals. Am J Med Genet A 2009;149A:626–32

ACMG and a joint statement by the Child Neurology Society and the American Academy of Neurology recommend test children with unexplained delays The National Society of Genetic Counselors and a mu lticenter working group of genetic counselors test possibly affected individuals followed by cascade testing of extended family members once a target individual has been confirmedAGOG test any child with developmental delay, autism, or autistic behavior and family; and offer carrier testing to women <40 years old with ovarian failure or an increased follicle-stimulating hormone levelThe American Academy of Pediatrics has no formal position on FX testing!

Page 37: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Which are the forces behind genetic variations?

Genetic drift: Deviation from the random proportional distribution of alleles from one

generation to the next in small populations (e.g. Frequency of Ellis van Creveld syndrome in PA - short stature, polydactyly and heart disease -)

Founder effect: Establishment of a deleterious rare allele at a relatively high frequency in

a small/isolated population derived from an ancestor (e.g. Huntington Disease in Maracaibo)

Inbreeding: Consanguineous mating (between relatives) increases homozygosity

NOTE: subpopulation stratification by selective mating (positive arrangements) continues to increase homozygous and the probability of distinct phenotypic traits

for recessive disorders in some groups

Natural selection: against Homozygous for a distinct allele and advantage for those

who are Heterozygous in a given environment that also produce more surviving offspring (e.g. frequency of the Sickle Cell gene mutation in Africa due to environmental Plasmodium falciparum)

Population bottle-neck: Alleles at a relatively high frequency in a population due to

historical population constrictions (e.g. frequency of Gaucher, Tay-Sachs, Torsion dystonia in the

Ashkenazi Jewish population)

Page 38: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Genetic polymorphism: Allele frequency greater than 1 in 100

• Natural selection: heterozygotes for some disease causing mutations may have survival advantage in certain ecosystems, becoming so common in the population that the frequency of the deleterious allele (disease causing mutation) fits the statistical definition of polymorphism

e.g. Htz. “carriers” for Cystic Fibrosis (North European descent) Htz. “carriers” for Sickle Cell Anemia (Western African descent)

Page 39: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

ConditionCarrier

FrequencyCystic fibrosis 1:26Tay-Sachs disease 1:30Canavan disease 1:57Familial dysautonomia 1:30Bloom syndrome 1:100Fanconi anemia (Group C) 1:89Gaucher disease 1:15Glycogen storage disease type 1a 1:71Maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) 1:81Mucolipidosis type IV 1:122Niemann-Pick Type A 1:90

Conditions and Carrier Frequencies in the Ashkenazi Jewish Population

• Screening should be offered to all couples in which one partner has at least 1-Ashkenazi Jewish grandparent

• Screening should be offered to the partner with the Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry for most risk reduction benefit

Screening panels in Ashkenazi Jewish

population

“Population bottlenecks”

Genetic polymorphism: Allele

frequency > 1 in 100

Page 40: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Genetics of Consanguinity

� Consanguinity increases the risk for multifactorial and recessive disease. Carrier testing should be done as appropriate, based on family history and ethnicity of parents. If multiple loops are noted in the pedigree “closed paths between the consultand and partner” to calculate the coefficient of inbreeding (f)

� First degree relatives (incest between father-daughter or brother-sister)

• Up to 40% for a significant abnormality. AR disorders (~12%), congenital malformations/SIDS (~18%), nonspecific severe intellectual impairment (~12%) and mild intellectual impairment (~14%)

� Second degree relatives (usually uncle-niece or half siblings)

• No good published estimates and the risk is scalable with (f). The overall risk for congenital anomalies lies between the risk for 1st cousins and children of incest I.e., ~6%-18%

� Third degree relatives (usually first cousins) sharing 1/8 of their genes

• Congenital anomalies ~2-3% above the Wt population risk. Increased risk for mental retardation , genetic disease. And ~ 4% risk for infant mortality

Empiric risks in non-informative families

NOTE: Consanguineous marriages and endogamy present in up to 60% in some

populations (geographic regions)

Back ground Risk in general Population~ Estimates for AD (1%); AR (0.25%); X-L (0.2%);Chromosomal (1%); Congenital Malformations (3-5%)

Page 41: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

• Q1. Chances for the fetus to inherit a recessive allele identical by descent from his great-grandfather at any genetic loci? : start from the consultand closing the loop to the fetus in question (1/2)4 or 1 in 16. The same can be said for the great-grandmother giving an overall risk of passing an allele identical by descent from the great-grandparents of 1/16 + 1/16 = 1/8 = number of shared genes for 1st cousins

• Q2. Chance that the great-grandmother passes the red allele to both of her grand children, and then that they each pass it to the fetus, (1/2)6 or 1 in 64

• Q3. The great-grandmothers risk of being a CF carrier (a-allele) is calculated from HWE = 1/25. The risk for a fetus inherits 2 mutant CF alleles that are identical by descent would be 1/25 x 1/64 = 1/1,600 in stead of 1/65 x1/65 x ¼ = 1 in 17,000 for AA population

Consanguineous Mating in non-informative families

Consanguineous = Term dates from the times when genetic determinants were believed to circulate in the blood – ‘bloodline’ meaning ancestry.

Consanguinity and inbreeding is one of the forces behind genetic stratification!

Consultand

1/21/2

1/2

IV

III

II

I

1/2

1/2

Cystic Fibrosis?

CaucasianAA

Page 42: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Thalassemia Iron Deficiency

RBC (3.7-5.3 x10E6/uL) N or

MCV (79-97 fL)

MCH (26.6-33 pg)

MCHC (31.5-35.7 g/dL)

Serum Fe (35-155 ug/dL) N or

Ferritin (15-150 ng/mL) N or

% Saturation (15-55) N or

TIBC (250-450 ug/dL) N or

Microcytic Anemia

Page 43: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

EthnicitySickle

Cell TraitBeta

Thal TraitAlpha

Thal TraitWest African 1:6 1:50 1:30African American 1:12 1:75 1:30

Non-Hispanic Caribbean, West Indian 1:12 1:50-1:75 1:30Southern European 1:30-1:50 1:20-1:30 1:30-1:50Northern European rare rare rareAshkenazi Jewish rare rare rareHispanic Caribbean 1:30 1:75 variableHispanic Mexican, Central American 1:30-1:200 1:30-1:50 variableAsian rare 1:50 1:20Southeast Asian rare 1:30 1:20Asian Subcontinent (India, Pakistan), Middle Eastern 1:50-1:100 1:30-50 variable

Hemoglobinopathy Carrier Frequency by Ethnic backgr oundCarrier Rate for Inherited Hemoglobin Disorders240,000,000 SC carriers 200,000 Newborns with

SC Disease worldwide/year

Screening Recommendations!

1) Low Risk patients with MCV <80 must have Iron

studies and then Hb-Electrophoresis

2) High Risk group patients should have MCV & Hb-

Electrophoresis

3) Detection of SC/HbC mutation carriers requires

Hb-Electrophoresis

4) Carriers of Hb variants can have a normal MCV

Asymptomatic Mother with MCV of 69 & SC trait on Hb-Electrophoresis

ASC/A2

Mother

Familial Hemoglobin Disorders

Page 44: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

Fragile X-linked Mental Retardation

Most common cause of inherited MR affecting 1:2,500-1:4,000 (IQ<50) males and 1:5,000-1:10,000 (IQ<70) females

Hyperkinetic /autistic

like behaviour/

learning disabilities

Macroorchidism

Induced by culturing in folate

depleted media in 60% cases

Likelihood of passing full mutation from mother to offspring increases with size of pre-mutation; 100% likelihood by 90 CGGs

Cytogenetic & Molecular Diagnosis

Page 45: Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Genetics Santolaya 20… · Population Genetic Screening in the “Omics-age” Joaquin Santolaya-Forgas, MD,PhD Professor of Obstetrics

ACMG, 2008 suggested SMA Screening “ Drawbacks”

SMN - 1

Carrier of SMA

SMN - 1

SMN - 1

Non-Carrier of SMA

SMN - 1 SMN - 1

Carrier of SMA

CLINICAL TYPES of SMA•Type 1 is lethal in infancy•Types 2 and 3 are lethal in childhood/ young adulthood•Type 4 has onset in 4th or 5th decade with normal life expectancy

SMA A.R. disease: of progressive motor weakness from degeneration and loss of anterior horn cells (lower motor neurons) in the spinal cord and brain stem. SMN1 and SMN2 involved (~95% Hz deletions of exons 7 and 8 in SMN1 and 4-5% have a deletion on one chromosome and a point mutation on the other!