24
POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar 1,2 , S. Strindberg 3 , T. Mueller 4 , P. Leimgruber 5 , P. Kaczensky 6 , B. Chimeddorj 7 , G. Naranbaatar 8 , S. Amarsaikhan 9 , B. Dashnyam 9 , T. Munkhzul 8 , T. Purevsuren 9 , J. Payne 1 , K. Murphy 1 , D.A. Hosack 9 , T.K. Fuller 2 Implementing wildlife-friendly measures in infrastructure planning and design in Mongolia, 25 29 August 2015, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia 1 Wildlife Conservation Society, Mongolia Program, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia 2 Department of Environmental Conservation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA, USA 3 Wildlife Conservation Society, Global Conservation Program, Bronx, New York, USA 4 Senckenberg Biodiversity and Climate Research Centre, and Goethe University Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Germany 5 Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute, National Zoological Park, Front Royal, VA, USA 6 Research Institute of Wildlife Ecology, University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna, Austria 7 Mongolia Program Office, World Wide Fund for Nature, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia 8 Institute of Biology, Mongolian Academy of Sciences, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia 9 Health, Safety, and Environment Department, Biodiversity Team, Oyu Tolgoi LLC, Mongolia

POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    10

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS

INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES

IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA

B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3, T. Mueller4, P. Leimgruber5, P. Kaczensky6,

B. Chimeddorj7, G. Naranbaatar8, S. Amarsaikhan9, B. Dashnyam9, T. Munkhzul8,

T. Purevsuren9, J. Payne1, K. Murphy1, D.A. Hosack9, T.K. Fuller2

Implementing wildlife-friendly measures in infrastructure planning and

design in Mongolia, 25 – 29 August 2015, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia

1Wildlife Conservation Society, Mongolia Program, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia2Department of Environmental Conservation, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA, USA3 Wildlife Conservation Society, Global Conservation Program, Bronx, New York, USA4 Senckenberg Biodiversity and Climate Research Centre, and Goethe University Frankfurt, Frankfurt, Germany5Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute, National Zoological Park, Front Royal, VA, USA6Research Institute of Wildlife Ecology, University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna, Austria7Mongolia Program Office, World Wide Fund for Nature, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia8Institute of Biology, Mongolian Academy of Sciences, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia9Health, Safety, and Environment Department, Biodiversity Team, Oyu Tolgoi LLC, Mongolia

Page 2: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Target species

Khulan Goitered gazelle

Status: Endangered Vulnerable

CMS: Appendix II Appendix II

Threats: Illegal hunting, habitat fragmentation, direct and indirect habitat loss

Page 3: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Developments in Southern Gobi

P. Kaczensky

Page 4: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Research goals

• Estimate density and abundance of ungulates

• Determine factors influencing their spatial distribution

Provide baseline for planning mitigation measures to reduce the

impacts of mining related developments

Page 5: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Study area – 98,216 sq.km

Page 6: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Survey transect (n = 29, spacing 20 km, total length 4,820 km)

Page 7: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Field surveys

2012 – Autumn (Sep 25-Oct 17)

2013 – Spring (May 23 – Jun 07)

2014 – Spring (May 24 – Jun 06)

2015 – Spring (May 23 – Jun 07)

Page 8: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Number of individuals of ungulates observed along the transect lines during 2012-2015

4941

3001

3571

1140863 894

3095

1058

Page 9: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

“Distance 6.2” software

Page 10: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Density and abundance estimates of ungulates during 2012 - 2015

Season Year Density Abundance CV

KhulanAutumn 2012 0.83 65,739 24.9

Spring 2013 0.46 35,899 18.5

2014 0.51 39,998 26.8

2015 0.46 36,298 27.1

Goitered gazelleAutumn 2012 0.50 39,602 14.7

Spring 2013 0.36 28,462 14.6

2014 0.39 30,774 12.9

2015 0.43 33,627 12.8

Page 11: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Khulan distribution (2012-2015)

Page 12: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Goitered gazelle distribution (2012-2015)

Page 13: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Layers

NDVI (MODIS)

Slope (DEM)

Household Surface water

Elevation (30 m DEM)

Disturbance layer (TNC)

Spatial modelling

Page 14: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Spatial modeling

5 km

N = 724

Page 15: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Parameter estimates of spatial model explaining distribution of khulan

Significance code: * 0.05, ** 0.01, *** 0.001

Page 16: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Parameter estimates of spatial model explaining distribution of goitered gazelles

Significance code: *** 0.001

Page 17: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Importance of predictor variables explaining spatial distribution of ungulates

Cumulative effects of human associated factors (82% for khulan and 65% for goitered gazelle) were higher than environmental variables

Page 18: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Autumn 2012

Khulan habitat: 0.55%

Spring 2013

Spring 2014 Spring 2015

Khulan habitat: 0.48%

Khulan habitat: 0.45% khulan habitat: 0.51%

Khulan habitat (probability threshold >0.5) during 2012-2015

During 4 years of study: 31% of the study area always classified as khulan habitat 32% of the study area never classified as khulan habitat

Page 19: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Goitered gazelle habitat (probability > 0.5) during 2012-2015

Autumn 2012

Gazelle habitat: 0.55%

Spring 2013

Spring 2014 Spring 2015

Gazelle habitat: 0.51%

Gazelle habitat: 0.53% Gazelle habitat: 0.50%

During 4 years of study: 46% of the study area always classified as gazelle habitat 40% of the study area never classified as gazelle habitat

Page 20: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Model validation: Khulan habitat + tracking data

• 88% of all tracking locations (n = 8,630) were found within the predicted preferred area

• Remaining locations located in close to predicted habitat (average distance of 2.30 ± 1.99 km)

Page 21: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Model validation: Gazelle habitat + tracking data

99% of all tracking locations (n = 1,051) were found within the predicted preferred area

Gazelle habitat

Page 22: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Summary

• Mongolia’s Gobi supports the largest population of khulan and goitered gazelle in the world

• It’s challenging to reliably detect changes in the population over the short-term, other population parameters, recruitment and mortality rates, should be studied

• Human associated factors were more important than environmental variables to influence the distribution of the two species

Page 23: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Acknowledgement

Institute of Biology, Mongolian Academy of Sciences Dornogobi Environmental Protection Agency Oyu Tolgoi LLC

Oyu TolgoiSustainability East Asia

Page 24: POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING ......POPULATION ESTIMATES AND FACTORS INFLUENCING DISTRIBUTION OF UNGULATES IN SOUTHERN, MONGOLIA B. Buuveibaatar1,2, S. Strindberg3,

Thanks!