Pondicherry Sensational Historysheeter Jegan Murder Case Judgement

8/9/2019 Pondicherry Sensational Historysheeter Jegan Murder Case Judgement

1/123

1IN THE COURT OF THE III ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGEAT PUDUCHERRY

PRESENT: TMT. S. MARY ANSELAM, M.A., M.L., III ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE

PUDUCHERRY

FRIDAY, the 12thday of DECE!ER 2"1#

SESSIONS CASE No.9/2013

$Co%%&tted to the Co'(t of Se))&o*), P'd'+he((y, y the J'd&+&a-a.&)t(ate/I, P'd'+he((y, y h&) O(de(, dated 2#0"102"1, a))ed &*P0R0C0 No02342"12 a*d ta5e* o* f&-e y the P(&*+&a- Se))&o*) J'd.e,P'd'+he((y, 6ho %ade o7e( the +a)e to th&) +o'(t y h&) O(de(, dated"80"02"19

(Crime No.91/2012 ofThavalakuppam Police Station, Puducherr.!

Na%e of the A++')ed : 10 a*& a*&5a*da* '(de( a*&$39 S4oS'.'*a(a;No0:38, a(&a%%a* 0 Sath&)h Ra7& $2#9 S4o =e-'No0:?, '*&+&a-&ty @'a(te(), Ta.oo(Dha7eedh' Petta&, =a*d(aet, Od&a*)a-a&


2/123

2P'd'+he((y

30 S'*da( Sa5th&7e- $239 S4o'th'5(&)h*a*Re)&d&*. at No0:1?, 1)tSt(eet, Seth&-a-Na.a(, ad'7aet, La6)et,P'd'+he((y

0 Ja*a Pa(&%a-aBha.a* $19 S4o Pa('th&

Re)&d&*. at No0:33, Pe(&yaPa-ayatha%%a*


3/123

P'd'+he((y

1#0 A('* A*aBha.a* $2#9 S4oA('%'.ha%Re)&d&*. at No0:2, P&--a&ya( ,Dha7eedh' Petta&'*&+&a- @'a(te(), =a*d(aet,Od&a*)a-a&, P'd'+he((y

130 ahe)h $29 S4o Jee-oRe)&d&*. at No0:8, '*&+&a- @'a(te(),Dha7eedh' Petta& =a*d(aet, Od&a*)a-a&P'd'+he((y

10 ahe)h ad'7'et ahe)h

ahe)6a(a* $"9 S4o Se-7a(a;Re)&d&*. at No0:2, thC(o)), Do&5a*a,La6)et, P'd'+he((y

180 Joh*a'- $219 S4o Ch&**aa(a;Re)&d&*. at No0:2", Pa-6ad& St(eet, Netha;&Na.a( /II, Ua-a%, Od&a*)a-a&P'd'+he((y

1?0 A-e


4/123

#220 Ja5)o* Ja&)o* Le*&* Jo)eh

Tha-a)h$1?9 S4o A(o5&ya*atha*Re)&d&*. at No0:1# F(a*)'7a thotta%,=a*d(aet, Od&a*)a-a&, P'd'+he((y

20 Sa)&5'%a( !ee%$29S4o Pa*d&a*Re)&d&*. at No0:#>, Sa6%&-- St(eet0 Oo)& Ta%&-)e-7a%$229 S4o


5/123

>Se*te*+e o( o(de( I* the (e)'-t, ta5&*. &*to +o*)&de(at&o* a--

the ao7e a)e+t), the offe*+e a--e.ed

a.a&*)t the a++')ed '*de( )e+t&o* 1#8 (46

1"? IPC #1 (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC a*d

"2 (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC a*d

"$>+o'*t)9 (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC0 23 $#

+o'*t)9 (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC a*d )e+t&o*

$A9 of the E-o)&7e S')ta*+e A+t 1?"8

$3 +o'*t)9 (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC 2$19 of

A(%) A+t 1?>? (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC 2

$> +o'*t)9 (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC $#

+o'*t)9 (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC Se+t&o* # of

the P(e7e*t&o* of Da%a.e to P'-&+

P(oe(ty A+t 1?8# (46 1#? a*d 1"? IPC

a(e *ot (o7ed y (o)e+'t&o* eyo*d

(ea)o*a-e do't a*d )o the a++')ed a(e

a+'&tted f(o% the +ha(.e) &* te(%) of

)e+t&o* 2>$19 of C(0P0C0 a*d they a(e

o(de(ed to e )et at -&e(ty &* th&) +a)e0 The

0O01 !-'e +o-o'( fo(+e 7a* PY/"1/G/

??31 &) o(de(ed to e (et'(*ed to

Go7e(*%e*t afte( the aea- t&%e &) o7e(0

0O020 / I**o7a +a( PY/"1/AC/##33 &)


6/123

3o(de(ed to e (et'(*ed to the R0C0 O6*e(

o* (od'+t&o* of R0C0 !oo5 afte( the

aea- t&%e &) o7e(0

0O0>, 0O03, 0O02 TO 0O023,

0O031 TO 0O0> the hoto) a*d CD)

a(e to e -a+ed 6&th the (e+o(d)0 The

0O0 , 0O0#, 0O0 to 0O01>, 0O02"

AND 21, 0O028 TO 3", 0O08?, 0O0

?2 TO 0O01"" a(e o(de(ed to e

de)t(oyed afte( the aea- t&%e &) o7e(,

)&*+e they a(e *ot ')ef'-0 The 7eh&+-e PY/

"1/!F/82>> 0O018 a-(eady (et'(*ed to

&t) o6*e( f(o% the +o'(t, the o6*e( )ha--

(eta&* the )a%e a*d the o*d ee+'ted &*

th&) (e.a(d )ta*d) +a*+e--ed0 0O013

Aa+h& oto(+y+-e, 0O01 !-a+5

+o-o't P'-)a(, 0O01? Red +o-o'( '-)a(,

0O022 He(o Ho*da Pa))&o*

%oto(+y+-e, 0O02 ye--o6 +o-o'(

Aa+h& %oto(+y+-e a(e o(de(ed to e

(et'(*ed to h&) R0C0 O6*e( o* (od'+t&o*

of R0C0 !oo5 afte( the aea- t&%e &) o7e(0

0O0?" P&)to- a*d 0O0 ?1 SLR (&ff-e)


7/123

a(e o(de(ed to e (et'(*ed to P'd'+he((y

Po-&+e Dea(t%e*t0

P-eade( fo( the a++')ed : 10 T7-0 T0 T&(o'*a7o+a(a))o' / A1,A>, A8, A11, A1, A1>,A2# A23

20 T7-0 !0 oha*, 0 =e-',!00 S'a)h / A3, A? A1#

0 T7-0 A0 Sa*5a(a*, L0 Sa%ath, 0D0!a' A#, A1", A1, A21 A22

#0 T7-0 oha*


8/123

8Ch'**a%a( !(&d.e, No*a*5'a%, Tha7a-a5'a% PS -&%&t, '*de( the &*)t&.at&o*

of A1 a*d A2, yo' A to A2#, A23, A2? a*d A1 a-o*. 6&th the ;'7e*&-e

de-&*'e*t), d'e to (&o( e*%&ty, &* (o)e+'t&o* of the&( +o%%o* o;e+t fo(%ed

the%)e-7e) a) %e%e() of '*-a6f'- a))e%-y +a((y&*. dead-y 6eao*) )'+h a)

5*&7e), +o'*t(y/%ade o%), +o%%&tted (&ot&*. the(ey +o%%&tted the offe*+e

'*&)ha-e '*de( )e+t&o* 1#8 IPC (46 1"? IPC0 A*d that, o* the )a%e day, t&%e,

-a+e a*d d'(&*. the +o'()e of )a%e t(a*)a+t&o*, &* (o)e+'t&o* of the&( +o%%o*

o;e+t, d'e to (&o( e*%&ty, '*de( the &*)t&.at&o* of A1 a*d A2, A to A1#, A13 to

A2", A23 6(o*.f'--y (e)t(a&*ed o*e Pa*&%a-a( !') ea(&*. Re.&)t(at&o* No0 PY/"1/

/?#? a*d Po-&+e e)+o(t 7eh&+-e ea(&*. Re.&)t(at&o* No0 PY/"1/G/??31 ')&*. the

I**o7a Ca( ea(&*. (e.&)t(at&o* No0PY/"1/AC/##33 a*d ')&*. -o*. 5*&7e) a*d

+o'*t(y %ade o%) a*d the(ey +o%%&tted the offe*+e '*&)ha-e '*de( )e+t&o*

#1 IPC (46 1#? IPC a*d 1"? IPC a*d that, o* the )a%e day, t&%e, -a+e a*d d'(&*.

the +o'()e of )a%e t(a*)a+t&o*, &* (o)e+'t&o* of the&( +o%%o* o;e+t, d'e to (&o(

e*%&ty '*de( the &*)t&.at&o* of A1 a*d A2, A -ead&*. to A# to A2#, A23, A1? a*d

A1 y +o%%&tt&*. the +(&%e a*d A e-oded the +o'*t(y %ade o% o* Ja.a*

Ja.a**atha* Jaya5(&)h*a*, 6ho 6a) )&tt&*. &*)&de the o-&+e e)+o(t 7eh&+-e

ea(&*. Re.&)t(at&o* No0PY/"1/G/??31 a*d A a*d A# a(%ed 6&th -o*. 5*&7e) a*d

+o'*t(y %ade o%) 6e*t &*)&de the )a&d o-&+e e)+o(t 7eh&+-e a*d e-oded the

+o'*t(y %ade o% o* Ja.a* Ja.a**atha* Jaya5(&)h*a* a*d A# a))a'-ted o*

h&% 6&th -o*. 5*&7e) o* h&) head a*d the(ey +a')ed &*)ta*ta*eo') death of the -&fe

+o*7&+t Ja.a* Ja.a**atha* Jaya5(&)h*a* a*d that 6o'-d e -&5e-y to +a')e

death o( 6o'-d e )'ff&+&e*t &* the o(d&*a(y +o'()e of *at'(e to +a')e death a*d

the(ey +o%%&tted the offe*+e '*&)ha-e '*de( )e+t&o* "2 (460 1#? a*d 1"? IPC

a*d that, o* the )a%e day, t&%e, -a+e a*d d'(&*. the +o'()e of )a%e t(a*)a+t&o*, &*

(o)e+'t&o* of the&( +o%%o* o;e+t, d'e to (&o( e*%&ty '*de( the &*)t&.at&o* of A1

a*d A2, A to A, A1", 1#, 13, 2", 21, '*-a6f'--y a*d %a-&+&o')-y +a')ed the

+o'*t(y/%ade o% to e-ode, )o a) to e*da*.e( -&fe o( to +a')e )e(&o') &*;'(y a*d

the(ey +o%%&tted the offe*+e '*&)ha-e '*de( )e+t&o* of the E-o)&7e

)')ta*+e) A+t, 1?"8 (460 1#? IPC a*d 1"? IPC a*d that, o* the )a%e day, t&%e,

-a+e a*d d'(&*. the +o'()e of )a%e t(a*)a+t&o*, &* (o)e+'t&o* of the&( +o%%o*


9/123

?o;e+t, d'e to (&o( e*%&ty '*de( the &*)t&.at&o* of A1 a*d A2, A a*d A# 6e(e &*

o))e))&o* of (oh&&ted a(%) a*d ')ed )'+h (oh&&ted a(%) &* +o*t(a7e*t&o* of

)e+t&o* of the A(%) A+t 1?>?, (e)'-t&*. &* the death of Ja.a* Ja.a**atha*

Jaya5(&)h*a* a*d the(ey +o%%&tted the offe*+e '*&)ha-e '*de( )e+t&o* 2>$1/A9

a*d 2 $9 of the A(%) A+t 1?>? (460 1#? a*d 1"? IPC a*d that, o* the )a%e day,

t&%e, -a+e a*d d'(&*. the +o'()e of )a%e t(a*)a+t&o*, &* (o)e+'t&o* of the&(

+o%%o* o;e+t, d'e to (&o( e*%&ty '*de( the &*)t&.at&o* of A1 a*d A2, A to A,

A1" a*d A1# atte%ted to +a')e death of &*;'(ed R0 Se*th&-5'%a(, SI of Po-&+e,

Th&('%'('.a*, ASI of Po-&+e, Ra;e*d&(a*, PC 182, Na.a(a;a* PC 221 a*d


10/123

1")e+t&o* IPC (460 1#? a*d 1"? IPC a*d that, o* the )a%e day, t&%e, -a+e a*d

d'(&*. the +o'()e of )a%e t(a*)a+t&o*, &* (o)e+'t&o* of the&( +o%%o* o;e+t, d'e to

(&o( e*%&ty A to A2#,A23,A2?,A1, '*de( the &*)t&.at&o* of A1 a*d A2 +a')ed

da%a.e) to the o-&+e e)+o(t 7eh&+-e ea(&*. (e.&)t(at&o* No0 PY/"1/G/??31 ')&*.

+o'*t(y %ade o%) a*d the(ey dete((ed )'+h '-&+ )e(7a*t) f(o% d&)+ha(.&*.

the&( d'ty a*d the(ey the a++')ed e()o*) +o%%&tted the offe*+e '*&)ha-e '*de(

)e+t&o* # of the P(e7e*t&o* of Da%a.e) to P'-&+ P(oe(ty A+t 1?8#, (460 1#? IPC

a*d 1"? IPC a*d the(ey a-- the a++')ed (e*de(ed the%)e-7e) -&a-e to e '*&)hed

'4) 1#8, #1, "2, ", 23, 2, IPC (46 1#? IPC a*d )e+t&o* 1"? IPC a*d

)e+t&o* $a9 of e-o)&7e S')ta*+e A+t 1?"8 a*d 2>$19$AAA9 a*d 2$19 of A(%)

A+t 1?>? a*d '4) # of the P(e7e*t&o* of da%a.e to '-&+ (oe(ty A+t 1?8# (46 1#?

IPC a*d )e+t&o* 1"? IPC0

20 O* the aea(a*+e of the a++')ed efo(e th&) Co'(t, I )at&)f&ed %y)e-f that

f(ee +o&e) of o-&+e (e+o(d), o* 6h&+h the (o)e+'t&o* (oo)ed to (e-y 'o* &t)

+a)e, 6e(e f'(*&)hed to the%, a) +o*te%-ated '*de( )e+t&o* 2" of C(0P0C0 The

P'-&+ P(o)e+'to( oe*ed the +a)e '*de( )e+t&o* 223 of C(0P0C0 The defe*)e +o'*)e-

6a) a-)o hea(d0 Cha(.e '4)0 1#8, #1, "2, ", 23, 2, IPC (46 1#? IPC a*d

)e+t&o* 1"? IPC a*d )e+t&o* $a9 of e-o)&7e S')ta*+e A+t 1?"8 a*d 2>$19$AAA9

a*d 2$19 of A(%) A+t 1?>? a*d '4) # of the P(e7e*t&o* of da%a.e to '-&+

(oe(ty A+t 1?8# (46 1#? IPC a*d )e+t&o* 1"? IPC0 6e(e f(a%ed a.a&*)t the

a++')ed, (ead o7e( a*d e-a&*ed to the% &* Ta%&-0 he* 'e)t&o*ed 6&th (e.a(d to

the )')ta*+e of the +ha(.e, the a++')ed -eaded *ot .'&-ty a*d +-a&%ed to e t(&ed0


11/123

110 O* the )&de of the (o)e+'t&o*, to (o7e the .'&-t of the a++')ed, P0)01 to

122 6e(e ea%&*ed a*d E)0P1 to P1# 6e(e %a(5ed a*d 0O)01 to 1"" 6e(e

%a(5ed0

#0 The +a)e of the (o)e+'t&o* &) that o* 1"0"802"12 at ao't 1301>h() at

P'd'+he((y C'dda-o(e %a&* (oad *ea( Ch'*a%a( (&d.e the a++')ed A to A2 a*d

fo'( J'7e*&-e offe*de() a.a&*)t 6ho% +ha(.e )heet ha) ee* f&-ed0 A to A2 fo(%ed

the%)e-7e) &*to a* '*-a6f'- a))e%-y a*d '*de( the &*)t&.at&o* th(o'.h +e--ho*e

+o%%'*&+at&o* a*d 6&th +o%%o* &*te*t&o* a*d d'e to (e7&o') e*%&ty of A1 a*d

A2 oth -&fe +o*7&+t '*de(.o&*. the )e*te*+e of -&fe &%(&)o*%e*t fo( )ea(ate

(e7&o') +ha(.e) &* the Ya*a% Se+&a- S' Ja&- to e-&%&*ate y 5&--&*. the de+ea)ed

Ja.a* Ja.a*atha* 6ho &) a-)o -&fe +o*7&+t '*de(.o&*. the )e*te*+e of -&fe

&%(&)o*%e*t fo( )ea(ate (e7&o') +ha(.e) &* the


12/123

12e()o**e- &*+-'d&*. the d(&7e( of the 7a*, 6ho 6e(e e)+o(t&*. the )a&d -&fe +o*7&+t y

&*te(+et&*. the e)+o(t 7a* a*d o-&+e a(ty 6&th the he- of a*othe( %oto( 7eh&+-e, a

Toyotto I**o7a Ca( ea(&*. Re.0 No0:PY/"1/AC/##33 a*d ')&*. -o*. 5*&fe a*d

+o'*t(y %ade o%) a*d the(ey +o%%&tted the offe*+e of 6(o*.f'- (e)t(a&*t0 That

&* the +o'()e of )a%e t(a*)a+t&o* a*d &*f'(the(a*+e of +o%%o* o;e+t a*d 'o* the

aet%e*t of A1 a*d A2, the a++')ed had +o%%&tted the %'(de( of de+ea)ed -&fe

+o*7&+t Ja.a* y 5*o6&*.-y +a')&*. h&) &*)ta*ta*eo') death y a))a'-t&*. h&% 6&th

-o*. 5*&7e) a*d e-od&*. +o'*t(y %ade o%) oth o't)&de a*d &*)&de the o-&+e

e)+o(t 7a* &* 6h&+h he 6a) t(a7e-&*. a-o*. 6&th o-&+e e)+o(t a(ty a) a (&)o*e( &*

J'd&+&a- C')tody a*d a-)o +o%%&tted the offe*+e of +o%%&tt&*. %'(de( of the o-&+e

e()o**e- y +a')&*. .(&e7o') h'(t a*d )&%-e h'(t to the% a*d &* that (o+e))

dete((ed the% f(o% e(fo(%&*. the&( d'ty a '-&+ )e(7a*t a*d a-)o +a')ed the

offe*+e of %&)+h&ef +a')&*. da%a.e to the o-&+e 7a*, a '-&+ (oe(ty a*d the(ey

a-- the a++')ed (e*de(ed the%)e-7e) -&a-e to e '*&)hed '4) 1#8, #1, "2, ",

23, 2, IPC (46 1#? IPC a*d )e+t&o* 1"? IPC a*d )e+t&o* $a9 of e-o)&7e

S')ta*+e A+t 1?"8 a*d 2>$19$AAA9 a*d 2$19 of A(%) A+t 1?>? a*d '4) # of the

P(e7e*t&o* of da%a.e to '-&+ (oe(ty A+t 1?8# (46 1#? IPC a*d )e+t&o* 1"? IPC0

>0 The (o)e+'t&o* +a)e, a) '*fo-ded d'(&*. t(&a-, &) a) fo--o6):

P14Se*th&-5'%a( deo)ed that o* 230"02"12 a +a)e 6a) (e.&)te(ed a) C(0

No0:21842"12 fo( th(o6&*. +o'*t(y o% o* the ho')e of Na(a)&%ha Pate-, )o the

a++')ed a*&5a*da* a*d


13/123

1a*d S0C0 >42""# a) -&fe +o*7&+t0 I* o(de( to a((e)t h&% a*d %a5e fo(%a- a((e)t o*

"80"802"12 he 6e*t to , A1", A3,

A1#, A1?, A/, A21, A2" a*d A18 +a%e f(o% the +(o6d a*d th(e6 +o'*t(y o%)0

So the d(&7e( too5 the 7eh&+-e eh&*d, at that t&%e a*othe( I**o7a Ca( da)hed o* the

a+5 )&de of the 7eh&+-e a*d o)t('+ted0 He too5 h&) SLR a*d )hoot fo'( t&%e),

Na.a(a;a* too5 h&) &)to- a*d he )hot t6o (o'*d), the* h&) &)to- .ot )t'+5, )o he

a)5ed Na.a(a;a* to )hoot a.a&*, he to-d h&% h&) SLR 6a) a-)o )t'+5, )o he (e+e&7ed

the &)to- f(o% Na.a(a;a* a*d )hot t6&+e, a.a&* &t .ot )t'+5 )o a-- the a++')ed e()o*


14/123

1#)tood a(o'*d the 7eh&+-e, A> to-d the% Po-&+e eo-e a(e atta+5&*. the%, )o they

a(e to e 5&--ed the* o*-y they +a* 5&-- Ja.a* a*d he th(e6 a +o'*t(y o% y

)ta*d&*. o* the (&.ht )&de of the fo(+e 7a*, &* that atta+5 Th&('%'('.a* a*d

Ra;e*d&(a* )')ta&*ed &*;'(&e)0 The a++')ed Iyyaa* y )ta*d&*. o* the (&.ht )&de

6&*do6 th(e6 a o% o* Ja.a*, that a-)o '()t, the* a-- the a++')ed th(eate*ed the%

y )ay&*. 6e 6&-- th(o6 +o'*t(y o%, )o he h&d h&%)e-f eh&*d the )eat a*d he

(a&)ed h&) head a*d fo'*d A a*d A# +o%&*. &*)&de the 7eh&+-e th(o'.h the f(o*t

doo( a*d they +'t Ja.a* 6&th 5*&fe o* h&) head a*d fa+e a.a&* a*d a.a&*0 The* they

)ho'ted Ja.a* &) *o %o(e a*d 6e*t a6ay0 The* he )ta*d ' a*d fo'*d the a++')ed

('**&*. a6ay f(o% the )ot &* the I**o7a +a( a*d &* the t6o 6hee-e(0 D'e to that

&*+&de*t the(e 6a) t(aff&+ ;a% &* that -a+e, he -oo5ed &*to the 7eh&+-e a*d fo'*d

Ja.a* &* a oo- of -ood a*d 6a) dead0 D(&7e(


15/123

1>)&.*at'(e &* &t0 The +o%-a&*t &) E0P10 He ha*ded o7e( h&) -ood )ta&*ed 6h&te )h&(t

a*d Jea*) a*t to the do+to(, he 6a) a.a&* 'e)t&o*ed y I*)e+to( o* 120"802"120

D'(&*. that f'(the( &*7e)t&.at&o* he to-d the I*)e+to( that Ja.a* to-d h&% that he had

da*.e( f(o% A1 a*d A20

P24Ra;e*d&(a* deo)ed that d'(&*. the o++'((e*+e he 6a) 6o(5&*. &* the

O(-ea*et Po-&+e, )o he had o++a)&o* to )ee A1 a*d A20 =ee(aya*

a*d


16/123

13ea(), )o he .ot do6* f(o% the 7a* a*d at that t&%e P0C0 Sa5th&7e- +a%e the(e a*d he

too5 h&% to the ho)&ta-0 h&-e (ea+h&*. the ho)&ta- he fe-- do6* '*+o*+&o') the*

he 6a) ta5e* to ad(a) fo( f'(the( t(eat%e*t0 He 6a) &* G0H0 fo( t6o to th(ee ho'()0

The(e 6a) )o%e 'a((e- et6ee* a*&5a*da* a*d Ja.a* efo(e the o++'((e*+e a*d

&* that &*+&de*t Ja.a* +'t the f&*.e() of a*&5a*da*, )o the(e 6a) e*%&ty a*d d'e to

that the o++'((e*+e had hae*ed0 The a++')ed (e7e*ted the% f(o% do&*. the&(

6o(5 a*d +a')ed da%a.e to the .o7e(*%e*t 7eh&+-e, )o he .a7e a +o%-a&*t to P1,

d'e to the &*+&de*t he -o)t 7&)&o* &* o*e of h&) eye) a*d he ha) -o)t hea(&*. &* o*e

ea(0 The a++')ed Iyaa*, Soth& a*&5a*da*, Sath&)h Ra7&, =a*a(aet a.e)h,

ad'7aet a.e)h, Ra;a, A-e, oo(thy, '(a-&, ath&ya), S')a&, Se-7a%,

Ta%&-)e-7a% 6e(e a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t0

P4Th&('%'('.a* deo)ed that )&*+e he 6a) &* the o-&+e dea(t%e*t fo( 2

yea() the a++')ed a(e 5*o6* to h&%0 A1 a*d A2 a*d h&) a))o+&ate) 6e(e 5*o6* to

h&%0 O* 230"02"12 the a++')ed .(o' th(e6 +o'*t(y o% o* the ho')e of

Na(a)&%ha Pate- a*d C(0 No0:21842"12 6a) (e.&)te(ed0 Ja.a* 6a) &*)&de the ;a&-,

)&*+e he .ot -&fe &%(&)o*%e*t &* C(0 No0:1"142""# a*d he 6a) &* 0%0 &* -'e +o-o'( fo(+e 7eh&+-e PY/"1/G/

??31 a*d &t 6a) d(&7e* y


17/123

1o%), they (a* to6a(d) the&( 7eh&+-e, A('* th(e6 a o% o7e( the&( 7eh&+-e a*d &t

fe-- o* the&( o**et a*d '()t0 It a-)o had fa--e* o* the ') a*d the .-a)) &* the ')

6e(e (o5e*, )o the a))e*.e() +a%e do6* f(o% the ') a*d 6e(e ('**&*. he(e a*d

the(e, at that t&%e Sath&)h th(e6 a o% o7e( the fo(+e 7eh&+-e 6h&+h a-)o '()t, )o

the d(&7e( too5 the 7eh&+-e &* the (e7e()e o)&t&o*, at that t&%e S'*da( Sa5th&7e-,

ad'7aet a.e)h,


18/123

18a(e 5*o6* to h&%0 O* 230"02"12 +o'*t(y o% 6a) th(o6* o7e( the ho')e a*d fo(

that C(0 No0:21842"12 6a) (e.&)te(ed a*d &* that +a)e they had fo(%a--y a((e)ted

Ja.a* o* "80"802"12 6ho 6a) '*de(.o&*. -&fe &%(&)o*%e*t &* a*othe( +a)e th(o'.h

PT 6a((a*t a*d 't h&% &* the 0%0 they

6e(e t(a7e--&*. f(o% *o(th to )o'th &* Ch'%*ae( (&d.e at that t&%e Pa*&%a-a& ')

6a) .o&*. &* f(o*t of the% a*d &t 6a) (e)t(a&*ed y )o%e eo-e a*d they th(eate*ed

the d(&7e( Ta%&-)e-7a%, Da7&d, Ta%&-, Che--a Se-7a% th(eate*ed the ') d(&7e( at

that t&%e the&( d(&7e( t(&ed to o7e(ta5e the ') o* the (&.ht )&de, at that t&%e o*e

I**o7a Ca( +a%e a*d o)t('+ted the%, &t 6a) (e.&)te(ed a) PY/"1/AC/##33 a*d

f(o% the +a( a.e)h, Ja*a, S'*da(, Soth& a*&5a*da*, Iyyaa*, Sath&)h Ra7&

A('* A*'aBha.a*, Da*daa*& +a%e do6* a*d (a* to6a(d) the fo(+e 7eh&+-e0

A('* A*'aBha.a* th(e6 a o% a*d &t fe-- o* the o**et a*d '()t0 Sath&)h

th(e6 a o% &t a-)o fe-- o* the o**et a*d '()t0 D'e to that the .-a)) of the ')

6e(e (o5e*, the .-a)) of the&( 7eh&+-e 6e(e a-)o (o5e*0 The* the d(&7e( too5 the

7eh&+-e &* the (e7e()e o)&t&o*0 At that t&%e D&-ee, Stehe*, A*to*y a*d othe()

th(e6 o% o7e( the 7a*, )o he )hoot o* the f(o*t )&de a*d h&) &)to- .ot )t'+50 P1

)hot fo'( (o'*d) a*d the* h&) &)to- 6a) a-)o )t'+5, )o P1 (e+e&7ed the SLR a*d

)hot t6&+e0 He h&d h&%)e-f eh&*d the )eat a*d at that t&%e Sath&)h )ho'ted y )ay&*.

&f the o-&+e a(e 5&--ed the* o*-y 6e +a* )5&-- Ja.a* a*d th(e6 a o%, &t fe-- o* the

)eat a*d +a')ed &*;'(y to Ra;e*d&(a* a*d Th&('%'('.a*0 Iyyaa* th(o'.h a o%

th(e6 the 6e)t )&de 6&*do6, &t fe-- o* Ja.a*, the* f(o% the )&de doo( Iyyaa* a*d

Sooth& a*&5a*da* +a%e &*)&de the 7a* a*d +'t Ja.a* o* h&) fa+e a*d head a*d 6e*t

a6ay0 Ja.a* 6a) fo'*d dead0 Ra;e*d&(a* )')ta&*ed &*;'(y o* the -eft fa+e0

Th&('%'('.a* )')ta&*ed &*;'(y o* the ha*d a*d -e.0 O*e S' I*)e+to( +a%e o* the

6ay a*d he too5 Th&('%'('.a* to Go7e(*%e*t ho)&ta-0 P0C0 Sa5th&7e- too5

Ra;e*d&(a* to G0H0 At that t&%e o(-ea*et I*)e+to( Ra.'*aya.a% +a%e the(e a*d he

too5 P1 a*d h&%)e-f a*d d(&7e(


19/123

1?6h&-e he 6a) &* the ho)&ta- P1 to P to-d h&% that '(a-&, Joh* Pa'-,

ad'7aet a.e)h, 4 0%0 a-o*. 6&th S' I*)e+to( Se*th&-


20/123

2"6h&te +o-o'( a-- o7e( the 7eh&+-e a*d &t fe-- o* the o**et a*d '()t, the* a*othe(

o% fe-- o* the to of the 7eh&+-e )o the(e 6e(e )+(at+he) o* the .-a))0 He too5 the

7eh&+-e &* the (e7e()e o)&t&o*, at that t&%e )o%e 2" e()o* th(e6 o%) o7e( the&(

7eh&+-e, he h&d h&%)e-f eh&*d the d(&7e( )eat a*d at that t&%e o% 6e(e th(o6*

&*)&de a*d o't)&de the 7a*0 h&-e he 6a) .o&*. (e7e()e &t da)hed a*othe( 7eh&+-e0

The +(o6d )tood a(o'*d the 7eh&+-e a*d d'e to the o% -a)t he 6a) '*a-e to hea(0

At that t&%e f(o% the -eft )&de doo( )ooth& a*&5a*da*, Iyyaa* +a%e &*)&de the

7eh&+-e 6&th 5*&fe a*d +'t Ja.a* o* h&) fa+e a.a&* a*d a.a&*0 h&-e .ett&*. do6*

they )ho'ted Ja.a* &) *o %o(e, the* a-- the a++')ed 6e*t &* the I**o7a +a( a*d t6o

6hee-e(0 D'e to the o% -a)t the(e 6a) )%o5e e7e(y6he(e0 He )tood ' a*d fo'*d

Ja.a* dead, he +a%e do6* f(o% the 7eh&+-e a*d Ra;e*d&(a* )')ta&*ed &*;'(y o* h&)

eye) a*d eye a-- +a%e o't0 So he )e*t h&% to G0H0 Th&('%'('.a* )')ta&*ed &*;'(y

o* h&) (&.ht )ho'-de(0 He a-)o )e*t h&% to G0H0 The* o* hea(&*. the *e6

Ra.'*aya.a% +a%e0 He a*d Se*th&- a*d Na.a(a;a* 6e*t &* the 7eh&+-e of

Ra.'*aya.a% to G0H0

P34=&*aya.a% deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at 01> 0%0 he +a%e f(o%

P'd'+he((y to Pa**&th&t' &* PY/"1/!C/"?> ') a*d aya7a* 6a) the +o*d'+to(0

At #01> 0%0 6he* they 6e(e *ea(&*. Ch'*ae( (&d.e )%o5e 6a) +o%&*. f(o% the

-'e +o-o'( fo(+e 7eh&+-e0 He +a%e eh&*d that 7eh&+-e a*d o*e I**o7a +a( 6a)

eh&*d h&) ')0 S&*+e he 6a) '*a-e to .o fo(6a(d he )toed h&) 7eh&+-e0 A-- the

a))e*.e() .ot do6* f(o% the 7eh&+-e0 The 7eh&+-e 6h&+h 6a) )ta*d&*. efo(e h&% &)

TN/21/AA/3 he had *ot )ee* a*y o++'((e*+e the(e a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P4a-a&7a)a* deo)ed he &) 6o(5&*. a) +o*d'+to( &* PRTC ')0 O*

1"01202"12 at 0>" 0%0 they )ta(ted the&( ;o'(*ey f(o% the ') )ta*d &* PY/"1/!C

"?> ')0 he* they 6e(e *ea(&*. Ch'*ae( !(&d.e the d(&7e( a-&ed )'dde* (a5e

0 He 'e)t&o*ed h&% a*d he to-d that the(e 6a) t(aff&+ ;a%, at that t&%e he hea(d )o%e

*o&)e, the a))e*.e() .ot do6* f(o% the '), he had *ot )ee* a*y o++'((e*+e the(e

a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0


21/123

21P84Ra;a(a% deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. a) d(&7e( &* Pa*&%a-a( '), he ')ed

to .o fo( 8 t(&) e( day0 So%e 1K yea() efo(e o* a day at 0#> 0%0 he too5 the ')

f(o% the ') )ta*d a*d he 6a) .o&*. to 0%0 he )ta(ted the ') f(o% ') )ta*d to6a(d)


22/123

22

P114S'(e)h !a' deo)ed that he 6a) 6o(5&*. a) d(&7e( &* NR ') a-o*.

6&th Ra.a7a*0 O* 1"0"802"12 they )ta(ted the ;o'(*ey f(o% Che**a& to Th&('*a--a(

a-o*. 6&th P1" h&) 6&fe a*d +h&-d(e* the Re.0 No0: &) TN/21/AA/3 at ao't

#0"" 0%0 6h&-e they 6e(e +(o))&*. Ch'*ae( (&d.e o*e -'e +o-o'( o-&+e 7a* 6a)

.o&*. efo(e the%0 At the e*d of the (&d.e he hea(d a -o'd *o&)e a*d +(o6d 6a)

+ha)&*. the o-&+e 7a*, )o they a-- .ot do6* f(o% the +a(, at that t&%e o-&+e 7a*

da)hed a.a&*)t h&) 7eh&-+e o* )ee&*. the +(o6d he (a* a6ay f(o% the(e0 O*

120"802"12 he a-o*. 6&th Ra.a7a* 6e*t to Tha7a-a5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o* a*d

)ho6ed the 7eh&+-e to RTO a*d (et'(*ed ho%e0

P124S&7a(a%a* deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at #01> 0%0 he a*d h&) f(&e*d

6e(e t(a7e--&*. &* a t6o 6hee-e(, &t 6a) d(&7e* y Sa5th&7e- a*d he 6a) the &--&o*

(&de(0 he* they 6e*t *ea( the Ch'*ae( (&d.e the +(o6d 6a) fo'*d the(e0 Po-&+e

o)t('+ted h&% f(o% .o&*. f'(the(0 So%eody 6a) +'t a*d o%) 6e(e th(o6* &) the

*e6) hea(d y h&%, )o he 6e*t a6ay f(o% that -a+e0 I* that -a+e -'e +o-o'( fo(+e

7eh&+-e 6a) fo'*d0

P14Nata(a;a* deo)ed that he 6a) 6o(5&*. a) d(&7e( &* the -oad +a((&e(

7eh&+-e o* 1"0"802"12 at #0" 0%0 &* o(de( to -oad the 7eh&+-e he 6e*t to


23/123

2a-&+at&o* to )ee h&) )o* &* the ;a&-0 !efo(e the o++'((e*+e he 6e*t to )ee Ja.a* &*


24/123

2#he 6e*t to G0H0 &* the e7e*&*., )&*+e h&) head 6a) (o5e* &*to &e+e), he &) *ot a-e

to )ee h&%0

P14!a(a*&tha(a* deo)ed o* 1"0"802"12 6h&-e he 6a) +at+h&*. f&)h at the

Ch'*ae( (&d.e at ao't #0"" 0%0 he hea(d a )o'*d of o% -a)t, He 6a) &* the

o-d (&d.e, 't the )o'*d 6a) hea(d &* the *e6 (&d.e0 He fo'*d )%o5e f(o% the

o-&+e 7a*0 So%e 2" e()o*) 6e(e fo'*d the(e, he 6e*t &*)&de the 7a* a*d fo'*d

)o%eody dead0 ho a(e the e()o*) &* the +(o6d &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 The* he

6e*t to G0H0 the(e &t 6a) &*fo(%ed to h&% that Ja.a* 6a) %'(de(ed0 Fathe( of Ja.a*

a*d h&) (othe( 6a) fo'*d the(e0 Iyyaa* had th(o6* o% a*d 5&--ed Ja.a* &) the

*e6) hea(d y h&%0 No &*'e)t 6a) do*e efo(e h&% a*d he 6a) *ot 'e)t&o*ed

efo(e Pa*+hayata() a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P184S'(ya deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at ao't #0"" 0%0 he 6e*t &* the

Pa*&%a-a( '), 6he* the ') (ea+hed Ch'*ae( (&d.e PY/"1/AC/##33 +a(

o)t('+ted the ') a e()o* 6ho .ot f(o% the +a( th(eate*ed the a))e*.e() &* the

'), at that t&%e -'e +o-o'( 7a* +a%e eh&*d the ') o* )ee&*. the o-&+e 7a* +(o6d

(a* to6a(d) the 7a* a*d th(e6 +o'*t(y o%0 That 7a* +a%e eh&*d a*d da)hed a

I**o7a Ca(, at that t&%e )o%e 1" e()o*) +a%e &* the&( %oto(+y+-e (o5e the .-a))

6&*do6 &* the 7a*, t6o e()o* 6e*t &*)&de the 7a* afte( )o%et&%e they a-- (a* a6ay

f(o% that -a+e0 O* 110"802"12 he 6e*t to the %o(t'a(y, &*'e)t 6a) do*e at 10""

*oo*, &t +o*t&*'ed fo( 2K ho'() fo( the o)t%o(te%0 !ody 6a) ha*ded o7e(0 he*

he e*'&(ed he 6a) to-d that the(e 6a) e*%&ty et6ee* Ja.a* a*d a*&5a*da* a*d

h&) a))o+&ate)0 Iyyaa* 5&--ed Ja.a*0 A%o*. the a++')ed the *a%e of Iyyaa*,

Sooth& a.e)h, Ja*a *a%e) 6e(e 5*o6* to h&% othe( e()o*) *a%e) 6e(e *ot

5*o6* to h&%0 The *a%ed th(ee e()o*) 6e(e a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t a*d he t'(*ed

ho)t&-e0

P1?4


25/123

2>Iyyaa*, Sath&)h Ra7&, A*tho*y, Ja*a Pa(&%a-aBha.a*, Joh* Pa'-,


26/123

23P2#4Th'-a)&*.a% deo)ed that he 6a) 6o(5&.* &* Tea )ho 6h&+h 6a)

oo)&te to the oat ho')e0 So%e t6o yea() efo(e eo-e *ea( the Tea )ho to-d h&%

that the(e 6a) o% -a)t *ea( Ch'*ae( (&d.e0 He had *ot )ee* the o++'((e*+e a*d

the a++')ed a(e *ot 5*o6* to h&% a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P2>4S''(aya* deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at #01> 0%0 he hea(d a -o'd

*o&)e, )%o5e 6a) +o%&*. *ea( +h'*ae( (&d.e, he 6e*t the(e a*d fo'*d the ') a*d

o-&+e 7a* &* a da%a.ed +o*d&t&o*0 I* the 7a* o*e e()o* 6a) -y&*. &* a*

'*+o*)+&o') )ta.e0 He e*'&(ed the *ea(y eo-e, they to-d h&% that 6h&-e '*de(

t(a*)&t -&fe +o*7&+t 6a) %'(de(ed y th(o6&*. +o'*t(y o%, 6ho had th(o6*

+o'*t(y o% &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 The a++')ed a(e *ot 5*o6* to h&% a*d he ha)

*ot )ee* the o++'((e*+e0

P234=e-' P(aa.a(a* deo)ed that he had *ot )ee* the o++'((e*+e, the

a++')ed a(e *ot 5*o6* to h&% a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P24=e--'%'('.a* '('.a* deo)ed that the 23tha++')ed &) *ot 5*o6*

to h&%0 G*a*a7e- &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%, *oth&*. 6a) )e&Bed efo(e h&%, he ha) *ot 't

h&) )&.*at'(e &* the +o*fe))&o*0 He had *ot )ee* the o++'((e*+e a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P284


27/123

2fo--o6e() of Ja.a* eat the d(&7e( a*d *ot a--o6ed the% to '*-oad the +e%e*t a.)0

!'t *o +o%-a&*t 6a) (e+e&7ed &* that0 O* ">0"302"12 )e(&e) a*d C0D0 I) 0O030

P"4S&7a5'%a( deo)ed o* 110"802"12 at ao't >0"" 0%0 he had a((e)ted

a++')ed a*&5a*da*, ath&a)h, Ta%&-, Joh* Pa'-, Ta%&-)e-7a* at ada.ad&att'

-'+5y a( &* +o**e+t&o* 6&th th&) +a)e a*d ha*ded o7e( the% efo(e C&(+-e I*)e+to(0

H&) )e+&a- (eo(t &) E0P?0

P14A*a*da(a; deo)ed that d'(&*. the o++'((e*+e he 6a) 6o(5&*. a)

)y)te% oe(ato( &* the U-t(ate+h +e%e*t, the a++')ed a(e *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 He had

*ot )ee* the o++'((e*+e, the )o+&ety &) a-)o *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 Fo( -oad&*. a*d

'*-oad&*. +o%%&))&o* 6a) a&d to -o((y d(&7e( &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 He had *o

5*o6-ed.e ao't the Netha;& S'a+ha*d(a o)e Load&*. a*d '*-oad&*. )o+&ety0


28/123

28-a+5 +o-o'( %a*&%a-a& 6&th Uth(a)ha% 0O01#, -ood )ta&*ed ea( )t'd 0O01>

6e(e )e&Bed '*de( the )&eB'(e %ahaBa(0

P4S&7a(a%a* deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. a) =AO0 O* 110"802"12 a) e(

the o(de( of Ta)h&-da( Ra%e)h he a*d =AO


29/123

2?)e&Bed &* the )e&B'(e %ahaBa( fo(%0 The %oto(+y+-e 6e(e a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t T=S

Aa+h& 0O013, !-a+5 +o-o'( '-)a( 0O01, a*othe( '-)a( 0O018, (ed

+o-o'( '-)a( 0O01?0 =ee+h'a('7a- )e&Bed y the Po-&e &) 0O02" a*d 0O0210

P#4a*a.att& deo)ed that o* 180"802"12 a) e( the o(de( of the Ta)&-ha(

he a*d =AO a*&5a% aea(ed efo(e A(&ya*5'a% I*)e+to( at ao't 30"" 0%0,

)o%e fo'( e()o*) 6e(e &* the o-&+e )tat&o* they a(e S')a& S')a&(a;, Sath&)h, Ja*a

Pa(&%a-aBha.a*, Ra;a Poo5a(a;a0 S')a& .a7e +o*fe))&o* a*d to-d the &*)e+to(

that he &) (eady to ha*d o7e( the 6eao*, the ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &* h&) +o*fe))&o* &)

E0P20 Sath&)h .a7e +o*fe))&o* a*d to-d the I*)e+to( the he &) a-)o (eady to ha*d

o7e( the 6eao* a*d the ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &* h&) +o*fe))&o* &) E0P280 Ja*a .a7e

+o*fe))&o* a*d to-d the &*)e+to( that he &) (eady to ha*d o7e( the 6eao*) a*d the

ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &* h&) +o*fe))&o* &) E0P2?0 Ra;a .a7e +o*fe))&o* that he &)

6&--&*. to &de*t&fy the 6eao* a*d ha*d o7e( the%, the ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &* the

+o*fe))&o* &) E0P"0 O* 1?0"802"12 at ao't 80"" a0%0 they 6e*t a-o*. 6&th

I*)e+to( a*d the a++')ed 6e*t to T&*d&7a*a* (a&-6ay a(5&*. a*d Sath&)h Ra7&

&de*t&f&ed o*e %oto(+y+-e Pa))&o* P(o a*d &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P1 that

%oto(+y+-e &) 0O0220 The* they 6e*t to the ')he) *ea( Iyyaa* te%-e a*d S')a&

ha*ded o7e( o*e o%, &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P20 The* Sath&)h &de*t&f&ed o*e

o%, &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P0 The* Ja*a ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe f(o% the ')h

a*d 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P#0 The 5*&fe 6h&+h 6a) )e&Bed f(o% the(e &) *ot a7a&-a-e

efo(e +o'(t0 Ra;a Poo5a(a;a f(o% eh&*d the ')h had ta5e* o*e 5*&fe a*d

ha*ded o7e( &t a*d that 5*&fe &) a-)o *ot a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t0 The* they a-- +a%e to

Ch'**a%a( (&d.e a*d )')a& &*fo(%ed ao't the %a**e( of o++'((e*+e, the* they

6e*t to A+ha(&ya S+hoo- a*d *ea( that -a+e they ha7e &*fo(%ed h&% ao't the

%a**e( of o% -a)t y 6ay of e-od&*. the +o'*t(y o%0 The* the e-oded

&e+e) 6e(e )e&Bed, the* )a%-e )o&- a*d the e-oded )o&- 6e(e )e&Bed, the (e%*a*t

of the +o'*t(y o% &) E0P>0 The )a*d ta5e* f(o% the -a+e &) E0P3 a*d *ea(

A+ha(ya )+hoo- hoto) 6e(e ta5e* to )ho6 the (e+o7e(y -a+e, tho)e hoto) a(e0O020 Se(&e)0 C0D0 I) 0O02#, hoto) ta5e* *ea( No*a*5'a% (&d.e &) 0O02>

a*d CD &) 0O0230 O* ">0"?02"12 a) e( the o(de( of the Ta)&-ha( they 6e*t to the


30/123

"o-&+e )tat&o* a.a&*, a++')ed Ja+5)o* 6a) fo'*d the(e0 He a*d =AO Daya-a* 6e*t

a*d o* that day Ja+5)o* .a7e +o*fe))&o* efo(e the% a*d to-d the &*)e+to( he &)

(eady to &de*t&fy the 6eao*0 The ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &* h&) +o*fe))&o* &) E0P0

The* Ja+5)o* too5 the% to h&) ho')e at F(a*+h'7a .(o'*d a*d ha*ded o7e( T=S

Aa+h& %oto(+y+-e, &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P80 That %oto(+y+-e 0O020 O*

1#0"?02"12 they 6e*t to Tha7a-a5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*, o*e oo(thy 6a) fo'*d

the(e, he a-)o .a7e +o*fe))&o*, he a-)o to-d the I*)e+to( that he &) 6&--&*. to ha*d

o7e( the 6eao*, the ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &* h&) +o*fe))&o* &) E0P?0 The* o* the

*et day at ?01> a0%0 they 6e*t to the o-&+e )tat&o* the* they 6e*t to .(ee* a(5

f(o% the ')he) o*e a('7a- 6a) &de*t&f&ed y oo(thy, &t 6a) )e&Bed &* the )e&B'(e

%ahaBa( E0P#" a*d 0O0280

P>4S&7aa-a* deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. a) =AO o* 210"802"12 Tah&)-da(

ath& &*fo(%ed h&% th(o'.h te-eho*e to .o to Tha7a-a5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*, )o at

>0"" 0%0 he 6e*t to the Po-&+e Stat&o*, the(e a++')ed A*tho*y)a%y, a.e)h

0 The +o*fe))&o*)

6e(e (e+o(ded y the ty&)t, 6h&+h 6a) to-d y the I*)e+to(0 A-- the a++')ed 't

the&( )&.*at'(e &* the +o*fe))&o*, the* he a*d ath&) 't the&( )&.*at'(e &* &t0 O*

280"802"12 at 80"" a0%0 He a*d ath& 6e*t to the Tha7a-a5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*,

the* a-- the f&7e a++')ed a*d ath& a*d o-&+e a(ty 6e*t to A&)he.aa55a%

.(a7eya(d a*d the a++')ed A*tho*y &de*t&f&ed o*e =ee+h'a('7a- 6h&+h 6a) h&dde*


31/123

1*ea( the ')h, &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P#30 The 5*&fe &) 0O020 The* a++')ed

a.e)h a-)o ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe 6h&+h 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P# a*d 5*&fe &)

0O0"0 D&-ee a-)o ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe 6h&+h 6a) ta5e* f(o% the ')he) a*d &t

6a) E0P#? that 5*&fe &) *ot a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t0 A++')ed Sa*5a( ha*ded o7e( o*e

5*&fe 6h&+h 6a) h&dde* &* the ')he), &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P>" that 5*&fe &)

0O020 He a*d ath& 't the&( )&.*at'(e &* a-- the )e&B'(e %ahaBa()0

P34# a*d 5*&fe &) 0O0 the a++')ed G*a*a7e- too5 the% to the -a+e 6e(e the

e-o)&7e) 6e(e h&dde* a*d f(o% h&) ho')e he ha*ded o7e( 1"" .%) e-o)&7e a*d &t

6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P>>0 The* )o%e t6o ho')e a6ay f(o% h&) ho')e the ho')e of

Sa)&5'%a( 6a) fo'*d Sa)&5'%a( 6e*t &*)&de the ho')e a*d ha*ded o7e( 1"" .%) of

e-o)&7e), &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( E0P>30 He a*d =aBh'%'*& 't the&( )&.*at'(e &* the

)e&B'(e %ahaBa()0

P4Joth&(a%a* deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12, he 6e*t a6ay f(o% the

%a*'(e )ho at 0"" 0%0, )o he had *ot )ee* the o++'((e*+e, the* he +a%e to the

)ho o*-y o* 10"802"12 a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P84


32/123

238?3 a*d 7ote( I0D0 h&+h 6a) ')ed fo( .ett&*. the ho*e

+o**e+t&o* &) -a+ed &* h&) +e-- a*d &) (eady to ha*d o7e( &t0 The ad%&))&-e o(t&o*

&* h&) +o*fe))&o* &) E0P>0 So they a-- 6e*t to Ya*a% ;a&- a*d &* a *oteoo5 the

7ote( I0D0 6a) fo'*d a*d &t 6a) ha*ded o7e( y A10 It 6a) )e&Bed y the Ja&-

S'e(&*te*de*t &* a ahaBa( 6h&+h &) E0P>8 a*d 7ote( I0D0 e(o &) E0P>?0 The*

at 0"" 0%0 o-&+e 'e)t&o*ed the )e+o*d a++')ed he a-)o .a7e the +o*fe))&o*0 The*

they a-- (et'(*ed to the o-&+e )tat&o*0


33/123

P##4Ra% deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. &* 4


34/123

#P>"4Se-7a5'%a( deo)ed that he had *ot )ee* PY/"1/AC/##33 I**o7a +a(,

%oto(+y+-e a*d a))e%-y of 2" e()o*)0 Noody 6a) )ta*d&*. &* the +o'(t +o%-e

o( efo(e h&) ho')e a*d ta-5&*. th(o'.h +e--ho*e0 He had *ot )ee* -'e +o-o'(

o-&+e 7a* +o%&*. o't of the +o'(t a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P>14'('.a* deo)ed that the f&()t a++')ed &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 He had

*ot ta-5ed to A1 th(o'.h ho*e0 A1 a-)o *e7e( ta-5ed to h&% th(o'.h ho*e0 He had

*o +e--ho*e0 Ce--ho*e *'%e( of A1 &) *ot 5*o6* to h&% a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P>240 '('.a* deo)ed that a-- the a++')ed a(e *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 The

f&()t a++')ed a*d a++')ed S'da5a(a* &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 He *e7e( ')ed to ta-5 6&th

the%0 He *e7e( a)5ed A1 to he- h&%0 He *e7e( a)5ed a*yody ao't the %o&-e

*'%e( of f&()t a++')ed a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P>4G0 A('%'.a% deo)ed that the f&()t a++')ed &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%,

*oody +o*ta+ted h&% th(o'.h ho*e f(o% ;a&-0 He had *o +e--ho*e a*d t'(*ed

ho)t&-e0

P>#4=0 !a-a5(&)h*a* deo)ed that Da*daa*& &) h&) (othe(0 He d&d *ot .&7e

+e--ho*e a*d I0D0 to h&%0 He a-)o *e7e( +o*ta+ted h&% th(o'.h ho*e0 He had *o

+e--ho*e a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P>>4P'**&ya7ath& deo)ed that he( )&)te( &) De7aya*& a*d he( da'.hte( &)

Dha*0 He *e7e( .a7e +e--ho*e to Dha*, )he had *o +e--ho*e0 F(o% he( +e--ho*e

Da*daa*& *e7e( ta-5ed to h&) 6&fe a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P>34I0 !ha(athy deo)ed that Da7&d a*d '(a-& a(e *ot 5*o6* to he(0 He(

+e--ho*e *'%e( &) 812#382??10 She *e7e( .a7e he( +e--ho*e to '(a-&0 '(a-& &)

*ot 5*o6* to he(0 She *e7e( ')ed to ho*e he(0 The +e--ho*e *'%e( of '(a-& &)

a-)o *ot 5*o6* to he( a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0


35/123

>P>4S0 Ja%e) S'*da( Shya% deo)ed that the a++')ed Da*daa*& &) *ot

5*o6* to h&%0 He ')ed to (&*. h&) I**o7a +a( fo( )e(7&+e 6&th the No0:PY/"1/AC/

##330 H&) +e--ho*e N'%e( &) ??18>#"20 The +e-- *'%e( of Da*daa*& &)

?8?#?#881#0 O* "80"802"12, Da*daa*& +o*ta+ted h&% th(o'.h ho*e fo( do&*.

)e(7&+e to h&) +a(0 He a)5ed to 't that 7eh&+-e a*d )e*t &t a+50 He had *o

5*o6-ed.e ao't the o++'((e*+e0

P>840 oha%ed I(ah&% deo)ed that the a++')ed Da*daa*& &) *ot

5*o6* to h&%0 &t*e)) '('.a* a*d De7aya*& a(e *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 H&) +e--ho*e

*'%e( &) ?"###30 He d&d *ot .&7e h&) ho*e to a*yody0 He *e7e( .a7e h&)

ho*e to Da*daa*&0 hethe( Da*daa*& &) a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t &) *ot 5*o6* to

h&% a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P>?4S0 Jaya)ee-a* deo)ed that Ra7& Sath&)h &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0

hethe( he &) a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 !y 6ay of )ee&*. the I0D0

He *e7e( .ot a ho*e +o**e+t&o* to Ra7&0 He 6a) 'e)t&o*ed y o-&+e a*d t'(*ed

ho)t&-e0

P3"4S0 Ta%&-a(a)a* deo)ed that the a++')ed S'*da( &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0

hethe( he &) a7a&-a-e efo(e +o'(t &) *ot 5*o6*0 Ce--ho*e *'%e( of S'*da( &)

*ot 5*o6* to h&%0 He *e7e( ta-5ed to S'*da( a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P3140 '('.a&ya* A.a%a& deo)ed that the a++')ed a(e *ot 5*o6* to

h&%0 The a++')ed S'*da( &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 S'*da( *e7e( a)5ed h&% to a((a*.e

fo( a Sa*.a% a*d he had +e--ho*e *'%e( ???###>3 a*d ?>""811?0

Ce--ho*e *'%e( of S'*da( &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 He *e7e( (e+e&7ed a*y +a-- f(o%

"8>>1181 a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P32433?>1?"10 S'*da( *e7e( ')ed to +a-- h&% th(o'.h ho*e a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0


36/123

3

P34A('tha(a; deo)ed that the a++')ed Iyyaa* &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0

H&) 6&fe *a%e &) A*&tha0 Noody th(eate*ed h&) 6&fe a*d (e+e&7ed the I0D0, (at&o*

+a(d a*d hoto) f(o% h&) 6&fe a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P3#4#>8, efo(e that he had a *'%e( a*d he ha) fo(.otte* &t0 Iyyaa*

*e7e( ')ed to +o*ta+t h&% th(o'.h ho*e a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0


37/123

P3?4S0 Ra7&5'%a( deo)ed that the a++')ed Sath&)h Ra7& &) *ot 5*o6*

to h&%0 The a++')ed a(e *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 H&) +e--ho*e *'%e( ?38832>381 a*d

t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P"4!0 Tho%a) deo)ed that the a++')ed Ja*a Pa(&%a-aBha.a* &) *ot

5*o6* to h&%0 He had -&'o( ha&t, he *e7e( .a7e h&) I0D0 to a*yo*e to .et ho*e

+o**e+t&o*0 hethe( a*yody ')ed h&) I0D0 a*d ota&*ed )&% +a(d &) *ot 5*o6* to

h&% a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P1440 '--a&7e*tha* deo)ed that he had +e--ho*e at the t&%e of

o++'((e*+e, he had fo(.otte* &t) *'%e(0 The (e)e*t +e--ho*e *'%e( &)

8"?8#"30 The a++')ed Ja*a &) *ot 5*o6* to h&%0 He +o*ta+ted h&% th(o'.h


38/123

8h&) +e--ho*e, he a)5ed h&% y te--&*. 6hethe( yo' a(e that e()o* a*d fo( that he

)a&d *o a*d )o he +'t the +o**e+t&o* a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P34=0 Ra7&)ha*5a( deo)ed that he had a I**o7a Ca( a*d &t) *'%e( &)

PY/"1/AC/##33, he )o-d that 7eh&+-e to E-'%a-a& &* the yea( 2"110 The R0C0 a)

t(a*)fe((ed &* h&) *a%e0 It 6a) to-d to h&% that I**o7a +a( 6a) ')ed &* the

o++'((e*+e0

P4T0 0"" 0%0 he 6e*t to

the Ua-a% E-&ad .(o'*d0 So%e fo'( o%) 6e(e 5et the(e, o% )'ad

e-oded the% efo(e h&%0 The e-oded o;e+t), )%a-- )to*e), a-('), th(ead, ae(,

*a&-) 6e(e )e&Bed '*de( E0P3"0 The* the o(t&o* of the o%, -a+5 +o-o'( *a&-,

th(ead, a-('), ae( 6e(e 0O0# )e(&e)0 He 't h&) )&.*at'(e &* the )e&B'(e fo(%0

P8"4R0 >, the* he +o*ta+ted the

a(5&*. o6*e( th(o'.h +e--ho*e, he &*fo(%ed h&% to +o*ta+t Tha7a-a5'a%

o-&+e, )o he 6e*t to o-&+e )tat&o* a*d they e*'&(ed h&% a*d a)5ed h&% 6hethe( he

had .&7e* h&) 7eh&+-e to a*yo*e of the a++')ed0 He )a&d *o the* they e(')ed h&)


39/123

?do+'%e*t) a*d )e*t h&% a+50 O* 2?0"?02"12 he 6e*t to the o-&+e )tat&o* a*d they

to-d h&% that 7eh&+-e &) a-)o &*7o-7ed &* the o++'((e*+e a*d a)5ed h&% to .et the

7eh&+-e a+5 f(o% +o'(t0

P8140 Na.a(a; deo)ed that &t 6a) &*fo(%ed to h&% that Ja.a* 6a)

%'(de(ed, )o he 6e*t to G0H0 Noody 6a) a--o6ed to .o &*)&de0 Po-&+e ota&*ed h&)

)&.*at'(e, he had *ot )ee* the dead ody, he had *ot .&7e* a*y o&*&o* ao't the

death of Ja.a*0 I*d&7&d'a- )'%%o*) 6e(e )e(7ed to h&%0 He 't th(ee o( fo'(

)&.*at'(e0 I*'e)t (eo(t &) E0P31, )'%%o*) &) E0P32 a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P824N0 So'*da(a;a* deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 he 6e*t to the )+e*e -a+e0

He 6a) *ot a--o6ed to .o *ea( the -a+e y the o-&+e0 Ja.a* 6a) fo'*d dead &*)&de

the o-&+e 7eh&+-e0 O* 110"802"12 he 6e*t to G0H0 He 6a) )e(7ed 6&th )'%%o*)0

Ra%a5(&)h*a* a-)o (e+e&7ed the )'%%o*)0 C't &*;'(y 6e(e fo'*d o* the dead ody0

H&) )&.*at'(e &* the )'%%o*) &) E0P30 S&.*at'(e &* the &*'e)t (eo(t &) E0P3#0

He d&d *ot .&7e a*y o&*&o* ao't the death of Ja.a* a*d t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P84!0 Ra%a5(&)h*a* deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at 30"" 0%0 he had

(e+e&7ed *e6) that Ja.a* 6a) %'(de(ed0 O* the *et day he 6e*t to G0H0 Po-&+e

a)5ed h&% to )ta*d a) Pa*+hayata(0 C't &*;'(&e) 6a) fo'*d o* the head of the dead

ody0 F(o% 10"" 0%0 t&-- #0"" 0%0 &*'e)t 6a) +o*d'+ted0 D'(&*. the &*'e)t he

to-d the o-&+e that o% a*d 5*&fe a(e ')ed fo( +a')&*. &*;'(y to Ja.a* a*d that &)

the (ea)o* fo( the death0 I*'e)t (eo(t &) E0P3>0 H&) )&.*at'(e &* the )'%%o*) &)

E0P330

P8#4She(&a* deo)ed that he had a '-)a( %oto(+y+-e a*d &t) (e.&)t(at&o*

*'%e( &) PY/"1/ P / "18, He '(+ha)ed that %oto(+y+-e y .ett&*. -oa*0 He ')ed

&t fo( th(ee %o*th) a*d the* )o-d &t to So-a%e*, &t) -oa* d'e 6e(e a&d y So-a%e*0

The* &t 6a) &*fo(%ed to h&% that 7eh&+-e 6a) &*7o-7ed &* th&) +a)e0


40/123

#"P8>4


41/123

#1-atte(0 He ha*ded o7e( the +a)e '*d-e) to =e-a&ya*0 The* &t 6a) (o'.ht to h&)

5*o6-ed.e that +a)e e*ded &* a+'&tta-0 O* 1"0"802"12 he +a%e to 5*o6 that &* the

%'(de( of Ja.a*, '(de( a*&5a*da* 6a) a-)o &*7o-7ed0 O* 20"802"1"

A(&ya*5'a% I*)e+to( 'e)t&o*ed h&% a*d he to-d h&% that the(e 6a) (e7&o')

e*%&ty et6ee* the de+ea)ed Ja.a* a*d a++')ed a*&5a*da*0

P8?4=0 S&7a5'%a( deo)ed that he 6a) 6o(5&*. a) =AO0 O* 110"?02""? a)

e( the o(de( of Tah&)-da( Ra%e)h at ao't 1"0" a0%0 He a*d Daya-a* 6e*t to the

o-&+e )tat&o*0 A++')ed ad'7aet a.e)h 6a) the(e, 't he &de*t&f&ed ath&a) a)

ad'7aet a.e)h, o-&+e 'e)t&o*ed h&% efo(e the% he .a7e +o*fe))&o* a*d to-d

the% that he &) 6&--&*. to ha*d o7e( the %ate(&a- o;e+t)0 The ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &*

h&) +o*fe))&o* &) E0P380 O* that day at 10"" 0%0 he too5 the% to A+ha(&ya a*d

ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe, &t 6a) )e&Bed '*de( )e&B'(e %ahaBa(, that 5*&fe 6a) a-(eady

%a(5ed a) 0O0210 O* "801"02"12 at 20" 0%0 he a*d Da-aya* 6e*t to the o-&+e

a*d a++')ed S'dha.a( 6a) the(e he a-)o .a7e +o*fe))&o* a*d to-d the% that he &)

(eady to ha*d o7e( the %ate(&a- o;e+t), the ad%&))&-e o(t&o* &* h&) +o*fe))&o* &)

E0P3?0 O* that day at 30"" 0%0 the a++')ed too5 the% to =a*a(aet Go thoe

6e(e h&) ho')e &) )&t'ated, &* h&) ho')e *ea( the ')he) he had ta5e* o*e 5*&fe a*d

ha*ded o7e( to the I*)e+to(, the 5*&fe &) 0O0>0 a*d the )e&B'(e %ahaBa( &)

E0P"0

P?"4S0 S(&*&7a)a* Ra7&)a*5a( deo)ed that o* 10"802"12 a) e( te

(e'&)&t&o* of the A(&ya*5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*, he had ea%&*ed o*e Te%o

t(a7e--e( PY/"1/G/??31 a*d I**o7a Ca( TN/1/AA/30 Head -&.ht of the Te%o

t(a7e--e( 6a) (o5e*0 He had )ee* 18 da%a.ed, the I**o7a +a( had da%a.e)0 H&)

(eo(t &) E0P10

P?14S0


42/123

#2a*d oth the a++')ed 6e(e ha*ded o7e( to h&% at #0#> 0%0 I*)e+to( had +he+5ed '

tho)e t6o e()o*), 6hethe( he had (e+e&7ed the )a%-e )&.*at'(e f(o% the a++')ed &)

*ot 5*o6* to h&%0 The* I*)e+to( ota&*ed the&( )&.*at'(e fo( (e+e&7&*. 7ote( I0D0

a*d he t'(*ed ho)t&-e0

P?24D(0 R0


43/123

#Tha7a-a5'a% o-&+e a)5ed h&% +e(ta&* +-a(&f&+at&o*) a*d that +-a(&f&+at&o*) -ette( &)

E0P8" a*d h&) (e-y &) E0P810 The I*;'(y a(e o))&-e y (o5e* .-a)) &e+e)0

P?#4D(0 A)6&*& deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at #02 0%0 the &*;'(ed

Th&('%'('.a*, Na.a(a;a*, Se*th&-5'%a(, Ra;e*d&(a* 6e(e (o'.ht y o-&+e0 She

had ea%&*ed Th&('%'('.a* at #02 0%0 He to-d h&% that 6h&-e t(a7e--&*. &* a 7a*

o* 1"0"802"12 at #0"" 0%0 d'e to th(o6&*. of o% at A(&ya*5'a% (&d.e he had

)')ta&*ed &*;'(y0 He to-d h&% that the(e &) d&ff&+'-ty &* hea(&*.0 She had )ee* )e7e(a-

&*;'(&e) o* h&) +e*t(e of (&.ht th&.h %ea)'(&*. 2 1 +%) a*othe( &*;'(y &) fo'*d o*

the (&.ht 5*ee 2 1 +%)0 A*othe( &*;'(y a(a)&o* 6a) fo'*d o* h&) (&.ht -e.

%ea)'(&*. 2 1 +%)0 I*;'(&e) a(e f(e)h, )&*+e the(e 6a) d&ff&+'-ty &* hea(&*. that

&*;'(y &) .(&e7o')0 The 6o'*d +e(t&f&+ate &) E0P82 a*d f&*a- (eo(t &) E0P80 O*

that day at >0" 00 )he had ea%&*ed Na.a(a;a*, he 6a) fo'*d &* d(o6)y +o*d&t&o*,

he +o%-a&*ed of heada+he, the(e 6a) ho-e o* the oth ea(d('%, that &*;'(y &)

.(&e7o'), he to-d he( that 6h&-e t(a7e--&*. &* a 7a* y the o% -a)t o* 1"0"802"12

at #0"" 0%0 he had )')ta&*ed &*;'(y0 The 6o'*d +e(t&f&+ate &) E0P8#, f&*a- (eo(t &)

E0P8>0 O* >01 0%, Se*th&-5'%a( 6a) (o'.ht efo(e he(, he a-)o to-d he( that

6h&-e t(a7e--&*. &* a 7a* y o% -a)t he had )')ta&*ed &*;'(y, he a-)o to-d he( that

the(e &) d&ff&+'-ty &* hea(&*.0 He to-d he( that he had )')ta&*ed &*;'(y o* the head

the(e 6a) a* a(a)&o* o* h&) -eft e-o6 %ea)'(&*. "02> "02> +%), that &*;'(y &)

)&%-e &* *at'(e0 The 6o'*d +e(t&f&+ate &) E0P83, f&*a- (eo(t &) E0P80 The

&*;'(&e) a(e f(e)h0 O* that day at #0" 0%0 he ea%&*ed Ra;e*d&(a*, he to-d he(

6h&-e t(a7e--&*. &* a 7a* o* 1"0"802"12 &* the o% -a)t he )')ta&*ed &*;'(y,

-a+e(ated &*;'(y o* the -eft eye f(o% f(o*t head f(o% the fo(ehead t&-- -eft eye >11

+%) a*othe( a(a)&o* 6a) fo'*d o* the -o6e( h& "01 "0> +%), a*othe( &*;'(y 6a)

fo'*d o* the (&.ht th&.h %ea)'(&*. 2 2 +%)0 I*;'(y a(e f(e)h0 The &*;'(y o* the eye

&) .(&e7o') &* *at'(e0 The 6o'*d +e(t&f&+ate &) E0P88, f&*a- (eo(t &) E0P8?0

P?>4D(0 S&7a)a*5a(&, deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at >01" 0%0


44/123

##heada+he a*d d&ff&+'-ty &* hea(&*.0 A) e( ENT %ed&+a- off&+e( o&*&o* the d&ff&+'-ty

&* hea(&*. &) .(&e7o'), the 6o'*d +e(t&f&+ate &) E0P?", f&*a- (eo(t &) E0P?10

P?34S0 S'*&- deo)ed that o* 1>01"02"12 a) e( the (e'&)&t&o* of the S0P0

R'(a-, he .a7e +a-- deta&-) of =odofo*e No0:8#8????#1 fo( the date o* ? tha*d 1"th

A'.')t 2"120 He .a7e the deta&-) o* 2301"02"12 a-o*. 6&th I0D0 (oof a*d

a-&+at&o* fo(%0 That 7odofo*e *'%e( e-o*.) to 0

P?4D(0 G0L0 Uadhya.a deo)ed that he had (e+e&7ed the 7&+e(a f(o% P0C0

Tha7a-a5'a% o* 220"802"120 He +he%&+a--y ea%&*ed the 7&+e(a a*d )'%&tted

h&) (eo(t0 The =&+e(a &) +o*+e(*ed 6&th Ja.a* a*d the 7&+e(a &) f(ee f(o% a*y o&)o*

&) h&) o&*&o* a*d the (eo(t &) E0P?30

P?84D(0 A**a%a-a& deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 f(o% #0" 0% t&-- >0""

0%0 the &*;'(ed e()o* +a%e fo( t(eat%e*t0 Po-&+e &*fo(%ed h&% that they a(e .o&*.

to (e+o(d the )tate%e*t of the &*;'(ed, )o he .a7e +o*)+&o') +e(t&f&+ate of S'

I*)e+to( Se*th&-5'%a( a*d &) E0P? a*d o* that day at 110"" 0%0 Po-&+e )e&Bed

the d(e)) of Se*th&-5'%a(, Ra;e*d&(a*,


45/123

#>

P1"14Uth&(ada* deo)ed 6h&-e he 6a) 6o(5&*. a) +o*)ta-e &*

Tha7a-a5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*, I*)e+to( had 'e)t&o*ed +e(ta&* 6&t*e))e), he had

(e+o(ded tho)e )tate%e*t)0

P1"24!a-a+ha*da( deo)ed that o* 10"?02"12 he 6e*t to J/I, a) e( the

o(de( of the C&(+-e I*)e+to(, H0C0 S&7a5'%a( a-)o +a%e a-o*. 6&th h&% a*d he

(e+e&7ed the )ea-ed +o7e( a*d %ate(&a- o;e+t) f(o% the +o'(t a*d ha*ded o7e( &t at

CFSL, Che**a&0 O* 10"?02"12 he had (e+e&7ed )ea-ed +o7e( f(o% CFSL a*d

ha*ded o7e( &t efo(e J/I0 He 6a) 'e)t&o*ed y the I*)e+to(0

P1"4See(a-a* deo)ed that 6h&-e he 6a) 6o(5&*. a) ASI, Tha7a-a5'a%

o-&+e he 6e*t to CFSL, Che**a& a*d (et'(*ed to J/I a*d ha*ded o7e( the o;e+t

the(e0

P1"#4Ra;e)h deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 6h&-e he 6) 6o(5&*. a) C&(+-e

I*)e+to( at A(&ya*5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*, &t 6a) &*fo(%ed to h&% th(o'.h -ette( that

fo(+e e)+o(t 7eh&+-e 6a) da%a.ed &* a o% -a)t0 So at 01> 00 he 6e*t to the )+e*e

-a+e, fo(+e t(a7e--e( 7eh&+-e PY/"1/G/??31 6a) fo'*d the(e &* a da%a.ed

+o*d&t&o*0 He 6e*t &*)&de a*d fo'*d !a-(') $#9, )%a-- *a&- $1#9 )%a-- )to*e) $89,

th(ead a*d ae( &e+e) a*d (e&* ae( a*d 6oode* &e+e)0 He +o--e+ted the% a*d

ha*ded o7e( &t to the o-&+e0 That )e&B'(e %ahaBa( &) E0P??0 He .a7e (e'&)&t&o* to

ea%&*e that &) E0P1""0 The* he had (e+e&7ed (e'&)&t&o* f(o% the S'e(&*te*de*t

to d&ff')e the )e&Bed fo'( +o'*t(y o%), that -ette( &) E0P1"10 The d&ff')ed fo'(

&e+e) &) 0O0>0 S%a-- *a&-) 0O0>#0 S%a-- )to*e) 0O0>>, th(ead &e+e) 0O0>3,

ae( &e+e) 0O0>0 f(o% the fo(+e 7eh&+-e )o*.e 6e(e )e&Bed a*d that &) 0O0>8,

the (e&* ta5e* f(o% the )eat &) 0O0>?0 The 6oode* &e+e) f(o% the )eat &) 0O03"0

O* 1"0"?02"12 he had )ea(+hed the 7a*, at the o-&+e )h'tt-e .(o'*d0 The(e 6a) a

ho-e o* the d(&7e( )eat, the(e 6a) a de*t o* the (&.ht )&de o**et0 The(e 6a) de*t o*

the f(o*t '%e(, -eft )&de .-a)) o**et &) fo'*d 6&th de*t0 !a+5 )&de of the d(&7e(

)eat 6a) da%a.ed0 The -o*. )eat a*d the -eft )&de )eat 6a) da%a.ed0 The doo(


46/123

#3%&((o( o* the -eft a*d (&.ht )&de 6e(e *ot (o5e*0 The ead&*. 6h&+h 6a) ')ed fo(

f&&*. the %&((o( 6a) da%a.ed0 The (e&* f&ed o* the 'e( o(t&o* 6a) da%a.ed,

(ea( )eat %&((o( 6a) da%a.ed0

P1">4Ra;a7e- deo)ed that he had (e+o(ded the )tate%e*t of 6&t*e))e) &*

Ta%&-0 The 6&t*e)) to-d the I*)e+to( a*d the I*)e+to( to-d h&% a*d he had 6(&tte*

&t &* Ta%&-0 He 't h&) )&.*at'(e &* a-- the )tate%e*t)0

P1"34Pe((&ya**a)a%y deo)ed that the 6&t*e))e) 6e(e 'e)t&o*ed y the

I*)e+to(0 I*)e+to( to-d &t to h&% a*d he (e+o(ded &t0

P1"4Ra*.a*atha* deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. a) Po-&+e Photo.(ahe(0 O*

1"0"802"12 at >0"" 0%0 I*)e+to( Pa-a*&7e- a)5ed h&% toe +o%e to the )+e*e -a+e,

)o he 6e*t to the Ch'*ae( (&d.e a*d too5 12 hoto.(ah) of Ja.a* 0O031

)e(&e)0 CD &) 0O0320 O* 1101202"12 at 120"" *oo* he 6e*t to the G0H0 A*d too5 3

hoto) of the dead ody of Ja.a* 0O03, CD 0O03#0 The* he 6e*t to

Tha7a-a5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o* a*d too5 hoto.(ah) of Pa*&%a-a( !') PY/"1////

At 20" 0%0 the hoto.(ah) 0O03>, C0D0 / 0O0330 O* 1?0"802"12 )+e*e -a+e

a*d the Ch'*ae( (&d.e 6e(e ta5e* hoto.(ah) 0O033, C0D0 / 0O0380 The* he

6e*t to Th&('5a*+h& A(+ha(ya )+hoo- a*d too5 the -a+e 6e(e the o%) 6e(e

e-oded a*d the hoto.(ah) 0O03?, C0D0 / 0O0"0 O* 2>0"802"12 at 120""

*oo* he 6e*t to 'da-&a(et 1"" feet (oad a*d too5 hoto.(ah) of Netha;&

S'a)h+ha*d(a o)e Load&*. a*d '*-oad&*. )o+&ety oa(d 0O01, C0D0 / 0O020

The* he 6e*t to Ath&a(a)a5th& Na.a( a*d too5 the Netha;& -oad&*. a*d '*-oad&*.

)o+&ety oa(d at 120"" *oo*, hoto.(ah) 0O0, C0D0/ 0O0#0 O* 1?0"802"12

he ha*ded o7e( a-- the hoto.(ah) to the I*)e+to(0

P1"84Ra%e)h deo)ed that o* 2?0"802"12, a) e( the (e'&)&t&o* of the

A(&ya*5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*0 He ha) ea%&*ed PY/"1/AC/##33 I**o7a Ca( &t)

(e.&)t(at&o* +e(t&f&+ate o6*e( &) Cha*d(a, the +ha)&) *'%e( 2


47/123

#*'%e( that 7eh&+-e 6a) -ed.ed to S(&(a% Ch&t U*&o*

F&*a*+e, (e'&)&t&o* &) E0P1"2 a*d (eo(t &) E0P1"0

P1"?4D(0 S0 =&;ay deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. &* CFSL, ad(a) a*d he had

ea%&*ed the e-o)&7e) a*d h&) f&*a- (eo(t &) E0P1"# a*d &t) +o7e( &) E0P1">0

P11"4D(0 S0 D&6a5a( deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. ha) Se*&o( Re)&de*t

Fo(e*)&+ ed&+&*e Dea(t%e*t, P'd'+he((y0 O* 110"802"12 &* the e7e*&*. he

(e+e&7ed the (e'&)&t&o* to +o*d'+t o)t%o(te% &* the dead ody of Ja.a*0 The

o)t%o(te% +o%%e*+ed at #0"" 0%0 a*d +o*+-'ded at >0"" 0%0 He had )ee*

19 E&de(%o de(%a- '(*) of 18 3 +%) o7e( the 'e( a)e+t of -eft

)ho'-de(0

29 E&de(%o de(%a- '(*) 8 +%) o7e( the -o6e( a*d o'te( a)e+t of

-eft fo(ea(%

9 2 8 +%) o7e( the to of the head 6&th -o)) e*t&(e (a&*0

#9 18 3 +%) o7e( the f(o*o te%e(o a(a&ta- a(ea) of the )+a-0

>9 > 2 +%) o7e( the %&dd-e of fo(ehead

39 # 1 +%) o7e( the -eft )&de of fo(ehead0

9 > 1 +%) o7e( the o'te( a)e+t of -eft eye0

89 10> 1 +%) o7e( the -eft +hee50

?9 0> 0>" +%) o7e( the 'e( a)e+t of the -eft ea(0

1"9 # "0>" +%) o7e( the %&dd-e of the -eft ea(0

I*te(*a- ea%&*at&o* the e*t&(e (a&* fo'*d -o)t &* a* e%ty )5'-- +a7&ty

6h&+h )ho6) +o%%&*'ted f(a+te( of the )5'-- o*e a(t of &t -o)t0 Sto%a+h +o*ta&*

a(t-y d&.e)ted +oo5ed (&+e a(t&+-e) 6&th +'(d0 The de+ea)ed d&ed of %'-t&-e +'t

&*;'(&e) o7e( the head0 He +o--e+ted the 7&+e(a a*d )e*t &t fo( +he%&+a- ea%&*at&o*

at the fo(e*)&+ -a at Go(&%ed'0 He +o--e+ted the )a%-e a*d a-)o )')e+ted a(ea) of

'(*) fo( e-o)&7e %ate(&a-) to CFSL, Hyde(ad0 The* he fo(6a(ded the o(&.&*a-

o)t%o(te% +e(t&f&+ate a*d the (ofo(%a of +')tod&a- death to Nat&o*a- H'%a*

R&.ht) Co%%&))&o*, De-h&0 O* .ett&*. the 7&)+e(a (eo(t f(o% La at Go(&%ed' the

f&*a- o&*&o* 6a) (ea(ed (eo(t )ho6) *o a(e+&a-e a%o'*t of a-+oho- &* the


48/123

#8de+ea)ed ody &) E0P1"3, the f&*a- (eo(t &) E0P1", the &*t&%at&o* to h'%a* (&.ht)

+o%%&))&o* &) E0P1"80 Death %&.ht ha7e o++'((ed 18 to 2" h() efo(e a'to)y0 The

(a&* fo'*d &* the )5'-- d'e to +'tt&*. of h&) )5'-- &*d&)+(&%&*ate-y0 !'(*) &*;'(&e)

%ay e d'e to )-&*te() f(o% the +o'*t(y %ade o%0 The &*;'(y to the )5'-- &) d'e

to hea7y +'tt&*. )ha( 6eao*0 The &*;'(y o* the de+ea)ed +a')ed &*)ta*ta*eo')

death0 A-- the ete(*a- &*;'(&e) to 1" a(e the +a')e of the +'%'-at&7e-y0

P1114D0 2? to ? a-)o +o*ta&* h'%a* -ood e+et &te% ? a*d 120 He(

(eo(t dated 101"02"12 &) )e*t to +o'(t0 The (e%a&*&*. &te%) 6e(e )e*t th(o'.h H0C0

Pa+haya&a* to J/I that -ette( &) E0P1110

P114


49/123

#?"?0"802"12 t&-- 1"0"802"12 f(o% 6h&+h to6e( te-eho*e 6e*t 6a) .athe(ed a*d he

+hat &t o't a*d that (e+o(d &) E0P11, &t) C0D0 I) 0O0>0

P11>4A0 Joh*)o* deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. &* A&(te- +o%a*y a) Noda-

off&+e( &* +o**e+t&o* 6&th th&) +a)e they a)5ed fo( )o%e o( 8 +a-- deta&-) a*d the

to6e( deta&-), he )e*t tho)e deta&-) th(o'.h %a&-0 He had (e+e&7ed the -ette( E0D2

a*d h&) (e-y &) E0D280 Po-&+e )ho6ed h&% the deta&-) )e*t y h&% th(o'.h e%a&-0

&th (e.a(d to %o&-e *'%e( 8">38?3 he .a7e 1" a.e) (&*t o't a*d 't h&)

)&.*at'(e &0e0 E0P11#, &t) e(o +oy &) E0P11>0 &th (e.a(d to %o&-e *'%e(

??##??#?# he .a7e 1" a.e) (&*t o't that &) E0P113 a*d e(o +oy &) E0P110

&th (e.a(d to %o&-e No0:?8?#?#881# a-)o he .a7e (&*t o't 6&th h&) )&.*at'(e &0e0

E0P118 a*d &t) e(o &) E0P11?0 &th (e.a(d to %o&-e No0:?32?"#33 he .a7e ?

a.e) (&*t o't a*d 't h&) )&.*at'(e &0e0 E0P12", &t) e(o &) E0P1210 &th (e.a(d

to %o&-e No0:??">88228 he .a7e a.e) (&*t o't 6&th h&) )&.*at'(e E0P122 a*d

e(o &) E0P120 &th (e.a(d to %o&-e No0:?8?3#?>3 he .a7e 1" a.e) (&*t o't

6&th h&) )&.*at'(e &0e0 E0P123 a*d e(o &) E0P120 &th (e.a(d to %o&-e *'%e(

822"8>#?> he .a7e > a.e) (&*t o't 6&th h&) )&.*at'(e &0e0 E0P128 a*d e(o &)

E0P12?0 &th (e.a(d to %o&-e *'%e( "8>>1181 he too5 a.e) (&*t o't 6&th

h&) )&.*at'(e &0e0 E0P1" a*d e(o &) E0P110

P1134D(0 P(adee deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. &* Sa*5a(a Neth(a-aya a) Eye

Se+&a-&)t0 O* 1"0"802"12 he ea%&*ed Ra;e*d&(a* &* the E%e(.e*+y dea(t%e*t at

a(o'*d 1101> 0%0 He had *o e(+et&o* of -&.ht &* the -eft eye a*d the(e 6a) a

6o'*d o* the fo(ehead of the -eft )&de a-o*. -&d tea( a*d -eft eye a-- 6a) ('t'(ed,

)o e%e(.e*+y )'(.e(y 6a) do*e to (ea&( the )5&* &* the fo(ehead 6o'*d a*d ('t'(e

of the eye a--0 The* he 6a) &* the ho)&ta- a) &*at&e*t o* 1"0"802"12, he '*de(6e*t

-&d (ea&( a*d d&)+ha(.ed o* 180"802"120 He 6a) e7a-'ated o* 2#0"802"12 at OPD

a)&), he had )'.a( +o*t(o- a*d 6a) ta5e* ' fo( f'(the( (et&*a- (o+ed'(e0 D'(&*. the

)'(.e(y &t 6a) *oted that the -eft eye 6a) +o%-ete-y da%a.ed a*d +o'-d *ot (e7&7e

h&) eye )&.ht a*d the +a)e 6a) aa*da*ded0 He 6a) -a**&*. to .o fo( o*e %o(e

)'(.e(y0 H&)to(y of the +a)e &) E0P12 a*d (e)e*t +a)e )heet &) E0P1 a*d the -&)t


50/123

>"of )'%%a(y &) E0P1#0 The &*;'(y )')ta&*ed y Ra;e*d&(a* &) .(&e7o'), he +a**ot

(e.a&* h&) )&.ht &* the -eft eye0

P114S(&*&7a)a* deo)ed 6h&-e he 6a) 6o(5&*. &* the Tha7a-a5'a%

Po-&+e Stat&o* &* the yea( 2"12 he had tyed +e(ta&* (e+o(d) &* +o**e+t&o* 6&th th&)

+a)e a*d ha*ded o7e( to the I*)e+to(0 The 6&t*e))e) 6e(e 'e)t&o*ed y the

I*)e+to( a*d he tyed the )tate%e*t a*d .a7e &t to h&%0

P1184N&(%a-aa& deo)ed that )he &) 6o(5&*. &* Fo(e*)&+ S+&e*+e

dea(t%e*t at Che**a&0 O* 10"?02"12 )he had (e+e&7ed the -ood )a%-e of Ja.a*

f(o% the +o'(t )he had ea%&*ed &t0 O* 110"802"12 o* ea%&*at&o* )he &) '*a-e to

f&*d o't the -ood .(o'0 He( )e(o-o.y (eo(t &) E0P130 I* +o**e+t&o* 6&th the

)a%e +a)e f(o% the !&o-o.&+a- dea(t%e*t )he had (e+e&7ed +e(ta&* &te%), )he had

ea%&*ed the% a*d h'%a* -ood 6a) fo'*d &* &te% 1",1,1# to 13, 1?, 2", 21 to 2>

2? to 8 a*d ?0 !-ood fo'*d &* Ite% No0:1?, 2" to 22 a*d 2 e-o*. to M! .(o'0

!-ood fo'*d &* &te% No0:>, a*d ? e-o*. to MO .(o' )he 6a) '*a-e to f&*d

o't the .(o' &* &te% No0:1", 1 to 13 2#, 2? to # 3 to 80 Ite% 8 a*d 11 -ood

-o)t &t) o(&.&*a-&ty0 !-ood &* &te% 2> &) &*)'ff&+&e*t fo( te)t&*.0 He( (eo(t &) E0P10

She had a-)o ea%&*ed )o+5), 5*&fe a*d # 5*&fe a*d &t +o*ta&*ed h'%a* -ood0

!-ood &* &te% 1 e-o*.) to M! .(o'0 She &) '*a-e to te-- the .(o' of &te% No0

a*d #, &te% 2 -o)t &t 'a-&ty, that (eo(t &) E0P180

P11?40 Ra%e)h deo)ed that he &) 6o(5&*. a) Tha)&-da( at P'd'+he((y0

O* 1"0"802"12 at ao't #0#> 0%0 he had (e+e&7ed &*fo(%at&o* f(o% the '-&+ that

the(e 6a) a o% -a)t &* the Ch'*ae( (&d.e a*d o*e Go7e(*%e*t 7eh&+-e 6a)

da%a.ed0 So he &%%ed&ate-y 6e*t the(e0 The )+e*e -a+e -oo5) -&5e a 6a( -a+e0

Se7e(a- o-&+e off&+&a-) 6e(e fo'*d the(e0 He e*'&(ed a*d &t 6a) to-d that -&fe

+o*7&+t Ja.a* 6a) ta5e* f(o% P'd'+he((y to


51/123

>1I*)e+to( Se*th&-5'%a( .a7e a +o%-a&*t o* 1"0"802"12 a*d +a)e 6a) (e.&)te(ed

6h&-e a -&fe +o*7&+t 6a) ta5e* f(o% P'd'+he((y to 0"" h()0 He had

(e+e&7ed the +a)e deta&-) o* 280"802"120 Othe( deta&-) +a%e f(o% Tha7a-a5'a%

Po-&+e )tat&o* a*d O(-ea*et Po-&+e Stat&o*0 F&7e o-&+e off&+e( too5 Ja.a* f(o%

P'd'+he((y to


52/123

>2)e*t to the H&.he( Off&+&a-) o* 220"802"12, a) e( the o(de( of the I*)e+to( he had

ota&*ed e(%&))&o* of Ja&- S'e(&*te*de*t, a0%0 A) e( h&)

o(de( he had do*e J'd&+&a- e*'&(y '4) 13 $19$a9 a*d )'%&tted h&) (eo(t to the

CJ o* "0"#02"10 H&) (eo(t &) E0P1#20 D'(&*. the e*'&(y he had e*'&(ed

6&t*e)) Se*th&-5'%a(, Th&('%'('.a*, Na.a(a;a*, 2 a.e) &) E0P1#20

P1224Pa-a*&7e- deo)ed that o* 1"0"802"12 at ao't 0" 0%0 he 6a) &*

!a*dh'') d'ty at


53/123

>th(o6&*. +o'*t(y o%) a*d +'t y 5*&fe0 It 6a) a-)o &*fo(%ed that the e)+o(t o-&+e

a-)o )')ta&*ed &*;'(y, eh&*d the e)+o(t 7a* o*e I**o7a +a( 6a) fo'*d TN/21/AA/

3 &* the da)hed +o*d&t&o*, efo(e that o* PRTC ') PY/"1/!C/"?> 6a) fo'*d0

He +a%e to 5*o6* that S0I0 Le**&* 6e*t to G0H0 To .et the +o%-a&*t f(o% the

&*;'(&e), he .a7e &*fo(%at&o* to the o-&+e hoto.(ahe( a*d o% )'ad a*d do.

)'ad0 He .a7e &*fo(%at&o* to the SDE I*)e+to( a*d o-&+e +o*t(o- (oo%0 I* o(de(

to a((e)t the a++')ed he .a7e &*fo(%at&o* fo( 7eh&+-e +he+5 '0 At that t&%e

A(&ya*5'a% a*d Tha7a-a5'a% a*d t(aff&+ o-&+e, P0C0 Ca%e to the )ot 6&th

the&( he- t(aff&+ ;a% 6a) +-ea(ed0 The 7eh&+-e PY/"1//?#? 6a) +a')&*.

&*+o*7e*&e*+e to the t(aff&+, &t 6a) )e*t to the Tha7a-a5'a% Po-&+e Stat&o*0 At

ao't 180> h() S0I0 Le*&* !ha(ath& +o*ta+ted h&% th(o'.h ho*e a*d &*fo(%ed h&%

that he had (e+e&7ed the &*t&%at&o* a*d (e+e&7ed the +o*)+&o') +e(t&f&+ate of

Se*th&-5'%a( a*d (e+o(ded h&) )tate%e*t0 He a-)o &*fo(%ed h&% he had (e.&)te(ed

C(0 No0:?142"12 o* the a)&) of the +o%-a&*t .&7e* y S0I0 Se*th&-5'%a(0 O* that

day f(o% 180#> h() t&-- 1?01> h() he had (ea(ed )5et+h, o)e(7at&o* %ahaBa(, +(&%e

deta&- fo(% 6&th the he- of P0C0 The )5et+h E0P1#, o)e(7at&o* ahaBa( E0P1##,

C(&%e deta&- fo(% E0P1#>0 I* the )5et+h the da%a.ed .-a)) &e+e) of Pa*&%a-a( ')

6a) )ho6*0 !efo(e the Pa*&%a-a( ') d(&7e( Ra;a(a% a*d +o*d'+to( the +(&%e deta&-

fo(% 6a) (ea(ed, oth of the% 't the&( )&.*at'(e &* &t0 At 1?0" h(), S0I0 Le*&*

!ha(ath& .a7e h&% the FIR a-o*. 6&th the )tate%e*t of Se*th&-5'%a(,

Th&('%'('.a*, Ra;e*d&(a* a*d Na.a(a;a* a*d


54/123

>#o(t&o* 0O083, >" .%) -ood )ta&*ed %eta- (oad o(t&o* 0O080 The '*&fo(%

of S0I0 Se*th&-5'%a( 6h&)t-e +a(d, (ed a*d -'e +o-o'( (&o*, -ood )ta&*ed f'-- a*t

(o6* a*d (o6* e-t, 2 6e(e

)e&Bed '*de( the )e&B'(e %ahaBa( a*d D(0 A**a%a-a& 't h&) )&.*at'(e &* &t0 O*

110"802"12 he had 'e)t&o*ed 6&t*e))e) Ra;a a*d Pa*ee( a*d (e+o(ded the&(

)tate%e*t at the )+e*e -a+e0 He had 'e)t&o*ed PRTC ') d(&7e( =&*aya.a%,

+o*d'+to( a-a&7a)a* at the )+e*e -a+e a*d (e+o(ded the&( )tate%e*t0 The* he .a7e

(e'&)&t&o* fo( ;'d&+&a- e*'&(y to the J a*d .a7e (e'&)&t&o* to +o*d'+t &*'e)t to

the D&)t(&+t Co--e+to(0 He had 'e)t&o*ed 6&t*e)) S'aya*, S'dha5a(, Daya-a*,

S&7a(a%, Sa5th&7e- '('.a*, D'(a&)a%y, Nata(a;a*, Th'-a)&*.a% a*d (e+o(ded

the&( )tate%e*t0 The* he .a7e (e'&)&t&o* to the RTO to ea%&*e the &**o7a +a( a*d

the o-&+e e)+o(t 7a*0 &th the he- of S0I0 !a';& at 10"" h() at o(t'a(y efo(e

Pa*+hayata() Na.a(a;a*, Go7&*da(a;, S'(&ya5'%a(,


55/123

>>h&% that he had a((e)ted a++')ed a*&5a*da*, ath&a), Se-7a% Lo'(d)a%y,

Iyyaa*, Oo)& Ta%&-)e-7a* o* 110"802"12 at 10"" h() at L'+5y a(,

ada.ad&et0 The* he ha*ded o7e( the% a-o*. 6&th a((e)t %e%o, a((e)t %e%o of

A# &) E0P1#8, a((e)t %e%o of ath&a) &) E0P1#?, the a((e)t %e%o of Joh* Pa'- &)

E0P1>", a((e)t %e%o of Oo)& Ta%&-)e-7a* &) E0P1>10 The* he had ea%&*ed

A# efo(e =AO S&7a5'%a( a*d 0"802"12 they 6e(e .&7e fo( o-&+e +')tody0 O*

130"802"12 at ao't 0"" a0%0 the &)to- a*d SLR (&ff-e 6e(e ha*ded o7e( y

O(-e*et S0I0 A*d he had (e+e&7ed &t '*de( fo(%/?> I,e, E0P1>20 The &)to-

0O0?", SLR ?%% a*d 032 %% SLR 0O0?1 a*d the th&(d a++')ed 7o-'*ta(&-y

.a7e +o*fe))&o* a*d he (e+o(ded &t efo(e 6&t*e)) S&7a5'%a( a*d


56/123

>3&de*t&f&ed the )+e*e -a+e0 O* 10"802"12 the a++')ed too5 the% to T&*d&7a*a% a*d

&de*t&f&ed o*e Aa+h& %oto(+y+-e a*d A &de*t&f&ed o*e Aa+h& %oto(+y+-e, &t

6a) a(5ed &* the Ra&-6ay a(5&*., &t 6a) )e&Bed at 801> h() &* that -a+e A8

&de*t&f&ed a -a+5 +o-o'( P'-)a(0 At 80#> h() a*d that 7eh&+-e 0O01#, o* that day at

?01> h() A3 &de*t&f&ed 0O018, at ?0#> h() A1# &de*t&f&ed 0O01? a*d othe(

7eh&+-e 6e(e )e&Bed &* the )e&B'(e %ahaBa( efo(e 6&t*e))0 The* &t 6a) &*fo(%ed to

h&% that Da7&d a*d Ta%&- had )'((e*de(ed efo(e J/II C'dda-o(e0 A too5 the% to

Th&('5a*+h& (oad a*d Od&a%et (oad ;'*+t&o* a*d ha*ded o7e( the o%) at 120""

h()0 It 6a) a-)o )e&Bed &* the Se&B'(e ahaBa( f(o% that -a+e A# ha*ded o7e( o*e

o% a*d &t 6a) )e&Bed at 120#> h()0 A18 ha*ded o7e( o*e A('7a- at 101> h()0 A3

&de*t&f&ed o*e A('7a-0 At 10#> h() a-- of the% 6e(e )e&Bed &* )e&B'(e %ahaBa( the*

a++')ed 6e(e )e*t fo( (e%a*d0 O* 180"802"12 at ao't 0#> h() he had 'e)t&o*ed

6&t*e)) Ra%' a*d too5 the% to the Ra&-6ay a(5&*. at T&*d&7a*a% a*d &de*t&f&ed the

%oto(+y+-e, &t 6a) )e&Bed &* the )e&B'(e %ahaBa(0 The* the a++')ed too5 the% to

A&)he.aa55a% Iyya*a( 5o&- a*d A1" ha*ded o7e( o*e o% &t 6a) )e&Bed efo(e

the 6&t*e)) at 1"01> h() *ea( that -a+e A> ha*ded o7e( o*e o% a*d &t 6a) a-)o

)eB&ed0 A ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe f(o% the ')he) a*d that 5*&fe 0"0?20 It 6a) a-)o

)e&Bed &* the )e&B'(e %ahaBa( at 110"" h()0 A11 &de*t&f&ed o*e 5*&fe 0O0?, A1"

&de*t&f&ed the )+e*e -a+e y )ta*d&*. 2"" %t) a6ay0 S+e*e -a+e 6a) ta5e* hoto)

at 120"" h()0 the -a+e 6e(e o%) 6e(e e-oded fo( ea%&*at&o* *a%e-y

The*.ath&tt' 6a) a-)o ta5e* hoto)0 The )a%-e (oad 6&th e-o)&7e) )')ta*+e)


57/123

>6e(e )e&Bed at 10" h(), the )a%-e (oad &) 0O0?#, E-o)&7e) %&ed (oad &)

O0?> A2 a*d A2# )'((e*de(ed efo(e the +o'(t at Che**a&, )o he f&-ed et&t&o* fo(

o-&+e +')tody of A?, A1, A13 a*d A2"0 O* that day at 130"" h() he ea%&*ed A>,

A, A1" a*d A11 a*d )e*t the% fo( (e%a*d0 O* 2"0"802"12 &* the ea(-y %o(*&*. at

>0"" a0%0 He (e+e&7ed the &*fo(%ed that A23 &) &* 'th&a-et %a(5et, )o he 6e*%t

the(e a*d a((e)ted h&%0 He 6a) (o'.ht to the o-&+e )tat&o* a*d he .a7e +o*fe))&o*

efo(e 6&t*e)) 0 O*

2"0"802"12 he ha*ded o7e( 2"" .%) e-o)&7e) o6de( f(o% h&) ho')e that

e-o)&7e) o6de( &) 0O0?3 a*d the )e&B'(e %ahaBa( &) E0P1>#0 The* he too5

the% to the ho')e of the a++')ed G*a*a7e- a*d &de*t&f&ed the -a+e 6e(e +o'*t(y

o%) 6e(e (ea(ed, the* &t 6a) &*fo(%ed to h&% that A1? 6a) a((e)ted a*d he 6a)

&* Od&a*)a-a& Po-&+e Stat&o*0 Afte( &*te(o.at&*. h&% A1? 6a) )e*t fo( (e%a*d0 O*

210"802"12 th(o'.h P0C0 S&7a(a% 7&+e(a 6a) )e*t fo( Go(&%ed' PHC at 1#0"" h()

A?, A1>, A13, A2" a*d A1 6e(e ta5e* fo( o-&+e +')tody0 At 101> h() A1 .a7e

+o*fe))&o* 6h&+h 6a) (e+o(ded efo(e S&7a(a%a*, oha//0 At 1?0" h() A3 .a7e

+o*fe))&o*0 At 130#> h() A13 .a7e +o*fe))&o* o* 2"0"802"12 at ""1> h() A? .a7e

+o*fe))&o*, A2" a-)o .a7e +o*fe))&o* efo(e the 7e(y )a%e 6&t*e))0 The* afte( the

+o*fe))&o* the a++')ed too5 the% to A&)he.aa55a% .(a7eya(d a*d A1 &de*t&f&ed

0O02? 5*&fe, A13 ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe a*d A1> ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe 0O01

at 80#> h()0 At ?0"" h() A? ha*ded o7e( o*e 5*&fe 0O0? they 6e(e )e&Bed &* the

)e&B'(e %ahaBa(0 The* a-- the a++')ed too5 the% to the )+e*e of o++'((e*+e &*fo(%ed

the% ao't the %a**e( of o++'((e*+e0 A1> &de*t&f&ed the -a+e 6e(e +o'*t(y o%)

6e(e e-oded fo( ee(&%e*t0 The* he .a7e a (e'&)&t&o* to J/I fo( fo(%a- a((e)t

of A1?, the a((e)t %e%o of A1? &) E0P1>>0 The* he .a7e (e'&)&t&o* to t(a*)fe(

A2 a*d A2# to P'd'+he((y Ja&-0 S0I0 Le*&* !ha(ath& 6e*t to the Ja&- a*d a) e( the

o(de( of J/I he %ade fo(%a- a((e)t of A2 a*d A2#0 The* the a++')ed 6e(e )e*t fo(

(e%a*d0 O* 20"802"12 he .a7e a (e'&)&t&o* to +o'(t fo( the &))'e of PT 6a((a*t fo(

A1?0 The* et&t&o* 6a) .&7e* fo( o-&+e +')tody of A2 a*d A2#0 A1? a*d A2 a*d

A2# 6e(e .&7e* o-&+e +')tody0 The* they 6e(e )e*t fo( %ed&+a- ea%&*at&o*0 A1?

to-d D(0


58/123

>8a*d 0"802"12 he had 'e)t&o*ed 80 O* "0"802"12 he .a7e a (e'&)&t&o* to J to

.&7e e(%&))&o* to d&ff')e the +o'*t(y o%)0 He had 'e)t&o*ed 6&t*e))

Jaya5'%a(, 0"?02"12 he had a((e)ted


59/123

>?A22 at o-d ') )ta*d P'd'+he((y at >0" a0%0, the a((e)t +a(d &) E0P1>?0 A22 6a)

(o'.ht to the o-&+e )tat&o* a*d he .a7e a +o*fe))&o* at ?0"" a0%0, &t 6a) (e+o(ded

efo(e Daya-a* a*d a*a.att&0 A) e( the +o*fe))&o* he too5 the% to h&) ho')e a*d

&de*t&f&ed T=S Aa+h& 0O02 a*d &t 6a) )e&Bed &* the )e&B'(e %ahaBa(0 A22 6a)

)e*t fo( (e%a*d0 O* "30"?02"12 he had 'e)t&o*ed the 6&t*e)) 6ho a(e +o**e+ted

6&th the +e--ho*e *a%e-y P'*&ya7athy, !ha(athy, oha%ed I(ah&%, PaBha*&,

A('tha(a;,


60/123

3"6a) (e%a*d0 He 'e)t&o*ed L&*.e)h6a(a* a*d =e-a(a)a* a*d (e+o(ded the&(

)tate%e*t0 O* 10"?02"12 he had 'e)t&o*ed =AO a*d 6&t*e)) a*a.att& at the

o-&+e )tat&o* a*d (e+o(ded the&( )tate%e*t0 O* 180?02"12 he .a7e a (e'&)&t&o* to

J/I fo( the fo(%a- a((e)t of A1 a*d A20 The* he .a7e (e'&)&t&o* to D(0 , A1" a*d A1?,

the (e-y .&7e* y the do+to( &) )e*t to the +o'(t &%%ed&ate-y0 He had 'e)t&o*ed

=AO S&7aa-a* a*d (e+o(ded h&) )tate%e*t0 He 'e)t&o*ed D(0


61/123

31Ra;e*d&(a*, Na.a(a; a*d


62/123

32(e+o(ded h&) )tate%e*t0 F(o% the CFSL Hyde(aad he had (e+e&7ed a -ette(

de%a*d&*. )o%e %o(e %ode- (o'*d), he )e*t tho)e &te%) o* the *et day0 O*

2#01"02"12 he had 'e)t&o*ed D(0 S&7a)a*5a( a*d (e+o(ded h&) )tate%e*t0 O*

2>01"02"12 he had 'e)t&o*ed D(0 A**a%a-a& a*d (e+o(ded h&) )tate%e*t0 O*

2301"02"12 he had (e+e&7ed the +a-- deta&-) a*d I0D0 (oof +e(t&f&+ate +oy of A2

a*d 'e)t&o*ed 6&t*e)) S'*&- a*d (e+o(ded h&) )tate%e*t0 O* 201"02"12 the

+e--ho*e *'%e( to6e( -o+at&o* +o%a(at&7e +ha(t 6a) (ea(ed a*d )e*t to +o'(t0

O* 2?01"02"12 he had (e+e&7ed the f&*a- o&*&o* of &*;'(y Na.a(a;a* f(o% D(0

A)6&*& a*d (e+o(ded he( )tate%e*t0 He 'e)t&o*ed =AO ath&da)) a*d (e+o(ded h&)

)tate%e*t), the* he )e*t a -ette( a)5&*. fo( f&*a- o&*&o* of the &*;'(ed Se*th&-5'%a(

a*d Ra;e*d&(a*0 The +a-- deta&-) a*d I0D0 (oof 6e(e )e*t to +o'(t &0e0 E0P13?0O*

"01"02"12 he had 'e)t&o*ed 6&t*e)) A-ho*)e, Sath&)h5'%a(, '(a-& P0C0 1?3"

'(a-&, ASI Go7&*da*, P0C0 S(&*&7a)a*, P0C0 Uth&(ada*, H0C0 S&7a(a%, P0C0

!a-a+ha*da(, ASI See(a-a*, H0C0 S&7a(a%, P0C0 Ra;a7e-, Pe(&ya**a)a%y a*d

(e+o(ded the&( )tate%e*t)0 The* he 6e*t to the off&+e of the D&)t(&+t Co--e+to( a*d

(e+e&7ed )a*+t&o* fo( (o)e+'t&o*0 The )a*+t&o* o(de( &) E0P1"0 O* "101102"12 he

had (e+e&7ed the da%a.e +e(t&f&+ate of the o-&+e 7eh&+-e0 O* "201102"12 he had

a-te(ed the )e+t&o* &*to )e+t&o* 2>$19$A9 a*d 2$19$+9 of A(%) A+t 1?>? a*d )e+t&o*

# of PPDL A+t a) add&t&o*a- )e+t&o* a*d )e*t (eo(t to the +o'(t, that a-te(at&o* (eo(t

&) E0P110 O* "01102"12 he had (e+e&7ed a (eo(t of 6&t*e)) $19$A9 , 2$9 of a(%) a+t 1?>? a*d

)e+t&o* # of PDPP A+t 1?8#0 He f'(the( deo)ed that o* 2#0">02"1 he added )e+t&o*

12"$!9 &* the +ha(.e )heet a*d )e*t (eo(t to the +o'(t &0e0 E0P120 O* "0">02"1

he had 'e)t&o*ed D(0 P(adee a*d Sa*tho)h a*d (e+o(ded the&( )tate%e*t0 He

ha*ded o7e( the +a)e )heet a*d &t 6a) )e*t to the +o'(t0 The (eo(t f(o% the

Hyde(ad CFSL &) E0P1 a*d E0P1#0


63/123

3

30 The a++')ed 6a) ea%&*ed '*de( )e+t&o* 1 of C(0P0C0 o* the &*+(&%&*at&*.

+&(+'%)ta*+e) a.a&*)t the% &* the e7&de*+e0 They de*&ed the% a) fa-)e a*d had *o

defe*+e 6&t*e))e) to e ea%&*ed o* the&( )&de0

0 The Point for coni!er"tion i#

hethe( the offe*+e) a--e.ed a.a&*)t the a++')ed 6e(e (o7ed y

the (o)e+'t&o* eyo*d a-- (ea)o*a-e do't)

$. ON POINT #

O* the (o)e+'t&o* )&de o(&.&*a--y 1#3 6&t*e))e), 't -ate( added 8 6&t*e))e),

tota--y 1># 6&t*e))e)0 Ho6e7e(, the (o)e+'t&o* ha) +ho)e* to ea%&*e o*-y 122

6&t*e))e) d&)e*)&*. the othe()0 They ha7e %a(5ed 1# Eh&&t) a*d 1"" %ate(&a-

o;e+t)0 No 6&t*e)) 6a) ea%&*ed o* the )&de of the defe*+e, 't > eh&&t) 6e(e

%a(5ed th(o'.h the (o)e+'t&o* 6&t*e))0 No %ate(&a- o;e+t) 6a) %a(5ed o* the )&de

of the defe*+e0 O*e do+'%e*t 6a) %a(5ed a) +o'(t do+'%e*t E0C1 y the +o'(t

th(o'.h P1> d'(&*. h&) ea%&*at&o*0 O't of the 122 6&t*e))e) ea%&*ed y the

(o)e+'t&o* >8 6&t*e))e) d&d *ot )'o(t the +a)e of the (o)e+'t&o* a*d they 6e(e

t(eated a) ho)t&-e 6&t*e))e) y the (o)e+'t&o*0

?0 It &) a(.'ed o* the )&de of the defe*+e that the %ot&7e 't fo(6a(d y the

(o)e+'t&o* &) *ot (o7ed &* th&) +a)e0 A++o(d&*. to the (o)e+'t&o* A1 a*d A2 had

(&o( e*%&ty a.a&*)t de+ea)ed Ja.a* o7e( the +o--e+t&o* of a%%'- a*d a a)t

7&o-e*t o't d'(&*. 6h&+h de+ea)ed dete((e*t +o*7&+t )-ayed the (&.ht f&*.e( of A2

fo( that (oof )e7e(a- 6&t*e))e) 6e(e ea%&*ed a*d P1 a-o*e )o5e ao't the

o++'((e*+e0 He deo)ed &* h&) e7&de*+e a) fo--o6): (12k; njjp Ma;thsh;


64/123

3#vd;id kPz;Lk; tprhhpj;jhh;/ mt;thW tprhhpf;Fk; nghJ

b$fd; vd;dplk; 1 k;Wk; 2 tJ vjphpaplk; jdf;F

mghak; !"g;gjhf brhd;ndd;/90 I* th&) (e.a(d he had )tated &* h&)

+(o)) ea%&*at&o* a) fo--o6) : $ g#fhhpnh vd;%ila thf;F

&'j;jnh b$fd; vd;%ld; ngrpaJ g;p tp;i)*)

F'(the( P1 deo)ed a) fo--o6): $fht; +piaj;jp; ,s;ns t+;J

bt-Fz;L tPrp bfhi bra;jjh; nghPrh"f;Fk; mth;kPJ ." tpnhjk; ,z;L/ +n,0; gl;nl; nghd;

gzf;fhh;fis kpl;- gzk;gpg;gJ b$f%f;F gf;fk;/*

1"0 The a--e.ed %ot&7e fo( the (o)e+'t&o* &) that the de+ea)ed +'t off the f&*.e()

of a*&5a*da* $A19 a*d &t &) the o*-y +a')e fo( th&) &*+&de*t0 It &) ad%&tted fa+t a*d

A1 a*d A2 6e(e a-)o &* Ya*a% S' Ja&- a*d the de+ea)ed &) at


65/123


66/123

3310 It &) a(.'ed o* the )&de of the defe*+e that the -a+e of o++'((e*+e &) a-)o *ot

+-ea(-y (o7ed &* th&) +a)e0 A++o(d&*., to the (o)e+'t&o* the &*+&de*t too5 -a+e

*ea( Ch'**a%a( !(&d.e, 't P1 deo)ed &* h&) e7&de*+e a) fo--o6:

z;zhk;ghW ghj;jp;Fk; mLj;j ghj;jp;Fk; !ilna

rk;gtk; +l+;jJ It &) f'(the( a(.'ed that the -a+e of o++

Documents

Pondicherry Sensational Historysheeter Jegan Murder Case Judgement