pnrp.gw.govt.nz · Web viewSubmission point. Further submission point. Submitter. Provision. Support Oppose. Decision requested. Panel decision. S19/001. Don Long. Rule R196: Motor

Topic – Activities in the CMA

Submission point

Further submission point

Submitter Provision Support Oppose

Decision requested Panel decision

S19/001 Don Long Rule R196: Motor vehicles - permitted activity

Amend Amend the PNRP to reinforce the existing local body regulation that makes parking on the beach at Day's Bay a parking offence.

Reject

/S29/038 Powerco Policy P145:

Reclamation, drainage and destruction

Support Retain Policy P145 without further modification. Accept

/S32/016 Wellington Recreational Marine

Fishers AssociationSchedule U:Trigger levels for river and stream mouth cutting

Amend [Amend Schedule U] and create a new mouth cutting regime for Makara Stream that acknowledges the role of the north-westerly weather patterns which will push shingle back into the river mouth. The present management plan is inadequate.

[Cease WRC placing logs] on the beach that prevents boat owners from accessing the sea, which is in breach of its own rules. This poorly worded schedule must not remain in its present form.

Reject


Fishers AssociationRule R193: River and stream mouth cutting - permitted activity

Amend [See submission point S32/016 e.g. amend Schedule U (trigger levels for mouth cutting)]

Reject


Fishers Association5.7.2 Coastal management general conditions

Amend Correct spawning times [for inanga] to 1st Jan to 31 May. We have a huge fluctuation of water temperatures over thesummer months and we have already proved inanga spawn in the early summer

Accept

Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Activities in the CMAPage 1 of 76

Submission point




months. They may spawn in August upnorth when the water temperature would suit them but not here as the waterwould be too cold.


Fishers AssociationRule R200: Dredging for flood protection purposes or erosion mitigation - controlled activity

Amend Find another method to dispose of the mud from the sand extraction process plant at the end of the Hutt River. It is unacceptable for the WRC to be knowingly in breach of [Rule 200].

Reject


Fishers Association5.7.2 Coastal management general conditions

Amend Reword [Note to 5.7.2(h)] to encourage stream banks to be protected with native plants. Include the words "native intertidal plants" so that WRC staff stop ripping out native intertidal plants. Stop this stream mismanagement by the WRC. The wording must make it clear native flax, raupo and toetoe are to be planted at the bottom of the stream banks to protect them.

Reject

/S33/041 Porirua Harbour and Catchment

Community Trust5.7.2 Coastal management general conditions

Not stated Clarify the origin of the coastal management general conditions [5.7.2], perhaps by referencing it in Schedule N(i).

Reject

/S34/001 Wendy Barry Rule R199: Motor

vehicles in the fossil forest at Titahi Bay - prohibited activity

Support Keep this rule in the final plan, but ensure there isadequate consultation and communication with the local community. It will create a big backlash if people feellike it has come out of the blue.

Accept in part

/S45/001 Claire Jones 5.7.13 Motor

vehicles on the foreshore

Amend Either amend the rules [relating to vehicles on beaches] to make them stronger or make the rules more public with more signage, more profile in our local papers, more patrols of the beaches and stronger penalties for breaking the law. Educating the public is important.

Accept in part


Submission point




/S55/041 The Oil Companies Policy P145:


Support Retain Policy 145 without further modification. Accept

/S66/023 GBC Winstone Rule R195:

Disturbance or damage inside sites of significance - non complying activity

Amend Add a note following Rule R195 to the effect that dredging for flood protection or erosion mitigation and associated disturbance and damage is covered in Rules R200 and R201.

Reject

/S68/003 Sophie Mormede Method M22:

Integrated management of the coast

Amend Engage with mana whenua, agencies, AND community groups that have governance responsibilities and INTEREST in the coastal marine area.

Reject

/S69/008 Friends of Taputeranga Marine

Reserve TrustRule R191: Disturbance associated with beach grooming - permitted activity

Not stated Make beach grooming at least a Discretionary or Restricted Discretionary activity (if not non-complying) within the marine reserve areas and other sites of significance.

Accept in part

/S69/010 Friends of Taputeranga Marine

Reserve TrustMethod M22: Integrated management of the coast

Not stated [Decision unclear; refer to original submission for details.] Reject

/S72/001 John Morrison Rule R193: River

and stream mouth cutting - permitted activity

Amend Clarify what is proposed to control the Waimeha Stream at Waikanae.Identify triggers for intervention which protect against excessive dune destruction.Require intervention within a faster time frame than at present.

Reject

/S72/002 John Morrison Schedule Amend Clarify what is proposed to control the Waimeha Stream at Reject


Submission point




U:Trigger levels for river and stream mouth cutting

Waikanae.Identify triggers for intervention which protect against excessive dune destruction.Require intervention within a faster time frame than at present.

/S73/001 Conrad John Toussaint Edwards Rule R199: Motor


Amend Amend the provisions to make it clear that cars are allowed to drive on Titahi Bay beach except where they could damage the fossil forest, which is where it is exposed at that time.[See original submission for further details].Do not redefine the area of the fossil forest in different words in Schedule J, or any of the rules. Rather cross reference Map 35, by adding "as shown in Map 35" or similar.Make clear that car access to Titahi Bay beach is permitted to launch and retrieve boats, and for boatshed owners to access their sheds.

Accept in part

/S73/002 Conrad John Toussaint Edwards Rule R190:

Launching, retrieving or temporary mooring of vessels - permitted activity

Amend [See submission point S73/001]. Accept in part

/S73/003 Conrad John Toussaint Edwards Rule R191:

Disturbance associated with beach grooming - permitted activity

Amend [See submission point S73/001]. Accept in part


vehicles - permitted activity

Amend [See submission point S73/001]. Reject


vehicles inside sites of significance - non



Submission point




complying activity/

S73/006 Conrad John Toussaint Edwards Schedule J: Significant geological features in the coastal marine area


/S73/007 Conrad John Toussaint Edwards Map 35: Titahi

Bay fossil forest (indicative)

Amend Make it absolutely clear what Map 35 will portray when it is no longer indicative. This should be known areas of fossil forest, i.e. areas of the beach where fossil remnants have been observed. This is NOT the whole foreshore as the crude indicative version implies.

Reject

/S73/008 Conrad John Toussaint Edwards Policy P149:

Protection of the Titahi Bay fossil forest

Amend [Make wording of references to the fossil forest area consistent. See submission point S73/001].

Reject

/S75/049 Minister of Conservation Objective O58:

Noise and underwater noise

Support Retain as notified Accept

/S75/110 Minister of Conservation Policy P143:

Deposition in a site of significance

Amend Retain policy but ensure that Policy 11 NZCPS is given effect to in policies.

Accept in part

FS41/023 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated

Oppose Disallow

FS74/198 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support AllowS75/111 Minister of Conservation Policy P144:

Dumping in a site with significant values

Amend Retain policy but ensure that Policy 11 NZCPS is given effect to in policies.

Accept in part


Reclamation, Support Retain as notified Accept


Submission point




drainage and destruction

FS41/024 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated

Oppose Disallow

S75/113 Minister of Conservation Policy P146: Introduction of pest plants



Motor vehicles in sites with significant value

Amend Include activities carried out by the Department of Conservation Reject

/S75/160 Minister of Conservation 5.7.2 Coastal

management general conditions

Support Retain as notified. Accept

/S75/172 Minister of Conservation Rule R195:


Support Retain as notified Reject

/S75/176 Minister of Conservation Rule R197: Motor

vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Amend Insert the following or similar:Conservation activities carried out by the Department of Conservation

Accept

FS73/022 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS75/177 Minister of Conservation Rule R200:

Dredging for flood protection purposes or erosion mitigation - controlled activity



Submission point





Destruction, damage or disturbance outside sites of significance - discretionary activity



Destruction, damage or disturbance inside sites of significance - non-complying activity



Deposition for beach renourishment - controlled activity



Deposition outside sites of significance - discretionary activity



Deposition inside sites of significance - non-complying activity


/


Submission point




S75/183 Minister of Conservation Rule R215: Reclamation and drainage - non-complying activity



Destruction - non-complying activity

Amend Clarify relationship for destruction between these sets of rules. Accept in part

FS69/081 Wellington International Airport Limited Support in part

Allow

S75/185 Minister of Conservation Rule R217: Planting - permitted activity

Amend Restrict planting to native plant species and to specified ecological enhancement and hazard mitigation objectives

Accept in part

/S79/001 Castlepoint Ratepayers and

Residents Association IncorporatedPolicy P148: Motor vehicles in sites with significant value

Oppose Amend P148 to allow recreational access onto the beach for vehicles, namely, Mataikona Beach, South of Suicide Rock Beach, Okau Beach [Sandy Bay] and adjacent sandy beaches, North, Whakataki Beach, and Castlepoint Beaches not covered [front beach] by the Masterton District Counil By-law.

Reject

/S81/007 New Zealand Defence Force 2.1.6 Definitions,

schedules and maps

Amend Include the following [new] definition of Temporary Military Training Activities:"Temporary Military Training Activity means a temporary military activity undertaken for defence purposes. The term 'defence purposes' is as per the Defence Act 1990."

Reject

/S81/008 New Zealand Defence Force Rule R185:

General surface water and foreshore activities - permitted activity

Amend Include the following definition of Temporary Military Training Activities:"Temporary Military Training Activity means a temporary military activity undertaken for defence purposes. The term 'defence purposes' is as per the Defence Act 1990."

Reject

/S84/011 Hutt City Council Rule R196: Motor


Amend Amend the activity status for disturbance in the coastal marine area to Discretionary Activity, regardless of whether it is located in an identified site of significance for birds. An exceptioncould be

Reject


Submission point




provided to identified sites of significance to birds of outstanding value or for areas of high natural or rural character.

/S84/012 Hutt City Council Policy P148:


Amend Amend the policy framework for disturbance in significant sites in the coastal marine area to require the management of specific effects, rather than simply demanding the avoidance of particular activities.

Reject

/S84/022 Hutt City Council Policy P148:


Oppose Reconsider the use of the term 'avoid' and ensure that it does not unnecessarily and inappropriately constrain activities that result in effects that are significant and/or provide essential services for the health and safety of the community and protection of the environment.Provide a policy framework that provides a pathway for new infrastructure reasonably needed to support existing or planned future development to gain resource consent. This would allow for resource consent for these activities to be granted in appropriate circumstances.

Reject

/S84/027 Hutt City Council Rule R198: Motor

vehicles inside sites of significance - non complying activity

Oppose Amend Rule R198 and change the activity status from a non-complying activity to a discretionary activity.

Reject

/S84/028 Hutt City Council Rule R195:



Reject


Destruction, damage or disturbance inside sites of


Reject


Submission point




significance - non-complying activity


Reclamation and drainage - non-complying activity


Reject

FS49/168 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS85/061 Roading, Parks and Gardens and

Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council

5.7.2 Coastal management general conditions

Amend Review the requirements for sediment discharges to ensure that these parametersare not exceeded by natural processes.

Reject

/S85/063 Roading, Parks and Gardens and


Rule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Support in part

Amend Rule R197 to provide for 'works for the protection' ofregionally significant infrastructure; ANDAmendthe definition of `regionally significant infrastructure' to include roads.

Reject

FS25/054 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowS85/066 Roading, Parks and Gardens and


Policy P145: Reclamation, drainage and destruction

Oppose in part

Remove the word `avoid' or alter the wording sothe requirements of the policy are less absolute and will provide forreclamation for other appropriate purposes.

Reject



Rule R214: Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure outside of sites of significance - discretionary activity

Amend Amend the plan to broaden the circumstances where reclamation is appropriate to includereasons other than regionally significant infrastructure.

Reject

FS49/167 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS85/068 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Rule R215: Amend Amend the plan to broaden the circumstances where reclamation Reject


Submission point






is appropriate to include reasons other than regionally significant infrastructure.



Rule R204: Destruction, damage or disturbance outside sites of significance - discretionary activity

Amend Clarify that coastal protection structures such as revetments areexcluded from the rules on the 'destruction' of the foreshore or seabed.

Reject

/S85/070 Roading, Parks and Gardens and


Rule R205: Destruction, damage or disturbance inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

Amend Clarify that coastal protection structures such as revetments are excluded from the rules on the 'destruction' of the foreshore or seabed.

Reject

/S88/023 Trelissick Park Group Method M22:

Integrated management of the coast

Amend The northern beach of the reclamation needs improved public access.

Reject

/S92/005 Linda Katherine Dale and Melis

Leonard van de WerkenRule R198: Motor vehicles inside sites of significance - non complying activity

Amend We seek to amend Rule 198 of the Proposed NRP to be a discretionary activity for the Golden Gate Peninsula including Browns Bay and Ivey Bay. That is, retain the existing provisions for this area.

Reject

/S92/006 Linda Katherine Dale and Melis

Leonard van de WerkenRule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Amend Remove the words "regionally significant" OR An additional provision be made under rule 197 to ensure that motor vehicles are permitted in the coastal area for the maintenance and operation of existing infrastructure.

Reject


Submission point




/S93/020 Coastal Ratepayers United

IncorporatedBeach recontouring (coastal marine area)

Amend Clarify that river and stream cutting is not included in "Beach recontouring (beds of rivers)" and "Beach recontouring (coastal marine area)". Reconsider the differences in the wording and make them consistent. Reconsider the use of the terms "river beach" and "beach" in the "beach contouring (beds of rivers)" definition and consider also including a reference to "bed".

Reject


IncorporatedPolicy P143: Deposition in a site of significance

Oppose in part

Clarify what is meant by "shingle".Delete "and in respect of (a) to (f): (g) there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the activity". Reconsider (b) and (d) and include reference to coastal hazard mitigation (including protection), using terminology consistent with that developed for the PNRP.

Reject


IncorporatedPolicy P145: Reclamation, drainage and destruction

Oppose in part

Revise the policy so that appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities are enabled (using appropriate language that is consistent with that used in the PNRP).Include definitions of "destruction", "disturbance", and "damage" so that the differences in meaning of the terms is clear

Reject

FS61/041 Minister of Conservation Oppose in part

Disallow

S93/077 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated

5.7.2 Coastal management general conditions

Amend [See decision requested for submission point S93/070]. In the rules that permit discharge of contaminants, remove the confusing interaction between the coastal management general conditions and the rules that refer to them, preferably by indicating that general condition (e) does not apply.

Reject

/S93/083 Coastal Ratepayers United Rule R192: Amend [See decision requested for submission point S93/070]. Accept


Submission point




Incorporated Beach recontouring for coastal restoration purposes - controlled activity

Reconsider why Rule R119 is a permitted activity but Rule R192 is a controlled activity and make them both either one way or the other.Consider whether reference to diverting water should be included in all of these rules as moving material for the beach grooming could arguably result in diversion of water when the water reaches that area.


IncorporatedRule R193: River and stream mouth cutting - permitted activity

Amend Change the references from "river and stream" to "river (including stream)" here and anywhere else such terminology occurs in the PNRP. Change the reference in (c) from "open coastal water" to "water" and anywhere else inappropriate "open coastal water" terminology appears in the PNRP. Remove the duplicated reference to "discharge of contaminants" and make the list consistent with equivalent lists in all other rules. Create a new rule that is the equivalent of Rule 193 but that deals with river and stream mouth cutting in the beds of rivers (including streams) or otherwise ensure that appropriate provision is made for such activities in beds of rivers (including streams).

Accept in part


IncorporatedRule R194: Disturbance or damage - discretionary activity

Amend Reconsider the relationship between [R194 and R195] and all of the other rules, including their reference to "damage" that is missing from most of the other rules. Revise these and all other rules to address the concerns expressed throughout this submission.Ensure that any coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities, including soft and hard engineering activities, are no worse than discretionary activities.

Reject


IncorporatedRule R196: Motor vehicles - permitted activity

Oppose in part

Exclude from this rule the areas in districts where motor vehicles are not permitted (and areas seaward of those areas). A suggestion is to create a new map, identify all of these areas and

Reject


Submission point




exclude these areas from Rule R196 and, with appropriate exceptions, make such an activity a discretionary activity.


IncorporatedRule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Amend Change "local authority activities" here and anywhere else that term (or any similar term) is used in the PNRP to activities carried out "by or on behalf of local authorities" or similar wording to convey the message that the provision covers not only work done by local authorities and but also work done by others (e.g., contractors) on behalf of local authorities for a range of purposes. Include coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities (using appropriate terminology) as one of the purposes so that motor vehicles for that purpose are permitted activities.

Reject


IncorporatedRule R200: Dredging for flood protection purposes or erosion mitigation - controlled activity

Amend Please see the decisions sought elsewhere in this submission. Reject


IncorporatedRule R201: Dredging for flood protection purposes or erosion mitigation inside sites of significance - discretionary activity

Amend Please see the decisions sought elsewhere in this submission. Reject


IncorporatedRule R204: Destruction, damage or disturbance outside sites of significance -

Amend Set out what destruction, damage or disturbance refers to. Address and remedy how these rules relate to other rules that do not refer to destruction or damage. Clarify the meaning of "damage" and "destruction" and how those terms differ from, and relate to, "disturbance". Make Rule R205 a discretionary activity or otherwise address the concerns expressed throughout this

Reject


Submission point




discretionary activity

submission.


IncorporatedRule R205: Destruction, damage or disturbance inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

Amend Set out what destruction, damage or disturbance refers to. Address and remedy how these rules relate to other rules that do not refer to destruction or damage. Clarify the meaning of "damage" and "destruction" and how those terms differ from, and relate to, "disturbance". Make Rule R205 a discretionary activity or otherwise address the concerns expressed throughout this submission.

Reject


IncorporatedRule R207: Deposition for beach renourishment - controlled activity

Support in part

Add diversion of water to this rule and to all other relevant rules as deposition may divert water when the water reaches that area. Change (d) "by, or for, a local authority" to "by, or on behalf of, a local authority" and use that terminology consistently throughout the PNRP when reference is made to things being done by a local authority or local authority activities so it is clear that the work can be done by others who are not part of the local authority.

Reject


IncorporatedRule R208: Deposition outside sites of significance - discretionary activity

Amend Clarify if the structures or seawalls rules cover the deposition of material to protect those structures or whether rules R208 and R209 apply. Add reference to associated diversion of water. Add reference to occupation of space in the coastal marine area for whatever rules do apply to the material used to protect any structures or seawalls or other materials deposited for coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities.

Reject


IncorporatedRule R209: Deposition inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

Amend Clarify if the structures or seawalls rules cover the deposition of material to protect those structures or whether rules R208 and R209 apply. Add reference to associated diversion of water. Add reference to occupation of space in the coastal marine area for whatever rules do apply to the material used to protect any structures or seawalls or other materials deposited for coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities.

Reject


Submission point





Incorporated6.10 Coast Amend Include a method outlining GWRC's intention to take the lead role

in the coordination of a partnership programme between Department of Conservation, city and district councils and their communities to proactively manage the beach and dune reserve environments and restore the form and function of the dune systems in the Wellington region

Reject

/S99/020 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings

LimitedRule R214: Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure outside of sites of significance - discretionary activity

Amend Rule R214: Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure outside sites of significance - Controlled activity, discretionary activity

Include appropriate matters for control. Such other additional or consequential relief as is necessary to achieve consistency with the above and to satisfy the concerns of the KCAHL.

Reject

FS61/066 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS112/034 Friends of the Paekakariki Streams Objective O58:


Support [Not stated] Accept

/S112/079 Friends of the Paekakariki Streams Policy P150:

Noise and lightingSupport [Not stated] Accept

/S112/080 Friends of the Paekakariki Streams Policy P151:

Underwater noiseSupport [Not stated] Accept

/S117/052 Kāpiti Coast District Council Policy P143:


Support Retain the provision Accept


Submission point








Motor vehicles on the foreshore





/S117/075 Kāpiti Coast District Council Rule R189:

Clearance of stormwater pipes - permitted activity


/S117/076 Kāpiti Coast District Council Rule R191:



/S117/077 Kāpiti Coast District Council Rule R193: River



/S117/078 Kāpiti Coast District Council Rule R197: Motor



/S117/084 Kāpiti Coast District Council Maps 42-48:

Coastal marine Amend Council establishes, and includes a mapped boundary to the

CMA, and prepares maps that show the location of coastal Reject


Submission point




area and river mouth boundaries

protection structures in relation to the CMA boundary within the Regional Plan

/S121/012 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Port Noise

Control LineSupport Retain this definition in

its current form.Accept

/S121/013 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Port related

activitiesAmend Amend definition as follows:

Activities within the Commercial Port Area, the Lambton Harbour Area and on the adjacent land within the district including, but not limited to, the berthing, departure and movement of ships, storage and cargo handling, handling of goods and passengers, all activities associated with the movement, storage and handling of cargo and any activities (including construction, maintenance and repair) associated with buildings, other structures, machinery and equipment used in connection with the port or its administration.

Reject

FS49/004 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS121/038 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O58:


Support Retain Objective O58 in its current form. Accept

/S121/082 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P143:


Not stated Amend Policy P143 as follows:Deposition of sand, shingle or shell in a site identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) and Schedule J (geological features) shall be avoided except where:...and in respect of (a) to (f):(g) there are no practicable alternative locations or methods of providing for the activity.

Accept


Reclamation, Support Retain Policy P145 in its current form. Accept


Submission point




drainage and destruction


Noise and lightingSupport Retain Policy P150 in its current form. Accept


Underwater noiseSupport Retain Policy P151 in its current form. Accept

FS69/068 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS121/106 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) 5.7.2 Coastal


Oppose in part

Amend the coastal management general conditions by either:1. deleting general condition (c), or2. Amend Map 30 to more accurately reflect the extent of the Aquifer, or3. Exclude the Commercial Port Area in the rule [from having to meet condition (c)].

Reject

FS25/051 Wellington Water Limited Oppose DisallowS121/107 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) 5.7.2 Coastal


Support in part

Amend Coastal Management General Management Condition (u) as follows:(u) Port Noise Management Plan

CentrePort shall at all times operate in accordance with the current Port Noise Management Plan for CentrePort Ltd

Reject

/S121/130 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R185:

General surface water and foreshore activities - permitted activity

Support in part

Amend Rule R185 to add a note excluding activity in theCommercial Port Area.

Accept in part


General surface water and foreshore

Support in part

Amend Rule R186 to add a note excluding activity in the Commercial Port Area.

Accept in part


Submission point




activities - restricted discretionary



Support Retain Rule R189 in its current form. Accept

/S121/133 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) 5.7.14 Dredging Amend Insert a new rule providing for maintenance dredging within a

CommercialPort Area or navigation protection area as a permitted activity.

Reject


Maintenance dredging outside a Commercial Port Area or navigation protection areas - controlled activity



Dredging inside the Commercial Port Area and in navigation protection areas - discretionary activity



Dumping of waste or other matter inside sites of significance - non-complying

Amend Amend Rule R212 to provide for dredging related deposition or dumpingwithin a scheduled site as a discretionary activity.

Reject


Submission point




activityFS74/312 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS61/065 Minister of Conservation Oppose Disallow

S121/137 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R214: Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure outside of sites of significance - discretionary activity

Support in part

Amend Rule R214 as follows:Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure activities outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area, including any associated: ...

Reject



Support Retain Rule R215 in its current form, subject to the relief sought inrelation to Rule R214. [see S121/137]

Accept in part



Amend Either delete Rule R216 or define "destruction" within the definitions section or within the context of the rule itself.

Accept

/S121/148 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Map 49:

Navigation protection areas in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicolson)

Amend Amend Map 49 as shown in attached Plan [see map on p33 of original submission] and include the Commercial PortArea as being a Navigation Protection Area.

Reject

/S125/020 Rural Residents Environmental

Society IncorporatedPolicy P150: Noise and lighting

Amend New Policy P150: Noise and lighting Noise shall be controlled so as not to cause nuisance to sensitive areas. Exterior lighting shall avoid being directed at sensitive activities, streets, roads and navigation tracks and shall minimise effects on other users and wildlife, unless it is for operational health and safety reasons.

Reject


Submission point




/S126/004 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Motor vehicle Amend Amend the definition of Motor Vehicle by removing the weight

restriction of 3500kg.Accept

/S126/021 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P143:


Support in part

Policy P143 is supported.WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for P143 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

Reject



Support in part

Policy P144 is supported.WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for P144 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.

Reject



Support in part

Policy P147 is supported, contingent on the definitions for 'regionally significant infrastructure' and 'motor vehicle' being amended in accordance with submission points S126/006 and S126/004 respectively.

Accept in part



Support in part

Policy P148 is supported, contingent on the definitions for 'regionally significant infrastructure' and 'motor vehicle' being amended in accordance with submission points S126/006 and S126/004 respectively.

Accept in part

/


Submission point




S126/035 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Rule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Support in part

Rule 197 is supported, contingent on the definition for 'motor vehicle' being amended in accordance with submission point S126/004.

Accept in part

/S133/018 Greater Wellington Regional Council Rule R191:


Amend Amend to include the requirement that beach grooming activities controlled by this rule meet the coastal management general conditions.

Accept

/S135/010 Wellington Water Limited Coastal

restoration planAmend Clarify what is meant by "natural state" and recognise that most of

the urban Wellington region coastline has been extensively developed.

Accept in part

FS69/006 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS135/130 Wellington Water Limited Policy P143:


Support Support (e) and (f) Accept

/S135/131 Wellington Water Limited Policy P147:


Support Support (d) Accept



Support Retain. Accept



Support Retain. Accept

/S135/182 Wellington Water Limited 5.7.2 Coastal

management general

Amend Clarify the applicability of these general conditions to the functioning and benefits of stormwater flap gates and three waters regionally significant infrastructure generally. Clarify condition

Accept in part


Submission point




conditions (m) applies to stormwater outfalls or what type of structures are included.

/S135/185 Wellington Water Limited Rule R189:


Support Support Accept

/S135/186 Wellington Water Limited Rule R214:

Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure outside of sites of significance - discretionary activity

Support Support Accept

/S140/007 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited In-water cleaning Support Retain Accept

/S140/010 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Port related

activitiesAmend Amend definition as follows.

Activities within the Commercial Port Area... associated with buildings, other structures, machinery and equipment used in connection with the port or its administration.

Reject

FS49/007 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS140/071 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R194:

Disturbance or damage - discretionary activity

Support in part

The disturbance or damage of the foreshore or seabed outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5...

Reject


Submission point




/S140/072 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R195:


Support in part

Disturbance or damage of the foreshore or seabed inside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) ) unless located in the Commercial Port Area...

Reject



Support in part

...Destruction, damage or disturbance outside a site and habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5...

Reject


Destruction, damage or disturbance inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

Support in part

...Destruction, damage or disturbance inside a site and habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area,...

Reject



Not stated ...Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure activities outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5...

Reject


Reclamation and drainage - non-

Not stated ...Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure activities outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F4

Reject


Submission point




complying activity (coastal sites), unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5...

/S141/006 CentrePort Properties Limited Noise sensitive

activitiesSupport Retain

the definition.Accept

/S141/007 CentrePort Properties Limited Port related

activitiesAmend Retainthis definition. Accept

/S141/008 CentrePort Properties Limited Port Noise

Control LineSupport Retainthis definition. Accept

/S141/034 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P145:


Amend (a) the reclamation, drainage or destruction is associated with the development, operation, maintenance and upgrade of regionally significant infrastructure (b) and there are no other locations outside the coastal marine area for the activity associated with the reclamation, drainage or destruction, or(b) the reclamation, drainage or destruction is associated with appropriate use and development in the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone); and...

Reject

/S141/035 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P150:

Noise and lightingSupport Retain in its current form. Accept

/S141/040 CentrePort Properties Limited 5.7.2 Coastal

management Amend Remove theLambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone) from the Hutt

Valleyaquifer zone and/or that the provision be amended.Reject


Submission point




general conditions

FS25/052 Wellington Water Limited Oppose DisallowS141/041 CentrePort Properties Limited 5.7.2 Coastal


Support Retainprovisions for noise in current form. Accept

/S141/061 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R186:

General surface water and foreshore activities - restricted discretionary

Support Retain in its current form. Accept

/S141/062 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R196: Motor


Support Retain in its current form. Accept in part

/S141/063 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R197: Motor


Amend The disturbance of the foreshore or seabed from motor vehicles in the coastal marine area, for the following purposes:(a) surf lifesaving operations...(d) the maintenance, upgrade and operation of regionally significant infrastructure or(e) use and development in the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone).is a permitted activity, provided the following conditions are met:...

Reject


Destruction, damage or disturbance outside sites of

Support Retain in its current form. Reject


Submission point




significance - discretionary activity



Support Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure activities and development inside the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone) outside a site or habitat identified...

Reject



Oppose DeleteRule R215. Reject



Oppose [DeleteRule R216.] Accept


Planting - permitted activity

Support Retainin its current form. Accept in part


Planting - discretionary activity

Support Retain in its current form. Accept

/S142/013 New Zealand Fire Commission and

Wellington Rural Fire AuthorityRule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Support Retain the inclusion of motor vehicles for firefighting in Rule R197. Accept

/


Submission point




S145/004 First Gas Ltd 2.2 Definitions Not stated Add a new definition: Best practicable option, means the best site, route or method for preventing or minimising the adverse effects on the environment having regard, among other things, to: (a) the nature of the discharge or emission and the sensitivity of the receiving environment to adverse effects; and (b) the financial implications, and the effects on the environment, of that option when compared with other options; and (c) the current state of technical knowledge and the likelihood that the option can be successfully applied.

Reject

FS57/003 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS56/016 Powerco Support Allow

S146/007 NZ Transport Agency 2.2 Definitions Not stated Add new definition which aligns with the RMA: Section 2 Interpretation definition of the term: Best practicable option means the best site, route or method for preventing or minimising the adverse effects on the environment having regard, among other things, to-- (a) the nature of the discharge or emission and the sensitivity of the receiving environment to adverse effects; and (b) the financial implications, and the effects on the environment, of that option when compared with other options; and (c) the current state of technical knowledge and the likelihood that the option can be successfully applied

Reject


Submission point




FS30/014 Masterton District Council Support AllowFS57/004 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS26/014 South Wairarapa District Council Support Allow

S146/010 NZ Transport Agency 2.2 Definitions Not stated Add a new definition for 'coastal marine area' which aligns with the RMA: Section 2 Interpretation definition of the term, as follows: Coastal marine area means the foreshore, seabed, and coastal water, and the air space above the water-- (a) of which the seaward boundary is the outer limits of the territorial sea: (b) of which the landward boundary is the line of mean high water springs, except that where that line crosses a river, the landward boundary at that point shall be whichever is the lesser of-- (i) 1 kilometre upstream from the mouth of the river; or (ii) the point upstream that is calculated by multiplying the width of the river mouth by 5.

Reject

FS43/012 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society

Support Allow

S146/133 NZ Transport Agency Policy P143: Deposition in a site of significance

Support in part

Amend Policy 143: Deposition of sand, shingle or shell in a site identified ... shall be avoided except where: . . .. (f) it is necessary to enable the efficient and effective development, operation, maintenance and upgrade or development of regionally significant infrastructure, and in respect of (a) to (f): (g) the activity represents the best practicable option there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the activity.

Reject

/


Submission point




S146/134 NZ Transport Agency Policy P144: Dumping in a site with significant values

Support in part

Amend Policy 144 Dumping in a site identified ... shall be avoided except where: (a) it is necessary to enable the effective and efficient development, operation, maintenance and upgrade or development of regionally significant infrastructure, and (b) the activity represents the best practicable option there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the activity.

Reject

/S146/135 NZ Transport Agency Policy P145:


Support in part

Amend Policy 145: Reclamation, drainage or destruction in the coastal marine area shall be avoided except where: (a) the reclamation, drainage or destruction is associated with the development, operation, maintenance and upgrade or development of regionally significant infrastructure, and (b) there are no other practical locations outside the coastal marine area for the activity associated with the reclamation, drainage or destruction, and (b) the activity represents the best practicable option there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the associated activity.

Reject

/S146/211 NZ Transport Agency Rule R187:

General surface water and foreshore activities - discretionary activity

Support in part

(i) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2.

Reject


Disturbance or Support Retain Reject


Submission point




damage - discretionary activity

FS56/110 Powerco Support AllowFS61/062 Minister of Conservation Support Allow

S146/213 NZ Transport Agency 5.7.12 General disturbance activities

Not stated Add a new rule which specifically provides for disturbance or damage of the foreshore or seabed inside a site of significance as a discretionary activity where there is a functional and operational need.

Reject


Allow

FS61/061 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS146/214 NZ Transport Agency Rule R195:


Oppose Retain Rule 195, subject to providing for disturbance or damage of the foreshore or seabed inside a site of significance where associated with regionally significant infrastructure and where there is a functional or operational requirement.

Reject

FS56/111 Powerco Support AllowFS51/025 GBC Winstone Support Allow

S146/215 NZ Transport Agency Rule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Support in part

Amend Rule 197: The disturbance of the foreshore or seabed from motor vehicles in the coastal marine area, for the following purposes: . . . . . (d) the operation, maintenance, repair, upgrade and development operation of regionally significant infrastructure is a permitted activity, provided the following conditions are met: (e) the vehicle shall take the most direct route, and shall only operate within the area necessary to carry out the activity to ensure minimal disturbance to the foreshore or seabed, and (f) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2.

Reject


Submission point





Allow

FS56/112 Powerco Support AllowFS61/063 Minister of Conservation Oppose Disallow

S146/216 NZ Transport Agency Rule R204: Destruction, damage or disturbance outside sites of significance - discretionary activity

Support Retain Accept

FS56/113 Powerco Support AllowS146/217 NZ Transport Agency 5.7.19

DestructionNot stated Add a new rule or amend rule 204 to specifically provide for

destruction, damage or disturbance inside a site of significance as a discretionary activity where associated with regionally significant infrastructure

Reject

FS22/049 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS56/114 Powerco Support Allow

S146/218 NZ Transport Agency Rule R205: Destruction, damage or disturbance inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

Oppose Retain Rule 205, subject to providing for destruction, damage or disturbance inside a site of significance where associated with regionally significant infrastructure

Reject

FS56/115 Powerco Support AllowS146/219 NZ Transport Agency Rule R208:

Deposition outside sites of significance - discretionary activity

Support Retain Reject

FS56/116 Powerco Support AllowS146/220 NZ Transport Agency 5.7.16

DespositionOppose Add a new rule which specifically provides for deposition inside a

site of significance as a discretionary activity where associated Reject


Submission point




with regionally significant infrastructure

FS56/117 Powerco Support AllowS146/221 NZ Transport Agency Rule R209:

Deposition inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

Oppose Retain Rule 209, subject to providing for deposition inside a site of significance where associated with regionally significant infrastructure

Reject



Support in part

Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure activities outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area, including any associated:....

Reject

FS61/064 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS146/223 NZ Transport Agency Rule R215:


Oppose No relief sought, subject to the relief sought under Rule 214 applying to regionally significant infrastructure by default.

Reject

FS64/022 New Zealand Defence Force Support AllowS146/224 NZ Transport Agency Rule R216:


Neither support or oppose

Provide clarity on what destruction means in the context of the Plan.

Reject

FS69/082 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS148/001 Rebecca Logan Rule R199: Motor


Support [Retain the prohibition] Accept

/S161/001 Susie Mills Rule R193: River

and stream Amend Submitter requests that a more comprehensive approach and

range of options are considered for the trigger points at the Reject


Submission point




mouth cutting - permitted activity

Waimeha stream mouth. Kapiti Coast District Council and any other person should be able to act if a trigger point is reached - not just Greater Wellington Regional Council.

/S162/013 Mt Victoria Residents Association

IncPolicy P145: Reclamation, drainage and destruction

Not stated Rule R214 contravenes the required avoidance by making the activities discretionary, except in sites of significance. This Rule should be more stringent by requiring evidence of why there are not other locations and practicable alternatives.

Reject

FS49/141 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS163/017 Porirua City Council Rule R199: Motor


Amend Amend Rule R199 insofar as it relates to the extension of the current prohibited area to vehicles. The continuation of the operative prohibited area is supported but the remaining area marked on Map 35 should be changed to non-complying status. In the longer term, PCC wishes to develop a collaborative management regime for Titahi Bay beach and surrounding area.

Reject

FS80/002 Titahi Bay Residents Association Oppose in part

Disallow

S163/028 Porirua City Council Noise sensitive activities

Amend Consider adding hospitals or similar to this definition. Reject

/S163/078 Porirua City Council Policy P148:


Support [Retain] Accept

/S163/079 Porirua City Council Policy P149:


Not stated [See submission point S163/017] Reject

/S163/128 Porirua City Council 5.7.2 Coastal


Amend Review conditions (a) and (i) in terms of how muchdisturbance is actually acceptable, regardless of the activity.Reconsider condition (k) to make construction andmaintenance of a structure actually practicable and allow fortemporary obstructions to fish passage that will not

Reject


Submission point




significantly affect fish ecology.Review condition (I) to allow for limited minor disturbanceassociated with essential works and provide an exemptionfor emergency works.

/S163/142 Porirua City Council Rule R189:





Amend Provide clarification to address the concerns raised in the comments [regarding situations where there is no boat ramp at the locality, the meaning of "exposed", and which rule applies to activities that do not meet the conditions of R190]

Reject

FS80/001 Titahi Bay Residents Association Support AllowS163/144 Porirua City Council Rule R194:


Amend The following may need to be added: "that is not permitted by ... Rule R190..." [See submission point S163/143].

Reject



Amend The following may need to be added: "that is not permitted by ... Rule R190..." [See submission point S163/143].

Reject

/S163/146 Porirua City Council Rule R197: Motor



/S163/147 Porirua City Council Rule R198: Motor Not stated Review the rule in light of the fact that in some sites of Reject


Submission point





significance such as Pauatahanui Inlet, residential property owners who use the foreshore to access their homes will now require resource consent under this rule as a non complying activity. Provide for the maintenance of existing access where this is historical or legally established as a controlled activity.

/S163/148 Porirua City Council Rule R199: Motor


Amend Retain prohibited activity status for the existing prohibited area as defined by the operative Regional Coastal Plan, and change the status of the remaining area marked on Map 35 so that it is non-complying, in line with rule R198. Amend Map 35 and GIS accordingly, and correct Map 35 and GIS so that the eastern boundary of the fossil forest matches the line of Mean High Water Springs.

Reject

FS80/003 Titahi Bay Residents Association Oppose DisallowS163/163 Porirua City Council Map 35: Titahi


Amend See the comments regarding Titahi Bay beach [submission point S163/017] and the requested amendments on Rule R199 [S163/148]. Amend Map 35 and GIS so that the existing prohibited area is reduced to the area defined by the operative Regional Coastal Plan, with the remaining area marked so that it is noncomplying.Correct Map 35 and GIS so that the eastern boundary of the fossil forest accurately follows the line of Mean High Water Springs.

Reject

FS80/004 Titahi Bay Residents Association Oppose DisallowS165/016 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P143:



/S165/017 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P144:







Submission point







/S165/083 Transpower NZ Ltd Rule R215:


Amend (e) diversion of open coastal waterthat is not a discretionary activity under Rule R160A or Rule R214 is a noncomplying activity.

Reject

/S167/003 Sustainable Wairarapa Inc 3.13 Coastal

managementNot stated While DOC is responsible for marine reserves, how can GWRC

work with DOC to identify and coordinate these within the plan?Reject

/S175/005 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 2.2 Definitions Amend Include appropriate definitions of "disturbance", "damage" and

"destruction" (or variations of those terms) to identify how they relate to, and differ from, each other and how they relate to and differ from "reclamation" and perhaps "drainage".

Reject

/S175/006 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Beach

recontouring (coastal marine area)

Amend Clarify that river (including stream) cutting is not included in the definition. Reconsider the differences in the wording of the provisions and make them consistent.

Reject

/S175/051 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P143:


Oppose in part

Clarify what is meant by "shingle" and ensure that terminology of PNRP is consistent. Delete "and in respect of (a) to (f): (g) there are....for the activity". Reconsider (b) and (d) and include a reference to coastal hazard mitigation (including protection).

Reject

/S175/052 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P145:

Reclamation, drainage and

Oppose in part

Revise the policy so that appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities are enabled. Include new definitions [See submission point S175/005].

Reject


Submission point




destruction/

S175/067 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R192: Beach recontouring for coastal restoration purposes - controlled activity

Amend Refer to decisions requested in submission point S175/055 and S175/060.

Reject

/S175/068 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R193: River


Amend Change the references from "river and stream" to "river (including stream)" here and anywhere else such terminology occurs in the PNRP. Change the reference in (c) from "open coastal water" to "water" and anywhere else inappropriate "open coastal water" terminology appears in the PNRP. Check the list of associated activities, remove the duplicated reference to "discharge of contaminants", consider whether in this rule and in all other rules the location of the discharge of contaminants should be specified rather than being silent, and make the list complete and consistent with equivalent lists in all other rules. Create a new rule that is the equivalent of Rule 193 but that deals with river and stream mouth cutting in the beds of rivers (including streams) or otherwise ensure that appropriate provision is made for such activities in beds of rivers (including streams).

Accept in part

/S175/069 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R194:


Amend Reconsider the relationship between these general rules [R194 and R195] and all of the other rules, including the reference to "damage" that is missing from most of the other rules. Revise these and all other rules to address the concerns expressed throughout this submission. Consider whether diversion of water should be added. Ensure that any coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities, including soft and hard engineering activities, are no worse than discretionary activities.

Reject

/


Submission point




S175/070 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R196: Motor vehicles - permitted activity

Oppose in part

Exclude from this rule the areas in districts where motor vehicles are not permitted (and areas seaward of those areas), including the area seaward of the houses on Rodney Avenue, Te Horo Beach. A suggestion is to create a new schedule and map, identify all of these areas, and exclude these areas from Rule R196 and, with appropriate exceptions, make such an activity a discretionary activity.

Reject

/S175/071 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R197: Motor


Amend Change "local authority activities" here and anywhere else that term (or any similar term) is used in the PNRP to activities carried out "by, or on behalf of, a local authority" or similar wording.Include coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities (using appropriate terminology) as one of the purposes.

Reject

/S175/072 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 5.7.14 Dredging Support in

partRules R200 and R100 - support and seek amendment. See decisions requested elsewhere in submission S175.

Reject

/S175/073 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 5.7.15 All other

destruction, damage or disturbance

Amend Reconsider the terminology used in all of the rules to ensure that it is consistent and appropriate. Set out what is being destroyed, damaged, or disturbed. Address how these rules relate to other rules. Make Rule R205 a discretionary activity and revise the category of Rule R204 or otherwise address the concerns expressed throughout this submission. New definitions for terms [see submission point S175/005].

Reject

/S175/074 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R207:

Deposition for beach renourishment - controlled activity

Support in part

Add diversion of water to this rule and to all other relevant rules as deposition may divert water when the water reaches that area.Change (d) "by, or for, a local authority" to "by, or on behalf of, a local authority" and use that terminology consistently throughout the PNRP.See the decisions sought in the rest of submission [S175].

Reject

/


Submission point




S175/075 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R209: Deposition inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

Amend Revise the rule and related rules (or create new rules) to address the concerns expressed here and throughout this submission. Clarify if the structures or seawalls rules cover the deposition of material to protect those structures (where the material is not fixed to the land) or whether these rules apply. Add reference to associated diversion of water. Add reference to occupation of space in the coastal marine area for whatever rules do apply to the material used to protect any structures or seawalls or other materials deposited for coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities. In terms of categorisation of the activities, a suggestion is that deposition outside sites of significance should be a permitted, controlled or restricted discretionary activity with deposition inside sites of significance being a discretionary activity.

Reject

/S180/001 Donna Zimmerman Rule R199: Motor


Oppose Amend provision to allow blanket resource consent for motor vehicles in the boat shed areas at the end of the beach.

Reject

/S181/001 Stephen Frank Warren Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S182/001 Sandy Jennings Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S184/001 Reeva Williams Rule R199: Motor



Reject


Submission point




/S185/001 Gordon Hutcheson Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S186/001 Deborah Maddox Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S187/001 Tammy Fitchett Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S188/001 Bonita Moana Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S189/001 Vietona Antogi Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S190/001 Kim Eastham Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S191/001 Chris Van Niekerk Rule R199: Motor

vehicles in the Oppose Amend provision to allow blanket resource consent for motor

vehicles in the boat shed areas at the end of the beach.Reject


Submission point




fossil forest at Titahi Bay - prohibited activity

/S192/001 Peter Hyngs Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S193/001 Louis Webster Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S194/001 Titahi Bay Boatshed Owners Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S195/001 John Linschoten Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S196/001 Tracey Waters Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S197/001 David and Marlena Peacock Rule R199: Motor



Reject


Submission point




/S198/001 Mary Iafeta Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S199/001 Emma Ward Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S200/001 Terese Church Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S201/001 John Ward Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S202/001 Krystal Rankin O'Regan Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S203/001 Manu Barclay Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S204/001 Joshua Holmes Rule R199: Motor




Submission point





/S205/001 Steve Wallace Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S206/001 Andrew Wallace Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S207/001 Steve Cranney Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S208/001 Greg Stanbridge Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S209/001 Pam Ringrose Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S210/001 Leiken Jahne Stapp Walker Rule R199: Motor



Reject


Submission point




/S211/001 Scott McIntosh Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S212/001 Tanya Bason Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S213/001 Falyn Kamana Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S214/001 Kiri Hunter Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S215/001 Kayla Hawea Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S216/001 Tephin Lao Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S217/001 Cathie Tomkies Rule R199: Motor




Submission point





/S218/001 Mark Whaley Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S219/001 Jaime Fearn Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S220/001 Jamie McIntosh Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S221/001 Alex Kelly Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S222/001 Vicky Phillips Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S223/001 Horouta Kohanga Reo Rule R199: Motor



Reject


Submission point




/S224/001 Luisa Power Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S225/001 Sophie Bevan Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S226/001 Terrie Thomson Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S227/001 T Essel Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S228/001 K Collins Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S229/001 Kirsty Cooper Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S230/001 Kimberley Linschoten Rule R199: Motor




Submission point





/S231/001 Janette Linschoten Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S232/001 Hemi Remuera Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S233/001 Jenny McIntosh Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S234/001 Nicole Remuera Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S235/001 Chris Eastwood Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S236/001 Carl Jamieson Rule R199: Motor



Reject


Submission point




/S237/001 Di Robertson Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S238/001 Trevor Carrier Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S239/001 Anita MacPherson Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S240/001 Michael and Pam Winthrop Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S241/001 Louise Fruean Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S242/001 Raewynne Graf Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S243/001 Marion Slow Rule R199: Motor




Submission point





/S244/001 Ezric Slow Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S245/001 Wendy Leary Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S246/001 Paul Murray Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S247/001 Rate Payer Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S248/001 Koro Pulman Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S249/001 Mr and Mrs Allan Rule R199: Motor



Reject


Submission point




/S250/001 Titahi Bay Fisherman's Club Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S251/001 Arthur Hunter Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S252/001 Autie Matthew Hunter Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S253/001 Ralence James Tahuparae Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S254/001 Shonn William Tupaea Roberts Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S255/001 Carlos Nathan Watters-Rangitiki Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S256/001 Danny Makamaka Rule R199: Motor




Submission point





/S257/001 Maikara Thorpe Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S258/001 Awhina Takerapa Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S259/001 Ben Notes Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S260/001 Neil Walter Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S261/001 Hayden Poole Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S262/001 Natalia Spooner Rule R199: Motor



Reject


Submission point




/S263/001 Fiona Apanui-Kupenga Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S264/001 Tyrone Gardiner Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S265/001 Murray Patterson Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S266/001 Emily Wikingi Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S267/001 Dave Abbott Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S268/001 Titahi Bay RSA Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S269/001 L Haggland Rule R199: Motor




Submission point





/S270/001 Sue Hagai Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S271/001 Vaero Hagai Rule R199: Motor



Reject

/S272/001 Titahi Bay Residents Association Policy P149:


Oppose To have this provision amended to allow blanket resource consent for motor vehicles in the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach.

That the local inner-beach boundaries of these areas be the streams across the beach at Bay Drive at the north end and south Beach Access Road at the south end.

Amend to allow blanket resource consent for motor vehicles in the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach.That the RC application requires public notification, assessment of environmental effects and an agreed, practical, sustainable management plan to satisfactorily avoid, remedy, or mitigate the identified potential adverse environmental effects.

Reject

/S272/002 Titahi Bay Residents Association Rule R196: Motor




Amend to allow blanket resource consent for motor vehicles in the

Reject


Submission point




boat shed areas at the ends of the beach. That the RC application requires public notification, assessment of environmental effects and an agreed, practical, sustainable management plan to satisfactorily avoid, remedy, or mitigate the identified potential adverse environmental effects.





Amend to allow blanket resource consent for motor vehicles in the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach. That the RC application requires public notification, assessment of environmental effects and an agreed, practical, sustainable management plan to satisfactorily avoid, remedy, or mitigate the identified potential adverse environmental effects.

Reject

/S272/004 Titahi Bay Residents Association Map 35: Titahi




Amend to allow blanket resource consent for motor vehicles in the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach. That the RC application requires public notification, assessment of environmental effects and an agreed, practical, sustainable management plan to satisfactorily avoid, remedy, or mitigate the identified potential adverse environmental effects.

Reject


Protection of the Amend Amendment to allow resource consent for special event motor

vehicles in the central prohibited area of the beach.Our support for Reject


Submission point




Titahi Bay fossil forest

this provision is contingent on first satisfying conditions of our submission Item 1. (ie RC conditions/agreement settled for the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach as a prerequisite to any possibility of RC for special activity in the central beach area).



Amend Amendment to allow resource consent for special event motor vehicles in the central prohibited area of the beach. Support for this provision is contingent on first satisfying conditions of our submission Item 1. (ie RC conditions/agreement settled for the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach as a prerequisite to any possibility of RC for special activity in the central beach area).

Reject



Amend Amendment to allow resource consent for special event motor vehicles in the central prohibited area of the beach. Support for this provision is contingent on first satisfying conditions of [this] submission Item 1. (ie RC conditions/agreement settled for the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach as a prerequisite to any possibility of RC for special activity in the central beach area).

Reject



Amend Amendment to allow resource consent for special event motor vehicles in the central prohibited area of the beach. Support for this provision is contingent on first satisfying conditions of [this] submission Item 1. (ie RC conditions/agreement settled for the boat shed areas at the ends of the beach as a prerequisite to any possibility of RC for special activity in the central beach area).

Reject



Oppose Deletion of the provision. Reinstatement of previous Coastal Plan wording which clearly specified Rule 82 (2) any motor vehicle used for litter removal or dog control; or (3) any motor vehicle used for beach grooming or clearance of piped storm water outfall, maintenance of lawful

Reject


Submission point




structures, or other activities permitted by this plan.



Oppose Deletion of the provision. Reinstatement of previous Coastal Plan wording which clearly specified Rule 82 (2) any motor vehicle used for litter removal or dog control; or (3) any motor vehicle used for beach grooming or clearance of piped storm water outfall, maintenance of lawful structures, or other activities permitted by this plan.

Reject



Oppose Deletion of the provision. Reinstatement of previous Coastal Plan wording which clearly specified Rule 82 (2) any motor vehicle used for litter removal or dog control; or (3) any motor vehicle used for beach grooming or clearance of piped storm water outfall, maintenance of lawful structures, or other activities permitted by this plan.

Reject



Amend Reinstatement of Coastal Plan Rule 29 (2) Conditions (7) If the activity is carried out on Titahi Bay beach, itshall be carried out by or on behalf of a local authority tomaintain amenity values and any vehicle used shall not have tracks and the activity is not to involve recontouring or reshaping. Reinstatement of the essence of Coastal Plan Rule 82 (albeit with a changed centre-beach area), which provides prohibition of motor vehicles, motorcycles, trailers and land yachts on Titahi Bay Beach within the centre of Titahi Bay...; and any part of the remaining foreshore at Titahi Bay where any fossil forest is exposed. Prohibition of tracked vehicles on any part of the foreshore and seabed of Titahi Bay beach.

Reject

/S272/013 Titahi Bay Residents Association Rule R190:

Launching, retrieving or temporary mooring of vessels -

Amend Reinstatement of Coastal Plan Rule 29 (2) Conditions (7) If the activity is carried out on Titahi Bay beach, it shall be carried out by or on behalf of a local authority to maintain amenity values and any vehicle used shall not have tracks and the activity is not to involve recontouring or reshaping. Reinstatement of the essence of Coastal Plan Rule 82 (albeit with a changed centre-beach

Reject


Submission point




permitted activity area), which provides prohibition of motor vehicles, motorcycles, trailers and land yachts on Titahi Bay Beach within the centre of Titahi Bay...; and any part of the remaining foreshore at Titahi Bay where any fossil forest is exposed. Prohibition of tracked vehicles on any part of the foreshore and seabed of Titahi Bay beach.



Not stated Reinstatement of Coastal Plan Rule 29 (2) Conditions (7) If the activity is carried out on Titahi Bay beach, it shall be carried out by or on behalf of a local authority to maintain amenity values and any vehicle used shall not have tracks and the activity is not to involve recontouring or reshaping. Reinstatement of the essence of Coastal Plan Rule 82 (albeit with a changed centre-beach area), which provides prohibition of motor vehicles, motorcycles, trailers and land yachts on Titahi Bay Beach within the centre of Titahi Bay...; and any part of the remaining foreshore at Titahi Bay where any fossil forest is exposed. Prohibition of tracked vehicles on any part of the foreshore and seabed of Titahi Bay beach

Reject


Beach recontouring for coastal restoration purposes - controlled activity

Amend Reinstatement of Coastal Plan Rule 29 (2) Conditions (7) If the activity is carried out on Titahi Bay beach, it shall be carried out by or on behalf of a local authority to maintain amenity values and any vehicle used shall not have tracks and the activity is not to involve recontouring or reshaping. Reinstatement of the essence of Coastal Plan Rule 82 (albeit with a changed centre-beach area), which provides prohibition of motor vehicles, motorcycles, trailers and land yachts on Titahi Bay Beach within the centre of Titahi Bay...; and any part of the remaining foreshore at Titahi Bay where any fossil forest is exposed. Prohibition of tracked vehicles on any part of the foreshore and seabed of Titahi Bay beach

Reject



Amend Reinstatement of Coastal Plan Rule 29 (2) Conditions (7) If the activity is carried out on Titahi Bay beach, it shall be carried out by or on behalf of a local authority to maintain amenity values and any vehicle used shall not have tracks and the activity is not to involve recontouring or reshaping. Reinstatement of the essence of Coastal Plan Rule 82 (albeit with a changed centre-beach

Reject


Submission point




area), which provides prohibition of motor vehicles, motorcycles, trailers and land yachts on Titahi Bay Beach within the centre of Titahi Bay...; and any part of the remaining foreshore at Titahi Bay where any fossil forest is exposed. Prohibition of tracked vehicles on any part of the foreshore and seabed of Titahi Bay beach



Oppose Delete or alternatively qualify it with addition of "also", "under a localbylaw" to clarify wording.

Reject


Introduction of pest plants

Oppose Deletion of the provision. Reject

/S277/012 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Policy P143:


Support in part

[Not stated] Accept in part



Support in part

[Not stated] Accept in part







/S277/016 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Rule R214:

Reclamation and drainage for

Support in part

[Not stated] Reject


Submission point




regionally significant infrastructure outside of sites of significance - discretionary activity



Not stated Submitter requests clarity of terms: "no practicable alternative" [Policy 144 (b)]

Accept in part



Not stated Submitter request clarity of terms: "no practicable alternative", Policy P143(g).

Accept in part

/S279/068 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O58:



/S279/162 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P144:


Amend Amend the policy and associated rules to require that dumping on the sites listed in the policy shall be avoided.

Reject

FS73/060 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowS279/163 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P145:


Amend Amend the policy and associated rules to require that any reclamation, drainage or destruction on the coastal marine areas shall only occur if adverse effects on natural character, water quality, aquatic ecosystems and identified significant sites in Schedules A-F are avoided.

Reject

FS69/067 Wellington International Airport Limited Oppose in part

Disallow

FS49/142 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose in part

Disallow

S282/026 Wellington International Airport Limited

Objective O58: Noise and



Submission point




underwater noise/


Policy P145: Reclamation, drainage and destruction

Amend Amend Policy P145 sub-clause (b) as follows:b) there are no other practicable or reasonable locations outside the coastal marine area for the activity associated with the reclamation, drainage or destruction, andc) there are no practicable or reasonable alternative methods of providing for the associated activity.

Reject

/S282/053 Wellington International Airport

LimitedPolicy P148: Motor vehicles in sites with significant value



LimitedPolicy P150: Noise and lighting

Amend Amend 5.7.2 to recognise relevant New Zealand Standards for aircraft noise.

Reject


LimitedPolicy P151: Underwater noise



LimitedRule R186: General surface water and foreshore activities - restricted discretionary

Oppose in part

Amend Rule R186 as follows:Matters for discretion...7. Effects on a site or habitat identified in or using Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats), or Schedule J (geological features) or Schedule K (surf breaks)

Accept

/


Submission point





Rule R192: Beach recontouring for coastal restoration purposes - controlled activity

Amend Amend Rule R192 as follows:Matters of control...6. Effects on sites and habitats identified in or using Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F2c (birds-coastal), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) and Schedule K (surf breaks)

Accept


LimitedRule R194: Disturbance or damage - discretionary activity

Oppose Delete R194 Accept


LimitedRule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

Amend Rule R197: Motor vehicles for certain purposes - permitted activity

The disturbance of the foreshore or seabed from motor vehicles in the coastal marine area, for the following purposes:...d) the development, maintenance, upgrade and operation of regionally significant infrastructure is a permitted activity, provided the following conditions are met:e) the vehicles shall take the most direct route...

Reject

FS73/066 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS282/072 Wellington International Airport

LimitedRule R200: Dredging for flood protection purposes or erosion mitigation - controlled activity

Amend Amend Rule R200 as follows:

Matters of control...6. Effects on sites or habitats identified in Schedule F2c (bird-coastal), or Schedule F2a (birds-rivers) or Schedule K (surf breaks)

Accept


Submission point





LimitedRule R202: Maintenance dredging outside a Commercial Port Area or navigation protection areas - controlled activity

Amend Amend Rule R202 as follows:

Matters of control...5. Effects on sites and habitats identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F2c (birds-coastal), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats), or Schedule J (geological features) or Schedule K (surf breaks)...

Accept


LimitedRule R204: Destruction, damage or disturbance outside sites of significance - discretionary activity

Oppose WIAL seeks that the relationships between Rules R165, R166, R194, R204, R208, R210 and R216 be reviewed to ensure that unnecessary duplication of control is avoided and that an all-inclusive non-complying activity status is not applied to activities that are otherwise provided for by the Proposed Plan.

Accept in part

FS22/048 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS49/166 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow


Rule R207: Deposition for beach renourishment - controlled activity

Oppose in part

Amend Rule R207 as follows:Matters of control...5. Effects on sites or habitats identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F2c (birds-coastal), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats), or Schedule J (geological features) and Schedule K (surf breaks)...

Accept


LimitedRule R208: Deposition outside sites of significance - discretionary


Accept in part


Submission point




activity/


Rule R210: Dumping of waste or other matter outside sites of significance - discretionary activity


Accept in part

FS60/027 NZ Transport Agency Support AllowS282/078 Wellington International Airport

LimitedRule R214: Reclamation and drainage for regionally significant infrastructure outside of sites of significance - discretionary activity



LimitedRule R216: Destruction - non-complying activity

Oppose in part

Delete Rule R216 or amend R216 to ensure that it does not conflict with or duplicate other rules that provide for destruction as a permitted, controlled, restricted discretionary or discretionary activity. A suitable amendment may be as follows:The destruction of the foreshore or seabed in the coastal marine area including any associated:a) disturbance of the foreshore or seabed, andb) deposition in, on or under the foreshore or seabed, andc) discharge of contaminants, andd) diversion of open coastal waternot otherwise provided for by this Plan, is a non-complying discretionary activity.

Accept

FS49/170 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS286/002 Wellington City Council 2. Interpretation Amend Define the location of MHWS in relation to all listed sites of

significance and within the urban coastal environment.Reject

/


Submission point




S286/051 Wellington City Council Rule R191: Disturbance associated with beach grooming - permitted activity

Amend Clarify whether beach grooming at Island Bay is a permitted activity. If not WCC submits that beach grooming at Island Bay should be permitted.Ensure that there are no other places within Wellington City (or the Region) where condition (f) of Rule 191 conflicts with the primary part of the rule.

Accept

/S286/052 Wellington City Council Rule R196: Motor


Amend Clarify the relevant rule for boat launching at Makara Estuary and ensure it is a permitted activity.Clarify whether Rule 196 applies to the coastal road around the south coast (starting at Owhiro Quarry).Ensure that the identification of the coastal road as a site of significance to Mana Whenua does not preclude the ongoing use of the road by motor vehicles. Wellington

Accept

/S286/053 Wellington City Council Rule R204:


Amend Clarify that coastal protection structures such as revetments are excluded from the destruction rules.

Reject

/S296/001 Becky Lasenby Rule R198: Motor


Amend Amend Rule 198 to be a discretionary activity. This allows for the careful and small amount of access for residents.

Reject

/S304/014 Anders and Emily Crofoot Maps 42-48:

Coastal marine area and river mouth boundaries

Amend The stream on the right should be deleted. Reject

/S311/042 Beef and Lamb NZ Rule R217:

Planting - Amend Amend as:

(d) the plant species shall not be identified in the an operative Reject


Submission point




permitted activity National Pest Plant Accord 2013 or in the an operative Greater Wellington Regional Pest Management Strategy 2002 - 2022 or otherwise be an Unwanted Organism under the Biosecurity Act 1993, and ...

/S311/043 Beef and Lamb NZ Rule R219:

Planting of pest species - prohibited activity

Amend Amend as:R219 Planting Introduction of pest species - prohibited activityThe introduction or planting of a pest plant or pest animal species identified in the an operative National Pest Plant Accord 2013 or in the an operative Greater Wellington Regional Pest Management Strategy 2002 - 2022 or otherwise be an Unwanted Organism under the Biosecurity Act 1993 in the coastal marine area is a prohibited activity.

Reject

/S313/001 Matt Dillon Rule R198: Motor


Amend Amend Rule 198 of the Proposed NRP to be a discretionary activity for the Golden Gate Peninsula including Browns Bay and Ivey Bay. That is, retain the existing provisions for this area.

Reject

/S315/001 K-J Dillon Rule R198: Motor


Oppose Amend Rule R198 of the Proposed NRP to be a discretionary activity for the Golden Gate Peninsula including Browns Bay and Ivey Bay. That is, retain the existing provisions for this area..

Reject


Submission point




/S325/001 Richard and Kim Massam Rule R198: Motor


Amend Submitter seeks to amend Rule 198 of the proposed NRP to be a discretionary activity for Seaview Road residents. That would be to retain the existing provisions for this area.

Reject

/S326/008 Te Runanga o Toa Rangatira Inc Policy P149:


Amend Reduce area to that which vehicle access is currently restricted to Reject

/S326/014 Te Runanga o Toa Rangatira Inc 6.10 Coast Support [Not stated] Accept

/S328/001 Golden Gate Peninsula Beach

ResidentsRule R198: Motor vehicles inside sites of significance - non complying activity

Amend Amend Rule 198 of the Proposed NRP to be a discretionary activity for the Golden Gate Peninsula including Browns Bay and Ivey Bay. That is, retain the existing provisions for this area.

Reject

/S330/001 Tom Kerr and Gabrielle Harris Rule R198: Motor


Amend We seek to amend Rule 198 of the Proposed NRP to be a discretionary activity for the Golden Gate Peninsula including Browns Bay and Ivey Bay.That is, retain the existing provisions for this area.

Reject

/S332/045 Hiwi Trust Rule R190:


Amend [Either the decision requested in submission points S332/043 & 44] OR amend Rules R190 and/or R198 to allow the current motor vehicle activity for the purpose of launching and retrieving boats to continue as a permitted activity [at the ramps on the Stony Bay - Sandy Bay foreshore].

Accept

/S332/046 Hiwi Trust Rule R198: Motor

vehicles inside Amend [See submission point S332/045] Accept


Submission point




sites of significance - non complying activity

/S353/050 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyObjective O58: Noise and underwater noise



SocietyPolicy P148: Motor vehicles in sites with significant value


FS74/168 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support AllowS353/129 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyPolicy P143: Deposition in a site of significance

Support in part

Delete (e) Reject


SocietyPolicy P147: Motor vehicles on the foreshore


FS60/017 NZ Transport Agency Support AllowS353/131 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyPolicy P148: Motor vehicles in sites with significant value


FS60/018 NZ Transport Agency Support AllowS353/132 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyPolicy P149: Protection of the Titahi Bay fossil forest



Society5.7 Coastal management rules

Support in part

Amend Schedules to ensure that apply to coastal environment not on CMA.

Accept in part

FS74/172 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support AllowFS49/144 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow

S353/159 Royal Forest and Bird Protection 5.7.2 Coastal Support Retain [general conditions and rules] subject to any consequential Accept in part


Submission point




Society management general conditions

amendments necessary to give effect to submissions on the objectives and policies.


SocietyRule R202: Maintenance dredging outside a Commercial Port Area or navigation protection areas - controlled activity

Support Retain subject to any consequential amendments necessary to give effect to submissions on the objectives and policies.

Accept in part


SocietyRule R203: Dredging inside the Commercial Port Area and in navigation protection areas - discretionary activity


Accept in part


SocietyRule R204: Destruction, damage or disturbance outside sites of significance - discretionary activity


Accept in part


SocietyRule R205: Destruction, damage or disturbance inside sites of significance - non-complying activity


Accept in part


Submission point





SocietyRule R200: Dredging for flood protection purposes or erosion mitigation - controlled activity

Support in part

Change activity status to non-complying Accept


SocietyRule R206: Re-deposition of wind-blown sand - permitted activity

Support in part

Delete matter of control (5) and make the activity in sites identified in (5) a restricted discretionary activity with discretion reserved over whether the activity should be undertaken within that site.

Reject

FS74/173 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support AllowS353/167 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyRule R207: Deposition for beach renourishment - controlled activity

Support in part

Delete matter of control (5) and make the activity in sites identified in (5) a restricted discretionary activity with discretion reserved over whether the activity should be undertaken within that site.

Reject

FS69/080 Wellington International Airport Limited Oppose DisallowS353/168 Royal Forest and Bird Protection

SocietyRule R211: Dumping or storage of waste or other matter - discretionary activity

Support in part

Make the activity non-complying in significant sites Accept

FS74/175 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Support in part

Disallow

S353/169 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society

Rule R210: Dumping of waste or other matter outside sites of significance - discretionary activity


Accept in part


SocietyRule R212: Dumping of waste

Support Retain subject to any consequential amendments necessary to give effect to [submitter's decisions requested] on the objectives

Accept in part


Submission point




or other matter inside sites of significance - non-complying activity

and policies.


SocietyRule R213: Incineration of waste - prohibited activity

Support Retain subject to any consequential amendments necessary to give effect to [submitter's decisions requested] on the objectives and policies.

Accept in part


SocietyRule R218: Planting - discretionary activity


Accept in part


SocietyRule R219: Planting of pest species - prohibited activity


Accept in part


SocietyRule R217: Planting - permitted activity

Support in part

Delete (d) and replace with: The plant species planted shall be native species that naturally grow in the area planting occurs.

Accept

/S362/001 Angela and Nigel Johns Rule R198: Motor


Amend Submitter seeks to amend Rule R198 of the Proposed NRP to be a discretionary activity for the Golden Gate Peninsula including Browns Bay and Ivey Bay. That is, retain the existing provisions for this area.

Reject

/S366/002 South Wairarapa District Council Rule R190:

Launching, retrieving or temporary mooring of vessels -

Oppose Schedule F2c and the associated Map andGIS be updated to identify the existing boat launch sites, including access; and excluded from the provisions in Rule R198; and provided for as a permitted activity in Rule R190.

Accept in part


Submission point




permitted activity/

S366/003 South Wairarapa District Council Rule R198: Motor vehicles inside sites of significance - non complying activity

Oppose Schedule F2c and the associated Map and GIS be updated to identify the existing boat launch sites, including access; and excluded from the provisions in Rule R198; and provided for as a permitted activity in Rule R190.

Accept in part

/S366/009 South Wairarapa District Council Schedule


Oppose Insert "Okau Stream" to Schedule U, including trigger levels Reject

/S366/012 South Wairarapa District Council 2.1.6 Definitions,

schedules and maps

Oppose Include a new Definition in the Plan for Best Practicable Option,

Best practicable option, in relation to a discharge of a contaminant or an emission of noise, means the best method for preventing or minimising the adverse effects on the environment having regard, among other things, to--

(a) the nature of the discharge or emission and the sensitivity of the receiving environment to adverse effects; and (b) the financial implications, and the effects on the environment, of that option when compared with other options; and(c) the current state of technical knowledge and the likelihood that the option can be successfully applied

Reject


Submission point




FS74/279 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowFS57/002 The Oil Companies Support Allow

S366/129 South Wairarapa District Council Rule R193: River and stream mouth cutting - permitted activity

Amend Insert "Okau Stream" into the list at Rule R193(e) Reject

/S367/002 Masterton District Council Rule R190:


Oppose Schedule F2c and the associated Map andGIS be updated to identify the existing boat launch sites, including access; and excluded from the provisions in Rule R198; and provided for as a permitted activity in Rule R190.

Accept in part

/S367/003 Masterton District Council Rule R198: Motor


Oppose Schedule F2c and the associated Map and GIS be updated to identify the existing boat launch sites, including access; and excluded from the provisions in Rule R198; and provided for as a permitted activity in Rule R190.

Accept in part

/S367/009 Masterton District Council Schedule


Oppose Insert "Okau Stream" to Schedule U, including trigger levels Reject

/S367/012 Masterton District Council 2.2 Definitions Oppose Include a new Definition in the Plan for Best Practicable Option,

Best practicable option, in relation to a discharge of a contaminant or an emission of noise, means the best method for preventing or minimising the adverse effects on the environment having regard, among other things, to-

Reject


Submission point




(a) the nature of the discharge or emission and the sensitivity of the receiving environment to adverse effects; and (b) the financial implications, and the effects on the environment, of that option when compared with other options; and(c) the current state of technical knowledge and the likelihood that the option can be successfully applied

FS74/280 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowS367/129 Masterton District Council Rule R193: River


Amend Insert "Okau Stream" into the list at Rule R193(e) Reject

/S405/001 William Craig Stewart Booth and

Eleanor Joan BoothRule R196: Motor vehicles - permitted activity

Amend Amend the wording of Rule R196 (b), as follows:'the activity is not within a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule E4 (archaeological sites), Schedule F2c (birds-coastal), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features), unlessa Resource Consent Application is approved as a 'Restricted Discretionary Activity'.

Reject

/S405/002 William Craig Stewart Booth and

Eleanor Joan BoothRule R198: Motor vehicles inside sites of significance - non complying activity

Amend Amend Rule R198 to allow the use of motor vehicles on the foreshore as a restricted discretionary activity, as per the status quo.

Reject


Submission point




/


Documents

pnrp.gw.govt.nz · Web viewSubmission point. Further submission point. Submitter. Provision. Support Oppose. Decision requested. Panel decision. S19/001. Don Long. Rule R196: Motor