Plug - Citron Report

8/12/2019 Plug - Citron Report

1/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- 2 %7 8

"#$%& '() (*'+

,-.//01/ 2134 5467 87#-039:

;#0$ 7$ 0? @* A713?

!/& 9%:-%&- ;)-/9- "& / 0/9"&%4 lets /# )-/9# 1/=- #1- -B;-$"-&0-C

!"#$%& D-9-/$01 *&>-$9#/&>9 ,-)) #1- >"77-$-&0- $-/: 9#%0?4 /&> /

0/9"&% 9#%0?E

F %.-39#%0? 1/9 / >-=%*# 7%))%,"&+ ;-%;)- >-=%#-> #% "#9 ;$%>*0#9G #1-$-7%$- "# 0/&

-)"=-$ +$-/# ;$%>*0#9G 1-&0- / 0*)# /$%*&> #1-"$ 91/$-9C

F B$7#69#%0? "9 / 9#%0? ,"#1 )":"#)-99 )-99 %7 0*$$- 7"&/&0"/)94

"&=-9#%$9 0/& /),/K9 )%%? #% #1- 7*#*$-C A& >$-/:)/&>4 ,- 1/=- :/&K /K4 ,1")- #*$&"&+ %=-$ "#9

-"$- 7)%/# %& ;-%;)- +/: / -:%&9#$/#-9 1%, N/)) P#$--# #$-/#9 #1"9 9#%0?E

&%#1"&+ :%$- #1/& / 0/9"&%C

N1% "9

7%$?)"7#9 ,"#1 7*-) 0-))9 #1-K /0W*"$- 7$%: J/))/$> (%,-$C I%#1"&+ 7/&0K 1-$-4 7%)?9C P/:-

-0/>- /9 / ;*-=-)%;"&+ &% A( %$ :-/&"&+7*) $-=-&*- +$%,#1C

($%7"#/-> $"+1#

/=-$/+- %7 /)) %7 #1-"$ $-0- 0/;"#/) $/"9-9UC ]& H1*$9>/K :/&/+-:- ,")) "99*- -/$&"&+9 /&>

+*">/&0-C N- ,/$& "&=-9#%$9C CDE AFGGDH H8E5H "FGFIJ"JGH IE2KFGAJ G43 JL71 #

M033-7 N03O ^-$- "9 / 1"9#%$K %7 -)"=-$ %7 ()*+ (%,-$ %=-$ #1-

K-/$9E


2/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- 3 %7 8

R-# *9 )%%? /# #1- ;$%:"9-9 %=-$ #1- K-/$9 VV 1%, #1-K /$- &%# _*9# :"99-9 /#- %7 23 :"))"%& %$>-$9 - ,/9 :/>- "& c*&- 3523E

We're also on track to meet our target of shipping $40 million of revenue in 2012.We

9-- 9"+&"7"0/ ;"0?*; ,"#1 %*$ ;$-9- 0*9#%:-$ /$- 7%$-0/9#"&+ /&&*/) %$>-$9

to range as expected between US$50 million to US$60 millionWe do expect that both

/ $/:; "& 91";:- =%)*:-9 /&> /& "&0$-/9- "& 91/$- %7 91";:- 7$%: &-, ;$%>*0#

;)/#7%$:9 %=-$ #1- $-:/"&"&+ W*/$#-$9 %7 3523 ,"))


3/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- L %7 8

87?.-3?: (*'( #%3.#- $7L71.7? >7$7 \(TO'"O I$4?? 6#$/01? >7$7 Y@@]O

(1B

.#$37$) (*'':

87?.-3?: H&7 %46Z#19 ?&0ZZ7B ')*(+ .103? 01 (*''O

87?.-3?: (*'* $7L71.7 4= \'SO@" #1B I" 4= YRS]O

In line with our path to profitability, I would now like to reiterate Plug Power's 2010

:")-9#%&-C ["$9#4 ()*+ (%,-$ ,")) >$/:/#"0/))K "&0$-/9- *&"# 91";:- 7%$ #1- K-/$4

91";;"&+ 3L55 9K9#-:9 0%&9"9#"&+ %7 /# )-/9# 2255 T-&M$"=- /&> 2555

T-&PK9 7*-) 0-))9C P-0%&>4 0%&9"9#- ,"#1 #1-9- 91";:-^ ()*+ (%,-$ ,")) +-&-$/#-/&0- ,/94 A

/&0- &%, #% _*9#

:%$- #1/& 24e55@CCC

N-))4 (1")4 A #1"&? %& ,1-$- ,-a$- /# /&> #1- />>"#"%&/) %$>-$9 #1/# ,- -B;-0# #%

%7 #1- W*/$#-$4 ,- -B;-0# #% 91"; 9#")) "& #1/# #/$+-# $/&+-


4/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- 6 %7 8

N- >*+ theres a consistent string of

/&0-C c*9# )"?- #1- /%-9 &%# %&)K :"99 -/$&"&+9 -9#":/#-94 #1- /:%* %7*&"#9 #1/# "&=-9#%$9 ,-$- promised. The companys promotional practices have /9 0%:;/&K &-,94 #1-K $-;$" /& /$#"0)- 7$%:

/ P--?"&+ F);1/ ;%9#-$E

1##;Eff,,,C;)*+;%,-$C0%:fI-,9f!%:;/&KI-,9f23V5LV23fN^dg(RSTg(]N`Dg!]SRMgM]SJR`C/9;B

87?.-3?: H&79 60??7B 3&0? Z.Q-0?&7B 7?306#37B Q9 %-4?7 34 @*]O

"4179 H#-P? N.--?&03 _#-P?O

!"#$%& D-9-/$01 "> / %#Z03#- $#0?7 #3 O'@ %713? ,"#1 / C2Z 0- ,/$$/\ T*-99 1%,:/&K 91/$-9 :/&/+-:- "> &%# ;/$#"0";/#- "& FId %7 #1-9- 0/;"#/) $/"9-9C Managements only

;/$#"0";/#"%& ,/9 #% #/?- 9%:- 9#%0? "& )"-* %7 9/)/$K 7$%: / ;$--B"9#"&+ /+$--:- ,1")- #1-

0%:;/&K ,/9 %& / #$/_-0#%$K #% bZCbY

F=-$/+- ($"0- 5C3b

A# 91%*)> #1/# #1- -W*"#K $/"9-9 / ,/$$/ 0%=-$/+-4 ,1"01 :/>- #1- >-/)9

-=-& 9,--#-$ 7%$ #1- "&=-9#%$9 K-# :/&/+-:- ,/9 &%#"0-/


5/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- Z %7 8

[%))%,"&+ #1"9 9;/& %7 -B#$/%$>"&/$")K #$/91K 0/;"#/) $/"9-94 :/&/+-:- >-0-;#"%& 1/9 &%#

9)%,-> >%,& -"#1-$C A& / [-KV:/$91V;$-9">-V2YZY5553ZC1#:)

F):%9# -B/0#)K %&- ,--? /7#-$ :/?"&+ #1/# 0%::- #1- 0%:;/&K 9%)> /&%#1-$ X33C6 :"))"%&

,%$#1 %7 9#%0? /# 2Zi >"90%* #% ;$"%$ >/K 0)%9"&+ ;$"0- OXZCbZUC `=-& ./$91 1":9-)7 0%*)> &%#-=-$ >$-/: #1"9 9#%0? ,%*)> -=-$ +-# %=-$ XZ4 9% #1- 0%:;/&K 1-);-> #1-:9-)=-9 #% K-#

/&%#1-$ 1-);"&+ of the publics moneyC

]j4 9% ,1/# 1/9 01/&+-> "& %&- K-/$ 9"&0- #1- 9#%0? ,/9 C2Z 0-@ FJP]RSH`Rd I]HÂIT\

A[ FIdHÂIT H^` PH]Dd ^FP T]HHÌ N]DP`C F)) "&=-9#%$9 1/=- #% ?&%, "9 $"+1# "& #1- ;*C

CmonA03$41Y _ #Q4.3 _#-"#$3 #1B ;7BJx? Doesnt that

67#1 ?467 /$7#3 3&01/? #&7#B`

F&K%&- 0)%9- #% #1- 9#%$K ?&%,9 #1/# N/)V./$# /&> [->-B4 /:%&+9# / 7-, %#1-$ :*)#"&/#"%&/)94

1/=- "#9 7%$ $-&-,/7

1##;9Eff,,,C9%)9K9#-:90%:;/&KC0%:fVc/&*/$K4 /7#-$ $/"9"&+ XL5 :"))"%&4 ,- 1/=- X6e :"))"%& %& #1-

,- ,"))

)-/=- #1"9 K-/$ ;$%7"#/ ?4 >7 ?77 14 177B =4$ %#?& 34 =.1B 3&7 Z$7?713 Q.?017??

Z-#1.!! #$% &'() *+,-./ 231;


6/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- e %7 8

H1"9 "9 &%# !"#$%& #/)?"&+4 *9#$K c%*$&/)E

1##;Eff,,,C7*-)0-))#%>/KC0%:f:->"/f2YY8b66f70#g$-="-,g352LC;>7

N.3 F-- 4= 3&0? 0? FQ4.3 34 J1B

F# #1- -&> %7 352e4 #1"9 ;*&01-/#1-90$" #% 0%"&*- [->-$/) "&0-"=-9 #% :/?- #1-"$ :-/&9C1%*9-C+%=f*;)%/>->7")-9f;)*+g;%,-$g"&0Cg7063e23C;>7

H1"9 "9 >"90)%9-> "& 9#/$? $-)"-7 /9 / $"9? 7/0#%$ "& #1-"$ 25VjE

[$%: 25Vj 7%$ 3523E

!"#$ &"'()*)"'+ ", &"'*)'-$'&)$+ *./* /,$ "0* "1 "0,&"'*,"2 #/3 )'&20($4 50* /,$ '"* 2)#)*$( *"4 -"6$,'#$'* */7

8"2)&34 -"6$,'#$'* 10'()'- 8,"-,/#+4 /'( -"6$,'#$'*

incentive programs.

N1/# "9 :%9# /9#%&"91"&+ is that even with government subsidies and lack of competition4

()*+ (%,-$ 9#")) 0/&&%# -"#1-$ :/?- / ;$%7"# %$ -=-& +$%, $-=-&*- "& / :-/&"&+7*) ,/KC

A:/+"&- 1%, #1"9 "&+

/))%0/#-> 7$%: #1- F:-$"0/& D-0%=-$K /&> D-"&=-9#:- F0#4 ,1"01 9/, #1-

9* 9/)- %7 7*-) 0-)) -W*";;-> 7%$?)"7#9 >-;)%K-> /# #1- ,/$-1%*9-9 %7

:/&K 1"+1Vprofile American brands, including BMW Manufacturing, CocaV!%)/4

FedEx and Walmart.!!@A78#788B5(+)

C'(A-=,) D7>


7/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- b %7 8

K#617B 0= C4. K4) K#617B 0= C4. Kont

A7 #1-:9-)=-9 / :/$?-#4 #1-$- /$- &*:-$%*9 "7 >-:/&>

"&0$-/9-9C

It seems like Plug Powers only competitive advantage is going to be selling product at negative

+$%99 :/$+"&C

2=#1- -0-:W*/$#-$9

1##;Eff,,,C#%K%#/7%$?)"7#C0/f;/+-9f/"&+ "-9C

()*+ (%,-$ >%-9 1/=- %&- *0# "n which they dont even own the technology.

;4$/73 FQ4.3 A03$41Y _ B4 3&7 D3&7$ ,$4=7??041#-?

b#L7 34 5#9`

F)#-$&/#"=- `&-$+K /&> !)-/& H-01&%)%+"-9 /$- 9%:- %7 #1- :%9# #1%$%*+1)K 0%=-$-> 9-0#%$9 %&

/)) %7 N/)) P#$--#C M-9;"#- #1- ;%;*)/$"#K %7 #1"9 9-0#%$4 %&)K 2 /&/)K9# 0%=-$9 ()*+ (%,-$C F&>,1% "9 #1"9 /&/)K9#@ A#9 %*$ ;/) D%< P#%&- 7$%: A4>71 #1B A46Z#19\ I%# #%% 9*$;$"9"&+)K4

!%,-& _*9# 7/0")"#/#-> /& %77-$"&+ 7%$ (RSTC

!%,-& /&> .$C P#%&- 1/=- /99"+&-> / ;$"0- #/$+-# %7 XZCZ5 #% ()*+ (%,-$4 ,1"01 ,- /& "-$-9#"&+ K-/$ ,"#1 .$C P#%&- /&>

!%,-&C H1"9 "9 #1- 9/:- /&/)K9# #1/# ;*# / X6e ;$"0- #/$+-# %& S&";"B-) "& 352L #1- 9/:-

:% !"#$%& 7%0*9-> "#9 0%::-/$K %& #1- 0%:;/&K. Citrons take was a single digit stock.

1##;Eff%&)"&-C)-99 #% 9/K #1- 9#%0? 1/9 +%&- 7$%: XLZ #% X254 ,1")- !%,-& /&> P#%&- 0/;"#*)/#-> /&>

-=-*/))K )%,-$-> #1-"$ #/$+-# #% X25C

1##;Eff%&)"&-C,9_C0%:f/$#"0)-fJHV!]V35265253Vb5L6ZbC1#:)

!"#$%& D-9-/$01 /&> .$C P#%&- /&> !%,-& :-# *; /+/"& "& I%=-:


8/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- Y %7 8

1##;Eff,,,C9#$--#"&9">-$C0%:f^%#mI-,m!%=-$/+-f!%,-&mP#/$#9ml%B-)_-#mFTmOlc`HUm/#m]*#;-$7%$:fYYb26ZeC1

#:)

H1- 9/:- :% !"#$%& ;*9f352Lf22f=_-#VQ2V0%::-V7"&/)C;>7

21 3&7 =4--4>01/ @ 6413&? 3&7 ?34%P ? soared =$46 4L7$ \T* 34 \R(O

N1")- ,- ,%*)> )%=- #% 0/)) .$C P#%&- "&0%:;-#- ,- ,")) &%#C A&9#-/> ,- ,")) 0/)) 1": /

company man who takes one for the team. Cowen raises money and he puts out a buy

$-0%::-&>/#"%&C 23 ?&4.-B Q7 1437B 3 7L71 >03& &0? 64?3 /-4>01/ $7%46671B#3041) &7

%4.-B 41-9 /73 34 \@O@ # ?$7 41 ,-./ ,4>7$W>&0%& 0? Z$4Q#Q-9 \@ 344 &0/&)X

A&=-9#%$9 :*9# &%#- #1/# *&)"?- %#1-$ 0)-/& #-01 9#%0?()*+ (%,-$ %,&9 &% *&"W*-

#-01&%)%+KC F9 ,- 9-- "& #1-"$ 7")"&+9E

2137--7%3.#- ,$4Z7$39: G43&01/ 5Z7%0#-

A& #1-"$ %,& 25VK, they admit they dont have proprietary protection :

1##;Eff,,,C9-0C+%=fF$01"=-9f->+/$f>/#/f258Le82f555255L38b2L555252f-9;)*+;%,-$25?2C1#:

Remember, Plugs primary source for the power systems in those forklifts comes from Ballard

(%,-$C

I.1 34 b7#B: 54 2 b#L7 34 D>1 # ;.7- A7-- A46Z#19

N1")- ,- -$ #%

(RSTC F)9% 7"&/&0"/))K4 -=-& "+&%$"&+ #1-"$ $-0- $*&V*;4 #1-$- "9 / +$%99 >"90%&&-0# "& 91/$-

;$"0- while J/))/$> 1/9 -9#/-9 /# e2B $-=-&*-9

./$?-# 0/;4 7*))K >")*#->4 O$-:-: X2Ce J"))"%&

J/))/$> (%,-$ OJRM(UE

XY25. `-$;$"9- l/)*-

H$/>"&+ /# only 2LC3B 9/)-9 O$%*+1 0/)0 %& 25. ,/$$/ ]fPU

We believe that neither we nor our competitors can achieve a significant proprietary

;%9"#"%& %& #1- "& (`. 7*-) 0-)) 9K9#-:9.!!E8AF E5?7, 13!G
http://www.streetinsider.com/Hot+New+Coverage/Cowen+Starts+Voxeljet+AG+(VJET)+at+Outperform/8871456.htmlhttp://www.streetinsider.com/Hot+New+Coverage/Cowen+Starts+Voxeljet+AG+(VJET)+at+Outperform/8871456.htmlhttp://www.streetinsider.com/Hot+New+Coverage/Cowen+Starts+Voxeljet+AG+(VJET)+at+Outperform/8871456.htmlhttp://www.citronresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/vjet-Q1-comment-final.pdfhttp://www.citronresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/vjet-Q1-comment-final.pdfhttp://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1093691/000100329713000101/esplugpower10k1.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1093691/000100329713000101/esplugpower10k1.htmhttp://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1093691/000100329713000101/esplugpower10k1.htmhttp://www.citronresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/vjet-Q1-comment-final.pdfhttp://www.streetinsider.com/Hot+New+Coverage/Cowen+Starts+Voxeljet+AG+(VJET)+at+Outperform/8871456.htmlhttp://www.streetinsider.com/Hot+New+Coverage/Cowen+Starts+Voxeljet+AG+(VJET)+at+Outperform/8871456.html


9/9

!"#$%& %& ()*+ (%,-$ ./$01 234 3526 (/+- 8 %7 8

A41%-.?041: ,-./ ,4>7$ 01 # G.3?&7--

I% ;$%7"#9

I% *&"W*- #-01&%)%+KI% 90/)/-:/&>

I% -W*"#K

I% :->"/ 1K;-

I% /&/)K9# 9*;;%$#

F&> #1"9 %7 +%=-$&:-

9* *; / ,"&&-$ /# / 0/9"&%@@@

A#.304.? 21L7?301/ 34 F--

Documents

Plug - Citron Report