37
[email protected] PI meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007 PI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge and suspension flats included PARAMETERS: T_ETM = 5ppm T_ITM = 0.5% T_PRM = 6% Wavelength = 1.064e-06 m Arm length = 4000 m Mirror radius = 0.17 m (coated 0.168m) Optical mode order –> up to the 13 th Total number of optical modes = 59 Optical mode family : LGM Axial mode order = 5 Total number of acoustic modes = 2500 (range: 9.42kHz – 165.6KHz) RoC step: 0.2m

PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

  • Upload
    vuxuyen

  • View
    216

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

PI for Adv.LIGO

FEM Model:No. nodes 95,278No. elements 92,952Element type:solid45 – substratesolid46 – coatingchamfers, wedge and suspension flats included

PARAMETERS:T_ETM = 5ppmT_ITM = 0.5%T_PRM = 6%Wavelength = 1.064e-06 mArm length = 4000 mMirror radius = 0.17 m (coated 0.168m)Optical mode order –> up to the 13th

Total number of optical modes = 59Optical mode family : LGM Axial mode order = 5Total number of acoustic modes = 2500

(range: 9.42kHz – 165.6KHz)RoC step: 0.2m

Page 2: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

HOMsmode (n,0) n=1 n=2 n=3

mode (n,n) n=1 n=2

a b a b

Page 3: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Diffraction losses

Page 4: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Diffraction losses

TEMb01

TEMa01

Page 5: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

HOMs

TEM01

Page 6: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper

TEM16

Page 7: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Adv.LIGO HOMs

Page 8: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Elastic modes

19287 Hz 19476 Hz 20438 Hz 20514 Hz

28943 Hz 28972 Hz 35118 Hz

Page 9: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

PI at 2076 m

1197 modes with R>0 and 20 modes with R>1

Page 10: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

PI for Adv.LIGO

Page 11: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

LCGT

Page 12: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

LCGT

Page 13: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

LCGT

Including diffraction losses

Page 14: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Flat top beam

Page 15: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Flat top beam losses

L = 4km

Page 16: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Overlapping factor

Optical modes – eigenvectorsElastic modes - FEM

Page 17: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Flat top beam

Δf ± f, step 1 Hz, 345 unstable with Rmax =1032

Page 18: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Flat top beam

Page 19: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Gauss beam

Δf ± f, step 1 Hz 172 unstable R=1439

Gaussian beam with diffraction losses corresponding to the flat top beam

Page 20: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

Ring damper

Page 21: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Optical coatingStrip

Ring damper

mQR ∝

⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛Ω×

Δ+Λ

−Ω×Δ+Λ

= aiaiai

aiaii

ii

ii

mj

jmj

QQMcL

PQR 12

121

1112

121

112 /1/1

4δωδωω

Page 22: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper

1) thermal analysis

-FEM (coating, substrate and side wall strain energy)- optimal configuration (ring width, thickness and loss

angle)

2) modal analysis

- FEM (coating, substrate and side wall strain energy for acoustic modes)

- acoustic mode damping

dvrrrE

fFTkfS B ∫

⎥⎥⎦

⎢⎢⎣

+=

1)()()(4)(

220

r

rr

φφ

π

⎥⎥⎦

⎢⎢⎣

+

=

dvrrrE

dvrEQ

n

nn

1)()()(

)(

2 r

rr

r

φφ

Page 23: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected]

Null position

beam

side wall

Minimum Strain Energy

0 thickness (m) 0.130

d

eg36

0

-Gaussian pressure profile -ω = 6e-2 m (1/e2)

lossEE ⋅=Δ ωat Emin Δ Emin TNmin

The front face edge has smaller energy concentration than the back face of the test mass

PI meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Page 24: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper

constVring =⋅φ

~ 20 mm (Gaussian,1ppm )~ 10 mm (Messa,1ppm)

21 −= erφ

For the ring at the null position:

Page 25: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper- FEM model

-part of substrate- the same elastic properties as substrate

solid45

Page 26: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper- sapphire

assumed isotropy C-axis

Page 27: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper- sapphire

Page 28: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper- f.silica

Page 29: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Null position

Secondary minima due to the thickness of the test mass

Page 30: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Thermal noise results

Brownian Noise at 100Hz with RoC = 2076 m (FEM result ): m/√Hz

ITM ETMCoating 5.7031e-21 8.5523e-021Substrate 7.8192e-22 7.8196e-22

Total IFO 1.4621e-20

Page 31: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper configuration

loss angle, strip width – variables, thickness assumed to be 20μm

Page 32: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Ring damper -models

widths thickness loss angle ΔTN

A 3.0 cm 20μm 1.0e-4 0.1% B 10.0 cm 20μm 1.0e-4 0.5%C 3.0 cm 10μm 1.0e-3 0.5%D 5.0 cm 10μm 1.0e-3 1.0%E 3.0 cm 20μm 1.0e-3 2.0%F 3.0 cm 20μm 5.5e-3 5.0%

Page 33: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Mode suppression

77.012106.7 fsub ⋅⋅= −φ fSiO ⋅⋅+= −− 94 101.1102

φfOTa ⋅⋅+⋅= −− 94 108.1108.3

52φ

Substrate Coating

Page 34: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

F model

Page 35: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

PI for Adv.LIGO

Page 36: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

Mode suppression

Page 37: PI for Adv - University of Western · PDF filePI for Adv.LIGO FEM Model: No. nodes 95,278 No. elements 92,952 Element type: solid45 – substrate solid46 – coating chamfers, wedge

[email protected] meeting, GinGin 16-18 July. 2007

AIGO 5km Ring damper