PH PROCEEDINGS - Welcome to Environmentenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...Proposed Dugda NLW Washery A-III-31 The proceeding of the Public Hearing for obtaining

Proposed Dugda NLW Washery A-III-1

PH PROCEEDINGS

Prabhat Khabar, Dhanbad Times of India, New Delhi 26.12.2015































The proceeding of the Public Hearing for obtaining Environmental

clearance before installation of M/s Dugda 2.5 Mtpa NLW Coal Washery,

Dugda, Bokaro, held on 27.01.2016 at Milan Kendra, Near Dugda Coal

Washery Guest House, Dugda, Dist : Bokaro.

In pursuance of the notification no. 1533/E.I.A. dated 14/09/2006 and revised notification no. S.O. -3067(E),

dated 01/12/2009 issued by Ministry of Environment &Forest , Govt. of India, New Delhi, the notice , issued by

Jharkhand State Pollution Control Board, Ranchi was published in the Hindi Daily “ Prabhat Khabar” (Dhanbad

Edition) and the national English newspaper “ Times of India” (Delhi Edition) on 26.12.2015 in the process to

get Environmental Clearance.

In pursuance of the above notification, the Public Hearing was arranged on 27.01.2016 at 11.00AM on the

Milan Kendra, near Dugda Coal Washery Guest House, Dugda, DistBokaro, which was presided by Sri Jugnu

Minz, Addl. District Magistrate, Bokaro, Public hearing was done for getting environmental Clearance for

Dugda 2.5 Mtpa NLW Washery.

Sri Mitilesh Jha, Asstt. Scientist , Jharkhand State Pollution Control Board, Ranchi, Sri Manoj Kumar, Asstt.

Scientist Officer, Jharkhand State Pollution Control Board, Regional Office, Dhanbad, Smt Priti Lata Kishku, C.O.

Dugda, Sri Chandra Shekhar Prasad, GM (Washery Construction Division), Koyla Bhawan, BCCL, Sri Goutam

Kundu, GM (Wastern Washery Zone), BCCL, Sri A.K. OJha, Project Officer (Dugda Coal Washer), Sri Bijay Modi,

Chief Manager (Environment Deptt),Koyla Bhawan, BCCL and several other senior officials of BCCL and CMPDI,

were present during the Public Hearing. Inspite of them, Public/citizens from the nearest villages like Dugda

Basti, Dugda Purbi, Budhsera, Dugdasouth, Budhidih, KarmaTand, RatariBasti, Chanduadih, BeraBasti and all

other nearest villages were present in the Public Hearing.

At the outset, the proceedings of the Public Hearing was started with the welcome of all the invitees by Sri A.K.

Ojha, Project Officer, (Dugda Coal Washer). Sri Amit Raj Mishra, Asstt. Manager, CMPDI, Dhanbad presented

the technical knowhow regarding the proposed project, to apprise the citizens present in the hearing.

The chairman has apprised the citizens/public about the aim of this Public Hearing. With the permission of the

chair, Questions & Answers session were started. Thereafter, the citizens present in the public hearing has

started to put forward several questions and suggestion one by one mostly related to e.g. Water, Electricity,

Medical facilities, Education and employment to the land losers.

The questioners put forded by the villagers and citizens were answered by Sri A.K. Ojha, Project Officer, Dugda

Coal Washery. The chairmen, on behalf of administration assured the villagers that the problems related to the

land will be solved according to the law.

The videography of the whole proceedings of the Public hearing had been done and the DVD of the

proceedings and Question- answers session of the Public Hearing is enclosed herewith.


The Chairman, on behalf of the administration assured the villagers to give all essential help to solve any

problems. The Chairman, thanked to all and with his declaration, the proceeding of the Public hearing were

concluded.

Encl : As stated.

Sd/- Sd/- Sd/-

Mithilesh Jha, Manoj Kumar Jugnu Minz,

Asstt. Scientist Asstt. Scientist Officer Addl. District Magistrate

Jharkhand State Jharkhand State Bokaro

Pollution Control Board Pollution Control Board

Ranchi Dhanbad


Questions and answers of the Public Hearing held on 27.01.2016 at Milan Kendra, near Dugda Coal Washery

Guest House, Dugda, Dist :Bokaro for M/s Dugda 2.5 Mtpa NLW Coal Washery

Sl.

No

.

Name & Address

of the Citizens

asked question

Questions asked by Citizens / Villagers Answers given by company

representative.

1. Sri Gaur Chand

Mandal, Dugda

East,

Chandrapura

Employed should be given to the Raiyat

or Local Land Loosers whose land were

acquired in the year 1957-58 and in the

year 1983-84 . Facilities should be given

for water and electricity under welfare.

Previously in the year 1992, settlement

has been done by DC that for two(02)

Acre Land employment should be given

to the Raiyat but till only 22 persons

have got employment. Trees should be

planted.

Twenty two (22) people have

been employed for acquiring

land previously and eight (08)

applications are under process.

All the applications will be

processed under company rule.

Other facilities will be given

according to rule. Trees will be

planted.

2. Sri Dhirendra

Mandal, Dugda

Basti

Please see the land acquired in the year

1957-58 and 1983-84. In 1992, Rs.288/

decimal was paid as compensation. It

should be paid again on present value.

CISF prohibits while passing through

washery premises. Local people only

should get fourth class job.

All the proceedings are done on

the basis of the rules of the

company. The compensation in

respect of land acquiring has

been done according to the rule

& law. The problem related to

passing through washery

premises will be solved with

discussion at local level

management. Preference is

given to eligible people for

fourth class job & its equivalent

job.

3. Sri Lakan Chand

Mandal,

DugdaBasti

Inspite of two (02) acre land,

employment should be given on two (02)

decimal land. Fundamental facilities like

Electricity, Water, Education etc. should

be given to villagers.

Employment and other facilities

are provided only on the basis

of R.R. Policy of the company.

Other facilities will be provided

on the basis of rule only. Govt.

pond, Govt. School, Community

hall, Marriage Hall, playground

etc. will be taken up under CSR

of the company.

4. Sri Raju Kevat,

DugdaBasti

Employment should be also given to

those people whose small land is

acquired. All jobs of fourth class should

be given to local villagers.

Employment and all other

facilities will be provided under

the rule of the company.

5. Sri Bodhan

Yadav,

Budhsera

Employment should be given to literate

unemployed and local land losers.

Employment should be given to local

I.T.I & Diploma. The job which is not

filled by local should be filled by outsider.

The payment did not received for the

land acquired in the year 1957-58

Preference is given to eligible

local people in facilities related

to employment and for payment

the process is done according to

the rule & law.

6. Sri Satish

Pandey, Dugda

South

All types of cooperation will be given for

plant installation. All expected facilities

should be given to us on plant

All facilities will be provided

under rules of the company.


installation. Level of ground water has

gone down so arrangement should be

done for supply of water after installing

Filter Plant in which water should be

taken from intake well.

7. Sri Ruplal

Thakur,

DugdaBasti

Land taken but job had not been given.

Local people are migrated outside for

job. Take land and give job and job

should be given to the local people only.

Employment against acquired

land is given on the basis of the

rule of the company and in

future if land will be acquired

then all the facilities will be

provided under the rule of the

company.

8. Sri Ravi

Shankar

Upadhyay,

Dugda, Basti

There are major problems related to

health. There is Dugda Hospital but it

has not proper facilities. Water of hand

pump is not good. Facilities in Hospital

should be increased and supply drinkable

water.

Suitable action under rule will

be taken in this regard.

9. Sri Kailas

Prasad Gupta,

Budhidih

Land losers has not got facilities against

land acquired in the year 1957-58.

Interview has taken in the year 1987-88,

they should get employment first. School

should be made for the children of land

losers. Mineral water plant should be

erected/ build for drinking water.

All the essential facilities will be

provided under rule in the

villagers of land losers and

suitable action under rule will be

taken under the CSR of the

company and all other facilities

will be provided under the rule

of the company.

10. Md. Haidar

Ansari, Dugda

Please clarify that this washery is buildup

by BCCL or outsider company.

This washery is proposed to be

buildup by BCCL on Build

Operate and Maintain System

(BOM).

11. Sri Shankar

Prasad Barnwal,

Karmatand

In colony, filter water of Damodar river is

supplied but care is not taken for nearby

villages. Arrangement should be done.

Suitable action under rule of the

company will be taken in this

regard.

12. Raj Kishore

Mandal,

DugdaBasti

A list of employment should be prepared

before land acquired for this new plant.

There is no need of land

acquisition for this plant at

present.

13. Sri

ChandraShekha

rMahtha,

RatariBasti

Please do arrangement between

Management and those whose land will

be acquired before the administration. All

the manpower should be local, there

should be an agreement. Outsider should

be employed only when there is no

availability of skilled labor in the area.

There is no need of land

acquisition for this plant

installation at this time but all

the action will be taken under

the rules of the company.

14. Sri

HiralalRavidas,

Barkitand

Local unemployed should be provided

employment so that they do not migrate

to outside. The facilities of water,

Electricity, Irrigation, Education, health

etc. should be provided to the villagers.

All necessary action will be

taken under the rule of the

company and all facilities will be

provided under CSR. The

facilities of Govt. Pond, Govt.

School etc. are provided under

CSR. Medical facilities are

provided in the villagers by

Medical Van.

15. Sri Bajnath

Soren, Budhidih

Provide employment to the land losers.

Don’t cheat we welcome the plant for

development by heart. Development

All action will be taken

according to the rule of the

company.


should start on land so that Naxal

activities and terrorism do not develop,

the dream of Digital India of our

respected Prime Minister should be

completed.

16. Sri Jagadish

Kewat,

DugdaBasti

We have got one job while six (06) acre

land acquired in 1983-84. A certificate

should be given to the land losers for

identification.

All action should be taken


company.

17. Sri Nandal

Mahtha,

Amaratand

D.V.C. has acquired 12.5 Acres land but

do not provided employment. This plant

will be constructed by departmental or

by the contractor. If this will be

constructed by the contractor, please

ascertain that Identity card should be

given to labours and all facilities should

be provided by the contractor.

This plant is proposed to be

build up on B.O.M basis (Build

–Operate Maintain) Scheme by

Bharat Coking Coal Limited.

Employment and other facilities

to local people will be provided

under the rule of the company.

18 Sri Vijay Kumar

Manghi ,

Budhidih

Evaluate your work done under CSR. The

work of plant construction may be done

by those whom BCCL had award the

work of Plant Construction .The work

should not be done by any sub-

contractor. Do the Plant Construction, do

the employment and help the land

losers.

Evaluation of this will be done.

This should be ascertain that

the main Contractor should not

get work done by sub

contractor. Employment to the

local people will be given under

the rule of the company.

19. Sri Ranjeet

Hansada,

BudhidihBasti

An enquiry should be done for the

damage occurred to the land by entering

dirty water of washery.

This should be solved by the

discussion with the local

management and it should be

ensured in the construction of

new washery that water will not

go outside washery premises.

20 Sri Ghuran

Prasad ,

DugdaBasti

We support for new Plant Construction

and employment to people. It should be

ensured for coal availability to both the

washery.

Coal availability will be ensured.

21 Smt. Satyavati

devi,

Chanduadih

We have not got any facilities while forty

one (41) dismal land had taken from our

forefather e.g. Company Quarters not

been provided. If company do not need

land please return the land. An

agreement should be made that land will

be acquired against employment only.

Employment is given against

the land acquired on the basis

of R.R. policy under the rule of

the company.

22. Sri Phulchand

Murmu,

BeraBasti

Management has not provided any help

in the primary school which I had

established by own. Arrangement of

medical treatment to the land losers

should be made in the hospital of

washery.

The facilities under the rule of

the company under its C.S.R.

are provided. Facilities for

medical treatment to the land

losers are available in the

hospital of washery.

23. Sri Baijnath

Kewat,Dugda

Information of Public Hearing has not

given.

Information regarding Public

hearing has been given in the

newspapers according to the


rule. In addition one week in

advance of the Public Hearing

advertisement by mike and

loudspeakers was made in all

the nearby villages

24. Sri Yugul

Kishore,

Chanduadih

We welcome the construction of the Plant

in view of the affected area like

Budhsera, Chanduadih, Dugdabasti, etc.

Thanks. All will be taken care in

accordance with company rule.

25. Sri Shyam

Sunder Mandal,

Dugdabasti

The development work should be done

along with the construction of the

washery and not after the construction.

Arrangement should be done for

education, I.T.I. for the landlosers

It is accepted, arrangement of

all facilities should be made


company.

Sd/- Sd/- Sd/- (Mithilesh Jha) (Manoj Kumar) (Jugnu Minz) Asstt. Scientist Asstt. Scientist Officer Addl. District Magistrate Jharkhand State Jharkhand State Bokaro Pollution Control Board Pollution Control Board Ranchi Ranchi

Documents

PH PROCEEDINGS - Welcome to Environmentenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...Proposed Dugda NLW Washery A-III-31 The proceeding of the Public Hearing for obtaining