Personal Services and Public Health Issues

Personal Services and Public Personal Services and Public Health IssuesHealth Issues

Christian Lapensee B.A.Sc., C.P.H.I. (C)

(613) 724-4122 Ext. 26308

[email protected]

Topics of DiscussionTopics of DiscussionHistory, changes and revisions to the PSSPEnforcement and legislationMycobacterium outbreaksBlood-borne pathogensDisinfectant / germicide researchTools of the trade and associated infectionsPiercing, tattooing and body modificationsCleaning, disinfecting and sterilizingAesthetic concerns at the SpaMethyl Methacrylate

History of Personal ServicesHistory of Personal Services To reduce and control spread of infectious disease Unofficial survey of personal services (ON/QU) Lack of appropriate information in Health Units Not widely taught in Universities No solid, reliable data in the first place Very new to industry / fairly new to Public Health Ministry of Health and Health Canada Documents Minimum hours of classroom and practical

training required in many states in US Mandatory guidelines clarify inspection role

PSSP – Ontario, 1998PSSP – Ontario, 1998

Personal Services Settings Protocol

Graphic

Health Canada - 1999Health Canada - 1999

Canada Communicable Disease ReportGraphic

By-laws - LicensingBy-laws - LicensingStrictest between Federal, Provincial, and

Municipal should override when including by-laws (already considered in some health units)

Licensing in Ontario – should be treated same as restaurants – approval required

Only a few Health Units in Ontario seem to be licensing – in some cases only a one city by-law within the Health Unit

U.S.A. - Personal ServicesU.S.A. - Personal ServicesCDC infection control document from 1985Some states have mandatory training to

allow a license to practice servicesBoard of barbering and cosmetology“X” hours of classroom and practical

application requiredEar piercing guns banned in some statesCartilage piercing also banned in some

states

What’s New in Personal ServicesWhat’s New in Personal ServicesRevisions to PSSP / working groupNew sections and additionsNew information and researchMore infections being revealedIndustry getting more involvedPast, present and future concernsControversial issuesRe - Education, promotion and awareness

must be required for all groups involved

What’s New in PSSP What’s New in PSSP More charts and tablesAcupuncture sectionEar LOBE piercing sectionElectrolysis - mandatory sterilization is no

longer requiredThe sink situationHand hygieneSterilization changesMinor tattoo changes

AcupunctureAcupuncture…“but not limited to”… clauseNeedle manipulation not clearOttawa document based on original PSSPSome other Health Units also enforcingWhy a specific section was requiredMycobacterium abscessus infections in

Toronto brought to surfaceAcupuncture and T.C.M. seek regulation

under the Regulated Health Professions act (RHPA)

“… “… but not limited to …”but not limited to …”(page 1 – applicability)(page 1 – applicability)

This protocol applies to any facility …Graphic

Must Be SterilizedMust Be Sterilized

Classification for Methods of Disinfection/SterilizationGraphic

Manipulation of needlesManipulation of needlesTattooing – manipulation by soldering and

creating appropriate widthBody piercing – manipulation by removing

hub and fitting to sizeMicro pigmentation – manipulation same as

tattooingElectrolysis – no manipulation clearly

defined Acupuncture – is now defined as no

manipulation (to clarify and avoid confusion)

Needle Manipulation in Needle Manipulation in TattooingTattooing

Needle bar for tattooing - graphic

Example of Needle Example of Needle Manipulation in Body PiercingManipulation in Body Piercing

Needle Graphic

Must Be Sterile, Single-use, Must Be Sterile, Single-use, DisposableDisposable

Electrolysis - Graphic

Ottawa Acupuncture DocumentOttawa Acupuncture Document

City of Ottawa – Draft Letter

Proposed PSSP AcupunctureProposed PSSP Acupuncture

Acupuncture - Graphic

Acupuncture – Key PointsAcupuncture – Key PointsMust be sterilized, single-use, and

disposable immediately after useMany Asian manufacturers do not sterilize

prior to shipping – package in bundlesConsider devices used to manipulate sterile

needles (Chimbong – Korean hand acupuncture)

New section defines needles to be supplied as pre-packaged, sterile, single-use, disposable

RHPA

Regulated Health Professions ActRegulated Health Professions Act

Graphic

Emerging Issues - MycobacteriaEmerging Issues - MycobacteriaMore Mycobacteria infections being foundToronto is just one of latest to make health

headlinesInjectable cosmetics and pedicuresNot all confirmed by culture Mycobacterium abscessus infections in

Toronto (April to December, 2002)29 people with skin infections (on going

investigation)How link was made in Toronto

Mycobacterium abscessusMycobacterium abscessus InfectionsInfections

adrenal cortex extract injections (ACE) Infected 87 people in 16 states (1995, 1996)Unlicensed alternative medicineCan be taken orally as wellUsed for weight loss, fatigue, stress, easing

withdrawal symptoms, depression, etc.FDA claims “never been shown to be

effective for treating any medical condition”FDA recall 1996 (poor manufacturing

standards)

New York City, January to June 200225 cases of skin infections from cosmetic

injections (silicone, collagen, vitamin, etc)12 required hospitalization (up to 51 days)15 required invasive medical procedures,

and antibiotic therapy (up to 6 months)1 case had a bloodstream infectionWounds seeping fluid for months


Santiago, Chile July to December, 200251 cases of infection from 5 cosmetic

establishmentsMesotherapy injections to reduce obesityMycobacterium chelonae also possible

(same family of bacteria)All 51 cases had extensive scarring (up to 4

inches long)Abscesses drained and up to 8 months

antibiotics


Mycobacterium fortuitumMycobacterium fortuitum PedicuresPedicures

Mycobacterium fortuitum infection first recorded in 1936 (vitamin injection)

California pedicure establishmentLargest outbreak of Mycobacterium fortuitum

in the USA110 people affected with various infectionsOne case had 37 open sores for months Hard to treat – antibiotics not always successful20/20 episode got a lot of attention

Mycobacteria InfectionMycobacteria Infection

Graphic

Mycobacteria InfectionMycobacteria Infection

Graphic

Lack of Infection ControlLack of Infection Control

Graphic

Lack of Infection ControlLack of Infection Controlgraphic

Not “Sanitizable” - Disposable Not “Sanitizable” - Disposable

Graphic

DisposableDisposable

Graphic

DisposableDisposableGraphic

Clean and Disinfect Tub ……Clean and Disinfect Tub ……

Graphic

……. And Screen. And Screen

Graphic

Mycobacteria InfectionsMycobacteria InfectionsThe five Mycobacteria outbreaks just

discussed were all from elective procedures for cosmetic purposes (Personal Services)

Expect to see more infections from Mycobacteria

Use of disinfectants in establishments using semi-critical instruments (usually covered by intermediate level disinfection) will need to be reviewed to address this situation

Mycobacteria requires high level disinfection

Mycobacteria - DisinfectionMycobacteria - Disinfection

Graphic

Why so many infections ?Why so many infections ?Lack of knowledge of basic infection control

procedures by operators and manufacturers and suppliers

Not using proper disinfectant solutions, etc.Improper products and devices used for

serviceOperators are unaware of the diseases that

can be transmittedMany carriers are not aware they are infectedChronic carriers and incubation periods not

considered

Linkages – Incubation periodsLinkages – Incubation periodsThe link between developing blood-borne

diseases and infections, and the event in which it was contracted has been difficult to establish

10 year incubation periods (or worse) Some carriers never get sick Lucky to find link in Mycobacteria

infections Some cases in Toronto acupuncture outbreak

didn’t notice infection for five months

Blood-borne PathogensBlood-borne PathogensIncubation periods and chronic carriers1/3 of people with HIV in Quebec are

unaware (recent study)Hepatitis B immunizationHepatitis C escalating Have to go beyond the big 3 (HIV, Hep B,

Hep C) when considering infection control in Personal Services

Many operators only using surface disinfectants

Hepatitis C - USAHepatitis C - USA

Over 4 million infectedOver 3 million chronic carriers35 000 new cases per yearVirus can survive weeks on instruments170 million cases worldwideUp to 70% chronic carriersMany showing no symptoms

Chapped Skin – Open WoundChapped Skin – Open Wound

Graphic

Disinfectant DilemmasDisinfectant Dilemmas

Graphic

Disinfectant ProblemsDisinfectant ProblemsImproper use of disinfectant solutions is

biggest PSSP problemOperators educated by suppliers and

salespersonsChemical formulations clarified Roughly over 80% Quaternary ammonium

compoundsNo pre-cleaning item, not making solution

fresh, not immersing in solution, no contact time, etc.

Convenience and ‘ease of use’ dictates use

Name That DisinfectantName That Disinfectant

N - Alkyl (60% C14, 30% C16, 5% C12, 5%C18)

dimethyl ethylbenzyl ammonium chloride

Low level disinfectionLow level disinfectionAlthough the big 3 are easier to kill than

Mycobacteria, low level disinfection is not effective

Quaternary ammonium compounds are the most widely used by PSS operators

A surface disinfectant must never be used to disinfect a disposable item (sharps, etc.)

One container of low level disinfectant used for days – dirty items thrown in and retrieved when needed for client (actually believing that this is effective)

BarbicideBarbicide

Graphic

Intermediate to High Level Intermediate to High Level DisinfectionDisinfection

Alcohol’s optimum concentration is between 70% to 90%

If solution is to pure (99% isopropyl alcohol, for example) it will not be effective in disinfection of item

Denaturation requires water to be effectiveHigh level required for MycobacteriaStay away from toxic chemicals

(Glutaraldehydes, etc.)

Disinfectant SolutionsDisinfectant Solutions

Graphic

70% to 90% 70% to 90%

Graphic

70% to 90%70% to 90%

Graphic

70% to 90%70% to 90%

Graphic

Levels of DisinfectionLevels of Disinfection

Graphic

Health Canada’s Drug Product Health Canada’s Drug Product DatabaseDatabase

Graphic

D.I.N. #Brand nameCompany nameRoute of administrationPharmaceutical formActive ingredients and # of active ingredientsEtc

Health Canada’s Drug Product Health Canada’s Drug Product DatabaseDatabase

Labelling LawsLabelling Laws

Ingredient labelling not mandatory

Health Canada working on labelling

Cosmetics exempt from MSDS/WHMIS

Disinfectant Research Disinfectant Research Dr. Syed Sattar and I are preparing a

manuscript on the proper use of disinfectant solutions in personal service settings

For various health professionals (Health Units, etc.) and infection control organizations

To be used by operators, suppliers and manufacturers

As an educational tool to be applied through proper health promotion and education

‘‘Barbicide Info SheetBarbicide Info Sheet

Graphic

Flow ChartFlow Chart

Graphic

Disinfectant ChartsDisinfectant Charts

Graphic

Information Mail outsInformation Mail outs

Graphic

Piercing Problems - GeneralPiercing Problems - GeneralAge restriction issueDriving services undergroundMore piercing gun useOne day body piercing coursesAfter care is still a major concernMany secondary infections, disfigurations

and surgeries required

After CareAfter Care

Graphic

Ear Lobe PiercingEar Lobe Piercing

Re-defined section nameAdded noteCartilage mutilationsPseudomonas infectionsIllegal in some statesDermal punchPlastic jewellery to decrease allergic

reactions to Nickel

Banned ? Banned ?

Graphic

FixedFixed Stud Adapter and Clasp Stud Adapter and Clasp RetainerRetainer

Graphic

Disposable partsDisposable parts

Graphic

Disposable cartridgeDisposable cartridge

Graphic


Graphic


Graphic

Piercing GunsPiercing Guns

Graphic

Disposable CartridgeDisposable Cartridge

Graphic

Medical Plastic - EarringsMedical Plastic - Earrings

Graphic


Graphic


Graphic

Plastic Body Piercing Plastic Body Piercing JewelleryJewellery

Graphic

Plastic Body Piercing Plastic Body Piercing JewelleryJewellery

Graphic

Piercing Problems - GunsPiercing Problems - GunsRe-named -Ear LOBE piercing sectionSpecial note on use of gunsCan’t ignore secondary infectionsGun piercing chemical solutionsDisinfection of sterile items has caused

infectionsClaims of promoting healing simultaneouslyWhy disinfect a sterile item ?????Driving body piercing services underground is

not the answer (age restriction increases risk)

Mutilated NavelMutilated Navel

Graphic

Mutilated CartilageMutilated Cartilage

Graphic

Mutilated CartilageMutilated Cartilage

Graphic

Cartilage InfectionsCartilage Infections

Graphic

Body ModificationsBody Modifications

Surface piercingDermal punch (biopsy tool)BrandingScarificationImplants“Mods”

Surface PiercingSurface Piercing

Graphic

Dermal Punch Dermal Punch Graphic

Dermal Punch Dermal Punch Graphic

ImplantsImplants

Not a very common procedure Originally beading (or pearling) Transdermal and 3D-Art implants Dermal pockets formed away from incision site

(similar to breast implants) METALS – stainless steel, titanium, niobium PLASTICS – nylon, Teflon, silicone, etc. Silicone injections

ImplantsImplantsGraphic

ImplantsImplants

Graphic

R.H.P.A.R.H.P.A.Graphic

Some Tattooing ChangesSome Tattooing Changes

Disposable needle barAfter careAccessible sink – translates to all

(except ear lobe piercing)

Tattoo Machine Tattoo Machine

Graphic

Needle BarNeedle Bar

Graphic

Needle BarNeedle Bar

Graphic

Cleaning and SterilizingCleaning and Sterilizing

Ultrasonic – cleaning deviceHigh level disinfectionCold sterilization = high level disinfectionAutoclavingDry Heat

Ultra-sonicUltra-sonic

Should always be in a separate room with sinks and autoclave, etc.

Operating without lid is already a problem

Lid may not be enoughEnclosure has shown that contents are

being aerosolized

Ultrasonic EnclosureUltrasonic EnclosureGraphic

Ultrasonic EnclosureUltrasonic EnclosureGraphic

AutoclavingAutoclavingMany operators don’t understand

sterilization (outside of Tattooing, Body Piercing, Micro pigmentation and Electrolysis)

Three spore testsPrestige model – can also be used with

packagingProper packaging of instruments

Prestige AutoclavePrestige Autoclave

Graphic

PackagingPackaging

Graphic

Piercing ToolsPiercing Tools

Graphic

Various aestheticsVarious aesthetics

Double-dipping still not clearCosmetic policies (Shoppers Drug Mart,

Loblaws, Giant Tiger, various cosmetic counters, etc.)

Sharps – needle stick injuriesMedical Spas and Cosmetic ClinicsBogus services

Double - DippingDouble - Dipping

Graphic

Double - DippingDouble - Dipping

Graphic

SharpsSharps

Graphic

Sharps – Needle stick Sharps – Needle stick

Graphic

Ear CandlingEar Candling

Graphic

Medical SpasMedical SpasServices not by a physicianLaserMicrodermabrasionVeinsWrinklesFat reductionTanning concerns Etc.

Laser Hair RemovalLaser Hair RemovalElectrolysis being replaced ???Not around the eyesPSSP requirementTypes of lasersExposure to blood ???ShavingSkin contactHeat increases blood flow

PSSP RequirementPSSP Requirement 7.2.1 (vi) 7.2.1 (vi)

Equipment/instruments used in laser hair removal must be cleaned and disinfected or sterilized.

Types of LasersTypes of Lasers

CO2 laser - cuts skinHair removal lasers do notRuby (old style)Alexandrite (distance gauge – disposable)Alexandrite (good results - $$$$$)Yag – painful (good for dark pigment)Diode – very popular (more affordable)

LaserLaser

Graphic

LaserLaser

Graphic

LaserLaser

Graphic

MicrodermabrasionMicrodermabrasion

Sanding the skinPowdered aluminum oxide crystalsCrystals are very expensiveClosed loop system a mustMost from Europe – not closed loopDisposable tipsDisposable lines

MicrodermabrasionMicrodermabrasion

Graphic

MMAMMA

Methyl Methacrylate monomer banned in the USA

Ban is in effect in CanadaEnforcement will be difficultRegulations and laws not helpful Tell operators how to spot Methyl

Methacrylate in establishments

Spotting Methyl MethacrylateSpotting Methyl Methacrylate

Strong, pungent odourCauses headaches and dizzinessVery inexpensive cost for serviceNails are very hard (cannot be filed)Nails must be soaked in harsh chemicals for

a long time (not usual acetone soak)Nails have to be pried off sometimes

Infection Leading to Infection Leading to AmputationAmputation

Graphic

MMAMMA

Graphic

Labelling LawsLabelling Laws

Ingredient labelling not mandatory

Health Canada working on labelling

Cosmetics exempt from MSDS/WHMIS

EnforcementEnforcement

Section 13 order is only way to go (unless some local by-laws apply)

Competition is a big factorWorker safety is a big factorClients see the service as being done to

them (can’t see inside the kitchen)FP vs. BPPEducation and promotion goes far

Section 13 OrderSection 13 Order

Graphic

EducationEducation

Graphic