Performance Management Part 2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    1/77

    Performance Management:

    HELPING ACTIVELY MANAGEEMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    2/77

    Session Objectives:

    At the end of this session you will be able to: Explore the essential elements of a

    successful, organization-wide performancemanagement system

    Implement training and coaching tools to beused when guiding supervisors and managerson performance-related issues

    Recognize best practices in the field ofperformance management coaching and

    training

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    3/77

    WhyPerformance Management

    is Important It helps us achieve organizational

    _______________________.

    It enhances __________________between employees and supervisors.

    It facilitates important human resources

    ________________.

    It covers the organizations

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    4/77

    Performance management

    OVERVIEW Is the process of providing direction, feedback,and recognition to an employee in anorganizational setting.

    Performance management is one of the mostimportant but least understood or implementedaspects of business.

    It is the activity of tracking performance againsttargets and identifying opportunities for

    improvement The focus of performance management is the

    future - what do you need to be able to do andhow can you do things better?

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    5/77

    Managing performance is about

    managing for results.It should demonstrate that the Organization

    knows:

    W

    hat you are aiming for What you have to do to meet your objectives

    How to measure progress towards your

    objective

    How to detect performance problems andremedy them.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    6/77

    WhatWould You Do?Case study 1; Probation In your organization employees pass probation and gain certain rights

    after six-month trial period. One of your relatively inexperiencedsupervisors comes to you with a real dilemma. Its been five and one-half months into a new employees tenure and the supervisor realizesits time to do the employees evaluation and dreads the task. Thesupervisor confides in you that the employee really hasnt performed up

    to expectations, is often late to work, and has a habit of irritating co-workers with messy habits. The supervisor tells you that he hasnt saidanything to the employee during the last five months because hes beenso busy with budget activities and the implementation of new programs.He is concerned that if he brings these issues up with the employeenow, he will be in for a battle. He is considering approving the probationand vows to work with the employee, whom he considers has potential.

    What are the potential consequences of the supervisors decision?

    What advice would you give the supervisor?

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    7/77

    Case study 2; The Inherited

    Employee A new supervisor has come to you for

    some coaching on a difficult employee

    issue. The supervisor has inherited anemployee who has a reputation for being

    somewhat unproductive. In fact, this

    employee is consistently late for work,

    often calls in sick on Mondays andFridays, and rarely produces error-free

    work.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    8/77

    You have heard the employee being rude to

    customers on the phone. when you and the newsupervisor take a look at the file left behind by

    previous supervisors, you find only glowing

    comments about this employee. In fact, her last

    three performance evaluations are aboveaverage and none of them mention attendance,

    accuracy, or rudeness.

    What advice do you give the new supervisor?

    What additional steps can you take to make sure this

    situation does not reoccur in other places throughout

    the organization?

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    9/77

    Managements Role in the PM

    CycleSetting expectations

    Use a competency model to define

    expected behaviors Provide a format for helping supervisors

    express clear expectations (SMAART)

    Tie individual performance goals to theorganizations or departments goals or

    strategic plans

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    10/77

    ocumentation

    Train supervisors on what is appropriateand inappropriate to document

    Perform audits of supervisor files toensure that they are sound and legallydefensible

    Offer monthly or quarterly reminders to

    supervisors about performancemanagement and the importance ofdocumentation

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    11/77

    Writing the Performance

    Evaluation Simplify and shorten the form to focus on

    only the most important feedback

    Use technology to ease the preparationof the document

    Provide sample wording, phrases, and

    examples

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    12/77

    Conducting the Performance

    Evaluation Meeting Use behavioral modeling to train

    supervisors to give feedback

    Individually coach and role play withsupervisors

    Provide a discussion format for

    supervisors to follow

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    13/77

    The Performance ManagementCycle

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    14/77

    Your Best and Worst Experience

    Objective: To differentiate betweeneffective and ineffective performance

    evaluation and performance management

    practices.

    EXERCISE

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    15/77

    Exercise:

    Ask participants to write down a list of wordsthat describes the best performanceevaluation experience they ever had.Next, have them write down a list of words

    that describes the worst performanceevaluation experience they ever had. Askthe class to share their words and theirexperiences (either in pairs, small groups,or as a large group). Use this discussion to

    generate as much discussion about reallife examples as possible. The discussionshould lead to a summary of whyperformance management is important in

    an organizational setting.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    16/77

    Exercise:

    After presenting the performance management cycleto the learners, ask them to draw or write the cycle usedin their organization. Ask them to include all the stepsthe organization requires them to follow related toperformance management. Once they have defined theirown performance management cycle, have each learner

    share their perspective with a partner. As they describetheir cycle with a partner, ask them to identify questionsthey may have about their organizations performancemanagement expectations. After both partners haveshared their cycles with each other, conduct a large classdiscussion about the variances between the performance

    management cycle presented in the text and the stepsthey follow in real life. Focus the discussion on thestrengths or weaknesses in their current approaches andencourage each learner to go back to their organizationand ask questions about the process if they are unclear.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    17/77

    1.1What is performance

    management?

    It is the management of anactivity toward achieving and

    improving results. Or, more

    concretely.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    18/77

    performance management

    involves the following1. Definition of goals and desired outcomes

    2. Definition of criteria by which to judge the

    outcome3. Collection and analysis of data to

    measure that criteria

    4. Adjustments or corrections to improveresults

    5. Continual measurement and feedback

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    19/77

    1.2 Why is it important?

    The Modern agendas sets challenging new performance objectives fororganizations, from the delivery of high quality services that meetthe needs of their customers and stakeholders, to doing more withinthe constraints of available resources, through to continuousimprovement in how the organization itself operates. Performancemanagement underpins the operations and processes within astrategic change programme framework. Sound practices andtargets, which are both flexible and reactive to change, are neededto achieve performance improvement.

    The effective performance of your organization depends on thecontributions of activities at all levels - from top management policy

    development through to efficiently run operations. In response to thepressures and opportunities for improving organizationalperformance, you need to understand how to define and measureperformance as part of a concerted strategy for relevant, successfuland cost-effective operations.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    20/77

    Performance Management

    Applies to More than Employees

    Typically, when we think of performance in organizations, we thinkon the performance of employees. However, performancemanagement should also be focused on:1. The organization2. Departments: (computer support, administration, sales, etc.)3. Processes: (billing, budgeting, product development, financial

    management, etc.)4. Programs: (implementing new policies and procedures to

    ensure a safe workplace; or, for a non-profit, ongoing delivery ofservices to a community)

    5. Products or services: to internal or external customers6. Projects: (automating the billing process, moving to a new

    building, etc.)7. Teams or groups organized to accomplish a result for internal

    or external customers

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    21/77

    Maximum Performance

    Different Things to Different

    People

    Despite the recent attention to achieving

    maximum performance, there is no standard

    interpretation of what that means or what ittakes to get it. Still, you should be aware of the

    various views and be Able to choose your own.

    Information in this subsection will orient you to

    what people are suggesting that it takes fororganizations to achieve maximum performance

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    22/77

    Exploring Organizational

    Effectiveness

    The phrase, organizational effectiveness,

    is commonly referred to when discussing

    organizations that have achieved

    maximum performance. Perhaps one of

    the best overviews of the concept of

    Organizational effectiveness is provided

    by Herman and Renz (2002). The authorsidentify nine Fundamental propositions

    about organizational effectiveness.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    23/77

    1. Organizational effectiveness is

    always a matter of comparison When determining the effectiveness of an

    organization, to what are you comparing

    the Organization to conclude whether it is

    effective or not?

    For example, are you comparing to a

    certain set of best practices or to another

    highly respected organization?

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    24/77

    2. Organizational effectiveness is

    multi-dimensional.

    Organizational effectiveness cannot be

    measured by one indicator.

    For example, a budget Surplus or astrong product outcome does not

    guarantee that the organization has

    achieved Overall maximum organizational

    effectiveness.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    25/77

    3. Boards make a difference in

    organizational effectiveness, but

    how is not clear.

    There is a correlation between effective

    Boards and effective organizations.

    However, it is not clear that one

    necessarily causes the other

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    26/77

    4. Organizational effectiveness is

    a social construction

    The concept of organizational

    effectiveness is in the eye of thebeholder. One person might have a

    completely different interpretation than

    another person.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    27/77

    . More effective organizations

    are more likely to use correctmanagement practices

    The authors are careful to point out that thereverse is not necessarily true that

    Organizations that use correct

    management practices will be judged asbeing effective.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    28/77

    6. Claims about best practices

    warrant critical evaluation

    The authors explain that the results of their

    study do not agree with the wide assertion

    that certain practices, for example,automatically produce the best Boards.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    29/77

    7. Measures of responsivenessmay offer solutions to differing

    judgments

    This proposition reframes the concept ofeffectiveness for an organization to be

    about how well that organization is doing

    in responding to whatever is currently

    important.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    30/77

    8. It can be important to

    distinguish different types oforganizations

    This is true to make progress inunderstanding the practices, tactics and

    strategies that may lead to organizational

    effectiveness.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    31/77

    9. Network effectiveness is as

    important to study asorganizational effectiveness.

    This proposition recognizes that the

    effectiveness of an organization might

    depend to a great extent on the

    effectiveness of the wide network of

    organizations in which the particularorganization operates

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    32/77

    Critical factors for success Focusing on outcomes that meet business objectives,

    rather than outputs

    Managing performance by cascading down from the top

    and building bottom-up Defining and using measures that evolve over time

    Using a mix of short and long term measures, andselecting measures that link cause and effect

    Measuring effectiveness (doing the right things) andefficiency (doing things right) in parallel

    Relating individuals' reward and remuneration withachievement of outcomes.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    33/77

    1.4 Who is involved?

    Business managers are responsible for

    setting targets and managing performanceagainst those targets; contract managers

    monitor service performance from the

    customer viewpoint; service providers

    supply performance information.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    34/77

    Exercise -

    Maintaining Effective

    Performance Documentation

    Objective: To identify effective and

    legally-defensible pieces ofdocumentation

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    35/77

    Exercise:

    Collect sample pieces of documentation fromyour own experience and assemble them intoa mock working file for an employee.

    Remove any personal information from thedocumentation. Give each pair of learners acopy of the mock file and ask them to critiqueeach piece of documentation. Ask them todetermine if the documentation is appropriate

    to include in the file and if the documentationis complete. Conduct a discussion about theclasss findings.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    36/77

    Exercise:

    Ask participants to bring to the session a sampleperformance evaluation that they have written or that hasbeen for them. Remind them to delete references tonames or other personal information that they are not

    willing to share with the class. Have them critique thecomments written on the performance evaluationdocument using guidelines provided in the coursematerial. The guidelines should provide ideas for how towrite an effective performance evaluation document.

    Have them identify the strengths and areas forimprovement of the written comments on theperformance evaluation. Conduct a discussion abouttheir findings.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    37/77

    Painless Performance Evaluation

    Painless Performance Evaluation

    A Painless Performance Evaluation is one in which the employeeand the supervisor are clear about the expectations for the job. Anenvironment where Painless Performance Evaluations exist is onewhere:

    There are no ___________________! The employee fully participates in the ______________________

    and ___________________ of their performance.

    The focus is on the _________________, rather than on the past.

    . . . the majority of problems I see in both professional and personalrelationships are due to a lack of clear expectations of all parties,

    and the rest are due to a lack of accountability to appropriateexpectations.Susan ScottHow do we insure that ourorganizational goals arelinked to our people?

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    38/77

    BEST PRACTICES (Baseline

    Practices plus ...) Manager encourages employee to share responsibility

    in a reciprocal process

    Process begins with written self-appraisal by employee

    Manager solicits feedback from colleagues, customers,and direct reports

    Every employee, including senior managers, receivesa review

    Department provides training for employees about

    their roles and responsibilities in performancedevelopment

    Department management selects review forms that aremeaningful and consistent within department

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    39/77

    Tips forSuccessful Performance

    Reviews

    Frequent Conversations Prepare

    Managers and Employees for the Annual

    Review

    Mid-year conversations present

    opportunities to assess progress towardgoals and to make midyear corrections.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    40/77

    Document the Conversations

    A written performance review form or

    memo important because it documents a

    shared understanding of past

    performance and provides a record of

    expectations for the work going forward

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    41/77

    Create a Reciprocal Process

    Frequent conversations about performance

    create a reciprocal process and an atmosphereof shared responsibility for the work.

    Managers and employees who do meet

    regularly to discuss performance goals report

    that the annual review conversation becomes asummarya low-stress "non-event" that is just

    part of an ongoing cycle.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    42/77

    Start with a Self-Appraisal

    Individual managers can also ensure that

    every employee receives an annual

    review and that the review process isbased on a self Appraisal form

    completed by the employee.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    43/77

    Consider Multi-rater Feedback

    Finally a richer view of the employee's

    contributions can often be gained by

    including feedback from colleagues and

    customers. Get more information on

    creating an informal multi-rater review.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    44/77

    Ways of retaining top performers

    Studies show that one of the most effective ways toretain top performers is to reward them based on jobperformance. One way managers can do this mosteffectively is by carefully distributing their merit pool. Weencourage managers to differentiate merit increase

    amounts to recognize each employee's performance,contributions, and past year's achievements. Individualswho demonstrate superior performance should berecognized with review increases at or above theestablished merit allocation amounts, even though lesseramounts will then be available for individuals whodemonstrate average performance. In addition, werecommend that managers engage in opencommunication with staff regarding the specific meritallocation so that employees understand their level ofperformance as it compares to the merit range

    established.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    45/77

    INSTALLING A PERFORMANCE

    MANAGEMENT SYSTEMBusiness processes can be distinguished by:

    The extent to which the activities involved are people-oriented asopposed to automated Whether the activities are primarily 'front-office' or 'back-office' - that is,

    the amount of direct contact which the staff have with the customers orrecipients of the process

    Whether the process itself is the important feature of the activity - forexample, in delivering consultancy - or whether the activities areconcerned primarily with the generation of defined outputs

    The extent to which the activity is customized or tailored to the needs ofeach customer, as opposed to being routine and procedural

    The amount of discretion which needs to be exercised in the activities

    The duration of the contact with the customer.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    46/77

    Processes

    You will need to review the effectiveness of your procedures for:

    Setting performance targets

    Designing measures of performance relevant to the targets

    Systematically and accurately measuring outcomes

    Assessing the performance of external service providers

    Using results for informed decision-making Improving performance.

    Research shows that most organizations have the components ofperformance management in place, but they are not always used tooverall advantage.

    A possible five-step approach that could help organizations inimproving the performance management of the IS/IT contribution isoutlined below, with suggested techniques.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    47/77

    Step 1: Identify your level of

    maturity in performance

    management

    Look at how the organization is performing in all its aspects ofperformance management - from direction setting through to review

    and measurable improvement. Do an assessment; this will help to identify your organization'smaturity and the strengths and weaknesses.

    Establish where you are now as a series of baselines, looking atperformance management at strategic programme, tactical andoperational levels.

    Bottom-up measures of economy and efficiency are likely to bereasonably strong and have good management. This may not be sowell developed for effectiveness measures - innovation, processimprovement, customer satisfaction, and contribution to policyobjectives. Most have a good understanding of financial measure;this level of understanding needs to be developed for othermeasures. Techniques: Assessment; baseline

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    48/77

    Step 2: Identify where

    performance management isimportant to your organization

    Is it in setting direction or ensuring the delivery of required benefits

    or improving the alignment, performance and contribution of theinternal and external resources used by the organizations?

    Identify the values for your organizations.

    Key values for safety critical operational services are speed andintegrity of information. A different organization might place highvalue on information flows or on single points of access to

    information at a contact/call centre. Techniques: Value chain analysis; benchmarking with other

    organizations (which may identify things you had not thought of)

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    49/77

    Step 3: Resolve any mismatch

    between steps 1 and 2

    Review performance management at each of the fourlevels - (organizations, strategic, programme and

    tactical). Are there weaknesses in areas that areimportant to your organizations?

    Techniques: to become more outward looking andcustomer-focused, use the well established balancedscorecard and EFQM techniques.

    To answer questions about where IT makes acontribution, use Goals, Questions and Metrics (GQM) toidentify and define measures.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    50/77

    Step 4: Establish where you want

    to be and begin to build

    performance management intobusiness processes and into the

    culture The aim is to have target, measurement and review processes for

    those things that the business considers important such asproduct, process, service and staff.

    You will have lots of measures which need to be prioritized againstyour particular perspective on effectiveness, efficiency andeconomy and against your values.

    Techniques: establish benefits management as a norm. Usedatabases to collect performance information and analyze trends.Include performance management in the business, programmeand project lifecycle

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    51/77

    Step 5: Feed information back

    into performance improvement

    Monitor and take action on:

    Did we achieve what we set out to do?

    Where are the opportunities to improve?

    What can we do to improve? You areseeking answers to:

    What is achievable?

    What is important for our organizations? What was achieved?

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    52/77

    Benefits at a glance

    Easier, faster creation, distribution and amendment of allorganizational processes, legal and non-legal

    Control resides in-house, reducing reliance on and costsof third party supplier

    Process efficiencies and productivity gains can beextended across the enterprise

    Ability to meet risk management andlegislative/compliance issues through ease of use of thesystem and ease of design & deployment of workflows

    Greater command over all facets of business allows formore proactive, intelligence-based monitoring andmanagement of personnel and performance

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    53/77

    Approaches to performance

    Appraisals What the Experts Say about

    Performance Appraisals

    a performance appraisal is: One of those special humanencounters where the managergets no sleep the night before and

    the employee gets no sleep thenight after.

    Thomas B. Wilson-

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    54/77

    Overarching Goal

    To create and promote a workforce that

    can achieve the organizations mission to

    provide the most value to its stakeholders

    Aspects of Performance

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    55/77

    Aspects of Performance

    Appraisals

    Focus on behavior, not the individual

    Be fair remember Appraisal Errors

    Consistent / Continuous Feedback Document ~ Document ~ Document

    Do you have what you need for Fact

    Finding?

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    56/77

    During Evaluation Meeting

    First ask for employee comments and

    suggestions and be sincere, stay job oriented

    and objective. Summarize previousmemos/suggestions, then suggest new

    approaches with timelines and use good 2-way

    communications, active listening, paraphrasing

    and restating. Use different approach fordifferent employees.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    57/77

    After Evaluation Meeting

    Finalize Form and add your comments and

    signature

    Give to employee for comments and signature

    Give copy to supervisor for review

    Give copy to employee

    Send signed original to Human Resources for

    filing Set date for planning meeting for next year.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    58/77

    Rating

    Rate each individual responsibility

    quantitatively or qualitatively

    Exceeds expectations

    Between meets and exceeds

    Meets expectations

    Between meets and needs improvement

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    59/77

    Exceeds Expectations Rating

    Employee significantly exceeds the

    expectations related to this section of the

    evaluation. This rating is very unique and

    difficult to achieve because it represents

    consistently exceptional performance or

    achievement beyond the expectations of

    the position. A definitive, significant resultmust be cited. It requires written

    supportive information.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    60/77

    Between Meets and Exceeds Expectations

    Employee demonstrates understanding of work

    beyond assigned area of responsibility.

    Identifies needs and executes beyond assignedjob responsibilities.

    Performs well above expectations based on the

    job description

    .

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    61/77

    Meets Expectations

    Employee independently and competently

    performs all aspects of the responsibility or

    goal. This indicates consistently good

    performance at the level expected of a

    fully trained, capable individual.

    Between Meets Expectations &

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    62/77

    Between Meets Expectations &

    Needs Improvement

    Employee (new to position) exhibitsappropriate progress in the course oflearning the responsibilities of a new

    position. Employee (seasoned in position) is not

    performing all duties up to the levelexpected.

    Performance Plan is typically indicated.

    Written supportive information required

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    63/77

    Needs Improvement

    Employee fails to meet expected job standards

    and must show change in performance to

    competently perform most aspects of this

    responsibility. This rating requires a writtenPerformance Plan and timeline for improvement.

    Review and update job description as necessary

    Sign off on completed job description and

    include with performance appraisal. If there areupdates, send to HR in electronic format.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    64/77

    Overall Rating

    This is the Big Picture. It adds comments

    as to why the person/Organization isreceiving this rating. How the individual or

    organization is performing the job as a

    whole

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    65/77

    Skills self assessment Approach

    Documents required are:- the role description, the IT Profession skills framework diagram and accompanying narrative skills descriptions

    Use these to identify the skills and level of skill used

    Document the result on the Ski lls Record Sheet (or equivalent) 2. Analyze the gap between the theoretical (original role description) and actuality:

    Compare findings of the skills used with the skills assessment written for the role

    Identify and record differences different skills used, different levels of skill needed against expectations

    3. The result is a skills gap analysis showing the dif ferences between planned and actual skills used

    4. The gaps are the basis of the personal development plan. Organize a formal discussion of completed skills self assessment will happen during:

    Performance appraisal with a line manager Identifying development needs to produce a Performance Development Plan

    Preparing for a career development discussion - for example with a mentor Assessing suitability for a new role The inputs to the discussion include: The current role description including the skills needed for that role

    The skills self assessment A draft Personal Development Plan including proposed development opportunities to fill skills gaps A forward look at new development opportunities to gain skills and experience needed for possible future roles The manager (or mentor) and job holder uses the role description and the completed skills self assessment to identify and discuss: whether the

    competency and skills for the role have been correctly described, and any adjustments that need to be made, the skills needed for the role and skillsgaps identified during self assessment. The discussion is used to identify and agree action and development needed to: Close skills gaps and developthe individual towards their next career move.

    Outputs from formal appraisal discussions will include: Performance assessment of the past year. The forward job descriptions; Objectives for the role,deliverables and targets. The personal developments plan that, when implemented, will enable the professional to meet agreed objectives and progress

    their career. From self assessment as part of a mentoring or coaching process the outcome of the discussion will be: A mutual understanding of pointsfor personal and career development and an agreed action plan of development to close skills gaps

    Follow-up

    Thejob holderis responsible for managing personal development of skills and experience, planning and completing in-year development such asformal training, mentoring and broadening / deepening work experience through placements and secondments.

    The manageris responsible for ensuring that, the objectives of the role and the skills needed to meet them are kept under review. Developmentopportunities are made available. Learning is consolidated through use in the role and that; there are no barriers to achievement of the PersonalDevelopment Plan.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    66/77

    Managing performance

    discrepancies Why Appraisal Processes Often Fail when;

    Appraisal process only operates for part of the yearnotmeaningful if goals are not monitored.

    Ratings are based on managers opinions, only include

    what managers remember. Managers avoid honest feedback to prevent conflict.

    Organizations try to meet too many objectives (feedback,development, pay raises, etc.).

    Employees believe criteria are vague, subjective; can bedemoralized by ratings, especially when pay isinvolved

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    67/77

    Common Appraisal Errors

    Halo Effect

    It is also known as Halo and Horns. It refers to thetendency to rate based on one outstandinglypositive or negative aspect of the individuals overallperformance. The ratings for other aspects ofperformance will mirror the outstanding aspect,regardless of actual level of performance.

    Leniency/Severity

    This is the tendency to; either rate all individuals ina group very high or very low. All my people arestars and deserve the highest rating. No one canget higher than meets expectations, I dont believein it. Leads to frustration for the person evaluated,as no true picture of strengths and challenges canemerge.

    Central Tendency

    This is similar to Leniency and Severity. Rating isdone right down the middle. the easy way out. Itproduces little value for the evaluated employee as

    little thought is behind the rating. Recency Effect

    The tendency to remember what happened in themonth or two before the evaluation, at the expenseof the other 10 to 11 months of the year. Keepnotes over the course of the year of good andnegative events. Will help in creating a full picture.Of course, events should be recognized/ addressedat the time as well.

    Contrast Effect

    This is the tendency to compare employees againsteach other as opposed to against the standards ofthe job. It refers to the job description and remindsyou that each employee has different strengths andchallenges.

    Subjectivity

    Performance Appraisal by its nature containssubjectivity. The goal is to minimize it, to focus onbehaviors and the job description as much aspossible. Bias should be carefully monitored as well.Focus on behaviors and the job at hand, notpolitics, etc.

    Biases

    Performance Appraisal by its nature containssubjectivity. The goal is to minimize it, to focus onbehaviors and the job description as much aspossible. Biases should be carefully monitored aswell. Focus on behaviors and the job at hand, notpolitics, etc.

    Poorly Planned Meeting and unpreparedSupervisor

    Have an agenda Keep the session moving forward in a positive

    manner Follow the guidelines for mentoring and appraisal

    meetings

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    68/77

    . Preparing a Framework for your

    organizations

    This will provide a systematic method for

    building the right package for each

    individual employee and give guidance on

    how best to deliver it.

    The topics and components essential to

    any programme will cover:

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    69/77

    A)Competence in the work role

    Filling gaps and deficiencies in

    performance

    Up skilling to meet changing demands and

    working practices

    Certification and re-certification to meet

    regulatory requirements

    Career development

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    70/77

    B) Knowledge and understanding

    related to the work role

    Filling gaps and deficiencies in knowledgeand understanding

    Responding to changes in the operational,

    technological, regulatory, marketand organisational environment

    Expanding and broadening knowledge toimprove judgment and develop expertise

    Sharing and comparing knowledge andunderstanding with others

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    71/77

    C) Personal development

    Addressing issues related to confidence, attitude, motivation andbehaviorImproving ability to deal with relationships, communications andstressDevelop personal growth and contribution as a professional

    Each organization will have its own procedures for identifying,

    planning, supporting and organizing the firm. At one end of thescale, employers will simply respond to requests from individualemployees or their line managers and judge each on its merits. Atthe other end, the organization is integrated with corporate HRpolicy and procedures and there is a clear framework within whichtraining and development operates. Best practice will involveestablishing:

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    72/77

    An Organization Policy

    that sets out the organizations policy on

    continuing training and development andcriteria by which support to individuals is

    based.

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    73/77

    A performance appraisal system

    that includes the identification of trainingand development needs and would

    normally be initiated during Induction

    training for each new employee.

    T i i & P l

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    74/77

    Training & Personal

    Development Plans

    for each employee (and is normally held

    by them) that records what training and

    development is required and has been

    agreed

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    75/77

    A training and development

    record system

    that maintains a listing of what training

    has been done, the outcome and what isagreed and planned for the future.

    2 D l i th T i i &

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    76/77

    2. Developing the Training &

    Personal Development Plan The Training & Personal Development Plan (PDP) lies at the heart

    of an effective organization system. Without the tangible ownershipby the employee of their own commitment to continuing learning, theorganization plan can be perceived as something imposed on themthat reflect their limitations rather than their aspirations and potential.While the plan does serve an important purpose in remedying

    weaknesses and filling gaps, any deficiency driven model is boundto be less effective than one that encourages personal growth andcareer progression.

    The Personal Development Planning process should be initiated atthe induction stage for new employees and reviewing and updatingthe Personal Development Plan should be an integral part ofPerformance Appraisal.

    There are many examples of good practice in the design of PDPdocumentation. This toolkit helps you design your own, or build adatabase that you can paste into your own or a proprietary system.

    2 D l i th T i i &

  • 8/6/2019 Performance Management Part 2

    77/77

    2. Developing the Training &

    Personal Development Plan It is normally easiest to start the analysis of the plans needs by

    looking at the individuals Job description and current workfunctions.

    The Job Description will come from the Contract of Employment orfrom Personnel files. The individuals work functions may already beincorporated in the Job description, if not the Job Competence

    framework provides a schedule of work functions for Managers thatcan be cut and pasted into Needs Template, to which can be addedany other work functions particular to the individuals job. This caneither be done in summary form (Unit level) or in more detail(Element Level). The purpose is to provide a systematic frameworkfor analysis and decision making.

    It is also important to include any extension or variation to the workrole; hence a section that relates to new work functions is alsoincluded.

    The attached template provides a format for doing this.