51
PARTY WORLD CONSULTING REPORT MANAGEMENT 498 FALL 2012 CONSULTANTS: RAZA HAMID, MATT ALSTAD, & KATIE HALPIN

Party World Consulting Report

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Party World Consulting Report

PARTY WORLD

CONSULTING

REPORT

MANAGEMENT 498 – FALL 2012

CONSULTANTS: RAZA HAMID, MATT ALSTAD, & KATIE HALPIN

Page 2: Party World Consulting Report

1 Consulting Report | Party World

TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................. 2

Project Scope ............................................................................................................................................ 3

Business Description ................................................................................................................................. 4

INDUSTRY ANALYSIS ...................................................................................................................................... 7

Industry Overview ..................................................................................................................................... 8

The Economy and the Retail Industry ................................................................................................... 8

Current Trends ........................................................................................................................................ 10

MARKETING PLAN ....................................................................................................................................... 12

Marketing Analysis .................................................................................................................................. 12

SWOT Analysis ..................................................................................................................................... 12

Porter’s Five Forces Analysis ............................................................................................................... 18

The Marketing Mix .............................................................................................................................. 23

Marketing Warfare.............................................................................................................................. 26

Product Diffusion Curve ...................................................................................................................... 28

Search Engine Optimization .................................................................................................................... 30

Website Recommendations .................................................................................................................... 31

Summary of Web Recommendations ................................................................................................. 35

Social Media ............................................................................................................................................ 36

SUCCESSION PLAN ...................................................................................................................................... 44

Keeping the Business in the Family ......................................................................................................... 45

Selling the Business ................................................................................................................................. 47

BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................................................ 50

Page 3: Party World Consulting Report

2 Consulting Report | Party World

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Party World is a small-business that provides retail party supplies and rentals including but not

limited to: wedding supplies, tables, chairs, podiums, sound equipment, decorations, tents,

costumes, games, flatware, dinner ware, dunk tanks, grills, etc.

This following report covers three outcomes that were determined after an initial discussion

with the owner of Party World. These outcomes include, an in-depth industry analysis of the

retail industry, a comprehensive marketing analysis with emphasis on increasing the social

media presence of the business, and finally information pertaining to the future of the business

upon the exit of the existing owners.

The consulting team conducted research on the party industry and the retail industry in

connection with Party World. The team also looked into current trends within the industry to

assist Party World in providing strategies to attract additional customers. Party World is a small

business with only one location and their main competitor, with in the immediate vicinity, is

Party Time. Additional competitors that have franchise locations include Party City, Costco and

Wal-Mart. The comprehensive marketing plan includes numerous tools Party World can

implement to figure out what the business is doing well and what they may want to improve

on. These tools analyze issues through: SWOT analysis, Porter’s Five Forces, Marketing Mix,

Marketing Warfare, and the Product Diffusion Curve. Finally, the marketing plan includes

recommendations on improving Party World’s website and social media presence. Having a

Page 4: Party World Consulting Report

3 Consulting Report | Party World

good marketing plan may be one of the most important things a business needs and can set a

business apart from its competitors. The succession plan looks into the option of the family

continuing the business and information that would assist in valuing and selling the business as

an alternative option.

Project Scope

The following three outcomes make up the bulk of the report and represent the scope of the

project after discussion with Party World and the consulting team.

1. Industry Analysis

2. Marketing Plan

3. Family Succession Plan

The industry analysis recognizes the industry that Party World operates in, analyzes current

trends and concerns that may follow, and provides insight for future economic growth in the

industry.

The marketing plan provides tools to help Party World assess itself as a business, provides

strategies that may be used to help Party World, and gives recommendations for Party World to

update its website and gain a better social media presence.

The succession plan provides two options for Party World and teaches them how to use each

option. The first option includes Party World deciding to keep its business in the family and

transitioning the business to the next generation. The second option examines selling the

business.

Page 5: Party World Consulting Report

4 Consulting Report | Party World

Business Description

Party World is a ‘party retail and service rental’ store focusing on wedding rentals and specialty

balloon setups. The business is an ‘S-Corp’ and is located in Baxter, Minnesota. The business

was established in 1998 by the owner’s parents. Kelli Mankowski and her husband eventually

acquired the business, from her parents, and took over the operations in 2004. It was

previously located on: 15808 Edgewood

Drive Baxter, Minnesota 56425, on Highway-

371, but due to a recent change in the

highway infrastructure, the business lost its

direct access of traffic and decided to

relocate. Party World relocated to its current

location in 15867 Edgewood Drive Baxter,

Minnesota 56425 in 2006. An advantage of

the new location is that Party World attained

more land which increased the value of its current asset holdings. The adverse effect of this

relocation is diminished visibility that contributes to lower random customer traffic. The facility

is a 12,000+ square feet warehouse setting with 15,000 square feet of total space available to

their disposal.

Inventory is comprised of: wedding supplies, tables, chairs, podiums, sound equipment,

decorations, tents, costumes, games, flatware, dinner ware, dunk tanks, grills, etc.

Page 6: Party World Consulting Report

5 Consulting Report | Party World

Accessibility to the business is reasonable and ample parking is available for customers. Party

World is open seven days a week with limited hours on the weekends. Average traffic flow for

the business is five to ten people per day. Phone inquiries during the winter season are two per

hour. While, during the busy season (Spring/Summer) the business receives about twenty

phone inquiries per hour.

Key employees are Kelli and her husband Mike. Their younger son, Adam, further supports the

operation, on a part-time basis. Party world hires 8-11 employees on a seasonal part-time basis

and their responsibilities include Tent and Décor installation and dismantling. These employees

are vital to the business since Party-World’s business peaks during the summer. Importantly,

the labor demands of peak-season, weddings and events, can only be met with these

employees being brought on to support the business. Kelli’s previous management experience

entails serving as a Manager at Superior Shores for over ten years and an Office Manager for

Crowing County Services for two years. She currently serves as a Business Manager for Lakes

Area Yoga, and she is a diving instructor at Minnesota School of Diving.

The business focuses a bulk of its efforts through its rental services in the summer. January

through February, the focus shifts to soon-to-be brides and their mothers looking at planning

weddings. April/May, the business focuses on graduation parties and the wedding season. In

the fall, target market is high school and college students looking to spend their disposable

income on Halloween and party supplies. Also, the business services the local October-fest.

Current advertising strategies comprise of a vehicle wrap on the business owner’s personal car,

signage on a trailer outside of Baxter on the main Highway-371, a business card with every

Page 7: Party World Consulting Report

6 Consulting Report | Party World

balloon, word-of-mouth, an active Facebook page and a smart phone application. Party World

has not been able to monitor which medium has been successful to date. The business owner is

a member of Chamber of Commerce in Brainerd, MN, Minnesota Rental Association and

Qualtex Balloon Association. Goals of Party World include: “don’t go broke,” increasing business

during Halloween, making more money, and increasing awareness of the location. Some new

directions Party World would like to take are having more business during the Fall/Halloween

season and differentiating themselves from their main competitor Party Time. Unique

Features/Services include the Certified Balloon Artist (only one of its kind in the Brainerd area).

Primary competitors include Party Time in Brainerd and Party City in St. Cloud. Party Time

operates an identical business operation and prices itself marginally lower than Party World.

Party City in St. Cloud is a well-known franchise business and generates potential customers

through its nationally recognized name. Walmart and Target are one-stop, department-store-

style businesses that offer the convenience of shopping for everything possible to their

customers. These businesses do not specialize on any particular supplies and often offer

cheaper quality products. Further, they do not service any rental options. A future Costco may

prove to be potential competition to the business.

Page 8: Party World Consulting Report

7 Consulting Report | Party World

INDUSTRY ANALYSIS

Foreword

This industry analysis will take a bottom up approach by understanding the macro economic

factors that affect sales and success in this industry. The consulting team will further explore

our efforts into understanding the factors that affect businesses in this industry, and finally

channeling its efforts on explaining growing trends and evolution of this industry sector.

The competition and attractiveness of new entrants in this industry will be analyzed through

identification of key players of this industry, nationally and locally, as well as the fundamental

operational methodology adopted by successful businesses in this sub-sector.

From there the consulting team will focus on defining the core business practices of the subject

company, by explaining the core products/services that drive revenue, the client’s skill-set and

finally how the business currently markets itself to potential clients.

Page 9: Party World Consulting Report

8 Consulting Report | Party World

Industry Overview

Party supplies and rentals, the business of the subject company, is categorized under a broader

umbrella of the retail industry. The business operates in the ‘Miscellaneous Store Retailers’

category of the retail industry as per the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS).

More specifically, the business concentrates in the rental and sales of merchandise related to

the Party Supplies arena; specializing in renting tents, chairs, tables as well as complementary

party decorations for weddings and themed parties. The business operates from a physical

location and currently does not have an online store. It does, however, have an operational

website as well as an active social media presence in the form of a Facebook page. The business

is owner operated, holds deep levels of inventory - which is centrally warehoused, and prices its

products and services in the medium to high range.

The Economy and the Retail Industry

A bulk of the U.S economic growth heavily relies on consumer spending habits. Demand in this

industry is a strong indicator of a healthy financial system. The success of this sector depends

greatly on sales generated from discretionary income of households. The economic slowdown

in the recent years, decline in wages and unemployment has greatly influenced people’s

everyday spending habits. As a general rule of thumb, luxury purchases are the first to be put

off in times of financial turmoil.

With the U.S. slowly clawing its way out one of the worst recessions since the Great Depression,

the recent months have seen steady growth in the labor markets and increased spending in the

Page 10: Party World Consulting Report

9 Consulting Report | Party World

retail sector. The housing and auto sales often show patterns of income available for

consumption beyond basic needs. Unemployment rate has declined to 7.9% while Americans

have increased spending by 1.3% in the recent month showing signs of a steady recovery.

Source: (CBS Money Watch)

Bulk business depends on seasonal events in the party supplies sector with retailers focusing

strongly on sales and rentals through the wedding, Graduation and Halloween seasons.

Birthdays and miscellaneous events account for general everyday sales and are usually of

varying magnitude depending on customers’ intent on how significant the celebration is and

availability of disposable income.

Page 11: Party World Consulting Report

10 Consulting Report | Party World

Current Trends

Market indicators of 2011 and early 2012 reflect a positive trend for continued growth in the

near future for the retail industry. The statistics from the Special Events group show that 52% of

top party rental operators expect to handle more events in 2013, while last year only 37%

expected more events. This shows an optimistic upsurge in how confident people in the party

industry are. The indicator predicts that within the next five years the service industry will

continue to flourish and the party rental industry, specifically, has been highlighted as a

potential industry leader. The economy continues to increase and people are looking for better

ways to host parties for various occasions. This industry is closely related with the income that

the average person makes. The more income people have to spend, the more money they will

put into rentals for a party. When people have weddings, they want them to be extravagant but

also need the capital to host such a type of wedding. Since the economy is showing positive

signs of growth and unemployment rates are predicted to drop within the next two years, the

forecast for growth in the party industry throughout that time is expected to be encouraging.

Finally, specific trends that are stirring in the industry within the past 2-3 years are important to

look at.

Paper Decorations

Inexpensive and very original are two significant reasons that make this trend extremely

popular. Some of the decorations that are made with the paper actually turn out very pleasant

and can be designed with color to add some specialization to them.

Page 12: Party World Consulting Report

11 Consulting Report | Party World

Customized Linens

Examples here include: Faux burlap (which goes great with country-western themed events),

Croc (which is crocodile-skin fabric that goes well with sexy parties) and Damask (which goes

along with classic parties).

Decoration Education

A trending term currently evolving in the industry is ‘educore’ which translates to educational

décor. This is an easy and affordable way to use branding and messaging about the business.

Party World can utilize this coined term by putting the business’ brand name or brand image on

a piece of decoration.

Price Bargaining

The recent recession has caused people to pinch pennies and save money any way possible.

Businesses that decide to raise prices dramatically, to make higher profits each year, could be

facing trouble. Prices cannot be raised because customers are moving toward saving money

and are resorting to demanding discounted prices. As part of the party industry, the business

will want to slowly increase prices in the coming years in line with growing inflation. This will

help manage revenues and profits for the business reliably.

Page 13: Party World Consulting Report

12 Consulting Report | Party World

MARKETING PLAN

Foreword

When deciding how to approach the marketing plan, the consulting team employed industry-

grade marketing tools that are used as a benchmark. Further, the consulting team incorporated

the knowledge learned through formal education in order to assist in the promotion of Party

World. This approach analyzes and breaks down a comprehensive marketing plan that would be

valuable to the business. The following section will include five vital tools utilized by marketing

professionals, the SWOT analysis, Porter’s Five Forces Model, Marketing Mix, Marketing

Warfare, and Product Diffusion Curve. All of these tools help the business analyze its operations

and can help determine what parts the business is succeeding in and highlight areas of

improvement.

Marketing Analysis

SWOT Analysis

The SWOT analysis is a strategic planning tool that is used to evaluate the strengths,

weaknesses, opportunities, and threats that are involved when looking at a business venture. It

involves specifying a goal and identifying internal and external factors that are favorable or

unfavorable to achieving that final goal. After the SWOT analysis has been evaluated, a

business’s goals can be set, products and services can be further analyzed, strategies will be

reviewed, key weaknesses and opportunities will be discovered, what the business is doing well

can be defined, and can ultimately analyze and prepare the business for a better future and

Page 14: Party World Consulting Report

13 Consulting Report | Party World

learn what may need to be worked on or capitalized to better help the business thrive in the

future. With all of these factors in mind, the SWOT analysis provides a basic framework for

businesses to discover factors not known about beforehand.

SWOT Explanations

Strengths

Party World’s main strength that they should be taking, the most, advantage of is the fact that

Kelli is a CBA (Certified Balloon Artist). Having only 2300 CBA artists worldwide makes this a

great advantage to Party World and having the business owner (Kelli) advertising this fact by

presenting people with her great balloon-creations can prove to assist the business

tremendously. Considering, Party World has a specialty of renting items for parties such as

weddings, graduations, homecoming, etc. This helps them make money and provide great

results to customers, keeping them happy. Party World has great customer loyalty. Customers

using Party World’s services will usually refer friends or family through word of mouth. The

business owner proudly indicates customers being highly satisfied with the service the business

offers. Another great strength is the fact that helium is still available to Party World. The

business owner was able to well-prepare her business to tackle the helium shortage faced by

the balloon industry by keeping herself well informed in advance. This inclined the business to

stock up on helium beforehand making it one of the few businesses that were able to access

the limited availability of this gas. If advertised efficiently, Party World’s access to helium can

continue to increase customers, thus increasing revenues. The business owner (Kelli) recently

completed a profit mastery class which aided her ability to further understand the financials of

Page 15: Party World Consulting Report

14 Consulting Report | Party World

her business and provided advice that could increase profits and help the business develop in

the future. The business is extremely innovative in its strategy and continues to evolve, adapt

and change to thrive in its industry. With future promise for growth in the industry, this attitude

will prove to be an asset for the business, considering profit margins and market share will

steadily increase every year.

Weaknesses

Party World has many great strengths but every business cannot be complete without having

some weaknesses as well. The awareness of where Party World is located is perceived by the

consulting team as a deterrent and could be improved if they focus on letting more people

know of their location through advertising or other marketing routes. Better signage on and off

the highway would help customers become better informed of Party World’s presence in

Brainerd and aid in the increase of direct customer traffic to the store. Although the retail side

of Party World performed well this year, during Halloween, the consulting team still believes it

could use more attention as far as attracting customers in the store and marketing to the right

target clientele. A lack of successor identification could prove to be a weakness because when

the business owner (Kelli) is ready to retire she may not be very confident in the abilities of an

untrained family member. The succession plan at the bottom of this report recommends a

framework to develop the thought process when considering transfer of ownership within the

family. If Party Worlds’ website was updated with minor tweaks it could prove to bring more

customers to the website thus increasing store awareness and possible customer base.

Although Party World does have an existing Facebook presence, the business expressed its

Page 16: Party World Consulting Report

15 Consulting Report | Party World

desire to enhance its social media presence and support on future routes that can be pursued

to increase visibility. Since a few of Party World’s competitors charge lower prices, customers

may tend to frequent them instead for this reason alone. The consulting team will cover the use

of market warfare to regain competitive advantage and keep competitors on their toes. The last

weakness affects customers’ ability to see the physical location of the store due to trees and

other businesses covering that area. Strong signage would aid customers in spotting the store

easily thereby increasing footfall.

Opportunities

Looking at future opportunities that Party World may have the business owner’s balloon

specialty will prove to be a great advantage. This will help bring in customers that no other

store in the area is capable of servicing. Future economic growth will be a big opportunity since

people will have more disposable income and will be willing to spend more of their savings on

rentals and/or retail items. Halloween sales improving every year is an opportunity Party World

must capitalize on since this will account for a vast improvement of future profits. This would

further be in line with the businesses strategic vision to shift from a rental specialty business to

a seasonal retail sales model. In the close future, Party World can implement marketing

techniques found in this report to further assist in gaining a competitive advantage over Party

Time, its main competitor and others alike. If Party World gains a dominant social media

presence within its local group of businesses, then this may prove to be a major competitive

advantage for the business.

Page 17: Party World Consulting Report

16 Consulting Report | Party World

Another opportunity that may prove to be a major competitive advantage is improving the

website currently in use. An overhaul of the interface of the webpage will enable ease of use to

the average browser and address customer friendliness – both of which should support an

increase to the online business. Again, implementing marketing warfare strategies described

later in this marketing plan will contribute to the businesses need to stay on top.

Threats

After discussing future opportunities the consulting team must address future threats in

response to these opportunities. Local competition, Party Time, remains a direct threat to the

business and its client base in Brainerd. Others include the successful franchise of Party City in

St. Cloud. Although these persist as an imminent risk, implementing sound marketing strategies

listed in this report will help Party World mitigate the danger posed by these firms. However, it

is important to note the fact that one of its direct competitors, being a big retail franchise

chain, i.e. Party City, means they will not be going away anytime soon.

Finally, the fact that future competition cannot be predicted and how the competition may

react prove to be a threat. While still an opportunity, the economy, due to its unpredictable

nature, may continue to pose as a threat to businesses small or big. The possibility of not having

a successor to Party World is a weakness as well as a threat.

Page 18: Party World Consulting Report

17 Consulting Report | Party World

SWOT Summary

Strengths

•Certified Balloon Artist (CBA): Only 2300 worldwide

•Rental specialist

•Customer loyalty

•Still has helium to use in balloons

•Profit Mastery class

•Innovation and growth

•Future promise for growth

Weaknesses

•Awareness of Party Worlds’ location

•Retail side of the business needs more attention

•Kids are not so interested in the business

•Website could use some updating

•Social media presence

•Competitors charging lower prices

•Trees in front of the highway blocks location of the store

Opportunities

•Balloon specialty can prove to be an advantage

•Future economic growth

•Halloween is growing every year

•Gaining competitive advantage over Party Time

•Dominant social media presence

•Improved website will increase

Threats

•Local competitor Party Time

•Party City – A national party store with big awareness

•Unpredicatable economy

•Possibility of no successor to the business

Page 19: Party World Consulting Report

18 Consulting Report | Party World

Porter’s Five Forces Analysis

Porter’s Five Forces Model is a very important tool that helps comprehend the level of

competitiveness in operations and also the attractiveness of a firm or company. The analysis

manages to dissect a company’s worth into five different categories.

These forces help determine an industry’s profit potential and benefit in determining the

strength of the competition. When focusing on the five forces the business needs to remember

to focus its efforts on customers’ needs rather than looking at specific industry boundaries only.

The business needs to recognize that their suppliers as well as their buyers may pose as

competitors to a firm.

Industry Rivalry

Bargaining Power of Buyers

Threat of New

Substitutes

Bargaining Power of Suppliers

Threat of New

Competition

Page 20: Party World Consulting Report

19 Consulting Report | Party World

Threat of New Competition

When businesses are trying to identify new competition, they threaten the market share of

existing competitors. New competition poses a threat because it brings additional production

capacity. Unless the demand for a good or service is increasing, additional capacity will hold

consumers’ costs down, meaning that there will be less revenue and lower returns for

competing firms. New competition is usually very concerned with gaining a large market share

and as a result it may force existing firms to be more efficient and learn how to compete on

new dimensions. The likelihood of new competition is determined by two factors, barriers to

entry and retaliation. Barriers to entry, primarily, determine whether a firm will prosper as a

new competitor or not. These include, but are not limited to: economies of scale, product

differentiation, and switching costs. Retaliation arises when the existing firms in the market

fight back to drive down the advantage a new competition may have gained, thus making it

harder for the new entrant to remain in business. Additionally, the need for a fair amount of

capital and knowledge can prove to be a barrier to entry for new competitors looking to enter

the party/retail industry. Switching costs are low because a customer may easily decide to go to

another store if Party World’s prices are too high. This being said the barriers to entry create a

high threat of new entrants and yet, simultaneously, allows for higher profit potential due to

limited competition.

Bargaining Power of Suppliers

Increasing prices and reducing the quality of their products are things suppliers can do to exert

their power over firms that are competing within an industry. This means that suppliers can

Page 21: Party World Consulting Report

20 Consulting Report | Party World

control the profits a firm may make by increasing their prices and making the firm unable to

recover costs. Suppliers remain in power when they are dominated by a few large companies

and are very concentrated within an industry. When a supplier has more power it makes it

harder for the firm to prosper and survive. There is a strong, direct, bond between the power of

suppliers and the power of buyers. These two forces go hand in hand and help determine how

successful or ineffective a firm may be. Party World has an abundance of suppliers it can go

through and has built a great relationship with some of its suppliers already. This makes the

bargaining power of suppliers weak. Hence, the operations become more attractive which in

turn should continue to increase profits for Party World.

Bargaining Power of Buyers

Usually a buyer will want to purchase a product at the lowest possible price when they are

looking at all competitors. To reduce costs; buyers will bargain for higher quality, greater levels

of service, but at a lower price. The buyer wants a product to be affordable with good quality

while receiving good service. This is achieved when firms are encouraged to have competitive

battles within their industry. Buyer groups are powerful when they purchase a large portion of

an industry’s total output. The sales of the product being purchased account for a significant

portion of the seller’s annual revenues when they can switch to another product at little, if any,

cost. This may be, something as easy as buying a generic brand because it is cheaper and works

just as well, or as complicated as having bad service and paying a little more for better service.

Consumers hold a lot of power and keeping them content is a key determinant in making sure

they do not switch to another product or firm. Buyer power within the party industry can be

Page 22: Party World Consulting Report

21 Consulting Report | Party World

particularly potent. If a customer came into Party World and did not like the prices, they could

easily look for another party store with lower prices. Since, Party World has good standing with

its suppliers, it needs to utilize this to its advantage to control prices and ensure that their

customers continue to stay loyal to them.

Threat of Substitute Products

Substitute products are goods or services from outside a given industry that perform similar or

the same functions as a product that the industry produces. Product substitutes present a

strong threat to a firm when customers face few switching costs and when the substitute

product’s lower price is lower or its quality and performance capabilities are equal to or greater

than those of the competing product. Differentiating a product along dimensions that

customers value reduces a substitute’s attractiveness. Since there are many substitute products

available the threat of substitute products is strong. The fact that Party Time offers substitute

products for a cheaper price than Party World shows this relationship very well.

Intensity of Rivalry among Competitors

Traditionally, rivalry among competitors can be a good thing, as it provides for efficiency in the

market place and choices to the general public. In many industries, firms actively compete

against one another. Competitive rivalry can intensify when a firm is challenged by a

competitor’s actions or when a company recognizes an opportunity to improve its market

position. Firms within an industry, rarely, operate on the exact same basis. They may differ in

resources and capabilities and seek to differentiate themselves from competitors. Most times

Page 23: Party World Consulting Report

22 Consulting Report | Party World

firms seek to differentiate their products from competitors’ offerings in ways that customers

value them and, further, in which the firms have a competitive advantage. Common dimensions

on which rivalry is based are: price, service after-the-sale, and innovation. Since there are two

party stores located in the Baxter area (Party World and Party Time), and they both offer similar

services (rentals, retail party supplies) - the intensity of rivalry among competitors is strong.

This can be a good thing since both companies competing may prove to bring each other’s

profits up. When rivalry is high, businesses manage to figure out their core abilities quite

efficiently and develop strategies they can utilize to benefit them down the road.

Overall Attractiveness

When looking at attractiveness for the party industry, it is important to examine the factors

that influence profitability. Since bargaining power of suppliers is weak, this will prove to help

drive up profits because having power over suppliers helps get better prices. Threat of new

competition has also proven to be weak because the barriers to entry cause trouble for new

competition to enter. In summary, lesser competition results in higher profit margins. Intensity

of rivalry is strong and proves to bring up profitability. When looking at bargaining power of

buyers it can be seen that it is strong and this proves to bring down overall profitability. Since

there are many substitute products available profitability will not be as high. Three of these five

factors help bring up profitability thus helping us conclude that this industry is definitely

attractive.

Page 24: Party World Consulting Report

23 Consulting Report | Party World

The Marketing Mix

The marketing mix is a tool that provides managers with information that can help them reach

their target market. It has four basic categories that are covered and in the end will help the

business further reach its target market. These four categories are: product, price, place, and

promotion. Each one has its own niche and once understood, can help managers satisfy their

customers within the target market.

When a business can blend these four variables together it can generate a positive response in

regards to reaching the target market and keeping the customer happy.

Page 25: Party World Consulting Report

24 Consulting Report | Party World

The first variable of this mix is known as the product. The product is the physical product or

service that the business offers to the customer. For Party World, this will include the retail

products carried in the store and all of the rental services that they provide. When making

product decisions businesses want to keep in mind things like function, appearance, packaging,

service, warranty, etc. This will help the business better decide which products to keep and

which products it may not want to invest in. Party World has numerous product lines, and

keeping in mind all of these factors when deciding on whether or not to carry a product, can

further help the business operate efficiently.

The second variable of mention is the price. When making pricing decisions businesses must

take into account their profit margins and the pricing response of competitors (e.g. Party Time).

Pricing includes not just the list price, but also discounts, financing, and other options such as

leasing. When Party World examines its pricing strategy they may want to look at Party Time’s

strategy of charging fifteen cents cheaper for everything and respond with a possible

competitive price that will undermine them. The price reductions in direct products can be

softened by an increase in other products or services that are unique to the business.

Place (or placement) decisions are those connected with channels of distribution that serve as

the way for getting the product to the target customers. Some of these decisions include:

market coverage, channel member selection, logistics, and levels of service. Party World could

think about implementing more market coverage to its target customers and look into how

Page 26: Party World Consulting Report

25 Consulting Report | Party World

they channel their member selection. Trying different placement approaches may prove to be

resourceful and advantageous.

Promotion dictates how a business will communicate and sell to potential customers. Simply

understood, it relates to advertising expenses and costs, and analyzes their effectiveness in

reaching the target market. Since these costs can be significant, and are connected to the price,

Party World may want to consider conducting a break-even analysis when making promotion

decisions. It is useful to recognize the value of the customer when determining whether the

impact on the top-line is worth the cost of advertising. Many forms of advertising could be used

to promote Party World, and will be covered in more detail throughout the marketing plan.

Product

• Appearance

• Brand

• Functionality

• Packaging

• Quality

• Service/Support

• Warranty

Price

• Allowances

• Discounts

• Financing

• Leasing Options

• List Price

Place

• Channel members

• Channel motivation

• Locations

• Logistics

• Market Coverage

• Service Levels

Promotion

• Advertising

• Budget

• Media

• Message

• Personal selling

• Public relations

Page 27: Party World Consulting Report

26 Consulting Report | Party World

Marketing Warfare

Marketing warfare is a tool that may be used when businesses do not get results with just using

a customer-oriented philosophy of marketing. Businesses may want to also look into becoming

competitor-oriented when marketing is involved. When using this tool businesses will need to

understand that performing the best market research will not put them on top. For instance,

marketers can learn a tremendous amount when looking at some military strategies that have

been used. Learning lessons from famous battles in history helps illustrate this term. It

implements the basic concepts of planning, maneuvering, and overpowering the opposition. To

understand the principle of force, marketers often seek inspiration from a famous military

personality, Karl von Clausewitz. He is noted to have said that ‘it is easier to get to the top than

stay there”. However, with marketing warfare once a business is at the top, it can use this

power of position to stay there.

When dealing with a big competitor with lots of resources (Party City), a smaller company

(Party World) must realize that they cannot win the battle with brute force but by means of a

superior strategy. Once consumers deem a product as number one in their heads, it is hard to

take over that number one spot no matter what. When looking to win the battle of marketing,

the business must look at executing a superior strategy alongside having better employees or

better products. An entrenched defense that is expecting an attack will have an advantage that

can only be overcome by an overwhelming larger attack. For example, a defense that is in a

trench will be shielded from the attackers, and the attackers will suffer more casualties than

the defenders. For this reason, these attackers will need a much larger force to overcome

Page 28: Party World Consulting Report

27 Consulting Report | Party World

defensive positions. The same holds true for marketing warfare. Companies cannot simply

attack a leader when they have insufficient resources because this will prove to be

unsuccessful. Having the element of surprise this will help achieve the retaliation wanted.

Launching product lines that take care of more than one customer segment can prove to be a

very great strategy.

There are four strategies that can be used in marketing warfare. These strategies include:

defense, offense, flanking, and guerrilla. When determining which strategy to use businesses

must look at their market share compared to the competition. The firm that is dominating the

market will want to implement the defensive strategy since if the firm gets too big the

government may attack them with antitrust laws. The next biggest firm will want to use an

offensive attack on the dominating market to help close the big gap between the two

companies. The third biggest firm (Party World vs. Party Time) is too small to sustain an

offensive attack on a larger firm. The best strategy for them is to launch a flanking attack,

avoiding direct competition, for example, by releasing a product that is positioned differently

than that of larger firms. To help differentiate them and gain a competitive edge over Party

Time, Party World should implement the flanking technique. This involves coming up with some

variation of a product that will help differentiate them from Party Time and thus help gain a

competitive edge. Whether it is adopting a new type of rental service, or carrying something

that Party Time is not able to carry, it is an important part of marketing warfare and becoming

the top competitor.

Page 29: Party World Consulting Report

28 Consulting Report | Party World

Product Diffusion Curve

When consumers start buying a new product they can be put into certain groups. On one side

of an extreme, consumers adopt the product as soon as it becomes available. On the other side,

some customers will be the last to purchase a new product. As a whole, the new product

adoption process can be modeled in the form of a bell-shaped diffusion curve, which is shown

in the following chart:

When looking at these groups, it can be seen what part of the percentage is in which category

and how they fit into the product life cycle. Each category of customers can be defined:

Page 30: Party World Consulting Report

29 Consulting Report | Party World

Innovators

Innovators are well-informed risk-takers who are willing to try an unproven product. They

represent the first 2.5% who adopt the product.

Early adopters

Based on the positive response of the innovators, early adopters will begin to purchase the

product. They tend to be educated opinion leaders and represent about 13.5% of the consumer

base.

Early majority

These are the careful consumers who will tend to avoid risk, and they adopt the product once it

has been proven by the early adopters. They rely on recommendations from others who have

experience with the product. The early majority represents 34% of consumers which is a big

chunk of the market.

Late majority

They are somewhat skeptical about the product and like to acquire a product only after it has

become common. The late majority also represents 34% of consumers.

Laggards

The laggards tend to avoid change and may not adopt a new product until traditional

alternatives are no longer available. They represent 16% of consumers.

Page 31: Party World Consulting Report

30 Consulting Report | Party World

Using this table and the information provided about the type of adopters (innovators, early

adopters, etc.) Party World can better prepare themselves for the type of customers they have

and become informed on how to market certain products and services to their customers based

on the type of adopter they are. This tool can be very important, because it divides the

consumer into groups, and shows who buys new products the most, and how they think when

deciding to buy the product.

Search Engine Optimization

Search engine optimization (SEO) gives the opportunity to improve sections of a website that

helps users and search engines locate the website through non-paid searches. By using certain

techniques, a website can position them to make it at the top of the search results. This is an

extremely important technique to have for Party World because most consumers are on the

Internet, and when they are searching for products, most consumers only look at the first page

of the search results. Proven keywords are the best way to get Party World’s business to the

top of the search results, example of such keywords that are relevant to the business are rental,

party, supplies, etc. If there is a hard time thinking of keywords, just go to SEOBook.com

Keyword Suggestion Tool for Google daily estimates. SEO is very important to implement into

the Party World website because it gets awareness out for the business and puts it at the top

for people to select first.

Page 32: Party World Consulting Report

31 Consulting Report | Party World

Website Recommendations

When searching for Party World’s website through google.com, two websites appear;

partyworldbrainderd.com and partyworldbaxter.com. Party World would want just to focus on

one website due to confusion to the consumer not knowing which website to go on. By looking

at the two websites, the consulting team’s recommendation would be to delete the

partyworldbaxter.com website knowing that there isn’t as much effort in that website

compared to partyworldbrainderd.com.

By looking at the home page of the website, there are about five different types of

font/typefaces. This is something that sounds like a little problem but could make a huge

difference in the consumers’ eyes. When looking at a website it is important to control where

the onlooker is navigating with their eyes. With multiple different typefaces, the onlooker will

not be able to know where to concentrate on the website, will get distracted, and most likely

not even bother with the rest of the website. Most major websites have a maximum of two to

three typefaces, if not,

just one typeface. Most of

them go with a basic

typeface such as Helvetia,

Arial, Times New Roman,

or even their own unique

type.

Page 33: Party World Consulting Report

32 Consulting Report | Party World

On Party World’s website, there is a lot of space at the top still open that should be utilized. Try

to make the logo bigger to stand out and have Party World’s tag line “we rent celebrations of a

lifetime” bigger. That tag line is great for the business, so make it stand out by making it bold,

big and maybe even a different color (purple). Also, the statement that starts off the page, “We,

at Party World, are in the business of celebrations - all celebrations. And, whether rented or

bought,our goal is for you to have the time of your life..,” could be summed up more into

something such as, “Party World is the one place to go for ALL of your festivities. Whether

rented or bought, we are here to create a celebration of a lifetime!” That way the tag line is

brought into the statement and it gets right to the point because people get distracted easily

and don’t want to read for a long time. When editing the statements, read through it and think,

if I were the customer - was the point of the statement made in the shortest, yet descriptive

way in the strongest words.

To make a bigger presence in the social media world, Party World will have to make sure that it

is clearly presented on the website. Currently, Party World just has a small Facebook icon on

the way bottom of the website which doesn’t even direct the customer to Party World’s

Facebook page. Most major websites have all of their social media icons bigger and bolder on

the top of their website which brings the customer right to their page after it is selected. Once

Party World becomes more familiar with other social media programs other than Facebook,

make sure that is perceptible on the website.

Page 34: Party World Consulting Report

33 Consulting Report | Party World

On the main page of the website, the picture of Kelli is fuzzy and should be updated and clear

with better resolution. Same as the statements, make sure the pictures that are being used on

the website are to the point and specific. If Party World offers all of these types of celebrations,

which is an advantage compared to its competitors, then make that apparent on the home

page. Suggest the different types of festivities the customer can have that they never even

thought of but would try from that suggestion from pictures to statements. Party World has

different sections in the store; make those sections on the website so the customers know all of

their options. Party World could try to replace the picture of the people dancing with the disco

ball, with a picture of what makes the business special; an example would be an extravagant

picture of a balloon setup or a unique celebration setup.

When browsing through the website, there is so much information in just one category, for

example Canopies. From looking at it through a consumer’s eye, it would be confusing and

overwhelming. With the tabs on the left side of the website, the consulting team would

recommend that sub-categories are also created so when a consumer puts their mouse over

the name canopies for example; white, striped, canopy lights, fans, heaters, hints for canopy

size will pop up. With selecting on canopies white sub-category, then the sizes and a picture of

what an average one looks like appears. Hints on each page could also be added so the

consumers know right away or when looking at a certain section, create a link so they don’t

have to find it but instead all they do is click on, “see canopy page” and it brings them there for

example. The consulting team would extremely recommended this because it shows the

potential customer their opinions and is clear and concise with a picture, direct sizes and prices,

Page 35: Party World Consulting Report

34 Consulting Report | Party World

and recommendations of what they can include with it also. This would be very time consuming

to take pictures and create a page for each category, but it would make the website much

easier to navigate through and would create more traffic, which would be worth the time.

When people think of celebrations they think bright and colorful thoughts. The website should

reflect that image. The current color scheme is green, purple and white on Party World’s

website. Green and purple stand out but white can get dull and dreary after a few pages. Even

just changing the white to a cream/tan color could really make the website pop more. By going

to the bright idea, try using Party World’s green color for the main background to brighten the

website all together instead of the darker purple and see what it looks like.

In the future, try to create Party World’s website to be the one stop shop for everyone’s

celebrations. The website could have customers create a wish list, basket, etc. They can then go

back and add to their list and purchase the items right over the website and pick a time to have

it either dropped off or ready at the store. This would create great convenience for Party

World’s customers, since the store is farther from the more populated cities, plus it is a

guaranteed sale for the business.

When people are browsing websites for ideas of what to have at a celebration, they are excited

and want to see their options. That is why the consulting team’s top recommendations for

Party World’s website is to have more specific photos for each product, easy navigation,

additional fun colors, and examples/reviews from Party World’s social media sites linked to the

Page 36: Party World Consulting Report

35 Consulting Report | Party World

main website noticeable. The consulting team thinks that having the different celebration

examples on the main page will bring in more than just the average customer. People will get

enthusiastic by those ideas and go through Party World. The consulting team understands that

the need for the webpage to be fast and not have as many photos but by formatting the photos

in the correct way, there wouldn’t be that problem and Party World’s customers will love it

because they can start to picture in their head what their celebration will look like.

Summary of Web Recommendations

Delete one of the websites

Change font to just one or two main typefaces

Reword statements and make theme bigger

Enhance social media presence

Update pictures; make sure they’re of good resolution

Arrange products into sub-categories along with photos

Add more colors

Have the website be a ‘One-stop shop’

Page 37: Party World Consulting Report

36 Consulting Report | Party World

Social Media

Party World currently has a small social media presence but can be improved further by using

the social media marketing and advertising techniques. Social media is a platform that is easily

available to anyone who has internet access and is one of the most common marketing tools

businesses use for cheap and convenient advertising to help reach their target market. When

using social networking sites, businesses are allowed to communicate in an easy way to a much

bigger market. Internet usage increases dramatically each year and what is better than reaching

people through the Internet. Consumers could be in their pajamas at home surfing the web and

see business websites all over the country. This proves to reach a different customer base and a

much larger customer base than ever before. Party World can benefit by implementing

strategies and tips by looking into new routes of social media provided below.

Facebook

Party World currently operates a Facebook

page which needs to be incorporated into

their website a little better after the above updates have been

implemented. It does require some time throughout the week to keep up with Facebook and

requesting input from close friends and family for creative posts can prove to be a great

marketing tool. Hosting more parties and making events on Facebook that people may attend

will also increase awareness of Party World as a store and as a presence on the social media

stratosphere. The Pink Mustache party was a great idea; just keep those ideas coming every

month or every other month to keep people involved with the business even during the slower

Page 38: Party World Consulting Report

37 Consulting Report | Party World

months. Keep up the good work with posting the different balloon creations on Facebook and

start showing those on Party World’s website as well.

Twitter

Twitter is a great tool for businesses when they want to

post updates about upcoming sales, coupons and

products that customer may want. Party World would

benefit greatly by setting up a Twitter account and learn

how to keep it updated. Twitter will help spread awareness of Party World and customers will

be better informed of great deals they can receive. At the bottom of the page, on Twitter’s

webpage, is a tab for businesses. Select the tab provides examples of best practices, videos,

and success stories to other small businesses, and how to get started. A recommendation

would be to take the time out before the upcoming busy season and create a profile for the

business and master the use through the tutorials that have been provided.

Instagram

Instagram is a picture application that can be accessed through

an application on any smart phone. This would be a great

social media tool for Party World because the business

owner (Kelli) is a Certified Balloon Artist. Posting pictures on

Page 39: Party World Consulting Report

38 Consulting Report | Party World

Instagram of the balloon designs/creations and the setups of the rental service could increase

customer awareness of some of the unique talents that other party stores do not offer. This will

help create a great competitive advantage and increase social media awareness.

Pinterest

Pinterest can be one of the greatest tools for Party World’s

business. Pinterest is a website that is devoted to pinning,

which is adding a picture of a product or idea, where

businesses can post different pictures of their highly

diversified products that they offer compared to competitors. Many people love pinning and

looking through pictures of items they think are stylish. Party World could take advantage of by

marketing many of the products through this service. To start an account through Pinterest,

visit business.pinterest.com and create a profile by following the steps under, New to Pinterest?

Join as a business. Steps that can be taken to help market through Pinterest include:

1. Making the company known – Telling people about the business and its offerings.

2. Craft a presence – Show people what makes the product unique.

3. Add a Pinterest icon to the website – This will ensure people know about the Pinterest

presence and make them aware of the items offered and what they look like.

4. Give Back – Offer promotions to customers who frequent the Pinterest account and reward

people who have been loyal and really like the brand and company.

Page 40: Party World Consulting Report

39 Consulting Report | Party World

5. Update the content! – With all social media websites, users like when content remains up to

date and they aren’t left wondering if the website was abandoned.

6. Re-Pin. Repeat. – Making sure to constantly be on Pinterest on a daily to weekly basis shows

customers are cared for and re-pinning will help get to more customers at a faster rate.

Make sure to keep sharing everything and never slow down.

7. Celebrate the fans – Offering fans an opportunity to post their own sections on the

Pinterest board shows care for them and allows them to stay updated with the business.

Google+ and YouTube

Google+ and YouTube are

created underneath the

same ‘Google username.’

Google+ is similar to Facebook but has different ways they organize friends through circles.

‘Circles’ is a way to group people, for example a business may have circles that represent loyal

customers, friends, fans, etc. It is a great option to create an account to be open to all

customers, no matter what network they are going through. YouTube is a website that the

public can place their own videos, they created, online. Since this is open to the public, a

business really does not know what it will see. It would be a good option for Party World

because the business could post videos of its choice. A good example would be posting ‘how to

videos.’ By searching through some of the videos related to the party industry, the consulting

team discovered informative videos such as, how to start a grill, which linked up with that

industry’s website, which could be a great idea for Party World.

Page 41: Party World Consulting Report

40 Consulting Report | Party World

Linkedin

Linkedin is a social media site for business and

professional connections. It is used to display company information and

connect with various organizations and job candidates. For Party World’s business, it would be

recommended to get the businesses information on the site and start networking with other

organizations that it does business with in order to stay updated on what they are doing also.

Foursquare

Foursquare is an application for smartphones

that allows people to “check in.” When people

“check in” it pops up on their other social networks to let their friends know

where they are. It is great for a business to have because it gets that business name on their

webpage of the social network the consumer is using. Some businesses give deals to the people

that “check in” a certain amount of time. This could be a great way for people to say where

they get their party supplies. So when their friends need to get supplies too, they know where

to go. Party World can get started by going to foursquare.com/business and start creating the

account.

Google Places

Google Places is a great marketing tool to show what Party World’s

business is all about if people Google the business or keywords about

the business. It shows people that Party World is in the area they

Page 42: Party World Consulting Report

41 Consulting Report | Party World

searched and people can also write reviews about the business when they stop by. When

searching for Party World on Google, a ‘Google Place’ mark comes up, with the correct

information on the business plus there is already a review for Party World. The consulting

team’s recommendations for this marketing tool would be to manage Google Places, if Party

World doesn’t already have access to it. To be able to manage it, simply ‘Google’ Party World

and click on the map where it says Party World is located. When Party Worlds’ information

under the red pin shows up, click on more info. Then toward the bottom right corner under, “Is

this your business?” there will be an option to ‘manage this page.’ Create that Google account

and make sure that Party World’s brand name looks strong because people might only give it a

few seconds.

Yelp

Yelp is a search engine for local business that people can write

reviews and rate a business they go too. It is designed to help

consumers find new businesses. This is a great way to get a

business name out to a consumer because if they search for party supplies, whatever business

has their information on file it will pull it up and suggest going to that location. To create an

account and learn more about it, just go to biz.yelp.com.

Groupon

Groupon is a marketing tool through coupons/deals.

Business can create offers and upload detailed business

Page 43: Party World Consulting Report

42 Consulting Report | Party World

information which creates higher traffic flow once they put a special deal on the website.

Consumers can then rate the deal and give feedback. Groupon is being used more and more

every day and would be a great way to get people through the door during the slow months.

They offer daily deals for major US markets for a fee (% of sales). In order to feature a certain

product or just browse the site to see more information, just go to grouponworks.com/get-

featured.

Deal Chicken

Deal Chicken is a marketing tool through coupons/deals just like

Groupon but offers more specific locations. Deals are run for a

specific time and for a fee (% of sales). Focus on trying out one

network first and then try another to see which one works best for the business. For more

information on Deal Chicken just go to dealchicken.com/merchant/aboutus.

Living Social

Living Social is a marketing tool through coupons/deals

just like Groupon and Deal Chicken. Living Social also

features activities people can get involved in locally. Living Social has been proven to help out a

lot of small businesses. To start an account and see reviews from other businesses just go to

getfeatured.livingsocial.com/getfeatured/us.

Page 44: Party World Consulting Report

43 Consulting Report | Party World

Tumblr

Tumblr is a very simple micro-blogging platform

where photos, videos, audio and blog content can be uploaded. Users can

share and follow other blogs. It is good for businesses to get into blogs for a fast way to get

their name out in the market and get people informed about the business. For more

information, just go to tumblr.com.

Word Press

Word Press is a place where users create a simple to

use blog based website. It offers a specific blog homepage, compared to

Tumblr. It is easy to maintain, change, and update information about the business. For more

information, just go to wordpress.org.

The consulting team would recommend not getting into multiple social media networks all at

once but instead learn and build one at a time. First focus mainly on creating a Twitter,

Pinterest, Yelp, and Groupon. Keep updating Facebook weekly and look further into Google

Places because information is already set up for Party World. If Party World elects to

experiment with in other social media networks as discussed, the consulting team recommends

that the business defiantly attempt this as it could benefit the business immensely.

Page 45: Party World Consulting Report

44 Consulting Report | Party World

SUCCESSION PLAN

Foreword

Effective estate succession planning is of vital significance for any business. The importance of

this planning is magnified for family-run businesses since often times family members may be

directly or indirectly tied to the well-being of the business. Statistically, the failure rate of

family-business is around, an alarming, 80 percent mark. Of these, less than eight percent

manage to successfully transition over to the next generation. The factors that dictate these

failures are pool planning and lack of clear communication between family members.

This is a dynamic planning process and needs to be revisited on a regular basis in order to

assess and gauge the objectives and involvement of all parties. Importantly, an efficient and

well informed succession planning process means that business owners are able to proactively

prepare for scenarios that may face the business in the future.

At any given junction, when wanting to plan the future of the business and the members

involved, the decision faced is to either,

1) Keeping the Business in the family, or

2) Selling the Business

Page 46: Party World Consulting Report

45 Consulting Report | Party World

Keeping the Business in the Family

Businesses that have been built from the ground up will hold great emotional value for the

founders. Finding a successor is easy; identifying the right successor is the tough part. It is

important to understand the importance of successor management in order to mitigate any

issues that may emerge at the time of passing down the business to the chosen heir.

Initial steps include involving all stakeholders and encouraging them to work together on a

regular and ongoing basis. Regular family meetings will further help identify who may be well

deserved to take control of the business eventually. In order to plan the future ownership on

the business, family participation will play a key role. This will not only help build a stronger

family but also a stronger business. When faced with responsibilities, emergence of a leader

amongst the stakeholders is greatly catalyzed. Furthermore, involvement will help the business

owner to aid the next generation at managing any inherited wealth. Finally, the process will

enable the business to understand,

What are the family’s core values and business philosophy?

What is the family’s vision of their relationship to each other and the business?

Is the family willing to participate actively in supporting the business?

How will the family prepare family members for management and leadership roles?

Preserve it’s family values, traditions, and history

Manage relations between family, customers and suppliers

Recognize and resolve conflict before it becomes a crisis

Page 47: Party World Consulting Report

46 Consulting Report | Party World

The Five C’s of Planning

Control

Establishing, in a fair way, how the family

will address decision-making in the family, in

management and in ownership of the

business.

Career

Making it possible for various family members

to pursue rewarding careers or other roles in

the business with advancement and rewards based on

performance.

Capital

Creating systems and agreements so that family members can

reinvest and, if necessary, harvest or sell their investment without damage to

other family members’ interest.

Conflict

Addressing the conflicts that business families

face because their work and personal lives

intersect so closely.

Culture

Using family values in developing plans and

actions. Family business culture

represents enacted family values.

Page 48: Party World Consulting Report

47 Consulting Report | Party World

Selling the Business

Understanding what the business is worth is of significant value to matter what a business

owner may be planning for its future. Even if selling it is not on a consideration, it is

recommended practice that the value be assessed through a banker or a third party that may

have no vested interest in the business at any given period. Business valuations are undertaken

for a number of significant reasons. These may include but are not limited to,

Clarifying the difference between Perceived versus Market-value of the business

Raising growth capital

Estate and Inheritance planning

Valuation Techniques

Valuation techniques are processes that help determine the economic value of an asset, in this

case a business. The procedure is rigorous and involves an in-depth analysis of the financials of

the business. Before any valuation is undertaken, it is important to understand the purpose and

value of the valuation itself. The ‘premise of value’ assesses whether the business being valued

will continue to be operational or will be liquidated. Since the intent is to provide maximum

value to stakeholders (both buyers and sellers), identification of the intent becomes

significantly important before examining its financial details.

Industry norms see valuations undertaken, either from an Asset, Income or Market approach

for any given business. Picking the right technique is reliant upon the nature of the economy,

the history and nature of the business, the industry and its evolvement and market value of

Page 49: Party World Consulting Report

48 Consulting Report | Party World

similar sized businesses. However, for this study, the consulting team recommends assessing

the value through the Asset-based approach and explores its methods in the following section.

Alternatively, the Income-based approach focusses greatly on a business’ ability to generate fair

returns on investment on an ongoing basis. The approach focusses on the Income statement

and managing the top-line and bottom-line are the focus here. In either case, management of

financial statements plays an important role. The Market-based approach is rooted in concept

of competition. Valuation through this method looks at comparable businesses and analyzes

recent transactions (if any) to assess probable value of the subject business.

The Asset Approach

Businesses that hold high levels of seasonal inventory may often find themselves focusing

efforts on valuing themselves through the Asset-based approach. This means that

understanding and managing the balance sheet is of fundamental importance.

The fundamental premise of this approach is that any business, when being valued, is the sum

of its parts, in this case – its assets. Under this approach, a buyer will only be willing to pay for a

business what it can pay while attempting to procure similar assets. The process entails

objectivity, however, with US accounting standards, it fails to assess assets at fair market value,

since under US accounting rules assets are reported at cost.

Page 50: Party World Consulting Report

49 Consulting Report | Party World

Methods used to value business under this technique involve calculating,

1. Book Value – i.e. Total Assets – Total Liabilities. This is also known as Owner’s Equity. This

technique applies to assets that are highly liquid and easily convertible to cash. Since,

inventory available for sale is not considered highly liquid, a more relevant measure is

utilized to calculate the fair book value of the business.

2. Adjusted Net Book Value – Under this technique, the value of assets is closely reflected by

their fair current market value rather that their value at cost. The method factors in the

appraised value of the inventory and writes up or down the value of assets accordingly.

3. Liquidation Value – Unlike the above two techniques that assume the business will continue

to be run by its existing owners, this method operates on the premise that the business will

cease to operate after the sale of its asset and payment of its liabilities. Since, liquidations

are often done under pressure, a relevant assumption is that fair value will be hard to

achieve and discounts will come into play when calculating final worth.

4. Replacement Value – A process that is similar to an undertaking by an insurance company to

assess the value of assets of a business, if it were to replace them at any given period. The

method is extremely objective and takes into account the replacement cost of the actual

asset, rather than substitutes. The process does not take into account intangibles, such as

goodwill, and hence is considered a more conservative and discount-driven methodology of

valuation under the asset-based approach.

Page 51: Party World Consulting Report

50 Consulting Report | Party World

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. National Retail Federation:

http://www.nrf.com/modules.php?name=News&op=viewlive&sp_id=1430

http://www.nrf.com/modules.php?name=Pages&sp_id=449

2. CBS Money Watch: http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-505123_162-57534431/how-are-consumers-

paying-for-more-spending/?tag=categoryDoorLead;catDoorHero

3. Yahoo Voices: http://voices.yahoo.com/a-look-economic-factors-affect-retail-sales-

4712978.html?cat=3

4. Quick MBA: http://www.quickmba.com/

5. The Next Web: http://thenextweb.com/

6. Special Events: http://specialevents.com/

7. Biznik: http://biznik.com/articles/how-to-write-a-marketing-plan-the-five-things-you-should-include

8. Tutor2u: http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/business-studies/comments/porters-five-forces-

explained-by-the-man-himself

9. Party World: http://www.partyworldbrainerd.com

10. Wordpress: http://www.wordpress.org

11. Tumblr: http://www.tumblr.com

12. Living Social: http://www.livingsocial.com

13. Deal Chicken: http://www.dealchicken.com

14. Groupon: http://www.groupon.com

15. Facebook: http://www.facebook.com

16. Twitter: http://www.twitter.com

17. Pinterest: http://www.pinterest.com

18. Linkedin: http://www.Linkedin.com

19. Instagram: http://www.instagram.com

20. Four Square: http://www.foursquare.com/business

21. Yelp: http://www.yelp.com

22. Google: http://www.google.com

23. YouTube: http://www.youtube.com

24. Carlock, Randel, and John Ward. Strategic Planning for the Family Business. Houndmills,Basingstoke:

PALGRAVE, 2001. Print.

25. Hoskisson, Robert, R. Duane Ireland, and Michael Hitt. Strategic Management. 9. Mason, Ohio:

Thomson Learning, 2010. Print.

26. Social Media: An Introductory Guide to Social Media and Your Small Business. St. Cloud: Minnesota

Small Business Development Centers Print.