Palestinian children in armed Palestinian children in armed conflictconflict

ReportReport Sumaya Y. Sayej RN MSN Ph DSumaya Y. Sayej RN MSN Ph D

AL-Quds UniversityAL-Quds University

Submitted to UNFPASubmitted to UNFPAJune 10/2007June 10/2007

Presented as part of the Garca Machel report Presented as part of the Garca Machel report The Under-Secretary -General Special representative to the The Under-Secretary -General Special representative to the

Children and Armed conflict / UN /USA Children and Armed conflict / UN /USA ONON

October 17/2007October 17/2007

IntroductionIntroduction

The study design was based on Graca Machel The study design was based on Graca Machel Study questions and has followed the attached Study questions and has followed the attached facilitator’s guide to conduct focus groups with facilitator’s guide to conduct focus groups with children on “working together to protect children children on “working together to protect children in armed conflict”. in armed conflict”.

The study aimed to gain insight into how the The study aimed to gain insight into how the children themselves are affected by the armed children themselves are affected by the armed conflict, the way they view their situation, conflict, the way they view their situation, challenges, and coping mechanisms they or challenges, and coping mechanisms they or someone in their communities has taken to help someone in their communities has taken to help them, and efforts made to protect them and grant them, and efforts made to protect them and grant them their rightsthem their rights

Sample selection and sizeSample selection and size The sample selection took into account; age group (10-13 years The sample selection took into account; age group (10-13 years

and 14-18 years), gender (where girls and boys were and 14-18 years), gender (where girls and boys were represented in equal proportion) and place of residence (West represented in equal proportion) and place of residence (West Bank and Gaza).Bank and Gaza).

Permission to conduct the focus group discussion was granted Permission to conduct the focus group discussion was granted from school directors from school directors

93 children in 9 focus groups with an average of (8-14) children 93 children in 9 focus groups with an average of (8-14) children in each group participated in the discussion from both sides of in each group participated in the discussion from both sides of the Palestinian Occupied territories; 5 focus groups from the Palestinian Occupied territories; 5 focus groups from Ramallah region in the middle of the West Bank and 4 focus Ramallah region in the middle of the West Bank and 4 focus groups from Biet Hanoun region in the north of Gaza Strip.groups from Biet Hanoun region in the north of Gaza Strip.

The participants were vocal and got the confidence to express The participants were vocal and got the confidence to express their views, the discussion was lively, and sense of respect their views, the discussion was lively, and sense of respect toward each other was noted, also appreciated being asked toward each other was noted, also appreciated being asked about their about their

QUESTIONS FOR FOCUS GROUPSQUESTIONS FOR FOCUS GROUPS

Consequences of warConsequences of war What are the greatest challenges you have faced as a result of What are the greatest challenges you have faced as a result of

conflict?conflict? Are these challenges different for boys and girls, and do they Are these challenges different for boys and girls, and do they

differ according to the ages of the children and youth?differ according to the ages of the children and youth?

Coping with warCoping with war What is the best action you or someone in your community has What is the best action you or someone in your community has

taken to help with the problems children face because of taken to help with the problems children face because of conflict?conflict?

What has your government done to respect, protect and fulfill What has your government done to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of war-affected children?the rights of war-affected children?

What have about humanitarian agencies such as the UN and What have about humanitarian agencies such as the UN and NGOs done to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of war-NGOs done to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of war-affected children?affected children?

How have diplomatic efforts, such as resolutions and treaties How have diplomatic efforts, such as resolutions and treaties prepared by the UN and its member states, have helped children prepared by the UN and its member states, have helped children affected by armed conflict?affected by armed conflict?

Peace and reconciliationPeace and reconciliation What do you think has been the most important factor What do you think has been the most important factor

towards advancing a peace process and building towards advancing a peace process and building reconciliation in your community and/or country? reconciliation in your community and/or country? 

What opportunities are there for young people to What opportunities are there for young people to participate and express their concerns?participate and express their concerns?

RecommendationsRecommendations Are there any issues and/or groups of young people who Are there any issues and/or groups of young people who

are affected by conflict that have not been mentioned and are affected by conflict that have not been mentioned and should be addressed?should be addressed?

What would you recommend to be done – and by who – so What would you recommend to be done – and by who – so that all children affected by conflict have their rights that all children affected by conflict have their rights respected, protected and fulfilled?respected, protected and fulfilled?

FindingsFindings

A number of issues were identified by the A number of issues were identified by the children which constitute risk factors that children which constitute risk factors that they need to challenge: they need to challenge:

Broadly, the children responses can be grouped Broadly, the children responses can be grouped as describing problems derived from their:as describing problems derived from their:

Sense of security Sense of security Socio-economic and educational difficulties,Socio-economic and educational difficulties, Issues associated with conflict - related Issues associated with conflict - related

violence. violence.

What are the greatest challenges you have faced as What are the greatest challenges you have faced as a result of conflict?a result of conflict?

There was a relative difference in the responses of children There was a relative difference in the responses of children between both regions; this difference is assumed to depend between both regions; this difference is assumed to depend on the type of exposure to violence, the source of threat, on the type of exposure to violence, the source of threat, and the extent of this threat to jeopardize their lives. and the extent of this threat to jeopardize their lives.

The exposure of Gaza children The exposure of Gaza children to extreme armed conflict to extreme armed conflict inflicted by the continuous and unpredictable brutal attacksinflicted by the continuous and unpredictable brutal attacks by the Israeli army and jet strike made them feel that their by the Israeli army and jet strike made them feel that their life is threatened, and consequently increased their worries, life is threatened, and consequently increased their worries, felt unsafe and frustrated as for example; Yassar 12 years felt unsafe and frustrated as for example; Yassar 12 years old added, “I’m afraid that the Israelis will shoot me and old added, “I’m afraid that the Israelis will shoot me and demolish our house over our heads”.demolish our house over our heads”.

Mahmoud 10 from Gaza said “I ask my mother to let me Mahmoud 10 from Gaza said “I ask my mother to let me

sleep in her room during the Israeli attacks”, Hassan 11 sleep in her room during the Israeli attacks”, Hassan 11 added “I hate nights because it scares me”, added “I hate nights because it scares me”,

On the other side; the majority of West Bank children On the other side; the majority of West Bank children concerns were related to the concerns were related to the discriminating wall;discriminating wall; they they expressed sense of insecurity, loss of freedom and the expressed sense of insecurity, loss of freedom and the feeling of being under surveillance have increased their feeling of being under surveillance have increased their sense of rage, humiliation and disrespect. sense of rage, humiliation and disrespect.

Coupled with the Coupled with the enormous check pointsenormous check points and personal and personal search for every Palestinian going through these points; the search for every Palestinian going through these points; the children considered it as another demeaning factor that children considered it as another demeaning factor that makes them feel oppressed and frustrated and most of the makes them feel oppressed and frustrated and most of the girls and boys expressed the feeling anxiety and worried to girls and boys expressed the feeling anxiety and worried to go through these check points as Fadel 17 from Ramallah go through these check points as Fadel 17 from Ramallah said “we are always under pressure and really this is not a said “we are always under pressure and really this is not a kind of life that any human being should live”. kind of life that any human being should live”.

Formal and informal sources agree that Formal and informal sources agree that domestic violencedomestic violence has been on a steady rise since the outset of the second has been on a steady rise since the outset of the second Intifada. Violence creates violence an expression made by Intifada. Violence creates violence an expression made by Itidal 16 years girl from Ramallah Itidal 16 years girl from Ramallah

The majority of the children expressed concerns regarding The majority of the children expressed concerns regarding the growing violence in their localities at different levels the growing violence in their localities at different levels including the family, school and street. including the family, school and street.

With emphasis on domestic violence, the children from all With emphasis on domestic violence, the children from all regions have discussed the issue, and some of them have regions have discussed the issue, and some of them have had the experience as Yara 14 from Ramallah area said had the experience as Yara 14 from Ramallah area said “my father is used to hit my mother and all of us, he has no “my father is used to hit my mother and all of us, he has no job and the family needs are enormous, the only way for job and the family needs are enormous, the only way for him to express his frustration is by shouting and hitting him to express his frustration is by shouting and hitting

The issue of The issue of economy and financial statuseconomy and financial status was of major was of major concern expressed by the interviewed children 14-18 years in concern expressed by the interviewed children 14-18 years in both regions. The children reported that they themselves had both regions. The children reported that they themselves had less pocket money, their parents have limited resources, and less pocket money, their parents have limited resources, and that they have observed changes in how family members that they have observed changes in how family members interacted with each other regarding these matters interacted with each other regarding these matters

Economic decline and lack of financial and/or physical access Economic decline and lack of financial and/or physical access to schools has resulted into thousands of children have not to schools has resulted into thousands of children have not had regular classes in their schools had regular classes in their schools

The major concerns expressed by the children interviewed The major concerns expressed by the children interviewed were about the were about the quality and effectiveness of the educationquality and effectiveness of the education they received through the last academic year, as Dana 16 they received through the last academic year, as Dana 16 years said “this is a year of ignorance”years said “this is a year of ignorance”

The girls explicitly were more of concern than boys regarding The girls explicitly were more of concern than boys regarding the frequent school closures as they the frequent school closures as they consider school a place consider school a place for socializationfor socialization as stated by some "school is a place that we as stated by some "school is a place that we can go and socialize", other girls said "school gives us a can go and socialize", other girls said "school gives us a chance to exchange stories and ideas". chance to exchange stories and ideas".

What is the best action you or someone in your community What is the best action you or someone in your community has taken to help with the problems children face because of has taken to help with the problems children face because of

conflict?conflict?

Most children expressed their coping mechanisms and Most children expressed their coping mechanisms and means of help to face the challenges of conflict and to means of help to face the challenges of conflict and to improve their lives is primarily by developing academically improve their lives is primarily by developing academically and socially as Salah , Issa, Maram and others said “the and socially as Salah , Issa, Maram and others said “the best way to cope and to develop is to finish our education best way to cope and to develop is to finish our education

Others reflected their coping mechanisms by engaging Others reflected their coping mechanisms by engaging themselves in extra curricular and social activities that themselves in extra curricular and social activities that seems to be constructive and positive in nature as said by seems to be constructive and positive in nature as said by Ibrahim, Suzan and others from Ramallah "we enjoy Ibrahim, Suzan and others from Ramallah "we enjoy volunteering in any social and national events in our area of volunteering in any social and national events in our area of residence or the school". residence or the school".

Gaza children coping mechanisms and social involvement Gaza children coping mechanisms and social involvement have reflected their tragic situation as Mohammad 18 and have reflected their tragic situation as Mohammad 18 and others said “we participate in demonstrations, and many others said “we participate in demonstrations, and many times we were exposed to violence” while Majed and Munir times we were exposed to violence” while Majed and Munir said “many times we helped other families in evacuating said “many times we helped other families in evacuating their houses before it was bombarded”. their houses before it was bombarded”.

Generally, the children were influenced by the events and Generally, the children were influenced by the events and circumstances and were enthusiastic to cope with this given circumstances and were enthusiastic to cope with this given situation and to be active participants in their surroundings situation and to be active participants in their surroundings

While most of the children appraised the role of their families While most of the children appraised the role of their families in supporting and protecting them, as Asheera, Itidal and in supporting and protecting them, as Asheera, Itidal and many others said “our families are our hope and the only many others said “our families are our hope and the only source of help”. source of help”.

Others raised concerns regarding Others raised concerns regarding the helplessness of their the helplessness of their families to secure and protect their childrenfamilies to secure and protect their children as said by some as said by some Nidal, Issa, Haneen and many others “our families need Nidal, Issa, Haneen and many others “our families need help”. help”.

Generally, the children were influenced by the events and Generally, the children were influenced by the events and circumstances and circumstances and were enthusiastic to copewere enthusiastic to cope with this given with this given situation and to be active participants in their surroundings situation and to be active participants in their surroundings

What has your government done to respect, protect What has your government done to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of war-affected children?and fulfill the rights of war-affected children?

Some children described the Some children described the government as helpless and government as helpless and cannot protect any one,cannot protect any one, and do not expect any thing from and do not expect any thing from this government as many said “the government in siege, this government as many said “the government in siege, how can it be of help”. Tareq, and others found an excuse how can it be of help”. Tareq, and others found an excuse to the government performance as said “to the government performance as said “the government is the government is loaded with the political issuesloaded with the political issues”. Mohammad 18 appraised ”. Mohammad 18 appraised the role of government in offering free health and the role of government in offering free health and education services for children. education services for children.

On the contrary, the majority On the contrary, the majority were criticalwere critical to the Palestinian to the Palestinian Government role in providing the minimum requirement to Government role in providing the minimum requirement to protect the Palestinian children’s rights to survival as protect the Palestinian children’s rights to survival as Abdulla 16 from Gaza said “Abdulla 16 from Gaza said “the government personnel are the government personnel are busy to keep themselves on their seats”.busy to keep themselves on their seats”.

What have about humanitarian agencies such as the UN and What have about humanitarian agencies such as the UN and NGOs done to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of war-NGOs done to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of war-

affected children?affected children?

Iyad from Gaza said hesitantly Iyad from Gaza said hesitantly “safety, protection, respect, “safety, protection, respect, these are terms that we hear about but do not have it”these are terms that we hear about but do not have it” while while Munir 17 from Gaza commented “no one is safe, at any time, Munir 17 from Gaza commented “no one is safe, at any time, the Israelis can invade the land, kill the people and kidnap the Israelis can invade the land, kill the people and kidnap the young men and no one can stop them”. the young men and no one can stop them”.

Many children especially those who live in camps are aware Many children especially those who live in camps are aware of UNRWA as a major UN humanitarian agency that provides of UNRWA as a major UN humanitarian agency that provides them with assistance and appreciate its role in offering free them with assistance and appreciate its role in offering free education and health services. Some children in Gaza education and health services. Some children in Gaza appreciated the role of UNRWA in renting apartments for appreciated the role of UNRWA in renting apartments for whose their houses have been demolished until they can whose their houses have been demolished until they can rebuild them again rebuild them again

Some other children appreciated the help and support they Some other children appreciated the help and support they get from local NGOs supported and funded by UN particularly get from local NGOs supported and funded by UN particularly UNFPA through the many projects which is indirectly UNFPA through the many projects which is indirectly contributing to the development and empowerment of contributing to the development and empowerment of Palestinian children and adolescentsPalestinian children and adolescents

Some children were aware of UNICEF role in Some children were aware of UNICEF role in offering counseling and education about taking offering counseling and education about taking precautionary and safety measures regarding precautionary and safety measures regarding land mines and shelling in Gaza as Fidaa said “we land mines and shelling in Gaza as Fidaa said “we appreciate what UNICEF is offering us through appreciate what UNICEF is offering us through awareness program they offer” awareness program they offer”

Many children appreciated the role of the Red Many children appreciated the role of the Red Cross in helping their families and beloved Cross in helping their families and beloved prisoners by visiting them and helping in knowing prisoners by visiting them and helping in knowing about any detainee by the Israelis. about any detainee by the Israelis.

Other children particularly from villages were the Other children particularly from villages were the least to have any support even by the local NGOs least to have any support even by the local NGOs except for some activities provided by Sheikhs except for some activities provided by Sheikhs and religious leaders in their communitiesand religious leaders in their communities

How have diplomatic efforts, such as resolutions and treaties How have diplomatic efforts, such as resolutions and treaties prepared by the UN and its member states, have helped prepared by the UN and its member states, have helped

children affected by armed conflict?children affected by armed conflict?

The majority of the children 14-18 and agreed to The majority of the children 14-18 and agreed to the useless diplomatic efforts and Peace treaties the useless diplomatic efforts and Peace treaties proposed by UN and international communities. proposed by UN and international communities. Mohammad 18 and Fidaa 17 and many others Mohammad 18 and Fidaa 17 and many others commented “despite the continuous diplomatic commented “despite the continuous diplomatic efforts and resolution acts been made by UN for efforts and resolution acts been made by UN for the last 60 years, nothing was implemented on the last 60 years, nothing was implemented on the ground”.the ground”.

When referred to the UN declaration of children’s When referred to the UN declaration of children’s rights; no one agreed to that and believed all rights; no one agreed to that and believed all Palestinian citizens human rights including the Palestinian citizens human rights including the children have been violated. children have been violated.

Peace and reconciliationPeace and reconciliation

The majority agreed that peace process can be advanced if The majority agreed that peace process can be advanced if all UN resolution actsall UN resolution acts are implemented and Palestinians can are implemented and Palestinians can get their rights to return, end of occupation and Jerusalem get their rights to return, end of occupation and Jerusalem is the capital for the Palestinian stateis the capital for the Palestinian state

Many children Many children emphasized the importance of negotiationsemphasized the importance of negotiations that should be back on track as Bahjat and Issa from that should be back on track as Bahjat and Issa from Ramallah said. Some Ramallah said. Some children opposed these commentschildren opposed these comments and said “we hear about diplomatic efforts, but it is ink on and said “we hear about diplomatic efforts, but it is ink on papers”, “there is no peace” etc... papers”, “there is no peace” etc...

Many children Many children emphasized the importance of reconciliation emphasized the importance of reconciliation among Palestinian themselvesamong Palestinian themselves and the importance of unity and the importance of unity to make them stronger and live in peace together as to make them stronger and live in peace together as someone said “it is not enough to have the Israelis, we someone said “it is not enough to have the Israelis, we have ourselves to fight each other”. have ourselves to fight each other”.

Few particularly from Gaza and from the older age group Few particularly from Gaza and from the older age group believed in the return of all historic Palestine believed in the return of all historic Palestine

What opportunities are there for young people to What opportunities are there for young people to participate and express their concerns?participate and express their concerns?

The majority agreed to the limitation of opportunities for them The majority agreed to the limitation of opportunities for them to express their needs and concerns not because they are not to express their needs and concerns not because they are not allowed to speak out but because of the deteriorating and allowed to speak out but because of the deteriorating and constrictive environment and lack of opportunities to do so. for constrictive environment and lack of opportunities to do so. for example; Nidal and others said “we play sports in the example; Nidal and others said “we play sports in the neighborhood as alternative to playgrounds”. neighborhood as alternative to playgrounds”.

Few children have the opportunity to participate in some Few children have the opportunity to participate in some extracurricular activities through some local organizations as, extracurricular activities through some local organizations as, but many others were critical as said “how many children do but many others were critical as said “how many children do benefit or have an access to these NGOs”. Some girls and benefit or have an access to these NGOs”. Some girls and others emphasized the importance of the use of the computer others emphasized the importance of the use of the computer and net and net

Mohammad and Tareq from Gaza commented “the impact of Mohammad and Tareq from Gaza commented “the impact of socio-economic and political situation has contributed to socio-economic and political situation has contributed to increase the increase the children affiliation with either political or religious children affiliation with either political or religious groups as a mean to express their views and channel their groups as a mean to express their views and channel their energies”.energies”.

RecommendationsRecommendationsAre there any issues and/or groups of young people who are Are there any issues and/or groups of young people who are

affected by conflict that have not been mentioned and should affected by conflict that have not been mentioned and should be addressed?be addressed?

The older age group mentioned four important issues The older age group mentioned four important issues regarding child care and right to live in dignity that should be regarding child care and right to live in dignity that should be addressed by the Palestinian government, NGOs and UN addressed by the Palestinian government, NGOs and UN agencies:agencies:

disabled childrendisabled children who got injured by the Israeli army and the who got injured by the Israeli army and the

importance of their integration into the society, education importance of their integration into the society, education and in finding job opportunities for them. and in finding job opportunities for them.

Care for Care for orphanage childrenorphanage children who are numerous as a result of who are numerous as a result of their father deaths due to struggle or any other orphan and their father deaths due to struggle or any other orphan and lack institutional or any source of assistance. lack institutional or any source of assistance.

To work on releasing the To work on releasing the arrested childrenarrested children, those below the , those below the age of 18 and currently being held in Israeli detention age of 18 and currently being held in Israeli detention facilities. facilities.

And last to work And last to work on DEPORTIEESon DEPORTIEES whom were obliged to leave whom were obliged to leave their own homes into other places. their own homes into other places.

What would you recommend to be done – and by who – so What would you recommend to be done – and by who – so that all children affected by conflict have their rights that all children affected by conflict have their rights

respected, protected and fulfilled?respected, protected and fulfilled?

Promote the governmental institutions effectiveness in Promote the governmental institutions effectiveness in executing constructive programs related to children rights executing constructive programs related to children rights with monitoring and follow up for these programs; “many with monitoring and follow up for these programs; “many times we hear about a program, then it is not there”times we hear about a program, then it is not there”

Development of the media campaigns to raise awareness of Development of the media campaigns to raise awareness of the society regarding the children’s rights the society regarding the children’s rights

Demand from the international community to provide rights Demand from the international community to provide rights and safety for Palestinian children and to expose all and safety for Palestinian children and to expose all inhuman acts done by Israelis against children inhuman acts done by Israelis against children

Provision of rehabilitative services for all injured, disabled, Provision of rehabilitative services for all injured, disabled, detained and orphan Palestinian children detained and orphan Palestinian children

Launch awareness programs for the parents and teachers Launch awareness programs for the parents and teachers to be able to deal with children in such armed conflict to be able to deal with children in such armed conflict situatio situatio