42
Session 2: Overview of Accessions Overview of Accessions Dimitar Bratanov, Accessions Division, WTO

Overview of Accessions › english › thewto_e › acc_e › ... · Session 2: Overview of Accessions. Observer status • Requests to be made in accordance with the Guidelines for

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Overview of Accessions

    Dimitar Bratanov, Accessions Division, WTO

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    1. The basic procedures

    2. The track record to date

    3. The state of play in ongoing accessions

    4. What is expected of acceding governments?

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    1. The basic procedures

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    A closer relationship with the WTO?

    • Request for observer status in the General Council and its subsidiary bodies

    OR

    • Request for accession under Article XII of the Marrakesh Agreement

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Observer status

    • Requests to be made in accordance with the Guidelines for Observer Status forGovernments in the WTO (Annex 2 of the Rules of Procedure for Sessions of theMinisterial Conference and Meetings of the General Council, WT/L/161).

    • Governments have to:– express an intent to initiate negotiations for WTO accession within 5 years;– provide a description of economic and trade policies, including future reforms.

    • 10 governments have been granted observer status under these procedures.

    • Not to be confused with ad hoc observer status for WTO Ministerial Conferences.

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    WTO Accession: legal basis

    Article XII of the Agreement Establishing the WTO (the Marrakesh Agreement)

    1. Any State or separate customs territory possessing full autonomy in the conduct of its external commercial relations and the other matters provided for in this Agreement and the Multilateral Trade Agreements may accede to this Agreement, on terms to be agreed between it and the WTO. Such accession shall apply to this Agreement and the Multilateral Trade Agreements annexed thereto.

    2. Decisions on accession shall be taken by the Ministerial Conference. The Ministerial Conference shall approve the agreement on the terms of accession by a two-thirds majority of the Members of the WTO.

    3. Accession to a Plurilateral Trade Agreement shall be governed by the provisions of that Agreement.

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    WTO Accession: legal basis

    “…by a two-thirds majority…”

    • In practice, since 1995 decisions on accession have beentaken by consensus in accordance with WTO practice(Article IX:1 of the Marrakesh Agreement).

    • Paragraph 2 of Article XII refers to the final stage of theaccession process, when the accession documents areadopted by the Ministerial Conference (or by the GeneralCouncil as per Article IV:2 of the Marrakesh Agreement).

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    WTO Accession: legal basis“…on terms to be agreed…”

    The specific terms of accession are unique to each acceding government.

    WHY

    • Legal/institutional/economic frameworks of acceding governments are different.• Accession negotiations are WTO Member-driven and Members’ interests vary.• The WTO rulebook and “acquis” evolve over time.• …

    Note: while the specific terms agreed in each accession may vary, the accessionprocess per se has remained largely unchanged since 1995.

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    The WTO Accession ProcessStage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Stage 1: Working Party Establishment

    • The General Council considers accession requests andestablishes Working Parties to examine applicationsand elaborate terms of membership.

    • Working Party membership open to all WTO Members.

    • Consultations on the selection of a Working PartyChairperson begin after circulation of all documentsnecessary for holding the 1st Working Party meeting.

    • Observer status automatically granted to the AccedingGovernment upon Working Party establishment.

    • Annual financial contribution of approx. CHF 30’000. Establishment of the Working Party on the Accessions of Somalia and Timor-Leste

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Stage 2: Fact-finding & negotiationStage 2 – the substantive phase of the process – consists of 2 basic negotiating tracks:

    – Multilateral negotiations;

    – Bilateral negotiations;

    NOTE: plurilateral discussions are also afeature in many accessions

    These negotiating tracks proceed more or less in parallel.

    The accession procedures are outlined in WT/ACC/22/Rev.1, a document developedby the Secretariat in consultation with Members as a practical, non-binding guide.

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Stage 3: Final steps

    • Adoption of the Accession Package by Working Party

    • General Council/Ministerial Conference approval

    • Domestic ratification /acceptance

    • Membership

    THE ACCESSION PACKAGE

    • Decision• Protocol

    1

    • Report of the Working Party2

    • Schedule of Concessions & Commitments on Goods3

    • Schedule of Specific Commitments on Services

    4

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    2. The track record to date

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Map of WTO Members and Observers

    Most recent acceding government: Curaçao (March 2020)

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Completed (36) and ongoing (23) accessions (LDCs in red)

    Africa Europe/CIS Asia Pacific Middle East America

    3 (2) 16 11 (6) 4 (1) 2

    Cape Verde*, 2008Seychelles, 2015 Liberia*, 2016

    Bulgaria, 1996 Kyrgyz Rep., 1998 Latvia, 1999 Estonia, 1999 Georgia, 2000Albania, 2000Croatia, 2000Lithuania, 2001Moldova, 2001Armenia, 2003FYR of Macedonia, 2003 Ukraine, 2008Montenegro, 2012Russian Fed. 2012 Tajikistan, 2013Kazakhstan, 2015

    Mongolia, 1997 China, 2001Chinese Taipei, 2002Nepal*, 2004 Cambodia*, 2004 Tonga, 2007Viet Nam, 2007Samoa*, 2012 Vanuatu*, 2012Lao PDR*, 2013 Afghanistan*, 2016

    Jordan, 2000 Oman, 2000Saudi Arabia 2005Yemen*, 2014

    Ecuador, 1996Panama, 1997

    9 (6) 6 2 (2) 4 1

    Algeria, 1987Sudan*, 1994Ethiopia*, 2003Libya, 2004Sao Tomé & Principe*, 2005Comoros*, 2007Equatorial Guinea, 2008Somalia*, 2016South Sudan, 2017

    Belarus, 1993Uzbekistan, 1994Azerbaijan, 1997Andorra, 1997 Bosnia & Herzegovina, 1999Serbia, 2005

    Bhutan*, 1999Timor-Leste*, 2016

    Lebanese Rep. , 1999 Iraq, 2004 I.R. of Iran, 2005 Syrian Arab Rep., 2010

    Bahamas, 2001Curaçao, 2020

  • What has been done so far? 36 accessions completed to date(By accession date)

    19

    96

    19

    97

    19

    98

    19

    99

    -Ecuador-Bulgaria

    -Mongolia-Panama

    -Kyrgyz Republic

    -Latvia-Estonia

    20

    00

    -Jordan-Georgia-Albania-Oman-Croatia

    20

    01

    -Lithuania-Moldova -China

    20

    02

    -Chinese Taipei

    20

    03

    -Armenia-FYR Macedonia

    20

    04

    -Nepal-Cambodia

    -Saudi Arabia

    20

    05

    20

    07

    -Viet Nam-Tonga

    20

    08

    -Ukraine-CaboVerde

    -Montenegro-Samoa-Russian Federation-Vanuatu

    20

    12

    -Lao PDR-Tajikistan

    20

    13

    --Yemen

    20

    14

    20

    15

    -Seychelles-Kazakhstan

    -Liberia-Afghanist

    20

    16

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Shares of world trade

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    Article XII Members Rest of the World

    Growth rate of merchandise exports of Article XII Members

    Growth rate of merchandise imports of Article XII Members

    WTO accession results (1/3)

    0

    300

    600

    900

    -5 years WTO accession

    +5 years +10 years +15 years +20 years

    Article XII Members Rest of the World

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    -5 years WTO accession +5 years

    Article XII Members Rest of the World

    Growth rate of commercial services exports of Article XII Members

    (1996-2011)

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    -5 years WTO accession +5 years

    Article XII Members Rest of the World

    Growth rate of commercial services exports of Article XII Members

    (2012-2018)

    WTO accession results (2/3)

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Average DTF Changes for a Member

    0

    2000

    4000

    6000

    8000

    -5 years WTO accession

    +5 years +10 years +15 years +20 years

    Article XII Members Rest of the World

    Growth rate of FDI inward stocks of Article XII Members

    Improvements in Business Environment

    WTO accession results (3/3)

    Chart1

    During AcessionDuring AcessionDuring Acession

    After AccessionAfter AccessionAfter Accession

    2004-20142004-20142004-2014

    Improved

    Unchanged

    Declined

    Indicators

    5.33

    2.42

    1.33

    6.45

    2.27

    1.27

    7

    1.67

    1.33

    Sheet1

    ImprovedUnchangedDeclined

    During Acession5.332.421.33

    After Accession6.452.271.27

    2004-201471.671.33

    To resize chart data range, drag lower right corner of range.

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    3. The state of play

  • What remains to be done? 23 ongoing accessions, plus ….(By application date)

    19

    87

    19

    93

    19

    96

    19

    99

    19

    97

    20

    01

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    07

    21

    05

    -Sudan -Uzbekistan

    -Belarus

    -Iran

    -Azerbaijan-Andorra

    -Lebanese Republic-Bosnia & Herzegovina-Bhutan

    -Bahamas-Syrian Arab Rep. -Libya

    -Ethiopia

    -Iraq-Serbia

    -Sao Tomé & Principe

    -Comoros-Equatorial Guinea

    -Timor-Leste-Somalia

    20

    17

    -South Sudan

    -Algeria

    19

    94

    -Curaçao

    20

    20

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Multilateral negotiations (Rules)

    Bilateral negotiations (Market Access)

    • Curaçao• Equatorial

    Guinea• Libya• Sao Tomé and

    Principe*• Syrian Arab

    Rep.

    • Bahamas• Ethiopia*• Sudan*

    • Algeria • Azerbaijan • Belarus • Bhutan* • Bosnia &

    Herzegovina • Comoros* • Lebanese Rep. • Serbia

    Working Party

    Established

    Factual Summary of Points Raised

    Memorandum on Foreign Trade

    Regime

    Draft Working Party Report

    • Andorra • Iran• Iraq• Timor-Leste*• Somalia*• South Sudan*• Uzbekistan

    (No documents submitted)

    Initial Goods & Services Offer

    • Andorra • Ethiopia*

    (revised goods offer)

    Revised Goods & Services Offer

    • Algeria • Azerbaijan• Bahamas • Belarus • Bhutan* • Bosnia and Herzegovina• Comoros*• Lebanese Rep.• Serbia • Sudan*• Uzbekistan

    Draft Goods and Services

    Schedules

    Accession negotiations – state of play

    Application

    • Turkmenistan(application for observership)

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    General Status Accession WP (establishment) Last WP meeting Next WP meeting(based on Secretariat’s assessment)

    Strategic focus 1. Belarus (1993) 2. Bosnia & Herzegovina (1999)3. Comoros* (2007)4. Serbia (2005)

    12WPM, July 201913WPM, February 2018 4WPM, March 201813WPM, June 2013

    2nd half of 20202nd half of 2020Q3 2020TBD

    Work in progressOn-going efforts to move the WP process

    1. Azerbaijan (1997)2. Bahamas (2001)3. Ethiopia* (2003)4. South Sudan* (2017)5. Sudan* (1994)

    14WPM, July 20174WPM, April 20194WPM, January 2020 1WPM, March 20194WPM, July 2017

    2nd half of 2020 TBD2nd half of 2020 TBDTBD

    Reactivation Efforts to resume the WP process after at least 5 years

    1. Iraq (2004)2. Lebanese Republic (1999) 3. Uzbekistan (1994)

    2WPM, April 20087WPM, October 20093WPM, October 2005

    TBDTBD7 July 2020

    Activation 1st WP yet to be held

    1. Curaçao (2020)2. Equatorial Guinea (2008) 3. Somalia* (2016)4. Timor-Leste* (2016)

    No WP held to dateNo WP held to dateNo WP held to dateNo WP held to date

    TBDTBDTBD31 July 2020 (TBC)

    Inactive No WP held at least during last 5 years

    Algeria (1987), Andorra (1997), Bhutan* (1999), Iran (2005), Libya (2004), Sao Tomé and Principe* (2005), Syrian Arab Republic (2010)

    Notes: * LDCs

    Accessions by status

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    WTO accessions: new “themes”

    A larger number of active accessions• New applications – Somalia, Timor-Leste, South Sudan, Curaçao (+

    Turkmenistan)• Resumption of accession Working Parties after years of inactivity

    • Comoros (2016), Belarus (2017), Sudan (2017), Bosnia and Herzegovina (2018), Bahamas (2018), Ethiopia (2020), Uzbekistan (2020)

    Increased role for technical assistance?• Members’ broad support for WTO accessions, at WP level or through

    technical assistance• Strong interest & support from international partners, e.g. IMF, World

    Bank, ITC, African Union/UN Economic Commission for Africa (UNECA), Arab Monetary Fund

    Fragility and conflict (trade as an engine of peace?)

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    4. What is expected of acceding governments?

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    WTO Accessions – what are the yardsticks?

    Average length of accession: 10 years and 2 months (and 12 years and 2 months for LDCs)

    • Shortest: 2 years and 8 months (Kyrgyz Republic, 1998) • Longest: 19 years and 9 months (Kazakhstan and Seychelles, 2015)

    Accession commitments• Number of accession commitment paragraphs in Working Party Report: 17

    (Mongolia) – 163 (Russian Federation) • Tariff concessions: 5.1% (Montenegro) - 39.7% (Vanuatu) for all products;

    7.6% - 43.7% (AG), 4.3% - 39.1% (Non-AG)• AG Domestic Support & Export Subsidies: 5, 8.5, 10% de minimis levels;

    AMS (various); export subsidies bound at zero• Number of services sub-sectors with commitments: 37 (Mongolia) – 147

    (Moldova)

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Policy Framework for LDC Accessions

    2002 General Council Guidelines for LDCs’ Accessions (WT/L/508)– Market Access, WTO Rules, Process, technical assistance

    2012 General Council Decision to “strengthen, streamline and operationalize” the 2002 Guidelines” (WT/L/508/Add.1)– Benchmarks on market access on Goods and Services– Transparency in accession negotiations– “Facilitation” by Chairs of SCLDC & Accession Working Parties – Special and differential treatment & transition periods– Technical assistance and capacity building

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Length of WTO Accession Process: From 1st Working Party to Membership

    * Acceded as an LDC. On average, 9 LDC accessions took 5 years and 4 months

    Average: 6 years

    and 7 months

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Length of WTO accession process: From application to membership, in years

    * Acceded as an LDC. On average, 9 LDC accessions took 12 years and 6 months

    Average: 10y.04m

    Average: 10 years

    and 2 months

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    31Tariff commitments: agricultural products

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35

    40

    45

    25.5

    18.9

    35.5

    27.7

    12.3

    34.6

    17.5

    23.7

    11.79.4 9.4

    28

    15.2

    12.2

    15.815.314.7

    11.3

    28.1

    41.4

    12.4

    18.5 19.2

    10.7

    19.3

    10.8

    25.8

    10.8

    43.6

    19.3

    10.1

    24.9

    17

    7.6

    23.8

    33.7

    (NOTE: average final bound rates, %)

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    32Tariff commitments: non-agricultural products

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35

    40

    21.1

    17.3

    23.6 22.9

    6.7

    9.47.3

    15.2

    6.5 6.65.5

    11.6

    8.4

    6

    9.1

    4.8

    7.56.2

    17.7

    23.7

    10.510.3

    17.3

    5

    15.3

    4.3

    20.4

    7.3

    39.1

    18.7

    7.6

    20.5

    8.3

    5.9

    27.2

    10.3

    (NOTE: average final bound rates, %)

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Services: specific commitmentsN

    o. o

    f ser

    vice

    s sub

    -sec

    tors

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    No.

    Article XII Members

    Length of accession process

    # of WP Meetings

    held

    # of documents

    issued

    # of questions

    replied

    # of legislation

    submitted to WP

    1 Ecuador (1996) 3yr.4mo 10 11 111 69

    2 Bulgaria (1996) 10yr.1mo 9 7 276 26

    3 Mongolia (1997) 5yr.3mo 5 12 146 33

    4 Panama (1997) 5yr.11mo 5 23 502 45

    5 Kyrgyz Rep. (1998) 2yr.8mo 6 63 952 155

    6 Latvia (1999) 5yr.2mo 6 49 396 77

    7 Estonia (1999) 5yr.8mo 9 44 490 77

    8 Jordan (2000) 6yr.3mo 5 53 929 52

    9 Georgia (2000) 3yr.11mo 3 56 512 53

    10 Albania (2002) 7yr.9mo 8 95 607 66

    11 Oman (2000) 4yr.5mo 6 52 808 55

    12 Croatia (2000) 7yr.1mo 6 94 919 111

    13 Lithuania (2001) 7yr.3 mo 5 90 640 167

    14 Moldova (2001) 7yr.7mo 6 84 861 124

    15 China (2001) 14yr.9 mo 18 71 441 2,300

    16 Chinese Taipei (2002) 9yr.4mo 11 50 960 96

    17 Armenia (2003) 9yr.2mo 5 42 434 87

    18 N. Macedonia (2003) 8yr.4mo 5 52 829 132

    No.

    Article XII Members

    Length of accession process

    # of WP Meetings

    held

    # of documents

    issued

    # of questions

    replied

    # of legislation submitted to

    WP

    19 Nepal* (2004) 14yr.10mo 3 34 466 24

    20 Cambodia* (2004) 9yr.10mo 5 48 460 85

    21 Saudi Arabia (2005) 12yr.5mo 14 98 1218 95

    22 Viet Nam (2007) 12yrs 14 105 3511 184

    23 Tonga (2007) 11yr.8mo 3 36 416 74

    24 Ukraine (2008) 14yr5mo 17 225 3810 385

    25 Cabo Verde*(2008) 8yrs 6 69 888 73

    26 Montenegro (2012) 7yr2mo 8 67 1015 114

    27 Samoa* (2012) 13yr10mo 2 52 914 123

    28 Russian Fed. (2012) 19yr1mo 31 187 2566 529

    29 Vanuatu* (2012) 17yr1mo 2 36 343 123

    30 Lao PDR* (2013) 15yrs 10 105 1224 159

    31 Tajikistan (2013) 11yr8mo 9 71 1296 137

    32 Yemen* (2014) 13yr11mo 11 98 1164 58

    33 Seychelles (2015) 19yr.9mo 7 110 1043 287

    34 Kazakhstan (2015) 19yr.9mo 20 229 1900 412

    35 Liberia* (2016) 8yr.7mo 4 39 264 102

    36 Afghanistan* (2016) 11yr.7mo 5 62 773 75

    Accession in numbers: completed accessions

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    2,3001,166

    449412

    174155141137135133133126112107106

    773326

    0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500

    China (2001)Russian Federation (2012)

    Ukraine (2008)Kazakhstan (2015)

    Moldova (2001)Kyrgyz Republic (1998)

    Tajikistan (2013)Lithuania (2001)

    Croatia (2000)The FRY of Macedonia (2003)

    Montenegro (2012)Estonia (1999)

    Armenia (2003)Albania (2000)Georgia (2000)

    Latvia (1999)Mongolia (1997)Bulgaria (1996)

    Legislation enacted by Article XII Members

    M. Lekic and C. Osakwe, "WTO Rules, Accession Protocols and Mega-Regionals: Complementarity and Governance in the Rules-Based Global Economy" in A. Kireyev and C. Osakwe (eds.) Trade Multilateralism in the Twenty-First Century – Building the Upper Floors of the Trading System Through WTO Accessions, 2017, p. 137.

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Number of commitments undertaken by Article XII Members

    22 27 1824 29 22 24

    29 29 29 26 27 28 28

    168

    65

    39

    24 25 29

    5970

    29

    63

    2635 37

    163

    30 26

    4028

    40

    118

    40

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140

    160

    180

    Ecua

    dor '

    96

    Bulg

    aria

    '96

    Mon

    golia

    '97

    Pana

    ma

    '97

    Kyrg

    yz R

    epub

    lic '9

    8

    Latv

    ia '9

    9

    Esto

    nia

    '99

    Jord

    an '0

    0

    Geo

    rgia

    '00

    Alba

    nia

    '00

    Om

    an '0

    0

    Croa

    tia '0

    0

    Lith

    uani

    a '0

    1

    Mol

    dova

    , Rep

    blic

    of '

    01

    Chin

    a '0

    1

    Chin

    ese

    Taip

    ei '0

    2

    Arm

    enia

    , Rep

    ublic

    of '

    03

    FYR

    Mac

    edon

    ia '0

    3

    Nep

    al '0

    4

    Cam

    bodi

    a '0

    4

    Saud

    i Ara

    bia

    '05

    Viet

    Nam

    '07

    Tong

    a '0

    7

    Ukr

    aine

    '08

    Cabo

    Ver

    de '0

    8

    Mon

    tene

    gro

    '12

    Sam

    oa '1

    2

    Russ

    ian

    Fede

    ratio

    n '1

    2

    Vanu

    atu

    '12

    Lao

    Peop

    le's

    Dem

    ocra

    tic '1

    3

    Tajik

    istan

    '13

    Yem

    en '1

    4

    Seyc

    helle

    s '15

    Kaza

    khst

    an '1

    5

    Libe

    ria '1

    6

    Copyright © WTO Secretariat

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140

    Mon

    etar

    y an

    d Fi

    scal

    Pol

    icy

    Com

    petit

    ion

    Polic

    ySt

    agin

    g of

    dism

    antli

    ng o

    f Tar

    iff A

    djus

    tmen

    t…Sp

    ecia

    l tra

    de a

    rran

    gem

    ents

    , inc

    l. ba

    rter

    …Tr

    ansit

    iona

    l pro

    duct

    -spe

    cific

    safe

    guar

    d…Re

    serv

    atio

    ns b

    y W

    TO m

    embe

    rsTr

    ansit

    iona

    l Rev

    iew

    Mec

    hani

    smSp

    ecia

    l Exc

    hang

    e Ag

    reem

    ent b

    etw

    een

    the…

    Bala

    nce-

    of-p

    aym

    ents

    mea

    sure

    sN

    on-d

    iscrim

    inat

    ion/

    Chi

    na's

    wor

    king

    par

    ty…

    Text

    ile re

    gim

    esFo

    reig

    n ex

    chan

    ge a

    nd p

    aym

    ents

    Inve

    stm

    ent r

    egim

    eO

    ther

    cus

    tom

    s for

    mal

    ities

    Trad

    e in

    civ

    il ai

    rcra

    ftEx

    port

    dut

    ies,

    fees

    and

    cha

    rges

    Tran

    sitEx

    port

    subs

    idie

    sO

    rdin

    ary

    cust

    oms d

    utie

    sG

    over

    nmen

    t pro

    cure

    men

    tPr

    e-sh

    ipm

    ent i

    nspe

    ctio

    nO

    ther

    dut

    ies a

    nd c

    harg

    esRu

    les o

    f orig

    inTr

    ade

    agre

    emen

    tsEx

    port

    rest

    rictio

    nsAg

    ricul

    tura

    l pol

    icie

    sTa

    riff r

    ate

    quot

    as, t

    ariff

    exe

    mpt

    ions

    Tran

    spar

    ency

    - pu

    blic

    atio

    n of

    info

    rmat

    ion

    on…

    Tran

    spar

    ency

    - no

    tific

    atio

    nFe

    es a

    nd c

    harg

    es fo

    r ser

    vice

    s ren

    dere

    dIn

    dust

    rial p

    olic

    y, in

    clud

    ing

    subs

    idie

    sTr

    ade-

    rela

    ted

    inve

    stm

    ent m

    easu

    res

    Free

    zone

    s, sp

    ecia

    l eco

    nom

    ic a

    reas

    Pric

    ing

    polic

    ies

    Trad

    ing

    right

    sAn

    ti-du

    mpi

    ng, c

    ount

    erva

    iling

    dut

    ies,

    …Cu

    stom

    s val

    uatio

    nAp

    plic

    atio

    n of

    inte

    rnal

    taxe

    s on

    impo

    rts

    Fram

    ewor

    k fo

    r mak

    ing

    and

    enfo

    rcin

    g po

    licie

    sPo

    licie

    s affe

    ctin

    g tr

    ade

    in se

    rvic

    esSt

    ate

    owne

    rshi

    p an

    d pr

    ivat

    izatio

    n; st

    ate…

    Qua

    ntita

    tive

    impo

    rt re

    stric

    tions

    , inc

    l.…Tr

    ade-

    rela

    ted

    aspe

    cts o

    f int

    elle

    ctua

    l…Te

    chni

    cal b

    arrie

    rs to

    trad

    eSa

    nita

    ry a

    nd p

    hyto

    sani

    tary

    mea

    sure

    s

    Frequency of commitments undertaken by Article XII Members

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    In the vanguard of WTO reform?

    1500+ accession specific commitments undertaken by 36 Article XII Members: tailored to individual circumstances, but patterns have emerged.

    “WTO+” commitments: obligations to abide by the rules created by the commitment paragraph and not contained in the multilateral trade agreements.

    Example 1: Before the Trade Facilitation Agreement’s entry into force, WTO accessions contributed 37 commitments on transparency in dedicated “Transparency” section of WP Reports and 200+ commitments on transparency under other WP Report headings (RoO, SPS,TBT, TRIPS…).

    Example 2: While a multilateral decision to end agriculture export subsidies was taken in 2015, all Article XII Members have committed to bind such subsidies at zero since 1996 .

    Accessions rule-making = a counterpart to multilateral rule-making? E.g. transparency, export subsidies

    Setting the stage for future negotiations = pressure to level the playing-field?

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Acceding Government• Foster and consolidate domestic reform• Economic diversification and modernization• Better integration into global supply chains• Predictable and transparent rules • Participate in the shaping of global trade rules• Positive signalling to foreign and domestic investors• Improve economic resilience post- COVID-19

    WTO• Deepen international cooperation for trade• Expand market access for the WTO membership• Extend the reach of WTO rules and strengthen their application• Facilitate smoother trade flows• Achieve universality of the multilateral trading system

    The aim and rationale of WTO accession

    • The accession process aims to ensure that an Acceding Government’s legislationand practices will be compliant with WTO rules and that it becomes a full andeffective player from its first day of membership.

    • The WTO accession process involves learning and preparation for WTOmembership. It benefits both the Acceding Government and the WTO.

    • Why join the WTO?

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Best practices• Early identification of benefits and interests, which should be

    reflected in a negotiating strategy

    • Impact assessment of WTO Membership

    • Assessment of trade-related legislation and practices to determine conformity with WTO rules

    • Establishment of a national steering committee (e.g. ministries, private sector, and civil society representatives)

    • Involvement of lawmakers for sustainability of reforms, transparency and domestic mobilization.

    • Identification of a 'model accession’

    • Use of technical assistance & capacity building

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    Accession-Related Technical AssistanceTechnical Assistance and Capacity building activities include inter alia:

    • National seminars;• Sessions on accessions in advanced trade policy courses, regional courses

    and introductory courses for LDCs;• Workshops;• Technical missions;• Establishment/upgrade of WTO reference centres;• E-learning courses and e-lecture series;• Outreach dialogue with WTO groupings;• Participation in conferences; and• Customized briefings on accessions for delegations (including non-

    residents in Geneva) are also provided by the Secretariat.

  • Session 2: Overview of Accessions

    [email protected]

    Questions?

    Overview of AccessionsSlide Number 2Slide Number 3A closer relationship with the WTO?Observer statusWTO Accession: legal basisWTO Accession: legal basisWTO Accession: legal basisThe WTO Accession ProcessStage 1: Working Party Establishment�Stage 2: Fact-finding & negotiationStage 3: Final stepsSlide Number 13Map of WTO Members and Observers�Completed (36) and ongoing (23) accessions �(LDCs in red)What has been done so far? �36 accessions completed to date�(By accession date)Shares of world tradeSlide Number 18Slide Number 19Slide Number 20Slide Number 21What remains to be done? �23 ongoing accessions, plus ….�(By application date)Slide Number 23Slide Number 24WTO accessions: new “themes”�Slide Number 26WTO Accessions – what are the yardsticks?Policy Framework for LDC AccessionsLength of WTO Accession Process: �From 1st Working Party to Membership Length of WTO accession process: �From application to membership, in yearsTariff commitments: agricultural productsTariff commitments: non- agricultural productsServices: specific commitmentsSlide Number 34Slide Number 35Number of commitments �undertaken by Article XII MembersFrequency of commitments �undertaken by Article XII MembersIn the vanguard of WTO reform?The aim and rationale of WTO accessionBest practicesAccession-Related �Technical AssistanceSlide Number 42