Outline 3 PROPERTY Cases

7/23/2019 Outline 3 PROPERTY Cases

1/96

!" $%"&

'()*) "+) ,-./01) 234+567 8.9 810:);

!" $%& '($$&) *+ $%& $&,$($& &,$($& *+ -'./ 0(1).2& 3(2%)(2%4 5&2&(,&56 0789 0:;; 37:?87:? 9 67-

?F67 4C6 S?AA?3CTA644A7T@69 ? A4+3U F=V=F6>F =A 3+>A=F676F F 56@+>IA 4+ 4C6 76W?=>F67W?>M XC=@6 T>F67 4C6 Y6>>AZ@V?>=? 7T@69

?@@ 6?7>=>IA +G ? 3+79 XC6> F63@?76F ?A F=V=F6>FA => XC?46V67 G+7W9 W?F6 FT7=>I 4C6 @=G64=W6 +G 4C6 TATG7T34T?7Z9

56@+>I 4+ 4C6 @?4467)

.) OH)M OH) R LC6 Y6>>AZ@V?>=? 7T@6 =A W+76 => ?33+7F X=4C +T7 A4?4T4+7Z @?XA 4C?> 4C6 S?AA?3CTA644A 7T@6) K>F67 A634=+> 8/

+G +T7 &+7 ,?X9 >+ 3+7 W?Z W?U6 +7 F63@?76 G7+W =4A 5TA=>6AA) %>Z F=V=F6>F9 4C676G+769 XC64C67 3?AC +7

A4+3U9 764 AT7FTA47=?@9 ?>F 3=V=@ G7T=4A +G 4C6 F => ]T6A4=+> => 4C=A 3?A6 =A ? 3=V=@ G7T=4 +G

4C6 +7=I=>?@ =>V6A4W6>4) LC6 AC?76A +G A4+3U =AAT6F => =W?@ W?Z 56 A+@F =>F6F6>4@Z +G =4A W+4C67)

;-:!A!IA 4+ 4C6 TATG7T34T?7Z9 +7 =A =4 3?` LC?4 =A 4C6 ]T6A4=+> 7?=A6F => 4C=A ? C=A @?A4 X=@@ ?>F

46A4?W6>4 W?F6 V?7=TA @6I?3=6A => 3?AC ?>F X=@@6F 4C6 76W?=>F67 +G C=A 6A4?46 ?A G+@@+XA_

bB=a4C_ O4 =A WZ X=@@ ?>F F+ C676X=4C 56]T6?4C ?>F F6V=A6 4+ WZ 56@+V6F X=G6 S?7Z S3H+>?@F $?3C7?3C G+7 @=G6 ?@@ 4C6 G7T=4A

?>F TATG7T34 +G 4C6 76W?=>F67 +G ?@@ WZ 6A4?46 ?G467 F I=G4A F AC6

W?Z 6>^+Z A?=F TATG7T34 ?>F TA6 +7 AF AT3C G7T=4A ?A AC6 W?Z => ?>Z W?>>67 X=AC)b

LC6 X=@@ GT74C67 ?@F $?3C7?3C9 +>6-C?@G +G ?@@ C=A 6A4?46 bAC?@@ 56 F=V=F6F AC?76?>F AC?76 ?@=U6 5Z ?>F 564X66> WZ @6I?@ C6=7A9 4+ 4C6 6a3@TA=+> +G WZ 57+4C67A)b

LC6 6A4?46 +G !) S) $?3C7?3C9 ?A +X>67 +G 8:c9::: AC?76A +G A4+3U +G 4C6 %4+U-$=I d6FI6 S=>=>I &+)9 O >3)9 7636=V6F G7+W 4C6

@?4467 0[9::: AC?76A 764=>I 0: 4 A4+3U F=V=F6>F +> 4C6 A?=F 8:c9::: AC?76A) 2> ET>6 8:9 81[c9 S?7Z S3H+>?@F

$?3C7?3C9 ?A TATG7T34T?7Z +7 @=G6 46>?>4 +G 4C6 6A4?469 6F 4C6 @+X67 3+T74 4+ ?T4C+7=e6 4C6 Y6+U ?>F L7TA4

&+WZ9 ?A ?FW=>=A47?4+7 +G 4C6 6A4?46 +G !) S) $?3C7?3C9 4+ 47?>AG67 4+ C67 4C6 A?=F 0[9::: AC?76A +G A4+3U F=V=F6>F 5Z

=>F+7A=>I ?>F F6@=V67=>I 4+ C67 4C6 3+776AF=>I 3674=G=3?46 +G A4+3U9 3@?=W=>I 4C?4 A?=F F=V=F6>F9 ?@4C+TIC F 4C676G+76 56@+>I6F 4+ C67 ?A TATG7T34T?7Z +7 @=G6 46>?>4) B+F !@=A? !@=?>+GG9

@6I?@ C6=7A +G 4C6 F636?A6F9 +F 4C?4 4C6 A4+3U F=V=F6>F => ]T6A4=+> X?A >+4 =>3+W6 5T4

G+7W6F F 4C676G+76 56@+>I6F >+4 4+ 4C6 TATG7T34T?7Z 5T4 4+ 4C6 76W?=>F67W?>) %>F 4C6Z C?V6 ?I 4C6 ?>F +V677T@=>I 4C6=7 +5^634=+>)

dC=@6 ?F =A ?> =>3+W69 4C6Z 3+>46>F 4C?4 ? A4+3U F=V=F6>F =A >+49 5T4 W676@Z 764A ?>?FF=4=+> 4+ 4C6 =>V6A46F 3? T7=AF=34=+>A => 4C6 K>=46F B4?46A9

AT) O4 76I?7FA 3?AC F=V=F6>FA9 C+X6V67 @?7I69 ?A =>3+W69 ?>F A4+3U F=V=F6>FA9 C+X6V67 W?F69 ?A

3?+4 VA) Y?=>69 11 S?AA)9 8:8M 1/ %W) H63)9 \:0)h O4 C+@FA 4C?4 ? A4+3U F=V=F6>F =A >+4 => ?>Z 47T6 A6>A6 ?>Z F=V=F6>F

?4 ?@@ A=>36 =4 =>V+@V6A >+ F=V=A=+> +7 A6V67?>36 G7+W 4C6 3+7FM 4C?4 =4 F+6A >+4

F=A47=5T46 I G7+W 4C6 +4C=>I 4+ 4C6 =>4676A4A +G 4C6 AC?76C+@F67A)

2> 4C6 +4C67 C?>F9 4C6 A+-3?@@6F Y6>>AZ@V?>=? 7T@69 XC=3C V?7=+TA +4C67 T7=AF=34=+>A => 4C6 K>=46F B4?46A9

AT=>IA +G 4C6 3+7 W?F6 I 4+ 4C6 3+7F 4C?4 ?@@ 6?7>=>IA9 XC6> F63@?76F ?A F=V=F6>FA => XC?46V67 G+7W9 W?F6

FT7=>I 4C6 @=G64=W6 +G 4C6 TATG7T34T?7Z +7 @=G6 46>?>4 ?76 =>3+W6 ?>F 56@+>I 4+ 4C6 TATG7T34T?7Z +7 @=G6 46>?>4) g!?7


2/96

.c Y?)9 i/c)h

b) ) ) O4 =A 3@6?7 4C?4 46A4?4+7 =>46>F6F 4C6 76W?=>F67W6> AC+T@F C?V6 +>@Z 4C6 3+7 47TA49 ?>F 4C?4 ?@@

F=V=F6>FA AC+T@F I+ 4+ 4C6 @=G6 46>?>4A) O4 =A 47T6 4C?4 +4 F=V=F6>FA T>4=@ F63@?76F 5Z 4C6 F 4C6 G+7W +G 4C6 F=A47=5T4=+> =A =WW?467=?@)b gO>

76 LC+WfA !A4?469 ./. Y?)9 .\cM 8:0 %4@) .\i9 .\[)h

O> j=46 VA) j=46 g1i NZ)9 .0\M .: B) d)9 \\c9 \c:h9 4C6 &+T74 +G %F9 ?@4C+TIC F63@?76F => A4+3U9 =A 5?A6F T 4C6 6?7>=>IA +G 4C6 3+WZ9 =4 =A => 76?@=4Z9 XC64C67 3?@@6F5Z +>6 >?W6 +7 ?>+4C679 4C6 =>3+W6 +G 4C6 3?V6A46F => =4) O4 =A 5T4 ? W+F6 +G F=A47=5T4=>I 4C6 +4 =>3+W69

XC?4 =A =4` OG =4 =A9 4C6> =4 =A 7=IC4GT@@Z ?>F 6]T=4?5@Z 4C6 4) OG =4 56 76?@@Z C6 AC+T@F C?V6 =49

XC64C67


3/96

!" $%"&

'()*) "+) i0..i) B64A-?467V6>+7-? E) ,?3A+> G+7 =>467V6>+7-?+ !e


4/96

b8) O> C+@F=>I 4C?4 4C6 5+>TA XC=3C 4C6 L?@=A?Z-B=@?Z S=@@=>I &+)9 O>3)9 5+T>F =4A6@G 4+ 467A XC+ C?F W+74I?I6F

4C6=7 @?>F 4+ 4C6 YC=@=


5/96

%AATW=>I 4C?4 => 4C6 57+?F ^T7=F=3?@ A6>A6 +G 4C6 X+7F b=>3+W6b =4 W=IC4 56 A?=F 4C?4 4C6 5+>TA => ]T6A4=+> =A b=>3+W6b T>F67

?74=3@6 i00 +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F69 =4 =A +5V=+TA 4+ =>]T=76 XC64C67 =4 =A F67=V6F G7+W 4C6 @?>F W+74I?I6F 5Z S?7=?>+ ,?3A+>

,6F6AW? 4+ 4C6 ?U G+7 4C6 56>6G=4 +G 4C6 36>47?@M G+7 =G =4 =A >+4 +54?=>6F G7+W 4C?4 @?>F 5T4 G7+W A+W64C=>I 6@A69 =4

=A >+4 3=V=@ G7T=4A +G 4C?4 @?>F9 ?>F 4C6 5?>UfA 3+>46>4=+> =A T>46>?5@6)

O4 =A 4+ 56 >+46F 4C?4 4C6 A?=F 5+>TA 56?7A >+ =WW6F=?469 5T4 +>@Z ? 76W+46 ?>F ?33=F6>4?@ 76@?4=+> 4+ 4C6 @?>F W6>4=+>6F9

C?V=>I 566> I7?>46F ?A 3+WA?4=+> G+7 4C6 7=AU +G C?V=>I AT5^6346F +>6fA @?>F 4+ ? @=6> => G?V+7 +G 4C6 5?>U9 G+7 4C6 56>6G=4

+G 4C6 6>4=4Z I7?>4=>I A?=F 5+>TA) OG 4C=A 5+>TA 56 =>3+W6 +7 3=V=@ G7T=4A +G ?>Z4C=>I9 =4 =A =>3+W6 ?7=A=>I G7+W A?=F 7=AU9 +79 =G

+>6 3C++A6A9 G7+W S?7=?>+ ,?3A+> ,6F6AW?fA I6>67+A=4Z => G?3=>I 4C6 F?>I67 G+7 4C6 +G 4C6 36>47?@9 5T4 3674?=>@Z =4

=A >+4 3=V=@ G7T=4A +7 =>3+W6 G7+W 4C6 W+74I?I6F 6F9 C?A >+4C=>I 4+ F+ X=4C =4)j6>369 4C6 ?W+T>4 +G 4C6 5+>TA9 ?33+7F=>I 4+ 4C6 76A+@T4=+> +G 4C6 36>47?@ I7?>4=>I =49 =A >+4 5?A6F T 4C6 V?@T69

=W36 +7 ?>Z +4C67 3=73TWA4?>36 +G 4C6 W+74I?I6F >T?@ 5?@?>369 XC=3C =A A+W64C=>I ]T=46 F=A4=>34 G7+W ?>F =>F6F6>4 +G 4C6 I >+ W67=4 => 4C=A ?9 B476649 S?@3+@W9 P=@@?W+79 2A47?>F9 P=@@?-*6?@?>FOW3T7)

!" $%"&

'()*) "+) 8iic\1) "+V6W567 .89 .::8); -JE7D 8-7>D9 ;-K->4) !A46@=4+ Y) S6>F+e? G+7 67)

H6 $+7^? S6F=?@F6? $6@@+ (T6V?77? D (67+F=?A ,?X 2GG=36A G+7 4)

A9=3) X?A ? @6AA66 +G A +G ? 5T=@F=>I +X>6F 5Z &?7W6@+ D $?T67W?>>9 O>3) LC6=7 @6?A6 3+>47?34A

3+>4?=>6F ? I7?>4=>I S?ZG?=7 ? 7=IC4 +G G=7A4 76GTA?@ 4+ &?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@9 AF F?W?I6A) O> 811/9 4C6 &+T74 7T@6F => G?V+7 +G S?ZG?=7) $?76@Z G=V6 W+>4CA ?G467 S?ZG?=7 C?F AT5W=446F =4A S+4=+> G+7

!a63T4=+>9 !]T?4+7=?@ G=@6F ?> ?34=+> G+7 3+@@634=+> +G ATW +G W+>6Z ?I?=>A4 S?ZG?=7 3@?=W=>I 4fA TA6 +G 4C6 AT5^634 47?34A C?F 6aU6F 4C6 3@?=W +G !]T?4+7=?@ G+7 T>Z V6A46F +7 76A=FT?@ 6a3Z) O4 GT74C67 7T@6F 4C?4 4C6

&+T74 3?46I+7=3?@@Z A4?46F 4C?4 4C6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 C?F 566> 76A3=>F6F AT5^634=>I 4C6 4 3+W4 4+ 76A TF=3?4?)

j6>369 !]T?4+7=?@ G=@6F 4C6 4 )

LC6+764=3?@@Z9 ? 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34 =A V?@=F T>4=@ 76A3=>F6F) j+X6V679 4C=A I6>67?@ 3=+4 F63=A=V6 4+ 4C6 =AAT6 +G

XC64C67 !]T?4+7=?@ 6V67 ?3]T=76F 4C6 7=IC4 4+ 3+@@634 76>4?@A) dC?4 =A F63=A=V6 =A 4C6 3=V=@ @?X 7T@6 4C?4 +X>67AC=< =A ?3]T=76F9

>+4 5Z W676 ?I766W6>49 5T4 5Z 47?F=4=+> +7 F6@=V67Z) K>F67 4C6 G?34T?@ 6>V=7+>W6>4 +G 4C=A 3+>47+V67AZ ?A G+T>F 5Z 4C=A

&+T74 => 4C6 W+4C67 3?A69 !]T?4+7=?@ X?A >6V67 ?34T?@ ?>F 6GG634=V6 3+>47+@ +7 +G 4C6 4C6 W+4C67 3?A69 4C=A &+T74 3?46I+7=3?@@Z F6>=6F 4C6


6/96

80:89 +7 => ?>Z +4C67 W?>>67 A=I>=GZ=>I ?> ?I766W6>4 4C?4 4C6 =A 47?>AG6776F G7+W 4C6 V6>F+7 4+ 4C6 V6>F66)b LC=A

7=IC4 =A 47?>AG6776F9 >+4 5Z 3+>47?34 ?@+>69 5T4 5Z 47?F=4=+> +7 F6@=V67Z) "+> >TF=A AG67?>4T7)

i) OH)M OH)M OH)M Lj!*! OB H!,OP!*Q dj!" Lj! LjO"( B2,H OB Y,%&!H K"H!* Lj! &2"L*2, %"H Y2BB!BBO2" 2J Lj!

P!"H!!) R 'L;C676 =A A?=F 4+ 56 F6@=V67Z =G ?>F XC6> 4C6 4C=>I A+@F b=A 4C6 3+>47+@ ?>F +G 4C6 V6>F66)b

LCTA9 =4 C?A 566> C6@F 4C?4 XC=@6 4C6 6a63T4=+> +G ? A47TW6>4 +G A?@6 =A 763+I>=e6F 5Z @?X ?A 6]T=V?@6>4 4+ 4C6

F6@=V67Z +G 4C6 4C=>I A+@F9 AT3C 3+>A47T34=V6 +7 AZW5+@=3 F6@=V67Z9 56=>I W676@Z F66 4+ 4?U6 ?34T?@ +G 4C6 @?>F A+@F) H6@=V67Z C?A 566> F6A37=56F ?A ? 3+WI =>

XC=3C 5+4C F 4C6 W=>FA +G 5+4C


7/96

1) BL%LKL2*Q &2"BL*K&LO2"M (!"!*%, Y*2Y2BOLO2"B H2 "2L H!&OH! BY!&OJO& &%B!B) R %A 46F +T4 5Z ETA4=36

j+@W6A9 I6>67?@ +4 F63=F6 A467 4C6 3+>46a4 +G 4C6 +G 6?3C 3?A6) !?3C 3?A6 C?A =4A +X> G@6AC ?>F 5@++F ?>F 3?>>+4 56 F63=F6F +> 4C6 5?A=A +G =A+@?46F 3@=>=3?@

3@?AA7++W 3=I G+7 4C6 A?U6 +G ?7ITW6>4 4C?4 4C676 X?A V?@=F F6@=V67Z9 67 =A

>+4 6>4=4@6F 4+ ?>Z 56>6G=4A G7+W 4C6 b76A3=>F6Fb H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 563?TA6 +G =4A 5?F G?=4C) LC=A 56=>I 4C6 @?X +G 4C6

W+4C67 3?A6 F63=F6F => 811/9 =4 W?Z >+ @+>I67 56 3C?>I6F 563?TA6 =4 C?A @+>I 563+W6 G=>?@ ?>F 6a63T4+7Z) ) ) ) LCTA9

67 X?A ?>F A4=@@ =A 6>4=4@6F A+@6@Z 4+ 4C6 764T7> +G 4C6


8/96

&?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@ 56C=>F 4C6 5?3U ?>F => V=+@?4=+> +G 4C6 7=IC4A +G S?ZG?=7) dCZ AC+T@F 4C6 =>>+36>4 ?>F X7+>I6F

T>@?XGT@ 3+>47?34 4+ XC=3C =4 X?A >+4 A+G?7 ?A !]T?4+7=?@ ?>F

&?7W6@+ ?76 3+>367>6F9 4C6=7 81\c 3+>47?34 W?Z C?V6 V?@=F@Z 47?>AG6776F +X>67AC=< G7+W +>6 4+ 4C6 +4C67) $T4 >+4 ?A G?7 ?A

S?ZG?=7 =A 3+>367>6F)

i) OH)M OH)M OH)M "2"-!kOBL!"L 2* P2OH J*2S OLB O"&!YLO2" %B J%* %B Lj! O"EK*!H LjO*H Y%*LQ OB &2"&!*"!H) R

S?ZG?=7 A4?74A =4A ?7ITW6>4A X=4C ? F=A3TAA=+> +G %74=3@6 8ic8 +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6 4C?4 3+>47?34A 6>4676F =>4+ => G7?TF +G

376F=4+7A ?76 76A3=AA=5@6) LC676 =A W67=4 => S?ZG?=7fA 3+>46>4=+> 4C?4 4C6 @6I?@ 6GG634A ?76 >+4 76A47=346F 4+ 4C6 3+>47?34=>I


9/96

i) OH)M OH)M OH)M P%,OH,Q L*%"BJ!**!H 2d"!*BjOY 2J Lj! Y*2Y!*LQ L2 Lj! $KQ!* J*2S Lj! LOS! Lj! H!!H 2J

B%,! d%B !k!&KL!H) R 'd;C6> 4C6 &+T74 C6@F 4C6 3+>47?34 4+ 56 bF66W6F 76A3=>F6Fb => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i9 4C6 &+T74 F=F >+4

W6?> ? bF63@?7?4=+> +G >T@@=4Zb +G 4C6 ]T6A4=+>6F 3+>47?34) LC6 ?I766W6>4 564X66> 67 ?>F &?7W6@+9 56=>I 6GG= 3?3=+TA

T>4=@ 76A3=>F6F9 V?@=F@Z 47?>AG6776F +X>67AC=< +V67 4C6 4 +> i: ET@Z 81\c T< 4+ 4C6 4=W6 4C?4 4C6 F63=A=+> => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i 563?W6 G=>?@ +> 8\ S?73C 811\) O4

X?A +>@Z G7+W 4C6 @?4467 F?46 4C?4 4C6 3+>47?34 C?F 36?A6F 4+ 56 6GG=3?3=+TA) LC6 G?34 4C?4 4C6 AT5^634 FA +G ? @6AA669 +7 G+7 4C?4 W?4467 +G ?>Z +X>679 X+T@F >+4 G67W6>4 +G +X>67AC=< T 4C6 +7 56 ?> =W4 G7+W 4C6 47?>AG67 +G +X>67AC=< G7+W 4C6 A6@@67 4+ 4C6

5TZ67)

[) OH)M OH)M OH)M OH)M (22H J%OLj %"H $%H J%OLj Y,%Q "2 *2,!M $KQ!* OB !"LOL,!H L2 %,, O"&OH!"LB 2J 2d"!*BjOY

O"&,KBOP! 2J Lj! *O(jL L2 Lj! J*KOLB 2J Lj! Y*2Y!*LQM %YY,O&%$,! O" &%B! %L $%*) R Y64=4=+>679 56=>I 4C6 +X>67

+G 4C6 +>6 +4C67h T>4=@ 4C6 ^TF=3=?@ 76A3=AA=+> +G 4C6 A?@6 => =4A G?V+79 X?A 6>4=4@6F 4+ ?@@ =>3=F6>4A +G +X>67AC=3@TA=V6 +G9 ?W+>I =4A +4C67 6@6W6>4A9 4C6 7=IC4 4+ 4C6 G7T=4A +G 4C6 4?@ V?@T6 +V67 4C?4 F=A I++F

G?=4C +7 => 5?F G?=4C)

0) OH)M OH)M *!B&OBBO2" 2J &2"L*%&LB HOJJ!*!"LO%L!H J*2S Lj! *!B2,KLO2" 2J *!&OY*2&%, 2$,O(%LO2"B) R LC6

76W6FZ +G 76A3=AA=+> => 4C6 3?A6 +G 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34A T>F67 %74=3@6 8ic8 =A >+4 4+ 56 3+>GTA6F X=4C 4C6 76W6FZ +G

76A3=AA=+>9 +7 W+76 F67 %74=3@6 8818 +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6) dC=@6 5+4C

76W6F=6A 36 76A3=>F6F9 X+T@F 76]T=76 WT4T?@ 76A4=4T4=+>9 =4 =A

5?A=3?@@Z9 C+X6V679 => 4C=A ?A6 XC6> 4C6 4X+ 3+>363=F6) *6A+@T4=+> T>F67 %74=3@6 8818 X+T@F 4+4?@@Z 76@6?A66?3C +G 4C6 +5@=I+7A G7+W 3+W36 X=4C

4C6=7 76A?>4A) O4 W=IC4 56 X+74CXC=@6 4+ >+46 4C?4 => A+W6 3?A6A9 >+4?5@Z 23?W47?34A XC=3C ?76 F66W6F bV+=F ?4

=>36b 4C6 G+3?@ 4 =A 4C6 576?3C +G 4C6 +5@=I?4=+> =>V+@V6F 4C?4 X+T@F ?@@+X 76A+@T4=+> 4 4+ %74=3@6 8818 +G 4C6

&=V=@ &+F6) LC6 +5V=+TA 76?A+> =A 4C?4 XC6> 4+ @6?V6 4C6 W?4467

=> ? A4?46 +G 3+>4=>T=>I T>3674?=>4Z) LC6 76AT@4 +G 4C6 76A+@T4=+>9 XC6> F63766F9 76>F67A 4C6 763=A

=>+36)b K 4C6 +4C67 C?>F9 4C6 76A3=AA=+> +G ? 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34 T>F67 %74=3@6 8ic89 4?U6> =>

3+>^T>34=+> X=4C %74=3@6 8ic09 =A ? 76@=6G XC=3C 4C6 @?X I7?>4A G+7 4C6 +G ? 3+>47?34=>I F F?W?I6 4C?4 4C6 3+>47?34 W?Z 3?TA69 +7 4+ 3+WF 4=?@ 7=IC4 376?46F 5Z 4C6

3+>47?34) *6A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34A ?76 >+4 V+=F ?5 =>=4=+9 ?>F 4C6 3=T@@TW 6A4 >T@@TW V+=F

?>F =>6a=A46>4 3+>47?34A =A =>? ?> ?F=>I ?>F => G+736) O4 X+T@F 56 X7+>I 4+ A?Z 4C?4 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34A + @6I?@ 6GG634A XC?4A+6V67 ?>F

4C?4 >+ ?3]T=A=4=+> +7 @+AA +G 7=IC4A 3+T@F W6?>XC=@6 +33T7 ?>F 56 ?447=5T46F 4+ 4C6 467W=>?46F 3+>47?34) LC6 6GG634A +G 4C6

76A3=AA=+>9 ?4T769 3?> 3+W6 ?5+T4 +>@Z T =4A 4A >636AA?7Z 4+ 764T7> +X>67AC=< 4+ &?7W6@+ D $?T67W?>> +G 4C6 F=A+4 763+I>=e6 4C6 47?>AG67 +G +X>67AC=< G7+W &?7W6@+ 4+ !]T?4+7=?@ T>F67 4C6

3+>47?34 +G A?@6) J+7 XCZ X+T@F 4C6 &+T74 +7F67 !]T?4+7=?@ 4+ 6a63T46 4C6 F66FA ?>F F+3TW6>4A >636AA?7Z 4+ 764T7>

+X>67AC=< 4+ &?7W6@+ =G9 ?@@ ?@+>I9 =4 56@=6V6F 4C?4 +X>67AC=< 76W?=>6F X=4C &?7W6@+` JT74C67W+769 4C=A &+T74 6a 4C6 H63=A=+> 4C?4 !]T?4+7=?@ 7636=V6F 76>4?@A G7+W S?ZG?=7 FT7=>I 4C6 F6>3Z +G 4C6 3?A6) ) ) ) 25V=+TA@Z9 4C=A &+T74

?3U>+X@6FI6F 4C6 F6@=V67Z +G 4C6 C=WA6@G9 4C6

A?@6 564X 66> &?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@ C?F >+4 +>@Z 566> b


10/96

b3+>ATWW?46F)b

i) OH)M Y*2Y!*LQM *!&!OPO"( *!"L%,B OB %" !k!*&OB! 2J %&LK%, Y2BB!BBO2") R LC?4 ?34T?@ +G 4C6 4A G7+W S?ZG?=7) B=I>=G=3?>4@Z9

7636=V=>I 76>4?@A =A ?> 6a673=A6 +G ?34T?@ ) Y+AA6AA=+>9 ?A F6G=>6F => 4C6 &=V=@ &+F69 =A 4C6 C+@F=>I +G ? 4C=>I +7 4C6

6>^+ZW6>4 +G ? 7=IC4) O4 W?Z 6=4C67 56 5Z W?467=?@ +33T


11/96

!]T?4+7=?@ +G =4A 6>4=4@6W6>4 4+ 4C6 76>4 3+776AF=>I 4+ 4C6 I XC=3C 4C6 3+>47?34 X?A AT@Z 56 T>^TA49 =4 X+T@F ?@A+ F=A4T75 4C6 V67Z >?4T76 +G ? 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34)

c) OH)M OH)M *!B&OBBO$,! &2"L*%&L %"H P2OH &2"L*%&LM HOJJ!*!"LO%L!H) R %74=3@6A 8ic: 4C7+TIC 8ic1 +G 4C6 &=V=@

&+F6 F6?@ X=4C 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34A) % 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34 =A +>6 4C?4 =A V?@=F@Z 6>4676F =>4+9 5T4 =A AT5A6]T6>4@Z 467W=>?46F

+7 76A3=>F6F G+7 3?TA6A


12/96

2> ET>6 89 81/\9 &?7W6@+ 6>4676F =>4+ ? &+>47?34 +G ,6?A6 X=4C S?ZG?=7 LC6?467 O>3) gbS?ZG?=7bh G+7 ? F G@++7 ?>F W6ee?>=>6 +G ? 4X+-A4+76Z 5T=@F=>I X=4C ?5+T4 89/8: A]T?76 W6467A +G G@++7

?76?9 XC=3C 76AF6>4 TA6F ?A ? W+V=6 C+TA6 U>+X> ?A S?a=W LC6?467)

LX+ Z6?7A @?4679 +> S?73C i89 81/19 S?ZG?=7 6>4676F =>4+ ? A63+>F &+>47?34 +G ,6?A6 X=4C &?7W6@+ G+7 4C6 @6?A6 +G ?>+4C67

+G 4C6 @?4467fA F 4X+ A4+76 AF 4C6 W6ee?>=>69 X=4C ? 3+W5=>6F G@++7 ?76? +G ?5+T4 i::

A]T?76 W6467A) O> 4C?4 A+4C67 W+V=6 C+TA6 U>+X> ?A S=7?W?7 LC6?467) LC6 &+>47?34 +G ,6?A6 X?A

@=U6X=A6 G+7 ? 4?=>6F ? I7?>4=>I S?ZG?=7 ? 7=IC4 +G G=7A4 76GTA?@ 4+ 3C \h G+7 g?h 4C6 ?>>T@W6>4 +G 4C6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 564X66> &?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@9 g5h AF g3h F?W?I6A) %G467 47=?@ +> 4C6 W67=4A9 4C6 @+X67 3+T74 76>F676F ? H63=A=+> => G?V+7 +G &?7W6@+ ?>F

!]T?4+7=?@) LC=A 3?A69 6>4=4@6F bS?ZG?=7 LC6?4679 O>3) V) &?7W6@+ ?>F $?T67W?>>9 O>3)9 64 ?@)9b X?A F+3U646F ?A &=V=@ &?A6 "+)

88c:81)

2> ? 4C=A W+4C67 3?A69 =4 F6>=6F 4C6 Y64=4=+> G+7 *6V=6X => 4C=A X=A6_

bdj!*!J2*!9 4C6 G+7 76V=6X +G 4C6 F63=A=+> +G 4C6 &+T74 +G % &%-()*) &P "+) i.18c9

=A j!*!$Q H!"O!H) LC6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 564X66> 67A !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z H6V6@+49 O>3) ?>F &?7W6@+ D

$?T67W?>>9 O>3) =A C6765Z F66W6F 76A3=>F6FM &?7W6@+ D $?T67W?>> =A +7F676F 4+ 764T7> 4+ 67 !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z

H6V6@+4 4C6 4A >636AA?7Z 4+ 764T7> +X>67AC=> +G 4C6 F=A> =A +7F676F 4+ ?@@+X S?ZG?=7 LC6?4679 O>3) 4+ 5TZ 4C6

?G+76A?=F @+4A G+7 Y889i::9:::)::)b Q

LC6 G+76I+=>I H63=A=+> +G 4C=A &+T74 563?W6 G=>?@ ?>F 6a63T4+7Z +> S?73C 8\9 811\) 2> %

G+7 !a63T4=+>9 XC=3C 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 I7?>46F)

j+X6V679 &?7W6@+ 3+T@F >+ @+>I67 56 @+3?46F) LCTA9 G+@@+X=>I 4C6 +7F67 +G 6a63T4=+> +G 4C6 47=?@ 3+T749 S?ZG?=7 F6


13/96

3+WA?4=+> G+7 4C6 F6G6>F?>4fA TA6 +G 4C6 AT5^634 47?34A C?F 6a X?A 4C6

=4+7 +G 4C6 4 3?A6)

O> =4A &+W49 !]T?4+7=?@ ?@@6I6F ?W+>I +4C67 4C=>IA 4C?4 4C6 ,6?A6 &+>47?34 3+V67=>I 4C6 I 4C6 67 +G 4C6 AT5^634 +G 4C6 &+>47?34 +G B?@6 +> ET@Z i:9

81\c9 =4 3@?=W6F 76>4?@A ?7=A=>I G7+W S?ZG?=7fA +33T


14/96

b&)

LC6 *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T74 @=U6X=A6 6776F => C+@F=>I 4C?4 4C6 ?G+76A?=F H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@69 F?46F ET@Z i89 81\c9 C?V=>I 566>

fF66W6F 76A3=>F6Ff 5Z 4C6 BT ()*) "+) 8:/:/i9 67 f=A >+4 4C6 +X>67 ?>F F+6A >+4 C?V6 ?>Z 7=IC4 4+

F6W?>F 5?3U76>4?@A G7+W 4C6 AT5^634 +G 4C6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 5Z 4C6 BT+4 3+>G67 4+ 67 f?>Z V6A46F 7=IC4 >+7 ?>Z 76A=FT?@ 6a3Z)f

bH)

LC6 =AAT6 T XC=3C 4C6 *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T74 F=AW=AA6F 4C6 3=V=@ 3?A69 ?A A4?46F => =4A 27F67 +G S?73C 889 811c9 X?A >+47?=A6F 5Z 76AF6>4 => =4A S+4=+> 4+ H=AW=AA)

b!)

LC6 A+@6 I7+T>F T XC=3C 4C6 *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T74 F=AW=AA6F &=V=@ &?A6 "+) 1\-c08[8 =A >+4 +>6 +G 4C6 I7+T>FA +G ? S+4=+>

4+ H=AW=AA T>F67 B63) 8 +G *T@6 8/ +G 4C6 811\ *T@6A +G &=V=@ Y7+36FT76)b

$?A=3?@@Z9 4C6 =AAT6A 3?> 56 ATWW?7=e6F =>4+ 4X+_ g8h 4C6 AT5A4?>4=V6 =AAT6 +G XC64C67 !]T?4+7=?@ =A 6>4=4@6F 4+ 5?3U 76>4?@AM

?>F g.h 4C6


15/96

Y+AA6AA=+> "6V67 %3]T=76F 5Z Y64=4=+>67

,64 TA >+X ? 4+ 4C6 4 =AAT6) J7+W 4C6 6V67 4++U ?34T?@ 3+>47+@ ?>F +G 4C6 4fA 4=W6@Z +5^634=+> 4+ 4C6 A?@6 ?>F 4C6

3+>4=>T6F ?34T?@ +G 4C6 =W=>I 4C6 A?@6 XC=3C9 ?A X6

U>+X9 X?A 76A3=>F6F 5Z ? ^TFIW6>4 76>F676F 5Z 4C=A &+T74 => 4C6 W+4C67 3?A6) O4 C?A 566> C6@F 4C?4 4C6 6a63T4=+> +G ?

3+>47?34 +G A?@6 ?A ? G+7W +G 3+>A47T34=V6 F6@=V67Z =A ? @6I?@ G=34=+>) O4 C+@FA 47T6 +>@Z XC6> 4C676 =A >+ =W4 4C?4 W?Z

4 4C6 FA +G 4C6 V6>F+7 =>4+ 4C+A6 +G 4C6 V6>F66) MS dC6> 4C676 =A AT3C

=W49 bG=34=+> Z=6@FA 4+ 76?@=4Z R 4C6 F6@=V67Z C?A >+4 566> 6GG6346F)b MT

j6>369 76AF6>4fA +AG67 +G 4C6 FA) O3%?BH

LC=A X?A 4C6 A?W6 =W4 3+>46W PF?) F6 B?7W=6>4+ V) ,6A?3?9 NU => XC=3C 4C6 &+T74 C6@F ?A G+@@+XA_

bLC6 ]T6A4=+> 4C?4 >+X ?7=A6A =A_ OA 4C676 ?>Z A4= => 4C6 A?@6 => ]T6A4=+> G7+W XC=3C X6 3?> =>G67 4C?4 4C6 V6>F+7 F=F

>+4 =>46>F 4+ F6@=V67 +T47=IC4 4C6 +G 4C6 @?>FA 4+ 4C6 V6>F66` d6 G=>F >+>6) 2> 4C6 3+>47?7Z9 =4 3?> 56 3@6?7@Z A66>

4C676=> 4C?4 4C6 V6>F+7 =>46>F6F 4+ F66 => ?34T?@ +G 4C6 @?>FA =WW6F=?46@Z ?A 3?> 56 =>G6776F G7+W

4C6 A4= 4C?4 4C6 V6>F66 f4?U6A ?34T?@ 4C676+G ) ) ) X=4C GT@@ 7=IC4A 4+ F=A^+Z ?>F W?U6 TA6 4C676+G =>

AT3C W?>>67 ?>F G+7W ?A X+T@F 56 W+A4 ?FV?>4?I6+TA 4+ C67A6@G)f LC6 76G6776F 4+ => 4C6 3+>47?34 6V=F6>4@Z 76G67A

4+ ?34T?@ ?>F >+4 W676@Z AZW5+@=3?@ =>G67?5@6 G7+W 4C6 W676 6a63T4=+> +G 4C6 F+3TW6>4)

bj?A 4C6 V6>F+7 3+W+4) %A %74=3@6 8[/.9 4C6 4C=>I A+@F AC?@@ 56F66W6F F6@=V676F XC6> 4C6 V6>F66 =A 4C6 3+>47+@ ?>F 4C676+G9 XC=3C A=4T?4=+> F+6A >+4 C676 +54?=>

563?TA6 G7+W 4C6 6a63T4=+> +G 4C6 A?@6 T< 4+ 4C6 4 4C6 V6>F66 X?A >6V67 ?5@6 4+ 4?U6 +G 4C6 @?>FA FT6 4+ 4C6

=>A=A46>4 76GTA?@ +G S?74=> H6@+A+ 4+ AT776>F67 4C6W 3@?=W=>I +X>67AC=< 4C676+G) %>F ?@4C+TIC =4 =A 4C6 A?W6

?74=3@6 4C?4 4C6 6a63T4=+> +G ? 4 =A 6]T=V?@6>4 4+ F6@=V67Z9 4C=A @6I?@ G=34=+> +>@Z C+@FA 47T6 XC6> 4C676 =A >+

=W4 4C?4 W?Z 4 4C6 FA +G 4C6 V6>F+7 =>4+ 4C+A6 +G 4C6 V6>F66) ) ) ) )b NL

LC6 6a63T4=+> +G ? A47TW6>4 I=V6A 7=A69 4C676G+769 +>@Z 4+ ? 4 =4A6@G 6a46>F6FM +7 XC6> 5Z +4C67 W6?>A =4 =A

AC+X> 4C?4 AT3C F6@=V67Z X?A >+4 6GG6346F9 563?TA6 ? 4C=7F X?A ?34T?@@Z => +G 4C6 4C=>I) O > 4C6 @?4467 3?A69

4C6 A?@6 3?>>+4 56 3+>A=F676F 3+>ATWW?46F) !B?3j&

j+X6V679 4C6 4 W?Z 56 7?=A6F 4C?4 T>F67 %74=3@6 88/[ +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F69 !]T?4+7=?@ ?A 5TZ67 ?3]T=76F ? 7=IC4 4+ 4C6 G7T=4A

+G 4C6 4C=>I A+@F G7+W 4C6 4=W6 4C6 +5@=I?4=+> 4+ F6@=V67 4C6 ET@Z i:9 81\c9 G7+W XC=3C W+W6>4 4C6 @?XA F 36) NN H+6A 4C=A W6?> 4C?4 F6A4 76A3=>F=>I 4C6 A?@69 4C6 7=IC4 4+ 4C6 G7T=4ANO

56@+>I6F 4+9 ?>F 76W?=>6F 6>G+736?5@6 5Z9 !]T?4+7=?@`

%74=3@6 8ic0 +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6 ?>AX67A 4C=A ]T6A4=+> => 4C6 >6I?4=V69 563?TA6 b '7;6A3=AA=+> 376?46A 4C6 +5@=I?4=+> 4+ 764T7> 4C6

4C=>IA XC=3C X676 4C6 +5^634 +G 4C6 3+>47?349 4+I64C67 X=4C 4C6=7 G7T=4A9 ?>F 4C6 4676A4M ) ) ) )b "+4 +>@Z 4C6 @?>F

?>F 5T=@F=>I A+@F9 5T4 ?@A+ 4C6 76>4?@ Z9 C?F 4+ 56 764T7>6F 5Z 4C6 5TZ67)

%>+4C67 4) LC6 H63=A=+> => 4C6 W+4C67 3?A6 A4?46F 4C?4 b!]T?4+7=?@ ) ) ) C?A 7636=V6F 76>4Ab G7+W S?ZG?=7 bFT7=>I ?@@ 4C6

Z6?7A 4C?4 4C=A 3+>47+V67AZ C?A 566> @=4=I?46F)b LC6 B6


16/96

LC6 76>4?@


17/96

Y64=4=+>67fA 3@?=W +G 76?A+>?5@6 3+WA?4=+> G+7 76AF6>4fA TA6 ?>F +33T>+4 56 3+T>46>?>36F) OG =4 ATGG676F ?>Z @+AA9 67 WTA4 56?7 =4 => A=@6>369 A=>36 =4 C?F X7+TIC4 4C?4 @+AA

T =4A6@G) 24C67X=A69 5?F G?=4C X+T@F 56 76X?7F6F =>A46?F +G =AC6F)

d6 T+4 G+7 4C6 76?A+> =4 I?V69 5T4 G+7 g?h 4C6 F g5h

67fA 5?F G?=4C9 ?A ?5+V6 F=A3TAA6F)

B63+>F OAAT6_ (7+T>F => S+4=+> 4+ H=AW=AA

Y7+36FT7?@@Z9 67 3@?=WA 4C?4 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 F6V=?46F G7+W 4C6 ?336F TAT?@ 3+T7A6 +G TF=3=?@ IA XC6>=4 F=AW=AA6F &=V=@ &?A6 "+) 1\-c08[8 +> ? I7+T>F >+4 7?=A6F => 76AF6>4fA S+4=+> 4+ H=AW=AA) d+7A69 =4 ?@@6I6F@Z 5?A6F =4A

F=AW=AA?@ +> ? I7+T>F >+4 ? W+4=+> 4+ F=AW=AA ?A 6>T>3=?46F => 4C6 *T@6A +G &+T74)

d6 ?76 >+4 3+>V=>36F) % 76V=6X +G 76AF6>4fA S+4=+> 4+ H=AW=AA &=V=@ &?A6 "+) 1\- c08[8 AC+XA 4C?4 4C676 X676 4X+

I7+T>FA =>V+U6F9 ?A G+@@+XA_

bg%h Y@?=>4=GG =A IT=@4Z +G G+7TW-AC+4=GGfA 3?TA6 +G ?34=+>9 =G ?>Z9 =A 5?776F 5Z 4)b NT

LC6 3+T74 ? ]T+ 7T@6F9 =>467 ?@=?9 4C?4 4C6 3?TA6 +G ?34=+> +G 67 g4=GG => 4C6 3?A6 56@+Xh C?F 566> 5?776F 5Z ? 4 +G 4C=A &+T74 => (* "+) 8:/:/i9 4C6 W+4C67 3?A6)

%@4C+TIC =4 6776F => =4A =>467 +G 4C6 A?=F H63=A=+> XC6> =4 ?7IT6F 4C?4 4C6 76A3=>F6F H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 X?A

bV+=F9b X6 C+@F9 >+>64C6@6AA9 4C?4 67fA

3?TA6 +G ?34=+> =A =>F66F 5?776F 5Z ? 4 +G 4C=A &+T74) %A ?@76?FZ F=A3TAA6F9 +T7 H63=A=+> => (* "+) 8:/:/i

AC+XA 4C?4 67 =A >+4 6>4=4@6F 4+ 5?3U 76>4?@A9 563?TA6 =4 >6V67 563?W6 4C6 +X>67 +G 4C6 F=AI ?7IT6>F+ 4C?4 4C676 X?A ? V?@=F F6@=V67Z9 67fA 5?F G?=4C >6I?46A =4A 6>4=4@6W6>4

4+ 4C6 3=V=@ G7T=4A +G +X>67AC=4676A4 ?>F 76>4?@A)

K>F67 4C6 F+347=>6 +G 76A ^TF=3?4? +7 5?7 5Z 49 ? W?4467 4C?4 C?A 566> ?F^TF=3?46F 5Z ? 3+T74 +G 3+W4

^T7=AF=34=+> WTA4 56 F66W6F 4+ C?V6 566> G=>?@@Z ?>F 3+>3@TA=V6@Z A644@6F =G =4 ?7=A6A => ?>Z AT5A6]T6>4 @=4=I?4=+> 564X66> 4C6

A?W6 F G+7 4C6 A?W6 3?TA6) OU LCTA9 b'?; G=>?@ TFIW6>4 +> 4C6 W67=4A 76>F676F 5Z ? 3+T74 +G 3+W4

^T7=AF=34=+> =A 3+>3@TA=V6 ?A 4+ 4C6 7=IC4A +G 4C6 F 4C6=7 F 3+>A4=4T46A ?> ?5A+@T46 5?7 4+ AT5A6]T6>4

?34=+>A =>V+@V=>I 4C6 A?W6 3@?=W9 F6W?>F9 +7 3?TA6 +G ?34=+>)b OL *6A ^TF=3?4? =A 5?A6F +> 4C6 I7+T>F 4C?4 b4C6 F AC+T@F >+4 56 )b OM

O4 G766A 4C6 F 76I +G 3+T74 F+3U64A) !]T?@@Z =W49 =4 A4?5=@=e6A 7=IC4A ?>F F >+ >66F 4+ 76I F=A]T=A=4=+>A +> 4C6 G=7A4 =AAT6 4+ AC+X A?4=AG?34=+> +G 4C6 6@6W6>4A +G 76A TF=3?4?)

BTGG=36 =4 4+ A?Z 4C?49 3@6?7@Z9 +T7 7T@=>I => 4C6 W+4C67 3?A6 5?7A 67 G7+W 3@?=W=>I 5?3U 76>4?@A G7+W 76AF6>4)

%@4C+TIC 4C6 3+T74 ? ]T+ 6776F XC6> =4 F63@?76F bV+=F G7+W =>36b 4C6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 564X66> &?7W6@+ ?>F

679 +T7 G+76I+=>I F=A3TAA=+> AT 4+ H=AW=AA +> 4C6 I7+T>F 4C?4 +T7 4 => (*

"+) 8:/:/i C?A ?@76?FZ 76A+@V6F 4C6 =AAT6 +G 5?3U 76>4?@A)

2> 4C6 5?A=A +G 4C6 6V=F6>36 46F FT7=>I 4C6 C6?7=>I +G S?ZG?=7fA S+4=+> 4+ H=AW=AA9 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 G+T>F 4C?4 4C6 =AAT6

+G +X>67AC=< +G 4C6 AT5^634 G?V+7 +G S?ZG?=7) d6 ]T+46 4C6 *L&_

bLC6 BT 4C6 !]T?4+7=?@ 3?A69 ()*) "+) 8:/:/i C?A 3?46I+7=3?@@Z A4?46F 4C?4 4C6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 F?46F ET@Z

i89 81\c C?A 566> 76A3=>F6F AT5^634=>I 4C6 4 3+W4 4+ 76A TF=3?4?) b ON g!W 4C6 +7=I=>?@h

j6>369 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 F63=F6F 4C6 S+4=+> 4+ H=AW=AA +> 4C6 5?A=A +G 76A TF=3?4?9 6V6> =G =4 6776F => =>467I 4C6 W6?>=>I

+G b76A3=>F6Fb ?A 6]T=V?@6>4 4+ bV+=F)b O> AC+749 =4 7T@6F +> 4C6 I7+T>F 7?=A6FM >?W6@Z9 5?7 5Z 4) $Z I7?>4=>I 4C6

S+4=+>9 =4 F=A =G =4A @6I?@ 76?A+> G+7 >T@@=GZ=>I 4C6 A?@6 X?A X7+>I) LC6 3+77634 76?A+>A ?76 I=V6> => 4C=A

H63=A=+>)


18/96

dj!*!J2*!9 4C6 Y64=4=+> =A C6765Z H!"O!H) &+A4A ?I?=>A4 67) %H&L?3

B2 2*H!*!H) H?V=F69 E7)9 &)E)9 lT=ATW5=>I9 Y?7F+9 $T6>?9 Q>?76A-B?>4=?I+ ?>F &?73T7) S6@+9 E)9 3T77=>I +=+>) YT>+ ?>F S6>F+e?9 EE)9 3+>3T7 ?>F ^+=> 4C6 3+>3T77=>I +=+> +G E) S6@+) $6@@+A=@@+9 E)9 ^+=> 4C6 F=AA6>4=>I

+=+> +G E) B?>F+V?@-(T4=6776e) P=4TI9 E)9 4=>I +=+>) N??>9 E)9 O ^+=> 4C6 F=AA6>4=>I +=+>A +G EE) P=4TI

?>F B?>F+V?@-(T4=6776e) H6 ,6+>9 E7)9 E)9 ^+=> 4C6 F=AA6>4=>I +=+> +G E) P=4TI) B?>F+V?@-(T4=6776e9 E)9 4=>I

+=+>)

A&V()($& 3T77=>I +=+>_

dC=@6 O 6aG+7W=4Z 4+ 4C6 6>3=? +G +T7 F=A4=>IT=AC6F 3+@@6?IT69 S7) ETA4=36 %746W=+ P) Y?>I?>=5?>9 O X+T@F TA4

@=U6 4+ W?U6 4C6 G+@@+X=>I +5A67V?4=+>A_

8) LC6 =AAT6 => 4C=A 3?A6 X?A A]T?76@Z 76A+@V6F => +T7 811/ !> $?>3 F63=A=+> => 4C6 W?=> 3?A6) dC?4 67 =A ?AU=>I TA 4+

F+ >+X =A 4+ 76V67A6 +7 W+F=GZ ? ^TFIW6>4 XC=3C =A ?33T7?46 => 6V67Z 76AG+7W?5@6 4+ @?X ?>F ^T7=A369 ?>F

G?=4CGT@ 4+ 3=6AA ?>F ^TA4=36)

.) Y64=4=+>67fA AT5W=AA=+>A ?76 F636=V=>I) O4 =A 47Z=>I 4+ 3+@@634 T>^TA4=G=6F ?>F T>56@=6V?5@Z =>376?A6F 76>4?@A 5Z I ?

9 ?A G?7 ?A 76AF6>4 =A 3+>367>6F9 +G ? >+>-?47?34A)

i) L+ I7?>4 4C6 =A 4+ 76X?7F 5?F G?=4C9 G+7 67 C?A F64 +G 4C6 @?4467fA F C?A G+736F =4 4+ F6G6>F =4A =>4676A4A => 3?A6 ?G467 3?A6 FT7=>I 4C?4 @6>I4CZ 67 >+X

47=6A 4+ =>G@=34 GT74C67 =>^T7Z => 4C6 G?>4?A4=3 ?>F I7+T>F@6AA ?W+T>4 +G Y88091[\9c/\)::) L+ 76W?>F 4C=A 3?A6 4+ 4C6 @+X673+T74 => +7F67 4+ F6467W=>6 4C6 5?3U 76>4?@A ?@@6I6F@Z FT6 4+ 67 !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z H6V6@+4 &+79 O>3) =A 4+

6>3+T7?I6 3+>4=>T?4=+> +G 37?G4Z 4?34=3A ?>F 4+ ?@@+X 4C6 GT74C67 F=AA=F 76A+T736A)

LC6 =>A4?>4 ?7+A6 G7+W ? 3+W4 G+7 5?3U 76>4?@A9 =>376?A6F 76>4?@A ?>F =>4676A4A G=@6F 5Z 67 !]T?4+7=?@

*6?@4Z H6V6@+49 O>3) g!]T?4+7=?@h ?I?=>A4 76AF6>4 S?ZG?=7 LC6?4679 O>3) gS?ZG?=7h) O4 C?A 4+ 56 ?F^TF=3?46F => 4C6

3+>46a4 +G 4C766 6?7@=67 A F63=F6F 5Z 4C=A &+T74)

% F=A 4C6 4X+ F 5T=@F=>I ?@+>I &@?7+ S) *634+ %V6>T6 =>

S?>=@? C?A @6F 4+ .i Z6?7A +G 9 =>3@TF=>I 4C6 G=@=>I +G [ A X=4C 4C6 &+T749 >?W6@Z9 ()*) "+) ,-

8:/:/i9 F63=F6F +> "+V6W567 .89 811/ g./[ B&*% [cihM ()*) "+) 8:ii88 F63=F6F +> S?73C [9 811.M ()*) "+) 8i/..89

F63=F6F +> S?Z 8.9 .:::M ?>F 4C6 4 9 ()*) "+) 8iic\1)

LC6 3?A6 ?4 5?7 =A ? 3@?AA=3 =@@TA47?4=+> +G C+X ? FT5=+TA =>467 +G 4C6 F=A G+767 3+T@F @6?F 4+ 0 W+76 Z6?7A +G 5=4467 @=4=I?4=+> ?G467 4C6 =>=4=?@ 8c Z6?7A +G @6I?@ IA +V67 4C6 G=7A4 3?A6)

,6?A6 3+>47?34A +V67 4C6 AT5^634 6 89 81/\ ?>F S?73C i89 81/1 5Z +7=I=>?@ +X>67 &?7W6@+ ?>F

$?T67W?>>9 O>3) g&?7W6@+h => G?V+7 +G C676=> 76AF6>4 S?ZG?=7) LC6 @6?A6A 6a S?Z i89 81c\ ?>F S?73C i89 81c19

76A47?34A 6W5+F=6F A I=V=>I S?ZG?=7 ? 7=IC4- +G-G=7A4-76GTA?@ AC+T@F &?7W6@+ A6@@ 4C6

?34 3C?7?3467=e6F ?A 5?F G?=4C 5Z 4C=A &+T749 4C6 +G 4C6 7=IC4-+G-G=7A4-76GTA?@9 X?A A+@F 5Z &?7W6@+

4+ C676=> 67 !]T?4+7=?@9 +> ET@Z i89 81\c G+7 Y889i::9:::)::) 2> B6>T@W6>4 +G 4C6 3+>47?34 +G A?@69 AF F?W?I6A) LC6 *6I=+>?@

L7=?@ &+T74 g*L&h +G S?>=@? F63=F6F 4C6 3?A6 => G?V+7 +G !]T?4+7=?@ +> J657T?7Z \9 8118) &+T>4673@?=WA G+7 3+WA?4=+>

?7=A=>I G7+W 4C6 TA6 +G 4C6 )

2> ET>6 .i9 811.9 4C6 &+T74 +G %I 4+ 4C6 G=7A4 9 ()*) "+) 8:/:/i9 G=@6F

?I?=>A4 S?ZG?=7 5Z 5+4C !]T?4+7=?@ ?>F &?7W6@+)

2> "+V6W567 .89 811/9 4C=A &+T74 !> $?>3 76>F676F =4A F63=A=+> g./[ B&*% [ci '811/;h9 F=AI_

dj!*!J2*!9 4C6 G+7 76V=6X +G 4C6 F63=A=+> +G 4C6 &+T74 +G % &%-()*) &P "+) i.18c9 =A

j!*!$Q H!"O!H) LC6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 564X66> 67A !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z H6V6@+49 O>3) ?>F &?7W6@+ D

$?T67W?>>9 O>3) =A C6765Z 76A3=>F6FM 67 &?7W6@+ D $?T67W?>> =A +7F676F 4+ 764T7> 4+ 67 !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z

H6V6@+4 4C6 4A >636AA?7Z 4+ 764T7> +X>67AC=> +G 4C6 F=AF $?T67W?>> =A +7F676F 4+ ?@@+X S?ZG?=7 LC6?4679 O>3) 4+ 5TZ 4C6

?G+76A?=F @+4A G+7 Y889i::9:::)::) OB3?%!


19/96

O> 4C6 &+T74 +G %


20/96

O> =4A F63=A=+> F?46F S?Z 8.9 .:::9 => ()*) "+) 8i/..8 gJ=7A4 H=V=A=+>9 9 ?>F

Q>?76A-B?>4=?I+9 EE)9 3+>3T77=>Ih9 4C=A &+T74 76=467?46F 4C6 TFIW6>4 => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i) O4 6W

?X?7F=>I 4C6 I ?44?=>6F G=>?@=4Z9 4C676 X?A >+4C=>I @6G4 G+7 4C6

F?46A +G 4C6 F63=A=+>) %OBj3H

O> 4C6 F=A G+@@+X=>I A47=34@Z 4C6 467WAb

+G 4C6 811/ F63=A=+>) j+X6V679 ?A 6?7@=67 A4?46F9 4C=A 3+T@F >+4 56 F+>6 563?TA6 &?7W6@+ C?F 36?A6F 4+ 6a=A4) LC676 X?A >+

@+>I67 ?>Z &?7W6@+ XC=3C 3+T@F 764T7> 4C6 Y889i::9:::):: 3+>A=F67?4=+> +G 4C6 81\c A?@6 4+ !]T?4+7=?@ ?A +7F676F => 4C6

F=A) !]T?4+7=?@ 3+T@F >+4 ?>F X+T@F >+4 ?@A+ 6a63T46 4C6 F66FA 764T7>=>I 4C6 ) "6=4C67 3+T@F 4C6 F6GT>34 &?7W6@+ A6@@ 4C6 G+7


21/96

S?ZG?=7) %@@ 4C6 3=73TWA4?>36A 4 4+ ? 3?@3T@?46F ?>F 3+>47=V6F +G >+>-3+W36 X=4C 4C6 ?I766W6>4 +G G=7A4 76GTA?@)

2> 4C6 >+4 56 ? 5TZ67 => I++F G?=4C 563?TA6 =4 5+TIC4 4C6 F GT@@ U>+X@6FI6

4C6 S?ZG?=7 C?F ? 7=IC4 4+ +7 =>4676A4 => 4C6 3+>A3=6>4=+TA

?FV?>4?I6 +G S?ZG?=7)

"6=4C67 W?Z &?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@ ?V?=@ +G 3+>A=F67?4=+> 5?A6F +> 6]T=4Z XC=3C W=IC4 X?77?>4 4C6 I7?>4 +G =>4676A4A) LC6

V6>F+7 7636=V6F ?A F G?=7 3+W6 +7 =>4676A4 G7+W 4C6 ?W+T>4) !]T?4+7=?@9 +> 4C6 +4C67 C?>F9 C?A 7636=V6F 76>4A

?>F +4C67X=A6 I ?@@ 4C6 Z6?7A 4C?4 4C=A3+>47+V67AZ X?A 56=>I @=4=I?46F) S?ZG?=7 =>G67=+7 7=IC4 4+ 4+ Z =>4676A4A ?7=A=>I G7+W 4C=A ^TFIW6>4 4+ 6=4C67 &?7W6@+ +7 !]T?4+7=?@ g./[

B&*% [ci9 3T77=>I +=+> => +T7 811/ F63=A=+> +G S7) ETA4=36 L6+F+7+ *) Y?F=@@? ?A G+@@+XA_

LC6 6]T=4=6A +G 4C6 3?A6 ATI 4C6 =>467V6>=>I Z6?7A 564X66> 8 %TITA4 81\c ?>F

4C=A F?469 !]T?4+7=?@ g?G467 ?3]T=7=>I 4C6 &)S) *634+ 4?@ =>3+W6 4C676G7+W) O> G?349 +>6 +G 4C6 @6AA66A => 4C6 9 566>

TA=>I 4C6 V6A4W6>4-X=A6 ?>Fn+7 + X=A6 => =4A +X> 5TA=>6AA) 3B?%H&

O4 W?Z ? AT5W=446F 5Z 4C=A +=+>9 563?TA6 4C6 XC6> 4C6 A?W6 ?W+T>4 X?A


22/96

%74T7+ S) L+@6>4=>+9 &=V=@ &+F6 +G 4C6 YC=@=I S?>76A?M OP !FI?7F+ ,) Y?7?A9 &=V=@ &+F6 +G 4C6

YC=@=+4 4+ ?I766 X=4C 4C6 6a?4=+>A +G S?ZG?=79 4+ X=4_

[)..) %A ? 3+>A6]T6>36 +G 4C6 76A3=AA=+> +G 4C6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@69 =4 X?A ?A =G !]T?4+7=?@ >6V67 5+TIC4 ?>F 563?W6 4C6

@6AA+7 +G 4C6 AT5^634 7T@=>I 4C?4 !]T?4+7=?@ =A >+4 4C6 +X>67 ?>F F+6A >+4 C?V6

?>Z 7=IC4 4+ F6W?>F 5?3U 76>4?@A G7+W '4C6; AT5^634 +9 AT => ?> ?33=+> ? 7647+?34 4+ 4C6 F?46XC6> 4C6 376F=4 +7 7=IC4 56=>I 6>G+736F X?A ?3]T=76F)

bdC=@6 =4 =A >636AA?7Z 4C?4 4C6 376F=4 +G 4C6 4=GG => 4C6 ?33=+> ? WTA4 56 4 ?@=6>?4=+>9 4C6 F?46

+G 4C6 TFIW6>4 6>G+73=>I =4 =A =WW?467=?@) !V6> =G 4C6 TFIW6>4 56 AT5A6]T6>4 4+ 4C6 ?@=6>?4=+>9 =4 =A W676@Z F63@?7?4+7Z9 X=4C

7647+?34=V6 6GG634 4+ 4C6 F?46 XC6> 4C6 376F=4 X?A 3+>A4=4T46F) ) ) )b g6W>=V=>I F &?7W6@+9 G7+W 56>6G=4=>I => ?>Z

W?>>67 G7+W 4C6=7 T>@?XGT@ ?34 +G 6>467=>I =>4+ ? 3+>47?34 => G7?TF +G =>>+36>4


23/96

d6 7T@6F 4C?4 563?TA6 +G 5?F G?=4C9 >6=4C67 W?Z &?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@ ?V?=@ 4C6WA6@V6A +G 3+>A=F67?4=+>A 5?A6F +> 6]T=4Z

XC=3C W=IC4 X?77?>4 4C6 I7?>4 +G =>4676A4A ?>F9 => 4C=A 3?A69 T>3+>A3=+>?5@Z =>376?A6F 76>4?@A)

P67=@Z9 =G S?ZG?=7 X676 ? >?4T7?@ =4 3+T@F V67Z X6@@ C?V6 ?AU6F G+7 W+7?@ F?W?I6A =>A46?F +G G?3=>I ? @6>I4CZ ?>F

6aA=V6 AT=4 4+ Z 4=W6A C=IC67 4C?> 4C+A6 A4= 4C6 3+>47?34 +G @6?A6) K>F67 4C6 &=V=@ &+F69 S?ZG?=7 =A

4C6 V=34=W => ? 576?3C +G 3+>47?34 X C676 &?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@ ?346F G7?TFT@6>4@Z ?>F => 5?F G?=4C)

&+>A=F67=>I 4C6 TFIW6>4A => +T7 i 6?7@=67 F63=A=+>A9 S?ZG?=7 =A T>F67 >+ +5@=I?4=+> 4+ Z =>4676A4A9 XC64C67 5?A6F +>

@?X +7 6]T=4Z9 4+ &?7W6@+ +7 !]T?4+7=?@) S?ZG?=7 =A 4C6 X7+>I6F 6>4=4Z9 4C6 +>6 XC=3C C?A ATGG676F =>^T7Z A=>36 81\c +7 G+7

4C6 .i Z6?7A =4 X?A F66G=4A G7+W 4C6 TA6 +G 4C6 4A ?>F 56>6G=4A

XC=3C X+T@F C?V6 ?337T6F 4+ S?ZG?=7 =G =4A 7=IC4A C?F >+4 566> V=+@?46F)

LC676 =A >+ +5@=I?4=+> +> 4C6 Z =>376?A6F9 ?FF=4=+>?@9 5?3U +7 GT4T76 76>4?@A +7 =>4676A4A

+G ?>Z U=>F 4+ 67 !]T?4+7=?@ T>F67 4C6 3=73TWA4?>36A +G 4C=A 3?A6)

O9 4C676G+769 3+>3T7 X=4C 4C6 W?^+7=4Z +=+> => F6>Z=>I FT6 3+T7A6 ?>F F=AW=AA=>I

4C6 )

K!DEH9 E)9 F=AA6>4=>I +=+>_

&=V=@ ,?X9 => =4A TAT?@ A+9 3@?AA=G=6A F6G634=V6 3+>47?34A gT>@=U6 4C6 A66W=>I@Z I6>67=3 476?4W6>4 => &+WW+> ,?Xh9

=>4+9 G=7A49 4C6 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34A9 L XC=3C ?76 4C6 @6?A4 =>G=7WM G+@@+X6F 5Z9 A63+>F9 4C6 V+=F?5@6 3+>47?34AM M 4C6>9 4C=7F9 4C6

T>6>G+736?5@6 3+>47?34AM N ?>F9 G=>?@@Z9 G+T74C9 4C6 X+7A4 +G ?@@ +7 4C6 V+=F 3+>47?34A)O O> 467WA +G 4C6=7 6GG=3?3=+TA>6AA9

76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34A ?76 76I?7F6F9 ?W+>I 4C6 G+T79 ?A 56=>I 4C6 3@+A6A4 4+ 47?34A) % 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34

3+>4?=>A ?@@ 4C6 76]T=A=46A +G ? V?@=F 3+>47?34 ?>F ?76 3+>A=F676F @6I?@@Z 5=>F=>I9 5T4 5Z 76?A+> +G =>^T7Z +7 F?W?I6 4+ 6=4C67

+G 4C6 3+>47?34=>I 36 +G 4C6


24/96

@6AA669 +7 G+7 4C?4 W?4467 +G ?>Z +X>679 X+T@F >+4 G67W6>4 +G

+X >67AC=< T 4C6 +7 56 ?> =W4 G7+W 4C6 47?>AG67 +G +X>67AC=< G7+W 4C6 A6@@67 4+ 4C6 5TZ67) Y64=4=+>679

56=>I 4C6 +X>67 +G 4C6 +>6 +4C67h T>4=@ 4C6 ^TF=3=?@ 76A3=AA=+> +G 4C6 A?@6 => =4A G?V+79 X?A 6>4=4@6F 4+ ?@@

=>3=F6>4A +G +X>67AC=< =>3@TA=V6 +G9 ?W+>I =4A +4C67 6@6W6>4A9 4C6 7=IC4 4+ 4C6 G7T=4A +G 4C6 4?@ V?@T6

+V67 4C?4 F=A I++F G?=4C +7 => 5?F G?=4C)

d=4C ?@@ FT6 76A?5@6 4+ ^+=> => 4C=A =>A4?>36 WZ 3+@@6?IT6A => 4C6 W?^+7=4Z)

A7=;GHED!-88-F9 E)9 F=AA6>4=>I +=+>_

bB4?76 F63=A=A 64 >+> ]T=64? W+V676 R G+@@+X F F+ >+4 F=A4T75 XC?4 C?A 566> A644@6F) %FC676>36 4+ 4C=A

3= A4?5=@=4Z => T7=A36)

O 76I764 4C?4 O ?W T>?5@6 4+ ?I766 X=4C 4C6 W?^+7=4Z +=+>)

LC6 3=F =>6GG634=V6 G7+W =4A =>36) LC=A =AAT6 =A >+4 ?

>+V6@ +>6) "6=4C67 =A =4 F=GG=3T@4 4+ 76A+@V6 ?A =4 =>V+@V6A 4C6 ?4?7Z 3= 4C6 @?X +> 3+>47?34A9

A 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34A9 ?A F=A4=>IT=AC6F G7+W V+=F +7 =>6a=A46>4 3+>47?34A)

LC6 G?34A ?76 A=W ET>6 89 81/\9 76AF6>4 S?ZG?=7 LC6?4679 O>3) gS?ZG?=7h @6?A6F A +G 4C6 I7+T>F9 W6ee?>=>6 ?>F A63+>F G@++7A +G ?

4X+ A4+76Z 3+WW673=?@ 5T=@F=>I @+3?46F ?@+>I &)S) *634+ %V6>T69 S?>=@?) LC6 5T=@F=>I 4+I64C67 X=4C 4C6 @?>F +> XC=3C =4 X?A

3+>A47T346F X?A 4C6> +X>6F 5Z &?7W6@+ D $?T67W?>>9 O>3) g&?7W6@+h) *6AF6>4 TA6F 4C6A6 S?73C i89 81/19 S?ZG?=7 @6?A6F G7+W &?7W6@+ ?>+4C67 +G 4C6 A63+>F G@++79 ?A X6@@ ?A 4X+ g.h A4+76 AF W6ee?>=>6 G@++7A +G 4C6

A?W6 5T=@F=>I) *6AF6>4 S?ZG?=7 TA6F 4C6 +X> ?A bS=7?W?7 LC6?467)b

$+4C @6?A6A 3+>4?=>6F 4C6 G+@@+X=>I =F6>4=3?@ A_

bLC?4 =G 4C6 ,!BB2* AC+T@F F6A=76 4+ A6@@ 4C6 @6?A6F i:-F?ZA 6a3@TA=V6 + 4+ 4C6 6V6>49 C+X6V679 4C?4 4C6 @6?A6F 6 +4C67 4C?> 4C6 ,!BB!!9 4C6 ,!BB2* =A 5+T>F ?>F

+5@=I?46F9 ?A =4 C6765Z 5=>FA ?>F +5@=I?46A =4A6@G9 4+ A4= 4C6 H66F +G B?@6 4C676+G 4C?4 4C6 =e6

4C=A @6?A6 ?>F 56 5+T>F 5Z ?@@ 4C6 467WA ?>F 3+>F=4=+>A 4C676+G)

2> ET@Z i89 81\c9 &?7W6@+ 6>4676F =>4+ ? H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 XC6765Z =4 A+@F 4C6 AT5^634 @?>F ?>F 4X+-A4+76Z 5T=@F=>I 4+

67 !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z H6V6@+49 O>3) g!]T?4+7=?@h G+7 Y889i::9:::)::) j?V=>I ?3]T=76F G7+W &?7W6@+ +X>67AC=< +G

4C6 AT5^634 4@Z9 S?ZG?=79 3@?=W=>I =4 C?F 566> F6>=6F =4A 7=IC4 4+ 47?34A X=4C &?7W6@+9 G=@6F X=4C 4C6 *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T749 $7?>3C \9 S?>=@?9 ? AT=4 G+7 AF ?>>T@W6>4 +G A?@6 X=4C G+736 =4A b6a3@TA=V6 + 4+ F9 ?>F &?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@ +> 4C6 +4C679 76?3C6F 4C=A &+T74 => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i9

b!]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z H6V6@+49 O>3) D &?7W6@+ D $?T67W?>>9 O>3) VA) S?ZG?=7 LC6?4679 O>3)b L 2> "+V6W567 .89 811/9 4C=A

&+T74 76>F676F ? H63=A=+>9 4C6 F=A +G 4C6 &+T74 +G % &%-()*) &P "+) i.18c9

=A j!*!$Q H!"O!H) LC6 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 564X66> 67A !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z H6V6@+49 O>3) ?>F &?7W6@+ D

$?T67W?>>9 O>3) =A C6765Z F66W6F 76A3=>F6FM &?7W6@+ D $?T67W?>> =A +7F676F 4+ 764T7> 4+ 67 !]T?4+7=?@ *6?@4Z

H6V6@+4 4C6 4A >636AA?7Z 4+ 764T7> +X>67AC=> +G 4C6 F=A> =A +7F676F 4+ ?@@+X S?ZG?=7 LC6?4679 O>3) 4+ 5TZ 4C6

?G+76A?=F @+4A G+7 Y889i::9:::)::)


25/96

B2 2*H!*!H)b

LC6 H63=A=+> +G 4C=A &+T74 => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i 563?W6 G=>?@ ?>F 6a63T4+7Z +> S?73C 8\9 811\)

2> % G+7 6a63T4=+> XC=3C X?A I7?>46F)

j+X6V679 &?7W6@+ 3+T@F >+ @+>I67 56 @+3?46F) LCTA9 S?ZG?=7 F6


26/96

?>F 3+>A47T34=V6 F6@=V67Z +G 4C6 F=AF => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i LU 4C?49 b>+ 7=IC4 +G

+X>67AC=< X?A 47?>AG6776F G7+W &?7W6@+ 4+ !]T?4+7=?@ => V=6X +G ?


27/96

+)

LC6 G?34 4C?4 S?ZG?=7 C?A 76W?=>6F => b?34T?@ +G 4C6

&?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@ T< 4+ 4C6 G=>?@=4Z +G 4C=A &+T74fA H63=A=+> => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i g?>F 6V6> T< 4+ 4C6 4h9 3+T@F >+4

4 4C6 3+>ATWW?4=+> +G AT3C 3+>47?34) %A O C?V6 4=W?46F9 S?ZG?=7fA =A >+4 T>F67 ? 3@?=W +G

+X>67AC=>+4 => ?>Z X?Z 3@?AC X=4C 4C6 +X>67AC=< ?337T=>I 4+ !]T?4+7=?@ 5Z V=74T6 +G 4C6 A?@6) LC6 3= 4C?4 4C6 +>6 XC+ +X@6FI6A => ?>+4C67 ? AT67AC=?>4 I @6?A6F ?A ? W676 C+@F679 A+ F+6A 4C6 TATG7T34T?7Z +G 4C6 4C=>I => TATG7T34M ?>F 4C6 5+77+X67 +G 4C64C=>I @+?>6F => 3+WW+F?4TW) "+>6 +G 4C6A6 C+@F67A ?AA674A ? 3@?=W +G +X>67AC=< => C=WA6@G +V67 4C6 4C=>I) B=W=@?7@Z9 S?ZG?=7

F+6A >+4 3@?=W +X>67AC=@Z ?A ? @6AA66 X=4C 4C6 4=@ S?ZG?=7 ?34T?@@Z 6a673=A6F XC?4 =4 X?A ?@@+X6F 4+ F+ 5Z 4C=A

&+T74 => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i9 A =W4 => 4C6 3+>ATWW?4=+> +G 4C6 3+>47?34 564X66>

&?7W6@+ ?>F !]T?4+7=?@`

Y674=>6>4@Z9 =4 F+6A >+4 ?@X?ZA G+@@+X 4C?49 563?TA6 ? 47?>A?34=+> =A 4C6 A?34=+>9 F+6A >+4 AG67+7 4+ 4C6 V6>F669 F+>66 +7 47?>AG6766) ML

%>F 4C=7F9 3+>G+7W?5@Z 4+ 4C6 G+76I+=>I F=A]T=A=4=+>9 O W?=>4?=> 4C?4 !]T?4+7=?@ C?A 4C6 7=IC4 4+ 56 V) &+T74 +G

%


28/96

?A=F6 4C6 ?34 +7 3+>47?34 G+7 ^TA4=G=?5@6 76?A+>A +G 6]T=4Z)b MR

"636AA?7=@Z9 4C676G+769 ? 76A3=AA=5@6 3+>47?34 76W?=>A V?@=F ?>F 5=>F=>I T 4C6 ?47?349 XC=3C =A 476?46F => %74=3@6A 8[:1 4C7+TIC 8[.. +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F69 =A =>6a=A46>4 ?>F

+ @6I?@ 6GG634 XC?4A+6V67) LC6 3+>47?34=>I F AT3C 3+>47?34 =A >+4 AT5^634 4+

7?4=G=3?4=+>)

O> F=AW=AA=>I 67 !]T?4+7=?@fA 3+W4 => &=V=@ &?A6 "+) 1\-c08[89 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 X?A ?Z +4C67

W6?>=>I) LC6 A?=F H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 =A V+=F ?4 =4A =>36)

aaa aaa aaa

LC6 AT5^634 H66F +G %5A+@T46 B?@6 C?V=>I 566> 76A3=>F6F 5Z 4C6 BT+4 4C6 +X>67 ?>F F+6A >+4

C?V6 ?>Z 7=IC4 4+ F6W?>F

5?3U 76>4?@A G7+W AT5^634 +X>67 3?> 6>^+Z 4C6 G7T=4A +G ? 3674?=> 3@TF6A 4C6 7=IC4 4+ 7636=V6 G7+W AT5^634 6Z 764=>I 76>4?@A ?>F 76?A+>?5@6 3+WA?4=+>)

%4 4C=A 49 O WTA4 76=467?46 4C?4 !]T?4+7=?@ ET@Z i89

81\c) dC=@6 4C6 3+>47?34 +G A?@6 X?A bF66W6F 76A3=>F6Fb 5Z 4C=A &+T74 => ()*) "+) 8:/:/i9 >6V674C6@6AA 4C6 A?@6 C?F

76W?=>6F V?@=F ?>F 5=>F=>I 564X66> 4C6 3+>47?34=>I


29/96

8) % @6AA+79 => ? 3+>47?34 +G A?@69 3?>>+4 47?>AG67 +X>67AC=< +G C=A


30/96

$+4C


31/96

LC6 TFIW6>4 +G 4C6 @+X67 3+T74 =A ?33+7F=>I@Z W+F=G=6F 5Z 6@=W=>?4=>I 4C676G7+W 4C6 76A67V?4=+> W?F6 => G?V+7 +G 4C6

F6G6>F?>4- ? ?@@ +4C67 76A36W6>4 76I?7F=>I 3+A4A) B+ +7F676F)

%V?>36o?9 &)E)9 P=@@?-*6?@9 OWF H=?e9 EE)9 3+>3T7)

J++4>+46A

8) Y7+WT@I?46F H636W567 /9 81i:9 >+4 76


32/96

bg.h LC?4 4C6 F6G6>F?>4A ?76 6>4=4@6F 4+ C+@F 4C6 +G 4C6 76A=F6>4=?@ @+4 T>4=@ ?G467 4C6Z ?76 F I7?>?7=6A 676346F 4C676+>9 T>@6AA 4C6 4=GGA 4=?@ @+49 => XC=3C 3?A6

F6G6>F?>4A AC?@@ F ?33+7F=>I 4+ !aC=5=4 $M ?>F

bgih LC?4 T F6G6>F?>4fA G?=@T76 4+ 4=?@ @+4 => ]T6A4=+>9 A?=F F6G6>F?>4A AC?@@ 76W+V6 4C6=7 C+TA6A ?>F

I7?>?7=6A ?G467 4C=A F63=A=+> 563+W6A G=>?@ ?>F X=4C=> 4C6 G+7W6F

=> X7=4=>I +G 4C6 ?44=4TF6 +G 4C6


33/96

=> 4C6 =>A4?>4 3?A6)

J+7 ?@@ 4C6 G+76I+=>I9 4C6 X7=4 +G 6a63T4=+> =AAT6F 5Z ETFI6 "?4=V=F?F =A C6765Z A64 ?A=F6 ?>F 4C6 @+X67 3+T74 +7F676F 4+ C+@F

? C6?7=>I => 4C6 3=F +G 4C6 76A=F6>4=?@ @+4 XC676 4C6Z ?76

676346F9 ?A X6@@ ?A 4C6 XC=3C 4C6 4=GGA-76AF6>4A W?Z 6a673=A6 4C6=7 + 6=4C67 4+ F9 ?>F9 => 4C6 @?A4 =>A4?>369 4C6 XC=3C 4C6 F6G6>F?>4A-67A W?Z F9 ?@@ 4C6A6 46F G7+W 4C6 F?46 4C6 TFIW6>4 563+W6A 6a63T4+7Z +7 T>?F67 ? G=>?@ TFIW6>4 ?33+7F=>I 4+ 4C6 6V=F6>36 46F 5Z 4C6


34/96

C?>F9 !*"!BL2 46A4=G=6F 4C?4 4C6 4C6> 3+A4 +G 4C6 *!BOH!"LO%, j2KB! X+T@F 56 G7+W Yi:9:::):: 4+ Y[:9:::)::) LC6 G=IT76A

X 676 >+4 ]T6A4=+>6F 5Z B%*SO!"L2)

LC6 ST>=3=


35/96

dj!*!J2*!9 4C6 Y64=4=+> G+7 &674=+7?7= =A C6765Z +7F676F F=AW=AA6F9 X=4C+T4 +T>36W6>4 ?A 4+ 3+A4A)

B2 2*H!*!H) L66C?>U669 Y@?>?9 *6@+V?9 (T4=6776e9 E7) ?>F H6 @? JT6>469 EE )9 3+>3T7)

JO*BL HOPOBO2"

'()*) "+) ,-0\i[c) S?Z 8/9 81c0);

C87=:!A:< ;-B879 4=GG -?4-?67+A G+7 4=GG-?


36/96

>T@@ ?>F V+=F?5 =>=4=+ 563?TA6 =4A ^T7=AF=34=+> =A @=W=46F 4+ 4C6 A+@6 =AAT6 +G 9 XC676?A F63=A=+>A ?GG634=>I @6?A69

XC=3C =A ?> 6>3TW57?>36 +> 76?@ F676F 5Z &+T74A +G J=7A4 O>A4?>36)

%FF76AA=>I +T7A6@V6A 4+ 4C6 =AAT6 +G V?@=F=4Z +G 4C6 H63=A=+> +G 4C6 ST>=3=F V+=F) LC6

^TFIW6>4 => ? F64?=>67 3?A6 =A 6GG634=V6 => 76A@Z gB63) \9 *T@6 \:9 *T@6A +G &+T74h) L LC6 ST>=3=


37/96

4C6 +9 T>F67 ?74=3@6 i/8 g>+X %74=3@6 [[ch9 6=4C67 4+ F 4+ 4C6 +X>67 +G 4C6 5T=@F=>I)

$T4 C6 3?>>+49 ?A 76AF6>4A C676 F=F 76GTA6 5+4C 4+ F 4+ A6@@ 4C6 @?>F ?>F 3+W67 +G 4C6

5T=@F=>I 4+ 76W+V6 =4 G7+W 4C6 @?>F XC676 =4 676346F) j6 =A 6>4=4@6F 4+ AT3C 76W+4=+> +>@Z XC6>9 ?G467 C?V=>I 3C+A6> 4+ A6@@

C=A @?>F9 4C6 +4C67


38/96

A66 &?57?@9 64 ?@ VA) O5?o6e 'B)&); 0. 2GG) (?e) .8\M S?7G+7= VA) P6@?A3+9 '&)%); 0. 2GG) (?e) .:0:h)b S

dj!*!J2*!9 4C6 ^TFIW6>4 +G 4C6 47=?@ &+T74 =A C6765Z A64 ?A=F69 ?>F 4C=A 3?A6 =A C 6 7 6 5 Z + 7 F 6 7 6 F 7 6 W ? > F 6 F 4 + 4 C 6

* 6 I = + > ? @ L7 = ? @ & + T 7 4 + G O @ + = @ + G + 7 G T 7 4 C 6 7 IA 3+>A=A46>4 X=4C %74=3@6A [[c ?>F 0[/ +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F69 ?A

G+@@+XA_

8) LC6 47=?@ &+T74 AC?@@ F6467W=>6 R

8)

?h 4C6 4 G?=7 FM

.)5h 4C6 ?W+T>4 +G 4C6 6aA6A A4 5Z HKS,%2 G+7 4C6 5T=@F=>I +G

4C6 U=43C6>M

3h 4C6 =>376?A6 => V?@T6 gb 4C676+G9 ?>F

Fh XC64C67 4C6 V?@T6 +G A?=F ?76? +G @?>F =A 3+>A=F67?5@Z W+76 4C?> 4C?4 +G 4C6 U=43C6> 5T=@4 4C676+>)

.) *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T74 AC?@@ 76>F67 ^TFIW6>49 ?A G+@@+XA_

%G467 A?=F ?W+T>4A AC?@@ C?V6 566> F6467W=>6F 5Z 3+W4 6V=F6>369 4C6

?h LC6 47=?@ &+T74 AC?@@ I7?>4 H!Y*% ? g80h F?ZA X=4C=> XC=3C 4+ 6a673=A6 C=A + T>F67 4C6 @?X g%74=3@6[[c9 &=V=@ &+F6h9 XC64C67 4+ ?


39/96

LjO*H HOPOBO2"

'()*) "+) 8:cc1[) J657T?7Z 8:9 811\);

D-:=!BB!=-A 07=EC7:DE8!=H : 67 F G7+W Y?7=e O

>FTA47=6A9 4C6 5T=@F=>IA ?>F +4C67 A47T34T76A X676 ?@76?FZ => 6a=A46>36) LC6 763+7F =A >+4 3@6?7 ?A 4+ XC+ ?34T?@@Z 5T=@4 4C+A6

A47T34T76A9 5T4 =4 W?Z X6@@ 56 ?AATW6F 4C?4 67fA - =>4676A49 Y?7=e O>FTA47=6A9 F=F A+) %74=3@6 0.\ +G 4C6

&=V=@ &+F6 F A=>36 >+ 37+?3CW6>4 +V67 ? >?77+X9 >66F@6- AC?F X?A F+>6 => 5?F G?=4C 5Z 4C6 5T=@F67 +G 4C6 6>37+?3C=>I A47T34T76A9 4C6 @?4467 AC+T@F 56

I++F G?=4C) O4 =A 4=>T6A 4+ 56 6>^+Z6F => 4C6 A?W6 3C?7?3467 =>

XC=3C =4 X?A ?3]T=76F9 T>4=@ 4C6 3+>47?7Z =A A=A4A => 4C6 56@=6G +G 4C6 5T=@F67 4C?4 4C6 @?>F C6 =A 5T=@F=>I

+> =A C=A9 ?>F C=A =I>+7?>36 +G ?>Z F6G634 +7 G@?X => C=A 4=4@6) j6>369 AT3C I++F G?=4C9 5Z @?X


40/96

B7=H7=!37=9 E =@?) O4 X?A F=A3+V676F => ? AT7V6Z 4C?4 ?

+G ? 5T=@F=>I +G 679 XC=3C X?A A47T346F 5Z =4A -=>4676A49 6>37+?3C6F +> ? +G 4C6

@+4 +X>6F 5Z 4) dC?4 ?76 4C6 7=IC4A ?>F +5@=I?4=+>A +G 4C6 F 5+T>FA +G C=A 4+ 4C6 I++F G?=4C +7 5?F G?=4C +G C=A -=>4676A4 XC=3C

A47T346F 4C6 5T=@F=>I`

LC6A6 ?76 4C6 ]T6A4=+>A 7?=A6F => 4C6 G+7 76V=6X +G 4C6 H63=A=+> L F?46F %TITA4 .c9 811.9 => &%-()*) &P "+) .c.1i +G76AF6>4 &+T74 M XC676 4C6 F=A 76?FA_ N

bdj!*!J2*!9 A=F676F9 4C6 H63=A=+> +G 4C6 *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T74 =A C6765Z 76V67A6F ?>F A64 ?A=F6 ?>F ?>+4C67

+>6 6>4676F R

8) H=AW=AA=>I 4C6 3+W4 G+7 @?3U +G 3?TA6 +G ?34=+>M

.) 27F67=>I L63>+I?A 4+


41/96

4C6 X?@@ ?4 4C6 5?3U +G =4A @?>F 4CTA I=V=>I 4+ F6G6>F?>4 +G ? +G C=A @?>F 3@+A6F 5Z

4=GGfA X?@@M 4C?4 F6G6>F?>4 @?467 G=@6F ? 3+W4 56G+76 4C6 +GG=36 +G ST>=3==@? ?A

X6@@ ?A 56G+76 4C6 2GG=36 +G 4C6 Y7+V=>3=?@ J=A3?@ +G *=e?@ ?I?=>A4 4=GG => 3+>>634=+> X=4C 4C6 6>37+?3CW6>4 +7 +33TF X?@@A +G ? +G =4A @?>F 5T4 A?=F 3+W4 F=F >+4 4 FTI +7 3?TA6F 4+

56 FTI ? 3?>?@ ?@+>I 4=GGfA X?@@9 ? +G XC=3C 3+@@? ET>69 81c:9 ?>F @6F 4+ 4C6 G=@=>I 5Z 4=GG +G 4C6

AT 4C6 ?5+V6-6>4=4@6F 3?A6 ?>F ? A64 ?>F C=A X=G6 XC=3C T@4=W?46@Z 76AT@46F =>4+ 4C6 3+>V=34=+> => 3+T74 +G F6G6>F?>4fA X=G6 G+7 4C6 37=W6 +G W?@=3=+TA

W=A3C=6GM 4C?4 XC=@6 47=?@ +G 4C6 3?A6 X?A => &+T74 ? G+7W?@ 4)b

%G467 47=?@ +> 4C6 W67=4A9 4C6 *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T74 Q +G Y?A?Z &=4Z9 $7?>3C 88\9 => &=V=@ &?A6 "+) Yl-\/i8-Y9 76>F676F ?

F63=A=+> F?46F H636W567 [9 81c1 => G?V+7 +G 67 XC+ X?A 4C6 4=GG 4C676=>) LC6 F=A4 =A C6765Z 76>F676F => G?V+7 +G 4=GG ?>F ?I?=>A4 F6G6>F?>4 ?>F +7F67=>I 4C6 @?4467 4+ A6@@ 4+

4=GG 4C?4 +G @?>F +X>6F 5Z C=W ?>F +33TIA ?>F X?@@ ?4 4C6


42/96

&) LC6 76AF6>4 3+T74fA 3=4?4=+> +G 4C6 4X=> 3?A6A +GLT?A+> D &+) V) ,TW?>@?> ?>F LT?A+> D &+) V) S?3?@=>F+>I =A >+4 4C6

f^TF=3=?@ ?T4C+7=4Zf G+7 ? 5+T>F?7Z F=A 564X66> ?F^?36>4 4+776>A 4=4@6F @+4 +X>67A9 ?A 4C6 G?34A +G 4C6 4

3?A6 F+ >+4 G?@@ X=4C=> >+7 A]T?76 X=4C 4C6 =>V+@V6F 3=47?7Z 4+ 76AF6>4 KZfA 76?A+>=>I9 67 L63>+I?A 3+>4=>T6A 4+ 56 ? 5T=@F67 => I++F G?=4C9 6V6> =G =4

AT5A6]T6>4@Z 5T=@4n766>4 A47T34T76A 4C676+> XC=@6 4C6 3?A6 ? ]T+ X?A F=>I ?>F 6V6> XC=@6

76AF6>4 A6>4 4C6 67 W?>Z @64467AnG=@6F 3?A6A 4C676+>) LM

H) g!)h LC6 ?W=3?5@6 A644@6W6>4 564X66> 4C6 F 6>G+736F +>@Z => ?33+7F?>36

X=4C =4A 6aF >+4 +V67 ?>F 56Z+>F 4C?4 ?I766F TM 563?TA6 4C6 3+T74A F+ >+4 C?V6 4C6 47?34 >+7 6aF =4A A3+67?@ 7T@69 ?@4C+TIC 4C6 @?>F+X>67 C?A 4C6 + 4+ 3C++A6 564X66>_ g8h f5TZ=>I 4C6 5T=@F=>I 5T=@4 => I++F

G?=4Cf9 +7 g.h fA6@@=>I 4C6 +G C=A @?>F +> XC=3C A4?>FA 4C6 5T=@F=>If T>F67 %74=3@6 [[c +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6M 4C6 G=7A4 +

=A >+4 ?5A+@T469 563?TA6 ?> 6a36 4C6764+9 +>36 =4 X+T@F 56 =WF+X>67 4+ 3C++A6 4+ 6a673=A6 4C6 G=7A4

?@467>?4=V69 =)6) 5TZ 4C?4 +G 4C6 C+TA6 A4?>F=>I +> C=A @?>F9 G+7 4C6 XC+@6 5T=@F=>I W=IC4 56 76>F676F TA6@6AA) LC6

X+7U?5@6 A+@T4=+> =A G+7 C=W 4+ A6@634 4C6 A63+>F ?@467>?4=V69 >?W6@Z9 4+ A6@@ 4+ 4C6 5T=@F67 4C?4 F +> XC=3C X?A

3+>A47T346F ? +G 4C6 C+TA6)b LO

Y7=V?46 76AF6>49 +> 4C6 +4C67 C?>F9 ?7IT6A 4C?4 4C6 =A bATGG67=>I G7+W 4C6 G+@@+X=>I G@?XA_ LP

8) O4 F=F >+4 I=V6 4C6 6a?34 3=4?4=+>A +G 3?A6A F63=F6F 5Z 4C6 j+>+7?5@6 BT47?F=34A 4C6 7T@=>I +G

4C6 j+>) &+T74 +G %6 @?=F F+X> => LT?A+> VA) ,TW?>@?> 3?A6 3=4=>I ?@A+ LT?A+> VA) S?3?@=>F+>I

3?A6 gBTI 4C?4 4C6 F+347=>6 => 4C6 ?@@6I6F &+ L?+ VA) &C=3+ 3?A6 =A 3+>47?F=34+7Z 4+ 4C6 F+347=>6 => LT?A+> VA) ,TW?>@?> ?>F

LT?A+> VA) S?3?@=>F+>I9 4C6 4X+ 3?A6A 56=>I W+76 3T776>49 4C6 A?W6 AC+T@F 46>FA 4C?4 4C6 G+@@+X=>I bT>W=A4?U?5@Zb 4 4+ 4C6 5?F G?=4C +G 67_ g8h 4fA F @+4 G7+W Y?7=e

O>FTA47=6AbM g.h 4C6 F63@?7?4=+> +G 4C6 (6>67?@ S?>?I67 +G L63>+I?A 4C?4 4C6 A?@6 564X66> 67 ?>F Y?7=e O>FTA47=6A

bX?A >+4 76I=A4676Fb 563?TA6 +G A+W6 ? $?>U=>I &+7M ?>F gih 4C6 H66F +G B?@6 => G?V+7 +G

67 X?A 76I=A4676F => =4A >?W6 +>@Z => b4C6 W+>4C +G S?Z 81\i)b LQ

LC6 &+T74fA *T@=>I

LC6 AC+T@F 56 I7?>46F) (++F J?=4C +7 $?F J?=4C

*6AF6>4 &+T749 3=4=>I 4C6 3?A6A +G E) S) LT?A+> D &+)9 O>3) VA) PF?) F6 ,TW?>@?> LR ?>F E) S) LT?A+> D &+ )9 O>3) VA)

S?3?@=>F+>I9 LS 7T@6F 4C?4 67 b3?>>+4 56 3+>A=F676F => I++F G?=4Cb 563?TA6 ?A ? @?>F +X>679 =4 =A b+X

4C6 W646A ?>F 5+T>FA +G C=A +X> =>I @+4 AC+T@F 56 3+>A=F676F ? 5T=@F67 => g5h?F gGh?=4C9 4C676 56=>I A 4=4@69 4C6 ?76?9 ?>F 4C6 6a46>4 +G 4C6 5+T>F?7=6A)b LT 3F?

d6 F=A?I766 X=4C 76AF6>4 &+T74) LC6 4X+ 3?A6A =4 76@=6F T F+ >+4 AT36W6>4 4C?4 ? 76I=A4676F

+X>67 +G @?>F C?A F 5+T>FA +G =4A +X> @?>F9 ?>F =A 4C676G+76 => 5?F G?=4C =G C6

W=A4?U6>@Z 5T=@FA +> ?> ?F^+=>=>I @?>F) %A=F6 G7+W 4C6 G?34 4C?4 4C+A6 3?A6A C?F G?34T?@ W++7=>IA 7?F=3?@@Z F=GG676>4 G7+W

4C+A6 +54?=>=>I C6769 4C676 =A >+4C=>I => 4C+A6 3?A6A XC=3C X+T@F ATII6A49 C+X6V67 76W+46@Z9 4C?4 5?F G?=4C =A =W67 +G @?>F XC6> ? F9 A=W C=A 3674=G=3?46 +G 4=4@6) "+ AT3C F+347=>?@ A4?46W6>4 3+T@F C?V6

566> W?F6 => 4C+A6 3?A6A 563?TA6 AT3C =AAT6 X?A >+4 56G+76 4C6 BT47?7Z9 X6 C?V6 76^6346F AT3C ?

4C6+7Z => &+ L?+ VA) &C=3+9 MU XC676 X6 C6@F 4C?4 T>@6AA +>6 =A V67A6F => 4C6 A3=6>36 +G AT7V6Z=>I9 b>+ +>6 3?> F6467W=>6 4C6

4 +7 @+3?4=+> +G C=A I C=A


43/96

5?F G?=4C 5Z 4C6 5T=@F67 +G 4C6 6>37+?3C=>I A47T34T76A9 4C6 @?4467 AC+T@F 56 I++F G?=4C) ML O4 =A

4=>T6A 4+ 56 6>^+Z6F => 4C6 A?W6 3C?7?3467 => XC=3C =4 X?A ?3]T=76F9 T>4=@ 4C6 3+>47?7Z =A

A=A4A => 4C6 56@=6G +G 4C6 5T=@F67 4C?4 4C6 @?>F C6 =A 5T=@F=>I +> =A C=A9 ?>F C=A =I>+7?>36 +G ?>Z F6G634

+7 G@?X => C=A 4=4@6) MN j6>369 AT3C I++F G?=4C9 5Z @?X9


44/96

XC=3C 76?F_ MT

bLC?4 4C6 4 ?>F

76AF6>4 AC?@@ 56 F6W+@=AC6F T< 4+ 4C6 5?3U +G 4C6 5T=@F=>I C+TA=>I 4C6 W?3C=>67=6A XC=3C F6W+@=A=+> gA=3h AC?@@ 56

T>F674?U6> 5Z 4C6 3+W?>4 ?4 ?>Z4=W6)

LC?4 4C6 G6>36 XC=3C A67V6gAh ?A ? X?@@ C+TA=>I 4C6 6@6347+I W?3C=>67=6A AC?@@ >+4 56 F6W+@=AC6F => 4C6 W6?> 4=W6

XC=3C AC?@@ 56 AT5^634 4+ >6I+4=?4=+> 5Z C676=>


45/96

=4Z9 +7 g.h +5@=I=>I 4C6 @?4467 4+ 5TZ 4C6 @+4 +33T>+4 6a673=A6 ? 76W6FZ +G C=A +X>

@=U=>I)

"6=4C67 =A 67fA F NO 4C6 (7?>? ?>F L+77?@5? VA) LC6 &+T74 +G %46F

=> 4C?4 3?A6 ?A 4C6 @?>F+X>67A X676 F=76346F 4+ 6a673=A6 bX=4C=> i: F?ZA G7+W 4C=A F63=A=+> 4C6=7 + 4+ 6=4C67 5TZ 4C6

+G 4C6 67Af C+TA6 +> 4C6=7 @?>F +7 A6@@ 4+ A?=F 67A 4C6 +G 4C6=7 @?>F +> XC=3C =4 A4?>FA)b NQ

S+76+V679 => (7?>? ?>F L+77?@5?9 4C6 ?76? =>V+@V6F X?A +>@Z c\ A]T?76 W6467A XC=@6 4C=A 3?A6 =>V+@V6A 0.: A]T?76 W6467A

NR ) O> @=>6 X=4C 4C6 3?A6 +G H6F6F 4+ 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 G+7 GT74C67 IA

4+ GT@@Z =W4 4C6 W?>F?46 +G %74) [[c) O4 =A ? 7T@6 +G 47+V67AZ => ? A=>I@6 I @6?V=>I >+ 7++4 +7 57?>3C 4+ 56?7 4C6 A66FA +G GT4T76 @=4=I?4=+>) NT

Y64=4=+>679 C+X6V679 WTA4 ?@A+ F 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74M

4C?4 =A9 =G AT3C + =A G+7 4 4+ ? AT3C 6V6>49 67 X+T@F

C?V6 ? 7=IC4 +G 7646>4=+> XC=3C >6I?46A 4C6 +5@=I?4=+> 4+


46/96

?76?) LC6 76>4?@ 4CTA G=a6F AC?@@ 56 =>376?A6F 5Z 46> 4 g8:qh G+7 4C6 A63+>F Z6?7 +G 4C6 G+736F @6?A6) Y64=4=+>67 AC?@@

>+4 W?U6 ?>Z GT74C67 3+>A47T34=+>A +7 =W4A +> 4C6 5T=@F=>I) K 6a +G 4C6 4X+-Z6?7 4C6 F9 ?>F 4+ C?V6 4C6 +G 4C6 5T=@F=>I 76W+V6F 5Z 67 +7 ?4 @?4467fA

6aA6) LC6 76>4?@A C676=> F676F 5Z 67 4+ 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 G+7 F AT3C 46>F67 AC?@@ 3+>A4=4T46 6V=F6>36 +G XC64C67 +7 >+4 3+W36 X?A W?F6 X=4C=> 4C6 ?>Z 6V6>49 67 AC?@@ ?W+T>4 3+WF ?5@6 3+WA?4=+> G+7 4C6 +33T3Z +G 4fA @?>F G+7 4C6 46F G7+W 234+567 [9 81\19 T+4=36 +G =4A + 4+ ?AG67 +G +X>67AC=< 4+ 67 +79 => 3?A6 ? G+736F @6?A6 C?A 4+ 56 =W36W6>4 F?46 +G 4C6

G+736F @6?A6 76G6776F 4+ => 4C6 I F T G?=@T76 +G 4C6 +7F67 +G

6a63T4=+> G+7 4C6 6>G+736W6>4 +G F G+7 3+W36 X=4C AT3C +4C67 ?34A ?A W?Z 56 76]T=76F 5Z

4C6 FT6 4C6 +5@=I66)

"+ 3+A4A) B2 2*H!*!H)

"?7V?A?9 & )E )9 H?V=F69 E7)9 S6@+ ?>F J7?>3=A3+9 EE )9 3+>3T7)

B!&2"H HOPOBO2"

'()*) "+) ,-i.1\[) ET@Z i:9 81\1);

378D4=4@6F b$?74+@+W6 274=e VA) B63764?7Z +G %I7=3T@4T76 ?>F "?4T7?@

*6A+T736A9 64 ?@)9b ?>F 4C6 d7=4 +G !a63T4=+> =AAT6F 4+ =W4 A?=F 27F679 ?@@6I6F@Z G+7 56=>I =>3+>A=A46>4 X=4C 4C6

ETFIW6>4 A+TIC4 4+ 56 6>G+736F),,I 36 4+ 4C6 A?@6A ?+ &+W=>4?> ?>F

!@6T467=+ m?W+7? +V67 ,+4 "+) 0\c09 Y,B-[09 @+3?46F ?4 $?77=+ &?5T@T?>9 &?@?T?I9 lT6e+>)

O LC6 G?34T?@ 5?3UI7+T>F +G 4C6 3?A69 ?A G+T>F 5Z 76AF6>4 &+T749 =A ?A G+@@+XA_

b) ) ) LC6 @+4 => 3+>47+V67AZ X?A G+7W67@Z 4C6 AT5^634 +G j+W6A46?F % H+@+7=3+ OO >?W6F C=A T>3@69 S?74=> H+@+7=3+ O ?A C=A C6=7 ?>F AT336AA+7 => =>4676A49 A+ 4C?4 => 8108 S?74=> H+@+7=3+ O

6a63T46F ?> ?GG=F?V=4 76@=>]T=AC=>I C=A 7=IC4A +V67 4C6 F?>4A lT=7=>+ &+W=>4?> ?>F !@6T467=+

m?W+7?9 C=A I7?>FA+> ?>F A+>-=>-@?X9 76AF 76]T6A46F 4C6 H=7634+7 +G ,?>FA 4+ 3?>36@ 4C6 C+W6A46?F ? 4C6 A476>I4C +G 4C6 ?GG=F?V=49 j+W6A46?F %


47/96

76AI 4C?4 C6

AC+T@F 56 I=V6> 36 4+ ?AWT3C ?A C6 =A 4C6 ?34T?@ +33T4 ?>F C?A 566> => 3+>4=>T+TA

+G 4C6 A?W6 A=>36 81i8M ?>F =>A4 &+W=>4?> X?A 4C6 +>@Z 5=FF67M 4C?4 +> ET>6 c9 810\9 =>V6A4=I?4=+> X?A 3+>FT346F +> 4=GGfA 4

YT5@=3 ,?>FA O>A XC+ AT5W=446F C=A 76?@ ,?>F 2GG=3679 ?>F XC+ => 4T7> 76>F676F ?

F63=A=+> +> %I 4=GGfA 3@?=W ?>F I=V=>I FT6 3+T7A6 4+ F6G6>F?>4Af A?@6A ? 4C6 I7+T>F

4C?4 4C6 76@=>]T=ACW6>4 +G 4C6 C+W6A46?F 7=IC4A +G S?74=> H+@+7=3+ O => G?V+7 +G &+W=>4?> ?>F m?W+7? =A F6A=I>?46F ?A AT336AA+7 => =>4676A4 +G 4C6 +7=I=>?@ C+W6A46?F ?F 4C?4 563?TA6 4=GG G?=@6F 4+

FA => C=A +7F67 F?46F ET>6 8:9 8101M 4C?4 G=>?@@Z9 +> ?F BT5F=V=A=+>h +>6-C?@G +G 4C6 @+3?46F ?4 $+) &?5T@T?>9 &?@?T?I9 lT6e+> =>

G?V+7 +G F6G6>F?>4 lKO*O"2 &2SO"L%"9 56=>I 4C6 AT336AAGT@ 5=FF67 => 4C6 3+>FT346F 5Z 4C6 $T76?T +G ,?>FA

+> %F C6765Z I=V=>I FT6 3+T7A6 4+ 4C6 B?@6A %>+T>36F 5Z 4C6 $T76?T +G ,?>FA9 S?>=@?) j+X6V679 AC+T@F 4=GG $?74+@+W6 274=e 56

>+4 F63@?76F 4C6 AT336AAGT@ 5=FF67 4C676+G F6G6>F?>4A lT=7=>+ &+W=>4?> ?>F !@6T467=+ m?W+7? ?76 +7F676F 4+ 76=W5T7A6

^+=>4@Z A?=F 4=GG 4C6 =W4A C6 C?A =>47+FT36F +> 4C6 XC+@6 4 +G LjO*L!!" Lj2KB%"H BOkjK"H*!H LjO*LQ-Ld2 gY8i9/i.)::h Y!B2B9 4C6 @?4467 C?V=>I 4C6 7=IC4 4+ 764?=> 4C6 GT@@Z

F X=4C 3+A4A ?I?=>A4

4C6 4=GG)b M

Y@?=>4=GG ?4 5Z 4C6 3+T74 ? ]T+9 XC=@6 4C6 3?A6 X?A F=>I ?+ &+W=>4?> ?>F !@6T467=+ m?W+7?9 76AF6>4 &+T74 ?4 P=36>46 J677+9 &@67U

+G &+T749 ?A *636=V67 4+ 3+@@634 4+@@A +> ? +G 4C6 %TITA4 819 81/19 4C6 &+T74 +G

%>T@@=>I 4C6 27F67 ?I 4C6 *636=V67) BT5A6]T6>4@Z9 +> J657T?7Z 819 81\:9 4C6 % 3674=+7?7= +G 4C6 F63=A=+> +G 4C6 &+T74 +G % %6X 7636=V67 X=4C 4C6 3+T74 ? ]T+) LC=A X?A

I7?>46F ?>F 4C6 7636=V67 X?A 76?67 A+TIC4 4C6 ?>>T@W6>4 +G 4C=A 27F67 X=4C 4C6 &+T74 +G %?@ ?>F 4C?4 4C6 763+7FA +G 4C6 3?A6 X676 4+ 56 76W?>F6F 4+ 4C6 47=?@

3+T74),,


48/96

bJ=>?@@Z9 4+ 3+>F6W> 4=GG 4+ 4 => ?> ?W+T>4 4C=A

&+T74 W?Z F66W ^TA4 => 4C6 I B6I9 ?W+>I +4C67A9 4C6 G+@@+X=>I_

T < + > 4 C 6 G + 7 6 I + = > I W + 4 = + > 9 7 6 A < + > F 6 > 4 E T F I 6 = A A T 6 F ? > 2 7 F 6 7 9 F?46F

bLC6 763+7FA GT74C67 F=A3@+A6F 4C?4 G7+W S?73C 81/\ 4+ H636W567 i89 81/c9 4=GG $?74+@+W6 274=e 3+@@6346F 4+@@A +> ?

+G 4C6 XC676=> C6 C?A >+4 =>47+FT36F ?>Z =W4


49/96

+7F676F 4C?4 +G 4C6 I++FA ?>F 3C?446@A +G $?74+@+W6 274=e +G $+) N?5T@T?>9 &?@?T?I9 lT6e+>9 56 3?TA6F 4+ 56 W?F6 ?>Z 6a36AA

=> 4C6 ?5+V6W6>4=+>6F ?W+T>4 4+I64C67 X=4C Z+T7 @?XGT@ G66A ?>F 4C?4 Z+T 76>F67 A?W6 4+ F6G6>F?>4 lT=7=>+ &+W=>4?>) OG

ATGG=3=6>4 ?@ +4 56 G+T>F 4C676+G 4+ A?4=AGZ 4C=A 6a63T4=+> ?>F @?XGT@ G66A 4C676+>9 4C6> Z+T ?76

3+WW?>F6F 4C?4 +G 4C6 @?>FA ?>F 5T=@F=>IA +G 4C6 A?=F $%*L2,2S! 2*LOm Z+T W?U6 4C6 A?=F 6a36AA ?W+T>4 => 4C6 W?>>67

76]T=76F 5Z 4C6 *T@6A +G &+T749 ?>F W?U6 764T7> +G Z+T7 IA X=4C=> 4C=A &+T74 X=4C=> A=a4Z g/:h F?ZA G7+W F?46 +G

A67V=36)

bQ+T ?76 ?@A+ +7F676F 4+ 3?TA6 $?74+@+W6 274=e 4+ V?3?46 4C6 g80h F?ZA ?G467 A67V=36 4C676+G 4C6

F6G6>F?>4 lT=7=>+ &+W=>4?> C?V=>I G=@6F 4C6 76]T=76F 5+>F => 4C6 ?W+T>4 +G LjO*L!!" Lj2KB%"H BOk jK"H*!H LjO*LQ-

Ld2 gY8i9/i.)::h Y!B2B)b Q

2> 234+567 8.9 81\:9 67 G=@6F ? S+4=+> G+7 *63+>A=F67?4=+> +G 4C6 ?G+76A?=F 27F67 ?>F d7=4 +G !a63T4=+>9 ?@@6I=>I_

bg?h LC?4 4C6 76AF6>4 TFI6 C?A >+ ?T4C+7=4Z 4+ 4A => +G 4C6 +G 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 4C?4 4+@@A 3+@@6346F G7+W 4C6 F=V67A=+>?7Z 7+?F

+> 4C6 4AM

bg3h LC?4 4+ ?AA6AA 67 ? Y.09:::):: @=?5=@=4Z G+7 F?W?I6A =A )b

LC6 G+76I+=>I S+4=+> G+7 *63+>A=F67?4=+> X?A F6>=6F 5Z 76AF6>4 ETFI6


50/96

7=IC4 4+ 764?=> 4C6 A?W6 T>4=@ ?G467 C6 C?A F @+A4 => 4C6 I +G 4C6 @?>F 4+ 56 3+>FT346F 5Z 4C6

$T76?T +G ,?>FA) O4 =A 3@?=W6F 4C?4 =4 =A +>@Z => 4C6 6V6>4 4C?4 C6

@+A6A => 4C6 5=FF=>I 4C?4 C6 3?> 56 @6I?@@Z F=A


51/96

LC676 =A >+ ]T6A4=+> 4C?4 ? I++F G?=4C =A 6>4=4@6F 4+ 4C6 G7T=4A 7636=V6F 56G+76 4C6 =A @6I?@@Z

=>4677T => I++F G?=4C 36?A6A +7 =A @6I?@@Z =>4677T4 F6G634A => 4C6 4=4@6 ?76 W?F6 U>+X>

4+ 4C6 6+TA 6V=F6>36 +7 5Z 4C6 G=@=>I +G ?> ?34=+> => 3+T74 5Z 4C6 47T6 +X>67 G+7 4C6 763+V67Z +G 4C6

3+T749 +7 XC6> C6 ?>AX67A

4C6 3+W49 WTA4 56 F6@=V676F ?>F


52/96

%+4 ?I 4C6 >636AA?7Z 6aA6A

G+7 C=A ?FW=>=A47?4=+>9 4+ ?F 4C6 5?@?>36 4+ 4C6


53/96

.) OH)M ,!%B!M Lj! *O(jL L2 O"H!S"OLQ %*OB!B 2",Q OJ Lj! ,!BB2* 2YLB L2 %YY*2Y*O%L! Lj! OSY*2P!S!"LB) R

LC6 7=IC4 4+ =>F6W>=4Z T>F67 %74=3@6 8/\c +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6 ?7=A6A +>@Z =G 4C6 @6AA+7 +F =W4A) "6=4C67 3?> 4C6Z 764?=> 4C6 4=@ 76=W5T7A6W6>4 =A W?F6) LC6 4Af A+@6 7=IC4 4C6> =A 4+ 76W+V6 4C6 =W4A X=4C+T4 3?TA=>I ?>Z W+76 =W =A >636AA?7Z)

;-:!A!A => &=V=@ &?A6 "+) 1.8[ +G $7?>3C i +G 4C6 ST>=3= &=4Z G+7 T>@?XGT@ F64?=>67 ?>F F?W?I6A) LC6 67A ?AU 4C6 &+T74 4+ A64 ?A=F6 4C6 F63=A=+> +G 4C6

&+T74 +G % +G $7?>3C [: +G 4C6 *6I=+>?@ L7=?@ &+T74 g*L&h +G H?IT &=4Z9 XC=3C9 => 4T7>9

76V67A6F 4C6 SL&&M +7F676F 4C6 67A

4+ 76=W5T7A6 4C6 4A 4C6 V?@T6 +G 4C6 C+TA6 => ]T6A4=+> ?>F +4C67 =W4AM ?>F ?@@+X6F 4C6 @?4467 4+

764?=> 4C6 4=@ 76=W5T7A6W6>4 X?A W?F6)

O4 ? ?@@6I6F 47?34 +G@6?A6 +V67 ? 8./ A]T?76-W6467 +G 4C6 @+49 =>3@TF=>I 4C?4 +> XC=3C 4C6 C+TA6 A4++F9 => G?V+7 +G 4C6 4A G+7 Y[:):: 4C G+7 ? Z6?7A 3+WW6>3=>I +> 80 "+V6W567 81\c)L LC6 4A

4C6> =>47+FT36F ?FF=4=+>?@ =W4A ?>F 76I=A4676F 4C6 C+TA6 => 4C6=7 >?W6A) %G467 4C6 6a +G 4C6 @6?A6 3+>47?34

=> "+V6W567 81c09 C+X6V679 4C6 67Af W+4C67 76GTA6F 4+ ?3364C@Z 76>4?@A)

O4 4T7>6F +T4 4C?4 4C6 @+4 => ]T6A4=+> X?A 4C6 AT5^634 +G ? AT=49 XC=3C 76AT@46F => =4A ?3]T=A=4=+> 5Z +>6 S?7=? ,66 => 81\.) O>

81c.9 ,66 A+@F 4C6 @+4 4+ ,=@Z B?@36F+9 XC+ => 4T7> A+@F =4 => 81c[ 4+ 4C6 A ?>F !A467 H=+>=A=+)

2> 8[ J657T?7Z 811.9 4C6 H=+>=A=+ A?W6A) N

2> 1 J657T?7Z 811i9 4C6 67A A6>49 V=? 76I=A4676F W?=@9 ? @64467 ?FF76AA6F 4+ 4 S?7Z "=3+@?A

F6W?>F=>I 4C?4 AC6 V?3?46 4C6 F


54/96

@6AA66A @=U6 4C6 4A9 563?TA6 4C6 @?4467 U>6X 4C?4 4C6=7 +33T


55/96

I 47?>AG6776F9 LU +>@Z 4C6 46WF 6>^+ZW6>4 4C676+G) LL

O> 4C=A 3?A69 5+4C F => ]T6A4=+> X?A +7=I=>?@@Z +X>6F 5Z 4C6 67Af W+4C67) LC6 @?>F X?A

?@@6I6F@Z ?3]T=76F @?467 5Z +>6 S?7=? ,66 5Z V=74T6 +G ?> 6a47?^TF=3=?@ G+763@+AT76 +G W+74I?I6) ,669 C+X6V679 >6V67 A+TIC4 ?

X7=4 +G => +7F67 4C?4 AC6 I?=> +G 4C6 ) LM LC6 67Af W+4C67 4C676G+76

76W?=>6F => +G 4C6 @+4)

O4 =A T>F=A4+ +G ? 8./ A]T?76- W6467 +G 4C6 A?=F @+4 5Z V=74T6 +G

? 3+>47?34 +G @6?A6 6a63T46F 5Z 4C6 67Af W+4C67 => 4C6=7 G?V+7) LC6 ^T7=F=3?@ 76@?4=+> 564X66> 4C6 67Af W+4C67

?A @6AA+79 ?>F 4C6 4A ?A @6AA66A9 =A 4C676G+76 X 6@@- 6A4?5@=AC6F9 ?>F 3?77=6A X=4C =4 ? 763+I>=4=+> +G 4C6@6AA+7fA 4=4@6) LN LC6 4A9 ?A @6AA66A XC+ C?F T>F=A4T756F G+7 4C6 6>4=76 467W T>F67 4C6 @6?A69 ?76 4C6> 6A4+F@+7FfA 4=4@69 +7 4+ ?AA674 ? 564467 4=4@6 >+4 +>@Z => 4C6WA6@V6A9 5T4 ?@A+ => A+W6 4C=7F XC=@6 4C6Z 76W?=> =>

+G 4C6 @6?A6F F T>4=@ 4C6Z AT776>F67 4+ 4C6 @?>F@+7F) LO LC=A 6A4+F @6AA66 X?A 376?46F9 LP ?>F W?Z 56 ?AA6746F >+4 +>@Z 5Z 4C6

+7=I=>?@ @6AA+79 5T4 ?@A+ 5Z 4C+A6 XC+ AT3366F 4+ C=A 4=4@6) LQ

$6=>I W676 @6AA66A9 4C6 4A U>6X 4C?4 4C6=7 +33T


56/96

LjO*H HOPOBO2"

'()*) "+) \1/cc) J657T?7Z 89 811/);

B>-7A7=DK!>>- ;-K->


57/96

6V6> 56G+76 4C6 3+W +G ?@@ =>A4?@@W6>4


58/96

!>4673) =A F=AW=AA6F) LC6 +7F67 ?I?=>A4 LC=7F-Y?74Z H6G6>F?>4A 4+ F 3+A4A +G

@=4=I?4=+> =A 76V67A6F)b Q

J+@@+X=>I 4C6 F6>=?@ +G C=A W+4=+> G+7 763+>A=F67?4=+> +> 234+567 .:9 81c/9 N66 ?6+TA F6@=V67Z X?A FT6 4+ 4C6 >6I@=I6>36 +G &OL!O9

?>F 4C?4 AT3C X7+>I F6@=V67Z X?A @=U6X=A6 =W


59/96

b/) LC6 ?X?7F +G ?44+7>6ZfA G66A =A 3@6?7@Z X=4C+T4 5?A=A ?>F =A 6]T=V?@6>4 4+ I ? gA=3h 3+T74 @=4=I?4=+>)b

J7+W 4C6A6 I7+T>FA9 4C6 =AAT6A 3+T@F 56 76-A4?46F ?A G+@@+XA_

g8h d?A N66 ? 5T=@F67 => I++F G?=4C`

g.h dC?4 =A 4C6 @=?5=@=4Z9 =G ?>Z9 +G 67 ?>F =4A ?I6>49 &)L) L+776A !>4673)` ?>F

gih OA 4C6 ?X?7F +G ?44+7>6ZfA G66A 46>FA 4C?4 4C6 &+T74 +G %I 4C6 *L&fA 7T@=>I 4C?4 N66 X?A ? 5T=@F67 => 5?F G?=4C)

Y64=4=+>67 G?=@A 4+ F+> 4C6 G=>F=>IA ?>F 3+>3@TA=+>A +G 4C6 &+T74 +G %I +5A67V?4=+> +G 4C6 &+T74 +G % 56 47?36F F=7634@Z 4+ 4C6 677+7A 3+WW=446F 5Z &LL!O9 XC6> =4 46F 4C6 X7+>I F C=A X=G6) O4 =A C=IC@Z =WI@Z ?>F X=@@=>I@Z 5T=@F C=A 76A=F6>36

+> ? @+4 +X>6F 5Z ?>+4C679 F6@=567?46@Z 6aI C=WA6@G ?>F C=A G?W=@Z 4+ 4C6 7=AU +G 56=>I 6^6346F G7+W 4C6 @?>F ?>F @+A=>I

?@@ =W4A 4C676+>9 >+4 4+ W6>4=+> 4C6 A+3=?@ CTW=@=?4=+> 4C?4 X+T@F G+@@+X)

bK>F67 4C6 3=73TWA4?>36A9 N66 C?F ?346F => 4C6 W?>>67 +G ? 4 W?> => ?A3674?=>=>I 4C6 =F6>4=4Z +G C=A 369 T>F67 4C6 L+776>A AZA46W +G @?>F 76I=A47?4=+>9 N66 =A +X@6FI6 +G 4C6 W646A ?>F 5+T>FA +G 4C6 >+4 V67A6F => 4C6 463C>=3?@ F6A37= +G C=A 4C?4 XC?4

X?A F6A37=56F => L&L "+) /10/8 W?43C6F ,+4 c) LCTA9 C6 X6>4 4+ 4C6 AT5F=V=A=+> F6V6@+4 ?>F ? 5Z &LL!OfA I6+F64=3 6>I=>667) K N66fA 7636= A=46 ?33+W=6F 5Z &LL!OfA 6W+9 XC+ ?T4C+7=4?4=V6@Z F63@?76F 4C?4

4C6 @?>F AC6 X?A 4=>I 4+ X?A =>F66F ,+4 c) j?V=>I GT@@ G?=4C ?>F 3+>G=F6>36 => 4C6 76 +G &LL!O9 ?>F 563?TA6 +G 4C6

3+WZfA 4=G=3?4=+> +G 4C6 4+ ATA ? W=AF6@=V67Z) LC6 A46 4+ 4676A4A X676 76?A+>?5@6) LC676 X?A >+ >66F G+7 C=W 4+ C?V6 ?346F 6a-?5T>F?>4=? 3?T46@?9 AT3C

?A 56=>I 4 FT7=>I 4C6 I6+F64=3 6>I=>667fA 76@+3?4=+> AT7V6Z +7 C=7=>I ?> =>F6F6>4 I6+F64=3 6>I=>667 4+

3+T>4673C63U G+7 677+7A9 G+7 4C6 G=>?@ F6@=V67Z +G AT5F=V=A=+> @+4A 4+ 4C6=7 +X>67A =A


60/96

Y64=4=+>67 >6a4 3+>46>FA 4C?4 N66 3?>>+4 b3@?=W 4C?4 ?>+4C67 @+4 X?A 677+>6+TA@Z 46F +T4 4+ C=Wb 563?TA6 4C6 @?4467

?I766F 4+ 4C6 G+@@+X=>I => 4C6 &+>47?34 +G B?@6 +> O>A4?@@W6>49 4+ X=4_

b8i) LC6 P6>F66 C6765Z F63@?76A 4C?4 +G C=A

3+>47?34 C6nAC6 C?A ?@@Z 6a?W=>6F +7 =>A?4T7?@

3+>F=4=+> +G 4C6 @+4A ?>F G7+W 4C6 F?46 C676+G XC?46V67 3+>A6]T6>4=?@

3C?>I6 4C676=> W?F6 FT6 4+ 67+A=+>9 4C6 A?=F P6>F66 AC?@@ 56?7 4C6

6aA6A +G 4C6 >636AA?7Z G=@@=>IA9 XC6> 4C6 A?W6 =A A+ F6A=76F 5Z C=WnC67)b

LL

LC6 AT5^634 W?4467 +G 4C=A +G 4C6 3+>47?34 =A 4C6 3C?>I6 +G 4C6 @+3?4=+>9 3+>4+T7 ?>F 3+>F=4=+> +G 4C6 @+4 FT6 4+

67+A=+>) O4 W676@Z F669 C?V=>I 6a?W=>6F 4C6 I G7+W AT3C 3C?>I6)

d6 F+ >+4 ?I766 X=4C 4C6 =>467 +G 67 4C?4 N66 3+>47?346F ?X?Z C=A 7=IC4 4+ 763+V67 F?W?I6A 76AT@4=>I G7+W

67fA >6I@=I6>36) BT3C X?=V67 X+T@F 56 3+>47?7Z 4+ >+4 56 ?@@+X6F) b*=IC4A W?Z 56 X?=V6F9 T>@6AA4C6 X?=V67 =A 3+>47?7Z 4+ @?X9 F &LL!O9 XC=3C X?A F=AW=AA6F 5Z 4C6 *L& ?G467 7T@=>I 4C?4 4C676 X?A

>+ 6V=F6>36 G7+W XC=3C G?T@4 +7 >6I@=I6>36 +> 4C6 F &LL!O 3?> 56 =>G6776F) LC6 &+T74 +G %F &LL!O >6I@=I6>4 G+7 4C6 677+>6+TA F6@=V67Z +G 4C6 @+4 5Z 234?V=?>+9 =4A 6W67 F+6A >+4 F=A4) $T4 =4

3+>46>FA 4C?4 4C6 677+>6+TA F6@=V67Z +G ,+4 1 4+ N66 X?A ?> ?34 XC=3C X?A 3@6?7@Z +T4A=F6 4C6 A3+F

3+>A6]T6>4@Z9 &LL!O ?@+>6 AC+T@F 56 @=?5@6) O4 ?AA674A 4C?4 bXC=@6 '&LL!O; X?A ?T4C+7=e6F 4+ A6@@ 4C6 @+4 56@+>I=>I 4+ 4C6C676=> 679 =4 X?A >6V67 ?T4C+7=e6F 4+ F6@=V67 4C6 X7+>I @+4 4+ N66)b 8i

Y64=4=+>67fA 3+>46>4=+> =A X=4C+T4 W67=4) ,,F AC+T@F 56?7

4C6 F?W?I6 3?TA6F 4+ 4C=7F A) 8[ 2> 4C6 +4C67 C?>F9 4C6 ?I6>4 XC+ 6a366FA C=A ?T4C+7=4Z =A ?@@Z @=?5@6 G+7 4C6

F?W?I6) LP

&LL!O X?A ?34=>I X=4C=> =4A ?T4C+7=4Z ?A 4C6 A+@6 76?@ 6A4?46 764?4=V6 +G 67 XC6> =4 W?F6 4C6 F6@=V67Z 4+ N66) O>

?34=>I X=4C=> =4A A3+6I@=I6>4) O4 =A 4C=A >6I@=I6>36 4C?4 =A 4C6 5?A=A +G 67fA @=?5=@=4Z9 ?A

3=F 818: +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6)

Y6>F=>I 76A+@T4=+> +G 4C6 3?A6 56G+76 4C6 &+T74 +G %F N66 +> ET@Z .[9 81c\ 6>4676F =>4+ ? F66F +G A?@69XC676=> 4C6 G+7W67 A+@F ,+4 1 4+ N66) E?7F=>=3+ ?>F N66 F=F >+4 =>G+7W 4C6 &+T74 +G %6F 4C6 G+@@+X=>I _

b8) LC?4 &=V=@ &?A6 "+) ic80 6>4=4@6F bE?7F=>=3+ VA) N66b XC=3C =A >+X F=>I ?F X=4C+T4 6GG634 XC?4A+6V67Mb LQ

N66 ?AA674A 4C+TIC 4C?4 4C6 b467WA ?>F 3+>F=4=+>A => 4C6 A?=F F66F +G A?@6 ?76 A47=34@Z G+7 4C6 F 4C?4

bg4hC676 =A >+ X?=V67 W?F6 5Z 6=4C67 +G 4C6


61/96

76AF6>4 &+T74 +G %A4 C676=> 67 Y@6?A?>4V=@@6 H6V6@+4 &+7

?>Fn+7 4 &)L) L+776A !>4673)b LR

25V=+TA@Z9 4C6 F66F +G A?@6 3?> C?V6 >+ 6GG634 +> 4C6 @=?5=@=4Z +G 67) %A X6 C?V6 6?7@=67 A4?46F9 67fA @=?5=@=4Z =A

I7+T>F6F +> 4C6 >6I@=I6>36 +G =4A ?I6>4) 2> 4C6 +4C67 C?>F9 XC?4 4C6 F66F +G A?@6 76IT@?46A ?76 4C6 763=F E?7F=>=3+M =4 A476AA6F 4C?4 4C6Z C?F 76?3C6F ?> ?I766W6>4 =>F6F6>4 +G 4C6 +T43+W6 +G 4C6 3?A6)

Y64=4=+>67 GT74C67 ?AA?=@A 4C6 G+@@+X=>I C+@F=>I +G 4C6 &+T74 +G %


62/96

g.h Y64=4=+>67 Y@6?A?>4V=@@6 H6V6@+4 &+7 ?>F 76AF6>4 &)L) L+776A !>4673) ?76 F63@?76F A+@=F?7=@Z

@=?5@6 G+7 F?W?I6A FT6 4+ >6I@=I6>36M C+X6V679 A=>36 4C6 ?W+T>4 ?>Fn+7 6a46>4 +G AT3C F?W?I6A X?A FT7=>I 4C6 47=?@9

4C6 A?W6 3?>>+4 >+X 56 ]T?>4=G=6F ?>F ?X?7F6FM

gih Y64=4=+>67 Y@6?A?>4V=@@6 H6V6@+4 &+7 ?>F 76AF6>4 &)L) L+776A !>4673) ?76 +7F676F 4+


63/96

V?@T6 +G C=A =W4A) dC676T9 4C6 3+T74 ?67 4+ ?A3674?=> 4C6 >?4T76 ?>F V?@T6 +G 4C6 ?@@6I6F

=W4A9 ?>F 4C676?G467 G+T>F 4C?4 A?=F =W4A X676 W?F6 5Z F6G6>F?>4 6=4C67 ?G467 4=GG C?F =>G+7W6F C=W

+G C=A =>46>4=+> 4+ 763+V67 4C6 @?>F9 +7 ?G467 4C6 3+W4 C?F 566> G=@6FM A+W6 +G 4C6 =W4A X676 6V6> =>47+FT36F

?G467 ? 3+WW=AA=+>67 C?F ?@76?FZ 566> ? 5?F

G?=4C ?>F >+4 6>4=4@6F 4+ 76=W5T7A6W6>4 G+7 C=A =W4A) H6G6>F?>4 X?A9 @=U6X=A69 +7F676F 4+ ?3364 +G

Y89\:: F6 3+T749 4+ 6a63T46 => G?V+7 +G 4C6 @?4467 4C6 3+776AF=>I F66F +G 763+>V6Z?>369 ?>F 4+

76A4+76 C=W => +G 4C6 @?>F => ]T6A4=+>)

%4 4C6 +T4A649 =4 WTA4 56 W?F6 3@6?7 4C?4 ?A 4C6 A?@6 => ]T6A4=+> X?A 6a63T46F 5Z 4C6 F ,?X9 4C6 A?W6 =A ?5A+@T46@Z >T@@ ?>F V+=F ?>F =>6GG634=V6 G7+W =4A =>36)&+>A6]T6>4@Z9 ?67AC=< +V67 4C6 @?>F => ]T6A4=+>9 ?>F 4C676 X?A >+ >66F 6=4C67 G+7 C=W 4+

7636 => C=A G?V+7) LC6 3?A6 =A ?34T?@@Z G+7

WT4T?@ 76A4=4T4=+>9 =>3=F6>4 4+ 4C6 >T@@=4Z ?5 =>=4=+ +G 4C6 3+>V6Z?>36)

LC6 ]T6A4=+> >+X =A_ S?Z ? 4C6 @?>F => ]T6A4=+>9 +> 4C6

4C6+7Z 4C?4 ?A 5+4C C6 ?>F ?F V+=F9 4C6Z X676 5+4C => 5?F G?=4C ?>F 3+>A6]T6>4@Z9

%74) [0i +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6 ?6 ?>F 4C6 +4C67 AC?@@ 56 4C6 A?W6 ?A 4C+TIC 5+4C C?F ?346F => I++F

G?=4Cb`

LC6 7T@6 +G %74) [0i +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6 =>V+U6F 5Z ? >+4 56 ?4 3?A6 G+7 4C6 76?A+> 4C?4 4C6

@+X67 3+T74 G+T>F9 ?>F ? ]T6A4=+> X676 W?F6 +> 4C6 @Z ?G467 ? ]T6A4=+> G7+W ?F 6V6> FT7=>I 4C6 F6>3Z +G 4C=A ?34=+> => 4C6 3+T74 56@+X)

%G467 ?F 4+ 4C6 ? C?F 4+ 76A+74 4+ 4C6 4?34=+> 4+ 763+V67 C=A G+7W6F 4+ 4C6 =W4A 4C676?G467 W?F6 5Z ? 4C6 F9 ?=e=>I ?A C6 F+6A ? C6 W?F6 =W4A +> 4C6 @?>F => ]T6A4=+> ?G467 C6 C?F ?@76?FZ 566> ?AU6F 6a47?-^TF=3=?@@Z ?>F TF=3=?@@Z9 4+

AT776>F67 ?>F 764T7> =4A 4+ ?Z 7=IC4 4+ 76=W5T7A6W6>4 4C676G+7) bj6 XC+ 5T=@FA9 4A +7 A+XA => 5?F G?=4C +> 4C6 @?>F +G ?>+4C679 @+A6A XC?4 =A

5T=@49 46F9 +7 A+X> X=4C+T4 7=IC4 4+ =>F6W>=4Zb g%74) [[19 "6X &=V=@ &+F6h)

dC676G+769 4C6 TFIW6>4 ?+4 6a63T46 ? F66F +G

763+>V6Z?>36 => ?V6Z?>36 56=>I C6765Z F63@?76F V+=F ?5 =>=4=+) &+A4A ?I?=>A4 ?Ie+>9 S+>46W?Z+79 *6Z6A9 %)9 $?T4=A4? %>I6@+9 ,?57?F+79 &+>369 !>F6>3=? ?>F J6@=a9 EE)9 3+>3T7)

C**$"*$&

8) %*L) [0i) OG 4C676 X?A 5?F G?=4C9 >+4 +>@Z +> 4C6 46F +7 A+X6F +> 4C6 @?>F +G

?>+4C679 5T4 ?@A+ +> 4C6 F9 4C6 7=IC4A +G +>6 ?>F 4C6 +4C67 AC?@@ 56 4C6 A?W6 ?A 4C+TIC

5+4C C?F ?346F => I++F G?=4C) ) ) )

JO*BL HOPOBO2"

'()*) "+) 808c80) J657T?7Z .i9 .::0);

AB!=;7 D6 =EHE!; 9 67A9 @,6 ?F?>4A9 ?W+>I 4C6W 67 C676=> ET?> "TIT=F9 4+


64/96

C676=> Y6F7+ Y) Y63A+>9 4C6 ATW +G Y89i[[9::: ?A 76=W5T7A6W6>4 +G T>76?@=e6F =>3+W6 G+7 4C6 >=>I "+V6W567

..9 811i 4+ H636W567 811\) LC6 ? G7+W 4C6 A?=F

Y89i[[9::: 4+ Y.c:9:::) !]T?@@Z ?AA?=@6F 5Z 4C6 67A =A 4C6 ?T?7Z 8:9 .::.9

F6>Z=>I 4C6 W+4=+> G+7 763+>A=F67?4=+>)

O4 W?Z 56 763?@@6F 4C?4 76@?46F@Z => +T7 H63=A=+> F?46F S?Z ./9 81109 => ()*) "+) 880c8[9 6>4=4@6F Y63A+> V) &+T74 +G % &=4Z9 $7?>3C 8:8 ?>F 76W?>F6F 4C6 3?A6 4+ 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 G+7 4C6 F6467W=>?4=+> +G 4C6 3T776>4 W?7U64 V?@T6 +G 4C6

G+T7-F++7 4X+-A4+76Z ?


65/96

LC6 3?A6 =A C6765Z 76W?>F6F 4+ 4C6 47=?@ 3+T74 G+7 =4 4+ F6467W=>6 4C6 3T776>4 W?7U64 V?@T6 +G 4C6 ?


66/96

LC6 +>@Z ]T6A4=+> @6G4 =A 4C6 F6467W=>?4=+> +G =>3+W6 +G 4C6 G+T7 T>=4A +G ?


67/96

+G 5T=@F67A => I++F G?=4C) O4A +5^634 =A 4+ IT?7?>466 GT@@ ?>F +4 566> 76=W5T7A6F g5Z 4C6 XC+ F6G6?46F C=W => 4C6 3?A6 G+7

+G 4C6 F TA6GT@ =W4A W?F6 5Z C=W +> 4C6 4C=>I I@Z9 ? 5T=@F67 => I++F G?=4C 3?>>+4 56 3+W


68/96

JO*BL HOPOBO2"

'()*) "+) ,-/8/[\) 234+567 8.9 81c[);

8-BE3>!: !BB!=-A ];!8-:D3T776>36 +G 4C766 76]T=A=46A 56G+76 ?> ?33764=+> 3+V676F 5Z 4C=A


69/96

K5=C?>9 S6Z3?T?Z?>9 $T@?3?> 5+7F67=>I +> 4C6 S6Z3?T?Z?> ?>F $+3?T6 7=V67A)

2> ET>6 .[9 81\i9 4C6 4A G=@6F ?> ? +G 4C766 @+4A ?F^?36>4 4+ 4C6=7 G=ACF


70/96


71/96

LC6 76?A+> 56C=>F 4C6 @?X I=V=>I 4C6 7= +X>67 4C6 7=IC4 4+ ?>Z @?>F +7 ?@@TV=+> F6I67 +G @+AA 4C?4 C6

ATGG67A 563?TA6 +G 4C6 @+3?4=+> +G C=A @?>F) OG 6A4?46A 5+7F67=>I +> 7=V67A ?76 6aF +4C67 6V=@A F =G 5Z V=74T6 +G @?XGT@ A9 A?=F 6A4?46A ?76 AT5^634 4+ =>3TW57?>36A ?>F V?7=+TA

U=>FA +G 6?A6W6>4A9 =4 =A ) g&+746A V) &=4Z +G S?>=@?9 8: YC=@) 0/\h) j6>369 4C6 7= +X>67 F+6A >+4 ?3]T=76 4C6 ?FF=4=+>A 4+ C=A

@?>F 3?TA6F 5Z AF6F +7 F6A=I>6F 4+ 57=>I ?5+T4 ?33764=+>) dC6> 4C6 4A

47?>AG6776F 4C6=7 F=U6A 4+X?7FA 4C6 7=V67 56F9 4C6 F=U6A X676 W6?>4 G+7 763@?W?4=+> +4 4+ Z +G 4C6 4Af @+>6 X=4>6AA 4+ 4C6

6GG634 4C?4 ?A 6?7@Z ?A 81i1 4C676 ?@76?FZ 6a=A46F AT3C ?@@6I6F ?@@TV=?@ F6+ W67=4) O4 AC+T@F 56 >+46F 4C?4 4C6

@+4A => ]T6A4=+> X676 >+4 =>3@TF6F => 4C6 AT7V6Z +G 4C6=7 ?F^?36>4 S?Z 8:9 81[: ?>F => 4C6 &?F?A47?@

BT7V6Z +G 4C6 6>4=76 ST>=3= 3+>FT346F 564X66> 4C6 Z6?7A 810c 4+ 81/:) LC6 ?@@6I6F ?33764=+> X?A

F63@?76F G+7 4?a?4=+> 81\. +7 ii Z6?7A ?G467 =4 C?F AT@Z V?@=F

3+>3@TA=+> 4C676G+76 =A 4C?4 4C6 A?=F ?76?A 3+T@F >+4 C?V6 566> 4C676 => 81i1) LC6Z 6a=A46F +>@Z ?G467 4C6 4A

47?>AG6776F 4C6=7 F=U6A 4+X?7FA 4C6 56F +G 4C6 S6Z3?T?Z?> 7=V67 => 8108) dC?4 4A 3@?=W ?A ?33764=+> =A

76?@@Z ?> 6>37+?3CW6>4 +G ? +G 4C6 S6Z3?T?Z?> 7=V67 5Z 763@?W?4=+>),,>+4 V?@=F@Z +7F67 4C6 76I=A47?4=+> +G ,+4A 8 D . => 4C6 >?W6A +G 4C6 4A) LC6A6 @+4A X676

A +G 4C6 56F +G 4C6 S6Z3?T?Z?> 7=V67 ?>F ?76 4C676G+76 3@?AA=G=6F ?A


72/96

LC6 G?34A +G 4C6 3?A69 XC=3C ?76 T>F=A67A ?76 4C6 +X>67A +G ? F9 X=4C ?> ?76? +G i)0:i.

C634?76A9 @+3?46F ?4 5?77=+ *?I?>9 WT>=3=36 G7+W

4C6=7 F636?A6F W+4C67 Y?47=3=? %>IT= gXC+ =>C67=46F =4 G7+W C67 F %>? ,+ XC+A6 >?W6 A?=F @?>F ??@ &674=G=3?46 +G L=4@6 "+) .1c.9 =AAT6F

+> ET>6 19 81i[h) B?=F F 4C6=7 -=>4676A49 X676 G+7W67@Z => F 3+>4=>T+TA 4C676+G9 T>4=@

B6 76AF6>4A 6>4676F T 4C6 @?>F T>F67 3@?=W +G +X>67AC=67A ?@A+ ?AU6F G+7 F?W?I6A

3+776AF=>I 4+ 4C6 V?@T6 +G 4C6 G7T=4A +G 4C6 @?>F ?A X6@@ ?A ?44+7>6ZfA G66A ?>F 3+A4A) O> 4C6=7 ?>AX67 gF?46F J657T?7Z 8c9

810ch9 76AF6>4A 3@?=W +X>67AC=< => 4C6WA6@V6A9 ?AA674=>I 4C?4 4C6Z C?V6 566> => 3+>4=>T+TA9 +9 ?>F T>F=A4T756F

+G A?=F 9 A=>36 A4?>36 +G OA?56@?9 +> S?Z [9 81019 76>F676F ? F63=A=+> ?F^TFI=>I 4C6 +X>67AC=< +G 4C6

=> ]T6A4=+> 4+ 67A9 ?>F +7F67=>I 76AF6>4A 4+ V?3?46 4C6 F F6@=V67 4C676+G 4+ 67A9

?>F 4+


73/96

AC+T@F 36 X=4C 4C6 7T@6 +G >?4T7?@ ?336AA=+> => %74=3@6 i// +G

4C6 +@F &=V=@ &+F6 g>+X %74=3@6 [0\h9 XC=3C 67 +G @?>FA ?F^+=>=>I 4C6 5?>UA +G 7=V67A9 56@+>IA 4C6

?33764=+> XC=3C 4C6Z I7?FT?@@Z 7636=V6 G7+W 4C6 6GG634A +G 4C6 3T776>4 +G 4C6 X?467)f LC6 F6G6>F?>4A9 C+X6V679 3+>46>F 4C?4

4C6Z C?V6 ?3]T=76F +X>67AC=< 4C7+TIC 46>4=+> 4C=A 3?A6) LC6 &+T74 ? ]T+9 C?A

76A+@V6F =4 => G?V+7 +G 4C6 4=GGA9 +> 4X+ I7+T>FA_ J=7A49 A=>36 5Z ?336AA=+>9 4C6 @?>F => ]T6A4=+> A 4+ 4C6 +7=I=>?@

6A4?469 ?>F A=>36 => 4C=A =>A4?>36 4C6 +7=I=>?@ 6A4?46 =A 76I=A4676F9 4C6 ?33764=+>9 3+>A6]T6>4@Z9 G?@@A X=4C=> 4C6 [/ +G %34 "+) [1/9 XC=3C A4?46A 4C?4 f>+ 4=4@6 4+ 76I=A4676F @?>F => F67+I?4=+> 4+ 4C?4 +G 4C6 76I=A4676F +X>67 AC?@@ 56

?3]T=76F 5Z F9 A63+>F9 4C6 ?FV67A6 +G 4C6 F6G6>F?>4 56I?> +>@Z => 4C6

W+>4C +G B6 4C6 8:-Z6?7 A4=4T46F)

b%A ? @6I?@ F 76@=6F T 5Z 4C6 47=?@ 3+T749 =A >+4 ]T=46 3+77634) %> ?33764=+> 4+ 76I=A4676F @?>F9

XC=@6 F63@?76F 5Z AI 4+ 4C6 +X>67 +G 4C6 @?>F ?A ? >?4T7?@ ?336AA=+> 4C676+G9 F+6A

>+4 =4=4@6F 4+ 4C6 +G 4C6 7T@6 +G =W

%34) BT3C F+6A >+4 6a46>F 56Z+>F 4C6 ?76? I=V6> ?>F F6A37=56F => 4C6 3674=G=3?46) L+ C+@F +4C67X=A69 X+T@F 56

GTA=+>) O4 X+T@F V=74T?@@Z F6F 4C6 463C>=3?@ F6A37= +G 4C6 @?>F I=V6> 4C676=>9 +G 4C6=7

3C?7?3467 +G 3+>3@TA=V6>6AA ?A 4+ 4C6 =F6>4=4Z ?>F ?76? +G 4C6 @?>F 4C?4 =A 76I=A4676F) ETA4 ?A 4C6 BT ?

>6I?4=V6 W?>>679 C?A A4?46F 4C?4 76I=A47?4=+> F+6A >+4 F

4C7+TIC I7?FT?@ 3C?>I6A => 4C6 3+T7A6 +G 4C6 ?F^+=>=>I A476?W gY?Z?4?A !A4?46 H6V6@+4 &+) VA) LT?A+>9 0i YC=@) 00h9 A+

76I=A47?4=+> F+6A >+4 6>4=4@6 C=W 4+ ?@@ 4C6 7=IC4A 3+>G6776F 5Z 4C6 ,?>F *6I=A47?4=+> %349 => A+ G?7 ?A 4C6 ?76? ?FF6F 5Z

?33764=+> =A 3+>367>6F) dC?4 7=IC4A C6 C?A9 ?76 F63@?76F >+4 5Z A?=F %349 5T4 5Z 4C6 A +G 4C6 &=V=@ &+F6 +> ?336AA=+>M

?>F 4C6A6 A F+ >+4 +G 4C6 ?FF=4=+>?@ ?76? 5Z ?>+4C67 4C7+TIC 4C6 3?A6 +G (?@=>F6e9 64 ?@) VA) $?IT=A?9 64 ?@)9 &%-() *) "+) 81.[1-*9 ET@Z 8\9 8101)

bd6 >+X F 76@=6F T 5Z 4C6 47=?@ 3+T749 76I?7F=>I 4C6 @6>I4C +G 4=W6 4C?4 4C6

F6G6>F?>4A C?V6 566> => ) H+W=>I+ &?@?@T>I 46A4=G=6F 4C?4 C6 +33TF => ]T6A4=+> G+7 4C6 G=7A4 4=W6 =>

81i[9 >+4 => 81[c ?A 3@?=W6F 5Z 4C6 4=GGA) LC6 ?76? T>F67 +33T3Z I7?FT?@@Z =>376?A6F ?A 4C6 Z6?7A X6>4 5Z) O> 81[/9

C6 F63@?76F 4C6 @?>F G+7 X?A AT 81[c 5Z ?>+4C67 g!aC=5=4 .h9

?G467 4C6 >?W6 +G 4C6 WT>=3=I6F G7+W LTW?T=>= 4+ S?IA?ZA?Z) &?@?@T>IfA 46A4=W+>Z =A

3+77+5+7?46F 5Z 4X+ X=4>6AA6A9 5+4C +X>67A +G 9 \. Z6?7A +G ?I69 XC+ X?A ST>=3=F => ]T6A4=+> ?F^+=>A C=A +X> +> 4C6 A+T4C9 ?>F 4C?4 A=>36 81[: +7

81[89 C6 C?A ?@X?ZA U>+X> =4 4+ 56 => 4C6 F?>4A) P=36>46 &) $?3?>= 46A4=G=6F 4+ 4C6 A?W6 6GG6349

?@4C+TIC9 C6 A?=F 4C?4 4C6 F6G6>F?>4Af A4?746F A+W64=W6 => 81ii +7 81i[) LC6 ?76? 4C676+G9 C6 A?=F9 X?A 4C6> @6AA

4C?> +>6 C634?76)

bd6 G=>F 4C6 46A4=W+>Z +G 4C6 A?=F X=4>6AA6A 6>4=4@6F 4+ WT3C I76?467 X6=IC4 ?>F 376F6>36 4C?> 4C?4 +G 4C6 4=GG Y6F7+

(7?>F6 ?>F C=A @+>6 X=4>6AA9 ,?T76?>? *+F7=IT6e) LC6 G=7A4 A4?46F 4C?4 4C6 F6G6>F?>4A +33TF

Documents

Outline 3 PROPERTY Cases