37
Keith R. Holden, M.D. Ponte Vedra Beach, FL www.Dr-Holden.com

Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising Treatment Options

  • Upload
    sona

  • View
    44

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising Treatment Options. Keith R. Holden, M.D. Ponte Vedra Beach, FL www.Dr-Holden.com. Osteoporosis Controversies. Guidelines for prevention and tx vary Bone quality versus bone quantity Same BMD can have different fx risk (age) - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Keith R. Holden, M.D.

Ponte Vedra Beach, FLwww.Dr-Holden.com

Page 2: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Guidelines for prevention and tx vary

Bone quality versus bone quantity

Same BMD can have different fx risk (age)

Cumbersome dosing requirements

Drug side effects

Page 3: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Esophagitis

Esophageal stricture

Esophageal cancer

Osteonecrosis of jaw

Atypical Femur Fracture

Page 4: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Bisphosphonates ↓ osteoclast fxn & induce osteoclast apoptosis

Suppress bone resorption = hard, brittle bone

Path: ↓ bone heterogeneity = ↓ bone quality Complete lack of TCN labeling = severe ↓ bone formation Stress injury-like cortical hypertrophy in other femur with

unilateral AFF

Page 5: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

↑ BMD does not always = ↑ bone strength

T-score not consistent predictor of osteoporosis outside of elderly postmenopausal white♀

Other populations, Z score may be better predictor of low bone density

Page 6: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

www.shef.ac.uk/FRAX/tool.jsp

FRAX estimates 10-yr. fx risk based on BMD femoral neck + osteo risk factors

Page 7: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Bone quality = bone strength (cortical bone structure/quality of collagen) + rate of remodeling

Bone densitometry measures BMD (quantity), helps assess fx risk, aids in dx of osteo, but does NOT measure bone quality

Page 8: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Healthy bone requires a balance of:

Bone building by osteoblasts

Resorption by osteoclasts

Page 9: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

90% collagen (majority Type 1)

Osteoclast degradation & osteoblast synthesis create circulating peptides of Type 1 collagen

Type I collagen is cross-linked by deoxypyridinoline (DPD)

DPD provides rigidity and strength (quality) to bone

Page 10: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Reflects bone remodeling yrs. before BMD ∆

↑ T score + ↑ biomarker → fx risk (odds 4.1)

Allow tracking of response to therapy

May improve adherence to therapy

Page 11: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Cross-link Type IC (relatively selective)

Measure of bone resorption - ↑ urine level > bone loss

Unaffected by diet

Easy to measure spot AM urine

Recheck within 30-90 days after initiating therapy

Covered by Medicare

Page 12: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Calcium Vitamin D Magnesium Boron Strontium ranelate Ipriflavone Vitamin K Choline stabilized orthosilicic acid (ch-OSA)

Page 13: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Ch-OSA = bioavailable silicon

RDBPC trial: added to calcium and D3 showing improved bone biomarkers and BMD ↑ 2%

RDBPC trial: ↑ tensile strength of hair

RDBPC trial: + effects of skin surface changes, mechanical properties, ↓ brittleness hair/nails

Page 14: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Pulsed Electromagnetic Field (PEMF) therapy has shown promise in clinical trials for tx and prevention of osteoporosis

Mediates process via cell signaling proteins – growth factors, cytokines, and prostaglandins

Page 15: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 16: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

PEMF 72Hz 10 hrs daily for 12 wks to radius of “osteoporosis prone” ♀

BMD showed sig. inc. in exposed areas 36 wks

Similar but weaker response in non-treated arm

(Tabrah, et. al., 1990)

Page 17: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Evaluated rats with surgically induced DOP

After 8 wks, PEMF sig. ↑BMD, ↑ TGF-beta 1, ↓IL-6 in proximal femur

Conclusion: PEMF efficiently suppresses bone loss in DOP via local factors

(Shen, et al., 2010)

Page 18: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Evaluated CR with PEMF in ovariectomy-induced osteoporosis in rats

12 weeks, (OVX-DPEMF) group had better prevention against OVX-induced bone loss

↑BMD, ↑osteoblast activity, ↑ trabecular health markers; ↓bone markers of resorption (uDPD)

(Jing, et. al., 2010)

Page 19: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Rats with streptozotocin-induced DM bone loss

PEMF daily 8 hrs x 8 wks

PEMF improved biomechanical bone quality DM bone

PEMF partially reversed DM-induced bone deterioration

Conclusion: PEMF might become an additive method for inhibiting DM osteoporosis

(Jing, et al., 2011)

Page 20: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Study on in-vitro osteoblastic cell culture

PEMF ↑osteoblastic growth, ↑ TGF-beta 1

PEMF ↓ prostaglandin E2

Conclusion: Study sheds light on mechanism of action of PEMF in non-union fx & prevention of osteoporosis

(Li, et al., 2007)

Page 21: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Studied rats subjected to bil ovariectomy

PEMF augmented/restored trabecular bone mass/architecture in PEMF groups

PEMF attenuated higher serum PGE(2) of OVX rats and restored levels to that of controls

Conclusion: PEMF may be useful in prevention of osteoporosis resulting from ovariectomy

(Chang, et al., 2003)

Page 22: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

PTH used to tx osteoporosis; Insulin & IGF-1 anabolic roles in osteogenesis

Cell signaling proteins IRS-1, S6 RSK, & eNOS were phosphorylated by PTH, Insulin, & PEMF to the same extent in osteoblast-like cells

Conclusion: Anabolic affects of PEMF may be mediated through these proteins

(Schnoke, et. al., 2007)

Page 23: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

↑ BMD

↑ TGF-beta 1

↓ IL-6

↓ PGE(2)

↑ osteoblast growth

Phosphorylation of IRS-1, S6 RSK, eNOS

Page 24: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 25: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Alkalinizing plant based diet

Address food sensitivities Mineral rich foods

Page 26: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Remove

Replace

Reinnoculate

Repair

Rebalance

Page 27: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Foci of interference (ANS) Stress Inflammation Toxins Allergy Infection (occult, dysbiosis, dental) Heavy metals

Page 28: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Resistance training

Nutritional supplementation

Hormonal balance

PEMF

Page 29: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 30: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

66 y.o ♀ with osteoporosis (T-score -3.1) Baseline: mostly plant based diet,

resistance training, Ca, Mg, and D (1/27/11) uDPD 9.7 nM/mM Cr (NL < 6.5) Weekly 1 hr PEMF sessions x 2 mos

(3/16/11) uDPD 4.5 (53% drop!) Maintenance: Monthly 1 hr PEMF

(7/21/11) uDPD 5.5 (10/24/11) uDPD 4.5

Page 31: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 32: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

63 y.o. ♀ osteoporosis (‘09 T-score LS -3.9; ‘11 T-score LS -4.1)

Hx FMG, CFS, IBS, MCS & hx multiple fxs Baseline: BHRT, Ca, Mg, D Added ch-OSA + tx gut dysbiosis Started PEMF (3/26/11) monthly; (7/26/11) inc.

freq. to weekly; (9/12/11) 2-3 X week (4/13/11) uDPD 9.7; (10/4/11) uDPD 5.0

(48.45% drop!)

Page 33: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 34: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 35: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 36: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options
Page 37: Osteoporosis – Controversies and Promising  Treatment Options

Keith R. Holden, M.D.

822 A1A North, Suite 310Ponte Vedra Beach, FL 32082

(904) [email protected]

www.Dr-Holden.com