20
Title 科学的根拠と技能 : 理学療法哲学試論 Author(s) 堀, 寛史 Citation 臨床哲学. 19 P.45-P.63 Issue Date 2018-03-31 Text Version publisher URL http://hdl.handle.net/11094/68163 DOI rights Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA https://ir.library.osaka-u.ac.jp/repo/ouka/all/ Osaka University

Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

Title 科学的根拠と技能 : 理学療法哲学試論

Author(s) 堀, 寛史

Citation 臨床哲学. 19 P.45-P.63

Issue Date 2018-03-31

Text Version publisher

URL http://hdl.handle.net/11094/68163

DOI

rights

Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKAOsaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA

https://ir.library.osaka-u.ac.jp/repo/ouka/all/

Osaka University

Page 2: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

45

WHO

1981 1

4

1981 WHO

WHO 2001International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health, ICF

Page 3: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

46

1965

1965 6 29 137 2

50

ICF

2 34

2

3 4

Page 4: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

47

physics: physical:

physical medicine

( ) philosophy

physical therapist

physiotherapy physiotherapist physical

physiotherapy

physiology

Page 5: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

48

�� (: -)� ��8?� ���(: 7" ���3"50"�%/�

Page 6: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

49

2007 2001.

G 1987.

knowing how

disposition 5

D 2001.

on in

Page 7: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

50

on Task Achievement

in

how to

33 2017

2 1

Page 8: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

51

6

Page 9: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

52

educated guess

Page 10: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

53

on in

A B

EBM Evidence Based Medicine

Haynes, 2002. EBM

EBM

� �

Page 11: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

54

���3"50�"�%>�

7

50

NBM Narrative-based Medicine

Page 12: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

55

( 2013.) 1984 20136

. 22

1

Page 13: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

56

,2002.

Page 14: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

57

2007 ”Academic Medicine”

Whitcomb, 2007

humanistic professional

Cohen,2007

3

324

Page 15: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

58

2015.

Page 16: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

59

2

3

2013.

Page 17: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

60

.

Page 18: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

61

1992.

� �

Page 19: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

19

62

5 - 2007. -

2011. - 1987 - ―

2001 p.89 - R Brian Haynes, P J Devereaux Gordon H Guyatt, ”Physicians' and patients' choices in

evidence based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350.

- 6 2013. - 2002 p.41. - Whitcomb,M.E. Special Issue: Professionalism in Medicine, Academic Medicine, 82(11):

1009, 2007 . - Cohen, Jordan J. Linking Professionalism to Humanisum: What It Means, Why It

Matters, Academic Medicine, 82(11), 1029-1032, 2007. - 33 2017 - PHP 2015 - 2 FD

2013 pp.32-53. - 1992 p.135.

1.

2. 2006

3.

4.

5.

6. 7.

Page 20: Osaka University Knowledge Archive : OUKA based practice Evidence does not make decisions, people do”, BMJ. 2002, Jun 8; 324(7350): 1350. - F Âó d e f B P U ! ÷ z6 8 f÷ ÌÙ

� � � ʾžĠŐ 19đ

63