65
rk OSAGE - GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~ BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM Uited States Armiy AiDrooge Il Crs ofnnsers 12 .Z rpdv St. Louis District PREPARED BY: U.S. ARMY ENGINEER DISTRICT, ST. LOUIS 8 FOR: STATE OF MISSOURI DECEMBER 1979 "l II o) 0 06 AIeIjr u~ri mam

OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

rk

OSAGE - GASCONADE BASIN

AD I I , 4 5, 6

WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~

BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI

MO 310152

PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORTNATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

Uited States Armiy AiDroogeIl Crs ofnnsers 12 .Z rpdv

St. Louis District

PREPARED BY: U.S. ARMY ENGINEER DISTRICT, ST. LOUIS

8 FOR: STATE OF MISSOURI

DECEMBER 1979

"l II o) 006

AIeIjr u~ri

mam

Page 2: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

·•·

THIS DOCUMENT IS BEST QUALITY AVAILABLE. THE COPY

FURNISHED TO DTIC CONTAINED

A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF

PAGES WHICH DO NOT

REPRODUCE LEGIBLY,

Page 3: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

UNCLASSIFIED

SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE ('Tmhi Date Entered)

REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE BEORE COMPLETING FORMI. REPORT NUMBER 12. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S CATALOG NUMBER

4. TITLE (and Subtitle) S. TYPE OF REPORT & PERIOD COVEREDPhase I Dam Inspection ReportNational Dam Safety Program Final Xepert.Hayes, William Lake Dam (MO 31052) R*iFPE-IwRMINUORO. WEORT NUMBER

Benton County, Missouri7. AUTHOR(s) S. CONTRACT OR GRANT NUMBER(s)

Anderson Engineering, Inc.

, DACW43-79-C-0070I9. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME AND ADDRESS 10. PROGRAM ELEMENTPROJECT, TASK

U.S. Army Engineer District, St. Louis AREA & WORK UNIT NUMBERS

Dam Inventory and Inspection Section, LMSED-PD / , K210 Tucker Blvd., North, St. Louis, Mo. 63101

II. CONTROLLING OFFICE NAME AND ADDRESS 12. REPORTQATIU.S. Army Engineer District, St. Louis 1 Decembw IV79Dam Inventory and Inspection Section, LMSED-PDI " ,S. NUMBEA6F PAGES

210 Tucker Blvd., North, St. Louis, Mo. 63101 Approximately 6014. MMOTORING AGENCY NAME & ADDRESS(if dillerent from Controlling Office) IS. SECURITY CLASS. (of thie report)

National Dam Safety Program. William UNCLASSIFIEDHayes Lake Dam (MO 31052), Osage - . DECLASSIFICATION/DOWNGRADING

Gasconade Basin, Benton County, Missouri. SCHEDULE

1 Phase I Inspection Report. "/"

Approved for release; distribution unlimited. /

17. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (of the abstract entered In Block 20, If dfifeteat frm Report)

1. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

19. KEY WORDS (Cmlnue on reverse side if neceaary aid Identify by block number)

Dam Safety, Lake, Dam Inspection, Private Dams

2& AWT'ACT (Caff - ,emre N e mie deguf il by block mvmbe)

This report was prepared under the National Program of Inspection ofNon-Federal Dams. This report assesses the general condition of the dam withrespect to safety, based on available data and on visual inspection, todetermine if the dam poses hazards to human life or property.

JINT / UNCLASSIFIED

SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE (When Date Entered)

-7-

Page 4: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGS(fWhi bela 80o*

SEtCURITY CLASSIFICATION OF TIS PAGR(VWben DMaleEtered)

Page 5: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMYST. LOUIS DISTRICT, CORPS OpF ENGINEERS

210 NORTH 12TH STREETST. LOUIS, MISSOURI 63101

SUBJECT: William Hayes Lake Dam Phase I Inspection Report

This report presents the results of field inspection andevaluation of the William Hayes Lake Dam (MO 31052).

It was prepared under the National Program of Inspection ofNon-Federal Dams.

This dam has been classified as unsafe, non-emergency by theSt. Louis District as a result of the application of the

following criteria:

1) Spillway will not pass 50 percent of the Probable Maxi-mum Flood

2) Overtopping could result in dam failure3) Dam failure significantly increases the hazard to loss

of life downstream

SUBMITTED BY: SIGNED MARChief, Engineering Division Date

3. AIR QAPPROVED BY: _ _ _ _ _ _ ___"

€olonel._ CL7; frict .ncjine_. Date

Ic r

L 0'..! . .. . ...

- I,

-- f i X4*j "CJ '.

Page 6: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM

BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI

MISSOURI INVENTORY NO. 31052

PHASE I INSPECTION REPORTNATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

Prepared by

Anderson Engineering, Inc. Springfield, MissouriHanson Engineers, Inc., Springfield, Illinois

Under Direction of

St. Louis District, Corps of Engineers

Fo r

Governor of Missouri

March, 1980

'a I tA%-- -

Page 7: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

PHASE I REPORTNATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

Name of Dam: William Hayes Lake DamState Located: MissouriCounty Located: Benton CountyStream: Tributary to Lake of the OzarksDate of Inspection: 6 September 1979

William Hayes Lake Dam was inspected by an interdisci-plinary team of engineers from Anderson Engineering, Inc. ofSpringfield, Missouri and Hanson Engineers, Inc. of Spring-field, Illinois. The purpose of the inspection was to makean assessment of the general condition of the dam with re-spect to safety, based upon available data and visual in-spection, in order to determine if the dam poses hazards tohuman life or property.

The guidelines used in the assessment were furnishedby the Department of the Army, Office of the Chief of Engi-neers, and they have been developed with the help of severalFederal and State agencies, professional engineering organi-zations, and private engineers. Based on these guidelines,the St. Louis District, Corps of Engineers has determinedthat this dam is in the high hazard potential classifica-tion, which means that loss of life and appreciable propertyloss could occur if the dam fails. The estimated damagezone extends approximately one half mile downstream of thedam. Located within this zone are several dwellings. Thedam is in the small size classification, since it is greaterthan 25 ft. high but less than 40 ft. high, and the maximumstorage capacity is greater than 50 acre-ft. but less than1000 acre-ft.

Our inspection and evaluation indicates that the com-bined spillways do not meet the criteria set forth in theguidelines for a dam having the above size and hazard poten-tial. The combined spillways will pass 25 percent of theProbable Maximum Flood without overtopping. The ProbableMaximum Flood is defined as the flood discharge that may beexpected from the most severe combination of critical meteo-rologic and hydrologic conditions that are reasonably pos-sible in the region. The guidelines require that a dam of

Page 8: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

small size with a high downstream hazard potential pass 50to 100 percent of the PMF. Considering the small volume ofwater impounded, and the height of the dam, 50 percent ofthe PMF has been determined to be the appropriate spillwaydesign flood. The 100-year frequency flood will not overtopthe dam. The 100-year flood is one that has a 1 percentchance of being equalled or exceeded in any given year.

Deficiencies visually observed by the inspection teamwere: (1) lack of wave protection along the entire frontface of dam; (2) heavy weed growth on front face of dam; (3)weeds and concrete block around primary spillway inlet; (4)erosion at east embankment-abutment contact; (5) seepage ar-eas at downstream toe beyond primary spillway outlet; and(6) small amount of water coming out of primary spillwayoutlet even though there was no flow over the spillwaycrest. Another deficiency was the lack of seepage and sta-bility analysis records.

It is recommended that the owners take the necessaryaction in the near future to correct the deficiencies re-ported herein. A detailed discussion of these deficienciesis included in the following report.

JoxfM .Healy, F.E.Has n Engineers, In

Anderson Engineering, In

Tom Beckley, P.E.Anderson Engineering,\ Inc.

Gene Wertepn , P'.E.Hanson Engineers, Inc.

Dan Kerns, Y.I.T.Hanson Enallneers, Inc.

-.

Page 9: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

AERIAL VIEW OF LAKE AND DAM

Page 10: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

r

PHASE I INSPECTION REPORTNATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM - ID No. 31052

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Paragraph Page

No. Title No.

SECTION 1 - PROJECT INFORMATION

1.1 General 11.2 Description 11.3 Pertinent Data 3

SECTION 2 - ENGINEERING DATA

2.1 Design 72.2 Construction 82.3 Operation 92.4 Evaluation 9

SECTION 3 - VISUAL INSPECTION

3.1 Findings 103.2 Evaluation 12

SECTION 4 - OPERATION PROCEDURES

4.1 Procedures 134.2 Maintenance of Dam 134.3 Maintenance of Operating Facilities 134.4 Description of Any Warning System in Effect 134.5 Evaluation 13

SECTION 5 - HYDRAULIC/HYDROLOGIC

5.1 Evaluation of Features 14

SECTION 6 - STRUCTURAL STABILITY

6.1 Evaluation of Structural Stability 16

SECTION 7 - ASSESSMENT/REMEDIAL MEASURES

7.1 Dam Assessment 177.2 Remedial Measures 18

I-.

' _ .... : . ... ,aIm.JUL

Page 11: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

APPENDICES

APPENDIX A Sheet

Location Map 1Vicinity Map 2Plan, Profile and Section of Dam 3Plan Sketch of Dam 4SCS Survey Sketch 5SCS Survey Notes 6 - 7SCS Earthwork Computation Sheet 8

APPENDIX B

Geologic Regions of Missouri 1Thickness of Loessial Deposits 2

APPENDIX C

Overtopping Analysis - PMF 1 - 7SCS Hydraulic Design Sheets 8 - 9

APPENDIX D

Photographs of Dam and Lake 1 - 8

.....

Page 12: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 1 -PROJECT INFORMATION

1.1 GENERAL:

A. Authority:

The National Dam Inspection Act, Public Law 92-367,authorized the Secretary of the Army, through the Corps ofEngineers, to initiate a program of safety inspection ofdams throughout the United States. Pursuant to the above,the St. Louis District, Corps of Engineers, District Engi-neer directed that a safety inspection be made of WilliamHayes Lake Dam in Benton County, Missouri.

B. Purpose of Inspection:

The purpose of the inspection was to make an assessmentof the general condition of the dam with respect to safety,based upon available data and a visual inspection in orderto determine if the dam poses hazards to human life or prop-erty.

C. Evaluation Criteria:

Criteria used to evaluate the dam were furnished by theDepartment of the Army, Office of the Chief Engineers, "Rec-ommended Guidelines for Safety Inspection of Dams, AppendixD.11 These guidelines were developed with the help of severalfederal agencies and many state agencies, professional engi-neering organizations, and private engineers.

1.2 DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:

A. Description of Dam and Appurtenances:

William Hayes Lake Dam is an earth fill structure ap-proximately 32 ft. high and 360 ft. long at the crest. Theappurtenant works consist of an 18 in. diameter primaryspillway pipe with 30 in. diameter riser pipe, a four in.diameter drawdown pipe with a four in. gate valve connectionto a two in. diameter gate valve and an emergency spillwaycut into natural ground in the east abutment. Sheet 3 ofAppendix A shows a plan, profile and typical section of theembankment.

. . .~- . ...

Page 13: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

B. Location:

The dam is located in the central part of Benton Coun-ty, Missouri on a tributary of Lake of the Ozarks. The damand lake are within the Edwards , Missouri 7.5 minute quad-rangle sheet (Section 14, T4ON, R21W - latitude 38 14.9';longitude 93 14.3'). Sheet 2 of Appendix A shows the gener-al vicinity.

C. Size Classification:

With an embankment height of 32 ft. and a maximum stor-age capacity of approximately 80 acre-ft., the dam is in thesmall size category.

D. Hazard Classification:

The St. Louis District, Corps of Engineers has classi-fied this dam as a high hazard dam. The estimated damagezone extends approximately one half mile downstream of thedam. Located within the damage zone are several dwellings.

E. Ownership:

The dam is owned by Mr. and Mrs. William Hayes. Theowners' address is Warsaw, Missouri 65355. (Telephone num-ber is 816-438-6367)

F. Purpose of the Dam:

The dam was constructed primarily for recreational pur-poses.

G. Design and Construction History:

The dam was designed by the United States Department ofAgriculture, Soil Conservation Service. Design plans andnotes were obtained from the SCS office in Warsaw, Missouri,and are included in Appendix A. The dam was constructedover a two year period by Mr. Hayes and completed in 1975.During the construction period Mr. Dan Philbrock of the SCSoffice in Warsaw supervised the construction of the dam. Atrench 15 to 20 ft. deep was excavated to solid bedrock.Borings were taken along the length of the core to check forrock ledges. A layer of bentonite was placed in the bottomof the trench after the remaining soil material was sweptoff the bedrock. The material for the cutoff trench was ob-tained from the lake area. Bedrock was exposed during exca-

-2-

Page 14: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

vation in the lake area. Material was spread over the ex-posed area and compacted. After the filling and compactionoperation reached an elevation above the proposed top ofspillway pipe, a trench was cut across the crest and downthe embankment and the spillway pipe was then placed in thetrench. The material surrounding the pipe was then handtamped. Three anti-seep collars were installed on the 18in. spillway pipe. Drainage into the lake area during theconstruction of the dam was removed via the four in. drainpipe. After the lake began filling, a two in. gate valvewas connected about two ft. downstream from the four in.gate valve due to leakage through the four in. valve. A twoin. diameter pipe extends the outlet for the drawdown systemabout 20 ft. downstream of the embankment toe.

All of the information listed above was furnished byMr. William Hayes, the owner of the dam.

H. Normal Operative Procedures:

Normal flows are to be passed by an uncontrolled 30 in.CMP drop inlet through an 18 in. CMP outlet near the centerof the dam. Excess flows are passed by the emergency spill-way in the east abutment. Mr. Hayes stated that the maximumpool elevation was about one foot above the primary spillwayinlet.

1.3 PERTINENT DATA:

Pertinent data about the dam, appurtenant works, andreservoir are presented in the following paragraphs. Sheet3 of Appendix A presents a plan, profile and typical sectionof the embankment.

A. Drainage Area:

The drainage area for this dam, as obtained from theU.S.G.S. quad sheet, is approximately 92 acres.

B. Discharge at Dam Site:

(1) All discharge at the dan site is through uncontrolledspillways. Rating curves were developed assuming acombination of Weir and pipe flow for the primaryspillway and critical flow for the emergency spillwaysection.

(2) Estimated Total Spillway Capacity at Maximum Pool (Topof Dam - El. 734.1 ft., MSL): 100 cfs

-3--

Page 15: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

(3) Estimated Capacity of Primary Spillway: 23 cfs

(4) Estimated Experienced Maximum Flood at Dam Site:Elevation 730.5 , 17 cfs

(5) Diversion Tunnel Low Pool Outlet at Pool Elevation:Not Applicable

(6) Diversion Tunnel Outlet at Pool Elevation: Not Appli-cable

(7) Gated Spillway Capacity at Pool Elevation: Not Appli-cable

(B) Gated Spillway Capacity at Maximum Pool Elevation: NotApplicable

C. Elevations:

(All elevations are consistent with an estimatedMSL elevation of 730.0 for the top edge of the 36in. drop inlet.)

(1) Top of Dam: Low Point: 734.1 , High Point: 734.5

(2) Principal Spillway Crest: 730.0

(3) Emergency Spillway Crest: 732.4

(4) Principal Outlet Pipe Invert: 705.7

(5) Streambed at Centerline of Dam: 702.7

(6) Pool on Date of Inspection: 729.1 (0.9 ft. belownormal pool)

(7) Apparent High Water Mark: .730.5

(8) Maximum Tailwater: Unknown

(9) Upstream Portal Invert Diversion Tunnel: Not Applicable

(10) Downstream Portal Invert Diversion Tunnel: Not Appli-cable

D. Reservoir Lengths:

(1) At Top of Dam: 1080 ft.

-4-

Page 16: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

(2) At Principal Spillway Crest: 1000 ft.-

(3) At Emergency Spillway Crest: 1050 ft._

E. Storage Capacities:

(1) At Principal Spillway Crest: 54 Acre-ft.

(2) At Top of Dam: 80 Acre-ft.

(3) At Emergency Spillway Crest: 69 Acre-ft.

F. Reservoir Surface Areas:

(1.) At Principal Spillway Crest: 5.9 Acres

(2) At Top of Dam: 7.3 Acres

(3) At Emergency Spillway Crest: 6.7 Acres

G. Dam:

(1) Type: Earth

(2) Length at Crest: 360 ft.

(3) Height: 32 ft.

(4) Top Width: 12 ft.

(5) Side Slopes: Upstream slope to water edge is 2.46H:IV;Downstream Varies from 2.68H:IV & 3.31H:IV. (See Sheet3, Appendix A).

(6) Zoning: Homogeneous

(7) Impervious Core: None

(8) Cutoff: According to Mr. William Hayes a trench 15 to20 ft. deep was cut down to bedrock. The trench wasfilled with compacted clay after placing a layer ofbentonite on the bedrock surface.

(9) Grout Curtain: None

H. Diversion and Regulating Tunnel:

(1) Type: Not Applicable

-5-

Page 17: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

(2) Length: Not Applicable

(3) Closure: Not Applicable

(4) Access: Not Applicable

(5) Regulating Facilities: Not Applicable

I. Spillway:

I.1 Principal Spillway:

(1) Location: Near the center of the dam at Sta. 2+00

(2) Type: 30 in. CMP drop inlet riser pipe with an 18 in.CMP through the embankment.

1.2 Emergency Spillway:

(1) Location: East abutment

(2) Type: Earth Channel

I. Regulating Outlets:

A four in. diameter pipe with a four in. gate valveconnecting to a two in. gate valve with a two in. diamteroutlet pipe.

-6-

-- 6 -

Page 18: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 2 - ENGINEERING DATA

2.1 DESIGN:

Design notes of the embankment are available from the

Department of Agriculture Soil Conservation Service Officeat Warsaw, Missouri. Copies of these notes are included inAppendix A and hydraulic calculations are included in Appen-dix C. No documentation of construction inspection recordshave been obtained. To our knowledge there are no document-ed maintenance and operation data.

A. Surveys:

A site suvey conducted by the SCS before the dam wasbuilt was copied from a drawing in the Warsaw Office and isincluded in Appendix A. The top edge of the 30 in. primaryspillway riser was used as datum for our survey. From pho-tographs and quad sheets the elevation was estimated to be730.0 ft. mean sea level elevation.

B. Geology and Subsurface Materials:

The site is located in the Western edge of the Ozarksgeologic region of Missouri. The Ozarks are characterizedtopographically by hills, plateaus and deep valleys. Themost common bedrock types are dolomite, sandstone and chert.Information supplied by the Missouri Geological Survey indi-cates that the lake area is underlain by the Roubidoux for-mation of the Canadian Series in the Ordovician System. TheRoubidoux formation consists of sandstone, dolomitic sand-stone and cherty dolomite. The publication "Caves of Mis-souri" lists two caves known to exist in Benton County.These caves are several miles from the site.

The "Geologic Map of Missouri" indicates the nearestfault to be approximately 20 miles east of the site. TheMissouri Geological Survey has indicated that the faults inthis area are generally considered to be inactive and havebeen for several hundred million years (rock associated withthe Ordovician Period - 500 million years old).

Soils in the area of the dam site appear to be primar-ily deposits of residual silty clays with rock fragments.The soils are of the Clarksville-Fullerton-Talbott Soil As-sociation and have developed from thin loessial soils depos-ited over weathered material from cherty dolomites. The

-7-

Page 19: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

loessial thickness map indicates that upland areas may havebetween 2.5 and 5.0 ft. of loess cover.

C. Foundation and Embankment Design:

No foundation or embankment design information wasavailable. Information from the owner indicates the pres-ence of a 15 to 20 ft. deep cutoff trench to bedrock. Bed-rock was verified at the base of the cutoff by a number ofborings into the rock material. A layer of bentonite wasplaced on the rock prior to filling the trench with clay ob-tained from the lake area. The remaining material for theembankment also came from the lake area. During borrowingoperations, bedrock was exposed in the lake area. The ownerindicated these areas were covered with a layer of compactedclay. There is apparently no particular zoning of the em-bankment and no internal drainage features are known to ex-ist. No construction inspection test results are available.

D. Hydrology and Hydraulics:

The original hydraulic and hydrologic design data hasbeen obtained from the Soil Conservation Service and is in-cluded in Appendix C. Based on a field check of spillwaydimensions, embankment elevations and a check of the drain-age area on U.S.G.S. quad sheets, hydrologic analysis usingU.S. Army Corps of Engineers guidelines were performed andappear in Appendix C. It was concluded that the structurewill pass 25 percent of the Probable Maximum Flood withoutovertopping. The 100-year frequency flood will not overtopthe dam.

E. Structure:

The appurtenant structures associated with the dam arethe drawdown pipe and primary spillway pipe. The owner re-ported that three anti-seep collars were installed on the 18in. diameter spillway pipe.

2.2 CONSTRUCTION:

No construction inspection data were available. Peri-odic inspection during construction was performed by person-nel from the SCS office in Warsaw but no records were avail-able.

-8-

77

Page 20: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

2.3 OPERATION:

No operation and maintenance records were available.Inspection indicates that maintenance of the dam (mowing thegrass and brush removal) is done on a regular basis. Thedownstream face of the embankment has been recently mowedand grass on the embankment was well established. Some weedgrowth was present on the front face of the embankment.Weed growth was present around the riser pipe of the primaryspillway.

2.4 EVALUATION:

A. Availability:

The engineering data available are as listed in Section2.1. No seepage or stability analyses, or construction testdata were available.

B. Adequacy:

The engineering data available were inadequate to makea detailed assessment of the design, construction, and oper-ation. Seepage and stability analyses comparable to the re-quirements of the "Recommended Guidelines for Safety Inspec-tion of Dams" were not available, which is considered adeficiency. These seepage and stability analyses should beperformed for appropriate loading conditions (includingearthquake loads) and made a matter of record.

C. Validity:

The design sheets prepared by the Soil ConservationService, included in Appendix A and C, are valid engineeringdata on the design of the dam.

-9

I

Page 21: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 3 - VISUAL INSPECTION

3.1 FINDINGS:

A. General:

The field inspection was made on 9 September 1979. Theinspection team consisted of personnel from Anderson Engi-neering, Inc. of Springfield, Missouri and Hanson Engineers,Inc. of Springfield, Illinois. The team members were:

Tom Beckley P.E.- Anderson Engineering, Inc. (Civil Engineer)Steve Brady P.E.- Anderson Engineering, Inc. (Civil Engineer)John Healy P.E.-Hanson Engineers, Inc.(Geotechnical Engineer)Gene Wertepny P.E.- Hanson Engineers, Inc. (Hydrologic andHydraulic Engineer)Dan Kerns E.I.T.- Hanson Engineers, Inc. (Geotechnical Engi-neer)

B. Dam:

The embankment of the dam appears to be in good condi-tion. No sloughing of the embankment was noted. The hori-zontal alignment of the dam is straight. The crest of theembankment is fairly level and no surface cracking or unusu-al movement was obvious. Shallow auger probes into the em-bankment indicated the top portion of the embankment to con-sist of red-brown silty clay with chert fragments. Slighterosion at the west abutment and downstream embankment wasnoted. An erosion channel approximately two ft. wide andone foot deep was observed at the east downstream contact.No additional erosional areas were observed.

The embankment is grass covered and the crest and down-stream face appear to be mowed regularly. Heavy weed growthis starting on the upstream face of the embankment. No rip-rap was observed except for large rock slabs on the upstreamface beyond the sloped bench. The large rock slabs were inthe middle third of the dam. The owner indicated that heintended to continue the placement of the large rocks thefull length of the dam. No erosion was noted on the frontface of the embankment. No animal burrows were detected inthe embankment.

A flow of water was observed about 50 ft. downstream ofthe toe in the old streabed. The rate of flow was approxi-mately three to four ;allons per minute. A significant

- 10 -

Page 22: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

amount of iron-oxide discoloration was noted as shown inphoto nos. 22 and 23 in Appendix D. The water was comingout from underneath an earth mound formed by prior excava-tion work. The water was clear except for a flow that wasthe iron-oxide color. No sediment was noted in the water.An additional area of standing water was observed just be-yond the toe of the dam between the primary spillway outletand the two in. drawdown pipe outlet. No movement of waterin this area was detected.

No instrumentation (monuments, piezometers, etc.) was

observed.

C. Appurtenant Structures:

C.1 Primary Spillway:

The primary spillway consists of a 30 in. vertical ri-ser at the front face of the embankment near the center ofthe dam and an 18 in. pipe through the embankment. A trashrack was installed at the top of the riser and appeared tobe in good condition. On the date of inspection the poollevel was approximately 12 in. below the spillway intake.Considerable weed growth was observed surrounding the spill-way inlet. The owner had placed a perimeter row of concreteblocks around the riser to retain an additional four in. ofpool elevation. A trickle of water was observed flowing outthe downstream outlet of the spillway pipe. The apparentingress of this water is near the spillway pipe and riserjuncture. Three anti-seep collars were reportedly installedon the spillway pipe. No seepage around the pipe outlet wasobserved.

C.2 Emergency Spillway:

The emergency spillway located at the east abutment hasnever been used according to the owner. The spillway sec-tion was cut into natural ground. The spillway channel ispartially covered with vegetation growth. No noticeableerosion was observed in the spillway, although erosion couldresult if the spillway was used regularly. The outlet chan-nel is separated from the dam by a berm and spillway re-leases would not be expected to endanger the embankment.

C.3 Drawdown Pipe:

A four in. diameter pipe is located at Sta. 2+22. The

pipe was used during construction to drain water from the

Page 23: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

lake area. A four in. gate valve is located in a concretepipe riser at the toe of the dam. A two in. gate valve wasinstalled immediately downstream of the four in. valve wherethe four in. valve began to leak. It also is located in aconcrete pipe riser.

D. Reservoir:

The watershed is now primarily wooded with the plansfor the area to be developed into lakeside residential de-velopment. The slopes adjacent to the lake are moderate,and no sloughing or serious erosion was noted. There doesnot appear to be a problem with siltation.

E. Downstream Channel:

The downstream channel is lightly wooded with an estab-lished vegetation growth.

3.2 EVALUATION:

The erosion area at the east abutment-dam contact couldworsen and adversely affect the stability of the dam. Theseepage areas at the downstream toe should be investigatedby an engineer experienced in the design and construction ofdams. The heavy weed growth and concrete blocks around theprimary spillway inlet can restrict flood flows. The watertrickling from the primary spillway outlet should be moni-tored on a regular basis to detect any increase in thequantity of water flow. The above deficiencies should becorrected under the direction of an engineer experienced inthe design and construction of dams.

Because the valve of the lake drain is located on thedownstream side of the dam, the full head of water impoundedby the dam is acting entirely through the dam. The areaaround the lake drain outlet should be periodically inspect-ed for seepage which might indicate a leak or rupture of thedrain pipe and could eventually initiate a piping failurethrough the embankment.

Photographs of the dam, appurtenant structures, thereservoir, and the watershed are presented in Appendix D.

- 12 -

7. .

Page 24: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 4 - OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES

4.1 PROCEDURES:

There are no controlled outlet works for this dam, ex-cept for the four in. drawdown pipe which is operational buthas not been used since the filling of the lake in 1975. Anattempt was made by the owner to increase the pool elevationby the placement of concrete blocks around the primaryspillway inlet. The spillways are uncontrolled, so that thepool is normally controlled by rainfall, runoff, evapora-tion, seepage, and the capacities of the uncontrolled spill-ways.

4.2 MAINTENANCE OF DAM:

The crest and downstream face of the dam appear to beregularly mowed. No additional maintenance procedures areregularly performed.

4.3 MAINTENANCE OF OPERATING FACILITIES:

The drawdown pipe is apparently maintained. The pipeand its associated valves appear to be in good condition.

4.4 DESCRIPTION OF ANY WARNING SYSTEM IN EFFECT:

The inspection team is unaware of any existing warningsystem for this dam.

4.5 EVALUATION:

Weed growth and concrete blocks around the primaryspillway inlet can impair flood flows. The seepage areasalong the downstream toe of the dam, erosional area at thedownstream dam-abutment contact, lack of erosion protectionfor the upstream face of the dam and leakage into the pri-mary spillway pipe are serious deficiencies which should becorrected under the direction of an engineer experienced inthe design and construction of dams.

-13 -

Page 25: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 5 - HYDRAULIC/HYDROLOGIC

5.1 EVALUATION OF FEATURES:

A. & B. Design and Experience Data:

The hydraulic and hydrologic analyses were based on:(1) a field survey of spillway dimensions and embankment el-evations; and (2) an estimate of the pool and drainage areasfrom the U.S.G.S. quad sheet; and (3) hydrologic designsheets by the SCS. The owner indicated that the highestwater level, this spring, was about one foot above the pri-mary spillway inlet. Normally the lake level is below nor-mal pool during the summer months. An attempt has been madeto raise the pool level by placing an eight in. concreteblock collar around the drop inlet structure. our hydrolog-'ic and hydraulic analyses using U.S. Army Corps of Engineersguidelines appears in Appendix C.

C. Visual Observations:

The weed growth and concrete blocks surrounding theprimary spillway inlet could restrict flood flow. The emer-gency spillway channel is away from the dam and spillway re-leases would not be expected to endanger the dam.

D. Overtopping Potential:

Based on the hydrologic and hydraulic analysis pre-sented in Appendix C, the combined spillways will pass 25percent of the Probable Maximum Flood. The Probable MaximumFlood is defined as the flood discharge that may be expectedfrom the most severe combination of critical meteorologicand hydrologic conditions that are reasonably possible inthe region. The recommended guidelines from the Departmentof the Army, Office of the Chief Engineers, require thatthis structure (small size with high downstream hazard po-tential) pass 50 percent to 100 percent of the PMF, withoutovertopping. Considering the small volume of water impound-ed, and the height of the dam, 50 percent of the PMF hasbeen determined to be the appropriate spillway design flood.The structure will pass a 100-year frequency flood withoutovertopping.

The routing of 50 percent of the PMF through the spill-ways and dam indicates that the dam will be overtopped by0.87 ft. at elevation 734.97. The duration of the overtop-

- 14-

Page 26: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

ping will be 3.75 hours, and the maximum outflow will be 875cfs. The maximum discharge capacity of the spillways is 100cfs. Overtopping of an earthen embankment could cause seri-ous erosion and could possibly lead to failure of the struc-ture.

- 15-

, ,a -*

Page 27: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 6 -STRUCTURAL STABILITY

6.1 EVALUATION OF STRUCTURAL STABILITY:

A. Visual Observations:

Observed features which could adversely affect thestructural stability of this dam are discussed in Sections3.1B and 3.2.

B. Design and Construction Data:

No structural design and construction data were able tobe obtained on this dam. Construction survey notes were lo-cated in SCS files and are included in Appendix A. Seepageand stability analyses comparable to the requirements of theguidelines were not available, which constitutes a deficien-cy which should be rectified.

C. Operating Records:

No operating records have been obtained.

D. Post-Construction Changes:

To our knowledge no post-construction changes have beenmade except that according to Mr. Hayes, the additional twoin. gate valve was added to the drawdown pipe after con-struction was completed.

E. Seismic Stability:

The structure is located in seismic zone 1. An earth-quake of this magnitude would not generally be expected tocause severe structural damage to a well constructed earthdam of this size. However, it is recommended that the pre-scribed seismic loading for this zone be applied in stabil-ity analyses for this dam.

-16 -

Page 28: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 7 - ASSESSMENT/REMEDIAL MEASURES

7.1 DAM ASSESSMENT:

This Phase I inspection and evaluation should not beconsidered as being comprehensive since the scope of workcontracted for is far less detailed than would be requiredfor an in-depth evaluation of dams. Latent deficiencies,which might be detected by a totally comprehensive investi-gation, could exist.

A. Safety:

The embankment is generally in good condition. Severalitems were noted during the visual inspection which shouldbe corrected or controlled. These items are: (1) lack ofwave protection along the entire front face of the dam; (2)heavy weed growth on front face of dam; (3) weeds and con-crete block around primary spillway inlet; (4) erosion ateast embankment-abutment contact; (5) seepage areas at down-stream toe beyond contact; and (6) small amount of watercoming out of primary spillway outlet even though there wasno flow over the spillway crest. Another deficiency was thelack of seepage and stability analysis records.

The dam will be overtopped by flows in excess of 25percent of the Probable Maximum Flood. Overtopping of anearthen embankment could cause serious erosion and couldpossibly lead to a failure of the structure.

B. Adequacy of Information:

The conclusions in this report were based an review ofthe information listed in Section 2.1, the performance his-tory as related by others, and visual observation of exter-nal conditions. The inspection team considers that thesedata are sufficient to support the conclusions herein. Seep-age and stability analyses comparable to the "RecommendedGuidelines for Safety Inspection of Dams" were not avail-able, which is considered a deficiency.

C. Urgency:

The remedial measures recommended in paragraph 7.2should be accomplished in the near future. If the deficien-cies listed in paragraph A are not corrected, and if goodmaintenance is not provided, the embankment condition will

-17 -

Page 29: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SECTION 7 - ASSESSMENT/REMEDIAL MEASURES

7.1 DAM ASSESSMENT:

This Phase I inspection and evaluation should not beconsidered as being comprehensive since the scope of workcontracted for is far less detailed than would be requiredfor an In-depth evaluation of dams. Latent deficiencies,which might be detected by a totally comprehensive investi-gation, could exist.

A. Safety:

The embankment is generally in good condition. Severalitems were noted during the visual inspection which shouldbe corrected or controlled. These items are: (1) lack ofwave protection along the entire front face of the dam; (2)heavy weed growth on front face of dam; (3) weeds and con-crete block around primary spillway inlet; (4) erosion ateast embankment-abutment contact; (5) seepage areas at down-stream toe beyond contact; and (6) small amount of watercoming out of primary spillway outlet even though there wasno flow over the spillway crest. Another deficiency was thelack of seepage and stability analysis records.

The dam will be overtopped by flows in excess of 25percent of the Probable Maximum Flood. overtopping of anearthen embankment could cause serious erosion and couldpossibly lead to a failure of the structure.

B. Adequacy of Information:

The conclusions in this report were based on review ofthe information listed in Section 2.1, the performance his-tory as related by others, and visual observation of exter-nal conditions. The inspection team considers that thesedata are sufficient to support the conclusions herein. Seep-age and stability analyses comparable to the "RecommendedGuidelines for Safety Inspection of Dams" were not avail-able, which is considered a deficiency.

C. Urgency:

The remedial measures recommended in paragraph 7.2should be accomplished in the near future. If the deficien-cies listed in paragraph A are not corrected, and if goodmaintenance is not provided, the embankment condition will

- 17 -

Page 30: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

(5) The erosion areas along the dam-abutment contact shouldbe corrected and maintained.

(6) The seepage areas at the downtream toe of the damshould be investigated by an engineer experienced inthe design and construction of dams. Remedial measuresmay be required. As a minimum, this seepage should bemonitored to determine if there is any increase inquantities and whether soil particles are being carriedwith the water.

(7) The source of the water coming from the primary spill-way outlet should be investigated and stopped if possi-ble. As a minimum the flow should be checked on a reg-ular basis for any increase in the amount or the pres-ence of soil particles in the water.

(8) A detailed inspection of the dam should be made period-ically by an engineer experienced in the design and con-struction of dams.

-19-

Page 31: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

APPENDIX A

I~~~~~~~ -__- ------ -

Page 32: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

\ 0 "KAN#SA S

O*Me. J/O52* sr L OUIS

SPRINGFIELD

LOCATION MAP

SHE(T r OF APPENDIX A

Page 33: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

0 0 0 0 0o 0 0 0 0

o - +

UNGE POOL

I "

PLAN1 VIAEWLE I

TOP. OFE CMP RISROTAPE

-tT44+ J' PROF73.7ALAE

1~ &-

Page 34: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

-735

12.4

-. 730SWATER LEVEL

729.08

-7253.31 72

720

I I I I II60 40 20 0 20 40

SECT ION A-A STA 1+00

Sheet 3 ot Appendix AANDERSON ENGINEERING, INC.

730 730 NORTH BENTON AVENUE

SPRINGFIELD, MISSOURI 65802

WILLIAM HAYES LAKE

MO. No. 31052i25

PLAN t. PROFILE

BENTON COUNTY, MO.

( -

Page 35: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

T 43

Ic

SITE ICINIY MAShet2 ppndx

Page 36: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

FLOWING WATER19E1PAGE AREA

Ia

SPILWAY RAWDWN~tSIm

LAIPE

PINSPIECT O U E V rDAMNoOMOK30$

KhS fA~eda

L. A K F

Page 37: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

SCALE: Cz50'

90 6

390, LENGS

/ / 6.

q96.

J,

Page 38: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

I.b

00

245' LENGTH4

%o.7

Page 39: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

STOR AGE

ELEV. A C AC FT

101.7 6.5 0103.7 8.0 14.5

104.7 8.8 22.9 Emerg IC Deep

PROPOSED ELEV. U

UNSETTLED FILL ELEV. 107.1SETTLED FILL ELEV. 105.7

EMERG. *, 103.7INLET 101.7BOT. RISER

END PIPE 78.5

2: 5 + 2-5?: 5 z 14'TOP= 14'2: 5 :69'

END: 8

105

--511 0

0

NOT.

%V~

..1.

Page 40: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

Emerg C Deep

23, 565 CU. YDS. EARTH FILL

L EV. U S ED CHECKED RISER SIZEFILL ELEV. 107.1 18 CMPFILL ELEV 105.7 30" CMP RISER

103.7101 .7

PE 78.5FOR FRONT SLOPE 2-5

2:5 + 2" 5 BACK SLOPE =2.5

2:5 14' 110'- 16"

TOP 14'2;5 6 9'END: 8

1055

110

NOTE: THIS IS A COPY

Sheet 5 Appendix 4ANDERSON ENGINEERING, INC.,730 NORTH BENTON AVENUESPRINGFIELD, MISSOURI 65802

WILLIAM HAYES LAKE

MO. No 31052

SURVEY NOTESAS COPIED FROM

SCS DRAWING

BENTON COUNTY, MO.

, o

Page 41: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

too u 5 Ong.q~q Ag-.wft'

44~ot 5A~rd, P400I ~ 1 1

AC? N..

mo

Page 42: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

_77-

IF---r~

-t -1?, .- --- - *----L---~-----

Ib T

-- -

I I

~ Ikj

Shoo APodi

Page 43: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

M'.W-5(Forvw-rly 14-01-19 s. ?i-24*11 _74______: I

U.S. DEPAfl"Mr OF All' :C;.T*2..~ E SOILC:3r.z *I -C1MLI,?.

&owner or

Wctershee *0 <4' 1j- ;,r ' r,

Top of Fill;, Width /4 ;Eiev. 7____Upstr'ici em - "idt~ Ii

ISt,-- Grour c! ii II Fil 'J--.ut.:*bIe

*icy. linot. Yd.3/ :,;t I~ I J2 e ! ew~~'1

0.4 TS

4-5- 14_Z__-

~ I ~-/35- 435

- f/

7 6,/O. .5 S7 Io

. 13

Tina - Ie -- - eTI

A14ewlm.. -~ etl r

fillJh~ Ex: ._.._._

____ ____ ____ ____ ____NOW&,mmmmu ~ I 10& I1

Page 44: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

APPENDIX B

Page 45: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

14)4

L~Oj

(nI.

oH E F7' PP IV .

Page 46: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

*From 0Soils of Missouri'

'w\ W, '

*~ 4144

20~' HICKNESS OF

10-20LOESS/AL DEPOSITS

2.5-SHEETr 2 OF APPENDIX 0

Page 47: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

APPENDIX C

Page 48: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

From Edwards,, Ma 7 5 Quad

r

mo. Dom No. 31am Lake

15

WOtershed

lblf-

'CIO1900

-IL

2 2

000

'24

Scale A 000I V,

Ax

0 0

27,

L A KE A ND WA MRSHED MA P

Sh"t AAP#ndix C

Page 49: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

HYDRAULICS AND HYDROLOGIC DATA

Design Data: From Field Measurements and Computations

Experience Data: No records are available. The owner indi-cated that the highwater, this spring, was about one foot abovethe primary spillway inlet. Normally the lake level is belownormal pool during the summer months. An attempt has been madeto raise the pool level by placing an eight in. concrete blockcollar around the drop inlet structure.

Visual Inspection: At the time of inspection, the pool levelwas approximately 0.9 ft. below normal pool.

Overtopping Potential: Flood routings were performed to de-termine the overtopping potential. The watershed and the reser-voir surface areas were obtained by planimeter from the U.S.G.S.Edwards, Missouri 7.5 minute quadrangle map. The storage volumewas developed from this data. A 5 minute interval unit graph wasdeveloped for the watershed, which resulted in a peak inflow of484 c.f.s. and a time to peak of 8.4 minutes. Application of theprobable maximum precipitation, minus losses resulted in a floodhydrograph peak inflow of 1988 c.f.s. Rainfall distributionfor the 24 hour storm was according to EM 1110-2-1411.

Based on our analyses, the combined spillways will pass 25percent of the Probable Maximum Flood (PMF). The Probable Maxi-mum Flood is defined as the flood discharge that may be expectedfrom the most severe combination of critical meteorologic and hy-drologic conditions that are reasonably possible in the region.The recommended guidelines from the Department of the Army, Of-fice of the Chief of Engineers, require that the structure (smallsize with high downstream hazard potential) pass 50 to 100 per-cent of the PMF, without overtopping. Considering the small vol-ume of water impounded and the height of the dam , 50 percent ofthe PMF has been determined to be the appropriate spillway designflood.

The routing of the 50 percent of the PMF through the spill-ways and dam indicates that the dam will be overtopped by 0.87ft. at elevation 734.97. The duration of the overtopping will be3.75 hours, and the maximum outflow will be 875 c.f.s. The maxi-mum discharge capacity of the combined spillways is 100 cfs.Analysis of the data indicates that the 100-year frequency floodwill not overtop the dam. The computer input, output and hydro-graph for 50 percent of the PMF are presented on Sheets 5, 6 and

of this Appendix C.

Sheet 2 Appendix C

C,.

Page 50: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

OVERTOPPING ANALYSIS FOR WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM

INPUT PARAMETERS1. Unit Hydrograph - SCS Dimensionless - Flood Hydrograph

Package (HEC-l); Dam Safety VersionWas Used.Hydraulic Inputs Are as Follows:

a. Twenty-four Hour Rainfall of 25.7 Inches for 200

Square Miles - All Season Envel pe

b. Drainage Area = 92 Acres; = 0.14 Square Miles

c. Travel Time of Runoff 0.16 Hrs.; Lag Time 0.10Hrs.

d. Soil Conservation Service Soil Group B

e. Soil Conservation Service Runoff Curve No. 78(AMC 1II)Soil Conservation Service Runoff Curve No. 60(AMC II)

f. Proportion of Drainage Basin Impervious 0.08

2. Spillways

a. Primary Spillway: 30 inches I.D. CMP (Riser) and18 inches I.D. CMP (Outlet Pipe)

b. Emergency Spillway: Trapezoidal ChannelLength 13 ft.; Side Slopes 3.25:1 & 5:1; C=Varies

c. Dam Overflow

Length 360 ft.; Crest El. 734.1; C = Varies

3. Spillway and Dam Rating:

Curve Prepared by Hanson Engineers. Data Provided toComputer on Y4 and Y5 Cards. (See sheet 5 Appendix C)

Formula and Method Used:Primary Spillway: Charts for entrance and outletcontrol in CMP pipes.Equation Used for Emergency Spillway: Q- A

T 3 385Note: Time of Concentration From Equation Tc - (11.9 L

(H) .385Sheet 3 Appendix C

7

Page 51: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

California Culvert Practice, California Highways and

Public Works, September, 1942.

SUMMARY OF DAM SAFETY ANALYSIS

1. Unit Hydrograph

a. Peak - 484 c.f.s.

b. Time to Peak 8.4 Min.

2. Flood Routings Were Computed by the Modified PulsMethod

a. Peak Inflow

50% PMF 994 c.f.s.; 100% PMF 1988 c.f.s.

b. Peak Elevation

50% PMF 734.97; 100% PMF 735.49

c. Portion of PMF That Will Reach Top of Dam

25%; Top of Dam Elev. 734.1 ft. (Lower Point)

Computer Input and Output Data are shown on the followingsheets of this Appendix.

Sheet 4 Appendix C

Ci

Page 52: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

A OVERTOPPING ANALYSIS FOR WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAMA STATE ID NO. 31052 CD. NO. 015 CO. NAME BENTONA HANSON ENGINEERS INC. DAN SAFETY INSPECTION JOB # 79511B 300 5Dl 5J 1 7 1Ji .15 .20 .30 .40 .50 .75 1.0K 0 1 3 1K1 INFLOU HYDROGRAPH COMPUTATION **N 1 2 0.14 0.14 1 1P 0 25.7 102 120 130T -1 -79 0.08U2 0.16 0.10X 0 -.1 2K 1 2 0 4 1KI RESERVOIR ROUTING BY iODIFIED PULS AT BAN SITE **Y 1 1Y1 1 53.7 -1Y4 730 731 732.4 733 734.1 735 736 737Y5 0 1 21 31 100 224 425 665$A 0 5.9 9.2tE 702.7 730 740St 730D 734.1kL 0 125 275 361 394 428 454 459 462 466

$Y 734.1 734.2 734.4 734.5 735.0 735.5 735.9 736.5 737.0 737.5K 99

P.M.F. Input DataSheet 5, Appendix C

|'l ' I

Page 53: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

P. 0 * Laio wo 01t co CoCo C

.4 In n S

*I- C.4*~LL S. 2 0V

C. or* *-.J N0: =. 0& w 4* P', m - %

b.=-* - M(% -. 0 0

L3 Co )-

in .L6 s-iMC2 km 6r 4

me atl- - r% N%.00 c 0 to ** CLaUW CIi A cm 0 ZC3

* 0 0 ~ q- r 3- 1.-4=qqNt ocaJ I- . r 0 0o -C W

0 C .u Ir L, .-j 0i co In- OSQ In Co" P19 CS L6~a 5-. m 0-.0 co. (A c*C ")l 00. j% @-.~C*CALAS ml4 .0 W)c -

cc 5-4 -W I- t

.. J(JC ~ - 00 5 *

Lai S- C co 0.J l(*9 04 1-5 Co c

* S~~~~LiJW( 0 * a-

im U. W ~ = M C C4w"" CLJ a.t 0. 4wIC . 0 ;C

0-4 .3

ahi c CD I- oC l-C luja = -j I- Ic C - C2 r WI Im -

to 5-4 CA CA. * P .

c a LL

I. - 5IM

0C2

C 2

-U CArn0d6n

0 = U

C* Sheet 6, Appendix C

Page 54: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

• " : •INPUT-OUTPUT :HYDROGRAPH

:Max. Inflow = 994 c.f.s.:Max. Outflow = 8 5 c.f.s.

U, ,

. . .

a . .

800

U

"" Inflow

1000

400

• :5

800 C=

: • Outflow.600 :

. . .C C . . . . . . .400 •:

200 "

SheetD , Apen C, C, -.. -0 0 0. b Q . W ... a .. ....... ' " - i -0 . .l ..... V) .......-... C.

00 * AW! vt1:nC t ! ii I 0 1

Timeo (r .

Shee 7,Apni

Page 55: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

?40-ENG JNL I:i STAT .S DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE12/70 SO:L CONSERVATION SERVICE

b.L3IGN SEflr $:"R CLASS iA[ * , - r* DtIEN!ONSTORAGE STRUCTURE

71 DROP INLET St, -.LWAY 4-I~-'-A* -- CAiNC" ilif SPR11 Y

L jow,~ ___ !. ~-)uflt'/y

OeSian "v. ~ Da te 7 - i.rdb-_____ Date_____

Draina:. -t-t~a £5 ac x*.rp, ___ x-

WATLURS1HUDcCODi "'ND tl FACTORS

Topoqv-ap-*c ac,: g__ Averd-la ;.f 7 ~ 6

Shape .cc: rf' i:'e-~9~?S _______

Cover fu t-o:-: u ~6d _ nast.re __ rte-C

ContoUrinq ~tJ

Storaqe factor: - t -a.

PLAK RAT ut- $il AW YOLUJtM OF RY10,!F

Prodijcz of 'actor's -L x~ T Y, T~ V -* c.f.s.

V x I~~

For Princioal__'J lwav 'Josiir:

______ 1 -y. - r~i dte o f runof' - 7' .'~.

Rate of viulume i~t ruin...i a, t/r . i .9

Total volure )- r'.4113ff trnq:i ' of "6nolf) x L

-~~a S5 P? o( '~. ~ . 5Z

For Both_pij.;.1 'j~ ls c. .c

~-year Peak rate of crciv' 76- ~e c. f.s.

k of volum~e of rUn';*i

Totall ol vow- (if rurn'vif - - _ -. t.' /e' aZ 5c ft.

*Mark out those I'teiv Lr' i:, jo not *apy~'y.

Ifhtruation for u,.( z)f rrim&: Mi*ke we ont.1~ ., oi iOf au e sruct ure. File withother worksheets trno tr~m; plan in inflr.wr ~ ti Hlo )ftice.

Skev A dppea18 g

m.mas"

Page 56: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

PRINCIPAL SPILLWAY DESI6N

Available storaqe at stage of £.0 ft V /4-5 ac. ft (See map)

rp z/1/ 5 tac. ft. Z53 ac. ft. Q . (Table 2, 1519)

QOP a QIpxeo3 .257c.f.s. f.

Conduit.Type 'Z' , Length Z ft. TotdI head on conduit */"f

0F)ameter - i n. Discharqe capactj . '1520)

Minimim, entrance head - J ft. (IFm '-:: //.t -

Riser:I

Type __,_i - ev Heiqilt L >'rmE.-t - , :151:)

Control Section:

Depth of flow ft. at thL oeuth u,. *t (See map)

s V r ac. ft. •7 c,. -

or 01 c.f.s. - ?7 c.f.s. . Lue " _Qi ,rable 3, 1519)

Q =Q x _ c-f. . x - C.

Width - ft. Total depth = depth ,J iow free,,odrd /0 ft. + 1.0-

ft. Use 2,c ft. (Table 4, 151.'

EAlt Section:

SIope ____ Qua].ty of vegetation: (dtdr) (,;oua) (exce;lent *

(Less, (More) erosive soiIs. F',r.: b ;ec k 1517)

Leoth _ _ft, Design veloclt .- - ft, (1517 or 1505)

Use width of ft.

Length ot saturated zone - L -.- ,.," (1515)

n = (L X __) V - ( .. .ie collars.Ma,'- out thobe !tems that uo noJt aup,

"*.Applies only to Drop Inlet Srtllwev:.

Sheer . AA900is R

Page 57: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

APPENDIX D

Page 58: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

LOWING WATERSEEPAGE AREA

IT

EROPLAN S ETCHIO

KEILW Y TOWDW PH TO RA HDAME PI.MOP305

SheT peda

Page 59: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

INDEX TO PHOTOGRAPHS

Photo No.1. Aerial - Lake and Dam, Looking South

2. Aerial - Lake and Dam, Looking West

3. Aerial - Dam and Emergency Spillway - NoteErosion at Toe of Embankment

4. Crest of Dam - Looking East

5. Primary Spillway Inlet - Note Weed Growth

6. Primary Spillway Inlet - Note Weed Growth andConcrete Blocks

7. Crest and Downstream Face - Looking East

8. Upstream Face - Looking West

9. Downstream Face - Looking West

10. Emergency Spillway - Looking North

ii. Emergency Spillway - Looking Southwest

12. Emergency Spillway - Looking South

13. Downstream Channel - Looking North

14. Lake - From Crest of Dam

15. Downstream Floodplain - Looking North16. Primary Spillway Outlet

17. Primary Spillway Outlet

18. Downstream Ploodplain-Primary Spillway Outlet

19. Drawdown Valve - Overhead View

20. Drawdown Pipe Outlet

21. Seepage Area 50 Feet Downstream of Toe

22. Flowing Water from Seepage Area - NoteDiscoloration

23. Flowing Water from Seepage AreaSheet 2 Appendix D

da"-a

Page 60: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

lo

ft

"No

Jill"--

Page 61: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

I.5.

4

Page 62: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

4 4 tj~

*~ 4~

I &

Page 63: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

V

,..

*

Page 64: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

pig, V.

'I gip

1 40

Page 65: OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN - DTICrk OSAGE -GASCONADE BASIN AD I I , 4 5, 6 WILLIAM HAYES LAKE DAM ~BENTON COUNTY, MISSOURI MO 310152 PHASE 1 INSPECTION REPORT NATIONAL DAM SAFETY PROGRAM

I