.•

0 D ORIGINAL RECORD ON APPEAL

mnittb ~tates Cll:ourt of ~pptals FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

No. 73-2185 73-2186 73-2187 73-2188 73-2199 /'

September Term, 19

UNITED S~TES OF AMERICA

v.

BERNARD L. BARKER EUGENIO R. MARTINEZ FRANK A. STURGIS VIRGILIO R. GONZALEZ ~ EVERETTE HOWARD HUNT~

APPELlANTS

APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

73-2252

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

v.

JAMES W. McCORD, JR. ,

APPELlANT

FILED DECEMBER 19,

APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

FILED DECEMBER 20,

N.OTICE

This record contains original papers. DO. NOT REMOVE OR MARK PAPERS IN ANY WAY

NW 7067 Docld:59162157 Page 1

• • ;.:=

;:(·t ·,·· . .. .:.. ;-" •,

iTED STATES DISTRICT COUR'I 'OR THE -- -DISTRICT OF COLtmBIA · · \

Del.

- ~ ...

---------ITED STATES OF AMERICA

vs. United States Court of Appeal for the Oistrlct of Columbb Ci;cuit (GEORGE GOROON LIDDY, et al)

In re•' OQ ~ 1827 m2 #2; Hunt .,c:::._ ., '!1· ~', -, -urllfllhal No. - ntED DEC 2 01973 #3: McCord · _

U- ·t· (1- - States Court of 1\pt:H.\s.GH --E. KLINE m e , . l / ~~m<: ·"' - for the Olztricl of Colvmb.~ ClrCUI .

#4: Barker- -·-. 3-: '2- \ ~J #5: Martinez..-:::: 1 ?7- 2-\ ?& #6: Sturgis ---.1 ~ 2... \3' l #7: Gonzalez -(__ - FILED DEC i 919_/3

\:> L-\ ~ t"'Jr.:· _.-:.( , ~0 . HUGH E. KLINE:

I, JAMES F! 'i:>AVl!:Y~t'J.erk of THE UNITED STATE§L~TRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, do hereby certify the annexed to be the original:

___ Pleadings

Remaining Papers r:< -o=ne~r~o....-lder containing. • • • • 9

_ (9) Reporters Transcript( s) Ordere . SEALED y _directio_ n of the _ Court - (See attached list), t . ed under separate

- certificate. .. - .11 _ J.MtiJu••

,_

Exhibits ---'

~xceptions (if any): .f

and other papers on file in th~ above-entitled cause, ·and a true and correct .eopy (or portion) of the docket entries, as they appear of record in this office; said originals and copy being transmitted to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to constitute: ·

(seal) mb

A Preliminary Record. X (as part~-o-f~)'The Record on Appeal.

A Supplemental Record. -----A Supplemental Record on Remand.

Return of the Original Record~ -----,.­

;'!

IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I hereunto subscribe my name and · affix the seal of said Court, at the City of Washington, -this 14th day of December , 197_.1_.

JAMES F. DAVEY, Clerk

Byrt~ ?;Q§...~ pu y erk -~

NW 7067 Docld:59162157 Page 2

I

I.

•'

I ('

I ! I.

I .

I ~ .

I !.. ,.

Del.

.-----· ~TED STATES. DISTRICT COUR•t".' oR '!'HE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA --

----------·.•.

' .. . ~ . ' '

ttN:rTgh STATES OF AMERiCA

.· ' • ...

GORDON LIDDY" et al) ~1 No. 1827-7~2'

Hunt McCord Barker Martinez Sturgis . Gonzalt;!Z

,, .. ....... :

. . :;:

I, JAMES F. DAVEY, Clerk of THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR • THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, do hereby certify the annexed to be the

.~ original: · '-'-.:

' ~~·._t < \

'.:···

I .

Pleadings ----. Remaining Papers

.... o~n~e--:!llr'"""o ..... lder contain.:i.rig '.;;. • • . . (9) Reporters Tran~cript( s) Or.dered SEALED by direction of the

Court ~ (~ee attached list), transmitted under separate c·erti.ficate·• . Exhibits .· -----

Exceptions (if any):

(

and other papers on file in the above-entitled cause, ·and a:· 'true · and correct eopy (or· portion) of the docket entries, as ,theyappear of record in this office; said originals and copy being tral)smitted to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of qolumbia Circuit to constitute:, ·

A Preliminary Record. x (as p~r~t-o-t-!':"")'The Record on Appeal.

A Supplemental Record. ----A Supplemental Record on Remand. .,..._ __ Return of the Original Record.

. , .. -

. . i

IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF 1 I hereunto subscribe my n,ame and . affix .the seal, of said Court, at the City of Washington,; this 14th day of December , 197_3._. · .. · ':

JAMES F. DAVEY, Cl~rk

By_~~~~~~--~ Deputy clerk

i. · (seal) mb r ··· , .. _ ---. __ ______ __ ···-· - · --- ·- · - ··-- ~ - - ---- - - - ·--- - --

NW 7067 Docld:59162157 Page 3

· -. . ·'._:·.

• i . ' •

. . -· ~ · - ··· _ .. . • •• >.

... .. ! ' .: . . :·_ ,, ' r ' ~ .' •

l· :'· . . .

•. ~ • ~- . . •• , . . .; . : i .

. ·.UNITED STATES <, O.F 'AMERICA . -~-. ; >

' • :· ,· . ·~ ~l~ . . . !

. ,...- ·-· ~ - . ' ;.' ' ./ .. · ... CRilviiNAL CASE NO •

'.; i,.

-:· •. :

VS ' -· . ·. · : ;,

: . GEORGE GORDON LIDDY ET AL

\ '

.. . . .. '.

R E}"· C E I P . T .. , .

1827-72 .

, Receip ·~ is acknowledg-e, ··!this 14th day · of November, 1973, .· ·' of the following lis ted documen:ts which have been ordered ·

sealeCl by the Court and which a·re to be transmitted to the · United States · Court of Appeals for · the District of Col 1.un1Jia under seal in connection with the ' appeals filed by Defendants EVERETTE HOWAHD HUNT, J AHES W McCOHD, BERNARD L BARKF..R, EUGENIO R NARTINEZ, FRANK A STUHGIS & VIRGILIO R GONZALEZ:

· . jr~: J·J· c:/... (1) One (l) manila and/or kraft type envelope, 12"x9" ~ . :{ · in size, containg three copies (original and two copies) of

. ....

.· . · the transcr i pt of proceedings held in Chief Judge Sirica' s chambers on Tuesday, July 17, 1973, together with the stenotype

· ~r Wt~.. notes of Court Reporter Nicholas Sokal. Transcr..lllt filed · ·· . Ju1y_l8' 1973. .

· "!.~r. \ '~JL ":• ·:~· · . · (2) One (1) manila and/or kraft type envelope, 12ux9"

:z&J fZ -in size, containing transcript of the proceedings held in ·· ~- . ·. . Chief :Judge Sirica' s chambers on Tuesday, July 24, 1973; ' ·,: . .

~ envelope contains Court's copy of the transcript only. !:. . 'l'ranscrip_t filed July 25, 1973. ,.,

:J.J-..• / .. (3) One (1) manila and/or kraft type envelope, 12"x9" ..;:pf!p{)- in size, containing the sealed addendum to the supplemental

memo of the United States . in opposition to the motion filed by Defendant #3(James W McCord) in the nature of a writ of . error coram .nobis. Document filed Sept. 18, :1~973. '

. . . . . ( 4) One ( 1) manila and/or kraft type envelope, l2"x9" ~J~.3 -in. size, cont~ining the original copy of the transcript of ·.

. · .. trlal proceed1ngs held at the bench on Wednesday, J anuary 3, · . · 1973, pag~s 1-5, inclusive. Transcript filed on September 18,

. . . 1223. /

,·,

_ ( 5) One (l) manila and/or kraft type envelope, 12"x9'' in size, containing the original and one carbon copy of the transcript of proceedings held in Chief Judge Sirica's chambers bn Sept. 17, 1973, from 10:00 AM to 10:20 AM, pages 1-.12; inclusive, RELATIVE TO DEFENDANT #2(E HOV/ARD HUNT), · together with notes of Court Reporter Nicholas Sokal. D_ocutnents , filed September 18, 197 3.

······ · 1/ "f _ . (6) One (1) manila and/or kraft type envelope, 12"x9n

·--.,

j ~ . ;' • ; .

'r--: . .

--~J >'pl... in ~i?e, cor:ta~ning the o~iginal an~ two (2) <;a;-bon copies of >> · · · · the transcrlpt of proceedlng s held ln Judge Slrlca' s chambers . ... .

····• · _.·. _: .. o~rl: S.!?Pt~~P..ei' l-7, ,~1.9-7-J., ~from 1:30 .. PM .. _to--2:00 PM ., (7pa.ges-.l-IJt-,:"-incl-usive)' • . ... · . . :rela.tive to }lefendants #4,#5,#6,#7.(BARKERJ STURGIS, GO.· NZALEZ ~ .···.1 ·• . ;, .:

(. · '- · . ~RTINEZ) ~ · Transcript . filed September H~, 1973. . .. · .: ' : .· ·.

:.: .J • .i:t;5J.·b?i_;. . ·: . (7) One (1) manila and/or .kraft ~ type enve_lope, -12· ,~~-9" . ·. ·>:-.·.

-: ""r'o/( ' j ·' in size, containing the original and one carbon co.py of )'tl:);e .. . ·_: . .

. - ~

transcript of proceedings held in Judge Sirica' s chamber:s, · · together with notes of Court Reporter. Nicholas s ·okal, on October ~].,, ~-1973. Tran~cript filed October 11, 1973. ,,' · .. ;, :. ' ·

... .. ' .. . '

CONTitruED ''ON PAGE 2

' '

\

' \

'>·

··:. : ,. ,,.•;; <"""· •

. ··,· ., '. (

I

4i

f' ·. _· _;. .

. , 'r' . . ,;. ·. I·\ I'

".'.·J <· ' . • ' - ~ '":, ~!!"!1 ";, 1:

I' i ~·:' ':;}':·E~-! .· :·r;-;: \ ,, No·,n~mber 15~ 1973:

!· • .

•• • '. :_ : :·_~-.:·: ..... 1 :~~-~,~~'i .·.: . . ' { . ·'

'f:J ''.liji -~ Receipt · is also acknowl P-<lRP<l, this dat8/ of one (1) nla nili. '', '·, ' ,_, . T7 and/or kraft t.ype envelope, ] ? 11 x:9" in s:t.z .e, wh:ich · contcdn ~; the

. ''.·'· · · . . or:Lginal and tt-Jo (2) carbon ':e; :)ics or transcript of proc(;:ed jn;;;s .,,.,.

I . . .

~-···

,. . held in Judge E.d .rica• s chambb:rs on August 7c; 19'73, pages 1~ ~?.1 , · · ·· ·, inclusive, to gether ~Vi t h·. sterH)fSl~ <3.phi c .not,2:s of NicboJ..'?!.S Sok :::J .. , ._:_

~ C"'>"'.''t. · Reno""te· .. · (u·::.a.r·-lno ·in ,.,.,J.,·,·n l--.ers ,.?ac hr->ld· 'lt J'Pn'"'•C'+ cf' • . 1 •• U . ..l. . . .l. .I.- ... ~- . o · l.!t.;.! .. \...I..Jr::') . .. : . ., .I. . .. Cil . .. .. . .. ')' . "'·' ·-"' "- . ·-· . •. LLt ... .J .. ,_ , _., .

. Daniel . E~ Schultz, EsquirE!, . c:oun::; el for defendants . Barker, J,·ir:', ,.'tinez, .. Sturgis & Gon zalez). [~-'2--fW~§D.t~{iJ_,_f'~d AiJg_Us t 8, l '12 .. 3... . ·

: . ~ · . .

. . . · . ·, ·. ,_ . .

,.· ..

. · .. · . :

. ' .. :.~

. . : . ' .

.1

.-, , ·.

·· . . . . . '· ·· .. :.

: • .~ I

~ ., .

.· .-;

· '. • -

. ~ .

··.· .

. . , , ,· .

... ;· ' . ' ·

·. '"

. ' ' ~·

. . . . ,.

; . ' .

. :·.: . . . i.:b - ~ ; .

' ' .

; , .

'- ..

4: v

I

. t . ., . . .'. ; . i., · . . ,'. --

UNITED STATES DISTRICT GOlJRT-FOJ~ --THE --, -- _. _ ! ·, ·'. DISTRICT OF COLUl\UllA \, MAY ?. t9T3 ·; ,_

. co.:.5o1 . ·_ 'Rep n-10:

. ' UNITED STATES OF AMERICA I " ' \- .. . . ~· ·. ', ·····-- ~~ ---···· · ········ ········ ·· ·· ····· · · ··· ·· · ._ .. ··· · · · · ·· · · ·· ·· : ..... .. ··· ·· · ··· ' Umte~ . Statu court of APP.Wi ................ ... , .............. .. ..... . .................. . , plaintiff ...... ~ crim~n~the !ll~'rlot Qf CcL~r.llla OIFSI!~ ~ .

·) . • vs. , J1 No. ~82?-:-. ?.? \ ... .. ~~! tftEIJ· MAY 2 .i. 1S73

·:~:~()~~~ <~~~~~ ~IJ)D~ , ~c;~.d~nt ~ ::~II~% . -~ ltu\H~ IWNB I, JAMES F. DAVEY, Clerk ]ot THE UNITED STATESDISTRICT COUR~ FOR THE DISTRICT

:. ·, \ '.I

OF COLUl'rfBIA, do hereby certify th e cmnexed to be ~e<~lfOH{~~~:?P:~~-~~:I§~. the original ....... . folders ( 2) contain:ing sealed material,, namely: \_

., 159~ Tapes ( 6'): and Transcript of Baldwin Interviews fi~ed 12/21/72 7

160 :~Tr. of G.J. Pro. of 12/4/72, pp. 1-12, incl. filed 12/2l/72. ~ 'l 176 :~ Letter dated 1/1/73 by deft. McCord filed 1/2/73 7 ·.

187'~ Two letters dated 1/2/73 &1/3/73 re: Hunt_ filed 1/8/737 . 18'~:- Tr. of Pro. of 12/21/72, pp. 71-75, incl. filed 1/8/737

.- 190~ Tr. of Bench Conf. held 1/5/73, pp. 1-8; incl. filed 1/8/73~ 191~ Tr. ofc-,Pro. held in chambers 1/9/73, pp. 1-8, incl. filed 1/ffi¢';/:i~i~ 196:.-- Tr. of Pro. of 1/11/73 (held in Conf~\- Rm.) pp .133-155...:.B, incl.

filed 1/11/73: _ . 1

.

197:..,.... Tr. of Pro. of 1/12/73 pp_. 302j13rf18~fi~ed 1/12/73~ 2006--... Tr. of Pro. of 1/12/73 PP.~ 319-352 . incl. filed 1/15/737 205:_... Exhibits A,B,&C to In Camera Pr6c. of 1/17/78 filed 1/17/73~ 20S:'(A) Tr. of Pro.of 1/17/73,- pp.971-1017, incl. filed l/17/73f 207:~Qpinion sett~ng forth reasons for allowing contents of inter- .

cepted conversation~ to be admitted, filed·l/18/737 I·· - - 287: - Tr. -o( Pro. of 1/24/73 pp. 1490-1500G, incL filed 4/26/73 ~

_ · ~ 288 ~->Tr ~ ·'of . ttl;'q_. of 1/26/73 pp. 1676-16139( 1690) inc 1. filed 4/26/73~ \ . .28~- ;~ Tr • . of Pr6· . .. o.f 1/27/73 pp. 1466-1467( Original & 5 copie13) filed

' <-> .. . 4/2e?/173 ~ \ "-( ; , \ . . '' /as- they ·appe:a:r of · i~p'ord in this office, said sea led materials being

-·· r .: . - - ·~ . .~./-

.·, t:tC!nsmitted<. ~to the Y,nited States Court of Appeals for the Distr-ict of - qolumbia Ci~cuit as . .:.~a .: part of the Record on Appeal.

~)I I

NW 7067 Docid:59162157 Page 6

IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I hereunto subscribe my na.m ._ and dJfix j

the seed of said Court, at the City of lt' ashington. this_ l}:th . _

day of .. , .. M~Y. ... .. ........... ........ ~ .. .. ... , 1.9 .. 73. -

JAMES F. DAVEY, Clerk

By ... ~£'~ ............. ............. , Deputy Clerk . .