53
UOJCC ]ACU O IC 2OIILCC bibp urnA pc dnoicq ,iipocii cxbJ!c! bcun!ou bLoiqqq qrni jpjj cLcqj ucjnqpi © © Jô P QOJqU fl L1JJf2 LC2GLAGq 21J014 CCPOIJ Oj GX UO1 10 CXCCCq WO QJC MOUJ BflLfl O ECOUOUJ!C JQ2LCJF Ecouow? wiq r'co nqic uA obiuoua cxbi.ccq ULG qioc o ipc rIqJOL uq UO poc CO1JOL jp JI yiBEJc2 LC2CLC bLoI.w iu qc DcAcJobuJGui o qic yuJLictcu io ?on qo !uJflL bc oj uj? jOL jpc uccuucqrnic copoLt [copoz4 mJ -- ! ° bLouibq O JA4iC lV! P L''1 coujwcur ou pc bI.cAIorI2 1c2!ou: 1j worijq joic Icp OL WC!L LC2LCIJ V2WUCG OU iJJ ACI2O1F ['ELLA K COWUJCUiG OU POW cjW UJJCOiCJI OL P! LCGLCJJ 22WUCC OU IpC C4!CL A2!011 i3q Opui oumrnpu auq r!q OJJIJ 2U' q BP L0I.1. 2 MC!J V2 WO2C Oj luG OWCL bI.luc!bmu i pn'F BOL! J"I" J8- JÔÔ BCH!O iwP uq ccjcuoMJcqc qic pcjbrq cou,ujcu o wc qcnmu ca1!cL bbcL i bi.ccuicq i qic coui ou jowcu nurnu CbJWJ uq jcAcJobwcIU JJqJ flU!ACI2?t flhJ!AGLA O J,jgpmjr uq qic flIJ!AC2!1A O jOL rpciL couJwcui Jpc flhJ!AGLC2 ILOU qiGW R1G11C2JGA CO!JG B1 COJJG 2mJwOIJ COJJ B'q cou urn Jfl2 J0L qJi 2ulqX iiuq qic bm.qcbu12 o bnppc jccmi.c2 UflWGLOfl2 COjjcG miq wi b,bCL pA qujqu qic wqcu o ECOUOW!C (bz.u JJ) OL nuqpu qic B(ILn O ECOUOWTC KCGICJJ OLU bcL J40 40ôô i Lcbc qic icjcuo!Iqcqcwciu umqc crnu o ojjcc !U iuc flAGs o vwcucmi Jowcu: u ii HflUL AcI.211 iou J2(1G ill qic )OLjthJTCC Could! flU!AGL2IA VbL!J j- jji brthci qcuAc2 LOW JJ1 JLGGUG 1JJG Jfl-COLUGJj pJ2qUUG OL pOL L1G bOJ!C!G COIJTP1.UCG 11QGUqGL uq Jfl1JiJA injA cvwpqqc NV JOO YIJU V'" MvnoMvr BflBEVfl OE ECOMONIC BE2EVIcCH JOLJCUJ bIthcL M° J88 oqpu A&0NE14 TOOK 10 hUE bV2l CVIEEK VVID hVNIFA: COTTEGE I1BEI /AOKKII4O bVbEI 2EK1E2

oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

UOJCC ]ACU O IC 2OIILCCbibp urnA pc dnoicq ,iipocii cxbJ!c! bcun!ou bLoiqqq qrni jpjj cLcqj ucjnqpi ©© Jô P QOJqU fl L1JJf2 LC2GLAGq 21J014 CCPOIJ Oj GX UO1 10 CXCCCq WO

QJC MOUJ BflLfl O ECOUOUJ!C JQ2LCJFEcouow? wiq r'co nqic uA obiuoua cxbi.ccq ULG qioc o ipc rIqJOL uq UO pocCO1JOL jpJI yiBEJc2 LC2CLC bLoI.w iu qc DcAcJobuJGui o qic yuJLictcuio ?on qo !uJflL bc oj uj? jOL jpc uccuucqrnic copoLt [copoz4 mJ --! °bLouibq O JA4iC lV! P L''1 coujwcur ou pc bI.cAIorI2 1c2!ou: 1j worijq joicIcp OL WC!L LC2LCIJ V2WUCG OU iJJ ACI2O1F ['ELLAK COWUJCUiG OU POW cjWUJJCOiCJI OL P! LCGLCJJ 22WUCC OU IpC C4!CL A2!011 i3q Opui oumrnpu auq r!qOJJIJ 2U' q BP L0I.1. 2 MC!J V2 WO2C Oj luG OWCL bI.luc!bmu i pn'F BOL!J"I" J8- JÔÔ BCH!O iwP uq ccjcuoMJcqc qic pcjbrq cou,ujcu o wc qcnmuca1!cL bbcL i bi.ccuicq i qic coui ou jowcu nurnu CbJWJ uq jcAcJobwcIUJJqJ flU!ACI2?t flhJ!AGLA O J,jgpmjr uq qic flIJ!AC2!1A O jOL rpciL couJwcui JpcflhJ!AGLC2 ILOU qiGW R1G11C2JGA CO!JG B1 COJJG 2mJwOIJ COJJ B'q cou

urn Jfl2 J0L qJi 2ulqX iiuq qic bm.qcbu12 o bnppc jccmi.c2 UflWGLOfl2 COjjcG miqwi b,bCL pA qujqu qic wqcu o ECOUOW!C (bz.u JJ) OL nuqpu qic

B(ILn O ECOUOWTC KCGICJJ OLU bcL J40 40ôô i Lcbc qic icjcuo!Iqcqcwciu umqccrnu o ojjcc !U iuc flAGs o vwcucmi Jowcu: u ii HflUL AcI.211 iouJ2(1G ill qic )OLjthJTCC Could! flU!AGL2IA VbL!J j- jji brthciqcuAc2 LOW JJ1JLGGUG 1JJG Jfl-COLUGJj pJ2qUUG OL pOL L1G bOJ!C!G COIJTP1.UCG 11QGUqGL uq Jfl1JiJA

injAcvwpqqc NV

JOO YIJU V'"MvnoMvr BflBEVfl OE ECOMONIC BE2EVIcCH

JOLJCUJ bIthcL M° J88

oqpu

A&0NE14 TOOK 10 hUE bV2lCVIEEK VVID hVNIFA: COTTEGE

I1BEI /AOKKII4O bVbEI 2EK1E2

Page 2: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

88R nbhoW MH84 QQ1 '1ut

HOaJJOD :YJIMA1 UMA $IHL$1AD T2A 3HT OT )IOOJ MIMOW

TDA$ITflA

1 111w d1 zI3do 3th nth1s31 noiitiaiM qx ninow iub 11o3 1n335L

iuói lo 33nn3qx 31o1 todsi bits 3idqs1om3b rIi f1i3ffiT .limj1 bits its ninidmo3 Ni

bits 3bsm ths aiocb th vtdo 03 w wo11n vwin isq &b Ot35 nmow 3311o3 lo 1torIo3

.,mij tvo b,noo1 n3mow g1Io3 nits1 alit siiano di won

nirndmo3 NI jst aa33tJ2 nIid £ bsd lasq 3d3 iii nfnow 33subE1 31IO3 lo flonlo3 oT4

astdW .aanaaIbIirb 10 ist s bsd (OIQI .3 nirsubs1BJ I riodoD .iis bns 1irna1

no1 todsi wol 11jiiini bsrl ii ,nhadb!id3 lo ,lst niid s bsd (QI . niisubi) III itonioz)

a'bo3 tol 3biu 3sibmmi raom di bivotq (VQI . niisubzi) VI liodoD .noisqi3rtisq

xl ns3 isift rioclo3 s oaTs all! .vioiaiil 3i11fl31 au b bn nft 03 aoI3 ai bits nmow !1o3

bIo ats Vt ou V asw quoi sift nclw IQQI nil .nmoW nuoY 2.J.M ,n1i niau bthuia

tol a3smiia dT .driid iail1 £ ,snf ol r bsd 113(110W (iidw) 3isubst ,llo3 aIqmsa 311110

03 \0I Ino aiulT .!qmsa 3113 iii nmow subsi 11oo ifs tol EF2 01 C? moil 'CI35i53

nomA .blo ats (M 3uod 25W ii 3m13 du d "135153 bits s1irns1' b3v3id3s quoi 3113 10 t odw nmow lo quo IIsffts £ 2(11531103 VI flodoD .2231b11r13 313W 1331B3 b3NthlIs odw aodi

.3viaul3 anismsi 1so 3113 laom tol iud ,135153 nijiw 1irris1 b3nidmo3 3v511

nibloD aibusiD 231ffl0f1033 lo ln3mllsq3U

ti213vinU btsvisH 8O AM bhcfmsD ILflM bits

Page 3: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

i1orIo euoivslq lo 29Df19fl9X9 scIT .199Th) bns 'c1irns1 cDod flmw sboi fISfflOW ss1IoD

svfil-1 nsrnow ssI1oD .wollol oi tniw isth slqmsxs sift 2srkimul scion iud esbiu iisrli svtse

rI1Vi9D91 9Th 19fft Eimcp9inuO) 916ff! 119(11 rLftw tsdmun in iimq rnvsxrbs in bsbssiue

eloorbe sisiibst him Isriokes1oiq in thurñino sm srf1 brI6 (ii16up Ifiups fuodfi lo enoifnsbs

91d6q16q i siscli bn6 1fio 9vi2u19 ff6 2(11992 11i1 ii1sups ilul isY '.siolsd 19V9 116(11 910(11

.nOii6lf2tJ•11

nsmow 9sI1o) 10 efiorio iohq lo eslsl DtmOfIOD9 bus ir1qsom9b srIf sisd 9dft29b I

919W 9)fl9U92fIOD Iniinsiedue lo e11o9b61T .cmrnow 991i0D 2'Xsboi 101 Isborn s1dioq 6 rbss

msqqs noii619ct9 1n9291q sill 2s2tmolqrno) fl9fflOW 9911o) lo 2nOrIs19fl9 isq d sbsrn

)1f1qS1O1T19b iii 'filrnspsm isbns cxirisrb bus e11obsii 11111(12 sikq2sG .sAsm of Wiiffiwriu

.iX9rI 9(11 101 s6f2 sill I se sisubi s9llo) slsmsl lo noiisisns rFms esrno(1uo DifflOciO9 bits

121Jf(I sw nO1fs1sfl9 1r19r1u) si-ft id bsml esDiorb srlf Is bsvrtm si-sn sw won brIsrlslqmo oT

.2Th9( bslbfluIfI iesq sift eeOts snsi-b bnrsfeisbniu

ylsmmu2 A :ehonloD sviI .1

.(t 91(1ST 992) noii&nib in 2Th9X O itiods rbss e9isubs1 99IIOD lo 2110(10) 9V11 isbiCcioD I

9(11 in bssiismmue sd cis ellosbsii lo no1e291o1q 9r11 him msnli niorrrs 29)nSlsIIib silT

-- 0Q81 bnuom mod bins OIQI brniom rnfsubs quo1 — I 110(10) ui .isnimm rnwo1Io1

cull in 1191110W 120ff! 1oI .199Th) brm 'c(IiciIsI f199Wl9d 29Vii6fi19ifs lo 192 Amie is bsirIseslq 99fl0D

bsviovcii eiwIs feonnis Ii 199Th) 6 26W floIbsise sill ci9rlw him tsdlo 9(11 10 9110 asw Ii quo 9111152 9(11 1 nods is esilxrnsl bsrl bus bshmrn fl0d619fl9 &inli ui 119ff! 991I0D r1uon1f[A .niirbssf

(11011 tisqs 192 919W fl0iiS19ci9 cliii iii 1191110W 99110D fl0ii6)1Jb9 19(1if1 I noriliw 11911! 213 9151

(I 01161 911T .88Q1 iii . t fud OQt iii esw eloorbe IsnoiecsIolq iii nsrnow of risrn lo oifsi silT 9161I9W bus n0ii6Dub rIiksH 10 fn9rflimqsCl 2JJ) 88Q1 ui OQO fud OQ1 iii 81 esw eloorbe fsubsi

.(oQr aio ;88Q1 ie9iU

I

Page 4: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

19r1119 ftodoD kr1i iii fI9fflOW 9UbS1-99ll0D 10 o\0O nr1t sloM .eimqlsinuoD 9911oD-non usd1

noibsul ilEme 919W 1191110W 99ll0D .rrsublirb syBil ion bib bib srli Ii ro 'uim Ion bib

riwBub susw rliod r1uor1i1A .o X1113up9 ieornuis smw nsrn sslloD lud noiIs1uqoq riuo srlI lo

iu 293(191911th JsrI:1 9Dn9biVs i susrli u1ibrmi2 bn.6 rlilssw nsDnsmA lo 211019(1)9 sqqu 9fli irioul

919w ah6psinuoD ss11oD-non usd1 bits nsrnow s911oD risswisd esnshsqxs Dir1qsuomsb sill

9sllOD silt i isrlT .esid 11011)9192 01 nsrli usrlisi 9911oD lo "1)9119 irisrrrlssui" 13 01 sub xismi

.msrli b913911s 9DfI9fl9X9

usr1irl bsnisuii — OfQI brmom mod bits &I briuom ciiisubsu -- 1101103 bnoD9E silT

noiisluqoq iniivslsi srIi lo nothoqouq 9(11 iuH .ilorloD uoe2sDsbsuq elk nsrli esisu sBh1sm

bits ssnusm sill ei isriT .rbum sessuth tori bib CTh91( suom uo uriol rol ssI1o rrkbnsiis

olni noibslse lnslsqql silt lud sno euoivstq sill mom bsessrrli 1101-103 ciii lo sist nimsdb1irb

e9vil 91-li 21119)110) 11)11-lW guouD silT 1sir1qsmoidoius e'rlhsDDM XmM srmrb ion bib s511oD

xie 1eu qrou 9111 lii sno 10 nibbsw 9111 15 ansqo .CCQJ 10 22613 9111 1-11 1191110W TheesY idis lo

srII luods Isvorr s mol 911932 mnsqo scli ns9d 9v61-1 ton bluow iisrIT .rioiiubsu usil msils 2)199w

\(sHi bsirmm 1rio Ion 1101103 bnose ciii lo etsdmsmn silT .nsrnow s911oD lo 110110) euoivsmq

ems lsusvse uol *row is bsnismsu v,srff .noiisubsu si1s icu 996!q *10W 91-11 bsuslns ocis

nsrll bs9ld tnstsllib £ 919W X9fIT" .t99Th3 11th s lo bs11h11th X191s1 enoiisriqes rlliw 1Insupsu1

*10W ol seoqouq tori bib 9110 tori" quor msrl lo 11-1hsJM siouw "sbsDsb euoivsuq sill lo seorli

dot" rtinisi1s es II Itorlo 9s.flsiDBThrlD I .bsitsvusini '1lsuinvs ihrns1 iua ".11131 fflffIO) cult

lo irismsvocn sill 1 rtimoeeo1d 11th 91ff .111 01 I moil sbird s es ii W9iv bits "lims1 119(11

Ion 111w I .111 trOrIo rlliw cO11 sill 191113 sf1113) rnssitcrism rIsDnsmA 9111 olin nsrnow s911oD

.11 irorlo no listsb uscltuth 'ns olrii o

on riivsn1 o\° ) 0\°ô.] + (b9him I9V9fl \° =) o\°1.IE :OQ8LD mod 1101103 9111 tol ci 9iui1 \°O. si-IT .[(bshmm isvs \° =) 0\°Q.8 x (eiss N-E ss d risiblirl

Page 5: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

3

9W0U 1j1026 MJJO 9ff96q fJJ6 if V q6L6G' \0 pqUOf XGf pq fjJ6Jl I2f P4P pX JJ MJJ6U

(149fou9J ['oufnqu9J 2rnA6X o) joriu M°1M611 9IJ 91.6 2friq6q l.1 6f9fl p6J0M I f9f

4.16 COJJ0Lf -- 1JJ026 MjJO M6L6 N fO 5f X69L2 °N flJ JQ -- M61.6 auibj&g 11.16 12f V1'V2

uq 21 X69L2 ojq uq fp6n. CJJjqpP4p uq W9419J jJ!210L!62 91.6 U691.J?. cOwbJGfG y boLpou o

OL MJJOUJ 9 C01121q6L9pJ6 1.9C40U JNAG C0U26L6 4.16 C9L66L b9fp JJJGX 91.6 C(ILLGU11X GfM66LJ

JJJG MOUJGU 0J COJJOI3 LA — L9(19111J 9LO(UJ uq pow 91.OIIUq J2O --91.6 4J6 U1.2f

-- fjJ6 L62f1LGUC6 0 j6IJJ11J2W

fO fJJ6 C01JfL91.X' JJOMGAG1.' fJJG CO466 MOW9IJ 0 4.16 1à202 26f 4.16 2f96 0L fjJ6 6AGUf 2 O fJJ6 JO2

CJJJL6U 9f 9ILJJO2f 4.16 291116 L9f62 92 WGL U0U-COll66 COUI6UJbO1.91.!62 D62bU6 ll 9bb69L91JC62

6C91JJ6 2M6bf 9M9Ap?. 4.16 bo2f-oLJq M91. L6/4A9J O 9JJJTJX' C0fj66 MOIJJGU w9u6q 9uq pq

2CPOOI Gf1C9fG L0flJY 2 COJJG6 6C9IJJ6 1.1101.6 9CC6224pJ6 fO IJJG W92262 uq 92 y1M6L1C9

rucOuJG-6u61.9pJJ wu om 9mou 4.16 coJJ66-6qr1c9f6q LOrIb 92 MGjj 92 LOW 9UJOIJ fJ.JG pip-

C0U2q6L9pX P!J6L CJJ9IJC6 0 W9LLXJIJ 9 C0fl66-.6qr1C9f6q UJ9IJ' IJJ6X 9j20 W9UJ6 fjJ6 p!jJ61.

IJJG W91J(Gf 0L COJJ66-6qnC916q IJJ6IJ 140f 0JJJJ qq MOW61J MJJO 9ff6U6 COJJ66 219U 9

6qu1c9fou fiG 91J2M6L M92 fji9f f 6U6L911X q!q UOf' pflf 1JJ9f CO466 YJjOM6 4.16W fO f91) ITJf 0

1.6ff1L1J2 fO COJJ66 1r1246q 416 1J1!40U 911(4 OLbOl4fIIJ!IA C02f2 O fjJGU Of1L ?.69L2 0 JJJJ6L

01.16 WJJJ1 92j( O W9UX O fJJG MOUJ6IJ LOW COJJOJ4 flJ MpGfJJGI. 416 L6C1 (b6criuJ9LX)

9J20 901.6 fJJ6 MOIJJ6IJ 0J 4.112 COJJOI4 14.16 ObbOLISITiTIX fO W9LLX 9 C0Jj66-6qflC9f6q m9w

q&urnuq 9uq fG9CJU CL6GUI49I2 6u6L9JJ). L6UJ9UJ6 A9Hq qnLu op WfGLLflbf!OU 911f COH66

bGu91 If M92 9 bLOJ622101J 0116 corijq 9JJ 9Cj( OIJ\ 6C91126 fG9CjJ1J MOIIJq 9JM9X2 6 u

6UJB1OAJJJ6IJ1 O CpOTC6 M92' OUC6 f69CppJ' 0L !f 9fl0M6 2TICJJ 2649J fJ1JJIU M!IPOfIf 9 J9L6

2C6(41J6(4 -- 91JJJJX C9IJJ6 111 fG1.11J2 0 4W{1J 911(4 bL!o4fX' 4.1611 6WbJOXWGUf 1116

-- 4.16 obboLV1u!f). fO JJ9A6 04J uj14X uq biq GUJbJOAIJJGUf Bf 4.16 fMO M6L6 fO 6 26L!9fjX

C0ll66 06L6 4.16 MOWGU 11.1 COJJOLf ffl -- L9q119pU9LOfW 122 uq pow iorwq J3

Page 6: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

r1k2u '\ADMI 199Th)" 6 no 919W o\0& ol 0\0à luods duorIiIA E.blo ems' oi E esw quo 9111

10 9Of1i 01 9Vi16191 eO8Qf sisl 9111 fIX eniJTtfl9 ixSr{i rnrrt9DnO) noiftriilsb UO19fl9 119V 6

9cnd isrli d "rssmD him Iirn61" bsvsirbs bsrl o\0t 01 t 's(Irio nscn 9ldsmqmoD

mod him 08Q1 miIs rnisubs — V horlo th nsrnow si-li rths11o 9d ol emsqqs sslloD

I'ISIXIOW ssl1oD .iThq19ifluO) 916111 iisrli rliiw (ix16ups 9U11 iol viiniJttoqqo 9111 -- 8Qf 9)111

jsi-li ",c1oj nsrli lims1" hi-is I i'1orlo lo noifqo si-Il '\'ssis io xlirnsI" lo sDiOrb 91-li b9ts'I Xflboi

(imm lo isrli '\1irim1 nsrli '199Th)" lo 9)10(1) si-Il rliiw sldflholrnorw 9Th "(9111 bnA .111 hOlIOD 10

dsisr1i bim XIlsul9e eirl9vs slubsrbe 01 riilliwrw Sm y9rlT .m9rli b9b9D9tq i2JJj orlw VI 110110)111

bris I9bOffl SldSuiuE £ 29bivo'1q 16111 horlo euovslq on bnFI ns '(si-IT .msrli lo ss-io ii1isIioI Aeh

919W isrll '1oob si-Il lo rmM •svsrl orlw thoclo si-li 10 "(cm 111 fl9fflOW 10 nOiiD6'1I Ilfirne s lno

iesq si-li lo e9i6ub61 9111 is'! .n9qo won sm fl9fflOW 99lloD 10 enoil61sn9 euoivslq ol bseob

.quo'1 11191110)2kb 6 ffl992 9b6D9b

nscnoW bi-is nsM iol SISU noiiEubs'1D him simbrisiiA 9sl1oD . 9fflfflSXS ol SVrbLrdedu ciii ,bsts11o leuj enoiiflsnsbBThrl) si-li lol eiesd si-li rthoIqxs 910198

eli-li EO'1)6 99H0D moll bslsubs'1 him b9bnsfls orlw e91srn91 him esifim lo es6ins)'19q si-li

sIqmfie bsiDsIse-119a IrlirI S 9d bhio '(9111 910ffl si-li ss1!oD bsbnsiis orlw '1swsI 91ff 'ruin9D

lo irIsmissTi" si-li sisloek ol 9)1k! bluow I se11698 .noiisliiqoq 9111115 si-li flO1flB ri-iou

.99l1oD oith noiiDsIse lo aesouq si-li bimie'19b1111 01 sviffllSqffIi Cf ii 99ll0D

hid wo1 919W 9sHoD bsbrisiis orlw nsrnow bns cism lo eriothoqouq 9111 O1Qt 01 uoiu9

\0.8) rioii&njbs 10 e'1S9 I � rlftw 1191110W sfirlw 101 iQ1 d erFhid ieiil ci '101 o\08.8 Ci s'nji1 r1T £

.rQr ru 9tqmSC srLt i-ui riisd rio IsruoifibnoD (esssb .A.a rlliw rusmOW sit-lw o1

'1srllo eeelD & &imonoD "tm ru seorli -- slqmse Ilfime s no fbsiiirnbs beed ci noievbrloD eirlT" rbssi odw e'1sdio "nsm lo enoIecs'1qrrIi si-li bns b6lno vrl I moclw clfiw C9isubs'11sbnu blllvmH

.X fI0L1S'19n9

Page 7: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

88f moñ) O8t briuom mod seoul nomA .X9C d mlirnie 1ds*rsm9i 919W e9slnsD1sq sill

sril lo o\°Q.8 25919f1W IS9X Sf10 12691 Is iol S9llOD bSbfI9flS fl9ffl 9f11 lo o\°.Q sIqrnsxs tol (BI ol

8t) OOQt bnuom mod eflorloD tol t9r1ic1 1iriile lno sm estuil sDrtsbrisiis bits bib

imqs t9r11m1 isrlwsmoa sm 291st noilsubstD .( IA sicisT xthnsqqA bits I siuN sse OOQ I ol

bits stuiq 952) ems 910111 to 11101 tol fIibn911E 21 ssllo rtiisubs 10 nOiiiruI9b 9th rtsilw

2fs919rlW s9llOD b9J6Lth61 f19111 lo o\0O. O8I brrnom mod horlo sill 10 '.(tA sldsl xibrisqqA

noiisubt usd1 01 9V116151 tl9fflOW 101 tsd1r1 ml 919W 29151 sDnsbnsiiA .bib itSifiOW lo o\°.E

ml '{11f19D9t lilnU 8.slsb sill ru bsbuIDrui 9Th 299h1OD m9X-OWI 9etJ5D9d Imq i-ti "lno kid 29161

OQI iii mod liodoD sill J .bsisubs Xilsubs 9slloD b9bclsiis oulw nsm rir1l fI9fflOW 19W91

eslsmsl ol esism niisubst lo oust sill esxse sill rrsswlsd bsworcsrr bsrl esisi noiisrjbst (19 VS

.sLrrujuIOD 01 ion esw t9v9W0rI bnsti silT .1.I esw

fIisfflSl bits OIt bcrnom mod ehoclo) 1111W -tvxb bits I esmi1 iii esrtil owl silT

usd1 bss1sb OQf bnuom mod e:ttorloD sill th nsm sill lo srno2 .bohsq 1n9D9t sill Ilium imqs

s9lloD s bsvisst svsrl ion bliiow etsrhlo nsm H tsW bhoW rthub noiisDubs ss1foD

nsm 9lidw xIrlo ewollol tech *10w I6Drnqm9 9111 lo lie iii isdi te1uo 'tsv 9th le befori sd bluorle II b9brlstte orlw estiilwrion lo 'i9dmIrn 191161-ne 1deisbierio srli lo seIJsD9d b9l9bienoD se nsmow brie

Aeeq 9111 111 99lloD

d e9)nslsIIib iiporiiIs thorlo isblo 9th 1o1 b9ls19sx9 sd sm s91ioD r1ibri91te 9slrI9Yl9q 9rIT 29161Jb6Th loorbe r1id iol eteb 9111 setJsDsd bste19ex9 916 e9ilJi1 sri bsqeLle I .916IIJDDS 9d blIJoD xse

.(1-QQI riibioD sse) CUCIISD O4QI silt iii bsieteisvo 916

99e .21E9\ 01 2 10 4 01 ,4' 29S lo 26 9Th 29161 9DfiSbfIstie sill brie estei nodeube'i sift nba .esbori bns esyiuoe tol brie I

brie e9iem nltod 101 2991101r19 991t0D lie lo o\04t tol B9IflLJODDS 29911oD Th9(-OWi s1qrnexs 101 QI uI 8

ni e9lemsl lol \0g4 tud esiem 101 o\0I esw 29181 sDnebnstbe ol eebei noiteijbe lo oitet silt tsY .egfsrnSl 2916111 rlssWi9d 29161 noiieube ru e9DrI91911ib silt eurlT .(IA sideT xibrisqqA sse) O4QI lo tiorfoD rftiid 91-ft

2i 9m6e SI-IT .es91IoD m9(-1uo1 rnoll noiieubet isibrisisilib 'id ioI bstnuoDDe sd beum esIem9I brus etiodoD suit cii rusi-now ioI iswol rlDurrl 919W esiet noiisubei3 etIorloD 19i11e9 101 926D 9111 boi-i 1dedoiq

oniw CilorloD 929111 1-li i-191riøW 9th 1 noitisil 9isi A .QI buods 91019(5 riiteubsi etirlt aOQI 91019d i-nod i691-ow1 9111 91e'Isqse ob tiuDillib ax Ii iud eloorbe lermoru bris 2991IoD 'etsrlDest iii 919W 99lioD b9bnsfle

shill lo 915 eloorbe [errrioh4 .2i69' 920111 iii e9sIIoD 'eusibesl iss-iijo1 silt rriouu eloorbe inrnon .eO4QI sill 19116 9Drlstloqmi

a

Page 8: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

1i9b91 lo sob 9m1 letil srIi b9bivotq irIi5I lo lIiH ID 9(11' .16W 9ff t tol ion ii 919W norisDubs

him iIrI9wi iisrli fri nm lo noiiDstl I6!ins1due 6 b9Diins bim noiiiui 99lloD lo noiissibiedue

.lOOtb2 01 mIrf9I 01 E9i1lifli X1Th9

9111 Iitriu b9iit9q 9i61 noii6ubs1 9slloD 111 fl9JTIOW bris nm n99w19d 29)1191911kb smJ 110(10) 9(11 tol Q.f ol b9269tDrli E9i6Ub61 916(1191 ol 1sm lo oust 9111' .e0t 9(11 in mod 2110(10)

bsrl ii risdi trlirI ml 11112 sw hid 2Th9( 1191 ixsri sf11 nk .t ol b9rIilDsb II .Ot bnuom mod

noilini odw nsm s2u6D9d imq ni e9I b9tsluib 29161 9Dfl6bfl9flA .1njin9D srll fri 1911169 r199d

rn bim 119(110W bib imrIl 29161 t9l69t 16 991IOD bsl9lqmoD JI mW bhoW isfis bSxibiedu2 sw

rilod i-ri qs r{T .2l9drnxJcI r9lssi fr1wscnoe ni 2loorb2 tss-owi b9bnslls 119(110W 921J6)9d lmq

8 .2Of lms sff 1 ru mod 21iorloJ si-li d b9m9qqsib I[6I.rtfl9V9 9Dflsbn9llfi bins noilsubst

.e.A.8 WIIVI9)9i 919W 119(11 imrIl fISITIOW sioffi 08Q1

sc1l 11911W hid 591I0) 011119W 1191110W bins 11911! W9I nsrlw 99llOD bsbnsfls I tior1o aunT

nsrlw s9HoD b9bn9lifi III itorloD .enoiieluqoq 1r9r11 01 ecroiltoqotq mlirni2 1r1uo1 111 b9bnsflfi

bsibnurl feBq 9(11 in 9(1111 1flfi 15 rnsdl 191sst esw sDnlsbnsiis ni e1sms1 ol 2916ff lo oust sill

nflod ni 1JkIsup9 isbns les1sst srIi lo sis its ink 9sIIoD nibnsJJs 21 V horlo llsrnI .eiss'

.29161 noilsubsi bins sDrrnbnslls

2f1012!D9U issmD bins ylim&1 cri snsu{D riibns1eisbnU tol )l10W9ffi61 A .E

99lioD dnD61 Elnksli2rioD 9111 won sfsrl2nomsb 01 bslDnruI2rToD 21 )I10WSIIThII 9Iqrni2 A

9V9iI9d I es1esi dnn6dD Ion 2lruisll2noD W11n6fID .XLJIfI9D 125q 9(11 2201)6 b9Imcb II9ffiOW

.199Th) him ',1irns1 ol bissi 111kw nsmow 99lloD lo aruok2bsb 9(11 19116 01 b9vt9e

n9sWi9d 26 lo in1uodi 9d bluorlE rbirlw lo (1)69 abohsq 951(11 211i611109 *iOW9ffIfihI 91ff

9919b 10 9bs1 129r1in1 1911 29v9111D6 immow 9111 19116 iurno ebohsq HA .rI1rr1 (It 2Th91( 01 01

911111 &rilimow boitsq rbss nil .(rrsmow 99II0D lo 926) 9(11 rri s9i9b tcIiin1 to. .A.8 s)

Page 9: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

ni b9vlovrli ro (1) srnii4lul ylirrmI rIiiw s(s) srnii-lliiI bso1qms 1n9q2 sd nD (T) in9rnwobn9

1im131 rlIiw 1n9q2 srnii T lo noibnth 6 2i iiliiU .smi1-hsq HD6S owl 9111 lo rioil6nkdmo 9(1108

:Y 9fflOD(fl bns

(Y "T)U = U

:12691 i rrtss ci b9au 9d fifiD *tow 9m11-HuI i bonq 1b139 fI9ffi0W 99110D io1

1T1Dw Dy

dot ol rnuisi s 2thsicfo 9rk thoh9g 9V1iUD92f1OD owl iol 9ffl11-Ihñ 8)110W 1113(110W 99l10D s 11

-911J .2boilsq 991(11 iol smii-lliR 2)110w 9(12 11(t) rnul9l 1911101113 2niEido srk bns t) 9Dfl919X9

:lqrflt2 9Th (nuiriuoD2rb on lo 9213D 9(11 ni) 2rnms9 91(111

+ f)ETw ÷ (i + 1)Tw + 1T*Dw Dy

fUU1DDS 211111 ebohsq 9viIuD92rIOD owl 12691 is iol srmi-Ilul rthhow 26 bsniI9b 21 "199ThD' A

:iEom is bonsq rbs9 ms9 9sI1oD 9isubfi1 Ion ob oriw 1191(10W °'.9Dn9n9qxe doj ci 2rrILrI9l

"w <W 91911W .T"w =

srli 9101919111 bns n9ffl0w 9isubs1I 99lloD-non 9(11 01 29111DD6 9DflSil9qX9 doj ol crtuisi oT/I

nivsn1 es bsriilsb ei "1imsI ".1991SD s 9vsnl ionlmD 9911oD 9if3LIb61 Ion 29ob orlw immow

9(1 ieum isdil bohsq 9rmi 13 10 1) noilDst1 mhIfTIiftirrI 6 291HJ91 blirb cbs3 •blirb 9110 12691 16

.fl9lblfflD svsnl 1{snIi 22911111 "9(1111 lirrith" nit 9fitI9 IonrmD rismoW .ilims1 rliiw irl9q2

2'bflsd2IJfl 9ldre2oq tuonliiw) immow srii lo iniEliErtoD 1sbud 9m119111 9(11 l9bi2fIOD I

9111 II .9bSfIl Ieuj 2noiiqmue2s 9Iqfflle 9(11 l9bcw iflifilientoD 21r11 2iDiq9b 91Ui{ ".(9moDni

l9flflSffl I8LFLJ 9± (Ii 9IT1ii-lILJ1 bus (1fr19flim19ffii-non) noiiqu'riini fuofiliw erism 9'19nt 9mii1IuI .(A99w\wod O ol nsnli 910w nxns9m)

.els9X biirlf 1die2oq bnis bnoD9 9(11 lo bci9 9(11 is eunod 91s1 6 ol ubls 916 ewIirnss 199ThD ° 991IoJ 01 1(19W 91qrn6X3 101 JII hOriOD (U (191(10W 9(11 n1w iol irwoDDs ol bsbnsqx9 n J9borrl 91-IT '

101 99110D 11 .fnUl9'l lo 9161 did 1ifl9iDfflU2 e ui 1111291 ion bib fl!fl169 li9rIi (Ii 9eE91Dni 91-LI fl9flW f19V9 19bLJd 91-Il wo19d ruisiD 111w I s '\19,hsm sirtsm" 9viisrDljI s 01 1in9 m9rli b9nis 1101-lcD irLf

.eblswqu b9ilirIe 9d 111w irIisli2noD

Page 10: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

irIsml(OIqms bisq) esiiiviis owi sift lo 9110 iS 9md-llu1 2bohsq 991111 9(1110 1b69 2bnsq2 nsrnow

iohslni its asDubo.!q noiisthdmoD rllniri silT .anoiisnidmo Isnoilsi ir119 Sm sisrli (x111 io

1) isrllis d bslscnmob 2k lirns1 d bsiqi.rrtsink 2115q2 frtsimo1qms owl rnrissm (s 1 s) inkoq

21 inislienoD isbud siff 'Jnsimolqms 2uounulnoD of 2mLrt9l 9111 lo saUfiDSd (1 s s) to (s s ' .nsvi 2noilqmue2s sill isbnu 2rIoi2bsb sill lo nirnkl sill ol irishsvnk

sill lo sthsv sldi2eoq i(19V9 mslnoD inislierloD ibijd silt thrllkw bris no Eirloq silT

(1 1 1) inioq i2om-lr1F1 9111 rftiw rnnrns8 situ 'ni3rfiow 99l1oD 6 lo noilsDOIls scmlshl

l1s1 sill ol WIivoM rrIoDffi on mrrtss bits x11rnsi (11kw srnil-lluI 2bortsq us rIibrIsq2 Elnsesiq91

lriioq silT .w sisi 9fiW lii isAmm 9(11 ni *tow of situ 21r11 lo riothoq ns IIo-sbsii ns nsmow £

(1911W 1 6111 2W0f12 :tIsf 9111 ol isrltxsl rivoM .srrtii Ikrris1 rn T bcis smoni T Dw SVi (9 1 1)

lsbud 9111 bits Twi lo crtuisu £ 2q65.! srk 2bor!sq 9viluD9EnoD owl 101 2*10W nsmow sill

1euoivsiq bslon 26 (s s 1) io (1 s s) lsrlfk9 lnsas.!qsi IISD linoq airiT .Assid s esri irIsllerIoD

sill bits (1 1 1) 1195W19d 2inIoq ils isrlt 9ioM .nhtht sill d bslDsIIsnu 21 lnks.!i2no tsbud sill

us * T ilno stiupsi n9.!btxrb 92usDsH .isAmrn sf11 111kw srrurt riibsul d bsvsirbs sd ns lssid

111kw lim22sDsn ton rluoilhls '\dot" bins lirns1 rliiw insi2rerxoD 916 Asstd sill 01 elnIoq sill

".199Th) bits lituI' bins lirnsI" lo snsi sill at Isili saus)sd tasisIni 1o Sm T bins A T risswlsd enoilsollA

9111 is rrtss T Io aitnu bonsq svtl!nSectoD owl 101 5)101 tocfsl 9(11 iii et nsmow sill t9lIA ".199Th)

rltkw smorf is bnosa 9111 smd 11th 9)101 iodsl 9r11 ni bolrsq lalkI silt :nsrri I 91qrfIsx9 tol (s 1 s) 1i ' im asubotq nolisDoff s silT strut 11th 9)101 iocisl srD ni boiisq IsriiI bns bunt silt brrs smit 11th i1kmth

.euouriitno 21 9)fl9fl9X9 nsrlw '(mo 9tDfi 9Dfl9fl9X9 dot rnot1 etiie sift 92LJSD9d tnioq iorrsfrii

ot niulsi 5 21 919111 *iowsrnst1 ekrli ni e risrfw Irisitsvnii sd ton sm trlisItenoD l9bud silT ' svlovrii 11kw rioiiuoq irishsvni silt lud taiu1 9111 lo noitroq s to boitsq fasi sift lo rtoitioq 5 tol srisrxsqx9

owl *tow n& riscnow £ 2! isilT .b9brjbxe esw isrfi (s 1 s) noit6r1idrnoD sift ot tslkmi€ "toris nirnki" s bstiupsi smit murnkcikm srlT .bohsq tasl 9(11 10 letil silt tsrlli9 iii blkrb s svsil bns ebohsq 9V1tU)9enOD

sill lo lisle silt is nsist ci noiitoq (A-r>T srli II .tnscmo1qrns bksq 101 (A-t)T rtivssl AT ci blirb s tol + I)'w 9qole (11kw noktioq sill SbuIDrIi Ion 111w Ink 511db) 1sbud sill bits 'w '(Ito Is ernss ii boiisq teikI

(t

8

Page 11: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

9111 2ffi69 ebohsq ssidi sums srli uol suol tods! sill iii cnsm9i orlw imrnow silT .(u + I)Dw 91s1

bnsqE oi Isnoilsu sd ion bluow II .(s s 9) oi qrnt4 irlis'tieno isbud sill bits 9ff1ODffi murnixscn

qmu irnsui&toD lsbud si-li eucli bits 1ims1 no AT rtsrll 9l sw lsrli sri-ni lo lnuorns svi1roq £

inioq isrli Is

= T isrli 2noiiqmuas 9111 usbnu nwsub r199d ei sE sarij in imsilerIoD lsbud silT

silT ".msi isq o\0 Juods ei srisrtsqxs ol muisu 911111 sulsv sldsnoessi fi = u bits .O =

\9 s) sill sbuIDni 'srIT .einioq 155Th) sill mn991qsi lriisuiano i9bLrd sill lo enoihoq bsrls!mb

[(A-r)- s + A•1] s s) bits (1 s s) nsswlsd insrnse sill ols bits '\lno issm?' ei rbidw irüoq (9

".ussrsj bins 1ims1" i rbirlw

ion kid sboi rismnow 99llO nbs1 9iorb lo Ise sill evk iriksuieno isbud si-IT

919W 1 florlo in nsmow srfT .erIoiisi9rI9 lasq lo rismow ssllo ol sldslisvs seorft lime9D9n

seusD9d (9 9 s) bits ET ci lsrli (1 1 1) eiriioq smsuixs owl nsswlsd siorb *tsie is rlliw b9sI

111kw 9qscie esAsi irnslienoD 1sbud 91!'!' u.sq ioI *tow ion bib 'llisisns rismow bsirtsrn

nwoi sisw nsiblirb n9db -isils sq tol *row ol nssd rismow bshmm nsclw III bits II etrorlo

rioitroq "155Th) bits xlimsI' sill VI hofioD rliiW .erioittoq "195Th) bits xlimsI' si-li bsbubxs ii mR

lo sDnsiqsDDs t9ls9i sill 01 9IJb 915W lthsuienoD isbud sill in esrisrb si-li lo HA .bsbbs esw

erioiceslotq ieorn iii bris fl9ffloW s9l1oD tei.4 ion suo1 todsi sill iii nscnow

irlisuieno lsbud sill s911o iuorliiW risrnow sesrli lo esvil sill snsrb sslloD bib woH

owl sill iei4 left ci inisuierIo lsbud si-li sslloD i-IIIW .dE smi1 ni "w sqote rlliw sin! sill ci

situ nsAotd si-li 11sni1 bits w sqole cIliw 91111 sill risrli (s s s) bits (1 1 1) cinioq smsiixs

bsiqo luoilo Icuul sill iii nsm oc xrlw mslD won ciii .emnkoq "tsstrs bits l1rris1" 9111 fnr11siflOD

= Of) 9eu6D9d ci culT H

on lud eboiisq C tol *10w smil-Ilul ci (1)111w 'Y c o iduor1i sd ols bluoD tIorl0D Cf iii ml ,Y ' .19916)

Q

Page 12: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

quoi 9isIJbis1 9911oD-rxor1 sth 213 29Dn919197q 9ffl132 9rD bsrl 1 fI9V9 ithoq (9 .9 s) scli lol

is isw 9lsrIi rri b9IliI 9cnsD9d sriil 9r1 s XrIW ln9mqenshi oclis ci ii bnA .14 inioq eocb oriw

rIw 1f39h \(l113up9 ci II .111 lnioq "dot bnis i1irnis1" lo noilisnidmoD £ 01 nii1irk quoi 9Th1

muhdiliup9 bsliesb 9111 in91T19e 'ssu bns lirns1" srIi bsbuIDrli ithslienoD ibud srIi risrfw

9r11 9lis19n9 IThD E9V'tIJD 9Dfl9ISlIlbrlt Dii9rfiomocl lo ie is lsrIi eworle dE 91uiI .VT 01 b9iIirle

.VI hi-us \III J ettorlo sisubisi-9911oD 9(11 10 ihosm is d n9eocb cnoiiisnidrrloD rrzuildiliup9

10 eleisi riinisrb iuorFliw 119V9 brus rI9mow 9i5rJbs1-9911oD rtiDE1 cirnShienOD srIi rn 29fI131fl

199ThD )how mbm9i e169'( b9lbnurl Iefiq 9(11 eeois 2flOilSV't9CdO 9l619fI9 1113) fI0th9192-1192

.Iimis1 bns

"199Th) 10 y1imsP' :1 110110) . r1uor1i1A .Of bnis OO1 n99wi9d e9919b .A.8 119111 bsi9Iqmo I tIOdOD 10 1191110W srIT

129(1169 si-Fl 9Th I 1101109 lo fl9fflOW 9111 b9ibLrt2 9d (IS) 29is1Jb61 9slloD 915ffi91 lo ciloflo) ioriq

sd 1159 si-noDni e'bnisdeuH bcis 9is 96k11Effl (fi1ii191 no1i6qIJDDo fIOiiSDUb9 no slisb rbirlw iol

.21J2f19) cioiiisiuqoq 11319b91 9111 lo (MUI) s!qmse SISU-oIDkM seU i1du Of 9(11 i-ri brruol

srIi lilnu ion eisw ii luct E81 iii nthsdO esw nsmow 01 eioob cii nsqo ol 99lloD ieiiI silT

sift (111w ImlirrImq bsbnsqxs noiifiDubS 19f1i11 cr1 1191110W 101 esiirnutroqqo usd1 eO8f

19f1ir1 lo C11OIILJ:liieni si-li 10 xnism 19v9W0f1 91Ttii usd1 IA .e99110D 911311191 1 ifI9mhICildSiC9

IlSUJD9119Jni 910111 on 119110 E9tThfflffl92 919W hid e9911OD 9Lrti ion 919w nscnow 01 nsqo nirrms1

eO81 9111 111 IrIO .einecn9lILrp9l 9911511(19 auoiorr krocliiw bns eloorIDe r1ir1 nisril rtibnsmsb

bits c1iirn2 bits meesV es 119112 2s911OD e'nsmow mi-ill 9111 lo in9rrIrleiIdsie9 si-li 1111w e0881 bns

19f{ir1 2'n91110w lo 619 9(11 bib fl9fI1OW 01 e9iiieisvinii susIe ei:soimv lo rririsqo srIf (11kw

rbirlw lo \'O8 ieornls nscnow 01 nsqo 9mw e9911oD His lo \° OtI '(8 .dll9d XItrIi noiisDubs

biscl IsrIl 299IIOD 2'fi5fiTOW 9(11 lo icoM .(E .q QI IsmoDwsVl) enoiiuliierii IsnoiiiiDubsoD 919W

01

Page 13: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

ol b9lovs9bn9 113111 enoiiuiiiani nibrr6fEqu 919W 21S9\ (1991X12 lo ffiSm9liUpSl 9s murniriicn sf11

lo ii1sups iol svoli2 1(9(11 :rim of IIIVI 919W es9H0D 19(110 Isrlw fl9fflOW 01 9bivolq

cu muluDimn 2h6 1f3IsdiI £ idusi 2Sift2lsvirw brIE 299110D foM .(QQt booW) mIJILIDITIIJD

brIE fl9ffiOW 2Ur1T .Dihin9!D2 brIE 1&)ies1D —

1(bu12 10 2921U0D owl 1(llSDiEEd 919W 919(11 birlw

.flOiiLJliii2fll 9(1162 9111 16 ion 919W 1(9111 n9(IW fl9V9 292261D mlirnie 1(19V )100i nsrn

cioifsDub9 lo nEhoi2iIi bsion 9r11 1(booW armor1T isdw bsrl noiisDubs 19r1ir1 2'cismoW

919W nsmow 9911oD lsrli m91D sw ii 20Q81 9(11 1(8 •9Dfl9up92noD bslsqbiirmnu ns ts bswsiv

119V9 i611i bits 99ll0D bnsiis ion bib orlw 920(11 919W nisrll 29161 19W01 1(Ib9bbsb IS rIP(fl6ffl

bsisDubs-e91 119111 nSfIi nSlbIirb 19W91 'c(ld619bi2noD nwsr1 919W 1(9111 1b9i116m 1(9111 Ii

6191113 lii 1(fl6ITI 01 1111Tflf31S 26W ii 101 91111619111 9V121I91X9 its b9nwsqe thbn11 srfT .eJmqlsimJoD

r1t1(1i ru JTI9Idolq 911162 9r11 b9DBI 9V511 219f1DTh9e91 inSnuD brts 1(9dT '.m2ivi16n rtiwot 1o

noiiDsIse sIqms2 01 9IJb 26W 29Dfl9119X9 Drc1qB1omsb cr1 9r191911ib 911110 bum won rrisi1sDe6 01

9111 110 sDnsbtvs svtiinilsb r1uor{11A .99lIoD lo fD9uI9 Jn91T11691i 9111 i 9Ub atsw rbum woul bits

9(11 (111w insi2iarIoD eW11bnft insbnsqsbni oWl 9Th 919111 b9r1iTh9rru 1199d 191( loft 2611 bsdtie

(16111 (191110W 101 bib 9911oD 1611w lo rIoiiDfUuI 13 910ffl 919W 29Dn91911th 9(11 16(11 norlfii9lq*191ru

.99llOD of Ittsw 1191110W (1)1(1W

lo 29161 1(filsuiquct 9(1110 2sibIrl2 2U01V91 9111 lo crtsm 16(11 b9ion 9d bluorle Ii bis isrlT

i2oM .E\(svlue irimuls no 19(1161 hid 2s1qrr16E sbiW-rIOtisrl no b9213d ion 919W fl9fflOW 99II0D

29s1I0) 2'cl9moW nsllo i269r1t1on 9(11 lo 29911o) 91119 9(11 cr1 n9mo lo E1(9V1U2 919W 1I6 10cr kid

ioT.' .(81Q1 )1991)I nsV s1qrnsxs iol ss2) iwsM mCI8 bits 11(9129119W 91hbb65f m2esV r1iim2 9)111

ssrtsiri wol 119(11 101 flWOfL)I risilo 21oorbe 1o noiiDsI9e 119111 lii b9261d 29th 1112 9(11 919W '(1(10

911111 101 in9fItI2iJtbfi oct 1111w fl9Vt 919W 29161Jbfi1 1119D91 '(1911116191 101 29161 96i1113m k,d e9i61

rlotheoqfrloT 1o 9u111v 1(d r11od b9261d sisw esibule aro1vstq 9r11 cr1 29161111123 .n0ii6ubs1 9rii2

.29Dfl919I91 'tol (8Q1) mSr1f1D1ooD 992 '

Page 14: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

.119q2 lo ee9n9i9lqmoDni lo 21ffl91 ru bris

fi9ffl0W 99lloD lo ii1Eiiqun 9th lo W9IV 1eisvinu nom s EblollE 2MU'1 oir cr 10 enOiiD9lIOD9l 9r11 rniq9DDs 8 .noiiD9Trb 9ii2oqqo sill ru 1dsdorq ei stsrI 2sid 91-li rluor{ils

isili lsAil 2k ii '\bshmcn l9V9ff' s 29v192m91li bsfeil orlw 9sin9Dl9q 91-li uiw bits nsmow 19b10

0Q8t brniom mod saorli nomA .bsisiemvo 2k bsirxsm-mv9 svsrl ol bsmislD orlw noihs1 sill

19V911 \o iuods 0Of brwom mod 920111 ioI 9is d bskimm isvsri 0\°OC risrli stom

.( sldsT 992) ss d b9nmm

s moil bsisubsi oclw io) 9911oD moil sisubst ion bib lud bsbnsfls orlw 11131-now si-IT

srli iuH . ss d ii'ç1mm lo iilidsdoiq isr1icl ifirlwsmo2 13 booi2 (9911oD ms'-owi

nscnow tol cmrli mis91 Xldslsbi2noD sw quoi s9lloD lsrlii9 tol m"(1mrn-i9v9r1 9sirI9DT9q

w 081 bnuom mod iubst 9slloD slsmsl si-IT .( 9IdsT ss2) 991IoD bsbnsiis isv9ii 011w

.(o\08. i2thss o\°Ll€) iThq'191f1L109 9911OD-nOn 1511 213W rIsrD 9lf112 1-11131-1191 oi 'sl9Ak1 stom esrnii 1

.( ol bss 1191110W tol b9iuqmoD) i 0881 bnuom mod seorli tol Dii2iisi2 smse silT

29iiilrdsdolq 9smscn 9(11119111 bsrf 1 ol OOQI tuods rnoiI 2169X 91-li 1-11 1191-flOW 5i611bl31 99t1OJ

.2ft&pstIruOD 99IIOD—1TOf1 iisrli rusrIl tswol 2iruoq 9sirI9D19q 0 X11'1 919W isrli

sw s9lIoD bns iils11qun no esibuitE 1lu1n99-9111-Io-mui sill lo noieulDrxo3 lsiscis silT

91131 9131116ffl iswol 13

9V6r1 01 1191-flOW bsldsns bits bs2usD i-hod 9Df19i-t9X9 sslloD 91-li isrhi

.bnsd2url bits 91"ie911l 10 99101-b iisrhi iii fl1m9D2kb siom sd 01 fI9fflOW bsiiirrrrsq sslloD

6 26 213W IeS3 91-Il 1-Il 11s1u3th13q f19iT1OW sisibsi 99llOD tol nolisquDDo l133iqi 9111 isiliitiI

IsDirmrH o (nun s lo isdi svse) slit ni 11011612 on 21 519111" bits 100flD2 '2l1r 9113v11q 13 ru 19119691

ii nsm 1(1lsniI .(8 .q Q81 nnirl2) "loorbe 'eIti s ru 19119691 1r19b129t lo isdi 25 961lThffl 01

b92isl 26W noiiDsts2 slqrrus2 lo ii1idi22oq 91-IT .immow Isub9Il9irui srli b9AilEib 119110 bkSe 26W

-owl Is 920111 29bU19fl1 931-16b119116 991toD isrlI ms!doiq sill bnuois J9 01 €9I6UbS'I 99Il0D no euDol I ' b1o 'tS9 Is 991f0D moiu b9ifiLIbfi1 119(110W IsrIl b9rnue2s 3vsrI I .21001192 lsrrnon bits a9s11oD '1s9{

.isr1irl rburri 1dsdoiq sw elloiloD 1911169 9111 -ioI 9S 9r11 bits mjjmirIim s \(11E19n9 ci isrIl it.id

Page 15: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

9ausD9d sLqrns2 bssid s b9rrrtol s911oD oi riio b9I9bi&IoD orlw (19(110W isrIi b9ion 9ffl02 bris

s9lloD si-ft tsi-ft noijon si-ft iu .(Ct-f .qq t lsmoDwsL4) nnJo1( bsirtsm ion bsrl yrf1

.b92imib 1suin9 ion cIuocIi Hsmns sw woc{Xns bsinsm 9v6r1 ion bluow risrnow

iiidsdo1q -iswol £ svrI 1(min9D rIi9iirIswi XITh9 9(11 lo nsmow ssHoD si-li bib xlcIo ioV

si-k Ii fl9V9 n9lbIirID mvscI ion lo ii1idsdo1q isr1ir1 i-bum s booi2 o1s si-k rIi1Crmm 10

bns) O1Qf ci blo ms 14 ol & 919W 0(1w 29ifiubs1 9sll0D sirimsl 10 o\°OC l9briu i2u .bsinsm

(19(110W lo ir1i Esfflti . f sw sinsisq srlT .ecftuid sf11119111 on bsbloDsl (bsirrsm-isvs 519W

r1qsi 1 91ut1 .(E sldsT sse) rsr1ir1 1nioq 9sin9D19q .II esw bris noii6Dubs s911OD on (1iiw

99llOD ioI 1$ ol s d c1iiid on n1vsr1 (19(110W (sii(1w) bsiimm-rsvs lo 9sinsD19q si-li

no sisb srIi rliiw tsdisoT ' .esisubsi lno Ioorbe-r1ir1 bns 991loD on rliiw sorli esisubsi

01 88l moil mod esisubsi ssIIoD slsmsl Us 1 o\0O I si-li work nsibIicb no sor1i ssmsm

.( smil ss) ss bsrbssi sdi smii si-li c1 n9lbiicb on bsrl io bsFrrsm 'tsvsn isrliis 8f sDrorb iDniikb s simm wns ic1i lo rrtui 9c11 bnuom 9i6ubfiI 99I10D slscnsl 9iff

o\0 1no 26919(1W n91b1irb bns bnsdeurl lol iqo ion bib o\0O krodA .199169 bns lirnsI s1 sDiwl esw 615 isdi lo nsmow ss1IoD si-IT ''.irjoi isi-li Aooi 99lloD bn9ifs ion bib orlw s2oi-Ii lo

i snO .sItI cr1 511101 1s3iqis 2irft 9)161 01 99llo) bnsiis ion bib oulw crsmow sdi s XIs)hI es

.fims1 lo 9961q si-li )1ooi isdw )126 ol bsl 91o19isi-ii

bsrl o(1w bris O1 cr1 blo ms 1 ol 919W orlw nscnow 9f6ubs1 s911oD s2orli 10

o\0O) 219fb1391 919W '(ii1ot6ffl i2fiv si-li bcm O1Q1 i-u 99101 iodsl srli i-il 919W o\01.88 bshmm 19V9fl

01 n9Va .(299lloD ci cticbssi 919W o\0 bcis eloorbe 'mbnoDse bits \1sin9ms19 cu 919W

bs)1es sd ii II" :lSIlLD9q es b9wsiv 26W nolisquDDo lo 5)iOrb 119(11 21Oi6in9JTimoD Th1oqm9inoD

.sib luI3Ds'I l2om cft lo ebsmm9b srIl d bsriirrnsisb i quo 9 9rfT

ir1i i-ri rimow f19V9 lErIi bsiesdqms 9d b1uor1 ii .blo eiss 1 ol risrriow iol 9Th eiui1 s2srIT .cIr(r16rn-'19v9 lo 91s1 wol isd1r s brI o2th 9s11oD bnsffs ion bib orlw tlorloD

El

Page 16: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

to i ii isrlf ...

b9lswElm 9d X1916e 19V XEffl 11 19cIfo imrlf e91 'T1SffI 119(110W 99II0D xrlw

l9r1:Thsf-1oor1De sm msr{f lo ihosm r1f ioI s1i1 Dilduq bim rIifbX9 910(11 S 9VS1D \9fff 9e1J6)9C1

cHild S bsrl 19V911 bsrl orlw blo xs !. of sor1f 10 .(1sriiFto cii eIsr{qm9 1Q .q 8f ncihl)

XHfI9TIUD 919W oclw sorH lo 9D1O1 lodsi sill uI 919W \°L4E quo1 b9xTtSJTI-19V9 9(11 111 919W kid

f191bh1t) on rlfiw (151110W 9f6UbS1 99llOD Silt iol rl9Va .9)101 lodsI 9111 cii 919W \°f.8 bsillsm

.insrmolqms 19(1 fIt 101)61 9Vieb9b 6 sw sshmrri

99llOD 9(11 f3 2911111161 911162 9(11 molI rIwfilb 1199(1 9V6f1 Of Xl9)l1l 919W 119(11 sslloJ

ii! .29n9i19qx9 99110D 119(11 d b919115nu 919W ESiSI DxHqs1orn9b 119(11 1 ircl I 110110) iii 1191110W

El rbirlw bsiimm 19V9fl 919W 1)10 ETh9'( ! Of €slsm SIIIIW 9f6Ubs1 99ll0) ils 10 0\°.O1 or 19V911 919W \°1.tt 99II0D Oft rlliw quo 9S 21111 fIt (19(11 10 .119(110W iol 9151 9(11 b11rlJ-srio

99llO) Its lo \° IS1)IILJ f2LI(OQ1 111 .29isubs1 9sI1o) lol SISI srIf imili 19r1irI 1l1rlik bsiimm

OQ1 iii .nsmow iol 9161 silt 19t!sup-sno 10 b9i1mm 19V911 bsd blo 2Th9X I of fI9m 9fsub61

o\0 tuods .sw Ii Ot cii bim 1I9f11OW 101 isrlf bi&11-sno 10 \0 oEls 26W 119111 101 9sir19D19q 9(11

9mri 9(11 d bsilmrn oilw n9m 9fsubs1 9911oD lo 9sirIs)mq 9rlT 0.ci9ffiOw 101 isrli Ilsrl-Sno 10

rifiw nsm lo I scif jisrli isr1ir1 fsrlwsmo2 bssbnl oi 16D1tfl9bi 11sijttiv 26W 9S b9rbssI 'sr1i

101 f silt 25919(1W 99llOD d b91)9115nu 11ijtiiv 25W (ISifi lo 9161 96u11Sfft 9111 u1fT .99l1o) on

.XIIEIIIIS1EdLIE srnii Is b9ub91 26W 119(110W

foci bib isdf i9 I flOflOD rn e9i6ubs1 9slloD slsmsl 10 o\0O I silt 1)sI 9(11 101 EfnhJoDs 1 srlW

1 uoilf iw nmow 101 o\0 25W 91LI11 9111 119(1W 1 of ss d nsibhcb svscl Ion bib 10 XIISffl

9110 srnui silt is wol X19V Esw 99llOD riioil riiisubsi 9fiifl9Yt9q 9(11 9Dr1i2 \{l161LDifTh 99llOD

svsrl bluow orlw quo bs1)9192-1192 6 919W fI9ffiOW 99llOD tsdll filidie2oq 9111 1 uo 9krt fonrt&

1WEM IT(Ia 9)111 299l1OD .9sllOD bsbrxsfls 1 0(1 sr(f bs(1 IISVS sIsI Dill qsiornsb 9ffl52 9c11 bsr{

9vsr{ of bns rrncimm lo noxtnsfrn 011 bsrf orfw (191110W fwO bsbsifls svsrl of riwonA 919W

.2MU O!Qt rlt bim (Wt QI Ct) 2U2119:) 9111 lo LJ69IUa .a.u

Page 17: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

orlw 2noiiu1iini lcmi-bcm1 sill moll 9shrisnsq sill 1u8 ".fIil1flD 19rl1d" s (111w msrll bsbivorq

to ss11oD lo qsi sill no 1stiins last Ion ob 2sDnslsIIib sift 2urlT .r1iil oels sw icrrsm Jon bib

.nsmow sill lo 2bnuo1*md lsboe 91-li

inscrssti' s bsbivo-tq XllsuiD6 sslloD lsi-ll noilorl sill lo ltoqqua i-ri snsbivs lesd 9rIT

(ss rlDs 16) bsirtsm 19V9fl orlw 2slsub61 991loD slsmel 10 961n9)19q sill i1l i ":bsils

919W orlw (191110W lo sslnsisq srI! in 926919r1i 0(1 26W 919111 (19(1W 119V9 XllsulrrEladu2 bs2sslDsb

(1992 9(1(16) 26 991IOD bslsubfl to bsbnsfls oriw fismow lo 9flln9)-t9q silT .2sisub6i sslloD

sill lii8 O(?l ol Of ff011 mod 21101109 9ff! 101 11-1512(10) l1i6I bsnismsl bc-is I 2s1uiq 1-li

9(11 19116 smlismo2 Ilsi 01 1m9d stui1 i-u nss sd sm a bshmrrr 19V9fl orlw 96lf19Yt9q

9(11 99llOD moil nh1subBi sslcIsD19q srIi i-ri iiids1e 9(11 siiq2sU O8I i-ri mod 110(109

ol OI mo-ti i-trod 2110(109 tol \°Of ol o\0? bnuom moil bsisrncmilq rrrtmm isvsn s6in9D19q

01 bs(1 svsrl bluow otq rrilisbriu si-li noib9fse-1ls2 bsv!ovni 99!Jo nibnsfls 11 OQ1

slilil 26 919(11 isrIl snsbivs sbsl firrthq 21 stsrlJ 2urlT iluast eurll subolq ol 11sDi12Etb scrs(1D

bsn&b es1subsi ssl1oD slsmsl Ia esnsnsqxs Dir1q6tomsb si-Il seuflDsd 1101199152-1192 0(110

.29161 noi1subs bns sDnsbnsfl 6 ru 9269131-ti 9(11 siolsd 110(103 rlttid d -non lo Elsvsl rlirl si-li 101 1(1009)6 10(1(153 (101139192-1192 16111 thrkildsi2s lo XSW tscllonA

nsswls8 enoi1s1sns insupsedu2 i-n bsnsqqsrl isdw sv'isedo 01 21 1 trorlo norncs 9flu1tflffl

ss110D bbrislls odw noilsluqoq slsmsi icisvslst sill io sslnsrrsq 9(11111 1101-103 bns I 110(109

norim noiltoqotq sill bns (IA sldfiT xibnsqqA sse) 0\°4t 01 \° rrrotI bs2sslni 2Th9"( lLroI 101

1)0112(103 Iliw I .(2lssX 1) (11 96 Is) o\08 ol o\00€ moti bslsrnmulq bsnmm tsvsn oriw mscll

-1192 915 I 1101103 Iii (191-flOW 9iShJb1S1-99ll0) bsFnsm-tsvsn us rbirlw f1 926) l&iisr11oqrl £

.2!e9rftocpr1 sc-Il 21 9St si-nil tsvo scisrb 9ff! 16111 worl2 bc-is bsis!se

isBesi s ol bns esii rioiisubs 99IIo3 1-li 926913(11 psrle 91-li 'ml ell-luoDDe lsdw worn! is ion ob I I isW bhoW sill isiii sldxeeoq ciii W81 bnxuois i-nod etlonloD niliw eslsi SDrIsbnsflfi 99llo ictsixs

.9211 9ff! ioI einuoDDs t1ib iefilim

Page 18: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

1)9192-1192 OE rriorlw lo 001 lo t2i2fIOD ol I tlOfIOD ill fl9fflOW 9iEUbS1 9911OD sill lsbi2noD

926) Iiiisi±Ioqr1 21111 ff1 99ll0D ei isrlT .imm ol irisw ion ob sdi 92u6D9d 99lloD ol o ol

9is1Jb61 s9ffo lo lsdmun sill sfduob 9W 11 .9611Thffl n b1691 "1)9119 ffi9ffu1691f' on esbivoiq

silT .111 iiorloD oil 110110) ff011 svorn srli ru bsrisqqsrl 1611w niisilqiib 9Th 9W 00 ol nsrnow

nfl EA .quo si-Il iii nmmsi iliw "uflsrnlfl9li" on Esbivolq s9llO) JT1OIIW iol Ii9ffIOW 91fI12 OE

thsmsi XIIEUTIflSV9 11kw orlw IThiflOW Ofl 2i sisrlf 001 I6noiiibbfl 9111 lo 16111 9fflL1226 92SD 9ffi911X9

lo 96insYr9q si-IT mobcri ion 2 sirrflrri-r1on is'isns IsrLi so1q sill i lisili bshmrnnu

16111 usc! —

o\08 01 IlsI ii huH o\0r ol \0Ø mon IthI bluorl2 s1ine fIXSffI9I orlw III 110110) ru II9ITIOW

rbiclw cr1 noihskrqoq s moil bsiD9Ise-119E nssd svsrl ion bluo I trodo flu nsmow 0 silT .icruoms

2101)61 lo 192 191110cm nssd svsi-l feum sisrlT JrmirroD bsrrismsi s1nie rusmsi ol 91129b 9111

.bsrrmm 19V9 odw nscnow s9lloD lo ruothoqoiq sill cix sriflrl) sill 101 nulnuoD)6

iii 101)61 \1smnq sill Ion 26W fIotlDsIse-1192 isrIl fthflb sill 10 hoqqu2 fIX 9Dr19b1v9 tsr1iO

lo ise 9vi2nsix9 nA .2b1oDs1 ssncntils m brwol 9d nfl) I 110(10) noms sisi ssiimm wol sill

noms nu1(1mm-1sv9n 9Eln9D19q si-li isrlI 2!69V91 sslloD s11i1DbsI ff1011 2X9V1U2 ssrirnuls

sill IuH .20'Q I si-li ol 0Q8 I moil X!s2ob '(19V 9fl19V6 1iiio11n 91.11 2)19611 29i61JbS1 slhbbsM

II .irjsieno hm1 bsrrismsi 2sisLrbs1 sllibbs5l scfi lo 2brwo1*md !sboe bnfl DImOnODS

moil rrwsrb eiasbui2 sIIkbbs5I lo nothoqoiq sf11 flu 926919r11 (16 26W 9(11 92u699d nirlhiris

moil smo svsrl sm ol 0It moil 2loocbe mbnosa ilduq 01 bs2oqqo 26 s1svriq

.bs26siDni 29161 96ifl6ffl 1i9(1I 19Y .29111(1161 sills E291 nscli 1911161 910ffl

sill bib xflw bris esisi wo! is rism fl5fflOW ssl1oD lo iiorlo 12111 sri bib nsrli rlW

sill :e91sub61 911iIDb5I lo evsv'we 'isriibiosi1xs ow-i nieu iDsjoiq s rrioi1 mo enibrii1 sesrlT -imse si-li riiiub nslsl ifirll bnfi (QI 01 01I molI €1101109 ni1subsi grInsvoD) ev'iue IiiiriliiJ

911J1U1 i-u 2X9VIJ€ 9€9r11 1-Iie1J 9d 111w I (0Q81 bnuo'is crioil eflorloD rii1subsi rni9vOD) 8f Iii Ifiufhfl9ufl9) 9111 uo1 0\°ô ew eloodDe 1ebnoD9e Dilduq mo11 rui1eubsi 9sfr19Y19q 9f1T cisrnow 9911oD no (19169291

s ioI (8QI) nomofo 99a .1101109 fIiiBUb6 QQ1-0t 9111 iol \°11 tud 1101103 rui1subsi rr-otr .'9V11J2 Isiflnsifls)-im9€ 9111 b noie€uDCib

Page 19: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

bslsDubs ifirlw i-u brrnoI i sub icmhoqcrii i-iA horioD fn9upsedu riiiw sss1Dr1i oi cnsd esisr

bsisDub3 .srmi si-li fli ob ol bswoll6 519W n9fflOW bsFnsrn bsisubs mltnihsq i-ri 119ITIOW

rIins9i9nin si-li lo bris si-li bnuom SfffliSfflOE fIiflIfl9d bri isdssi 51El bits d ssw rismow

nhi1 bits nsrriow bshmm lo rihurl si-li iibhr esbtloq bsiqobs aiDFIiib looflD (1LrhrIsD

bits eOQ I srIi ol 'lwola bsss1Dru "Emd ssrnsm" sesi-IT .9)ivi5 iii bsFrtsrn or! w nsmow slriie

I si-li itt bsislsDes srlJ noi2es1q9Cl issiD sf11 rihub edot noilsi ol 'Øi2esDsn si-li rliiw nsrli

risM (1Qf OQf riibfo3) 2rIoiiiaoq isrilo uoimv bns 2c10irI9rnm9VO *tow sDñIo riirbssf ni

briuol to 2loorb2 sisvhq 'd bsolqms 919W b9rrIsrn nsrlw irliisi orlw rismow ssl1oD 9111 lo

emd ssinsm usd1 bseisvsi isdi esiib sml &noifsri srli lo smoa i-u euioiiieoq loorb2 Dilduq

mundoiqqo lsbo2 sldsisbi2rioD o215 sw sisriT .sbiloq rbu2 bsul isvsn to 1uinsD 9i-li ni isiFiss

eOPI si-li siolsd edoj mIloD—9iirlw i-il seoul nsvs nsmow bsiimm lo insml{olqrns si-li riibmsi

.siorb sliiil unsrli 11sf sis usd1 ,I liolioD lo nsmow bsisubs-s9fIoD si-li lo nsm io1

rfiod oh 'Iiess ion bluoD isñi Jud thcbssi ru isis s svsi-l bluoD 'srli o imm bluoD sdT

mw si-li lo esbnsixs si-li i-Hod nsrlw II islIs b9vocnsi lsmI 919W uiir{D65i i-ti 216C1 96fli5M

sd oi eisd ssFrism bsmbsb enilut iluoD smsique sisie 10 sisqe bsislsi Idieeoq si-li bits

.(OI .q OQI rilbloD sse) "teunu bits euoiDriqsD'

4 01 9,6 d bsiimm isvsfi orlw rxsi-iiow 59llOD lo 96in9D19q Si-H cfuoi-li nsv 99lloD Ion 919W orlw seodi ioI o\°t. esw ii OtI bciuom mod ilorfo si-li d o\°f.Qt oi bsesslDsb

leut oi b9esslDsb ii bnuois mod ttoi-loD si-li d o\°E.' ol bsisrrri-nulq ii i-luor1iIA .bsisubs

ikIsiiqun ni bnsi1 s iiwoHo1 919W fI5ftiOW sslfoD .noiisDubs s9lloD on rliiw seoul ioI o\08.

bitoDse si-IT rimow sslloD—non tol siuFl i-ti insmqqs bnsii is rioiisn si-li rnq9swe 26W isi-li

iii 92691Dm lsisns si-li 26W fl5fflOW 99llOD lo 29151 ss sm si-ft bsCssiDrui svisrf 01 n9fH 1O1DSI

i-hod svsrl ol bsIdsrrs 919W nsmow 9slloD noiae9iqsCl is9iD si-li isfIs lirris1 bits ssirrsm

.Issqqs Iiseisvirrn srriiI s tol bsrl isrli ri-non wsrr is d oc oh oi bsDkuris 915W bits dot bits lims1

Page 20: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

suq L9qrI96q (owcG O fl{6U1J!91 2IILAGA O Eq C90lJ J5\3o)9Of1 3O\° O 9fl 6W9j6 1HJGLL9t19f62 MpO p69U 1J G9C6J2 COJJ662 IJ2JJ6q 1pG OflL-X69L bLoL9w169C1J6L2 COfI66 uq LJOLW9J 2CP0012 OLJJA 5Oo\0 M6L6 Iii UOLW9J 2CJJ00J2 jJJG 29JJJ6 99 9J20 IJqC9IG 11J9196LJqGq 296 69C6L2 COJIGG2 D99 J0L Jo\(J JUq1C96 9W0U ll 6W9IG fT1J6LLSfT9G2 !' 2496b6Loq' J0M6AGL' qo uo couA6uI&uJA 26b9L96 pJquJqrlaJ2 iqio 96uqGq UOUJJ9J 2COOJ2 LOW JJO26 MJJO69CGI2 COjJGg62 9pOfiJJ 4JJ6 9GL M6L6 4OflL-X69L !Ulu0U jG Gf94OU 29!C OL luJ6 bL6-JO2Cn1UJ!U9(G Hi 9 q6LGG MOHiGU' O 9 t9L L696L 6XI6JJ fJJ9U UJGIJ' 9I4GUG LJOLW9I 2CjiOO2 9uq 29G

92 MOHiGU jp6 9W6 M92 uo }J6 C926 OL UOWJ9 2C}JOOJ' 9 69CpGL-P9IJ!U bLoL9w fJJ9 q!q UOnuqsLL9qn9l6 6ULOJJW6U pA 26X' lrIuloL (oi. o-A&i) COJ1G62 JJ9A6 PGGU 96UqGq pX WGU O JJG 291116J9U OL W61J 0J M6LG u6uq6q OL j622 p91J 9 tOflL-A691. b6Loq r2 9 bcus O

GU9UCG 9 pop lfJIJ!O1. COJJ6G2 9LJq UOUJJ9j 2COOJ2 corijq !U1J916 f6 9I2PC2 OL MOLJJGIJ WOLG

L6261.A6q OL LJJ6U oiijX2IICJJ H9LA9Lq' cpu€q P6!L Lf1J62 qnuii M0L M9L ' 9JJOMU MOUJ6U fO 9J(6 CJ92262 bL6A!OfT2fAMGJ.6 9JJOMG O GIJLOJJ Hi 9L L696L U11UJ6L2 qr1I4u JJ6 2JJOI49G O !JJ9j6 2r1q6uf2 IJX rTIJ!AGL2!62'

i ojq 6 uoq LJq M9L j 9J20 9T6C6 M0LJJGIJ%2 bLG2GucG iii JJ6 9c9qGwA P6C9fl26 fJGA

COfl6G MOUJGU MGLG U0J J6 0r1J O JJI2 p6uq 6ifJJ6 yW0u JJG COJJ66 MOIJJ6U MJJO qiq ujgu.X'

jsuijjA' uo )n urnu.ii' ooy comipA pA ouu iii jj& bo2f-o14q ML J 6L' 9Uq

btoboLpoii2 O IJJJG2 iuq GJJJJG2 Ui C0fl66 qru.ni bcnJL X69L

q' M6I692 j1J026 iJ JflI62 J 9Uq 5 ¶JLG 0L 4JJC0p0142' cpGX WOLG 9CCr1L6JX L6U6C LIJ6

6WJ6 tU6J SJ1962 pA j o j BGCSi26 qJ6 792C2 Ui 9L6 pOW cOulGwbOLguGOn2

EA6U j16L JJ6 bGgJ( Ui bo7-MgI. &JJLOJ]11J6142' aA mi jØ'ujgj& f1Uq6I&9qrUJ62 OtIJiJfIWpGI.6q

flU6LL&fl962 (766 irn6 w' pA jj JJJGLG MGLG 5 wu oi. GAGLA M0UIU Ui C0JJ6G

UJgJG ruJq6LLYqrI62' s'JJq 0L JJ6 6U A&ia bL6C6qW JJ6L6 pq 66U LJJOL6 MOLJJGU fJJU UJ6U

2f1p79iJYflA 0I1(JJf1W616 MOUJ6IJ J J5 4JJ61$ M61$ 92 JJJ9TJX 6WJG flUq61L9qr1962 92

0 W6TJ flJ10 C0fl66' flf W6 !1JCL6926 0 UJ6IJM92 20 J9bq IJJ pA 11J6 GlJq 0 JJ.J6 J'fO2 UJ6U

LfUifOU uq L46a qouipj&q (766 bb6LJqp( !9P16 w) M01J16U OJJOM6 JJ6 J69

JJ61TL UJJGL2 lu bLoboLçiou O qj6 Gwgf6 bobnjgoij Dr1LThJ W6 5O-A69L &xbua& o JJJ2 cOpOJ4'

yuq COjJ66 MOWGU M6LG LJOf IfI2L IUcL62IJJ 4JJ611 wgwg6 Lg62' p&A MGL6 9J20 ThJCL692U

sqricpou gJJumGu' MGL6 wgLLXw gf JIp6a LS67 IJ fJJG 4M6IJ16IJ cGugrLA (766 LüLG

11X copoi hr COfl66 MOUJGU psq 1oTJ6q g p9uqM9o1r J yWGLCYIJ7' q6b6uq6u o

C0PO4 III: JgIJA fJJ6U lop

Page 21: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

60L6 01. Hi X6SL 0j 2CIJOOI coUJbj6fJoLJ 92: 69L2 0 2CpoOJ 96Uq6q + )5 96 9f UL2f UJ9LL!9666 ojqu (J)' fSpJ6 5' JJJ6 UflL6 2 COWbtIf6q L0W JØ fly p? quu W9L14S6

(= \o 1J6A6L UJ9LL6q) + [J'o\o X JfJ\° (= \o MIfJJ hO CJJqL6U 9W0hi fJi026 6A6L-w9L146q' pA 96 -ff)]'O'I W5o\° 0 fJ6 COjJOLI 0LU qflL1u U6A6L UJ9LU6 pA 96 JJJ6 T'2\° flL6 !2: W30\

jJJ6ff16L ff16 U$Cf b6cnu191.X 1.6f1LU fO C0Jj66 M92 L69f6L fJJ9IJ 201116 9bb1.0b149f6

jJIJ9TJq9J 9W jL0W qow 20 —M92IJJ9q6 9L W0L6 Jfl(GJX ff1L0tJJJ fJJ6 LOfif6 0 C0fl66 9ff6uq9uc6'

01. MJfpTu Xn o COJJ66 yii.?uu 9 C0fl66 uiu -- uq ff161.6 M92 9

yW0IJ ff16 6UJ9j6 C0JJ66 1.9fl9f62 !U COf1OLI JJ N4JO 6A6IJffT9fjX 1u9u46q' 25o\0 qiq 20 p6O1.6

fJJ9I 9f J69/41J 2CJJOOJ f1JCL69262' ff16 bLop9ppIX 0 UJ66f11J 0U62 2b0fl26 ill 2CJJOOJ UC1.G9262'

JJ112p9uq2 1.69fJA onf2p4bbGq ff16 6W9IJ W 6U6L9J' 92 ff16 96 9f UJ2I IJJ9JJ.J96 q6CplJ62 uq

11 C0JJ66 6C9W6 q6 9Cf0' 91J 9Cf1AG W9L1496 W9LJ6f 1J MJJICJJ ff16 2IIbbJA o

MOUJ6U 90f1f fMO fO 01J6' 92 C9U 6 266U IJ hJflL6 M!IP ff16 6CJTIJ6 UJ ff16 W9L1J96 S6 01.

JJJO2f M&JJ2 0 ff6' JJJ6 C0jJ66 6IJLOflUJ6UI 0 W6IJ 2091.6 11.1 ff16 JØ2 MJJ6IJ fJJGA0f14JJtiW6L6

VL161. M0LJCJ M9L JJ C0JJ66 P6CYIJJ6 IJJOL6 9CC622!PJ6 fO 9uq q62p.6q pA VUJ6L!C9U2 1.0UJ

6U1.0jJW6Uf2 conjq IJOf 6 ff16 2016 UAE1J 01.C6 !1.J ff16 C}19U?JI1 q6uJ0L9bpX o COjJ66 M0uJ6u'

!UCL6926 Ju ff16 b1.oboLpou 0 MOUJ6U MJJO J9tI9fG f1.0W C0jJ66 6j-26J6Cf!0IP MfjJ UCL692!JJ

92 UO16 90A6 ff16 UJ9U496 9uq 6LfflfX WC169262 M6L6 drI9upf9f!A6IX J96L fJJ9IJ ff16

JU W9U496 uq 61.fmfX £9f62 bL6C6q6q ff16 UCL6926 lu C0J66 9ff6U9UC6 suq Wfl9fJ0U L9f62'

6UJbJJ92JS6 ff19f ff16 UJJU 0 fJJ626 CJJ9IJ62 J2 fLJJbOLf9Uf fO ff16 9L11TM6LJf 9uq ff19f ff16 C}J91J6

IJJUAJTJ 9f 9 L69f6L L9f6' 9TJq fJJ6X M61.6 69141J 9L UJO1.6 CJJqLGU MJJ6U m9LL6q Rt1f I

A9L10t12 M9A2 C0H66 M92 COU2Jq61.9pJX 11101.6 ob6u fO ff16 UJ92262' C0JJ66 MOUJ6U M6L6

0L ff16 b1.6A!0112 C0f10Lf C0ll66 MOUJ6U p9q 6C0UJ6 b9Lf 0 ff16 UJ614C9U UJ9UJ2fL69IJJ !U

26C0U COjJO1.f' J,'0\° M6L6 6ffJJ6L UOf w9LL)q1J' UOf JJ9JUIJ cf1JqL6u' OLpOff1' C0Wb9L6q MJfJJ 2O\°

C0JJ0J.f' qiq JJOf p9116 9 papA pA 962 fO f JIJ ff16 C0f1014 po1.u JL0W J5Q fO J3' 1JJI'12 0L ff1G

9 91. 211591161. b6LC6Uf96 M61.6 IJOf f19AUJ cpJqL6u p0f1f JOo\0 01. 9 JJIq ff16 j6116j 0L ff16 1JL2f

Page 22: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

mlinilmq lo noiisup 9111 slsm to i1 2uolmV .2ilorlo 116 toI insvsl9I ei sisi 9viismgiIs

bsbkvolq "dub (rhrwoD" 9(11 29226b 991loD bsisrtimob 291i19 (19(1W .111 horlo iol 9)nshoqrni

iol sDsIq 'lno sill 991l0D 01 1(19W "901. Thrnb10" nsrlw iu8 .isAmm sshmm bsns1stq si-li

.dub tlnuoD si-Il lo sDslq sill AooI euqrns si-Il bits 991lo) Is sw i-mci lssm 01 "snsl Xmnk&io"

sill 10 lIorle Ilsi 1dsdoiq sIub slsmsl imthsm si-li 101 Errlulsl 'cmintnsq 1)91kb srff

bluo JsAmrn 9Eth1sm 9r11 rliioi(1J arrtuisi imkmn9q 1D911bf11 9(11 ii.i8 .muisi lo sist 9vi1sm9l1

sill 101 euisqcm lsiiurit si-li n9sd svsrl ism bris llsI-horle si-li to1 qu 9bsm nsrli siom svsrl

.11911(0W lo 9)ftfibflSiis 991l0D 9(11 cii 92691)11k irlsups2du2

lo isdmun £ Isbi-ILI rloilsubs s9llo) 2'tI5OW 01 2(r115191 si-Ft shiqmo i1kss fIB) sriO

19(1 i-ti bsinsm 2Ot-bim 9(11 iii slsubsi 9sllo 91511191 flsib9frl srlT .2noifqrr1ue6 sldsnoass-t

9)101 lodsl si-Ft bsiixs rI9rFl bris 2Th9X 4 iol bs*tow si-Ia bshmm si-k Ii bris no!isubsI lo ms 100(1)2 rli(1 A .E ss luods Is s101s19± syto1 iodsl sill bsIstnssI srI ,2Issx 8 luods iol

iol tuo bsnismsl iud 2169\ I 19116 9)101 tods1 si-Il moil bslkxs oels bsrnuaas sd 111w ii s1subsi

s9lloD s lo 2f1S9 9(11 Ia oilsi SIlT .916Ub61 991l0) siLl 116(11 2Th9'( siom 10 2169 Of

s9II0) sdi nsrfw &f luods asw sJsubsx Ioorba rlirl lo seorli ol 115(110W s1subsi

Iscirmon ni 8ji-çJj lo ñiod ioI sI-I-him d .f fuods ol bs2ssini bits isAmm iodsl 9(11 bsisins

8 nirlliw 10 solsd bsirism o\01 Q1 lo eesb 9111 lo esfsubst 916m91 OO iuods 10 slqrnsc nI 19116 e169 fl9V92 to 1Qt d bsirrsm 9'19W oriw scorh 10 .(QQ1 riibloD sse) noi1ubs lo erlfnom

risibsm sri Qf iii .noi1subs 19iIs eiss 'iuol iol ro 1Q1 lilriu bskiow nsrnow cisibsm 9111 rroiIEub6 iuorliiw scoill nornA (srto r1iiD9qxs 1dsdrnq esw -to) frishrii os bris blo iss-E 9(10 bsd s1subs b9Dubsl blo eiss-E isbriu bif i-b s lo rioiiibbs sriT .9)101 iodsl sift iii 9i9W o\0O8 smdl 9-tom fl91blifb

ebb iss- r{ikw (191110W w91 001 919W 9lsrIT •0\°C 01 ii bsDubs1 blo i69- 01 C £ bits \0 01 noiIsqiDirlsq isrli 91911 smuea I .ls.*ism todsb 9(11 191(1991 ol rissd 91qmse eirlt iii rismow osi-Iw sv'tsedo of 19V0 bits luo bsriims-i bris etss' (5116 bsfixs 'sili eurlT sbst ieiil rtssd n9IbIicID usd1 risrlw bsuslcissi leorn uol fsd1 ci sense XM .blo e1s9(- of sd of owl si-If 1o fe9rnJo sill tol r1uons rio1 to euss' 8 101

i-is ni lhiest suo1stsr1f Jliw bos luo inisqe smif risibsm 9(11 lo 916rni129lsbrw its ci cliff \COOCS91 euoFisv .rruufsi lo 9151 si-If lo lnsm9isfeIsvo

('isIIob ',Q1) OO8C fuod esw QI lo cesiD 9111 i-il €lsubsi ss11oD 101 smorn riiIisie 1611006 silT 111 9259IDflI lsucins ris niirnuees 1191110W 9f5tJb61 9sIboD iol 2MUCI OQf si-Il rnoII 9-nJi1 si-Il of scolD

C.f esw 9ffl0D01 Isunris e'sfsubst IooriDC r1id s of sslboD s lo 01161 sill' \0 ftjocfs 1o emtsl Isriirnon ebb tSS' Q of 1$ tol 1.1 hd ebb ms Q of & oI 8M1JC1 OQ1 9rIf nil

Page 23: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

p6iu2 91.1 3 P!11. L!262 10 J f f)) wq-J69 Q0 M92 0L POW JJ 2CjJOOj 91Jq C0Ij66 L9fl91.6 MOIJJ6U L!76 MIfJJ !op LXb6L!61JC6 20 1.}J91 1.JJ6 L91OQO' J 21.16" 1J2169q' L9J9f62 JL0W C0J16g6' 2}16 MOLJC2 LOW 5 10 5' 6XJ2 91 ' L661J16L2 91 f' 9IJq L61.1L62fJJ6 JYOL 0LC6 (bL62nw&pJX 10 L9126 9 iijijA) 9f 96 ' L66IJf6L 1JJ6 J90L OLC6 91. 96 uq LGIJL6 91 966flC916 MOW9U MOIJJSIJ I? 92211UJ6 10 L9f19fG L0W JJJ}J 2CJJ00J 9f 96 J' M0L( flUIIJ 2jJ6 6X!f 2 0W

c = q!1C02f 2 O cojJ66' ) = IJCOIJJ6 0 9 C01J66 qncaçq MOW9U' J,, = IIJCOIJJ6 0 9 pp-2cpO01C\(i÷L) + = E A11'\(J+L)

1P6 CSJCfTJ9POU 201A62 0L 1. 11.1 1.1.16 219U9L 6df19f10U:

OWC6 0 qnc91.ou9L6 01. 1.n1!0u" L11' 91Jq (-qX) poq (na D6b9L1w6u1 0 H6911P' qI1C91OU' 91Jq M6R96'

MOJJJGU W9UJ6 9 C066 L9qr19f6 (266 ojq J' 191)16 3)

C0H66' 1)flf qiq UO1. L9qr1916 p.om 9 0tU-X69L 2CJJOOj' q!q oij1X J00\° 0 11.16 JjJ 2C00J L9qr19f6

X69L2 uq u59u46q) uI9LL6q 9 C0jJ66 L9fl9f6 uq IJJOL6 fJJ9IJ ou6-lpuq 0 fO26 MJJO 91.16U6

pX 61 L9qr19fl1J p.0W C0JJ66' J1JJ02f fM0-fJJLq2 0 9fJ coJJ66-9qrIsf6 MOW6U (ao iq

p.16 &OP9PMIX 9 MOUJ9IJ o0 3 X69L2 oq Monjq W9U 9 C0H66 L9ti9f6 M92 A92f 1X UJCL6926

L620tBC62 1.PL0fljJ 16 W9TJ 2JJ6 W9UJ6q' MJJ9f I M!II f6iJJJ 11.16 JUp.GC1. £611W 10 C0fl66' J JQØ

P111 f6 2UJJbJ6 C9[Cflj91)0U 062 UOf C0U2q6L p.19f COJJ66 96Cf6 9 M01JJ9IJ2 t1ff1L6

P9R 11.191. 0L WGU 6C9f126 °L 1)14661 6WbJOXIJJ6Uç

f}J026 0 9 pp 2CJJOOj L9fl9f 6 -- M92 COWb9L9pj6' 11.16 !U161.I.191 £91.6 O L6fIUU 0L MOW6U M92

1.0 C0fl66 0L LJJ6U 9uq MOIJJ6U -- A6U pX 11.16 £91.10 0 M962 69LIJ6 pX 9 C0fl66 L9f191.6 fO

6XC66qGq JOo\o" 01 JJJOL6 fJJ9TJ qOflpj6 fJJ9f 01. MOIJJGU (LL66w9u A6U 1.JJ011JJ 1.1.16 L6fJ1UJ

1Ut62fUJ6Uf M92 61.M66U cf 9Uq Q0\°0 flJ6 fI.Jf6U19j £91.6 0j L6f511.JJ f0 C0jj66 0L UJ6U 911.1.191. fITJJ6

0 6Xif fluq6x. 1JJ626 92arWJbfIOUa' fJJ6 4IJf6JJJ9j £91.6 0 £6fI1LU fO fJJ6 0flL X69L2 0 C0jj66

£66U16L 1jJ6 MOLJ( 0LC6 (IIJ1.fl 96 co"uq fJJ6I1 £66IJfLA 69UJ2 96 19Y6U fO 6 11.1026 91 }JG P1.1.16

POW fjJ6 pjJJ 2CJJOOj 9uq C0jj66 9fI9f6 MOWGIJ 9L6 922flW6 fO MOLJ( COUpIJ11OI121X 9f6L fp6X

11.16 0flL X691.2 0 C0fl66 M92 oi. brip1jc nu!A6L2!f162 9uq J5 0L bqASfG fiU!A6L2!f!62

M61692 p.16 p1p 2CJJOOJ L9qr19f6 0 6S1.U6q sLonuq 3jJ6 p.6Cf 6Xb6U26 0L 69CJJ 0

&WO11IJ1.2 fJJ6 C0JJ66 M0LJ.191J' 91. 1.JJG JJJOIJJ6IJf 0 6L L9fl9OU JIJ JØ' 69LU6 orwq fØJfJ

Page 24: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

£ riiirtsm 10 iiilidsdoiq isrliH i-burn s smI risrnow b9isDubs-ss1JoD bib ilno ioI4

tsifrruq .1svl IsnoiifDnb9 rbss riiriliw 2smODcri 19r1tr1 rliiw rxsm bshmm o215 9r1i jmm 99ll0D

rthub bshmm 011w s2orli ,n9m 99ll0D bsinsm bits ssI1oD bsbrtsfls orlw fl9fflOW srli noms

hs9 srlT .enirrtss 1sr1ir1 cliiw ebrrsckud bsddsri noiisubs WthwoIIoI 'Isisib9mmi -to 9911oD

:11311w9m02 s bsr! Ilii 1191110W 99H0D isvswor1 sbia 9Viifi9f1 si-li nO i-rrtow 19xd si-li lo e&nid

91-11 ioI nscli -t9rIirl X1ds19bi2noD sw ii rluorli1s b9iTtsm riiiis 19v9 lo lffidsdoiq iswol

'2h0d0D euoivsIq

oI tnsbrmie A MUCI 0f 9111 292u bits slqmie 911up 21 nollstuqrrloD bstibrtk si-IT

2'911W i-t I119DIIOD 291dl3tThV bsbbssm i-bk-lw ol 2bnsd2url si-li to1 bsisrriilas El nOiisup9 Efllffi59

91d61 ,QQf riibloD 992) rloilsDubs 1911 oi noitsisi iii 9shmrfI tisrll lo riirnij 9i-li bits nodsDub9

riivi 0t srli ni nsmow slsubs loo(1D2 c1id s nb1sl 29v10vr11 irlsrnnsqx9 1rluodl 9ff .(l

25W 9112 nsrlw 0I i-ti smoDni 2'bnsdeurl tsd rnv19edo rt9rll bits 9SllOD lo ems iuol isd

1om1s d smoni 2'bnsd2ucl 19(1 921591)111 01 21 lDlsqfnLi Islol 9ff .2Th9 QE bits OC nssw-Jsd

£ XlThffl 111w sffe lffidsdo'iq si-li frn9lls moil 29ffl0D (\0.) lnsnoqmo iEsisl 91ff o\00

bsbnslis orfw i-mi-n s nsm ffiw 9112 IsdI boorlilsAil 9rff elsvsl IsrIoilsubs mIuDkimq Is i-mm

219v91 ir1io ils is 'rtsm ffiw 9112 Isr{l boodlilslil sf11 2591911w e9ES91Dfti 9sllOD motI blsubsi to

\O 'd 91110)11k 'EbrIEdELIcl 292691Dm fl9f1i 9f15f{D 21-IT .292159tD9b

nsrriow 9l6rJbs1 99IloD si-IT JDSIIS isr{loris i-ti 2111,291 noilsDubs isd it 2S91D iu8

lo o\02. ioI elnuo:xm -tolDs1 eu-IT .noiisDtJbs eli-I nsvi cmm rIimss-9rnoDni -t9rlir1 9111 bshmm

bnsfl6 ion bib lud Ioorbe rIgid bsisubs-i orlw sor11 lo o\° 0QI ni blo eIss ol 0€ nsrnow 'ioT ion bsrl o\°f. 2169{ 'iuol sislqmoD Ion bib lud 9s11oD bsbristls orlw seoth 10 .binsrn tsvsn bsrf 991loD

duor1II6 \0Qt cii quor bsinsm--rsvsa-r sill rn hue 919W o\0f.I 99h1o b9l5ubsi offw 98011110 .bsFnBrrl .b9frnsm 19V911 bsrt qiJo eir{i 10 o\8 '(mo eO8QI sdi id

.lrTsDtsq O1 luods o &f = (EE.0)qxs brie €E.0 ci mot1 91-110)111 (lo o1 srli) cxi srisrb Isioi si-IT

eunim 9911oD) noifsub9 2'911W no effI9iDiII9OD srIi (Ii sDfI91911!b 9(11 of IsDifrl9b! feom! ei 9iui1 1E€.0 srIT tscffo '(cifi nibuIDni Ion 9tflOD1Ii e'brtedeurl 119th flO flOi229t9'I s ni (4C.0 = 916ub6Th 10011)2 dic1

.e9iSiISVOD

Page 25: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

rIgid 9I11 lo i6tft TSV0 lThfflOW 9b6 99lloD 9r11 iol SfflODfli 'bn6dud fli ciis o\° s io I6io 9Hi

ocfw nm b9hmm n9mow sisubsi 99ll0D 116 lo o\0O8 iOm1fi 9eusD9a .91SLJb6 1oorb

9sirrsm 9lloD rft moil eni sd lo tuiq efi lo r1uorIJ sd ns bslIs sd ssI1oD smo bsbn9iis

o sld6 isiisd stsw noiisDubs 9TOdfl IHIW fISifiOW 161ft ai nO!isi9lqlstrn s1dieoq isrftociA Js*tsm

iDsIls bürll s I1srriT .smoDni risc1i bsnscfns Xlbslib dsisr1i brui bnsdur1 ikscft iei2

2'SflO e9ssTDrn oeIE noii6ubfii noqu o s9lloD fri mc{iis 1ms rtirmm isrli 1m1 sift 5vI0vfL1

iii nig \0 s iuods io !sioi sift lo o\°f ninismsi sift ebbfi bslI9 "friki Im9" sifT .2mcrtE9

rnVI lo ifisffIfl9qXs'-irIuOfft 91ft 5iO1919di llfi19VO .fIEfflOW 9iELJbfi 59llOD sr ft iol smoni

r1uoirft 9fflODffl isri bssnni O?1 sift cii noii6Drjbs 9slloD 6 fIEITIOW 9if3LJbfii Ioorb2 r1M

o\0Ot d 19*t6ffl 9S1Tt6ffi sd

moil nis iDstib sd esob 5i10 86 nis tsiibru sd riIifisri lo Dio1 sift niwoL1oI

isrl o emuIsi Isioi rft 9Diovib on esob bris eshmm nsrnow sift riimuees bim noftsubs

Isoi srJT .slduob 2noiiqmu2as sldsnoassi isbcrn bim b9insrnufi '1fssi won sm noiisubs

ssa) quo'i blo iss Q oi O 91ff 'ml 9DnstiOqITXi lo ton at "99I10D fit bSiTIsffI" ioIsl 9th 921J6D98 .ni11sqrno 910th 21(1992 aie9r{iocpr1 19A'ISITI 96iTISTfl 9rIf QQI riibloD

.saocpuq frI9lsllxb s diiw fud eMU9 OQt sib riieu noifsups ishrrne s a9fsmdas (Qt) rnsrlns8 nui6DkbrIi as noxfsups anurris9 slsm srlf ru rloif6Dubs &ruemow ito irl9tDill9oD sviHeoq 9th ais'iqlsffii sH e'brtsdeurl risrlf rio fDsqmi isth bus smorf 9th iii rl9mow b9fDJJb9 9mm lo iiviiubrnq sfsi sub

siLl esbuIDrn msdrI9U asasrftoqr1 'fivifDubo1q bits :t9Amm 9siTtSm srlf nsswisd rfaiunifaib oT .anirnss lo 219v91 sviiDsqa9'l 'Ii9rIf diiw 'isr1fsoi noiisup anirtm9 &bnsdeurl 9iff ni 9SiT1sffl is 9S a'sliw

riivsd lo iifidsdo'iq 'isrfirf s svsrf rioifsDubs lo fvI iisrff n9vi rsis1 imm orlw rusrrioW .noHsDube 9d bluorla ariirnss e'bnsdaurl eia9thoqrt \fivifD9t9e 9th 'isbitU .ssrrism '19fl6 noifsDlJbs -xisth b91-Iainhl

eiasrftoqrf ifivifDubo'iq si-li 'isbitu bsiD9lls sd irIim ii 86919(1W noifSDLJbs 9srrIsm-ieoq d b9fDsulsnu sill nitioqqua ion as 11 ais'iq'isfni bits ssfrism is ss 9rhf no insbillsoD 9vifssn s abriil msdnsa

svsrl of {I9)hl aesl 919W fIOii5DLJb9 lo lvsI '119th fl9Vi 'ieisl 'rism orlw nsmow iua .8ie9di0q(rl 1ffVIiD9192 ru)lDiq 81 sldlsrl6v &msrinsH ai isrIT .Ioorba rIirl 'io 99IIoD i-il 19*Ism sshmm 9(11 lo ssfnsvbs nsAsi

.bs1l "b'iid t'iss' sib lo tisq qu 91ff nirrt9DruOD fsth rrtoil eiasrhfoqrI iivibubo'iq 9(11 ntfs'isqse lo 'c(sw xm 'Ffnthoqmi sioM

.aquo'1 Isnoiisjubs nirhf 1w 'hrio IDSIIS sAsl flED aiesiboqrI fivx1iuboiq sill 16(11 slon of ei feAism ssirrsm -9slloD sub nr''nsrn mo'il esw 9sh1oD of nio mo'iI smoni a'nsrnow s no IDS1IS 9lt1i2 fa9'isl si-IT irIuoe sd bsslani ,laum lud ixvilJIJbo'iq aid nbrisr1ns r9r1 of sub sd lonnsD I D9119 tsrlT .nsrn bsisDub9

.tsborn fs*ism ssh'tsm s i-il

arxisms'i 9112 noJ won enoiiqmuees eiiohsv no 2brIsqsb 9fnODn! auth alss'il 9(10 woH .smoni a'brisdaud 'isil of noitloqo'iq nil norniIs 29v!9D9'i si-la suovib 9112 blriorfe 'i9r1i9dw bns bsirism

Page 26: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

isob won i o\° of lo snisi si-If i-ti riisd 1161-li TSrlfsl i1o1foD brioDs 91ff ro1 99ll0D of m1119T

moi1 b9a91Dni i O1 si-If cii noif13Dubs 99110D e'nmow of m11191 11th si-Il euciT \°11 io 01 of

91ff ill 1W 91111 1-11 910ffl 21 isrIi 9110 of 2192213 of mu191 11391 91-11 (161ff 2291 i6rlW9moe ei irir1f suI6v £

£ bnse of thffiw n99d svfirl bluork sio1sisr1i 29i1rm&:1 .nscn lol nOiffiDubs 99IIOD of 2m1E191

.sDnsnsqx9 si-li d bsDrisrins riisd as aiDsqaoIq s6nmm lsrI bswsiv 1(911i Ii 99IIOD of 19if1usb

noiisDubs a'rsirlrmb -tisdi lol csq of bsaths'i estltriml 'rtsm Ii iiaiiq-tue 9d ion bluow ii audT

".ioob fxsrr od" sdi ximm 1qrriie bluow 91k ur1uor1i icIf Ii

sriT .ai9rfrmsl sd of bsmqsiq 1 ilorfoD ru faom 9)11! JII iTorloD i-ui seorD 10 fhojsm si-IT

tud quo euoivsiq sill 1o iscli moil 1fc1i1a b9a6stDsb 0Q1 i-ui usi-bssi 519W orlw 9BfnsD1sq

asvil li9fIi ni 9rnui 9ffl02 113 ir1usi oilw 96insD19q sill briA .1n99Isq 0 bnis 0 n9swisd Ilifa esw

III florIo cii 1191110W bsrrffim 10 291131 insm'o1qms 91-IT .19f13s1 1d6isbi2noD ns9d 91J131f feum

o\0.) fIUO1 919W \9fH nsrfw ilOffOD auOIVslq 9i1i 10 seorli 919W nsrli mr1id i-bum fort 919W

sslloD bnsii6 foci bib oriw 1191-flOW 10 9201ff bs9Dxs XIifi91 ion bib eurli bc1fi (\°E 2U219V

bib orlw risrnow 10 saodf bsb9sDxs 29161 fn9rnolqcn9 1191-If 1u8 t(0\o EIJC1SV o\.Q)

bsi-I brufi b9nmm orlw 1191110W s9lloD ai f6rIT .isbio 919W equoi ilfocl n9ilw 99lIoD bnsfl6 ion

usrlf nr1w bris 1irns1 l\ -- \\una insrrr\o1qm9 bnis 'lims1 fliV6uI WOlf 9t9W fl9lbIlfID

.in9rrno1qm9 21913fl99f 919W flslblufb

lo seodi imrlf asifil Xiilitt9I briE ssnmm 19rIi(I 11siinsiadue bEd III florIoD q6D91 oT

9101-if i-bum ion fud 19b10 nsrlw 9101-fl XldsIsbiarioD 9)101 iodsl srff 111 919W j ilofloD

d bsiiI9nsd III ttodo lo ri9ffiOW si-IT .9919b 91-1162 Si-Il 1201(116 of 219dD69i 919W briE ,isrtuo lo vii1otEm 121W 91ff e0Qf si-If 910198 .fnsrno1qms usd1 of 2T9iTlEd (Ii 92691)9b lsiirisiedua sill

I £111 e9biloq bsisie -- "elfid 961Tt6ffl" bsrl 219)110W 9DiIIo lo 219olqms imm bns afiuiaib foorbe

seorli iol i ui o\°.Q srli ssisdw CQ1 of 8Qt briuom riifsubs 9eorIf tol ci iui1 \°& sill' Qf of 81 bnuot nifsubst

Page 27: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

99) siimm noqu bsiiI 9d bluow fl9ffl0W s1rn isrli bim bsiirl 9d on bhiow n9IIIOW b9iimm

&rnon 9v!sv1sq bim n1D1O1rn9r 919W md ssmm di oi b9bbA .(fQt OQt n.ibloO

rfJ isrfi i 9Dctfthoqrnl Ifinoilibbfi 10 .'(fiq iol *IOW oi fI9fflOW bhmm lo JiIids si-li bhisi us '(Hsni1 .eOI bns O[Qf r1i i-u llsiJnsiduE bss91Dni 99I1oD nhsins nsm 10 isdmuri

si-li bsbslls asnsrb sesrli hi-is rI91bhrb siom nivsrl him i911m9 ni'nsm 919W nsDrt9mA

bsii isriol 0(1 (l9fflOW sslloD rflD1O11119i 919W e9f1sJt) 991-u si-IT .119W is bsisDub9 ssllOD

9Dslq s iei4 isriol on sw 991loD bns s1il ü 29v116m9116 s in9m0lqrn9 bris 96flThffl issil 01

.suoqa e'sno issm ol 9Dslq s oicik bsrmoiErisli obs1 9b sw ti ioI mssl ol

9V1229DD112 bim 29fl0iDW 1151112 all i-li iw 11191(10) 2291 91T16)9d ii bss fI0t1619fi9 21111 s iuH

Issi ioI xiisriii him 'cii1sups 9iOffl ioI riisqms s bsrbriusl nsmow 99llOD lo 2noiisisrI9

1191(1w ni (EQ1) supiivM sninii-nsT si-IT d bs2uom 1190W 9111 bsbubni III horloD .ii1sups

9111 (11 9911O) b9isubs1 oclw iioiifiisn9 (IWO 19(1 lo 25)fl9(t9X9 9111 b9driesb imbsiiT x" iii ebnshl slsrrr usd1 es sids s sisw ir1j W9IL)I orlw quoi eidi moil nuiq m2irnmsq .2OIQ1

.nisrfi 101 bs91 ion esw isril s9lloD sbiefuo bFrow s bsIsfruJoDns odw hid 9SIIOD

ylim&l (19(11 19515D :VI horloD . 191(19 i 12111 9(11 esw -- ol 1$QI mod bns QWI ol Ô1 moil riflsubsi -- VI hodoD

(19111 199Th)' bsiiE9b riivsd 2S ii 9n9iDs1s1t) I .rneirIifn9I rrt9bOrn lo 619 9(11 iii 9)101 iodsl si-li

i-il iuH .199Th) bsu2luq 2511 ii 91111w nsiblirb bns 9Ei115ffi bsXsl9b 26(1 ii s2usDsd "xlimsI

22999u2 211 isrli Worle ocis ffiw I .eesneeslblirb lo 9161 did s hsnsh9qxs esrl ii 9Dn9ups2rIOD

25 bssihoq n9110 21 ii eesiq mluqoq si-li nI .m11912 f199d ion esd 5(1915 insm'(olqrns 9111 i-u 9151

.smorf is qisri Iscuoqe 911111 1111w nbc! riiluj lirnsI (111w 199Th) 9thdmo ol rnii 9101(1 10 iuol tliiw 920(11 fl0IT15 I&1I 2159V91 29fl92 O- 2hoq95J noiisltiqo9 tn91lUD si-IT

Page 28: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

seorli norns briA .OQQt Xci rlhkd i2liI s bsrl i9 ion svsrl ilorloD airli lo \°t 99I1oD lo 2159k

9ffl91iX9 2S ion n!ijorll1s 29flJil 929dT .iori 9V6fl o\0.& 99ll0 10 2Th9X 11101 usd1 910ffi rliiw

nsrnow lo riothoqoTq 9dB bus 9)f112 110(10) f16 101 iisr{:t 19ffi(I 9Th J 110(10) lol 920(11 as

tol boos Aool ion ob 291u1l 929(IT O11 in asw 11 isrlw smii 01 i2ornls el s9l1o iistbsi

noittoqolq tsr11rl ml s ei1odo euoivsiq (111w noelmqmo) ui 1u8 .siuo-t "199Th) bits ilims1" 9(11

bsnl i91 ion 9Vsnl nrn i-I uonl I n9V3 .noiisubs ssIIoD 9)fIE bsoIqrns rissd esrl VI ilorloD lo

".lls Ii nivsd" 9d bluoi 110(10) 9r11 lo nothoqolq [iinidu £ r1hid ieti1 s

19916) ni rnsiis is quo sill lo 229)Du2 9(11 sus oi bsbssri sm sisb lsnibu1iuioJ

26W ii 1Q1 i-n w91v-x9idn 1261 is bus les-isim lo ilorloD si-li lsebsiq ci nsmoW nuoY ..J.V silT

hid cinsqbiiisq OO0 iuods thiw 8Qt i-n nssd XSVIIJ2 srlT bIo emsi bits ' risswi9d

nsswisd 26W quo sth nscl 88Q1 iii 001 luods 01 awob b9liiirlw n9sd asw noithiis 1-luo1rli

00 asw ssisb A.H s bsmss oi-lw itSifiOW iun1w lo 881 itt sIqrfIfie srIT .blo CISSX 14 bins 1E

)1rIqs1om9b 211 fllJ0fI9 '1nisms isY .ssllo) lo 2Th9X 9101T1 10 11101 rliiw 920(11 101 bris

.qLroi tf16V9191 9(11 (11 920(11 01 m1irm XT9V 9Th 291111691

01 E 9s d erihid on riivsr1 uI9fflOW 99ll0) lo 9sin9)1sq 9(11 nivi butts i 881 itt ilo(1o ..JJ4 sill iol einoq sisb bits hoslo .2.J.V 9(11101 69Th bsisnsmsb finisinOD

2-i59X 14 01 E brie 9911O) lo 269X 910(1110 11101(11kw (19(110W bshmm-lsvs 2J.t'I siir1w nornA

.0\°Q81 21 .2.tIJ iimvslsi 9111 iii 91tJI1 9111 (4 9mi) rlhid 12111 6 bsrl i9 ion bsrl o\°Q1 88Q1 i-n blo

ci 2.dI.D 9111 ni isili 26919(1W ( 91u13) 0\°t.Q 21 9uii1 .J.t4 sill cqu lsiimm ils ioI

e169 14 oi & bus 2Th9X 4 01 296 d bsFImm-lsvsn 96insD1sq ito LilSb si-li iol xlmhrme

9f16rl) 29flo9lSD lSflOifSDIJb9 sill rluor1i1s QQI iii 0\°Q ci 9s9b .A8 S rlliw 920(11 'tol 91LJi1 9f{T i � 9'1U259ffl 9(11 rno'iI riivom i-1i'tid ic-uI s lujorlfrw 920(11 iii sesslDsb s ci 9't9rlT &QQI 01 OQQI mo'ñ .slsb .2.J.T4 sill ru lrislxs srrioc 01 bsisi1qub sd ITh) Isril ssisb .A. s riivSr{ 01 99lloD lo

Page 29: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

.21J2fl93 O8f scII m lscU bcm isisb .2,J,Vi 9111 fl99Wi9d in9m991is 92019 9111 2Wofk

ri&1i 9Vr1D9(dO 2291 XIdsl9bienoD 21 "1Th" is bsv9irbs EBlI lThfflOW 13 19di9rIW thijs) 9Th 2199Th9 921J1399H .1(1611IC1Th sd lfiw 911J269ffl riA .rthid I111 £ bisrl 91k isrfisdw Wnrnrrn9fsb

cm n 11 61113 ets " ssiisf' is rtini1sb d ciid I bmbns12 916(11 £ 1ecii6 b92292213 1{11619fI9

slisI 119111 ni 1191(10W lo ernmss 9111 su I .bsvsirlDs eisrl 119(11 lo quo srnoe usd1 rlltsq ernmss

.9i9IqrnoD iI1sisn9 919W alrl9rnI2svrI WIioorb2 bcis i1hns1 rllod risrlw 29th01 '1ms bns e9lhxrIi

loft 111w "199Th)" £ 9V91db6 01 1191110W ioI .sIiurlsDlsq r1iS sill 16 1mm 9(11 sd 111w bmblmi2 silT

.Th9 9110 XfIS ni 2fII139 XIlUorl sliscrx lo nisibsrn sill rbs9l srll usd1 91111p91 119V9

116 sd 01 99l10D lo 2Th9X 910111 10 11101 rlliw 1191110W .2.J.1/I 9fFt 101 "199163" 6 9flh19b 121111

rnmss huor1 119111 rbrrlw rthub (88Q1 bns '8Qt x62) 2Th9X 10 291192 13 1o1 cllisq 2fU69 lo 2169k 910111 10 iuol rliiw oels (.1.D Irisvslsi 9111 ni) 916(11 9liln9D19q (11& 9d11 lo lisrft 2b99DX9

ibriu 2Th9 9(11 liii lol b91n9291q91 9Th orlw fl91fl0W ol 9lqmfie 2.J.L4 sill 19111291 I .9slloD

.(2rIokEubxs 191110 101 brrs 1 291(1ST ol 291011 oelis 992) noiisl9bienoD

9Th 99I10D lo 2159X 910111 10 11(01 1111w 1191110W iol 2fIfffi69 i1iuod nskbsm bits rrs9M

slqrns2 1911119(1 r1uor11 119V9 boi1sq 88t 01 O8I 9111 101 ..Ji4 bits .e.q.j sill ni ThIifIIiE XIlifiI

910(1 01 flu12919lth 21 Ii 1sd1i1U 9ldsT 992) 19u11ffl sldfilfiqmoD 'ns ni bslr1isw d199d srI

.nokludhleib 9113111 9111 ru 91i1n9319q (11 9111 lo 9flS1 9(11 (11 9Th 1191(10W 101 ensibsrn sill IsrIl

x1o e9bubnI 12111 silT .21911(1131(1 owl ru 9IdisT ni bs1nseiq 9Th "199163" 110 2111J291 91ff

srlJ 111 920111 XlflO 21 Isili b91sbi2no 21139X scll lo rbss iii 2WuirrIs9 XI1IJOfI 9viii2oq i±Iiw 920111

10(161 scIi i-n Ion 919W orlw 1191110W 101 21(1110336 bno392 silT .bsio1qms-1192 Ion bits 93101 iodsl

rfliw 2riothsqmoD rib1sm risrlw 9ierJbfi'r 99IloD lo noilrrulsb sill eis rnlooH3e lo eus9i ôî � S2LJ I

01 219191 etioqs5l noklf31uqo liisyi1jJ sill 10 291192 O-9 9(11 risrlW Ion (19(1W 99Th9b .A.a s lud .aq.D 9rIj (11kw bslqrrisfls i XDnslel2noD .riorisqrno ml .2.J.1'I 9rlf ru 9E l29rIuo' sill qolb I 2bIo 1S9( N ol lE

.J.1'I 9(11 (111w 2noehsqmoD niAsm nI Ise slfib 'rie

920(11 iol .(1 91d6T ssa) 9'uOIsd rmrll 1Q1 in 'hrI9'1911ib eIIIITIS9 'huod bslfiluDIsD J14 '-ç 8C

"199163" lo fl0ilShJD1D sill ni IQQI 921.1 Ion ob I noesi

Page 30: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

rismow (siiulw) HE lo 0\°&t '\199Th)" 6 lo flOiiifuI9b srIi nsviD .2Th9X 9r11 lo 116 10 9110 1(116 111 9)101

-use .*tfilTI srli 9VOdE 9Th 88Q1 brxs 8i rliod ni bso1qrns 99lloD lo 910111 to etss' 4 rliiw

ni bsbubth 9Th lud toisnimonsb bns toistsmun 9(11 i-Dod moil bsbubxs 9Th 1191-flOW bs1(olqrn9

9110 12691 16 b&1 oriw nsrnow iol \0 ei iuiI "lssThD" 9rlT '.199Th)" lo 911J269ffl isrDoris

iol IloluD 91-11152 9111 flifIiEfl6 01 fIOiiifIII9b sill thbh:ts5I ion bib onlw seonli iol \o bnfi blurb

.iuorljiw 920111 tol o\0I bus n9tblirb ilfiw fl9fflOW tol o\0O svi 88t bnf '8t 8t 9111 lo 1-1369 ru bs1(olqm9 519W orlw 1191-110W tol bsiuqmo 9Th fl9V1 I2IJt 296in9Y19q grIT

2Th91( si-li lo 116 to 9110 ni 9)101 todsl 9(11 i-fl loft 919W fI9fflOW 9tH lo sma iu1 .b9t9bi2no ETh91(

1192-non 91-H lo) 9161 noiisqbiimq 9rnol todsl 9111 tol 21214b6 sldsl Ia 8 i9116q .bslsbi2no

lo \° bnus 1191b11(b nifiw nismow si-li 10 \°1 29vk nokliruilsb Th91(-0wi 9111 rtieU .(bs1(oIqcn9

nstblirb bsrl 011w 1191110w si-li lo \°8t 29Vi rxoiiiruilsb ms-ssic1i sri! nii1(o1qrn .Iuorliiw seodl

1911161 19ffl09111 ffl2U d b9rlisido 9Th 29i611th29 mlirni2 1(isV °.9non bsrl orlw soclf lo o\0 bris

26 bs1(olqrns-1192 srli lo noieubni suli asldsns 91U2691-fI 9O3fl1 si-li bits nirrtss 1(lluorl 91-H nsrli

.bsiiimo sm ernmss 1(huorl 92011W 2191110 26 119W

sldsT i-n 11992 sd (115) 1991133 t 1(1111161 bsrnsfls orlw 1191110W 9291-li lo sEin9:Yr9q si-IT

bits 96W 1(huorl si-H i-Hod tol 291u269ffi tss- bus 1s91(- si-li :199163 1o 2nOijinhIsb tuol 101

cimss lo sDioclD sri! 1(d bsb9IIs 1(Hsiinsi2du2 ion 9Th 211012u19fl03 9flT '.s1sb 9ffiODfui lsunris

iss4 sri! ruieU .2i1u29t enIirr!69 hziorl 91-11 01 '(1110 9911919191 9AEITI ifiw I bris sldsrtsv

199163 bsrl o\0I 1911101-IA ".199163 bns 1(1111161" i-Hod bsni6fls quot sill lo o\°€I '(1110 1noiiinil9b

Th91(- 9111 WIi2U .1(limsl bsrl o\08 rnorlw 1o 199163 flifsiis Ion bib \° bris 1(1irns1 on iud

.qJ 9th Iii 291LJ11 2flim69 1(11110(1 9111 moul bsbuIDxs 0216 916 bs1(olqrns-1192 9dT

.8Qf iol sisb lo 931-leeds eth lo seusD9d 2t1591( 11101 ensqe 1(11691 rtoiiinilsb 1S91(-99t11i 91-11 isrll 91ot4 ° '(11110(1 srli 29211 II .9'111269f11 9EW 1(111101-I 9(11 26 9m152 9111 1(1136X9 feomls Cj 9111269111 9ffl031li 91-IT

bebuIDrli n9mOw lo quot erIT tuor1 OOO 1(d bsUqiiIum sIiirr9Yrsq H1 91-If is 916(11 91-1110 96W .be1(olqm9-1192 91-Il eebubni ii eeIJSD9d ttsq ni ebr1sqx9

8

Page 31: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

.Iims1 on iid ec1 o\°t irlions bns "isrs bits Iims1" rliod b9thsfls o\°f noiiini1sb

19915) b9msfls ociw IIEITIOW 191110(15 25W 919(11199Th) bits "Ikms1 b9nisfls orlw nsrnow 119V9 1oI

.anOilithl9b sift lo '(its W1i2u [irns1 oct bsrl iud

iqobs \(srlt usd1 m21 ii ) sill ol i)9du2 sd 'sm bso1qms leut 1991&. lo anoiiiniIsb silT

s Isubivibni srIi '(d bsbuj s 229))UE xo*xq 01 irussm 21 *199Th II .bmbrns1 91(10)111 slsm s

fl9ITIOW l9rIi9rlW 1T19)21b oi ion 21 fnsim sill iu8 .sfshqoiqqs stom sd bluow bmbrusi 1srioisq

rrisrli nV*192cIO 920111 19r1i911w 229226 01 21 ii isrfts5I .*row bisq usd1 iii inscnlnsino) briuol

OI ss usfis 2suruinO) 9111 lsrft 21 ffl2i)i ) IsiifI9ioq usrftonA .eussus bsnisfls '(9cli isril sbu asil VI 110110) *19f119dW 21 91911 9U22t sill crkss swtO .sIiI-birn Irk nisd rmm tol ussus bits

.V bits VI 21todoD irk irisrn Ic Iso bsisi-i1o cts s1il-bkrn '(d "199Th) brrs 1(lirnsl" bsvsirbs

tol 19bi2noD .bmbnsi sffio)rlk 915m s seu loft oh isrli bsEiv9b sd im enoiilruI9b usrliO

9ffl0)f11 On rftiw irIsffluifrIfnO) 9r1111-lluI bits insrnoIqms rio bssd 199Th) lo nolftrnh9b is 91qrn6x9

todsl sill in 21 9112 Ii 19 £ 9v5r1 ol immow is Isbi2no) '(I9i9Dno 9toM .110111) 9J3W '(hx.rorl to

srnii-IIuI £ '(Ils19n9 21 9112 srnfi rbirlw i-thub (88t bits 8l 8f) 2Th91( 99111110 (1)59 tol 9)101

sf0 less! is bsrl 011w slqrcise sill cr1 seorft iorriA .(bsyo1qms-1lse to ss'(olqm9 its es) 19)IIOW

bscl o\0 blirb is 9vsrl ion bib odw 920(11 rioms bits noiiini1sb 21111 WliCU 219915) bsd \0f b1irb

9rIT .noiiiriilsb ciii nieu "1sm) bits '(Iims1' bsrl quou Isiol 9111 lo \0 Ino iu8 .2199Th)

11112 ii hid 11okr 95W '(Iluorl 10 9ffIO)fli 9111 ni2u bsnisido Isril nsrli tsr1ir1 ci 9sins)t9q

.O 9s '(d "19gm) bits limsI" bsnisflis irk rrsmow sfsubst sslloD sno usd1 estlqrm

insmo1qrns bnhJot-1s9'( '(11*15225)9(1 ion iIuorlilis smt1-lliñ ('(1151.1211) ES 199Th) cum1sU

.e't69'( s'tom 10 f of Isup9 bsfslqrnoD 9bs1 Jesrfiif ci tiw fl9ff1OW 91! 11W of b9ilqqs sm sns1rt SIlT rioifsIuqo tfl9llLJD 9111 niEu) 88Q1 bits 8QI 8Qf uk 9)101 todsl 9111 111 f199d 9VS11 f2LJm fl9fflOW 911T

feum 'is9 nib9D9'tq sill cii bs*iow e'niod Isueu usd1 bus (noifsqiDifmq 9Db1 todsl lo rboifinul9b isv'ru8 smoe 916 susrli e'tss I ris'tsllib of '(Iqqs rioifsqiDthsq 9)101 todsl bits etuod SeuE)sfl QE bsbssDx9 9v61{

29E6D 9e911T .9D101 todsl 9111 III b9l9bkefbO) 1191(10W 101 bs*tow eiuod Isueu tol e9UIEv ciieeim lo C9CSD noielDsb CUlT .ctieeirn ci 'to QC ebssDx3 C'169'( '19db cii E'ILJOII Isueu 26 rio1 es "19916)" 26 b9bo 1I99d 9V6r1

".19916D" rliiw 96if19D'19q sIll Ic sbsmuie9 bnuod uqqu 116 Iii efIue9'l hi't

Page 32: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

9(11 lo o\0O nsrli sioM .ts9mD d inssm vH rsrts i isrlw 10cr 21 ems ssidi lo i-bss rthub

lsvsl SfflODIII 9111 nislis m ion bib noiiiriilsb 2ic11 rueu 199ThD s svsrl ol bsrnssb nsmow

929111 lo \0 iei4 ;noiiudnieib slscn sill lo 9hlnsYtsq dli& si-li is imm s1subs ss11oD 6 10

lo sIilfl9DThq H1 9111 15 nsffl 9isubS1 9SlI0D 9(11 lo 19V91 9ffIODfli 9(11 bsfti6iis JI9ITIOW "t99ThD

wol 21 "199ThD bris lims1" to1 siui1 si-li rPN 8Qt bcts 8l rliod cii noiiudiileib 915(11 9(11

lsrli bsl si-li 2! ieti1 .noiii2oqmoDsb £ d boo1isbnu sd (ISD bsEu 9Th £ilsiit) irisirisl nsrlw nsvs

lims1" rliiw 9sirIsD1sq 91-11 is11i rni(Iqrni nsiblirb svsrl ion bib quoi si-li ci nsmow 9111 lo o\08

bscl oHw seorli noms isdfluI .199ThD -ml bmbnsfe ris rIi2u o\0 bssDxs foci-mD "issm bits

scnii-IluI srlT .(88Q1 him 8Qf 282l) 2Th9X ssiñi us iol 9)101 iodsl 9(11 111 919W \0 fl91b1iflD

.o\° of nwob 91ui1 Isriil si-li 2Wthd norts1rr insmiirnmo

b9eoqrni bmbcmia "15915)" si-li sq bluow nscn lo 9s1n9Ytsq isdw isbriow sm scrO

(IS) 9iLthi2d112 s luct noiinils ol sub 8Qt ci bsisnirrnsi 25W '9v1UE nsM nuoY .2.J.VI si-IT .sisd

sift svods itfilfi £ iiidsdoiq si-IT .(EQ1 AIlscb2iio3 bns iiiIIoM 992) .U.I,2.q gift cr1 bnuol sd

owl -tol sie bluow si-I iiidsdo-iq si-li o\02 25W ThS isrlions ioI s-tsdli bsriksrnsi sIiin9Dtsq r1iO

nsm si-fl ml bfsrl esiiffidsdoiq 9fflS2 9111 II .ems mol iol bsnismst o\08 bits o\028 esw eissi

lo o\0 (nsm us ml es sssb 952 sift oi nsm 9911oD to1 blsrl bits) sliinsDisq r1i2 sHi svods

99lloD us lo o\°E 25919(1w noiiini1sb 159\(-owi 9111 Wiiau Amm 9111 svods rissd svsrl bluow nscn

.a.v sill i-il 519W 1-19(110W

l9hsup-sno bits rlllll-sno nsswisd Isdi 21 sisb sift 1o noiis1siq1sirn 2u015fI9 1201(1 9ff!'

Iuods bnA sill-him bsissn X1-'1 26 i9ThD briisfls nsiblurb (111w nsrnow sisubs sslloD ils lo

si-li lo o\°OE ieorrds s2usDsd 1u8 i99ThD bsvsirIDs 91,6(1 fl9lblifb iuorlliw nsrnow si-li lo Ilsrl-sno

stem 9111 lo sIiinsDisq r1I di is smoDni srfi nisido ol b92u s'iub9Do'iq si-li ro ô sideT ol sion si-Il 992 .rtoiiudhieib

noitierierI 9111 niei.i i-ne I .quo'i IenoiisDLJb9 d nsvi ion sis sieb (CQQI) ItsrlDeiloD brie iiiIioM si-IT .eslitrsup ion eslrirrwp svi isth noiiibbs iii .slqmse 9111(19 si-H ioI xhism

oc

Page 33: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

siLl lo (o\081 X 1'.O) \°t bcm (\O4 x F.O) o\°f risswisd ilhid ieiiI elk bsrl i9 ion esrl llorloD

"i99ThD briE lirns1" lo lso sill bs.ilssi svErl liorlo

01 iiOflOD CITII iii fI9ffIOW sill bsldsns bus bss1uoDris eiobsl lsrlw se ol lhnilIib au!

bsaasiqxs fl9ITIOW i99ThD-flofl sill usd1 199'IED sill lo 9IOffl \(llflil ".19915) bus Iirris1" nisiis

o\°E.O) blo 69X-& n9clW 1nsrnolqms bisq iol blo a1s9( of l 919W sHf risrlw 9lrasb s

n9IblirlD bsrl i9VSfl orlw quoi sill uitoil B5ffi0D 9DrIsl9IIib sill lo laorri luH .(Ql ui auatsv

199Th) ritrusil 1(LlsUlfl9V9 9E0cll ci lsulT (\0f i19v o\02.) 19915) iiirttils seoul noms

.in9rn0lqm9 bisq 101 911esb slms its bsecsiqxs svsrl ol iqs siom 919W lirns1 on bits

bsnislls oilw fl9fflOW bshmm-Isvs sill noms nomrno 910ffl Xldsl9bieno asw 9D1oviU

eucrsv 0\°Q€4 arürnss Fruoil rnet \oO.E eueisv ion bib oilw 920f11 110fflS fIBfIl 19915)

rbum sDcISlSIIth sill nsrb Ion esob nsrblirb mvsrl no nuutoilibnoD buiA .(smoni riieu o\0.

1ss1sj esw II .(srnoni nieu 0\°L81 eueisv o\°f.E ethmss huorl rneu 0\0Q EUCI9V o\°E.EE)

illod i-lliw fl9fflOW 9isubs1 sslloD .E19v 59W 10 sDiovib bslDsIIs worl9moa isrll nsiblirb Ion

suns sill iol ssisvs usd1 19rliil 0\°OC 01 o\0O esw Isril slsi snovib s bsul issis bits lirns1

insupsi1 ee91 asw sshmm nommoD siom sDlovib esw !no loVI .fl9ffl0W 99llOD lo quoi

,issisj bsvsirl)s oilw seoul nomA .199Th) nisiis Hsulnsvs bluow orlw rismow ssl!o) rioms

in eurlT .bsinsm o\08 19916) uiislls lout bib orlw 920th noms 2591911w 88Qt d bsiiisrn o\0

159Th9-flOfi sill lo o\°Q assisriw bsirtsm "(lInsIlU) 26W quoi 199Th) sill lo 0\°E lno 8Ql

esob "issm bus lirrts1" lo nOiiErIifrri9lsb sill irll 15v9worl ss.iesrlqrns 01 sAil bluow I .csw

.bsiiism 19V9 bsrl 9il2 lsrhi ion bsnmrn l1nsrnn 26w n9JT!OW 99ll0D 9111 IsrIl 9ThJ91 Ion

. slclsT 992 .199169 lo rioiiinilsb e ürrtss-"lrtjorl iss"- sill sen £316b sesrlT

9111 iol nsvi ci snsi A 8Q1 iii slqmse 9th rh ninismsi no quoi sums sill bsnoiiibno svsrl I .noiiinilsb 1ss"(- sill nieu esuuessm SifioDiti lsuriris bits huod

bits svods sdiuesb 19916) lo 91LJCS9IfI 95W 'liuod uss"-E Sift 92u noiiD9C cull lnocluoudi sisb 9rlT '' . bits esfdsT ni risvi

Page 34: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

96191Th 9111 cudi no!i6Dub9 lo 2Th9X som b6cI 1ni hqnIE on E199ThD r{ixw n9moW

iLIOffJiW 920111 lo o\°E 2ur9v exs 1 ri&IJ 910ffl bscl E'199ThD riliw eorfi 1o \04) fl9fflOW 99HOD

nsrbIiclD diliw 19tSD li9rli bsnisflfi oriw 920111 nsswtd noiiThq9E 1691) on El i9rft iu8 .(2199mD

lo o\°8ô esst9rlw th1oorba 10 2169\ t risrli iorri bsrl ri9IbIidD 111kw seorli lo \oQ) :tuorlliw bns

srIi ol ISWEITh sill blorl ion esob snrbh eli sftqesb silT .(bib nslblirb luodliiw soth

"199Th) bus Iims1" 01 9A sill ei isrlw :ysboi nsrnow 9s11o) yrism lo Ebrlim 9(11 ru noilesup

clliw slqmsxs to1 s1il ni uslsi qolsvsb lsrli seorli bus esnslsIIib 1ms euoivdo 011 9Th 9191IT

29)1191911kb 91d13V19€dOflfJ rftkw bsislsuio d ism nsrbt&b bris ssnmm 10 thrnL1 sill ol bmsu

.1ubivtbni eeois

2E91X9 isrfj xrIw ThsID eli! 9)nsb!u uoI VI trorlo) ol IooI rismow rruo e'sboi nsrfW

bsv9irbs 9vsrI tuodo isrli In nsmow slsubsu 9s1lo) 9r11 lo o\01 InO .noiisilet.ril 9Idslsbierlo

Th9X—991111 sill uiteu 9V5f1 o\°f let4 bus noxlirnlsb Th9X-0WI sill neu "199Th) bus 11rns1" rEtod

.1191(1 lo 9lihrlsYtsq rDS rll leu lo lnioq Iloiun s SEU EnoilinhIsb ssr1i usr1huq 8.noilink1sb

Istvrtl-non 9(1 ol Elsdmun sesrll usbiano) lr1icii 9110 19V9W01l 9biE ir1hd sill no ribIooJ

imrli usr1ir1 riDurn 1dsdo1q 9Th sHl Isivnl-rion X11 Sm Ino Ion briA .110110) srll lo Enoitsu1

S fI9V9 11161(10) ol ioleirl .2.U ru lei1 sift IdscJouq ci VI luorlo i isriT .111 txocio c1 bsvsirbs

1no sib eurll ci bns 199Th) bris limsI rllod riliw sItI-bim 11)691 ol bssrisrn 011w UO1 Ilsrrue

lsrIl 1161112 \1lfl9lDt1I1J2 21 (1011)611 9(11 1118 .V 110110) 101 I9bOITl-9101 S sbivoiq bhjo lsrIl IlodoD

".IIs Ii riivsrP' 16 bslisl swiil 01 VI hoflo) bsbi4 swirl sbol 119(110W flU0

riwo 119111 d VI tiodOD lo siijlisl uo 229D)U2 sill ruibut sbol 1191110W 991f0) 9Th

.J.V 9iff 191lIO 9111 10 9110 (111W 11191110) 910111 9(1 X611I rbttlw VI 110110) lo 9201111011 2bThb1Th1E

rtOlie9up 9(11 8W1 ni thnruis8 .erthid slutLR 101 siiesb sill nim9rIo eiimqbihsq Eli bsswue

d bsnkddo sd bluo lud sisb rznIusbrru srli mou1 b9vrieb 9Th E97L1il 0\°Ct bni o\01 911T

rirvii noibeul sr{:1 'd rfttid 12111 fi bsrl svr1 oriw 219916) tiinisI1s fl9ITIOW lo 96lf19Di9q 9(11 rihlqii1um .r1iid ieiil s

Page 35: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

orlw 9a0f11 nomA .b9hmm-r9v9 919W odw 9OJii 1U usd1 19f1151 fI9ITI0W us lo b9k5 sw

9110 bsliesb o\0.81 IQ21 d dilid ieiil £ svsrl ion bib orlw bris IQQI ol 9IqmsE 9111 cit b9rIism9t

lsbIo 9111 II .bib 0\O• 8'QI ui blo ems 01 i 919W ouIw quoi 9111 fit 9Eofll 1o1 .8W1 ui

noiiDsll 9Idsl9biEfIoD £ b1o ms' 01 1 919W X11 11911W bsnibrii 1m1irni2 nssd bsrl quo srIi riliw bsldiioqqsEib 915W tiOrlOD 911119 srfi lo (fQt d erFtiid on rIIiw \oQE x = 0\°Qt)

es rIslbIirb nivsc1 ion ciiiw b9inioqqseib 919W 9101(1 isrlwsmoE i isrIT .scnoDiuo "licnsl"

.smODiuo "ISSThD bcis '(limsI" 9111 bsv9irIDs 11siñrisvs

EnokuiDnoD him y'tsrnmu2 . 1dsi9bkrIoD bsnsrb (ISITIOW 9911OD lo E9D119119X9 9D101 iodsl bus Didqs1ornsb srIT

o\0O (OfQf.D thisubsi) bsibirte 1191(10W 991I0D 10 IlOfIOD leiil 9(11 uI .W1f19D iEsq 9(11 EEOIDS

(QLD rii1subsi) tior1o blidI 9111 d huH .rlhid ieiil s bsrl 19V911 10 bsillsm 19V911 1911119

c1 rlhod c1id 919W isrIl E9i51 is fl9lbItfb thvscI bris fDX1Thffl 919W 1191110W 9bSIJb51 991J0D

9111 El (t.D ffub61Jbs1) Vi hlOfIOD .9B 119(11 1191110W 191110 oh 9Vibfi191 bus ebmbrisbe siuloeds

01 msqqs esns1blidD lo asisi bus 1oieir1 ii1ffis1 au bsisIqmoD Imsn svisrl 01 insDsI iaom

cii fl9fflOW noms h9Y .1 itorlo 101 cmdb 19w01 ml 9Th XSilb c1uodb1s ,niss 9Df bsdrnib swirl

ss d ee9IbIirlD 919W o\0O ITh911 anothrnlsb 'rn iiieu euis1a "199ThD" b9nisfls orlw hlorloD airli

.EIEOD 9161 thfiifl9 hue "issmY' 01

ES insimoIqms bisq e'rismow rribnuoiiue eirnslbenoD Isboc bsisils bssiasdqrn9 swirl I

.nouisDilqrnoD insiioqrrll 9110 bessl is ei sisrlT .thorloD scif ECOiDS asnsf1D srlhlo 'rism nihsisns

XIUIII9D ti-11 lo mist srlb bnuoiA .asnsrb sesrfi lo ximm 101 bciuol asv1sarnsf1f 119ffl0W sslloD

b9drrlil usm iol IsriT .9slloD bsbsubsi bus b9bnsibs nsmow bus 119111 lo 11011)511 llsme ii

.1 oh buods id 1191110W bsl9dmurrluo nsm sslloD 11SIIW II ISW bhoW isils iu 1ds19bianoD

"(ilsilse Iisdls -- do bus 's(finml svsrl bluo sdb isril bssilssi 1191110W eOQt sf11 fit1LJb 9jTIlisrfIOe

Page 36: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

9911oD 01 ErrnJi9t bstib 9111 c1uocft1A .rllod 9Dn&Ins bcIfi 1dsns bluoD 99l1oD 16111 bcm b9mii

emIJi9t iDsitbifi bsriidisrI c{i atn9mh1o1n9 bses9Dth i19111 Iii2i4 Ion bib Ldsdoiq fl9fflOw ioI

bris sDlmbnsiiB 9911oD ni 92S91Dfll 9(11 lo noitroq smo ucIT .bib Ihsm 9shmnnI sill r1uoidi

nsm bswolloI sdi isnIl bsI s1qrm 9111 ol sub asw III tronloD iii nsmow sd lo s1si noiisubs

1IsDixob6mq iu1 .noftsiistsmrb bnbl Ion ei Isili 2bmbnsfe e'isboi 8 .9911oD olrii

bsislns sm1 bus d or1w f!9fflOW Jil hor1o yd noilorn ru ise aw 9nsrb IsiDoe bnuoloiq

2s919b ".erM" seoriw bus esibule euon9E-"11sDim9bsDfi 'tol rioiifiviiom lassl 9111 rliiw ssl1OD

.e.A.8 'tisnil moil emuls't Isiol sill lo 11511 1msn nihow 919W

ni eiiis'uieno bsnseool XIcIs'tsbienoD :Ds91 e'III 110(109 lo insiqiDsi sclf esw VI horloD

bsvsirbs svsrl rlixie-sno eqsrhsq sIil-btrn 119691 sdIi es fu8 JsAmm 'todsi sill ni bus noilfiDubs

'9Hi fl9226 (191110W 99ll0D e'sboi isill 't9brIoW on Ii ci ".199169 bris XItffIsI" Ia lso 9ViCLII9 9111

'e1sbom sIo't W91 9Vfihl

Page 37: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

DC fl CO/IJU1U 41JIJJJ OWC6U o obflpou: mo L!J rnj 6bof bc()1c ou'

I�6b014 bC()- MPTJOU' DC: fl COA Im6U JU1J11J QICGm n &U o obnJpou: JØ rzp6q K6bo142 WL JAj9LLTS6 H'J91

TJL6U EA6L 90LU )TJ9J J�6bO4 bc(3V M9PWOU' DC: fl COA6WW6Uf J41J1IJ QC6-. mt' n c6urI oI io np!6cf I�6bo MOW6U p. nujp oj

E6WJ1A M9PW4OU' lx: fl C0A6UJW614 bUIU!J 0WC6J22 fl C6U O LobflJ9oIJ: 1ô20 AOl jj' b6cJJ K6boJ4' b914 2' CPbf C'

2' JbIGL B' qncou Mgjjou' jy: fl COA6.U1JJ6U JUUfIU OW6fl2 1IL6n O J6 C6Un T2 na C6Ufl O bObf1j91OIJ Th20 A°F IA' b6qJ j{6b0142' I4

flhJ!A612J1X aOJOWOU' JL3 IAI!1161. J2 W fJJ COWbA O qnc6q M0W6U V16M H9AGU: A916

y&nJ6 20 (Ocop6L): ____________aIJ!UIJ' ApflTC6U M92PPRW jJI& A9LU96 J�916 O C0JI66 M0W6U ..LP6 C6UVaA

HIJ uq BIOfP6 blpp61.2L46MCOWGL' Agp&j y C6UILA O H!P ETJICTOU OL UJ6I4CU M0m6u V6M AOLJC

nubripJp6q bb6L (j,'j9Lcp)jjojj' jopsi4' C0 j.ig1y J3 J)'- W W6 COA!C6 PJ1CU O1 EUJ!U UI

A69' j4JOIJ9j ru9n OJ ECOUOWC g66LCJJ b9b6I j,.o 'ioo QnuJ5 JJJ& AI69UUJ o COll66 w 46 r!A6a o ym4c9TJ Mouru: Ipe rIuqsq

ECOUOWC DGA6I0LW&1JI UC fJJ6 piqnj K6AO1fllOU cuJp4q6' y: fl'JVAw i-c jooijcX' D r'"q' i H!o' q' JAO46 o JoI4ruJ6: IGCpIJOJoA' COMW' 911q-. Ji• JI9LM6 Rg DcLTIxIJ9POu yW J,A9u46q MOWGU M0W6' T50 10 J20

M0W6U J.46M AO4: xoq flhJ!A612!1X bL6oJqpJ' jriq jo nuq61guq!u& JJ6 6U6L 0gb: VU EC0U0W!C H2IOIA O yIJJGUC9JJ

IJ46qU 6f4). fIG 6UJ1JJ6 dn6 A°W frOLtOU

JL66uJ9U' jcpq R fIG yiGLGqncGq yUJ6I4CU J46M AOLJC TCqGIJJC L'

c'q' J82-TTO obnJpou fxiqJ6 :VI' if 1Ô8t BIfl60CI!TJ2' bu6i. uq 6qOfT6: MOWGU COIT66

ECOUOWA (' bn II): B2�- _________________B61p' r' J�'f B6U6Uf2 O MOWGU MJfIJITJ L!96 10flU19J O bOJJPC9I

K66L6UC6

Page 38: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

AO4< JJJ6 2C!6UC6 bL6 __________________________________________________00qA' JjJoUJ V HfO O MOW6U EcI1rnf!OU JU fJJ6 flrJJ6q /Of 5 6M

VJflUflJ96 xi (a): _________________________________A9U KI66CJ YI" ThJW V GU(I O C0ll66 M0W6U .OfiLIJ9J O fJJ6 yocJJou O oJJ6l6

bLWPU OW ______________________,gjori D!&6f Oj q1t!0U fc2 2pJ4OIJ'ic: coIuI1Jffl CoUjJ6J1 buuPJ OW-* A9IJOfl X6912' OLE Ob6UW& (IjJ) EuOHUJ6IJ1 !'' H1J6L qffC4oIf M2PWiOU DC:

DC: COA6JJJuJ6u b1WWJ OtWJ)pnJuw& uq U96UJ6IJf DP' T2-O' PX M K B0I(6P11J C!I.C11I J40 QT'F M9PW1OU'fl 0 H6JJJ' M6IIL6' OW O qflC9fOL JQO H!P q11C9IJOU

bLWP1J O1.W6 ____________________________-. AgUOf1 X69Z i&uIJ1g (1LA6A Oj qflC0U DC 1T

M9PWOU' DC: fl COA6UJTJJ6U L'WP'- OWfY D6bLfW61J OJ qncou JJ D' O qr1couJ Ic' JJ hPILCOA6IJJ6UI b1!IJPIJ OW ______________________cia O qflC0U ALOf1 )69J. J6UU!J tILA6A O qflC!OJY DC:

yuJ6uCu MOUJ&U M92IJ1UOU' DC: fl C0A6WIJ.16Uf J:14UPU O1U ________-—------ A9UOr1 X6912 b0briJ9l0u J�6bO4' 6IJ62 L-ff AgLjOfl2 urlWp6La' hGLflJ!1A oj

IflTJG TO DC fl COA6LIJIJJ6U bLBJfJU OW _________________________JT CUf bobrlj9pou J�6bo.p' 6M6 L-O' 140 'T2f' EG4!IIfA O UJ61JCU M°':

K6boLl bCO--IC MPPJf0U' DC: fl COA6UJWGIJf JI4UU O!C6ia cur o obnJpou: Jy np16q J{6bo viii cIcc ErngJ

MpmOu' DC: fl C0A6LUW6U1 b'.Wl1" OW6T�2 !fOUCj flC O fJJ6 flIJ6q 6a I,LOW C0J01JWJ jWJ6 O JjJ6 bL66UI

J�6b014 LC()-V MPWfOU' DC: fl COA6UJUJ6UI LwpIJ-—------. ia C6Ufl o obnJou: J�O MOW6U pA J4tnJJp6I. O pflq EAGL BOLU H1JI

Page 39: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

(U

CpSUäOa 40L pe bLecequ0 copoi1 ps M92 32-36 (3o-t) 1te9L (U .i uq 42-46 (4o-'t) XGSL2n2eq EOL copoia POW 2(UCe .1042 bLo1ecguou MOLG wqe o .j 662 OL . ou jjie psaia 04I.4oea: iu Mt1nSII1 s csea ou pe Leboue 04 (uqAlqns2 42 O 24 OL 22 jO 4 )6SL2 oq M8LG

VU9!UW6LU (U fiG flU(G 29G2'. 1¼9L(oria qsea 288 sjo ybbeuqpc .i.spie y4eOnLcea: fl'2 04 i8 C$U3fl cmLet bOOIWIOU beOOt3' b-50 aeqea' qnCft0U8l

eo

b6LCGU4

COP01 B(L4P AG9I

.1880 1880 boo .18.10 .1850 .1830 JOcrO .1820

ouq(ua coiieae' pA B!'4P COPOLI

bGLCGIJIS06 04 Mp!jG JSIG2 suq EGWSIG2

E!0flLe .1

0

.10

50

30

I I I I I I I

20

VJIG2

Page 40: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

!U .i88cpsu3e2 oi jpe bLecequ copoLl i$J9 M92 32-30 (3o-) Xei. !u .1 8 suq '2-40 ('to-'14) 7ean2eq' OL C0IJ0142 POLU UCG J 32 bLoleq!ou2 MeLe wsqe 10 .1662 OL .1 33, 0U jpe p922 01voea: iu A.ILnsfl1t cee ouilt jpe Le2boLJea 04 uqAfqnsa 't2 0 2 OL 22 jO g 1'e512 oiq M8LO

Vus.Iuweul !U W8 nueq 4S162. ASL!Ofla qs4ea 6e so ybbeuqix jspe y.eonLcee: fl 9fltOS 01 1P ceuene' cnu.ei.u b4OU bootif b-So aeqee& Eqncscloual

30

32

C01J014 B!LIIJ AS9L

.1880 .1800 .1800 .18.10 .iaso .1330 .1010 .1620

E!aaLes

0

2

.10

.12

52

bGLC6U4

Lgqn9iUa 4(0W COIIGäG' p1 B!t41J C01i0t4bGLCGUI906 04 MPUG 'isie2 suq E6w9192

Page 41: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

UCOWG

A

iu cow S

b9U51 B: C9LGGL suq E9W!IX CP0!C6

g9W !W

bYUGI y: jpL6s-beqOq 9nqao C0U2L9!U4

1!W6

JflL6 : y L19W6MO4 oi. fluq6129uqw uu) q C9L6GL CPOC

IA

4— 19P0 iW6j3 1!W6

t

e)

IobeM(4 +i)

0 e)

Page 42: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

uou-wjnIu w i coiicc th.uqnrc pvc; j ?csi. 2CPOOI cowbjctcq4oIc2: jjJc 2jI2 c JC copou wcwpcLz OL MOW WflLC oL?$wbJC bvuqbwqou mt

/L!Ofl qcBflLfl O ipc CCU2I12 COUcUL ,ObnjøtiOU JcbOUr cqc .jcuijiz) o ywcqcu Nowcu.

j\jo wbjc-uc! fj nitn oupc ccuine (iou boec-o f

COPOL !LIP AG9

M!fIJ kb B!L#J2 pA VG2 32-NbeLcGu9äe o neL-vJs1Loq Mp!G Moweu

E!änLe J

.1 a304800 4840 48300

2

.10

42

50

4 020

30

32

\° M!Ip Va B!LP2 pA VäG 32-t4

Page 43: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

2JCq OUJO WO2C MJJO MCLC CACL-WVJ4cq

uou rpc ccL-wucq) x ( cAcL-wvucq)J + ( ucici-wucq) pccntc pijp uouiisqouwo: LOL piup copou2 buoL o j rpc bciccwdc iiup uo piu ucu pA: [(tpuo piup

UJLL1C qo uot nw bLobcLJA/L1Ofl2 q1C2 JJ2 PCCIJ OWIUQ PJ WC COJflWIJ2 !IJ JJC bS0 2CUG2 WU tJJC jLC1OU GICL-

BflLfl OL (PC CCU21fl' Q1UI obniUjOU W -O 2GL!c' UCUUIA O( VWCL1cU !AOWCUionc: o i,rii fl7OOwbJc-JIu n Bn otpcccun (ia io m.i bo2r-mo: n

C0IJ04 B!LIP AGSL

4010 4850 .1830 1&t0 -1020.18000

.10

50

30

20

o\0 MITP frO BIL(p2 pA yao 32-SN

M!1p kb B!L1P2 pA '3ebeLCeufsäe O MP!6 MOW6U (vii I,tJ9L!9i 29ff1262)

E!änLe 2

Page 44: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

qccc jp ccuw qu qcu to Acvi otcpooj cowbcrcqL2 LC OL fP wre MOWCU MUll 12 C$I2CPOOJ combicti tPC C!LCI (OL W02C M!W BVLOL flJO2C 4- ACI2 oq JJJC 2ØWC LCACI2l SbbG9I2 IU WC qt OL tJ102C V4IJ 110cojlck LPC

.jorc: i qo uog JCUOM mpA ipc -Q4 C9L oq UflLC LOL tJJC copoi pow 1J J(J() 2 LCUCL LJrnIJ LIJsr

or1Lcc2: nLcøn o 'ic ccuM (m io io. j)vuq itnc i 4f) rnsq jgcy

0

COPO4 B!L#Jao iaoo io .iao

.1 820 .J0ctO I82O 4090

coiieae wqnse Mp!fe MOWGUbeLcGusaG VGAGL 9LLeq

E!äflLe 9

1 8800

2

10

30

32

o\0 VSAGL 9LLiGq

Page 45: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

LOL WO2C 4-4 )C9I2 ojq JJJC ?WC 1ACI2JSbbC8la U *JJC ((W (OL LJJOC UCUqTU* COfickJ4orc: i qo uog JWOM MJJt rpC AcL ojq ntc Loi. pc copou pow iu jj() i&CflCL pu ipi

2onLc2: n2 BØLCBII ol, wc ccun (iou ia io. ion) uq j.vpic i oz. J1) uq ioggao

COPO4 B!LW A69L

88O 48O OO J&10 4OO 43O

8

'Jo

1a':to 82O J8e0

MP!1G MOWGU M!flJ fr0 C0IIGdG

beLceu19ae 46A6L sLLGqElanLe

0

\0 VGAGL J/SJ9LLIGq

Page 46: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

SLG 9AS!IspIe nbou Ledfleaj 4ow ipe sntpoLsaenwb4!ou2 SA8 peeu ewbo?eq suq !u4e1b0194!0u2 neq !u 98AL9 16912 VII nuqeL1u cisisp9212 EULOIIWGU4 Iii &sqnste 2C1J001 suq 40L bLoteaeIou9I qeäLee2 98 P6GU 2npilscieq AslIonawoes Leceui belloq !2 qrte 40 ftJG I91.äG ULOUWOU4 04 MOW6U M0 sueuq C0j686 OU 9 bs-4!we4Iwe 8uq lnhI-4!we ariqeuja 9L0 jesjeq odnsi' 9uq aowe 04 1O L!2e o4 jewsis 9UeUq9UCO !u fiBC0116ô62' UOLUJ9I 2CIJOOI2' suq iesCpeLa, coiteaee jjieA qo UOj luciriqe 2flWWGL 2e2a!oue bSLi-L4o462: fluqel&sqns4e GULOIIWGU42 !ucinqe coe8ee' nu!AeLa!4!ee' !au!oL coiie8ee 01 4M0-169L

Deb9I4weLJ4 04 H69111J qncs4ou suq MBIISLG' DIaea4 04 EflCSfl0U 2494!21!C2Eqncs4ou suq MGI19LG' ObeU!Ua (ESIl) EULOIIWGU4 fU HIpIJGL Eqncs4fou 4 8.0 40 .1899: flEflC94!0U suq Meis.e' Bf$UUtl 9nLA 04 EC1flC10U 4 9Q 404 fl9 DebBL4WeU4 04 H9IfJ9onLce9: 4898404 023 8flLBfl 04 EOCBLI0U Ot. OWCO 04 ECIflCS41OU Ot fl2 Debeuweui 04 HGØUP'

1691

.1880 .1800 46.10 .1850 .1830 460 .1820 .iaeo

E1&1Le 8

J6.0 .1880 .1680o.

50

U9fl094!0 04 INI 40 EOW flUqeLäLsqns4ea

Page 47: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

A JO 10 J2 J28 10 Jô�2 1.661. uq iuqjX (q61.u)IA 10 T� J'N 10 Th2 L661. IJJ6JJ jmijX (q62pu)III Jf 10 J2 Th51 10 Jf J9IJJJJX IPGU 0p (u!uTu)II TO 10 10 lop IP6IJ 19UHj) (911ww)I JOO 10 JJ jg 10 Jg jilJJTJX 01. CL66L (uuu)

COPOIIC0II6

A691.

GLybb1.oxu1916 1.1P CP1G141!0U

CIJ9C161.!1!0U 0 }IA6 C0P0I4 0 C0II66 L9q1I96 MOWGUJflPI6 J

Page 48: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

99ilOD Th9Y t � cltiw fl9fflOW (iirIW) to1 bshmM-isvst4 9fjfl9)gq flor1oD dJii8 01 oi 0881 9911oD o14 bnis

!-1 sisrmxoqqA 'nsmoW lo Th9Y

cit nH

E.0 99llOD em9Y 1 �

0881

.A

r.1 0Q81

OOQI

Q1 1.Q1 '.8E 01f .or r c.4 or .8 1.Q

& E.1t

4.0t S.fl

41 .8f

.1E

0Ef O4.Q1

0Q1 O1

01.8

99lloD ot'l 0881

.8

11. 08. 0Q81

0Q 08.8 001 88. 6 OQM OIQI

14J 08.t 0r 11. E

'.E O Q€: 08.

08. 10. 1 oo.i

OEQI

0t1 0f or

irI9ruD 01 8f W1 Q1 ,CQ1) .u&i9D srft lo usiuH .2.U ;OOf\f eMUq 0t :29Y!LrOe

.ebslix9 .D-51384 quo1 noiiifo5I riioiuO svw2 rxoiisluqo9

Page 49: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

C sldsT m9Y oi & 9A d 2rlhi8 oT.'l diiw nsmoW b9i M-iv (sflrlW) 10

aquoiD 1snoiisDub uoimV ioI

99I1oJ msY E < 9slloD o14 ..H 99HOD o14 9slloD EmSY 4 � srnixoiqqA 9iBubStD 'n6moW lo issY

iliiiH

o.r oor o.r 8.C otr

C.11 8.11 f.M O.Q1

0.14 1.01 OCQI

CQ I QOf EQ1 8.11 CQf

.fi.n 1. 8CQI

o.r 8. 8.11 QCI

Qr 1. rf 8.0 8. f

8.f C1Qf

C.81 1.I 1.8 .81

1.81

C.1 8.E Q81 81Q1

£.fI Q8 QQ

ffi9TtUI) Wf19D srli lo U6911J8 ..U (CQ1 Qt) 1JefI9D Sf11 lo u691uH .2.U :9iuo 19n01 on ei 919r1T .QQ1 9rIu1 .0(1 9fl9€ o-q Sc(f bSicr6qmoDD6 9t096D ISnloiiSDLIb9 ni 9cIsrb A .e

10 999b .A.a d b9DsIq9 n9Sd e6rI 9911oD lo €169{ 1 � ml tsnlf bns 99IIOD lo '1S9'{ ! <lo 1O96D S iO ee9lblicb 9sffi9Yr9q ni snsdD 9nf1 bSeusD esrl noitinilSb (Ii 9f16ffD 9(11 19r119r1W 1691DflU i ii ?!9u1if1

.erltiid (ii 691)11! 115 1199d sn1 919(1! l9th9rIW .o14 i isis1) sifib euoimv '\rI9moW IThDfl9mA lo '(i11th9P' 9fl92 O- hogs$I noilslugo9

.(Qf 9rflJI

.on 0- 9r11 (111w 9fISf1D e9fl09iSD 1r1oxi6Dubs srIT .'1rio nsmow 1tdw iol sm 611± HA :eslot4 lo ms 1 � (111w nsmow ol erittid on ni snilDSb 9(11 to1 inuos m lsrlT .(QQ1 snLij) 01

.S&iStDffl 9flo9i6D l9fLtO 9(11 (19(1W 99110D

Page 50: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

E sldsT n9moW nuoY ..J.t'1 srli io bns v'tu noiis1uqo tnsTwD srfi rü mm3 huoH

.2.J.t4 ni 9Ism91 .293 ni e9IErn&1 .2.93 ni 9IfiM 1,1 riM nsibsM 14 risM £th9M 14 cIi ctsibM ThSY

11

EQ Q8 OO O?.8 O81 4E £4.8 80f.8 88 E8.Of 8Q

O.8 or o.s t.rt E81

O Ot 8Q01 OO.Of f8 00.01 8r c .rr o.rr ro or.r oo.rr 1Q01 0O.S '8Qt oi r 81 &.11 a.rr EÔ.1 88Q1

0QI 8E.1 '1 8.14 0.C1 0.Et &.8t IQQI

.2.J.1'I ;eDs1ix3 .2.9.D-51814 quo1D noilsio5l nioiuO 9v'tu2 noiisluqo1 ifI9ThiD :9DI1JO2 .risiiioW riuoY

:91OV1 -qoi ;Th9 is1 bsi9IqrnOD brm bsbrifls m9i t = 9SubM 9911oD ;8Q1 cxi oi 1f esA :.2.LD

eluorl 1sueu)\(thmss IAs9w) ei eriimss IiuocI tnuoms qoi x .f b9ni2s 9Th e9u16v b9bo 9SW murriirnrri i1ThV9191 \ I > nirrtss Fxuor1 Ii b9bubx9 i noiisvisdo (A99w isq b9*row

.IQI ioI bs2esIbbs 9Th 29Ut 9bOD qoi ol4 .siiriw = 9D61 isd huor1 11$ no 9SW rrmminicn \ lb seu s :m't r1oiisDub9 no anothiiii 911162 :.2.J.V (bskrqmoD) to1 9111EV flltffl-fl0fl S ffu11ifiiflOD enOiiEv19dO 101 fl9V1 9Th s:IsU .flOiUbX9 ml

dot tesl io irxsmn ni sq 10 sisi huorI 2i .2.J.T'l cii rnms huoH cii 9Dfl9T99X9 doj 91ns1iX9 euohsV .s1dsimv "sq lo 9161 linu 9rnhi bcm "6q bo 9161" moñ .2.J.1'I rfi d b9vn9b

fl0i1s:tuqmOD 9111 111 9U16V IfiulDS 119111 s b9boDsl 9Th ixd) 29111EV riia2irn 26 b9boD 9Th 219111110

b9es9lDcii rbirlw II cxi 9lubsDolq 1i bsnsrb .2.J.t4 9rlT .( 9ldsT cii e9Idshsv 199169 9111 bo cii .eIsrbs9i moll bsiD9ffoD noiisrmomni boh9q srrnl 916mq92 cxi nhobs1 d "sq bo sisi" 9111

Jnsm\(olqm9-119e cnoil isrIi 29b1119x9 EWIims9 .2.J.14 bris .2.93 sill r{fod

Page 51: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

9IdET ..JI4 r1i m n9moW 9isubsrO 991ioD noms insrnnisflA 199mJ

rodfiI 9cIi cr1 1oorbe 2Th9X f � riliw nsmow sin-lw no1 issii nkriisii 96insxnsI .A 88Q1 8Qt 82I 9Y101

tniorktiw rI9mOW nsiblkrD

riiiw nsrnoW IflioT rrsthlirlD

o\o 88I 8Qt :rssm o\0I o\°E 8Qt 82I :ssmJ

88Qf

loorbe 2Th9X M � rliiw fI9ffIOW siirlw tol 199Th) rnrn6fl6 9SifI9D19 a noiiqbiimq sxroI todsi no Isnoiithnonu

iuorliiw nsrnoW ristblirlD

rliiw rxsmoW IflioT nsiblirD

o\04 88Q1 8Qt :t99mD

\0 o\o81 o\0 8Q1 :tssmD 88Q I

.nsriioW nuoY .e.J.W :9DtuO

slsm 9liinsDt9q r1i srli lo isrli nib99Dxs riirriss yhuorl thv&1 s bsthlsb 2i 199tSJ :291011

9Th II9fflOW ..JJ4 .(I 9ldfiT 992) tiss irivslst sill lo .e,ij 9(11 cr1 (niloorbe 2Th9X f � sii(1w) svfic1 bnf; (8821 bns '8Q1 %9) bslsbienoD 21691( srli lo 116 tol 9Iqrnse sill iii 9Th 19fli Ii bsbulDrlI bins toistsmun clod moil bsbubx9 9Th bsolqms-11s 9rlT .nieim ion sm usd1 slsb nfmss

mod nstblirlD risrl no 2noii2SLrp 19W21Th 01 bseulst orlw seOrli 9Th 26 TOI6rumon9b (82f 191113 2r11tid-1e1i1 I 'lno 9Th 9r9r11 rluor1i1s j221) X9VIU2 srIi 10 bns 9111 lilnu nsmow ol

O19 S 9V1 noiisqnthsq 9)101 rod6I no lsnoiiibnonu sm isrli esruñ silT .bsbubth 916 nsmoW .b9tsbi2no 2Th9'( sill lo 'ti6 iii SYIOI rods! sill lo hjo 9Th otlw nsrnow tol 199Th) 01

to dsi sill 10 Iuo 9d oi bslsbi2rloD 9Th 96W rnumiciim sill \ I wolsd 9Th aitimss XIIEJOI{ 920(1W rodsl no lsnoiiibno Essur19)19q 19916) 9i11 9)101 10d61 srI cii bsbubrii nssd sd1 bnsH .9)101 9)101 rods! no lsnoilibnonu 920111 01 19201) brrs tswol ttsrlwsmo2 9d bluow noiusqiDdmq sDroI

.noiisqiDriThq

Page 52: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

bLoG22Jou9J' 9Uq 9LW 1JC0W6wcfrxqGq u JJ6 69WTU2 E'W 2 p& L69f6 o ii& uq 2gJgLX' uq pn2!u622'MOWGU 1J JJ6 4T MjJO M6L6 26J-6wLJ0X6q iiq 0f6L2 M}J UJT22IJ 011L2 !T40LUJ90U 91.6P0fl1.I M96 JJJ6 Cf1-0 boWf (1262 11J6 q& 0L UJ6IJ III JPPI6 f Wflbp6q p? 'ooo JJ0r1L2

14062: 66 J9pJ62 f 2 fiG 6IJI0U 01 C9L66L (12W WCOUJG !2 21Uj91. tO J9I fl2W tP6

0r1LC6: ira A0flU MOUJ6U

(i'i = 211)fl21TJ H0(1LJA M96 tA1692f11.6:

Jg8 (14 = 211)fl21TJ JUCOWG J/J692flL6: J'

J2' Jà' Th (i =fl2!IJ HOflLIX M96 y692nL6:

C9L661. 140

12 1' (i'i = 22)fl2ThJ JUCOUJG At692fl1.6:

b9t1!1X C91.661. 01. COIJOI4 I/\ fl21J L°111. D6WJWOU2 0 IJq iJJ6 41jgpJG

140

A62

C9L661. 140

140 !2E9JJJTA

140

E9UJ!JX

140

140 J(2

E9UJTIX

140

E9TJJJJX

Page 53: oqpu - National Bureau of Economic Research · 9111 e9i6ub61 lo si-li iesq 9b6D9b ffl992 6 11191110)2kb .quo'1 . 9sl1oD simbrisiiA him noiiEubs'1D SISU iol nsM bi-is nscnoW 910198

OL JJ6 bGc6qw copol4 pJf (-) w m� uq (o-ti)?iwi�n&q oi copo pow uc bLo6c!ou M6L6 wq& o oi ou p& pg o cpuju p4n9jJI. H cs oujA q& isLou2ci o uquqnj o OL 22 X69L2 ojq M6LG

0WC6' 4ofl q6y&juw6u IJ 1JJ6 flIJJl6q 9f6' AguOn UrrnJp6L' (9jJju4Ou' DC COA6WW6IJ JMU1U2onLc6: fl B69 O IIJ6 C6LI CnLI4 bObflj9OU j�6b0L12' 6I4G b-SO' qncpouj

WO1CTOU O Oi OIJ flJG 6XB6q6UC6 O JJ6 bL6AJOfl copoi.

Jà229 Of 2t0 JOJ2'f9 22 2 5W1 TO 2T2O 2� 22 5WJMI 25 22O1M2 2O� T'f

TfO TmT20 115

T3 5'f S HO 2 2gT3O T 501 115 2Q 133

3JÔ 15 55R JO 5 22Jô5'f2 T�O 2J HIT502 52f T T 22 110JT82 TQ �1 2 1181à122 500 J10 TQ 110

5O\ 110 J2 01a152 JI JT 88 WaTOW2 IWS TOTôO2 TT T8 8 80 10TOT2 T't 102 J28TO52 128 12"f TWO

TTf 28 118T8O2 2 20 8J882 à1 10018802 �5 T T J2

22 50 8Q 2 18GL COH66 C0ll66 C0II66 COI16 (a)\(T) (i)\(s) ()\(a)

yf46uqiu qriju yuqm ()\Q)-b6LC6U bGLC6IJf j,GLCGUf EGLC6UI

U) (s) (a) () (2) () ()M1JiI6 yI9II6 h6W9I

L9PI yj: C0ll66 yff6uquc6 uq i.qn914ou I962 pX x' oi COPOL ow I82 O T22