49

Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 2: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 3: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 4: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 5: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 6: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 7: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a

150 to 170 kiloton nuclear

punch

It’s about the size of an office trash can

Let’s start with a

modern nuclear weapon

Here’s one – this is a US

W80-1 thermonuclear

warhead

It’s about 800mm long by

300mm diameter and weighs 130kg

Page 8: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 9: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 10: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 11: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 12: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 13: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 14: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 15: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 16: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Here’s a button, let’s

see if it works!

Page 17: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Let’s click through

that sequence!

Page 18: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

So, basically, the trick is to compress a

fissile material

down to its critical mass very quickly

There is another way to achieve a critical mass

but it requires a different

fissile material

Page 19: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 20: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

950mm100mm

110kg

Page 21: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

This baby is the US W79 with

dial-a-yield of 2 to 10 kilotons – wanna see it go

nuke ?

and it converts with a tritium boost to an enhanced

radiation or neutron bomb

Page 22: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 23: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

So, Iran’s nuclear weapon development

relates to its procurement of these IAEA SAFEGUARDED

materials

Page 24: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Only LEU

This is what Iran claims to

have capacity

for

Zirconium for its Bushehr

fuel fabrication plans

Depleted uranium

from reactor

fuel enrichme

nt

No plutoniu

mBUT the IAEA found several milligrams of

plutonium nitrate from extraction

activities during 1988 and 1992

No polonium

BUT the IAEA found traces of

polonium in 1993

TritiumNothing much to speak of

Only Low Enriched Uranium for the

Bushehr and Tehran

reactor fuel

development

BUT the IAEA found several

particles of HEU in cascades in

2003 – this led to the current IAEA-IRAN

crisis.

So let’s examine

those areas where the IAEA and

Iran are in dispute

Page 25: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

If so, that’s a lot of trouble and expense from

mining to fuel in the reactor

Iran claims its enrichment

programme is solely for the civil nuclear reactor at Bushehr

Page 26: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

From the cooling capacity you can backtrack to the

size of the enrichment

cascades which, here, is about

30,000 centrifuge units

Page 27: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 28: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

So, if the IAEA

cannot access the

Natanz plant it looks at

the radioactive waste

for traces of HEU

This is what

caused the IAEA-Iran

spat in 2003 when the IAEA

found >36% HEU particles at Kalaye

The IAEA’s concern is that

HEU can be diverted at

Natanz

Page 29: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

say by 2007

100kg/y - 2009 small scale small scale

Now we can fill in IRAN’s DU and

HEU capacity

Page 30: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Now let’s look at Iran’s progress

with materials for the compression

weapon

Page 31: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

For this route, fissile plutonium has to be

extracted from natural uranium U-238 irradiated in a

reactor

So the IAEA require the Bushehr fuel to be supplied by and

RETURNED to Russia

RU

SS

IAN

FED

ER

ATIO

NR

US

SIA

N F

ED

ER

ATIO

N

Iran could do this by reprocessing the uranium fuel from

Bushehr

Page 32: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

So, to overcome this, Iran builds a new, high capacity research reactor,

thereby bypassing Bushehr

To separate the

plutonium from the fuel

a small reprocessing

plant

A plant to provide the

Heavy Water for the reactor

The ARAK Heavy Water plant was

started this year, it produces ~10 to 15 tonnes HW per year

and the RD-40 reactor requires an initial 60-80 tonnes – so 4 to 5

years before it is commissioned

Page 33: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 34: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

say by 2007 10kg/y - 2010

100kg/y - 2009 small scale small scale

Now we can fill in IRAN’s

plutonium capacity

Page 35: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

say by 2007 10kg/y - 2010

100kg/y - 2009 small scale small scale

The RD-40 reactor will also

provide a Polonium-

210 generator

Page 36: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

say by 2007 10kg/y - 2010 now TRCR by 2010 100kg/y - 2009 small scale small scale

And the heavy water

moderator is a rich

source of tritium

Page 37: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Let’s compare the Iran, North Korea and Israel nuclear

programmesIran’s programme is dual-role and

complex

Bushehr and Tehran reactors are safeguarded

under IAEA

Page 38: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Economy Model

No Frills

One Track Military

Page 39: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

One Track Military

Sophisticated

Thermonuclear

Page 40: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 41: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Iran has experimented

with and is now building

the technology – so when will it break out?

Page 42: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

MUCH OF THIS

MATERIALS TECHNOLOGY IN PLACE AT

ESFAHAN

TROUBLE AT NATANZ

WITH MULTIPLE CASCADES

TAKE TEHRAN REACTOR OUT

OF SAFEGUARDS OR WAIT FOR

RD-40 AT ARAK

COULD BE PROCURED

AND POLISHED AT ESFAHAN

WAIT FOR ARAK RD-40 REACTOR TO COMMISSION

Page 43: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

Well, what’s

it to be ?

Is IRAN on a dash

for nuclear

weapons

Or is it a confused

civil nuclear power

programme?

Remember what the US

and Brits concluded

about Iraq’s WMD !

Whatever, one outcome is

there is now to be UN Security

Council sanctions

against Iran

Page 44: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

}

Page 45: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 46: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 47: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear
Page 48: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear

It may be that the risk is not be

directly with Iran’s nuclear

weapons programme but, because of UN sanctions, a

breakdown of nuclear safety at

Bushehr!

Page 49: Oh, I almost forgot, it packs a 150 to 170 kiloton nuclear punch It’s about the size of an office trash can Let’s start with a modern nuclear