60
O tlin ICMS ICMS-ICMR Winterschool on Chemistry and Physics of Materials, Nov. 6 ICMR Winterschool on Chemistry and Physics of Materials, Nov. 6-13, 2007, Bangalore 13, 2007, Bangalore 1. Introduction Brief history of molecular magnetism [1-6] Outline 2. Mononuclear species (complexes) 2.1. Prequisites : free ion terms, states, orbitals and ligand field. Point Group Symmetry 2.2. Metal-ligand interaction to tune electronic structure. 2.3. Spin states, spin cross-over, devices [7] 3. Magnetism of molecular assemblies in interaction. Polynuclear complexes l h l l d l h 3.1. Interaction between two electrons : phenomenological and orbital approaches 3.2. Interaction Models [1] Kahn ; comparison with Hoffmann (molecules) Comparison with Anderson, Goodenough-Kanamori (solids) 3.3. Case studies : Binuclear complexes [1 5] Binuclear complexes [1,5] Ferrimagnetic chains [1,5] Molecule-based magnets ; devices [8] 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets [9] Molecular, "bottom-up", approach of nanosystems, highspin molecules The "Mn 12 " and "Fe8" molecules Local anisotropy ; magnetic quantum tunneling effect. 5. Prospects Multifunctional materials [10] Magnetism of a single molecule ; Information storage. Electronic quantum computing Magnetism of a single molecule ; Information storage. Electronic quantum computing

O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

O tlin

ICMSICMS--ICMR Winterschool on Chemistry and Physics of Materials, Nov. 6ICMR Winterschool on Chemistry and Physics of Materials, Nov. 6--13, 2007, Bangalore13, 2007, Bangalore

1. IntroductionBrief history of molecular magnetism [1-6]

Outline

Brief history of molecular magnetism [ 6]2. Mononuclear species (complexes)2.1. Prequisites : free ion terms, states, orbitals and ligand field. Point Group Symmetry2.2. Metal-ligand interaction to tune electronic structure.2.3. Spin states, spin cross-over, devices [7]3. Magnetism of molecular assemblies in interaction. Polynuclear complexes

l h l l d l h3.1. Interaction between two electrons : phenomenological and orbital approaches3.2. Interaction Models [1]

Kahn ; comparison with Hoffmann (molecules)Comparison with Anderson, Goodenough-Kanamori (solids)

3.3. Case studies :Binuclear complexes [1 5]Binuclear complexes [1,5]Ferrimagnetic chains [1,5]Molecule-based magnets ; devices [8]

4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction :Single-molecule, single-chain magnets [9]Molecular, "bottom-up", approach of nanosystems, high spin molecules, p , pp y , g pThe "Mn12" and "Fe8" moleculesLocal anisotropy ; magnetic quantum tunneling effect.

5. ProspectsMultifunctional materials [10]Magnetism of a single molecule ; Information storage. Electronic quantum computingMagnetism of a single molecule ; Information storage. Electronic quantum computing

Page 2: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

molecule-based magnets ? Why ?y

L d it

Specific propertiesLow densityTransparentNanosizedOften biocompatible and biodegradableVery flexible chemistryMild chemistry : Room T Room PMild chemistry : Room T, Room P, Solution Chemistry

Fragile Agingg gDiluted

Page 3: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Multifunctional materials

• Flexibility of molecular chemistryT bl St t d P tiTunable Structures and Properties

• Magnetic and optical propertiesMagnetic and optical propertiesColor, chirality, non linear optics

M ti d l t i l ti• Magnetic and electrical properties(Supra)Conducting magnetic materials

Page 4: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Conducting magnets See P. Day lecture Nº2

Coronado et al. Nature 2000

Page 5: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Multifunctional materials

• Interplay of Spin with Light

• Light reveals the spin (magnetisation) :

• Interplay of « Spin » with Light

Light reveals the spin (magnetisation) Photomagnetic Prussian Blues analoguesPhotomagnetic molecules

• The spin (magnetisation) transforms light :Magneto-opticsO i ll i MOptically active Magnets

Page 6: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Ph t tPhotomagnets

Transforming magnetism by light

J. Miró, Muro de Luna, Mural ceramics, UNESCO, Paris

Page 7: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Spin cross over

Page 8: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Photoexcitation … Jablonski Diagramme

Many things can happen after excitation …

EnergySinglet Spin = 0

Intersystem crossinggy

Triplet Spin = 1hνIntersystem crossing

hν ‘

hν ‘’

Singlet Spin = 0

Coordinate

Page 9: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Photomagnetism in coordination chemistry• LIESST Effect • LD-LISC Effect• LIESST Effect

Light-Induced Excited Spin State

HS

• LD LISC EffectLigand-Driven Light-Induced

Spin Change

HSHSHS HS

HSh

LShν

L

D ti t l I Ch 1984 24 2174

LS

R t l I Ch 1994 33 2273

LS

Decurtins et al. Inorg. Chem., 1984, 24, 2174.

NN322 nm

Roux et al. Inorg. Chem., 1994, 33, 2273.

FeII(BS) → FeII(HS)hν

T < 50 K260 nm

Trans-StpyFeII(BS)

Cis-StpyFeII(HS)T < 90 K

Page 10: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

« L.I.E.S.S.T. » Effect

LightInducedExcitedSpin StateStateTrapping

J.

Page 11: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

« L.I.E.S.S.T. » Effect , Interpretation

P. Gütlich et al. et al., Angewandte Chem., 1994

Page 12: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Photoexcitation …

ESpin = 0

Many things can happen after excitation …

Energy

Spin = 1

Intersystem crossing

Metastable state(s)

Spin = 1

M ( )

• LIESST EffectLi h I d d E i d S i SSpin 1

Spin = 0

Light-Induced Excited Spin State

• LD-LISC Effect

CoordinateLigand-Driven Light-Induced Spin Change

S.Decurtins, A. Hauser, P. Gutlich Inorg. Chem. 1984, 24, 2174C. Roux, J. Zarembovitch et al. Inorg. Chem. 1994, 33, 2273

Page 13: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Gymkhana campus Bangalore, December 8, 2007

Page 14: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

1) Ph t ti1) Photomagnetism= Transforming magnetism by light

2) Magneto optics2) Magneto-optics= Transforming light by magnetism

3) Applications3) Applications= Writing and reading

magnetic information with lightmagnetic information with light

Page 15: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

What about the 8 branches star?What about the 8 branches star?Octacyano Complex ?

PolynuclearComplexp

Page 16: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Interaction with lightOctacyanometalate Precursors Heptanuclear Complexes

WIVC II WIVNiII WIVM IIWIVCuII6

MoIVCuII6

WIVNiII6MoIVNiII6

Monoclinic P na = 24 89 Å; b = 14 39 Å; c = 30 11 Å

Monoclinic 22 03 Å b 28 39 Å 22 01 Å

Monoclinic C ca = 25 39 Å; b = 15 22 Å; c = 30 72 Å

WIVMnII6

MoIVMnII6

a = 24.89 Å; b = 14,39 Å; c = 30,11 Åa = g = 90°; b = 108.81°;

a = 22.03 Å; b = 28,39 Å; c = 22,01 Åa = g = 90°; b =99.48°;

a = 25.39 Å; b = 15,22 Å; c = 30,72 Åa = g = 90°; b = 111.45°;

V. Marvaud, J.M. Herrera, work in progress

Page 17: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

MoCu6 : Photomagnetic high spin molecule

hν (=405 nm), 19 h 5 K 5,0

6 x S = 1/2

S = 364 % S = 3

After hν

After hv and T> 300 K

Before hν4,0

4,5

mol

-1.K

)

h

3,0

3,5

χT (c

m3 .m hν406 nm

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

2,5H = 20000 G

T (K)

Collaboration: C. Mathonière, ICMC Bordeaux

Page 18: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Photo-induced electron transferPhoto-induced electron transfer

MoIV CuIIhν MoV CuI

5

MoIVCuII MoVCuI CuII

+5 +5

Mo VCu 6 MoVCu 1Cu 5MoV, d1 , S=1/2

Ferro interaction …MoIV, d2 , S=0No exchangeNo exchange6 isolated S=1/2 S=3

Page 19: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

10

12

MoCu6BT avant Ir

Evolution de MoCu6 avant Ir, apres Ir et apres relaxation

8

10 MoCu6BT, avant Ir

MoCu6BTI2, apres Ir

RT Apres relaxation

4

6

Abs

orba

nce

2

4

0

2510 2520 2530 2540 2550 2560

EnergieEnergie

From V. Marvaud, F, Villain, A. Bachschmidt, Elettra, Triesta

Page 20: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

MoCu6 : Magnetization under Irradiation in a microSQUID

4

60.008 T/s

2

4

B

0

M/N

µ B

-4

-2 0.04 K0.5 K1 K2 K

0.04 K0.5 K1 K2 K

0 h 10 h

-6-1 -0 5 0 0 5 1

2 K4 K

2 K4 K

1 0.5 0 0.5 1µ0 H (T)

V. Marvaud and Wernsdorfer, Louis Néel Laboratory, Grenoble

Page 21: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Looking at ther Mo-Cu compounds (also W analogues)

Monoclinic P 21/ca = 10.514 Å; b = 14.584 Å; c = 22.182 Åα = γ = 90°; β = 96 18°; V= 3381 4 Å3

MoIVCu2-(tren)

Monoclinic P 21/aa = 14.790 Å; b = 15.901 Å; c = �18.395 Å

MoVCu (AF, S=0)

α = γ = 90 ; β = 96.18 ; V= 3381.4 Å3

MoVCu4

α = γ = 90°; β = 109.208°; V= 4085.2 Å3

Orthorhombic P bcma = 10.388 Å; b =22.000 Å; c = �30.172 Å

α = β = γ = 90°; V= 6895.4 Å3

NH2

N NH2

H2N

MoIVCu6-(TPA)

Monoclinica = 27.0�95 Å; b = 17.13�5 Å; c = 33.172 Å

α = γ = 90°; β = 66.42°; V= 14114 Å3

NH2 H2N

li i 21/

N

N N

N

MoIVCu6

Monoclinic P na = 24.89 Å; b = 14,39 Å; c = 30,11 Å

α = γ = 90°; β = 108.81°;

Monoclinic P 21/na = 14.292 Å; b = 24,554 Å; c = 15,017 Åα = γ = 90°; β = 108.78°; V=4989.6 Å3MoIVCu6-Cis

TPA

Work by V. Marvaud et al.

Page 22: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Theoretical Study (DFT)Theoretical Study (DFT)

Collaboration : J.Tercero, E. Ruiz, S. AlvarezBarcelona University

Page 23: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Molecular Orbitals [Mo(V)(CN) ]3- (DFT)[Mo(V)(CN)8]3 (DFT)

Mo Square Antiprism Mo DodecahedronMo Square Antiprismd z2

Mo Dodecahedrond x2 -y 2

Page 24: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Molecular Orbitals for a pair[Mo(V)(CN) ] CN Cu(II)[Mo(V)(CN)7]-CN-Cu(II)

Dinuclear MoCu square antiprism Dinuclear MoCu dodecahedron

Page 25: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

3,00000

SAP CSM - (Photo)MagnetismAntiprism

2,50000 WIVCu2SAPR

Antiprism

2,000001MoIVCu6FM

MoVCuAF

1'WVCuAFMoIVCu6FM(Trifl)

1'MoIVCu6FM

WIVCu4FM

1WVCuAF

1,50000Est1

2MoIVCu6FM

CuWV5 FMMoVCuFM(cyc)

MoIVCu2(en)N3D

1 Mo Cu6FM

2'MoIVCu6FM

Photomagnetism

0 50000

1,00000

Est2 MoIVCu6(Tpa) Dodecahedron

0,00000

0,50000

Est3DD

MoIVCu2

MoIVCu2(cyc)N2D

MoIVCuAF(bipy)

Dodecahedron

,0,00000 0,50000 1,00000 1,50000 2,00000 2,50000 3,00000 DD

Page 26: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

in Prussian blue analogues … (3D) g ( )

Photomagnetism

C III F II [(C II(HS)F III(BS)]*hν

CoIII-FeII ⇒ [(CoII(HS)FeIII(BS)]*diamagnetic pairs paramagnetic

3D ferrimagneticbelow TCbelow TC

Hashimoto et al., Science, 1996 ; Verdaguer, Science, 1996

Page 27: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Photomagnets Cobalt-Iron Prussian blue analogues

The properties are deeply modified by the insertion of alkali cations

Co4[FeIII(CN)6]8/3•nH2O Cs2CoIII10/3CoII

2/3[FeII(CN)6]10/3 Cs4CoIII4[FeII(CN)6

8

on /

10-3

em

u

No effect of light

on /1

0-3

emu

neti

zati

on 1

0-4 /e

mu

4

4

2.5

Very small effect of light

n /1

0-3

emu4

h

0

4

5 10 15 20 25

Mag

neti

zatio

Mag

netiz

atio

Temperature /K

Mag

n

248 12 16 20

0

2

8 12 16 20 24

1

Temperatu re /K

Mag

netiz

atio

n

0

2

8 12 16 20 24T t /K

Temperature /K Temperature /KTemperature /K

Under pressure V. Ksenofontov P. Gütlich, A. Bleuzen et al. Phys. Rev. B, 2003, 68, 0244151-6A. Bleuzen et al. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 2004, 43, 3728.

Page 28: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Synthesis.[FeIII(CN)6]3- + [CoII(H2O)6]2+ + C+ (C+=K+, Rb+, Cs+)

increasing size of the cation C

Rb1.8Co4[Fe(CN)6]3.30 13H2O Cs3.7Co4[Fe(CN)6]3.7 9.2H2OK0.1Co4[Fe(CN)6]2.8 18.4H2O

increasing size of the cation C

K+ Rb+ Cs+

O

O

O

O

OO

O

O

Fe/Co 0.70 0.83 0.93

IIIN C-N

C-N O

O

O

O

O

O

O

O

N

Co ligand field

CoIII -FeII

rally induced CoIIN4O2

CoIIIN6

a = 10.04 ± 0.05 Å

a 10 36 ± 0 05 Å

Co

N

N N

NN

N

Co

N

N O

O

CoII-FeIIIstructurally ind

electron transfera = 10.36 ± 0.05 Å

∆ 0 3 ÅN

N

O ∆a = 0.3 Å

Page 29: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Formation of CoIII-FeII pairs …I ti f lk li tiInsertion of alkali cation …

1) + n C+

Fe(CN)6

2) + n/3 [Fe(CN)6]3-

O

OO

O

OO

OO

O

OO

O

Fe(CN)6Co

H2OC N

OO

O

O

O

O

Co(NC)4+n/2(OH2)2-n/2

C-N O

• Insertion of C+ increases the ligand field ∆Co of Co(II)g Co ( )

Page 30: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Cobalt(II) : Ligand Field, spin state, geometry and reactivity

H O OHOH2

NC CNCN

CN NCNC

H2OCo

H2O OH2

OH2OH2

NCCo

NC CN

CNCN

CNCo

CN NC

OH2OH2OH2 CN

E² ² t

OH2

²² oct oct² oct

Strong FieldIntermediate FieldWeak Field Strong FieldLow SpinS = 1/2

Very Reducing Short Co-C

Intermediate Field Spin Transition ?

S = 3/2 or 1/2Reducing

Weak FieldHigh SpinS = 3/2Long Co-O Very Reducing Short Co CReducingLong Co O

Page 31: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

CN

Origin of the diamagnetic pairs in Co-Fe Prussian Blues

NC FeIIINC CN

CN

CN

C NC FeIINC CN

CN

CNCoII

CN N

OH2

CNCN

C

CNCoIII

CN N

OH

NC FeII

CNCN

C215 pm

195 pm2

OH2

CN OH2OH2

E eg*e * El fAntibonding ! g

t2gt2g

eg* Electron transferAntibonding !

2g2g

HS CoII LS FeIII LS CoIII LS FeII

Paramagnetic : 3/2, 1/2 Diamagnetic : 0, 0Paramagnetic 3/2, 1/2 Diamagnetic 0, 0Distance CoIINeighbours ­ 215 pm Distance CoIINeighbours ­ 195 pm

Page 32: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Photo-induced electron transfer L l t t d C

• Photo-induced electron transfer = important dilation of the network

Local structure around Co.p

Rb1.8Co4[Fe(CN)6]3.30 Cs3.7Co4[Fe(CN)6]3.7hν =

defects = strains relaxation easy dilation

dilation strong strains very small effect of light

Rb C• Excited pairs CoII-NC-FeIII - same electronic structure - same local structure

Rb2 Cs4

as CoII-NC-FeIII pairs in K0.1Co4[Fe(CN)6]2.8

Page 33: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Oxidation StateOxidation StateXANES at the Co K edge : 1s2 4p 1s1 4p1

[CoII(OH2)6]2+

orba

nce

/a.u

.

1

23

K+

Rb+

Cs+

CoII

CoIII ]

Abs

o

[CoIII(CN)6]3-

Cs

• K0.1CoII4[FeIII(CN)6]2.8 18.4H2O

7700 7720 7740 7760 7780 7800Energy /eV

• Rb1.8CoII0.7CoIII

3.30[FeII(CN)6]3.30 13H2O • Cs3.9CoIII

4[FeII(CN)6]3.9 9.2H2O

Page 34: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Photoinduced electron transfer …hν

Spin = 0Intersystem crossing

[Co(II)-Fe(III)]*Co(III)-Fe(II)hν

Spin = 1

Energy Intersystem crossing+ Electron transfer

Spin = 1 Metastable stateSpin 1

Spin = 0 Co Fe distance

Metastable state

Pair : Paramagnetic3D : FerrimagneticCo-Fe distance 3D : Ferrimagnetic

Co(III)-Fe(II)

Diamagnetic

[Co(II)-Fe(III)]*

ParamagneticDiamagnetic Paramagnetic

Page 35: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Towards devices … ?

Magneto-opticsg pHow magnetism transforms light …g g

Page 36: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

1

Eff

et

0

0,005

0,01

0,015

2 he res

Faible flux lumineuxP = 0.7 mW /mm2Spot du�

laserMagneto-optics

Le composˇ est initialement faiblement paramagnˇ tique�Le syst me ne transite pas sous faible flux lumineux

Champ /Oe

-0,015

-0,01

-0,005

-8000 -6000 -4000-2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000

2 heures

Echantillon Reading

Le syst¸ me ne transite pas sous faible flux lumineux

0,005

0,01

0,015

Fort flux lumineux0 / 2S t d �

2 Writing

-4000 -3000- 2000 -1000 0 1000 2000 3000 4000

Champ /Oe

Eff

et

-0,015

-0,01

-0,005

0

2 heuresP = 70 mW /mm2

Au même point de

l'échantillon

Spot du�laser

Echantillon

Example of a+ Reading

Le syst¸ me transite sous fort flux lumineux = ECRITURE

0,0153

Example of aphotomagneticerasable

d it blAu même point de

l'échantillon

Spot du�laser

Echantillon

Eff

et

-0,015

-0,01

-0,005

0

0,005

0,01Faible flux lumineux

2 heuresP = 0.7 mW /mm2

3and rewritablememory

ReadingEchantillon

Champ /Oe-4000 -3000- 2000 -1000 0 1000 2000 3000 4000

Le signal dichro•que est tr¸ s faible : une partie des paires excitˇes relaxent

LECTURE

Coll. J. Ferré, J.P. Jamet, LPS Orsay

g

Page 37: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Next step : going to nanosize

200 200 nm200 nm

x 23000 nanometricr anisati n

200 nm

nanoparticles organisationof particles

A. Bleuzen, LCI Orsay, private communication

Page 38: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Work in progress : Magnetization of a few nanoparticles of CoFe Prussian Blue analogues, microSQUID, 4 K, under irradiaction

14 K

g , Q , ,

0.5

4 K

A50

00 min

M/M

s

irradiation with white light

-0.5

0 min1 min5 min20 min30 min70 min100 min3 h

-1-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1

3 h4 h12 h

µ0 H (T)µ0 ( )

(A. Bleuzen, W. Werndorfer)

Page 39: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach
Page 40: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Chi l M tChiral Magnets

Page 41: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Optically Active Magnets : Why ?

θθn

εn-θn

M

M

θm

εm-θm

-εnCotton Effect Faraday Effect

M-εm

Cotton : breaking of space symmetryFaraday : breaking of time symmetry

Formal Similarity of Faraday and Cotton Effects

Page 42: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

MichaelMichaelMichaelMichaelFaradayFaraday ……FaradayFaraday ……1791-1867Fullerian Professor of Chemistry1833-1867

Page 43: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

andand…… and and AiméAiméAiméAimé

CottonCotton

1869 - 1951French PhysicistOptical Physics

Circular dichroïsmCircular dichroïsm

Page 44: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

What is new with Optically Active Magnets ?

Breaking of space and time symmetry

Cross-effect MagnetoCHiral Dichroism (MChD)

Unpolarised light

k Id+

contributionγd(ω)k.M

to theUnpolarised light

k Id-

dielectric tensor

L.D. Barron, J. Vrbancich, Mol. Phys. 51 (1984) 715

Page 45: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Magnetochiral Dichroism (MChD) :

µ(k,M,ω) = αd,l(ω)k + β(ω)M + γd,l(ω)k.M

CottonChi lit

FaradayM ti ti

Cross-Term2 d dChirality Magnetisation 2nd order(MChD)

k light wave vectorM magnetisation

Cf Barron, Rikken ...

Page 46: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Oxalate ligand1. Bis-Chelating

2 Stable (and inert) precursors complexes2. Stable (and inert) precursors complexes

3. Complexes as ligands

O

O

M'O

O

OM

O O

O

OO

O

O

M'O

MO O

O

OO

O

O

O

O

O

1 O OO

O

OO

M' 3

OO

O 21

Chiral complex

Page 47: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

STRUCTURES OF 2D and 3D NETWORKS

Λ∆

ΛOO

MM1

L. Atovmyan et al, JETP Lett. 1993, 58, 766

2D∆∆

ΛOO

M2M1

∆ − Λ

Heterochiral Honeycomb Plane 2D Materials∆-Λ

Heterochiral Honeycomb Plane 2D Materials

ΛΛΛ

Λ ΛΛ

S. Decurtins et al, Inorg. Chem.1993, 32, 1888

3DO

O

O

O

M2M1

Λ − Λ or ∆ − ∆

Λ ΛΛ

ΛΛ 3D

Λ-Λ ou ∆-∆Λ Λ or ∆ ∆Homochiral Helix Structure 3D Materials

Interconnected helices

Λ-Λ ou ∆-∆

Fabrice Pointillart, Ph.D ThesisFabrice Pointillart, Ph.D Thesis

Page 48: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

A very useful cation for chiral design

∆-[RuII(bpy)2(ppy)]+

• dimension• D3 Symmetry• Charge : +1g

ll lé

Cf Clément et al., Monatsh. Chem. 497 (2002), 117

Gruselle, Malézieux, Brissard …

Page 49: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

BUILDING the 3D NETWORKS. Decurtins et al, Inorg. Chem. 1993, 32, 1888 R. Andrès et al, Inorg. Chem. 1999, 38, 4637 , g , ,

R. Andrès et al. Inorg. Chem. 2001, 40, 4633

The anionic subnetwork WRAPS around the assembling cation [Ru(bpy)3]2+

Page 50: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Helix PHelix M

STRUCTURES of 3D NETWORKSeHelix M

(P)(M)

Anionic Subnetwork Cationic Subnetwork[M(L)3]n+

- Cation Symmetry D3

Charge and

[MaMb(ox)3]n-

- Charge and size ad hoc

Page 51: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

INDUCING CHIRALITY

Ru – N : 2,063(5) Å

{[RuΛ(bpy)3][Mn2Λ(ox)3]}n

Groupe d’espace : P4132

Mn – O1 : 2,135(5) Å

Mn – O2 : 2,169(5) Å

a = 15,508(1) Å

α = β = γ = 90°

{[Ru∆(bpy)3][Mn2∆(ox)3]}n

Groupe d’espace : P4332

a = 15,492(2) Å

Ru – N : 2,059(4) Å

Mn – O1 : 2,167(5) Å

α = β = γ = 90° Mn – O2 : 2,133(5) Å

The assembling chiral cation [Ru(bpy)3]2+ induces chirality on all the metallic centres of the anionic subnetwork

Page 52: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

[Ru(bpy)2 (ppy)][MnCr(ox)3][ ( py)2 (ppy)][ ( )3]

Page 53: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

They are chiralThrough resolved precursor [∆ or Λ MIII(ox)3]3-

NBu4[MnΛCr∆(ox)3]NBu4[MnΛCr∆(ox)3]

300

350

100

150

200

250

ΛCottonEffect

-100

-50

0

50

300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700

Effect

300

-250

-200

-150

-100

-350

-300

Wavelength / nm

Page 54: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

2D or 3D : Magnets below 10-20Kg

2 5

3.0

3.5

50

60

70

cm-3

1 5

2.0

2.52D-{MnCr}

20

30

40

M /

µ B

χ−1 /

mol

.c[Ru(bpy)3][ClO4][MnCr(ox)3][R (b ) ( )][M C ( ) ]

0 5

1.0

1.5

0 50 100 150 200 250 3000

10

T / K

M [Ru(bpy)2(ppy)][MnCr(ox)3][Ru(bpy)2(ppy)][NiCr(ox)3]

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

0.0

0.52D-{NiCr}

T / K0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

Page 55: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

TBAC NiO T 4 4K (l 580 )

Evidence of the MChD unpublished …3000 250

TBACrNiOx T= 4.4K (l=580 nm)

Phase Delta / °

Phase Lambda / ° ∆

2000

2500

200M Delta / ua

M Lambda / ua

Phase Lambda / °

Phase°a gr

ee

1500150

sign

al d

elta

/ua P

hase delta

≈ 180°

nal /

ua

se /

deg

500

1000100M

s/ °

Sign

Pha

Λ

00

0

0

50

-500 0-100 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700

H / mVC. Train, Coll. G. RikkenDFG MM SPP

Page 56: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Noyori museum, nagoya

Page 57: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

On the way to transparent single crystals(work in progress)(work in progress)

R. Gheorghe, M. Gruselle, C. Train

Page 58: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

1. (NH4)3[Cr(C2O4)3] + Mn(NO3)2+ ... 2. (NH4)3[Cr(C2O4)3] + Mn(NO3)2+ …

HCH3

CH3

+

H CH3CH3

+S+ R-N+ CH3

CH3

CH3

I- N+

CH3

CH3

CH3

I-S+ R-

NMePr2(S+)-secBuI NMePr2(R-)-secBuI

[NMePr2(S+)-secBu]3[Mn-∆-Cr(C2O4)3] [NMePr2(R-)-secBu]3[Mn-Λ-Cr(C2O4)3]

R. Gheorghe, M. Gruselle, C. Train

Page 59: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach

Structure of one of the enantiomers

Along a axis

Pl bHexagonalP 63 (no 173)Plane ab P 63 (no. 173)a = 9.4160 Åc = 16.8430 ÅVolume = 1293.11 Å3

Page 60: O tlin Outline 2007/Lectures/Michel 0 Bangal… · 4. Magnetism of molecules assemblies without interaction : Single-molecule, single-chain magnets[9] Molecular, "bottom-upp,", approach