4
Search All NYTimes.com Advertise on NYTimes.com Multimedia EXHIBITION REVIEW A Jewish Museum Shifts Identity Keegan Houser Magnes Collection of Jewish Art and Life A Bay Area museum is part of the University of California, Berkeley. Above left, Italian Book of Esther scroll; right, German Torah binder, both 18th century. More Photos » By EDWARD ROTHSTEIN Published: January 22, 2012 BERKELEY, Calif. — The story of how the Judah L. Magnes Museum — whose collection of Judaica is the third largest in the country — became the Magnes Collection of Jewish Art and Life at the Bancroft Library of the University of California, Berkeley , might not seem terribly ripe with complication or implication. In recent years small private museums facing financial strain have often sought refuge by negotiating new lives within universities. Perhaps on Sunday, when the Magnes opened its doors to the public in a building it had long owned near the campus here, it was simply inaugurating another phase of its 50-year life. But along the way the Magnes has had more than its share of high drama, including a much anticipated union with another local Jewish museum in 2002, closely followed by a quickie divorce on grounds of irreconcilable differences. Then, the Magnes had to watch as its onetime partner achieved local glory as the Contemporary Jewish Museum , opening in downtown San Francisco in 2008 in a new building designed by Daniel Libeskind . Meanwhile the Magnes struggled to map out a future for its rambling and exotic collection of some South Carolina’s Divisive Message Magnes Judaica Museum Joins Berkeley Library Review Log In With Advertise on N MOST E-MAILED MOST VIEW Log in to see what your friends are sharing on nytimes.com. Privacy Policy | What’s This? What’s Popular Now Ads by Google Eileen Fisher on Sale Save 40-70% Eileen Fisher Sweaters! All the Sales, Place. DesignerApparel.com/EileenFisher Clean your Mac Award-winning Clean-up utility for Top Performance Mac! MacKeeperapp.ZeoBIT.com Emeryville Lofts for Sale Photos, Pricing - Updated Daily! Loft & Modern Hom Specialists www.EastBayModern.com Cautionary tale 4 parents of autistic children who deal with unsympathetic syn drrws.com Ask Antique Art Appraiser An Art Appraiser Will Answer Now! Art Appraisals To Appraisals.JustAnswer.com/Art Vitamin D and Depression Learn About The Relationship Between Vitamin D & Now. www.chewonit.com 1. THE IECONOMY How the U.S. Lost Out on iPhon 2. Bird-Watchers Revel in Unusua Subscribe: Digital / Home Delivery Log In Registe HOME PAGE TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR TIMES TOPICS Art & Design WORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS REAL ESTA ART & DESIGN BOOKS DANCE MOVIES MUSIC TELEVISION THEATER VIDEO GAMES EVENTS RECOMMEND TWITTER LINKEDIN SIGN IN TO E- MAIL PRINT SINGLE PAGE REPRINTS SHARE

NYTimes - A Jewish Museum Shifts Identity by Edward Rothstein 01.22.2011

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/23/arts/design/magnes-judaica-museum-joins-berkeley-library-review.html

Citation preview

Page 1: NYTimes - A Jewish Museum Shifts Identity by Edward Rothstein 01.22.2011

Search All NYTimes.com

Advertise on NYTimes.com

Multimedia

EXHIBITION REVIEW

A Jewish Museum Shifts Identity

Keegan Houser

Magnes Collection of Jewish Art and Life A Bay Area museum is part of the University of California, Berkeley. Aboveleft, Italian Book of Esther scroll; right, German Torah binder, both 18th century. More Photos »

By EDWARD ROTHSTEINPublished: January 22, 2012

BERKELEY, Calif. — The story of how the Judah L. Magnes Museum— whose collection of Judaica is the third largest in the country —became the Magnes Collection of Jewish Art and Life at the BancroftLibrary of the University of California, Berkeley, might not seemterribly ripe with complication or implication. In recent years smallprivate museums facing financial strain have often sought refuge bynegotiating new lives within universities. Perhaps on Sunday, whenthe Magnes opened its doors to the public in a building it had longowned near the campus here, it was simply inaugurating anotherphase of its 50-year life.

But along the way the Magnes has hadmore than its share of high drama,including a much anticipated union

with another local Jewish museum in 2002, closely followed by a quickie divorce ongrounds of irreconcilable differences. Then, the Magnes had to watch as its onetimepartner achieved local glory as the Contemporary Jewish Museum, opening in downtownSan Francisco in 2008 in a new building designed by Daniel Libeskind. Meanwhile theMagnes struggled to map out a future for its rambling and exotic collection of some

South Carolina’sDivisive Message

Magnes JudaicaMuseum JoinsBerkeley Library -Review

Log In With Facebook

Advertise on NYTimes.com

MOST E-MAILED MOST VIEWED

Log in to see what your friendsare sharing on nytimes.com.Privacy Policy | What’s This?

What’s Popular Now

Ads by Google

Eileen Fisher on SaleSave 40-70% Eileen Fisher Sweaters! All the Sales, All in OnePlace.DesignerApparel.com/EileenFisher

Clean your MacAward-winning Clean-up utility for Top Performance of yourMac!MacKeeperapp.ZeoBIT.com

Emeryville Lofts for SalePhotos, Pricing - Updated Daily! Loft & Modern HomeSpecialistswww.EastBayModern.com

Cautionary tale 4 parentsof autistic children who deal with unsympathetic synagogues.drrws.com

Ask Antique Art AppraiserAn Art Appraiser Will Answer Now! Art Appraisals Today: 35Appraisals.JustAnswer.com/Art

Vitamin D and DepressionLearn About The Relationship Between Vitamin D & DepressionNow.www.chewonit.com

1. THE IECONOMYHow the U.S. Lost Out on iPhone Work

2. Bird-Watchers Revel in Unusual Spike in

Subscribe: Digital / Home Delivery Log In Register NowHOME PAGE TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR TIMES TOPICS

Art & DesignWORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS REAL ESTATE

ART & DESIGN BOOKS DANCE MOVIES MUSIC TELEVISION THEATER VIDEO GAMES EVENTS

RECOMMEND

TWITTER

LINKEDIN

SIGN IN TO E-MAIL

PRINT

SINGLE PAGE

REPRINTS

SHARE

Page 2: NYTimes - A Jewish Museum Shifts Identity by Edward Rothstein 01.22.2011

Magnes Collection of Jewish Artand Life

Breaking news about the arts,coverage of live events, criticalreviews, multimedia and more.

Go to Arts Beat »

A sortable calendar of noteworthycultural events in the New Yorkregion, selected by Times critics.

Go to Event Listings »

15,000 objects and manuscripts, which since 1966 had beenhoused in a rambling and exotic mansion on a residentialstreet. It attracted no more than 10,000 visitors annuallyand cost $2 million a year to maintain.

The story also has larger resonance. The fate of the Magneshas much to do with the evolution of the American identitymuseum, with its chronicles of ethnic liberation amidhardship. And it is also intimately connected to the politicaland cultural temperament of the Bay Area.

But to understand those issues it is best, first, to considerthe collection itself. The Magnes was created in 1962 bySeymour Fromer, a Jewish educator, and Rebecca CamhiFromer, his wife. Its artifacts were deliberately wide-ranging, including not just Jewish ritual objects butmanuscripts, music and ephemera. As the collections grewthey shed light on Jewish life in the pioneering era of theAmerican West, on Jewish observance in communities inIndia or Tunisia, and on artworks that testified in someway to Jewish experience in the 20th century. Over thedecades scholarly catalogs were published and exhibitions

were mounted in the museum’s Berkeley mansion, examining, say, the culture of KurdishJews or the nature of Jewish cemeteries during the Gold Rush.

I visited the Magnes only once in its old home, and its slightly ramshackle style, along withits displays mixing the eccentric traditional and the provocatively experimental, gave it analmost esoteric charm. Only a small fraction of the collection was on site, and only a smallpart of that was ever on display. But the place, even in its late days, was clearly the work ofparticular personalities with their own idiosyncrasies and preoccupations. It was not an“objective” museum; it was personal, invitational, as if saying, “Come and look at what wehave gathered and learned.”

Now all that has been — as was once said — “modernized.” The Magnes Collection,donated to the university along with a lease on its new building, is still under thedirectorship of the Russian-born art historian Alla Efimova, who is partly revisiting herpast: before joining the Magnes in 2003 she had taught in Berkeley’s art historydepartment and had worked in the school’s art museum. The Magnes’s Italian-borncurator, Francesco Spagnolo, who holds a doctorate from Hebrew University in Jerusalemand has taught both philosophy and music, remains in place as well. Eighty percent of thecollection is now on site; a digital catalog of its riches is developing, along with an onlinephotographic record.

But the new Magnes Collection bears little resemblance to the old Magnes Museum. Thenew building, near the campus, once a printing plant, filters away most glints ofpersonality. The San Francisco architect Peter Pfau has made it crisp, spare, rectilinearand clean. Its design also ensures that archival storage drawers and cabinets can be seenon either side of a central 1,500-square-foot exhibition gallery.

Function has changed along with design. Its largest space is a gathering place for events,concerts and lectures: an auditorium. Another room is designed for researchers toexamine material from the archives. The Magnes, we sense, is primarily a place for study,lectures and social gatherings, the main modes of university life.

The museum aspect — the public display of artifacts and interpretations — is more muted.

Go to Complete List » Show My Recommendations

The Carpetbagger on Awards Season

Snowy Owl Sightings

3. A Sharper Mind, Middle Age and Beyond

4. OP-ED COLUMNISTHow Mrs. Grady Transformed Olly Neal

5. What You (Really) Need to Know

6. OP-ED COLUMNISTShowtime at the Apollo

7. Chefs, Butlers, Marble Baths: Hospitals Viefor the Affluent

8. Cracking Teenagers’ Online Codes

9. PRACTICAL TRAVELERSurfing for a Vacation Rental

10. OP-ED COLUMNISTIs Our Economy Healing?

Frederick Wiseman's "CrazyHorse"ALSO IN ARTS »

"Smash": Broadway's big prime-time momentAn Oscar shortlist tilts east

ADVERTISEMENTS

Ads by Google

The Future JewA gripping reply to the Holocaust.

Slide Show

Page 3: NYTimes - A Jewish Museum Shifts Identity by Edward Rothstein 01.22.2011

A version of this review appeared in print on January 23, 2012, on pageC1 of the New York edition with the headline: A Jewish Museum ShiftsIdentity.

Get Free E-mail Alerts on These Topics

Jews and Judaism

Art

Archives and Records

Partly this is because the largest gallery space is temporarily given over to a video artinstallation, “Dissolving Localities,” created by Emmanuel Witzthum and Arik Futterman;it overlays sounds and images from Jerusalem on one large screen and of Berkeley on theother. It wasn’t complete when I visited, but it was difficult to imagine it as much morethan a conceptual commentary on the collection.

The central gallery is where we are meant to focus, where the first temporary exhibition istitled “The Magnes Effect: Five Decades of Collecting.” It is a sampling of the museum’sholdings. There is a marriage contract from 1915 from the Kochi Jewish community ofIndia and a Jewish wedding dress from 19th-century Rhodes, Greece. A painting showsthe early-20th-century incarnation of San Francisco’s Temple Emanu-El. A posteradvertises the San Francisco Jewish Film Festival, which the Magnes helped establish. Anda sword and scabbard are shown from 19th-century Palestine: they were presented by theOttoman government to the Jerusalem-born businessman Yosef Navon to honor his role inthe creation of the Jaffa-Jerusalem railway in 1892.

Each object, of course, could easily become a centerpiece of another exhibition, but theirpresentation here seemed less important than the suggestion that these were markers for aprofusion of other objects, which could be seen on either side, encased in the archivalcabinetry. The point of the display is how much more there is to display. But this meansthat being a museum has become secondary to the other roles the Magnes is taking on.

This may simply be the price a private institution must pay to ensure that its collection iscared for, that it will serve scholars and that it will, over time, become a center for socialand intellectual life. (Its current annual budget is $820,000.) But the compromises aresignificant; it is also unfortunate that one of the cores of the Magnes, the collectionsrelating to Western Jewish life, are being folded into the Bancroft Library. They will fill outthe university’s collection about the history of the American West instead of serving theMagnes’s survey of Jewish life and history.

NEXT PAGE »

The Magnes Collection of Jewish Art and Life is at 2121 Allston Way, near Shattuck

Avenue, Berkeley, Calif.; magnes.org.

The New York Times and the Bay Area -- save 50% onhome delivery plus FREE All Digital Access.

Hardcover $25; Kindle $7.77

www.thefuturejew.com

1 2

SIGN IN TO E-MAIL

PRINT

SINGLE PAGE

REPRINTS

Page 4: NYTimes - A Jewish Museum Shifts Identity by Edward Rothstein 01.22.2011

Museums

Ads by Google what's this?

Why Jews Say No to Jesus

The Jewish Response to Christian

Missionaries Who Target Jews

www.jewsforjudaism.ca

U.S. »

Unusual Spike in SnowyOwl Sightings

ARTS »

Javits Center Plans AreDeflating for Architects

OPINION »

Room for Debate: WhyVoters Let Politicians Lie

SPORTS »

A Link to the Past Has theRebels Runnin’ Again

OPINION »

Op-Ed: NewYork’s Bad BetCasinos might createjobs and generate staterevenue, but supportersignore or play down thecosts.

BOOKS »

When Children’s SpeechTurns Lethal

Home World U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Estate Autos

© 2012 The New York Times Company Privacy Your Ad Choices Terms of Service Terms of Sale Corrections RSS Help Contact Us Work for Us

INSIDE NYTIMES.COM