8/17/2019 Not Finished
1/1
VERLEEN TRINIDAD, FLORENTINA LANDER, WALLY CASUBUAN, MINERVA
MENDOZA, CELEDONIO ALOJADO, ROSENDO VILLAMIN and AUREA
TOLENTINO vs. ATTY. ANGELITO VILLARIN
A.C. No. 9310 February 27, 2013
Facts : The ns!an! "ase s!e##ed $% a C'(an! $&% s'e"$"
'e%$&%#an"e
$(ed )!h !he *&+sn and Land Use Re+(a!&%- B&a%d
*LURB/ 0- !he
0+-e%s &$ !he (&!s n D&n J&se Zava((a
S+0dvs&n aans! !he s+0dvs&n1s
&)ne% and deve(&'e%2 3+%en"e Rea(!-
C&%'&%a!&n and R&0e%!& Bass. The
*LURB &%de%ed !he &)ne% and !he deve(&'e% !&
de(ve% !he Deeds &$ Sa(e
and !he T%ans$e% Ce%!$"a!es &$ T!(e !& !he )nnn (!an!s.
The De"s&n dd
n&! evn"e an- d%e"!ve $&% !he 0+-e%s !& va"a!e !he
'%&'e%!-. 3+%en"e
Rea(!- and R&0e%!& Bass dd n&! a''ea( !he
De"s&n, !h+s #a4n ! $na(
and e5e"+!&%-. The%ea$!e%, !he *LURB ss+ed a W%! &$
E5e"+!&n. I! )as a!!hs '&n! !ha! %es'&nden! V((a%n
en!e%ed hs s'e"a( a''ea%an"e !&
%e'%esen! 3+%en"e Rea(!-. S'e"$"a((-, he $(ed an O#n0+s
M&!&n !& se!
asde !he De"s&n and !& 6+ash !he W%! &$ E5e"+!&n
$&% 0en n+(( and v&d
&n !he %&+nd &$ (a"4 &$ 7+%sd"!&n d+e !&
!he #'%&'e% se%v"e &$ s+##&ns
&n hs "(en!. Ths #&!&n )as n&! a"!ed +'&n 0-
!he *LURB. Res'&nden!
sen! de#and (e!!e%s !& he%en "'(anan!s. In a(( &$ !hese
(e!!e%s, he
de#anded !ha! !he- ##eda!e(- va"a!e !he '%&'e%!- and
s+%%ende% ! !&
3+%en"e Rea(!- )!hn $ve da-s $% %e"e'!. O!he%)se, he )&+(d
$(e !he
ne"essa%- a"!&n aans! !he#. T%+e en&+h, 3+%en"e Rea(!-,
as %e'%esen!ed
0- %es'&nden!, $(ed a C'(an! $&% $&%"0(e en!%-
0e$&%e !he M+n"'a( T%a(
C&+%! MTC/ aans! T%ndad, Lande%, Cas+0+an and Mend&8a.
A%eved,
!he $&+% "'(anan!s $(ed an ad#ns!%a!ve "ase aans!
%es'&nden!. A
#&n!h a$!e%, A(&7ad&, V((a#n and T&(en!n&
$(ed a ds0a%#en! "ase aans!
%es'&nden!. As $&+nd 0- !he In!e%a!ed Ba% &$ !he
3h(''nes IB3/ and
a$$%#ed 0- !s B&a%d &$ G&ve%n&%s, "'(anan!s
asse%!ed n !he% %es'e"!ve
ve%$ed C'(an!s !ha! !he de#and (e!!e%s sen! 0- V((a%n had 0een
ss+ed
)!h #a("e and n!en! !& ha%ass !he#. The- nss!ed !ha! !he
(e!!e%s a(s&
"&n!%avened !he *LURB De"s&n &%de%n hs "(en! !&
'e%#! !he 0+-e%s !&
'a- !he 0a(an"e &$ !he '+%"hase '%"e &$ !he s+0dvs&n
(&!s. Iss+e 9
Whe!he% &% n&! !he %es'&nden! sh&+(d 0e
ad#ns!%a!ve(- san"!&ned $&%
sendn !he de#and (e!!e%s: R+(n9 The %es'&nden! A!!-.
Ane(!& V((a%n s
"(ea%(- '%&s"%0ed 0- R+(e ;
