Upload
mark-h-jaffe
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 1/27
JS-ACtioNYREV. 12/2005
JUDGE HELLERSTEINCIVIL COVER SHEEf
CV 64 Q4upplement the fainted sJJ£tce»f* *—g*The JS-44 civilcoversheet and the information containedherein neither replacenor su _^pleadings or other papers as required by law, except as provided by local rules ofcourt. This form, approved by theJudicial Conference oftheUnited States in September 1974, is required for useof the Clerk ofCourt for the purpose ofinitiating th e civil docket sheet.
SEP 13 2013
PLAINTIFFS North Jevsey Media Group |nc. DEFENDANTS SarahPAC andSaranPa|in
ATTORNEYS (FIRM NAME, ADDRESS, AND TELEPHONE NUMBER
Dunnegan &Scileppi LLC, 350 Fifth Avenue, New York,New York, 10118, (212) 332-8300
ATTORNEYS (IF KNOWN)
CAUSE OF ACTION (cite the U.S. civil statute underwhich you are filing and writea briefstatementof cause)
Copyright infringement under 17 U.S.C. 101 et seq.
Has this ora similar case been previously filed in SDNY atany time? Nog Yes? D Judge Previously Assigned
If yes, was this case VolD Invol. D Dismissed. NoD Yes D If yes, give date—
(PLACE AN [x] IN ONE BOX ONLY) NATURE OF SUIT
& Case No .
ACTIONS UNDER STATUTES
TORTSFORFErTURBPENALTY
CONTRACTPERSONAL INJURY PERSONAL INJURY
[ ]362 PERSONAL INJURY-MED MALPRACTICE
[ ]365 PERSONAL INJURYPRODUCT LIABILITY
[ ]368 ASBESTOS PERSONALINJURY PRODUCT
LIABILITY
PERSONAL PROPERTY
[ ]370 OTHER FRAUD[ ] 371 TRUTH IN LENDING[ ]380 OTHER PERSONAL
PROPERTY DAMAGE
[ ]385 PROPERTY DAMAGE
PRODUCT LIABILITY
11610
[ I 620
[]625
AGRICULTURE
FOOD & DRUG
DRUG RELATED
SEIZURE OF
PROPERTY
21 USC 88 1
LIQUOR LAWS
RR S TRUCK
AIRLINE REGS
OCCUPATIONAL
SAFETY/HEALTH
OTHER
BANKRUPTCY
[ ]422 APPEAL28 USC 1 58
[ ]423 WITHDRAWAL28 USC 1 57110 INSURANCE
120 MARINE
13 0 MILLER ACT
140 NEGOTIABLE
INSTRUMENT
150 RECOVERY OF
OVERPAYMENT &
ENFORCEMENT OF
JUDGMENT
151 MEDICARE AC T
15 2 RECOVERY OF
DEFAULTED
STUDENT LOANS
(EXCL VETERANS)
15 3 RECOVERY OFOVERPAYMENT OF
VETERAN'S BENEFITS
160 STOCKHOLDERS SUrTS
190 OTHER CONTRACT
195 CONTRACT PRODUCT
LIABILITY
19 6 FRANCHISE
[1
REAL PROPERTY
[ ]210 LANDCONDEMNATION
[ ]220 FORECLOSURE[ ]230 RENT LEASE &
EJECTMENT
[ ] 240 TORTS TO LAND
[ ] 2 46 TORT PRODUCT
LIABILITY
[ ]290 ALLOTHERREAL PROPERTY
[ ]310 AIRPLANE[ ]315 AIRPLANEPRODUCT
LIABILITY
[ ]320 ASSAULT, LIBEL&SLANDER
[ ]330 FEDERALEMPLOYERS'
LIABILITY
[ J340 MARINE
[ ]345 MARINE PRODUCTLIABILITY
[ ]350 MOTORVEHICLE[ ]355 MOTORVEHICLE
PRODUCT LIABILITY
[ 1360 OTHER PERSONALINJURY
ACTIONS UNDER STATUTES
[ I 630
[ ]640
[ ]650
[ ]660
[ ]690
LABOR
PROPERTY RIGHTS
IX] 820 COPYRIGHTS[ ]830 PATENT[ ]840 TRADEMARK
SOCIAL SECURITY
[ ]861 MIA(1395FF)[ ]862 BLACKLUNG(923)
[ l 863 DIWC(405(g))[ ]863 DIWW(405(g))[ ]864 SSID TITLEXVI
[ ]865 RSI (405(g))
CIVIL RIGHTS
[]710 FAIR LABOR
STANDARDS ACT[ ]720 LABOR/MGMT
RELATIONS
[ ]730 LABOR/MGMTREPORTING &
DISCLOSURE AC T
[ ]740 RAILWAY LABORACTI ]790 OTHER LABOR
LITIGATION
[ ] 791 EMPLRET INCSECURITY AC TPRISONER PETITIONS
[ ]510 MOTIONS TOVACATE SENTENCE
2 0 U S C 2255
[ ]530 HABEAS CORPUS[ ]535 DEATHPENALTY[ ] 540 MANDAMUS &OTHERI ]550 CIVILRIGHTS[ ]555 PRISON CONDITION
[]441
[ ]442[]443
[ ]444
M4 4 5
VOTING
EMPLOYMENT
HOUSING
ACCOMMODATIONS
WELFARE
AMERICANS WITH
DISABILITIES -
EMPLOYMENT
AMERICANSWITH
DISABILITIES -OTHEROTHER CIVIL RIGHTS
FEDERAL TA X SUITS
[ ] 870 TAXES[ ]871 IRS-THIRDPARTY
20 USC 7609
[1446
[ )440
OTHER STATUTES
[ ]400 STATE
REAPPORTIONME
[ ]410 ANTITRUST
[ ]430 BANKS& BANKIN[ ]450 COMMERCE/ICC
RATES/ETC
[ ]460 DEPORTATION
[ ]470 RACKETEER INFL
ENCED & CORRU
ORGANIZATION A
(RICO)
[ ]480 CONSUMERCRED[ ]490 CABLE/SATELLIT( ]810 SELECTIVE SERV
[ ]850 SECURITIES/COMMODITIES/
EXCHANGE
[ ]875 CUSTOMERCHALLENGE
12 USC 3410
[ ]891 AGRICULTURE A
[ I892 ECONOMIC
STABILIZATION A
[ ]893 ENVIRONMENTAL
MATTERS
[ ] 8 94 ENERGY
ALLOCATION AC
[ ] 895 FREEDOM OF
INFORMATION AC
[ ]900 APPEALOFFEEDETERMINATION
UNDER EQUAL A
TO JUSTICE
[ J950 CONSTITUTIONAOF STATE STATU
( J890 OTHER STATUTOACTIONS
Check if demanded in complaint:
CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTION
UNDER F.R .C .P . 23
DOYOUCLAIM THISCASE IS RELATED TOA CIVIL CASE NOW PENDING IN S.D.N.Y
IF SO, STATE:
DEMAND $ OTHER
Check YESonly ifdemanded incomplaint
JURYDEMAND: Dffl YES NO
JUDGE DOCKET NUMBER
NOTE: Please submitat the timeof filing an explanation ofwhycases are deemed relate
(SEE REVERSE)
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 2/27
' » A(PLACE AN x IN ONEBOX ONLY) ORIGIN ~~
l*J1 Original I—I 2a. Removed from I I3 Remanded from Q 4 Reinstated or CH 5 Transferred from Q 6 Multidistrict O 7 Appeal to DisProceeding State Court Appellate Court Reopened (SpecifyDistrict) Litigation Judge from
I— I 2b. Removed from State Court Magistrate JuANDat least one party isa pro se lit igant Judgment
(PLACEAN x IN ONE BOX ONLY) BASIS OF JURISDICTION IF DIVERSITY, INDICATE
1 U.S. PLAINTIFF 2 U.S. DEFENDANT [H 3 FEDERAL QUESTION 4 DIVERSITY CITIZENSHIP BELOW.(U.S. NOT A PARTY) (28 USC 1332, 1441)
CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES (FOR DIVERSITY CASES ONLY)
(Place an [X] in one box for Plaintiffand one box for Defendant)
PTF DEF PTF DEF PTF DEF
CITIZEN OFTHIS STATE []1 []1 CITIZEN OR SUBJECT OFA [ J3 [ ] 3 INCORPORATED and PRINCIPAL PLACE []5 []5FOREIGN COUNTRY OF BUSINESS IN ANOTHER STATE
CITIZEN OFANOTHER STATE [J 2 [ ]2 INCORPORATED or PRINCIPAL PLACE [ ] 4 [ ] 4 FOREIGN NATION (1 6 (]6OF BUS IN E S S IN THIS STATE
PLAINTIFF(S) ADDRESS(ES) ANDCOUNTY(IES)
North Jersey Media Group Inc.1 Garret Mountain Plaza
Woodland Park, NJ 07424
Passaic County
DEFENDANT(S) ADDRESS(ES) AND COUNTY(IES)
SarahPAC Governor Sarah Palin
Attn: Governor Sarah Palin PO Box 521591
Mr. TimothyCrawford Big Lake, AK 99652P.O. Box 7 71 1
Arlington, VA 22207
DEFENDANT(S) ADDRESS UNKNOWNREPRESENTATION ISHEREBY MADE THAT, AT THIS TIME, IHAVE BEEN UNABLE, WITH REASONABLE DILIGENCE, TOASCERTAIN THE
RESIDENCE ADDRESSES OF THE FOLLOWING DEFENDANTS:
Checkone: THIS ACTION SHOULD BE ASSIGNED TO: Q WHITE PLAINS H FOLEY SQUARE(DONOT check either box ifthisa PRISONERPETITION.)
DATE SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD ADMITTED TO PRACTICE INTHIS DISTRICT9/13/13 \ , . A l ] NO
. ~ ) , II ' I /J*. « . W YES (DATE ADMITTED Mo. QQ Yr. 1981 )RECEIPT* VVMK, 4 J Li/TVnJyMhTiy Attorney BarCode # WD9316
Magistrate Judge is to be designated by the Clerk of the Court .
agistrate Judge I fW&**w-Jl~'^o Designated.
Michael McMahon, Clerk of Court by Deputy Clerk, DATED
STATES DISTRICT COURT (NEW YORK SOUTHERN)
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 3/27
U NIT ED S TATES DIS TRI CT COURT
S OU TH ER N D IS TR IC T OF NEW YORK
-x
NORTH JERSEY MEDIA GROUP INC., :
Plaintiff, :
-against- : 13 Civ.
SARAHPAC AND SARAH PALIN, :
Defendant. :
------------------ -x
RULE 7.1 STATEMENT
Pursuant to Rule 7.1 of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure and to enable Judges and Magistrate Judges
of the Court to evaluate possible disqualification or
recusal, the undersigned counsel for plaintiff North Jersey
Media Group Inc. ("NJMG") certifies as follows: (i) NJMG is
a non-governmental corporate party; and (ii) NJMG is a
wholly-owned subsidiary of Macromedia Incorporated, a New
Jersey corporation, shares of which are not publically
traded.
DATE:
1 ATTORNEYIGNATURE O F
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 4/27
UNITED STATES D IS TR IC T C OU RT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
- x
NORTH JERSEY MEDIA GROUP INC.,
Plaintiff,
-against- : 13 Civ.
SARAHPAC AND SARAH PALIN, :
Defendants. :
------------------ -x
COMPLAINT AND JURY DEMAND
Plaintiff North Jersey Media Group Inc. ("NJMG"), by
its undersigned attorneys, for its complaint against defendants
SarahPAC and Sarah Palin, alleges:
Nature of the Action n t/> '^c/> ,,-, o
1. NJMG is bringing this action to enforce^itsp
copyright in its iconic photograph of the September lj?f 2®01o""t< XT o
c _
flag raising at the World Trade Center site. ro ^
Jurisdiction and Venue
2. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over
the claim in this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338
because it arises under the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. § 101 et
seq.
3. Upon information and belief, venue is proper in
this District pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391 and 1400(a).
JUDGE HELLERSTE1N
1 3 CV 6494
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 5/27
4. Defendants, upon information and belief, are
subject to the personal jurisdiction of this Court pursuant to
C.P.L.R. §§ 301 and/or 302.
Parties
5. NJMG is a corporation organized and existing under
the laws of the State of New Jersey, with its principal place of
business in Woodland Park, New Jersey. NJMG is engaged in the
business of news reporting.
6. It publishes two daily publications, The Record
and Herald News, which have a daily circulation of approximately
151,000 and a Sunday circulation of approximately 175,000. It
publishes more than forty weekly community newspapers, which have
a combined circulation of approximately 630,000. It publishes
twelve magazines, which have a circulation of approximately
350,000. It publishes two websites, www.northjersey.com, and
www.Bergen.com, which have approximately 11.5 million and 750,000
page views per month, respectively.
7. SarahPAC is a federally registered political
action committee with its principal place of business in
Arlington, Virginia.
8. Upon information and belief, Sarah Palin is a
natural person and a resident of Alaska. Upon information and
belief, Sarah Palin is the principal of SarahPAC.
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 6/27
N JM G' S C OP YR IG HT
9. On or about September 11, 2001, an employee of
NJMG, acting within the scope of his employment, took a
photograph of the three firefighters raising the American flag on
the ruins of the World Trade Center site (the "WTC Flag Raising
Photograph") . A copy of the photograph is annexed as Exhibit A.
The WTC Flag Raising Photograph has become an iconic image that
has received international attention. Because an employee of
NJMG took the WTC Flag Raising Photograph while acting within the
scope of his employment, it is a "work made for hire" as defined
by § 101 of the Copyright Act. NJMG is therefore the sole owner
of the copyright in the WTC Flag Raising Photograph.
Palin's Infringing Acts
10. Defendants have, without permission, posted a copy
of the WTC Flag Raising Photograph on their web pages, including
at least www.sarahpac.com, a copy of which is annexed as Exhibit
C, and www.facebook.com/sarahpalin, a copy of which is annexed as
Exhibit D.
CLAIM FOR RELIEF
(Copyright Infringement - 17 U.S.C. § 501)
11. NJMG repeats the allegations in paragraphs 1
through 10 as if set forth in full.
12. NJMG owns, registered and received the United
States Certificate of Copyright Registration No. VA 1-014-297 for
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 7/27
the WTC Flag Raising Photograph ("WTC Flag Raising Copyright"). A
copy of the certificate is annexed as Exhibit B.
13. NJMG's WTC Flag Raising Copyright is valid and
enforceable.
14. Defendants have infringed NJMG's WTC Flag Raising
Copyright in violation of 17 U.S.C. § 501 by using it to promote
Sarah Palin, and to raise money for SarahPAC.
15. Defendants' acts have irreparably damaged and,
unless enjoined, will continue to irreparably damage NJMG. NJMG
has no adequate remedy at law for these wrongs and injuries.
NJMG is, therefore, entitled to a preliminary and permanent
injunction restraining and enjoining defendants and their agents,
servants, employees, and attorneys and all persons acting in
concert with them, from infringing NJMG's WTC Flag Raising
Copyright.
16. Defendants have willfully infringed NJMG's WTC
Flag Raising Copyright.
17. NJMG is entitled to recover damages sustained as a
result of Palin's unlawful conduct including (1) Palin's profits,
or (2) NJMG's losses, or alternatively at NJMG's election, (3)
statutory damages.
WHEREFORE, NJMG demands judgment:
A. Preliminarily and permanently enjoining
defendants, their agents, servants, employees, and attorneys and
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 8/27
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 9/27
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 10/27
^j*£*s..
1
, 'U.S.C. 706)
Certificate ofRegistration
ThisCertificate issuedunder the sealof theCopyrightOffice in accordance with title 17, United States Code,
attests thatregistration hasbeenmadefor theworkidentified below. The information on this certificate has
beenmadea part oftheCopyrightOffice records.
^7%uiL .A EstateRegister ofCopyrights, United States ofAmerica
FORMVA
Vy-0l4M
111111 _iBJi-rBiWiltd*"*1 Bwr
Tr«»g?&,,.v»
^ 0 0 /
Trn,E OF THISWORKV. .^hree •Firefighters Raising The American Photographymthe Rv— *»-k«-Wc*tt Trade Center -^ .„,.,
FREVIOVS OR ALTERNATIVETITLESV
SSKlFfMi. Tltl.efC.lkeHr.Werl.V
IfjMblUtodlnijicilodiwlentwUllW VitaeM* N«»b« fY
NAMEOFAUTHOR*?
Im t tHWCMTHHT
DATESOFBIRTH AND DEATHYewBomV YwfDIed
WeVTwTAl^^Mooyrwwrt OYe» grfe '. ofthe«f<»ue*«oT»»'
*,e»«<»y»cW, OYei gK« r*'"«*W«J
8 H^rti .TBrflev-JlPllla firnvipinfo ;. . •
NOTEUnder the tew.
the wither'e»I *work Hl*44le t Mr** legenerally theemployer,rtotthe employe*teee Jnjtrut.--
Mirt«fW«W6rkthit*»« , , n r 111 • rniri m
et*&PtoVNAME0F^^ *theepee* , 1*1wovWed,»tve »-#
thee«Bloy»f(Or otherMrtonfor
whom thework
fawbUcttont*
NATURE OF AUTHORSHIF CheckWref»M«>x(ei> 8«« KwtrutUtaWD J-DUtwnsioo«J KUlpWPS DMfppa-D«nc»«ioo»I»rtw«k' g Photograph
Wit thiiCMitri»(|ti9» totht work«
«wo**»o« fortire"*-
OYw
DNo
AtitW^W»n»Hr> orWmWI*';OR|ete«ttot-te-
iDolrtclkdta Ifc.
OTeehtttad^w&ig
' Text' ; ,
tl ArcWlectiiirel work
DATESbr BIRTH AN»Dfe«THYeWBortlT . Ye»rD*a 1>.
W«tTub AwhortCootribti«o»''^SJ**^,,,^ottt*wouw««wli
Yet/yeihmxihut w.Worn.
t iY«J
DYm
tiNo
DN o
AnOnyttxxuV
PMOdoeywoot?
thet*erl,»WleeVe the<M«etor«etoe NATUREOF AWTHORS$IF CheekW«*!u.ea.<«). *>•mw*W**
C] TecHinM dwwirig
13Text '.'.'••'QAitWUsAirtlwptV
deeth Mel*.
Q J-Dimeneiooel itvAptW
a. 24>imeii«trW«rt*pftD lUproductlonofworkofirt
Q^togripci
' D'ewettyOeiigft
m
VeertaVrtkkCr.erlrt^TW.WerttWe.^^ i , ^™^TV^"l,t^Nr^el^-r«l*«*«:»fTtoW«cW»Wer* .
_JX-*re»> -2ML
S . / u -40W-
4. •.. -.' COPYRJGHT 'fctAiMAKttS) Neme miMkm**** oW «*•'«*• eW"v*,a *<* -"*»*. m(h»t'iiv»irto4»*«fI*' .
North Jersey Me<dla Group Inc. .^^^ 150 River Street , • £?«<**»* p^AVtortgariV^^,t^jQ3j6jQ.1.-i-^-XZ
!>. oNeoeposrTRiEceiviD
TWO)
' smfrfs rFUNDS RECEIVED
,-elrWonM
i i—i i i iiiimtmi* I'liiflit——^•—^«««mm«»" [AXKBtSKi^rtnti
J K o S b ^ k T I ^ ^ ^[OtMirpOTr^rtt^BtlWt**^^ ooNonmrmHUE
N9.1of-2^pe{ie««S*e oeieMdheltMoMie.
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 11/27
%
EXAMINED BY
o-iHCHECKED BY
DCORRESPONDENCE
Y es
DONOTWRITE ABOVE THIS UNE. IFYOO NEEDMORE SPACE, USE A SEPARATE CONTINUATION8HEET.
J ' onuePREVIOUSREGISTRATION Hu rcgiitnikw for thiswork, or for soeerller venkmof this work, already been nudefat Ihc Copyright Office?
D Ym £l Ne Ifyour loewer k"Yet," why itMother regtarstioo being sought? (Check appropriate box.)T
a. D This isthe feel eubUsbed edition ofawork previously reglttm^
k. CD Thisb thefin*application submittedbythi« author a* copyright claimant
e. •TiU Isachanged verrioa ofthework.»« shown by space t cathisapplication.
lfyo«raniW frU«Ye«,"give;P«VhwRaj|latralleeN»«»berT YeareURajlatnutteaT
DERIVATIVEWORKOR COMPILATIONComplete both apace Stmt 6bfanderivativework; complete ooly «bfor acompJatSoo.a. rreexbtiegMaterial Identify anypreexisting work orworks that thisworkishatedoeortacoipontes. V
b. Malarial Added to TUaWerk Olve a brief, generalsieieniet*of iteinsterlalil»ihanbMni»»Wto
DEPOSIT ACCOUNT If the registration fee la tobe charged to*Deposit Accountestabllsbsd in the Copyrifjit Office, jjive name endmioberofAceeutt.NaaeeT AmmMXvmMiV
CORRESPONDENCE Give name and address to which correspondence about this application should be job. Naaw/Address/Apt/Cfty/Stsre/ZlP V
Sally A. Steffen, Esquire
Ballard Spahr Andrews & Ingersoll, LLP
1735 Market Street, 51st Floor
Philadelphia, PA 19103Ar*.c^endoey*neWip*x»rwr*M»> (gjej 864-8222 reamer** *. <215>864-8999
.Brffn** [email protected]»eaeaa»aane«aaea»aa»»»ea»a»«a»as«apaeemwi»auai»jiiii»i " *a*im«li«s»Mtaa»iOT)«araei«»ir«w^^
CERTIFICATION* Lti»urKler>iiEne<J,rrertbycertify that I »mOw
suih*/
O othercopyrightclaimant
O ownerof exclusive r%ht(j)
3authoriseda*tmrf-Jfeyrh..rr>xci.»y MorHn drnun T^r,Xrft»rtrMw«otJ«*(w^fIe'c»i*^i/o«wofe>dij#AIl^e;»)i,
ofthework Identifled In this application rind that the statement* nudebymeIn thisapplication arecorrect tothe bestofmyknowiedae.
cheek only one>
Typed orprinted name anddetoY Ifthis ippl(cation ejveea date of publication inepece J,donotsign and submit itbefore thatdite.
Sally A. Steffen . p.^ 9/28/01
Handwritten algnature (X)V
BT^u*^MBaBi»t iBTOJMM3Bwtt i i . iaiaaay,«^aaaf f i i^^^^
NameT
Sa l l y A. S t e f f e n , Esqu i re
FORMVA
FO R
COPYRIGHT
OFFICE
US E
ONLY
a
5
6Se e eievucaons
befcreeornpteengthis epece.
b
. a7
b
CartJflcat*
will bemailed In
window
mrtlopa
to thjg»ckrr»»»:
Norr*arfstr«evAptv Ballard Spahr Andrews £ IngereollT- LLP1735 Market S t ree t , 51s t Floor
CthVSWerZIPT
Philadelphia, PA 19103
&^tfundoWflliu to aichedter money a.*.**,, ,_
llimn I1WII nwnieMiwleMiimiei VeHMVAIltM.
ssssssss^^^June 1WW-10O.OOOWEB RBft June 1MB
© PfOntOOK WCraEOKiWl
.... i lOKce
101hseponejeneeAvenue S,E.JWaihinsbn. O.C, 2O55MOO0
nl).S. GOvnnNMEMTPRiMDNO OfflCt 1W9-45W7W71
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 12/27
Sarah Palin I Facebook
Email or Phone Password
3 . 6m
Photos
Pagel of 7
I t Takes a Village.:
Slay a Salmon
The beauty of catch)
some of our Alaskan'
Notes 39 0
Highlights
Sarah Palin
19 hours ago
Never forget.
Wewill never forget
Like •Comment •Share 20,635
ReglnaBlair, DonBoessel, PattiWeber and 129,629others likethis.
View previous comments 2 of 1,454
Don Nicholas lib's saidthere's not enough"diversity"inthatpicture. Funny, the buildings didnt fed thatwaywhenthey fell.7 minutes ago via mobile
Paul J. Klosferman Let's roll!
2 minutesago
https://www.facebook.com/sarahpalin
Recent Posts by Others on Sarah Palin
I JoeNewby
Report:Obama's Syrianalliesdismember littlegirlwith fr...
3 minutes ago
Kristi Kinn Becker
I'm hoping youcould share this to the parents you know.
10 minutes ago
James Odell Kewi sh
I thinkyou do a greatJobasa parentandwithyour polidca..
59 minutes ago
More Pos ts
Sarah Palin shared a link.
September 9
Enough of this foreign fiasco distraction. Get back to work, it is
t ime to bomb Obamacare.
http://youtu.be/Hgt87inKDUE
Like• Comment Share 6,014
LindaDavidElls, AlbertCurtisSr., LarryW Smith and 64,228 others likethis.
View previous comments 2 of 2,31!
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 13/27
Sarah Palin I Facebook
Like • Comment • Share 2,033
MarkWirtz,Vee Gouveia,CarolShekel and 60,200 others likethis.
View all 2,549 comments
LET ALLAH SORT IT OU T
"So we're bombingSyria because Syria is bombing Syria?AndI'm
th e idiot?" - Sarah Palin
* President Obama wants America involved in Syria's civilwar
pitting the antagonistic Assad regime against equally
antagonis... Se e More
https://www.facebook.com/sarahpalin
Page 2 of 7
Jon Dee Asa foreigner 1 never pass comment upon USpolitics,save to say that, inmy humbleview,Sarah P isthe onlyUSpoliticianwholooksgoodfrom behind. Yes, you're right;I spend toomuchtime in Slavic Europe
•1 rour« ago via mobile
Mark Adams Sarah Palin Was Right—MoreDems Ditch Death
Panel s
http //news.investors.com/...
Sarah Palin Was Right—More Dems
Ditch Dea th Panels
news. lnvesto rs .com
Sarah Palin is vindicated as more Democra ts
facing re-election admit that the In. .. See More
3 hours ago 2
Happybirthday,Todd! He's finally as old as I am! We've beenaway hunting this week in an "undisclosed location." It's that time
of year when Alaskansfill their freezers for the winterwithhomegrown organic protein. (AsmyDad likesto r... See More
Li ke Comment Share 2,163
VeeGouveia,TomTribke, Rlckie LynnAragonand 72,398others likethis.
View previous comments 1 of 5,424
Ricardo P. Limon Happy BirthdayTodd, I willbeon a bullElk
Hunt In October in th e state of Colorado. I hope Miss. Palin
becomes th e first Women President of Th e United States of America.
I have two beautiful daughters. I would Liketo work, for the Palin
Administration when sh e Wins.
6 hours ago • 1
Here's a great photo posted on mycousin JD's Facebook page of
a reunion of Vietnam vets (3rd Battalion, 7th Marine Regiment) in
Savannah, GA. Noticethe "MissingStateside" t-shirt worn by
Jared Moody, who Is the son of a proud Marine vet.. . See More
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 14/27
Sarah Palin I Facebook
Like' Comment• Share 36,895
Allison Skartvedt, MarkWirtz,LeeVaughan and 86,274 others likethis.
view previous comments 1 of 7,538
Mark Adams Judge Jeanlne: Another false narrative from th e
White House?
http://www.youtube.com/watch ?v=0JN3RIIaGKk
Judge Jean ine: Another false
narrative from th e Whi te House?
www.youtube.com
Why should American public believe
President Obama about Syria?
3 hours ag o
Sarah Pal in shared a In k
August 29
Loveit when good things happen. (Thanks for sending this, UncleRon!)
Uke • Comment • Share
Tchaikovsky Flashwata a t Hadassah
Hospitalyoutu.be
Forty students from Hie Jerusalem
Academy of Music and Dancetook a
classical approach to the flashmob as
5,834
LizTaub, Joan Benstock,Pranbha Pandhare-Shende and 13,738 otherslike this.
View previous comments 2 of 1,136
Sandra Hirschman Evans I am inawe!Suchamazingtalentandespeciallyat this Hmeof the year. Thanksto the wonderfullady responsible. We love you, Sarah!
10 hours ago
Jack ie Samuels Gibson So wonderful...
9 hours ago
May his dream always be reality.
https://www.facebook.com/sarahpalin
Page 3 of 7
Like • Commen t ' Share 2,053
Geid Schdler, Ranu Tarat Cornell, Dennis Grandon and 27,268 others
like this.
View previous comments
Mike Parker oh yes, PLEASE run
20 hours ago 1
Mr.President, please giveAmericajustification before you spend
bloodand treasure to intervene. Start with:whoare you rootingfo r in this7
Like Comment Share 32,475
Tidy Williams,GhomariMokhtar,CindyIngraham and 62,550 others likethis.
View previous comments 1 of 3,265
Mark Adams 14 PrincipledAnti-WarCelebritiesWe FearMayHave Been Kidnapped
http://www.buzzfeed.com/...
14 PrincipledA nti-War Celebrities We Fea r
May Have Been Kidnapped
www.buzzfeed .com
Our governmentis yet again marching ustowards a war of choice in th e Middle
Ea... Se e More
Yesterday at 12:08am • 1
I'm just waiting for the guys to finishloading up gear, so I'm
using the "wait time" to finish reading MarkLevin'sgreat new
bookThe Liberty Amendments." It offersa real solutionand way
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 15/27
Sarah Palin I Facebook
Like Comment • Sliare 10,475
Tannie Wichern, Elisa Rodriguez, MariaStewart and 48,567 others likethis.
view previous comments 1 of 1,533
Michael Bellew Mayhis dream be appreciated by making the
effort to go and vote
September 10 at 9:03am
Sa r a h Pa l in sha red a link.
August 27
I 'm there with these folks inspirit!
VIDEO:Thousands lineup fo r Mark levin's booksigning; "The
Liberty Amendments" #1 on NYTimes...
theiightscoop.com
Dude. Aton of people showed up for one of MarkLevin'srecent bookssigningsforhis new#1 NewYorkTimesbest seller, The LibertyAmendments,"that went outside the store and began to circleth...
Like • Comment • Share 501
Anna MitzlIrwin, Susan Ally,HalTrader and 11,507 others likethis.
View previous comments 2 of 199
H9 | Mare SoulieThat was agreat video Mark thank you for sharing
September6 at 4:56pm 1
Melvin F.Whata great speech back 50 yearsago! Andthewords,"notjudged bythe colorof their skin, but bythe contentof their character" is truer now than ever.
September 7 at 11:07am
First day of school!
https://www.facebook.com/sarahpalin
Page 4 of 7
forward to restoring our republic. Please ge t this book, read it,
and let's make it happen!
Sarah Palin
Like Comment Share 6386
MarkWirtz,Simons Fontaine, Craig Gollihar and 93,316 others likethis,
view previous comments 2 of 3,841
M Tammy Overton Our Country still needs you Sarah Palin, pleasekeep fighting for th e good of US OfA! Hope you help defund
ObamaCare.
6 hours ago
HgH Craig Gollihar please 2016 we need you mrs president
Sa r a h Palin
August 27
Forced enrollment In Obama's "Unaffondable Care Act" is weeks
away. Thisbeast must be stopped ~ by not funding i t. Today,Todd and I joined with many of our fellowcitizens to urge those
in th e U.S. S en at e t o n ot fund Obamacare.
We Th e .. . Se e More
DON'T FUND OBAMACARE!IFYOU FUND IXYOU OWN IT!
Like • Comment Share
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 16/27
Sarah Palin I Facebook
Like • Comment • Share 3.509
Dee Latta, Chan Mariow, Henry Eilertand 249,575 others likemis.
View previous comments 2 of 8,414
Albin Galich Youare a luckyman, Todd. HappyBirthday!
September 10 at 11:30am
Marie Ros e s o cute..!!!
17 hours ago
So, friends...inside scoop into the "PalinWorld."This isTodd's
airplane hanger (under ANOTHER autumn double rainbow
tonight!)where he parks his bush plane to transport us to our
commercial and sport fishing grounds. And as
importantly,... See More
tike Comment Share
RebeccaDeBaar, DarcyleCote,LennyHamilton and49,916others Ikethis.
View previous comments 2 of2454
Kalene AnnParker Ltoyd...not sure ifyouare beinga smartaHeck, or sincere., just an fyipeopledont paytaxesto her.
September 7 at 8:27am
Marie Rose nice!!!
17 hours ago
Sarah Palin
August 23
Mypot of gold under a double rainbow.
https://www.facebook.com/sarahpalin
Page 5 of 7
Pamela Mortensen, KevinMartin, Lenny Hamilton and 47,794 others likethis.
View previous comments 2 of 1,82S
Quita Mamie Bemah HeyMadam Palin,I love and appreciateyou familylifestyle. So cute of you, please keep itup!
September 10 at 7:09am •. 1
Laura Locke please run for prisedent
September 10 at 5:06pm l
First day of school!
Li ke • Comment • Share 1,890
Laura S Hines, RickieLynnAragon, Chan Mariowand 140,533 others likethis.
view previous comments 2 of 4,159
Gloria Kleve What a special pic
September 7 at 8:31am 1
ConnieMeranda Absolutely pricetes.Youcan sure tell they arefather and son. Whata dollbaby. Cant believe hisis this oldalready. Heis a big boy.
September8 at 8:12pm 1
Sarah Pal in shared a l ink.
August 24
http://youtu.be/c8C7i9kdEf8
Madison Rising - The Star Spangled
Banne r
youtu.be
To book the band, pleasecontact:[email protected] Availableon fTunes at
Like CommentShare 2,175
Darcyle Cole, Harry WBksSr., Kenneth Alienand 7,844 others likethis.
View previous comments 2 of 594
• Shirley Breshears Bayer I dare you to watch/listen to thiswithout tingling,tearing or outright crtng injoy!!Please SHARE foryour Nation, USA!!!
September 6 at 5:05pm • 1
jfijjjfe ScottSchneider this is the most awesome versionH I September 7at2:01pm
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 17/27
Sarah Pa lin I Facebook
&&y
like • Comment • Share 1,575
ChanMariow,DarcyleCole,Biyan Mcmullenand 95,863 others likethis.View previous comments 2 of 2,094
IjjS^I Donna Macero thafs right sarah, good to see uhave you're|jHf priorities still In order.
September 6 at 5:07am
MB TheJourneyofthe Little Ladybug Agreat reminder ofGod'sjefegg promises.
September 10 at 1:29am
So, the FederalGovernment,er. WeThe People,are employing
someone at the Department of HomelandSecurity whose side job
is running a hate website advocating ethnic cleansing and other
despicable acts?! This official is promoting a race war. Hisfellow
employees say they're "astounded" he isemployed by the
taxpayers. His side "job" running the "War On the Horizon"
website was reportedly approved by supervisors. Really, Fed?
Really?
Friends, let your government knowwe deserve better; we
demand better. We're payingthe tab.
Unflippingbelievable.
- Sarah Palin
Read th e article here:
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2013/08/22/dhs-employee-
spends-spare-time-promoting-race-war-against-whites/
Like Comment 17,982
George Wight,A!Teper, GwenMillerand 36,703 others likethis.
View previouscomments 2 of 3,571
Lenny Hamilton Andwhat has our so called Governmentdid
aboutthis you haven't heard nothing else aboutit ishe stallon thejob Ifit was a white pushing hat the newswouldbe allover it
11 hours ago
Rhapsody Hahn Homelandsecurity?I'mWhite Myman IsBlackOurkidsare perfect Our"home"ispeachy.I'm notfeelingvery"secure" rightnow, UncleSam.
10 hours ago
https://www.facebook.com/sarahpalin
Page 6 of 7
Congratulations to Dance to Bristol for winning the Ballerina
Stakes today! This amazing horse ison a great winning streak.
It's wonderful to have something more fun to wri te about at a
t ime when so many troubling things ar e in th e news.
I... See More
Like Comment • Share 1,115
ChanMariow,LennyHamilton, NitzaOrtizHernandez and 20,519 othersBke this.
View previous comments
H Puppie Love Couture beautiful!f§ September 2at ll:S7pm
Chakib Hassa ine ilovethe horse
September 7 at 2:50am
2 of 57 6
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 18/27
Sarah Palin | Facebook Page 7of7
Mobile FindFriends Badges People Pages Places Apps Games Must
About CreateAd CreatePage Developers Careers Privacy Cookies Terms Help
Facebook C- 2013 Englisli (US)
https://www.facebook.com/sarahpalin 9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 19/27
SarahPAC - Sarah Palin's Official PAC
SarahPAC - Sarah Palin 's Official PAC
Home
Abou t
Sarah 's Story
Palin's Picks Donate
Contact
12345
Clickhere
to support SarahPAC with a financial contribution today!Contribute
Schedule Even t
Click here to schedule an event.
Book An Event
Ge t Connec ted
Stay in touch with Sarah!
Twit ter
YouTube
RSS
http://www.sarahpac.com/: i
Pagel of 8
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 20/27
SarahPAC - Sarah Palin's Official PAC
Setting the Record Straight
Support SarahPAC with a financial contribution today.
Videos
First Name Las t Name
Zip Code
Re c e n t Po s t s
VIDEO: Jus t Savin'
Posted on September 10, 2013
See the latest video on the continuing threat ofObamacare.
Just Sayin*
Read More
Twee t {l9
http://www.sarahpac.com/
Page 2 of 8
E-mail Address
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 21/27
SarahPAC - Sarah Pal in 's Offic ia l PAC
Like 98 people like this. Sign Up to see what yourfriends like.
Don ' t Fund Obamaca r e
Posted on August 27, 2013
Page 3 of 8
Forced enrollment in Obama's "Unaffordable Care Act" is weeks away. This beast must be stopped -- bynot funding it. Today, Todd and I joined with many ofourfellow citizens tourge those in the U.S.Senate to n ot fund Obamacare .
We The People must continue to make our voices heard and hold those elected to serve this great nationaccountable. Those in the Senate and those seeking to serve there must stand strong against thisdevastating program before it reveals its true face now recognized byboth sides of the aisle as thebureaucratic and economic beast that will deny our families, our businesses, and our sick the ability toaccess health care.
The time for rhetoric and ceremonial votes in Congress is over. The time to take serious action to stopObamacare is now. Join us in urging Senators ~ Don't Fund Obamacare! Just remember -- ifyou fundit, you own it!
http://www.sarahpac.com/ 9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 22/27
SarahPAC - Sarah Palin's Official PAC
- Sarah Palin
P.S.:Clickhere tojoin us in signing this petition: doiitfundobamacare.com
Read More
Tweet !<15 J
57 people likethis. Sign Upto see what your friends like.Like
Page 4 of 8
Inspir ing
Posted on August 22, 2013
Looks like the Duck Dynasty dudes aren't the only ones speaking truth to power lately. Hollywood starAshton Kutcher gave a heartfelt speech about hard work at thisweek's "Teen Choice Awards". It'sworth the time to click on Bristol's blog where she links the speech. In this, Ashton says:
1licfd my f-rsf Job with Dcd carrying shingles to the mof, and .ifien 1got ci job wc«hfrig dishes of e restaurant, and ilmn Igot€5 Jobmc grocery store deli, and then ! tmio mh In 0 facfoiysweeping? Cheerio tins! off flie ground, .Arid I fit-vet hce? a Jobin my IHe lhal Iwqs ksefter ilmn, Iwes tiWmys, §mi lucky Icrhave a job. Ami every Job 1hod %vos ci stepping stone to mynext Job, and 1never qui! my Job ijiilll I iiaef my next job. And
so oppoi-foiiilief; look a lot like wcjik, 5*
Good to see his Iowa roots shining through all that Hollywood glitter! On our trips to Iowa our familyhas always admired the strong work ethic and dedication to freedom thatthose who live there in the
http://www.sarahpac.com/9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 23/27
SarahPAC - Sarah Palin's Official PACPage 5 of 8
heartland hold dear. As they say -- you can take the boy out ofIowa, but you can't take Iowa out of theboy.
In a reflection ofthe sad state ofaffairs in Washington, one mainstream media newspaper even had toacknowledge, "Who knows, maybe Ashton Kutcher was able to do something America's politicalleadership can't do, which is to talk honestly to America's youth about the dignity ofwork." Wake up,Washington, and kudos to Ashton for speaking out for America's youth.
- Sarah Pa li n
R ea d Mo re
Twee t
Like 37 people like this. Sign Up to see what yourfriends like.
Duck Dynasty Wisdom
Posted on August 22, 2013
http://www.sarahpac.com/9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 24/27
SarahPAC - Sarah Palin's Official PAC Page6 of 8
Like those 3:00 am wake up calls tojoinmy dad duck hunting in the canoe before the school day began,it's time ourpoliticians wake upandhearsome Duck calls from far outside the beltway. The self-made,hugely successful businessmen (andwomen) of DuckDynastymadehistory this weekwiththe "mostwatched non-fiction series" inTV history. What'smost interesting and inspiringis to see the numberofyoung peopletuning in to watch this all-American, hardworking family - and learn the key to theirsuccess (as well as tips on how best to bag the ducks!).
Todd and I hada greattimemeeting DuckCommander Willie Robertson at thisyear'sNRAconvention.And just theotherday, Phil Robertson offered some of their refreshing trademark plainspoken talk thatso manycrave from our leaders in Washington. Speakingon the issue of the sanctity of life, Philreminds usthat all life isGod-given, nomatterhow small or howspecial. Watch Phil's entire remarkson the abor t ion culture here.
Toour GOPleadersinWashington, especially - this iswhatAmericans desire and deserve; we'renotrooting foryoursocial truces. AsPhil so rightly asks, "What in theworld has happened to us?"
Kudos to these Duckdudes for speaking theirminds, andfor theirboldness in livingtheAmericandream ofLIFE, liberty, andthepursuit of happiness ~ reminding us all that it'sonlywith freedom thatanything is possible.
- Sarah Palin
Read More
Tweet] {{H
41 people like this. Sign Up to se e what your friends like.ike
View All Posts
http://www.sarahpac.com/ 9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 25/27
SarahPAC - Sarah Palin's Official PAC
Find u s on Facebook
Sarah Palin
Like
18 hours
ago
Sa r ah
Pal in
Enough of
3,637,537 people likeSarah Palin.
Facebooksocialplugin
http://www.sarahpac.com/
v.]
Page 7 of 8
9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 26/27
SarahPAC -Sarah Palin's Official PAC p gofg
Twee t s Follow
JSarah Palin 1st. .I©SarahPalinUSA
Never forget. fb.me/2CRJheiqO ;\ .
Expand jjpte ?
Sarah Palin 9 Sep
©SarahPalinUSA
Enough ofthis foreign fiascodistraction. Get back to work. It i s
time to bomb Obamacare....
fb.me/2MtJlgvLp
Show Media
Sarah Palin 6 Sep
©SarahPalinUSA
I posted 11 photos on Facebook
inthe album "Hunting"
fb.me/10eNDCL9a
Expand
Sarah Palin e Sep
©SarahPalinUSA
Happy birthday, Todd! He'sfinallyas old as Iam! We've been awayhunting this week in an
"undisclosed... fb.me/2RIGptn4p
Expand
m
$
Sarah Palin 30Aug :;J„.©SarahPalinUSA S**
Tweet to ©SarahPalinUSA
vmm t h e om r
Paid for by SarahPAC
Notauthorized byany candidate or candidates committee.
www.SarahPAC.com
Pr ivacy Pol icy
Site by Upstream
http://www.sarahpac.com/ 9/12/2013
7/29/2019 North Jersey Media Group Inc v Palin
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/north-jersey-media-group-inc-v-palin 27/27
North Jersey Media Group Inc. v. SarahPac et al, Docket No. 1:13-cv-06494 (S.D.N.Y. Sept 13, 2013), Court Docket
General Information
Docket Number 1:13-cv-06494
Court United States District Court for the Southern District of NewYork
Nature of Suit Property Rights: Copyright