20
?Wt' ~ JI.A~ /j/ fk;c/ Co v~ f k ~;'.Jf4tfl ~)ck/cl 12 i Mrc o4iPW DOC NO f < EC 'DI FI LED 20i 7 FEB 16 AH 9: 50 PETE1, OPP ENE[,:. _ Cl ERK 11s DIS T cr: i: i.. :, WO OF VII · · kJwyaz/ w A Ith~ N efAf CAY8EJ i> ,,Ac N OW C{)/'(k;f 1k. ,L V& M . . - ..ti,!d)CA ( A4-. CJ: , , bi: ,,i/c/ _ d'f o<f/G~ d '1dJrJ.dA{ wt""! 1/cJ±. MU CAu~;r . 1 1 M;di M k;ll'dclk hf:J . !4±v , "'d I I.IN;/) v~ ,tgur-f:f; 4f ) Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 1 of 20

NO ?Wt'~ JI.A~ Cov~f k ~;'.Jf4tfl ~)ck/cl i 50A-:'.Jt/r liA. /,4.././,.2 /~A!,,,rJ!b.:;_-d Jfro-j /,._; /J; llf/ ... tr T . . , t:. '--" • t2ctvlt ... tJJ.osbfk~k,vJ {J,.,;:3b"'f1

  • Upload
    lecong

  • View
    213

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

?Wt'~ JI.A~ /j/fk;c/ Cov~f

k ~;'.Jf4tfl ~)ck/cl 12i Mrco4iPW

DOC NO f < EC 'DI FI L ED

20i 7 FEB 16 AH 9: 50

PETE1, OPP ENE[,:. _ Cl ERK 11s DIS T cr:i: i..: ,

WO OF VII

· · kJwyaz/ w A Ith~ N efAf CAY8EJ i> ,,Ac NOW C{)/'(k;f 1k. ,L V& M . . -

..ti,!d)CA ( A4-. CJ:, ~ , bi: ,,i/c/ _ d'fo<f/G~ d ~ '1dJrJ.dA{ wt""! 1/cJ±.

MU CAu~;r . 1 1 M;di M k;ll'dclk hf:J . !4±v , "'d I I.IN;/) v~ ,tgur-f:f; 4f

)

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 1 of 20

; ,. / J. .

~) ~ f~wf lM 01!)4~ / i!J1L,ol1cib&1 o_l/e,1-lur Acll<?AL v,v~'- -~-- --~,;<; ~)

. · .... -. r· ·)· ._ .. ~ .· -

~ - ' ·. /. -, ,~-~-' ,:·

..... '~- ""'-· .

(~ ) & Cou1I- ,4!r-:f Vk:N0Z CJ'f= ?f)r· CA&~ ~ =di d.J.. t IMU(h)t&'~

> r l~--=- y/ .,...-_. - ' ~-. ,..

_,., --- ... _.

, .. ,/

-.

---· . {

.W,..,;,,d;l~/1,* "f d ttJ"k-<VM!l:lbzkff kpl~ ~/,fo,m,,,eQ~

_,,.. ,_ . ~

< _" ·:.Ct) f1Iz-w.1d,4/\lik A:-tfKA:! blW.(7 ,' ./k. :J/v;&-0.J <ex ·, 4= cfllctkckloe

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 2 of 20

,4 c/dh;;-«rt1NI) d too f!-jJ_JC"-Ad ,f/&l·J Lt.,licdiro.11., §Ir, ~~'l?Q_J #}-c=--... ··"-,--~ -·-._-­~ -hd!~/\I< -4~.,-l u0;J&r -coo;,Z'/\tVJJo,-,, £-e1ri1 f!o 4>< Pd2:>$ d~~I-

cY~ doe,fv;f.g AACC?[ a ?J, ffflR/,1--d: w.£ Cilwlc.J _(/Jpi/1I) M!E b.rdk-nAJ'"+/f---. --­Jd r .df-\"uPR:tf,eA!h"o11rd. 4'Jvh-,U Mfd Ldi( ·---:,__ : . '• ': .

. - \ .

-

( \ .- ..

CA-lc)u11 /R,_~ _ g£Yi ~t4-z{ Al~ !/heRa&.ckv4'?~t?A,4 hr,.~'di ___ t. __ _ {t../Jtp} !Mid.ex -;6-: L1_1c-it'Ck( wa If- d,_~jw/ Cbk'. " b AtAf 1-olcl £Uim.

f /"'~-- ( ~J

/90 .)\ f:__;;i,\ >-JIPF A,!//1ht---C #JI: ,~f WM q;;M, )/.- fte/+6+ ))£ '4 dJk Qr! kNp

-~. ::'' - - - .. . ·- ..... .

' ; ' . ), .

"-..-:..-,.,-"

):_ . t;t·2. .. lf -- :Z2,22 { _t ~P~~f?J1 atw4+rJr · (/!rA) k~ u&~7(

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 3 of 20

:'. "'-", "7-.

/~:··~ .. ' "\- ~-/" , . ;

(~) kr Jvn3. ,A-:'.Jt/r liA . /,4.././,.2 /~A!,,,rJ!b.:;_-d Jfro-j /,._; /J; llf/ ... tr

T . . , t:. '- -" •

t2ctvlt /l4/;t,/ u Ahr CQL::1.l2Hd,-.nzcl 129= '4. ··:2!5e;cc:2k, DAI A-9-t-ws ..

~ .. ~::~-~ ;,= ~

(3-n') d,1011 ~3 b .11?v lD~ ~~-c~~~ u/c/uq kl/Id& ~k-:m:

·. r '- .,,,........ .· ·t44rt A-Ard__ ~y1,1)qAAf /~?{--~-~~;:~//__ 0~ u/,M k G9,1&rbvs:74·-/.D

( i •. ry

AzA£.rfp0//ea r k~,f? ·· //k:/31 4c,,r$Jr<if A:.£1.A.eiLQ •

..... _ :• i

. (j L) 4:/~~~:~ & &/Vd,rJbo1 KNVJw-1L 4 4Y;,e,4cdc,-cr,14 1 &c~~k

-,:..,::

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 4 of 20

..... ~: .

.,,/1 ·:.. '·

{Js) It ~uky /1.0SJ71 '1J'di ~Alk:d AhJd ijt cdc/wt q:~~ ~1--·,,:...,--,,;"--k _' --'---

4J/,LcJ.. J.i d fl-1_tcl/,d A i6lclu"6 , '' u oxdd,,.,r o.y.d,J, ,, ev;~~~ fl!y;J-#

.L

(i'i) fJ)b.,.;kl W d>/i!i nAl~Nb..,J,(!3!* ~I, ~¥du~ ~ "'"f

/ ' '•,<:;,:

-<.~// (;}'·"> A/I a'}~ ~VRe ,JYo;-krzsJ c£'f';,::,4 C_i:$) - Cis>. A.~J)Jf{,,i{ / '-;. ~ -· - - . . --, l

'~<~ J ~? .;....2-oaR H&;;d -1J'«IA-Al&o M1r& eP1_0t9kd__ bu'lt lou, kf-lA,~,,,,1

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 5 of 20

. J . .

lo ,Lf),e_ (ol( &-tso{ /J,~f Cv,£A}·Jtas; ±RRVsbtv.~(\10 fe Alo -4114[(, Lj/M h~.-<-,< _

,, -- , ./ t.,. ,_

(J . ..r1'> .A~ .,9- t? 4bv/G'-!f/"i/)·1.on1. ~h~J1.- C1J)-c1.0) 1-k~Jtilidi-~cr I , T ~ ,.

~-Q.odoi k,rc/ 4}4l,__ C0Ni-h11uk--d h wHJUt.! io !)~~ -,~~~ ~v{ '1~1,e,gf

· I 7 . "' ; -

&--Id oJ../'44/ LAio/ c vR R&C)i Ir.rt= ~i! {).,o;io JJr t;;(/h1;.j;U;le2Jl2AX-t-~ lo ·

i ; .....-- .. . ...... -- .

(ll) Ptv4Jjj i (},1/ ~-ill- :k:ioF ~lf/1~~1;:7} lJ 1; ~ff~ ffi-< (//! Q 0Jb:4 e<he

T . . /· -.,,,;;. " .~ I

b It, Md!~Lj/-dcd~ fj :~f~K Ml:fu/-;J6-&rilke:. 11. b,1,,-1_

. .. -7m, .'\,>,.-'

Uf I.er. do(),<-(. 71"£ Af+; e:Ji~r4Ho .. l '1M-R 4fofj,t>ejr,eJfezdy dJ1', Co><, --

\ ,,_. ···,· / .0 ~/./ :h~:C~ ifJ<ou2i,h frc,d:c tvird ?&01tJ,-jtp lt~INA¥ #Ae-f).

' : "'-• - -· -

, ·~:' -:~) cQAI ,i.j_ 12--.2Q1pj -4)~1+ wwN/--lArk /.o UtJHc_ :P-o~ A !k&toi-11

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 6 of 20

I -=; I - I I .

. t-fufd /tJftr~ dRrteflfk uff- !AJ/-1m 1 A11.n4 ~-z:/ -/pj /t:7lif 1:Jo/k!7 i /!MJV -- ·

SM (dh)k 011,J :ltz~,J;'rAft1q_,,J ·-/J..eh< MJ?f,,(J zleo2 kl: fiw..Jb.x k-VA{y~,._; -/o~--·---­cl_g,4y1J1/M5 iJ:;z ~Vl....vc o'.t--- A 1,,rlJ /a tc, N-A-. V:,?l,vA-~u /.e,1-d- (;_. U. c) Juh;a- ·

V ? r ,l J . .. __,

~e, NiJI k:rJt-- e,t/cl"tt._ k.,'1; oe a#w-_§jryk.h,. ,;,J,o. J?.M ~b'fl:*'-;c

,. ~ ._. \. . . . ...,.. ·-..:\.' ,~

{61-) .l)A , C,x di J /lo I jL,.,-sfve[i/v= ~ · c/hfr i;~,1-:/.J-w,vi: fkr,1_

'--··

J1eV;ee4/ f/~'j~to/f/k:f rw ~~ &-!)/#)c&;1 Wcu/ag lv :z.fu- LW

l . ' ',

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 7 of 20

r . < · / OVZ/L 1w: ~RtM~ t'trc(u.d/~ kMf &t1l Maq,-frtf--R- Motkttsi1/ttJd Jf;A/,,.r,g h fJ,1. CPx:

~, ( '

ha~ he f;'u, NKM 4- r4:r4-d"') A .,, v Lbxl... 7lv= ,wst k clwu

J r . A-m;{ 10-,) £ l1& 100 °1" CAlc/w1 (0,v y-ll-11)1 A:Nt1 ;lt11: bl' MzA:l- ~'!&9 UA!

_ __ __,Ga_r;;) A/{ Ji:Nloct2)t1Lol°e[St tr A: tiocfr4 tJk, f-&:Ait' (o,yd/lh66 121.d,J:r,--d, Jo fii5 J/,.,vde oj-: 7Ze kl/AN ;("' H ~ lu.R lto!L!d:S &c:Ld.. .fl!igbj_~ -/tJf &

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 8 of 20

- I

I

h d(,ve dAu;11Al

. ? uyo1M J!.ok l~J (QA[f&;c/-,'1 .LfJ,1J'Cks, 4.g[&":,1!)1 ho,Ut,otl«s M}dLA!!ll/'f' MoAfe~

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 9 of 20

;- , ~ I

h -k1c /4l<1-ti1mic184Ndr u&rJ. ll<td.t-les tl()ocL c:#dut:{ kv41 1#d law V:h-

I J

,4Chi?S>' lt/d"ef ./¥p1A.=r(1 ft~ bu/wu.s. 1 &ko;at2>i~l.e, &R!'.Vow: ,~11.pct!w-u,

~ ~ .

62-- "ti ;,JL?J, :tfj 4 t)\J /t'r Cffl:1 t41f eA-S f#f+/Mk Ir, 4::1 &4 .. , #;t

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 10 of 20

' - . (}'.z) m, fol( J t2.-3-l2 ~co//J4N, _sio/'µ- ( .?£), tJM clUE -&Mf? ~Mf

• 7 I

jZfo 64:11, k/6,,'c/,_, I~ 4d_r;///.,'r;1/ h A4Vt~ CA-YS'a A'bmt7trrtJtl~vRZi ~'r111£n >1 /,JAf

cf1'Jd AJ<Mallkij6'os/t (f4-:-H-h;~ cloA1€ 't-'1-13)1 ~,'P./,e -1~&,tfJ ,W/~~' , ___ _ ~ CAl4~ &I -KN~ rnfc/'-/er2' 1tJJ.osbfk~k,vJ {J,.,;:3b"'f1 doAILS-i-~j

~ ' / I

.i

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 11 of 20

I I I '1+/,v, Aip/rkzMl rA, -/41- ltd ,evn 1.;7-/;UiQ/\/u.,,-;J. h!}.oR,,, oA ,Yi\fca, I - ' l

I .

ud it - ~v/&\1 lto4i', 4J4h /,JAif Ji/ik Wl2@, tw~ik/Ald1 v/Jd b-r wcr-

? - r ; Ale J-,h1{ f)/fatwA!, 4~ d,c£ 4,,,,4 ~ ct,lciu11. kvdr ~ebeuk-d :b AloR.aefANd.

· rr> i+s d~tiW-raA :#ii 't-16-0 -k.e:-4nArMd: 4- iJuA~icil ad',/ ·a} :.~f¥10,Jl£4

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 12 of 20

RA:/-,af · ~ jp /o~ 1 4t1a~ #&11: (j) h/rh tloJ~Si,fRR, -CVRt<~ /ufgf\[.J.ai,._~~td.',-L-'~~>R--­

OVd {, fR:M.i) (.Jj)g4-.J Ae-Mf 4,.,u{ leM-f Yt!IYt:./:eotk-ns. CMH.--:d 6J ~ 4 /J-d;.(J,,.

J I ( / f (

kOMr. ,ol.ohk::a.s -J/.,1(_/Be~kl;r:Jelftff ~:fk, '1J-~1.c~~.,.,f~t4)1. Lo!V~ 1v~1;

. ' I

- f.{!Rk'eij &rel Cx.v,';) .Jlull.J;k Jw;t~et:, t kM, P-,e~JJ-,bvl4t,f&t~~l~/ efl/7AA1-

C . .· T · -#411!'. A alm:cA-cl& 6,§-ba ,~~ CrM,,e:-d, 1u,./J,,_ Ju~u;, Q/)1 9-i_t-fL ·.

# kU v,,.J~. r t . .

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 13 of 20

r . · rr · !);,,.11) ie: (}WfJG o?: £'r Sflty/vlfr;.' 411) l!~udilf .,+ CiJJtr! Ar.Jrf~ U:t'A-z cy~- ' • • f< I

D~ ~.fQ

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 14 of 20

]

• ~ I , . • (

ViA/h .dod&s o'r f&.£A111~J ·,tb";J AA'ik7ii i./th 4Ni kr&e!;,*' M/Mrl« Prit. bi h

. c

[

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 15 of 20

(60)

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 16 of 20

. t 'JI"!. ........ • ~ ,. '

(63) ~o&oV, ·- , ,,. • . ,; . • -

C6s) -a -

tr CM2 ~>ttlltif /1,,x, (bdllet£\ Ix, k ~. wv~,,.. ,='••· oi,cz , , 6! ~c4Nk l/tJ If( . 'kl:, a it,

i

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 17 of 20

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 18 of 20

, , I C . r«9=-~0 due: /.v ~N/sJ Aei,'oALtl' A.if~g 01:1/U/DMt'J &vd h S'/-;ttJ~ut:-

l... -

fzch? du.If. fo ii, A-Nfi 2-ott. v/u'd ii£ ~dfe it;g b4u1,~ M/e:f: ~ . Ci> iJ~cbu~Jar 1uJ;lf.fvvf; A'!at't /Ml cl.~ iav~ k11!t.~

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 19 of 20

T - . lo . tz(k'; @14e.l\-;; ~u11 la S<'1 bo,~ I-~ &i dl.rrulacdtoAI) CA:U.Sb?:I .l h/tt. al~db

( {I

{).R;-1211;.J}d h (QR.&cl: du~ h hJfPFk:Joc l?aCs, t/,lJJ--lo.i.r}i·f)o/PltA~( F . ~ • I

Je,,Jc,k h f'.ovl;/i,- ~;.,tb ,8':4v/M 1,dJ~ ;/; ,~V,)g ~ Wl[..,-#c :£..

I ---/!o. &x t'iao -WSPF

Case: 3:16-cv-00639-bbc Document #: 36 Filed: 02/16/17 Page 20 of 20