nishat project

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

strategic management

Citation preview

ContentPakistan Textile Industry3Textile as the backbone of Pakistan economy:4Nishat Textile Mills. Ltd5History5Over the years5TEXTILE CAPACITY5EXPORT ORIENTED ORGANIZATION5COMPANY INFORMATION6Plant location6Vision & vision Statement8Vision statement8Mission statement8Input stage10EFE MATRIX FOR NISHAT TEXTILE11IFE MATRIX FOR NISHAT TEXTILE13CPM (Competitor PROFILE MATRIX)16MATCHING STAGE18SWOT MATRIX OF NISHAT TEXTILE19THE STRATEGIC POSITION AND ACTION EVALUATION (SPACE) MATRIX.21SPACE Matrix of Nishat Textile21THE SPACE MATRIX23AGGRESSIVE STRATEGY23THE BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP (BCG) MATRIX24INTERPRETATIONS:26THE INTERNAL-EXTERNAL (IE) MATRIX27INTERPRETATIONS:28THE GRAND STRATEGY MATRIX29INTERPRETATIONS:29DECESION STAGE31THE QUANTITATIVE STRATEGIC PLANNING MATRIX (QSPM)32INTERPRETATION:33

Pakistan Textile IndustryAccording to the textile ministry of Pakistan, export targets for the year 2012 are US $ 14 billion. However exporters fear a shortage of 30% ($4 billion) in textile exports this year due to severe energy shortage. So, Due to severe energy shortage, textile industry of the country is likely to miss export target by US $ 4 billion during the current year.

Textile as the backbone of Pakistan economy: Textile sector is the backbone of Pakistans economy and contributes significantly to the export sector. Pakistan is the fourth largest producer of cotton and third largest consumer. It contributes 8.5% to the GDP and employs 38% of the workforce in the manufacturing sector. Its share to the total exports is about 60%. It is ranked 12th in the global textile exports. Despite facing numerous challenges due to persistent power crisis, high cost of doing business, poor law and order situation and host of other issues, Pakistans textile exports managed to grow by 28% during the year 2010-11 as against the exports of last year.At present an unorganized part of weaving sector is producing comparatively low value added grey cloth. The power loom sector employs poor technology; it faces scarcity of quality yarn and lacks institutional financing for its development. The growth record of Pakistan's textile industry shows a reverse trend, especially in the weaving capacity of the mill sector, in which the installed capacity of looms shrunk from 26,000 in 1978-79 to only 8,000 in 2010-11. The organized sector seemingly made a shift towards cotton spinning rather than make efforts to develop and modernize the weaving sector.Textiles Exports from Pakistan Textiles constitute a major exporting sector for Pakistan, which accounts for about 60%of the countrys total foreign exchange earnings. The major export items are yarn; gray Cloth, finished cloth, towels and bed sheets and their major customers are the USA, EU, Japan and Hong Kong. Many textile exports take place under quota arrangements With the EU and the United States. Gray cloth constitutes roughly 16- 18% of total cloth.Nishat Exports from Pakistan. Nishat gray cloth exports account for roughly 20 % of Pakistani gray cloth exports. The firm has been exporting to the USA for many years, and has only recently started to export to EU countries. In Pakistan, the cotton crop season runs approximately from August to March. Prices are generally high at the start of the season in August/September, and fall later on as supply increases. Following income tax law, the fiscal year runs from October to September for textiles sector.

Nishat Textile Mills. LtdHistoryNishat Mills Limited is the flagship company of Nishat Group. It was established in 1951. It is one of the most modern, largest vertically integrated textile company in Pakistan. Nishat Mills Limited has 199,536 spindles, 604 Toyota air jet looms and 40 Sulzer shuttle-less looms. The Company also has the most modern textile dyeing and processing units, 2 stitching units and Power Generation facilities with a capacity of 89 MW. The Companys total export for the year 2011 was Rs. 35.610 billion (US$ 416 million). Due to the application of prudent management policies, consolidation of operations, a strong balance sheet and an effective marketing strategy, the growth trend is expected to continue in the years to come. The Company's production facilities comprise of spinning, weaving, processing, stitching and power generation.Over the years1951Nishat Mills Limited commenced its business as partnership.

1959The company incorporated as private limited company.

1961Nishat Mills Limited was listed on Karachi Stock Exchange.

1989The Company was listed on Lahore Stock Exchange.

1992The Company was listed on Islamabad Stock Exchange.

1996Acquired the operating assets of Nishat Tek Limited and Nishat Fabrics Limited.

2005Acquired the assets of Umar Fabrics Limited.

2008Acquired the assets of Nishat Apparel Limited.

TEXTILE CAPACITY Production process consists of spinning, weaving, processing, and finishing. The processing includes dyeing, engraving. The textile capacity of the group is the largest in the country. An addition of 20000 new spindles, 100 new air jets looms and new dyeing plant has increased the existing capacity of 24000 spindles, 740 looms and dyeing and finishing capacity of 5 million meters. The group is the largest exporter of textile products from Pakistan for more than a decade.EXPORT ORIENTED ORGANIZATIONNishat mills limited are an export-oriented organization. Nishat mills limited exports more than 90% of its products mainly to the Far East, Europe and United States.COMPANY INFORMATIONBOARD OF DIRECTORS: Mian Umer Mansha Chairman/Chief Executive Mian Hassan Mansha Mr. Muhammad Nawaz Tishna (NIT) Mr. Khalid Qadeer Qureshi Mr. Muhammad Azam Rana Muhammad Mushtaq Ms. Nabiha Shahnawaz CheemaMILLS: Nishatabad, Faisalabad (Spinning units and Power Plant) 12 K.M. Faisalabad Road, (Weaving units & Power Plant) Sheikhupura. 21 K.M. Ferozepur Road, Lahore. (Stitching unit) 5 K.M. Nishat Avenue (Weaving, Dyeing & Finishing unit, Off 22 K.M. Ferozepur Road, Lahore. Processing unit, Stitching unit andPower Plant) 20 K.M. Sheikhupura Faisalabad (Spinning unit)Road, Feroze WatwanPlant locationPlant location is one of the main long-term strategic decisions normally taken by top management. Nishat mills limited is ideally located in, Niashatabad Faisalabad. 12- K.M Faisalabad road Shiekhupura. 21- K.M Ferozepur road Lahore. 5 K.M Nishat Avenue Lahore. Off 22.K.M Ferozepur road Lahore. 20-K.M Shiekhupura Faisalabad (ferozewatan)Main factory is located at Niashatabad. It is a composite unit. Composite unit means all the process i.e. from spinning to stitching takes place under one roof. Product process includes spinning, weaving, processing, finishing and stitching units.

Vision & vision StatementVision statementTo transform the Company into a modern and dynamic yarn, cloth and processed cloth and finished product manufacturing Company that is fully equipped to play a meaningful role on sustainable basis in the economy of Pakistan. To transform the Company into a modern and dynamic power generating Company that is fully equipped to play a meaningful role on sustainable basis in the economy of Pakistan.

Mission statementTo provide quality products to customers and explore new markets to promote/expand sales of the Company through good governance and foster a sound and dynamic team, so as to achieve optimum prices of products of the Company for sustainable and equitable growth and prosperity of the Company.

Mission statement analysis of Nishat TextileComponents

Costumers No

Products / services No

Markets No

Technology No

Philosophy No

Self-ConceptNo

Concern of EmployeesYes

Concern of Public Image Yes

Concern of public growth and profitabilityYes

Input stage

EFE MATRIX FOR NISHAT TEXTILE

KEY EXTERNAL FACTORS

WEIGHTRATINGWEIGHTED SCORE

OPPORTUNITIES

1) Organization can expand Product line 0.1030.3

2) Cost reduction by modern Technology. 0.0640.24

3) Capture new market segments around the world.0.0930.27

4) Hire more well-educated and experienced persons.0.0820.16

5) Organization can reduce the Cost by proper utilization of Resources. 0.0930.27

6) Local market development0.0840.32

7) People prefer quality fabric( quality awareness)0.0740.28

THREATS

1) Export of raw cotton.0.083 0.24

2) Exchange Rate Fluctuations.0.052 0.1

3) Political instability. 0.042 0.08

4) Globally economic instability0.053 0.15

5) Energy crises. 0.064 0.24

6) New entry of competitors.0.073 0.21

7) Buyer needs changes.0.084 0.32

Total 1 3.18

Reasoning for the weight:The result for EFE matrix is 3.18 that is really good. That is showing they can effectively take advantage of existing opportunities and can minimize the adverse effect of external threatsInterpretations: Opportunities: Product Expansion: Currently the Nishat is not dealing in knitwear they can expand their product line by producing knitwear. They have plants and the extra cost for the production will be low forNishat. And they also have bettermarket repute. Cost Reduction: If the cost of different matters which is not utilizing properly is controlled by the Nishat management they can produce more in a few costs. It has to develop a further systematic process for controlling and managing resources. New Hiring: They can take advantages by hiring more skilled people and they should hire young, fresh and energetic staff for their betterment. R&D and Global Competition: Because of the research and development the design and the product ofNishat is just satisfactory as compare to competitors globally andthey are notfulfilling the demand of customer.Threats: Political Instability: Political instability effects the Nishat because of the quota system the company can be restrict by the government to export. Unpredictable Government Policies: Government policies are changing day to day so it is a threat for the Nishat to survive in such a changeable situation. Economic Instability: Because of the economic instability the Nishat affected a lot. Dumping system which is rising on dailybasis in the world can create many problems for the company and any uncertainty in the world like 9/11 may affect also the overall export. Energy Crisis: energy crisis prevailing in the last five years is also creating a pathetic situation even for the big giant like Nishat to survive.

IFE MATRIX FOR NISHAT TEXTILE

KEY INTERNAL FACTORS

WEIGHTRATINGWEIGHTED SCORE

STRENGTHS

1) Latest mechanized machinery. 0.08 3 0.24

2) Adequate financial resources. 0.09 4 0.36

3) Competitive advantage. 0.10 4 0.4

4 Equipped with MIS system 0.07 3 0.21

5) Own power generation plant. 0.08 4 0.32

6) ISO 9000 & IKO certified. 0.06 4 0.24

7) Biggest composite unit. 0.08 3 0.24

WEAKNESS

1) Centralized Decision making. 0.06 4 0.24

2) Weak image in International market. 0.07 2 0.14

3) Lack of benefits & reward to employees. 0.08 3 0.24

4) High employee turnover. 0.09 3 0.27

5) High production cost. 0.04 2 0.08

6) Small international market share 0.06 3 0.18

7) Less promotional activities. 0.04 4 0.16

Total 1 3.32

Reasoning for the weight:For the matrix the average score is 2.5 and our score is 3.32 which really good so this good score show a strong internal position of theNishat textile. This means that theNishat textile is above in its internal strength.Interpretations: Strengths: ISO Certification: Nishat textile is certified underISO9001-2000 and so it meets the requirement of international standard and has a value in the mind of concern people. Adequate financial resources. Modern Technology: They are using modern looms which they have purchased from Japan and France. And by using that latest machinery the productivity of the employees are very high. Business Giants: As we know that Nishat is a big giant in industry and they are enjoying a competitive advantage. The owner of the Nishat is one of the richest persons of the Pakistan and they have more plant and investment in other industries like cement, Bank, They have adequate financial resources to meet theirrequirements. Because it is an old textile and it has still keep its position in the textile market on all others competitors in the nationwide whichis its competitive advantage MIS management: They have a management information system by which the departments and employees are connect with each other and they have a data ware house by which they can share their resources easily. Power Generation: They have own power generation plant and Nishat is the pioneer in the private organization who start the power generation. And also selling to the WAPDA Its produced power.Threats: Centralized Decision Making: The decisions are made by the upper management which is weakness of the Nishat because they have no proper idea aboutthe situation and their decision can be not fruitful for the company. Scarce Resource Availability: Because of the other textile specialized countries like China, Bangladesh etc. the international image in the textile sector is very weak. Those countries providing cheap product to the market than Pakistan textile industries because of the resource availability and cheap raw materials. Small Market Share: Although Nishat has very strong in the national wide but it has small market share in the global textile industry due to the sound competitors like china, and Bangladesh etc. Weak Promotional Strategies: The advertising and promotional cost of the Nishat textile is very low it can take advantage for more turnouts. Weak Reward system: Some facilities that other providing to their employees like Transport and medical fee etc. Nishat notproviding to their employees because of which the productivity of the employees decrease.

CPM (Competitor PROFILE MATRIX)Critical Success FactorsNishat TextilesKohinoor Textile Mill

WeightRatingScoresRatingScores

Customer Satisfaction0.3030.941.2

Global Expansion0.0530.1540.2

Market Share

0.0520.1030.15

Pricing

0.1040.430.3

Conformance to standard0.3041.230.9

Promotional Activities0.1030.3020.2

Persuasion0.0540.2030.15

Organizational involvement of employees0.0530.1540.2

Total1.003.43.3

Evaluation As we know that competitive profile matrix identifies firms major competitors and its particular strengths and weaknesses in relation to a sample firms strategic position. Comparisons been made on the basis of the strengths and weaknesses encountered by careful in depth analysis of competing firms. We have grouped the strengths and weaknesses of existing firm Nishat mills in order to compare the ratings and weighted scores with its rivalry potential firm Kohinoor textile mills. This comparative analysis provides important internal strategic information. In our case the two most important factors to being successful in industry are gaining and maintaining Customer Satisfaction and Quality as indicated by weights of 0.30. As satisfaction of prospective customers plays vital role in enhancing the sales and building reputation of the firm and Quality provides as a means of excellence in the product or service that fulfills or exceeds the expectations of the customer. Nishat mills is strongest on maintaining quality control standards under the ISO stated standards and is indicated by the rating of 4 whereas the competitor firm is a step behind in adapting to ISO quality management systems . The company has a diverse customer base with sales in both the local and export markets. The main international markets include Asia, Europe, USA and Australia. Kohinoor has a diversified customer base because of its association and partnership with most of the top leading brands of the world which has strong persuasion and brand image in market place. Zara, old navy , champion , Dockers ( san Francisco ) , wrangler, Levi Strauses signature, banana republic, Yakka ,Li & Fung Limited, Jc Penney ( everyday matters ) , Dickies, fruit of the loom, Payless (shoe source). Kohinoor is strongest in retaining more customers and is strongest on customer satisfaction indicated by rating of 4 as compare to Nishat with rating of 3. Overall Nishat is strongest as indicated by the total weighted score of 3.4

MATCHING STAGE

SWOT MATRIX OF NISHAT TEXTILESTRENGTHS____S

Latest mechanized machinery adequate financial resources Competitive advantage own power generation plant ISO 900 and IKO certified Biggest composite unit Equipped with MIS system

WEAKNESS____W Centralized decision making Weak image in international market Lack of benefits and rewards to employees High employee turnover Small international market share Less promotional activities High production cost

OPPURTUNITIES____O Organization can expand its product line Cost reduction Cotton cloth export also export also increased to $1.13 billion during this period as compared to $1.03 billion in 2000-01. The future in the UAE markets appears promising Capture new market segments around the world Local market development Organization can hire more experienced trainers and skillful employees Government could apply sustainable policies for the interest of exporters and investors

THREATS___T Buyers need change Political instability Global economic instability Export of raw cotton Energy crises Entry of new competitors Exchange rate fluctuation

SO STRATEGIES Technical filtration with the help of Nishat's mechanized machinery can help the company achieve expansion i-e through expanding its current product line. (S1, O1) Nishat can gain competitive edge through cost cutting by the proper utilization of financial resources. (S2,O2) Using the company's competitive advantage over other firms Nishat can focus on local market development as well as capture new market segments around the world. (S3,O5,O4)

ST STRATEGIES By capitalizing on the latest mechanized machinery Nishat can effectively meet the changing needs of its buyers(S1,T1) Keeping in mind Nishats competitive advantage and reputation in the textile industry new entrants would find it a big risk and will be hesitant before entering the industry so sustainable competitive advantage would be best policy here(S3,T6) Keeping in view the energy crises Nishat set up an independent power plant which allows automation and uptime flexible production of products(S4,T5) Nishat is a trendsetter with adequate financial resources which facilitates it to introduce innovative strategies that can meet the changing demands of the customers(S2,T1)

WO STRATEGIES Competitively capturing new market segments will result in strong market image internationally(W2,O4) Organization can reduce operating cost by considering employees suggestions and providing both financial and non-financial benefits hence boosting up the morale which in turn increase employees motivation(W3,O2)

WT STRATEGIES By focusing on strong brand endorsement by international and national models to gain customer loyalty in order to minimize the risk of new entrants(W6,T6) Government should develop conducive policies and appropriate measures should be taken such as TQM programmers and, to ensure that standardized products are being produced(W2,T2) Employees should be appreciated by the organization and supervisors. Employee recognition programs should be introduced in the organization. Such plans can motivate employees not to just work for the sake of money but also for their learning experience.So the employees will be encouraged to work which in turn decrease turnover rate. (W4, T3)

THE STRATEGIC POSITION AND ACTION EVALUATION (SPACE) MATRIX.

SPACE Matrix of Nishat Textile

FINANCIAL POSITION (FP)

Return on Investment.3Liquidity.4Leverage.4Working capital.2 13INDUSTRY POSITION (IP)

Resources utilization.4Growth potential.3Financial stability.4Profit potential.5 16

STABILITY POSITION (SP)

Rate of inflation.-3Barriers to entry into market.-2Technological changes.-2Price range of competing products.-3-10

COMPETITVE POSITION (CP)

Product quality.-3Market share.-1Technological knowhow.-4Product lifecycle.-4-12

CONCLUSIONS

SP average is -10/4 = -2.5

IP average is +16/4 = 4

CP average is -12/4 = -3

FP average is +13/4 = 3.25

Directional Vector Coordinates:x-axis: -3 + (+4) = 1 y-axis: -2.5 + (+3.25) = 0.75

THE SPACE MATRIX

CONSERVATIVE6AGGRESSIVEMarket penetration 5 Backward, forward, horizontal integrationProduct development 4 Market penetrationMarket development 3 Market developmentRelated diversification 2Product development 1 Diversification (related or unrelated) 0 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 -1 DEFENSIVE-2COMPETITIVERetrenchment -3 Backward, forward, horizontal integrationDivestiture -4 Market penetrationLiquidation -5 Market development -6 Product development

This graph shows that Nishat textile is in the third quadrant which is aggressive strategy quadrant.

AGGRESSIVE STRATEGYNishat textile directional vector is located in the aggressive quadrant (upper-right quadrant) of the SPACE matrix, Nishat is in an excellent position to use its internal strengths to(1) Take advantage of external opportunities,(2) Overcome internal weaknesses, and(3) Avoid external threats. Therefore, market penetration, market development, product development, backward integration, forward integration, horizontal integration, or diversification can be feasible.

THE BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP (BCG) MATRIX

No of divisionDescriptionRevenues%RevenuesProfits%profitsMarket shareRelative market shareGrowth rate

1Nishat textileRs.4856562.2484443%80.20.8%53.99%

2DGKCCRs.1857723.81711.5%40.30.4%14%

3Power plantRs.1090213.9629556.4570.10.7%-88%

TotalRs.78,044100Rs.11156100

Market Share High LowStars

High

IndustrialGrowth

Question Mark

Cash Cow

Low

Dogs

INTERPRETATIONS:Nishat Textiles is a composite textile unit of Nishat Group. Total number of players in the industry is 60, and Nishat Textiles is the market leader. It captures 12% market share as a whole. In 2011, the industrial overall growth rate is 11%, but that of Nishat Textiles is 24% as compare to the sales of 2008.Source: KSE (Karachi stock exchange) data for 2011, and 2012.The industrial growth is high and Nishat Textiles has high market growth as well. So, it lies in the first quadrant (Stars) of the BCG matrix. It implies that, company has the opportunity to go for Market penetration to capture more shares in the existing market by using new technology, and increasing promotional activities. It also has a tremendous option of local market development.Other feasible strategies may be the backward integration to secure the supplies in order to tackle with the threat of exporting of local raw material to foreign markets. Also Nishat Textiles goes for forward integration to minimize its weakness of transit time of goods and services to its customers.

THE INTERNAL-EXTERNAL (IE) MATRIX

IFE TOTAL SCOREA- B- Strong 3.0-4.0 Moderate 2.0 2.99 Low 1.0- 1.99C- I

Grow and Build

II

Grow and BuildIII

Hold and Maintain

IVGrow and Build

VHold and MaintainVIHarvest

VII

Hold and Maintain

VIII

HarvestIX

Divest

D- High3.0-4.0

E- F- G- H- I- Medium2.0-2.99

J- EFE TOTALSCORE

K- L- M- N- O- P- Q- R- S- Low1.0-1.99

T- U- V-

INTERPRETATIONS:IFE Total Score (As per IFE Matrix) = 3.18EFE Total Score (As per EFE Matrix) = 3.32W- As per IE Matrix, Nishat Textiles lies in first cell, which implies that it should go for aggressive strategies that are grow and build strategies. The possible strategies for Nishat Textiles may be the integrations, intensive, and diversifications.Nishat Textiles has the opportunity to go for intensive strategies to capture more shares in the existing market by market penetration, market development and product development.Other feasible strategies may be the backward integration to secure the supplies in order to tackle with the threat of exporting of local raw material to foreign markets. Also Nishat Textiles goes for forward integration to minimize its weakness of transit time of goods and services to its customers.

THE GRAND STRATEGY MATRIXRapid Market GrowthQuadrant II

Quadrant I

Quadrant III

Quadrant IV

StrongCompetitiveAdvantege

WeakCompetitiveAdvantage

Slow Market Growth

INTERPRETATIONS:Total number of players in the industry is 60, and Nishat Textiles is the market leader. It captures 12% market share as a whole. In 2011, the industrial overall growth rate is 9%, but that of Nishat Textiles is 24% as compare to the sales of 2008.NML got the edge of having their own power plant due to that they are not suffering from industrial power crisis. And sustaining their position in Market. As the market growth is high, and Nishat Textiles has strong comparative position in the market. So, it lies in the first quadrant of Grand strategy matrix, which implies that it should go for aggressive strategies. The possible strategies for Nishat Textiles may be Market Development, Market Penetration, Backward and Forward Integrations. And Nishat is also implementing these strategies by developing their market in a combination with forward integrations by opening their retail stores named Nishat Linen. They are also going in cotton production which is also a competitive edge as they are controlling the whole supply chain. And implying with quality sustainability to cope up with ISO standards.

DECESION STAGE

THE QUANTITATIVE STRATEGIC PLANNING MATRIX (QSPM)

Develop a shoe line for womenCapturing new market segments around the world

Key factors

Weight ASTASASTAS

OPPORTUNITIES

1) Organization can expand Product line2) Cost reduction by modern Technology3) Capture new market segments around the world4) Hire more well-educated and experienced persons:5) Organization can reduce the Cost by proper utilization of Resources:6) Local market development:7) People spend on quality fabric

0.100.060.09

0.08

0.09

0.080.07

4-1

-

-

310.4

0.09

0.240.07

1-4

-

-

230.10

0.36

0.160.21

THREATS

1) Export of raw cotton.2) Exchange Rate Fluctuations3) Political instability4) Globally economic instability5) Energy crises6) New entry of competitors7) Buyer needs changes

0.080.050.040.050.060.070.08--22--3

0.080.1

0.24--22--2

0.080.1

0.16

TOTAL1.00

STRENGTHS

1) Latest mechanized machinery2) Adequate financial resources3) Competitive advantage4) Equipped with MIS system 5) Own power generation plant 6) ISO 9000 & IKO certified7) Biggest composite unit

0.080.090.100.070.080.060.08243----0.160.360.3

243----0.160.360.3

WEAKNESSES

1) Centralized Decision making2) Weak image in International market3) Lack of benefits & reward to employees4) High employee turnover5) High production cost6) Small international market share7) Less promotional activities0.060.070.080.090.040.060.04-1--31-0.07

0.120.06-4--34-0.28

0.120.24

TOTAL1.00

Sum Total Attractive Score2.292.63

INTERPRETATION:The two strategies that are considered by Nishat are achieving expansion through expanding product line and Capturing new market segments around the world. According to Sum of Total Attractive Score the company should go for capturing new market segment around the world as its STAS is 2.63. The attractive score are given on the basis of how much these factors affect the strategy. the more they effect the higher the score is given. the highest score given is 4 mean the factor is highly attractive to the strategy. Nishat can expand product line by developing a shoe line for women so it is highly effective strategy so it has been given a score of 4. But by entering into international market Nishat is not expanding the product line so a score of 1 is given. By entering into international market Nishat will be able to capture international market therefore has been given a score of 4. The strengths and threats almost effect both the strategy equally as both requires financial resources and machinery to be implemented. These both strategies if successfully implemented can lead to competitive advantage but of course only these two strategies cannot gain competitive advantage but they can help in gaining competitive advantage that is why they have been given the score of 3. Financial resources is needed to develop new product line and is also needed to enter into international market that is why it has been given a score of 4. Threats of political instability, global economic instability somewhat effect the both strategy equally and buyers need change effect the strategy of developing a new product line so has been given a score of 3.Weak image in international market and small international market share are affected by the strategy of entering into international market that is why they have been given a score of 4 and 4.The strategy of entering into international market is a attractive strategy for Nishat to pursue.