NATOs Relationship With Russia

8/11/2019 NATOs Relationship With Russia

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/natos-relationship-with-russia 1/15

Dr Andrew FoxallThe Henry Jackson Society

September 2014

A Fateful Summit:The Future of

NATO’s Relationshipwith RussiaRussia Studies CentrePolicy Paper No. 1 (2014)



"

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

),--./0

1,223.42 356.2375 .58 399:;.9 .55:<.=375 7> ?/3-:. 35 *./@A BC"D E =A: >3/2= 7,=/3;A= 9.58;/.F 35 &,/7G: F0 . -.H7/ G7I:/ 235@: =A: :58 7> =A: ?798 J./ E @.,;A= K#%L 7>>M;,./8 .58 A.2 =A/7I5 =A: .993.5@:42 /:9.=3752A3G I3=A 1,223. 35=7 @/3232N 1,223. A.2 ;75:>/7- F:35; . O2=/.=:;3@ G./=5:/4 P.9F:3= . 83>>3@,9= 75:Q =7 . A72=39: .;;/:227/N

K#%L -,2= /:63:I =A: =A/:.= G72:8 F0 1,223. .58 @75238:/ A7I 3= I7,98 /:2G7582A7,98 =A: 23=,.=375 35 'R/.35: I7/2:5 7/ /:G:.= 3=2:9> 35 . K#%L @7,5=/0N 1,223.G:/@:36:2 =A.= K#%L 9.@R2 =A: [email protected] I399 =7 /:2G758 =7 .;;/:22375S .58 =A: .F2:5@: 7>2,@A . /:63:I I7,98 /32R @75>3/-35; =A32N

K#%L -,2= 8:6:97G 5:I 2=/.=:;3:2 >7/ 8:.935; I3=A =A: =A/:.= G72:8 F0 1,223.S35@9,835;T .88/:2235; ,5@756:5=375.9 >7/-2 7> I./>./:U ,58:/=.R35; . G/7;/.--: 7>

/:./-.-:5= =7 /:F,398 3=2 -393=./0 @.G.@3=0U ,58:/=.R35; /:;,9./ 9./;:[email protected]: -393=./0:<:/@32:2 35679635; .99 9:6:92 7> 8:@32375M-.R35;U 8:6:97G35; @/:83F9: @756:5=375.9 >7/@:2U.58 ,58:/=.R35; =A: >7/I./8 8:G970-:5= 7> =/77G2 =7 :.2=:/5 &,/7G:N

$7/ 76:/ =I7 8:@.8:2S K#%L42 2:@,/3=0 G/37/3=3:2 A.8 >7@,22:8 75 =://7/32- .58 >.39:82=.=:2N JA39: =A:2: /:-.35 63=.9S =A: 8/.I87I5 35 #>;A.532=.5 @7,G9:8 =7 :6:5=2 35'R/.35: -:.5 =A.= =A: .993.5@: 32 /:V,3/:8 =7 G/37/3=32: =A: 8:>:5@: 7> :.2=:/5 &,/7G:.;.352= 1,223. 35 3=2 5:<= @A.G=:/N

%7G 9:.8:/2A3G 35 K#%L A.2 673@:8 2:/37,2 @75@:/52 =A.= =A: .993.5@: I7,98 57= F: .F9:=7 2=.58 ,G =7 1,223.5 .;;/:22375N %A32 -.R:2 3= 3-G:/.=36: >7/ K#%L -:-F:/2 =7

/:5:I =A:3/ @7--3=-:5= =7 2G:58 BW 7> =A:3/ XYZ 75 8:>:5@: 2G:5835;N

%A: J.9:2 ),--3= 32 =A: -72= 3-G7/=.5= -::=35; E .58 -72= 83>>3@,9= =:2= E >7/ K#%L35 . ;:5:/.=375N K#%L -,2= /32: =7 =A: @A.99:5;: G/7638:8 F0 1,223.42 .;;/:22375 .58 358735; 27 /:.22:/= 3=2 7I5 @/:83F393=0N



B

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

+5=/78,@=375

JA:5 Z/3-: *3532=:/ Y.638 ?.-:/75 .557,5@:8 35 K76:-F:/ BC"[ =A.= =A: '\ I7,98 A72==A: K#%L 2,--3= 35 K:IG7/=S 27,=A J.9:2 75 D .58 ] ):G=:-F:/ BC"DS >:I 3-.;35:8 =A.= 3=

I7,98 F: . 8:>3535; -7-:5= >7/ =A: .993.5@:N # 2,--3= =A.= I.2 :<G:@=:8 =7 /:63:I =A:

+5=:/5.=375.9 ):@,/3=0 #2232=.5@: $7/@: P+)#$Q -322375 35 #>;A.532=.5 .2 3= :582 35 9.=: BC"D -,2=

352=:.8 7>>:/ . 8:>353=36: /:2G752: =7 1,223.42 .@=3752 35 'R/.35:N %A:2: .@=3752 =A/:.=:5 =7

/:G9.@: . /,9:2MF.2:8 35=:/5.=375.9 7/8:/ I3=A 75: ;76:/5:8 F0 [email protected] 8:2=.F3932.=375 =:@A53V,:2S

-393=./0 G7I:/ .58 :@757-3@ @7:/@375N

1,223.42 356.2375 .58 399:;.9 .55:<.=375 7> =A: ?/3-:.5 G:5352,9. 35 *./@A BC"D E =A: >3/2=

7,=/3;A= 9.58 ;/.F 35 &,/7G: F0 . -.H7/ G7I:/ 235@: =A: :58 7> =A: ?798 J./ E @.,;A= K#%L

7>>M;,./8 .58 A.2 =A/7I5 =A: .993.5@:42 /:9.=3752A3G I3=A 1,223. 35=7 @/3232N #= =A: =3-:S K#%L

):@/:=./0MX:5:/.9 #58:/2 $7;A 1.2-,22:5 8:2@/3F:8 1,223.42 .@=3752 .2 @.,235; ^=A: -72=

2:/37,2 @/3232 35 &,/7G: 235@: =A: >.99 7> =A: _:/935 J.99` .58 8:@9./:8 =A.= =A: .993.5@: @.5 ^57

975;:/ 87 F,235:22 .2 ,2,.9 I3=A 1,223.`N" K#%L42 /:2G752:S A7I:6:/S A.2 F::5 93-3=:8 E

2=/:5;=A:535; @77G:/.=375 I3=A 'R/.35:S /:.>>3/-35; 3=2 @7--3=-:5= =7 8:>:58 @:5=/.9 .58 :.2=:/5

&,/7G:.5 .993:2S .58 /:F,R35; 1,223.N L5 " #G/39S =A: .993.5@: 2,2G:58:8 .99 G/.@[email protected] @77G:/.=375

I3=A *72@7I E =A: 2:@758 =3-: 3= A.8 875: 27 235@: BCCaS IA:5 1,223. 356.8:8 X:7/;3.N ),@A

I7/82 .58 .@=3752S A7I:6:/S 2@./@:90 A38: =A: >.@= =A.= =A: .993.5@: >.39:8 =7 8:=:/ 1,223.42

.;;/:22375 .58 I.2 399MG/:G./:8 =7 @7,5=:/ 1,223.42 ,2: 7> ,5@756:5=375.9 I./>./: .58 3=2

35>7/-.=375 I./ IA:5 3= 7@@,//:8N &6:5 -:-F:/2 7> =A: .993.5@: 3=2:9> E 5.-:90S Z79.58 .58 =A:

=A/:: _.9=3@ 2=.=:2 E A.6: F::5 A3;A90 @/[email protected] .= IA.= =A:0 2:: .2 =7R:532- 35 K#%L42 /:2G752: =7

=A: 'R/.35: @/3232N

L5 =A: :6: 7> =A: J.9:2 2,--3=S Z/:238:5= b9.83-3/ Z,=3542 35=:5=375 =7 :<=:58 1,223.42 2GA:/:

7> 35>9,:5@: .58 G723=375 A32 @7,5=/0 .2 .5 .5=3MJ:2=:/5 G7I:/ 32 57= =A: 7590 322,: >.@35;

K#%LN %A: /32: 7> =A: +29.-3@ )=.=: 35 =A: *3889: &.2= .58 =A: 93-3=:8 2,@@:22 7> K#%L42

7G:/.=3752 35 #>;A.532=.5 .58 (3F0. ./: 7=A:/2 >.@=7/2 =A.= I399 8:=:/-35: K#%L42 >,=,/:

83/:@=375N K:6:/=A:9:22S =A: 'R/.35: @/3232 E IA3@A I399 >:.=,/: A3;A90 35 35=:/5.=375.9 2:@,/3=0

8:F.=:2 >7/ =A: >7/:2::.F9: >,=,/: E 32 @A3:> .-75;2= =A:2:N += G72:2 G/7>7,58 .58 =/7,F935;

V,:2=3752 /:;./835; K#%L42 >,=,/: G/:G./:85:22 2A7,98 =A: 23=,.=375 35 'R/.35: I7/2:5 7/

/:G:.= 3=2:9> 35 . -:-F:/ 2=.=: 7> =A: .993.5@:N

"

O# )=/75; K#%L 35 . ?A.5;:8 J7/984S .6.39.F9: .=T A==GTccIIIN5.=7N35=c@G2c:5c5.=7936:c7G353752d"CaB"]NA=-S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN

http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/opinions_108215.htm






[

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

N K#%L4) 1:9.=3752 I3=A 1,223. Z/37/ =7 =A: 'R/.35:

?/3232

K#%L42 /:9.=3752A3G I3=A 1,223. F:;.5 35 Y:@:-F:/ "ee" I3=A =A: 35.,;,/.9 2:22375 7> =A:

K7/=A #=9.5=3@ ?77G:/.=375 ?7,5@39 PK#??QN %A: K#??S IA3@A I.2 9.=:/ /:5.-:8 =A: &,/7M

#=9.5=3@ Z./=5:/2A3G ?7,5@39 P&#Z?QS I.2 @/:.=:8 F0 K#%L 9:.8:/2 .>=:/ =A: :5835; 7> =A: ?798

J./ .2 .5 .==:-G= =7 >72=:/ . 5:I /:9.=3752A3G I3=A =A: 2=.=:2 7> @:5=/.9 .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G:N

#9=A7,;A =A: K#?? 2=7GG:8 2A7/= 7> :2=.F932A35; . >7/-.9 /:9.=3752A3G F:=I::5 K#%L .58

1,223.S 3= 838 9.0 =A: ;/7,58I7/R >7/ >,=,/: 8:6:97G-:5=2N

%A: /:9.=3752A3G 8::G:5:8 35 "eeDS IA:5 1,223. H735:8 =A: Z./=5:/2A3G >7/ Z:.@: PZ>ZQS .

K#%L 353=3.=36: =7 /:.@A 7,= =7 @7,5=/3:2 =A.= A.8 >7/-:/90 F::5 ,58:/ )763:= 35>9,:5@:N %A:

F/.35@A398 7> ') Z/:238:5= _399 ?935=75S =A: Z>Z I.2 8:23;5:8 =7 76:/2:: G/.@[email protected] 2:@,/3=0

@77G:/.=375 F:=I::5 K#%L .58 Z./=5:/2A3G 2=.=:2S G./=3@,9./90 I3=A /:;./82 =7 G:.@:R::G35;

7G:/.=3752NB +5 "eefS 1,223.5 27983:/2 I:/: 8:G970:8 =7 _7253. .58 g:/h:;7635. .2 G./= 7> =A:

K#%LM9:8 G:.@:R::G35; >7/@:2 E +-G9:-:5=.=375 $7/@: P+$L1Q .58 )=.F3932.=375 $7/@: P)$L1QN

#= =A: =3-:S 1,223.42 @75=/3F,=375 I.2 =A: 9./;:2= 575MK#%L @75=35;:5= 35 =A:2: >7/@:2N

#2 K#%L :<G.58:8 3=2 -:-F:/2A3G =7 35@9,8: >7/-:/ )763:= 2.=:993=: 2=.=:2 E Z79.58S =A: ?h:@A

1:G,F93@ .58 g,5;./0 F:;.5 .@@:22375 =.9R2 35 i,90 "eej .58 H735:8 =A: .993.5@: 35 *./@A "eee E

3= F.9.5@:8 =A: 35=:/:2=2 7> 7=A:/ .993.5@:M.2G3/.5= -:-F:/2 I3=A 1,223.5 @75@:/52S 5.-:90 =A.=

K#%L I.2 . -393=./0 F97@ A72=39: =7 1,223.42 35=:/:2=2N #2 . /:2,9=S 35 "eejS K#%L .58 1,223.

.;/::8 =A: ^$7,5835; #@= 75 *,=,.9 1:9.=3752S ?77G:/.=375 .58 ):@,/3=0`N %A: #@= ;.6: 1,223.

=A: .F393=0 =7 23= .= =A: 2.-: =.F9: .2 -:-F:/2 7> =A: .993.5@: P35 =A: ^"fk"` >7/-.=S .58 9.=:/

^"ek"`Q .58S 35 8735; 27S 27,;A= =7 >72=:/ 2=.F393=0 .58 2:@,/3=0 35 =A: &,/7M#=9.5=3@ /:;375N[

%7;:=A:/ I3=A =A: :2=.F932A-:5= 7> . Z:/-.5:5= i735= ?7,5@39 PZi?QS =A: #@= 7,=935:8 IA.=

K#%L I7,98 .58 I7,98 57= 87N K#%L @7--3==:8 =A.= 3= I7,98 57= 8:G970 ^2,F2=.5=3.9`

@7-F.= >7/@:2 35 [email protected] 2:523=36: /:;3752S .58 3=2 -:-F:/2S =A: #@= 2=.=:8S ^A.6: 57 35=:5=375S

57 G9.5 .58 57 /:.275 =7 8:G970 5,@9:./ I:.G752 75 =A: =://3=7/0 7> 5:I -:-F:/2`N %A32 I.2

7>>2:= F0 =A: 38:5=3>3@.=375 7> . 5,-F:/ 7> ./:.2 IA:/: K#%L .58 1,223. @7,98 @77G:/.=: 75

G/.@[email protected] -.==:/2 E IA:/: 2=/.=:;3@ G/37/3=3:2 .58 =.@[email protected] @A.99:5;:2 76:/9.GG:8N

J3=A =A: Zi?S /:;,9./ 83.97;,: F:=I::5 K#%L .58 1,223. F:;.5 =7 =.R: G9.@: .58 @77G:/.=375

@75=35,:8 76:/ =A: >7997I35; 0:./2 E 35 "eeaS >7/ :<.-G9:S 1,223. :2=.F932A:8 . 83G97-.=3@

-322375 =7 K#%LN K#%LM1,223. /:9.=3752 I:/:S A7I:6:/S 2:6:/:90 2=/.35:8 F0 OLG:/.=375 #993:8$7/@:4 E =A: .993.5@:42 "eee 35=:/6:5=375 35 l,;729.63.N L5 B[ *./@A "eeeS =A: 8.0 =A: LG:/.=375

F:;.5S 1,223. 2,2G:58:8 =3:2 I3=A K#%L .58 I3=A8/:I 3=2 /:G/:2:5=.=36:2 >/7- K#%L

A:.8V,./=:/2N JA39: 1,223.5 G:.@:R::G:/2 I:/: 2,F2:V,:5=90 8:G970:8S 35 2,--:/ "eeeS .2 G./=

7> =A: K#%LM9:8 G:.@:R::G35; >7/@: 35 \72767S 1,223. 6:A:-:5=90 7GG72:8 =A: 35=:/6:5=375

3=2:9>ND

B O%A: Z./=5:/2A3G >7/ Z:.@: G/7;/.--:4S .6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN5.=7N35=c@G2c:5c5.=7936:c=7G3@2d]C[DeNA=-S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN[ O$7,5835; #@=T 75 *,=,.9 1:9.=3752S ?77G:/.=375 .58 ):@,/3=0 F:=I::5 K#%L .58 =A: 1,223.5 $:8:/.=375 23;5:8 35 Z./32S $/.5@:4S Bj *.0 "eejS.6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN5.=7N35=c@G2c:5c5.=7936:c7>>[email protected]=:<=2dB]DfaNA=-S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DND

1,223.42 =/77G2 I:/: I3=A8/.I5 >/7- =A: K#%LM9:8 G:.@:R::G35; -322375 35 =A: _.9R.52 35 BCC[N

http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/topics_50349.htm



http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/official_texts_25468.htm







D

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

JA:5 (7/8 17F:/=275 F:@.-: K#%L ):@/:=./0MX:5:/.9 35 L@=7F:/ "eeeS A: @7--3==:8 =7

F/:.R35; =A: .993.5@:42 2=.9:-.=: I3=A 1,223. 76:/ \72767N )3< -75=A2 9.=:/S b9.83-3/ Z,=35 I.2

:9:@=:8 Z/:238:5= 7> 1,223. .58 .557,5@:8 =A.= A: I7,98 /:F,398 1,223.42 /:9.=3752 I3=A K#%L

^35 =A: 2G3/3= 7> G/.;-.=32-`N] %A: =://7/32= .==.@R2 35 =A: ') 75 "" ):G=:-F:/ BCC"S IA3@A 2.I

=A: >3/2=M:6:/ 3567@.=375 7> #/=3@9: b 7> =A: J.2A35;=75 %/:.=0S G/7638:8 =A: 7GG7/=,53=0 >7/ F7=A

K#%L .58 1,223. =7 87 =A32N %A: .==.@R2 -.8: @9:./ =A.= F7=A K#%L .58 1,223. >.@:8

@7--75 2:@,/3=0 =A/:.=2 E =://7/32-S I:.G752 7> -.22 8:2=/,@=375S .58 352=.F393=0 35 ?:5=/.9 #23.N

%A32 9:8 =7 =A: BCCB 17-: Y:@9./.=375S IA3@A 2.I =A: :2=.F932A-:5= 7> =A: K#%LM1,223.

?7,5@39 E . >7/,- 35 IA3@A 1,223. .58 K#%L -:-F:/2 23= .2 :V,.92 P^Bj -:-F:/2`S /.=A:/ =A.5

^Bfk"`Q .58 8:@323752 ./: -.8: 75 =A: F.232 7> @752:52,2N

%A: K#%LM1,223. ?7,5@39 G.6:8 =A: I.0 >7/ 1,223. .58 =A: .993.5@: =7 @77G:/.=: 35 :6:/M@972:/

G/.@[email protected] -393=./0 :<:/@32:2N +5 BCCDS 1,223. .58 K#%L 9.,5@A:8 =A: O#@=375 Z9.5 75 %://7/32-4N

$/7- BCCD 75I./82S =A:/: I:/: H735= :<:/@32:2 /:9.=:8 =7 O%A:.=/: *32239: Y:>:5@:4N +5 BCC]S =A:

O?7,5=:/MK./@7=3@2 %/.3535; Z/7H:@=4 I.2 :2=.F932A:8 =7 .88/:22 =A: =A/:.=2 G72:8 F0 =A:

=/.>>3@R35; 7> 5./@7=3@2 >/7- #>;A.532=.5N +5 BCCfS 1,223. H735:8 OLG:/.=375 #@=36: &58:.67,/4S

K#%L42 @7,5=:/M=://7/32- 7G:/.=375 35 =A: *:83=://.5:.5N #58 35 #G/39 BCCaS 1,223. 2,GG7/=:8

K#%L42 'KM-.58.=:8 +)#$ -322375 35 #>;A.532=.5 F0 >.@393=.=35; =A: 9.58 =/.523= 7> 575M-393=./0

:V,3G-:5= .@/722 1,223.5 =://3=7/0Nf

#9=A7,;A =A: 8.5;:/ 7> -393=./0 @75>93@= F:=I::5 1,223. .58 X:7/;3. A.8 >9./:8 2:6:/.9 =3-:2 35

/:@:5= 0:./2S K#%L I.2 @.,;A= F0 2,/G/32: IA:5S 35 :./90 #,;,2= BCCaS 1,223. .58 X:7/;3. I:5=

=7 I./ 76:/ =A: 2:G./.=32= /:;3752 7> #FRA.h3. .58 )7,=A L22:=3.N 1,223.42 ^832G/7G7/=375.=:

-393=./0 .@=375` 35 X:7/;3. /:2,9=:8 35 K#%L =:-G7/./390 2,2G:5835; -::=35;2 7> =A: K#%LM

1,223. ?7,5@39N K#%L A.9=:8 @77G:/.=375 35 @:/=.35 ./:.2S F,= @75=35,:8 35 7=A:/2 IA:/: =A:/:

I.2 @7--75 35=:/:2=S 2,@A .2 @7,5=:/M5./@7=3@2 .58 =A: >3;A= .;.352= =://7/32-N 1,223. /:2G758:8F0 @758,@=35; . /:63:I 7> 3=2 /:9.=3752 I3=A K#%L .58 2,2G:5835; -393=./0 @77G:/.=375N #2

K#%L -:-F:/2 35 @:5=/.9 .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: 2=/:22:8 .= =A: =3-: 7> =A: I./ .58 A.6:

/:G:.=:890 2=/:22:8 235@:S =A: .993.5@:42 /:2G752: I.2 =:G38 .58 9:>= =A:- .5<37,290 977R35; 76:/

=A:3/ 2A7,98:/2 .= 1,223.Nj

K#%LM1,223. 83.97;,: 2,F2:V,:5=90 /:2,-:8 35 *./@A BCCeS F,= =A: /:9.=3752A3G /:-.35:8

2=/.35:8N +5 #G/39 BCCeS .= =A: .993.5@:42 fC=A #5536:/2./0 ),--3=S K#%L 9:.8:/2 @7--3==:8 =7 .

5:I =/.52.=9.5=3@ .GG/7.@A =7I./82 1,223. .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G:S 2::R35; =7 8::G:5 @77G:/.=375

.58 :5;.;:-:5= =A/7,;A =A: K#%LM1,223. ?7,5@39N _./:90 . I::R 9.=:/S A7I:6:/S 1,223.

I3=A8/:I >/7- =A:2: :>>7/=2 @3=35; =:523752 76:/ . Z>Z :<:/@32: 35 X:7/;3.N

+5 Y:@:-F:/ BCCeS .= =A: >3/2= K#%LM1,223.5 ?7,5@39 -::=35; 235@: =A: 1,227MX:7/;3.5 I./S

K#%L .58 1,223.5 9:.8:/2 27,;A= =7 /:3563;7/.=: =A:3/ /:9.=3752A3G F0 .;/::35; =7 9.,5@A . Oi735=

1:63:I 7> B"2= ?:5=,/0 ?7--75 ):@,/3=0 ?A.99:5;:24N %A: 1:63:I I.2 :587/2:8 =A: >7997I35;

] O__? _/:.R>.2= J3=A $/72= +5=:/63:IT b9.83-3/ Z,=35S *./@A ] = AS BCCC4S __?S .6.39.F9: .=TA==GTcc5:I2NFF@N@7N,RcA3c:5;932Ac2=.=3@c.,837d638:7cG/7;/.--:2cF/:.R>.2=dI3=Ad>/72=c=/.52@/3G=2cG,=35]N-./N=<= S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DNf %A:2: .//.5;:-:5=2 I:/: :<G.58:8 35 BC"CS .58 9.=:/ ,G8.=:8 35 BC"BN )::S K#%LM1,223. ?7,5@39S Om,:2=3752 .58 #52I:/2 75 +)#$ =/.523= .581,223.4S "a i,90 BC"BS G;N "[S .6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN5.=7M/,223.M@7,5@39N35>7c:5c./=3@9:2cBC"BMCjM"aM5/@M=/.523=M.;/::-:5=MV.c S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/BC"DNj )-3=AS iN O%A: K#%LM1,223. 1:9.=3752A3GT Y:>3535; *7-:5= 7/ YnHo b,p4S ?:5=/: >7/ )=/.=:;3@ q +5=:/5.=375.9 )=,83:2S K76:-F:/ BC"BS .6.39.F9: .=T

A==GTcc@232N7/;c>39:2c-:83.c@232cG,F2cCa"""Cd2-3=Ad5.=7/,223.dI:FNG8> S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN

http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/static/audio_video/programmes/breakfast_with_frost/transcripts/putin5.mar.txt


http://www.nato-russia-council.info/en/articles/2012-07-18-nrc-transit-agreement-qa/



http://csis.org/files/media/csis/pubs/081110_smith_natorussia_web.pdf







]

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

0:./S .= =A: (32F75 2,--3=Na %A: (32F75 2,--3= .927 2.I =A: =I7 :5=3=3:2 /:2,-: @77G:/.=375 75

O%A:.=/: *32239: Y:>:5@:4 .58 8:6:97G . @7-G/:A:5236: .5.90232 >7/ >,=,/: H735= I7/R 75 =A:

322,:N ?77G:/.=375 @75=35,:8 76:/ =A: >7997I35; 0:./2T 35 BC""S =A: K#%LM1,223. ?7,5@39

,G8.=:8 3=2 BCCD O#@=375 Z9.5 75 %://7/32-4U 35 BC"BS =A: ?A.3/-.5 7> K#%L42 *393=./0

?7--3==::S X:5:/.9 \5,8 _./=:92S 6323=:8 1,223. =7 F772= -393=./0M=7M-393=./0 @77G:/.=375U .58 35

BC"[S #58:/2 $7;A 1.2-,22:5 -:= I3=A 1,223.42 $7/:3;5 *3532=:/S ):/;:0 (.6/76S =7 832@,22 I.02

=7 .86.5@: 83.97;,: 75 -32239: 8:>:5@:N

%A:5 @.-: =A: 'R/.35: @/3232 .58 1,223.42 .55:<.=375 7> ?/3-:. 35 *./@A BC"DN

BN %A: 'R/.35: ?/3232

%A: 'R/.35: @/3232S IA3@A F:;.5 I3=A G/7M8:-7@/.@0 8:-752=/.=3752 75 \03642 *.38.5 35 9.=:

BC"[S F:@.-: .5 35=:/5.=375.9 @/3232 35 9.=: $:F/,./0 .>=:/ G/7M1,223.5 >7/@:2 =77R @75=/79 7>

'R/.35:42 ?/3-:.5 G:5352,9.N 1,223. 353=3.990 @9.3-:8 =A.= =A: >7/@:2 I:/: [email protected] 2:9>M8:>:5@: ,53=2SF,= 9.=:/ .8-3==:8 =A:0 I:/: 1,223.5 -393=./0 G:/2755:9 I3=A7,= 3523;53.N e +5 :./90 *./@AS K#%L

@758:-5:8 1,223.42 -393=./0 :[email protected].=375 35 ?/3-:. .58 :<G/:22:8 ^;/.6: @75@:/5` .= =A: 1,223.5

Z./93.-:5=42 8:@32375 E 75 " *./@A E =7 ;36: Z/:238:5= Z,=35 .,=A7/32.=375 =7 ,2: 1,223.42 ./-:8

>7/@:2 75 =A: =://3=7/0 7> 'R/.35:N L5 "" *./@AS .,=A7/3=3:2 35 ):6.2=7G79S =A: @.G3=.9 7> ?/3-:.S

8:@9./:8 ?/3-:.42 358:G:58:5@: >/7- 'R/.35: .58S >7997I35; .5 399:;.9 .58 399:;3=3-.=:

/:>:/:58,- 75 "f *./@AS =A: G:5352,9. I.2 35@7/G7/.=:8 35=7 1,223. 75 B" *./@AN

&-F798:5:8 F0 =A32 O2,@@:224S *72@7I @75=35,:8 =7 8:2=.F3932: 'R/.35: F0 .-.2235; 1,223.5

-393=./0 >7/@:2 75 'R/.35:42 :.2=:/5 F7/8:/S ,58:/=.R35; -393=./0 :<:/@32:2 35 I:2=:/5 1,223.S .58

G/763835; 2,GG7/= E >[email protected] 97;[email protected] .58 -393=./0 E =7 =A: 2:G./.=32= -76:-:5= 35 :.2=:/5'R/.35:S IA39: .= =A: 2.-: =3-: 8:5035; =A.= 3= I.2 8735; 27N %A:2: 2:G./.=32=2 I:/: .9-72=

@:/=.3590 /:2G7523F9: >7/ =A: 8:2=/,@=375 7> >93;A= *g"j 75 "j i,90S IA3@A R399:8 Bea @36393.52S

35@9,835; "C _/3=752N Y:2G3=: =A32S 1,223. A.2 @75=35,:8 =7 G/7638: =A: 2:G./.=32=2 I3=A -393=./0

2,GG7/=N l:= IA39: 3=2 353=3.9 2,GG7/= I.2 832@/::= .58 .997I:8 3= OG9.,23F9: 8:53.F393=04S 3= A.2

F:@7-: -7/: F/.h:5 .2 =A: -75=A2 A.6: G.22:8T 35 :./90 #,;,2=S I3=A 1,223.42 O%/7H.5 A7/2:4

@75670 7> A,-.53=./3.5 =/,@R2 I.3=35; =7 :5=:/ 'R/.35:S B[ 1,223.5 A:.60 -393=./0 6:A3@9:2

@/722:8 =A: F7/8:/U .58 35 9.=: #,;,2=S 1,223. 2:5= 3=2 >7/@:2 =7 27,=AM:.2= 'R/.35: =7 7G:5 ,G .

O=A3/8 >/75=4 35 \03642 @75>93@= I3=A G/7M1,223.5 2:G./.=32=2 P3= A.8 G/:637,290 F::5 @75@:5=/.=:8 75

=A: /:F:9 2=/75;A7982 7> (,A.52R .58 Y75:=2RQN +5 @.2: =A:/: I.2 :6:/ 87,F=S 3= 32 57I @9:./ =A.=

1,223. 32 356796:8 35 -393=./0 .@=363=3:2 35238: 'R/.35:N

%A: 'R/.35: @/3232 32 . O;.-: @A.5;:/4 >7/ K#%LN $7/ 76:/ =I7 8:@.8:2S K#%L42 2:@,/3=0

G/37/3=3:2 A.8 >7@,22:8 75 =://7/32- .58 >.39:8 2=.=:2N JA39: =A:2: /:-.35 3-G7/=.5=S :6:5=2 35

'R/.35: -:.5 =A.= =A: .993.5@: -,2= ,58:/=.R: . >,58.-:5=.9 /:M.22:22-:5= 7> =A: =A/:.=2 3= >.@:2

.58 =A: -393=./0 @.G.F393=3:2 3= /:V,3/:2N $7/ =A: >3/2= =3-: 235@: =A: :58 7> =A: ?798 J./S K#%L 32

/:V,3/:8 =7 G/37/3=32: =A: 8:>:5@: 7> :.2=:/5 &,/7G: .;.352= 1,223.N += -,2= .927 8:6:97G . 2=/.=:;0

>7/ .88/:2235; ,5@756:5=375.9 >7/-2 7> I./>./:N

a OK#%LM1,223. ?7,5@39 i735= )=.=:-:5=T .= =A: -::=35; 7> =A: K#%LM1,223. ?7,5@39 A:98 35 (32F75 75 BC K76:-F:/ BC"C4S BC K76:-F:/ BC"CS.6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN5.=7N35=c@G2c:5c5.=7936:c5:I2dfaaj"NA=-S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DNe OZ,=35 .@R57I9:8;:2 1,223.5 -393=./0 2:/63@:-.5 I:/: 35 ?/3-:.4S 1%S "j #G/39 BC"DS .6.39.F9: .=T A==GTcc/=N@7-c5:I2c@/3-:.M8:>:52:M/,223.5M27983:/2M

"Cac S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN

http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/news_68871.htm



http://rt.com/news/crimea-defense-russian-soldiers-108/









f

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

[N K#%L42 1:2G752: =7 1,223.5 #;;/:22375

)35@: 1,223.42 .55:<.=375 7> ?/3-:.S K#%L42 /:2G752: A.2 F::5 9./;:90 /A:=7/[email protected] +5 *./@AS

K#%L ,/;:8 1,223. =7 =.R: 3--:83.=: 2=:G2 =7 /:=,/5 =7 @7-G93.5@: I3=A 35=:/5.=375.9 9.IS =7

.8A:/: =7 3=2 35=:/5.=375.9 7F93;.=3752 .58 /:2G7523F393=3:2S .58 =7 :5;.;: 35 . 83.97;,: I3=A \036=7I./8 . 83G97-.=3@ .58 [email protected] 279,=375 =7 =A: @/3232 =A.= I7,98 /:2G:@= 'R/.35:42

35=:/5.=375.990M/:@7;532:8 F7/8:/2N +5 #,;,2=S -:.5IA39:S #58:/2 $7;A 1.2-,22:5 @.99:8 75

1,223. =7 ^2=:G F.@R >/7- =A: F/35R` 7> I./N

K:6:/=A:9:22S K#%L A.2 ,58:/=.R:5 27-: G/.@[email protected] 2=:G2N L5 " #G/39S =A: .993.5@: 2,2G:58:8 .99

G/.@[email protected] @36393.5 .58 -393=./0 @77G:/.=375 I3=A 1,223.N +5 =A: I7/82 7> Y:G,=0 ):@/:=./0 X:5:/.9

#9:<.58:/ b:/2AF7IS

$7/ BC 0:./2S =A: 2:@,/3=0 7> =A: &,/7M#=9.5=3@ /:;375 A.2 F::5 F.2:8 75 =A: G/:-32: =A.=

I: 87 57= >.@: .5 .86:/2./0 =7 7,/ :.2=N %A.= G/:-32: 32 57I 35 87,F=N

"C

)7 =77S 75 Be i,90S 838 =A: &,/7G:.5 '5375 PBB -:-F:/2 7> IA3@A ./: .927 -:-F:/2 7> K#%LQ

@7--3= =7 :58 .99 >,=,/: ./-2 2.9:2 =7 1,223.N %A: :-F./;7S A7I:6:/S 87:2 57= .GG90 =7

G/:637,290 .;/::8 2.9:2N

%A: .993.5@: A.2 .927 /:35>7/@:8 3=2 @7--3=-:5= =7 8:>:5835; @:5=/.9 .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: F0

,58:/=.R35; . 5,-F:/ 7> [email protected]: 353=3.=36:2N %A:2: A.6: @A3:>90 @:5=/:8 75 .3/ 8:>:5@: .58

2,/6:399.5@:S -./3=3-: 8:G970-:5=2 .58 -393=./0 :<:/@32:2N ""

#3/ Y:>:5@: .58 ),/6:399.5@:

)35@: -38M*./@A BC"DS K#%L .3/F7/5: I./535; .58 @75=/79 202=:- P#J#?)Q 2,/6:399.5@:

.3/@/.>= A.6: F::5 @758,@=35; =I3@:M8.390 >93;A=2 =7 -753=7/ 8:6:97G-:5=2 35 'R/.35:N +5 #G/39S

K#%L 35@/:.2:8 =A: 5,-F:/ 7> >3;A=:/ H:=2 .==.@A:8 =7 =A: _.9=3@ #3/ Z793@35; -322375 >/7- >7,/

=7 "fN

*./3=3-: Y:G970-:5=2

)35@: 9.=: #G/39S K#%L A.2 8:G970:8 . ;/7,G 7> >36: =7 2:6:5 6:22:92 =7 G.=/79 =A: _.9=3@ ):.N #

2:@758 @75=35;:5= A.2 F::5 8:G970:8 =7 =A: *:83=://.5:.5 235@: *.0N +5 -38Mi,90S . =A3/8 ;/7,G

E @7-G/3235; 7> >7,/ 2A3G2 E G./=3@3G.=:8 35 5.6.9 :<:/@32:2 35 =A: _9.@R ):.N

*393=./0 &<:/@32:2

_:=I::5 "f .58 B[ *.0S /7,;A90 fSCCC K#%L =/77G2 G./=3@3G.=:8 35 . -393=./0 :<:/@32: E 5.-:8

O)=:.8>.2= i.6:935 "4 E 35 &2=753.N

Y:2G3=: =A:2: 353=3.=36:2S K#%L -,2= ,58:/=.R: . -7/: /7F,2= 8:-752=/.=375 7> 3=2 I39935;5:22

.58 @.G.@3=0 =7 8:>:58 3=2 .993:2 .58 3=2 35=:/:2=2S G./=3@,9./90 35 :.2=:/5 &,/7G:N 1,223.42

8:2=.F3932.=375 7> 'R/.35: A.2 2A./G:5:8 @75@:/52 35 @:5=/.9 .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: .F7,= Z/:238:5=

"C O# 5:I 2=/.=:;3@ /:.93=0 35 &,/7G:T )G::@A F0 K#%L Y:G,=0 ):@/:=./0 X:5:/.9 #-F.22.87/ #9:<.58:/ b:/2AF7I =7 =A: B"2= +5=:/5.=375.9 ?75>:/:5@:75 &,/7M#=9.5=3@ ):@,/3=0S \/.R7IS Z79.584S D #G/39 BC"DS .6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN5.=7N35=c@G2c:5c5.=7936:c7G353752d"CaaaeNA=-S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/BC"DN"" )::S #993:8 ?7--.58 LG:/.=3752 #22,/.5@: *:.2,/:2 I:F23=:S .6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN.@7N5.=7N35=c5.=7M.22,/.5@:M-:.2,/:2N.2G<S 9.2= 6323=:8T B

):G=:-F:/ BC"DN




http://www.aco.nato.int/nato-assurance-measures.aspx







j

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

Z,=3542 ;:[email protected] .-F3=3752 35 =A: /:;375N $7/ . ;778 5,-F:/ 7> 0:./2S .5.902=2 .58 7>>[email protected] 35

@:5=/.9 .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: A.6: 673@:8 @75@:/52 .F7,= 1,223.42 .;;/:2236: .58 5:7M3-G:/3.932=

.-F3=3752S F,= =A:2: I:/: 9./;:90 3;57/:8 35 =A: J:2=N

DN JA:/: Y7:2 K#%L X7 $/7- g:/:p

K#%L I.2 @.,;A= 7>>M;,./8 F0 1,223.42 .@=363=3:2 35 'R/.35:N %A: .993.5@:42 35=:993;:5@: 5:=I7/R2

I3=A35 1,223. .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: >.39:8 =7 I./5 7> =A: =A/:.=S .58 =A: .993.5@: I.2 399MG/:G./:8 =7

@7,5=:/ 1,223.42 ,2: 7> ,5@756:5=375.9 I./>./: .58 3=2 35>7/-.=375 .58 83235>7/-.=375 I./N )35@:

$:F/,./0S K#%L A.2 F::5 2=/,;;935; =7 8:6:97G 5:I 2=/.=:;3:2 >7/ 8:.935; I3=A =A: /[email protected]

@A.5;:8 @75=:<= E 35 IA3@A 1,223. A.2 ;75: >/7- F:35; . O2=/.=:;3@ G./=5:/4 P.9F:3= . 83>>3@,9= 75:Q

=7 . A72=39: .;;/:227/N +5 =A: I7/82 7> #58:/2 $7;A 1.2-,22:5S

J: A.6: =7 >.@: =A: /:.93=0 =A.= 1,223. 87:2 57= @75238:/ K#%L . G./=5:/N 1,223. 32 .

5.=375 =A.= ,5>7/=,5.=:90 >7/ =A: >3/2= =3-: 235@: =A: ):@758 J7/98 J./ A.2 ;/.FF:8 9.58F0 >7/@:N LF637,290 I: A.6: =7 .8.G= =7 =A.=N

+5 =A32 @75=:<=S K#%L -,2= /:63:I =A: =A/:.= G72:8 F0 1,223. .58 @75238:/ A7I 3= I7,98

/:2G758 2A7,98 =A: 23=,.=375 35 'R/.35: I7/2:5 7/ /:G:.= 3=2:9> 35 . K#%L @7,5=/0N 1,223.

G:/@:36:2 =A.= K#%L 9.@R2 =A: [email protected] I399 =7 /:2G758 =7 .;;/:22375S .58 =A: .F2:5@: 7> 2,@A .

/:63:I I7,98 /32R @75>3/-35; =A32N #2 . /:@:5= '\ Y:>:5@: ?7--3==:: /:G7/= -.R:2 @9:./S ^%A:

I39935;5:22S .F393=0 .58 /:.835:22 =7 .@= .;.352= @7--75 =A/:.=2 ./: 63=.9 >7/ =A: >,=,/: :<32=:5@: 7>

K#%LN`"B

)A7/=90 .>=:/ =A: 1,227MX:7/;3.5 J./ 7> BCCaS K#%L >7/-.990 /:M:5;.;:8 I3=A 1,223.N %A32/:>9:@=:8 . @752:52,2 I3=A35 =A: .993.5@: =A.= . 2=/75;S @77G:/.=36: /:9.=3752A3G F:=I::5 K#%L

.58 1,223. /:-.35:8 5:@:22./0 >7/ =/.52.=9.5=3@ 2:@,/3=0N += /:-.352 =/,: =A.= =A:/: ./: . 5,-F:/

7> ./:.2 7> 2A./:8 35=:/:2= F:=I::5 K#%L .58 1,223.S 35@9,835;T ./-2 @75=/79U @7,5=:/M=://7/32-U

575MG/793>:/.=375 7> I:.G752 7> -.22 8:2=/,@=375U .58S 2:@,/3=0 35 =A: #/@=3@N _,= .>=:/ =A:

'R/.35: @/3232 3= 32 @9:./ =A.= .2 I:99 .2 I7/R35; I3=A 1,223.S K#%L 32 /:V,3/:8 =7 G/7638: .

F,9I./R .;.352= 1,223.5 .;;/:22375 35 :.2=:/5 &,/7G:N

%A7,;A =A: .993.5@: 87:2 57= 0:= A.6: .5 .;:58. 7/ 2=/.=:;0 =7 @7,5=:/ 7/ /799 F.@R 1,223.42

35>9,:5@:S 3= 5::82 =7 8:6:97G 75: .2 . -.==:/ 7> ,/;:5@0N +5 i,5: BC"DS #58:/2 $7;A 1.2-,22:5

.@R57I9:8;:8 =A32 IA:5 A: .557,5@:8 =A.= .5 .993.5@: 1:.835:22 #@=375 Z9.5 E IA3@A I7,98

.997I K#%L =7 /:2G758 V,3@R90 IA:5 .58 IA:/:6:/ 3= I.2 /:V,3/:8 E I.2 F:35; G/:G./:8 >7/ =A:

K#%L 2,--3= 35 J.9:2N %A: Z9.5 2G:@3>[email protected] :<.-35:2S

rst A7I I: @.5 F:2= 8:G970 7,/ >7/@:2 >7/ 8:>:5@: .58 8:=://:5@:N %A32 35@9,8:2 >7/@:

G72=,/:S G723=3752S .58 G/:2:5@:N J: ./: @75238:/35; /:35>7/@:-:5= -:.2,/:2S 2,@A .2

5:@:22./0 35>/.2=/,@=,/:S 8:23;5.=375 7> F.2:2 .58 G/:MG723=37535; 7> :V,3G-:5= .58

2,GG93:2N J: ./: /:63:I35; 7,/ 8:>:5@: G9.52S =A/:.= .22:22-:5=2S 35=:993;:5@:M2A./35;

.//.5;:-:5=2S :./90MI./535; G/7@:8,/:2S .58 @/3232 /:2G752: G9.5535;N J: ./: 8:6:97G35;

"B g7,2: 7> ?7--752 Y:>:5@: ?7--3==::S O%7I./82 =A: 5:<= Y:>:5@: .58 ):@,/3=0 1:63:IT Z./= %I7 E K#%L4S %A3/8 1:G7/= 7> ):22375 BC"DM"]S ["

i,90 BC"DS .6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIING,F93@.=3752NG./93.-:5=N,RcG.c@-BC"D"]c@-2:9:@=c@-8>:5@:c[]ac[]aNG8> S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201415/cmselect/cmdfence/358/358.pdf






a

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

. 5:I :<:/@32: 2@A:8,9:S .8.G=:8 =7 =A: 5:I 2:@,/3=0 :563/75-:5=N #58 I: I.5= =7

>,/=A:/ 2=/:5;=A:5 7,/ K#%L 1:2G752: $7/@: .58 )G:@3.9 $7/@:2S 27 I: @.5 /:2G758

-7/: V,3@R90 =7 .50 =A/:.= .;.352= .50 -:-F:/ 7> =A: .993.5@:S 35@9,835; IA:/: I: A.6:

93==9: I./535;N"[

Y:6:97G35; =A32S 35 :./90 ):G=:-F:/ BC"DS K#%L 7>>[email protected] .557,5@:8 =A.= =A: .993.5@: I7,98

>7/- . ^2G:./A:.8` A3;AM/:.835:22 >7/@: 7> DSCCC =/77G2 E 8/.I5 75 . /7=.=375.9 F.232 >/7-

.993.5@: -:-F:/2 E =A.= @7,98 F: 8:G970:8 ^I3=A35 Da A7,/2` =7 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: 35 7/8:/ =7

G/7=:@= -:-F:/2 2=.=:2 .;.352= 1,223.5 .;;/:22375N "D #2 I:99 .2 G/763835; . =A/:.= .;.352=

@756:5=375.9 I./>./:S =A: >7/@: I7,98 .927 F: =/.35:8 =7 8:.9 I3=A 1,223.42 ,5@756:5=375.9

I./>./:N

JA39: =A:2: 353=3.=36:2 ./: =7 F: .GG9.,8:8S =A:/: /:-.352 -7/: =A.= K#%L @.5 87N _0 I.0 7>

G/.@[email protected] -:.2,/:2S K#%L @7,98 ,58:/=.R: =A: >7997I35;T

DN 1:M#/-

+> K#%L 32 2:/37,2 .F7,= 8:=://35; 1,223.5 .;;/:22375S =A:5 3= -,2= ,58:/=.R: . G/7;/.--: 7>

/:./-.-:5= =7 /:F,398 3=2 -393=./0 @.G.@3=0N

&6:/0 K#%L -:-F:/ A.2 @7--3==:8S F0 63/=,: 7> F:35; . -:-F:/ 7> =A: .993.5@:S =7 2G:5835;

BW 7> 3=2 XYZ 75 8:>:5@:N L> =A: .993.5@:42 Ba -:-F:/2S A7I:6:/S 7590 >7,/ @7,5=/3:2 87 =A32T

=A: ')S =A: '\S X/::@: .58 &2=753.N "] _:=I::5 BCCa .58 BC"[S .993.5@: -:-F:/2 75 .6:/.;:

8:@/:.2:8 =A:3/ 8:>:5@: 2G:5835; F0 BCWS IA39: 27-: @,= =A:3/ 8:>:5@: F,8;:=2 F0 ,G =7 DCWN "f

%A:/: A.2S 35 2A7/=S F::5 . G/7;/:2236: 832-.5=935; 7> -393=./0 @.G.F393=0 35 J:2=:/5 &,/7G: 235@:

=A: :58 7> =A: ?798 J./N

%A32 2=.582 35 2=./R @75=/.2= =7 1,223.N JA39: 1,223.42 BCCa 356.2375 7> X:7/;3. I.2 . -393=./0

2,@@:22S =A: 7G:/.=375 /:6:.9:8 2:/37,2 >.39,/:2 35 =A: @7--.58 .58 @75=/79 7> 1,223.5 >7/@:2N

1,223. 9:./5= >/7- =A32S .58 A.2 -.8: @75238:/.F9: 5:I 356:2=-:5=2 .58 8/[email protected] 3-G/76:8

3=2 @.G.F393=3:2N )35@: BC"BS :<G:583=,/: 75 =A: -393=./0 A.2 35@/:.2:8 .58S F:=I::5 BC"[ .58

BC"jS 8:>:5@: :<G:583=,/: I399 .-7,5= =7 DNaW 7> 1,223.5 XYZN"j 1,223. A.2 :-F./R:8 75 .

')ujBC F399375 I:.G752M-78:/532.=375 G/7;/.--: IA3@A .3-:8 =7 35@/:.2: =A: "CW 7>

:V,3G-:5= 3= @9.22:2 .2 ^-78:/5` 35 BC"B =7 jCW F0 BCBCN

K#%L I.2 ,5.F9: =7 8:=:/ 1,223. >/7- .55:<35; ?/3-:. .58S .2 =A35;2 @,//:5=90 2=.58S =A:

.993.5@: I7,98 F: ,5.F9: =7 2=7G . 1,223.5 @756:5=375.9 -393=./0 356.2375 7> :3=A:/ 'R/.35: 7/

:.2=:/5 &,/7G:N %7 V,7=: X:5:/.9 )3/ 13@A./8 )A3//:>>S >7/-:/ K#%L Y:G,=0 ),G/:-:

?7--.58:/S 2G:.R35; 35 #,;,2= BC"DS

"[ 1.2-,22:5S #N $N Ov%A: $,=,/: 7> K#%LT # )=/75; .993.5@: 35 .5 '5G/:83@=.F9: J7/984S ?A.=A.- g7,2:S "e i,5: BC"DS .6.39.F9: .=TA==GTccIIIN@A.=A.-A7,2:N7/;c23=:2c>39:2c@A.=A.-A7,2:c>3:98c>3:98d87@,-:5=cBC"DCf"e1.2-,22:5NG8> S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN"D OK.=7 =7 @/:.=: A3;AM/:.835:22 >7/@: =7 @7,5=:/ 1,223.5 =A/:.=4S %A: X,./83.5S " ):G=:-F:/ BC"DS .6.39.F9: .=TA==GTccIIIN=A:;,./83.5N@7-cI7/98cBC"Dc2:GcC"c5.=7MA3;AM/:.835:22M2G:./A:.8M>7/@:M@7,5=:/M/,223.5M=A/:.= S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN"] += 2A7,98 F: 57=:8 =A.= %,/R:0S Z79.58S 17-.53.S (.=63. .58 (3=A,.53. A.6: G/7-32:8 =7 /:.@A =A: BW 7> XYZM9:6:9 F0 BCBCN"f O+5>7/-.=375 7> Y:>:5@: &<G:583=,/:24S .6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN5.=7N35=c@G2c:5c5.=7936:c=7G3@2dDe"eaNA=-S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN"j ?77G:/S iN Og7I ).5@=3752 J399 g3= 1,223.v2 1:./-.-:5= Z9.524S ?A.=A.- g7,2:S "[ #,;,2= BC"DS .6.39.F9: .=T

A==GTccIIIN@A.=A.-A7,2:N7/;c:<G:/=c@7--:5=c"]]B[S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN

http://www.chathamhouse.org/sites/files/chathamhouse/field/field_document/20140619Rasmussen.pdf


http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/sep/01/nato-high-readiness-spearhead-force-counter-russian-threat





http://www.chathamhouse.org/expert/comment/15523








e

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

%A: /:.93=0 32 =A.= K#%L I7,98 F: 6:/0 A./8 G/:22:8 .58 =A:0 I7,98 >358 3= 6:/0 83>>3@,9=

=7 G,= 35=7 =A: >3:98S .= 2:. 7/ 35=7 =A: .3/ =A: -:.52 /:V,3/:8S G./=3@,9./90 75 9.58 + I7,98

.22:22S =7 @7,5=:/ .50 >7/- 7> 1,223.5 .86:5=,/32-N"a

J3=A7,= 23;53>[email protected]= 2,GG7/= >/7- =A: I./MI:./0 .58 35@/:.235;90 3279.=37532= ')S I:2=:/5 &,/7G:

I7,98 57= F: .F9: =7 8:>:58 3=2:9> >/7- 1,223.5 .;;/:22375S 57 -.==:/ A7I ,593R:90 =A.= 2@:5./37

2::-2N

DNB * 393=./0 &<:/@32:2

K#%L 5::82 =7 ,58:/=.R: /:;,9./ 9./;:[email protected]: -393=./0 :<:/@32:2 35679635; .99 9:6:92 7> 8:@32375M

-.R35;N %A: .993.5@: A.2 57= G/.@=32:8 9./;:[email protected]: :<:/@32:2 .58 9./;: [email protected]: ./-7,/:8 -76:-:5=2

>7/ 76:/ =I7 8:@.8:2N %A: 9./;:2= K#%L :<:/@32: 76:/ /:@:5= 0:./2 I.2 O)=:.8>.2= i.hh4S IA3@A

=77R G9.@: 35 Z79.58 .58 (.=63. 35 BC"[ .58 356796:8 . >7/@: 7> 7590 fSCCC =/77G2N

_0 @75=/.2=S 1,223. A.2 8:-752=/.=:8 3=2 35@/:.2:8 -393=./0 :>>:@=36:5:22 =A/7,;A . 5,-F:/ 7>

353=3.=36:2 76:/ /:@:5= 0:./2T 235@: BCC]S 1,223. A.2 23-,9.=:8 2=/.=:;3@ F7-F:/ 2=/3R:2 .;.352=57/=AMI:2=:/5 &,/7G:U 35 BCCjS 1,223. I.2 -72= G/7F.F90 /:2G7523F9: >7/ . @0F:/M.==.@R 75

&2=753.U 35 BCCeS 1,223. :<:/@32:8 . 2@:5./37 35 IA3@A =A/:: K#%LM93R: F/3;.8:2 356.8:8 I:2=:/5

1,223. .58 3= 23-,9.=:8 . 5,@9:./ 2=/3R: 75 J./2.IS Z79.58U 35 BC"CS 1,223. 23-,9.=:8 . 5,-F:/

7> 5,@9:./M2=/3R: 2@:5./372U .58 35 BC"[S 1,223.5 I./G9.5:2 2=.;:8 23-,9.=:8 F7-F35; .==.@R2 75

(3=A,.53.S Z79.58S .58 )I:8:5N

1,223. A.2 .927 ,58:/=.R:5 9./;:[email protected]: -393=./0 :<:/@32:2S -72= 57=.F90 Ow.G.8MBC"[4N g:98 H735=90

I3=A _:9./,2S =A: :<:/@32:2 2=/:=@A:8 >/7- =A: #/@=3@ 35 =A: 57/=A =7 b7/75:hA 35 =A: 27,=A .58

356796:8 -.57:,6:/2 .975; =A: F7/8:/2 7> (.=63.S (3=A,.53.S .58 Z79.58S .58 35 \.93535;/.8S

1,223.42 :[email protected]: =A.= 23=2 F:=I::5 Z79.58 .58 (3=A,.53.N &2=753. =77 I.2 .>>:@=:8S .2 1,223.52=/.=:;3@ F7-F:/2 2R3/=:8 3=2 .3/2G.@: :5 /7,=: =7 \.93535;/.8N %A: :<:/@32:2 356796:8 .99 F/.5@A:2

7> 1,223.42 ./-:8 >7/@:2 .58 2G:@3.9 >7/@:2S .2 I:99 .2 97;[email protected] -:[email protected] .58 7=A:/ G:/2755:9N

L>>[email protected] .9-72= "BSCCC =/77G2 I:/: 356796:8S IA39: J:2=:/5 :2=3-.=:2 2,;;:2= =A: .@=,.9 5,-F:/

I.2 @972:/ =7 jCSCCC =/77G2N"e

+5 =A:7/0S Ow.G.8M"[4 I.2 . @7,5=:/M=://7/32- 7G:/.=375 =./;:=35; ^399:;.9 ./-:8 ;/7,G2`N +5

G/.@=3@:S 3= I.2 7/3:5=:8 =7I./8 >3;A=35; @756:5=375.9 ./-3:2 35 &,/7G:N #@@7/835; =7 /:G7/=2S =A:

-393=./0 =/.3535; 2@:5./37 >:.=,/:8 .5 .==.@R F0 ^_.9=3@ =://7/32=2` =./;:=35; _:9./,2 >/7- =A: _.9=3@

):. @7.2=N

Ow.G.8MBC"[4 @9:./90 8:-752=/.=:2 =7 K#%L =A: 27/= 7> @756:5=375.9 -393=./0 7G:/.=3752 1,223. 32

@.G.F9: 7> -7,5=35;N #2 =A35;2 2=.58S K#%L I7,98 57= F: .F9: =7 -7,5= . 2,>>3@3:5= 8:>:5@:

.;.352= =A:2:N

DN[ ?/:83F9: ?756:5=375.9 $7/@:2

K#%L 5::82 =7 8:6:97G @/:83F9: @756:5=375.9 >7/@:2 =7 8:=:/ 1,223.5 .;;/:22375N JA39: =A:

.993.5@: 87:2 G722:22 . 1:2G752: $7/@: E @/:.=:8 35 BCCBS 3= 32 . =:@A5797;[email protected] .86.5@:8

"a OK.=7 I7,98 F: G7I:/9:22 =7 2=7G . 1,223.5 356.2375 7> &.2=:/5 &,/7G:S 2.02 =7G _/3=32A ;:5:/.94S %A: Y.390 *.39S Bj #,;,2= BC"DS .6.39.F9: .=TA==GTccIIIN8.390-.39N@7N,Rc5:I2c./=3@9:MBj[]]C"cK.=7MG7I:/9:22M2=7GM1,223.5M356.2375M&.2=:/5M&,/7G:M2.02M_/3=32AM;:5:/.9NA=-9x3<hh[_-_.RZ2FS 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DN

"e

%A: >3;,/: 7> "BSCCC 32 3-G7/=.5= .2 3= 32 F:97I =A: "[SCCCM=/77G =A/:2A798 IA:/:35 1,223. 32 7F93;:8 =7 3563=: 7,=238: 7F2:/6:/2 =7 3=2 :<:/@32:2N

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2735501/Nato-powerless-stop-Russian-invasion-Eastern-Europe-says-British-general.html#ixzz3BmBakPsb





"C

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

-,9=35.=375.9 >7/@: 7> ,G =7 B]SCCC =/77G2 =A.= @7,98 2=.58 ,G 2,>>3@3:5=90 .;.352= [email protected]:8

1,223.5 .;;/:22375 E =A: $7/@: A.2 5:6:/ F::5 8:G970:8 F:@.,2: .99 Ba -:-F:/ 2=.=:2 A.6: 57=

F::5 .F9: =7 /:.@A . @752:52,2N

%A: .993.5@: /:93:2 =77 A:.6390 75 =A: 5,@9:./ 8:=://:5=S IA3@A E .9=A7,;A .5 3-G7/=.5= 20-F79 7>

=A: ')42 #/=3@9: b @7--3=-:5= =7 =A: 2:@,/3=0 7> 3=2 K#%L .993:2 MM 9.@R2 @/:83F393=0 35 /:2G752:

=7 .99 F,= =A: -72= 2:/37,2 7> .==.@R2 .58 I7,98 F: [email protected] 83>>3@,9= >7/ -.50 K#%L .993:2N

$,/=A:/-7/:S 35 =A: /:@:5= G.2=S 2:6:/.9 K#%L -:-F:/2 35 &,/7G: A.6: @.99:8 >7/ . /:8,@=375 35

=A: 5,-F:/ 7> =.@[email protected] 5,@9:./ I:.G752 35 &,/7G:N BC (:8 F0 X:/-.50 .58 2,GG7/=:8 F0 _:9;3,-S

(,<:-F7,/;S =A: K:=A:/9.582 .58 K7/I.0S =A: -:-F:/2 A.6: .867@.=:8 .5 7G:5 83.97;,: 75

I.02 =7 /:8,@: =A: /79: 7> 5,@9:./ I:.G752 35 K#%LNB" %A: ') @75=/3F,=:8 =7 =A32 G/:22,/: >7/

5,@9:./ 832./-.-:5= 35 &,/7G: IA:5 Z/:238:5= _./.@R LF.-. ;.6: A32 ^X97F.9 w:/7` 2G::@A 35

BCCe .58 F0 5:;7=3.=35; =A: K:I )=/.=:;3@ #/-2 1:8,@=375 %/:.=0 PK:I )%#1%Q 35 BC"CN

+5 =A32 @75=:<=S 3= 32 5:@:22./0 >7/ K#%L =7 >7997I =A/7,;A 75 =A: O2-./= 8:>:5@:4 353=3.=36:2 =A.= 3=

@7--3==:8 =7 .= =A: BC"B ),--3= .2 I:99 .2 :<G.5835; 3=2 @,//:5= G9.52 >7/ . O$/.-:I7/R

K.=37524 @75@:G=S 35 IA3@A .993:2 @7-F35: @.G.F393=3:2S 3-G/76: ,G75 7G:/.=375.9 /:.835:22S .58

,58:/=.R: 2-./=:/ 8:>:5@: 2G:5835;N +5 .883=375S =A: .993.5@: 2A7,98 ;7 >,/=A:/ F0 ,G;/.835;

:<32=35; @.G.F393=3:2S 2,@A .2T @7-F.= .3/@/.>=S 35@9,835; >3;A=:/ .58 .3/M;/7,58 @.G.F393=0U G/:@32375

2=/3R: @.G.@3=0U .58 35=:993;:5@:S 2,/6:399.5@: .58 /:@755.322.5@:N

DND $7/I./8 Y:G970-:5= 7> $7/@:2

K#%L 2A7,98 G723=375 =/77G2 .58 :V,3G-:5= 35 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: =7 :52,/: =A.= =A32 /:;375 32 57=

63:I:8 .2 .5 O:.20 =./;:=4 F0 1,223.N %A32 I7,98 35@/:.2: K#%L42 @/:83F393=0 35 =A: /:;375N

)35@: =A: :5835; 7> =A: ?798 J./S K#%L A.2 .@R57I9:8;:8 1,223.42 @75@:/5 =A.= =A: .993.5@:-3;A= 75: 8.0 F.2: 3=2 27983:/2 75 =A: =://3=7/0 7> :.2=:/5 &,/7G: F0 87I5G9.035; =A: =A/:.= =A.=

=A32 I7,98 G72: =7 1,223.N +5 "eejS .5 .;/::-:5= E 2,F2:V,:5=90 @783>3:8 35 =A: K#%LM1,223.

$7,5835; #@= E I.2 /:.@A:8 F:=I::5 =A: .993.5@: .58 1,223. 93-3=35; =A: 2=.=37535; 7> K#%L

@7-F.= >7/@:2 35 @7,5=/3:2 =A.= H735:8 .>=:/ =A: @799.G2: 7> =A: )763:= '5375N %A: 8:G970-:5= 7>

K#%L =/77G2S =A: .993.5@: ./;,:8S I.2 57= 83/:@=:8 .= 1,223. .58 838 57= -:.5 =A: .993.5@: I.2

2,//7,5835; 1,223.N L6:/ /:@:5= 0:./2S =A: ') A.8 F::5 R::5 =7 :-GA.232: =A.= =A: 7GG723=: 32

=/,:U =A: ')42 7I5 8:>:5@: =/.52>7/-.=3752 -:.5= 3= I.2 I3=A8/.I35; =/77G2 >/7- &,/7G:N %A:

5,-F:/ 7> ') =/77G2 35 &,/7G: A.2 >.99:5 >/7- ./7,58 DCCSCCC .= =A: A:3;A= 7> =A: ?798 J./ =7

fjSCCC =78.0NBB

1,223.42 356.2375 7> ?/3-:.S A7I:6:/S A.2 -.8: =A: "eej .;/::-:5= 5,99 .58 6738N #58 1,223.42

.;;/:2236: F:A.637,/ .58 F9.=.5= 832/:;./8 >7/ 35=:/5.=375.9 9.I .58 ;97F.9 2:@,/3=0 -:.52 =A.=

K#%L 32 /:V,3/:8 =7 8:G970 >7/@:2 35 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: .;.352= 1,223.N %A: .993.5@: -,2=

8:-752=/.=: 3=2 @7--3=-:5= =7 3=2 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: -:-F:/2N

BC += 2A7,98 F: 57=:8 =A.= =A: 7GG723=: 32 .927 =/,:N $/.5@:S >7/ :<.-G9:S 32 2:523=36: =7 .50 8:6:97G-:5= =A.= @7,98 F: 2::5 .2 I:.R:535; =A: /79: 7> 5,@9:./ I:.G752 P:6:5 =A7,;A 3=2 7I5 I:.G752 ./: 358:G:58:5= 7> K#%LQS IA39: -:-F:/2 >/7- @:5=/.9 .58 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: .867@.=: R::G35; =A: 8:=://:5= .2 .9.2= /:27/= .;.352= 1,223.5 .;;/:22375NB" )::S K3@A792S %NS Y7,;9.2 )=,./= .58 i:>>/:0 YN *@?.,29.58 P:82QS O%.@[email protected] K,@9:./ J:.G752 .58 K#%L4S )=/.=:;3@ )=,83:2 +52=3=,=:S #G/39 BC"BS.6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN2=/.=:;3@2=,83:2352=3=,=:N./-0N-39cG8>>39:2cZ'_""C[NG8> S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/ BC"DNBB ?77G:/S gN .58 )=:6:5 &/9.5;:/S O*393=./0 ?,=2 1:58:/ K#%L (:22 $7/-38.F9: .2 Y:=://:5= =7 1,223.4S %A: K:I l7/R %3-:2 S Bf *./@A BC"DS.6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIIN50=3-:2N@7-cBC"DcC[cBjcI7/98c:,/7G:c-393=./0M@,=2M/:58:/M5.=7M9:22M>7/-38.F9:M.2M8:=://:5=M=7M/,223.NA=-9S 9.2= 6323=:8T B

):G=:-F:/ BC"DN

http://www.strategicstudiesinstitute.army.mil/pdffiles/PUB1103.pdf



http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/27/world/europe/military-cuts-render-nato-less-formidable-as-deterrent-to-russia.html







""

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

L5 Bj #,;,2=S #58:/2 $7;A 1.2-,22:5 .557,5@:8 =A.= K#%L I7,98 8:G970 3=2 >7/@:2 .= 5:I

F.2:2 35 :.2=:/5 &,/7G: 35 .5 .==:-G= =7 8:=:/ 1,223.5 .;;/:22375 =7I./8 =A: _.9=3@ 2=.=:2N

1.2-,22:5 2.38S

+5 7/8:/ =7 F: .F9: =7 G/7638: rst /.G38 /:35>7/@:-:5=2 07, .927 5::8 27-: /:@:G=375

>.@393=3:2 35 A72= 5.=3752N )7 3= I399 356796: =A: G/:MG723=37535; 7> 2,GG93:2S 7> :V,3G-:5=S

G/:G./.=375 7> 35>/.2=/,@=,/:S F.2:2S A:.8V,./=:/2N %A: F7==7- 935: 32 07, I399 35 =A:

>,=,/: 2:: . -7/: 6323F9: K#%L G/:2:5@: 35 =A: :.2=N

%A7,;A :<.@= 8:=.392 ./: :<G:@=:8 =7 F: .557,5@:8 .>=:/ =A: J.9:2 ),--3=S Z79.58S IA3@A A.2

A.8 3=2 975;2=.5835; @75@:/52 /:;./835; K#%L @.G.F393=3:2 @75>3/-:8 F0 =A: 'R/.35: @/3232S

I7,98 F: . 5.=,/.9 A72= =7 >7/I./8M8:G970:8 >7/@:2N Z79.58 A72=2 K#%L42 7590 A:.8V,./=:/2 35

:.2=:/5 &,/7G: .= )h@h:@35 .58 A.2 =A: ;/:.=:2= -393=./0 @.G.@3=0 35 =A: /:;375N $,/=A:/-7/:S

Z79.58 32 ;:7;/[email protected] @972: =7 7=A:/ @75@:/5:8 -:-F:/2 7> =A: .993.5@: .58S 7> @7,/2:S =7

1,223. 3=2:9>N #2 X:5:/.9 )3/ 13@A./8 )A3//:>> 57=:8 /:@:5=90S

rst =A:/: 32 . 1,223.5 .63.=375 F.2: I3=A35 DC -35,=:24 >9035; =3-: 7> 13;. r=A: @.G3=.9 7>

(.=63.t 27S ,59:22 K#%L A.2 2=.=375:8 >7/@:2 35 =A: _.9=3@ 2=.=:2S + =A35R 3= 32 A3;A90

,593R:90 =A.= K#%L @7,98 /:2G758 V,3@R90 =7 . 2,88:5S 2,/G/32: .==.@RNB[

J3=A7,= =A: >7/I./8 8:G970-:5= 7> K#%L >7/@:2 =7 :.2=:/5 &,/7G:S =A: .993.5@: I7,98 >358 3=

.9-72= 3-G7223F9: =7 /:2G758 =7 1,223.5 .;;/:22375N

B[ m,7=:8 35T g7,2: 7> ?7--752 Y:>:5@: ?7--3==::S O%7I./82 =A: 5:<= Y:>:5@: .58 ):@,/3=0 1:63:IT Z./= %I7 E K#%L4S %A3/8 1:G7/= 7> ):22375BC"DM"]S [" i,90 BC"DS G;N BBS .6.39.F9: .= T A==GTccIIING,F93@.=3752NG./93.-:5=N,RcG.c@-BC"D"]c@-2:9:@=c@-8>:5@:c[]ac[]aNG8> S 9.2= 6323=:8T B ):G=:-F:/

BC"DN







"B

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

?75@9,2375

L6:/ /:@:5= 0:./2S K#%L A.2 >.@:8 .5 38:5=3=0 @/3232N #5 .-F3;,7,2 G72=M?798 J./ /79:S >.9935;8:>:5@: 2G:5835; .-75;2= 3=2 -:-F:/2S .58 =A: .F2:5@: 7> @756:5=375.9 =A/:.=2 .99 @75=/3F,=:8 =7

. 2:52: =A.= =A: .993.5@: -.0 F: 3//:9:6.5= 35 =A: 2:@758 8:@.8: 7> =A: B"2= ?:5=,/0S 8:2G3=: 3=2

@7,5=:/M=://7/32- 7G:/.=3752 .>=:/ ec"" .58 35=:/6:5=375 35 (3F0.N K7 -7/:N 1,223.42 399:;.9

.55:<.=375 7> ?/3-:. .58 8:2=.F3932.=375 7> 'R/.35: ;36: K#%L /:5:I:8 G,/G72:N %A: =A/:.=

G72:8 F0 1,223. E . 975;M=3-: R:0 K#%L G./=5:/ .58 . @/,@3.9 @7,5=/0 >7/ =/.52.=9.5=3@ .58

;97F.9 2:@,/3=0 E 32 . G7I:/>,9 /:-358:/ =A.= K#%L42 =7G G/37/3=0 32 =A: 2:@,/3=0 7> 3=2 -:-F:/

2=.=:2N %7;:=A:/ I3=A *72@7I42 ,2: 7> :5:/;0 2,GG90 .2 . ;:[email protected] I:.G75S 356.2375 7> X:7/;3.

35 BCCaS .58 -.53G,9.=375 7> [email protected]:8 O>/7h:5 @75>93@=24 .2 =7 I:.R:5 2-.99:/ 2=.=:2 75 3=2 F7/8:/2S

1,223.42 /:@:5= F:A.637,/ 8:-752=/.=:2 .5 .;;/:2236: .58 5:7M3-G:/3.932= .;:58. =7I./8 :.2=:/5

&,/7G:N

_,= I3=A =A32 /:5:I:8 G,/G72:S K#%L >.@:2 83>>3@,9= V,:2=3752N 1,223.42 .55:<.=375 7> ?/3-:.

8:-752=/.=:8 =A: :>>:@=36:5:22 7> ,5@756:5=375.9 I./>./: =.@=3@2 .58 =A: 35:>>3@3:5@0 7> =A:

.993.5@:42 @756:5=375.9 8:=://:5@:N K#%L 32 /:V,3/:8S =A:/:>7/:S =7 8:6:97G . I.0 =7 8:.9 I3=A

,5@756:5=375.9 =A/:.=2N _,= 3= 32 ,593R:90 =7 F: .F9: =7 87 27 .975:N K#%L @.5 /:F,398 3=2 7I5

-393=./0 @.G.@3=0S F,= 3583638,.9 ;76:/5-:5=2 E =7;:=A:/ I3=A =A: &' E -,2= 2=/:5;=A:5 =A:3/

/:2796: .;.352= 1,223.5 .;;/:22375S IA:=A:/ =A/7,;A A./8 G7I:/ 7/ 27>= G7I:/N %A:0 @.5 >3;A=

@7//,G=375S G/7-7=: =A: /,9: 7> 9.IS .58 @A.99:5;: -757G793:2 =A.= I399 9:22:5 &,/7G:42

8:G:58:5@: 75 1,223.S G./=3@,9./90 35 =A: :5:/;0 2:@=7/N

K:6:/=A:9:22S . 2=/75; K#%L E =A: G/:M:-35:5= ;97F.9 8:-7@/.=3@ -393=./0 G7I:/ E I399 2:58 =A:@9:./:2= -:22.;: G7223F9: =7 1,223. =A.= 3= @.557= @75=35,: =7 .@= .2 3= A.2 35 'R/.35:N += 32

3-G:/.=36: =A.= K#%L 2=.02 =/,: =7 3=2 >7,5835; G399./ E 3=2 @7--3=-:5= =7 @799:@=36: 2:@,/3=0

:52A/35:8 35 #/=3@9: bN

%A: K#%L 2,--3= 35 J.9:2 I399 F: =A: .993.5@:42 -72= 3-G7/=.5= -::=35; E .58 3=2 -72=

83>>3@,9= =:2= E 35 . ;:5:/.=375N K#%L I399 A.6: =7 :5;.;: 35 2=/.=:;3@ 8:F.=: .F7,= IA0 8:>:5@:

-.==:/2 .58 IA.= -:-F:/2 2A7,98 87 =7 ,GA798 %/.52.=9.5=3@ 2:@,/3=0N _,= .F76: .99S .= .99 @72=2

=A: 2,--3= -,2= -.R: @9:./ =7 1,223. =A.= K#%L 32 /:.80 =7 G/7=:@= 3=2:9> .58 =A: :2=.F932A:8

/,9:2 7> =A: G72=M?798 J./ 35=:/5.=375.9 202=:- 35 =A: >.@: 7> .;;/:22375N



"[

# $#%&$'( )'**+%

#F7,= %A: g:5/0 i.@R275 )7@3:=0

%A: g:5/0 i.@R275 )7@3:=0 32 . =A35R =.5R .58 [email protected]; >7/@: =A.= >3;A=2 >7/ =A: G/35@3G9:2

.58 .993.5@:2 IA3@A R::G 27@3:=3:2 >/:: M I7/R35; .@/722 F7/8:/2 .58 G./=0 935:2 =7 @7-F.=

:<=/:-32-S .86.5@: 8:-7@/.@0 .58 /:.9 A,-.5 /3;A=2S .58 -.R: . 2=.58 35 .5 35@/:.235;90,5@:/=.35 I7/98N

#F7,= =A: 1,223. )=,83:2 ?:5=/:

%A: 1,223. )=,83:2 ?:5=/: 32 . /:2:./@A .58 .867@.@0 ,53= 7G:/.=35; I3=A35 %A: g:5/0 i.@R275

)7@3:=0 8:83@.=:8 =7 .5.90235; @75=:-G7/./0 [email protected] 8:6:97G-:5=2 .58 G/7-7=35; A,-.5 /3;A=2

.58 [email protected] 93F:/=0 35 =A: 1,223.5 $:8:/.=375N

#F7,= =A: #,=A7/

Y/ #58/:I $7<.99 32 Y3/:@=7/ 7> =A: 1,223. )=,83:2 ?:5=/: .= %A: g:5/0 i.@R275 )7@3:=0N g: A7982 .

_)@ Pg752Q >/7- =A: '536:/23=0 7> Z90-7,=AS .5 *)@ >/7- =A: '536:/23=0 7> _3/-35;A.-S .58 .

YZA39 >/7- =A: '536:/23=0 7> L<>7/8N #58/:I 32 =A: .,=A7/ 7> 5,-:/7,2 ./=3@9:2S F77R @A.G=:/2S

G793@0 /:G7/=2S .58 7G35375 G3:@:2 75 1,223.N g32 >3/2= F77RS &=A53@ 1:9.=3752 35 Z72=M)763:= 1,223. S

I399 F: G,F932A:8 F0 17,=9:8;: 35 BC"DN



The Henry Jackson Society

8th Floor, Parker Tower,43-49 Parker Street, London, WC2B 5PS

Tel: 020 7340 4520

www.henryjacksonsociety.org

Charity Registration No. 1140489

The views expressed in this publication are those

of the authors and are not necessarily indicative ofthose of The Henry Jackson Society or its Trustees

© The Henry Jackson Society, 2014

All rights reserved

Documents

NATOs Relationship With Russia