c

F

d

,Pb

l lI

al

4

e'

J.o:

=

pEo

l

r\\<

)o [F, '' , .!, lct

t ' t -l4 l -

l - l r l+ 'u l f l :

t l r lot< |

> | l rI t l

3l6lz.t I ?tl oal; l in le l r' lJ l r: l f F

t ( |I A I \

- I \ t tt I l -l .

I - t's l r-$ [ -o\

3 - '3

ErDrDTDaD

0J rr -':T5-\ roEfD =

-

t,l.

cD ct

: . ;ID

fo-f

TI9,=.c)-

-rD=-z.9,c)o$oJ

rD

5r

e Iit $is [i FEc! nl flF ? $*i;?ii€rii€3E*fff*filg€:E€ElFfIaFisiil*ic$gffgf#f,F$lf?iglliliiilig€gigI€?gitfifiglg?ilr+$F-'-*''-g*l€i *$rliflEgggFFEF[figgF$liFFi; t 13igilglfg; f{flgf *rgj3fF f If,Fsflg is?"$Fri,$1iffi{ pri rEr retFa16fl$€+f[iifl $if g*iir{i 1*'r$F iii ffiirli la+ flise $*si3iuii+ *[€ 1il geilg ie iEi€ EiErr rgrg $ q€iig llgug ni* +fligfqgi+E rgii i rlig i i

l f) l\ l

l ( -t r

I t\ r\

II

)

IJI

N

A0 1@ 2N 300 400m

Figure 7. I Areas of Beirut's archaeological site where archaeologists went 6rstSource.'Author's own drawing, 8/ 1997.

Aeas whsebu{dcz€rs

wql€d ahc:I

Ae6 wt€cbuil(bzsG w

blored byanhaedogbt(s):

EHE

Dmages in fFg, ascqldmt

be e€luated:q

Figure 7.2 Some of the areas of Beirut's archaeological site where bulldozers went firstSource: Author's own drawing, 8/ 1997.

E$<.

is [* f€ fg; iu q?si l r f fF: ;sx 'Fi ls+38?sgIe $

iv?$s r39 }iiF iFE EFgFEiEgFiiIIiffEii€ iiFflii if lfgggiFg€'gigggie+gggf il igg*rsj rrigrgigggi*ei rggeeFglgirglgiiigggggrgl: * [€ i

Fiirr€FFti €3fifg€iiEEgiFifiFiiiiFig

iiFFi$i iliiFEigfliif*;iFliriE €gf,E[$

fiisiiE{sgiEgiF{giFilliiiiiFiigFiEgrigfls it lgg;tffli ii rflgiiEi $ l€iig€igll?l $ 'irtiffi€€€iE ttglEff*$ rligg i

5 $' . E r

t t -

:

- : ' t : . :tA-. !=+-. . , , a ' : . :

t at€EEi€[i +iEi:a€+EtE E€r{'ilii ; xf

' i; r uif +iE ' :E a! $E f ;E?iEi*f$gu !Ei {!

B g;t i :€€iE f iE€f; iJir isi l f$EE!Ej *JE g i ;F ; ; r ; e E€5 +! '=";TEfsgi ; t , { ;EEE ; !

f iet FEe:*s'si$F;i eu *€ FgFt€ f €f i i iEr ;f t*€f [i;e;t€s; fEjiEfirt fisr+ E** t f?fEi ij E i j it i l{E I iFE E iEgf=fi+?ij i ;_fgE Ecxts=i i r r r ; r : Ff

I iff ; e E E ; silfgi { E iliaffii$FgI {iiFl*!stiE++; E-F; Ai++sl a€"i gFdE€tgE .itF

j

d

J

{

.1

'p

a

!

s

>>=cr-93r-o.g I* '7 'aH-F-.:*3t6'-

E 9g- xH(dt;

.: s'? !a-9

E 3 €€-o>q.)

Rixtr= ! o 'E

louXY T 'Eo;- : - r

L , , o c)

9 j j 3.9:5i=Et A- i5.2 'F o 41

€ P . ,

t 6: i; E€ oAF

'FLA-E€ E Hxcg!

rv. i+E

+ Y

14d

v,2 '1 U. rv i^kL

3H87,- -o3 2 cctZ!.9EoXqA-G

o.;

EoE

o

Eiif,E iFi t{re$i€?i irf €3iiifi3E i I$iiEEjiiiiiFiiiaifiEijiEEieFufigr$fsjr] rF ri i ;t aI isgit t;ig*i€ifii ii f-E -i i$E igigii liE rfE fiifi E€;E--= +u!€E+fi H *;g$iu g i{j, isf f15;;;i'i=ii$ilFiii}$fi

itsgeeE t*;l,t =iE ifEiitf'€,€fF$gF i;€$i iFf s: i

$r

ig I ri lE€iiEiigr F iisgiitgissisigiiigili i'l-'-flgtfiiiE?ii fE€? fIlgiF€{sggFi, **'i****ig3g6 1giiiggg;ii;lrliiiiiiiilsEigaiggiirli *ir?r=

iFr*i lgiigi{i*l€*l€ l , t*{ irEi€ is' i ;{*?i i iEqfE;,+F?

iFiEeiliiiiFii€iiiiiiEiiiifliifitffi uI*su*€}i [fli;E'l'fi **;i;g *liii'iEliiii€isEiElliB€$sFFlEi€rgirili$gflgFFiii+gii€[€ifiEiiFr;i1[[g qiil;irl t ffiffl[? g gf ffil fii3s! 'gar

tf'a-

6 XE +'d+8 F. r 'A;r2.4, g

; ' &; Y :isAf e: icx. =

-! 'EE; .<

w"o

' i qE ;axxo !;€ a-r ;aqEi 3q E 6q okdaLi. * 5 'PEf"H:.5

-9oE E'g6 5 ' t *

5's x=d?avTJ O-H E.i ' \<; i o-tD ^r< o6 g ' r

@O!,

es. =.Yid9q\

GOE.J96-h4, q'

oxttuz_ ?-A^

-tdo-3! .< 7aaa

i I F f € il i r ilg fi+[rg E rrlfi il€Fi+Hgs€FtFrl5*a E:suuilElgi t i i iEta*,u,*; s r r l f l l ;H{- i3* r l Q s ? A l/+l'rri++itiifllFJr l€t fHigl ' is s E r g * r iii ih'ig iq:rdaEi=q tE-H€ F: i r l f rcE e9- i e 1l n i+

9i fr*flHrEiH

FFr-. {gsgf +F€ $ irf ?ffis?F€ tr ; ly i i [ * gr [ t* i ] i j+ a

$gI iE3] * +i f i$sr; t€ [alseifiB€l?FfpIf€iIaiaIFF1 t [ i+r{Fi [€ *f lr$crfr 'E 3" ?tg$ r irF;r Fs urf

t? i ; F: FFi ;1€ i [ i [#E l i+€f ? FI*? gE? r *if Ei

LN

r i I igF€f f ler$#EH rr?E i* t r r€ErE f€ir t3F{ffllft€r ir; Fiarrsg1i+:€pgI1;iiig?3eE

ig i3 l*gg €f it+g lF+ rgt lf list€$ i€€sffigiggglig;g-l{ri;li{tigiliiggriggg+lgiliFErFt ;-* tli IrFEri ili[[griirfilr;lig iFr€[l;gf s l*+Fti**nEis:? ! sH€f€ri[Ergg s i

E g Er

sr

l ; '$5$F{Frrxt rs+e $Eir i lEi i r ?#rF3f i r€t i?F;$]

i al i *$i€egggFlfiEiiiigi.lgigfilgs;gssiI il if FHF;

ll;l -ffigeli€aifg9flestl IngiFrsigiiisr'*iits {F{}f€F liFiii€irEr FFF3g gisiiifiiiis + ila l I $ul{i€'3Fg+iFfig gg'E+guiFl€E'f -srerE-r ig i1fr T€i ieErt i f l f ; r3+gI l i i gt I F+1i3ii; Irfst iFIi i ; l f isi$*€ i{ 'sgs' iF, $Fi?f* 'Ei i l tgE€fgiFf , [ t i i$€ir i iFE?€i?e1iFilti ffi?r+aEiEgliE igtgfFiiiglfiitl ii lFisgi a€Eiirr:sflrri;lii9f?€ fi[g+ ft €glfgglf$lgtlg[ii*fiiifiei{+se'il $ 1€ i t gg€l}E{+$ilE$E1tlfI*ulfl[tgfilEggf E t$ a I i

G$;

F{;

$gI$?EgF?E *lE$ F; rgg?fr*'?il?rryiti;[$ $rs igi iirgigflsgig+a lgatiEigii i[*fgI[g rt ;[g ieiiig iiiigi€iF liffili+ilileFii i;iiE gis€tgg irF $;E f,? iFEiI giEgFEEg*F{gfEiif€3gigigf+EEii ?*g

'--"liFiFFgiu€:l i- $-?i'*?€i l€eai iigEggiE,

IFEggilgi;rgggiiriiggigiiigrfitggII€F3?3Eii I[Fir?gig€ € EFfllifE3r FB [{ 1${trtrrs[eiiiig1; f $ n5trF]s+; iF filFr gE Tlgritiiligg;rrlligisgglgErgsge+rl?Ei

HHr

&=F;

fl€frlrlFlgFf[EiEFs ilige lFllfl$ [ li IE;jgii€+f$i??lli$fl $rf,r{i€sg{r ? ri i'rii?*1tgE€i{ii€ggillqll€gli*fi is€$aiE: lF r i : F sig?i f l :5 lFi l r? i t i ;q i "FsT*+li*{r*+riiilrig I iFfillgfiiif e t-flf€! i.i*ailiaiirr +FlrrreitsF rsi[€[ [ i**1i l i ; ;*[ r€ ir i { j i I i I iFigr,l q ri; f,r€ i+ i$ €€ +*: ; r rF rE n

PLN

fi$i}[ig{!'gtg}ii,;ig**gg6;tgr1*ri l €i i €c ; *t,i i a; ir i [s g e g i€. I

E4:t i

--- 1 \ ;

[g iFigrE€: iFglp '= | | n | * l * ' 'n | = | Pr iie r-i:€sisuy $ y:F ig{}e;e s *+€$gii i[+;$f

,$fF i1iEi$$sgEiE g€F:E*i iF;rtx t E-F$ +Fs e Fq a5 iEgY ff [#€iiirE$ FEE Ftgl$:Itu?# Hti 3 1

c * * *$ [ gsEf,$r?flfl$ggEii$;ii$iF}Fur

- pEi r$€ft $* i tg+ g€* a A

l r i l igr ; r :3Eie i F 3f f t i ;nF n $F si#i $r E € gfle i s

H(t@

c)$

.D

@

Fr(al=C. i ,rD=r

€o='ooo; E 2 =.- -Y F

;9. ,=El-El ,o=.

c=-=gr<

2 $ .o 3

ae,

N9r.

9ro@9)

-l9r-

F Eg 9H s x qs f ig; FE t 9; i r ; s f l fs€€ F+;Fr;s $f l i i f15*rgr i iFSi iFis3E:t ; i gf?ssf i l [pai1rg i +nFg*$;i l r r l T IFFEurf i t1+* a e-Fi i lgi :e;r f r i iE+€a**ct F €f +.FiFF FF'-? "+ f"r t E ${i *gf+ * f *FFfE-19": i = + H++gEF; f lAg i ; iaaf* ' E=BB-€E. E I ITgFFEx

SE