20
Government of India Ministry of Urban Development Directorate of Estates J Type Special-II . ."."."."."."." No. 13/755/2014-TS Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi, Dated: 09.04.2014. "/ Shrl Subhash Chandra Agrawal, 1775, Kucha Lattushah, Dariba, Chandni Chowk, Delhi- 110006. Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. Sir, , I refer to your RTI application dated 18.03.2014 on the above subject, received In this DIvIsion on 03.04.2014 through the RTI Cell of this Directorate and to state that your queries at point No.2, 10, 11 and 12 pertain to this Division. As per available records in this Division, requisite information are hereby furnished point-wise as under: pOint No. Reply List enclosed. 2. 10 & 11. Requisite information are enclosed. 12. No such objections received. 2. Notings on the instant receipt is also enclosed. 3. Information on issues pertaining to other Division(s) will be furnished by the CPIOs concerned directly. . 4. If you are not satisfied, an appeal may be preferred with the Appellate Authority within 30 days from the receipt of this letter. The name and address of the Appellate Authority is as under: "Shri Munish Kumar Garg, Director of Estates, Ministry of Urban Development, Room No. 442, 'C' Wing, Nirman Shawan, New Delhi. Tel. No. 23061189." Yours faithfully, Dy. Director of Estates & CPIO Copy to: 1. AD, RTI Cell, Directorate of Estates w.r.t. O.M. No. 1/235/2014/RTIC/DE dated 28.03.2014. 2. AD, TS (Rent) w.r.t. their Note dated 03.04.2014. (S.K. Jain) Dy. Director of Estates & CPIO

Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

Government of India Ministry of Urban Development

Directorate of Estates J Allotmen~ Type Special-II .

."."."."."."."

No. 13/755/2014-TS Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi, Dated: 09.04.2014.

"/Shrl Subhash Chandra Agrawal, 1775, Kucha Lattushah, Dariba, Chandni Chowk, Delhi- 110006.

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir, , I ~m d!rec~e~ ~o refer to your RTI application dated 18.03.2014 on the above subject,

received In this DIvIsion on 03.04.2014 through the RTI Cell of this Directorate and to state that your queries at point No.2, 10, 11 and 12 pertain to this Division. As per available records in this Division, requisite information are hereby furnished point-wise as under:

pOint No.

Reply

List enclosed. 2. 10 & 11.

Requisite information are enclosed.

12. No such objections received.

2. Notings on the instant receipt is also enclosed.

3. Information on issues pertaining to other Division(s) will be furnished by the CPIOs concerned directly. .

4. If you are not satisfied, an appeal may be preferred with the Appellate Authority within 30 days from the receipt of this letter. The name and address of the Appellate Authority is as under:

"Shri Munish Kumar Garg, Director of Estates, Ministry of Urban Development, Room No. 442, 'C' Wing, Nirman Shawan, New Delhi. Tel. No. 23061189."

Yours faithfully,

~ (S.~

Dy. Director of Estates & CPIO

Copy to: 1. AD, RTI Cell, Directorate of Estates w.r.t. O.M. No. 1/235/2014/RTIC/DE dated

28.03.2014. 2. AD, TS (Rent) w.r.t. their Note dated 03.04.2014.

(S.K. Jain) Dy. Director of Estates &CPIO

Page 2: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

List of forn:rer Ministe!'8 who have relinquished the charge as Minister and are In occupation of GPRA as Hon'ble MP of 15th lok Sabha

SI. Name House No. Date ofNo. relinquishment of charge as Minister

1. Shri Mukul Roy, former 181, South Avenue 22.09.2012 Railway Minister

2. Shri Sudip 1-B, Maulana Azad Road, 22.09.2012 Bandyopadhyay, MoS New Delhi (Type-VIII) for Health & Family Welfare

3. Shri Sultan Ahmed, 48, Lodhi Estate, New Delhi 22.09.2012 MoS for Tourism (Type-VI B)

4. Shri Saugata Roy, 58, Lodhi Estate, New Delhi 22.09.2012 MoS for Urban (Type-VII) Development

5. Shri Sisir Adhikari MoS 15, Windsor Place, New 22.09.2012 for Rural Develo~ment Delhi (Type-VI B)

6. Shri C.M. Jatua, MoS 59, Lodhi Estate, New Delhi 22.09.2012 for Information & (Type-VII) Broadcasting

7. Shri S.M. Krishna, 1, Thyagaraja Marg (Type­ 27.10.2012 External Affairs VIII) Minister

36, Aurangzeb Road (Type­ 27.10.2012 VIII)

8. Shri Mukul Wasnik

9. Shri Dinesh Trivedi, 4, Lodhi Estate (Type-VII) 19.03.2012 Minister for Railwaj's Ms. Agatha Sangma,10. 34, Aurangzeb Road (Type­ 27.10.2012 MoS for Rural Dev. VIII)

11. Shri Subodh Kant 11, Akbar Road (Type-VIII) 27.10.2012 Sahay

12. Shri Mahadev Singh 47, Lodhi Estates (T-VI) 27.10.2012 Khandela Shri A. Raja November,

(Type-VII) 13. 2-A, Motital Nehru Marg

2010 14. Shri Dayanidhi Maran, 6, Akbar Road (Type-VIII) 12.07.2011

Minister of Communication and Information Technolqgy

27.10.2012 Minister of Water

21, B.R,Mehta Lane (Type­15. Shri Vincent H. Pala, VII)

Resources 10.05.2013

Minister of Railwaj's Shri S.S.

16. Pawan Kumar Bansal, 6, Ashoka Road, New Delhi.

47, Lodhi Estate,New pelhi 21.03.2013 Palanimanickam (Type-VI) MOS for Finance .._.C' .....: ...,. ... ."10

17

Page 3: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

Empowerment Dr. S. Jagathrakshakan, MoS in the Ministry of Commerce and Industry

19.

20. Shri S. Gandhiselvan, MoS in the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare Shri C.P. Joshi, Minister of Road Transport

21.

Shri Harish Rawat, Minister for Water Resources

22.

83, Lodhi Estate, New Delhi 20.03.2013 (Type-VI)

3, Motilal Nehru Marg, New Delhi (Type-VI)

20.03.2013

I

15, Ashoka Road VIII), New Delhi.

(Type­ 15.06.2013

9, Teen Murti Lane (Type-VII)

01.02.2014

Page 4: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

I

" ..qet1 .

'~, J Cy~

Member of ParlIament (Lok Sabha)

,.

~qGI Pt~~ICfj

Ptl11 0 1 ~ " ' :-~. '. ,I' ".~ • '. . ,,1

~f4~

r---..~: ~ ";fO 25 g~I(1Cfj m, ~ f46t41 ~ 11CJ51'1 ~ ~ ~ I

~: ~ CfjI41(1~ cpr "4?f tlBQI EC/99/ADILIT/20131T-S, f4'1iCfj

25/11/13 ~ ~ ~I

-tf ~~~ ~ ~";fO 25 g~I(1Cf> xts, ~ f4~l ~ ~ tlltiG ~ m ~m ~, ~ <l6 3TJCfR1 ti4GI ~~~lIclll ~11101 ~,-.,t f4 <M'l,am 3i I<:ired fcm:rr Tf<IT $2TI I cgt9 ~ ~ ~ ti ift G cfiT fI G~dl

ftl1l'<1 st ~ I 1ffi ~ cpr 'S1~~reG1 -qct Cf>1~~1 (~) cpr ~(1IG1 ~, ~ f4R41 ~ ~ -m ~ I ~~ :pr -qct ~~ 11Cf>1'1 ~ wa- ~ I ~ cpr 1ft W\1f f4~ -q ~ m ~ I -qct ~ cf) ~ f46t41 ~ ti'&flfft ~ ~ ~

~ ~I 3TTm5 ~ ~ ~ ftl1~1 "Cf>1 ~ ~, ~ 3l'4T

dtcPlcl ~ qtf (jq) ~ 11Cf>1'1 (25 gJI(1Cf> xts, ~ f4~) ~ ~ ~ ~I~~-tf~~ I

~

,

Page 5: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

Receipt at pages 44-45/Cor.

Ref.: Notes at pages 4-5/ante. , ~

It may be recalled that conse~uent upon disqualification of Shri Laloo Prasad as MP (LS), Bungalow No. ~~, Tughlak Road (Type-VIII), New Delhi was cancelled in his name w.e.f. 01l~1.2013 and due to non~vacation of the bungalow, the case was alsoref~Q~~d to litigation Divsiion to initiate evicti0lJ.1 proceedings vide letter dated 19.1 'f.2013. Now, Shri Laloo Prasad in his letter dated 'NIL' addressed to DE has stated that he'is staying in Bungalow No. 25, Tughlak Road allotted by the Directorate of E~t.ates to him in his capacity as M.P. and Minister of Railways. However, dU,' to disqualification as MP, this allotment has been cancelled. .

2. In this context, he has further stated th$)t due to diabetes and cardio problem he is under treatment at AIIMS, New belhi. His son and daughter is also residing with him. His 'daughter is also u~der treatment and his grand­daughter is also studying in the Sanskriti School.

3. Therefore, he has requested to allow Ilim to stay in the above Bungalow for a period of one year more. In this context. it may, however, be submitted that as per existing policy. there is no provision for retention of t~je bungalow beyond the permiSSible period.

File is submitted for kind consideration and orders please.

~

"fJ ('-;~-,

,,.~ ,~ol "'l~ ~;

, 1

-----------.. 1.1"

Page 6: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

t

Page 7: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

O'FFICE....Qf~~)Y. No.':'lifp:' . Date '~'I I

-8/N-

Reference Note on prepage:

As per order of Hon'ble UDM, a draft eCA Note regarding retention of Bungalow No. 25. Tughlak Road (Type-VIII). Ne Delhi in favour of Shri Lalu Pasad Yadav, former Member of Parliament (Lok $abha) for a further period of one year, Le. w.e.f. 01.11.2013 upto 30.10.2014 hs been attempted and Place~ below for kind' consideration and approval of Hon'ble UDM please.

)

j

TS (.(w41_- ,'/ .

PSto UOM

Page 8: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

- 'f ­

!'

.' . . "

., ;..... I

I

" .

Page 9: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

• Government of India Ministry of Urban Development

Directorate of Estates A"o·tme~t Type Special Section

No.: 2/134/2002-TS New Delhi 11, Dated 20.03.2014.

To Shri Lalu Prasad Former Member of Parliament (Lok Sabha), Bungalow No. 25, Tughlak Road, New Delhi.

Sub: Retention of Bungalow No. 25, Tughlak Road (Type-VIII), New Delhi beyond the permissible period. .

Sir,

I am directed to convey the approval of the competent authority for retention of Bungalow No. 25, Tughlak Road (Type-VIII), New Delhi by you for a further period of one year, i.e., w.e.f. 01.11.2013 upto 31.10.2014 on payment of special rate of licence fee.

Yours faithfully,

~ (S.K. Jain)

Deputy Director of Estates

.~ SECRET (NOO) C~y~: . Cabinet Secretariat, [Shri S.G.P. Verghese, Deputy Sec~1 tary (Cabinet)], Rashtrapati BhC\wan, New Delhi [Ref. Case No. 621CCN2014] for information. . V

(S.K. Jain) Deputy irector of Estates

(NOO) Copy to: t ­1. AD (Ncs) , Rent T.S Section, Dte. of Estates for info~at,on and necessary

action. I 2. AD (Policy-I), Directorate of Estates for info~ation.

(S.K~JaIn)Deputy Director of Estates

Page 10: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

f) IU}Pfl~'1

4f'/P'

rr~ ! < •• ~.

llv

? I , IT W

New Delhi 3 January, 2014

I am enclosing a copy of a letter of 13 December, 2013 from Dr. Buta Singh, former Union Home Minister regarding his residential accommodation.

Dr. Buta Singh continues to enjoy Z+ security cover. He and his family members face very severe threats from various terrorist groups, especially from terrorists in Punjab due to action taken by him in the past on behalf of the Union

. of India. In his letter, Dr. Singh has requested that the increased market rent may be revised to the earlier amount under special leave and license fee as he is a Z+ category protectee. .

I request you to have the matter reconsidered in .the light of the facts mentioned in the enclosed letter.

With regards,

Yours sincer~ly,

Shri Kamal Nath Minister of Urban Development and Parliamentary Affairs eN/ .....

New Delhi rtf, E'VlCQ. ~ O\h eJ,.o~.

Page 11: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

r­ ... ~/ "

ll-A, Teen Murti Marg, New Delhi - 110011lr. q,uta Singli TEL: 23016438 / TELEFAX: 23792754

(Former Union Home Minister) (DIRECT- FAX NO.) : 23015922

13th December.2013

I am writing to you regarding Bungalow No. 11A,Teen Murti Marg, Which was allotted tome on Security considerations on payment of special leave & license fee as I have been provided 'Z' + security cover.

Now the Directorate of Estates, Ministry of Urban Development has increased .....market rent from January 2013 onwards to Rs. 1,06,6031· PCM against Rs. 58,5001· as market rent due to non-reversion of my house--'~iiiotmEmt to special leave and license arrangement.

As you must be are aware that I am getting a ,Pension Rs. 60,000/- per month as an Ex MP, and would therefore request you to kindly reverse my accommodation rent as per special consideration and make it to t~e original amount of Rs 58,500/- (as was done under the special leave and license for Z + category protectees)

I am sure you will cons'der my request favorably and instruct for revision of my accommodation rental to the previous amount as a Z+ category protectee under special leave and license fee.

r, With warm regards

Yours Sincerely

~J¥ (Buta Singh)

Dr. Manmohan Singh ji, Hon'ble Prime Minister of India 7, Race Course Road, New Delhi ·110011

Page 12: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

Secretary (UD)

flAA).""---­ ~,~~~~ ~,

Reference Note on prepage:

I As per order of Hon'ble UDM, a draft CCA Note regarding review of I. the decision of the Ctabinet Committee on Accommodation aken in its meeting

held on 4.1.2013 (Case No. 17/1/2013) for reguiarisation of ungalow No. 11-A,! ' Teen Murti Marg, (T-VII), New Delhi, by Shri Buta Singh, fon er Union Minister

on Security Ground has been attempted and place below fo kind consideration and approval of Hon'ble UDM please.

.....

( lwyO)I' ~ ,\ tU_/v"+<':-;J ::>

J.!·I·/L"

Page 13: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

~ ~ 1 .

~\. "Nk. ~ ~~~ 'C.=--:__

~ \ .

l

Page 14: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

~ 45 ,:f:.... .;;{'...~~;;j,....':,J'~ I

Reference Note at pre-page.

V Comments of Ministry of Finance,. Deptt. of Expenditure have since been received in the CCA proposal regarding partial review of the decision of the I Cabinet Committee on Accommoda~ion for revision of rental liability in respect

I of Bungalow No.11-A, .Teen Murti Marg(T-VIII), New Delhi in occupation of Dr. Buta Singh, former Union Minister. The comments are as follows:~

IIPrescribed amount of licence fee is to be charged for su~h allotment in

I, terms of Supreme Court Judgement in WP(C) 585 of 1994 in Shiv Sagar Tiwari

Vs Uol & Ors, as has also been emphasized by the Minist •. of UD in its I comments to DoP&T vide a.m. No. 12035/2/94-Pol.lI(Pt.) dat 3.10.2012 inI another case relating to allotment of General Pool Residential ' ccommodation

& Office Accommodation to Kendriya Bhandar, wherein the f.\l ex Court has held that "Government has no power to waive the arrears, unl ss specifically conferred." I

The above case is not covered under the guidelines, a$ ~ ision of rental liability from market rate to special rate would be contrary to' tij, judgement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as that would amount to waiver of licence fee prescribed for such allotment for which the Government is n' t empowered. Since, the proposed case is not in conformity with the polict stated by the Ministry of Urban Development,. this Ministry does not supportth proposa!."

2. In view of the negation of the CCA proposal by the Mi)S ry of Finance, this Ministry shall be required to place counter comments in the raft CCA Note which have been attempted as .follows:­

" The reasons for partial review of the decision of the Ca .' i et Committee on Accommodation (CCA) for revision of . rental liability tn respect, of accommodation occupied by Dr. Buta Singh, former Union~ Minister have already been mentioned in para-2 above. It is further ciarified in~:this regard that .. had his case been covered within the provisions of the existi, g policy, there would not have been any need to place this matter befo' e the Cabinet Committee on Accommodation (CCA)." Ii

If approved, the above counter comments of this M,1nistry may be incorporated in the final draft CCA Note as per the draft Plr·ced below for ...

-I' consideration/approval of Hon'ble UDM please. I

I' " ;11'1

~ .~-?-r.;::_ · 'L}2­

t>~~1 f("'~/' &.t:A I1t:Jfe ~ '1' r o-pjw.,..v-l{.'., '.

\ '. ..' ~ I

. OFFICE'of 1JQM..,

Page 15: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

, .. ,",

\ \

I

I I

I .

II i ,I

;

!

Page 16: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

<, " ,., f" c;. 'H 6J,­.i) r :)?, ,""

~ "

.I

Receipt at pages 359-365ICor.

Policy-I Section 'of this Directorate has forw~d minutes of the CCA meeting held on 26.02.2014, received from Cabinet Secretariat. CCA in this meeting ha~onsidered the Note dated 14.02.2014 of this Ministry vide Case No. 68/CCAl2014. The Committee was apprised that in accordance with the earlier decision of the Committee to charge market rent from Shri Buta Singh, certain amounts' would have already accrued and the decision to charge the' licence fee at special rate now might amount to waiver of the amount and might be in contravention of the decision of the Supreme Court in Shiv Sagar Tiwari Vs Union of India. ' '

2. The Committee, after taking into account the fact that regularisation of allotment of accommodation was proposed to be allo\v19d on security grounds as a special dispensation and also keeping in vie~ the pas~ prec~dents,

~ decided that the licence fee be regulated as proposed in para~(aph 5 of the I Note regarding partial review of the earlier decision ,of the CCA taken in its /< meeting held on 04-01-2013 (Case No.17/1/2013) for revision of rental liability ,

of Dr. Buta Singh for the period from 25-06-2010 to 24-06-2014 from market rate of licence fee to special rate of licence fee, as amended from time to time.

3. In view of above decision of the CCA, if approved, we may now implement the decision of the CCA and accordingly convey it to the beneficiary and endorse copy thereof to all concerned, as per DFA.

~ Submitted please.

~ ~ ~ .. ~ - CIt"

~ C~;·· \ :y J)FA-(~'

\

¥.(;IIY

Page 17: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

." '"lIIIiS......" ;

"",." "-"'~1 "

__t,__

")1 ! ? ,

;----..,\

Page 18: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

,·.j'I\., \: . ~

. b., '~- \f./>_.,

I

ry;?" f> -,{)'fic- i ,

! ~

'\.1inister has dC3sired that this may pI. b~ examined on priority and put up.' Sell- PS to UDM/07,01 20"·4,

'..,.....-'Th~! afore-quoted observations !18ve been recorded on the D,O, letter of

Honl)n Prime Minister, addressed to UDM, requesting for reconsideration of tt18

matte; reGardmg revi~n of licence fee from market rate to special rate, as requested I:)y Dr, E3ut8 Singt1. keeping in view the severe thr~ctLgercepts· te him and his family, The Hon'ble Prime Minister has also enclosed a 'copy of the letter of Dr !:luta Sirigr\ forrner LJnion Minister addressed to him in this regard,

? in :lis repr03sentatlcn to the Hon'ble Prime Minister, Dr, r3utc! Sin~); ;,;.JS

conveyed his concern / reservation on the ilicrease in the rate ot' ma~ket ;eilt I"or" ,Januuw 20']:3 onwards and has requested for reversion of his mntai liclbiiity to th::i ,spe:Gla! rate of licence fee on the ground that as an ex-MP he i'3 getting C1 pHnf;iot"; ')i

r~s, 6Q..Q.OOi- per montrL Thf~ amount of market rent /specia! licence fee as rnentiOf1r::cl !)j' him, hOW(Ner, does nut appear to be factually correct.

3 Without going into the detailed background of the Inatter~ which is alrE':':ld~j available at pages 35-36/ante, and limiting it to the present c;:QD1ext of reference, it 1i'\,:IY

bo ~\itted in brid that tFli:! eCA in its meeting held on 04.'(5'1' ,2013 had approved the proposal of this Ministry for regularisation of BungCllow No, 'i'l-I\, TfJen Ml.:r1i r.jlar~; ;"Type-VII) in the nan';e of Or, Buta Sil1gh w,e,f. 25,06,2010 to 24,06, 20'1£1 on sf:c,,;;'ity Jf'Ouno on payrH~nt of rnclrket r::lte of licence fee, Therefore, 1)8Sicai!)' wh<3t Dr, (:;i(\,::-' r,ppeilrs lG ~ chsire in h:s repre:'3entation tv the :"lon'ble Prime M!niste:- i:-:; reVf::'~,;,Ci'l r;; ',nis ill<in .. 8t ratt; of iicer:c'~\ fee fr.:.Irrl ?5,O(3,20': C' ~o special iicenc\:: iee .;J[) 1i2;:"J'? ;:i:':]

lieer-ci,: bas:s 8::; hacl ;')~;.en th~? caS'2 r,l~ the tirnG 01 ir,iti21i allotl'nerlt of In(;' lXI"lge,;O'lv I:, )":1"1 ('/' I'I"-Il'" C,,"l'r:D""r'y ')')O~~• II' .. I.,. I , .. , j \ ... 1) I..GI ,_.~ v.

~

,j T!l(~ !l1~;:rhH (:"[88 of iiG8nCe ke 1,/)::1!11<;lqes) a:'ld thn spcci;::ji r<:It~ 01' !i',:;;:ncl; f':<i/

k;;- tho p\~'rior.ifrorn 2t),06,2010 lc 2'~\'!.I6,2G':4 :;:r'e rcsp';Jc(ively as lIIK;or:

25Ud20'IO to 3'1~2,,2UL: Fi..s, 5fJ/:) I.:?l·· p(~r p10n~t'1 O'U)1 ,20'13 to 30,052(1;::: r~~s. 91) 103/·· psr rnon!h 01,0720'1:3 c:rwarc/ r~ s 1 ,06, II b/.· per (;', ~)Pth

8_ ~ped<.'lJ Licence F(H~ :

:f5,G6,2010 to 3rJ,06,?C'iC Hs, 14, \!)IJt:;r p~,r r:; ~):'r(h 01 Or;W10 GI1'NarU F~5 26,33~)i· p(,~r rncn'iJ":

::;, ': in~,y J)Qi {;erhaps De O~it Co! p!,,',:;::} Lo ;'ne:ltion here Ih::lt l}'1e nd,11 (' (pr,:';r EL.l;: 3;m;::, fkJured in the list of unautn!lrised oCGuoants filed before thell-'Ior:'()j(~ :::;!i:)12':';'~:.' :>;"..r', ir! ~~IY No '12065/2009 titled ar:,U()! Vs. Virnal Gi-:.:1i and Ors, ~J i~s ()rder :j,:~:;.:,,! ~:~,()4,?d:;: 3, t!l,~ Hcm'bit') ;;upreme CO'..lrt had conveyeo it~: <;;.:lrious r",~:)~;rv::ltib()s ~)I'f t:';:,;::

!eowii'/ c,'"id con'ectn8sS of tl~e deCision taken by Ole GovernmfJr.t ;J~ allo! ithc o{fi':;:u; CA\;~con:,ITi~,jaticorl to S~',ri 8~l Singh in the name of p!'o)viding !:,.::CWlty to i'l/rll. !n :!"e ;1(:;(: (1<1':0 '.:of l;ea~ln9 O~lblJ804,20Jj~, the I~arned ASG, and the iea,~':'!e:l ~iJ:,:r':~~': ,<,or(:':3UI~~,r\~J Dr, BI.ita Singh gaveC$.)ut tilat [hey would fIle ~ne\r wntt<:'r! ClS~: ,ii,')! ,r,',:, l)'_~fc:"<::: (he ;:,:cur'i about vacating th/a b'..lng8Icvl.i\!att'lst by ~;006.2(J'~4. TilOUqh ;1).'; 1;:,Xl't)iG ~::UDferne Court has siolc:~ discharga1 the noticGsjs~;ucd ();I it !c' tt':;:;

UI~<iLllh'~'(:o(~d occuoants for vacating the gove accornmojatiops with t~lE: diriJctior; l,:\",~ th) 90:/: ::Jfld thl~ c'oncerne(j 8~10ncies must t81<8 action strictlY in 8::;col'd:::lW;~: 'N:!h 1:<;r~'J ::~~ (\'f if:(=) jllcigen'IGnt in S, D, 8andi's CClSl'!, the orders of tt',8 coun as rcl'ermd to ::H)CJ,,',

:.i::,,:! ,-r.;I·ldin iegai,y valid,

I', v;ew oi tr1l'! Dm;itio:'1 expkli;-:oCl above, the represnntatior. of ~':)t, ,l'ldUi ~:;::<,;; ;:c; ~.i[,;·.·t"':(':l rJI'I .. ·..,L.". i\11;'·:I~I·c.l~ o:Jn"J ~'J~ j'Qt'"'nrY"'YH:'I'n.~)(": ~".J ~h-;) !-tnr','hl::, r)/ip··.::~ !\/111"j~·.:ji'" ;.:.:

Page 19: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

< ,

~~~?~ ...

: MoS (UD)

f'I/!I- - ... - .. ~.....'"

)..ar ( t

UDM

P

i

iOFFICE OF UDM Dy. [\lo.~.o~~ .Date .~.cq.T1-~

~~h ~,

to MOS (UO)

I r

I

l , ,I '

Page 20: Moud(Lalu Buta Ex Ministers)

Government of India Ministry of Urban Development

Directorate of Estates Allotment Type Special Section

No.: 7/331/06-TS New Delhi 11, Dated 24.03.2014.

'. To

Dr. Buta Singh, Former Union Minister, Bungalow No. 11-A, Teen Murti Marg, New Delhi.

Sub: Partial review of the decision of the Cabinet Committee on Accommodation (CCA) for revision of rental liability in respect of Bungalow No. 11-A, Teen Murti Marg (Type-VII), New Delhi.

Sir,

I am directed to convey that the competent authority has reviewed partially the earlier decision of the CCA taken in its meeting held on 04-01-2013 (Case No.17/1 /20 13) and has approved the revision of your rental liability in respect of Bungalow No. 11-A, Teen Murti Marg (Type-VII), New Delhi for the period from 25-06-2010 to 24-06-2014 from market rate of licence fee to special rate of licence fee, as amended from time to time.

Yours faithfu lIy,

V (S.K. Jain)

Deputy Director of Estates

t5J,/.- SECRET (NOO) Copy to: Cabinet Secretariat, [Shri S.G.P. Verghese, Deputy Secretary (Cabinet)], Rashtrapati Bhawan, New Delhi [Ref. Case No. 68/CCN2014] for information.

~ (S.K. Jain)

Deputy Director of Estates

(NOO) {YCopy to:

1. AD (Ncs), Rent T.S Section, Dte. of Estates for information and necessary action.

2. AD (Policy-I), Directorate of Estates for information.

(S.K. Jain) Deputy Director of Estates

~D / J