Upload
stephen-k-tyring
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Molluscum contagiosum: The importance of early
diagnosis and treatment
Stephen K. Tyring, MD, PhD
Galveston, Texas
Molluscum contagiosum is a viral infection that is becoming an increasing problem in sexually active individuals
and in patients with human immunodeficiency virus. Although molluscum contagiosum lesions are generally
self-limiting, it may take 6 months to 5 years for lesions to disappear. Furthermore, patients with weakened
immune systems have increased difficulty in clearing lesions; therefore lesions typically persist for prolonged
periods. Although there has been continued debate about whether molluscum contagiosum lesions should be
treated or allowed to resolve spontaneously, many clinicians recommend treatment of genital molluscum
contagiosum lesions to reduce the risk of sexual transmission, prevent autoinoculation, and increase patient
quality of life. Treatment options for molluscum contagiosum include physician-administered and patient-
administered therapies. Novel patient-administered treatment options allow administration in the privacy of
a patient’s home, providing added convenience and reducing patient embarrassment or stress. With the novel
treatment opportunities currently available or in development, physicians are able to improve patient quality of
life while providing patients with a convenient, well-tolerated, easily administered treatment regimen. This
review summarizes the clinical diagnosis of molluscum contagiosum and provides a critical assessment of
several current and emerging treatment options. (Am J Obstet Gynecol 2003;189:S12-S16.)
Key words: Imiquimod, immune response modifier, molluscum contagiosum, poxvirus, sexuallytransmitted disease
Molluscum contagiosum is a viral infection that
produces raised, umbilicated lesions (ie, papules or
nodules) in the epidermal layer of the skin. Once
considered a benign disease usually observed in children,
molluscum contagiosum has also been recognized—
during the last 25 years—as a sexually transmitted disease
(STD) in adults. Although current statistics are lacking in
the United States, the overall incidence of molluscum
contagiosum accounts for approximately 1% of all
diagnosed dermatologic conditions.1 Furthermore, the
frequency of molluscum contagiosum appears to be
increasing. From 1966 to 1983, the number of mollus-
cum contagiosum-related visits to private physicians
by patients older than 15 years increased 11-fold.2 In
addition, patients 15 to 29 years were more likely than any
other age group to present with molluscum contagiosum
in STD clinics and private physician offices. Moreover, 5%
to 18% of patients with human immunodeficiency virus
(HIV) are infected with themolluscum contagiosum virus
(MCV).3
From the University of Texas Medical Branch.Received for publication January 30, 2003; accepted March 31, 2003.Reprint requests: Stephen K. Tyring, MD, PhD, Professor of Dermatol-ogy, Microbiology and Immunology, and Internal Medicine, Director,UTMB Center for Clinical Studies, University of Texas Medical Branch,301 University Blvd, Route 1070, Galveston, TX 77555. E-mail:[email protected]� 2003, Mosby, Inc. All rights reserved.0002-9378/2003 $30.00 + 0doi:10.1067/S0002-9378(03)00793-2
S12
The virus (genus Molluscipoxvirus) that causes
molluscum contagiosum is a member of the family
Poxviridae, of which smallpox is also a member. Three
subtypes of MCV have been identified, all of which have
a similar clinical presentation and are not localized to
a particular region of the body (eg, genital).4,5 Molluscum
contagiosum virus type 1 (MCV-1) is the most common
subtype detected in patients, whereas MCV-3 is rare.4,5
For example, an analysis of 106 MCV clinical isolates
indicated the occurrence of MCV-1, -2, and -3 as 80:25:1.5
In adolescents and adults, molluscum contagiosum is
most commonly transmitted by sexual contact.6 However,
MCV may be transmitted by casual contact, fomites, or
self-inoculation. The incubation time and communicabil-
ity of MCV have not been determined; however, the
average incubation period for MCV in humans ranges
from approximately 14 to 50 days.7 Molluscum contagio-
sum lesions are generally self-limiting, but it may take 6
months to 5 years for lesions to disappear.3 In addition,
patients with weakened immune systems (eg, patients with
HIV) have increased difficulty clearingMCVandmay thus
exhibit lesions for prolonged periods.
Because molluscum contagiosum is considered an STD
in adolescents and adults, obstetricians and gynecologists
should be aware of the clinical features of genital
molluscum contagiosum. Therefore, the clinical diag-
nosis of genital molluscum contagiosum is discussed and
a critical assessment of several current and emerging
treatment options is presented.
Volume 189, Number 3SAm J Obstet Gynecol
Tyring S13
Diagnosis
Diagnosis of genital molluscum contagiosum is gener-
ally made by clinical examination of lesions (Fig 1).8
Lesions caused by MCV typically appear as white, pink, or
flesh-colored, umbilicated, raised papules (1 to 5 mm in
diameter) or nodules (6 to 10 mm in diameter).9
Molluscum contagiosum lesions may occur as single or
multiple lesions (usually <30 papules). Key characteristics
are summarized in Table I. Although patients are usually
asymptomatic, theymay present with eczema surrounding
the lesion andmay experience pruritus or tenderness. On
rare occasions, in addition to the presence of lesions in
the genital region or on the lower abdomen, sexual
transmission may also result in intraoral or perioral
clinical manifestations, particularly in immunocompro-
mised patients.10
Immunocompromised patients may present with atyp-
ical manifestations of molluscum contagiosum, includ-
ing differences in morphology and growth patterns. For
example, patients with HIV tend to develop giant (>1
cm) lesions (Fig 2) or may have clustering of hundreds of
small lesions.6,9 Furthermore, molluscum contagiosum
lesions in patients with HIV do not resolve quickly, are
spread easily to other locations (eg, face), and are typically
refractory to common treatments.
Differential diagnosis includes condylomata acuminata
and vulvar syringoma for multiple small MCV lesions and
Fig 1. Classic pink umbilicated genital molluscum contagiosumpapule. Reprinted with permission from Diven.8
squamous or basal cell carcinoma for large, solitary
lesions. Analysis of biopsy specimens of lesions with
hematoxylin and eosin staining to identify epidermal
changes may facilitate a more definitive diagnosis. If geni-
tal molluscum contagiosum is identified, patients should
also be tested for other STDs as a precautionary measure.
Treatment options
Because molluscum contagiosum is considered a self-
limiting disease, debate continues about whether lesions
associated with this disease (MCV lesions) should be
treated or allowed to resolve spontaneously. Many clini-
cians recommend treatment of genital MCV lesions to
reduce the risk of sexual transmission and to prevent
autoinoculation. Although MCV lesions will generally
resolve if left untreated, the resolution rate is extremely
variable3and immunocompromisedpatientsareatgreater
risk for secondary inflammation and bacterial infection.
In addition to the risk for transmission to sexual
partners, some patients may experience pain and discom-
fort that adversely affect theirquality of life. Emotional and
psychological discomfort, particularly embarrassment,
Fig 2. Giant molluscum contagiosum lesion in HIV-infectedpatient.
Table I. Genital molluscum contagiosum
Epidermal viral infectionGenus Molluscipoxvirus3 subtypes
TransmissionDirect bodily contact (eg, sexual activity)Fomites (eg, underwear)Self-inoculation
14- to 50-d incubation period
Clinical presentationWhite, pink, or flesh-colored, umbilicated, raised papules(1-5 mm in diameter) or nodules (6-10 mm in diameter).
Lesions are self-limitingMay take 6 months to 5 years for lesion disappearance in theabsence of therapeutic intervention.
September 2003Am J Obstet Gynecol
S14 Tyring
mayalsobeassociatedwithgenitalMCVlesions.Therefore,
it would be advantageous in most cases for physicians to
treat MCV lesions, provided the treatment was safe,
effective, painless, and convenient to administer. Several
treatment options, both physician-administered and
patient-administered, for genitalMCV lesions are available
(Table II).
Physician-administered treatment options. Physicians
usually treat MCV lesions as they would treat warts caused
by human papillomavirus. Small lesions are commonly
removed by physical ablation of infected tissue and may
involve local excision by electrocautery, curettage, or
cryotherapy.11 Unfortunately, even with application of
a local anesthetic, these ablative procedures are associated
with pain, irritation, soreness, and mild scarring. Fur-
thermore, repeated treatments requiring additional office
visits may be necessary. The success of these physical
ablative procedures for genital MCV lesions has not been
rigorously evaluated, and high-quality, placebo-controlled
studies are lacking.12,13
Physician-administered chemical ablation has also been
used to treat genital MCV lesions. Acids such as
trichloroacetic acid have been applied to lesions.
However, controlling the depth of acid penetration can
be difficult and—as observed with physical ablation—
pain, irritation, and mild scarring are common.14 As an
illustration of the limitations in currently available
physician-administered chemical ablative procedures,
podophyllum resin (podophyllin) must be applied only
for a minimal period (eg, 1 to 4 hours) and then
thoroughly washed off. Because podophyllin is caustic
and may cause significant irritation, only a small number
of warts or limited area of skin should be treated at one
time. Furthermore, an increasing number of physicians
are no longer recommending this form of therapy
because of its low efficacy and significant toxicity.15,16
Patient-administered treatment options. In addition to
physician-administered treatments, several treatment
alternatives that may be self-administered in the privacy
of the patient’s home are available to patients with genital
MCV lesions. Podofilox (podophyllotoxin) is the active
component in podophyllum resin. Although not
indicated in the treatment of MCV lesions, podofilox is
Table II. Treatment options for molluscum
contagiosum lesions
Physician administeredElectrosurgeryCurettageCryosurgeryTrichloroacetic acidPodophyllin
Patient administeredPodofilox (podophyllotoxin)Retinoic acidImiquimod cream (immune response modifier)
approved in gel form for the treatment of cutaneous
(external) genital and perianal warts and as a topical
solution in the treatment of external warts. Several clinical
trials in patients with warts have demonstrated varied
response (clearance) rates (in 38% to 50% of patients)
after 2 to 4 weeks of treatment with podofilox. Common
adverse events have included burning, pain, inflamma-
tion, erosion, and itching.14 Retinoic acid (tretinoin) is
another form of chemical ablation that can be self-
administered and has been used topically to remove MCV
lesions.17 However, application of retinoic acid may cause
skin drying, peeling, irritation, and soreness.14
In addition to therapies that involve physical or
chemical ablation of MCV lesions, a novel patient-
administered topical treatment that uses localized
immune response modification has been used. Imi-
quimod is a member of a new class of drugs known as
immune response modifiers and is approved as a 5%
cream for the treatment of external genital and perianal
warts/condylomata acuminata in adults. Although the
mechanism of action of imiquimod has not been fully
elucidated, published studies indicate that imiquimod
indirectly activates antiviral activity by inducing cytokines,
including interferon alpha.18,19 The proposed mecha-
nism of action and demonstrated efficacy of imiquimod
against human papillomavirus (the causative agent for
genital warts) suggest that it might also be effective against
poxvirus, which causes molluscum contagiosum.
To determine the efficacy and safety of imiquimod
in the treatment of molluscum contagiosum, a small
number of clinical trials have been performed
(Table III).20-22 In 1 open-label study, 7 children and 8
adults with molluscum contagiosum (including 3 patients
with lesions in the anogenital region and 3 patients with
HIV) resistant to standard therapeutic treatment (eg,
salicylic acid, local surgery, and cryotherapy) self-admin-
istered 5% imiquimod cream once daily, 5 days per week,
for 4 to 16 weeks.20 After completion of therapy, 12 of 15
(80%) patients achieved either a complete clearance of
MCV lesions (8 patients) or a greater than 50% reduction
in lesion size (4 patients). There was no correlation of
response to HIV serostatus, gender, or atopic predis-
position. Furthermore, during the 32-week follow-up
period, only 1 patient had a recurrence develop at
a treated location, which occurred 10 weeks after
a complete clearance of initial lesions. Forty percent of
patients did not report any adverse events. In the
remainder of patients, the most commonly reported
adverse events were local inflammatory reactions, which
were generally mild and transient and included 7 (47%)
episodes of erythema, 5 (33%) cases of erosions, and 5
(33%) cases of pruritus. However, no patient discon-
tinued treatment because of adverse events.
An additional open-label study evaluated the safety
and activity of 5% imiquimod cream in the treatment of
Volume 189, Number 3SAm J Obstet Gynecol
Tyring S15
Table III. Imiquimod therapy in the management of molluscum contagiosum
Study Patients, n TreatmentClearance of >50%reduction, n (%)
Hengge et al20 15 5% imiquimod cream, once daily, 5 d per wk, for 4-16 wks 12 (80)Liota et al21 23* 5% imiquimod cream, once daily, 3 times per wk, for maximum of 16 wks 18 (78)Syed et al22 50 1% imiquimod cream, 3 times daily for 5 d, for maximum of 4 wks 41 (82)
*Number of adult patients who completed the study.
molluscum contagiosum in adults and children.21
Focusing on the adult study population, 28 patients with
10 or more MCV lesions were treated with 5% imiquimod
cream 3 times a week for a maximum of 16 weeks. Of the
23 patients who completed the study, 18 (78%) exhibited
clearance of MCV lesions by week 16, with 10 (43%)
patients achieving clearance of MCV lesions by week 4.
Furthermore, all HIV-infected patients (n = 4) and 9 of 10
(90%) patients with genital MCVhad complete resolution
of MCV lesions. Of all the patients who had a response to
imiquimod immunotherapy, no patient experienced
a recurrence at a 3-month or longer follow-up examina-
tion. Imiquimod was also safe and well tolerated. No
patient discontinued treatment because of adverse events.
Only 5 (22%) of 23 patients required treatment for
pruritus, which resolved with 1% hydrocortisone (n = 4)
or 0.1% triamcinolone (n = 1).
In addition to open-label studies, a double-blind,
randomized, parallel-group study was conducted to
compare 1% imiquimod cream with placebo in the
treatment of MCV lesions.22 One hundred male adults
and adolescents had a total of 733 MCV lesions (mean,
7.3; majority on thighs or genitalia) of 2 to 5 mm in
diameter per lesion. These patients applied 1%
imiquimod cream or placebo at home 3 times daily for
5 consecutive days for a total of 4 weeks (maximum
60 topical applications). Patients were followed weekly for
12 weeks, then followed monthly for an additional
9 months. At week 4, treatment with 1% imiquimod
cream resulted in a complete response in 82% (41 of 50)
of patients and eliminated 86% (309 of 358) of MCV
lesions compared with a complete response in 16% (8 of
50) of patients and 17% (63 of 375) of lesions treated with
placebo (P < .0001; Fig 3).22 In addition, the MCV lesion
responses to imiquimod therapy were durable. Only 1 of
the 41 patients successfully treated with imiquimod cream
relapsed (at month 10).
Imiquimod cream was also well tolerated; only 18%
(9 of 50) of patients treated with imiquimod cream
experienced an adverse event and no patient discon-
tinued from the study. All 9 of these patients experienced
mild fever, and 6 patients also experienced mild pruritus.
Although this study administered imiquimod 1% cream,
which contains less active agent than the imiquimod 5%
cream approved for the treatment of warts, the results
of this study suggest that imiquimod therapy is safe
and highly effective for the treatment of molluscum
contagiosum.
Additional studies in small numbers of patients have
also suggested that imiquimod therapy may be useful in
the treatment of molluscum contagiosum. In an open-
label safety study, 13 children were treated with 5%
imiquimod cream nightly for 4 weeks.23 Although the
studywasnot designed to test efficacy, complete resolution
of the target lesions occurred in 33% (4 of 12) of patients
by the end of week 4. In addition, case studies have indi-
cated that imiquimod can clear MCV lesions in special
patient populations (eg, HIV-infected patients).24-26
These studies indicate that both 1% and 5% imiquimod
cream (only 5% cream is currently available) are well
tolerated, may be useful in the treatment of mollus-
cum contagiosum, and provide a novel treatment
opportunity—particularly in patients who experience
adverse reactions or who are refractory to other forms of
treatment.
Patient education. In addition to treatment for MCV
lesions, it is important for patients to receive guidance on
Fig 3. Percentage of patients cured andmolluscum contagiosumviral lesions cleared by week 4. Data from Syed et al.22
September 2003Am J Obstet Gynecol
S16 Tyring
MCV transmission. Patients should be reminded that after
treatment there is a risk for recurrence and a risk for
reinoculation/transmission between sexual partners.
Latex condoms may help prevent some skin-to-skin
contact, but patients should recognize that MCV does
not require mucous membrane contact to be transmitted
and that other areas, such as the anal region, will not be
protected. Furthermore, patients should be counseled
that the occurrence of genital molluscum contagiosum
might indicate the presence of other STDs.
Conclusions
Genital molluscum contagiosum is a viral infection of
which the incidence in sexually active adults is increasing.
Because molluscum contagiosum is not life-threatening,
debate continues regarding the value of therapeutic
intervention. Therefore, health care practitioners,
including obstetricians and gynecologists, should work
with each patient to determine whether and how
treatment should be administered. However, it is
recommended that physicians treat this contagion,
particularly in light of the availability of safe, efficacious,
and convenient treatment options. Novel patient-admin-
istered treatment options allow administration in the
privacy of a patient’s home, providing added convenience
and reducing patient embarrassment or stress. With the
novel treatment opportunities currently available,
physicians have the appropriate tools to improve patient
quality of life while providing patients a convenient,
well-tolerated, easily administered treatment regimen.
REFERENCES
1. Bretz S. Molluscum contagiosum. EMedicine Journal 2002;3. Availableat: http://www.emedicine.com/emerg/topic317.htm. Accessed De-cember 17, 2002.
2. Becker TM, Blount JH, Douglas J, Judson FN. Trends in molluscumcontagiosum in the United States, 1966-1983. Sex Transm Dis1986;13:88-92.
3. Gottlieb SL, Myskowski PL. Molluscum contagiosum. Int J Dermatol1994;33:453-61.
4. Scholz J, Rosen-Wolff A, Bugert J, Reisner H, White MI, Darai G, et al.Epidemiology of molluscum contagiosum using genetic analysis ofthe viral DNA. J Med Virol 1989;27:87-90.
5. Porter CD, Archard LC. Characterisation by restriction mapping ofthree subtypes of molluscum contagiosum virus. J Med Virol1992;38:1-6.
6. Jacobs PH. Molluscum contagiosum. Aerosp Med 1970;41:1196-7.7. Fenner F. Poxviruses. In: Fields BN, Knipe DM, editors. Virology. 2nd
ed. New York: Raven Press; 1990.
8. Diven DG. Poxviruses. In: Tyring SK, editor. Mucocutaneousmanifestations of viral diseases. New York: Marcel Dekker; 2002.p. 39-68.
9. Fitzpatrick TB, Johnson RA, Wolff K, Suurmond D. Color atlas andsynopsis of clinical dermatology: common and serious diseases. NewYork: McGraw-Hill; 2001.
10. Fornatora ML, Reich RF, Gray RG, Freedman PD. Intraoralmolluscum contagiosum: a report of a case and a review of theliterature. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod2001;92:318-20.
11. Baker B. Approach molluscum lesions with benign therapies first.Pediatric News 1998;32:14.
12. Allen AL, Siegfried EC. Management of warts and molluscum inadolescents. Adolesc Med 2001;12:vi. 229-42.
13. Clinical Effectiveness Group (Association of Genitourinary Medicineand the Medical Society for the Study of Venereal Diseases). Nationalguideline for the management of anogenital warts. Sex TransmInfect 1999;75(Suppl 1):S71-5.
14. Drug facts and comparisons 2000. 54th ed. St. Louis, Mo: Lippincott,Williams, and Wilkins; 2000. p. 1656-7.
15. Longstaff E, von Krogh G. Condyloma eradication: self-therapy with0.15-0.5% podophyllotoxin versus 20-25% podophyllin preparations–an integrated safety assessment. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 2001;33:117-37.
16. von Krogh G, Longstaff E. Podophyllin office therapy againstcondyloma should be abandoned. Sex Transm Infect 2001;77:409-12.
17. Papa CM, Berger RS. Venereal herpes-like molluscum contagiosum:treatment with tretinoin. Cutis 1976;18:537-40.
18. Kono T, Kondo S, Pastore S, Shivji GM, Tomai MA, McKenzie RC,et al. Effects of a novel topical immunomodulator, imiquimod, onkeratinocyte cytokine gene expression. Lymphokine Cytokine Res1994;13:71-6.
19. Testerman TL, Gerster JF, Imbertson LM, Reiter MJ, Miller RL,Gibson SJ, et al. Cytokine induction by the immunomodulatorsimiquimod and S-27609. J Leukoc Biol 1995;58:365-72.
20. Hengge UR, Esser S, Schultewolter T, Behrendt C, Meyer T,Stockfleth E, et al. Self-administered topical 5% imiquimod for thetreatment of common warts and molluscum contagiosum. Br JDermatol 2000;143:1026-31.
21. Liota E, Smith KJ, Buckley R, Menon P, Skelton H. Imiquimodtherapy for molluscum contagiosum. J Cutan Med Surg 2000;4:76-82.
22. Syed TA, Goswami J, Ahmadpour OA, Ahmad SA. Treatment ofmolluscum contagiosum in males with an analog of imiquimod 1%in cream: a placebo-controlled, double-blind study. J Dermatol1998;25:309-13.
23. Barba AR, Kapoor S, Berman B. An open label safety study oftopical imiquimod 5% cream in the treatment of molluscumcontagiosum in children. Dermatol Online J 2002;7:20. Availableat: http://dermatology.cdlib.org/DOJvol7num1/therapy/iquimod/berman.html. Accessed December 17, 2002.
24. Brown CW Jr, O’Donoghue M, Moore J, Tharp M. Recalcitrantmolluscum contagiosum in an HIV-afflicted male treated successfullywith topical imiquimod. Cutis 2000;65:363-6.
25. Buckley R, Smith K. Topical imiquimod therapy for chronic giantmolluscum contagiosum in a patient with advanced humanimmunodeficiency virus 1 disease. Arch Dermatol 1999;135:1167-9.
26. Strauss RM, Doyle EL, Mohsen AH, Green ST. Successful treatmentof molluscum contagiosum with topical imiquimod in a severelyimmunocompromised HIV-positive patient. Int J STD AIDS2001;12:264-6.