26
z11.05.35.1;PP Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, Ph.D. JHU Applied Physics Laboratory USSOCOM CBR Conference and Exhibition Tampa, FL December 8, 2005

Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.1;PP

Mitigating the Effects of AllegedEBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports

Dorothy A. Canter, Ph.D.JHU Applied Physics Laboratory

USSOCOM CBR Conference and ExhibitionTampa, FL

December 8, 2005

Page 2: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.2;PP

Presentation

• USSOCOM Scenario/Presentation Assumptions

• Ebola Virus Information

• Ebola Notional Incident Timeline

• Ebola Best Case Decontamination Timeline

• Ebola Notional Public Health Timeline

• Recommended Preparedness Activities

• Potential Roles for Military in Responsesto Bioterrorism

Page 3: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.3;PP

USSOCOM-Specified EBOLA Scenario

• Reports on blogs/websites that “FreedomFighters” infected airline passengers at O’Hare,Logan, Hartsfield and Heathrow Airports withEbola virus

• Police, FBI, TSA find crude devices in airports

• Devices, environmental samples sent to labs foranalysis

• Boston police officer reports over nonsecureradio “We found the bioweapon in the trash..”- picked up by media

Page 4: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.4;PP

USSOCOM-Specified EBOLA Scenario

• Delta Flight 20, low on fuel, told to holdapproach pattern to Frankfurt Airport andawait further instructions

• Leader of Hartsfield baggage handlers uniontells members to stop unloading aircraft

• CNN reporter, wearing respirator, broadcasts“Breaking News”

Page 5: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.5;PP

My Assumptions

• Releases occur at same time at all airports

• Blogs/websites report incidents within one hour ofreleases

• Devices found in trash of food court area in securearea of terminal at all four airports

• Delta flight originated at Hartsfield Airport

• Incidents will yield confirmed attacks at Hartsfield,Logan and Heathrow Airports; O’Hare incident willbe hoax

• No sensitive electronic equipment(e.g., scanning equipment) affected by attacks

• Best case response based upon significantpreparedness and response planning/training

Page 6: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.6;PP

EBOLA Virus

• Fragile, RNA-containing Filovirus; causesEbola Hemorrhagic Fever (EHV)

• Incubation period of 2-21 days

• Symptoms include sudden onset of fever,weakness, muscle pain, headache; followedby vomiting, diarrhea, rash, impairedkidney/liver function, and internal/externalbleeding

• High mortality – no known treatment, onlysupportive medical care

Page 7: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.7;PP

EBOLA Virus

• Human-to-human transmission throughcontact with bodily fluids

– Risk greatest during latter stages ofdisease when viral loads highest

• Cases must be isolated from other patients– Soiled clothing/bed linens must be

disinfected

• Health care workers must use strict barriernursing techniques

– Non-disposable protective equipmentmust be disinfected prior to re-use

• Airborne transmission uncertain

Page 8: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.8;PP

EBOLA Virus

Page 9: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.9;PP

Facts About EBOLA Incidents

• No potentially exposed passengers, airline or airportworkers will become ill for about 2-21 days, if at all

• None of the above persons will be able to transmit thevirus before becoming ill

• If anyone develops EHF, that person(s) will need to beisolated

• Fragile virus, if viable, will not live long in air or onnonporous surfaces (at most several days)

• No antimicrobial products registered by EPA for useagainst Ebola virus, but number of products areregistered for use against viruses, including Vacciniavirus, on hard, non-porous sources

• Barrier nursing equipment available in CDC StrategicNational Stockpile (SNS)

Page 10: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.10;PP

Phases of EBOLA Airport Incidents

• Suspicious Incidents– Sufficient evidence to consider as credible

threats, no analytical laboratory confirmation– Online reports + finding of devices

• Presumed Positive Events– Positive findings in PCR, virus isolation,

antigen detection tests– Available within hours*

– US analyses done at CDC, USAMRIID only –BL-4 facilities

• Confirmed Attacks– Definitive tests at CDC/USAMRIID yield

positive findings– Results available within ½ to ¾ day*

*Source: Tom Ksiazek, CDC

Page 11: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.11;PP

EBOLA Notional Incident Timeline

Day 1 Day 2

Loga

nA

irpor

tH

eath

row

Airp

ort

O’H

are

Airp

ort

Blog

s/Web

sites

Broa

dcas

tRe

lease

s

Rel

ease

of S

pray

SuspiciousIncidents

PreliminaryLab Results

Crude DevicesFound

Terminal OperationsSuspended

Terminal OperationsSuspended

Terminal OperationsSuspended

+

+

-

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 25 26 27 28Hour

AirportClosed

TerminalOpens

z11.05.35.11;PP

SamplesArrive

SamplesArrive

SamplesArrive

AirportClosed

AttacksConfirmed

DefinitiveEbolaTest

+

+

-

Har

tsfie

ldA

irpor

t

PresumptivePositiveEvents

Terminal OperationsSuspended

+Samples

Arrive

AirportClosed+

Page 12: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.12;PP

Other Notional Activities During SuspiciousIncident Phase of Attacks

• Airport managers alert Mayors who alertGovernors who alert Secretary, DHS,and President

• Airports give media interviews

• Delta flight diverted to US air basein Germany

• Hartsfield baggage handlers unload baggageafter meeting with airport management andreceipt of Fact Sheets and FAQs

• Airports on high alert globally

Page 13: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.13;PP

Other Notional Activities During PresumptivePositive Phase of Attacks

• US airports activate Incident Command System

• EOCs activated (EPA, CDC, HSOC);PFOs appointed by DHS

• Interagency Committee on DomesticResponse Preparedness holds secureteleconference/prepares for next steps

• Decision to federalize National Guard units inaffected cities if attacks are confirmed

• Continuing interactions among governmentalunits and airport management

Page 14: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.14;PP

Other Notional Activities DuringPresumptive Positive Phase of Attacks

• Interactions among all airports

• CDC/local health departments confer onpotential public health responses

• Continuing airport briefings of media,distribution of Fact Sheets/FAQs

• Delta flight lands at Hartsfield/passengersquarantined

• Airlines notify passengers/flight crews onaffected planes

Page 15: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.15;PP

Responses to Confirmed Attacks

• Decontamination Activities

• Public Health Activities

• Forensic Activities

• International Coordination

Page 16: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.16;PP

EBOLA Best Case Decontamination Timeline

Day 2

Loga

nA

irpor

tH

eath

row

Airp

ort

3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24Hour

Day 3 Day 4 Day 5

3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24

* Unified Incident Commands

CoordinateWith UICs

Agree onClean-Up

Procedures

CBIRFArrives

z11.05.35.16;PP

Removal of Materials From Airportsfor Disposal Bleach Treatment

Removal of Materials From Airportsfor Disposal Bleach Treatment

FormUIC

CoordinateWith

HeathrowWasteRemoval

WasteRemoval

ECCMeets

AirportReopens

Har

tsfie

ldA

irpor

t

CBIRFArrives

Bleach TreatmentRemoval of Materials From Airportsfor DisposalForm

UIC*

CoordinateWith

HeathrowWasteRemoval

ECCMeets

AirportReopens

Page 17: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.17;PP

EBOLA Notional Public Health Timeline

0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24Day 2 (Hours) Days

Hour 3.5Activation of Strategic NationalStockpile (SNS)

Hours 5-6Designation of Quarantine Areasin Affected Cities

0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24

Day

4 FBI DetectsSuspiciousActivity onVideotapes

Labs ReportVirus NotWeaponizedD

ay 5

EBF Casein Atlanta –CDC/WHONotifiedD

ay 6

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 30

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 30

PeopleFleeAtlantaPanicD

ay 6

-7

Day 13: EHF Case inLondon Suburb –Day 19: People Returnto Boston and AtlantaDay 22: QuarantineLifted for ExposedPersonsDay 30: CommissionsAppointed to InvestigateAttacks/Responses

Day

s 11

-30

z11.05.35.17;PP

ExposedPersons

QuarantinedDay

3

FBIIdentifiesCases asPerpsD

ay 1

0

PeopleFleeBostonD

ay 9

-10

EBF Casein Boston –CDC/WHONotifiedD

ay 9

Days 1 - 4: Airlines/Airports Notify Potentially Exposed Persons

Days 3 - 22: Role of National Guard (NG) in Enforcing Quarantine

Page 18: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.18;PP

Response Assumptions

• Significant preparedness and response planning,including regular training, has occurred inadvance

• Teams are ready and equipment is pre-positioned

• Responses are 24/7• Interagency coordination alive and well• Effective audibles were called when needed at all

airports and immediately communicated to otherairports

Page 19: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.19;PP

• Fact Sheets and FAQs on biothreat agentsavailable at all US airports

– Cover public health, decontamination,and notification/management issues fortop bioterrorism agents

– Also distributed to First Responders,police

– Regularly updated

• Coordinated preparedness and responsetraining, including table tops

– Address both public health anddecontamination issues

Recommended PreparednessPlanning Activities

Page 20: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.20;PP

Recommended PreparednessPlanning Activities

Decontamination Related Activities

• Prototypical Health and Safety Plans(HASPs) for airports

• Designated areas of airport for detainmentof persons potentially exposed to bioagents

• Guidance on decontamination proceduresfor various biothreat agents

• Availability of portable PPE deconunits/pre-determined sites for theirlocation

Page 21: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.21;PP

Decontamination Activities (cont’d)

• Reachback

• Current lists of contractors withdemonstrated experience in bioagentdecontamination, waste removal

• Existing relationships with wastedisposal facilities

• Templates for remediation action plans

• Creation of Technical Advisory Committee(s)to provide guidance to airports on terrorismincidents – both real and hoaxes

• Possibly regional/national

Recommended PreparednessPlanning Activities

Page 22: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.22;PP

Interagency Committee on Domestic Response Preparedness

• Purpose– Planning for improved responses to multiple

domestic terrorist attacks with potentiallycatastrophic consequences• Research/Training/Coordination

– Advisory role during actual responses

• Co-chaired by DHS, DOD, and DHHS• Membership

– Civilian federal agencies: DHS (OP, TSA, FEMA),EPA, CDC (NIOSH, NCID), NIH, DOT,FAA, FBI, CIA, DOS

– DOD agencies: SOCOM, NORTHCOM, STRATCOM, others– State/local advisors– Member/surrogate from each agency -

electronically connected at all times onsecure equipment

Recommended PreparednessPlanning Activities

Page 23: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.23;PP

Potential Roles for Military in Responsesto Bioterrorism

• Transport of samples to analytical labs

• Analysis of clinical/environmental samples

• Role of CBIRF/CST units indecontaminations

• Use of National Guard armories aspotential quarantine centers/distribution ofSNS meds

• Role for USSOCOM OCONUS inidentifying/neutralizing terrorist cells

Page 24: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.24;PP

Need to be Prepared for theNext Bioattack,

Not Just the Last One!

Page 25: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.25;PP

If you have seen one bioattack,you’ve seen one bioattack

We need to be complete and flexibleto respond to asymmetric attacks

Page 26: Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at ... · Mitigating the Effects of Alleged EBOLA Attacks at Multiple Airports Dorothy A. Canter, ... radio “We found the bioweapon

z11.05.35.26;PP

Contact Information

Dorothy A. Canter, PhD

240-228-2616

The Johns Hopkins UniversityApplied Physics Laboratory

[email protected]