14
Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technolog E-rate Selection Process RFI/RFP Documents Developed Vendor Conference Initial Submissions First Review Mistake Addendum Second Review Recommendations Local Vendor Participation Next Steps

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process RFI/RFP Documents Developed Vendor Conference Initial Submissions First Review

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

E-rate Selection ProcessE-rate Selection Process RFI/RFP Documents Developed

Vendor Conference

Initial Submissions

First Review

Mistake

Addendum

Second Review

Recommendations

Local Vendor Participation

Next Steps

Page 2: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

RFI/RFP DocumentsRFI/RFP Documents RFI/RFP Documents Developed

Vendor Qualification

Internal Wiring and Network Configuration

LAN Maintenance

Classroom Counts by Sites

Six RFI’s for Internal Wiring (5-7 Schools Each)

One RFI for LAN Maintenance (52 Schools)

Page 3: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Vendor ConferenceVendor Conference 12/12/02 – Two Hour Vendor’s Conference

Process described to 35 vendors from 22 companies

Extensive Q&A (Proceedings audio recorded)

Vendor contact information gathered

All documents, including vendor contact list posted on-line

E-mail list for vendor questions established. Answers available to ALL vendors

12/13/02 & 12/16/02 Site walks to ALL sites

Page 4: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Initial SubmissionsInitial Submissions

Responses due 1/2/03 (extended from 12/27/02)

Initial Submissions Reviewed by Tech Services, Facilities, and Purchasing

11 responses to Internal Wiring RFI/RFPs

6 responses to LAN Maintenance RFI/RFP

Page 5: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

First ReviewFirst Review Vendors screened for qualifications and

responsiveness to RFI

5 responses to Internal Wiring RFI/RFPs eliminated for non-compliance

3 responses to LAN Maintenance RFI/RFP eliminated for non-compliance

Remaining responses reviewed and ranked based on technical design and cost.

Page 6: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Mistake in Form 470Mistake in Form 470 District is informed by vendor that our

Form 470 may contain error

SLD contacted. District advised to re-submit Form 470 for Internal Connections

1/8/03 Revised Form 470 submitted

New 28 day window begins

Additional vendors free to submit, existing vendors can modify proposals.

Page 7: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Addendum to RFI/RFPAddendum to RFI/RFP 1/10/03 - addendum to RFI/RFP

developed, e-mailed to all current respondents and posted on website. Additional site walks conducted.

Clarifies conditions for acceptable responses

Designed to improve quality of responses

Allow non-responsive vendors to modify response

Builds in additional protections and quality control for District

Page 8: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Second ReviewSecond Review 10 responses to Internal Wiring RFI/RFPs (1

eliminated as non-responsive). No new vendors submitted in 2nd round.

Responses to all RFI/RFPs are screened as before for technical design and cost

4 finalists for RFI/RFP 1-6 and 2 finalists for RFI/RFP 7 identified and asked follow-up questions.

1/28/03 – 2 of 4 finalists for RFI/RFP voluntarily withdrawn.

1/29/03 - Review committee’s recommendations given to District leadership

Page 9: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Recommended VendorsRecommended VendorsRFI Primary

VendorPartners

RFI 1 JDL CBX/ACCRA

RFI 2 Tucker AT&T/Kneal

RFI 3 Tucker AT&T/Kneal

RFI 4 Tucker AT&T/Kneal

RFI 5 JDL CBX/ACCRA

RFI 6 JDL CBX/ACCRA

RFI 7: Maintenance

CBX

Page 10: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Components of the WorkComponents of the Work

31%

69%

EquipmentService

Page 11: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Percent of Erate Local Vendor Participation

Percent of Erate Local Vendor Participation

5.3

41

05

1015202530354045

Year 5 Year 6

Page 12: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Funding Participation Expected by Local Partners

Funding Participation Expected by Local Partners

$7,486,970.67

$4,243,422.43

$0.00$1,000,000.00$2,000,000.00$3,000,000.00$4,000,000.00$5,000,000.00$6,000,000.00$7,000,000.00$8,000,000.00

Total Services Provided by LocalVendors

Page 13: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Changes to Process Resulted In:Changes to Process Resulted In:

Enabling Local Vendors to act as PrimariesSignificant Increase in Local ParticipationIncrease in collaboration and integration

between OUSD Departments.Increased competition = Reduced cost to

OUSD• After final negotiations, we expect the work come

under expected costs by approximately 20%.

Page 14: Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services E-rate Selection Process  RFI/RFP Documents Developed  Vendor Conference  Initial Submissions  First Review

Mitchell/Hutcher 2003 Technology Services

Next StepsNext Steps

Sign LOIs with Vendors

Submit 471 (By Thursday Night)

Finalize Agreements with Vendors including Management Structure and Oversight.

Notification of Award Expected in Late Spring